showing posts tagged #bestofinternetupdates — clear

0

[Mod Post] An update for the updates community!

preview

Sidebar Update

Our sidebar here at c/BestofInternetUpdates now includes links (they go to lemmy.world’s search) to sort your posts. You can now sort by the location tags and the story tags. This isn’t quite as well done as reddit, it’s essentially going to the community typing the tag in the search bar and searching “title only.” So you’re able to do this yourself as well.

Here is what they look like in the sidebar:

Post Sorting

Sort by Location Tag

- [Fedi] - [Reddit] - [AAM] - [CA]

Sort by Post Type

- [Concluded] - [Ongoing] - [New Update] - [Inconclusive] - [Ongoing] - [Confirmed Fake] - [Suspected Fake]

We try to use tags because we’re aware not everyone wants to see Reddit content. If you are one of those people, each post copied from Reddit will include a [Reddit] tag at the end. If you see these, you’re welcome to keep scrolling.

Reddit is not the only place on the internet we allow sourcing from. Basically any type of story update made by a user is allowed here as long as that website allows reposting. Some websites like Ask a Manager and Captain Awesome, have some requirements for reposting (don’t repost their responses, link back instead). So if you’re posting from a site that has these requests, please follow their rules for reposting.

Posting Rules Update

We did some minor updates to our Posting Guidelines Please check them out before you decide to make a post. The comments on the post even includes a copy and paste template if you wish to contribute to the community. It makes it easier to just replace the titles, dates, and stories with your own and not have to worry about markdown formatting.

Sidebar Update

Our sidebar here at c/BestofInternetUpdates now includes links (they go to lemmy.world’s search) to sort your posts. You can now sort by the location tags and the story tags. This isn’t quite as well done as reddit, it’s essentially going to the community typing the tag in the search bar and searching “title only.” So you’re able to do this yourself as well.

Here is what they look like in the sidebar:

Post Sorting

Sort by Location Tag

- [Fedi] - [Reddit] - [AAM] - [CA]

Sort by Post Type

- [Concluded] - [Ongoing] - [New Update] - [Inconclusive] - [Ongoing] - [Confirmed Fake] - [Suspected Fake]

We try to use tags because we’re aware not everyone wants to see Reddit content. If you are one of those people, each post copied from Reddit will include a [Reddit] tag at the end. If you see these, you’re welcome to keep scrolling.

Reddit is not the only place on the internet we allow sourcing from. Basically any type of story update made by a user is allowed here as long as that website allows reposting. Some websites like Ask a Manager and Captain Awesome, have some requirements for reposting (don’t repost their responses, link back instead). So if you’re posting from a site that has these requests, please follow their rules for reposting.

Posting Rules Update

We did some minor updates to our Posting Guidelines Please check them out before you decide to make a post. The comments on the post even includes a copy and paste template if you wish to contribute to the community. It makes it easier to just replace the titles, dates, and stories with your own and not have to worry about markdown formatting.

0

Post Submission Guidelines & Template

preview

Please note if you’re looking for a copy and paste template, it’s in the comments.

If you’re posting a submission please include:

  • Original Post title with link
  • OOP name (if available) and platform
  • Dates of original posts and updates Month, day, year
  • Trigger warnings using the mood spoiler
  • Make it readable (not in all caps or all bold)

Step 1:

  • Please don’t post if the original source has a rule or request against reposts
  • Only repost updates that are at minimum 1 week old, especially for platforms like reddit where they can still be interacted with.
  • Make sure your post hasn’t been posted here within the last year, search the community for your title and similar titles.

Step 2:

  • Please include all parts of a story. If they are too long, they can be shorted but please indicate it was shortened with a link to the original post.
  • If there is an update by the original poster made within 7 days, add the update to your existing post with a note at the top that there’s a new update at the bottom made after this post. If it’s been more than 7 days, you can make another post indicating a NEW update.
  • If posting from Ask A Manager, Alison has requested on reddit that we remove her advice from the post, we will also follow that rule here.
  • If posting from Captain Awesome, CA has asked here not to copy each story in full and make sure you give credit and link back. This can be accomplished the same way as Alison, by not posting the response from CA and is just generally good advice for any advice style blog post.

Title:

  • You can create your own title or you can use the OOP’s title
  • Do not use all caps in your title
  • Avoid spoilers and personal bias in your titles
  • Use your title as the first line in your post in Bold with the link to the original post or if posting from reddit, CA or AAM, to that post. Or use the link option when creating a post.

Title Format:

  • Title should include a beginning tag stating the type of story: Concluded, Ongoing, New Update, Inconclusive, Ongoing, Confirmed/Suspected Fake
  • After the Tag you should give the title using either the OOPs title OR a summary of the story
  • The end should include a tag for the location of the story: Reddit, AAM (Ask a Manager), CA (Captain Awkward), Fedi:Instance-Type (Type= Lemmy, Piefed, Mbin/Kbin and so on), etc.
  • Proper Format: [Type Tag] Summary of Story [Location Tag]
  • Examples:
    • [Concluded] My significant other left, what do I do? [Reddit]
    • [Ongoing] I think I need to break up with my gf [Fedi:Lemmy]
    • [Inconclusive] I just got kicked out of my house [Fedi: Piefed]
    • [Suspected Fake] My boss blew up the entire office! [Reddit]
    • [Concluded] I think I’m going to get fired [AAM]

Intro:

  • Second line under the title should read: "I am NOT OP. The original post is from (see next bullet point)
  • If you’re reposting from Reddit or another such site that has a best of updates, please include the user who compiled the best of example: Thanks u/username of Reddit for making the original BoRU. No need to link to their profile as the title will be linked to their post.
  • If you’re posting from Lemmy please include the instance. Example: "Originally posted to !asklemmy@lemmy.world"
  • Trigger warnings should be included using the spoiler tag. note: should be an emotion the reader will feel by the end of the post that does not spoil events. Required if the final update is distressing or bleak, otherwise optional. Positive/negative result is an acceptable mood spoiler. Or something along the lines of “self harm, sexual assault” or other things people might need to be wary of.

Body:

  • The original post should have a bold heading titled “Original:” followed by the date
  • Any updates should have a break between the previous and the next you can accomplish this by adding a line that’s dash space dash space dash
  • All updates should be in Bold and titled “Update # :” followed by the date of the update.
  • Adding a date marker is optional but beneficial (like 5 years from original post)
  • Include at the bottom in bold at the very end: “Do not comment in linked posts or message OOP’s” and below that in bold: "This is a repost community, I am not OP"

Readability

  • Use paragraphs, not an entire wall of text
  • Use formatting like Bold for titles, breaks in between updates etc.
  • Put them in order, Original post first, update #1 second update #2 third etc.
  • Remove any redundant summaries that the OP has used. Often on Reddit they will summarize their last post. We have it all in one post, it’s not necessary and takes up space. Please remove it.
  • If OP used an image, post an image URL so it will show up in the post. If that image no longer is accessible, please note that where the image would be example: "…post text (OP included an image which is no longer available) post text…"

Comments

  • You can include relavant comments made to and from OOP if they’re available. Try to keep it minimal, and make sure they add to the story.

  • If available please link to the comments section (not each individual comment)

  • Put the comments and reply from OP in quotes so it’s designated as a comment.

  • Comments should be structured as: Commenter 1: Comment text followed by OOP: Comment Text Flair

  • Please start your post with a “flair” by putting it within brackets and end it with a flair of the source. Example: [Concluded] Post title [Reddit]

  • More than one flair might be applicable to a post. Submitters should use their best judgement and include clarification in the title or the post. For instance, flairing a post CONCLUDED and in the title adding [NEW UPDATE].

  • Post flair includes:

    • [Concluded]
    • [Ongoing]
    • [New Update]
    • [Inconclusive]
    • [Ongoing]
    • [Confirmed Fake]
    • [Suspected Fake]
  • Sources can include but are not limited to:

    • [Lemmy]
    • [Reddit]
    • [AAM] - Ask A Manager
    • [CA] - Captain Awesome

In Addition:

Certain topics such as divorce, cheating or posts dealing with revenge, retaliation or hostility may have a higher bar for submission. Sensitive or grim content may be removed. You should also avoid injecting personal opinion or bias into the post. These are better saved for the comment section. Editor’s notes are okay, but should be clearly labeled as such.

If you get comments that your post doesn’t belong or isn’t bestof, you can report them under the META comment rule. Those types of comments are allowed if it’s under the stickied Moderator message on your post.

Do not include your own personal judgements or opinions in the body of your post. Personal opinions should be saved for the comment section.

Content curation is up for mod discretion.


Example:


Title: [Concluded] Title Name [Reddit] (title of actual post)

Title: Title Name - Thank you u/username1 for compiling the original BoRU

I am NOT OP. OP is Reddit user: u/username

Originally Posted to: Reddit’s r/subredditname Jan 01, 2020

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

Violence, Pregnancy Loss, Divorce

Editor’s Note: Optional Editors note if you had to condense anything, original pictures are missing, some updates are no longer recoverable etc.


Original Post: Jan 01, 2020

Paragraph one. Post text here.

Paragraph two. Post text here.


Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Comment Text

OOP: Comment Response


Update #1: Mar 01, 2020

Paragraph one. Post text here.

Paragraph two. Post text here.


Update #2: Dec 01, 2020

Paragraph one. Post text here.

Paragraph two. Post text here.


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

Please note if you’re looking for a copy and paste template, it’s in the comments.

If you’re posting a submission please include:

  • Original Post title with link
  • OOP name (if available) and platform
  • Dates of original posts and updates Month, day, year
  • Trigger warnings using the mood spoiler
  • Make it readable (not in all caps or all bold)

Step 1:

  • Please don’t post if the original source has a rule or request against reposts
  • Only repost updates that are at minimum 1 week old, especially for platforms like reddit where they can still be interacted with.
  • Make sure your post hasn’t been posted here within the last year, search the community for your title and similar titles.

Step 2:

  • Please include all parts of a story. If they are too long, they can be shorted but please indicate it was shortened with a link to the original post.
  • If there is an update by the original poster made within 7 days, add the update to your existing post with a note at the top that there’s a new update at the bottom made after this post. If it’s been more than 7 days, you can make another post indicating a NEW update.
  • If posting from Ask A Manager, Alison has requested on reddit that we remove her advice from the post, we will also follow that rule here.
  • If posting from Captain Awesome, CA has asked here not to copy each story in full and make sure you give credit and link back. This can be accomplished the same way as Alison, by not posting the response from CA and is just generally good advice for any advice style blog post.

Title:

  • You can create your own title or you can use the OOP’s title
  • Do not use all caps in your title
  • Avoid spoilers and personal bias in your titles
  • Use your title as the first line in your post in Bold with the link to the original post or if posting from reddit, CA or AAM, to that post. Or use the link option when creating a post.

Title Format:

  • Title should include a beginning tag stating the type of story: Concluded, Ongoing, New Update, Inconclusive, Ongoing, Confirmed/Suspected Fake
  • After the Tag you should give the title using either the OOPs title OR a summary of the story
  • The end should include a tag for the location of the story: Reddit, AAM (Ask a Manager), CA (Captain Awkward), Fedi:Instance-Type (Type= Lemmy, Piefed, Mbin/Kbin and so on), etc.
  • Proper Format: [Type Tag] Summary of Story [Location Tag]
  • Examples:
    • [Concluded] My significant other left, what do I do? [Reddit]
    • [Ongoing] I think I need to break up with my gf [Fedi:Lemmy]
    • [Inconclusive] I just got kicked out of my house [Fedi: Piefed]
    • [Suspected Fake] My boss blew up the entire office! [Reddit]
    • [Concluded] I think I’m going to get fired [AAM]

Intro:

  • Second line under the title should read: "I am NOT OP. The original post is from (see next bullet point)
  • If you’re reposting from Reddit or another such site that has a best of updates, please include the user who compiled the best of example: Thanks u/username of Reddit for making the original BoRU. No need to link to their profile as the title will be linked to their post.
  • If you’re posting from Lemmy please include the instance. Example: "Originally posted to !asklemmy@lemmy.world"
  • Trigger warnings should be included using the spoiler tag. note: should be an emotion the reader will feel by the end of the post that does not spoil events. Required if the final update is distressing or bleak, otherwise optional. Positive/negative result is an acceptable mood spoiler. Or something along the lines of “self harm, sexual assault” or other things people might need to be wary of.

Body:

  • The original post should have a bold heading titled “Original:” followed by the date
  • Any updates should have a break between the previous and the next you can accomplish this by adding a line that’s dash space dash space dash
  • All updates should be in Bold and titled “Update # :” followed by the date of the update.
  • Adding a date marker is optional but beneficial (like 5 years from original post)
  • Include at the bottom in bold at the very end: “Do not comment in linked posts or message OOP’s” and below that in bold: "This is a repost community, I am not OP"

Readability

  • Use paragraphs, not an entire wall of text
  • Use formatting like Bold for titles, breaks in between updates etc.
  • Put them in order, Original post first, update #1 second update #2 third etc.
  • Remove any redundant summaries that the OP has used. Often on Reddit they will summarize their last post. We have it all in one post, it’s not necessary and takes up space. Please remove it.
  • If OP used an image, post an image URL so it will show up in the post. If that image no longer is accessible, please note that where the image would be example: "…post text (OP included an image which is no longer available) post text…"

Comments

  • You can include relavant comments made to and from OOP if they’re available. Try to keep it minimal, and make sure they add to the story.

  • If available please link to the comments section (not each individual comment)

  • Put the comments and reply from OP in quotes so it’s designated as a comment.

  • Comments should be structured as: Commenter 1: Comment text followed by OOP: Comment Text Flair

  • Please start your post with a “flair” by putting it within brackets and end it with a flair of the source. Example: [Concluded] Post title [Reddit]

  • More than one flair might be applicable to a post. Submitters should use their best judgement and include clarification in the title or the post. For instance, flairing a post CONCLUDED and in the title adding [NEW UPDATE].

  • Post flair includes:

    • [Concluded]
    • [Ongoing]
    • [New Update]
    • [Inconclusive]
    • [Ongoing]
    • [Confirmed Fake]
    • [Suspected Fake]
  • Sources can include but are not limited to:

    • [Lemmy]
    • [Reddit]
    • [AAM] - Ask A Manager
    • [CA] - Captain Awesome

In Addition:

Certain topics such as divorce, cheating or posts dealing with revenge, retaliation or hostility may have a higher bar for submission. Sensitive or grim content may be removed. You should also avoid injecting personal opinion or bias into the post. These are better saved for the comment section. Editor’s notes are okay, but should be clearly labeled as such.

If you get comments that your post doesn’t belong or isn’t bestof, you can report them under the META comment rule. Those types of comments are allowed if it’s under the stickied Moderator message on your post.

Do not include your own personal judgements or opinions in the body of your post. Personal opinions should be saved for the comment section.

Content curation is up for mod discretion.


Example:


Title: [Concluded] Title Name [Reddit] (title of actual post)

Title: Title Name - Thank you u/username1 for compiling the original BoRU

I am NOT OP. OP is Reddit user: u/username

Originally Posted to: Reddit’s r/subredditname Jan 01, 2020

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

Violence, Pregnancy Loss, Divorce

Editor’s Note: Optional Editors note if you had to condense anything, original pictures are missing, some updates are no longer recoverable etc.


Original Post: Jan 01, 2020

Paragraph one. Post text here.

Paragraph two. Post text here.


Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Comment Text

OOP: Comment Response


Update #1: Mar 01, 2020

Paragraph one. Post text here.

Paragraph two. Post text here.


Update #2: Dec 01, 2020

Paragraph one. Post text here.

Paragraph two. Post text here.


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

0

[Ongoing] Paternal Parent Falsifying DNA Test Through Labcorp [Reddit] [Dallas Morning News]

preview

I am not the OOP, this is a repost community.

OOP is: u/kaitkaitlynlyn Originally posted to: r/legaladvice

Trigger Warning

stealthing, sexual assault, sex worker, loss of a child, manipulation, coercion, lies and deceit

Editors Note: This is a LONG one, in a news article and only parts 1 and 2 of 5 are out. You may want to save this for when all 5 parts are released.

Here is a link to part 1 if you’d prefer to read it in it’s original format with all the images intact. There are several screenshots of text messages that may be interesting to most people. I would recommend ad block though. Below is the original Reddit post that got us to this news article.


Original Post

2023

So I was dating this man for around 2 years when we decided to have a baby. We tracked my ovulation schedule and finally got pregnant. He ghosted me 2 months before my due date and I ended up having my child a month early. I have not heard from him since my child was born 10 months ago, with the exception of a text stating that he did not believe the child was his.

Fast forward and I came into contact with other women that he has done this to through a Facebook group. My child has 4 known siblings and there are 3 open child support cases against this man. One of the mothers received the dna results for her child and it said that he was not the father. She knew that he was the father so she ordered an Ancestry DNA kit and ran the kit on her child. The test results came back and connected her child with this man’s immediate family. She took that evidence to her state appointed attorney and her attorney requested that the test be retaken through their facility. The paternal father opposed and fought it in court.

He was not there because he was “in Greece for work” so he had his attorney represent him to argue why he shouldn’t have to take another DNA test. The other mother’s attorney stated that he had taken the test at a labcorp 150 miles from his home before he was even ordered to take it and consistently requested that the state accept that sample in place of him going through DDC. Her attorney finally authorized it because it was through a reputable company. However, the suspicions surrounding the case should call for a new court ordered DNA test through DDC.

His attorney argued that the paternal father shouldn’t have to take another test and that he took the test at that specific location due to being there for work. He then proceeded to defend the paternal father by saying that these are highly offensive allegations but that the paternal party was willing to take another test through ddc and he actually had went and paid for one through DDC “with his own money.” He continued to say that all the mother had to do was to bring her child to the facility to get tested. He then showed the judge a copy of where he had scheduled a test.

The other mother’s attorney objected and stated that her client has severe anxiety about that and that her client would pay for the new test to be done at one of the state designated facilities. The judge agreed and now he has to retake a new dna test through DDC but now the mother is paying for it.

His attorney panicked and ran up to the judge frantically waving the paper saying that he had already paid for the test and that his name would already be in the system and the judge did not care and said that her ruling was final.

After leaving the court room, his attorney passed the other mother and I in the hallway and the other mother stated “You should know more about your client.” And he responded by yelling “I KNOW MY CLIENT.” He then proceeded to walk aggressively down the hall, punching the air and saying “I know that’s not his baby!!!” He was making an absolute ass out of himself to the extent to where people were laughing at him. I feel like he knows the truth and that’s why his attorney reacted that way.

The test has not yet been scheduled but I worry that he’s going to bribe someone on this one as well being as he has ALOT of money. We have stacks of evidence against him and all of our children look very veryyyyyyy similar. What should I do? He has not yet been served for my child’s case but I’m concerned that he will do the same thing to me. What are the consequences of falsifying a dna test? Will I even be able to receive child support if this man is incarcerated?

It’s all tooooooo much


Update

Oct 12, 2026

Just an update on a previous post where I was seeking legal advice regarding my son’s biological father submitting a falsified dna test to the court. The Dallas News is running a series about it that began releasing this morning. I feel anxious but validated.

Location: Dallas, Texas News Article Here

Editor’s Note I believe there’s a post in between that I’m missing where OP shows what happened to her.


The News

Part 1

She was 22 and still mourning a pair of losses: her 3-month-old son, to sudden infant death syndrome, and her partner, to murder. Spiraling, she transitioned from exotic dancing to working as an escort.

When she said a man named Gary contacted her through one of her escort ads, she viewed it as an opportunity. They made arrangements to meet at his house in Mandeville, a suburb of New Orleans situated on the north shore of Lake Pontchartrain.

Nadia wasn’t intending to have sex with Gary that night. They had negotiated a price of $500, but they never agreed to anything specific. Still, she stowed a condom in her bra.

When Nadia arrived, Gary offered her a drink. She happily accepted.

Gary — who would later move to Dallas and split time between there and New Orleans — talked about his travels and work. Nadia shared what had happened with her son and partner.

As the night progressed and Nadia grew more intoxicated, she decided it would be beneficial to take Gary on as a client. He seemed cool, like he had his life together. And he wasn’t bad looking, either. Nadia said Gary told her he couldn’t use the condom because he was allergic to latex.

During sex, Nadia said Gary asked three times if he could ejaculate inside of her. Each time, she said no. The third time, she said, he did it anyway. As Nadia drove home to New Orleans, she said she received a text. It was from Gary.

“We’re about to go half on a baby.”

The saga of Gary Alton Matthews Jr.

This is much more than the story of one woman’s bad sexual encounter. What Gary had done to her, he had done before, Nadia would learn, and he would do it again. There were other women with stories similar to hers — not only in Louisiana, but also in North Texas.

Over the next six years, she would discover at least six other women who felt betrayed by him, leading to contentious legal disputes — some of which are still playing out in courtrooms from Dallas to Phoenix to Covington, La.

The saga of Gary Alton Matthews Jr., full of twists and turns, is not just a tale of salacious deceit. This is a story about a pattern of behavior that left a trail of financial hardship, abandoned children and broken homes in its wake. This is a story about a group of women who banded together, after enduring shame and shock, to advocate for themselves and their children.

It is a story about the limits of the family court system, which allowed one well-resourced man to evade accountability through the employ of private DNA tests, high-priced attorneys, the concealment of assets and what government attorneys in Texas and Louisiana contend is perjury and fraud. It’s about wasted taxpayer dollars, missed opportunities and unserved justice.

The legal cases against Gary are outliers but also emblematic of broader problems in the family court system. Relatively few cases involve years of contentious litigation or allegations of fraud, as Gary’s did, or result in hundreds of thousands of dollars being owed. Still, his cases illustrate challenges confronted by so many other Texas mothers who pursue and are owed child support in a state that collects more of it than any other, through a court system that is slow to react and favors those who can afford legal representation.

Through his attorney, Gary declined to speak with The Dallas Morning News. His version of events is largely represented through his testimony contained in nearly 4,900 pages of court records, as well as messages and emails shared with The News by nine of his former partners.

‘Lost dog’

Nadia didn’t want to have a baby with a man she had just met. A man who, she said, after that first text, had asked if she was ovulating. Her intuition told her that something about the situation was off. As a precaution, Nadia took Plan B.

What she didn’t know was that she was, in fact, already ovulating. Plan B temporarily delays ovulation but isn’t effective when an egg has already been released. Two weeks later, a faint line appeared on a home pregnancy test. When Nadia shared the news with Gary, he asked her what she wanted to do. She said she wanted to end the pregnancy.

Nadia said he agreed to send her money for an abortion, but he preferred that she keep the baby. She said he told her he really wanted to be a father. They could develop a relationship. He would be there for the baby. Nadia thought about the baby boy she had lost, who never had the chance to live. Maybe, she thought, having this baby could become a catalyst to better her life.

Around Father’s Day, Nadia agreed to go to dinner with Gary. Already, she said, he acted as if they were in a relationship. That night, they slept together again. When Nadia woke the next morning, she said Gary wasn’t in the bedroom. As she went to put her clothes back on, she said she saw something on the floor next to the bed. It was a pair of women’s underwear, size small. They weren’t hers.

Without speaking to Gary, she left.

When he texted, asking where she went, Nadia told him to check the side of his bed. She said Gary responded with a long text. He was an upstanding man, he said. The underwear, he said, belonged to a cousin who would house sit while he was out of town.

As the pregnancy progressed, Nadia struggled to reach Gary. When he finally responded, she said, he told her he was in Africa and could file for child support after the baby was born. Nadia wasn’t buying that story. She drove by his house in Mandeville. She could see he was home.

Nadia assumed he would be. She had already printed out a stack of homemade flyers. They included a picture of Gary under the title “LOST DOG.”

The flyer read, in part: “Spends a lot of time prowling the internet for escorts. Has a fetish for intentionally getting women pregnant. Acts like he wants to be involved and then goes non responsive. Lies constantly.” Nadia taped one to Gary’s door. She put others on a stop sign and in the neighbors’ mailboxes.

A private paternity test

Nadia gave birth to a baby girl in January 2021 in New Orleans. She filed for child support from her hospital bed.

Over the next year, the case proceeded slowly. Nadia moved on with her life, and so did Gary. A few months after the baby’s birth, he purchased a townhome in Dallas and began splitting his time between Texas and Louisiana. A few months after that, Nadia moved with the baby to Florida.

He did not respond to the court’s summons to establish his paternity and child support obligations. Nadia began contacting Gary’s family members, one of whom suggested a DNA test. That would prove to be anything but simple.

Nadia and Gary exchanged a series of heated messages. The paternity case couldn’t proceed, Nadia told him, until he responded to the court. By August 2022, Gary still had not responded to the court. A judge entered a default judgment legally recognizing Gary as the father.

Two months later, Gary visited a Labcorp location — but not in New Orleans or Dallas, where he spent the majority of his time. He flew to Houston, where a collector at a location on North Gessner Road swabbed the inside of his cheek. She also took Gary’s thumbprint, reviewed his driver’s license and passport and took his photo. Gary listed his home address as the Dallas townhome.

The following day, Gary’s attorney, Donald Rose, contacted the Department of Children & Family Services, which enforced child support for the state of Louisiana. Because of a procedural error, the default judgment was vacated, and Gary would now be allowed to contest his paternity. Rose requested that the department test the DNA sample Gary had just provided in Houston.

The request was received by Maria Treffinger, a longtime attorney with DCFS who litigated child support cases. Treffinger would ultimately become intricately involved in Gary’s legal battles with the mothers of his children.

Treffinger emailed Rose back to tell him the department preferred all testing be completed through DNA Diagnostics Center, commonly known as DDC, the laboratory exclusively contracted to perform testing for the state. The lab ensured neutral collection of samples and a strict chain of custody for legally admissible test results.

That would not be convenient for his client, Rose replied; Gary now lived in Texas and would be working in Toronto for several months.

After exchanging a series of calls and emails with Rose, Treffinger relented, reluctantly. The state would use the Labcorp sample collected in Houston.

Three samples from two different labs — Nadia and her daughter’s from DDC, and Gary’s from Labcorp — were merged. In March 2023, more than two years after Nadia’s daughter was born, the paternity results were in. There was a 0% chance, they showed, that Gary was the father of Nadia’s child.

Turning to Ancestry

On Instagram, Gary sent Nadia a screenshot of the paternity test. The series of accompanying messages was gleeful, and gloating.

“DNA proves you’re delusional,” he wrote, with a crying laughing emoji. “Now it’s my turn to get compensated on your defamation.”

“Maybe you should actually go find your baby daddy instead of stalking me. A restraining and protective order will be sent your way soon.”

“Move on with your life. Remove any content or stupid s— you put out about me and go live your life. If you continue to harass or defame me, I’m going to tie you up in court and take hundreds of thousands from you.”

Nadia was stunned.

“SO HOWD YA MANAGE THAT ONE GARY?” she messaged back, adding that she planned to dispute the results. “There is absolutely NO WAY she’s not your child.”

“What’d you do? Pay someone off? Slip someone else’s dna into a tube in your mouth or sum?”

Again and again, Gary sent Nadia the paternity test results.

At one point, Nadia recalls Gary saying something that puzzled her: No matter what she thought or did, a DNA test would never identify him as the father.

The phrasing confused Nadia. What on earth, she wondered, did that mean?

Nadia called Treffinger. She knew it sounded crazy — and she didn’t know how Gary had managed it — but it was impossible for anyone else to be the father of her child. Please, Nadia asked, couldn’t the state conduct another test? Treffinger respectfully listened to Nadia’s concerns, but Nadia got the impression that taking her call was a courtesy. After all, Treffinger told her, Gary had taken the test. The results spoke for themselves.

Nadia refused to accept them. She ordered a DNA test from Ancestry, the genealogy website. Within days, it was on her doorstep. Obtaining a DNA sample from her 2-year-old was no easy task. Somehow, she managed to get her daughter’s saliva into the test tube.

A few weeks later, Nadia logged onto her account to check the results. The first thing she noticed: Gary’s half-sister shared 11% of her DNA with her daughter. There was more: Relatives with Gary’s last name and his mother’s maiden name also showed up as familial matches.

Nadia sent screenshots of the results to Gary. He responded with a crying-laughing emoji.

“I wasn’t going to sue you for defamation but I will now,” he wrote back. “I’m not kin to any of those people.”

Nadia also emailed the screenshots to Treffinger, who called her.

The testing process, Treffinger acknowledged, had been highly unusual. It had been handled outside of the court’s normal procedures due to what she called pressure from Gary’s attorney. She would request another test. Treffinger filed a motion with the court in June 2023. The paternity results were not the only thing that caused Nadia to doubt Gary’s truthfulness. There was much more that he was hiding.

‘You won’t get a penny’

The same year Nadia met Gary, a single mother in New Orleans connected with him online. After a few months of exchanging messages, they met in person and began seeing each other.

For months, the woman — who asked The News not to identify her due to fear of retaliation and to protect the identity of her child — said she believed she had developed a close friendship with Gary. The News verified her account through a review of court records and other public records, text messages and emails and other interviews. He bought the woman’s child an expensive gift and brought her on an international trip.

Early on, the woman, who was in her 30s, said Gary told her he wanted to go “half on a baby” with her, a reference to an R. Kelly lyric. She said they both were open to having children. The summer of 2021 — around the same time Nadia’s child support case was opened — the woman found out she was pregnant. She told Gary. Suddenly, she said, he disappeared. She said he stopped talking to her on all platforms.

Embarrassed, she hid the pregnancy from her family for seven months. All that time, she still hadn’t heard from Gary. Before she gave birth, she sent out baby shower invitations to his parents. They did not respond or attend. The woman gave birth in New Orleans in May 2022. It was a girl. The new mother sent out a birth announcement.

A few months later, still having not heard from Gary, she texted him, asking him to send her $700 a month to support their daughter until she was in pre-kindergarten. When Gary didn’t respond, she told him she intended to file for child support. This time, he responded. He told her he had moved to Toronto and suggested the child was not his. He was also angry she had sent the baby shower invitations and birth announcement to his parents.

“I promise you if you go to the courts you won’t get a penny from me,” he wrote to her. “Don’t threaten me I’m not the one.”

“When you make a baby you have to be at least financially responsible for them,” the mother replied. “Yea it’s your choice to pretend they don’t exist but legally it doesn’t matter how many lawyers or accountants you have it is your obligation to support. That’s how it works I don’t make the rules.”

Within a week, Gary texted he was contacting the police and would be suing her for defamation. He also threatened to seek full custody of their daughter.

“You got me pregnant knowing I was a low income single mother just to do this?” the woman wrote back to Gary. “To destroy me? But why? I don’t understand you at all.”

“Continue messaging me,” he replied, “and I’ll make sure you don’t ever work again when I expose what you did to me!”

“Why would (you) want custody over our child,” the mother asked, “when you haven’t even met her, don’t even know her name or birthday?”

In the spring of 2023, a case to establish Gary’s paternity of the woman’s daughter was opened.

A few months earlier, the woman had grown suspicious. Using information that Gary had shared with her, along with social media and public records, the woman began investigating his background. She reached out to women who she thought might have had Gary’s children, too, and posted about him in private dating groups on Facebook. Most of the mothers were from Texas and Louisiana.

Ultimately, the woman said she connected with more than 20 women who said Gary had tried to get them pregnant. At least eight had become pregnant. Seven gave birth.

One of those women was Nadia. Nadia’s first conversation with the other New Orleans mother was validating. It was a relief to talk with someone who not only believed her story, but had lived it, too.

Nadia’s daughter had at least five other half-siblings — with another on the way. Two of the children would share a birthday. Two of the mothers had the same name. Five would eventually file for child support. Nadia wondered how many more women, and children, might be out there.


The News: 2

Part 2

On his online dating profiles, he listed his qualities: a high net worth, a tall and athletic build, an advanced education. To his partners, he presented himself as a successful professional, savvy business owner and aspiring family man. He didn’t have children, he would tell them, but he said he deeply wanted them.

Gary wore expensive clothes and frequented upscale bars and restaurants. He drove sports cars and Teslas. He owned nicely furnished homes in Dallas and the New Orleans area. He traveled regularly to domestic and foreign destinations.

The Dallas Morning News spoke to nine of Gary’s former partners, including seven who said they gave birth to his children. They said the persona he had crafted didn’t tell the whole story.

The full truth, they said, was much deeper, and darker. Through his attorney, Gary declined to comment for this story.

A distinct pattern

Gary Alton Matthews Jr. 40, was born March 22, 1986.

Growing up, he was known as “Lil Gary” by his family. He was the oldest of three boys. Later, they would be joined by two half-siblings.

When Gary was 13, his family moved from Virginia to the New Orleans area.

Less than two years later, his parents went through a divorce. Gary and his brothers initially lived with his mother and attended Warren Easton Fundamental Senior High School in New Orleans. He later moved in with his father in Greensburg and graduated from Destrehan High School.

Gary was a strong student. He played defensive back in football and second base in baseball. He attended the University of New Orleans, studying biological sciences.

In 2016, Gary bought a house in Mandeville. In 2021, he sold that house and bought a duplex in New Orleans. He moved into one half of the duplex and made preparations to rent out the other side. That same year, he purchased a townhome in Dallas south of downtown.

Gary flew between New Orleans and Dallas multiple times a month. In April 2018, Gary incorporated a private consulting company, Gary Matthews Healthcare Consulting LLC. He told the women he dated that he worked with hospitals on the management of their electronic medical record systems. Five years later, he would transfer that business to his Dallas address.

By 2020, Gary was dating online in the New Orleans area. At least five women said he began dating or sleeping with them that year.

Online, Gary crafted numerous aliases on dating apps and social media profiles. At different times, the women who dated him said he went by Mr. Grey, Philippe Laurent, and, most recently, Paris Matthews. He was active on Instagram and Facebook.

By the end of 2023, the women who said they’d given birth to Gary’s children had connected after one mother investigated Gary’s background and posted about him in private dating groups.

Most of the children — who the mothers say bear a striking resemblance to Gary — were born within a two-year period. Three were born within a few months of each other in 2022. Two were born on the same day, one year apart. Courts in Texas and Louisiana legally confirmed paternity in the four cases in which testing was completed.

Gary followed a similar pattern in his relationships, according to interviews with the nine former partners.

Gary would meet women online. Sometimes it was through mainstream dating apps such as Hinge or Bumble; other times it was through an escort ad or SeekingArrangement, a sugar baby website. Sometimes the relationship was casual. Sometimes it was transactional. Other times the women believed they were in a relationship.

He would arrange dates at his houses in New Orleans and Dallas, and at bars and restaurants in those cities. Gary’s appearance was distinctive — his boyish face was offset by black curls that were prematurely shot through with gray.

Gary seemed dedicated to his work. He talked about his frequent business travel, which he said included flying to different hospitals across the country. It was not unusual for him to be unavailable in person or by text for significant stretches of time.

Early on, the women said, Gary would share his desire to get married and become a father. He might tell a woman that he’d dreamt of her becoming pregnant. Often, he would joke about “going half on a baby,” a reference to an R. Kelly song. He would encourage family planning, asking about ovulation timing and birth control. At his New Orleans duplex, he showed several women a room he thought would work well for a nursery. He didn’t like to wear condoms. Three women said he ejaculated in them without their permission.

If a woman became pregnant, the tenor of the relationship would shift. Gary, those women said, became busy, distant, standoffish. Texts would go unanswered.

According to texts, messages and court records reviewed by The News, Gary would abruptly announce that, not only had he moved to another state, but he was working abroad — Africa, the Middle East, South America or Japan. There might also be a story about a family or health crisis that needed his attention. It was no longer a good time, he would say, to have a baby.

Sometimes, according to texts and interviews, he would suggest abortion. If that didn’t work, he would employ a different strategy.

Maybe the baby, he would say, wasn’t actually his. The women said Gary made it clear they were on their own.

A relationship falls apart

Katlyn Vlasak said Gary followed that pattern closely in his relationship with her.

Katlyn said she began dating Gary in New Orleans in early 2020, when she was 27, after meeting him on Bumble. They dated for more than a year. Katlyn believed they were in an exclusive relationship.

Early on, she said, Gary expressed the desire for children. They had conversations about the importance of bringing them into the world under the right circumstances.

Having children had never been a part of Katlyn’s plans. When she was a child, both of her parents were in the military, and her dad was frequently deployed. Katlyn had acutely felt their absence. She didn’t want to repeat their parenting mistakes in her own life.

Katlyn remained on the fence. She might consider it, for the right person. She thought Gary might be that person. She thought he was charismatic, and he clearly made good money. He took care of her.

Katlyn found out she was pregnant in mid-2021. She was surprised. She had still been taking her birth control pills every day. Maybe, she thought, it was a sign this was meant to be. Katlyn wondered if Gary might propose.

Katlyn’s hopes soon deflated as she struggled to get in touch with Gary to share the news of the pregnancy. She put together a gift bag that included a baby onesie and the positive pregnancy test. When she went to give it to him, no one answered the door, so she left it on his doorstep.

Later, she said she received a text from Gary, who told her his brother had found the gift bag. There was no excitement. There was no proposal. Instead, she said, he wrote to her that it wasn’t a good time.

Katlyn said Gary told her his aunt had been diagnosed with cancer. He was paying for her treatment. He was also paying for his sister’s tuition at Xavier University. He was now working in Dubai. He would be living there for the foreseeable future.

He shared his credit card information with Katlyn and told her to use it to pay for an abortion. She wrote it down on a slip of paper. It was the credit card he used for his business transactions.

She never heard from him again. Katlyn felt her life begin to unravel. Gary might be gone, but her pregnancy — and predicament — were not going anywhere.

Katlyn worked long hours as a bartender. She did not feel as if she could rely on her family for help. She had never intended to become a mother, much less a single mother. In her heart, she knew she could not parent this child, not without the man who had helped create him.

She considered ending the pregnancy like Gary had suggested, but she couldn’t bring herself to do that, either. Katlyn began exploring the idea of adoption. She connected with an agency called Lifelong Adoptions.

Arrangements did not work out with the first two families she spoke with, but she bonded with the third. The couple had strong family support, good jobs and owned their own home. They visited Katlyn in New Orleans and communicated with her daily as her due date approached. Katlyn felt they were the perfect choice.

The adoptive family met Katlyn at a New Orleans hospital when she began experiencing contractions in April 2022. During labor, Katlyn stopped dilating, and the baby’s heart rate dropped, so she underwent a cesarean section. Afterward, she was in agonizing pain, recovering from the dual insults of labor and major abdominal surgery.

Handing off her newborn son to another family, immediately after giving birth, was its own form of agony. Katlyn knew she was making the right decision. It didn’t make the moment any easier.

Finally, Katlyn shared news of the pregnancy with her mother. She hadn’t wanted her mom to confront Gary, try to change her mind about the adoption or become too attached to a baby she did not intend to keep. She didn’t want to tear her mother’s heart out the way she had just torn out her own.

When Katlyn returned home, she had never felt more alone. Nighttime was the worst. For days, she cried herself to sleep. She kept asking herself the same questions. How did this happen? How had this become her life? Wasn’t she smarter than this? She couldn’t help but feel as though Gary had hijacked her life and used her body against her.

Later, she learned she wasn’t the only one. In fact, she was one of at least three Louisiana women who gave birth to Gary’s children in 2022. There was one significant difference in their stories. Gary didn’t know she had gone on to have their baby. She does not know what he might do when he finds out the truth — that, out in the world, he has another child.

Like an SVU episode

Gary Matthews is far from the first man to father multiple children by different women.

In private online dating groups, men who are intent on getting women pregnant are frequent topics of discussion. Some are teenagers or college students. Others are older professionals and prominent members of the community.

Among the most visible are celebrities and public figures such as Elon Musk, who has at least 14 children with four women, and Nick Cannon, who has 12 children with six women. Both men have spoken proudly about fatherhood, the importance of having children and their unconventional families. There have also been cases of fertility doctors using their own sperm instead of that of intended donors to impregnate their patients.

Gary established a more unusual pattern with an inherent tension at its center. He expressed intent in starting a family, many women said, but only up until the moment they fell pregnant. His interest in fatherhood seemed to vanish the moment it became real.

Nadia Sutton, one of the mothers of Gary’s children, didn’t compare him to the Elon Musks or the Nick Cannons of the world. She recognized aspects of his behavior elsewhere.

There is an episode of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit where a man fathers as many as 47 children in multiple states and countries over the course of a decade. In the season 12 episode, attorney Ken Turner, played by John Stamos, deliberately impregnates a series of women by poking holes in condoms. The detectives on the case call him a reproductive abuser.

Turner tells one of the detectives he is “trying to follow my natural male urge to procreate” and insists he is enriching the women’s lives “with my progeny, and my money.”

“How much time do you spend with your kids?” the detective asks him. “Because it seems to me you spend all of it trying to make more. See, being a father is about support. Not spawn.”

“The only difference,” Nadia said of Stamos’ portrayal, “is he sends a check every month to every child’s mother.”

The desire to get a woman pregnant and the desire to have children with her stem from different psychological impulses, said Justin Lehmiller, a social psychologist specializing in human sexuality and senior research fellow with the Kinsey Institute at Indiana University. Lehmiller, who also hosts the podcast Sex and Psychology, has studied sexual fantasy and authored a textbook on the psychology of human sexuality.

Getting someone pregnant, Lehmiller said, touches on themes of masculinity and virility — a man wanting to spread his seed and genes, thereby perpetuating his likeness and image in the world. Evolutionarily, humans are hardwired to want to pass on their traits through the creation of offspring.

In a survey of more than 4,000 people that Lehmiller conducted for his 2018 book, Tell Me What You Want, 31% of male respondents said they had fantasized about getting someone pregnant. Women, meanwhile, are commonly attracted to men who appear to be financially stable, who can protect and provide.

Wanting to have a child, Lehmiller said, is a deeper and more meaningful desire. That impulse is about nurturing and supporting the growth of another human being. Lehmiller said he cannot diagnose Gary or surmise his motivations. He offered this general observation, based on The News’ reporting.

“It sounds like what we would refer to in this area of work as reproductive coercion,” he said, “where somebody is trying to manipulate another person’s reproductive choices for power, control, validation, or some other personal goal.”

Reproductive coercion, according to the American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists, includes the explicit attempt to impregnate a woman through pressure, persuasion or by tampering with contraception. It’s one of the most serious betrayals, Lehmiller said, that can occur within a relationship.

In a healthy, supportive relationship, the desire to have a baby and start a family together is often a positive sign of a relationship’s strength. When that pregnancy is achieved through reproductive coercion, it undermines that idea, said Karen Trister Grace, an assistant professor at George Mason University’s School of Nursing.

Lehmiller sees a parallel between Gary’s behavior and the growing prevalence of online romance scams, which involve creating a deep connection under false pretenses. While dating apps can work incredibly well for some people, Lehmiller said, they can also provide a new avenue for those who are looking to exploit and take advantage of others. As with any scam, Lehmiller said, it’s common for victims to feel intense shame and embarrassment.

His ‘thing’

Rosalyn Lillard felt like she narrowly escaped the shame and embarrassment felt by some of the mothers of Gary’s children.

Rosalyn said she began seeing Gary in 2016 in Pittsburgh, after meeting him on SeekingArrangement, a sugar baby website. On his profile, she said, his name was listed as “Suit & Ties.” Gary was in town for work. She remembers his profile indicating he was looking for a relationship, not an escort.

At the time, she was in her mid-20s and sleeping on a mattress in her mother’s dining room. The idea of entering a sugar baby arrangement seemed attractive. The second time Gary picked her up from her mother’s house, she said he handed her $350 in cash, and they went to eat at BJ’s.

For years, Rosalyn said Gary would periodically pay for her to fly from Pennsylvania to Louisiana, where she would meet him at his home in Mandeville and, later, his one in New Orleans. He seemed like a normal guy. The first time they had sex, Rosalyn said, Gary did not use a condom, and he ejaculated inside of her without her permission. She told him to never do that again. They had just met, and she didn’t want to get pregnant.

At one point, Rosalyn stopped seeing Gary when she entered a longterm relationship. When it ended, she reconnected with Gary at the end of 2021. She agreed to visit him in Louisiana over a long weekend in early 2022.

One night, Gary took Rosalyn to a party. Gary was walking ahead of her when she said she was stopped by another woman who looked visibly pregnant. The woman asked Rosalyn if she wanted to meet Gary’s baby. She also warned Rosalyn to be careful; Gary wasn’t kidding when he said he wanted to get her pregnant. Rosalyn was shaken by the encounter. When she asked Gary who that was, he told her it was an ex-girlfriend. Her baby, he said, wasn’t his.

“I do not have any kids,” Rosalyn said Gary told her.

Rosalyn didn’t believe him. She would soon learn she was pregnant with Gary’s child. The following month, she texted Gary a photo of a faintly positive pregnancy test. Gary responded with his own news. He said he had just been diagnosed with prostate cancer. He was also about to book a three-week trip to Canada for work. He was lying, Rosalyn assumed. Again.

“I don’t know why you would very intentionally get me pregnant,” she texted him, “when you knew you had all that going on.”

Days passed. Rosalyn realized Gary had blocked her on Facebook. Gary sent another text. He was packing to move to Utah with his mom for cancer treatment.

“I was not planning for this to happen or to have to make these types decisions with life at the drop of a dime,” he wrote. “I will try to call you today but I dunno about the baby stuff ma’am I don’t even know if I’m 100 percent sure I’ll best cancer I’m hopeful but we shouldn’t chance it.”

“This feels extremely fabricated,” Rosalyn replied.

“You don’t have to call,” she added. “You have a lot goin on. It’s very clear that whatever I end up doing is on me.”

A few days later, Rosalyn had made a decision. She asked Gary to send her money for an abortion. He sent $400. Rosalyn shared a screenshot of the transaction with The News, as well as medical records from an ultrasound.

Rosalyn terminated the pregnancy in March, the month before Katlyn gave birth to Gary’s son. The following year, Rosalyn found out about the other women in Gary’s life. Oh, she realized. This was his thing.

The more Rosalyn learned about what had happened to other women whom Gary had gotten pregnant, the more she felt relieved. The mothers of Gary’s children were all in the position she had chosen to avoid — single parenthood.

“Where are the legal stops,” she said, “to prevent somebody from destroying a dozen lives like this?”

Lacking legal protections

The reality is there aren’t many legal protections for deception that occurs within intimate relationships, said Jill Hasday, a law professor with the University of Minnesota who specializes in family and anti-discrimination law and legal history.

Hasday extensively studied deception between sexual partners, spouses and family members for her 2019 book, Intimate Lies and the Law. She has examined bigamists, adulterers and those who commit reproductive coercion.

If she learned one thing from that research, it’s that anyone can potentially be vulnerable to this kind of deception. Deceit in relationships, which includes violations of sexual autonomy and bodily integrity, Hasday writes in her book, can destroy lives. It is a betrayal that is particularly egregious, she writes, because it occurs within the bounds of relationships that are supposed to be based on a foundation of trust.

Biological parenthood in particular, Hasday writes, is an area that is ripe for intimate deception by men and women alike. There are women who try to entrap men through pregnancy or identify the wrong man as the father of their children. There are men who conceal the fact that they have fathered a child, maintain secret second families or deny paternity of a child they know to be theirs.

People lie, Hasday writes, about using or tampering with birth control, getting vasectomies, the existence of pregnancies and their desire or intent to have children.

Too often, Hasday said, the law fails to have remedies for such deception, even when physical, emotional or financial harm occurs. Lawsuits that involve deception in a business transaction are common. Lawsuits that seek redress for deception that led to the birth of a child tend to be less successful.

In the absence of clear legal remedies, Hasday said, victims tend to rely on self-help. They might find others in similar circumstances to lean on. Such was the case with the mothers of Gary’s children.

Family litigation can itself, Hasday said, become a tool of abuse and replicate the power imbalances in abusive relationships. She views Gary’s behavior, based on The News’ reporting, as abusive on multiple levels — the deceit around conception, the deceit around the paternity tests and his avoidance of paying the child support he owes. In all three areas, she said, Gary is alleged to have gone to extreme lengths.

Another aspect of Gary’s cases, Hasday said, is an uncomfortable truth of family law — that it can force a parent to pay for their children, but it cannot force them to be a part of their lives.

Wendy Murphy, a former sex crimes prosecutor and professor at New England Law Boston, agrees. Murphy, who co-founded the school’s Women’s and Children’s Advocacy Project, has long studied systemic problems in the legal system that mistreat and harm women. She has seen the courts award parental rights to rapists and domestic abusers.

These ingrained biases are highly visible in family court, Murphy said, because the proceedings by design are gendered, men against women. While some men may hold the belief that family court, and in particular custody battles, favor mothers, Murphy sees the system differently.

In that system, she said, there is a disproportionate capacity for judges to mistreat women through rulings, delays, assessment of mental health issues, biased language and inherent skepticism of women’s claims. Men, meanwhile, often have better resources to represent themselves. And they are afforded baseline rights as a father, even if they have never cared for — or even met — their children.

It would be a mistake, Murphy said, to view Gary’s behavior simply through the prism of family law. She believes men should be held accountable not only for the financial consequences of having a child, but for the reproductive coercion that produced the child.

The circumstances under which the women became pregnant, his response to the pregnancies, his repeated denials of paternity, his failure to pay child support and his lack of interest in the children leave Murphy with this conclusion.

Gary, she said, doesn’t deserve to be called a father.


Apparently they have not published part 3 yet. I will try to remember to come back and update the entire story when all 5 parts are out (assuming they’re not paywalled at which case I’m sorry!)

As a reminder, the actual news article has images and screenshots of text messages and such. If you’re interested I highly recommend going to the article.

Please remember I am not the OP, do not contact the OP!

I am not the OOP, this is a repost community.

OOP is: u/kaitkaitlynlyn Originally posted to: r/legaladvice

Trigger Warning

stealthing, sexual assault, sex worker, loss of a child, manipulation, coercion, lies and deceit

Editors Note: This is a LONG one, in a news article and only parts 1 and 2 of 5 are out. You may want to save this for when all 5 parts are released.

Here is a link to part 1 if you’d prefer to read it in it’s original format with all the images intact. There are several screenshots of text messages that may be interesting to most people. I would recommend ad block though. Below is the original Reddit post that got us to this news article.


Original Post

2023

So I was dating this man for around 2 years when we decided to have a baby. We tracked my ovulation schedule and finally got pregnant. He ghosted me 2 months before my due date and I ended up having my child a month early. I have not heard from him since my child was born 10 months ago, with the exception of a text stating that he did not believe the child was his.

Fast forward and I came into contact with other women that he has done this to through a Facebook group. My child has 4 known siblings and there are 3 open child support cases against this man. One of the mothers received the dna results for her child and it said that he was not the father. She knew that he was the father so she ordered an Ancestry DNA kit and ran the kit on her child. The test results came back and connected her child with this man’s immediate family. She took that evidence to her state appointed attorney and her attorney requested that the test be retaken through their facility. The paternal father opposed and fought it in court.

He was not there because he was “in Greece for work” so he had his attorney represent him to argue why he shouldn’t have to take another DNA test. The other mother’s attorney stated that he had taken the test at a labcorp 150 miles from his home before he was even ordered to take it and consistently requested that the state accept that sample in place of him going through DDC. Her attorney finally authorized it because it was through a reputable company. However, the suspicions surrounding the case should call for a new court ordered DNA test through DDC.

His attorney argued that the paternal father shouldn’t have to take another test and that he took the test at that specific location due to being there for work. He then proceeded to defend the paternal father by saying that these are highly offensive allegations but that the paternal party was willing to take another test through ddc and he actually had went and paid for one through DDC “with his own money.” He continued to say that all the mother had to do was to bring her child to the facility to get tested. He then showed the judge a copy of where he had scheduled a test.

The other mother’s attorney objected and stated that her client has severe anxiety about that and that her client would pay for the new test to be done at one of the state designated facilities. The judge agreed and now he has to retake a new dna test through DDC but now the mother is paying for it.

His attorney panicked and ran up to the judge frantically waving the paper saying that he had already paid for the test and that his name would already be in the system and the judge did not care and said that her ruling was final.

After leaving the court room, his attorney passed the other mother and I in the hallway and the other mother stated “You should know more about your client.” And he responded by yelling “I KNOW MY CLIENT.” He then proceeded to walk aggressively down the hall, punching the air and saying “I know that’s not his baby!!!” He was making an absolute ass out of himself to the extent to where people were laughing at him. I feel like he knows the truth and that’s why his attorney reacted that way.

The test has not yet been scheduled but I worry that he’s going to bribe someone on this one as well being as he has ALOT of money. We have stacks of evidence against him and all of our children look very veryyyyyyy similar. What should I do? He has not yet been served for my child’s case but I’m concerned that he will do the same thing to me. What are the consequences of falsifying a dna test? Will I even be able to receive child support if this man is incarcerated?

It’s all tooooooo much


Update

Oct 12, 2026

Just an update on a previous post where I was seeking legal advice regarding my son’s biological father submitting a falsified dna test to the court. The Dallas News is running a series about it that began releasing this morning. I feel anxious but validated.

Location: Dallas, Texas News Article Here

Editor’s Note I believe there’s a post in between that I’m missing where OP shows what happened to her.


The News

Part 1

She was 22 and still mourning a pair of losses: her 3-month-old son, to sudden infant death syndrome, and her partner, to murder. Spiraling, she transitioned from exotic dancing to working as an escort.

When she said a man named Gary contacted her through one of her escort ads, she viewed it as an opportunity. They made arrangements to meet at his house in Mandeville, a suburb of New Orleans situated on the north shore of Lake Pontchartrain.

Nadia wasn’t intending to have sex with Gary that night. They had negotiated a price of $500, but they never agreed to anything specific. Still, she stowed a condom in her bra.

When Nadia arrived, Gary offered her a drink. She happily accepted.

Gary — who would later move to Dallas and split time between there and New Orleans — talked about his travels and work. Nadia shared what had happened with her son and partner.

As the night progressed and Nadia grew more intoxicated, she decided it would be beneficial to take Gary on as a client. He seemed cool, like he had his life together. And he wasn’t bad looking, either. Nadia said Gary told her he couldn’t use the condom because he was allergic to latex.

During sex, Nadia said Gary asked three times if he could ejaculate inside of her. Each time, she said no. The third time, she said, he did it anyway. As Nadia drove home to New Orleans, she said she received a text. It was from Gary.

“We’re about to go half on a baby.”

The saga of Gary Alton Matthews Jr.

This is much more than the story of one woman’s bad sexual encounter. What Gary had done to her, he had done before, Nadia would learn, and he would do it again. There were other women with stories similar to hers — not only in Louisiana, but also in North Texas.

Over the next six years, she would discover at least six other women who felt betrayed by him, leading to contentious legal disputes — some of which are still playing out in courtrooms from Dallas to Phoenix to Covington, La.

The saga of Gary Alton Matthews Jr., full of twists and turns, is not just a tale of salacious deceit. This is a story about a pattern of behavior that left a trail of financial hardship, abandoned children and broken homes in its wake. This is a story about a group of women who banded together, after enduring shame and shock, to advocate for themselves and their children.

It is a story about the limits of the family court system, which allowed one well-resourced man to evade accountability through the employ of private DNA tests, high-priced attorneys, the concealment of assets and what government attorneys in Texas and Louisiana contend is perjury and fraud. It’s about wasted taxpayer dollars, missed opportunities and unserved justice.

The legal cases against Gary are outliers but also emblematic of broader problems in the family court system. Relatively few cases involve years of contentious litigation or allegations of fraud, as Gary’s did, or result in hundreds of thousands of dollars being owed. Still, his cases illustrate challenges confronted by so many other Texas mothers who pursue and are owed child support in a state that collects more of it than any other, through a court system that is slow to react and favors those who can afford legal representation.

Through his attorney, Gary declined to speak with The Dallas Morning News. His version of events is largely represented through his testimony contained in nearly 4,900 pages of court records, as well as messages and emails shared with The News by nine of his former partners.

‘Lost dog’

Nadia didn’t want to have a baby with a man she had just met. A man who, she said, after that first text, had asked if she was ovulating. Her intuition told her that something about the situation was off. As a precaution, Nadia took Plan B.

What she didn’t know was that she was, in fact, already ovulating. Plan B temporarily delays ovulation but isn’t effective when an egg has already been released. Two weeks later, a faint line appeared on a home pregnancy test. When Nadia shared the news with Gary, he asked her what she wanted to do. She said she wanted to end the pregnancy.

Nadia said he agreed to send her money for an abortion, but he preferred that she keep the baby. She said he told her he really wanted to be a father. They could develop a relationship. He would be there for the baby. Nadia thought about the baby boy she had lost, who never had the chance to live. Maybe, she thought, having this baby could become a catalyst to better her life.

Around Father’s Day, Nadia agreed to go to dinner with Gary. Already, she said, he acted as if they were in a relationship. That night, they slept together again. When Nadia woke the next morning, she said Gary wasn’t in the bedroom. As she went to put her clothes back on, she said she saw something on the floor next to the bed. It was a pair of women’s underwear, size small. They weren’t hers.

Without speaking to Gary, she left.

When he texted, asking where she went, Nadia told him to check the side of his bed. She said Gary responded with a long text. He was an upstanding man, he said. The underwear, he said, belonged to a cousin who would house sit while he was out of town.

As the pregnancy progressed, Nadia struggled to reach Gary. When he finally responded, she said, he told her he was in Africa and could file for child support after the baby was born. Nadia wasn’t buying that story. She drove by his house in Mandeville. She could see he was home.

Nadia assumed he would be. She had already printed out a stack of homemade flyers. They included a picture of Gary under the title “LOST DOG.”

The flyer read, in part: “Spends a lot of time prowling the internet for escorts. Has a fetish for intentionally getting women pregnant. Acts like he wants to be involved and then goes non responsive. Lies constantly.” Nadia taped one to Gary’s door. She put others on a stop sign and in the neighbors’ mailboxes.

A private paternity test

Nadia gave birth to a baby girl in January 2021 in New Orleans. She filed for child support from her hospital bed.

Over the next year, the case proceeded slowly. Nadia moved on with her life, and so did Gary. A few months after the baby’s birth, he purchased a townhome in Dallas and began splitting his time between Texas and Louisiana. A few months after that, Nadia moved with the baby to Florida.

He did not respond to the court’s summons to establish his paternity and child support obligations. Nadia began contacting Gary’s family members, one of whom suggested a DNA test. That would prove to be anything but simple.

Nadia and Gary exchanged a series of heated messages. The paternity case couldn’t proceed, Nadia told him, until he responded to the court. By August 2022, Gary still had not responded to the court. A judge entered a default judgment legally recognizing Gary as the father.

Two months later, Gary visited a Labcorp location — but not in New Orleans or Dallas, where he spent the majority of his time. He flew to Houston, where a collector at a location on North Gessner Road swabbed the inside of his cheek. She also took Gary’s thumbprint, reviewed his driver’s license and passport and took his photo. Gary listed his home address as the Dallas townhome.

The following day, Gary’s attorney, Donald Rose, contacted the Department of Children & Family Services, which enforced child support for the state of Louisiana. Because of a procedural error, the default judgment was vacated, and Gary would now be allowed to contest his paternity. Rose requested that the department test the DNA sample Gary had just provided in Houston.

The request was received by Maria Treffinger, a longtime attorney with DCFS who litigated child support cases. Treffinger would ultimately become intricately involved in Gary’s legal battles with the mothers of his children.

Treffinger emailed Rose back to tell him the department preferred all testing be completed through DNA Diagnostics Center, commonly known as DDC, the laboratory exclusively contracted to perform testing for the state. The lab ensured neutral collection of samples and a strict chain of custody for legally admissible test results.

That would not be convenient for his client, Rose replied; Gary now lived in Texas and would be working in Toronto for several months.

After exchanging a series of calls and emails with Rose, Treffinger relented, reluctantly. The state would use the Labcorp sample collected in Houston.

Three samples from two different labs — Nadia and her daughter’s from DDC, and Gary’s from Labcorp — were merged. In March 2023, more than two years after Nadia’s daughter was born, the paternity results were in. There was a 0% chance, they showed, that Gary was the father of Nadia’s child.

Turning to Ancestry

On Instagram, Gary sent Nadia a screenshot of the paternity test. The series of accompanying messages was gleeful, and gloating.

“DNA proves you’re delusional,” he wrote, with a crying laughing emoji. “Now it’s my turn to get compensated on your defamation.”

“Maybe you should actually go find your baby daddy instead of stalking me. A restraining and protective order will be sent your way soon.”

“Move on with your life. Remove any content or stupid s— you put out about me and go live your life. If you continue to harass or defame me, I’m going to tie you up in court and take hundreds of thousands from you.”

Nadia was stunned.

“SO HOWD YA MANAGE THAT ONE GARY?” she messaged back, adding that she planned to dispute the results. “There is absolutely NO WAY she’s not your child.”

“What’d you do? Pay someone off? Slip someone else’s dna into a tube in your mouth or sum?”

Again and again, Gary sent Nadia the paternity test results.

At one point, Nadia recalls Gary saying something that puzzled her: No matter what she thought or did, a DNA test would never identify him as the father.

The phrasing confused Nadia. What on earth, she wondered, did that mean?

Nadia called Treffinger. She knew it sounded crazy — and she didn’t know how Gary had managed it — but it was impossible for anyone else to be the father of her child. Please, Nadia asked, couldn’t the state conduct another test? Treffinger respectfully listened to Nadia’s concerns, but Nadia got the impression that taking her call was a courtesy. After all, Treffinger told her, Gary had taken the test. The results spoke for themselves.

Nadia refused to accept them. She ordered a DNA test from Ancestry, the genealogy website. Within days, it was on her doorstep. Obtaining a DNA sample from her 2-year-old was no easy task. Somehow, she managed to get her daughter’s saliva into the test tube.

A few weeks later, Nadia logged onto her account to check the results. The first thing she noticed: Gary’s half-sister shared 11% of her DNA with her daughter. There was more: Relatives with Gary’s last name and his mother’s maiden name also showed up as familial matches.

Nadia sent screenshots of the results to Gary. He responded with a crying-laughing emoji.

“I wasn’t going to sue you for defamation but I will now,” he wrote back. “I’m not kin to any of those people.”

Nadia also emailed the screenshots to Treffinger, who called her.

The testing process, Treffinger acknowledged, had been highly unusual. It had been handled outside of the court’s normal procedures due to what she called pressure from Gary’s attorney. She would request another test. Treffinger filed a motion with the court in June 2023. The paternity results were not the only thing that caused Nadia to doubt Gary’s truthfulness. There was much more that he was hiding.

‘You won’t get a penny’

The same year Nadia met Gary, a single mother in New Orleans connected with him online. After a few months of exchanging messages, they met in person and began seeing each other.

For months, the woman — who asked The News not to identify her due to fear of retaliation and to protect the identity of her child — said she believed she had developed a close friendship with Gary. The News verified her account through a review of court records and other public records, text messages and emails and other interviews. He bought the woman’s child an expensive gift and brought her on an international trip.

Early on, the woman, who was in her 30s, said Gary told her he wanted to go “half on a baby” with her, a reference to an R. Kelly lyric. She said they both were open to having children. The summer of 2021 — around the same time Nadia’s child support case was opened — the woman found out she was pregnant. She told Gary. Suddenly, she said, he disappeared. She said he stopped talking to her on all platforms.

Embarrassed, she hid the pregnancy from her family for seven months. All that time, she still hadn’t heard from Gary. Before she gave birth, she sent out baby shower invitations to his parents. They did not respond or attend. The woman gave birth in New Orleans in May 2022. It was a girl. The new mother sent out a birth announcement.

A few months later, still having not heard from Gary, she texted him, asking him to send her $700 a month to support their daughter until she was in pre-kindergarten. When Gary didn’t respond, she told him she intended to file for child support. This time, he responded. He told her he had moved to Toronto and suggested the child was not his. He was also angry she had sent the baby shower invitations and birth announcement to his parents.

“I promise you if you go to the courts you won’t get a penny from me,” he wrote to her. “Don’t threaten me I’m not the one.”

“When you make a baby you have to be at least financially responsible for them,” the mother replied. “Yea it’s your choice to pretend they don’t exist but legally it doesn’t matter how many lawyers or accountants you have it is your obligation to support. That’s how it works I don’t make the rules.”

Within a week, Gary texted he was contacting the police and would be suing her for defamation. He also threatened to seek full custody of their daughter.

“You got me pregnant knowing I was a low income single mother just to do this?” the woman wrote back to Gary. “To destroy me? But why? I don’t understand you at all.”

“Continue messaging me,” he replied, “and I’ll make sure you don’t ever work again when I expose what you did to me!”

“Why would (you) want custody over our child,” the mother asked, “when you haven’t even met her, don’t even know her name or birthday?”

In the spring of 2023, a case to establish Gary’s paternity of the woman’s daughter was opened.

A few months earlier, the woman had grown suspicious. Using information that Gary had shared with her, along with social media and public records, the woman began investigating his background. She reached out to women who she thought might have had Gary’s children, too, and posted about him in private dating groups on Facebook. Most of the mothers were from Texas and Louisiana.

Ultimately, the woman said she connected with more than 20 women who said Gary had tried to get them pregnant. At least eight had become pregnant. Seven gave birth.

One of those women was Nadia. Nadia’s first conversation with the other New Orleans mother was validating. It was a relief to talk with someone who not only believed her story, but had lived it, too.

Nadia’s daughter had at least five other half-siblings — with another on the way. Two of the children would share a birthday. Two of the mothers had the same name. Five would eventually file for child support. Nadia wondered how many more women, and children, might be out there.


The News: 2

Part 2

On his online dating profiles, he listed his qualities: a high net worth, a tall and athletic build, an advanced education. To his partners, he presented himself as a successful professional, savvy business owner and aspiring family man. He didn’t have children, he would tell them, but he said he deeply wanted them.

Gary wore expensive clothes and frequented upscale bars and restaurants. He drove sports cars and Teslas. He owned nicely furnished homes in Dallas and the New Orleans area. He traveled regularly to domestic and foreign destinations.

The Dallas Morning News spoke to nine of Gary’s former partners, including seven who said they gave birth to his children. They said the persona he had crafted didn’t tell the whole story.

The full truth, they said, was much deeper, and darker. Through his attorney, Gary declined to comment for this story.

A distinct pattern

Gary Alton Matthews Jr. 40, was born March 22, 1986.

Growing up, he was known as “Lil Gary” by his family. He was the oldest of three boys. Later, they would be joined by two half-siblings.

When Gary was 13, his family moved from Virginia to the New Orleans area.

Less than two years later, his parents went through a divorce. Gary and his brothers initially lived with his mother and attended Warren Easton Fundamental Senior High School in New Orleans. He later moved in with his father in Greensburg and graduated from Destrehan High School.

Gary was a strong student. He played defensive back in football and second base in baseball. He attended the University of New Orleans, studying biological sciences.

In 2016, Gary bought a house in Mandeville. In 2021, he sold that house and bought a duplex in New Orleans. He moved into one half of the duplex and made preparations to rent out the other side. That same year, he purchased a townhome in Dallas south of downtown.

Gary flew between New Orleans and Dallas multiple times a month. In April 2018, Gary incorporated a private consulting company, Gary Matthews Healthcare Consulting LLC. He told the women he dated that he worked with hospitals on the management of their electronic medical record systems. Five years later, he would transfer that business to his Dallas address.

By 2020, Gary was dating online in the New Orleans area. At least five women said he began dating or sleeping with them that year.

Online, Gary crafted numerous aliases on dating apps and social media profiles. At different times, the women who dated him said he went by Mr. Grey, Philippe Laurent, and, most recently, Paris Matthews. He was active on Instagram and Facebook.

By the end of 2023, the women who said they’d given birth to Gary’s children had connected after one mother investigated Gary’s background and posted about him in private dating groups.

