I’ve had the pleasure of picking up 3 or 4 straight razors being sold on AuctionNinja sort of locally over the past year. I’ve cleaned them all up with varying success, and I’m very happy with all of them.

I’ve been using Flitz to bring some shine back into the blades before honing, but I’ve been wondering if it’s worth it to get a buffing wheel. My most recent razor is the nicest one yet. I’d love to take the pin out, polish the entire blade including what’s hidden by the scales, and get it looking nice.

I’m hoping someone here can guide me. I have a bit of space where I could set up a buffing wheel, and already have the equipment to repin the razor (a skill which I’m willing to learn). Is a buffing wheel better or worse than Flitz on a paper towel? Of course I’d made sure to hold the razor so the edge doesn’t catch the wheel, and I’d hone the razor after buffing is done. Would a buffing wheel do any sort of permanent damage to the edge which can’t be fixed by honing?