Most of the children — who the mothers say bear a striking resemblance to Gary — were born within a two-year period. Three were born within a few months of each other in 2022. Two were born on the same day, one year apart. Courts in Texas and Louisiana legally confirmed paternity in the four cases in which testing was completed.

Gary followed a similar pattern in his relationships, according to interviews with the nine former partners.

Gary would meet women online. Sometimes it was through mainstream dating apps such as Hinge or Bumble; other times it was through an escort ad or SeekingArrangement, a sugar baby website. Sometimes the relationship was casual. Sometimes it was transactional. Other times the women believed they were in a relationship.

He would arrange dates at his houses in New Orleans and Dallas, and at bars and restaurants in those cities. Gary’s appearance was distinctive — his boyish face was offset by black curls that were prematurely shot through with gray.

Gary seemed dedicated to his work. He talked about his frequent business travel, which he said included flying to different hospitals across the country. It was not unusual for him to be unavailable in person or by text for significant stretches of time.

Early on, the women said, Gary would share his desire to get married and become a father. He might tell a woman that he’d dreamt of her becoming pregnant. Often, he would joke about “going half on a baby,” a reference to an R. Kelly song. He would encourage family planning, asking about ovulation timing and birth control. At his New Orleans duplex, he showed several women a room he thought would work well for a nursery. He didn’t like to wear condoms. Three women said he ejaculated in them without their permission.

If a woman became pregnant, the tenor of the relationship would shift. Gary, those women said, became busy, distant, standoffish. Texts would go unanswered.

According to texts, messages and court records reviewed by The News, Gary would abruptly announce that, not only had he moved to another state, but he was working abroad — Africa, the Middle East, South America or Japan. There might also be a story about a family or health crisis that needed his attention. It was no longer a good time, he would say, to have a baby.

Sometimes, according to texts and interviews, he would suggest abortion. If that didn’t work, he would employ a different strategy.

Maybe the baby, he would say, wasn’t actually his. The women said Gary made it clear they were on their own.

A relationship falls apart

Katlyn Vlasak said Gary followed that pattern closely in his relationship with her.

Katlyn said she began dating Gary in New Orleans in early 2020, when she was 27, after meeting him on Bumble. They dated for more than a year. Katlyn believed they were in an exclusive relationship.

Early on, she said, Gary expressed the desire for children. They had conversations about the importance of bringing them into the world under the right circumstances.

Having children had never been a part of Katlyn’s plans. When she was a child, both of her parents were in the military, and her dad was frequently deployed. Katlyn had acutely felt their absence. She didn’t want to repeat their parenting mistakes in her own life.

Katlyn remained on the fence. She might consider it, for the right person. She thought Gary might be that person. She thought he was charismatic, and he clearly made good money. He took care of her.

Katlyn found out she was pregnant in mid-2021. She was surprised. She had still been taking her birth control pills every day. Maybe, she thought, it was a sign this was meant to be. Katlyn wondered if Gary might propose.

Katlyn’s hopes soon deflated as she struggled to get in touch with Gary to share the news of the pregnancy. She put together a gift bag that included a baby onesie and the positive pregnancy test. When she went to give it to him, no one answered the door, so she left it on his doorstep.

Later, she said she received a text from Gary, who told her his brother had found the gift bag. There was no excitement. There was no proposal. Instead, she said, he wrote to her that it wasn’t a good time.

Katlyn said Gary told her his aunt had been diagnosed with cancer. He was paying for her treatment. He was also paying for his sister’s tuition at Xavier University. He was now working in Dubai. He would be living there for the foreseeable future.

He shared his credit card information with Katlyn and told her to use it to pay for an abortion. She wrote it down on a slip of paper. It was the credit card he used for his business transactions.

She never heard from him again. Katlyn felt her life begin to unravel. Gary might be gone, but her pregnancy — and predicament — were not going anywhere.

Katlyn worked long hours as a bartender. She did not feel as if she could rely on her family for help. She had never intended to become a mother, much less a single mother. In her heart, she knew she could not parent this child, not without the man who had helped create him.

She considered ending the pregnancy like Gary had suggested, but she couldn’t bring herself to do that, either. Katlyn began exploring the idea of adoption. She connected with an agency called Lifelong Adoptions.

Arrangements did not work out with the first two families she spoke with, but she bonded with the third. The couple had strong family support, good jobs and owned their own home. They visited Katlyn in New Orleans and communicated with her daily as her due date approached. Katlyn felt they were the perfect choice.

The adoptive family met Katlyn at a New Orleans hospital when she began experiencing contractions in April 2022. During labor, Katlyn stopped dilating, and the baby’s heart rate dropped, so she underwent a cesarean section. Afterward, she was in agonizing pain, recovering from the dual insults of labor and major abdominal surgery.

Handing off her newborn son to another family, immediately after giving birth, was its own form of agony. Katlyn knew she was making the right decision. It didn’t make the moment any easier.

Finally, Katlyn shared news of the pregnancy with her mother. She hadn’t wanted her mom to confront Gary, try to change her mind about the adoption or become too attached to a baby she did not intend to keep. She didn’t want to tear her mother’s heart out the way she had just torn out her own.

When Katlyn returned home, she had never felt more alone. Nighttime was the worst. For days, she cried herself to sleep. She kept asking herself the same questions. How did this happen? How had this become her life? Wasn’t she smarter than this? She couldn’t help but feel as though Gary had hijacked her life and used her body against her.

Later, she learned she wasn’t the only one. In fact, she was one of at least three Louisiana women who gave birth to Gary’s children in 2022. There was one significant difference in their stories. Gary didn’t know she had gone on to have their baby. She does not know what he might do when he finds out the truth — that, out in the world, he has another child.

Like an SVU episode

Gary Matthews is far from the first man to father multiple children by different women.

In private online dating groups, men who are intent on getting women pregnant are frequent topics of discussion. Some are teenagers or college students. Others are older professionals and prominent members of the community.

Among the most visible are celebrities and public figures such as Elon Musk, who has at least 14 children with four women, and Nick Cannon, who has 12 children with six women. Both men have spoken proudly about fatherhood, the importance of having children and their unconventional families. There have also been cases of fertility doctors using their own sperm instead of that of intended donors to impregnate their patients.

Gary established a more unusual pattern with an inherent tension at its center. He expressed intent in starting a family, many women said, but only up until the moment they fell pregnant. His interest in fatherhood seemed to vanish the moment it became real.

Nadia Sutton, one of the mothers of Gary’s children, didn’t compare him to the Elon Musks or the Nick Cannons of the world. She recognized aspects of his behavior elsewhere.

There is an episode of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit where a man fathers as many as 47 children in multiple states and countries over the course of a decade. In the season 12 episode, attorney Ken Turner, played by John Stamos, deliberately impregnates a series of women by poking holes in condoms. The detectives on the case call him a reproductive abuser.

Turner tells one of the detectives he is “trying to follow my natural male urge to procreate” and insists he is enriching the women’s lives “with my progeny, and my money.”

“How much time do you spend with your kids?” the detective asks him. “Because it seems to me you spend all of it trying to make more. See, being a father is about support. Not spawn.”

“The only difference,” Nadia said of Stamos’ portrayal, “is he sends a check every month to every child’s mother.”

The desire to get a woman pregnant and the desire to have children with her stem from different psychological impulses, said Justin Lehmiller, a social psychologist specializing in human sexuality and senior research fellow with the Kinsey Institute at Indiana University. Lehmiller, who also hosts the podcast Sex and Psychology, has studied sexual fantasy and authored a textbook on the psychology of human sexuality.

Getting someone pregnant, Lehmiller said, touches on themes of masculinity and virility — a man wanting to spread his seed and genes, thereby perpetuating his likeness and image in the world. Evolutionarily, humans are hardwired to want to pass on their traits through the creation of offspring.

In a survey of more than 4,000 people that Lehmiller conducted for his 2018 book, Tell Me What You Want, 31% of male respondents said they had fantasized about getting someone pregnant. Women, meanwhile, are commonly attracted to men who appear to be financially stable, who can protect and provide.

Wanting to have a child, Lehmiller said, is a deeper and more meaningful desire. That impulse is about nurturing and supporting the growth of another human being. Lehmiller said he cannot diagnose Gary or surmise his motivations. He offered this general observation, based on The News’ reporting.

“It sounds like what we would refer to in this area of work as reproductive coercion,” he said, “where somebody is trying to manipulate another person’s reproductive choices for power, control, validation, or some other personal goal.”

Reproductive coercion, according to the American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists, includes the explicit attempt to impregnate a woman through pressure, persuasion or by tampering with contraception. It’s one of the most serious betrayals, Lehmiller said, that can occur within a relationship.

In a healthy, supportive relationship, the desire to have a baby and start a family together is often a positive sign of a relationship’s strength. When that pregnancy is achieved through reproductive coercion, it undermines that idea, said Karen Trister Grace, an assistant professor at George Mason University’s School of Nursing.

Lehmiller sees a parallel between Gary’s behavior and the growing prevalence of online romance scams, which involve creating a deep connection under false pretenses. While dating apps can work incredibly well for some people, Lehmiller said, they can also provide a new avenue for those who are looking to exploit and take advantage of others. As with any scam, Lehmiller said, it’s common for victims to feel intense shame and embarrassment.

His ‘thing’

Rosalyn Lillard felt like she narrowly escaped the shame and embarrassment felt by some of the mothers of Gary’s children.

Rosalyn said she began seeing Gary in 2016 in Pittsburgh, after meeting him on SeekingArrangement, a sugar baby website. On his profile, she said, his name was listed as “Suit & Ties.” Gary was in town for work. She remembers his profile indicating he was looking for a relationship, not an escort.

At the time, she was in her mid-20s and sleeping on a mattress in her mother’s dining room. The idea of entering a sugar baby arrangement seemed attractive. The second time Gary picked her up from her mother’s house, she said he handed her $350 in cash, and they went to eat at BJ’s.

For years, Rosalyn said Gary would periodically pay for her to fly from Pennsylvania to Louisiana, where she would meet him at his home in Mandeville and, later, his one in New Orleans. He seemed like a normal guy. The first time they had sex, Rosalyn said, Gary did not use a condom, and he ejaculated inside of her without her permission. She told him to never do that again. They had just met, and she didn’t want to get pregnant.

At one point, Rosalyn stopped seeing Gary when she entered a longterm relationship. When it ended, she reconnected with Gary at the end of 2021. She agreed to visit him in Louisiana over a long weekend in early 2022.

One night, Gary took Rosalyn to a party. Gary was walking ahead of her when she said she was stopped by another woman who looked visibly pregnant. The woman asked Rosalyn if she wanted to meet Gary’s baby. She also warned Rosalyn to be careful; Gary wasn’t kidding when he said he wanted to get her pregnant. Rosalyn was shaken by the encounter. When she asked Gary who that was, he told her it was an ex-girlfriend. Her baby, he said, wasn’t his.

“I do not have any kids,” Rosalyn said Gary told her.

Rosalyn didn’t believe him. She would soon learn she was pregnant with Gary’s child. The following month, she texted Gary a photo of a faintly positive pregnancy test. Gary responded with his own news. He said he had just been diagnosed with prostate cancer. He was also about to book a three-week trip to Canada for work. He was lying, Rosalyn assumed. Again.

“I don’t know why you would very intentionally get me pregnant,” she texted him, “when you knew you had all that going on.”

Days passed. Rosalyn realized Gary had blocked her on Facebook. Gary sent another text. He was packing to move to Utah with his mom for cancer treatment.

“I was not planning for this to happen or to have to make these types decisions with life at the drop of a dime,” he wrote. “I will try to call you today but I dunno about the baby stuff ma’am I don’t even know if I’m 100 percent sure I’ll best cancer I’m hopeful but we shouldn’t chance it.”

“This feels extremely fabricated,” Rosalyn replied.

“You don’t have to call,” she added. “You have a lot goin on. It’s very clear that whatever I end up doing is on me.”

A few days later, Rosalyn had made a decision. She asked Gary to send her money for an abortion. He sent $400. Rosalyn shared a screenshot of the transaction with The News, as well as medical records from an ultrasound.

Rosalyn terminated the pregnancy in March, the month before Katlyn gave birth to Gary’s son. The following year, Rosalyn found out about the other women in Gary’s life. Oh, she realized. This was his thing.

The more Rosalyn learned about what had happened to other women whom Gary had gotten pregnant, the more she felt relieved. The mothers of Gary’s children were all in the position she had chosen to avoid — single parenthood.

“Where are the legal stops,” she said, “to prevent somebody from destroying a dozen lives like this?”

Lacking legal protections

The reality is there aren’t many legal protections for deception that occurs within intimate relationships, said Jill Hasday, a law professor with the University of Minnesota who specializes in family and anti-discrimination law and legal history.

Hasday extensively studied deception between sexual partners, spouses and family members for her 2019 book, Intimate Lies and the Law. She has examined bigamists, adulterers and those who commit reproductive coercion.

If she learned one thing from that research, it’s that anyone can potentially be vulnerable to this kind of deception. Deceit in relationships, which includes violations of sexual autonomy and bodily integrity, Hasday writes in her book, can destroy lives. It is a betrayal that is particularly egregious, she writes, because it occurs within the bounds of relationships that are supposed to be based on a foundation of trust.

Biological parenthood in particular, Hasday writes, is an area that is ripe for intimate deception by men and women alike. There are women who try to entrap men through pregnancy or identify the wrong man as the father of their children. There are men who conceal the fact that they have fathered a child, maintain secret second families or deny paternity of a child they know to be theirs.

People lie, Hasday writes, about using or tampering with birth control, getting vasectomies, the existence of pregnancies and their desire or intent to have children.

Too often, Hasday said, the law fails to have remedies for such deception, even when physical, emotional or financial harm occurs. Lawsuits that involve deception in a business transaction are common. Lawsuits that seek redress for deception that led to the birth of a child tend to be less successful.

In the absence of clear legal remedies, Hasday said, victims tend to rely on self-help. They might find others in similar circumstances to lean on. Such was the case with the mothers of Gary’s children.

Family litigation can itself, Hasday said, become a tool of abuse and replicate the power imbalances in abusive relationships. She views Gary’s behavior, based on The News’ reporting, as abusive on multiple levels — the deceit around conception, the deceit around the paternity tests and his avoidance of paying the child support he owes. In all three areas, she said, Gary is alleged to have gone to extreme lengths.

Another aspect of Gary’s cases, Hasday said, is an uncomfortable truth of family law — that it can force a parent to pay for their children, but it cannot force them to be a part of their lives.

Wendy Murphy, a former sex crimes prosecutor and professor at New England Law Boston, agrees. Murphy, who co-founded the school’s Women’s and Children’s Advocacy Project, has long studied systemic problems in the legal system that mistreat and harm women. She has seen the courts award parental rights to rapists and domestic abusers.

These ingrained biases are highly visible in family court, Murphy said, because the proceedings by design are gendered, men against women. While some men may hold the belief that family court, and in particular custody battles, favor mothers, Murphy sees the system differently.

In that system, she said, there is a disproportionate capacity for judges to mistreat women through rulings, delays, assessment of mental health issues, biased language and inherent skepticism of women’s claims. Men, meanwhile, often have better resources to represent themselves. And they are afforded baseline rights as a father, even if they have never cared for — or even met — their children.

It would be a mistake, Murphy said, to view Gary’s behavior simply through the prism of family law. She believes men should be held accountable not only for the financial consequences of having a child, but for the reproductive coercion that produced the child.

The circumstances under which the women became pregnant, his response to the pregnancies, his repeated denials of paternity, his failure to pay child support and his lack of interest in the children leave Murphy with this conclusion.

Gary, she said, doesn’t deserve to be called a father.


Apparently they have not published part 3 yet. I will try to remember to come back and update the entire story when all 5 parts are out (assuming they’re not paywalled at which case I’m sorry!)

As a reminder, the actual news article has images and screenshots of text messages and such. If you’re interested I highly recommend going to the article.

Please remember I am not the OP, do not contact the OP!

0

[Concluded] a job placement firm sent us someone who can’t do the work but they say they’ll lose their funding if we don’t keep her [AAM]

preview

I am not the OOP.

The original post was uploaded to Ask A Manager

Trigger Warning

Bad behavior being excused by a disability

Tap for mood spoiler

Starts bad, continues to terrible, ends OK

This repost was made by a human, not a bot.


Original Post

July 22, 2025

I’m an office manager for a niche type of job — think boats, expensive boats. I’ve been in my job for 20+ years, and we have traditionally had a position filled by a developmentally disabled adult through a nonprofit. “James,” an adult with special needs, worked for us for 10+ years and just retired. He was a great worker with a great attitude. So, we went back to the same nonprofit to fill his space. (The owner of the company fully believes in this organization; his son was a client before he passed away a number of years ago, so this is a non-negotiable).

The job requires the following abilities: answering the phones, managing the supply closets/lists, delivering mail inside the office and to the slips, setting up conference rooms, and general office tasks like filing/copying, etc. James had worked 25-30 hours a week when he was with us and did all of these tasks well.

The nonprofit sent us “Carol.” She is in her 40s and lives with her very wealthy parents. Carol cannot do any of these things and her mother insisted on setting her schedule around her daytime sports pursuits — lessons, clinics, matches. The job is secondary in her life — unlike James who needed a paycheck, Carol does not.

After two weeks of Carol’s placement, which I shall call The Disaster of Hellmouth Proportions, I called the nonprofit and spoke with “Alice.” Alice was cagey on the phone but sympathetic and then asked me to meet her for a coffee. While we’ve worked together during James’ tenure, I had never actually met her. So, I took her up on the coffee.

Alice told me that I had to make this work for Carol. Carol’s parents are extremely wealthy, had just moved in from out of state, and were making six-figure donations to the nonprofit to ensure their daughter received a good job, and they were very choosy. It had to be an office job, daytime, flexible hours — not many offerings in the nonprofit’s realm offered what we did. Alice said that with uncertainty from the federal government, they needed all of the funding they could procure. I told her I totally understood that situation but this woman was not a good fit. I outlined the following issues we had in just the first two weeks. I could not make this up if I tried. I deal with some weird, entitled, and wealthy people all day as part of the job, but nothing like this:

  • Carol cannot answer the phones. She picks it up, laughs into it (maniacally, I might add), and will yell “NO! HELLO! NO!” I’ve been having to cover the phones during the one-hour lunch break our receptionist receives since Carol could not fulfill that duty. I asked the mother to work with her so she could do the phones and the mother told me that was my responsibility!
  • Carol was told to deliver mail to the slips. Her mother left me an incensed voicemail about asking her daughter to go out on the docks because she “wanders.” Again, this is a major part of the job.
  • Carol has discussions with external personas (I don’t know the correct word here). She will argue with herself about random things — imagine the devil and angel on the shoulders from the cartoons. It’s like that, but real. I asked her mother about it and was told that she doesn’t medicate Carol and this is just her way of processing things. It’s upsetting the other people in the office. It has yet to stop and sometimes the external personas will yell at each other.
  • Carol yelled at a delivery man. He set a box down near her workspace and she told him to pick it up “because you’re fat and you need exercise.” I told her and her mother this was unacceptable behavior. Her mother then emailed me that I was “finding reasons to pick on her daughter” and I needed to “do my job and keep her busy.”
  • Carol was asked to staple packets. I showed her what was expected and watched her do a few. I came back 10 minutes later and she had thrown all of the papers on the floor because she “was done and wanted to do fun things.” I told her mother she could not do things like this. Her mother said, “Her last job managed to get her to work. It must be YOU!” (ME!?!?)
  • Carol “borrowed” a bunch of items from the supply closet. When it was discovered, her father came in and brought them all back and suggested we not allow her in there anymore because she was “confused.”

Alice said she was sorry, but her hands were tied. I told her even my boss, who fully believes in their mission and makes donations regularly as well as offering this job to their clients, said this is not a good placement.

A few weeks passed. Carol became more and more of a problem, and so did her mother. The mother came into the office to berate me in front of the rest of the staff for having her daughter set up the meeting space and pick it up afterwards. Apparently, this is “beneath” her! Again, part of the job! The owner happened to be in that day and told the mother to leave and that she was not allowed in our building again. So, now the father comes to “check in” on Carol. He’s a bit more reasonable, I guess.

After that, the owner called the nonprofit himself and also received the “we need this to work out because we need the donations from this family” line. He is friendly with their director, and told me to try and find things to occupy Carol while she’s there and he’s going to tell the parents himself she can only work 10 hours a week. This doesn’t do us any good, and now I’m tasked with finding “parent-approved” tasks for her. I can’t do my own job because I’m constantly keeping eyes on her and doing the parts of her job that she can’t. I’m just waiting for something catastrophic to happen here. I also feel it is totally unethical for this nonprofit to give jobs to those who can afford to “buy” their placements.

I don’t even know what I’m asking. Maybe the readers can chime in with ideas for my survival during Carol’s 10 hours. Any ideas what I can give her to do? She can file pretty well, but we have like … 20 minutes of filing a month, if that. Am I enabling this? Should I let Carol crash and burn to prove how little she’s doing when I’m not picking up her slack? Or would that be too mean to someone with her issues?


Alison’s Response

Can be found here


Update

Dec 12, 2025

I found some menial tasks from the lists given and put Carol on them. She really liked making paper chains, cutting out paper decorations for her desk, and coloring them. I spoke with my boss and Alice (the placement firm contact) about getting a job coach for Carol. I told my boss I needed to hire a second person to do the work Carol wasn’t able to do — which was just about everything on her job description. Alice agreed to “look into” getting a job coach. Carol made lots of paper decorations for her 10 hours a week when we were babysitting. My boss said I could hire someone else to do Carol’s job as a part-timer but to interview candidates in September, when I returned from my long-planned vacation.

Two weeks after I asked Alice for a job coach, she was no longer with the job placement firm. We were back at square one. Then, I went on my vacation for two weeks. In those two weeks, my boss covered for me and got to see just what a problem Carol was firsthand. Highlights of those weeks include:

  • Carol’s dad dropped her off extra early one day. She came into the building and took the receptionist’s chair, replacing it with the one at her desk. The receptionist is an older lady with mobility issues and has a large, high backed chair. Carol’s is a simple office chair like the rest of us. Carol refused to give the chair back even saying “I deserve it!” multiple times while waving her arms threateningly at the receptionist. My boss called her dad to pick her up. The next day, he delivered a pricey office chair for her.
  • Carol’s mother decided to try coming to speak to my boss without me there. She arrived during the day, after Carol had been picked up. My boss told her to leave. She yelled across the office at how much better Carol was doing without me around. My boss told her to leave before he called the cops. She left.
  • One of my coworkers was tasked with giving Carol work. Carol yelled at her and told her, “You don’t tell me what to do!” She did this every day I was gone, despite being told I was going on vacation and “Lauren” would be in charge in my absence.
  • One day, Carol’s external conversations with herself were so loud and out of control my boss called her dad to get her. He was honestly afraid she was going to hurt someone or herself.
  • Carol was asked to wipe down the microwave and sink after she used them during lunch and left a mess. She told my boss, “I’m not a maid. You get a maid to do it!”
  • Carol had another run-in with one of the delivery guys. He asked her to hold the door to the package room since she was coming out and he was going in with a large load. She yelled at him to “do his job” and called him fat. Again.

After all of this, my boss called the organization and said Carol could not come back until they sent a job coach. In the meantime, I hired a high school kid to work part-time after school. Best decision ever.

Three weeks later, Carol came back with a job coach in tow. The coach, Fred, wasn’t great and I don’t even think he was trained as a job coach. He seemed very young and inexperienced and spent a lot of time on his phone. I called the agency and asked about Fred. The director there spoke as if this guy walked on water but I wasn’t seeing it. I asked Fred what his last job was, and he said a front desk clerk at a lower tier hotel chain. He said he took this job because the hours were better. I told him I needed a lot more coaching because paying Carol to cut paper decorations all day was ridiculous. He agreed, but didn’t care enough to actually do something. I called the agency again and was told that he was all they had.

So that brings us up to mid-October. Mid-October is our company’s big fall festival for the employees and our families. Carol showed up with both parents in tow. My boss allowed the mom to be there since we weren’t in the office but in a rented space. The parents spent a lot of time socializing with people, including my boss, but the mother made a clear effort to avoid me.

While this was going on, Carol was wandering around trying to play games that were meant for kids. She was told she couldn’t be in the bounce house, since kids were in there. She wanted a pony ride but was told she was too big. Stuff like that. Then she happened upon the cornhole game. A bunch of kids, probably ages 8 – 12, were playing cornhole while “Danny,” one of our long-time employees, was watching and filming his kids. Carol walked up and grabbed the bags off the board and said it was her turn. Danny told her she could play when they were done. Carol kept yelling that it was her turn. Danny told her to go find her dad. Carol then picked up a cornhole board and threw it across the grass. It struck another employee in the legs. Carol then threw the bags at one of the boys, hitting him in the back.

And that’s when my boss fired her right on the spot and told the dad he could come get the chair and any of her belongings on Monday but they had to leave immediately. The mother threatened discrimination lawsuits and kept yelling and ranting about how she’s never been treated so poorly in her life and how awful we all are — that we needed “more compassion” for Carol.

My boss said get out or he’d call the cops because Carol had just assaulted two people.

The dad at least had the good sense to pull the mom towards the car and then went back to get Carol who was still in mid-tantrum.

They never came back for the chair, so I claimed it as my reward for dealing with this ridiculous family.

The other good news is my new part-timer is a great kid. He’s going to welding school next year and I told him if he ever wants a welding job, he’s got one with us.


Reminder this is a repost community and I am not OOP

I am not the OOP.

The original post was uploaded to Ask A Manager

Trigger Warning

Bad behavior being excused by a disability

Tap for mood spoiler

Starts bad, continues to terrible, ends OK

This repost was made by a human, not a bot.


Original Post

July 22, 2025

I’m an office manager for a niche type of job — think boats, expensive boats. I’ve been in my job for 20+ years, and we have traditionally had a position filled by a developmentally disabled adult through a nonprofit. “James,” an adult with special needs, worked for us for 10+ years and just retired. He was a great worker with a great attitude. So, we went back to the same nonprofit to fill his space. (The owner of the company fully believes in this organization; his son was a client before he passed away a number of years ago, so this is a non-negotiable).

The job requires the following abilities: answering the phones, managing the supply closets/lists, delivering mail inside the office and to the slips, setting up conference rooms, and general office tasks like filing/copying, etc. James had worked 25-30 hours a week when he was with us and did all of these tasks well.

The nonprofit sent us “Carol.” She is in her 40s and lives with her very wealthy parents. Carol cannot do any of these things and her mother insisted on setting her schedule around her daytime sports pursuits — lessons, clinics, matches. The job is secondary in her life — unlike James who needed a paycheck, Carol does not.

After two weeks of Carol’s placement, which I shall call The Disaster of Hellmouth Proportions, I called the nonprofit and spoke with “Alice.” Alice was cagey on the phone but sympathetic and then asked me to meet her for a coffee. While we’ve worked together during James’ tenure, I had never actually met her. So, I took her up on the coffee.

Alice told me that I had to make this work for Carol. Carol’s parents are extremely wealthy, had just moved in from out of state, and were making six-figure donations to the nonprofit to ensure their daughter received a good job, and they were very choosy. It had to be an office job, daytime, flexible hours — not many offerings in the nonprofit’s realm offered what we did. Alice said that with uncertainty from the federal government, they needed all of the funding they could procure. I told her I totally understood that situation but this woman was not a good fit. I outlined the following issues we had in just the first two weeks. I could not make this up if I tried. I deal with some weird, entitled, and wealthy people all day as part of the job, but nothing like this:

  • Carol cannot answer the phones. She picks it up, laughs into it (maniacally, I might add), and will yell “NO! HELLO! NO!” I’ve been having to cover the phones during the one-hour lunch break our receptionist receives since Carol could not fulfill that duty. I asked the mother to work with her so she could do the phones and the mother told me that was my responsibility!
  • Carol was told to deliver mail to the slips. Her mother left me an incensed voicemail about asking her daughter to go out on the docks because she “wanders.” Again, this is a major part of the job.
  • Carol has discussions with external personas (I don’t know the correct word here). She will argue with herself about random things — imagine the devil and angel on the shoulders from the cartoons. It’s like that, but real. I asked her mother about it and was told that she doesn’t medicate Carol and this is just her way of processing things. It’s upsetting the other people in the office. It has yet to stop and sometimes the external personas will yell at each other.
  • Carol yelled at a delivery man. He set a box down near her workspace and she told him to pick it up “because you’re fat and you need exercise.” I told her and her mother this was unacceptable behavior. Her mother then emailed me that I was “finding reasons to pick on her daughter” and I needed to “do my job and keep her busy.”
  • Carol was asked to staple packets. I showed her what was expected and watched her do a few. I came back 10 minutes later and she had thrown all of the papers on the floor because she “was done and wanted to do fun things.” I told her mother she could not do things like this. Her mother said, “Her last job managed to get her to work. It must be YOU!” (ME!?!?)
  • Carol “borrowed” a bunch of items from the supply closet. When it was discovered, her father came in and brought them all back and suggested we not allow her in there anymore because she was “confused.”

Alice said she was sorry, but her hands were tied. I told her even my boss, who fully believes in their mission and makes donations regularly as well as offering this job to their clients, said this is not a good placement.

A few weeks passed. Carol became more and more of a problem, and so did her mother. The mother came into the office to berate me in front of the rest of the staff for having her daughter set up the meeting space and pick it up afterwards. Apparently, this is “beneath” her! Again, part of the job! The owner happened to be in that day and told the mother to leave and that she was not allowed in our building again. So, now the father comes to “check in” on Carol. He’s a bit more reasonable, I guess.

After that, the owner called the nonprofit himself and also received the “we need this to work out because we need the donations from this family” line. He is friendly with their director, and told me to try and find things to occupy Carol while she’s there and he’s going to tell the parents himself she can only work 10 hours a week. This doesn’t do us any good, and now I’m tasked with finding “parent-approved” tasks for her. I can’t do my own job because I’m constantly keeping eyes on her and doing the parts of her job that she can’t. I’m just waiting for something catastrophic to happen here. I also feel it is totally unethical for this nonprofit to give jobs to those who can afford to “buy” their placements.

I don’t even know what I’m asking. Maybe the readers can chime in with ideas for my survival during Carol’s 10 hours. Any ideas what I can give her to do? She can file pretty well, but we have like … 20 minutes of filing a month, if that. Am I enabling this? Should I let Carol crash and burn to prove how little she’s doing when I’m not picking up her slack? Or would that be too mean to someone with her issues?


Alison’s Response

Can be found here


Update

Dec 12, 2025

I found some menial tasks from the lists given and put Carol on them. She really liked making paper chains, cutting out paper decorations for her desk, and coloring them. I spoke with my boss and Alice (the placement firm contact) about getting a job coach for Carol. I told my boss I needed to hire a second person to do the work Carol wasn’t able to do — which was just about everything on her job description. Alice agreed to “look into” getting a job coach. Carol made lots of paper decorations for her 10 hours a week when we were babysitting. My boss said I could hire someone else to do Carol’s job as a part-timer but to interview candidates in September, when I returned from my long-planned vacation.

Two weeks after I asked Alice for a job coach, she was no longer with the job placement firm. We were back at square one. Then, I went on my vacation for two weeks. In those two weeks, my boss covered for me and got to see just what a problem Carol was firsthand. Highlights of those weeks include:

  • Carol’s dad dropped her off extra early one day. She came into the building and took the receptionist’s chair, replacing it with the one at her desk. The receptionist is an older lady with mobility issues and has a large, high backed chair. Carol’s is a simple office chair like the rest of us. Carol refused to give the chair back even saying “I deserve it!” multiple times while waving her arms threateningly at the receptionist. My boss called her dad to pick her up. The next day, he delivered a pricey office chair for her.
  • Carol’s mother decided to try coming to speak to my boss without me there. She arrived during the day, after Carol had been picked up. My boss told her to leave. She yelled across the office at how much better Carol was doing without me around. My boss told her to leave before he called the cops. She left.
  • One of my coworkers was tasked with giving Carol work. Carol yelled at her and told her, “You don’t tell me what to do!” She did this every day I was gone, despite being told I was going on vacation and “Lauren” would be in charge in my absence.
  • One day, Carol’s external conversations with herself were so loud and out of control my boss called her dad to get her. He was honestly afraid she was going to hurt someone or herself.
  • Carol was asked to wipe down the microwave and sink after she used them during lunch and left a mess. She told my boss, “I’m not a maid. You get a maid to do it!”
  • Carol had another run-in with one of the delivery guys. He asked her to hold the door to the package room since she was coming out and he was going in with a large load. She yelled at him to “do his job” and called him fat. Again.

After all of this, my boss called the organization and said Carol could not come back until they sent a job coach. In the meantime, I hired a high school kid to work part-time after school. Best decision ever.

Three weeks later, Carol came back with a job coach in tow. The coach, Fred, wasn’t great and I don’t even think he was trained as a job coach. He seemed very young and inexperienced and spent a lot of time on his phone. I called the agency and asked about Fred. The director there spoke as if this guy walked on water but I wasn’t seeing it. I asked Fred what his last job was, and he said a front desk clerk at a lower tier hotel chain. He said he took this job because the hours were better. I told him I needed a lot more coaching because paying Carol to cut paper decorations all day was ridiculous. He agreed, but didn’t care enough to actually do something. I called the agency again and was told that he was all they had.

So that brings us up to mid-October. Mid-October is our company’s big fall festival for the employees and our families. Carol showed up with both parents in tow. My boss allowed the mom to be there since we weren’t in the office but in a rented space. The parents spent a lot of time socializing with people, including my boss, but the mother made a clear effort to avoid me.

While this was going on, Carol was wandering around trying to play games that were meant for kids. She was told she couldn’t be in the bounce house, since kids were in there. She wanted a pony ride but was told she was too big. Stuff like that. Then she happened upon the cornhole game. A bunch of kids, probably ages 8 – 12, were playing cornhole while “Danny,” one of our long-time employees, was watching and filming his kids. Carol walked up and grabbed the bags off the board and said it was her turn. Danny told her she could play when they were done. Carol kept yelling that it was her turn. Danny told her to go find her dad. Carol then picked up a cornhole board and threw it across the grass. It struck another employee in the legs. Carol then threw the bags at one of the boys, hitting him in the back.

And that’s when my boss fired her right on the spot and told the dad he could come get the chair and any of her belongings on Monday but they had to leave immediately. The mother threatened discrimination lawsuits and kept yelling and ranting about how she’s never been treated so poorly in her life and how awful we all are — that we needed “more compassion” for Carol.

My boss said get out or he’d call the cops because Carol had just assaulted two people.

The dad at least had the good sense to pull the mom towards the car and then went back to get Carol who was still in mid-tantrum.

They never came back for the chair, so I claimed it as my reward for dealing with this ridiculous family.

The other good news is my new part-timer is a great kid. He’s going to welding school next year and I told him if he ever wants a welding job, he’s got one with us.


Reminder this is a repost community and I am not OOP

0

[Concluded] the boss who fired me got hired at my new job — and she’s joking about how bad my work was [AAM]

preview

This is a repost made by a human

Title: the boss who fired me got hired at my new job — and she’s joking about how bad my work was

Originally posted to: Ask A Manager

I am not the OOP

trigger warning

bullying


Original Post:

Octo 13, 2021

About seven years ago, I worked for Company A. I met a lot of nice folks, and there is a lot of good to be said for the company. But the actual job function I was paid to do I hated, and it was in an industry I came to have a dim view of. As you can probably guess, I was not very good at this job. Throw in some unpleasant things going on in my personal life at the time, and the whole situation was very bad.

Eventually my boss had to fire me, and I deserved to be fired! My boss (Jane) handled the firing with all the dignity and sensitivity that I could have hoped for. No complaints there. I took some time after the firing to really think about my life, what I wanted, and what I wanted out of work. I made some changes, and one of those was to go to work for a nonprofit that advocates on an issue I care deeply about. I am MUCH better at this job, have received a couple promotions along the way, and feel like I have the respect of my colleagues. I am in a much better place compared to where I was with Company A.

Last month my nonprofit was onboarding some new hires, and I was surprised to see Jane among them. She wanted a change, and thus went from Company A to us. She had no idea I was working here. I work on the advocacy side, she works on the financial side, but our job titles are approximately equal. We spent a few pleasant minutes catching up. I was genuinely glad to see her.

Unfortunately, things have taken a turn. I have started hearing rumors that Jane has been regaling our colleagues with stories of what a screw-up I was back at Company A. While the stories are superficially true, they lack the context I described above and do not consider my good work since then, so I find these stories both embarrassing and unfair. I have asked Jane to stop doing this, but she feels I am overreacting as it is all meant in good fun.

But I am already seeing people become a lot more particular in their dealings with me. For example, I organize several public facing events with one of my colleagues. These events have always gone well, and he has been easy to work with; he tells me what he needs, I tell him what I need, then we do what needs to be done. Lately, he has been checking, and double checking, and triple checking that I understand what is required and my progress on meeting those requirements. That never happened before Jane. And when I called him out on it, he replied that my “track record” justified his attention. I replied that my track record with him was unblemished, and he sheepishly said, “Yeah, but I hear from Jane …”

I am appreciative of how Jane treated me back in the day, so I want to cut her all the slack I can. I do not believe she is being malicious. I think she just wants to integrate herself with her new colleagues and thinks telling funny stories is a way to do so. But she has badly misjudged the effect these stories have had. Do you have any thoughts on how I can get her to stop?


Please visit AAM to see Alison’s Reply


Update:

Nov 29, 2021 (6 weeks later)

Let me begin by saying I really appreciate of the support and advice you and your readers gave me. It was nice to know I wasn’t making too much out of it.

Two things maybe I should mention that I did not before. First, I am a pretty laid back guy, and when folks have a laugh at my expense, that usually doesn’t bother me if I think it is coming from a place of affection. I can laugh at myself, and Lord knows I enjoy teasing the people I love. I think I have pretty good boundaries generally, and I enforce them if I feel it’s not coming from a place of affection. But I think in this instance my boundary setting radar got confused because this generally has not been a problem at work, and because I so wanted to give Jane the benefit of the doubt.

Secondly, Jane’s behavior in all of this tracks, if you know Jane. She is, let’s say, hyperrational. Appeals to her emotions, or telling her how things make you feel, generally don’t work. But if you can quantify your point, if you can back up your argument with data, she is very persuadable, up to and including changing her behavior or backing off on points she’s made in the past.

As you advised, I took the issue up directly with folks who seemed to be treating me differently, calling out what I saw and asking them to please judge me on my record since they’ve known me. Most denied any change at all, and that was enough to shock them back into their pre-Jane behavior. A small number admitted Jane’s stories had made some impact, and agreed that maybe was not entirely fair. For the most part, they too have returned to pre-Jane behavior.

Then I went back to Jane and made my point; the stories were unflattering and unfair, they were harming my reputation with my co-workers, and it needed to stop. She again said she was just kidding and doubted it influenced anyone at all… I conceded she was just kidding and had no ill-will, but that wasn’t the point. We went through some emails I had with co-workers that I had printed out (including the exchange with the coworker I mentioned in my first note). The point I made was even if it was just this one guy (and it wasn’t) surely she would agree that if the stories kept coming more people might start thinking like this guy.

Having seen the evidence, she agreed. She promised she would stop, and she has. She even went so far as to email a couple folks we discussed (and cc’d me) apologizing for her behavior and saying she should not have put me in such a bad light. That was good enough for me.

And that has been it. We’re pretty much back to normal. The guy from the first e-mail is still double checking me, but less than he was before. Personally I think he’s just trying to cover his tracks.


I am not the OOP - This is a repost community

DO NOT message anyone linked in this post

This is a repost made by a human

Title: the boss who fired me got hired at my new job — and she’s joking about how bad my work was

Originally posted to: Ask A Manager

I am not the OOP

trigger warning

bullying


Original Post:

Octo 13, 2021

About seven years ago, I worked for Company A. I met a lot of nice folks, and there is a lot of good to be said for the company. But the actual job function I was paid to do I hated, and it was in an industry I came to have a dim view of. As you can probably guess, I was not very good at this job. Throw in some unpleasant things going on in my personal life at the time, and the whole situation was very bad.

Eventually my boss had to fire me, and I deserved to be fired! My boss (Jane) handled the firing with all the dignity and sensitivity that I could have hoped for. No complaints there. I took some time after the firing to really think about my life, what I wanted, and what I wanted out of work. I made some changes, and one of those was to go to work for a nonprofit that advocates on an issue I care deeply about. I am MUCH better at this job, have received a couple promotions along the way, and feel like I have the respect of my colleagues. I am in a much better place compared to where I was with Company A.

Last month my nonprofit was onboarding some new hires, and I was surprised to see Jane among them. She wanted a change, and thus went from Company A to us. She had no idea I was working here. I work on the advocacy side, she works on the financial side, but our job titles are approximately equal. We spent a few pleasant minutes catching up. I was genuinely glad to see her.

Unfortunately, things have taken a turn. I have started hearing rumors that Jane has been regaling our colleagues with stories of what a screw-up I was back at Company A. While the stories are superficially true, they lack the context I described above and do not consider my good work since then, so I find these stories both embarrassing and unfair. I have asked Jane to stop doing this, but she feels I am overreacting as it is all meant in good fun.

But I am already seeing people become a lot more particular in their dealings with me. For example, I organize several public facing events with one of my colleagues. These events have always gone well, and he has been easy to work with; he tells me what he needs, I tell him what I need, then we do what needs to be done. Lately, he has been checking, and double checking, and triple checking that I understand what is required and my progress on meeting those requirements. That never happened before Jane. And when I called him out on it, he replied that my “track record” justified his attention. I replied that my track record with him was unblemished, and he sheepishly said, “Yeah, but I hear from Jane …”

I am appreciative of how Jane treated me back in the day, so I want to cut her all the slack I can. I do not believe she is being malicious. I think she just wants to integrate herself with her new colleagues and thinks telling funny stories is a way to do so. But she has badly misjudged the effect these stories have had. Do you have any thoughts on how I can get her to stop?


Please visit AAM to see Alison’s Reply


Update:

Nov 29, 2021 (6 weeks later)

Let me begin by saying I really appreciate of the support and advice you and your readers gave me. It was nice to know I wasn’t making too much out of it.

Two things maybe I should mention that I did not before. First, I am a pretty laid back guy, and when folks have a laugh at my expense, that usually doesn’t bother me if I think it is coming from a place of affection. I can laugh at myself, and Lord knows I enjoy teasing the people I love. I think I have pretty good boundaries generally, and I enforce them if I feel it’s not coming from a place of affection. But I think in this instance my boundary setting radar got confused because this generally has not been a problem at work, and because I so wanted to give Jane the benefit of the doubt.

Secondly, Jane’s behavior in all of this tracks, if you know Jane. She is, let’s say, hyperrational. Appeals to her emotions, or telling her how things make you feel, generally don’t work. But if you can quantify your point, if you can back up your argument with data, she is very persuadable, up to and including changing her behavior or backing off on points she’s made in the past.

As you advised, I took the issue up directly with folks who seemed to be treating me differently, calling out what I saw and asking them to please judge me on my record since they’ve known me. Most denied any change at all, and that was enough to shock them back into their pre-Jane behavior. A small number admitted Jane’s stories had made some impact, and agreed that maybe was not entirely fair. For the most part, they too have returned to pre-Jane behavior.

Then I went back to Jane and made my point; the stories were unflattering and unfair, they were harming my reputation with my co-workers, and it needed to stop. She again said she was just kidding and doubted it influenced anyone at all… I conceded she was just kidding and had no ill-will, but that wasn’t the point. We went through some emails I had with co-workers that I had printed out (including the exchange with the coworker I mentioned in my first note). The point I made was even if it was just this one guy (and it wasn’t) surely she would agree that if the stories kept coming more people might start thinking like this guy.

Having seen the evidence, she agreed. She promised she would stop, and she has. She even went so far as to email a couple folks we discussed (and cc’d me) apologizing for her behavior and saying she should not have put me in such a bad light. That was good enough for me.

And that has been it. We’re pretty much back to normal. The guy from the first e-mail is still double checking me, but less than he was before. Personally I think he’s just trying to cover his tracks.


I am not the OOP - This is a repost community

DO NOT message anyone linked in this post

0

[Concluded] My [26m] boyfriend of 2 years flipped out because I [24f] used a mobility scooter in a store [Reddit]

preview

This is a repost made by a human (hello!)

Original Boru by: u/Direct-caterpillar77 post here.

I am not the OOP.

OOP is: u/scootscooty

trigger warning

Body shaming, fat phobia, ableism, gaslighting


Original Post:

Oct 29, 2014

I hurt my foot/ankle about a week ago at the gym during some stupid class. I can barely stand on it, walking is hard. I haven’t gotten crutches, just one of those stupid huge foot brace things, and it isn’t helping all the way. Nonetheless I have to go about my daily routine, correct? So bf and I went shopping yesterday. I was doing the hop-along with the cart while I read off the list and he grabbed stuff for us.

A store worker saw me and told me that she could grab one of the scooters for me. My boyfriend turned around and said “that’s not necessary,” but we still had a while to go, and I wasn’t getting far, so I said sure. He started getting annoyed and when she was gone, he asked me what I was doing. I said we’d get things done faster if I was just in the scooter thing.

The whole rest of the time, he would barely look at me or acknowledge that I was there. As far as I could tell, nobody was even looking at us. Except maybe one little girl in her mom’s shopping cart who pointed and was like “Mom, she has a big owie.”

When we finally finished and got out, I hopped along to the car and he put the scooter away for me and slammed the car door, frowned, looked super tense. I asked him what was wrong, and he blew up. He kept saying how embarrassed he was that I was in one of those, that only obese women use them and that he’s sure everyone was judging us and thinks that I’m just a lazy fat-ass slob.

I was completely taken aback. Ok, yeah, I’m a fat girl. 5’, size 12/14, big fuckin’ whoop. Not exactly the body type you see in the majority of the “obese women” he’s talking about. I told him that nobody was paying attention, nobody was watching, and that I thought it was fine. Besides, it would be hard to miss the gigantic boot on my leg! But he was so far gone, upset beyond belief about this that when we got home, he just went into his game room, shut the door, and wouldn’t help me put the groceries away.

I thought he would get over it but then this morning I found a note on my desk from him that says that he is really upset that I went against his wishes, embarrassed him in public, and made a spectacle of myself. He said that if I can’t apologize to him, he’s not sure our relationship has a future.

I’m lost at what to do. I don’t think I did anything wrong. All I did was ride a scooter for like 45 minutes, if that, while we got our groceries, so it wouldn’t take me longer. Is there a perspective that I’m not seeing here? Did I do something wrong?

tl;dr: boyfriend flipped that I used a mobility scooter, even though I have a brace on my leg.


Comments

jackiekeracky: mobility scooters are for people who, for whatever reason, have trouble with their mobility.

you did nothing wrong, your bf is being a dick

OP: That’s close to what I told him when we were in the car, actually. I mean, the part about what mobility scooters are for, not about him being a dick.

crystanow: “I found a note on my desk from him that says that he is really upset that I went against his wishes, embarrassed him in public, and made a spectacle of myself. He said that if I can’t apologize to him,”

This is some weird thought process/attitude going on - is this totally out of character for him or has he been resentful/asshole like this in the past?

OP: It’s pretty out of character for him, honestly. We have had a mellow, happy relationship for most of this time. I think the only other time he’s gotten angry was because me and my best friend got a little too drunk at our place and were being loud.

fuckdapolice4: What kind of dick makes his injured girlfriend hobble along with him? Why couldn’t he have gone by himself in the first place? And then he made you put away all of the groceries because he was too pissed off?

Uggh, from this one isolated incident, he sounds like a really selfish dude. Don’t apologize, and in fact, if he can’t apologize… I think you should be the one re-evaluating.

OP: I’m actually the one who wanted to go grocery shopping in the first place. We keep kind of a “chore schedule” sort of thing and I’d already messed up some of the week from being injured and all of that, so I wanted to get back on schedule and at least make sure we had food for our meals and whatever else. I was just going to go by myself, but he said he’d come so it went faster.

ThankYouEbolaChanNYC: Your weight is an issue for him.

hackberrydraw: This is the correct answer, sad to say. Was the only thing going through my mind as I read your post.

As much as he might love you and appreciate you for who you are, it embarrasses him to be with an overweight person. That’s the social stigma or social norm he is so stressed about. The scooter was just a catalyst to these thoughts. /armchair psychology


Update

Nov 21, 2014 (1 month later)

So, some of you were right. There was a weight issue, but it wasnew! We talked and he told me he wanted me to lose weight. He’d wanted me to for a while. I asked him why, despite me not gaining any weight or changing anything in my diet or exercise routine after years. He said it was a recent development, that he was starting to notice other women more and he didn’t want to feel embarrassed with me or anything.

He said he’s always been attracted to me, and still is, but it has shifted even though I haven’t gained anything since we met. So… he gave me an ultimatum: lose weight, or lose him.

I thought about it for a while, and in the end, decided to drop the dead weight. 180lbs of boyfriend later, I am happy, single, and on my way to a fun holiday season without worrying “Oh no, my boyfriend will dump me if I don’t lose weight!” Already had three great dates from Okcupid and looking forward to more! btw, Thanks!!! For all the recommendations on where to get the crutches. I got a great pair and my foot healed after that week!

EDIT: That’s about all the computer time I’ve got for one day. Anyhow, nice to chat with all of you! Good luck, see-ya!

tl;dr: Broke up with boyfriend after he requested I lose weight.


Comments

Upallnight88: I’m curious. How fit was your boyfriend? Was he carrying any extra weight?

OP: Yeah, he had some extra weight. I never really paid attention to him gaining or losing or anything like that. He wasn’t as active as me, though.

Upallnight88: I just had to have the answer! Was the pot calling the kettle black. Actually the #1 post by Bassoon-Commie was the best thing I’ve seen here for a long time. Glad you’re happy

When told its sucks that her ex only cares about what people think about him

OP; Yeah, agreed. To be honest, I don’t have the time or patience to deal with someone who cares that much about something as stupid as what other people think.

Bassoon_Commie: “I thought about it for a while, and in the end, decided to drop the dead weight. 180lbs of boyfriend later-”

I love this. Good choice. :)

cosmicberryfairypie: My initial reaction was “awe whaa…” Then “Aaawwwe yea girl!”


This is a repost community, remember I am not the OOP

Do not contact OOPS or anyone linked in the above post

This is a repost made by a human (hello!)

Original Boru by: u/Direct-caterpillar77 post here.

I am not the OOP.

OOP is: u/scootscooty

trigger warning

Body shaming, fat phobia, ableism, gaslighting


Original Post:

Oct 29, 2014

I hurt my foot/ankle about a week ago at the gym during some stupid class. I can barely stand on it, walking is hard. I haven’t gotten crutches, just one of those stupid huge foot brace things, and it isn’t helping all the way. Nonetheless I have to go about my daily routine, correct? So bf and I went shopping yesterday. I was doing the hop-along with the cart while I read off the list and he grabbed stuff for us.

A store worker saw me and told me that she could grab one of the scooters for me. My boyfriend turned around and said “that’s not necessary,” but we still had a while to go, and I wasn’t getting far, so I said sure. He started getting annoyed and when she was gone, he asked me what I was doing. I said we’d get things done faster if I was just in the scooter thing.

The whole rest of the time, he would barely look at me or acknowledge that I was there. As far as I could tell, nobody was even looking at us. Except maybe one little girl in her mom’s shopping cart who pointed and was like “Mom, she has a big owie.”

When we finally finished and got out, I hopped along to the car and he put the scooter away for me and slammed the car door, frowned, looked super tense. I asked him what was wrong, and he blew up. He kept saying how embarrassed he was that I was in one of those, that only obese women use them and that he’s sure everyone was judging us and thinks that I’m just a lazy fat-ass slob.

I was completely taken aback. Ok, yeah, I’m a fat girl. 5’, size 12/14, big fuckin’ whoop. Not exactly the body type you see in the majority of the “obese women” he’s talking about. I told him that nobody was paying attention, nobody was watching, and that I thought it was fine. Besides, it would be hard to miss the gigantic boot on my leg! But he was so far gone, upset beyond belief about this that when we got home, he just went into his game room, shut the door, and wouldn’t help me put the groceries away.

I thought he would get over it but then this morning I found a note on my desk from him that says that he is really upset that I went against his wishes, embarrassed him in public, and made a spectacle of myself. He said that if I can’t apologize to him, he’s not sure our relationship has a future.

I’m lost at what to do. I don’t think I did anything wrong. All I did was ride a scooter for like 45 minutes, if that, while we got our groceries, so it wouldn’t take me longer. Is there a perspective that I’m not seeing here? Did I do something wrong?

tl;dr: boyfriend flipped that I used a mobility scooter, even though I have a brace on my leg.


Comments

jackiekeracky: mobility scooters are for people who, for whatever reason, have trouble with their mobility.

you did nothing wrong, your bf is being a dick

OP: That’s close to what I told him when we were in the car, actually. I mean, the part about what mobility scooters are for, not about him being a dick.

crystanow: “I found a note on my desk from him that says that he is really upset that I went against his wishes, embarrassed him in public, and made a spectacle of myself. He said that if I can’t apologize to him,”

This is some weird thought process/attitude going on - is this totally out of character for him or has he been resentful/asshole like this in the past?

OP: It’s pretty out of character for him, honestly. We have had a mellow, happy relationship for most of this time. I think the only other time he’s gotten angry was because me and my best friend got a little too drunk at our place and were being loud.

fuckdapolice4: What kind of dick makes his injured girlfriend hobble along with him? Why couldn’t he have gone by himself in the first place? And then he made you put away all of the groceries because he was too pissed off?

Uggh, from this one isolated incident, he sounds like a really selfish dude. Don’t apologize, and in fact, if he can’t apologize… I think you should be the one re-evaluating.

OP: I’m actually the one who wanted to go grocery shopping in the first place. We keep kind of a “chore schedule” sort of thing and I’d already messed up some of the week from being injured and all of that, so I wanted to get back on schedule and at least make sure we had food for our meals and whatever else. I was just going to go by myself, but he said he’d come so it went faster.

ThankYouEbolaChanNYC: Your weight is an issue for him.

hackberrydraw: This is the correct answer, sad to say. Was the only thing going through my mind as I read your post.

As much as he might love you and appreciate you for who you are, it embarrasses him to be with an overweight person. That’s the social stigma or social norm he is so stressed about. The scooter was just a catalyst to these thoughts. /armchair psychology


Update

Nov 21, 2014 (1 month later)

So, some of you were right. There was a weight issue, but it wasnew! We talked and he told me he wanted me to lose weight. He’d wanted me to for a while. I asked him why, despite me not gaining any weight or changing anything in my diet or exercise routine after years. He said it was a recent development, that he was starting to notice other women more and he didn’t want to feel embarrassed with me or anything.

He said he’s always been attracted to me, and still is, but it has shifted even though I haven’t gained anything since we met. So… he gave me an ultimatum: lose weight, or lose him.

I thought about it for a while, and in the end, decided to drop the dead weight. 180lbs of boyfriend later, I am happy, single, and on my way to a fun holiday season without worrying “Oh no, my boyfriend will dump me if I don’t lose weight!” Already had three great dates from Okcupid and looking forward to more! btw, Thanks!!! For all the recommendations on where to get the crutches. I got a great pair and my foot healed after that week!

EDIT: That’s about all the computer time I’ve got for one day. Anyhow, nice to chat with all of you! Good luck, see-ya!

tl;dr: Broke up with boyfriend after he requested I lose weight.


Comments

Upallnight88: I’m curious. How fit was your boyfriend? Was he carrying any extra weight?

OP: Yeah, he had some extra weight. I never really paid attention to him gaining or losing or anything like that. He wasn’t as active as me, though.

Upallnight88: I just had to have the answer! Was the pot calling the kettle black. Actually the #1 post by Bassoon-Commie was the best thing I’ve seen here for a long time. Glad you’re happy

When told its sucks that her ex only cares about what people think about him

OP; Yeah, agreed. To be honest, I don’t have the time or patience to deal with someone who cares that much about something as stupid as what other people think.

Bassoon_Commie: “I thought about it for a while, and in the end, decided to drop the dead weight. 180lbs of boyfriend later-”

I love this. Good choice. :)

cosmicberryfairypie: My initial reaction was “awe whaa…” Then “Aaawwwe yea girl!”


This is a repost community, remember I am not the OOP

Do not contact OOPS or anyone linked in the above post

0

[Concluded] Being told my tea steeper is unprofessional [Reddit]

preview

This is a repost made by a human

I am not the OOP

OOP is: u/Electronic-Sell6402

Originally posted on: Reddit’s r/mildlyinfuriating

Best of compiled by: u/Direct-Caterpillar77 here.

mood spoiler

anticlimactic


Original Post

Sept 29, 2026

I 3d printed this tea steeper for my desk at work. I thought it was really cute and it makes me happy when I use it. Apparently because I printed it in all white, someone made a comment in front of my bosses boss, that it looks like the little guy is sitting on a toilet. Now I got an email from HR stating that I have “objects inappropriate for the work environment” on my desk, and that it must be removed before the end of the day. Like it’s just a dude holding a fishing pole.

So frustrating.

OOP posted 2 pictures of the little man with a fishing rod and a teabag hanging off the rod


Relevant Comments

okanagan_man84: Its a dude or dudette with a fishing pole. How is thay unprofessional. Seems like whoever is complaining has nothing better to do or is, at the very least, jealous of what you have. There fore, if they cant have one neither should you.

OP: I agree. The coworker in question always complains about stuff that doesn’t affect them on any way

zeus64: HR probably doesnt know what item it is that was reported for being inappropriate tell them you don’t know what it would be and then ask them if they can identify the item. If somehow they point that out ask them why and what rule it is breaking if they say it looks like its a guy is on a toilet act disgusted and tell them its obviously a guy fishing

OP: I actually like this suggestion. I think that’s what I’ll do is ask HR if they can identify the issue causing the problem


OOP Updated 3 Times

in the same post on the same day

UPDATE: after this post has quickly blown up, and made me laugh a few times. I talked to my immediate boss who agreed with a few of you that HR probably doesn’t even know what item I’m supposed to remove. So I have emailed HR back, and cc’d my boss, for them to come identify the “inappropriate object” as neither myself or my boss are able to identify what might be the problem. So we shall see what happens.

UPDATE 2: Electric Boogaloo: Just got off the phone with someone in HR. They are going to come over around 2pm (about an hour and 15 minutes from now) and look at the item. All they told me was that they received an email from an AVP (my bosses boss) that it was said to him that I had a 3d printed item on my desk that was about potty humor and that my “whole team” (it’s just the one coworker who has a problem, none of the other 7 do) finds it offensive. The person in HR said they will look at it and determine if there is any reason for the complaint.

UPDATE 3: Update with a vengeance: HR just left my office. Saw no problems, thinks the whole complaint is dumb and is going to write it up that way. Also asked if I could print them one too. So I will be doing that this evening. She (the HR person) asked me if I wanted to make a report of possible harassment by the coworker. I stated that I will write up something to put into a file with HR if needed for a future report, but not to open a case now on this issue.


Final Comments

Double_Resort_9223: Enemy for life

OP: Oh you can bet on that. They are the coworker who always has an opinion or a “better way” and just gets on everyone’s nerves as it is. Now they are on the enemies list


Final Update in the Comments

Last update. If anyone is bored, this guy on LinkedIn is trying to steal my story for his LinkedIn cred. He already blocked me and a friend of mine for calling him out. Here is the link

Editors Note: removed the link



THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

This is a repost made by a human

I am not the OOP

OOP is: u/Electronic-Sell6402

Originally posted on: Reddit’s r/mildlyinfuriating

Best of compiled by: u/Direct-Caterpillar77 here.

mood spoiler

anticlimactic


Original Post

Sept 29, 2026

I 3d printed this tea steeper for my desk at work. I thought it was really cute and it makes me happy when I use it. Apparently because I printed it in all white, someone made a comment in front of my bosses boss, that it looks like the little guy is sitting on a toilet. Now I got an email from HR stating that I have “objects inappropriate for the work environment” on my desk, and that it must be removed before the end of the day. Like it’s just a dude holding a fishing pole.

So frustrating.

OOP posted 2 pictures of the little man with a fishing rod and a teabag hanging off the rod


Relevant Comments

okanagan_man84: Its a dude or dudette with a fishing pole. How is thay unprofessional. Seems like whoever is complaining has nothing better to do or is, at the very least, jealous of what you have. There fore, if they cant have one neither should you.

OP: I agree. The coworker in question always complains about stuff that doesn’t affect them on any way

zeus64: HR probably doesnt know what item it is that was reported for being inappropriate tell them you don’t know what it would be and then ask them if they can identify the item. If somehow they point that out ask them why and what rule it is breaking if they say it looks like its a guy is on a toilet act disgusted and tell them its obviously a guy fishing

OP: I actually like this suggestion. I think that’s what I’ll do is ask HR if they can identify the issue causing the problem


OOP Updated 3 Times

in the same post on the same day

UPDATE: after this post has quickly blown up, and made me laugh a few times. I talked to my immediate boss who agreed with a few of you that HR probably doesn’t even know what item I’m supposed to remove. So I have emailed HR back, and cc’d my boss, for them to come identify the “inappropriate object” as neither myself or my boss are able to identify what might be the problem. So we shall see what happens.

UPDATE 2: Electric Boogaloo: Just got off the phone with someone in HR. They are going to come over around 2pm (about an hour and 15 minutes from now) and look at the item. All they told me was that they received an email from an AVP (my bosses boss) that it was said to him that I had a 3d printed item on my desk that was about potty humor and that my “whole team” (it’s just the one coworker who has a problem, none of the other 7 do) finds it offensive. The person in HR said they will look at it and determine if there is any reason for the complaint.

UPDATE 3: Update with a vengeance: HR just left my office. Saw no problems, thinks the whole complaint is dumb and is going to write it up that way. Also asked if I could print them one too. So I will be doing that this evening. She (the HR person) asked me if I wanted to make a report of possible harassment by the coworker. I stated that I will write up something to put into a file with HR if needed for a future report, but not to open a case now on this issue.


Final Comments

Double_Resort_9223: Enemy for life

OP: Oh you can bet on that. They are the coworker who always has an opinion or a “better way” and just gets on everyone’s nerves as it is. Now they are on the enemies list


Final Update in the Comments

Last update. If anyone is bored, this guy on LinkedIn is trying to steal my story for his LinkedIn cred. He already blocked me and a friend of mine for calling him out. Here is the link

Editors Note: removed the link



THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

0

[Concluded] I think my boss is tracking me. [Reddit]

preview

I am not OP.

Originally post by Reddit user: u/gem1n-eye in r/nanny

I am not the original poster of this compilation thread. This was originally posted by u/ABBR-5007 (now deleted) and was reposted today by u/BORUReposting.

Reminder - Do not comment on linked posts!

Tap for Trigger Warning

stalking

Tap for mood spoiler

unsatisfying

Editors note: MB= Mom/Mommy Boss


Original: I think my MB may be tracking me

Fri, Jan 27, 2023

This is really weird to post, and I feel crazy for even thinking it. But so many weird things have happened over the past month I’ve been working for this family, I feel like I need a second opinion or someone to tell me if I’m going crazy.

Like I said, I’ve worked for this family since just before the new year. They have two kids, 2 and 8. I know they have trackers sewn in to the 2 year old’s diaper bag and the 8 year old’s backpack, she told me about them and I obviously have no issue with that. The kids are great, MB is a single mom who seemed really lovely from our first few meetings.

A few weeks ago, she sent me a text asking if I could come in now because she got called in to work. I lied and said I was in (big city in my state) visiting my sister for the weekend. It was a dumb white lie because I didn’t want to be asked during the weekend if she kept being called in, as that has happened multiple times before and I really needed a full weekend to myself. She simply responded “You don’t need to lie, I’ll find a backup.” It definitely gave me super weird vibes and was super embarassing, but I shrugged it off and figured she may have been at Trader Joes earlier in the day when I went, or she saw my car, something like that.

Then this Tuesday, I came in and she was definitely cold towards me. I had been out celebrating a friend’s birthday Monday night at a bar, but I nursed one drink the entire night and was never even tipsy. I take showers in the morning and wore clean clothes, so there’s no way I smelled like alcohol. But she confronted me and accused me of being hungover, said I reeked of booze, and kept asking if I had a drinking problem because why would I be drinking on a Monday night? I was really put off, and told her the truth, that it was my friend’s birthday and I was just out celebrating with her and some other friends and hadn’t even drank. She paused for a super long time and just nodded, and left for work like nothing happened. MB is super religious and very vehemently anti-alcohol, but I still feel like it was a weird accusation. I asked my girlfriend when I got home if I smelled like alcohol or anything somehow, and she couldn’t smell anything.

Earlier today was the final incident that really cemented this stupid conspiracy theory in my head. I took the bus this morning when I normally take my car because I’m extra broke right now and need to save gas. I got to her house around 10 minutes early, but sat in a little wooded curb area for a while until it was my official time to start.5 minutes before my start time, MB texts me “Have you left yet?? I have a meeting at 10:30.” I am NEVER late. I walked in early, and she looked confused. When I mentioned taking the bus, she literally said “Oh that makes sense.”

What the hell do I do? I looked all over my car, in my backpack, and in my car’s carseat… I couldn’t find anything. Am I overthinking this?

Edit: I just looked with the help from yall, and found an AirTag ductaped to the underside of my car. So, very very creeped out currently. Not sure what to say or do now.


Follow-up on r/LegalAdvice: My employer put an AirTag on my car

Same day

Hi, I’m having some major issues right now. For the full story check my post history, but the gist is that I’m a nanny for a single mom of two. I’ve only worked with her for about a month, and I knew she was tracking her children’s location. After a series of weird comments, people recommended I check my car for AirTags using an Android app, and I found one very well hidden and ductaped under my car.

I am super creeped out. I live in California, what is possible here? Can police do anything? I don’t feel safe to confront my boss, and have called out sick today.


Update: Update to employer tracking me

Sat, Feb 04, 2023

If you saw my post from last week, you know I found an AirTag under my car put there by my MB. Sorry for not updating sooner, I’ve been stressed and busy trying to get another job pretty much all day every day.

So I ended up calling the police. They came to my place and checked out the car, AirTag, etc, and they went and spoke with MB. AirTag was in her name, by the way, I know some people were suggesting it could be someone else (which sadly was a probability for a while because I do have a stalker, only making all of this more stressful).

MB was shocked that I had called the police over the tag and totally tried to gaslight the officers. She said that she put it there to make sure I wasn’t speeding and as backup if I lost their bags with the trackers. She also flat out lied and said she had told me, but I must not have been listening. They just gave her a warning, and no further action was taken. I honestly don’t think they really took my concern seriously. If anything, they seemed to side with her perspective. So that’s awesome. Sarcasm.

I’m obviously not working for her anymore, and have blocked her phone number because she was belittling me over calling the police over “her keeping her children safe.” On to the next job I guess. Anyone with advice on how to warn other nannies in my area is appreciated.


I am not OP.

Originally post by Reddit user: u/gem1n-eye in r/nanny

I am not the original poster of this compilation thread. This was originally posted by u/ABBR-5007 (now deleted) and was reposted today by u/BORUReposting.

Reminder - Do not comment on linked posts!

Tap for Trigger Warning

stalking

Tap for mood spoiler

unsatisfying

Editors note: MB= Mom/Mommy Boss


Original: I think my MB may be tracking me

Fri, Jan 27, 2023

This is really weird to post, and I feel crazy for even thinking it. But so many weird things have happened over the past month I’ve been working for this family, I feel like I need a second opinion or someone to tell me if I’m going crazy.

Like I said, I’ve worked for this family since just before the new year. They have two kids, 2 and 8. I know they have trackers sewn in to the 2 year old’s diaper bag and the 8 year old’s backpack, she told me about them and I obviously have no issue with that. The kids are great, MB is a single mom who seemed really lovely from our first few meetings.

A few weeks ago, she sent me a text asking if I could come in now because she got called in to work. I lied and said I was in (big city in my state) visiting my sister for the weekend. It was a dumb white lie because I didn’t want to be asked during the weekend if she kept being called in, as that has happened multiple times before and I really needed a full weekend to myself. She simply responded “You don’t need to lie, I’ll find a backup.” It definitely gave me super weird vibes and was super embarassing, but I shrugged it off and figured she may have been at Trader Joes earlier in the day when I went, or she saw my car, something like that.

Then this Tuesday, I came in and she was definitely cold towards me. I had been out celebrating a friend’s birthday Monday night at a bar, but I nursed one drink the entire night and was never even tipsy. I take showers in the morning and wore clean clothes, so there’s no way I smelled like alcohol. But she confronted me and accused me of being hungover, said I reeked of booze, and kept asking if I had a drinking problem because why would I be drinking on a Monday night? I was really put off, and told her the truth, that it was my friend’s birthday and I was just out celebrating with her and some other friends and hadn’t even drank. She paused for a super long time and just nodded, and left for work like nothing happened. MB is super religious and very vehemently anti-alcohol, but I still feel like it was a weird accusation. I asked my girlfriend when I got home if I smelled like alcohol or anything somehow, and she couldn’t smell anything.

Earlier today was the final incident that really cemented this stupid conspiracy theory in my head. I took the bus this morning when I normally take my car because I’m extra broke right now and need to save gas. I got to her house around 10 minutes early, but sat in a little wooded curb area for a while until it was my official time to start.5 minutes before my start time, MB texts me “Have you left yet?? I have a meeting at 10:30.” I am NEVER late. I walked in early, and she looked confused. When I mentioned taking the bus, she literally said “Oh that makes sense.”

What the hell do I do? I looked all over my car, in my backpack, and in my car’s carseat… I couldn’t find anything. Am I overthinking this?

Edit: I just looked with the help from yall, and found an AirTag ductaped to the underside of my car. So, very very creeped out currently. Not sure what to say or do now.


Follow-up on r/LegalAdvice: My employer put an AirTag on my car

Same day

Hi, I’m having some major issues right now. For the full story check my post history, but the gist is that I’m a nanny for a single mom of two. I’ve only worked with her for about a month, and I knew she was tracking her children’s location. After a series of weird comments, people recommended I check my car for AirTags using an Android app, and I found one very well hidden and ductaped under my car.

I am super creeped out. I live in California, what is possible here? Can police do anything? I don’t feel safe to confront my boss, and have called out sick today.


Update: Update to employer tracking me

Sat, Feb 04, 2023

If you saw my post from last week, you know I found an AirTag under my car put there by my MB. Sorry for not updating sooner, I’ve been stressed and busy trying to get another job pretty much all day every day.

So I ended up calling the police. They came to my place and checked out the car, AirTag, etc, and they went and spoke with MB. AirTag was in her name, by the way, I know some people were suggesting it could be someone else (which sadly was a probability for a while because I do have a stalker, only making all of this more stressful).

MB was shocked that I had called the police over the tag and totally tried to gaslight the officers. She said that she put it there to make sure I wasn’t speeding and as backup if I lost their bags with the trackers. She also flat out lied and said she had told me, but I must not have been listening. They just gave her a warning, and no further action was taken. I honestly don’t think they really took my concern seriously. If anything, they seemed to side with her perspective. So that’s awesome. Sarcasm.

I’m obviously not working for her anymore, and have blocked her phone number because she was belittling me over calling the police over “her keeping her children safe.” On to the next job I guess. Anyone with advice on how to warn other nannies in my area is appreciated.


0

[Concluded] OOP wants recommendations for "terrible" places to take their racist great-aunt to in Houston, TX + UPDATE [Reddit]

preview

Original Reddit Post: Here

I am NOT the OOP

Update Post made by: Redditor u/red_earaches

Original post by: Redditor u/billionsandbillionsa in r/Houston

Trigger Warnings

potential discrimination, religious hypocrisy, MAGA


Recommendations for a Bad Time

May 22, 2026

I have my grandmother’s baby sister visiting next week. She’s in her 60s, but in very good shape and active. I kind of low-key hate her. She’s always making comments about my weight and why I’m not married and a list of other negative things. I want to take her out to places where she’ll be the most uncomfortable and potentially won’t be visiting Houston for a long time. She’s voted a certain way and her husband wears a red hat.

She’s very uncomfortable around minority groups. Where can I take her to make her visit miserable???

OOP clarifies in comments: I don’t ever contact her on my own but she is family and my mom and her are very close. She’s not a terrible person I just don’t prefer to be in her company. She’s just is very critical of younger people and always tries to give unsolicited advice and backhanded compliments.


Relevant Comments

Commenters give a wide variety of places to take this great-aunt to, including:

speaksoftly: Breakfast Klub. You’ll be in line for an hour, surrounded by black people enjoying themselves. (Breakfast Klub is known for its brunch soul food.)

cgreentx: Meow Wolf. Make sure you’re having an absolute blast and baffle them. They will be utterly confused and hate. (Meow Wolf is a radio station-theme immersive art experience that is known to be overstimulating.)

VanityJanitor: First, take her to the Houston farmers market. It’s a huge outdoor market with a bunch of spices, and it’s hella Mexican. Then stop at Gomez western wear so you can get her a true Texas outfit (also hella Mexican) before going jewelry shopping on Hillcroft Ave (Indian af).

And of course, stop at the Hong Kong food market before heading home. The penetrating fish smell and beautiful Asian culture is sure to put the nail in her maga coffin.

sashikku: Take her to Numbers (known for its alternative music venue and dance bar). Diverse environment, nowhere to sit, people dressed in anything from drag to BDSM gear.

Then take her to Boheme (known for its brunch drag shows).

Then take her to Menil Park (known for outside park and artwork). Also diverse crowd and it’s in the gayborhood.

ZaxZone: You can go visit the Donnellan Family Crypt under the Franklin Street Bridge. (It’s a 19-century creepy crypt.)

ThisIsNotACryForHelp:* Aga’s! The waitstaff are almost all immigrants, and if you go on Memorial Day, it will be so busy that you’ll have to wait outside with all of the other customers (who are typically mostly brown people) in the Houston humidity.

As a bonus, the food is top notch. But since she’s of the right-leaning persuasion, she probably won’t allow herself to enjoy such “exotic” foods as tikka masala or chicken makhani.

**SoSleepySue:**I’ll introduce her to my stepdad who doesn’t like the parking spot I picked, the grocery cart I picked, the way I drive, the way I shop, or the way I clean out his downspouts.



UPDATE

2 Weeks Later

I’m so grateful for everyone who contributed to the post. I never expected it to blow up so quickly.

For those who are wondering about my situation I do live with my parents, so my great-aunt visiting wasn’t something that I wanted but my mom and her are very close and I can’t control who visits my parents. I did spend a majority of the time in my room when she was there. But we did end up doing some family activities together.

I did get a lot of request to take my family to a drag show which I thought would be a hilarious suggestion, but my parents are very hardcore Christian and they would never go for such a thing. So I did suggest it very enthusiastically but was shut down immediately by them. At first they knew I was joking but I kept trying to push it and they said that “that’s the kind of event the devil lives at”.

I mentioned to my great aunt that according to the Bible, we’re all the bride of Christ so technically her husband Phil ( who’s ironically her 2nd husband) should identify as the bride of Christ. Which it wouldn’t and shouldn’t be considered sinful for men to express themselves as feminine since we are all the “bride of Christ”. This pissed them off in a way that gives me joy. It was mainly my mom who was scolding me, but my great aunt kept telling me she would pray for me. I told her as long as she was willing to pray I would like to give her some more prayer requests and she agreed. I told her to pray for the Palestinian children in Gaza and she literally rolled her eyes at me.

Saturday, we ended up visiting the zoo. We went around 10:30am and the parking was completely packed. I ended up circling the parking lot for at least 20 minutes with no success. All while my mom and aunt were back seat driving. I also did follow a person to their spot and sat in the lane and waited for them to put their three children in the car only to have another more aggressive driver overtake me and take my parking spot that I literally waited 5 minutes for. I thought it was so funny but my mom got absolutely livid. She wanted to get out of the car to confront them but told her to sit back down and shouting at these people wouldn’t be very Christ-like. I ended up driving off and parked in a paid hospital parking lot across the street from the zoo. We had to walk a far distance to the entry of the zoo in the hot sun, which I thought would piss my great aunt off but she didn’t actually complain about it and it was me who was a sweaty mess by the time we entered the zoo.

For lunch, I thought it was the most appropriate to take them to Trill burger since it’s pretty close to the zoo and the idea of greasy burgers and fries served in a casual style atmosphere with rap music blasting was exactly what I was going for. Bonus points because when we parked our car there were literally 2 cars hot boxing just a few feet away from us and the strong odor of cannabis isn’t something my family enjoys. My great aunt complained the whole time and at one point said something to the effect of “these people don’t even know how to spell THRILL burger”. It was such an interesting experience seeing some people dressed extremely well in suits and ties and others literally in their pajamas all in the same restaurant. I kept quietly singing along and nodding my head to the rhythm of the rap music that was playing in the background while my mom and great aunt kind of looked uncomfortable but continued chatting to themselves.

Unfortunately they didn’t allow me to choose dinner and my mom explained to me “we’re trying to have a good time” and we ended up eating at Taste of Texas which is a little more their scene. The waitress actually took a photo of us and printed it out as a gift since it was my great aunt’s first time and they wrapped a red bandanna around her and her husband was given a cowboy hat to take a picture with. My family had a great time there.

Sunday my family ended up going to church in the morning and I skipped out. But for a late dinner I kept telling them I was taking them to my favorite authentic BBQ spot. I took them straight to Chinatown and went to Gao’s Kabob, which is still bbq but definitely not what they expected. For those who never been there, it’s full of drunk Chinese people loudly singing Chinese love songs on a karaoke machine on a stage which is definitely not their scene. I ordered a bunch of pig feet and lamb skewers as well as spicy noodles. This definitely wasn’t what they were expecting and it didn’t seem like they ate much but they didn’t complain about it as much as Trill Burger. My mom kept saying we should have went to Treebeards.

Overall my great aunt actually kept an open mind about the places I took her and it was my mom who was the one who did the majority of the complaining. My great aunt told me she had a great time and is looking forward to me visiting her in Florida. I probably won’t be visiting anytime soon though.

Thanks to everyone for the suggestions!!! I love Houston!!


Reminder - I am not the original poster. DO NOT COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS.

Original Reddit Post: Here

I am NOT the OOP

Update Post made by: Redditor u/red_earaches

Original post by: Redditor u/billionsandbillionsa in r/Houston

Trigger Warnings

potential discrimination, religious hypocrisy, MAGA


Recommendations for a Bad Time

May 22, 2026

I have my grandmother’s baby sister visiting next week. She’s in her 60s, but in very good shape and active. I kind of low-key hate her. She’s always making comments about my weight and why I’m not married and a list of other negative things. I want to take her out to places where she’ll be the most uncomfortable and potentially won’t be visiting Houston for a long time. She’s voted a certain way and her husband wears a red hat.

She’s very uncomfortable around minority groups. Where can I take her to make her visit miserable???

OOP clarifies in comments: I don’t ever contact her on my own but she is family and my mom and her are very close. She’s not a terrible person I just don’t prefer to be in her company. She’s just is very critical of younger people and always tries to give unsolicited advice and backhanded compliments.


Relevant Comments

Commenters give a wide variety of places to take this great-aunt to, including:

speaksoftly: Breakfast Klub. You’ll be in line for an hour, surrounded by black people enjoying themselves. (Breakfast Klub is known for its brunch soul food.)

cgreentx: Meow Wolf. Make sure you’re having an absolute blast and baffle them. They will be utterly confused and hate. (Meow Wolf is a radio station-theme immersive art experience that is known to be overstimulating.)

VanityJanitor: First, take her to the Houston farmers market. It’s a huge outdoor market with a bunch of spices, and it’s hella Mexican. Then stop at Gomez western wear so you can get her a true Texas outfit (also hella Mexican) before going jewelry shopping on Hillcroft Ave (Indian af).

And of course, stop at the Hong Kong food market before heading home. The penetrating fish smell and beautiful Asian culture is sure to put the nail in her maga coffin.

sashikku: Take her to Numbers (known for its alternative music venue and dance bar). Diverse environment, nowhere to sit, people dressed in anything from drag to BDSM gear.

Then take her to Boheme (known for its brunch drag shows).

Then take her to Menil Park (known for outside park and artwork). Also diverse crowd and it’s in the gayborhood.

ZaxZone: You can go visit the Donnellan Family Crypt under the Franklin Street Bridge. (It’s a 19-century creepy crypt.)

ThisIsNotACryForHelp:* Aga’s! The waitstaff are almost all immigrants, and if you go on Memorial Day, it will be so busy that you’ll have to wait outside with all of the other customers (who are typically mostly brown people) in the Houston humidity.

As a bonus, the food is top notch. But since she’s of the right-leaning persuasion, she probably won’t allow herself to enjoy such “exotic” foods as tikka masala or chicken makhani.

**SoSleepySue:**I’ll introduce her to my stepdad who doesn’t like the parking spot I picked, the grocery cart I picked, the way I drive, the way I shop, or the way I clean out his downspouts.



UPDATE

2 Weeks Later

I’m so grateful for everyone who contributed to the post. I never expected it to blow up so quickly.

For those who are wondering about my situation I do live with my parents, so my great-aunt visiting wasn’t something that I wanted but my mom and her are very close and I can’t control who visits my parents. I did spend a majority of the time in my room when she was there. But we did end up doing some family activities together.

I did get a lot of request to take my family to a drag show which I thought would be a hilarious suggestion, but my parents are very hardcore Christian and they would never go for such a thing. So I did suggest it very enthusiastically but was shut down immediately by them. At first they knew I was joking but I kept trying to push it and they said that “that’s the kind of event the devil lives at”.

I mentioned to my great aunt that according to the Bible, we’re all the bride of Christ so technically her husband Phil ( who’s ironically her 2nd husband) should identify as the bride of Christ. Which it wouldn’t and shouldn’t be considered sinful for men to express themselves as feminine since we are all the “bride of Christ”. This pissed them off in a way that gives me joy. It was mainly my mom who was scolding me, but my great aunt kept telling me she would pray for me. I told her as long as she was willing to pray I would like to give her some more prayer requests and she agreed. I told her to pray for the Palestinian children in Gaza and she literally rolled her eyes at me.

Saturday, we ended up visiting the zoo. We went around 10:30am and the parking was completely packed. I ended up circling the parking lot for at least 20 minutes with no success. All while my mom and aunt were back seat driving. I also did follow a person to their spot and sat in the lane and waited for them to put their three children in the car only to have another more aggressive driver overtake me and take my parking spot that I literally waited 5 minutes for. I thought it was so funny but my mom got absolutely livid. She wanted to get out of the car to confront them but told her to sit back down and shouting at these people wouldn’t be very Christ-like. I ended up driving off and parked in a paid hospital parking lot across the street from the zoo. We had to walk a far distance to the entry of the zoo in the hot sun, which I thought would piss my great aunt off but she didn’t actually complain about it and it was me who was a sweaty mess by the time we entered the zoo.

For lunch, I thought it was the most appropriate to take them to Trill burger since it’s pretty close to the zoo and the idea of greasy burgers and fries served in a casual style atmosphere with rap music blasting was exactly what I was going for. Bonus points because when we parked our car there were literally 2 cars hot boxing just a few feet away from us and the strong odor of cannabis isn’t something my family enjoys. My great aunt complained the whole time and at one point said something to the effect of “these people don’t even know how to spell THRILL burger”. It was such an interesting experience seeing some people dressed extremely well in suits and ties and others literally in their pajamas all in the same restaurant. I kept quietly singing along and nodding my head to the rhythm of the rap music that was playing in the background while my mom and great aunt kind of looked uncomfortable but continued chatting to themselves.

Unfortunately they didn’t allow me to choose dinner and my mom explained to me “we’re trying to have a good time” and we ended up eating at Taste of Texas which is a little more their scene. The waitress actually took a photo of us and printed it out as a gift since it was my great aunt’s first time and they wrapped a red bandanna around her and her husband was given a cowboy hat to take a picture with. My family had a great time there.

Sunday my family ended up going to church in the morning and I skipped out. But for a late dinner I kept telling them I was taking them to my favorite authentic BBQ spot. I took them straight to Chinatown and went to Gao’s Kabob, which is still bbq but definitely not what they expected. For those who never been there, it’s full of drunk Chinese people loudly singing Chinese love songs on a karaoke machine on a stage which is definitely not their scene. I ordered a bunch of pig feet and lamb skewers as well as spicy noodles. This definitely wasn’t what they were expecting and it didn’t seem like they ate much but they didn’t complain about it as much as Trill Burger. My mom kept saying we should have went to Treebeards.

Overall my great aunt actually kept an open mind about the places I took her and it was my mom who was the one who did the majority of the complaining. My great aunt told me she had a great time and is looking forward to me visiting her in Florida. I probably won’t be visiting anytime soon though.

Thanks to everyone for the suggestions!!! I love Houston!!


Reminder - I am not the original poster. DO NOT COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS.

0

[Concluded] I (25M) “ruined” my girlfriends (28F) college graduation and she’s giving me grief for it months later [Reddit]

preview

Click for Original Reddit Post

This post was put together by: Reddit u/Direct-Caterpillar77

I am not The OOP, OOP is Reddit: u/ThrowRA-TheGraduate

Post was Originally Posted to: Reddit r/relationship_advice

Trigger Warning

Entitlement, emotional abuse


Original Reddit BoRU

Redditor Editors Note: the original BoRU was posted over 4 years ago and deleted, so reposting to bring back to the sub


Original Post

March 17, 2021

Hello. I don’t want to be content for your YouTube channel. If that’s your purpose, go away.

My gf finished college back in January. It’s been a long road for her - medical issues, mental problems and a change of major meant that her 5-year degree took seven. I graduated college a couple of years ago, and have been working ever since.

The run-up to her graduation was rough. She was stressed about her thesis, and I essentially didn’t have a partner for three months. I took care of everything at home, I helped her write her assignment, and I’m having a hard time keeping up at work, so I’m working maybe 5-10 hours of overtime every week.

For her graduation, I pulled out as many stops as I could. Her friends came to surprise her at a covid-approved distance outside our window, I made sure champagne was ready, and I had to leave the flat for a work thing, but came back ASAP when she had her final defence and got her grade. Which was the top one, of course, since she’s brilliant and poured her heart into this. I’d made sure her work got her flowers, and a lot of her family and friends remembered as well. We lived in a greenhouse for a good few days afterwards as they kept trickling in.

Anyway, we then went to pick up sushi of her choosing from her favourite place.

Now, for some context, I’ve been going through a rough time recently. I’ve been incredibly stressed, I’m in a new therapy schedule, and I felt very alone for months leading up to that day. On the day, work was particularly brutal. I’d felt like screaming the entire day.

When I graduated college, nobody really noticed. My girlfriend did a little thing with some champagne, but that was it. We did go out to eat as well.

So, when we were sat down for dinner, the immediate excitement of her grade and her finally finishing faded.

The last four months of emotional void kept creeping up on me, the stress of that particular awful day, and as much as I hate to admit it, a twinge of jealousy that she’s being celebrated so much more than I was.

As we were eating dinner, I was fighting back tears. I don’t know what the fuck happened to me. She could tell something was up, and I couldn’t keep up the facade for too long. I apologised profusely and went to get my shit together in the bathroom for a bit. I’ll be the first to admit that I wasn’t very fun for the rest of the evening.

Here’s the problem: she’s telling me I ruined her graduation from college. That particular word was used - I’ve ruined it. She told me a few days later, in tears, that I had to make up for it somehow. I asked her what to do, and she said ”just do what they’d do in a movie.”

Now, she’ll pull this line out occasionally. It’s an awful line, but I know what she means. She wants an over-the-top gesture, and it’s pretty obvious that she wants me to stage a new, fake graduation that I don’t fuck up.

But I’ll be honest, it’s hard. I just don’t have the energy to do it. She’ll bring it up now and again, and every time, she reiterates the same thing: The longer i wait, the more special and perfect it has to be.

I don’t do well under that kind of pressure. In fact, I hate it pretty intensely. So now I’m completely demotivated to do it, and I still feel a little betrayed.

On one hand, I get that she wanted the day to be all about just her.

On the other hand, I feel like I did everything I’m supposed to. I didn’t mean to get upset. I didn’t get angry, or lash out, or forget something, or fail to plan something up to code. I felt really shitty and started crying. And finally, I felt like it was the final day that was all about her on the tail end of four months where my needs, emotional or physical, didn’t exist.

What the fuck do I do? How do I talk to her about this in a way that doesn’t result in me feeling awful?

Tl;dr: Stress, emotional problems and general badness got the best of me during girlfriend’s college graduation dinner. I’ve now ruined it and she expects and over the top new fake graduation to compensate.


RELEVANT COMMENTS

Fragrant_Spray: Do like they do in a movie? Invite all her friends together, lock them in a room, and design a series of physical and psychological tortures?

Your gf dismissed your feelings on graduation day, and is upset that you aren’t addressing her feelings by jumping through a whole bunch of hoops for her entertainment. This attitude will continue if you don’t address it. Never trust someone who expects real life to be like the movies.

OOP: I’ll admit, that made me laugh pretty hard. Thanks, man.

Fragrant_Spray: In the romcoms she’s thinking about, there’s usually a scene where someone makes a big effort to make it work with a partner, and the partner is unappreciative (at the least). That’s when the protagonist realizes that they’re with the wrong person, which the audience knew all along. They realize that they aren’t being respected and they move on. If she wants to compare life to a movie, that’s the scene I think you’re seeing.

CherryBomb214: If I may be so bold…it kind of sounds like you’ve spent a LONG time attending to her needs above yours so I ask you: when does she attend to you? You should in an equal partnership. Who is taking care of you right now because you’ve just told us you’re spent and that’s okay. We all get spent some times. The key is to surround ourselves with people that help build us back up – not make things all about them.

I know this doesn’t answer your question directly but I really want you to take stock of how things are in your life and honestly examine your relationship.

OOP: Rarely. I’m not good at expressing my needs, though, so it’s not all on her. She’ll do nice things for me now and again, it’s not that, it’s just that when the chips are down, I have to be the glue every time. That’s okay, but I’m really down about this because at least she could be appreciative of it.

NotPiffany: Are you really bad at expressing your needs, or has she trained you not to express them in the first place?



Update 1

March 20, 2021 (3 Days Later)

Hey everyone. Thanks for the absolutely overwhelming amount of advice and attention you guys gave me. It was wonderful and, admittedly, a little terrifying.

I had a talk with my girlfriend last night. It was actually about her birthday, which is today. Some may have seen my dread for that in the comments of the last post. It went down exactly as I’d feared.

She asked me how many party supplies and decorations we had - I told her that I reckon we had enough, and she was upset that I didn’t go out and buy more.

Just to reiterate, here is my current agenda for the day:

  • Wake up at six AM to decorate the flat and get breakfast at a baker, including a custom-made cake from her favourite bakery that she likes. Keep in mind that her favourite rolls and favourite cake are in two different places, so I’m going two places.
  • have breakfast together
  • take her to see a castle she’s wanted to see nearby
  • buy her dinner from a place she’s been saying she wants to try
  • watch a film with her of her choosing
  • let her go early to bed without any grief.

Ladies and gentlemen, I have been told that I don’t put in any effort. See, none of these things count because she’s expressed a wish for doing them, or I’ve asked if she wants them. This means that they’re no longer surprises, and therefore not romantic.

I’ll be honest, that made me pretty livid, and especially so because she brought up the graduation again.

I told her that, in fact, I had given it some thought. We can have a day where we spoil her and get dinner somewhere nice or do something special, but I’m not throwing a new fake graduation, and I’m not accepting the premise that it has to be increasingly bombastic the longer I wait.

That didn’t go down well. In fact, she got increasingly angry that I didn’t understand that I’d ruined the most important day of her life so far. I asked her if all the gestures meant nothing because I got upset, and she said yes. She had to “walk on eggshells and couldn’t be limitlessly happy”, which ruined everything.

I told her how hard it was leading up to, and her reaction was to say I could’ve waited one more day to get upset then. I told her that I don’t feel as I get as much emotional support as I give, and she told me that her emotional support consists primarily of not leaning too much on me.

I feel like I’m taking crazy pills. What the hell do I do now? This was the weirdest conversation I’ve had for a long time.

Also, if you’ll have me excused, I have to go pick up a cake.🙃.


RELEVANT COMMENTS

[deleted]: She’s so ungrateful and nothing you do will ever be enough for her. May I ask what exactly she does for you? I expect her planning for your birthday to be nothing short of a weekend on Mars with a mariachi band. She doesn’t validate your feelings at all or try to be understanding. Please, do yourself a favour and get out of that toxic relationship. You don’t deserve to be emotionally beaten down every time there’s a celebration.

OOP: It’s funny, really. My birthday was a few weeks ago, and she planned roughly something akin to what I’ve done - except the restaurant I asked for was closed on Mondays, something she hadn’t investigated before the fact, and I had to think of something else. And pick it up after work, because she wanted us to go together and get it.

She did get me a really nice present, though, so that’s something, I guess. I felt it was just fine, but I’m not sure she would’ve been happy with it. 🤷🏼‍♂️.

Anti_Meta: Bro. This is word for word shit my soon to be ex-wife does/has said.

Going to skip all of the 8 years it took me to figure this out but I’mma stuff it into one sentence and set you free.

These are red flags of extremely low emotional intelligence. Extremely low. Everything bad in her life will be your fault, logic be damned.

Run your fucking ass off. I mean sell yourself naked for a bus ticket and deal with nude in public later.

nickis84: Why are you with this drama queen? Can you imagine how she’s going to be about her proposal? Heaven forbid you mess that up!



Update 2 An update from undersigned…

Apr 28, 2022 (1 year later)

I just remembered that this account exists - and I’m happy to come back and report that we broke up in the summer of last year.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, it got pretty ugly pretty fast, with her attempting all sorts of fun, manipulating things like going through my digital receipts, stealing my passport and the registration for my car, and gently implying to our common friends that I beat her.

So that was cool of her. We finished dealing with the last joint assets and dumb adult shit back around Christmas, and I haven’t seen or heard from her since some time in January.

As for me, I’m doing fucking great. I live in a tiny studio that costs a fortune, but my career is going phenomenally, I’ve met all sorts of great friends, and perhaps most importantly, I recently started dating someone. She’s fucking amazing, and she makes me feel appreciated in ways I didn’t think could happen.

I get it now. I get why other people like relationships.

Holy shit, that relationship was bad. I spent a long time after the breakup coming to terms with just how bad it was. I had experiences like a one-night stand that showed me more affection than she did. Shit was wild.

Afaik, she’s not doing too great. Life hit her pretty hard once I stopped being there to soften the blows for her - ironically, she’d always accuse me of being a loser that couldn’t take care of myself, lol.

There’s one main reason I’m back here, I guess. Go back and read my posts, and if it resonates with you, you deserve better. I want to let anyone know that no matter how deep that sunk cost feels, get out. It stings at first, but out here, you can breathe.


RELEVANT COMMENTS

Sweet-Advertising798: This is fantastic news, and you’re right, it will help a lot of other people in toxic relationships with narcissists.

Also - she stole your passport???!!! Wtf?

Are you still friends with anyone in the old friend group? Do they finally see her for who she really is?

OOP: Yeah - we had a box of “important documents” that she decided to swipe when she moved out, but she didn’t remove my things first. It was my passport, my college degree (how fitting, lmao), the registration for my car, and probably some other stuff. She gave it back eventually, but it was a hassle and a half.

All of our common friends except one either sided with me, or cut me out. The last guy is how I hear things now and again - but he’s keeping her at arms length after hearing the truth.



Update 3

May 2, 2021 (4 Days after 2nd update)

OOP showed up in the original BoRU comments

Hey everyone!

Wow, this blew up. I genuinely didn’t expect this many people to care about how I’m doing, but it’s nice to see. Everyone here is being incredibly lovely - and thanks to those who pinged me and told me about this thread.

I’m really glad to see those of you who said that they needed to read this, or the reminder to stick out the hard part. That’s why I kept this up - I actually considered deleting it, but I wanted to pass my lesson on instead. If anyone wants to talk in private, my messages are open.

Just to answer a few of the questions I see repeated here and there:

Can you share more details about how she’s doing?

Not really. I don’t know much, as our circles very much disentangled after the breakup. I try to avoid her, and I’ve blocked her everywhere, so I don’t get many updates except a loose mention here and there. I just know that she’s been having trouble with dealing with everything on her own.

Even if I knew, I wouldn’t tell, I think. I have no vindictive need to put her on blast - and my life isn’t about her anymore. That’s the best part. I’m not letting her live rent-free in my head any longer.

As much as I understand the spectator’s desire to see a toxic person get their comeuppance, it’s important to remember this: as long as I let her unhappiness make me happy, I’m still dependent on her feelings - just inversely so.

In that scenario, she still has power over me. I was truly free the day I no longer cared how she’s doing.

(on that note: for those of you who said I got a happy ending, I don’t think so. I got a new beginning, and that’s even better. For the first time in years, it doesn’t feel like my life is over.)

You were kind of shit too, weren’t you?

Yeah. I wasn’t a saint in that relationship, and while I maintain that I tried my hardest, I made mistakes too. I was bad at communicating my needs, bad at drawing boundaries, and bad at not keeping covert debts for nice things I did.

I’m working on being better. I’ve made conscious decisions to change those behaviours, and I’ve asked my new girlfriend to call me out on it if I ever do it. This story isn’t black and white, although the shades of grey aren’t exactly in the middle. I made mistakes too.


THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS.

Click for Original Reddit Post

This post was put together by: Reddit u/Direct-Caterpillar77

I am not The OOP, OOP is Reddit: u/ThrowRA-TheGraduate

Post was Originally Posted to: Reddit r/relationship_advice

Trigger Warning

Entitlement, emotional abuse


Original Reddit BoRU

Redditor Editors Note: the original BoRU was posted over 4 years ago and deleted, so reposting to bring back to the sub


Original Post

March 17, 2021

Hello. I don’t want to be content for your YouTube channel. If that’s your purpose, go away.

My gf finished college back in January. It’s been a long road for her - medical issues, mental problems and a change of major meant that her 5-year degree took seven. I graduated college a couple of years ago, and have been working ever since.

The run-up to her graduation was rough. She was stressed about her thesis, and I essentially didn’t have a partner for three months. I took care of everything at home, I helped her write her assignment, and I’m having a hard time keeping up at work, so I’m working maybe 5-10 hours of overtime every week.

For her graduation, I pulled out as many stops as I could. Her friends came to surprise her at a covid-approved distance outside our window, I made sure champagne was ready, and I had to leave the flat for a work thing, but came back ASAP when she had her final defence and got her grade. Which was the top one, of course, since she’s brilliant and poured her heart into this. I’d made sure her work got her flowers, and a lot of her family and friends remembered as well. We lived in a greenhouse for a good few days afterwards as they kept trickling in.

Anyway, we then went to pick up sushi of her choosing from her favourite place.

Now, for some context, I’ve been going through a rough time recently. I’ve been incredibly stressed, I’m in a new therapy schedule, and I felt very alone for months leading up to that day. On the day, work was particularly brutal. I’d felt like screaming the entire day.

When I graduated college, nobody really noticed. My girlfriend did a little thing with some champagne, but that was it. We did go out to eat as well.

So, when we were sat down for dinner, the immediate excitement of her grade and her finally finishing faded.

The last four months of emotional void kept creeping up on me, the stress of that particular awful day, and as much as I hate to admit it, a twinge of jealousy that she’s being celebrated so much more than I was.

As we were eating dinner, I was fighting back tears. I don’t know what the fuck happened to me. She could tell something was up, and I couldn’t keep up the facade for too long. I apologised profusely and went to get my shit together in the bathroom for a bit. I’ll be the first to admit that I wasn’t very fun for the rest of the evening.

Here’s the problem: she’s telling me I ruined her graduation from college. That particular word was used - I’ve ruined it. She told me a few days later, in tears, that I had to make up for it somehow. I asked her what to do, and she said ”just do what they’d do in a movie.”

Now, she’ll pull this line out occasionally. It’s an awful line, but I know what she means. She wants an over-the-top gesture, and it’s pretty obvious that she wants me to stage a new, fake graduation that I don’t fuck up.

But I’ll be honest, it’s hard. I just don’t have the energy to do it. She’ll bring it up now and again, and every time, she reiterates the same thing: The longer i wait, the more special and perfect it has to be.

I don’t do well under that kind of pressure. In fact, I hate it pretty intensely. So now I’m completely demotivated to do it, and I still feel a little betrayed.

On one hand, I get that she wanted the day to be all about just her.

On the other hand, I feel like I did everything I’m supposed to. I didn’t mean to get upset. I didn’t get angry, or lash out, or forget something, or fail to plan something up to code. I felt really shitty and started crying. And finally, I felt like it was the final day that was all about her on the tail end of four months where my needs, emotional or physical, didn’t exist.

What the fuck do I do? How do I talk to her about this in a way that doesn’t result in me feeling awful?

Tl;dr: Stress, emotional problems and general badness got the best of me during girlfriend’s college graduation dinner. I’ve now ruined it and she expects and over the top new fake graduation to compensate.


RELEVANT COMMENTS

Fragrant_Spray: Do like they do in a movie? Invite all her friends together, lock them in a room, and design a series of physical and psychological tortures?

Your gf dismissed your feelings on graduation day, and is upset that you aren’t addressing her feelings by jumping through a whole bunch of hoops for her entertainment. This attitude will continue if you don’t address it. Never trust someone who expects real life to be like the movies.

OOP: I’ll admit, that made me laugh pretty hard. Thanks, man.

Fragrant_Spray: In the romcoms she’s thinking about, there’s usually a scene where someone makes a big effort to make it work with a partner, and the partner is unappreciative (at the least). That’s when the protagonist realizes that they’re with the wrong person, which the audience knew all along. They realize that they aren’t being respected and they move on. If she wants to compare life to a movie, that’s the scene I think you’re seeing.

CherryBomb214: If I may be so bold…it kind of sounds like you’ve spent a LONG time attending to her needs above yours so I ask you: when does she attend to you? You should in an equal partnership. Who is taking care of you right now because you’ve just told us you’re spent and that’s okay. We all get spent some times. The key is to surround ourselves with people that help build us back up – not make things all about them.

I know this doesn’t answer your question directly but I really want you to take stock of how things are in your life and honestly examine your relationship.

OOP: Rarely. I’m not good at expressing my needs, though, so it’s not all on her. She’ll do nice things for me now and again, it’s not that, it’s just that when the chips are down, I have to be the glue every time. That’s okay, but I’m really down about this because at least she could be appreciative of it.

NotPiffany: Are you really bad at expressing your needs, or has she trained you not to express them in the first place?



Update 1

March 20, 2021 (3 Days Later)

Hey everyone. Thanks for the absolutely overwhelming amount of advice and attention you guys gave me. It was wonderful and, admittedly, a little terrifying.

I had a talk with my girlfriend last night. It was actually about her birthday, which is today. Some may have seen my dread for that in the comments of the last post. It went down exactly as I’d feared.

She asked me how many party supplies and decorations we had - I told her that I reckon we had enough, and she was upset that I didn’t go out and buy more.

Just to reiterate, here is my current agenda for the day:

  • Wake up at six AM to decorate the flat and get breakfast at a baker, including a custom-made cake from her favourite bakery that she likes. Keep in mind that her favourite rolls and favourite cake are in two different places, so I’m going two places.
  • have breakfast together
  • take her to see a castle she’s wanted to see nearby
  • buy her dinner from a place she’s been saying she wants to try
  • watch a film with her of her choosing
  • let her go early to bed without any grief.

Ladies and gentlemen, I have been told that I don’t put in any effort. See, none of these things count because she’s expressed a wish for doing them, or I’ve asked if she wants them. This means that they’re no longer surprises, and therefore not romantic.

I’ll be honest, that made me pretty livid, and especially so because she brought up the graduation again.

I told her that, in fact, I had given it some thought. We can have a day where we spoil her and get dinner somewhere nice or do something special, but I’m not throwing a new fake graduation, and I’m not accepting the premise that it has to be increasingly bombastic the longer I wait.

That didn’t go down well. In fact, she got increasingly angry that I didn’t understand that I’d ruined the most important day of her life so far. I asked her if all the gestures meant nothing because I got upset, and she said yes. She had to “walk on eggshells and couldn’t be limitlessly happy”, which ruined everything.

I told her how hard it was leading up to, and her reaction was to say I could’ve waited one more day to get upset then. I told her that I don’t feel as I get as much emotional support as I give, and she told me that her emotional support consists primarily of not leaning too much on me.

I feel like I’m taking crazy pills. What the hell do I do now? This was the weirdest conversation I’ve had for a long time.

Also, if you’ll have me excused, I have to go pick up a cake.🙃.


RELEVANT COMMENTS

[deleted]: She’s so ungrateful and nothing you do will ever be enough for her. May I ask what exactly she does for you? I expect her planning for your birthday to be nothing short of a weekend on Mars with a mariachi band. She doesn’t validate your feelings at all or try to be understanding. Please, do yourself a favour and get out of that toxic relationship. You don’t deserve to be emotionally beaten down every time there’s a celebration.

OOP: It’s funny, really. My birthday was a few weeks ago, and she planned roughly something akin to what I’ve done - except the restaurant I asked for was closed on Mondays, something she hadn’t investigated before the fact, and I had to think of something else. And pick it up after work, because she wanted us to go together and get it.

She did get me a really nice present, though, so that’s something, I guess. I felt it was just fine, but I’m not sure she would’ve been happy with it. 🤷🏼‍♂️.

Anti_Meta: Bro. This is word for word shit my soon to be ex-wife does/has said.

Going to skip all of the 8 years it took me to figure this out but I’mma stuff it into one sentence and set you free.

These are red flags of extremely low emotional intelligence. Extremely low. Everything bad in her life will be your fault, logic be damned.

Run your fucking ass off. I mean sell yourself naked for a bus ticket and deal with nude in public later.

nickis84: Why are you with this drama queen? Can you imagine how she’s going to be about her proposal? Heaven forbid you mess that up!



Update 2 An update from undersigned…

Apr 28, 2022 (1 year later)

I just remembered that this account exists - and I’m happy to come back and report that we broke up in the summer of last year.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, it got pretty ugly pretty fast, with her attempting all sorts of fun, manipulating things like going through my digital receipts, stealing my passport and the registration for my car, and gently implying to our common friends that I beat her.

So that was cool of her. We finished dealing with the last joint assets and dumb adult shit back around Christmas, and I haven’t seen or heard from her since some time in January.

As for me, I’m doing fucking great. I live in a tiny studio that costs a fortune, but my career is going phenomenally, I’ve met all sorts of great friends, and perhaps most importantly, I recently started dating someone. She’s fucking amazing, and she makes me feel appreciated in ways I didn’t think could happen.

I get it now. I get why other people like relationships.

Holy shit, that relationship was bad. I spent a long time after the breakup coming to terms with just how bad it was. I had experiences like a one-night stand that showed me more affection than she did. Shit was wild.

Afaik, she’s not doing too great. Life hit her pretty hard once I stopped being there to soften the blows for her - ironically, she’d always accuse me of being a loser that couldn’t take care of myself, lol.

There’s one main reason I’m back here, I guess. Go back and read my posts, and if it resonates with you, you deserve better. I want to let anyone know that no matter how deep that sunk cost feels, get out. It stings at first, but out here, you can breathe.


RELEVANT COMMENTS

Sweet-Advertising798: This is fantastic news, and you’re right, it will help a lot of other people in toxic relationships with narcissists.

Also - she stole your passport???!!! Wtf?

Are you still friends with anyone in the old friend group? Do they finally see her for who she really is?

OOP: Yeah - we had a box of “important documents” that she decided to swipe when she moved out, but she didn’t remove my things first. It was my passport, my college degree (how fitting, lmao), the registration for my car, and probably some other stuff. She gave it back eventually, but it was a hassle and a half.

All of our common friends except one either sided with me, or cut me out. The last guy is how I hear things now and again - but he’s keeping her at arms length after hearing the truth.



Update 3

May 2, 2021 (4 Days after 2nd update)

OOP showed up in the original BoRU comments

Hey everyone!

Wow, this blew up. I genuinely didn’t expect this many people to care about how I’m doing, but it’s nice to see. Everyone here is being incredibly lovely - and thanks to those who pinged me and told me about this thread.

I’m really glad to see those of you who said that they needed to read this, or the reminder to stick out the hard part. That’s why I kept this up - I actually considered deleting it, but I wanted to pass my lesson on instead. If anyone wants to talk in private, my messages are open.

Just to answer a few of the questions I see repeated here and there:

Can you share more details about how she’s doing?

Not really. I don’t know much, as our circles very much disentangled after the breakup. I try to avoid her, and I’ve blocked her everywhere, so I don’t get many updates except a loose mention here and there. I just know that she’s been having trouble with dealing with everything on her own.

Even if I knew, I wouldn’t tell, I think. I have no vindictive need to put her on blast - and my life isn’t about her anymore. That’s the best part. I’m not letting her live rent-free in my head any longer.

As much as I understand the spectator’s desire to see a toxic person get their comeuppance, it’s important to remember this: as long as I let her unhappiness make me happy, I’m still dependent on her feelings - just inversely so.

In that scenario, she still has power over me. I was truly free the day I no longer cared how she’s doing.

(on that note: for those of you who said I got a happy ending, I don’t think so. I got a new beginning, and that’s even better. For the first time in years, it doesn’t feel like my life is over.)

You were kind of shit too, weren’t you?

Yeah. I wasn’t a saint in that relationship, and while I maintain that I tried my hardest, I made mistakes too. I was bad at communicating my needs, bad at drawing boundaries, and bad at not keeping covert debts for nice things I did.

I’m working on being better. I’ve made conscious decisions to change those behaviours, and I’ve asked my new girlfriend to call me out on it if I ever do it. This story isn’t black and white, although the shades of grey aren’t exactly in the middle. I made mistakes too.


THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS.

0

[Inconclusive] Moved A Few Things into New Affordable Room. Woke up to Bedbug. Should I stay or leave? [Fedi:Lemmy]

preview

I am not the OOP, the OOP is theotherwoman

This is a repost community


Original Post:

Mar 4, 2025


Please help me, Lemmy.

I was staying at a friend’s for a month waiting for an affordable room to be available, only to move in and after a week see a bedbug.

It’s a single room, for poor people, with a shared kitchen.

I am poor, work remotely, and my financial situation is bad. I thought this could improve things.

I moved in a week ago, but didn’t move all my stuff in because it’s in boxes in my friend’s garage right now.

I have moved in with 2 outfits, 2 jackets, a work computer, some computer accessories, and have purchased 1 matress and pillow and bed sheet set at target.

The manager of the property beforehand said there haven’t been bed bugs for years, but one of the door has like a block over the bottom with powder in the doorway past the block to kill bugs as like a sort of trap. The manager said prior to my moving in this is just fear from 3 years ago. The units are very affordable and I had to be on a waitlist to get a unit.

I am not sure what to do. The place is mostly quiet and I could work here. I don’t love the area because although it’s low income rent, it’s in a high cost area with many food places nearby charging very high tourist amounts, like any burrito or sandwich is $13 at least. Rent is very low, however.

I could leave now before moving other stuff in, put my stuff in bags except for my work computer when getting back to my friends, and look for a different slightly more expensive place. I can’t stay with my friend long-term because her apartment is next to a distribution center with trucks pulling in and out all night and I wake up easily due to PTSD and always being on alert, even when sleeping. She sleeps through anything. I also don’t like ear-plugs and can’t sleep with them in. When I was staying there I was chronically tired.

Suggestions from Lemmy? How bad are bed bugs? It was only 1 but I squished it. Pest control coincidentally came that day and identified it is a bed bug.

Also, I have not paid rent for this month and it’s due by tomorrow. I could actually leave immediately, today even, and just not pay the rent. My credit is bad already and the money would be useful if it’s a mistake to stay. It’s sleazy to leave wirhout paying for this month, but I am poor and may not have the luxury of paying for a place that could result in a chronic bed bug infestation. I would also lose my deposit.

I also don’t know where it came from. I can’t be totally sure it didn’t come from my friend’s place although I stayed there 5 weeks and saw nothing bad. I also had purchased a new outfit from a store with vintage recycled clothes, like an upscale GoodWill store, but that was 2 weeks ago and there were no bites. It may not be from the new place, but I don’t think I was bitten before the move in. Strangely, I don’t even know if the bedbug I squished bit me. The pest control person said the city has many infestations and could have come from public transportation.

My friend lives 6 hours away by bus and I don’t know as many people there. It’s also a cheaper area and I could move there. I could actually just get a ticket and leave today if everything else is irrational.

I am very tired and don’t know what to think. The time at my friends impacted my mental health and I’m not sure I am seeing it rationally.


Comments

**ilmagico:**The problem is, if there’s bed bugs and you go somewhere else, it’s very likely they’ll attach to your belonging and hitch a hike to your new place… Best would be have the landlord take care of the issue, it is their responsibility after all.

If the landlord doesn’t cooperate, maybe you can tell them you’ll call pest control yourself and deduct the amount from the rent you owe… no idea how well that would go legally speaking, but maybe it’ll allow you some negotiating leverage. (obligatory IANAL)

OOP: If I stay, I won’t withhold rent. I am only withholding rent if I am leaving, and then I can say I left because it’s not habitable. These places are cheap and the legal costs of filing suit against me would not be worth recovery. They would keep my deposit and then I’d move on. It may be the rational thing to do, to just leave immediately.

grasshopper_mouse: Bed bugs are BAD. Where was the bug when you found it? Was it on you, the floor, your stuff? Was it alive or dead? Could you stay there a few more days without bringing the rest of your stuff from your friend’s place and see if more bugs appear?

Bed bugs spread quickly and can travel on you or your clothes and infest other locations. That being said, it may have just been one. Then again, if it came from the apartment next door, more will likely infiltrate your place. If they are coming from next door, it won’t be enough to spray just your apartment, the entire building will need it.

Sorry for the difficult situation you’re in, this is a tough call.

OOP: the bed bug was on my air mattress, on top of a target fitted sheet, below a larger target sheet used as a blanket. I saw it and squished it and blood came out. I don’t remember if it moved but seemed alive.

I could stay a few more days to see how it goes without bring more stuff in. But I would then need to pay this month’s rent or incur late fees and violate lease terms.

My stuff is all in a closet on shelves. The air mattress is on the ground. It could have come from another apartment. It may be that other residents know, but don’t want fumigation, hence the strange bug traps in front of a door and the white anti-bed-bug stuff sprinkled in front of another door. It could be the bugs come from the street, I slept with a windows open.

My room is almost empty so far.


Update:

Mar 10, 2025


fuck you spez

Now that that’s out of the way, here’s an exclusive Lemmy update on my horrible life with more questions.

After the last post, upon the advice of Lemmy, I put everything in trash bags, showered, and left with new clothes in shopping bags.

I changed into the new clothes in a Starbucks, at which the employees suspected I was an intravenous drug user and asked me if I was okay through the door, likely with Narcan in hand.

I told them I was fine, just washing my hands (which made no sense because I had been loudly placing things into garbage bags and opening sealed clothing packets in an echoey room without any water running). Then I continued to put more things in garbage bags, concealed slyly in large branded bags from Target.

Yes, they all thought I was a homeless junky, but it was actually much worse, and after over 10 minutes I emerged in a new sexy outfit, terrified that the police were being called, then grabbed my Frappachino and ran out.

I managed to get to the bus just in time.

All the bags were frozen for days and the contents washed. Everything was salvageable except my alarm clock radio which only plays static now and blinks strangely. It did not like being frozen and washed.

Since then, I have noticed 1 additional bite. I do not know if it was there before. I am terrified. Multiple days have passed since then, but it doesn’t prove I am safe since bed bugs can go days without feeding. If it turns out I still have them and may have spread them, I will deal with that guilt and agony when I know for sure.

I back with my friend but am now rethinking my approach, contemplating that I should have stayed at the bed bug place.

I did not end the tenancy when I left but did keep the cashier’s check that was the rent. I am still unsure of what to do.

I have a family member who is slowly dying in that area, I work remotely and expect I could lose my job any month, they’ve already gutted 90 percent of the department and I would expect other jobs will be next. I have survived many rounds of layoffs however. This family member lives in a small place and is somewhat crazy. I may not be able to see them if I am not in the area.

My credit has also taken a nosedive, so it will be very hard for me to rent something new. I’m considering going back and suffering instead of looking for something cheap here. I could probably get someone to cosign if I did look for a new place. I know no one in this area except my one friend who is not very social.

My head is completely messed up, even more than it was before. In the last post, people responded about the psychological devastation bed bugs cause. I am already there: 2 days of bed bugs and suddenly fleeing and I am on pins and needles, my normally mildly crazy brain gone extra bonkers with what ifs, fear, and suffering.

I am considering going back. The landlord won’t tell me how many treatments have been done in the past year. This seems concerning. I don’t know what to do. They did however do treatments to the room immediately after bed bugs were found, they said. I didn’t feel like they didn’t take it seriously, but am not entirely sure the building isn’t crawling with them all over in other rooms.

What would you do if you were me? Please, tell me Lemmy.

(in conclusion fuck spez)


Comments

Was_it_something_I_said: Bed bugs will only die from heat, not cold. You can put things in an industrial dryer at a Laundromat in high heat and it will kill them. That or not feeding them for over a year.

ch00f: Yeah, I think the cutoff is 122F which isn’t insanely high.

Mark Rober on the topic: www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JAOTJxYqh8

KingJalopy: There’s are a few reasonable responses in this thread but I’m a post control professional. If you want to feel free to message me and I’d be glad to tell you what you can do that will actually get rid of them. Diatomaceous Earth isn’t gonna cut it and cold will do nothing. You need heat and chemicals. They have likely laid eggs in the Tufts, or piping of the mattress. Pesticides won’t penetrate eggs so there is no one time treatment that will cure this. Even if you kill what’s alive you need to kill what hatches after before they lay more eggs. Insect growth regulators will also help. It will take time, patience, and professional grade products. If you can get your hands on crossfire or temprid those work best for bed bugs.

OOP: Would you recommend I return or is that too risky?

Keep in mind there are many, many small rooms there, over 50 likely.

KingJalopy: Oh if there’s that many rooms I would say it’s just gonna be a recurring issue unless they have hired a pest company to deal with this. I have a hotel account that I treat regularly. They have a legal obligation to do so if a customer complains but this is California. When we do find actual evidence of bed bugs we treat every room within 3 doors of that room even if it’s only the one room. They are prolific breeders and unless it’s being professionally addressed I wouldn’t risk it if you can avoid it.

I treat the entire hotel once a month and I still go there at least twice a month to address bed bugs when customers complain. Granted, at a hotel people are constantly coming and going and bringing them with them so it’s a constant battle.

Personally, I would find somewhere else unless the owner is proactively taking care of it. If not, you’ll be going through this more than once I can almost guarantee it.


Update in the Comments

Mar 13, 2025


I am considering going back more. The public health inspector I talked with said she last heard of a problem there in 2019, keep in mind this is an affordable housing place with 50+ units, and she said if there is pest control and they are doing treatments it doesn’t sound like a problem. Since many people there aren’t native English speakers, I unfortunately can’t easily ask many of the people who live there. Some of the other people seem a bit tough and I’m not sure how they would react to my approaching them.

I am really far away from most friends and family. I’m worried I may be making a mistake, especially if I were to suddenly get laid off. What if this is a treatable situation and I’m just overreacting?


Comments

MUTILATIONWAVE: You were being bitten by them. That’s an active infestation. People don’t just go pouring diatomaceous earth in doorways six years after there were bedbugs. I think you will regret living there. Health inspectors don’t know anything. They have no resources to inspect apartments. They can maybe make it to every restaurant twice a year in my experience.



OOPs last post was a year+ ago so we may never know what they decided to do. Marking this one as inconclusive

I am not the OOP

Do not message anyone mentioned in this post.

I am not the OOP, the OOP is theotherwoman

This is a repost community


Original Post:

Mar 4, 2025


Please help me, Lemmy.

I was staying at a friend’s for a month waiting for an affordable room to be available, only to move in and after a week see a bedbug.

It’s a single room, for poor people, with a shared kitchen.

I am poor, work remotely, and my financial situation is bad. I thought this could improve things.

I moved in a week ago, but didn’t move all my stuff in because it’s in boxes in my friend’s garage right now.

I have moved in with 2 outfits, 2 jackets, a work computer, some computer accessories, and have purchased 1 matress and pillow and bed sheet set at target.

The manager of the property beforehand said there haven’t been bed bugs for years, but one of the door has like a block over the bottom with powder in the doorway past the block to kill bugs as like a sort of trap. The manager said prior to my moving in this is just fear from 3 years ago. The units are very affordable and I had to be on a waitlist to get a unit.

I am not sure what to do. The place is mostly quiet and I could work here. I don’t love the area because although it’s low income rent, it’s in a high cost area with many food places nearby charging very high tourist amounts, like any burrito or sandwich is $13 at least. Rent is very low, however.

I could leave now before moving other stuff in, put my stuff in bags except for my work computer when getting back to my friends, and look for a different slightly more expensive place. I can’t stay with my friend long-term because her apartment is next to a distribution center with trucks pulling in and out all night and I wake up easily due to PTSD and always being on alert, even when sleeping. She sleeps through anything. I also don’t like ear-plugs and can’t sleep with them in. When I was staying there I was chronically tired.

Suggestions from Lemmy? How bad are bed bugs? It was only 1 but I squished it. Pest control coincidentally came that day and identified it is a bed bug.

Also, I have not paid rent for this month and it’s due by tomorrow. I could actually leave immediately, today even, and just not pay the rent. My credit is bad already and the money would be useful if it’s a mistake to stay. It’s sleazy to leave wirhout paying for this month, but I am poor and may not have the luxury of paying for a place that could result in a chronic bed bug infestation. I would also lose my deposit.

I also don’t know where it came from. I can’t be totally sure it didn’t come from my friend’s place although I stayed there 5 weeks and saw nothing bad. I also had purchased a new outfit from a store with vintage recycled clothes, like an upscale GoodWill store, but that was 2 weeks ago and there were no bites. It may not be from the new place, but I don’t think I was bitten before the move in. Strangely, I don’t even know if the bedbug I squished bit me. The pest control person said the city has many infestations and could have come from public transportation.

My friend lives 6 hours away by bus and I don’t know as many people there. It’s also a cheaper area and I could move there. I could actually just get a ticket and leave today if everything else is irrational.

I am very tired and don’t know what to think. The time at my friends impacted my mental health and I’m not sure I am seeing it rationally.


Comments

**ilmagico:**The problem is, if there’s bed bugs and you go somewhere else, it’s very likely they’ll attach to your belonging and hitch a hike to your new place… Best would be have the landlord take care of the issue, it is their responsibility after all.

If the landlord doesn’t cooperate, maybe you can tell them you’ll call pest control yourself and deduct the amount from the rent you owe… no idea how well that would go legally speaking, but maybe it’ll allow you some negotiating leverage. (obligatory IANAL)

OOP: If I stay, I won’t withhold rent. I am only withholding rent if I am leaving, and then I can say I left because it’s not habitable. These places are cheap and the legal costs of filing suit against me would not be worth recovery. They would keep my deposit and then I’d move on. It may be the rational thing to do, to just leave immediately.

grasshopper_mouse: Bed bugs are BAD. Where was the bug when you found it? Was it on you, the floor, your stuff? Was it alive or dead? Could you stay there a few more days without bringing the rest of your stuff from your friend’s place and see if more bugs appear?

Bed bugs spread quickly and can travel on you or your clothes and infest other locations. That being said, it may have just been one. Then again, if it came from the apartment next door, more will likely infiltrate your place. If they are coming from next door, it won’t be enough to spray just your apartment, the entire building will need it.

Sorry for the difficult situation you’re in, this is a tough call.

OOP: the bed bug was on my air mattress, on top of a target fitted sheet, below a larger target sheet used as a blanket. I saw it and squished it and blood came out. I don’t remember if it moved but seemed alive.

I could stay a few more days to see how it goes without bring more stuff in. But I would then need to pay this month’s rent or incur late fees and violate lease terms.

My stuff is all in a closet on shelves. The air mattress is on the ground. It could have come from another apartment. It may be that other residents know, but don’t want fumigation, hence the strange bug traps in front of a door and the white anti-bed-bug stuff sprinkled in front of another door. It could be the bugs come from the street, I slept with a windows open.

My room is almost empty so far.


Update:

Mar 10, 2025


fuck you spez

Now that that’s out of the way, here’s an exclusive Lemmy update on my horrible life with more questions.

After the last post, upon the advice of Lemmy, I put everything in trash bags, showered, and left with new clothes in shopping bags.

I changed into the new clothes in a Starbucks, at which the employees suspected I was an intravenous drug user and asked me if I was okay through the door, likely with Narcan in hand.

I told them I was fine, just washing my hands (which made no sense because I had been loudly placing things into garbage bags and opening sealed clothing packets in an echoey room without any water running). Then I continued to put more things in garbage bags, concealed slyly in large branded bags from Target.

Yes, they all thought I was a homeless junky, but it was actually much worse, and after over 10 minutes I emerged in a new sexy outfit, terrified that the police were being called, then grabbed my Frappachino and ran out.

I managed to get to the bus just in time.

All the bags were frozen for days and the contents washed. Everything was salvageable except my alarm clock radio which only plays static now and blinks strangely. It did not like being frozen and washed.

Since then, I have noticed 1 additional bite. I do not know if it was there before. I am terrified. Multiple days have passed since then, but it doesn’t prove I am safe since bed bugs can go days without feeding. If it turns out I still have them and may have spread them, I will deal with that guilt and agony when I know for sure.

I back with my friend but am now rethinking my approach, contemplating that I should have stayed at the bed bug place.

I did not end the tenancy when I left but did keep the cashier’s check that was the rent. I am still unsure of what to do.

I have a family member who is slowly dying in that area, I work remotely and expect I could lose my job any month, they’ve already gutted 90 percent of the department and I would expect other jobs will be next. I have survived many rounds of layoffs however. This family member lives in a small place and is somewhat crazy. I may not be able to see them if I am not in the area.

My credit has also taken a nosedive, so it will be very hard for me to rent something new. I’m considering going back and suffering instead of looking for something cheap here. I could probably get someone to cosign if I did look for a new place. I know no one in this area except my one friend who is not very social.

My head is completely messed up, even more than it was before. In the last post, people responded about the psychological devastation bed bugs cause. I am already there: 2 days of bed bugs and suddenly fleeing and I am on pins and needles, my normally mildly crazy brain gone extra bonkers with what ifs, fear, and suffering.

I am considering going back. The landlord won’t tell me how many treatments have been done in the past year. This seems concerning. I don’t know what to do. They did however do treatments to the room immediately after bed bugs were found, they said. I didn’t feel like they didn’t take it seriously, but am not entirely sure the building isn’t crawling with them all over in other rooms.

What would you do if you were me? Please, tell me Lemmy.

(in conclusion fuck spez)


Comments

Was_it_something_I_said: Bed bugs will only die from heat, not cold. You can put things in an industrial dryer at a Laundromat in high heat and it will kill them. That or not feeding them for over a year.

ch00f: Yeah, I think the cutoff is 122F which isn’t insanely high.

Mark Rober on the topic: www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JAOTJxYqh8

KingJalopy: There’s are a few reasonable responses in this thread but I’m a post control professional. If you want to feel free to message me and I’d be glad to tell you what you can do that will actually get rid of them. Diatomaceous Earth isn’t gonna cut it and cold will do nothing. You need heat and chemicals. They have likely laid eggs in the Tufts, or piping of the mattress. Pesticides won’t penetrate eggs so there is no one time treatment that will cure this. Even if you kill what’s alive you need to kill what hatches after before they lay more eggs. Insect growth regulators will also help. It will take time, patience, and professional grade products. If you can get your hands on crossfire or temprid those work best for bed bugs.

OOP: Would you recommend I return or is that too risky?

Keep in mind there are many, many small rooms there, over 50 likely.

KingJalopy: Oh if there’s that many rooms I would say it’s just gonna be a recurring issue unless they have hired a pest company to deal with this. I have a hotel account that I treat regularly. They have a legal obligation to do so if a customer complains but this is California. When we do find actual evidence of bed bugs we treat every room within 3 doors of that room even if it’s only the one room. They are prolific breeders and unless it’s being professionally addressed I wouldn’t risk it if you can avoid it.

I treat the entire hotel once a month and I still go there at least twice a month to address bed bugs when customers complain. Granted, at a hotel people are constantly coming and going and bringing them with them so it’s a constant battle.

Personally, I would find somewhere else unless the owner is proactively taking care of it. If not, you’ll be going through this more than once I can almost guarantee it.


Update in the Comments

Mar 13, 2025


I am considering going back more. The public health inspector I talked with said she last heard of a problem there in 2019, keep in mind this is an affordable housing place with 50+ units, and she said if there is pest control and they are doing treatments it doesn’t sound like a problem. Since many people there aren’t native English speakers, I unfortunately can’t easily ask many of the people who live there. Some of the other people seem a bit tough and I’m not sure how they would react to my approaching them.

I am really far away from most friends and family. I’m worried I may be making a mistake, especially if I were to suddenly get laid off. What if this is a treatable situation and I’m just overreacting?


Comments

MUTILATIONWAVE: You were being bitten by them. That’s an active infestation. People don’t just go pouring diatomaceous earth in doorways six years after there were bedbugs. I think you will regret living there. Health inspectors don’t know anything. They have no resources to inspect apartments. They can maybe make it to every restaurant twice a year in my experience.



OOPs last post was a year+ ago so we may never know what they decided to do. Marking this one as inconclusive

I am not the OOP

Do not message anyone mentioned in this post.

0

[Concluded] TIFU by not telling my doctor how many Tic-Tacs I eat per day [Reddit]

preview

TIFU by not telling my doctor how many Tic-Tacs I eat per day + 2 year update

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/DumpsterPuff

Thank you Reddit user: Direct-Caterpullar77 for compiling this story

Originally posted to r/tifu


Original Post 

Apr 24, 2024

So I’m absolutely fucking obsessed with the Fruit Adventure flavor of Tic-Tacs. The flavor combined with the soft smush they make between your teeth when you chew them makes my brain very happy. I’ve been buying them in bulk, where each container has 200 candies each, and they come in bulk packs of 12 containers. I tend to eat them by the handful while I’m working or gaming, so in a day I can easily slam through 1-2 containers.

Now keep in mind that on the nutrition label, it says the serving size is 1 candy, and is listed as having 0 calories, which I thought was awesome because I could have as many as I want!

Over the past year, I found that I gained about 40lbs, and nothing about my eating habits had changed as far as I was aware. I told my doctor about it and she was a bit worried, so she had me do a bunch of bloodwork to see if there was a reason why I gained so much weight in a short period of time. Everything came back normal. She referred me to see a weight loss doctor who would also have me see a dietician.

I had been working with the dietician for a few months now, and we have me keep a food log. I had a virtual visit with her today and during it, I was fiddling around with an empty container to keep my hands busy. She saw it and asked where I got such a large container from, so I told her about it and how I eat 1-2 of those per day. She asked why those weren’t on my food tracker and I said it was because they’re 0 calories so they wouldn’t count.

Apparently I was very, very wrong about this. She explained to me that food companies can label something as being “0 calories” if the food’s serving size contains 5 or less calories. In reality, each individual Tic-Tac actully has about 2 calories. So essentially, since each container has 200 pieces and I typically have 1-2 of those, I’ve been eating 400-800+ calories per day of Tic-Tacs, in addition to all the other food I’ve been eating - which is very likely why I’ve gained so much weight.

TL;DR: Didn’t realize that tic-tacs weren’t actually 0 calories and gained a ton of weight because I eat so many a day.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

Not3kidsinasuit: I just finished a diploma in a medical field, we were warned about people like you OP. I wish I was joking.

AngstyToddler: Reminds me of when I went to a friend’s house and watched him take the pump off a bottle of spray butter and just dump it into the mashed potatoes. I asked him why he didn’t just use butter or margarine and he said it was because the spray butter was zero calories. I had to explain the whole concept of “per spray” and did the math to show it had almost the exact same calories as margarine. His wife had gained about 30 lbs since they’d married the year before, and it was apparently because most of his diet hacks meant she was actually eating more calories than ever.

ETA: Remembered another one. He was buying low calorie bread, but never compared the calories to regular bread. Just assumed it was much, much less. Instead of serving her 2 slices of regular bread each morning (190 calories) he was serving her 4 slices of lower calorie bread (240 calories - slathered with “zero calorie” butter spray, of course).

skoulker: Tic tacs are funny. LESS THAN ONE GRAM OF SUGAR PER SERVING!!! But a serving is like one or two and they weigh so little it’s under a gram. (Less than a gram of pure sugar is still sugar)

[deleted] .49 grams per tic tac. Under .5 grams can be considered sugar free.

kafelta: Bro ate 40lbs of tictacs


Edits

made to the original post

Edit 1: Just wanted to clarify that I’m aware that sugar will in fact make you gain weight (I’m not that stupid), but I never actually read the product ingredients. I assumed they must have been made with something like Xylitol or some other artificial sweetener to make them “0 calories” so it never crossed my mind to check!

Edit 2: Dang y’all are brutal lmao. But at least some good came out of it since apparently, like me, a lot of people didn’t realize about the “less than 5 calories per serving” rule can legally be classified as 0 in the US. Personally I wish we could have the model they do in other countries where they list calories per X amount of grams.

Edit 3: MY TEETH ARE FINE 😂 I actually just had a dentist appointment two weeks ago. No cavities or decay, gums are healthy. Despite my candy habit I do take good care of my teeth!


OOP Updated

Aug 15, 2026/Same Post (over 2 Years later)

Edit 4: It’s 08/15/26 and I actually forgot about this post until the other day and I figured I’d share an update. So I did stop eating the tictacs, but did find out I have a legitimate health condition afterwards. After my gallbladder removal a few years ago, I kept having issues where I felt shaky, confused, lethargic, dizzy, irritable, and sweaty shortly after eating meals, especially in the middle of the day. All I knew was that if I grazed on tictacs throughout the day, my symptoms would go away. When I stopped eating the tictacs, my symptoms came back and my doctor had me wear a continuous blood glucose monitor, which was showing readings that kept hitting the low 60s/high 50s, indicating hypoglycemia.

It turns out I developed a condition as a result of the gallbladder removal called postprandial hypoglycemia, meaning you get rapidly dropping blood sugar shortly after eating meals. They don’t exactly know why the gallbladder removal causes it, but it explains why the tictacs made me feel better because it prevented those huge drops. After we figured this out, doctor put me on Zepbound in hopes that it will stop those blood sugar crashes. Thankfully it worked and I no longer need to eat candy to feel normal again! And I’ve been losing some of that weight I gained too. But yeah, it was a wild ride.


Reddit BoRU Comments of Note

Cassandracork: … did I just learn what is causing me to feel exhausted after meals from a BORU? (Had gallbladder removed last year, had issue ever since.)

TheNightTerror1987: Okay, that bit about gallbladder removal causing postprandial hypoglycemia for OOP is a bit alarming considering that he described how I feel when I eat pit foods, as I call them, (food that makes me hungry if I eat it) eating chocolate helped when I felt like that, and I’ve had my gallbladder out too . . .


THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS

TIFU by not telling my doctor how many Tic-Tacs I eat per day + 2 year update

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/DumpsterPuff

Thank you Reddit user: Direct-Caterpullar77 for compiling this story

Originally posted to r/tifu


Original Post 

Apr 24, 2024

So I’m absolutely fucking obsessed with the Fruit Adventure flavor of Tic-Tacs. The flavor combined with the soft smush they make between your teeth when you chew them makes my brain very happy. I’ve been buying them in bulk, where each container has 200 candies each, and they come in bulk packs of 12 containers. I tend to eat them by the handful while I’m working or gaming, so in a day I can easily slam through 1-2 containers.

Now keep in mind that on the nutrition label, it says the serving size is 1 candy, and is listed as having 0 calories, which I thought was awesome because I could have as many as I want!

Over the past year, I found that I gained about 40lbs, and nothing about my eating habits had changed as far as I was aware. I told my doctor about it and she was a bit worried, so she had me do a bunch of bloodwork to see if there was a reason why I gained so much weight in a short period of time. Everything came back normal. She referred me to see a weight loss doctor who would also have me see a dietician.

I had been working with the dietician for a few months now, and we have me keep a food log. I had a virtual visit with her today and during it, I was fiddling around with an empty container to keep my hands busy. She saw it and asked where I got such a large container from, so I told her about it and how I eat 1-2 of those per day. She asked why those weren’t on my food tracker and I said it was because they’re 0 calories so they wouldn’t count.

Apparently I was very, very wrong about this. She explained to me that food companies can label something as being “0 calories” if the food’s serving size contains 5 or less calories. In reality, each individual Tic-Tac actully has about 2 calories. So essentially, since each container has 200 pieces and I typically have 1-2 of those, I’ve been eating 400-800+ calories per day of Tic-Tacs, in addition to all the other food I’ve been eating - which is very likely why I’ve gained so much weight.

TL;DR: Didn’t realize that tic-tacs weren’t actually 0 calories and gained a ton of weight because I eat so many a day.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

Not3kidsinasuit: I just finished a diploma in a medical field, we were warned about people like you OP. I wish I was joking.

AngstyToddler: Reminds me of when I went to a friend’s house and watched him take the pump off a bottle of spray butter and just dump it into the mashed potatoes. I asked him why he didn’t just use butter or margarine and he said it was because the spray butter was zero calories. I had to explain the whole concept of “per spray” and did the math to show it had almost the exact same calories as margarine. His wife had gained about 30 lbs since they’d married the year before, and it was apparently because most of his diet hacks meant she was actually eating more calories than ever.

ETA: Remembered another one. He was buying low calorie bread, but never compared the calories to regular bread. Just assumed it was much, much less. Instead of serving her 2 slices of regular bread each morning (190 calories) he was serving her 4 slices of lower calorie bread (240 calories - slathered with “zero calorie” butter spray, of course).

skoulker: Tic tacs are funny. LESS THAN ONE GRAM OF SUGAR PER SERVING!!! But a serving is like one or two and they weigh so little it’s under a gram. (Less than a gram of pure sugar is still sugar)

[deleted] .49 grams per tic tac. Under .5 grams can be considered sugar free.

kafelta: Bro ate 40lbs of tictacs


Edits

made to the original post

Edit 1: Just wanted to clarify that I’m aware that sugar will in fact make you gain weight (I’m not that stupid), but I never actually read the product ingredients. I assumed they must have been made with something like Xylitol or some other artificial sweetener to make them “0 calories” so it never crossed my mind to check!

Edit 2: Dang y’all are brutal lmao. But at least some good came out of it since apparently, like me, a lot of people didn’t realize about the “less than 5 calories per serving” rule can legally be classified as 0 in the US. Personally I wish we could have the model they do in other countries where they list calories per X amount of grams.

Edit 3: MY TEETH ARE FINE 😂 I actually just had a dentist appointment two weeks ago. No cavities or decay, gums are healthy. Despite my candy habit I do take good care of my teeth!


OOP Updated

Aug 15, 2026/Same Post (over 2 Years later)

Edit 4: It’s 08/15/26 and I actually forgot about this post until the other day and I figured I’d share an update. So I did stop eating the tictacs, but did find out I have a legitimate health condition afterwards. After my gallbladder removal a few years ago, I kept having issues where I felt shaky, confused, lethargic, dizzy, irritable, and sweaty shortly after eating meals, especially in the middle of the day. All I knew was that if I grazed on tictacs throughout the day, my symptoms would go away. When I stopped eating the tictacs, my symptoms came back and my doctor had me wear a continuous blood glucose monitor, which was showing readings that kept hitting the low 60s/high 50s, indicating hypoglycemia.

It turns out I developed a condition as a result of the gallbladder removal called postprandial hypoglycemia, meaning you get rapidly dropping blood sugar shortly after eating meals. They don’t exactly know why the gallbladder removal causes it, but it explains why the tictacs made me feel better because it prevented those huge drops. After we figured this out, doctor put me on Zepbound in hopes that it will stop those blood sugar crashes. Thankfully it worked and I no longer need to eat candy to feel normal again! And I’ve been losing some of that weight I gained too. But yeah, it was a wild ride.


Reddit BoRU Comments of Note

Cassandracork: … did I just learn what is causing me to feel exhausted after meals from a BORU? (Had gallbladder removed last year, had issue ever since.)

TheNightTerror1987: Okay, that bit about gallbladder removal causing postprandial hypoglycemia for OOP is a bit alarming considering that he described how I feel when I eat pit foods, as I call them, (food that makes me hungry if I eat it) eating chocolate helped when I felt like that, and I’ve had my gallbladder out too . . .


THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS

0

[Concluded] my new manager is someone I slept with years ago … and he doesn’t know we have a child [AAM]

Ask a Manager my new manager is someone I slept with years ago ... and he doesn't know we have a child www.askamanager.org
preview

I am NOT OOP

Originally posted to: Ask A Manager

Trigger Warning

hostile workplace, possible sexism


Original Post:

October 16, 2023

The backstory: I went back to university in my late 20s to do my PhD, and shared an office with a few other students for many years. One of the students, Jacob, completed his thesis and was moving back to his home country, so we all went out for congratulatory/farewell drinks. One thing led to another and Jacob and I spent the night together. A few weeks later, I realized I was pregnant and I had no way to contact Jacob. His university email and mobile number had been deactivated since he’d left the university and the country. I didn’t need anything from him and was fine to raise the child alone, but I thought he had a right to know. I googled him a few times over the years but never found him.

This last week, our department head emailed everyone to introduce and welcome our new manager, Jacob, with a photo and a blurb about his education and work history so I know for sure it’s him. The night we spent together changed my life because it made me a parent, so I have thought about Jacob from time to time when my daughter asks about her dad or I notice a genetic trait she didn’t get from me. However, I doubt Jacob has given that night a second thought. I have no idea whether he will have any concerns about being my manager given our history, or whether I’m making a bigger deal of this than I should. For what it’s worth, in my years of sharing an office with Jacob, he seemed easy-going and practical.

In our company, it is common for everyone in the department to reply-all to these introduction emails and introduce themselves, welcome the newcomer aboard and explain how their role will interact with theirs. I’m not sure if my email should note that Jacob and I studied together years ago as a way to get that out in the open? Or should I email him individually and offer to have a discussion about keeping our history out of the workplace if he thinks it’s needed? I’d appreciate any suggestions for language that indicates I’m not concerned and will be completely professional.

And then, in direct contradiction to that, I’d also appreciate a script for a separate email saying “can we please meet outside of work because I need to tell you something important about our history” so I can tell him about his daughter. If you or any commenters think I shouldn’t tell him, or I should let him settle in to his new country and new job first, I would definitely take that on board.

For Alison’s response to OOP, please refer to the link here

Additional Information from OOP after Alison pinned her comment onto the post:

Thanks for your comment at the top, Alison. The extent to which I tried to find Jacob wasn’t relevant to my question so I didn’t include the efforts I went to. For the commenters who are curious (understandably), I really did try when I first found out I was pregnant. I asked the other people we shared an office with, but no one had any information. We were students who shared an office and sometimes went to the uni bar together, we never spent any time together outside of uni. I asked Jacob’s thesis supervisor, but it was Christmas/Australian summer here so he was on leave for two months. When he got back, he gave me the address on Jacob’s file, which was of course the Australian address he didn’t live at anymore. The uni had a “next of kin” Australian contact number on file for his aunt, but no one ever answered it when I rang. Jacob is Chinese with a very common surname, and “Jacob” is just the name he used in my country, I don’t know his actual given name. So attempts to find the correct “Mr Wong”, in a country where they don’t use Google or Facebook, went nowhere. I searched for recent publications about Jacob’s thesis topic and found a paper with “Jacob Wong” as one of the authors. I contacted the “corresponding author” and asked for Jacob’s email but they never responded. By this point, I had to give up because I was so sick with hyperemesis gravidarum and needed to focus on my baby’s health.


Update #1:

June 11, 2024 (About 8 months later)

Thank you for answering my letter. You were right, it was a really big deal. I was viewing the Jacob-as-my-manager problem from his perspective — until I told him otherwise, it was just a simple one night stand over a decade ago — and it didn’t seem like a huge problem. I hated and appreciated the reality check. I regret reading the comments, but thank you also for moderating them as quickly as you did.

A lot happened in a short space of time (thankfully I already had a therapist!). First, I spoke to my union rep who said, “Say NOTHING but call us if HR tries to set up a meeting with you.” Staying silent and having Jacob independently declare the prior relationship when he arrived would have been problematic because I’d still end up in the same position and I would have lied by omission. Our HR team can be gossipy and they know the age of my half-Chinese daughter, so I needed to have as much control as possible over the disclosure. I spoke to an employment lawyer who reviewed our policies and, at his suggestion, I wrote an email to HR declaring a prior relationship with Jacob.

And then I was immediately pushed out. Even if you have all the legal support in the world, you can’t prevent someone from doing something illegal, you just have recourse afterwards. In a meeting with my lawyer, the union rep, HR, and a member of the senior management team, I was asked to resign. When I said no, they insisted on a statutory declaration about the relationship with Jacob stating what happened, when it happened, how many times it happened (??) and who initiated it (??). I also said no to that. We ended the meeting with each side agreeing to think about possible solutions.

The company’s solution was to start messing with my pay, my benefits, my swipe card access to my office, my computer log in, and my email/calendar account. They spread rumors about me and I heard coworkers whispering that I’d had an affair with a manager. They sent me for a “random” drug test at a time when I was scheduled for an important meeting with clients. They cancelled accommodation that had been booked for upcoming travel, which I only found out about because I was getting paranoid and called the hotel.

I can’t describe how awful it feels to know that someone with this kind of power over your job is devoting their time and energy to thinking of ways to screw with you. Every day I was going into work wondering what was waiting for me and it was wearing me down fast. The advice from the union rep was to go back in time and follow their first piece of advice, or just keep documenting everything as we prepared to take legal action. The lawyer estimated that it would take at least a year to get any kind of resolution, and I didn’t even want the job anymore. By this point, I wasn’t sleeping much and I had cried a few times at work. I was beginning to crack and we were only just getting started.

So, I resigned. I wish I’d held up better under the pressure but it was all just too much with the looming deadline of Jacob’s start date at our office, and whatever way HR was going to drag him into this. I’m lucky that I can take my time looking for a new job, so I’ve had some space to process everything.

Outside of the work stuff, I spoke with a family lawyer who outlined all the possible ways this situation could go, and what the most likely outcomes were. Basically, my daughter is old enough that what she wants would get heavily weighted by a court if it came to that. I have spoken to my daughter many times about her father. I told her what I knew about him and that I had tried to contact him. I’ve offered for her to see a therapist if she ever wanted to talk about it with someone who wasn’t me, and she has always said “thanks, but no thanks.”

The family lawyer helped me write a letter which I left for Jacob. I told him about his daughter, said I wasn’t trying to get anything from him, and gave him the contact details of my lawyer. After a few weeks (of me freaking out that HR had somehow intercepted the letter), he emailed my lawyer. He was the easy-going and practical Jacob I remembered. He was still processing it but said he wasn’t going to take any legal steps, he offered us his family medical history, he apologized if I resigned because of him, and he said he would like to meet our daughter if she’s interested. She also has some siblings. I told her all this, she said she’s happy that she has her father’s contact info but she doesn’t want to meet him right now. She’s of the view that having him in our lives would cause unwanted disruption. And she doesn’t even know about the work clusterfudge.


Update #2:

June 9, 2025 (about one year later from the last update)

I’m incredibly grateful for the support you and the AAM community gave me at a stressful time, so I thought I’d share a final update.

My daughter changed her mind and has been in contact with Jacob. It’s still a bit awkward between them but they have some hobbies in common, which they’ve bonded over. My daughter also seems very excited to have some siblings who adore their cool new big sister.

I know some people were wondering why my old company reacted the way they did. For reasons I can’t go into, my work gets scrutinised by outside authorities and my manager’s role is primarily a quality control one. Any suggestion that my manager had not checked my work impartially enough due to a personal relationship could have been career-ending for both of us.

Additionally, the work I do is in a very specialist field and there are only a handful of people in the country who do it. Another company in a similar field had initially approached Jacob, who has had an amazing career by the sounds of it, to start a new department at their company doing the same thing. My old company paid a buttload of money to lure him over so that he wouldn’t be in direct competition for clients (and employees).

All of this meant that I couldn’t report to Jacob, there was no other manager I could report to, and the company couldn’t risk him going back to their competitor. Between the two of us, Jacob was the better asset to keep and the worse threat to lose. I’m not excusing the behaviour of my old company, but there was a logic to it. I’m still angry about the way they treated me and how helpless I felt, but that is slowly fading over time.

I had trouble finding a new job. Financially, we were okay so I was being picky (e.g. wanting to stay in my current city). After almost a year out of work, Jacob told me he’d been approached by the first company who still wanted him to start their new department. He was happy at my old company but he offered to take the new role if I wanted to try to get my old job back. I would never ask him to do that, and I also never want to go anywhere near that company again, so I said no.

Jacob turned the other company down but gave them my name. It’s a step up from where I was but they interviewed me and I got the job! I’ve been here about 6 months and it’s enjoyable so far, plus I’ve never procreated with anyone in my chain of command so it seems like a good place to work.

I’ve hired one of my former coworkers, plus two recent graduates from my alma mater who are bright, motivated and quickly getting up to speed. Unlike my old company, we don’t have a lengthy waitlist for our services (yet!) so a few clients have started coming to us instead of them. I am delighted that I am becoming the very threat my old company was trying to avoid when they pushed me out.


DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

Marked Concluded as we’re unlikely to get additional updates on this story.

I am NOT OOP

Originally posted to: Ask A Manager

Trigger Warning

hostile workplace, possible sexism


Original Post:

October 16, 2023

The backstory: I went back to university in my late 20s to do my PhD, and shared an office with a few other students for many years. One of the students, Jacob, completed his thesis and was moving back to his home country, so we all went out for congratulatory/farewell drinks. One thing led to another and Jacob and I spent the night together. A few weeks later, I realized I was pregnant and I had no way to contact Jacob. His university email and mobile number had been deactivated since he’d left the university and the country. I didn’t need anything from him and was fine to raise the child alone, but I thought he had a right to know. I googled him a few times over the years but never found him.

This last week, our department head emailed everyone to introduce and welcome our new manager, Jacob, with a photo and a blurb about his education and work history so I know for sure it’s him. The night we spent together changed my life because it made me a parent, so I have thought about Jacob from time to time when my daughter asks about her dad or I notice a genetic trait she didn’t get from me. However, I doubt Jacob has given that night a second thought. I have no idea whether he will have any concerns about being my manager given our history, or whether I’m making a bigger deal of this than I should. For what it’s worth, in my years of sharing an office with Jacob, he seemed easy-going and practical.

In our company, it is common for everyone in the department to reply-all to these introduction emails and introduce themselves, welcome the newcomer aboard and explain how their role will interact with theirs. I’m not sure if my email should note that Jacob and I studied together years ago as a way to get that out in the open? Or should I email him individually and offer to have a discussion about keeping our history out of the workplace if he thinks it’s needed? I’d appreciate any suggestions for language that indicates I’m not concerned and will be completely professional.

And then, in direct contradiction to that, I’d also appreciate a script for a separate email saying “can we please meet outside of work because I need to tell you something important about our history” so I can tell him about his daughter. If you or any commenters think I shouldn’t tell him, or I should let him settle in to his new country and new job first, I would definitely take that on board.

For Alison’s response to OOP, please refer to the link here

Additional Information from OOP after Alison pinned her comment onto the post:

Thanks for your comment at the top, Alison. The extent to which I tried to find Jacob wasn’t relevant to my question so I didn’t include the efforts I went to. For the commenters who are curious (understandably), I really did try when I first found out I was pregnant. I asked the other people we shared an office with, but no one had any information. We were students who shared an office and sometimes went to the uni bar together, we never spent any time together outside of uni. I asked Jacob’s thesis supervisor, but it was Christmas/Australian summer here so he was on leave for two months. When he got back, he gave me the address on Jacob’s file, which was of course the Australian address he didn’t live at anymore. The uni had a “next of kin” Australian contact number on file for his aunt, but no one ever answered it when I rang. Jacob is Chinese with a very common surname, and “Jacob” is just the name he used in my country, I don’t know his actual given name. So attempts to find the correct “Mr Wong”, in a country where they don’t use Google or Facebook, went nowhere. I searched for recent publications about Jacob’s thesis topic and found a paper with “Jacob Wong” as one of the authors. I contacted the “corresponding author” and asked for Jacob’s email but they never responded. By this point, I had to give up because I was so sick with hyperemesis gravidarum and needed to focus on my baby’s health.


Update #1:

June 11, 2024 (About 8 months later)

Thank you for answering my letter. You were right, it was a really big deal. I was viewing the Jacob-as-my-manager problem from his perspective — until I told him otherwise, it was just a simple one night stand over a decade ago — and it didn’t seem like a huge problem. I hated and appreciated the reality check. I regret reading the comments, but thank you also for moderating them as quickly as you did.

A lot happened in a short space of time (thankfully I already had a therapist!). First, I spoke to my union rep who said, “Say NOTHING but call us if HR tries to set up a meeting with you.” Staying silent and having Jacob independently declare the prior relationship when he arrived would have been problematic because I’d still end up in the same position and I would have lied by omission. Our HR team can be gossipy and they know the age of my half-Chinese daughter, so I needed to have as much control as possible over the disclosure. I spoke to an employment lawyer who reviewed our policies and, at his suggestion, I wrote an email to HR declaring a prior relationship with Jacob.

And then I was immediately pushed out. Even if you have all the legal support in the world, you can’t prevent someone from doing something illegal, you just have recourse afterwards. In a meeting with my lawyer, the union rep, HR, and a member of the senior management team, I was asked to resign. When I said no, they insisted on a statutory declaration about the relationship with Jacob stating what happened, when it happened, how many times it happened (??) and who initiated it (??). I also said no to that. We ended the meeting with each side agreeing to think about possible solutions.

The company’s solution was to start messing with my pay, my benefits, my swipe card access to my office, my computer log in, and my email/calendar account. They spread rumors about me and I heard coworkers whispering that I’d had an affair with a manager. They sent me for a “random” drug test at a time when I was scheduled for an important meeting with clients. They cancelled accommodation that had been booked for upcoming travel, which I only found out about because I was getting paranoid and called the hotel.

I can’t describe how awful it feels to know that someone with this kind of power over your job is devoting their time and energy to thinking of ways to screw with you. Every day I was going into work wondering what was waiting for me and it was wearing me down fast. The advice from the union rep was to go back in time and follow their first piece of advice, or just keep documenting everything as we prepared to take legal action. The lawyer estimated that it would take at least a year to get any kind of resolution, and I didn’t even want the job anymore. By this point, I wasn’t sleeping much and I had cried a few times at work. I was beginning to crack and we were only just getting started.

So, I resigned. I wish I’d held up better under the pressure but it was all just too much with the looming deadline of Jacob’s start date at our office, and whatever way HR was going to drag him into this. I’m lucky that I can take my time looking for a new job, so I’ve had some space to process everything.

Outside of the work stuff, I spoke with a family lawyer who outlined all the possible ways this situation could go, and what the most likely outcomes were. Basically, my daughter is old enough that what she wants would get heavily weighted by a court if it came to that. I have spoken to my daughter many times about her father. I told her what I knew about him and that I had tried to contact him. I’ve offered for her to see a therapist if she ever wanted to talk about it with someone who wasn’t me, and she has always said “thanks, but no thanks.”

The family lawyer helped me write a letter which I left for Jacob. I told him about his daughter, said I wasn’t trying to get anything from him, and gave him the contact details of my lawyer. After a few weeks (of me freaking out that HR had somehow intercepted the letter), he emailed my lawyer. He was the easy-going and practical Jacob I remembered. He was still processing it but said he wasn’t going to take any legal steps, he offered us his family medical history, he apologized if I resigned because of him, and he said he would like to meet our daughter if she’s interested. She also has some siblings. I told her all this, she said she’s happy that she has her father’s contact info but she doesn’t want to meet him right now. She’s of the view that having him in our lives would cause unwanted disruption. And she doesn’t even know about the work clusterfudge.


Update #2:

June 9, 2025 (about one year later from the last update)

I’m incredibly grateful for the support you and the AAM community gave me at a stressful time, so I thought I’d share a final update.

My daughter changed her mind and has been in contact with Jacob. It’s still a bit awkward between them but they have some hobbies in common, which they’ve bonded over. My daughter also seems very excited to have some siblings who adore their cool new big sister.

I know some people were wondering why my old company reacted the way they did. For reasons I can’t go into, my work gets scrutinised by outside authorities and my manager’s role is primarily a quality control one. Any suggestion that my manager had not checked my work impartially enough due to a personal relationship could have been career-ending for both of us.

Additionally, the work I do is in a very specialist field and there are only a handful of people in the country who do it. Another company in a similar field had initially approached Jacob, who has had an amazing career by the sounds of it, to start a new department at their company doing the same thing. My old company paid a buttload of money to lure him over so that he wouldn’t be in direct competition for clients (and employees).

All of this meant that I couldn’t report to Jacob, there was no other manager I could report to, and the company couldn’t risk him going back to their competitor. Between the two of us, Jacob was the better asset to keep and the worse threat to lose. I’m not excusing the behaviour of my old company, but there was a logic to it. I’m still angry about the way they treated me and how helpless I felt, but that is slowly fading over time.

I had trouble finding a new job. Financially, we were okay so I was being picky (e.g. wanting to stay in my current city). After almost a year out of work, Jacob told me he’d been approached by the first company who still wanted him to start their new department. He was happy at my old company but he offered to take the new role if I wanted to try to get my old job back. I would never ask him to do that, and I also never want to go anywhere near that company again, so I said no.

Jacob turned the other company down but gave them my name. It’s a step up from where I was but they interviewed me and I got the job! I’ve been here about 6 months and it’s enjoyable so far, plus I’ve never procreated with anyone in my chain of command so it seems like a good place to work.

I’ve hired one of my former coworkers, plus two recent graduates from my alma mater who are bright, motivated and quickly getting up to speed. Unlike my old company, we don’t have a lengthy waitlist for our services (yet!) so a few clients have started coming to us instead of them. I am delighted that I am becoming the very threat my old company was trying to avoid when they pushed me out.


DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

Marked Concluded as we’re unlikely to get additional updates on this story.

0

[Concluded] my boyfriend/manager yells at me when we work together [AAM]

Ask a Manager my boyfriend/manager yells at me when we work together www.askamanager.org
preview

I am NOT OOP

Originally posted to: Ask A Manager

Trigger Warning

Harassment, Shitty boyfriend


Original Post:

August 20, 2025

Am I in the wrong for not wanting to work on projects with my boyfriend/manager at work?

My boyfriend and I both work at the same place. He is the facilities manager and I am the facilities technician.

For the most part we work separately. But from time to time, something comes up where we have to work together, and whenever that happens my stomach starts flip flopping and turning the second I hear that we are going to be working together. I absolutely dread it.

Every time we have worked together in the past, he suddenly changes into almost a different person. He’s mean. He yells at me for everything I do and don’t do.

At first I thought it was me and that I just needed to back off and wait for his direction instead of just jumping in. I thought this because he would yell at me for being in his way and for not knowing how he was trying to do it (but he doesn’t communicate how he wants to do stuff, he just expects me to read his mind and know.) So I tried backing off and waiting for his direction. And doing that results in him yelling at me for standing there doing nothing and not knowing what he wants me to do (for not reading his mind.)

Since neither of those worked, I tried to initiate communication with him before we started and asked him to explain what he wants me to do so I can know going into it and won’t be in his way, slowing him down and am able to contribute what he expects me to. And I’ve told him I don’t want to get yelled at. Well, that doesn’t work either. He gets mad at me for asking questions and tells me I need to follow his directions and shut my mouth. But he doesn’t give me direction, yells at me when I try and get some direction, and yells at me if I try and wing it without asking for direction.

I’m frustrated. I just want to cry. He just informed me that next week we have to work together to replace the siding on one of the cabins on our site. My stomach is doing flip flops and I am stressing out. He saw in my face that I don’t want to work with him and told me that I’m going to have to figure it out.

But I’ve tried to figure it out! Nobody wants to be treated like shit by the person they are working with and if the person you are working with doesn’t communicate with you other than to yell at you, it’s very difficult to work efficiently with them.

I tried to explain that I can’t work with him if he’s going to yell at me the whole time, and he told me that I need to just shut my mouth and follow directions. I feel like he is being super disrespectful and I don’t understand why he acts like this when we work together. It literally doesn’t matter if I do exactly what he tells me to do (if he tells me what to do) or not, because either way he is going to yell at me and tell me how stupid I am. I’ve never been treated like this before by anyone I’ve worked with ever.

I feel like I’ve done and tried everything I can think of to make it work and not get yelled at, and I’m starting to think that maybe the problem isn’t just me. Maybe it’s him. Maybe he is actually being the one that is making it impossible for us to work together? But maybe I’m wrong? Maybe it is me? I don’t know? Am I wrong for not wanting to work with him? Am I wrong for starting to think that maybe he is the issue that we are having? What should I do?

Alison does not wish us to share her responses so you can find it here.


Update:

August 4, 2026 - Almost a year later

I went into work that day, the day we were set to be working together all day, and I was surprised to find that he had listened to all the little things that I thought had gone unnoticed and unheard the couple of days prior to project day. I had kept telling him that I really want us to be able to get along and work productively and easily together and would mention the things that I needed from him in order to avoid him getting frustrated. For example, one of the things I told him I needed was for him to explain to me exactly what he wanted me to do, like what my role/job was that day so I wasn’t getting in his way or not doing my part correctly, and so he wasn’t sitting there frustrated waiting for me to help him with something while I was wrapped up in doing something else that he didn’t need help with right at that moment … because our biggest issue, in my opinion, has always been his lack of communicating and instead just expecting me to read his mind and know what he wants or needs me to do.

At the time I was telling him those things, it seemed as though he wasn’t listening to what I was saying. So I was feeling hopeless and anxiety-ridden and I was stressed out about it and thought that it was going to be like every other time that we have tried to work together.

I went into work that morning dreading what was to come. But to my surprise, he was acting differently than he usually does when we have to work together. First thing when I got there, he told me that he wanted to take me over to the cabin that we were going to be working on so he could show me what we were going to be doing. So we drove over there and he showed me how he had set everything up and what lumber pile was what, and explained the process of how he wanted us to get it done and showed me how he wanted me to do it.

Because he took the time to explain everything to me in depth, I knew what my role was and what I needed to do and we worked great together! He didn’t get frustrated, I wasn’t walking on eggshells, everything just flowed, and we had a very productive day where we got along well and were able to finish everything so that he could paint that cabin and be done with it.

And since that day, we have had fewer issues when we have had to work together. There are still times where he doesn’t communicate with me and gets frustrated, but it’s happening less and less. He obviously had been listening to the things I had been telling him I needed. Maybe my sharing with him that I was stressed and anxious about having to work with him helped him to be open to trying what I was asking of him? I’m not really sure what caused him to approach things differently that day, but I’m really glad that we did that project together. It seemed to bring about a much needed shift in the way we work together.

We recently had a big project where we had three more cabins added to the 40 we have on the property. The higher-ups thought it would be a great opportunity to re-number all the cabins and move all the cabin names around so that they would be in alphabetical order from the entrance to the exit, because apparently that is how all our other outposts are set up. Well, that moving of the names around was a total nightmare! Not only did it cause mass confusion among all of our employees when trying to locate the cabins they are assigned to or need to deliver stuff to, but it was a nightmare of a project. We didn’t just have to move the signs for the cabins around, we had to also move their wifi equipment and their door locks because our tech guy said it was too much for him to rename all the wifi equipment and locks.

So the guy in charge of the project flew out to help my boyfriend and me for the two days they gave us to do the work. Well, after the first few cabins they did together, my boyfriend was so frustrated! Go figure … they weren’t working well together … it wasn’t just me. You could tell the other guy was feeling just totally down and was worried that the project wouldn’t get done on time.

Towards the end of the day, they still hadn’t gotten all the cabins done that they needed to that day to stay on schedule and so the guy who flew out to help asked if I could go around with him and help him get some more done since I don’t leave work until two hours after my boyfriend does. We worked together just fine. The next day he decided that he was going to send my boyfriend around on his own and he and I would work together. We were able to get it all done and neither of us had to deal with my difficult-to-work-with boyfriend. I felt so bad for this other person because of what happened the first day and I knew how he felt. And I’m glad that I was able to step in and help so he didn’t have to deal with all that again the next day.

So my boyfriend has been working on the way he goes about working with me, but he obviously isn’t putting that same effort into trying to work with anyone else better. Which sucks. But it’s a start, I guess.

He does treat me differently at work vs. at home and isn’t like that towards me outside of work. It’s like this weird work persona he puts on and attitude he has at work. I don’t understand it or why he does it. He’s used to working construction type jobs where the guys all talk smack to each other … maybe that is part of it? But I’m not some dude that he works with. And when I got my position, he was aware that he was going to have to teach me stuff, .that I didn’t know how to do everything that the job required of me. So I’m not sure why he just expected me to know.

Thank you for verifying to me that it wasn’t just a me thing. Deep down, I knew it wasn’t me but I’ve gone through some abuse and stuff in my past that probably contributes to my questioning myself. I’ve had counseling and even volunteered at a domestic violence agency for a while (which was so unexpectedly healing!) but I’m still working on learning and growing from that whole experience.

I was not at all expecting him to handle us working together the way that he did that day. But I believe that by him trying it differently, he was able to see things could flow and go well. And I think that has inspired him to work on taking that approach and allowed him to see the value in taking a little time to communicate and explain it all to me first when we have to work together. We have had our ups and downs and sometimes he doesn’t communicate, but those instances are happening less and less as time goes on.


DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs

THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT OOP

Marked Concluded just because we’re unlikely to get any additional updates.

I am NOT OOP

Originally posted to: Ask A Manager

Trigger Warning

Harassment, Shitty boyfriend


Original Post:

August 20, 2025

Am I in the wrong for not wanting to work on projects with my boyfriend/manager at work?

My boyfriend and I both work at the same place. He is the facilities manager and I am the facilities technician.

For the most part we work separately. But from time to time, something comes up where we have to work together, and whenever that happens my stomach starts flip flopping and turning the second I hear that we are going to be working together. I absolutely dread it.

Every time we have worked together in the past, he suddenly changes into almost a different person. He’s mean. He yells at me for everything I do and don’t do.

At first I thought it was me and that I just needed to back off and wait for his direction instead of just jumping in. I thought this because he would yell at me for being in his way and for not knowing how he was trying to do it (but he doesn’t communicate how he wants to do stuff, he just expects me to read his mind and know.) So I tried backing off and waiting for his direction. And doing that results in him yelling at me for standing there doing nothing and not knowing what he wants me to do (for not reading his mind.)

Since neither of those worked, I tried to initiate communication with him before we started and asked him to explain what he wants me to do so I can know going into it and won’t be in his way, slowing him down and am able to contribute what he expects me to. And I’ve told him I don’t want to get yelled at. Well, that doesn’t work either. He gets mad at me for asking questions and tells me I need to follow his directions and shut my mouth. But he doesn’t give me direction, yells at me when I try and get some direction, and yells at me if I try and wing it without asking for direction.

I’m frustrated. I just want to cry. He just informed me that next week we have to work together to replace the siding on one of the cabins on our site. My stomach is doing flip flops and I am stressing out. He saw in my face that I don’t want to work with him and told me that I’m going to have to figure it out.

But I’ve tried to figure it out! Nobody wants to be treated like shit by the person they are working with and if the person you are working with doesn’t communicate with you other than to yell at you, it’s very difficult to work efficiently with them.

I tried to explain that I can’t work with him if he’s going to yell at me the whole time, and he told me that I need to just shut my mouth and follow directions. I feel like he is being super disrespectful and I don’t understand why he acts like this when we work together. It literally doesn’t matter if I do exactly what he tells me to do (if he tells me what to do) or not, because either way he is going to yell at me and tell me how stupid I am. I’ve never been treated like this before by anyone I’ve worked with ever.

I feel like I’ve done and tried everything I can think of to make it work and not get yelled at, and I’m starting to think that maybe the problem isn’t just me. Maybe it’s him. Maybe he is actually being the one that is making it impossible for us to work together? But maybe I’m wrong? Maybe it is me? I don’t know? Am I wrong for not wanting to work with him? Am I wrong for starting to think that maybe he is the issue that we are having? What should I do?

Alison does not wish us to share her responses so you can find it here.


Update:

August 4, 2026 - Almost a year later

I went into work that day, the day we were set to be working together all day, and I was surprised to find that he had listened to all the little things that I thought had gone unnoticed and unheard the couple of days prior to project day. I had kept telling him that I really want us to be able to get along and work productively and easily together and would mention the things that I needed from him in order to avoid him getting frustrated. For example, one of the things I told him I needed was for him to explain to me exactly what he wanted me to do, like what my role/job was that day so I wasn’t getting in his way or not doing my part correctly, and so he wasn’t sitting there frustrated waiting for me to help him with something while I was wrapped up in doing something else that he didn’t need help with right at that moment … because our biggest issue, in my opinion, has always been his lack of communicating and instead just expecting me to read his mind and know what he wants or needs me to do.

At the time I was telling him those things, it seemed as though he wasn’t listening to what I was saying. So I was feeling hopeless and anxiety-ridden and I was stressed out about it and thought that it was going to be like every other time that we have tried to work together.

I went into work that morning dreading what was to come. But to my surprise, he was acting differently than he usually does when we have to work together. First thing when I got there, he told me that he wanted to take me over to the cabin that we were going to be working on so he could show me what we were going to be doing. So we drove over there and he showed me how he had set everything up and what lumber pile was what, and explained the process of how he wanted us to get it done and showed me how he wanted me to do it.

Because he took the time to explain everything to me in depth, I knew what my role was and what I needed to do and we worked great together! He didn’t get frustrated, I wasn’t walking on eggshells, everything just flowed, and we had a very productive day where we got along well and were able to finish everything so that he could paint that cabin and be done with it.

And since that day, we have had fewer issues when we have had to work together. There are still times where he doesn’t communicate with me and gets frustrated, but it’s happening less and less. He obviously had been listening to the things I had been telling him I needed. Maybe my sharing with him that I was stressed and anxious about having to work with him helped him to be open to trying what I was asking of him? I’m not really sure what caused him to approach things differently that day, but I’m really glad that we did that project together. It seemed to bring about a much needed shift in the way we work together.

We recently had a big project where we had three more cabins added to the 40 we have on the property. The higher-ups thought it would be a great opportunity to re-number all the cabins and move all the cabin names around so that they would be in alphabetical order from the entrance to the exit, because apparently that is how all our other outposts are set up. Well, that moving of the names around was a total nightmare! Not only did it cause mass confusion among all of our employees when trying to locate the cabins they are assigned to or need to deliver stuff to, but it was a nightmare of a project. We didn’t just have to move the signs for the cabins around, we had to also move their wifi equipment and their door locks because our tech guy said it was too much for him to rename all the wifi equipment and locks.

So the guy in charge of the project flew out to help my boyfriend and me for the two days they gave us to do the work. Well, after the first few cabins they did together, my boyfriend was so frustrated! Go figure … they weren’t working well together … it wasn’t just me. You could tell the other guy was feeling just totally down and was worried that the project wouldn’t get done on time.

Towards the end of the day, they still hadn’t gotten all the cabins done that they needed to that day to stay on schedule and so the guy who flew out to help asked if I could go around with him and help him get some more done since I don’t leave work until two hours after my boyfriend does. We worked together just fine. The next day he decided that he was going to send my boyfriend around on his own and he and I would work together. We were able to get it all done and neither of us had to deal with my difficult-to-work-with boyfriend. I felt so bad for this other person because of what happened the first day and I knew how he felt. And I’m glad that I was able to step in and help so he didn’t have to deal with all that again the next day.

So my boyfriend has been working on the way he goes about working with me, but he obviously isn’t putting that same effort into trying to work with anyone else better. Which sucks. But it’s a start, I guess.

He does treat me differently at work vs. at home and isn’t like that towards me outside of work. It’s like this weird work persona he puts on and attitude he has at work. I don’t understand it or why he does it. He’s used to working construction type jobs where the guys all talk smack to each other … maybe that is part of it? But I’m not some dude that he works with. And when I got my position, he was aware that he was going to have to teach me stuff, .that I didn’t know how to do everything that the job required of me. So I’m not sure why he just expected me to know.

Thank you for verifying to me that it wasn’t just a me thing. Deep down, I knew it wasn’t me but I’ve gone through some abuse and stuff in my past that probably contributes to my questioning myself. I’ve had counseling and even volunteered at a domestic violence agency for a while (which was so unexpectedly healing!) but I’m still working on learning and growing from that whole experience.

I was not at all expecting him to handle us working together the way that he did that day. But I believe that by him trying it differently, he was able to see things could flow and go well. And I think that has inspired him to work on taking that approach and allowed him to see the value in taking a little time to communicate and explain it all to me first when we have to work together. We have had our ups and downs and sometimes he doesn’t communicate, but those instances are happening less and less as time goes on.


DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs

THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT OOP

Marked Concluded just because we’re unlikely to get any additional updates.

0

[Concluded] My step dad is acting very creepy towards me (19) [Reddit]

preview

DO NOT COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS.

** I am NOT OP.** Original post by u/Majestic_Channel_815 in r/whatdoIdo and compilation Reddit post by u/PinkPussycatPower

Trigger Warning

Sexual predation, invasion of privacy, voyeurism, stalking, sexual harassment

Mood Warning

Deeply unsettling, infuriating, ultimately vindicating


Original Post:

August 12, 2026

My step dad is acting very creepy towards me (19)

I feel like I’m losing my mind so sorry if this is all over the place. My mom got married to this guy around a year ago, but they’ve been together for around two. He wasn’t weird till he moved in, or maybe I just didn’t notice it. It’s been little things but it’s just progressively gotten worse and I don’t know what do to. I’ll give some examples. One time I went shopping at Victoria Secret and I put the bags in my room. I left again immediately after because I went to hang out with a friend. When I came back, he asked me why I would buy such expensive underwear when I could just “get a pack at Walmart or something”.

I figured maybe he saw the bags when I got home? Then said “I mean blue? Really?” (The colour of the underwear i bought) I was immediately disgusted and embarrassed. Not only does that mean he went through my stuff, he also went in my room for no reason. Is that a regular occurrence and he just so happened to see the bags that time? I feel like if you see a victoria secret bag you already know what’s in it, so why would he have to go through it?? I told my mom and she said he’s just being overprotective… Another example is that I have a boyfriend and I do go see him often.

Every time I leave the house he’ll say “off to see that little boyfriend of yours again??” He never says his name even though I know he knows it. Or “don’t get pregnant or I’ll kick you out.” He always says he’s joking after but is that not an odd thing to say?? There’s a couple more examples but I don’t want to make this post too long. Anyway, what made me make this post is something that happened recently that makes me very uncomfortable and grossed out. Him and my mom went out on a date night so I asked my mom if I could invite my boyfriend over. She has never said no before, and this time is no different. He overheard and said “We both know why you want him over” in an angry tone.

My mom brushed him off and said yes, so they left. My boyfriend came over and we were in my room. We were watching tv but at the end of the day he is my boyfriend, so we started kissing. He crawled on top of me and that’s when my stepdad barged in without knocking and started yelling at us. We didn’t hear them come home. I’ll admit, it did look bad, but why does he care so much about my sex life? My mom knows and is fine with it as long as I’m safe. He said stuff like I can’t have sex in “his house” (it’s my mom’s) and just saying controlling things. My mom calmed him down but for the rest of the night he kept opening my door trying to “catch us” in the act, so my boyfriend just went home.

I feel like I’m entitled to my own space because I do partially pay for rent, but even if I didn’t, is his behaviour still not weird? The easiest solution is to move out but that’s just not possible right now. I only work part time because of school. I just feel stuck. I could try talking to my mom again but with more details, but I’m scared of her reaction. I don’t want to feel like I’m making a big deal of things again. Literally any advice would be appreciated. Thanks in advance.


TOP COMMENTS

CrashBangXD: None of those comments are ok. Ask your mum to spend time together one on one so that you’ve got an open and safe environment. Document instances of this, as in dates, times and instances to give you a proven breakdown of evidence of his behaviour

Apart_Foundation1702: Oh he is definitely a red flag! OP, He clearly doesn’t agree with your mum’s parenting, he does come off creepy. Is there another family member you can stay with, under the same arrangement as your mum?? Or maybe look for a room to rent.

OOP: I do have other family but they live too far away. I’ve been looking for places but have been unsuccessful so far

Educational_Ask_1790: I highly HIGHLY recommend buying an indoor ring camera or any sort of indoor surveillance camera to stick somewhere in your room. This guy is a creep and hes a weirdo. Hes more than likely going into your room or maybe he even has a camera of his own in there.

Frozencacticat: He 100% knows what he’s doing. This isn’t normal. You’re not crazy. You’re not being dramatic. You’re not wrong to feel like something is wrong. Your mother needs to step up and pay attention! I’d try to get some time alone with your mother and just be honest. Just start out with the fact that you don’t even want to talk about this and that it makes you very uncomfortable and stressed, and then tell her exactly what’s been going on. All of it. Tell her you don’t feel safe. Tell her you’re afraid of how he will react.

In the meantime, I’d find a way to lock your bedroom door. I don’t know if you can change the knob without them knowing and freaking out but maybe you can get something online to wedge it locked or push something in front of the door to make it hard to get in? Idk he just freaks me out. The underwear thing and the comments about your boyfriend are extremely inappropriate! If he cared about you in a normal fatherly way he would have told you gently to be careful and be safe and that you can always come to him if you need anything. He did not do that. He loudly told you to not get pregnant in a joking manner. That is not a joke and it is a weird thing to say to a young girl.

He also hasn’t been with your mother near long enough to have earned the “father” role. It’s tricky and it takes time. You can’t, as an adult man, barge into a girls life and expect her to immediately respect you as a father figure. You need to earn that, and it takes years. But that is beside the point, just a small part of the issue here Anyways, sorry this was a lot. It really upsets me to read this cause I remember being a 19 year old. Trying to figure out who I was, finishing school up and not knowing what I wanted to do with my life. Being essentially broke and completely reliant on my dad. It’s not easy. I’m 28 now and my God… I don’t think I’d ever go back and do that all again. Life is hard enough for a teenager without a creepy man living in your home saying and doing weird creepy stuff.

To recap: you are NOT crazy. You didn’t sound like you were trying to make him sound better or worse. Your post was very matter of fact + how you felt. You are not dramatic or wrong. He is wrong. He knows it. Your mother likely has already noticed and is either making an excuse in her head or possibly also thinking “no way he isn’t like that”. So I think talking to her and being honest about it all is key right now. Try not to spend time alone with him. He seems unpredictable. I know it’s an “easier said than done” situation but just do your best. Think about a plan b and c. Like, if your mom isn’t receptive, who are you going to go to next? I know it’s stressful but just have it in your back pocket just in case. Maybe a teacher or your boyfriend’s parents might be able to help as well.

Anyways, talk to your mom asap. Keep him far away as much as you can. Don’t ever feel crazy or wrong. Trust your instincts, they are there to protect you. One thing I wish I learned years ago was to always trust my gut. Being safe is better than being sorry. I’ll be thinking of you! Please, if you feel up to it, keep us updated! Good luck OP!

OOP: Thank you so much for this. It really helped.


Update:

August 16, 2026 (4 DAYS LATER)

My step dad is acting very creepy towards me - UPDATE

Firstly I want to thank everyone for the advice. Just to address some things I saw in the comments of my last post. Yes, my actual dad is in my life and our relationship is great. I haven’t/can’t move in with him because he lives too far. I also never told him about the situation with my step dad at that time because I’ll know he’d do something he’d regret. My dad is a good man but has severe anger issues when people hurt me. He’s been to jail over it in the past. He went to therapy and is way better now, but I didn’t want any chance of messing up all his progress. As for my boyfriend, I have stayed over at his place many times but moving in permanently isn’t really possible because he has a roommate of his own, so I’m not sure why people were trying to shift some blame on him. He’s not a bum, he’s not leeching off of me, he’s simply also 19 and starting out his life. As for moving out in general , you guys must have been very lucky to have been in a better position than me at my age. I can’t simply move out on a whim. I only work part time (trying to get more hours) plus I go to school. I can’t afford a place on my own plus tuition, the cost of living is too high where I am. Being 19 doesn’t immediately make you on your feet. It’s only my first year out of highschool. Just needed to get that out of the way.

As for the actual update, I’m afraid it’s worse than what i thought. As soon as I saw the first comment about a potential hidden camera it scared me so much so that I immediately bought one of those camera detector things. When it came, I waited till he wasn’t home to try it out. I found 3. One in front of my bed, one above it, and one on my dresser. They are scarily small, but I still feel so dumb for not noticing. Couldn’t describe the feeling I had when I found them. I threw up and my mom heard and ran to comfort me. When I got myself together, I told her everything. Every action that made me uncomfortable, every comment he said that felt weird. I showed her the cameras I found.

Her face immediately dropped and she started crying. She just asked over and over why didn’t I tell her sooner and it just made me feel that much more awful. It was my fault that I didn’t tell her. She apologized over and over again and said she failed me. We had a much needed convo and afterwards. Said that she just thought it was uncomfortable between us because it’s a new adjustment for all of us. She searched the rest of the house for me because i honestly couldn’t deal with finding others. She found one in the bathroom then searched his office. He always told us we weren’t allowed in because that’s where his work stuff is and he doesn’t want us to “mess it up.” I waited at the door while she searched, and in the drawers she found random stuff of mine and an old phone that we don’t know of.

On the phone there are pictures and videos from my social media accounts, of me sleeping, changing, me being intimate with my boyfriend, all in my room. She also found a couple pairs of my underwear that I didn’t even notice went missing, a couple of my hair ties, and after that I went back to my room. I couldn’t watch anymore of that. I called my boyfriend to pick me up while my mom called the police because I just couldn’t stay in that house for any longer. He held me and I cried for what felt like hours till I fell asleep. I woke up and called my mom and told me the run down of what happened. I don’t know all the details because I couldn’t bear to hear much. Basically he came home to the cops and completely owned up to putting cameras in my room. His defense was that he needs to know everything that’s going on in “his” house. As for my stuff and the pictures, he claims he doesn’t know how it got there.

He’s arrested but that’s all I know so far. I told my dad and he’s driving down now. I haven’t been asked to make a statement yet, and I don’t know how any of that works honestly. It’s triggering to even think about. But yeah, there’s the update. To the people who sent me hateful and hurtful things and told me this was all in my head, especially u/mysterymeat45 and u/pazsion80423294, i hope you never have kids. If you hate privately you should be called out publicly. Even if you are troll accounts it’s still insanely fucked up to say the things you did. To everyone who gave me actual, genuine advice, I wish nothing but the best for you all and thanks again so much. If it weren’t for you guys I’d probably think I was still being dramatic. I most likely won’t update again, i already want to move on from this situation. Sorry if this is jumbled. Everything is still so fresh, but writing it out is somehow helping me process it, I think.

Edit: stop calling me “lucky” because he didn’t do worse. I don’t feel lucky at all.

Here are just a couple more examples since people didn’t think the ones my other post were damming enough, and to also maybe help someone else in a similar situation see signs. 1, He would ALWAYS need to know where I am and who I’m with. I find this weird because he’s not my dad, I’m an adult, and I would tell my mom. My mom telling him wasn’t enough. He’d say “no, I want to hear it from HER mouth.” 2, he would often open my packages if I didn’t get to them in time. Very annoying and weird. I ordered the camera detector when the arrival time was while he was at work, so I got lucky there. 3, always commenting on my outfits. Would tell me unwanted “advice”, and that I look like a hooker if I wore shorts/skirts/anything “revealing”. 4, would always ask me about birth control/using protection. “Are you on the pill? If not that little fucker (my boyfriend) better be wrapping it up.” He’d say stuff like this at the most random times too. 5, would always try to use my mom against me. If we got into an argument he would make himself seem like the victim, always. My mom would always say to leave her out of it. 6, he would sometimes groan or say “you again??” Very annoyed when I walked in a room. It was over exaggerated to the point where he could brush it off as a joke if he wanted, but I knew it wasn’t a joke. 7, if I bought something and came home with bags, he’d interrogate me about what I bought. The VS bag is the only time I have hard proof that he went through my stuff. 8, he was super weird about my boyfriend. He would never say his name, just “that little boyfriend of yours.” If I went to go see him he’d roll his eyes and say “again?” Or “don’t you spent too much time with him?” 9, pushing me to call him dad even though he never even come close to having that title. 10, would never ever knock before opening my door. Even though I told him to, repeatedly. Thats all I can really think of right now.


TOP COMMENTS

lizziebee66: Sweetie, whilst your mum’s reaction upset you that she was also upset, hold on to the fact that she 100% believed you. She loves you and has your safety at the centre of her world. Stay safe and loved

Bulky-Mycologist-402: The fact that 3 separate cameras were found is absolutely sickening & frightening. I hope this guy gets punished to the fullest extent of the law. So sorry to hear you had to endure this, it’s very disheartening & wretched knowing this creep thought he can be sneaky and get away doing some shit like this.

Illustrious-Tart7844: Hi, OP. I’m a former domestic violence victim advocate and I’ve worked with women who have gone through similar incidents and worse… I’m so sorry this happened to you. You didn’t deserve this at all. You handled it PERFECTLY and I’m astounded by your strength. Please wrap yourself in support. You will get through this and come out stronger on the other side. Take care of yourself, please. 💜


DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOP

THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT OOP

DO NOT COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS.

** I am NOT OP.** Original post by u/Majestic_Channel_815 in r/whatdoIdo and compilation Reddit post by u/PinkPussycatPower

Trigger Warning

Sexual predation, invasion of privacy, voyeurism, stalking, sexual harassment

Mood Warning

Deeply unsettling, infuriating, ultimately vindicating


Original Post:

August 12, 2026

My step dad is acting very creepy towards me (19)

I feel like I’m losing my mind so sorry if this is all over the place. My mom got married to this guy around a year ago, but they’ve been together for around two. He wasn’t weird till he moved in, or maybe I just didn’t notice it. It’s been little things but it’s just progressively gotten worse and I don’t know what do to. I’ll give some examples. One time I went shopping at Victoria Secret and I put the bags in my room. I left again immediately after because I went to hang out with a friend. When I came back, he asked me why I would buy such expensive underwear when I could just “get a pack at Walmart or something”.

I figured maybe he saw the bags when I got home? Then said “I mean blue? Really?” (The colour of the underwear i bought) I was immediately disgusted and embarrassed. Not only does that mean he went through my stuff, he also went in my room for no reason. Is that a regular occurrence and he just so happened to see the bags that time? I feel like if you see a victoria secret bag you already know what’s in it, so why would he have to go through it?? I told my mom and she said he’s just being overprotective… Another example is that I have a boyfriend and I do go see him often.

Every time I leave the house he’ll say “off to see that little boyfriend of yours again??” He never says his name even though I know he knows it. Or “don’t get pregnant or I’ll kick you out.” He always says he’s joking after but is that not an odd thing to say?? There’s a couple more examples but I don’t want to make this post too long. Anyway, what made me make this post is something that happened recently that makes me very uncomfortable and grossed out. Him and my mom went out on a date night so I asked my mom if I could invite my boyfriend over. She has never said no before, and this time is no different. He overheard and said “We both know why you want him over” in an angry tone.

My mom brushed him off and said yes, so they left. My boyfriend came over and we were in my room. We were watching tv but at the end of the day he is my boyfriend, so we started kissing. He crawled on top of me and that’s when my stepdad barged in without knocking and started yelling at us. We didn’t hear them come home. I’ll admit, it did look bad, but why does he care so much about my sex life? My mom knows and is fine with it as long as I’m safe. He said stuff like I can’t have sex in “his house” (it’s my mom’s) and just saying controlling things. My mom calmed him down but for the rest of the night he kept opening my door trying to “catch us” in the act, so my boyfriend just went home.

I feel like I’m entitled to my own space because I do partially pay for rent, but even if I didn’t, is his behaviour still not weird? The easiest solution is to move out but that’s just not possible right now. I only work part time because of school. I just feel stuck. I could try talking to my mom again but with more details, but I’m scared of her reaction. I don’t want to feel like I’m making a big deal of things again. Literally any advice would be appreciated. Thanks in advance.


TOP COMMENTS

CrashBangXD: None of those comments are ok. Ask your mum to spend time together one on one so that you’ve got an open and safe environment. Document instances of this, as in dates, times and instances to give you a proven breakdown of evidence of his behaviour

Apart_Foundation1702: Oh he is definitely a red flag! OP, He clearly doesn’t agree with your mum’s parenting, he does come off creepy. Is there another family member you can stay with, under the same arrangement as your mum?? Or maybe look for a room to rent.

OOP: I do have other family but they live too far away. I’ve been looking for places but have been unsuccessful so far

Educational_Ask_1790: I highly HIGHLY recommend buying an indoor ring camera or any sort of indoor surveillance camera to stick somewhere in your room. This guy is a creep and hes a weirdo. Hes more than likely going into your room or maybe he even has a camera of his own in there.

Frozencacticat: He 100% knows what he’s doing. This isn’t normal. You’re not crazy. You’re not being dramatic. You’re not wrong to feel like something is wrong. Your mother needs to step up and pay attention! I’d try to get some time alone with your mother and just be honest. Just start out with the fact that you don’t even want to talk about this and that it makes you very uncomfortable and stressed, and then tell her exactly what’s been going on. All of it. Tell her you don’t feel safe. Tell her you’re afraid of how he will react.

In the meantime, I’d find a way to lock your bedroom door. I don’t know if you can change the knob without them knowing and freaking out but maybe you can get something online to wedge it locked or push something in front of the door to make it hard to get in? Idk he just freaks me out. The underwear thing and the comments about your boyfriend are extremely inappropriate! If he cared about you in a normal fatherly way he would have told you gently to be careful and be safe and that you can always come to him if you need anything. He did not do that. He loudly told you to not get pregnant in a joking manner. That is not a joke and it is a weird thing to say to a young girl.

He also hasn’t been with your mother near long enough to have earned the “father” role. It’s tricky and it takes time. You can’t, as an adult man, barge into a girls life and expect her to immediately respect you as a father figure. You need to earn that, and it takes years. But that is beside the point, just a small part of the issue here Anyways, sorry this was a lot. It really upsets me to read this cause I remember being a 19 year old. Trying to figure out who I was, finishing school up and not knowing what I wanted to do with my life. Being essentially broke and completely reliant on my dad. It’s not easy. I’m 28 now and my God… I don’t think I’d ever go back and do that all again. Life is hard enough for a teenager without a creepy man living in your home saying and doing weird creepy stuff.

To recap: you are NOT crazy. You didn’t sound like you were trying to make him sound better or worse. Your post was very matter of fact + how you felt. You are not dramatic or wrong. He is wrong. He knows it. Your mother likely has already noticed and is either making an excuse in her head or possibly also thinking “no way he isn’t like that”. So I think talking to her and being honest about it all is key right now. Try not to spend time alone with him. He seems unpredictable. I know it’s an “easier said than done” situation but just do your best. Think about a plan b and c. Like, if your mom isn’t receptive, who are you going to go to next? I know it’s stressful but just have it in your back pocket just in case. Maybe a teacher or your boyfriend’s parents might be able to help as well.

Anyways, talk to your mom asap. Keep him far away as much as you can. Don’t ever feel crazy or wrong. Trust your instincts, they are there to protect you. One thing I wish I learned years ago was to always trust my gut. Being safe is better than being sorry. I’ll be thinking of you! Please, if you feel up to it, keep us updated! Good luck OP!

OOP: Thank you so much for this. It really helped.


Update:

August 16, 2026 (4 DAYS LATER)

My step dad is acting very creepy towards me - UPDATE

Firstly I want to thank everyone for the advice. Just to address some things I saw in the comments of my last post. Yes, my actual dad is in my life and our relationship is great. I haven’t/can’t move in with him because he lives too far. I also never told him about the situation with my step dad at that time because I’ll know he’d do something he’d regret. My dad is a good man but has severe anger issues when people hurt me. He’s been to jail over it in the past. He went to therapy and is way better now, but I didn’t want any chance of messing up all his progress. As for my boyfriend, I have stayed over at his place many times but moving in permanently isn’t really possible because he has a roommate of his own, so I’m not sure why people were trying to shift some blame on him. He’s not a bum, he’s not leeching off of me, he’s simply also 19 and starting out his life. As for moving out in general , you guys must have been very lucky to have been in a better position than me at my age. I can’t simply move out on a whim. I only work part time (trying to get more hours) plus I go to school. I can’t afford a place on my own plus tuition, the cost of living is too high where I am. Being 19 doesn’t immediately make you on your feet. It’s only my first year out of highschool. Just needed to get that out of the way.

As for the actual update, I’m afraid it’s worse than what i thought. As soon as I saw the first comment about a potential hidden camera it scared me so much so that I immediately bought one of those camera detector things. When it came, I waited till he wasn’t home to try it out. I found 3. One in front of my bed, one above it, and one on my dresser. They are scarily small, but I still feel so dumb for not noticing. Couldn’t describe the feeling I had when I found them. I threw up and my mom heard and ran to comfort me. When I got myself together, I told her everything. Every action that made me uncomfortable, every comment he said that felt weird. I showed her the cameras I found.

Her face immediately dropped and she started crying. She just asked over and over why didn’t I tell her sooner and it just made me feel that much more awful. It was my fault that I didn’t tell her. She apologized over and over again and said she failed me. We had a much needed convo and afterwards. Said that she just thought it was uncomfortable between us because it’s a new adjustment for all of us. She searched the rest of the house for me because i honestly couldn’t deal with finding others. She found one in the bathroom then searched his office. He always told us we weren’t allowed in because that’s where his work stuff is and he doesn’t want us to “mess it up.” I waited at the door while she searched, and in the drawers she found random stuff of mine and an old phone that we don’t know of.

On the phone there are pictures and videos from my social media accounts, of me sleeping, changing, me being intimate with my boyfriend, all in my room. She also found a couple pairs of my underwear that I didn’t even notice went missing, a couple of my hair ties, and after that I went back to my room. I couldn’t watch anymore of that. I called my boyfriend to pick me up while my mom called the police because I just couldn’t stay in that house for any longer. He held me and I cried for what felt like hours till I fell asleep. I woke up and called my mom and told me the run down of what happened. I don’t know all the details because I couldn’t bear to hear much. Basically he came home to the cops and completely owned up to putting cameras in my room. His defense was that he needs to know everything that’s going on in “his” house. As for my stuff and the pictures, he claims he doesn’t know how it got there.

He’s arrested but that’s all I know so far. I told my dad and he’s driving down now. I haven’t been asked to make a statement yet, and I don’t know how any of that works honestly. It’s triggering to even think about. But yeah, there’s the update. To the people who sent me hateful and hurtful things and told me this was all in my head, especially u/mysterymeat45 and u/pazsion80423294, i hope you never have kids. If you hate privately you should be called out publicly. Even if you are troll accounts it’s still insanely fucked up to say the things you did. To everyone who gave me actual, genuine advice, I wish nothing but the best for you all and thanks again so much. If it weren’t for you guys I’d probably think I was still being dramatic. I most likely won’t update again, i already want to move on from this situation. Sorry if this is jumbled. Everything is still so fresh, but writing it out is somehow helping me process it, I think.

Edit: stop calling me “lucky” because he didn’t do worse. I don’t feel lucky at all.

Here are just a couple more examples since people didn’t think the ones my other post were damming enough, and to also maybe help someone else in a similar situation see signs. 1, He would ALWAYS need to know where I am and who I’m with. I find this weird because he’s not my dad, I’m an adult, and I would tell my mom. My mom telling him wasn’t enough. He’d say “no, I want to hear it from HER mouth.” 2, he would often open my packages if I didn’t get to them in time. Very annoying and weird. I ordered the camera detector when the arrival time was while he was at work, so I got lucky there. 3, always commenting on my outfits. Would tell me unwanted “advice”, and that I look like a hooker if I wore shorts/skirts/anything “revealing”. 4, would always ask me about birth control/using protection. “Are you on the pill? If not that little fucker (my boyfriend) better be wrapping it up.” He’d say stuff like this at the most random times too. 5, would always try to use my mom against me. If we got into an argument he would make himself seem like the victim, always. My mom would always say to leave her out of it. 6, he would sometimes groan or say “you again??” Very annoyed when I walked in a room. It was over exaggerated to the point where he could brush it off as a joke if he wanted, but I knew it wasn’t a joke. 7, if I bought something and came home with bags, he’d interrogate me about what I bought. The VS bag is the only time I have hard proof that he went through my stuff. 8, he was super weird about my boyfriend. He would never say his name, just “that little boyfriend of yours.” If I went to go see him he’d roll his eyes and say “again?” Or “don’t you spent too much time with him?” 9, pushing me to call him dad even though he never even come close to having that title. 10, would never ever knock before opening my door. Even though I told him to, repeatedly. Thats all I can really think of right now.


TOP COMMENTS

lizziebee66: Sweetie, whilst your mum’s reaction upset you that she was also upset, hold on to the fact that she 100% believed you. She loves you and has your safety at the centre of her world. Stay safe and loved

Bulky-Mycologist-402: The fact that 3 separate cameras were found is absolutely sickening & frightening. I hope this guy gets punished to the fullest extent of the law. So sorry to hear you had to endure this, it’s very disheartening & wretched knowing this creep thought he can be sneaky and get away doing some shit like this.

Illustrious-Tart7844: Hi, OP. I’m a former domestic violence victim advocate and I’ve worked with women who have gone through similar incidents and worse… I’m so sorry this happened to you. You didn’t deserve this at all. You handled it PERFECTLY and I’m astounded by your strength. Please wrap yourself in support. You will get through this and come out stronger on the other side. Take care of yourself, please. 💜


DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOP

THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT OOP

0

[Inconclusive][Suspected Fake] Bought A house in a non-mandatory HOA without signing contract (long) [Reddit]

preview

I am not the OOP, OOP is Reddit:u/Dunnachius

Story Compiled by: Reddit:u/JoySubtraction

Originally posted to: r/JustNoHOA (first 2 posts) and r/fuckHOA (last 2 posts)

Note: Possibly a fake story

click for possible fake spoiler

Reddit u/randomndude01 posted: > OOP has posted their living situation a year ago and it seems like his luck has completely flipped. > www.reddit.com/r/…/ub9mtHy6Wg > There’s a two year gap between his latest comment and this post, homeless and living in their car. > Can’t say if this entire thing was true or not but he does say he went into a debt spiral. Reddit u/Minimum_Reference_73 posted: > There’s a later post where he talks about stealth living in his van and stuff, so that makes me wonder. And there are several posts about how the legal system does not work that way where OP is claiming to be from.


Original Post: Jan 29, 2022

Long story short, I bought a house in an HOA, in a gated community.

(free standing single family residence)

The property was purchased through a foreclosure auction, knowing it had a property tax lien on it as well (and the dollar amount). I had to buy the tax lien from a speculator that bought the lien at auction. He told me he was waiting on some arbitrary timeframe in order to able to force a sale on the lien.

regardless… the sale is final and all Liens have been cleared.

The previous owner WAS in the HOA prior to his death.

Regardless of the situation I own the property free of clear of any and all liens. I didn’t purchase the house through “normal channels”. For example the “dead guy” never signed anything in the HOA documents transferring ownership. I also never agreed to follow the CCRs when I purchased the house. Because I didn’t buy the house from the former owner, just the gubment.

However every time (like literally every single time) I head out to the property to do any work on/in it I get hounded by one or more of 4 or so busy bodies who keep trying to get me to sign the contract, they keep telling me it’s mandatory and I keep telling them “I’m going to have my attorney look at them and I’ll get back to you”

They also point out that the HOA had right of first refusal in selling the home and I shouldn’t have been able to buy it without first signing the contract. (well I did, so screw them) Everything I can find says that the HOA is voluntary/non-Mandatory and I’ve never signed shit.

Well, one of my questions is that while the house used to be in the HOA, I don’t know if it is grandfathered in because it was in the HOA already? Or is it not in the HOA because I haven’t signed yet? Or is the mere act of buying the house legally put in me the HOA even if I haven’t signed anything?

Supposedly, the “voluntary” HOA is 100% (minus me) of the neighborhood and they have a contract giving right of first of first refusal on any resale of the property. (Good luck enforcing that on a tax/mortgage auction with a dead guy). They also required anyone who bought a house to sign the contract with the HOA before the builder would sell. And one of the things in the HOA contract is that the HOA has the right of first refusal on any sales.

So am I in a legal grey area in a very tightly controlled voluntary HOA? Or is there something sketchy going on with the way they have it set up?

I also have yet to receive a gate access key, I have had luck just tailgating other cars in thru the gate. I also don’t have a street parking sticker, nor do I have any way to request guest parking passes or any of that crap that the paper work talks about.

Or do I stand to have an issue over the right of first refusal crap?

I know… “Don’t sign” is the the correct answer, but what sort of troubles am I going to be in over this bullshit?

PS

If I can really get away with not joining i’m going to park the biggest most mad Maxian truck in the front yard in the grass and paint it neon orange/purple stripes, and build a 20 foot pirate ship in the back yard complete with crows nest.

OOP added in a comment:

I contacted a lawyer for a consultation and he has yet to get back to me. Which means one meeting over the phone to collect all my information, however long to research everything than he will let me know what the situation is.

There is in fact “community assets” that they spend money on and more than likely some potion of the infrastructure isn’t government maintained. The gates aren’t freely provided by the government of course.

I pulled a flyer off the club house bulletin board with instructions on what to tell the uber/door dash driver so they can access the gate and bingo… i’m in. They set up a code specifically to tell the delivery/rideshare/taxi drivers and posted it on the memo board. So this is like the least secure gate in the history of gates

The question of overnight parking tags is still a mystery I haven’t solved and they tow anything parked on the street after dark.

As of today I have gate access codes (but still no sticker).

They came by again and their reaction to me indicates that this is a voluntary HOA that is doing well to pretend to be a mandatory HOA.

They have been working me over with the “Carrot” trying to get me to sign. I’m curious as to when they will switch to the stick and start threatening fantasy legal action.

They’ve already promised to “Give me plenty of time” to fix the yard and the house before they start fining me. Which is a verbal handshake Promise from an HOA Karen so on a scale of 1-10 I trust them as -5/10.

“isn’t this a nice neighborhood?”

“Have you seen the club house?”

“Have you tried the pool?”

They are killings me with kindness, which is significantly better than then stabbing me in the back but still annoying as shit.

But yes, I’m making damned sure I don’t sign anything.

Additional things I’ve learned

But I also learned that yard from the sidewalk to the road (and mailbox) are all HOA property, which means there is a significant amount of HOA assets. And technically under the property ownership rules they can enforce no blocking of the sidewalks/parking in the drive way even if I’m not a member of the HOA. However the zone of my driveway between the house and the sidewalk are my property.

There’s also planters in the center of the Cu du sacs that are volunteer maintained with plants purchased with HOA funds, with home depot/lowes/walmart being the only approved sources that you can receive reimbursement in the CCRs.

I’ve been looking for “brother in law” kickback deals for contractors and it seems that the only requirements for contractors is that they use licensed bonded contractors and only approved paint colors/styles. Virtually everything in materials lists “or visually equivalent replacements”

It also doesn’t require approval for repairs/maintenance just notification.

For what they are actually charging I might consider paying them, I know that it’s a trap and I shouldn’t but I can see why people would.

Still leaning on diagonally painting orange/purple neon stripes and replacing my yard with natural wild flowers and other native plants. And then I’m also considering displaying a vintage 1994 pickup truck in the yard on display cinder blocks.

Comments

dobber1965: They have to give you gate access. There was a case here in central Florida somewhat similar and the HOA had to give access to the new owners.


Update 1

I beat the HOA… I won’t be forced to join. GO LAWYERS! posted 2022-02-18

So earlier this month I purchased a property in real estate lien auction. the property was in a voluntary HOA that had 100% membership.

My attorney looked into the situation and drafted a proposal and sent it to the HOA via registered mail.

He drafted up a proposal agreement with the HOA with the following conditions.

  1. The property owner has unrestricted access to any community owned roadways, gates, ect necessary to access his property.
  2. This does not constitute joining the HOA.
  3. The property owner will pay a figure monthly to the HOA to contribute to the non government owned infrastructure, at his discretion. The amount is non negotiable and not legally required, merely an acknowledgement that the assets exist and have costs for their upkeep.
  4. The property owner will not be held to any HOA standards.
  5. The property owner does not and will not get any voting rights in the HOA.
  6. Any further attempts to get the property owner to join will be considered harassment.
  7. Cashing of the attached checks constitutes agreeing to these terms.
  8. the HOA will provide any necessary access codes for the property owner to use for visitors, contractors, ect.

They received it and signed for it. That day the harassment from the HOA stopped. A week later their attorney sent back a response.

Dunnachius

The HOA board has met, they do not appreciate your uneighborly attitude and are not agreeing to your terms.

However they acknowledge that your claim to unrestricted access to your property may have legal merit if the issue is taken to court. I have been instructed to give you a gate access code, attached below. You will not be given a keyfob to the gate as it would give you unrestricted access to their clubhouse.

Furthermore they are notifying you of the following, the roadway and sidewalk are both HOA property and they reserve the right to remove any illegally parked vehicles or other property.

This is however a legal acknowledgement that you will not be held to their community standards. They also are requesting some leeway regarding harassment as community notices may inadvertently be delivered.

Finally they are returning the check uncashed.

The HOA attorney

I’m not quite understanding how this doesn’t constitute them agreeing to my terms thou… They are giving me everything I want and are turning down my gift towards the upkeep of the road/gate.

–

OOP added in a comment:

I put in a call to a solar company to come out and do a quote on installing solar. Completely not allowed by the HOA bylaws. So going to have to do it for sure. (note, not going to finance it, no contract ect, that’s how those turkeys make their money)

All joking aside…

Today I mowed my lawn, started at 7:00 am before it got too hot and knocked that out. Hmm… since i measured twice I’m going to cancel my long term parking for my RV and move it there since my driveway is plenty long enough. Plus I can sleep in the RV while i’m getting the house into livable shape.

I’d throw a party but the big issue with that is that it isn’t livable yet… as in it’s a toxic disaster and I can’t live in it. I have a call for a 12 foot dumpster to come in as well and the trash company is going to drop it in the driveway.

I’m also in the market for the tallest ugliest ham radio tower I can get. No actual interest in using, just in case…


Update 2:

FHOA Getting harassed by HOA I’m not a part of. (and have refused to join) posted 2022-03-01

So… I purchased my property in a quasi non-voluntary HOA in forced sale. I cleared the liens (Which were disclosed prior to my purchase) and have been fixing up the property.

I’m currently “living” in an RV I have parked in the front yard. I have it up on concrete blocks. Totally in violation of the HOA but I’m not a member. The interior of the house is not livable (pretty bad hoarding situation) and I have a standing order with the trash company to have a 10 yard bin that gets swapped out every Friday. I predict another 2-3 months until that service can be canceled.

The dumpster every week is on top of bags of clothing that goes to goodwill and all the crap I put up on craigslist and ebay for sale. Plus I have enough shampoo and conditioner to keep my hair silky smooth and smelling of spring time for the next 50 years.

The HOA has been harassing me to join, I thought we settled the argument but screw them. They also attempted to have my RV towed off my front yard, fortunately I had already made efforts to prevent it from being towed. Namely I called the towing company the HOA had a contract with and my lawyer explained the situation. They also started sending me fines in the mail and I’m adding them to the harassments file.

Not being dumb enough to be sued the towing company agreed that they wouldn’t tow any vehicle from any space that could be defined as “123 oak street” without my direct authorization. Including but not limited to the driveway, garage, front yard, or street in front of 123 Oak street.

We also saw a way for them to profit from the situation. This is my pro revenge on them.

We have a standing deal that they can drive the tow truck to my house, then they knock on my door and ask if I called the tow. If I say no they charge the HOA for wasting their time, and If I don’t answer they can still charge the HOA for wasting their time.

The towing company hit them for about $500 before they caught on to the deal they made with me.

Some good news… i’ve successfully gotten into the bathroom and cleaned out all the children’s clothing and decades old pizza boxes and bags of onion peels. So after a great deal of elbow grease I might actually be able to shower in my house soon.

OOP added in a comment:

House is livable and I’ve moved in.

Outside is up to my personal level of acceptable.

Livable is a matter of debate. Toxic death trap? No…

Could I rent it out? No…

I have one bedroom and the master bath done. I have the carpet/drywall etc ripped out and the insulation replaced.

The kitchen is not done and won’t be until I get the money to finish. It’s a do the work as the money comes up situation. I have tile down and the cabinets will be next.

I have a fridge, microwave and coffee pot inside and a gas grill outside I do my cooking on.

The other 2 bedrooms and living room are clean. It’s basically one really huge space with insulation showing and studs. I have a cheap area rug in the living room with a tv on a stand and my fugly couch.

Like I said the kitchen is the next and most expensive project. The old cabinets had literally started to rot apart from leaking/gunk on them.

Hoarding is a medical condition!

So im living in the house but there’s a ton of work to do and it’s going to take a big pile of money. Might take me years to finish it off.

Also there’s no way that it would be safe to have children or pets living in the place.

On the plus side I don’t have the typical half million in debt that most Americans do for housing so instead of a mortgage payment I can sink a $1,000 a month into home improvements for the foreseeable future.

The HOA has complied with s court order to stop harassing me. They tried to file a lien on the property for unpaid stuff and my lawyer got it blocked.

Someone got a hold of the mailing list and tipped everyone in the HOA off about the pending lawsuits and how much it would cost each owner in a special assessment if they lost.

There was a recall election scheduled and the board stepped down within a couple days and a new board was elected.

About a week ago I got certified mail from the HOA’s new attorney stating that they acknowledge their error in assuming the hoa is mandatory.

However my lawsuit continues due to the fact that my lawyer is a very good at writing bills.

The harassment and legal fees are the only things I’m suing for now.

So I’ve basically won my battle to stay out of the HOA and the new board wants this to stay quiet and not wreck their property values.


Update 3:

Update on my HOA. They forged my signature. posted 2022-04-11

Required background info,

It’s technically a “voluntary” Hoa but i’m literally the only person who didn’t opt in. Everyone else opted in as a purchase condition. I got my house through other than normal means bypassing the contractual obligation to join.

So my efforts to continue to exist as a hold out surrounded by the HOA have not been without new stories to tell. They got dirty and forged my signature on a copy of the HOA contract. They started up with the fines again.

The house color, dumpster, RV, fence, ECT.

My lawyer is taking them to court and he already got a temporary court order to block all liens levied by the HOA. They hadn’t even filed a lien yet and there’s already a temporary court order blocking them until the conclusion of the civil and criminal actions against the HOA board and the HOA. There’s also a detective from the FDLE (state law enforcement) investigating the forgery.

The running tally for this is already over $10,000 in legal fees. Gotta say I love my lawyer. He’s doing everything on a “we’ll sue them for the legal costs later” basis.

My lawyer says they are digging their hole all the way to china.

OH and someone tipped off the entire HOA using the HOA holiday event email list that this legal action is ongoing due to alleged criminal activities of the board. It’s almost like a lawyer wrote the letter or something…

There WAS a lawsuit against me for slander/libel (both) but my lawyer had it tossed out as they could neither prove I wrote it (which I didn’t) and it simply informed the HOA members them of the legal action taking place, there wasn’t a gag order, and it said “allegedly” rather than a flat out accusation.

Rumor has it there’s going to be a second lawsuit against the board members following the conclusion of mine for gross negligence, breach of fiduciary duty etc.

All I wanted to do was fix my new house and live in peace.

On the plus side It should only be a few more weeks until I finish gutting the interior.

I also found more copies of “Titanic”. The running total is 84 copies ranging from VHS to blue ray. One particular special edition of the VHS sold for a couple hundred bucks on Ebay new unopened.

I am not the OOP, OOP is Reddit:u/Dunnachius

Story Compiled by: Reddit:u/JoySubtraction

Originally posted to: r/JustNoHOA (first 2 posts) and r/fuckHOA (last 2 posts)

Note: Possibly a fake story

click for possible fake spoiler

Reddit u/randomndude01 posted: > OOP has posted their living situation a year ago and it seems like his luck has completely flipped. > www.reddit.com/r/…/ub9mtHy6Wg > There’s a two year gap between his latest comment and this post, homeless and living in their car. > Can’t say if this entire thing was true or not but he does say he went into a debt spiral. Reddit u/Minimum_Reference_73 posted: > There’s a later post where he talks about stealth living in his van and stuff, so that makes me wonder. And there are several posts about how the legal system does not work that way where OP is claiming to be from.


Original Post: Jan 29, 2022

Long story short, I bought a house in an HOA, in a gated community.

(free standing single family residence)

The property was purchased through a foreclosure auction, knowing it had a property tax lien on it as well (and the dollar amount). I had to buy the tax lien from a speculator that bought the lien at auction. He told me he was waiting on some arbitrary timeframe in order to able to force a sale on the lien.

regardless… the sale is final and all Liens have been cleared.

The previous owner WAS in the HOA prior to his death.

Regardless of the situation I own the property free of clear of any and all liens. I didn’t purchase the house through “normal channels”. For example the “dead guy” never signed anything in the HOA documents transferring ownership. I also never agreed to follow the CCRs when I purchased the house. Because I didn’t buy the house from the former owner, just the gubment.

However every time (like literally every single time) I head out to the property to do any work on/in it I get hounded by one or more of 4 or so busy bodies who keep trying to get me to sign the contract, they keep telling me it’s mandatory and I keep telling them “I’m going to have my attorney look at them and I’ll get back to you”

They also point out that the HOA had right of first refusal in selling the home and I shouldn’t have been able to buy it without first signing the contract. (well I did, so screw them) Everything I can find says that the HOA is voluntary/non-Mandatory and I’ve never signed shit.

Well, one of my questions is that while the house used to be in the HOA, I don’t know if it is grandfathered in because it was in the HOA already? Or is it not in the HOA because I haven’t signed yet? Or is the mere act of buying the house legally put in me the HOA even if I haven’t signed anything?

Supposedly, the “voluntary” HOA is 100% (minus me) of the neighborhood and they have a contract giving right of first of first refusal on any resale of the property. (Good luck enforcing that on a tax/mortgage auction with a dead guy). They also required anyone who bought a house to sign the contract with the HOA before the builder would sell. And one of the things in the HOA contract is that the HOA has the right of first refusal on any sales.

So am I in a legal grey area in a very tightly controlled voluntary HOA? Or is there something sketchy going on with the way they have it set up?

I also have yet to receive a gate access key, I have had luck just tailgating other cars in thru the gate. I also don’t have a street parking sticker, nor do I have any way to request guest parking passes or any of that crap that the paper work talks about.

Or do I stand to have an issue over the right of first refusal crap?

I know… “Don’t sign” is the the correct answer, but what sort of troubles am I going to be in over this bullshit?

PS

If I can really get away with not joining i’m going to park the biggest most mad Maxian truck in the front yard in the grass and paint it neon orange/purple stripes, and build a 20 foot pirate ship in the back yard complete with crows nest.

OOP added in a comment:

I contacted a lawyer for a consultation and he has yet to get back to me. Which means one meeting over the phone to collect all my information, however long to research everything than he will let me know what the situation is.

There is in fact “community assets” that they spend money on and more than likely some potion of the infrastructure isn’t government maintained. The gates aren’t freely provided by the government of course.

I pulled a flyer off the club house bulletin board with instructions on what to tell the uber/door dash driver so they can access the gate and bingo… i’m in. They set up a code specifically to tell the delivery/rideshare/taxi drivers and posted it on the memo board. So this is like the least secure gate in the history of gates

The question of overnight parking tags is still a mystery I haven’t solved and they tow anything parked on the street after dark.

As of today I have gate access codes (but still no sticker).

They came by again and their reaction to me indicates that this is a voluntary HOA that is doing well to pretend to be a mandatory HOA.

They have been working me over with the “Carrot” trying to get me to sign. I’m curious as to when they will switch to the stick and start threatening fantasy legal action.

They’ve already promised to “Give me plenty of time” to fix the yard and the house before they start fining me. Which is a verbal handshake Promise from an HOA Karen so on a scale of 1-10 I trust them as -5/10.

“isn’t this a nice neighborhood?”

“Have you seen the club house?”

“Have you tried the pool?”

They are killings me with kindness, which is significantly better than then stabbing me in the back but still annoying as shit.

But yes, I’m making damned sure I don’t sign anything.

Additional things I’ve learned

But I also learned that yard from the sidewalk to the road (and mailbox) are all HOA property, which means there is a significant amount of HOA assets. And technically under the property ownership rules they can enforce no blocking of the sidewalks/parking in the drive way even if I’m not a member of the HOA. However the zone of my driveway between the house and the sidewalk are my property.

There’s also planters in the center of the Cu du sacs that are volunteer maintained with plants purchased with HOA funds, with home depot/lowes/walmart being the only approved sources that you can receive reimbursement in the CCRs.

I’ve been looking for “brother in law” kickback deals for contractors and it seems that the only requirements for contractors is that they use licensed bonded contractors and only approved paint colors/styles. Virtually everything in materials lists “or visually equivalent replacements”

It also doesn’t require approval for repairs/maintenance just notification.

For what they are actually charging I might consider paying them, I know that it’s a trap and I shouldn’t but I can see why people would.

Still leaning on diagonally painting orange/purple neon stripes and replacing my yard with natural wild flowers and other native plants. And then I’m also considering displaying a vintage 1994 pickup truck in the yard on display cinder blocks.

Comments

dobber1965: They have to give you gate access. There was a case here in central Florida somewhat similar and the HOA had to give access to the new owners.


Update 1

I beat the HOA… I won’t be forced to join. GO LAWYERS! posted 2022-02-18

So earlier this month I purchased a property in real estate lien auction. the property was in a voluntary HOA that had 100% membership.

My attorney looked into the situation and drafted a proposal and sent it to the HOA via registered mail.

He drafted up a proposal agreement with the HOA with the following conditions.

  1. The property owner has unrestricted access to any community owned roadways, gates, ect necessary to access his property.
  2. This does not constitute joining the HOA.
  3. The property owner will pay a figure monthly to the HOA to contribute to the non government owned infrastructure, at his discretion. The amount is non negotiable and not legally required, merely an acknowledgement that the assets exist and have costs for their upkeep.
  4. The property owner will not be held to any HOA standards.
  5. The property owner does not and will not get any voting rights in the HOA.
  6. Any further attempts to get the property owner to join will be considered harassment.
  7. Cashing of the attached checks constitutes agreeing to these terms.
  8. the HOA will provide any necessary access codes for the property owner to use for visitors, contractors, ect.

They received it and signed for it. That day the harassment from the HOA stopped. A week later their attorney sent back a response.

Dunnachius

The HOA board has met, they do not appreciate your uneighborly attitude and are not agreeing to your terms.

However they acknowledge that your claim to unrestricted access to your property may have legal merit if the issue is taken to court. I have been instructed to give you a gate access code, attached below. You will not be given a keyfob to the gate as it would give you unrestricted access to their clubhouse.

Furthermore they are notifying you of the following, the roadway and sidewalk are both HOA property and they reserve the right to remove any illegally parked vehicles or other property.

This is however a legal acknowledgement that you will not be held to their community standards. They also are requesting some leeway regarding harassment as community notices may inadvertently be delivered.

Finally they are returning the check uncashed.

The HOA attorney

I’m not quite understanding how this doesn’t constitute them agreeing to my terms thou… They are giving me everything I want and are turning down my gift towards the upkeep of the road/gate.

–

OOP added in a comment:

I put in a call to a solar company to come out and do a quote on installing solar. Completely not allowed by the HOA bylaws. So going to have to do it for sure. (note, not going to finance it, no contract ect, that’s how those turkeys make their money)

All joking aside…

Today I mowed my lawn, started at 7:00 am before it got too hot and knocked that out. Hmm… since i measured twice I’m going to cancel my long term parking for my RV and move it there since my driveway is plenty long enough. Plus I can sleep in the RV while i’m getting the house into livable shape.

I’d throw a party but the big issue with that is that it isn’t livable yet… as in it’s a toxic disaster and I can’t live in it. I have a call for a 12 foot dumpster to come in as well and the trash company is going to drop it in the driveway.

I’m also in the market for the tallest ugliest ham radio tower I can get. No actual interest in using, just in case…


Update 2:

FHOA Getting harassed by HOA I’m not a part of. (and have refused to join) posted 2022-03-01

So… I purchased my property in a quasi non-voluntary HOA in forced sale. I cleared the liens (Which were disclosed prior to my purchase) and have been fixing up the property.

I’m currently “living” in an RV I have parked in the front yard. I have it up on concrete blocks. Totally in violation of the HOA but I’m not a member. The interior of the house is not livable (pretty bad hoarding situation) and I have a standing order with the trash company to have a 10 yard bin that gets swapped out every Friday. I predict another 2-3 months until that service can be canceled.

The dumpster every week is on top of bags of clothing that goes to goodwill and all the crap I put up on craigslist and ebay for sale. Plus I have enough shampoo and conditioner to keep my hair silky smooth and smelling of spring time for the next 50 years.

The HOA has been harassing me to join, I thought we settled the argument but screw them. They also attempted to have my RV towed off my front yard, fortunately I had already made efforts to prevent it from being towed. Namely I called the towing company the HOA had a contract with and my lawyer explained the situation. They also started sending me fines in the mail and I’m adding them to the harassments file.

Not being dumb enough to be sued the towing company agreed that they wouldn’t tow any vehicle from any space that could be defined as “123 oak street” without my direct authorization. Including but not limited to the driveway, garage, front yard, or street in front of 123 Oak street.

We also saw a way for them to profit from the situation. This is my pro revenge on them.

We have a standing deal that they can drive the tow truck to my house, then they knock on my door and ask if I called the tow. If I say no they charge the HOA for wasting their time, and If I don’t answer they can still charge the HOA for wasting their time.

The towing company hit them for about $500 before they caught on to the deal they made with me.

Some good news… i’ve successfully gotten into the bathroom and cleaned out all the children’s clothing and decades old pizza boxes and bags of onion peels. So after a great deal of elbow grease I might actually be able to shower in my house soon.

OOP added in a comment:

House is livable and I’ve moved in.

Outside is up to my personal level of acceptable.

Livable is a matter of debate. Toxic death trap? No…

Could I rent it out? No…

I have one bedroom and the master bath done. I have the carpet/drywall etc ripped out and the insulation replaced.

The kitchen is not done and won’t be until I get the money to finish. It’s a do the work as the money comes up situation. I have tile down and the cabinets will be next.

I have a fridge, microwave and coffee pot inside and a gas grill outside I do my cooking on.

The other 2 bedrooms and living room are clean. It’s basically one really huge space with insulation showing and studs. I have a cheap area rug in the living room with a tv on a stand and my fugly couch.

Like I said the kitchen is the next and most expensive project. The old cabinets had literally started to rot apart from leaking/gunk on them.

Hoarding is a medical condition!

So im living in the house but there’s a ton of work to do and it’s going to take a big pile of money. Might take me years to finish it off.

Also there’s no way that it would be safe to have children or pets living in the place.

On the plus side I don’t have the typical half million in debt that most Americans do for housing so instead of a mortgage payment I can sink a $1,000 a month into home improvements for the foreseeable future.

The HOA has complied with s court order to stop harassing me. They tried to file a lien on the property for unpaid stuff and my lawyer got it blocked.

Someone got a hold of the mailing list and tipped everyone in the HOA off about the pending lawsuits and how much it would cost each owner in a special assessment if they lost.

There was a recall election scheduled and the board stepped down within a couple days and a new board was elected.

About a week ago I got certified mail from the HOA’s new attorney stating that they acknowledge their error in assuming the hoa is mandatory.

However my lawsuit continues due to the fact that my lawyer is a very good at writing bills.

The harassment and legal fees are the only things I’m suing for now.

So I’ve basically won my battle to stay out of the HOA and the new board wants this to stay quiet and not wreck their property values.


Update 3:

Update on my HOA. They forged my signature. posted 2022-04-11

Required background info,

It’s technically a “voluntary” Hoa but i’m literally the only person who didn’t opt in. Everyone else opted in as a purchase condition. I got my house through other than normal means bypassing the contractual obligation to join.

So my efforts to continue to exist as a hold out surrounded by the HOA have not been without new stories to tell. They got dirty and forged my signature on a copy of the HOA contract. They started up with the fines again.

The house color, dumpster, RV, fence, ECT.

My lawyer is taking them to court and he already got a temporary court order to block all liens levied by the HOA. They hadn’t even filed a lien yet and there’s already a temporary court order blocking them until the conclusion of the civil and criminal actions against the HOA board and the HOA. There’s also a detective from the FDLE (state law enforcement) investigating the forgery.

The running tally for this is already over $10,000 in legal fees. Gotta say I love my lawyer. He’s doing everything on a “we’ll sue them for the legal costs later” basis.

My lawyer says they are digging their hole all the way to china.

OH and someone tipped off the entire HOA using the HOA holiday event email list that this legal action is ongoing due to alleged criminal activities of the board. It’s almost like a lawyer wrote the letter or something…

There WAS a lawsuit against me for slander/libel (both) but my lawyer had it tossed out as they could neither prove I wrote it (which I didn’t) and it simply informed the HOA members them of the legal action taking place, there wasn’t a gag order, and it said “allegedly” rather than a flat out accusation.

Rumor has it there’s going to be a second lawsuit against the board members following the conclusion of mine for gross negligence, breach of fiduciary duty etc.

All I wanted to do was fix my new house and live in peace.

On the plus side It should only be a few more weeks until I finish gutting the interior.

I also found more copies of “Titanic”. The running total is 84 copies ranging from VHS to blue ray. One particular special edition of the VHS sold for a couple hundred bucks on Ebay new unopened.

0

[Concluded] My sister cheated on her fiancé and then left her kids all because she wanted “a break”, and I’m not supposed to say anything to her. [Reddit]

preview

My sister cheated on her fiancé and then left her kids all because she wanted “a break”, and I’m not supposed to say anything to her.

This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

OOP: Reddit:u/Spunky_Munkey97

Story Compiled By: Reddit:u/BigONerd

Published on: r/TrueOffMyChest & r/TwoHotTakes

Story is: CONCLUDED

Story timeline


Main Post

January 13, 2025

Buckle up because this is a LOT but I’m really bothered by this and need to just vent because I can NOT believe this has happened.

My (27f) sister (22f) has two beautiful kids. One is 3 and the other is 14 months. When my sister had her oldest daughter, she suffered from PPD, but with support she was able to come out of it. She didn’t really bond with the kid much after though, occasionally she would do fun things with her but it was very rare. Shortly after, I had my son, and I was OVER THE MOON, I’ve never loved something as much as I love my kids ( I now have 2 as well).

When she found out she was pregnant with her 2nd, she didn’t get as excited as she did with the first but as the pregnancy progressed, she was getting more excited.

Fast forward to the second kid being born. She didn’t show any signs of PPD, but she bonded with the second kid way more than she did with the first. I’m not sure if it was because she was exclusively breastfeeding or what but definitely had a better bond with this one. She would get more irritated with the first born ( who was only 2 at the time) and just more distant with her.

Her youngest starting showing some health issues ( nothing super serious, some food allergies and skin issues) and that seemed to just utterly defeat my sister. All of the family, and her fiancé were very encouraging and tried to help her see the bright side, find recipes for the daughter etc. but she didn’t seem like she was interested in any of it. She started to distance herself from both kids now, only doing the bare minimum.

Now, we just found out that my sister had been emotionally cheating on her fiancé, who is the definition of a literal golden retriever partner lol he loves his kids and my sister and took very good care of all 3 of them. He would only ever push my sister to do better and never in a mean way. Anything they needed, he provided for them while my sister got to be a SAHM.

Two days ago, she broke things off with the fiance and had this complete stranger come get her from another state ( she has never met him, and only been FT or playing on Xbox for about a month). All because she said she “had no emotion and needed a break”.

She left with the guy, and I’m not supposed to know any of this. I’m distraught for my nieces and my brother in law ( or I guess not my brother in law anymore?). I don’t understand how a mother could leave her kids, go out of town with someone she didn’t know, without a care in the world. I love my kids and I couldn’t do that to them…

Part of me wonders if it’s PPD, or maybe a manic episode? I genuinely don’t know. I’ve also learned some other things about how she’s been recently that just make me think I never really knew who my sister was, and that’s heartbreaking because she was my best friend. I can not condone that behavior… my brother in law is filing for emergency custody, but I hope she doesn’t try to take those kids from him because she doesn’t deserve them. They deserve stability and she’s clearly not stable. Ugh.

COMMENTS

shesavillain: Why do you keep saying you’re not supposed to know any of this?

OOP: My brother in law told me and doesn’t want my sister to know I know until he files court paperwork just in case she tries anything since they’re not married

GilgameDistance: If this is the reason, BIL is wise - please listen to him and let his lawyers work out custody. It sounds like the best thing for those kids is for him to have sole, full custody. Please help him get that.

OOP: I plan on it

NatNatTh3CatMom: We really need to know how old is BIL

OOP: He’s 22

Maatable: What kind of “support” did your sister receive when she was going through PPD? Her behavior for thr last two years has been troubling, this escalation especially so. Your sister needs professional help desperately.

OOP: She saw a therapist for a few weeks but quit going. We would come over, help with chores, cook, babysit so she could take a shower or a nap or even so she could go out with her fiance.

honorthecrones (downvoted): He never was your brother in law. Why did they never marry?

OOP: They were going to have an October wedding this year. My sister didn’t want to just go to the court house, she wanted a ceremony and everything so they were saving for that.

peppermintvalet

“He would only ever push my sister to do better and not in a mean way” Can you elaborate on this?

OOP: If she wasn’t pulling her weight with house stuff, he would just have an adult conversation with her and then help her do whatever was needed to do. For example, he works from 8-7pm, and would come home and the dishes from the previous night were not done or any laundry etc. So he would talk to her about it and then they would do it together. Or if she was depressed and wanted to just lay in bed all day, he would do something like make her favorite breakfast and encourage her to get up even if it wasn’t easy.

oboejoe92: Possibly Borderline Personality Disorder?

She could be “monkey branching” as I have heard it called before- essentially always having her arm stretched out to the next branch (metaphorically speaking) looking for that next bit of validation, excitement, dopamine hit, whatever. “Swinging” from one thing/person to the next.

First it was her partner, then child one, then child two, now random dude.

OOP: She was diagnosed with that when she was younger, was medicated for a long time and when she turned 18, she took herself off of her medicine. She said she was feeling better off the meds so we all just assumed she was okay. That was our error, but her choice to be off of her medication.

oneofthesenights23: Why did nobody get her real help? Encouraging her to see the bright side isn’t help. She is so young to have 2 babies and ppd sounds like she needs real help if running away is easier than dealing with her life. Did she see a therapist after her first pregnancy?

OOP: Yes she did for a few weeks, and then she quit going and I guess she just masked that everything was fine

YakElectronic6713: Why does your sister have two kids at the age of 22, when it is so obvious she doesn’t enjoy being a mother? Has the Golden Retriever pressured her into having children?

OOP: Not at all, they planned the first one and then the second was a surprise. They weren’t really being careful, my sister was on BC but didn’t take it like she was supposed to ( would miss days etc)

Wh33lh68s3: That’s some fucking Bullshit that you can’t say anything to her about abandoning her children!!!

Make sure that the abandonment is well documented so that when the father of the children sues for full custody of the children it will be easier for him to do so…

Updateme:

OOP: Yeah he wants all of the court bs situated first and then I fully plan on losing my shit. I’ll probably also just send the link to the post so when she tries to say I’m judging her or whatever then she can see that I’m not alone in thinking she sucks. Mental health issues, I could sympathize with as I am type 1 bipolar. But even still, she should be able to be an adult and communicate that she needs help, and not cheat on a really good man and then abandon her kids….

Also a few people have said to update them when I can, and I plan to! But I’m newer to Reddit so I’m not sure how to do like a mass update lol


Update - 1 in the Main post - after 7 days

January 20, 2025

Since some of you have asked, I’ll update on the little bit of info we have. So my BIL changed phone plans, and did not include her on his new bill. She called him and asked him why he didn’t put her on it…. Like she genuinely didn’t understand that he is not going to be paying for her things anymore.

She told him that she isn’t going to fight him and that he can have full custody of the kids. And that she still wants to be able to call and visit when she feels like it. The guy she ran off with, just lost his car BECAUSE HE SIGNED DIVORCE PAPERS RIGHT BEFORE HE LEFT TO GET MY SISTER. And his ex took the car because it was in her name lol karma is beautiful. She also told my BIL that she plans on moving back with the new guy so they can be close to her kids…

I don’t get her logic in any of this really. Also, people have asked so some answers here!

  • BIL is 22
  • my sister asked my BIL not to tell us ( my mom and I) because she did not want us to get in the way of her being able to see her kids or to “judge her”. ( too late). My BIL doesn’t want her to know we know until after all of the court stuff is finalized.
  • he’s doing okay, him and his mom are actually going to be moving a little closer to our family, so we can all help out with the kids. It takes a village and he’s definitely got one.
  • since my sister being out of the picture for a week now, the youngest kid has taken her first steps and the oldest seems genuinely happier.

I’m coming from a much less angry place. I still can not stand that she did this, and I am cutting contact with her. My partner and I are supporting my BIL as much as we can with two kids of our own. This whole situation has been insane. I’ll update more if anything else happens. Thank you to everyone who gave advice and didn’t judge me venting. Once this all isn’t so fresh I’m going to show BIL the thread and let him see that it was not his fault.


Update 2 - after 17 days (after 10 days from last post)

January 30, 2025

Update! My sister cheated on her Fiance and then left her kids all because she wanted a break and I’m not supposed to say anything to her.

Okay so I have a few updates to this absolute insanity of a situation.

First, I posted the first update as an edit to the original post. Since then, my sister called my mom, and asked her for any legal contacts so she “looks like she has her shit together”. My mom told her no, and that she isn’t going to help her because she abandoned her children. My sister is still convinced that she did not abandon them.

She yelled at my mom stating that she hasn’t left them and that she’s only 3 hours away and calls to talk to them every night…… she doesn’t. She has called a few times but not every day. She’s still planning on moving back home with this new guy so she can be closer to the kids but I’m pretty sure my BIL is only going to allow her to have supervised visits since she has made comments about just taking the kids and how she should have done that from the start, her best friend suggested it.

When my mom tried to reason with her and ask her why she didn’t just come her, her response was “I just want to be on my own”. Which I find ironic because she hasn’t been on her own ever and she’s still not on her own. She is still mooching off of another guy with a job and she still doesn’t have a job, a license, or her GED. ( we have all offered to help her get those things but she has no drive to actually do it). BIL and his mom are moving closer to me and my parents so we can all help each other and hopefully make things easier on BIL as he tries to be a single dad with two toddlers.

BIL is in much better spirits. He was upset until my sister called him, while she was naked, and asked him for money and then she proceeded to put on the other guys hoodie and walk around the house until he could see the other guy in the background. My BIL said at that point, he knew he was never getting her back and didn’t want her back and he’s doing much better. He has good days and bad days but the good are outweighing the bad. The kids are actually thriving without my sister there too. My sister would “parent” by just turning on tv and letting them do whatever, but BIL is much more involved with them as is his mom.

If anything else crazy happens, I’ll post another update but for now I think we are just waiting for all of the long term court paperwork to be submitted. He got emergency custody and it was filed that she abandoned them and fled the state.

Thank you to everyone who has let me vent and given some good advice. This has definitely been a rollercoaster.


Final Update - After 1 year, 7 months

August 12, 2026

Final Update in the BORU comments

Hi guys! So I’m OP! Thought I would post another update as I was reminded of this post through a comment! So I hope you have your popcorn 😅

So my sister and the Xbox guy are still together and to put it simply, he sucks. He’s a raging narcissist and has a pretty explosive temper for someone who is almost 30.

They moved back to the same state as us, and lived with my mom and step dad for a little bit with the understanding that she was to get her life together. They never paid rent, they didn’t clean, and their room constantly smelled like B.O and sex. It was disgusting. When my parents addressed the issues, the Xbox guy said that he “doesn’t do dishes, instead he just throws them away” and that “if he doesn’t cook then he shouldn’t have to do dishes”. My sister and him would get into some pretty nasty arguments where he would name call and get in her face. For reference, my sister is 5’3 and he’s 6’5.

They ended up getting kicked out of my mom’s house when they refused to help financially or physically around the house. They wouldn’t even buy groceries except like maybe $50 every other month and my sister would need rides to work and not compensate for gas. My parents are not well off, they pay their bills and have very little extra financially to do anything else, so when paying for two extra adults, they were drowning.

They now live in a camper, that they bought with the Xbox guys divorce money but he put it in my sisters name only because he didn’t want to get a license and register it in his name just in case the courts came after him for not paying child support to his child who hasn’t even turned a year at this point ( I think he’s about to or just turned one, but they don’t see him so I’m not entirely sure, I’m pretty disconnected from that.)

Their relationship is sad but honestly she did it to herself. He’s put his hands on her, locked her in the bathroom and told her to figure out how to get out, spit in her face, etc. He doesn’t want her to work because “he’s very religious and believes in the traditional ways of life and that’s the woman stays home and he provides” meanwhile they barely pay their bills and he makes like $15 an hour which is not really anything in this economy especially him paying child support.

A few months ago she was going to leave him, because he got abusive and we honestly still don’t know the extent of it. But she ended up staying, and when I asked her why stay with this POS, her words verbatim to me were “ well you know how it is, when you’re with a narcissist, you know you’re the victim but you just can’t leave because they do have good qualities and it’s not bad ALL the time”. I was in a mentally abusive relationship but got myself out of it and I’m THRIVING so I don’t actually “know how it is”.

So she stays at home all day, getting high and just waits for him to come home. She doesn’t come to family gatherings because we all can’t stand him due to our own personal experiences with him and he hates to see independent women who won’t bow down to his stupid ass.

As for the kiddos and ex fiancé. He moved to another state with the girls where he has family support. They are very well taken care of, he works two jobs to support them and his mom and grandma helps watch them for him. Apparently she talks to them on FaceTime but not every day and the ex now knows about the abuse from the Xbox guy because she decided to call him crying for help and had him listen to how Xbox guy was talking to her during an argument. So I highly doubt that their dad will allow this POS to be around the girls. He even offered to drive the 12 hours to come get her and bring her back to their state so she could get away from him and be with the girls. He has said he will probably always have love for my sister but he knows they’re not a good match.

I talk to her maybe twice a month, because even though I don’t like her choices, I do care for my sister and my conversations are basically life checks at this point. Apparently she’s starting a job this week, because Xbox guy asked for help with bills. We will see how long this lasts.


This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

Please remember to follow the community rules.

My sister cheated on her fiancé and then left her kids all because she wanted “a break”, and I’m not supposed to say anything to her.

This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

OOP: Reddit:u/Spunky_Munkey97

Story Compiled By: Reddit:u/BigONerd

Published on: r/TrueOffMyChest & r/TwoHotTakes

Story is: CONCLUDED

Story timeline


Main Post

January 13, 2025

Buckle up because this is a LOT but I’m really bothered by this and need to just vent because I can NOT believe this has happened.

My (27f) sister (22f) has two beautiful kids. One is 3 and the other is 14 months. When my sister had her oldest daughter, she suffered from PPD, but with support she was able to come out of it. She didn’t really bond with the kid much after though, occasionally she would do fun things with her but it was very rare. Shortly after, I had my son, and I was OVER THE MOON, I’ve never loved something as much as I love my kids ( I now have 2 as well).

When she found out she was pregnant with her 2nd, she didn’t get as excited as she did with the first but as the pregnancy progressed, she was getting more excited.

Fast forward to the second kid being born. She didn’t show any signs of PPD, but she bonded with the second kid way more than she did with the first. I’m not sure if it was because she was exclusively breastfeeding or what but definitely had a better bond with this one. She would get more irritated with the first born ( who was only 2 at the time) and just more distant with her.

Her youngest starting showing some health issues ( nothing super serious, some food allergies and skin issues) and that seemed to just utterly defeat my sister. All of the family, and her fiancé were very encouraging and tried to help her see the bright side, find recipes for the daughter etc. but she didn’t seem like she was interested in any of it. She started to distance herself from both kids now, only doing the bare minimum.

Now, we just found out that my sister had been emotionally cheating on her fiancé, who is the definition of a literal golden retriever partner lol he loves his kids and my sister and took very good care of all 3 of them. He would only ever push my sister to do better and never in a mean way. Anything they needed, he provided for them while my sister got to be a SAHM.

Two days ago, she broke things off with the fiance and had this complete stranger come get her from another state ( she has never met him, and only been FT or playing on Xbox for about a month). All because she said she “had no emotion and needed a break”.

She left with the guy, and I’m not supposed to know any of this. I’m distraught for my nieces and my brother in law ( or I guess not my brother in law anymore?). I don’t understand how a mother could leave her kids, go out of town with someone she didn’t know, without a care in the world. I love my kids and I couldn’t do that to them…

Part of me wonders if it’s PPD, or maybe a manic episode? I genuinely don’t know. I’ve also learned some other things about how she’s been recently that just make me think I never really knew who my sister was, and that’s heartbreaking because she was my best friend. I can not condone that behavior… my brother in law is filing for emergency custody, but I hope she doesn’t try to take those kids from him because she doesn’t deserve them. They deserve stability and she’s clearly not stable. Ugh.

COMMENTS

shesavillain: Why do you keep saying you’re not supposed to know any of this?

OOP: My brother in law told me and doesn’t want my sister to know I know until he files court paperwork just in case she tries anything since they’re not married

GilgameDistance: If this is the reason, BIL is wise - please listen to him and let his lawyers work out custody. It sounds like the best thing for those kids is for him to have sole, full custody. Please help him get that.

OOP: I plan on it

NatNatTh3CatMom: We really need to know how old is BIL

OOP: He’s 22

Maatable: What kind of “support” did your sister receive when she was going through PPD? Her behavior for thr last two years has been troubling, this escalation especially so. Your sister needs professional help desperately.

OOP: She saw a therapist for a few weeks but quit going. We would come over, help with chores, cook, babysit so she could take a shower or a nap or even so she could go out with her fiance.

honorthecrones (downvoted): He never was your brother in law. Why did they never marry?

OOP: They were going to have an October wedding this year. My sister didn’t want to just go to the court house, she wanted a ceremony and everything so they were saving for that.

peppermintvalet

“He would only ever push my sister to do better and not in a mean way” Can you elaborate on this?

OOP: If she wasn’t pulling her weight with house stuff, he would just have an adult conversation with her and then help her do whatever was needed to do. For example, he works from 8-7pm, and would come home and the dishes from the previous night were not done or any laundry etc. So he would talk to her about it and then they would do it together. Or if she was depressed and wanted to just lay in bed all day, he would do something like make her favorite breakfast and encourage her to get up even if it wasn’t easy.

oboejoe92: Possibly Borderline Personality Disorder?

She could be “monkey branching” as I have heard it called before- essentially always having her arm stretched out to the next branch (metaphorically speaking) looking for that next bit of validation, excitement, dopamine hit, whatever. “Swinging” from one thing/person to the next.

First it was her partner, then child one, then child two, now random dude.

OOP: She was diagnosed with that when she was younger, was medicated for a long time and when she turned 18, she took herself off of her medicine. She said she was feeling better off the meds so we all just assumed she was okay. That was our error, but her choice to be off of her medication.

oneofthesenights23: Why did nobody get her real help? Encouraging her to see the bright side isn’t help. She is so young to have 2 babies and ppd sounds like she needs real help if running away is easier than dealing with her life. Did she see a therapist after her first pregnancy?

OOP: Yes she did for a few weeks, and then she quit going and I guess she just masked that everything was fine

YakElectronic6713: Why does your sister have two kids at the age of 22, when it is so obvious she doesn’t enjoy being a mother? Has the Golden Retriever pressured her into having children?

OOP: Not at all, they planned the first one and then the second was a surprise. They weren’t really being careful, my sister was on BC but didn’t take it like she was supposed to ( would miss days etc)

Wh33lh68s3: That’s some fucking Bullshit that you can’t say anything to her about abandoning her children!!!

Make sure that the abandonment is well documented so that when the father of the children sues for full custody of the children it will be easier for him to do so…

Updateme:

OOP: Yeah he wants all of the court bs situated first and then I fully plan on losing my shit. I’ll probably also just send the link to the post so when she tries to say I’m judging her or whatever then she can see that I’m not alone in thinking she sucks. Mental health issues, I could sympathize with as I am type 1 bipolar. But even still, she should be able to be an adult and communicate that she needs help, and not cheat on a really good man and then abandon her kids….

Also a few people have said to update them when I can, and I plan to! But I’m newer to Reddit so I’m not sure how to do like a mass update lol


Update - 1 in the Main post - after 7 days

January 20, 2025

Since some of you have asked, I’ll update on the little bit of info we have. So my BIL changed phone plans, and did not include her on his new bill. She called him and asked him why he didn’t put her on it…. Like she genuinely didn’t understand that he is not going to be paying for her things anymore.

She told him that she isn’t going to fight him and that he can have full custody of the kids. And that she still wants to be able to call and visit when she feels like it. The guy she ran off with, just lost his car BECAUSE HE SIGNED DIVORCE PAPERS RIGHT BEFORE HE LEFT TO GET MY SISTER. And his ex took the car because it was in her name lol karma is beautiful. She also told my BIL that she plans on moving back with the new guy so they can be close to her kids…

I don’t get her logic in any of this really. Also, people have asked so some answers here!

  • BIL is 22
  • my sister asked my BIL not to tell us ( my mom and I) because she did not want us to get in the way of her being able to see her kids or to “judge her”. ( too late). My BIL doesn’t want her to know we know until after all of the court stuff is finalized.
  • he’s doing okay, him and his mom are actually going to be moving a little closer to our family, so we can all help out with the kids. It takes a village and he’s definitely got one.
  • since my sister being out of the picture for a week now, the youngest kid has taken her first steps and the oldest seems genuinely happier.

I’m coming from a much less angry place. I still can not stand that she did this, and I am cutting contact with her. My partner and I are supporting my BIL as much as we can with two kids of our own. This whole situation has been insane. I’ll update more if anything else happens. Thank you to everyone who gave advice and didn’t judge me venting. Once this all isn’t so fresh I’m going to show BIL the thread and let him see that it was not his fault.


Update 2 - after 17 days (after 10 days from last post)

January 30, 2025

Update! My sister cheated on her Fiance and then left her kids all because she wanted a break and I’m not supposed to say anything to her.

Okay so I have a few updates to this absolute insanity of a situation.

First, I posted the first update as an edit to the original post. Since then, my sister called my mom, and asked her for any legal contacts so she “looks like she has her shit together”. My mom told her no, and that she isn’t going to help her because she abandoned her children. My sister is still convinced that she did not abandon them.

She yelled at my mom stating that she hasn’t left them and that she’s only 3 hours away and calls to talk to them every night…… she doesn’t. She has called a few times but not every day. She’s still planning on moving back home with this new guy so she can be closer to the kids but I’m pretty sure my BIL is only going to allow her to have supervised visits since she has made comments about just taking the kids and how she should have done that from the start, her best friend suggested it.

When my mom tried to reason with her and ask her why she didn’t just come her, her response was “I just want to be on my own”. Which I find ironic because she hasn’t been on her own ever and she’s still not on her own. She is still mooching off of another guy with a job and she still doesn’t have a job, a license, or her GED. ( we have all offered to help her get those things but she has no drive to actually do it). BIL and his mom are moving closer to me and my parents so we can all help each other and hopefully make things easier on BIL as he tries to be a single dad with two toddlers.

BIL is in much better spirits. He was upset until my sister called him, while she was naked, and asked him for money and then she proceeded to put on the other guys hoodie and walk around the house until he could see the other guy in the background. My BIL said at that point, he knew he was never getting her back and didn’t want her back and he’s doing much better. He has good days and bad days but the good are outweighing the bad. The kids are actually thriving without my sister there too. My sister would “parent” by just turning on tv and letting them do whatever, but BIL is much more involved with them as is his mom.

If anything else crazy happens, I’ll post another update but for now I think we are just waiting for all of the long term court paperwork to be submitted. He got emergency custody and it was filed that she abandoned them and fled the state.

Thank you to everyone who has let me vent and given some good advice. This has definitely been a rollercoaster.


Final Update - After 1 year, 7 months

August 12, 2026

Final Update in the BORU comments

Hi guys! So I’m OP! Thought I would post another update as I was reminded of this post through a comment! So I hope you have your popcorn 😅

So my sister and the Xbox guy are still together and to put it simply, he sucks. He’s a raging narcissist and has a pretty explosive temper for someone who is almost 30.

They moved back to the same state as us, and lived with my mom and step dad for a little bit with the understanding that she was to get her life together. They never paid rent, they didn’t clean, and their room constantly smelled like B.O and sex. It was disgusting. When my parents addressed the issues, the Xbox guy said that he “doesn’t do dishes, instead he just throws them away” and that “if he doesn’t cook then he shouldn’t have to do dishes”. My sister and him would get into some pretty nasty arguments where he would name call and get in her face. For reference, my sister is 5’3 and he’s 6’5.

They ended up getting kicked out of my mom’s house when they refused to help financially or physically around the house. They wouldn’t even buy groceries except like maybe $50 every other month and my sister would need rides to work and not compensate for gas. My parents are not well off, they pay their bills and have very little extra financially to do anything else, so when paying for two extra adults, they were drowning.

They now live in a camper, that they bought with the Xbox guys divorce money but he put it in my sisters name only because he didn’t want to get a license and register it in his name just in case the courts came after him for not paying child support to his child who hasn’t even turned a year at this point ( I think he’s about to or just turned one, but they don’t see him so I’m not entirely sure, I’m pretty disconnected from that.)

Their relationship is sad but honestly she did it to herself. He’s put his hands on her, locked her in the bathroom and told her to figure out how to get out, spit in her face, etc. He doesn’t want her to work because “he’s very religious and believes in the traditional ways of life and that’s the woman stays home and he provides” meanwhile they barely pay their bills and he makes like $15 an hour which is not really anything in this economy especially him paying child support.

A few months ago she was going to leave him, because he got abusive and we honestly still don’t know the extent of it. But she ended up staying, and when I asked her why stay with this POS, her words verbatim to me were “ well you know how it is, when you’re with a narcissist, you know you’re the victim but you just can’t leave because they do have good qualities and it’s not bad ALL the time”. I was in a mentally abusive relationship but got myself out of it and I’m THRIVING so I don’t actually “know how it is”.

So she stays at home all day, getting high and just waits for him to come home. She doesn’t come to family gatherings because we all can’t stand him due to our own personal experiences with him and he hates to see independent women who won’t bow down to his stupid ass.

As for the kiddos and ex fiancé. He moved to another state with the girls where he has family support. They are very well taken care of, he works two jobs to support them and his mom and grandma helps watch them for him. Apparently she talks to them on FaceTime but not every day and the ex now knows about the abuse from the Xbox guy because she decided to call him crying for help and had him listen to how Xbox guy was talking to her during an argument. So I highly doubt that their dad will allow this POS to be around the girls. He even offered to drive the 12 hours to come get her and bring her back to their state so she could get away from him and be with the girls. He has said he will probably always have love for my sister but he knows they’re not a good match.

I talk to her maybe twice a month, because even though I don’t like her choices, I do care for my sister and my conversations are basically life checks at this point. Apparently she’s starting a job this week, because Xbox guy asked for help with bills. We will see how long this lasts.


This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

Please remember to follow the community rules.

0

[Concluded] Who do you call when youre stuck? [Reddit]

preview

I am not OOP. OOP is u/Agent641 posting in r/perth. Thank you to Reddit user u/VN93SS9 for making their first BoRu post so entertaining

Concluded as per OOP.

Some useful terminology:

jarrah - Eucalyptus marginata, which the countertop is made of.

DFES - Department of Fire and Emergency Services in Australia.


Who do you call when youre stuck? - 2019-02-22


Like lets say you are stuck somewhere, and its not a life threatening emergency situation, but its fairly serious and its gonna require a bit of know-how and gumption to get you unstuck, who do you call? Fire department?

OOP elaborates in a comment thread:

Canigetamoment: Are you ok?

Im a bit stuck but otherwise yeah im fine.

Canigetamoment: Where are you stuck? Call the fire department I think, or a friend

The front door is locked and i cant open it from where i am, any of my friends that im ok with seeing me naked and vulnerable dont have a car. Also Im naked i didnt mention that before.

Canigetamoment: So definitely call the fire department I think, do you have a spare key outside they could access? Are you able to make yourself less nude if you could get someone to come help you?

I have a cushion. No key outside but with a ladder they could go over the roof and come in thru the garage. Ill google to see if theres a non emergency number for them.

Canigetamoment: Yeah I think that’s definitely your best bet. Legit though, how the fuck did you get this stuck?

Well I wanted a nice shiny coffee bar counter top, so I cut and sanded and stained it all nice, and i applied a coat of epoxy resin last night. Its supposed to set hard in 24 hrs. So tonight after having a shower i came to check on it, and I rapped my fingers on it and it sounded like hard plastic, so I thought it was set. I was curing it in the livingroom because its the least dusty place. Anyway I just happened to sit down on it while I was reading the destructions (sic) that came with the epoxy, wondering if i should give it another coat. When i was done reading the instructions, i went to stand up, and couldnt. So im kinda sitting here with a slab of live edge jarrah attached to my butt cheeks, watching battlestar galactica and waiting for the non emergency dfes number to return my call. If i could make it to the garage i know ive got some acetone there, but im not sure if it would help. My beer is empty which is a drag, but otherwise everythings great.

In response to OOP’s explanation of how they got themselves in this mess:

Muslim_Wookie: Mate call the police communications centre. Getting stuck with epoxy on your skin is no joke, don’t try to pull yourself off.

I managed to free my nutsack but the butt is gonna take some strategy.

littleblackcat: umm you should call the firies dude

I dnt know, they might laugh at my gross white naked body. I dont even have an ab.

postingstuff: Ok this makes my window comment obsolete. What a pickle.

OMG YES! One ofthe release agents google mentioned was vinegar. I cant get to the acetone or the thinners in the garage (wont fit thru the doorway) but I know i do have a jar of pickles in the cupboard i could get to, eat the pickles and use the vinegar to weaken the surly bonds of resin! This is now plan A. Dfes ops center still hasnt called back.

metao: I don’t even care if it’s real or not, this is the best thread to happen to r/perth in a long time.

Homie, I might be borderline r****ded, but Im no liar. (Image transcript: OOP posts a picture showing themselves sitting on top of the countertop by showing the top of their leg, next to a jar of pickles. Their butt is out of frame. Battlestar Galactica is shown on the TV.)

produrp: My attention is glued to this thread.

I’m fucking sorry man

No you’re not…

produrp: Mate I really feel for you.

Are you free tomorrow? I’m playing basketball with some mates and we need someone to come off the bench.

When I can reach my computer Im gonna gild that. (Editor’s note: OOP did not remember to gild that post.)

produrp:

A mates just finished a PC build and he’s wondering if you can help him Benchmark it?

Muslim_Wookie: You need a hypeman cause you are LIT

produrp: I’ve got more jokes, just working out how to mix them into the conversation. The next one’s a big longer and is in two parts. Part A and Part B.


OOP posts an update in the thread about 1.5 hours after posting the thread:

Update: The gods are good and kind, I made it to the fridge wherer the pickles were, and made it back. The gherkin juice is actually working, very slowly. Did you know that the apparent stickiness of a surface is called ‘stiction’? I thi k its mostly hair that is experiencing stiction. If my skin were chemically bonding with the epoxy resin, according to the google it would burn like fucckery, which its not. If it does, ill give in and call literally every emergency service there is.

Cmdr Adama is still in dire staits after being shot by a cylon, but Tigh is doing his best despite a boarding party fucking up the battlestar.

Im down to three gherkins and half a jar of juice. Ive been dabbing it furiously with pages torn from a book called “Man, The Builder”. I also got myself a couple of beers while i was at the fridge. Priorities. DFES has stillnot returned my voicemail.


OOP posts another update half an hour later:

Update 2: I am so fucking stupid. Im sitting here thinking, how am i gonna get to the meanest solvent in the house if I cant fit 1340x420mm of Jarrah sideways thru the garage door, but never thought until a couple minutes ago, why it have to stay 1340x420mm?

I know my jigsaw is battery operated and located just inside the door to the garage, so i take my ass that way and fetch it thru the door with a long stick.

Then i sat back on the coffee table snd sawed the countertop in three pieces, only one if which is glued to my person. Now that i can fit through almost all doorways, i was able to get the acetone and the turps and use these to acellerate the fantastic work my pickle juice has been championing. Still watiching BSG while i dissolve my assload of resin, and its going great!


Another half-hour later, OOP posts another update:

Update 3: I managed to pull myself off, my ass hurts like hell and I’m more exhausted than I’ve ever been in my life. I’m going to bed.


OOP posts their last update in the thread:

Update 4: It is the morning after. There is a little tenderness, but not much pain. If anything, my butt feels thoroughly exfoliated.

The scene of the battle (Image transcript: A piece of the countertop, with exoxy residue on it.)

The “Lay of the Land” (Image transcript: Multiple pieces of the countertop, laid out on a table.)

A close-up of our hero and messiah, this jar of spring valley gherkins (Image transcript: An empty pickle jar.)

I think at some point I said jarrah, and I know that’s not what this is, but in the heat of the moment I couldnt remember what kind of timber this colour/style is so I just used the best descriptor I could think of.

I’d like to thank everyone for their support and morbid fascination through this ordeal. Special thanks to u/postingstuff for the pickle idea, and to u/produrp for the thorough ridicule and complete lack of empathy, it really kept my spirits up.

I won’t be posting a picture of my butt, that would be a crime against humanity.

Some comments on the update:

produrp: If it’s not Jarrah what wood is it?

Blackbutt?

Anyway I’m glad you’re okay man. I was concerned for your safety and wellbeing initially, butt as we learned more of the situation and I was more confident you weren’t in mortal danger I knew what I had to do.

So in the future when I accidentally Vaculok my penis to a nightstand or dynabolt my testicles to the tiled floor I know you’ll be there to hand my ass to me.

🤗🤗

postingstuff: Any time mate, glad I could provide some inspiration in return for the entertainment 🤣


Final Update:

So I finished my new counter top - 2019-02-23

OOP posts a picture of the countertop. (Image transcript: Three pieces of wooden counter top, each with a white coating.)

I posted this just a moment ago, but I think I pasted the link wrong as the image wasn’t coming up in the thumbnail.

The time I spent looking at my epoxy job made me realize that not only is it not really worth the trouble, I actually started to dislike the ultra gloss finish of the epoxy. It looked kind of tacky and way too shiny.

I went and bought a new bit of timber from bunnings, added a strip to make it the required width, cut a gouge out to acommodate the geometry of the wall its going against, and coated it this time in matte clear polyurethane (Cabots), which dries in only 2 hrs and is way easier to apply. Three coats and a bit of light sanding and I was finally done with the job. I think it looks way better than the shiny epoxy. I even had time to make some nice cabinet doors, but I’ve still got to paint these white later this evening.

Two TV channels asked to interview me, one newspaper wanted to do a story and photo op with me and the jar of gherkins, which I’ve declined, and a couple of online news outlets have run my epoxy butt pickle story with pictures from the thread. I kinda hope that’s the end of this wild ride…

I’ll be in the workshop.


I am not the OOP. Please do not harass the OOP.

I am not OOP. OOP is u/Agent641 posting in r/perth. Thank you to Reddit user u/VN93SS9 for making their first BoRu post so entertaining

Concluded as per OOP.

Some useful terminology:

jarrah - Eucalyptus marginata, which the countertop is made of.

DFES - Department of Fire and Emergency Services in Australia.


Who do you call when youre stuck? - 2019-02-22


Like lets say you are stuck somewhere, and its not a life threatening emergency situation, but its fairly serious and its gonna require a bit of know-how and gumption to get you unstuck, who do you call? Fire department?

OOP elaborates in a comment thread:

Canigetamoment: Are you ok?

Im a bit stuck but otherwise yeah im fine.

Canigetamoment: Where are you stuck? Call the fire department I think, or a friend

The front door is locked and i cant open it from where i am, any of my friends that im ok with seeing me naked and vulnerable dont have a car. Also Im naked i didnt mention that before.

Canigetamoment: So definitely call the fire department I think, do you have a spare key outside they could access? Are you able to make yourself less nude if you could get someone to come help you?

I have a cushion. No key outside but with a ladder they could go over the roof and come in thru the garage. Ill google to see if theres a non emergency number for them.

Canigetamoment: Yeah I think that’s definitely your best bet. Legit though, how the fuck did you get this stuck?

Well I wanted a nice shiny coffee bar counter top, so I cut and sanded and stained it all nice, and i applied a coat of epoxy resin last night. Its supposed to set hard in 24 hrs. So tonight after having a shower i came to check on it, and I rapped my fingers on it and it sounded like hard plastic, so I thought it was set. I was curing it in the livingroom because its the least dusty place. Anyway I just happened to sit down on it while I was reading the destructions (sic) that came with the epoxy, wondering if i should give it another coat. When i was done reading the instructions, i went to stand up, and couldnt. So im kinda sitting here with a slab of live edge jarrah attached to my butt cheeks, watching battlestar galactica and waiting for the non emergency dfes number to return my call. If i could make it to the garage i know ive got some acetone there, but im not sure if it would help. My beer is empty which is a drag, but otherwise everythings great.

In response to OOP’s explanation of how they got themselves in this mess:

Muslim_Wookie: Mate call the police communications centre. Getting stuck with epoxy on your skin is no joke, don’t try to pull yourself off.

I managed to free my nutsack but the butt is gonna take some strategy.

littleblackcat: umm you should call the firies dude

I dnt know, they might laugh at my gross white naked body. I dont even have an ab.

postingstuff: Ok this makes my window comment obsolete. What a pickle.

OMG YES! One ofthe release agents google mentioned was vinegar. I cant get to the acetone or the thinners in the garage (wont fit thru the doorway) but I know i do have a jar of pickles in the cupboard i could get to, eat the pickles and use the vinegar to weaken the surly bonds of resin! This is now plan A. Dfes ops center still hasnt called back.

metao: I don’t even care if it’s real or not, this is the best thread to happen to r/perth in a long time.

Homie, I might be borderline r****ded, but Im no liar. (Image transcript: OOP posts a picture showing themselves sitting on top of the countertop by showing the top of their leg, next to a jar of pickles. Their butt is out of frame. Battlestar Galactica is shown on the TV.)

produrp: My attention is glued to this thread.

I’m fucking sorry man

No you’re not…

produrp: Mate I really feel for you.

Are you free tomorrow? I’m playing basketball with some mates and we need someone to come off the bench.

When I can reach my computer Im gonna gild that. (Editor’s note: OOP did not remember to gild that post.)

produrp:

A mates just finished a PC build and he’s wondering if you can help him Benchmark it?

Muslim_Wookie: You need a hypeman cause you are LIT

produrp: I’ve got more jokes, just working out how to mix them into the conversation. The next one’s a big longer and is in two parts. Part A and Part B.


OOP posts an update in the thread about 1.5 hours after posting the thread:

Update: The gods are good and kind, I made it to the fridge wherer the pickles were, and made it back. The gherkin juice is actually working, very slowly. Did you know that the apparent stickiness of a surface is called ‘stiction’? I thi k its mostly hair that is experiencing stiction. If my skin were chemically bonding with the epoxy resin, according to the google it would burn like fucckery, which its not. If it does, ill give in and call literally every emergency service there is.

Cmdr Adama is still in dire staits after being shot by a cylon, but Tigh is doing his best despite a boarding party fucking up the battlestar.

Im down to three gherkins and half a jar of juice. Ive been dabbing it furiously with pages torn from a book called “Man, The Builder”. I also got myself a couple of beers while i was at the fridge. Priorities. DFES has stillnot returned my voicemail.


OOP posts another update half an hour later:

Update 2: I am so fucking stupid. Im sitting here thinking, how am i gonna get to the meanest solvent in the house if I cant fit 1340x420mm of Jarrah sideways thru the garage door, but never thought until a couple minutes ago, why it have to stay 1340x420mm?

I know my jigsaw is battery operated and located just inside the door to the garage, so i take my ass that way and fetch it thru the door with a long stick.

Then i sat back on the coffee table snd sawed the countertop in three pieces, only one if which is glued to my person. Now that i can fit through almost all doorways, i was able to get the acetone and the turps and use these to acellerate the fantastic work my pickle juice has been championing. Still watiching BSG while i dissolve my assload of resin, and its going great!


Another half-hour later, OOP posts another update:

Update 3: I managed to pull myself off, my ass hurts like hell and I’m more exhausted than I’ve ever been in my life. I’m going to bed.


OOP posts their last update in the thread:

Update 4: It is the morning after. There is a little tenderness, but not much pain. If anything, my butt feels thoroughly exfoliated.

The scene of the battle (Image transcript: A piece of the countertop, with exoxy residue on it.)

The “Lay of the Land” (Image transcript: Multiple pieces of the countertop, laid out on a table.)

A close-up of our hero and messiah, this jar of spring valley gherkins (Image transcript: An empty pickle jar.)

I think at some point I said jarrah, and I know that’s not what this is, but in the heat of the moment I couldnt remember what kind of timber this colour/style is so I just used the best descriptor I could think of.

I’d like to thank everyone for their support and morbid fascination through this ordeal. Special thanks to u/postingstuff for the pickle idea, and to u/produrp for the thorough ridicule and complete lack of empathy, it really kept my spirits up.

I won’t be posting a picture of my butt, that would be a crime against humanity.

Some comments on the update:

produrp: If it’s not Jarrah what wood is it?

Blackbutt?

Anyway I’m glad you’re okay man. I was concerned for your safety and wellbeing initially, butt as we learned more of the situation and I was more confident you weren’t in mortal danger I knew what I had to do.

So in the future when I accidentally Vaculok my penis to a nightstand or dynabolt my testicles to the tiled floor I know you’ll be there to hand my ass to me.

🤗🤗

postingstuff: Any time mate, glad I could provide some inspiration in return for the entertainment 🤣


Final Update:

So I finished my new counter top - 2019-02-23

OOP posts a picture of the countertop. (Image transcript: Three pieces of wooden counter top, each with a white coating.)

I posted this just a moment ago, but I think I pasted the link wrong as the image wasn’t coming up in the thumbnail.

The time I spent looking at my epoxy job made me realize that not only is it not really worth the trouble, I actually started to dislike the ultra gloss finish of the epoxy. It looked kind of tacky and way too shiny.

I went and bought a new bit of timber from bunnings, added a strip to make it the required width, cut a gouge out to acommodate the geometry of the wall its going against, and coated it this time in matte clear polyurethane (Cabots), which dries in only 2 hrs and is way easier to apply. Three coats and a bit of light sanding and I was finally done with the job. I think it looks way better than the shiny epoxy. I even had time to make some nice cabinet doors, but I’ve still got to paint these white later this evening.

Two TV channels asked to interview me, one newspaper wanted to do a story and photo op with me and the jar of gherkins, which I’ve declined, and a couple of online news outlets have run my epoxy butt pickle story with pictures from the thread. I kinda hope that’s the end of this wild ride…

I’ll be in the workshop.


I am not the OOP. Please do not harass the OOP.

0

[Concluded] My new neighbors ‘parties’ are creeping me out [Reddit]

preview

My new neighbors ‘parties’ are creeping me out

This is a repost. The original was posted in r/TwoHotTakes by user Emotional-Letter8226. I’m not the original poster. Thank you Reddit used u/schattenspringer for compiling this post

Status: Concluded

Tap for mood spoiler

Not dramatic, not a sex cult

Original:

August 7, 2026

I (25M) just moved into a duplex. Rent is affordable, it’s nice to finally escape the apartment life and I’m so excited to be able to have a garden. Everything has been great so far except my neighbors/housemates are giving me weird vibes. I live in one half of the house and a couple, probably mid thirties lives on the other side. Let’s call them Arden and Andrea. I haven’t met them yet but in the week I’ve been here something kind of strange has been happening. Two times they’ve had a bunch of people over, like 15 people. For reference, the house isn’t super big to begin with so 15 people on their side is likely a bit of a squeeze but the weird thing is that there is ZERO NOISE from their side. Like complete silence. Our walls are not thick. I hear when they vacuum do you’d think 15 people hanging out would bleed through the walls but NOTHING. The people they’ve had over look to also be in their 30s and all walk up to their door, go in, and then nothing. Idk why it’s creeping me out but that’s 17 people on the other side of the wall and zero noise!! They’re in there for about an hour or so and then they all leave. Has anyone had anything like this before or have any ideas what they might be doing? I don’t wanna say anything cause that’d be weird but I also wanna know what goes on over there.

edit: okay there have been some developments, posted an update but don’t know how to link it here


Comments by OOP:

I heard them having a heated discussion the other day and that came through the wall so surely a bunch of people having book club would too?

Wow a lot of people commented on this. For the record I’m not trying to snoop just politely curious what goes on with all those people and zero noise like not even conversation. I made some chocolate chip cookies and am going over to introduce myself and give them to them tomorrow and maybe ask if it naturally comes up, praying they don’t have allergies to my gift of sustenance 🤞 A bunch of people asked if there’s a basement, not on my side so I would assume not on theirs but maybe idk thank you all for your ideas! I’ll report back if there’s any more info on what it is they do


Update:

August 8, 2026, 1 day later

Wow did not expect this post to get this much attention, y’all had a bunch of ideas I hadn’t thought of as to what my neighbors were doing last week. Unfortunately, I’m still if not more confused than I was before. I made cookies yesterday and took them over this morning to introduce myself and maybe ask what they’re up to if it came up naturally. And I can say 100% there is something weird going on with the neighbors. The woman opened the door and I said hey and my name and that I moved in next door and offered her the cookies. She looked at me for like fifteen seconds without saying anything like a head to toe kind of look and then smiled really big and was like hi I’m Andrea welcome to the neighborhood. And then she asked if I wanted to come over on Sunday night cause they’re having a gathering. I asked what kind of gathering and she just said to bring a notebook and a pen. I asked why and she said it’s going to be fun and I’ll meet new people and just kind of smiled at me. I WAS CREEPED OUT YALL. I said I’d have to check my schedule and she looked like she knew I was stalling but said she hoped I could make it and then I went back to my side of the house. Anyway I don’t know if I should go cause if it’s something religious I’m not interested and if it’s something else I don’t wanna just go in blind ahhhh what should I do?? And what do you think it is??


Update 2:

August 9, 2026, 2 days later

Okay guys thank you for all your ideas and thoughts on whether I should go or not. If you missed my first two posts, the TLDR is that I moved into a duplex and my neighbors had a bunch of people over but I would never hear any noise through the very thin walls which was weird. I went and introduced myself and got invited to one of these gatherings with no info except to bring a notebook and pen. Even though some people said I shouldn’t go I went and I just got back and I have a lot to update you on and am also not entirely sure what just happened so please hang with me.

So Andrea said 8 and at about 7:45 people started showing up like they did last week. I waited a few more minutes and then went over and knocked on their door with the notebook and pen she asked me to bring. A woman I didn’t recognize opened the door and I said Andrea invited me over. She introduced herself and led me inside. We walked through the living room and kitchen which were normal (I was expecting bondage gear after all y’all who were like it’s a sex thing) and she opened a door in the hall. Those of you wondering if they had a basement on their side were right.

We walked down the stairs and in the unfinished basement were all the people I’ve seen going into their house. They were milling around chatting, and there were chairs in a few rows. But the weirdest thing was what was on the walls: dozens of posters of people, cats, dogs, and items. Like missing posters. And sticky notes all around them too.

Andrea came up to me and was like you came yay! And she introduced me to her husband and I was like what is this and they told me that they run a group that tries to find missing people, pets, and and items and collect the reward money. I was like … what. And they kept explaining but I honestly tuned them out I was panicking more than a little bit cause of all the things yall said might be going on this wasn’t something I’d considered/prepared my mind for. I asked if they’d ever actually solved anything and Andrea said they’ve found a few pets and stolen items and feel like they have some leads on people. They introduced me to a few other attendees and then the meeting for lack of a better word began.

Andrea and her husband stood at the front while everyone else sat on the chairs and called people up who I guess had been like assigned different cases who gave updates on their progress. Like this couple came up and talked about how they’d gone to the police station to ask about a missing woman in the county and the police hadn’t told them anything like duh why would they. And a guy got up and gave his theory on a briefcase that was stolen out of someone’s car. It was so weird but if I had gotten up and left everyone would have seen me and I didn’t wanna stand out. At the end of the meeting Andrea called ME UP and pulled a missing cat poster off the wall and told me it was my first case. I was too stunned to say anything so I just took it and sat back down and when the thing ended i got the hell out of there and now I’m writing this.

So Reddit, my new neighbors run a civilian bounty hunter ring out of their basement which is why I didn’t hear any noise through the walls and I’m supposed to be looking for an orange cat named Peaches who has a $200 reward. What. The. Fuck. Do. I. Do. Anticipating a question, I have no idea what they do with the money they get I did not wanna hang around and dig any deeper. I guess this isn’t the weirdest thing te more I think about it but I don’t wanna be a member of whatever this is.

Edit: Now that some of the shock has worn off this is kinda rad and I feel it may be my moral duty to #findpeaches


Reminder this is a repost community and I am not OOP

My new neighbors ‘parties’ are creeping me out

This is a repost. The original was posted in r/TwoHotTakes by user Emotional-Letter8226. I’m not the original poster. Thank you Reddit used u/schattenspringer for compiling this post

Status: Concluded

Tap for mood spoiler

Not dramatic, not a sex cult

Original:

August 7, 2026

I (25M) just moved into a duplex. Rent is affordable, it’s nice to finally escape the apartment life and I’m so excited to be able to have a garden. Everything has been great so far except my neighbors/housemates are giving me weird vibes. I live in one half of the house and a couple, probably mid thirties lives on the other side. Let’s call them Arden and Andrea. I haven’t met them yet but in the week I’ve been here something kind of strange has been happening. Two times they’ve had a bunch of people over, like 15 people. For reference, the house isn’t super big to begin with so 15 people on their side is likely a bit of a squeeze but the weird thing is that there is ZERO NOISE from their side. Like complete silence. Our walls are not thick. I hear when they vacuum do you’d think 15 people hanging out would bleed through the walls but NOTHING. The people they’ve had over look to also be in their 30s and all walk up to their door, go in, and then nothing. Idk why it’s creeping me out but that’s 17 people on the other side of the wall and zero noise!! They’re in there for about an hour or so and then they all leave. Has anyone had anything like this before or have any ideas what they might be doing? I don’t wanna say anything cause that’d be weird but I also wanna know what goes on over there.

edit: okay there have been some developments, posted an update but don’t know how to link it here


Comments by OOP:

I heard them having a heated discussion the other day and that came through the wall so surely a bunch of people having book club would too?

Wow a lot of people commented on this. For the record I’m not trying to snoop just politely curious what goes on with all those people and zero noise like not even conversation. I made some chocolate chip cookies and am going over to introduce myself and give them to them tomorrow and maybe ask if it naturally comes up, praying they don’t have allergies to my gift of sustenance 🤞 A bunch of people asked if there’s a basement, not on my side so I would assume not on theirs but maybe idk thank you all for your ideas! I’ll report back if there’s any more info on what it is they do


Update:

August 8, 2026, 1 day later

Wow did not expect this post to get this much attention, y’all had a bunch of ideas I hadn’t thought of as to what my neighbors were doing last week. Unfortunately, I’m still if not more confused than I was before. I made cookies yesterday and took them over this morning to introduce myself and maybe ask what they’re up to if it came up naturally. And I can say 100% there is something weird going on with the neighbors. The woman opened the door and I said hey and my name and that I moved in next door and offered her the cookies. She looked at me for like fifteen seconds without saying anything like a head to toe kind of look and then smiled really big and was like hi I’m Andrea welcome to the neighborhood. And then she asked if I wanted to come over on Sunday night cause they’re having a gathering. I asked what kind of gathering and she just said to bring a notebook and a pen. I asked why and she said it’s going to be fun and I’ll meet new people and just kind of smiled at me. I WAS CREEPED OUT YALL. I said I’d have to check my schedule and she looked like she knew I was stalling but said she hoped I could make it and then I went back to my side of the house. Anyway I don’t know if I should go cause if it’s something religious I’m not interested and if it’s something else I don’t wanna just go in blind ahhhh what should I do?? And what do you think it is??


Update 2:

August 9, 2026, 2 days later

Okay guys thank you for all your ideas and thoughts on whether I should go or not. If you missed my first two posts, the TLDR is that I moved into a duplex and my neighbors had a bunch of people over but I would never hear any noise through the very thin walls which was weird. I went and introduced myself and got invited to one of these gatherings with no info except to bring a notebook and pen. Even though some people said I shouldn’t go I went and I just got back and I have a lot to update you on and am also not entirely sure what just happened so please hang with me.

So Andrea said 8 and at about 7:45 people started showing up like they did last week. I waited a few more minutes and then went over and knocked on their door with the notebook and pen she asked me to bring. A woman I didn’t recognize opened the door and I said Andrea invited me over. She introduced herself and led me inside. We walked through the living room and kitchen which were normal (I was expecting bondage gear after all y’all who were like it’s a sex thing) and she opened a door in the hall. Those of you wondering if they had a basement on their side were right.

We walked down the stairs and in the unfinished basement were all the people I’ve seen going into their house. They were milling around chatting, and there were chairs in a few rows. But the weirdest thing was what was on the walls: dozens of posters of people, cats, dogs, and items. Like missing posters. And sticky notes all around them too.

Andrea came up to me and was like you came yay! And she introduced me to her husband and I was like what is this and they told me that they run a group that tries to find missing people, pets, and and items and collect the reward money. I was like … what. And they kept explaining but I honestly tuned them out I was panicking more than a little bit cause of all the things yall said might be going on this wasn’t something I’d considered/prepared my mind for. I asked if they’d ever actually solved anything and Andrea said they’ve found a few pets and stolen items and feel like they have some leads on people. They introduced me to a few other attendees and then the meeting for lack of a better word began.

Andrea and her husband stood at the front while everyone else sat on the chairs and called people up who I guess had been like assigned different cases who gave updates on their progress. Like this couple came up and talked about how they’d gone to the police station to ask about a missing woman in the county and the police hadn’t told them anything like duh why would they. And a guy got up and gave his theory on a briefcase that was stolen out of someone’s car. It was so weird but if I had gotten up and left everyone would have seen me and I didn’t wanna stand out. At the end of the meeting Andrea called ME UP and pulled a missing cat poster off the wall and told me it was my first case. I was too stunned to say anything so I just took it and sat back down and when the thing ended i got the hell out of there and now I’m writing this.

So Reddit, my new neighbors run a civilian bounty hunter ring out of their basement which is why I didn’t hear any noise through the walls and I’m supposed to be looking for an orange cat named Peaches who has a $200 reward. What. The. Fuck. Do. I. Do. Anticipating a question, I have no idea what they do with the money they get I did not wanna hang around and dig any deeper. I guess this isn’t the weirdest thing te more I think about it but I don’t wanna be a member of whatever this is.

Edit: Now that some of the shock has worn off this is kinda rad and I feel it may be my moral duty to #findpeaches


Reminder this is a repost community and I am not OOP

0

[Concluded] AITA for "not even giving my girlfriend the bare minimum", as people I know have put it? (Additional updates) [Fedi:Lemmy]

preview

AITA for “not even giving my girlfriend the bare minimum”, as people I know have put it?


I am not OOP. OOP is Viktoria@Lemmy.CA Do NOT message them, comment on the original post or harass them!

Post was originally made to !amitheasshole@lemmy.world

AITAH does not have a way to determine Assholishness but the post has more down votes than upvotes.

Please note the OOP is still quite young without a fully developed brain.

Tap for Mood Warning

OOP is young. OOP acts like an ass to their partner.

Thank you fediverse user, YarrMatey@lemmy.dbzer0.com for pointing out additional updates


Original:

March 2026

So, a while ago, I (19NB/19F) have posted about this girl Nichole (18F). At the time, I was 18, and she 17. However, what happened is that there were personal stuff going on in my life and while I was so happy that Nichole liked me back and was DTF and all this stuff, I was too hung up on an old crush I was head over heels for, Karl (19M).

Karl has proven himself time and time again to be a bully who couldn’t treat me right even if I don’t know if he liked me that way, he probably just was using me when he flirted with me. So I moved on from him.

After one other girlfriend and I broke up, I fell for Nichole again, and she still liked me and was looking for a partner.

Well, I happen to be best friends with Max (20M). He is a year older than me. Way back in like sophomore year, we used to date when he was a girl and I was a boy. Now, I think I like him again, but I respect Nichole and Nichole is monogamous. I am not. I can be in polyamorous and monogamous relationships.

Nichole has recently been very depressed around me and I just want her to be happy and can’t take deep conversations or the drama. It just stresses me out and bothers me a whole lot.

Max and I have a very special friendship. He even has recently confessed feelings for me and been wanting to take me on dates. We still hang out without the official “boyfriend and girlfriend” title though because Nichole would be upset. Anyway, I have feelings for Max too and don’t quite know what to do with them.

We call every day for 4 hours, we just have that kind of friendship. I’ve even been having dreams of calling him and doing our usual stuff, but also cuddling, sleeping with him, giving him hickeys, etc. Stuff that I used to dream about with Nichole but not much with her anymore.

Truth be told, Nichole is HOT, but I love Max and his personality, and since he’s a more recent “crush” as a neurodivergent girl, I’m kind of “hyperfixated” on him. I get hyperfixations on people and Nichole used to be mine and while I still like her, now it’s Max who I fixate on.

Max and I always call for like 3-4 hours, maybe more, whereas I don’t even call Nichole because I’m too busy with Max. Recently, I’ve even slept over at his house, hung out with him, drank with him, and usually I fall asleep on the phone with him. We call them “long distance sleepovers”.

Nichole goes to bed really early though, like 8-9 while I go to bed at like midnight or later, so we never sleep on call. Nichole has talked to me about the whole thing, which I posted about before, and I answered her and then told her to stop talking about it, admittedly, because I didn’t want to deal with extra drama. But someone recently told her apparently, which she repeated to me, that someone who cares wouldn’t silence or dismiss her, but I do care and I don’t think that’s what I did.

If you know the anime trope “tsundere”, that’s kind of how Nichole is like now. Or rather, a “deretsun”. Normally, and at first, she acted “deredere” or sweet and lovestruck personalitywise, but then she became upset and super pissy and serious. I want the old Nichole back, not gonna lie. My Nikki.

But, again, I love my Maxmax too <3 He’s my best friend after all.


Comments

Canaconda:

tsundere

Anime has absolute fucked gen z up. Holy shit. Listen, anime is for kids in japan. It’s fiction written for a culture you can barely relate to. Applying it to your personal relationships is a bad life choice.

Nichole is monogamous. I am not. I can be in polyamorous and monogamous relationships.

Than you need to commit to Nichole or break it off cuz you’re definitely emotionally abusing her if she’s romantically interested in you.

Ignis:

You should end things with Nicole if you’re planning to continue your relationship to Max. It’s not fair to her or her feelings for you to be acting this way behind her back.

This sort of half in / half out thing is emotional cheating. She’s not poly. You can’t be looking for that type of emotional connection with another person while maintaining a relationship with Nicole.


Update:

Same post a few days later in the comments

OP: Sent a text to their significant other.

Transcription:

Ey bro listen. I don’t care much about you anymore. I don’t think we can hang out because of that sorry. I just don’t want to. Max is new to me and I like him, not you. So let’s break up, ok?

OP made a comment:

I told her I didn’t care about her anymore and broke up with her.


Comments

Canaconda:

Wow you went full autism on that one. Like I can be a dick but holy shit that was brutal.

Defs get a therapist / life coach that specializes in NDV clients because you really need some guidance… that doesn’t come from anime or reddit.

And if you ignore that advice… at least put your next breakup text through chat gpt first.


Update 2

No date, same month

So after everything that happened, she said she’s suicidal and may or may not do it and that if she doesn’t respond, she did it or is in the hospital. If she does, she will let me know that she’s alive or decided not to kill herself. She says I didn’t make her kill herself but I’m in shock

OOP updated Update: She said she decided she wouldn’t do it and she talked to her best friend about it


Update 3:

OP Sent texts:

click for text transcription

Text between OP and Nikki OP: I want you back babe. My wife (ring emoji) I’m sorry Nikki: honestily i[‘ll think about it but i’m down. i still love you, you know. even if our breakup was recent, i’ll give you another chance. Nikki: just promise me you’ll spend more time with me so it’s fairer. i’d be fine with you spending more time with max if i preffered alone time but i prefer you to my alone time. Nikki: so more time w me would be fairer :’) can you do that? if so we’re good Nikki: <3 OP: I can do that. By the way, can we be polyamorous? I was wanting to date Max too Nikki: as long as i get to have you, my answer will always be yes <33 End first text Single Image text OP to Nikki OP: You’re the best babe (2 double heart emoji and a single heart emoji) Additional text screenshot Text between OP and Max OP: Max, I really love you. I know you like me back. I was gonna get back with you anyway but I wanted Nikki so I asked her out again and asked if it was okay to date you if we dated again. She said yes. Again, I know you like me too and I’ve been wanting to do this for awhile. Will you go out with me? (heart emoji ring emoji) Max: Heart reacted that message Max: Of course (heart emoji) I would love to. I really like you too and was planning on asking YOU but didn’t know if that was ok with her

So we are polyamorous now and we are back together, Nikki and I. Max and I are now dating too.


Comments

driving_crooner@lemmy.eco.br:

How does that work? Max and Nikki have a relationship between them too? Or they have other relationships with other people too?

No, they are monogamous but okay with me dating multiple people


Update 4:

No date, same month.

OP made a new post titled: Just now, AITA for being depressed and saying “ok” as a response to the girl who is my girlfriend again?

I’ve been feeling a bit depressed and I don’t know exactly why. My (19F) girlfriend Nikki (18F) just told me she loves me. I said “Ok”. Then she said she couldn’t wait to spend time with me and I said “Cool” because I didn’t know how to respond.

She then asked if I was alright and I told her I was depressed. She asked if she could help and I said “No but I have Max”. She said she was here for me too and I said “Ok well I know that”.

Then she apologized and I told her not to, and that it wasn’t her fault I was depressed.


Comments

imsufferableninja@sh.itjust.works:

Yeah man, you’re the AH. You obviously aren’t into her, you’re just stringing her along.

Edit to add: I’m not just judging from this post, but from all the posts I’ve read from the OP about this situation

How am I not into her? I’m depressed

RumorsOfLove@lemmy.dbzer0.com:

Clearly you dont feel about her the same way you feel about Max. So be honest about that if you want to be done with the drama.

I’m just depresses so I’m dry Depressed. Max is able to take care of me since i see him every day


OOP has not posted on this account in 5 months so I’m calling this concluded.

Reminder I am not the OOP. This is a repost community! Do NOT contact the OOP or comment on the original thread!

AITA for “not even giving my girlfriend the bare minimum”, as people I know have put it?


I am not OOP. OOP is Viktoria@Lemmy.CA Do NOT message them, comment on the original post or harass them!

Post was originally made to !amitheasshole@lemmy.world

AITAH does not have a way to determine Assholishness but the post has more down votes than upvotes.

Please note the OOP is still quite young without a fully developed brain.

Tap for Mood Warning

OOP is young. OOP acts like an ass to their partner.

Thank you fediverse user, YarrMatey@lemmy.dbzer0.com for pointing out additional updates


Original:

March 2026

So, a while ago, I (19NB/19F) have posted about this girl Nichole (18F). At the time, I was 18, and she 17. However, what happened is that there were personal stuff going on in my life and while I was so happy that Nichole liked me back and was DTF and all this stuff, I was too hung up on an old crush I was head over heels for, Karl (19M).

Karl has proven himself time and time again to be a bully who couldn’t treat me right even if I don’t know if he liked me that way, he probably just was using me when he flirted with me. So I moved on from him.

After one other girlfriend and I broke up, I fell for Nichole again, and she still liked me and was looking for a partner.

Well, I happen to be best friends with Max (20M). He is a year older than me. Way back in like sophomore year, we used to date when he was a girl and I was a boy. Now, I think I like him again, but I respect Nichole and Nichole is monogamous. I am not. I can be in polyamorous and monogamous relationships.

Nichole has recently been very depressed around me and I just want her to be happy and can’t take deep conversations or the drama. It just stresses me out and bothers me a whole lot.

Max and I have a very special friendship. He even has recently confessed feelings for me and been wanting to take me on dates. We still hang out without the official “boyfriend and girlfriend” title though because Nichole would be upset. Anyway, I have feelings for Max too and don’t quite know what to do with them.

We call every day for 4 hours, we just have that kind of friendship. I’ve even been having dreams of calling him and doing our usual stuff, but also cuddling, sleeping with him, giving him hickeys, etc. Stuff that I used to dream about with Nichole but not much with her anymore.

Truth be told, Nichole is HOT, but I love Max and his personality, and since he’s a more recent “crush” as a neurodivergent girl, I’m kind of “hyperfixated” on him. I get hyperfixations on people and Nichole used to be mine and while I still like her, now it’s Max who I fixate on.

Max and I always call for like 3-4 hours, maybe more, whereas I don’t even call Nichole because I’m too busy with Max. Recently, I’ve even slept over at his house, hung out with him, drank with him, and usually I fall asleep on the phone with him. We call them “long distance sleepovers”.

Nichole goes to bed really early though, like 8-9 while I go to bed at like midnight or later, so we never sleep on call. Nichole has talked to me about the whole thing, which I posted about before, and I answered her and then told her to stop talking about it, admittedly, because I didn’t want to deal with extra drama. But someone recently told her apparently, which she repeated to me, that someone who cares wouldn’t silence or dismiss her, but I do care and I don’t think that’s what I did.

If you know the anime trope “tsundere”, that’s kind of how Nichole is like now. Or rather, a “deretsun”. Normally, and at first, she acted “deredere” or sweet and lovestruck personalitywise, but then she became upset and super pissy and serious. I want the old Nichole back, not gonna lie. My Nikki.

But, again, I love my Maxmax too <3 He’s my best friend after all.


Comments

Canaconda:

tsundere

Anime has absolute fucked gen z up. Holy shit. Listen, anime is for kids in japan. It’s fiction written for a culture you can barely relate to. Applying it to your personal relationships is a bad life choice.

Nichole is monogamous. I am not. I can be in polyamorous and monogamous relationships.

Than you need to commit to Nichole or break it off cuz you’re definitely emotionally abusing her if she’s romantically interested in you.

Ignis:

You should end things with Nicole if you’re planning to continue your relationship to Max. It’s not fair to her or her feelings for you to be acting this way behind her back.

This sort of half in / half out thing is emotional cheating. She’s not poly. You can’t be looking for that type of emotional connection with another person while maintaining a relationship with Nicole.


Update:

Same post a few days later in the comments

OP: Sent a text to their significant other.

Transcription:

Ey bro listen. I don’t care much about you anymore. I don’t think we can hang out because of that sorry. I just don’t want to. Max is new to me and I like him, not you. So let’s break up, ok?

OP made a comment:

I told her I didn’t care about her anymore and broke up with her.


Comments

Canaconda:

Wow you went full autism on that one. Like I can be a dick but holy shit that was brutal.

Defs get a therapist / life coach that specializes in NDV clients because you really need some guidance… that doesn’t come from anime or reddit.

And if you ignore that advice… at least put your next breakup text through chat gpt first.


Update 2

No date, same month

So after everything that happened, she said she’s suicidal and may or may not do it and that if she doesn’t respond, she did it or is in the hospital. If she does, she will let me know that she’s alive or decided not to kill herself. She says I didn’t make her kill herself but I’m in shock

OOP updated Update: She said she decided she wouldn’t do it and she talked to her best friend about it


Update 3:

OP Sent texts:

click for text transcription

Text between OP and Nikki OP: I want you back babe. My wife (ring emoji) I’m sorry Nikki: honestily i[‘ll think about it but i’m down. i still love you, you know. even if our breakup was recent, i’ll give you another chance. Nikki: just promise me you’ll spend more time with me so it’s fairer. i’d be fine with you spending more time with max if i preffered alone time but i prefer you to my alone time. Nikki: so more time w me would be fairer :’) can you do that? if so we’re good Nikki: <3 OP: I can do that. By the way, can we be polyamorous? I was wanting to date Max too Nikki: as long as i get to have you, my answer will always be yes <33 End first text Single Image text OP to Nikki OP: You’re the best babe (2 double heart emoji and a single heart emoji) Additional text screenshot Text between OP and Max OP: Max, I really love you. I know you like me back. I was gonna get back with you anyway but I wanted Nikki so I asked her out again and asked if it was okay to date you if we dated again. She said yes. Again, I know you like me too and I’ve been wanting to do this for awhile. Will you go out with me? (heart emoji ring emoji) Max: Heart reacted that message Max: Of course (heart emoji) I would love to. I really like you too and was planning on asking YOU but didn’t know if that was ok with her

So we are polyamorous now and we are back together, Nikki and I. Max and I are now dating too.


Comments

driving_crooner@lemmy.eco.br:

How does that work? Max and Nikki have a relationship between them too? Or they have other relationships with other people too?

No, they are monogamous but okay with me dating multiple people


Update 4:

No date, same month.

OP made a new post titled: Just now, AITA for being depressed and saying “ok” as a response to the girl who is my girlfriend again?

I’ve been feeling a bit depressed and I don’t know exactly why. My (19F) girlfriend Nikki (18F) just told me she loves me. I said “Ok”. Then she said she couldn’t wait to spend time with me and I said “Cool” because I didn’t know how to respond.

She then asked if I was alright and I told her I was depressed. She asked if she could help and I said “No but I have Max”. She said she was here for me too and I said “Ok well I know that”.

Then she apologized and I told her not to, and that it wasn’t her fault I was depressed.


Comments

imsufferableninja@sh.itjust.works:

Yeah man, you’re the AH. You obviously aren’t into her, you’re just stringing her along.

Edit to add: I’m not just judging from this post, but from all the posts I’ve read from the OP about this situation

How am I not into her? I’m depressed

RumorsOfLove@lemmy.dbzer0.com:

Clearly you dont feel about her the same way you feel about Max. So be honest about that if you want to be done with the drama.

I’m just depresses so I’m dry Depressed. Max is able to take care of me since i see him every day


OOP has not posted on this account in 5 months so I’m calling this concluded.

Reminder I am not the OOP. This is a repost community! Do NOT contact the OOP or comment on the original thread!

0

[Ongoing] Am I being unreasonable holding my ground here? about a funeral [Fedi:Lemmy]

Am I being unreasonable holding my ground here? about a funeral - Linux.Community linux.community
preview

Am I being unreasonable holding my ground here? about a funeral


I am not the OOP. OOP is Vestmoria@Linux.Community do NOT reach out to them

Post was originally made to AskLemmy.

Tap for Mood Warning

Death, bad family dynamics


Original Post:

Aug 08, 2026

My Christian, old republican southerner father wants me to attend his Christian funeral with all of his surviving relatives present. I don’t believe in any god, he knows that. He needs a religion to give a meaning to his life? Knock yourself out.

Religion is not the main problem here. The main problem is how close minded and fake people are in a southern small town in GA and above all, relatives. 2 aunts love to pretend everything is fine, they excel doing that on funerals and weddings, then stab you in the back as soon as you’re not within ear distance, either need drama to feel important or have way too much free time.

I wouldn’t mind a small Christian ritual with my mother, my brother, a priest and nobody else, but these women and their husbands? They drag everyone down with their stupid grudges about yard sales and business deals made in the early 2020s and seem to be envious of those who left that place and found something better. Last time I saw them, 7 years ago, they complained I don’t call them. What for?

I’m better off without them and don’t have the bandwidth to deal with them.

Family seems to be an identity issue for my father, the idea that his whole family won’t bury him together scares him. I told them I will honor him my way, with luck on the hospital bed where he dies or at home, that mother and brother are welcome to honor him with me, that I won’t attend a funeral with people I don’t like but he is not listening: he is now retorting to manipulate me (it would be so good, wouldn’t it be nice…?)

My father is not cognitively impaired. The easy way out would be to tell him ‘sure, I’ll come to your funeral with all those assholes you care so much about’ and after he dies, ignore it. I suspect my mother would agree, because she wasn’t born in GA and these aunts always felt superior to her, something my father always downplays because ‘we’re family’.

I like treating my father like an adult and want genuine conversations with him. To me, placating him on a thing like this means accepting my father has become a 5 year old who needs to be lied to so he doesn’t start feeling sad or feels I’m attacking him. It doesn’t feel right.

But it feels worse to pretend I respect those lying assholes or to listen to their boring life I don’t care about.

So what do I do?


Comments

Wewbull:

Yes. You’re being a dick.

Elephants aren’t religious (as far as I know) yet even they will gather to say goodbye to a family member. When the day comes, you’ll want to too.

RamRabbit:

You go to your father’s funeral to honor your father’s memory. He isn’t going to bar his sisters from attending his funeral, that would be wildly out of the norm. When your dad dies, go to his damn funeral. This beef you have with his sisters is immaterial.

placating him on a thing like this means accepting my father has become a 5 year old

Your father expecting you to attend his funeral is pretty fucking standard. It’s a colossally large dick move to not attend your own father’s funeral just because you have a grudge against his sisters. Be a fucking adult and bear the presence of a few people you don’t like for a few hours.

Ech:

Funerals aren’t for the dead, they’re for the living. People should feel free to commemorate or memorialize their loved ones how they see fit. Demanding they do it your way is shitty and self centered.


Update:

Same post, next day.

Thank you all for providing your opinion about this question. I’m contacting my mother and asking her about what she would want, I’ll follow her lead and support what she decides. As said I don’t believe she wants those toxic family members or her families around on a moment so special like saying your last goodbye to a husband. And neither do I.

I’d prefer a public funeral excluding them or conducting a small Christian ritual for family only where we can mourn him like we want but if she wants them around, so be it.

Funerals are for the living.

Thank you all.


Marking this ongoing since we don’t know what his mother has said. Lemmy doesn’t routinely get updates so, I have no idea if we will see an update.

Reminder, I am NOT OOP. Please do not harass the OOP per the rules of the community!

Am I being unreasonable holding my ground here? about a funeral


I am not the OOP. OOP is Vestmoria@Linux.Community do NOT reach out to them

Post was originally made to AskLemmy.

Tap for Mood Warning

Death, bad family dynamics


Original Post:

Aug 08, 2026

My Christian, old republican southerner father wants me to attend his Christian funeral with all of his surviving relatives present. I don’t believe in any god, he knows that. He needs a religion to give a meaning to his life? Knock yourself out.

Religion is not the main problem here. The main problem is how close minded and fake people are in a southern small town in GA and above all, relatives. 2 aunts love to pretend everything is fine, they excel doing that on funerals and weddings, then stab you in the back as soon as you’re not within ear distance, either need drama to feel important or have way too much free time.

I wouldn’t mind a small Christian ritual with my mother, my brother, a priest and nobody else, but these women and their husbands? They drag everyone down with their stupid grudges about yard sales and business deals made in the early 2020s and seem to be envious of those who left that place and found something better. Last time I saw them, 7 years ago, they complained I don’t call them. What for?

I’m better off without them and don’t have the bandwidth to deal with them.

Family seems to be an identity issue for my father, the idea that his whole family won’t bury him together scares him. I told them I will honor him my way, with luck on the hospital bed where he dies or at home, that mother and brother are welcome to honor him with me, that I won’t attend a funeral with people I don’t like but he is not listening: he is now retorting to manipulate me (it would be so good, wouldn’t it be nice…?)

My father is not cognitively impaired. The easy way out would be to tell him ‘sure, I’ll come to your funeral with all those assholes you care so much about’ and after he dies, ignore it. I suspect my mother would agree, because she wasn’t born in GA and these aunts always felt superior to her, something my father always downplays because ‘we’re family’.

I like treating my father like an adult and want genuine conversations with him. To me, placating him on a thing like this means accepting my father has become a 5 year old who needs to be lied to so he doesn’t start feeling sad or feels I’m attacking him. It doesn’t feel right.

But it feels worse to pretend I respect those lying assholes or to listen to their boring life I don’t care about.

So what do I do?


Comments

Wewbull:

Yes. You’re being a dick.

Elephants aren’t religious (as far as I know) yet even they will gather to say goodbye to a family member. When the day comes, you’ll want to too.

RamRabbit:

You go to your father’s funeral to honor your father’s memory. He isn’t going to bar his sisters from attending his funeral, that would be wildly out of the norm. When your dad dies, go to his damn funeral. This beef you have with his sisters is immaterial.

placating him on a thing like this means accepting my father has become a 5 year old

Your father expecting you to attend his funeral is pretty fucking standard. It’s a colossally large dick move to not attend your own father’s funeral just because you have a grudge against his sisters. Be a fucking adult and bear the presence of a few people you don’t like for a few hours.

Ech:

Funerals aren’t for the dead, they’re for the living. People should feel free to commemorate or memorialize their loved ones how they see fit. Demanding they do it your way is shitty and self centered.


Update:

Same post, next day.

Thank you all for providing your opinion about this question. I’m contacting my mother and asking her about what she would want, I’ll follow her lead and support what she decides. As said I don’t believe she wants those toxic family members or her families around on a moment so special like saying your last goodbye to a husband. And neither do I.

I’d prefer a public funeral excluding them or conducting a small Christian ritual for family only where we can mourn him like we want but if she wants them around, so be it.

Funerals are for the living.

Thank you all.


Marking this ongoing since we don’t know what his mother has said. Lemmy doesn’t routinely get updates so, I have no idea if we will see an update.

Reminder, I am NOT OOP. Please do not harass the OOP per the rules of the community!

0

[Ongoing] Dog acting weird about one breast. Am I crazy to be worried? [Reddit]

preview

Dog acting weird about one breast. Am I crazy to be worried?


I am not the OOP. The OOP is u/Mari-Loki posting in r/AskDocs, thank you reddit user u/SharkEva for compiling this post

Ongoing as per OOP

Tap for Trigger/Mood Warning

It’s exactly what you think, cancer. So far a happy ending as it was caught early but OOP is still waiting for a full treatment plan.


Original Post:

Jun 12, 2026

Female, 37, 5foot 1, 175lbs, non smoker, currently taking Mounjaro (for about a year)

I’m worried about my breast, not because I have any symptoms of an issue at all, but because my usually normal placid dog Winter has taken to sniffing, scratching, barking at and even nipping my right breast. In the 9 years I’ve had her she has never behaved this way. This started 3/4 weeks ago and has not let up.

It has gotten to the point where she can’t sit with me or lay on the bed with me because she can’t seem to keep herself from doing it. She’s behaving totally normally with everyone and everything else.

We took her to the vet who said she can’t find any issues with her but that her age may be contributing to a change in behaviour. The vet did not seem to think I should be worried about my health but it is worrying me that she won’t stop. I’ve also read about cancer detection dogs and can’t help my mind spiraling.

I have had no symptoms of an issue, no lumps or tenderness or anything at all in the breast.

My question is would a GP feel like I was wasting their time coming to them with this? I’m in the UK, doctors appointments are in high demand and I genuinely don’t want to take a spot from someone if I’m just being paranoid about this. I also don’t know if a doctor would even take me seriously.

At the same time I am concerned. Is this worth seeing someone about? Would I be laughed out of the room?

Thanks for reading!


Comments

questforstarfish

It’s definitely going to depend on the doctor…I would personally investigate that further, but I imagine some docs might shrug it off. If it’s something that’s worrying you, it can never hurt to go in to your GP and let them know you’re concerned! Maybe they can do a physical exam or do a test just to rule out anything abnormal. Anecdotally I have heard of cases of dogs detecting cancer or disease, but I don’t think we have any research on it.

OOP: Thank you for replying. My GP is new so I’m just concerned about making him think I’m a nut lol. I am quite stressed about it so maybe my GP would understand. I have to stop go ogling stories of dogs sniffing out cancer, it’s driving me more mad!

NCGranny

My German Shepherd started being obsessed with smelling my breath. I went in for routine bloodwork a few months later and my thyroid was all screwed up. Once it was straightened out, she no longer wanted to stick her snout down my throat.

marticcrn

Not a doctor (I am a nurse), I have breast cancer. Both my dog and my cat got very interested in my chest in the months before I found the lump myself. You’re 37, have some metabolic risk (Mounjaro), I’d think you could get a mammogram for whatever vague symptom, maybe including your pets indication?

livingonmain

My Australian Shepherd change in behavior around me caused me to make the doctor’s appointment that led to finding my lung cancer. He would sniff my breath then start licking my legs and feet. He had never exhibited the behavior before. Because the.tumor was so small, the chemo and radiation killed it. Six years and no reoccurrence! Sadly, though, no more foot baths from my Aussie.

I_Upvote_Goldens

I agree with everyone who is saying that this is actually worth investigating. Dogs are oddly sensitive to these things.

Anecdotally, when my daughter was the sickest she has ever been, our golden retriever slept in the hall outside of her bedroom for nearly a week. (The dog typically always slept in our room on her dog bed). It seemed like our daughter just had a minor virus, but it ended up blowing up into an ER visit. The dog knew something was up before we did. That was the only time the dog ever broke bedtime routine.

OOP: Yes I have read stories like that! That’s what had me worried. They’re even training dogs to detect colon cancer now. I’ve decided I’m going to skip the GP and pay out of pocket for an exam at a breast clinic. It isn’t as expensive as I had thought and it has to be worth it for peace of mind if nothing else!


Update 1:

Jun 20th 2026 - 8 days later

I just wanted to post an update for anyone who commented on my previous post and was curious to know what happened.

Long story short my dog was behaving very oddly towards my right breast, no actual symptoms of anything wrong. There’s more to it on my original post if you wanna see.

So I had my breast exam. I paid to have it done rather than wait as I was getting very anxious. It was an ultrasound rather than a mammogram, I’m not entirely sure why. A small solid mass was detected, right side of my right breast, sort of half way between my nipple and armpit. I am not able to feel the mass myself but the doctor could actually detect it when he physically checked my breasts.

I’m pretty shocked there is something there. Even though my dogs behaviour worried me I think I was pretty confident it was an issue with her age and not me. Doctor has said that there’s no need to panic, there’s a decent chance it is not something terrible but I’ll know more after the biopsy which is on Tuesday.

Thank you to everyone who commented and suggested I take this seriously. Hopefully it is nothing to worry about but I’ll update when I know more for anyone who wants to know.

Female, 37, 5ft, non smoker.


Comments

secret_tiger101

The dog is a hero

BicarbonateBufferBoy

The dogtor


Update:

Jul 15th, 2026 - 25 days later

Update - Cancer detection dog!

This is my second update, check my previous posts if you’re curious but the short version is:

My dog was acting weird about my breast, despite no symptoms I took it seriously. Ultrasound found a small lump, had needle biopsy.

So, my results came back and I was diagnosed with Invasive Ductal Carcinoma of the right breast. It is hormone receptor positive, and initially staged at 2A.

Ive just had a lumpectomy and they took some lymph node samples too. The oncology team are currently designing a treatment plan but it will likely involve some radiation and then HRT. They’ll know more once the mass and lymph node results are back. Apparently this can change the staging depending on what the results are.

Overall I’m feeling pretty positive, I’m confident I’ll get through this and I’m relived that I went to the GP rather than ignore it. I was in two minds about it, hence the initial post asking for advice, and I’m so grateful to everyone who advised me to go and get checked out.

I’m still in shock that my dog alerted me to this. You read about stuff like this, and I know dogs are incredible at all sorts, but it’s still so crazy to me that my sweet, daft, loving little bug has likely saved my life! She’s been so loving and attentive to me since I cane home. We’ve been treating her to a lot of her favourite foods, and we are taking her swimming this week which is her favourite. I’ve added a pic of her so everyone can see my little guardian angel ☺️ her name is Winter, she’s a 9yo Japanese Akita.

Anyway just wanted to update anyone who was curious. Moral of the story: listen to your dog, listen to your gut, and go get checked out if you’re worried!

Dog tax (Reddit link)


Comments

Medical_Madness

Good girl.

Silent_Medicine1798

She is a very good girl

ChaoticxSerenity

Perhaps even the best girl.

Different_Knee6201

I believe you mean goodest

SomethingComesHere

The goodest of all the best girls

alisgraveniI

I love this! Thank you for coming back to update us. Did you ever end up telling your doctor that you came in because of your dog’s change in behavior?

OOP: I did mention it to him yeah, but I also said I had some breast tenderness which wasn’t true 😐 but I was worried he wouldn’t take it seriously with no symptoms. He was dismissive about it but then found the lump so took it more seriously! My oncologist however is super interested about my dogs behaviour and has said she’s heard stories from colleagues about similar things happening.

RepulsiveOlive757

This is awesome! How did she alert on you or what did she do to make you notice?

OOP: She was really weird for about a month, kept nosing my breast very hard and eventually scratching at it and even nipping me once, which she has never done. I took her to the vet before I went to my GP, who said it might be her age but did suggest I follow up with GP. She’s stopped now I’ve had the lumpectomy which I’m taking as a good sign!

smooshybabyelephant

Fascinating! What I’m especially interested in knowing is WHY she was doing that. What was HER reason? Does cancer smell bad to dogs? How does she know it shouldn’t be there? Or is it more that a foreign smell appeared, like an intruder, and she was trying to investigate?

I would look into seeing if she can be trained to do this for other people! Maybe she can screen your friends and family.

OOP: Yeah I’m wondering the same thing. She’s such a sweetheart, never been even the slightest bit off with anyone or anything, but she did not like the scent of my breast! You could tell it was frustrating her, and she couldn’t settle. So I’m guessing whatever the scent it, it’s bad. From reading up on it, it looks like we still don’t really fully understand a dogs sense of smell and how it is as good, if not better, than medical tests. A recent study apparently showed that dogs can detect bowel cancer weeks before the best medical tests. There must be some evolutionary benefit to sniffing out malignancy?

cantxtouchxthis

Did you go private for the exam and then report the findings to your doctor? How did you get them to move so quickly?

OOP: I did end up paying for it, which has been pretty pricey, but my radiation etc will be on the NHS. I could have gone through NHS for the lumpectomy but it wouldnt have been as quick, GP said two weeks, and I was so anxious I didn’t think I could wait without going out of my mind! My aftercare and testing is all covered from the lumpectomy but everything after that I’ll be with the NHS hospital. I just have to wait for the results of the lumpectomy and then they will be sent to the NHS multidisciplinary team. The private oncologist is writing up a proposed treatment but ultimately it’ll be down to the MDT what happens next.


I am not the OOP. This is a repost community. Please do not message the OOP.

Dog acting weird about one breast. Am I crazy to be worried?


I am not the OOP. The OOP is u/Mari-Loki posting in r/AskDocs, thank you reddit user u/SharkEva for compiling this post

Ongoing as per OOP

Tap for Trigger/Mood Warning

It’s exactly what you think, cancer. So far a happy ending as it was caught early but OOP is still waiting for a full treatment plan.


Original Post:

Jun 12, 2026

Female, 37, 5foot 1, 175lbs, non smoker, currently taking Mounjaro (for about a year)

I’m worried about my breast, not because I have any symptoms of an issue at all, but because my usually normal placid dog Winter has taken to sniffing, scratching, barking at and even nipping my right breast. In the 9 years I’ve had her she has never behaved this way. This started 3/4 weeks ago and has not let up.

It has gotten to the point where she can’t sit with me or lay on the bed with me because she can’t seem to keep herself from doing it. She’s behaving totally normally with everyone and everything else.

We took her to the vet who said she can’t find any issues with her but that her age may be contributing to a change in behaviour. The vet did not seem to think I should be worried about my health but it is worrying me that she won’t stop. I’ve also read about cancer detection dogs and can’t help my mind spiraling.

I have had no symptoms of an issue, no lumps or tenderness or anything at all in the breast.

My question is would a GP feel like I was wasting their time coming to them with this? I’m in the UK, doctors appointments are in high demand and I genuinely don’t want to take a spot from someone if I’m just being paranoid about this. I also don’t know if a doctor would even take me seriously.

At the same time I am concerned. Is this worth seeing someone about? Would I be laughed out of the room?

Thanks for reading!


Comments

questforstarfish

It’s definitely going to depend on the doctor…I would personally investigate that further, but I imagine some docs might shrug it off. If it’s something that’s worrying you, it can never hurt to go in to your GP and let them know you’re concerned! Maybe they can do a physical exam or do a test just to rule out anything abnormal. Anecdotally I have heard of cases of dogs detecting cancer or disease, but I don’t think we have any research on it.

OOP: Thank you for replying. My GP is new so I’m just concerned about making him think I’m a nut lol. I am quite stressed about it so maybe my GP would understand. I have to stop go ogling stories of dogs sniffing out cancer, it’s driving me more mad!

NCGranny

My German Shepherd started being obsessed with smelling my breath. I went in for routine bloodwork a few months later and my thyroid was all screwed up. Once it was straightened out, she no longer wanted to stick her snout down my throat.

marticcrn

Not a doctor (I am a nurse), I have breast cancer. Both my dog and my cat got very interested in my chest in the months before I found the lump myself. You’re 37, have some metabolic risk (Mounjaro), I’d think you could get a mammogram for whatever vague symptom, maybe including your pets indication?

livingonmain

My Australian Shepherd change in behavior around me caused me to make the doctor’s appointment that led to finding my lung cancer. He would sniff my breath then start licking my legs and feet. He had never exhibited the behavior before. Because the.tumor was so small, the chemo and radiation killed it. Six years and no reoccurrence! Sadly, though, no more foot baths from my Aussie.

I_Upvote_Goldens

I agree with everyone who is saying that this is actually worth investigating. Dogs are oddly sensitive to these things.

Anecdotally, when my daughter was the sickest she has ever been, our golden retriever slept in the hall outside of her bedroom for nearly a week. (The dog typically always slept in our room on her dog bed). It seemed like our daughter just had a minor virus, but it ended up blowing up into an ER visit. The dog knew something was up before we did. That was the only time the dog ever broke bedtime routine.

OOP: Yes I have read stories like that! That’s what had me worried. They’re even training dogs to detect colon cancer now. I’ve decided I’m going to skip the GP and pay out of pocket for an exam at a breast clinic. It isn’t as expensive as I had thought and it has to be worth it for peace of mind if nothing else!


Update 1:

Jun 20th 2026 - 8 days later

I just wanted to post an update for anyone who commented on my previous post and was curious to know what happened.

Long story short my dog was behaving very oddly towards my right breast, no actual symptoms of anything wrong. There’s more to it on my original post if you wanna see.

So I had my breast exam. I paid to have it done rather than wait as I was getting very anxious. It was an ultrasound rather than a mammogram, I’m not entirely sure why. A small solid mass was detected, right side of my right breast, sort of half way between my nipple and armpit. I am not able to feel the mass myself but the doctor could actually detect it when he physically checked my breasts.

I’m pretty shocked there is something there. Even though my dogs behaviour worried me I think I was pretty confident it was an issue with her age and not me. Doctor has said that there’s no need to panic, there’s a decent chance it is not something terrible but I’ll know more after the biopsy which is on Tuesday.

Thank you to everyone who commented and suggested I take this seriously. Hopefully it is nothing to worry about but I’ll update when I know more for anyone who wants to know.

Female, 37, 5ft, non smoker.


Comments

secret_tiger101

The dog is a hero

BicarbonateBufferBoy

The dogtor


Update:

Jul 15th, 2026 - 25 days later

Update - Cancer detection dog!

This is my second update, check my previous posts if you’re curious but the short version is:

My dog was acting weird about my breast, despite no symptoms I took it seriously. Ultrasound found a small lump, had needle biopsy.

So, my results came back and I was diagnosed with Invasive Ductal Carcinoma of the right breast. It is hormone receptor positive, and initially staged at 2A.

Ive just had a lumpectomy and they took some lymph node samples too. The oncology team are currently designing a treatment plan but it will likely involve some radiation and then HRT. They’ll know more once the mass and lymph node results are back. Apparently this can change the staging depending on what the results are.

Overall I’m feeling pretty positive, I’m confident I’ll get through this and I’m relived that I went to the GP rather than ignore it. I was in two minds about it, hence the initial post asking for advice, and I’m so grateful to everyone who advised me to go and get checked out.

I’m still in shock that my dog alerted me to this. You read about stuff like this, and I know dogs are incredible at all sorts, but it’s still so crazy to me that my sweet, daft, loving little bug has likely saved my life! She’s been so loving and attentive to me since I cane home. We’ve been treating her to a lot of her favourite foods, and we are taking her swimming this week which is her favourite. I’ve added a pic of her so everyone can see my little guardian angel ☺️ her name is Winter, she’s a 9yo Japanese Akita.

Anyway just wanted to update anyone who was curious. Moral of the story: listen to your dog, listen to your gut, and go get checked out if you’re worried!

Dog tax (Reddit link)


Comments

Medical_Madness

Good girl.

Silent_Medicine1798

She is a very good girl

ChaoticxSerenity

Perhaps even the best girl.

Different_Knee6201

I believe you mean goodest

SomethingComesHere

The goodest of all the best girls

alisgraveniI

I love this! Thank you for coming back to update us. Did you ever end up telling your doctor that you came in because of your dog’s change in behavior?

OOP: I did mention it to him yeah, but I also said I had some breast tenderness which wasn’t true 😐 but I was worried he wouldn’t take it seriously with no symptoms. He was dismissive about it but then found the lump so took it more seriously! My oncologist however is super interested about my dogs behaviour and has said she’s heard stories from colleagues about similar things happening.

RepulsiveOlive757

This is awesome! How did she alert on you or what did she do to make you notice?

OOP: She was really weird for about a month, kept nosing my breast very hard and eventually scratching at it and even nipping me once, which she has never done. I took her to the vet before I went to my GP, who said it might be her age but did suggest I follow up with GP. She’s stopped now I’ve had the lumpectomy which I’m taking as a good sign!

smooshybabyelephant

Fascinating! What I’m especially interested in knowing is WHY she was doing that. What was HER reason? Does cancer smell bad to dogs? How does she know it shouldn’t be there? Or is it more that a foreign smell appeared, like an intruder, and she was trying to investigate?

I would look into seeing if she can be trained to do this for other people! Maybe she can screen your friends and family.

OOP: Yeah I’m wondering the same thing. She’s such a sweetheart, never been even the slightest bit off with anyone or anything, but she did not like the scent of my breast! You could tell it was frustrating her, and she couldn’t settle. So I’m guessing whatever the scent it, it’s bad. From reading up on it, it looks like we still don’t really fully understand a dogs sense of smell and how it is as good, if not better, than medical tests. A recent study apparently showed that dogs can detect bowel cancer weeks before the best medical tests. There must be some evolutionary benefit to sniffing out malignancy?

cantxtouchxthis

Did you go private for the exam and then report the findings to your doctor? How did you get them to move so quickly?

OOP: I did end up paying for it, which has been pretty pricey, but my radiation etc will be on the NHS. I could have gone through NHS for the lumpectomy but it wouldnt have been as quick, GP said two weeks, and I was so anxious I didn’t think I could wait without going out of my mind! My aftercare and testing is all covered from the lumpectomy but everything after that I’ll be with the NHS hospital. I just have to wait for the results of the lumpectomy and then they will be sent to the NHS multidisciplinary team. The private oncologist is writing up a proposed treatment but ultimately it’ll be down to the MDT what happens next.


I am not the OOP. This is a repost community. Please do not message the OOP.

0

[Ongoing] AITAH for inviting my neighbour's husband over for coffee and a playdate? [Reddit]

preview

AITAH for inviting my neighbour’s husband over for coffee and a playdate? His wife accused me of pursuing him, and my husband thinks she was right to confront me

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/Independent-State802

AITAH for inviting my neighbour’s husband over for coffee and a playdate? His wife accused me of pursuing him, and my husband thinks she was right to confront me.

Originally posted to r/AITAH & r/Redditor_Updates Thank you Reddit user u/Direct-Caterpillar77 for compiling this story.

Tap for trigger warning

Domestic Violence, galsighting, infidelity

Tap for mood spoiler

Looking positive for now

Original Post  June 4, 2026

About a year ago, a couple (Emily (F30s) and Jake (M 30s)) moved into the house next to ours (30s). Emily and I were both pregnant at the time, with due dates a few weeks apart. We would run into each other in the neighborhood or out on the street and eventually became friendly. We texted occasionally to check in on each other during our pregnancies, and our husbands became friends as well.

For some context, Emily had a very difficult pregnancy and was on bed rest for the last month of her pregnancy before she gave birth. They moved away from their support system for Jake’s job and didn’t have family nearby, so I would sometimes drop off meals when I was cooking for my own family. Emily had her baby about a month before I had mine. After the babies were born, we didn’t see much of each other. I invited her a few times to go for walks with the babies, but she always declined, saying the baby was fussy or napping. I figured she was just overwhelmed as a first time mom. Our husbands continued to see each other occasionally during this time.

Last week, I was out walking my baby when I ran into Jake, who was also out walking his baby. We ended up walking together and chatting for about 30 minutes. Our chat did not include anything personal; we talked about the babies, our jobs, our summer plans. When we got back to our street, the babies had woken up, so as we passed my house I asked if he wanted to come in for a coffee and let the babies play together. He thanked me for the invite and declined, saying he needed to get home because he had errands to run.

A few days later, Emily invited me over for a playdate. I accepted and even offered to bring some food for the babies because she had mentioned being nervous about introducing non-puréed foods. While the babies were playing, she suddenly said, “Jake told me you went for a walk together last week.” I said yes, we ran into each other while out with the babies. She then asked, “Why did you invite him back to your house?”

I was caught off guard and tried to explain that the babies had woken up and I had meant it as a playdate. She responded that she didn’t know what I was playing at, but her husband was off-limits and uninterested in case I had any ideas.

I  was in shock, so I froze up for a couple minutes. When I was able to respond, I told her it was bizarre that she would interpret a walk with her husband and an invitation for coffee and a baby playdate as anything other than innocent. I also told her that my husband was working from home that day and was in the house. I also said that I hope she heals from whatever happened in her life that made her view something so innocent as a threat. She laughed in my face and said rich coming from you, just because your husband treats you like dirt doesn’t make it okay for you to go after my husband. My jaw dropped and I just picked up my baby and left. I fucking hate myself for not giving her a piece of my mind and leaving without saying anything. But I felt like I had just been slapped. 

My husband and I have been having some serious issues. When I got home, I told him what happened and asked if he has said anything about our problems to Jake. He swore that he hasn’t but I am not sure I believe him because how else would Emily know anything? My husband then said Emily was right, that it was inappropriate to invite Jake in and my husband is now mad at ME over the whole thing. 

AITAH?

ETA: I discovered my husband was cheating on me 2 months ago.

ETA 2: I am going through some of the comments and I think I may have not explained this part well. emily didn’t avoid hanging out with me or “us”. The four of us with our kids and their baby have spent time together on multiple occasions, going to the park, we have had them over, they have had us over. But always the four of us and the kids. My older child really likes Emily and Jake, they have always been nice to us. Jake and my husband hang out together alone sometimes, but Emily has always had a reason not to hang out alone with me. The other day when she invited me over was the first time we‘d had a solo playdate for the babies.

Update  June 28, 2026

I am posting this here because I posted it incorrectly on the AITA sub and I am not allowed to repost it anymore.

TW: Domestic Violence

2 months ago, I made another post on a different sub, once again seeking outside perspective about a very awkward situation that took place. You can find that post here: AITAH for inviting my neighbour’s husband over for coffee and a playdate? His wife accused me of pursuing him, and my husband thinks she was right to confront me.

I came back to post an update. I think it’s a way for me to process what has happened since.

Shortly after my last post, my husband admitted that he had confided in Jake about his infidelity. He said he felt guilty and remorseful and wanted to talk it out with a friend. He claimed he didn’t realize Jake would tell Emily and that she would throw our marriage struggles in my face the way she did. He apologized for discussing our issues without my consent and promised to distance himself from them.

He also apologized again for the affair, which he swore was over. He told me the affair partner was a coworker who had since left the company. He promised he wanted to change and rebuild our relationship, so I forgave him and gave him another chance… again.

Things had been going well. My husband was attentive and loving. He was helping more at home, spending more time with the kids, and showing me affection. For a moment, it really felt like my husband had returned to me. In hindsight, though, I think it was love bombing.

Last week, I had a medical appointment that I needed to attend alone, so my husband stayed home with our baby. I was anxious because he had never been alone with the baby for that long and I wasn’t sure he would be able to put him down for his nap.

While I was sitting in the waiting room, I logged into our baby camera just to check that the baby had gone down okay.

That’s when everything began to unravel.

The baby was asleep in his crib and my husband was walking out of the room. Then I heard a woman’s voice asking if the baby was finally asleep. My husband replied confirming that he was. I couldn’t see the woman because she was outside the camera’s view, but her voice was familiar. I thought it sounded like Emily.

After my appointment, I checked our Ring doorbell recordings from that day. There she was. Emily had knocked on our door and my husband let her in minutes after I left for my appointment. She left an hour and a half later.

I was in complete shock.

When I got home, I didn’t confront my husband. I was tired of his lies and wanted the truth before saying anything. I went through our doorbell camera history and found many more instances of Emily coming over while I was gone. In one video, I saw them kissing on our front porch! I saved everything.

The next day, I messaged Jake and told him I needed to speak with him because I had bad news about my husband and his wife that I believed he deserved to know. He didn’t reply Shortly afterward, my husband called me, furious. Jake had forwarded my messages to him and warned him that I was trying to frame him and Emily. He went quiet and then ended up the call.

Later that evening, he came home late and intoxicated. He was angry and blamed me for “destroying our lives” and for trying to expose the affair. I yelled at him and then said I wanted a divorce.

He lost it. He hit me, kicked me, punched me, and he even tried to choke me. Somehow, I managed to get away from him. My 4-year-old woke up because of the screaming and commotion, so I grabbed her and ran into the bedroom and locked the door. My daughter was terrified and clinging to me while my husband banged and kicked the door, threatening to break it down. Luckily, I had my phone with me and I called 911.

The rest of the night was a blur. My husband was arrested close to midnight on a Tuesday. The entire street woke up to the sirens and confrontation with the police. I was taken to the hospital afterward because I was bleeding and covered in bruises. Our neighbourhood was shocked. We had always been the friendly, polite neighbours, and no one expected this could happen behind closed doors. I was done protecting my husband’s image. He destroyed our life, not me. When neighbours asked what happened, I told them the truth: he hurt me after I discovered he was cheating on me with Emily.

A few days later, Jake reached out to me. He was apologetic and felt responsible for not believing me when I tried to warn him. Jake told me my husband had been confiding in him about our marriage problems. According to Jake, my husband had told him that I was the one who cheated in the past, that I was unstable because of my PPD/PPA, and that I had been hurting our children. None of that is true. Jake also told me he had confided in my husband about problems in his own marriage. Looking back, it seems my husband used those vulnerabilities and the information Jake shared with him to get closer to Emily.

After everything happened, I finally called my family and told them the truth. They knew I had been struggling and distant, but they thought it was because of the PPD. They had no idea how much I had actually been carrying alone. I told them about the affair, the threats, the manipulation, and how scared and exhausted I had become. They are in my corner and they are trying to help me figure out my next steps. I feel like a weight has been lifted off me and for the first time in a long time, I don’t feel alone. 

RELEVANT COMMENTS

LanceWayne2024

I hope Emily loses her marriage

OOP

I don’t know what Jake’s plans are, but after he sent me that text, I sent him the images I had saved of Emily coming to my house at odd times and the video of them kissing. He has all the information now to make an informed decision.

At the very least, I am sure Emily is having a really hard time because she hasn’t shown her face around the neighbourhood since last Wednesday.

Master_McKnowledge

Whatever. Emily can go to hell and so can Jake. The sheer audacity of the guy to reach out to you in any other way than on his knees in shame.

OOP

My husband successfully manipulated both me and Jake, maybe even Emily… who knows? Jake seemed very remorseful and apologetic in the text, he blamed himself for my what happened. And yeah, if he hadn’t forwarded my message, this may not have happened. But like I told Jake, my husband made the choice to physically assault me and no one is to blame for that but my husband.

~

MeadowMuffinFarms

I’m so glad you are safe. Do you have a restraining order against him? At best I think he would get supervised visits.

OOP

I do, especially because he is out on bail.

MoonButterfly1111

I never understand why people would bail out people like him.

OOP

His very wealthy parents bailed him out because he is their golden boy who can do no wrong.

THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS

AITAH for inviting my neighbour’s husband over for coffee and a playdate? His wife accused me of pursuing him, and my husband thinks she was right to confront me

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/Independent-State802

AITAH for inviting my neighbour’s husband over for coffee and a playdate? His wife accused me of pursuing him, and my husband thinks she was right to confront me.

Originally posted to r/AITAH & r/Redditor_Updates Thank you Reddit user u/Direct-Caterpillar77 for compiling this story.

Tap for trigger warning

Domestic Violence, galsighting, infidelity

Tap for mood spoiler

Looking positive for now

Original Post  June 4, 2026

About a year ago, a couple (Emily (F30s) and Jake (M 30s)) moved into the house next to ours (30s). Emily and I were both pregnant at the time, with due dates a few weeks apart. We would run into each other in the neighborhood or out on the street and eventually became friendly. We texted occasionally to check in on each other during our pregnancies, and our husbands became friends as well.

For some context, Emily had a very difficult pregnancy and was on bed rest for the last month of her pregnancy before she gave birth. They moved away from their support system for Jake’s job and didn’t have family nearby, so I would sometimes drop off meals when I was cooking for my own family. Emily had her baby about a month before I had mine. After the babies were born, we didn’t see much of each other. I invited her a few times to go for walks with the babies, but she always declined, saying the baby was fussy or napping. I figured she was just overwhelmed as a first time mom. Our husbands continued to see each other occasionally during this time.

Last week, I was out walking my baby when I ran into Jake, who was also out walking his baby. We ended up walking together and chatting for about 30 minutes. Our chat did not include anything personal; we talked about the babies, our jobs, our summer plans. When we got back to our street, the babies had woken up, so as we passed my house I asked if he wanted to come in for a coffee and let the babies play together. He thanked me for the invite and declined, saying he needed to get home because he had errands to run.

A few days later, Emily invited me over for a playdate. I accepted and even offered to bring some food for the babies because she had mentioned being nervous about introducing non-puréed foods. While the babies were playing, she suddenly said, “Jake told me you went for a walk together last week.” I said yes, we ran into each other while out with the babies. She then asked, “Why did you invite him back to your house?”

I was caught off guard and tried to explain that the babies had woken up and I had meant it as a playdate. She responded that she didn’t know what I was playing at, but her husband was off-limits and uninterested in case I had any ideas.

I  was in shock, so I froze up for a couple minutes. When I was able to respond, I told her it was bizarre that she would interpret a walk with her husband and an invitation for coffee and a baby playdate as anything other than innocent. I also told her that my husband was working from home that day and was in the house. I also said that I hope she heals from whatever happened in her life that made her view something so innocent as a threat. She laughed in my face and said rich coming from you, just because your husband treats you like dirt doesn’t make it okay for you to go after my husband. My jaw dropped and I just picked up my baby and left. I fucking hate myself for not giving her a piece of my mind and leaving without saying anything. But I felt like I had just been slapped. 

My husband and I have been having some serious issues. When I got home, I told him what happened and asked if he has said anything about our problems to Jake. He swore that he hasn’t but I am not sure I believe him because how else would Emily know anything? My husband then said Emily was right, that it was inappropriate to invite Jake in and my husband is now mad at ME over the whole thing. 

AITAH?

ETA: I discovered my husband was cheating on me 2 months ago.

ETA 2: I am going through some of the comments and I think I may have not explained this part well. emily didn’t avoid hanging out with me or “us”. The four of us with our kids and their baby have spent time together on multiple occasions, going to the park, we have had them over, they have had us over. But always the four of us and the kids. My older child really likes Emily and Jake, they have always been nice to us. Jake and my husband hang out together alone sometimes, but Emily has always had a reason not to hang out alone with me. The other day when she invited me over was the first time we‘d had a solo playdate for the babies.

Update  June 28, 2026

I am posting this here because I posted it incorrectly on the AITA sub and I am not allowed to repost it anymore.

TW: Domestic Violence

2 months ago, I made another post on a different sub, once again seeking outside perspective about a very awkward situation that took place. You can find that post here: AITAH for inviting my neighbour’s husband over for coffee and a playdate? His wife accused me of pursuing him, and my husband thinks she was right to confront me.

I came back to post an update. I think it’s a way for me to process what has happened since.

Shortly after my last post, my husband admitted that he had confided in Jake about his infidelity. He said he felt guilty and remorseful and wanted to talk it out with a friend. He claimed he didn’t realize Jake would tell Emily and that she would throw our marriage struggles in my face the way she did. He apologized for discussing our issues without my consent and promised to distance himself from them.

He also apologized again for the affair, which he swore was over. He told me the affair partner was a coworker who had since left the company. He promised he wanted to change and rebuild our relationship, so I forgave him and gave him another chance… again.

Things had been going well. My husband was attentive and loving. He was helping more at home, spending more time with the kids, and showing me affection. For a moment, it really felt like my husband had returned to me. In hindsight, though, I think it was love bombing.

Last week, I had a medical appointment that I needed to attend alone, so my husband stayed home with our baby. I was anxious because he had never been alone with the baby for that long and I wasn’t sure he would be able to put him down for his nap.

While I was sitting in the waiting room, I logged into our baby camera just to check that the baby had gone down okay.

That’s when everything began to unravel.

The baby was asleep in his crib and my husband was walking out of the room. Then I heard a woman’s voice asking if the baby was finally asleep. My husband replied confirming that he was. I couldn’t see the woman because she was outside the camera’s view, but her voice was familiar. I thought it sounded like Emily.

After my appointment, I checked our Ring doorbell recordings from that day. There she was. Emily had knocked on our door and my husband let her in minutes after I left for my appointment. She left an hour and a half later.

I was in complete shock.

When I got home, I didn’t confront my husband. I was tired of his lies and wanted the truth before saying anything. I went through our doorbell camera history and found many more instances of Emily coming over while I was gone. In one video, I saw them kissing on our front porch! I saved everything.

The next day, I messaged Jake and told him I needed to speak with him because I had bad news about my husband and his wife that I believed he deserved to know. He didn’t reply Shortly afterward, my husband called me, furious. Jake had forwarded my messages to him and warned him that I was trying to frame him and Emily. He went quiet and then ended up the call.

Later that evening, he came home late and intoxicated. He was angry and blamed me for “destroying our lives” and for trying to expose the affair. I yelled at him and then said I wanted a divorce.

He lost it. He hit me, kicked me, punched me, and he even tried to choke me. Somehow, I managed to get away from him. My 4-year-old woke up because of the screaming and commotion, so I grabbed her and ran into the bedroom and locked the door. My daughter was terrified and clinging to me while my husband banged and kicked the door, threatening to break it down. Luckily, I had my phone with me and I called 911.

The rest of the night was a blur. My husband was arrested close to midnight on a Tuesday. The entire street woke up to the sirens and confrontation with the police. I was taken to the hospital afterward because I was bleeding and covered in bruises. Our neighbourhood was shocked. We had always been the friendly, polite neighbours, and no one expected this could happen behind closed doors. I was done protecting my husband’s image. He destroyed our life, not me. When neighbours asked what happened, I told them the truth: he hurt me after I discovered he was cheating on me with Emily.

A few days later, Jake reached out to me. He was apologetic and felt responsible for not believing me when I tried to warn him. Jake told me my husband had been confiding in him about our marriage problems. According to Jake, my husband had told him that I was the one who cheated in the past, that I was unstable because of my PPD/PPA, and that I had been hurting our children. None of that is true. Jake also told me he had confided in my husband about problems in his own marriage. Looking back, it seems my husband used those vulnerabilities and the information Jake shared with him to get closer to Emily.

After everything happened, I finally called my family and told them the truth. They knew I had been struggling and distant, but they thought it was because of the PPD. They had no idea how much I had actually been carrying alone. I told them about the affair, the threats, the manipulation, and how scared and exhausted I had become. They are in my corner and they are trying to help me figure out my next steps. I feel like a weight has been lifted off me and for the first time in a long time, I don’t feel alone. 

RELEVANT COMMENTS

LanceWayne2024

I hope Emily loses her marriage

OOP

I don’t know what Jake’s plans are, but after he sent me that text, I sent him the images I had saved of Emily coming to my house at odd times and the video of them kissing. He has all the information now to make an informed decision.

At the very least, I am sure Emily is having a really hard time because she hasn’t shown her face around the neighbourhood since last Wednesday.

Master_McKnowledge

Whatever. Emily can go to hell and so can Jake. The sheer audacity of the guy to reach out to you in any other way than on his knees in shame.

OOP

My husband successfully manipulated both me and Jake, maybe even Emily… who knows? Jake seemed very remorseful and apologetic in the text, he blamed himself for my what happened. And yeah, if he hadn’t forwarded my message, this may not have happened. But like I told Jake, my husband made the choice to physically assault me and no one is to blame for that but my husband.

~

MeadowMuffinFarms

I’m so glad you are safe. Do you have a restraining order against him? At best I think he would get supervised visits.

OOP

I do, especially because he is out on bail.

MoonButterfly1111

I never understand why people would bail out people like him.

OOP

His very wealthy parents bailed him out because he is their golden boy who can do no wrong.

THIS IS A REPOST COMMUNITY - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS

0

[Ongoing] AIO, My wife believes in strict gender? [Reddit]

preview

AIO, my wife believes in strict gender roles?

This is a repost community. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

OOP: u/john_7292. Than you Reddit user u/BigONerd for compiling this.

Published on: r/AmIOverreacting

Story is: ONGOING

Story timeline


Main Post

^(July 03, 2026)


AIO, my wife believes in strict gender roles?

So for some context my wife and i (both 29 yrs old) are both fairly religious Christians but she and her family take it more seriously than I do. Before we married we discussed that she wants a traditional marriage where she is SAHM. I would be fine with her working but I do believe a man should be a provider so this is fine with me too and that’s what we’ve done. She said she didn’t like modern men who do things like wear a baby sling or push a stroller and I was fine with that.

Our first child was born a bit over 4 yrs ago and then our second a little under 2 years later. When our kids were young I admittedly did not help with them very much. She had a lot of help from both her mom and mine, and I also was working long hours in these days. So I never changed a diaper, maybe fed them a couple of times. If I tried to step in she would generally wave me off and say I shouldn’t worry about it so I didn’t. Her mom actually lived with us until my youngest was about 6 months old and still visits fairly often. Her sister sometimes comes over to help too. So she definitely has her “village” so to say.

But now that the kidss are getting older and I’m working less, making more money, I honestly want to be involved more. But it’s like she doesn’t want me to do anything for them ever. She always brushes me off and says that’s a woman’s job, I shouldn’t be doing that, and even that our kids shouldn’t see a man picking up dirty laundry or making them snacks. I think that’s weird, my parents have a traditional marriage but my dad still did stuff like that from time to time and I turned out fine. If she sees me playing with them she usually doesn’t look happy and tries to distract them from it after a little while. This is getting really bothersome because those are my kids too. I would think most women would be happy their husband wants to do stuff like that.

It all kind of finally came to a final straw the other day when i had a day off work. I secretly turned off her alarm in the night so she could sleep in that morning. I woke up early, bought her some flowers and made the kids breakfast (there was some for her too when she woke up). I’m not gonna lie, we haven’t had sex in awhile either and that was part of my thinking here. But I thought it would be a nice thing to do for her and a nice morning to spend with the kids and it was. I thought maybe we could all go to the park later since it was a nice day.

My wife ended up waking up around 7 AM (normally 5:30 or 6 for her) and came down to see what was going on. I could see that she was hiding her anger for the kids. She smiled and said isn’t that a nice thing daddy did but the look she gave me was glaring. Then she said to my 4 year old son why don’t you take your sister to watch tv. When they went to the next room she started whispering quietly at me like, what the hell were you thinking, why would you do something like that, why would you let me sleep in, do you think I’m a bad mother?

Honestly this kinda got my hackles up because I did nothing wrong here and I retorted, do you think I’m a bad father? Why do you never want me to do anything with the kids? She flat out denied it and said that is not true, she just doesn’t want me overstepping in to take on women’s work. It’s setting a bad example and I’m acting woke (and all these other things). So I asked her what she DOES think it’s okay for me to do for/with the kids and she kinda stopped for a second like she didn’t really have an answer. Then she said it’s a father’s job to be a provider and disciplinarian.

I was like, that’s it? You think I’m here to make a paycheck and yell at them if they do something bad? And she got upset and said NO it’s just not my job to take over mother’s roles and it makes me less of a man and her less of a woman.

At this point we were both starting to raise our voices and I looked into the next room and I was like can we please try to calm down, we don’t need to scare the kids. Can you honestly explain to me why it’s a problem for a father to make his kids breakfast and buy his wife flowers? But she just got more upset and said if I didn’t understand then I’m not the man she married and I’m not godly.

Honestly I just gave up and went out and spent the rest of the day walking around the mall and doing some errands. I came home and the kids were in bed and she didn’t speak to me and I slept in the guest bedroom. It’s been a couple days now and we still haven’t talked and frankly I don’t even know what to say to here. The more I think about it the more upset I get. I keep trying to see it from her perspective and all I can think is maybe it wasn’t right for me to change her alarm because she might have had things she wanted to do that morning but this is obviously much bigger than that.

AIO to this? Should I try to find some compromise with her or what?

 

COMMENTS

Cheap-Ad-2175

Go to marriage counseling with a counselor or y’all’s preacher. Taking care of your children is BOTH parents jobs??? Providing isn’t just shelter and food. It’s providing love, care, and support to them as well.

OOP

This is actually a great idea and I do not think our pastor will agree with her at all. So I will be interested to see how she reacts to that. I will talk to her about it thank you.


bothfeetofftheground

This is the strangest thing I’ve ever heard. You sound like a dream husband. I wish I could have a day to sleep in. Moms are humans and deserve time off and personal time. And kids need to see men doing chores.

OOP

I hope I didn’t make myself come off as a saint because I’m definitely not but I wanted to do something nice for my wife and kids which I rarely have had time to - and to be cut back like this over it was very hurtful.


JuliaX1984

Just tell her that trying to tell her husband what to do isn’t godly. Quote Paul’s verses about how women should be quiet and never talk back to men. If she objects, she’s not godly.

OOP

To be exact those verses say a woman shouldn’t preach in church. She seems to think the woman is the “queen of the house.” My words not hers.


crackpotpourri

Y’all need couples therapy at a minimum. But I’m guessing she won’t think that’s very “godly.”

OOP

I am definitely going to try to get her to see our pastor for counseling. I don’t think there’s anyway she can disagree to that and claim not to be a hypocrite.

I would never tell my wife to shut her hole and do as I say, I am the leader of the house, that does not make her my slave.


facinationstreet

What exactly do you think we can tell you? You married this. You agreed to this idiocy. You had kids with this. Wait until you get divorced. Shit will hit the fan. Homeschooling (handicapping) your kids, no outside people, etc. Ya’ll just baffle me.

NOR but get your life together for your kids if for no one else.

OOP

I agreed to a traditional marriage with the one my parents had in mind, where my dad was a good dad and played with us, chatted with us, took us to soccer practice and fun things like fairs, taught us things, showed good values, cleaned up after himself, even made dinner sometimes, and my mom was a SAHM. I did not agree to this. We also are not homeschooling.


ConsciousNectarine9

NOR

I think she has gone waaaaayyy past the old ‘traditions’. She is pushing you out of your childrens lives on the excuse of ‘it’s not manly’. Well I am sorry but even back in the day a lot of dad’s would do things with their children and those who didn’t… their kids 9 times out of 10 would have grown up resenting them.

You need to have a long, hard think about what you want your role to be with your children. If you want to be able to actually care for them, bond with them and for them to actually have you as part of their everyday lives instead of just being the ‘bad’ parent/paycheck you will have to leave this marriage. You will never be given that place in your childrens lives as long as you are together with your wife.

OOP

I agree, it’s like she wants me to be the stereotypical absent father who never sees their kids. I didn’t think anyone ever thought that was alright even back in the day.


camioblu

Make an appointment with your pastor and see what the religion you follow says about all of this nonsense. She’s got some control and trust issues for sure. Was she ever abused by a man?

OOP

I think her father was abit of an asshole but he died 15 or so years ago so I don’t know firsthand. I will definitely be making a counseling appointment with our pastor thank you.


Alert-Beautiful9003

Wut? You were a lazy dad/husband and she thinks she can control her feels by micromanage ans controlling everything. Both of you need to get some help for yourselves and especially for the kids.

OOP (downvoted)

Please understand that back when our kids were babies I was working anywhere from 70-80 hours a week to keep our family a float and out of debt. I am trying not to get defensive in this thread but I do not like being called lazy, we were both working hard, and she had help at home in her mom, my mom and her sister.


bmyst70 (downvoted)

YOR

Yes, your wife is very extreme and rigid in her beliefs. Agreed 100%. But you knew this before you married her. Therefore, you are firmly over-reacting. She made very clear SHE was the only one to ever be involved with the kids.

If she suddenly showed you this side abruptly I would agree with you 100%. However, this is very clearly her hill to die on and she will not compromise with you on this. If you try interacting with the kids in any way, it will get worse.

Bluntly put if you truly want more interaction with the kids, you have to divorce her and push very hard for split custody. That will of course put more responsibility on you, and yes it is indeed the nuclear option for your marriage. Decide if you want that or not. If not, don’t ever interact with the kids again. Otherwise, get ready for divorce court.

OOP

Did she make this clear before we married? Well, she said she wanted a traditional marriage. I definitely had my parents’ marriage in mind when she said that. My mom is a SAHM. My dad did not push a stroller or wear a baby sling (though my mom didn’t do the baby sling either). He is definitely a masculine man who would think that’s weird. But he also was an involved father and I have so many happy memories of him when I was younger that I’m afraid my kids won’t have with me.

I do not believe in jumping to divorce and that would make things way worse. I don’t want to have them part time or never. I don’t have literally zero interaction with them now, I see them and talk to them every day. She just doesn’t want me “doing” things for them that she sees as her job. I still do sometimes but she pushes back on it and she’s become harsher on that when she does.

What I want is for her to open her mind to the idea that this is not traditional marriage and a father can be more involved with his kids. And I want to understand what is going on to make her like this because it is hurtful and seems like more than just a misapplied belief at this point.


bubonis

Since both of you are so entrenched in your religion, naturally you’re both going to want to discuss your marital issues with your priest like all good Catholics do.

OOP

We are not Catholic, not sure where you got that idea, we are nondenominational Christian.


Update - after 1 month

^(August 03, 2026)


Update to AIO, my wife believes in strict gender roles?

About a month ago I posted on here about my relationship with my wife and how she is trying to keep me from raising my kids. Thanks everyone to responded to my first post and sorry I didn’t reply to everyone. There were a lot more responses than I expected. If you want details you can see the post in my profile. Unfortunatley things have taken a turn for the worst. There is a TLDR at the bottom if you scropp down.

A lot of things happened since my last post. I told my wife I wanted to go to counseling with our pastor. She immediately agreed and I could tell she thought he would agree with her on this issue.

The counseling appointment did not go as she expected. When we got there he let us both say our peace first. She said in sum that I was trying to usurp our godly roles as man and wife. She did not get into detailed specifics about the kids. I said I was trying to be a better husband and father and that my wife seemed to have a problem with me interacting with my children.

He asked me some pretty pointed questions about myself as a husband. Am I working hard and providing, yes, am I cheating, drinking, gambling, no. Do I yell and scream, swear, break things, do I hit her or the kids? No. Do I stay out all night, do I run away on fishing trips. No, none of that. At this point he’s looking at my wife and asks her if she has anything to add to that? She says not really. I put in that I think I am upholding my marital covenant as a man and provider.

Pastor didn’t say anything about that but kept talking to my wife. He started to get some real concrete details out of her. She reaffirmed this is not a situation of abuse or cheating. She said it was effeminate for me to do women’s chores and pick up after our kids, make them meals, etc. Not biblical. Etc. Pastor kindly told her there is nothing unbiblical about that, but does she feel like less of a woman if she can’t do 100% of those things? She agreed to that. He then started to talk about biblical womanhood and feeling feminine before God, and saying he thinks what we need to do is help my wife feel more womanly in general so these activities won’t feel like a threat to her. And basically that everything will be OK if we add more romance to our marriage.

At this point I was relieved and felt like things were going well. But almost immediately I could tell my wife was unhappy. She started arguing back with the pastor on Adam and Eve and all this. He is a pretty chill guy and he stayed calm and said he basically said as a spiritual leader he wanted to guide our marriage back to happiness and could she please at least give his suggestions a try and see how she feels about it, and we can talk about it again next week. He pointed to some Bible verses about fatherhood and some ones about women doing “manly” things like running a business, to say this isn’t all black and white. My wife begrudgingly agreed with him but I could tell she was still upset.

He has a drawer full of papers with couple’s activities in them and he pulled out a few that he said would be good for us. My wife took hers but didn’t read it. Awkward car ride home. Pastor told us not to immediately talk about the appointment because it leads to fighting but we didn’t have much else to say to each other that evening. We were supposed to have another appointment in 2 weeks. Wife was pretty passive aggressive that night. But over the next week she started to be a little nicer and more relaxed and I thought maybe she had read some of the materials the pastor gave us (I did read mine). I suggested we do an “us day” which is one of the suggestions the pastor had given us and we agreed to send the kids to my parents a day that weekend (shocker, I’m sure my dad probably helped out with them while they were there).

Well that day ended up being the worst day of my life probably. At first things were nice, I planned everything as the worksheet suggested, made her a nice breakfast, had plans in the afternoon to take her to get her nails done and walk along the lake front which is a date we used to do when we were first dating. But that didn’t end up happening because that morning we started talking about some of the big themes of our relationship and our values and goals (again as pastor suggested).

I told her I wanted a loving relationship with a woman I could adore and trust, who has the brains and values to nurture our kids into great adults, who loves me and is there for me, and I would always be there for her. Basically thinking of my mom and dad. But her answer was completely focused on kids. She always wanted kids, she wanted to be a great mother, she wanted a good and trustworthy father to her children. I definitely noticed this and pressed a little harder to ask well what about your husband, what about me? What kind of romance or relationship do you want? She kept deflecting and saying these things aren’t as important when you’re an adult, past a certain age it’s all about your duty to your kids. I disagree with that and plus we are 29, we’re still young, we should still have romance and passion and sex!

So at this point she obviously got VERY annoyed that I brought up sex and was rolling her eyes and saying like “oh so that’s what this is really about.” I tried really hard to say calm and tell her well no it’s not what it’s about but yeah that’s a factor in our relationship, I want intimacy and don’t you? She kept deflecting and she started to get upset like in a hurt/scared way. I was asking her - are you not attracted to me? Are you just not interested in sex, are you asexual? No. I don’t even remember how it got to this point but finally she ended up blurting out that she’s not interested in sex WITH MEN.

Obviously I was stunned. And this is where it all started to come out. Literally I guess. She kind of tried to backpedal but I asked her directly, are you telling me you’re a lesbian? And she couldn’t deny it. She didn’t say yes or no but she started talking about gender roles and how important it is for children to have male and female role models so that they grow up into proper men and women and not confused about sex or stuck in sexual sin. And I asked her again directly to clarify: you are telling me that you’re a lesbian and you married me in a marriage with gender roles so that your kids wouldn’t end up gay?

She started crying and yelling at me…like… I don’t know how lonely it is and she shouldn’t be denied a proper married life just because of her sexual sins, she’s repented and God will forgive her as long as she keeps working on being a good wife to a man. And all of this is because her father was a shit dad and died when she was young and that’s why our kids need to see a real man in their lives.

Well that was a couple weeks ago and as you can imagine the last few weeks have been hell. There is no way I’m staying with her and I’ve just been talking to a divorce lawyer and trying to figure out how this will work. And also frankly just crying a lot which I guess is un manly so we never would have worked out anyway. I’m staying with my parents because I don’t think the kids should see us interacting this way but my lawyer told me I should move back or get a custody order so I need to work on that now. I’m just frankly so numb and I can’t believe someone I loved would do this to me.

So that’s the update, I wasn’t sure if I was going to write this but honestly hearing how crazy she was helped me the first time and I think it will help me again, but I don’t think I"m going to keep posting more from here. I would appreciate any advice or perspective on if I am overreacting by not wanting to move back home or be around her and trying to get a 50/50 custody order instead.

TLDR: Wife and I went to pastoral counseling for our marriage, didn’t work, wife admitted she is a lesbian and used me to get her fantasy dream life of Christian husband and babies.

 

COMMENTS

Bynming

NOR. I’d be surprised if none of that insanity showed up in any way before having children and marrying.

OOP

I am certainly reflecting on a lot of things about our relationship and wish I had been less blind overall. To be honest I never had the best luck with women before her and maybe the first red flag should have been that this pretty, nice christian girl wanted to be with me


Neither-Lie-4029

Well damn. At first I was gonna say, let the woman do woman shit. Better for you. Just go work come home and chill. Let her wash, cook, clean and smash you. Why would that bother you? After reading the end. Idk what to say to you. Sorry about that fam. Good luck, get her to have a threesome I guess ?

OOP

You seem immature, I’m happy to leave domestic work to wife while I work full time but she was keeping me away from my kids and that was the issue here.


andrey_not_the_goat

I don’t understand why you thought the pastor was the right place for you to have counseling?

OOP

Well for one it’s free, we both trust my pastor, I knew she would agree to see him, I knew he was not going to agree I shouldn’t help raise my children, and what do you think he did wrong in this situation?

andrey_not_the_goat

Because it literally offers no proper outlook. He’s biased, and will always take your wife’s side.

OOP

He didn’t though…did you read the post?


No-Suit8587

Your wife’s a lunatic run and take the kids as fast as u can

OOP

My lawyer advised me it’s highly unlikely I will get full custody as her gender views don’t come into whether she is a fit parent legally speaking. I will be looking for 50/50 immediately.


Regular-Tell-108

NOR.

When people like me talk about how sexism and homophobia are bad for everyone — including men and straight people — this is part of what we mean. Your wife’s deeply ingrained self-loathing and adherence to imaginary but strict gender roles had caused enormous and unnecessary pain for a whole family.

OOP

I never could have imagined she took it this far. I would never advocate anyone to deny who they are and get in a sham marriage even if I’m not into gay pride and all that.


DollySheep32

INFO - how supportive/accepting is your pastor and church of LGBTQ people? I’m guessing not very since wife felt she had to use OOP as a non-consenting beard.

OOP

We promote traditional marriage, two genders, heterosexuality as ideal. Some of our church friends have had gay kids and there are varying degrees of acceptance on that. My wife grew up not really being very religious until her dad died and I think she and her mom go overboard to compensate in a way.

Diddly_eyed_Dipshite

How would you react if one of your kids tells you they’re gay?

OOP

I would not necessarily be happy about that but I would love them nonetheless. It’s not something I can control. I would just hope they keep a relationship with Christ no matter what.


Tree_Color_Wizard

Obviously you are going to get divorced. That’s just something to accept now and allow yourself to grieve.

But your wife has been a friend and co parent to you. She has probably seen you through some hard times. As her friend, please encourage her to accept and love herself. To be true to her feelings. It will affect your kids in harmful ways if she keeps repressing her real feelings. It’s in everyone’s best interests for her to accept that she’s gay and live honestly. Or at least for her to find a healthy version of a lavender marriage lol. But find it in your heart to take it easy on her. I know that might be really hard right now but being closeted and repressed fucking sucks.

Find yourself a therapist who is familiar with queer dynamics that can help you process this and maybe help you find a way to be supportive.

So sorry, hope you and your kids are okay.

OOP

As a Christian I want to be compassionate and hope I can grow toward more of that in the future but right now all I can think about is her lying to me and using me for almost 7 years. I was just a puppet with sperm to her. I will be praying for her and hope God gives me the grace to forgive her.


SavageRabbitX

Dude that is fucking rough. You have my sympathy. Id be going full scorched earth if I was you so your a better man than me. What do you thinks gonna happen when people find out why you are divorcing?

OOP

I don’t know, I told my parents but we aren’t exactly going to spread it around, she will probably make up whatever she wants because she knows I’m not going to go telling everyone she’s a lesbian… hopefully we can both just say it was irreconcilable differences and leave it at that


Just_Log_8528

Bigger question for you is do you believe that the issue is your wife’s a lesbian or a religious fanatic? Your romantic relationship is pretty clearly dead but coparenting is going to force you to some uncomfortable paths

OOP

Not sure what you mean by that, they’re both issues. I can’t be married to a lesbian, so that’s an issue, and her trying to keep me from raising my kids or teaching them her insane warped version of Christianity is another issue. For my lawyer or for custody it’s not about her religion or sexual orientation, it’s solely about her keeping me from the kids which is why he wants me to move back ASAP, so yeah that’s definitely uncomfortable.

 


This is a repost community. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

Please remember to follow the rules.

Let’s aim for a respectful and friendly discussion for everyone involved.

AIO, my wife believes in strict gender roles?

This is a repost community. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

OOP: u/john_7292. Than you Reddit user u/BigONerd for compiling this.

Published on: r/AmIOverreacting

Story is: ONGOING

Story timeline


Main Post

^(July 03, 2026)


AIO, my wife believes in strict gender roles?

So for some context my wife and i (both 29 yrs old) are both fairly religious Christians but she and her family take it more seriously than I do. Before we married we discussed that she wants a traditional marriage where she is SAHM. I would be fine with her working but I do believe a man should be a provider so this is fine with me too and that’s what we’ve done. She said she didn’t like modern men who do things like wear a baby sling or push a stroller and I was fine with that.

Our first child was born a bit over 4 yrs ago and then our second a little under 2 years later. When our kids were young I admittedly did not help with them very much. She had a lot of help from both her mom and mine, and I also was working long hours in these days. So I never changed a diaper, maybe fed them a couple of times. If I tried to step in she would generally wave me off and say I shouldn’t worry about it so I didn’t. Her mom actually lived with us until my youngest was about 6 months old and still visits fairly often. Her sister sometimes comes over to help too. So she definitely has her “village” so to say.

But now that the kidss are getting older and I’m working less, making more money, I honestly want to be involved more. But it’s like she doesn’t want me to do anything for them ever. She always brushes me off and says that’s a woman’s job, I shouldn’t be doing that, and even that our kids shouldn’t see a man picking up dirty laundry or making them snacks. I think that’s weird, my parents have a traditional marriage but my dad still did stuff like that from time to time and I turned out fine. If she sees me playing with them she usually doesn’t look happy and tries to distract them from it after a little while. This is getting really bothersome because those are my kids too. I would think most women would be happy their husband wants to do stuff like that.

It all kind of finally came to a final straw the other day when i had a day off work. I secretly turned off her alarm in the night so she could sleep in that morning. I woke up early, bought her some flowers and made the kids breakfast (there was some for her too when she woke up). I’m not gonna lie, we haven’t had sex in awhile either and that was part of my thinking here. But I thought it would be a nice thing to do for her and a nice morning to spend with the kids and it was. I thought maybe we could all go to the park later since it was a nice day.

My wife ended up waking up around 7 AM (normally 5:30 or 6 for her) and came down to see what was going on. I could see that she was hiding her anger for the kids. She smiled and said isn’t that a nice thing daddy did but the look she gave me was glaring. Then she said to my 4 year old son why don’t you take your sister to watch tv. When they went to the next room she started whispering quietly at me like, what the hell were you thinking, why would you do something like that, why would you let me sleep in, do you think I’m a bad mother?

Honestly this kinda got my hackles up because I did nothing wrong here and I retorted, do you think I’m a bad father? Why do you never want me to do anything with the kids? She flat out denied it and said that is not true, she just doesn’t want me overstepping in to take on women’s work. It’s setting a bad example and I’m acting woke (and all these other things). So I asked her what she DOES think it’s okay for me to do for/with the kids and she kinda stopped for a second like she didn’t really have an answer. Then she said it’s a father’s job to be a provider and disciplinarian.

I was like, that’s it? You think I’m here to make a paycheck and yell at them if they do something bad? And she got upset and said NO it’s just not my job to take over mother’s roles and it makes me less of a man and her less of a woman.

At this point we were both starting to raise our voices and I looked into the next room and I was like can we please try to calm down, we don’t need to scare the kids. Can you honestly explain to me why it’s a problem for a father to make his kids breakfast and buy his wife flowers? But she just got more upset and said if I didn’t understand then I’m not the man she married and I’m not godly.

Honestly I just gave up and went out and spent the rest of the day walking around the mall and doing some errands. I came home and the kids were in bed and she didn’t speak to me and I slept in the guest bedroom. It’s been a couple days now and we still haven’t talked and frankly I don’t even know what to say to here. The more I think about it the more upset I get. I keep trying to see it from her perspective and all I can think is maybe it wasn’t right for me to change her alarm because she might have had things she wanted to do that morning but this is obviously much bigger than that.

AIO to this? Should I try to find some compromise with her or what?

 

COMMENTS

Cheap-Ad-2175

Go to marriage counseling with a counselor or y’all’s preacher. Taking care of your children is BOTH parents jobs??? Providing isn’t just shelter and food. It’s providing love, care, and support to them as well.

OOP

This is actually a great idea and I do not think our pastor will agree with her at all. So I will be interested to see how she reacts to that. I will talk to her about it thank you.


bothfeetofftheground

This is the strangest thing I’ve ever heard. You sound like a dream husband. I wish I could have a day to sleep in. Moms are humans and deserve time off and personal time. And kids need to see men doing chores.

OOP

I hope I didn’t make myself come off as a saint because I’m definitely not but I wanted to do something nice for my wife and kids which I rarely have had time to - and to be cut back like this over it was very hurtful.


JuliaX1984

Just tell her that trying to tell her husband what to do isn’t godly. Quote Paul’s verses about how women should be quiet and never talk back to men. If she objects, she’s not godly.

OOP

To be exact those verses say a woman shouldn’t preach in church. She seems to think the woman is the “queen of the house.” My words not hers.


crackpotpourri

Y’all need couples therapy at a minimum. But I’m guessing she won’t think that’s very “godly.”

OOP

I am definitely going to try to get her to see our pastor for counseling. I don’t think there’s anyway she can disagree to that and claim not to be a hypocrite.

I would never tell my wife to shut her hole and do as I say, I am the leader of the house, that does not make her my slave.


facinationstreet

What exactly do you think we can tell you? You married this. You agreed to this idiocy. You had kids with this. Wait until you get divorced. Shit will hit the fan. Homeschooling (handicapping) your kids, no outside people, etc. Ya’ll just baffle me.

NOR but get your life together for your kids if for no one else.

OOP

I agreed to a traditional marriage with the one my parents had in mind, where my dad was a good dad and played with us, chatted with us, took us to soccer practice and fun things like fairs, taught us things, showed good values, cleaned up after himself, even made dinner sometimes, and my mom was a SAHM. I did not agree to this. We also are not homeschooling.


ConsciousNectarine9

NOR

I think she has gone waaaaayyy past the old ‘traditions’. She is pushing you out of your childrens lives on the excuse of ‘it’s not manly’. Well I am sorry but even back in the day a lot of dad’s would do things with their children and those who didn’t… their kids 9 times out of 10 would have grown up resenting them.

You need to have a long, hard think about what you want your role to be with your children. If you want to be able to actually care for them, bond with them and for them to actually have you as part of their everyday lives instead of just being the ‘bad’ parent/paycheck you will have to leave this marriage. You will never be given that place in your childrens lives as long as you are together with your wife.

OOP

I agree, it’s like she wants me to be the stereotypical absent father who never sees their kids. I didn’t think anyone ever thought that was alright even back in the day.


camioblu

Make an appointment with your pastor and see what the religion you follow says about all of this nonsense. She’s got some control and trust issues for sure. Was she ever abused by a man?

OOP

I think her father was abit of an asshole but he died 15 or so years ago so I don’t know firsthand. I will definitely be making a counseling appointment with our pastor thank you.


Alert-Beautiful9003

Wut? You were a lazy dad/husband and she thinks she can control her feels by micromanage ans controlling everything. Both of you need to get some help for yourselves and especially for the kids.

OOP (downvoted)

Please understand that back when our kids were babies I was working anywhere from 70-80 hours a week to keep our family a float and out of debt. I am trying not to get defensive in this thread but I do not like being called lazy, we were both working hard, and she had help at home in her mom, my mom and her sister.


bmyst70 (downvoted)

YOR

Yes, your wife is very extreme and rigid in her beliefs. Agreed 100%. But you knew this before you married her. Therefore, you are firmly over-reacting. She made very clear SHE was the only one to ever be involved with the kids.

If she suddenly showed you this side abruptly I would agree with you 100%. However, this is very clearly her hill to die on and she will not compromise with you on this. If you try interacting with the kids in any way, it will get worse.

Bluntly put if you truly want more interaction with the kids, you have to divorce her and push very hard for split custody. That will of course put more responsibility on you, and yes it is indeed the nuclear option for your marriage. Decide if you want that or not. If not, don’t ever interact with the kids again. Otherwise, get ready for divorce court.

OOP

Did she make this clear before we married? Well, she said she wanted a traditional marriage. I definitely had my parents’ marriage in mind when she said that. My mom is a SAHM. My dad did not push a stroller or wear a baby sling (though my mom didn’t do the baby sling either). He is definitely a masculine man who would think that’s weird. But he also was an involved father and I have so many happy memories of him when I was younger that I’m afraid my kids won’t have with me.

I do not believe in jumping to divorce and that would make things way worse. I don’t want to have them part time or never. I don’t have literally zero interaction with them now, I see them and talk to them every day. She just doesn’t want me “doing” things for them that she sees as her job. I still do sometimes but she pushes back on it and she’s become harsher on that when she does.

What I want is for her to open her mind to the idea that this is not traditional marriage and a father can be more involved with his kids. And I want to understand what is going on to make her like this because it is hurtful and seems like more than just a misapplied belief at this point.


bubonis

Since both of you are so entrenched in your religion, naturally you’re both going to want to discuss your marital issues with your priest like all good Catholics do.

OOP

We are not Catholic, not sure where you got that idea, we are nondenominational Christian.


Update - after 1 month

^(August 03, 2026)


Update to AIO, my wife believes in strict gender roles?

About a month ago I posted on here about my relationship with my wife and how she is trying to keep me from raising my kids. Thanks everyone to responded to my first post and sorry I didn’t reply to everyone. There were a lot more responses than I expected. If you want details you can see the post in my profile. Unfortunatley things have taken a turn for the worst. There is a TLDR at the bottom if you scropp down.

A lot of things happened since my last post. I told my wife I wanted to go to counseling with our pastor. She immediately agreed and I could tell she thought he would agree with her on this issue.

The counseling appointment did not go as she expected. When we got there he let us both say our peace first. She said in sum that I was trying to usurp our godly roles as man and wife. She did not get into detailed specifics about the kids. I said I was trying to be a better husband and father and that my wife seemed to have a problem with me interacting with my children.

He asked me some pretty pointed questions about myself as a husband. Am I working hard and providing, yes, am I cheating, drinking, gambling, no. Do I yell and scream, swear, break things, do I hit her or the kids? No. Do I stay out all night, do I run away on fishing trips. No, none of that. At this point he’s looking at my wife and asks her if she has anything to add to that? She says not really. I put in that I think I am upholding my marital covenant as a man and provider.

Pastor didn’t say anything about that but kept talking to my wife. He started to get some real concrete details out of her. She reaffirmed this is not a situation of abuse or cheating. She said it was effeminate for me to do women’s chores and pick up after our kids, make them meals, etc. Not biblical. Etc. Pastor kindly told her there is nothing unbiblical about that, but does she feel like less of a woman if she can’t do 100% of those things? She agreed to that. He then started to talk about biblical womanhood and feeling feminine before God, and saying he thinks what we need to do is help my wife feel more womanly in general so these activities won’t feel like a threat to her. And basically that everything will be OK if we add more romance to our marriage.

At this point I was relieved and felt like things were going well. But almost immediately I could tell my wife was unhappy. She started arguing back with the pastor on Adam and Eve and all this. He is a pretty chill guy and he stayed calm and said he basically said as a spiritual leader he wanted to guide our marriage back to happiness and could she please at least give his suggestions a try and see how she feels about it, and we can talk about it again next week. He pointed to some Bible verses about fatherhood and some ones about women doing “manly” things like running a business, to say this isn’t all black and white. My wife begrudgingly agreed with him but I could tell she was still upset.

He has a drawer full of papers with couple’s activities in them and he pulled out a few that he said would be good for us. My wife took hers but didn’t read it. Awkward car ride home. Pastor told us not to immediately talk about the appointment because it leads to fighting but we didn’t have much else to say to each other that evening. We were supposed to have another appointment in 2 weeks. Wife was pretty passive aggressive that night. But over the next week she started to be a little nicer and more relaxed and I thought maybe she had read some of the materials the pastor gave us (I did read mine). I suggested we do an “us day” which is one of the suggestions the pastor had given us and we agreed to send the kids to my parents a day that weekend (shocker, I’m sure my dad probably helped out with them while they were there).

Well that day ended up being the worst day of my life probably. At first things were nice, I planned everything as the worksheet suggested, made her a nice breakfast, had plans in the afternoon to take her to get her nails done and walk along the lake front which is a date we used to do when we were first dating. But that didn’t end up happening because that morning we started talking about some of the big themes of our relationship and our values and goals (again as pastor suggested).

I told her I wanted a loving relationship with a woman I could adore and trust, who has the brains and values to nurture our kids into great adults, who loves me and is there for me, and I would always be there for her. Basically thinking of my mom and dad. But her answer was completely focused on kids. She always wanted kids, she wanted to be a great mother, she wanted a good and trustworthy father to her children. I definitely noticed this and pressed a little harder to ask well what about your husband, what about me? What kind of romance or relationship do you want? She kept deflecting and saying these things aren’t as important when you’re an adult, past a certain age it’s all about your duty to your kids. I disagree with that and plus we are 29, we’re still young, we should still have romance and passion and sex!

So at this point she obviously got VERY annoyed that I brought up sex and was rolling her eyes and saying like “oh so that’s what this is really about.” I tried really hard to say calm and tell her well no it’s not what it’s about but yeah that’s a factor in our relationship, I want intimacy and don’t you? She kept deflecting and she started to get upset like in a hurt/scared way. I was asking her - are you not attracted to me? Are you just not interested in sex, are you asexual? No. I don’t even remember how it got to this point but finally she ended up blurting out that she’s not interested in sex WITH MEN.

Obviously I was stunned. And this is where it all started to come out. Literally I guess. She kind of tried to backpedal but I asked her directly, are you telling me you’re a lesbian? And she couldn’t deny it. She didn’t say yes or no but she started talking about gender roles and how important it is for children to have male and female role models so that they grow up into proper men and women and not confused about sex or stuck in sexual sin. And I asked her again directly to clarify: you are telling me that you’re a lesbian and you married me in a marriage with gender roles so that your kids wouldn’t end up gay?

She started crying and yelling at me…like… I don’t know how lonely it is and she shouldn’t be denied a proper married life just because of her sexual sins, she’s repented and God will forgive her as long as she keeps working on being a good wife to a man. And all of this is because her father was a shit dad and died when she was young and that’s why our kids need to see a real man in their lives.

Well that was a couple weeks ago and as you can imagine the last few weeks have been hell. There is no way I’m staying with her and I’ve just been talking to a divorce lawyer and trying to figure out how this will work. And also frankly just crying a lot which I guess is un manly so we never would have worked out anyway. I’m staying with my parents because I don’t think the kids should see us interacting this way but my lawyer told me I should move back or get a custody order so I need to work on that now. I’m just frankly so numb and I can’t believe someone I loved would do this to me.

So that’s the update, I wasn’t sure if I was going to write this but honestly hearing how crazy she was helped me the first time and I think it will help me again, but I don’t think I"m going to keep posting more from here. I would appreciate any advice or perspective on if I am overreacting by not wanting to move back home or be around her and trying to get a 50/50 custody order instead.

TLDR: Wife and I went to pastoral counseling for our marriage, didn’t work, wife admitted she is a lesbian and used me to get her fantasy dream life of Christian husband and babies.

 

COMMENTS

Bynming

NOR. I’d be surprised if none of that insanity showed up in any way before having children and marrying.

OOP

I am certainly reflecting on a lot of things about our relationship and wish I had been less blind overall. To be honest I never had the best luck with women before her and maybe the first red flag should have been that this pretty, nice christian girl wanted to be with me


Neither-Lie-4029

Well damn. At first I was gonna say, let the woman do woman shit. Better for you. Just go work come home and chill. Let her wash, cook, clean and smash you. Why would that bother you? After reading the end. Idk what to say to you. Sorry about that fam. Good luck, get her to have a threesome I guess ?

OOP

You seem immature, I’m happy to leave domestic work to wife while I work full time but she was keeping me away from my kids and that was the issue here.


andrey_not_the_goat

I don’t understand why you thought the pastor was the right place for you to have counseling?

OOP

Well for one it’s free, we both trust my pastor, I knew she would agree to see him, I knew he was not going to agree I shouldn’t help raise my children, and what do you think he did wrong in this situation?

andrey_not_the_goat

Because it literally offers no proper outlook. He’s biased, and will always take your wife’s side.

OOP

He didn’t though…did you read the post?


No-Suit8587

Your wife’s a lunatic run and take the kids as fast as u can

OOP

My lawyer advised me it’s highly unlikely I will get full custody as her gender views don’t come into whether she is a fit parent legally speaking. I will be looking for 50/50 immediately.


Regular-Tell-108

NOR.

When people like me talk about how sexism and homophobia are bad for everyone — including men and straight people — this is part of what we mean. Your wife’s deeply ingrained self-loathing and adherence to imaginary but strict gender roles had caused enormous and unnecessary pain for a whole family.

OOP

I never could have imagined she took it this far. I would never advocate anyone to deny who they are and get in a sham marriage even if I’m not into gay pride and all that.


DollySheep32

INFO - how supportive/accepting is your pastor and church of LGBTQ people? I’m guessing not very since wife felt she had to use OOP as a non-consenting beard.

OOP

We promote traditional marriage, two genders, heterosexuality as ideal. Some of our church friends have had gay kids and there are varying degrees of acceptance on that. My wife grew up not really being very religious until her dad died and I think she and her mom go overboard to compensate in a way.

Diddly_eyed_Dipshite

How would you react if one of your kids tells you they’re gay?

OOP

I would not necessarily be happy about that but I would love them nonetheless. It’s not something I can control. I would just hope they keep a relationship with Christ no matter what.


Tree_Color_Wizard

Obviously you are going to get divorced. That’s just something to accept now and allow yourself to grieve.

But your wife has been a friend and co parent to you. She has probably seen you through some hard times. As her friend, please encourage her to accept and love herself. To be true to her feelings. It will affect your kids in harmful ways if she keeps repressing her real feelings. It’s in everyone’s best interests for her to accept that she’s gay and live honestly. Or at least for her to find a healthy version of a lavender marriage lol. But find it in your heart to take it easy on her. I know that might be really hard right now but being closeted and repressed fucking sucks.

Find yourself a therapist who is familiar with queer dynamics that can help you process this and maybe help you find a way to be supportive.

So sorry, hope you and your kids are okay.

OOP

As a Christian I want to be compassionate and hope I can grow toward more of that in the future but right now all I can think about is her lying to me and using me for almost 7 years. I was just a puppet with sperm to her. I will be praying for her and hope God gives me the grace to forgive her.


SavageRabbitX

Dude that is fucking rough. You have my sympathy. Id be going full scorched earth if I was you so your a better man than me. What do you thinks gonna happen when people find out why you are divorcing?

OOP

I don’t know, I told my parents but we aren’t exactly going to spread it around, she will probably make up whatever she wants because she knows I’m not going to go telling everyone she’s a lesbian… hopefully we can both just say it was irreconcilable differences and leave it at that


Just_Log_8528

Bigger question for you is do you believe that the issue is your wife’s a lesbian or a religious fanatic? Your romantic relationship is pretty clearly dead but coparenting is going to force you to some uncomfortable paths

OOP

Not sure what you mean by that, they’re both issues. I can’t be married to a lesbian, so that’s an issue, and her trying to keep me from raising my kids or teaching them her insane warped version of Christianity is another issue. For my lawyer or for custody it’s not about her religion or sexual orientation, it’s solely about her keeping me from the kids which is why he wants me to move back ASAP, so yeah that’s definitely uncomfortable.

 


This is a repost community. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

Please remember to follow the rules.

Let’s aim for a respectful and friendly discussion for everyone involved.

0

[Concluded] I 28F invited my 30M best friend over for dinner and he said I'm not your husband [Reddit]

preview

I 28F invited my 30M best friend to dinner and he said “I’m not your husband” What does he mean?

This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP) Thank you Reddit user u/BigONerd for compiling this story

OOP: u/throwra26024

Published on: r/relationship_advice

Story is: CONCLUDED

Story timeline


Main Post

^(July 29, 2026)


I 28F invited my 30M best friend to dinner and he said “I’m not your husband” What does he mean?

I 28F got divorced about three months ago, and my 30M best friend was there for me throughout the whole thing. We’ve actually been best friends since childhood and have always been really close.

We hang out a lot, go out randomly, try new restaurants, and sometimes I’ll cook and invite him over. We’ve always had this kind of friendship, so none of it ever felt unusual to me.

Just 2 days ago, he asked me to go with him to try a new restaurant, and everything seemed completely fine. Then yesterday, I called him and told him I’d made enough food for both of us and asked if he wanted to come over since he lives nearby. (We’ve done this many times before, so I didn’t think much of it)

But his response completely caught me off guard. He said he wasn’t “in the mood for this lately” and then added “I’m not your husband”. I honestly don’t understand where that came from. I wasn’t asking him for a favor or expecting him to do anything for me. I was just inviting him to dinner like I normally would.

I tried calling him afterward because I wanted to understand what he meant, but he didn’t answer. I don’t want to pressure him by showing up at his place or blowing up his phone, so I decided to give him some space.

Now I’m just confused and wondering if I somehow crossed a boundary without realizing it, What did he mean by “I’m not your husband”?

 

COMMENTS

Both-Enthusiasm708

Does he have a gf? He could either think you developed feelings, he developed feelings, his gf doesn’t like the interactions, or since the divorce you have been relying on him more then usual and he got tired.

OOP

No he’s single. And I really wouldn’t say I’ve been relying on him more since the divorce. I barely talked to him about it because I don’t like burdening him with my problems or unnecessary drama. If anything, we’ve actually been hanging out more lately, and we’ve always invited each other over for food, so inviting him to dinner felt completely normal to me.

PolitelyHostile

The last time you two hung out, did you talk about some other guy you’re into or talk about dating in general?

OOP

No, we didn’t talk about another guy or dating in general. The only thing remotely related was that he asked me something along the lines of “If your husband came back, apologized, and realized he’d lost a good woman, would you take him back?” That was pretty much it.

I told him I’m trying to move on and honestly can’t even think about something like that right now.


fluffybottompanda

you were thinking about going to his house??

OOP

Here’s what I said: I don’t want to pressure him by showing up at his place or blowing up his phone.


Professional-End347

I think he meant to say - “ Im not your husband so you dont have to cook for me . Im not your husband so I don’t NEED to eat your boring home cooked food”

He is saying that he prefers to be a friend and have fun times with you, eat out , hang etc.

Its also possible that one of his male friends got to his head … and indicated that bro you hang with her at her home and eat home cooked food? Are you like playing husband with her ? A dumb comment can impact a man’s mind if he is conflicted about you.

Give him space , be kind to him, if you are interested in him, wait for him to approach. If he doesn’t respect him and if he does, pick up signals quickly and reciprocate to avoid drama

OOP

Thanks for your perspective, I really appreciate it. And I do love him, but only as a friend. I’m not interested in him romantically, otherwise I definitely would’ve mentioned that in my post. That’s why his comment confused me so much. From my side, I was genuinely just inviting my best friend over for dinner like I’ve done many times before.


FindingHerStrength (downvoted)

Are you going to ask him to elaborate. We’re just assuming. Why not ask him outright for clarity?

OOP

I already mentioned why:👇🏻 I tried calling him afterward because I wanted to understand what he meant, but he didn’t answer.


Final Update - after 3 days

^(August 01, 2026)


Update: I 28F invited my 30M best friend to dinner and he said “I’m not your husband” What does he mean?

Hi, first of all thanks everyone for your perspectives on my original post. I wanted to give an update now that I finally have some clarity.

As I mentioned in my original post, I called him once after he told me “I’m not your husband” but I didn’t hear anything from him after that, until he showed up at my apartment.

He looked really ashamed and nervous. He started by apologizing and then we sat down and talked about what happened. He explained that he wasn’t the one who came up with that comment, It was a woman he’s been seeing recently, and she’s the one who told him what to text me.

This honestly surprised me. As I mentioned before, we’ve been best friends since childhood and we basically tell each other everything, but he had never mentioned this woman to me before.

Anyway I told him that if I had known he was seeing someone, I wouldn’t have agreed to go to that new restaurant with him in the first place, and I probably wouldn’t have invited him over for dinner either. If she’s uncomfortable with the way we interact, then I don’t want to knowingly cross that line or make things harder for them.

He apologized again and explained that things are still new with her, and that he he was planning to tell me once things became more serious between them.

He also kept asking me whether the text had hurt me and whether I thought he should end things with her. I told him no but I think we should set some boundaries going forward (to respect her wishes because I wouldn’t want to do anything that makes her uncomfortable).

He disagreed and said that he doesn’t think we’re doing anything wrong and that he’d rather things stay the same between us. He ended up staying for a few hours and we talked about everything, but he seemed really conflicted about the whole situation.

As for me, I’ve decided to take a small step back anyway. I’m going to try to cut down on how often we go out and hang out, and I’m also going to stop our habit of eating at each other’s homes for now.

I love him as my best friend, but I don’t want our friendship to get in the way of him having a healthy relationship.

 

COMMENTS

Ilovewally

I get it, you’re trying to take the higher road, but this woman he is seeing sounds a bit jealous and territorial if you ask me

stupidpoopoohead00

im lowkey skeptical about her saying any of this. seems all we have abt her is what he says and he clearly has feelings for OP

Necessary_Tap343

And OP saying she wasn’t hurt his a very obvious lie.

OOP

I didn’t say no to that. I said no when he asked if I thought he should end things with her.


Icy_Guard_8216

Do you have feelings for him?

OOP

I already answered this in my post. I’ve always seen him as my best friend, nothing more. And I’m the one who suggested putting some boundaries in place once I found out he was seeing someone, because I don’t want our friendship to interfere with his relationship. I don’t think I’d be doing that if I had romantic feelings for him.

Antique_Teaching_333

Or you are trying to protect yourself from becoming more attached as he is seeing someone. I’m not saying you do have feelings, but creating boundaries isn’t necessarily a sign they aren’t there.

Aren’t you hurt he didn’t tell you about her and that he sent the text to begin with because of “her”? Why would it be wrong to go out to dinner with a friend and inviting them over. Why would that be inappropriate if you are just friends?

OOP

I get what you mean, but I wouldn’t say there’s anything inappropriate with two friends going out to dinner or inviting each other over. It’s just different now that I know the woman he’s seeing is uncomfortable with it. At this point, it’s not really about me and him, It’s about being considerate of her feelings. I’m a woman too and if I were in her position, I wouldn’t want another woman knowingly doing something that made me uncomfortable… I don’t have to see things the way she does to respect her feelings.


unzunzhepp

Plot twist: that woman doesn’t exist and he wanted to make you jealous.

OOP

I really hope that’s not the case because I trust him completely. If I found out he made all of this up just to make me jealous, I honestly wouldn’t even know how to process it. I don’t think I could see our friendship the same way again.


Throw_RA099

Just imagine this. We see this kind of post on reddit every day. 

If your friend or his girlfriend came to this sub and posted that you invited your friend out for a 1 v 1 dinner, there would be almost unanimous comments that this kind of things is out of bounds and inappropriate, and that his girlfriend would feel right to be insecure and would be advising her to break up with your friend.

I don’t think you did anything wrong here as it seems that your friend was communicating poorly, but just something to consider and keep in mind moving forward. If you’re going to invite your friend somewhere, invite his SO too.

OOP

I know, but he never told me he’d been seeing someone lately.

 


This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

Please remember to follow the subreddit rules, especially the ones about brigading.

Let’s aim for a respectful and friendly discussion for everyone involved.

I 28F invited my 30M best friend to dinner and he said “I’m not your husband” What does he mean?

This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP) Thank you Reddit user u/BigONerd for compiling this story

OOP: u/throwra26024

Published on: r/relationship_advice

Story is: CONCLUDED

Story timeline


Main Post

^(July 29, 2026)


I 28F invited my 30M best friend to dinner and he said “I’m not your husband” What does he mean?

I 28F got divorced about three months ago, and my 30M best friend was there for me throughout the whole thing. We’ve actually been best friends since childhood and have always been really close.

We hang out a lot, go out randomly, try new restaurants, and sometimes I’ll cook and invite him over. We’ve always had this kind of friendship, so none of it ever felt unusual to me.

Just 2 days ago, he asked me to go with him to try a new restaurant, and everything seemed completely fine. Then yesterday, I called him and told him I’d made enough food for both of us and asked if he wanted to come over since he lives nearby. (We’ve done this many times before, so I didn’t think much of it)

But his response completely caught me off guard. He said he wasn’t “in the mood for this lately” and then added “I’m not your husband”. I honestly don’t understand where that came from. I wasn’t asking him for a favor or expecting him to do anything for me. I was just inviting him to dinner like I normally would.

I tried calling him afterward because I wanted to understand what he meant, but he didn’t answer. I don’t want to pressure him by showing up at his place or blowing up his phone, so I decided to give him some space.

Now I’m just confused and wondering if I somehow crossed a boundary without realizing it, What did he mean by “I’m not your husband”?

 

COMMENTS

Both-Enthusiasm708

Does he have a gf? He could either think you developed feelings, he developed feelings, his gf doesn’t like the interactions, or since the divorce you have been relying on him more then usual and he got tired.

OOP

No he’s single. And I really wouldn’t say I’ve been relying on him more since the divorce. I barely talked to him about it because I don’t like burdening him with my problems or unnecessary drama. If anything, we’ve actually been hanging out more lately, and we’ve always invited each other over for food, so inviting him to dinner felt completely normal to me.

PolitelyHostile

The last time you two hung out, did you talk about some other guy you’re into or talk about dating in general?

OOP

No, we didn’t talk about another guy or dating in general. The only thing remotely related was that he asked me something along the lines of “If your husband came back, apologized, and realized he’d lost a good woman, would you take him back?” That was pretty much it.

I told him I’m trying to move on and honestly can’t even think about something like that right now.


fluffybottompanda

you were thinking about going to his house??

OOP

Here’s what I said: I don’t want to pressure him by showing up at his place or blowing up his phone.


Professional-End347

I think he meant to say - “ Im not your husband so you dont have to cook for me . Im not your husband so I don’t NEED to eat your boring home cooked food”

He is saying that he prefers to be a friend and have fun times with you, eat out , hang etc.

Its also possible that one of his male friends got to his head … and indicated that bro you hang with her at her home and eat home cooked food? Are you like playing husband with her ? A dumb comment can impact a man’s mind if he is conflicted about you.

Give him space , be kind to him, if you are interested in him, wait for him to approach. If he doesn’t respect him and if he does, pick up signals quickly and reciprocate to avoid drama

OOP

Thanks for your perspective, I really appreciate it. And I do love him, but only as a friend. I’m not interested in him romantically, otherwise I definitely would’ve mentioned that in my post. That’s why his comment confused me so much. From my side, I was genuinely just inviting my best friend over for dinner like I’ve done many times before.


FindingHerStrength (downvoted)

Are you going to ask him to elaborate. We’re just assuming. Why not ask him outright for clarity?

OOP

I already mentioned why:👇🏻 I tried calling him afterward because I wanted to understand what he meant, but he didn’t answer.


Final Update - after 3 days

^(August 01, 2026)


Update: I 28F invited my 30M best friend to dinner and he said “I’m not your husband” What does he mean?

Hi, first of all thanks everyone for your perspectives on my original post. I wanted to give an update now that I finally have some clarity.

As I mentioned in my original post, I called him once after he told me “I’m not your husband” but I didn’t hear anything from him after that, until he showed up at my apartment.

He looked really ashamed and nervous. He started by apologizing and then we sat down and talked about what happened. He explained that he wasn’t the one who came up with that comment, It was a woman he’s been seeing recently, and she’s the one who told him what to text me.

This honestly surprised me. As I mentioned before, we’ve been best friends since childhood and we basically tell each other everything, but he had never mentioned this woman to me before.

Anyway I told him that if I had known he was seeing someone, I wouldn’t have agreed to go to that new restaurant with him in the first place, and I probably wouldn’t have invited him over for dinner either. If she’s uncomfortable with the way we interact, then I don’t want to knowingly cross that line or make things harder for them.

He apologized again and explained that things are still new with her, and that he he was planning to tell me once things became more serious between them.

He also kept asking me whether the text had hurt me and whether I thought he should end things with her. I told him no but I think we should set some boundaries going forward (to respect her wishes because I wouldn’t want to do anything that makes her uncomfortable).

He disagreed and said that he doesn’t think we’re doing anything wrong and that he’d rather things stay the same between us. He ended up staying for a few hours and we talked about everything, but he seemed really conflicted about the whole situation.

As for me, I’ve decided to take a small step back anyway. I’m going to try to cut down on how often we go out and hang out, and I’m also going to stop our habit of eating at each other’s homes for now.

I love him as my best friend, but I don’t want our friendship to get in the way of him having a healthy relationship.

 

COMMENTS

Ilovewally

I get it, you’re trying to take the higher road, but this woman he is seeing sounds a bit jealous and territorial if you ask me

stupidpoopoohead00

im lowkey skeptical about her saying any of this. seems all we have abt her is what he says and he clearly has feelings for OP

Necessary_Tap343

And OP saying she wasn’t hurt his a very obvious lie.

OOP

I didn’t say no to that. I said no when he asked if I thought he should end things with her.


Icy_Guard_8216

Do you have feelings for him?

OOP

I already answered this in my post. I’ve always seen him as my best friend, nothing more. And I’m the one who suggested putting some boundaries in place once I found out he was seeing someone, because I don’t want our friendship to interfere with his relationship. I don’t think I’d be doing that if I had romantic feelings for him.

Antique_Teaching_333

Or you are trying to protect yourself from becoming more attached as he is seeing someone. I’m not saying you do have feelings, but creating boundaries isn’t necessarily a sign they aren’t there.

Aren’t you hurt he didn’t tell you about her and that he sent the text to begin with because of “her”? Why would it be wrong to go out to dinner with a friend and inviting them over. Why would that be inappropriate if you are just friends?

OOP

I get what you mean, but I wouldn’t say there’s anything inappropriate with two friends going out to dinner or inviting each other over. It’s just different now that I know the woman he’s seeing is uncomfortable with it. At this point, it’s not really about me and him, It’s about being considerate of her feelings. I’m a woman too and if I were in her position, I wouldn’t want another woman knowingly doing something that made me uncomfortable… I don’t have to see things the way she does to respect her feelings.


unzunzhepp

Plot twist: that woman doesn’t exist and he wanted to make you jealous.

OOP

I really hope that’s not the case because I trust him completely. If I found out he made all of this up just to make me jealous, I honestly wouldn’t even know how to process it. I don’t think I could see our friendship the same way again.


Throw_RA099

Just imagine this. We see this kind of post on reddit every day. 

If your friend or his girlfriend came to this sub and posted that you invited your friend out for a 1 v 1 dinner, there would be almost unanimous comments that this kind of things is out of bounds and inappropriate, and that his girlfriend would feel right to be insecure and would be advising her to break up with your friend.

I don’t think you did anything wrong here as it seems that your friend was communicating poorly, but just something to consider and keep in mind moving forward. If you’re going to invite your friend somewhere, invite his SO too.

OOP

I know, but he never told me he’d been seeing someone lately.

 


This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

Please remember to follow the subreddit rules, especially the ones about brigading.

Let’s aim for a respectful and friendly discussion for everyone involved.

0

[Concluded] Neighbors who use you for free childcare [Reddit]

preview

Neighbors who use you for free childcare

I am NOT the Original Poster. That is WineyPrincesss. She posted in r/neighborsfromhell

Thank you to Reddit user u/LucyAriaRose for compiling this and their thanks is: Thanks to u/BakingGiraffeBakes for the rec!

Do NOT comment on Original Posts. Latest update is over 7 days old.

Tap for mood spoiler

happy ending I guess, but confusing, frustrating and weird

Original Post: August 2, 2025

Our new neighbors moved in this past winter, so we’ve known them for maybe three months. At first, everything was great. They seemed friendly, and our kids (along with the other neighborhood kids) got along well. Our neighborhood has this informal setup where the kids “yard hop,” and we all take turns supervising. It’s been a really fun, communal vibe…until recently. The dynamic completely changed when the wife returned to work from maternity leave. It became immediately clear that the husband cannot handle both of their kids on his own, especially their older child (age 4).

Here’s what keeps happening: within minutes of getting home, he finds whatever neighbor child is outside and dumps his 4-year-old with them — no heads-up, no check-in with the adult at home, no offer to return shortly or hang around. He’ll say something vague like “I need to check on the baby” and then disappear for 1–2 hours.

I’m not exaggerating. He’s literally opened my closed backyard gate, sent his child in, and walked past me on the porch without saying a single word — leaving me to supervise without ever asking if that’s okay. My problem with this is that their child isn’t self-sufficient like the other neighborhood kids. They still need help using the bathroom, getting dressed, eating snacks, riding a bike, etc. I don’t mind helping kids in general — but helping someone else’s 4-year-old with personal care like bathroom use or dressing? That crosses a line IMO. Still, the dad acts like I’m just expected to do it. He’s told his child to go inside MY house to get a snack or use the bathroom, saying I’LL help, again, without asking. (I’ve started telling them to go find their dad if they need these things—I can be passive aggressive too, dude).

That’s not even the half of it. The parents regularly invite themselves over. They help themselves to food and drinks from our patio during our family pool nights (Fridays are kind of our thing with pizza and swimming). I explained multiple times that it’s a potluck-style situation and everyone brings something, but they continue to show up empty-handed and eat whatever’s available.

And the pool situation? Every single time we swim, they send their child over in a swimsuit. No asking. No checking if it’s okay. They just open the gate and in their child comes. We’ve sent them back to get an adult, but when the dad finally does show up, he plops on a deck chair, stares at his phone, and still doesn’t watch. Meanwhile, their child needs constant assistance in the pool, which makes it impossible for us to properly supervise our own slightly older (but still non-touching) kids. Our kids can swim without floaties and need close supervision as well, but their kid is hanging all over us demanding our undivided attention the entire time.

We’ve tried setting firm limits, like saying “no swimming today” when we’re hosting a family-only event. Their child throws a huge meltdown. And suddenly we’re the villains for not letting someone else’s kid crash our pool party.

I’m exhausted. I didn’t sign up to be their free babysitter, lifeguard, snack provider, and summer camp coordinator. My subtle boundary-setting has been completely ignored. I’ve tried being polite, but it’s not working. I don’t want to cause drama or burn bridges. They’re going to be here long-term and our kids will likely go to school together. But I now hide inside when they’re outside because I just can’t deal with them anymore and my summer is being tainted because they have no boundaries.

Has anyone else dealt with this? How do I set stronger boundaries without creating a huge neighborhood feud?

Edit: Our pool is locked at all times unless we are in it. When I say gate it means our yard gate not the pool gate, it seems that part was confusing. We always lock our pool!

Some of OOP’s Comments:

Glittering-Set-2510: Talk to the wife, Does she know her husband is dumping the 4yo on you?

OOP: Doubt it, she works 12 hour shifts and is exhausted when she gets home. I don’t see much of her until the weekend. I don’t know how to approach it tbh.

Knitsanity: (Top Comment) I am sorry but this whole situation hinges completely and utterly on you. You need to say no. You need to take the kid back to Dad every time. You need to put a lock on your gate.

You are old enough to have a house and children. Use your words. Do you really care if the moochers are mad at you? Are any of the other neighbors tired of being used?

The wandering in on Friday empty handed? No way.

OOP: We’ve talked to a few other neighbors and they are annoyed he disappears for hours and their kid is at their house need all this extra attention. They don’t have the pool issues because we’re the only one with a pool.
I’ve started saying no, thought I made that clear in my post but thanks for your very kind words. This went on for about a month until I started to shut it down. But it isn’t the KID’S fault and they shouldn’t be shunned or not able to play because their dad can’t be a parent for a few hours after work. I’m not cool with punishing a kid for their parent’s choices. So when they need help, I send them to their dad. Period.

In response to a longer Comment:

lol my parents said to lock the gate too, it’s wrought iron so I’d have to get a padlock for it. Not against the idea but don’t know if I’m ready for that level of petty but I’m here for it in the future!
Love how you worded the feedback for the parents. Putting that in my back pocket for sure! I don’t have their email but I guess I could text the wife that. I want it to seem natural and not out of the blue so I’ll waiting for the next time we swim, which will probably be later today or tomorrow!

OOP adds:

We have backyard camera and lock is on pool at all times.

Where they live:

We 100% live in the Midwest, we grew up around here and the neighborhood dynamic (yard hopping) is what kids do. It’s wild to me the people that are appalled by this because this is the norm where I’m from. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Mini Update Comment: August 3, 2025 (Next Day)

They f’d off this weekend thank goodness. We’ve been swimming all day! I’m looking forward to them coming home and me telling them it’s a family day and they can’t. That’s my new answer every time now. Also considering a privacy fence for next summer.

Mini Update Comment: August 21, 2025 (19 days from OG post)

Any update?

Not much, really. The neighbor husband finally upset my husband enough to cut relationship ties (that’s a whole other loooong story). We’re cordial with them but every time they ask to swim our answer is either not today or we invite family over and say it wouldn’t be appropriate for them to crash. The past few weeks we’ve either been out of town or they have so we haven’t had much chance to confront anyone, I don’t think it’s necessary at this point tbh. They seem to have gotten the message since they royally pissed my husband off and have backed off a lot since then.

I was supposed to have a “play date” with just the wife and was planning on talking to her then but she canceled last minute and we haven’t rescheduled. (The play date was her idea, I was confused as to why a scheduled play date was necessary when my kids are always outside and she can just send her kid out to play too but whatever)

So unfortunately, no drama (yet). We always have a bit showing for Halloween in our neighborhood and my family basically tailgates in our garage as we pass out candy, I’m interested to see if they try to crash it (which the answer will be no). Hopefully my rbf and our lack of being overly friendly gives them a “f off” vibe by then. Knowing her, she’ll passive aggressively text me if something is wrong before then and this time I won’t hold back.

Stay tuned. I’ll update if anything happens.

Mini Update Update: October 10, 2025 (2 months from OG post)

No dramatic update unfortunately. We stopped having them over and told them no when they’d ask to swim. I’d send their kid back if they asked for help with something or needed anything. The message seemed to be received that we were done with their bs and we basically ignored each other for months. They barely came outside during that period of time so it wasn’t like we went out of our way to ignore them, we’d wave but that’s it.

I just had my first cordial conversation with them over the weekend, actually. I hadn’t spoken more than a “hello” to them since August prior to that. With our pool now closed, my point of contention with them has eased but it took time for me to be even friendly towards them again. The wife got a new job where she’s home earlier so that helped with the dad problem. They are definitely people that use others for their own advantage and I see that now, won’t be sucked into that again next summer.

Update Post: July 15, 2026 (Just shy of 1 year from OG post)

It’s been a year and I am happy to say the neighbors finally got the hint! (Kind of, it took some time and not so subtle f-off vibes)

It all really came to a head in October, Halloween, specifically. Halloween is always a big event at our house. My family comes over to pass out candy, and cousins join us for trick-or-treating, so there are always a lot of people, food, and chaos.

The neighbors came over completely uninvited. The husband said his kid wanted to say hi. Fine, whatever. I turned around and caught him helping himself to the pizza on our food table, feeding not only his kid but himself. I was already in a terrible mood for unrelated reasons, so I sarcastically said, “Make yourself at home, why don’t you?” He left shortly after, but then the wife wandered over…and started eating our food too! That was it, I was done. You show up to a family gathering you weren’t invited to and then start eating someone else’s food? Who does that?

Fast forward to early May. After months of zero contact and absolutely no effort on our part to be friendly, I was in the backyard alone with my kids. My husband’s hobby keeps him away most Sunday afternoons, and my neighbors know that. The kids were playing while I was doing work related things on my laptop at the patio table. Our yards are separated by 4-foot fences because of city ordinances, so I could see the rude neighbors in their yard as well.

I loudly reminded my kids they needed to stay in our yard because I had to get dinner started soon and wanted to keep an eye on them. Not even two minutes later, I looked up and saw the husband…standing in my backyard. He had simply opened our fence gate and walked in with his kid.

No “Hi.” No “Is this okay?” Nothing.

He just stood there about three feet away from me while his kid played. I was completely speechless and incredibly uncomfortable. I didn’t like that this man felt comfortable enough to walk in a person’s yard uninvited. One who knew my husband wasn’t home, he never does this crap when my husband is there, or at least isn’t so creepy about it. Thankfully, my youngest got hurt after about three minutes and came crying over to me. They left shortly afterward, and my husband got home not long after that. The first thing I told him was to bungee our fence gate shut on their side. We can’t permanently lock the gate because our fertilizer company comes whenever they feel like it without giving us any notice, but a bungee cord does the job well enough.

The following Sunday, he tried it again. He walked over to the gate, stopped when he saw the bungee cord, and then turned around. Instead, he took his kid to the front of the house, and the whole family went for a walk. I was left in peace and he hasn’t tried it since!

About a week later, the wife texted asking if I’d like to meet for coffee soon. I politely declined meeting somewhere and told her that if there was something she wanted to chat about, we could just have coffee in our own backyards.

I immediately told my husband, “Pool season is coming. I bet she suddenly wants to be friends so we’ll invite them over to swim.” She never followed up. Never came over. Never tried to have the conversation. I’m outside with the kids every single day, there’s been plenty of opportunities to chat. She just gets out of her car and goes inside her house without saying anything. Fine with me.

Honestly, I’m not interested in hearing whatever she had to say, so I let it go and put the ball in her court.

She’s only reached out one other time since. It started with, “How are you guys doing with this heat wave?” small talk and quickly turned into, “Can I ask you for a favor?” It wasn’t anything but texting her some school information, but I should’ve seen that coming.

They’re users. They only invest in relationships when there’s something in it for them. That isn’t going to be us. They only want the “it takes a village” community if they benefit from it, not contributing anything at all on their end.

Now we’re in the pool almost every day. They either close their blinds whenever we’re outside or come out to water their plants while glaring at us the entire time.

I don’t care anymore about being neighborly to them. There was a point where we seriously considered moving because I dreaded what our future summers would be like. Then we decided we weren’t going to spend our summer living in fear of our neighbors. Turns out…they’ve done nothing.

My favorite part, though?

They bungeed their gate too.

Bro…we’re not the ones walking into other people’s backyards uninvited. Is that supposed to send us a message? It makes me laugh every time I go water the plants on that side of the yard. 😂

So that’s the one-year update.

For now, it seems the message has finally been received and I can relax in my yard in peace. I’m not dumb, though, summer isn’t over and I’m keeping my head on a swivel.

Some of OOP’s Comments:

More clarification because there were so many comments:

We have an above ground pool with a locked gate. My 4 foot fence is my yard fence, not pool fence.
Our yard and pool are code complaint. 😊
To another commenter:
I merely mentioned the fact that our fence was 4 foot tall to emphasize the fact that we can see our neighbors every time we’re outside and vice versa. Thank you for your concern but we passed all code inspections for our set up.
To another commenter:
City code doesn’t allow for 6ft fences in my town, unfortunately. Price is not the problem, ordinance is. I would happily pay for it if we could!

KnownBodybuilder4948: I’d plant some nice landscape screening along that common fence line. Fast-growing lilac bushes, dwarf fruit trees, whatever.

OOP: Thank you! We talked about this! There’s some sort of arborvitae species that grows fast that we’ve talked about planting as well. It’s on the list! ☺️
OOP adds:
We’ve also joked about putting an addition on that side of the yard. A 4 seasons room or something to block their view of the patio area at least. Ideas are brewing over here!

-DeathBySnuSnu-: What does the dynamic look like with the other neighbors now?
Do you still kinda rotate watching each other’s kids? Or is that kinda ruined now because you don’t want to encourage the hell neighbor to drop their kid off too?

OOP: The only mom that still talks to them is across the street but she has ties to the schools here and feels she has to be nice for her job (her words). I get it, that would suck. The other kids in the neighborhood are 3-5 years older than their kids and don’t care much because their kids are much younger. My kids play with their kids occasionally in the front yard but they honestly never come outside anymore.
The yard hopping still happens but it is much less than last year which is a bummer. The kids are also older and ride their bikes to other streets to see their friends now, or are in summer programs/sports so that plays into it too.

b7lasagne: *(heavily downvoted- I’m including because of OOP’s responses)*The problem is you women communicate with hints. Fuck that. Say what you want to say.

OOP: And as women we have to be careful what we say and who we say it to. We never know how you men will react to our precious feelings. Should I have screamed at a man who is much larger than me standing in my yard uninvited when my husband wasn’t home and he knew it? Smh, you don’t think about this stuff but we do. All the time because that’s how we have to think.

b7lasagne: You neednt get into a physical nor screaming match. A simple excuse me i dont appreciate you walking into our yard uninvited would suffice

OOP: I explained to a previous poster I was so flabbergasted that he was in my yard in the first place, it took some time to properly formulate words so they wouldn’t have come out sarcastic or with an impatient (or outright mean) tone because that’s how done I was with him at that point. My kid then got hurt and the moment was over and they left while I was consoling my child.
It’s easy for you to analyze from the outside, not so simple to do in that moment, which was a total of 2-3 whole minutes. But before you come at me with the “you women” comments, please think about how that would look or feel from a woman’s perspective. I’m a small woman who has been raised in a world where we have to be careful around men because you don’t know how they’ll react to the word “no”.

Top Comment:

Coquitlam444: Of course they bungeed their gate too 🤦‍♀️

Neighbors who use you for free childcare

I am NOT the Original Poster. That is WineyPrincesss. She posted in r/neighborsfromhell

Thank you to Reddit user u/LucyAriaRose for compiling this and their thanks is: Thanks to u/BakingGiraffeBakes for the rec!

Do NOT comment on Original Posts. Latest update is over 7 days old.

Tap for mood spoiler

happy ending I guess, but confusing, frustrating and weird

Original Post: August 2, 2025

Our new neighbors moved in this past winter, so we’ve known them for maybe three months. At first, everything was great. They seemed friendly, and our kids (along with the other neighborhood kids) got along well. Our neighborhood has this informal setup where the kids “yard hop,” and we all take turns supervising. It’s been a really fun, communal vibe…until recently. The dynamic completely changed when the wife returned to work from maternity leave. It became immediately clear that the husband cannot handle both of their kids on his own, especially their older child (age 4).

Here’s what keeps happening: within minutes of getting home, he finds whatever neighbor child is outside and dumps his 4-year-old with them — no heads-up, no check-in with the adult at home, no offer to return shortly or hang around. He’ll say something vague like “I need to check on the baby” and then disappear for 1–2 hours.

I’m not exaggerating. He’s literally opened my closed backyard gate, sent his child in, and walked past me on the porch without saying a single word — leaving me to supervise without ever asking if that’s okay. My problem with this is that their child isn’t self-sufficient like the other neighborhood kids. They still need help using the bathroom, getting dressed, eating snacks, riding a bike, etc. I don’t mind helping kids in general — but helping someone else’s 4-year-old with personal care like bathroom use or dressing? That crosses a line IMO. Still, the dad acts like I’m just expected to do it. He’s told his child to go inside MY house to get a snack or use the bathroom, saying I’LL help, again, without asking. (I’ve started telling them to go find their dad if they need these things—I can be passive aggressive too, dude).

That’s not even the half of it. The parents regularly invite themselves over. They help themselves to food and drinks from our patio during our family pool nights (Fridays are kind of our thing with pizza and swimming). I explained multiple times that it’s a potluck-style situation and everyone brings something, but they continue to show up empty-handed and eat whatever’s available.

And the pool situation? Every single time we swim, they send their child over in a swimsuit. No asking. No checking if it’s okay. They just open the gate and in their child comes. We’ve sent them back to get an adult, but when the dad finally does show up, he plops on a deck chair, stares at his phone, and still doesn’t watch. Meanwhile, their child needs constant assistance in the pool, which makes it impossible for us to properly supervise our own slightly older (but still non-touching) kids. Our kids can swim without floaties and need close supervision as well, but their kid is hanging all over us demanding our undivided attention the entire time.

We’ve tried setting firm limits, like saying “no swimming today” when we’re hosting a family-only event. Their child throws a huge meltdown. And suddenly we’re the villains for not letting someone else’s kid crash our pool party.

I’m exhausted. I didn’t sign up to be their free babysitter, lifeguard, snack provider, and summer camp coordinator. My subtle boundary-setting has been completely ignored. I’ve tried being polite, but it’s not working. I don’t want to cause drama or burn bridges. They’re going to be here long-term and our kids will likely go to school together. But I now hide inside when they’re outside because I just can’t deal with them anymore and my summer is being tainted because they have no boundaries.

Has anyone else dealt with this? How do I set stronger boundaries without creating a huge neighborhood feud?

Edit: Our pool is locked at all times unless we are in it. When I say gate it means our yard gate not the pool gate, it seems that part was confusing. We always lock our pool!

Some of OOP’s Comments:

Glittering-Set-2510: Talk to the wife, Does she know her husband is dumping the 4yo on you?

OOP: Doubt it, she works 12 hour shifts and is exhausted when she gets home. I don’t see much of her until the weekend. I don’t know how to approach it tbh.

Knitsanity: (Top Comment) I am sorry but this whole situation hinges completely and utterly on you. You need to say no. You need to take the kid back to Dad every time. You need to put a lock on your gate.

You are old enough to have a house and children. Use your words. Do you really care if the moochers are mad at you? Are any of the other neighbors tired of being used?

The wandering in on Friday empty handed? No way.

OOP: We’ve talked to a few other neighbors and they are annoyed he disappears for hours and their kid is at their house need all this extra attention. They don’t have the pool issues because we’re the only one with a pool.
I’ve started saying no, thought I made that clear in my post but thanks for your very kind words. This went on for about a month until I started to shut it down. But it isn’t the KID’S fault and they shouldn’t be shunned or not able to play because their dad can’t be a parent for a few hours after work. I’m not cool with punishing a kid for their parent’s choices. So when they need help, I send them to their dad. Period.

In response to a longer Comment:

lol my parents said to lock the gate too, it’s wrought iron so I’d have to get a padlock for it. Not against the idea but don’t know if I’m ready for that level of petty but I’m here for it in the future!
Love how you worded the feedback for the parents. Putting that in my back pocket for sure! I don’t have their email but I guess I could text the wife that. I want it to seem natural and not out of the blue so I’ll waiting for the next time we swim, which will probably be later today or tomorrow!

OOP adds:

We have backyard camera and lock is on pool at all times.

Where they live:

We 100% live in the Midwest, we grew up around here and the neighborhood dynamic (yard hopping) is what kids do. It’s wild to me the people that are appalled by this because this is the norm where I’m from. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Mini Update Comment: August 3, 2025 (Next Day)

They f’d off this weekend thank goodness. We’ve been swimming all day! I’m looking forward to them coming home and me telling them it’s a family day and they can’t. That’s my new answer every time now. Also considering a privacy fence for next summer.

Mini Update Comment: August 21, 2025 (19 days from OG post)

Any update?

Not much, really. The neighbor husband finally upset my husband enough to cut relationship ties (that’s a whole other loooong story). We’re cordial with them but every time they ask to swim our answer is either not today or we invite family over and say it wouldn’t be appropriate for them to crash. The past few weeks we’ve either been out of town or they have so we haven’t had much chance to confront anyone, I don’t think it’s necessary at this point tbh. They seem to have gotten the message since they royally pissed my husband off and have backed off a lot since then.

I was supposed to have a “play date” with just the wife and was planning on talking to her then but she canceled last minute and we haven’t rescheduled. (The play date was her idea, I was confused as to why a scheduled play date was necessary when my kids are always outside and she can just send her kid out to play too but whatever)

So unfortunately, no drama (yet). We always have a bit showing for Halloween in our neighborhood and my family basically tailgates in our garage as we pass out candy, I’m interested to see if they try to crash it (which the answer will be no). Hopefully my rbf and our lack of being overly friendly gives them a “f off” vibe by then. Knowing her, she’ll passive aggressively text me if something is wrong before then and this time I won’t hold back.

Stay tuned. I’ll update if anything happens.

Mini Update Update: October 10, 2025 (2 months from OG post)

No dramatic update unfortunately. We stopped having them over and told them no when they’d ask to swim. I’d send their kid back if they asked for help with something or needed anything. The message seemed to be received that we were done with their bs and we basically ignored each other for months. They barely came outside during that period of time so it wasn’t like we went out of our way to ignore them, we’d wave but that’s it.

I just had my first cordial conversation with them over the weekend, actually. I hadn’t spoken more than a “hello” to them since August prior to that. With our pool now closed, my point of contention with them has eased but it took time for me to be even friendly towards them again. The wife got a new job where she’s home earlier so that helped with the dad problem. They are definitely people that use others for their own advantage and I see that now, won’t be sucked into that again next summer.

Update Post: July 15, 2026 (Just shy of 1 year from OG post)

It’s been a year and I am happy to say the neighbors finally got the hint! (Kind of, it took some time and not so subtle f-off vibes)

It all really came to a head in October, Halloween, specifically. Halloween is always a big event at our house. My family comes over to pass out candy, and cousins join us for trick-or-treating, so there are always a lot of people, food, and chaos.

The neighbors came over completely uninvited. The husband said his kid wanted to say hi. Fine, whatever. I turned around and caught him helping himself to the pizza on our food table, feeding not only his kid but himself. I was already in a terrible mood for unrelated reasons, so I sarcastically said, “Make yourself at home, why don’t you?” He left shortly after, but then the wife wandered over…and started eating our food too! That was it, I was done. You show up to a family gathering you weren’t invited to and then start eating someone else’s food? Who does that?

Fast forward to early May. After months of zero contact and absolutely no effort on our part to be friendly, I was in the backyard alone with my kids. My husband’s hobby keeps him away most Sunday afternoons, and my neighbors know that. The kids were playing while I was doing work related things on my laptop at the patio table. Our yards are separated by 4-foot fences because of city ordinances, so I could see the rude neighbors in their yard as well.

I loudly reminded my kids they needed to stay in our yard because I had to get dinner started soon and wanted to keep an eye on them. Not even two minutes later, I looked up and saw the husband…standing in my backyard. He had simply opened our fence gate and walked in with his kid.

No “Hi.” No “Is this okay?” Nothing.

He just stood there about three feet away from me while his kid played. I was completely speechless and incredibly uncomfortable. I didn’t like that this man felt comfortable enough to walk in a person’s yard uninvited. One who knew my husband wasn’t home, he never does this crap when my husband is there, or at least isn’t so creepy about it. Thankfully, my youngest got hurt after about three minutes and came crying over to me. They left shortly afterward, and my husband got home not long after that. The first thing I told him was to bungee our fence gate shut on their side. We can’t permanently lock the gate because our fertilizer company comes whenever they feel like it without giving us any notice, but a bungee cord does the job well enough.

The following Sunday, he tried it again. He walked over to the gate, stopped when he saw the bungee cord, and then turned around. Instead, he took his kid to the front of the house, and the whole family went for a walk. I was left in peace and he hasn’t tried it since!

About a week later, the wife texted asking if I’d like to meet for coffee soon. I politely declined meeting somewhere and told her that if there was something she wanted to chat about, we could just have coffee in our own backyards.

I immediately told my husband, “Pool season is coming. I bet she suddenly wants to be friends so we’ll invite them over to swim.” She never followed up. Never came over. Never tried to have the conversation. I’m outside with the kids every single day, there’s been plenty of opportunities to chat. She just gets out of her car and goes inside her house without saying anything. Fine with me.

Honestly, I’m not interested in hearing whatever she had to say, so I let it go and put the ball in her court.

She’s only reached out one other time since. It started with, “How are you guys doing with this heat wave?” small talk and quickly turned into, “Can I ask you for a favor?” It wasn’t anything but texting her some school information, but I should’ve seen that coming.

They’re users. They only invest in relationships when there’s something in it for them. That isn’t going to be us. They only want the “it takes a village” community if they benefit from it, not contributing anything at all on their end.

Now we’re in the pool almost every day. They either close their blinds whenever we’re outside or come out to water their plants while glaring at us the entire time.

I don’t care anymore about being neighborly to them. There was a point where we seriously considered moving because I dreaded what our future summers would be like. Then we decided we weren’t going to spend our summer living in fear of our neighbors. Turns out…they’ve done nothing.

My favorite part, though?

They bungeed their gate too.

Bro…we’re not the ones walking into other people’s backyards uninvited. Is that supposed to send us a message? It makes me laugh every time I go water the plants on that side of the yard. 😂

So that’s the one-year update.

For now, it seems the message has finally been received and I can relax in my yard in peace. I’m not dumb, though, summer isn’t over and I’m keeping my head on a swivel.

Some of OOP’s Comments:

More clarification because there were so many comments:

We have an above ground pool with a locked gate. My 4 foot fence is my yard fence, not pool fence.
Our yard and pool are code complaint. 😊
To another commenter:
I merely mentioned the fact that our fence was 4 foot tall to emphasize the fact that we can see our neighbors every time we’re outside and vice versa. Thank you for your concern but we passed all code inspections for our set up.
To another commenter:
City code doesn’t allow for 6ft fences in my town, unfortunately. Price is not the problem, ordinance is. I would happily pay for it if we could!

KnownBodybuilder4948: I’d plant some nice landscape screening along that common fence line. Fast-growing lilac bushes, dwarf fruit trees, whatever.

OOP: Thank you! We talked about this! There’s some sort of arborvitae species that grows fast that we’ve talked about planting as well. It’s on the list! ☺️
OOP adds:
We’ve also joked about putting an addition on that side of the yard. A 4 seasons room or something to block their view of the patio area at least. Ideas are brewing over here!

-DeathBySnuSnu-: What does the dynamic look like with the other neighbors now?
Do you still kinda rotate watching each other’s kids? Or is that kinda ruined now because you don’t want to encourage the hell neighbor to drop their kid off too?

OOP: The only mom that still talks to them is across the street but she has ties to the schools here and feels she has to be nice for her job (her words). I get it, that would suck. The other kids in the neighborhood are 3-5 years older than their kids and don’t care much because their kids are much younger. My kids play with their kids occasionally in the front yard but they honestly never come outside anymore.
The yard hopping still happens but it is much less than last year which is a bummer. The kids are also older and ride their bikes to other streets to see their friends now, or are in summer programs/sports so that plays into it too.

b7lasagne: *(heavily downvoted- I’m including because of OOP’s responses)*The problem is you women communicate with hints. Fuck that. Say what you want to say.

OOP: And as women we have to be careful what we say and who we say it to. We never know how you men will react to our precious feelings. Should I have screamed at a man who is much larger than me standing in my yard uninvited when my husband wasn’t home and he knew it? Smh, you don’t think about this stuff but we do. All the time because that’s how we have to think.

b7lasagne: You neednt get into a physical nor screaming match. A simple excuse me i dont appreciate you walking into our yard uninvited would suffice

OOP: I explained to a previous poster I was so flabbergasted that he was in my yard in the first place, it took some time to properly formulate words so they wouldn’t have come out sarcastic or with an impatient (or outright mean) tone because that’s how done I was with him at that point. My kid then got hurt and the moment was over and they left while I was consoling my child.
It’s easy for you to analyze from the outside, not so simple to do in that moment, which was a total of 2-3 whole minutes. But before you come at me with the “you women” comments, please think about how that would look or feel from a woman’s perspective. I’m a small woman who has been raised in a world where we have to be careful around men because you don’t know how they’ll react to the word “no”.

Top Comment:

Coquitlam444: Of course they bungeed their gate too 🤦‍♀️

0

[Concluded for now] Ex wants to take our child abroad. I am not comfortable with the location they have chosen. [Reddit]

preview

Title: Ex wants to take our child abroad. I am not comfortable with the location they have chosen.

I am NOT OP. OP is u/own-county-569 and thank you to Reddit user u/sharkeva for putting this together

Originally Posted to: Reddit’s r/legaladviceuk Jul 26, 2026**

Trigger Warning

Possible child abduction

Original Post: Jul 26, 2026

Ex wants to take our child abroad with their new partner. Child is 11.

I have never objected to any holidays preciously, but the locations involved in this holiday are making me extremely concerned as a parent.

Am I able to block our child from leaving?

I currently have her passport, but my ex and her new partner are demanding I turn it over on Tuesday evening. I do not wish to do so unless the holiday locations are changed to somewhere in Europe or another MEDC.


Relevant Comments:

Commenter 1: Where do they want to take them? You would extremely convincing grounds that it is not in the child’s best interest for the courts to stop it.

Are there any court orders in place already?

OP’s Response:

They’ll be flying to Pakistan.

My concerns are twogold. Firstly about the ongoing war and border skirmishes with Taliban

The place they are visiting is his home city which is near the Afghan border.

Secondly I’m also concerned about my daughter’s general safety there.

I wouldnt mind if they went to USA, Canada, New Zealand, China, EU, Japan etc.

I just don’t want them going to somewhere unstable and potentially dangerous. I’d also object to Ukraine etc.

Commenter 2: Hi OP as a person of South Asian descent I implore u to not let your daughter go to Pakistan. Your daughter and your ex are not of Pakistani origin, do not have any family based there and have no support system there whatsoever if anything goes wrong. There is no valid reason for your daughter to be going. (Same goes for your ex as this isn’t a holiday resort like destination) I assume your ex’s partner is Pakistani or is of Pakistani origin. Do you actually know anything about him? What’s the purpose of the visit? If your ex getting married to her partner?

FCDO advises against travelling www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/pakistan

Next the area your ex and her current partner is next to Afghanistan and not considered a safe place to be. Your daughter and your ex run the risk of getting kidnapped/held to ransom/being sold into slavery/be victim to forced child marriage.

Also if exs new partner decides they are all staying there(even if it’s against your ex’s wishes there is little that anyone can do)

Do not hand over the passport. Please contact the passport advice line. Speak to your MP. I implore you not to relent on this as your daughters safety is on the line.


Update: Jul 26, 2026

6 Hours Later

I’ve hidden the passport at a secure location. I’ll alert the Home Office on Monday, and I won’t be returning my daughter to my ex on Tuesday. Police are investigating.

Thank you for your advice.

Flights to Pakistan were booked for 2nd August.

I’ve put my foot down and explained that she will not be going.

I’ve hidden the passport at a secure location which isn’t my home. I’ll alert the Home Office on Monday morning to avoid issuing any kind of new passports.

Separately, I have spoken with my daughter. A couple of other issues have emerged including someone who my ex’s partner has been having my daughter chat to online who lives in Pakistan. She said he wanted her to make a friend before she visited. He claims to be 12 in the messages, but there are only large group photos and I cannot verify he is actually a child.

She will not be returned to this man or my ex. Police were contacted on 101 and an officer and a sergeant came out very promptly. They asked to takr my daughter’s phone as evidence, which I agreed to.

I’d like to send a massive thank you to everyone who provided advice.

I’d also like to thank the eight Pakistani women and women of Pakistani heritage who reached out to me to provide cruical context beyond the legal answers. Some of the stories of what you went through were gutwrenching. I appreciate the linking to Karma Nirvana as well, although we do not require their assistance as of yet.

A couple of you also provided me some excellent help and advice and also assisted with the translation of some posts on the social media account of this mysterious “boy” in Pakistan. You helped point out some red flags which I appreciate.

You have all been invaluable. Every single one of you.

Thank you.


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

Title: Ex wants to take our child abroad. I am not comfortable with the location they have chosen.

I am NOT OP. OP is u/own-county-569 and thank you to Reddit user u/sharkeva for putting this together

Originally Posted to: Reddit’s r/legaladviceuk Jul 26, 2026**

Trigger Warning

Possible child abduction

Original Post: Jul 26, 2026

Ex wants to take our child abroad with their new partner. Child is 11.

I have never objected to any holidays preciously, but the locations involved in this holiday are making me extremely concerned as a parent.

Am I able to block our child from leaving?

I currently have her passport, but my ex and her new partner are demanding I turn it over on Tuesday evening. I do not wish to do so unless the holiday locations are changed to somewhere in Europe or another MEDC.


Relevant Comments:

Commenter 1: Where do they want to take them? You would extremely convincing grounds that it is not in the child’s best interest for the courts to stop it.

Are there any court orders in place already?

OP’s Response:

They’ll be flying to Pakistan.

My concerns are twogold. Firstly about the ongoing war and border skirmishes with Taliban

The place they are visiting is his home city which is near the Afghan border.

Secondly I’m also concerned about my daughter’s general safety there.

I wouldnt mind if they went to USA, Canada, New Zealand, China, EU, Japan etc.

I just don’t want them going to somewhere unstable and potentially dangerous. I’d also object to Ukraine etc.

Commenter 2: Hi OP as a person of South Asian descent I implore u to not let your daughter go to Pakistan. Your daughter and your ex are not of Pakistani origin, do not have any family based there and have no support system there whatsoever if anything goes wrong. There is no valid reason for your daughter to be going. (Same goes for your ex as this isn’t a holiday resort like destination) I assume your ex’s partner is Pakistani or is of Pakistani origin. Do you actually know anything about him? What’s the purpose of the visit? If your ex getting married to her partner?

FCDO advises against travelling www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/pakistan

Next the area your ex and her current partner is next to Afghanistan and not considered a safe place to be. Your daughter and your ex run the risk of getting kidnapped/held to ransom/being sold into slavery/be victim to forced child marriage.

Also if exs new partner decides they are all staying there(even if it’s against your ex’s wishes there is little that anyone can do)

Do not hand over the passport. Please contact the passport advice line. Speak to your MP. I implore you not to relent on this as your daughters safety is on the line.


Update: Jul 26, 2026

6 Hours Later

I’ve hidden the passport at a secure location. I’ll alert the Home Office on Monday, and I won’t be returning my daughter to my ex on Tuesday. Police are investigating.

Thank you for your advice.

Flights to Pakistan were booked for 2nd August.

I’ve put my foot down and explained that she will not be going.

I’ve hidden the passport at a secure location which isn’t my home. I’ll alert the Home Office on Monday morning to avoid issuing any kind of new passports.

Separately, I have spoken with my daughter. A couple of other issues have emerged including someone who my ex’s partner has been having my daughter chat to online who lives in Pakistan. She said he wanted her to make a friend before she visited. He claims to be 12 in the messages, but there are only large group photos and I cannot verify he is actually a child.

She will not be returned to this man or my ex. Police were contacted on 101 and an officer and a sergeant came out very promptly. They asked to takr my daughter’s phone as evidence, which I agreed to.

I’d like to send a massive thank you to everyone who provided advice.

I’d also like to thank the eight Pakistani women and women of Pakistani heritage who reached out to me to provide cruical context beyond the legal answers. Some of the stories of what you went through were gutwrenching. I appreciate the linking to Karma Nirvana as well, although we do not require their assistance as of yet.

A couple of you also provided me some excellent help and advice and also assisted with the translation of some posts on the social media account of this mysterious “boy” in Pakistan. You helped point out some red flags which I appreciate.

You have all been invaluable. Every single one of you.

Thank you.


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

0

Community Rules

preview

1. Never Contact the OOP

  • Never contact the OOP for any story that has been posted.
  • The person posting the update is rarely if ever going to be the OOP and will not know the answers to your questions.

2. Be Respectful/No Trolling or Spamming

  • No name calling or starting fights
  • No arguing with others
  • Don’t get baited into a back and forth with another user
  • Bigotry or racism of any kind will not be tolerated
  • No spamming or repetitively posting the same or similar comments/posts.

3. Follow ALL The Rules

4. Posting Rules

  • When posting, follow the posting guidelines. Failure to follow the posting guidelines will result in having your post removed.
  • No repeat posts from the last 4 months, please search to make sure what you’re posting has not been posted recently.
  • Make sure you’re giving credit where credit is required. Some sources do legally require credit like Ask A Manager and Captain Awkward (you can find that in the posting guidelines above).

5. No Self Promotion

  • No selling things
  • No trying to promote your own community or SubReddit
  • No trying to push an agenda on others or convert them to your way of thinking (whether it’s politics, religion or anything else).
  • No trying to take people off site to your own website.
  • Self promotion MIGHT be granted by talking to the mods but truly, there shouldn’t be any reason for it in this community.

You can report any rule breaking by reporting the offending post and a mod will review it as soon as possible.


1. Never Contact the OOP

  • Never contact the OOP for any story that has been posted.
  • The person posting the update is rarely if ever going to be the OOP and will not know the answers to your questions.

2. Be Respectful/No Trolling or Spamming

  • No name calling or starting fights
  • No arguing with others
  • Don’t get baited into a back and forth with another user
  • Bigotry or racism of any kind will not be tolerated
  • No spamming or repetitively posting the same or similar comments/posts.

3. Follow ALL The Rules

4. Posting Rules

  • When posting, follow the posting guidelines. Failure to follow the posting guidelines will result in having your post removed.
  • No repeat posts from the last 4 months, please search to make sure what you’re posting has not been posted recently.
  • Make sure you’re giving credit where credit is required. Some sources do legally require credit like Ask A Manager and Captain Awkward (you can find that in the posting guidelines above).

5. No Self Promotion

  • No selling things
  • No trying to promote your own community or SubReddit
  • No trying to push an agenda on others or convert them to your way of thinking (whether it’s politics, religion or anything else).
  • No trying to take people off site to your own website.
  • Self promotion MIGHT be granted by talking to the mods but truly, there shouldn’t be any reason for it in this community.

You can report any rule breaking by reporting the offending post and a mod will review it as soon as possible.


0

[Concluded] I think my professor fucked me up [CA]

CaptainAwkward.com Update: &#8220;I think my professors fucked me up.&#8221; captainawkward.com
preview

I think my professor fucked me up

I am NOT OP.

Originally Posted to: Captain Awkward Dec 20, 2021

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

cult like abuse, mentions of sexual assault, mentions of self harm

Editors Note: Might want to read the trigger warning on this if you think you could at all be triggered. Also added a paragraph break for easier reading.


Original Post: Dec 20, 2021

Dear Captain Awkward,

I am a 25 year old woman about to finish a three-year professional degree. I had a pretty intense undergrad experience. Or, I thought it was intense, but I am starting to think maybe it was worse than just intense, and I don’t know what to do.

From about week 3 of my freshman year at age 19, two professors in my program (married, basically the program’s center of gravity, both regarded nationwide/even internationally as Important Leaders In The Field) adopted me into the fold of their “favorites,” which basically meant “if you do exactly what we say you’ll get one of the best jobs in the country when you graduate.”

They controlled pretty much every hour of my life for two years straight. In week 8 of my freshman year, they told me I couldn’t go home for fall break to visit my parents because of a project they wanted me to work on, and made me convince my dad to drive home without me. They had me come over to their home to work on projects and wouldn’t drive me back to my dorm until late at night. They coerced me into skipping classes so often I had to repeat a class once because my attendance record was so bad. Once I tried to say no to them when they attempted this, and one of them emailed the class’s TA behind my back to tell them I couldn’t come because I had to work on something for him. They made fun of me for going to church until I stopped going. They invented all kinds of scenarios that pitted me against my classmates for no good reason. They told me my parents wouldn’t understand the program and I shouldn’t talk to them so often. They would talk about their best students and how they would work for more than 24 hours straight and how great that dedication was.

They talked me into taking an unpaid internship out of state I couldn’t afford because one of their friends ran the organization. When I mentioned interviewing for an internship at an organization they didn’t have connections to, they told me they knew somebody who worked there who said she wanted to kill herself after five years in the job. They created arbitrary deadlines I’d have to drop everything to meet and then say that we actually had months to work on it anyway. I wasn’t getting credit or pay for a lot of my projects. I got about four hours of sleep a night for two years straight. After a year of that my thyroid failed and I gained a bunch of weight and my hair started falling out and I stopped having a period. One of their other students sexually assaulted me at the end of my sophomore year and I reported it (and that was a whole other nightmare, the university admin tried to get me to either shut up about it or drop out) and those two professors never spoke to me again.

But they loved me and cared about me. They fought for me at every turn when they could. They gave me opportunities I never could have imagined, and they encouraged me, and told me I was talented, and acted as mentors and parent figures when I was isolated from my own family. They put in good words for me with organizations and introduced me to powerful people in the field and entered my work in contests that won me thousands of dollars. And lots of their other students still basically worship them – they got almost every graduate of that program with a job in that field their job – so it seems like maybe I’m overreacting. Whenever I worried about whether I was cut out for the work or if I should leave the field, they were so quick to assure me I had a place no matter how I was feeling and that my work was important. They gave me space to rest when it all got too intense. They wanted me to succeed. I wanted and still want them to be so proud of me.

But I had to leave it all behind after I was assaulted, and they act like I don’t exist now, and so many people love them, and they didn’t do anything illegal. But I break out in a sweat when I get emails from professors in my graduate program and I’m really scared to even go to office hours and I can’t figure out why. Once a professor at my graduate program said students could call him by his first name and it’s like I physically can’t do it. And whenever I’m not working or if I turn in something a little late I feel like I’m going to be obliterated. And I feel guilty about going to bed before midnight, especially when I usually can’t sleep anyway. I don’t know what’s wrong with me. They gave me every advantage in the world and for some reason I still just couldn’t hack it. Every time I see them promoting the work of current or former students I feel sick. Especially because I’m never among them. I live alone now in a different city but it’s like my head is full of loud static all the time. It was never like that before.

What’s going on? What do I do? I graduate in May and I feel like I’m about an inch from a nervous breakdown I don’t deserve to have. I have no idea how I’m going to perform well in the job I’m supposed to start next September when I can’t even get to all my classes every week because I keep having to throw up in the school bathroom out of anxiety. I’m not even on the same campus I was at in undergrad. Should I tell the school about the kinds of things they say? Every other graduate, at least from when I was there, would tear me down in a heartbeat. I feel like you’re supposed to report teachers who abuse their students but I don’t think that’s what happened to me. What would I say? They had high expectations and I took it all too seriously. I tried to read about abusive relationships online but everything was about sexual abuse or domestic violence, so maybe this wasn’t that bad. I know this is way more than 400 words but it’s like I sat down to ask a question and all of this came out of me at once.

– Burned out before I even got a real job


Update #1: Jan 31, 2023

I have wanted to write in with an update for a little while now, and now I can, because I finally got this news I was waiting for: Today I found out I passed my state’s bar exam!

My life has changed so much since I wrote in last fall. I graduated from law school. I took the bar exam. I moved back to my hometown, into my own apartment. I started my first job as a lawyer, as a professional instead of a student.

I found a therapist who taught me how to set reasonable boundaries and schedules, how to deal with the horrible feelings and memories I couldn’t make sense of. I got diagnosed with PTSD and OCD pretty quickly. I got therapy and meds that helped me feel more even-keeled. I am starting to learn how to stop hurting myself. I found some good doctors, and I got diagnosed with some other chronic physical illnesses that developed, apparently, as a result of truly harmful physical stress on my body for so long. They’re hard to deal with sometimes. But I deal with them. I take my meds, and I try to cook things that are good for me, and I go for long walks and I go to the gym, and I go to bed early, and when I panic I try to just wait it out, and mostly I feel safe.

I got an apartment that’s in my own space but near my parents. I go over to their house for dinner once a week or so. I call my mom to tell her how my days are. I help my dad with projects he’s working on. I listen to REM like he always did when I was a kid. I’m not totally sure about going back to church yet, but I can sit near my window and pray. I have a quiet, clean, perfect little space where I live with my dog. My bed is covered by a quilt my grandmother made me. My boyfriend comes over sometimes (my boyfriend!) and he is solid and steady and kind, and I think that maybe I can still love. Every day I wake up and take my dog outside and look at the river and feel the wind and listen to the geese, and I feel safe.

I got a job where I have my own little office, with a big window and a door that shuts if I need it to, and I get to do what I’ve been trained to do and what I’m really good at now. I work on a small team, and my coworkers are kind and smart and friendly. My boss sends me home if I stay even a few minutes past 5 p.m. He doesn’t call me at weird hours. He doesn’t mind if I have to leave for an appointment during the workday. He doesn’t corner me. He lets me work at my own pace, he lets me work how I like to work. Sometimes people at the office tell me I’ve done a good job on something. I’ve learned that I like to talk to the people I work with; I’ve learned that even when I’m feeling anxious, it’s okay to go to work and sit in my office and focus on breathing and maybe only do a little bit that day. Nobody seems to mind. My boss makes me laugh, I think because he’s trying to get me to chill out a little bit, and I feel safe.

When I was a kid I begged my parents for horseback riding lessons, which were short-lived but the most free I’ve ever felt. I started riding again — I found a riding club and a family willing to lease me a horse on the weekends. I ride with them on Saturdays, and I bake cinnamon rolls to bring them as a thank you, and I talk to friends from all over, of all different ages and occupations, and I love them. I get to literally gallop across open fields, I get to let it take my breath away, and I feel safe.

Things are still hard. It’s hard to take care of myself sometimes. Some nights I wake up terrified, not breathing. Some days I still can’t call what my professors did “abuse”; some days I still can’t call what that other student did “rape.” Sometimes I’m so furious about what they did to me I think it’ll kill me. But for the most part, that fire in me doesn’t burn me to death. For the most part, it keeps me alive. My friend told me once that I can be like the burning bush: aflame but never consumed. There isn’t really an “old” me to go back to, a version of me from before all of this that I can access. But there is a version of me that gets to choose what she does, and she is choosing to connect with the things she always loved, and she feels safe.

I passed the bar exam, and I’m a lawyer now, and that means the escape plan I set in motion years ago without really knowing why I felt like I had to escape has finally, finally, finally come to pass. I did it. They can never blow my life up ever again. I know what they did to me. I didn’t have any power over it. That hurts. But I get to say what I was made for. I get to say what I do. I don’t know if I’m making all the right choices yet, but I’m the one making the choices. I’m going to bed tonight without something clawing at my chest. Thank you (and Amy) for giving me the words and the tools I needed to make that happen.


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

I think my professor fucked me up

I am NOT OP.

Originally Posted to: Captain Awkward Dec 20, 2021

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

cult like abuse, mentions of sexual assault, mentions of self harm

Editors Note: Might want to read the trigger warning on this if you think you could at all be triggered. Also added a paragraph break for easier reading.


Original Post: Dec 20, 2021

Dear Captain Awkward,

I am a 25 year old woman about to finish a three-year professional degree. I had a pretty intense undergrad experience. Or, I thought it was intense, but I am starting to think maybe it was worse than just intense, and I don’t know what to do.

From about week 3 of my freshman year at age 19, two professors in my program (married, basically the program’s center of gravity, both regarded nationwide/even internationally as Important Leaders In The Field) adopted me into the fold of their “favorites,” which basically meant “if you do exactly what we say you’ll get one of the best jobs in the country when you graduate.”

They controlled pretty much every hour of my life for two years straight. In week 8 of my freshman year, they told me I couldn’t go home for fall break to visit my parents because of a project they wanted me to work on, and made me convince my dad to drive home without me. They had me come over to their home to work on projects and wouldn’t drive me back to my dorm until late at night. They coerced me into skipping classes so often I had to repeat a class once because my attendance record was so bad. Once I tried to say no to them when they attempted this, and one of them emailed the class’s TA behind my back to tell them I couldn’t come because I had to work on something for him. They made fun of me for going to church until I stopped going. They invented all kinds of scenarios that pitted me against my classmates for no good reason. They told me my parents wouldn’t understand the program and I shouldn’t talk to them so often. They would talk about their best students and how they would work for more than 24 hours straight and how great that dedication was.

They talked me into taking an unpaid internship out of state I couldn’t afford because one of their friends ran the organization. When I mentioned interviewing for an internship at an organization they didn’t have connections to, they told me they knew somebody who worked there who said she wanted to kill herself after five years in the job. They created arbitrary deadlines I’d have to drop everything to meet and then say that we actually had months to work on it anyway. I wasn’t getting credit or pay for a lot of my projects. I got about four hours of sleep a night for two years straight. After a year of that my thyroid failed and I gained a bunch of weight and my hair started falling out and I stopped having a period. One of their other students sexually assaulted me at the end of my sophomore year and I reported it (and that was a whole other nightmare, the university admin tried to get me to either shut up about it or drop out) and those two professors never spoke to me again.

But they loved me and cared about me. They fought for me at every turn when they could. They gave me opportunities I never could have imagined, and they encouraged me, and told me I was talented, and acted as mentors and parent figures when I was isolated from my own family. They put in good words for me with organizations and introduced me to powerful people in the field and entered my work in contests that won me thousands of dollars. And lots of their other students still basically worship them – they got almost every graduate of that program with a job in that field their job – so it seems like maybe I’m overreacting. Whenever I worried about whether I was cut out for the work or if I should leave the field, they were so quick to assure me I had a place no matter how I was feeling and that my work was important. They gave me space to rest when it all got too intense. They wanted me to succeed. I wanted and still want them to be so proud of me.

But I had to leave it all behind after I was assaulted, and they act like I don’t exist now, and so many people love them, and they didn’t do anything illegal. But I break out in a sweat when I get emails from professors in my graduate program and I’m really scared to even go to office hours and I can’t figure out why. Once a professor at my graduate program said students could call him by his first name and it’s like I physically can’t do it. And whenever I’m not working or if I turn in something a little late I feel like I’m going to be obliterated. And I feel guilty about going to bed before midnight, especially when I usually can’t sleep anyway. I don’t know what’s wrong with me. They gave me every advantage in the world and for some reason I still just couldn’t hack it. Every time I see them promoting the work of current or former students I feel sick. Especially because I’m never among them. I live alone now in a different city but it’s like my head is full of loud static all the time. It was never like that before.

What’s going on? What do I do? I graduate in May and I feel like I’m about an inch from a nervous breakdown I don’t deserve to have. I have no idea how I’m going to perform well in the job I’m supposed to start next September when I can’t even get to all my classes every week because I keep having to throw up in the school bathroom out of anxiety. I’m not even on the same campus I was at in undergrad. Should I tell the school about the kinds of things they say? Every other graduate, at least from when I was there, would tear me down in a heartbeat. I feel like you’re supposed to report teachers who abuse their students but I don’t think that’s what happened to me. What would I say? They had high expectations and I took it all too seriously. I tried to read about abusive relationships online but everything was about sexual abuse or domestic violence, so maybe this wasn’t that bad. I know this is way more than 400 words but it’s like I sat down to ask a question and all of this came out of me at once.

– Burned out before I even got a real job


Update #1: Jan 31, 2023

I have wanted to write in with an update for a little while now, and now I can, because I finally got this news I was waiting for: Today I found out I passed my state’s bar exam!

My life has changed so much since I wrote in last fall. I graduated from law school. I took the bar exam. I moved back to my hometown, into my own apartment. I started my first job as a lawyer, as a professional instead of a student.

I found a therapist who taught me how to set reasonable boundaries and schedules, how to deal with the horrible feelings and memories I couldn’t make sense of. I got diagnosed with PTSD and OCD pretty quickly. I got therapy and meds that helped me feel more even-keeled. I am starting to learn how to stop hurting myself. I found some good doctors, and I got diagnosed with some other chronic physical illnesses that developed, apparently, as a result of truly harmful physical stress on my body for so long. They’re hard to deal with sometimes. But I deal with them. I take my meds, and I try to cook things that are good for me, and I go for long walks and I go to the gym, and I go to bed early, and when I panic I try to just wait it out, and mostly I feel safe.

I got an apartment that’s in my own space but near my parents. I go over to their house for dinner once a week or so. I call my mom to tell her how my days are. I help my dad with projects he’s working on. I listen to REM like he always did when I was a kid. I’m not totally sure about going back to church yet, but I can sit near my window and pray. I have a quiet, clean, perfect little space where I live with my dog. My bed is covered by a quilt my grandmother made me. My boyfriend comes over sometimes (my boyfriend!) and he is solid and steady and kind, and I think that maybe I can still love. Every day I wake up and take my dog outside and look at the river and feel the wind and listen to the geese, and I feel safe.

I got a job where I have my own little office, with a big window and a door that shuts if I need it to, and I get to do what I’ve been trained to do and what I’m really good at now. I work on a small team, and my coworkers are kind and smart and friendly. My boss sends me home if I stay even a few minutes past 5 p.m. He doesn’t call me at weird hours. He doesn’t mind if I have to leave for an appointment during the workday. He doesn’t corner me. He lets me work at my own pace, he lets me work how I like to work. Sometimes people at the office tell me I’ve done a good job on something. I’ve learned that I like to talk to the people I work with; I’ve learned that even when I’m feeling anxious, it’s okay to go to work and sit in my office and focus on breathing and maybe only do a little bit that day. Nobody seems to mind. My boss makes me laugh, I think because he’s trying to get me to chill out a little bit, and I feel safe.

When I was a kid I begged my parents for horseback riding lessons, which were short-lived but the most free I’ve ever felt. I started riding again — I found a riding club and a family willing to lease me a horse on the weekends. I ride with them on Saturdays, and I bake cinnamon rolls to bring them as a thank you, and I talk to friends from all over, of all different ages and occupations, and I love them. I get to literally gallop across open fields, I get to let it take my breath away, and I feel safe.

Things are still hard. It’s hard to take care of myself sometimes. Some nights I wake up terrified, not breathing. Some days I still can’t call what my professors did “abuse”; some days I still can’t call what that other student did “rape.” Sometimes I’m so furious about what they did to me I think it’ll kill me. But for the most part, that fire in me doesn’t burn me to death. For the most part, it keeps me alive. My friend told me once that I can be like the burning bush: aflame but never consumed. There isn’t really an “old” me to go back to, a version of me from before all of this that I can access. But there is a version of me that gets to choose what she does, and she is choosing to connect with the things she always loved, and she feels safe.

I passed the bar exam, and I’m a lawyer now, and that means the escape plan I set in motion years ago without really knowing why I felt like I had to escape has finally, finally, finally come to pass. I did it. They can never blow my life up ever again. I know what they did to me. I didn’t have any power over it. That hurts. But I get to say what I was made for. I get to say what I do. I don’t know if I’m making all the right choices yet, but I’m the one making the choices. I’m going to bed tonight without something clawing at my chest. Thank you (and Amy) for giving me the words and the tools I needed to make that happen.


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

0

[Concluded] I’m dreading the prospect of a summer houseguest, but I feel like I can’t say no. [CA]

CaptainAwkward.com #564: I&#8217;m dreading the prospect of a summer houseguest, but I feel like I can&#8217;t say no. captainawkward.com
preview

Title: I’m dreading the prospect of a summer houseguest, but I feel like I can’t say no.

Source: Captain Awkward

I am not the original poster

Tap for Trigger Warning

Depression, emotional manipulation, financial struggles, entitlement


Original Post: Apr 24, 2014

Dear Captain,

I have a dilemma. I’ve been having a terrible year in 2014 (and 2013 was pretty shit also!) My husband and I have been having a rocky year in our marriage, I have just started an antidepressant to deal with my ongoing and dangerous depression, we have a $25,000 fee to pay to our condo I still don’t know how we’ll finance, and I have been balancing full-time work and full-time school schedule for nine months. Basically, I’m tired to the bone physically and emotionally.

My husband, Jack, and I are currently in the process of going through some counseling and things on that front seem positive and hopeful. The problem is, he recently asked me if his brother can come stay with us from June to August to work in our town. Jack’s brother, Bill*, along with the rest of his family members, live in a faraway province with little economic action. We live in a booming economy with many jobs, especially in Bill’s area of interest.

I had not been planning to take any courses over the summer and was looking forward to some rare downtime and the chance to recover and feel like myself again. With an air mattress in the basement serving as a “spare room” and only one shower, living area and kitchen, it’s inevitable that Bill would end up encroaching on our space. Although he’s in college now he’s still a teenager, so I’m also concerned about his cleaning ability or lack thereof. Plus, frankly, I just don’t want to deal with a houseguest for the whole summer!

Jack misses his family a great deal. This would be a great chance for him to catch up with his brother and bond, to say nothing of the opportunity for Bill to build work experience in his field. I can’t help but feel like the bad guy if I say no, but I’m already mourning my lost, private summer full of reconnecting with Jack and having plenty of alone time. Should I kibosh the trip and live with the guilt? Say yes and quietly resent every moment? PLEASE SEND HELP.

Yours, Houseguest versus Hag

Note: You can read the reply at the link above.


Update #1: Jan 5, 2017 (~3 years later)

Thank you Captain! LW #564 here. You advised me to have my husband manage some of the tasks and stress associated with a houseguest and looming financial burden. Well, the houseguest did not arrive after all (not due to me, he just decided not to come out). But there’s more good news – reading that list made me realize, on a level where I KIND OF suspected but now REALLY KNEW, that my husband was never going to support me on that level. His favourite thing to do was find fault with me, unless I was being The Cool Wife Who Never Complains (and sometimes even then!) He expected me to achieve his dreams for him at the expense of mine, which would have included figuring out how to move him to a more exotic country while also making sure he never felt the pain of a $25K condo bill.

I ditched him that August, and 2+ years on I’ve never been happier and more self-confident. I have a loving partner who raises me up. I have my own business. I’ve achieved so many of my dreams and proved to myself I wasn’t holding him back from his dreams like he thought – he was holding ME back.

So thank you for everything you do here. This site has been a big part of my healing since I left and built myself up again – and was definitely part of me seeing the problem for what it was in the first place.


Update #2: Jan 5, 2017 (same day ~12 hours later)

I wrote the letter about dreading a summer houseguest (and left an update in the 6th birthday post, but I thought I’d write a better one here.) [OP linked original post]

Feeling like I couldn’t say no turned out to be a recurring theme in my marriage, and though I was very good at rationalizing it, the root cause was actually that my husband expected me to make his life happen for him. Whatever that meant to him at the moment.

For example, he wanted to live as an expat in another country, but he blew off work all the time and spent all his money. Hard to travel without money, right? But the reason we couldn’t go was because of my job and my schoolwork, obviously.

He wanted to be travel guide and have fun all day for a living, but he never found anything local to get experience or settled on a definite where/when to work toward. But the reason this wasn’t going to happen for him is because he was stuck here making money to pay for our house which I wanted. (Spoiler alert: it wasn’t just me!)

He wanted to have sex with other people behind my back because I “never wanted to do it”, but always had an excuse whenever I wanted to be intimate.

He wanted a better job, but he wouldn’t spend time working his way up or go to school to improve his skills. When I went to school (while working full-time) he made all kinds of pouty faces about how long it would take and how it was stopping us from leaving the country.

Can you imagine why I didn’t want to chuck in my life to move to New Zealand so my husband could be a tour guide and I could (??? What I would do was never discussed.)

When Captain suggested I let him take the lead on the $25K condo fee, so I could get a break, I knew instinctively I could not trust him to do that, to take care of me in a meaningful way. He could bring me tea, but only if he could use it as evidence of His Saintly Goodness later. His idea of financial decisions was getting $4,000 into payday loan debt without telling me and then coming to me to pay it off.

Btw, I said no to the payday loans and told him to figure it out, and that was the beginning of the end. He bummed it off an uncle and aunt who thought I was the devil for not saving him from his foolish choices. Then he spent the summer in the basement, getting high and watching TV, while I was the loneliest I have ever been.

And so, I left him. It was hard – I was unemployed at the time and had no guarantee of work, thought I was interviewing. I had to drain my savings and credit to pay 3 months rent in advance on a new place, figure out renting my former home, move, and cross my fingers I would find a new job before I ran against my credit limit.

He went back home to his mother at age 30 and knocked up a girl he’d known for three weeks. He’s never gone anywhere since. The uncle and aunt who loaned him the money have never seen a penny and no longer speak to him.

I found a partner who loves me as I am and raises me up, started my own successful business, travelled to Europe and got a great apartment with a view. I’ve never been happier.

Divorce is final in a couple months. 🙂


Reminder, I am not the OOP. This is a repost community

Do not comment on any linked posts or try to reach out to the OOP!

Title: I’m dreading the prospect of a summer houseguest, but I feel like I can’t say no.

Source: Captain Awkward

I am not the original poster

Tap for Trigger Warning

Depression, emotional manipulation, financial struggles, entitlement


Original Post: Apr 24, 2014

Dear Captain,

I have a dilemma. I’ve been having a terrible year in 2014 (and 2013 was pretty shit also!) My husband and I have been having a rocky year in our marriage, I have just started an antidepressant to deal with my ongoing and dangerous depression, we have a $25,000 fee to pay to our condo I still don’t know how we’ll finance, and I have been balancing full-time work and full-time school schedule for nine months. Basically, I’m tired to the bone physically and emotionally.

My husband, Jack, and I are currently in the process of going through some counseling and things on that front seem positive and hopeful. The problem is, he recently asked me if his brother can come stay with us from June to August to work in our town. Jack’s brother, Bill*, along with the rest of his family members, live in a faraway province with little economic action. We live in a booming economy with many jobs, especially in Bill’s area of interest.

I had not been planning to take any courses over the summer and was looking forward to some rare downtime and the chance to recover and feel like myself again. With an air mattress in the basement serving as a “spare room” and only one shower, living area and kitchen, it’s inevitable that Bill would end up encroaching on our space. Although he’s in college now he’s still a teenager, so I’m also concerned about his cleaning ability or lack thereof. Plus, frankly, I just don’t want to deal with a houseguest for the whole summer!

Jack misses his family a great deal. This would be a great chance for him to catch up with his brother and bond, to say nothing of the opportunity for Bill to build work experience in his field. I can’t help but feel like the bad guy if I say no, but I’m already mourning my lost, private summer full of reconnecting with Jack and having plenty of alone time. Should I kibosh the trip and live with the guilt? Say yes and quietly resent every moment? PLEASE SEND HELP.

Yours, Houseguest versus Hag

Note: You can read the reply at the link above.


Update #1: Jan 5, 2017 (~3 years later)

Thank you Captain! LW #564 here. You advised me to have my husband manage some of the tasks and stress associated with a houseguest and looming financial burden. Well, the houseguest did not arrive after all (not due to me, he just decided not to come out). But there’s more good news – reading that list made me realize, on a level where I KIND OF suspected but now REALLY KNEW, that my husband was never going to support me on that level. His favourite thing to do was find fault with me, unless I was being The Cool Wife Who Never Complains (and sometimes even then!) He expected me to achieve his dreams for him at the expense of mine, which would have included figuring out how to move him to a more exotic country while also making sure he never felt the pain of a $25K condo bill.

I ditched him that August, and 2+ years on I’ve never been happier and more self-confident. I have a loving partner who raises me up. I have my own business. I’ve achieved so many of my dreams and proved to myself I wasn’t holding him back from his dreams like he thought – he was holding ME back.

So thank you for everything you do here. This site has been a big part of my healing since I left and built myself up again – and was definitely part of me seeing the problem for what it was in the first place.


Update #2: Jan 5, 2017 (same day ~12 hours later)

I wrote the letter about dreading a summer houseguest (and left an update in the 6th birthday post, but I thought I’d write a better one here.) [OP linked original post]

Feeling like I couldn’t say no turned out to be a recurring theme in my marriage, and though I was very good at rationalizing it, the root cause was actually that my husband expected me to make his life happen for him. Whatever that meant to him at the moment.

For example, he wanted to live as an expat in another country, but he blew off work all the time and spent all his money. Hard to travel without money, right? But the reason we couldn’t go was because of my job and my schoolwork, obviously.

He wanted to be travel guide and have fun all day for a living, but he never found anything local to get experience or settled on a definite where/when to work toward. But the reason this wasn’t going to happen for him is because he was stuck here making money to pay for our house which I wanted. (Spoiler alert: it wasn’t just me!)

He wanted to have sex with other people behind my back because I “never wanted to do it”, but always had an excuse whenever I wanted to be intimate.

He wanted a better job, but he wouldn’t spend time working his way up or go to school to improve his skills. When I went to school (while working full-time) he made all kinds of pouty faces about how long it would take and how it was stopping us from leaving the country.

Can you imagine why I didn’t want to chuck in my life to move to New Zealand so my husband could be a tour guide and I could (??? What I would do was never discussed.)

When Captain suggested I let him take the lead on the $25K condo fee, so I could get a break, I knew instinctively I could not trust him to do that, to take care of me in a meaningful way. He could bring me tea, but only if he could use it as evidence of His Saintly Goodness later. His idea of financial decisions was getting $4,000 into payday loan debt without telling me and then coming to me to pay it off.

Btw, I said no to the payday loans and told him to figure it out, and that was the beginning of the end. He bummed it off an uncle and aunt who thought I was the devil for not saving him from his foolish choices. Then he spent the summer in the basement, getting high and watching TV, while I was the loneliest I have ever been.

And so, I left him. It was hard – I was unemployed at the time and had no guarantee of work, thought I was interviewing. I had to drain my savings and credit to pay 3 months rent in advance on a new place, figure out renting my former home, move, and cross my fingers I would find a new job before I ran against my credit limit.

He went back home to his mother at age 30 and knocked up a girl he’d known for three weeks. He’s never gone anywhere since. The uncle and aunt who loaned him the money have never seen a penny and no longer speak to him.

I found a partner who loves me as I am and raises me up, started my own successful business, travelled to Europe and got a great apartment with a view. I’ve never been happier.

Divorce is final in a couple months. 🙂


Reminder, I am not the OOP. This is a repost community

Do not comment on any linked posts or try to reach out to the OOP!

0

[Concluded] I was written up for having a visible thong outside of work [AAM]

Ask a Manager I was written up for having a visible thong outside of work www.askamanager.org
preview

Title: I was written up for having a visible thong outside of work

Source: Ask A Manager

I am not the original poster

Tap for Trigger Warning

sexual harassment


Original Post: Nov 5, 2025

In my free time, I love going to this nightclub by my apartment building. They have parties monthly based on different eras such as the 80s, 90s, and the 2000s. In the past year, I have gone to three 2000s parties, and the guests attending are supposed to wear things that represent fashion trends from that decade. All three times, I wore a pair of those ultra low-rise jeans that were so in back then and paired that with a visible thong (whale tail) as this was a trend back then as well. Well, all three times, the photographer at the club asked me to pose for a photo and I agreed. The photos were posted on their website.

I’m not sure how, but somehow HR at my work has found the photos. They called me into their office, showed me the photos, and wrote me up for “behavior that puts the company in a bad light,” as she said. I asked the director of HR if she was sure she was able to do this and she said that at the last management meeting it was discussed and the photos were shown to the management team before this action was taken. She also told me that the write-up and photos would go in my file and that I was not allowed to have a visible thong outside of work.

I have a huge problem with all of this and cannot believe that this has happened. I have had so many thoughts about this: (1) Why was the entire management team, including the men, shown photos of my underwear? (2) Why can I not show my thong at these parties if I want to? (3) Is a visible thong at a nightclub even a big deal or am I crazy? Have they seen what other women wear? (4) Can they write me up for this? (5) How do I get the photos removed from my file? I really don’t want future managers/directors and HR to see my underwear in my employee file for the rest of my time at this workplace!

Note: You can read Alison’s response at the link above. (It’s a good one)


Update: June 15, 2026

I met with HR again and pushed back on the policy. They declined to show me any policy that is even written down except a generic policy that says we cannot engage in highly offensive social media activity. I asked what that has been used for in the past and the only things they could point to were an employee badmouthing the employer and some racist posts. Apparently my thong is at this level of offensiveness.

I then asked them to take the photos out of my personal file and they declined.

In April, a new manager took over my department and made an inappropriate joke about seeing my underwear and winked at me. I went to HR about it and again nothing was done. I did try to make the point about men’s underwear, but they said they haven’t seen any men exposing their underwear who work here and that “men’s underwear isn’t sexualized in the same way.” They then told me they would be keeping track of my internet presence and all concerning photos would be reviewed in management meetings.

At this point, I started looking for a new job. I found one almost right away but they don’t need me to start until mid-June. I gave early notice but with an end date at the end of the first week of June. They told me they wanted me to stay and saw a future, but that if I have this bad of an attitude then I can just leave in June.

At this point, I got really mad. I actually used up a week of vacation days, which they allowed me to do. I decided to have some fun and get revenge if they are so concerned about my underwear. I attended the club five nights that week and each time requested that my photo be taken. I didn’t really care about each night’s theme. But I was photographed with my thong sticking out higher than ever and my jeans frankly lower than ever. I was photographed from my back side in a dress that is sheer at the back, and I wore the tiniest of g-strings. I was also photographed wearing a sheer mesh top with pasties on underneath. The next night I entered a “sexy slip in slide contest” in a very small bikini and was photographed a bunch of times, and the final night I was photographed wearing a top that showed a massive amount of cleavage.

They were indeed keeping track, and they gave me a warning again when I got back. They said they reviewed it at the management meeting again and I told them I didn’t care. The funny part is they still didn’t fire me, as apparently they need me to do some Important work before I go. At least I got my anger out of my system. I cannot understand how unreasonable they are. Just because something is available on the internet doesn’t mean it has anything to do with work. Nobody is going to know where I work anyway, and nobody looks poorly on a company because of stuff like this. My job isn’t sensitive in any way.

Reminder, this is a repost community. I am not the OOP

Title: I was written up for having a visible thong outside of work

Source: Ask A Manager

I am not the original poster

Tap for Trigger Warning

sexual harassment


Original Post: Nov 5, 2025

In my free time, I love going to this nightclub by my apartment building. They have parties monthly based on different eras such as the 80s, 90s, and the 2000s. In the past year, I have gone to three 2000s parties, and the guests attending are supposed to wear things that represent fashion trends from that decade. All three times, I wore a pair of those ultra low-rise jeans that were so in back then and paired that with a visible thong (whale tail) as this was a trend back then as well. Well, all three times, the photographer at the club asked me to pose for a photo and I agreed. The photos were posted on their website.

I’m not sure how, but somehow HR at my work has found the photos. They called me into their office, showed me the photos, and wrote me up for “behavior that puts the company in a bad light,” as she said. I asked the director of HR if she was sure she was able to do this and she said that at the last management meeting it was discussed and the photos were shown to the management team before this action was taken. She also told me that the write-up and photos would go in my file and that I was not allowed to have a visible thong outside of work.

I have a huge problem with all of this and cannot believe that this has happened. I have had so many thoughts about this: (1) Why was the entire management team, including the men, shown photos of my underwear? (2) Why can I not show my thong at these parties if I want to? (3) Is a visible thong at a nightclub even a big deal or am I crazy? Have they seen what other women wear? (4) Can they write me up for this? (5) How do I get the photos removed from my file? I really don’t want future managers/directors and HR to see my underwear in my employee file for the rest of my time at this workplace!

Note: You can read Alison’s response at the link above. (It’s a good one)


Update: June 15, 2026

I met with HR again and pushed back on the policy. They declined to show me any policy that is even written down except a generic policy that says we cannot engage in highly offensive social media activity. I asked what that has been used for in the past and the only things they could point to were an employee badmouthing the employer and some racist posts. Apparently my thong is at this level of offensiveness.

I then asked them to take the photos out of my personal file and they declined.

In April, a new manager took over my department and made an inappropriate joke about seeing my underwear and winked at me. I went to HR about it and again nothing was done. I did try to make the point about men’s underwear, but they said they haven’t seen any men exposing their underwear who work here and that “men’s underwear isn’t sexualized in the same way.” They then told me they would be keeping track of my internet presence and all concerning photos would be reviewed in management meetings.

At this point, I started looking for a new job. I found one almost right away but they don’t need me to start until mid-June. I gave early notice but with an end date at the end of the first week of June. They told me they wanted me to stay and saw a future, but that if I have this bad of an attitude then I can just leave in June.

At this point, I got really mad. I actually used up a week of vacation days, which they allowed me to do. I decided to have some fun and get revenge if they are so concerned about my underwear. I attended the club five nights that week and each time requested that my photo be taken. I didn’t really care about each night’s theme. But I was photographed with my thong sticking out higher than ever and my jeans frankly lower than ever. I was photographed from my back side in a dress that is sheer at the back, and I wore the tiniest of g-strings. I was also photographed wearing a sheer mesh top with pasties on underneath. The next night I entered a “sexy slip in slide contest” in a very small bikini and was photographed a bunch of times, and the final night I was photographed wearing a top that showed a massive amount of cleavage.

They were indeed keeping track, and they gave me a warning again when I got back. They said they reviewed it at the management meeting again and I told them I didn’t care. The funny part is they still didn’t fire me, as apparently they need me to do some Important work before I go. At least I got my anger out of my system. I cannot understand how unreasonable they are. Just because something is available on the internet doesn’t mean it has anything to do with work. Nobody is going to know where I work anyway, and nobody looks poorly on a company because of stuff like this. My job isn’t sensitive in any way.

Reminder, this is a repost community. I am not the OOP

0

[Concluded] How do we hire someone who won't be freaked out by our cardboard coworker? [AAM]

Ask a Manager how do we hire people who won’t be alarmed by our cardboard coworker? www.askamanager.org
preview

Title: How do we hire people without them being freaked out by our cardboard coworker?

Source: Ask A Manager

I am not the original poster


Original Post: Mar 18, 2026

Recently my manager asked me to help revise a job posting and the hiring process because the last two people we hired left only a few weeks after starting. One said she didn’t think our workplace had a professional environment, and the other said she realized her values didn’t align with the company. Since I’m the most recent successful hire, my manager wants me to help her understand what was different about how I was selected.

You’re probably assuming my workplace must be toxic or terrible, but honestly it’s the most fun place I’ve ever worked, and that might actually be the problem. Nothing about it fits the usual idea of a bad workplace, but it is definitely … peculiar.

People often eat lunch together. Not everyone every day, but a few times a week most of us end up eating with coworkers. (Not everyone participates. The person who splits tasks with me says she already sees us enough at the office and never joins us, and no one minds.) Lunch is where most of the unusual things happen.

One employee created a betting sheet for which celebrity will be the next to die or get involved in a scandal. You can add one name per month, and if you guess correctly you win a day off. It sounds worse written down than it actually feels, but the people who participate genuinely enjoy it.

Lunch conversations can also drift into very unprofessional territory. The week one employee resigned, the lunch debate was whether extraterrestrials are capable of orgasms. That discussion lasted more than one lunch break because people kept proposing different possible alien anatomies.

But the least professional thing we do might be the cardboard figure sitting at a desk named Robert. Robert has been part of the company culture long before I joined. The story behind him is about a former employee who would arrive, greet everyone, and then disappear until it was time to go home. No one ever knew where Robert was, and whenever someone needed him they couldn’t find him, but the work always appeared completed.

One day the company needed a team photo, and someone grabbed a cardboard box, drew a face on it, added a badge, and included “Robert” in the picture. After the real Robert retired, the box eventually evolved into a full cardboard cutout that now sits at its own desk.

At the end of each month we usually have less work, and there’s a game where someone hides Robert somewhere in the company and everyone searches for him. At the end, everyone gets candy. Not everyone actively participates, one person keeps a map coordinating where Robert hasn’t been searched for yet, some people give suggestions, and others don’t care about the game, but no one objects to it except HR did ban hiding Robert in the interview room and the public-facing areas.

Both employees who resigned witnessed a “Find Robert” search. They didn’t mention it specifically, but I imagine it might have contributed to their impression that the environment wasn’t professional.

My manager wants help finding people who would think these things are funny rather than strange, and she asked how I felt when I started. I happened to begin (luckily or unluckily) when people were decorating Robert with a heart-pattern tie and a box of bonbons while discussing what kind of box Robert would like as a girlfriend. I thought it was weird in a funny way, and it didn’t bother me enough to reconsider the job.

Outside of lunch and the occasional Robert hunt, people are actually very professional during working hours, aside from occasionally greeting the cardboard coworker or decorating him for holidays. We’re a very productive and inclusive team, but I understand how it might seem strange to someone seeing it for the first time.

I honestly don’t know how to help my manager find competent people who would be comfortable with this environment. The person who interviewed me said the team was laid-back, but that definitely didn’t prepare me for what the office is actually like.

Someone suggested hiding Robert for a while, but wouldn’t it be better for new hires to know what they’re getting into? How could we find people who would feel comfortable discussing whether the aliens from Arrival understand sex and also think it’s perfectly normal to greet a cardboard coworker?

I realize your answer might be that our company isn’t the wonderful place I think it is and that we should behave more professionally. But considering that our CEO once hid Robert in his own office during one of the searches, I don’t think the culture will change. (Still, feel free to say so if that’s your view, sometimes an outside perspective is very different.) I’m mainly looking for ideas on how to select people who would actually find this kind of thing fun rather than uncomfortable.

Note: You can read Alison’s response at the link above.


Update: April 6, 2026

Thank you for responding to my letter. After reading the response and comments, I realized that the alien orgasm example drew more attention than I expected, even though I had meant it as one particularly bad example rather than the main issue itself. I wanted to add a little more context and clarify a few points.

The alien orgasm example was an outlier, and one of the worst examples I could remember, which is why I used it. The “alien anatomy” discussion was also less about sex itself than about whether extraterrestrials would experience pleasure or physical sensation the same way humans do, especially if they did not even have bodies like ours. I understand that it was still inappropriate, but some commenters seemed to come away with the impression that sex is a regular topic in the office, and that is not really the case.

A more typical version of these conversations would be discussions about books, movies, and TV shows. We have had conversations like which horror movie character was so stupid that you actively rooted for their death. We have also had conversations like which politician you would “make disappear” if you could get away with it, but when someone pointed out that it was inappropriate, the conversation moved on without any fuss. In general, the conversations tend to get strange in a morbid way rather than in a sexualized one. That is still a problem, of course, just not quite the same one some people focused on.

The office betting pool is less about hostility toward specific celebrities and more about the kind of morbid joking people make about public figures who seem as though they have been old forever. The attitude is usually more “I cannot believe this person is still alive” than “I want this person to die.” Similarly, the “scandals” people talk about are usually things like cheating, wearing something provocative, or being rude to a fan, rather than actual criminal behavior. I do not participate in the betting pool because I would feel too guilty winning a paid day off by correctly guessing someone’s death, but people do sometimes mention their picks during lunch.

I mentioned lunch because that is usually when the conversations can get strange. Most of our work requires concentration, so there is not much chatting during the day, and many people wear headphones most of the time. Team lunches also really are optional. We are a small team inside a large company, so the whole team does not eat together every day, but there are usually six to eight people having lunch together, even if it is not always the same group.

I described cardboard Robert as the strangest part because all the other things are occasional, and lunch itself is optional. Some people never have lunch with the team, and that is completely fine. But Robert is there every day, sitting at a desk and being greeted. It took me about two months to find out there was a death pool, and some time before I heard one of the more inappropriate lunch conversations, but I was introduced to Robert on my first day. My manager even told the team to act normal during my first week so they would not scare me off. The monthly “hunt” for Robert is optional and avoidable, but comments about him happen every day, and new employees are introduced to him as though he is simply part of the team.

In your response, it seemed as though my letter came across as asking, “How can we change our culture so people don’t feel this is a sexualized environment?” I can understand why, given the example I used, but the help I was really hoping for was a little different. What I was trying to ask was something more like, “How can I help my manager hire someone who is likely to fit in here, while also giving candidates a fair sense of what the office is like, so neither side feels misled?” Someone suggested inviting candidates to join a typical team lunch, and that was much closer to the kind of suggestion I had been hoping for.

I also appreciated your point that inappropriate conversations are inappropriate no matter when they happen. I do know that, and I think at least part of the team knows it too, given the ongoing joke that there is probably a reason our room is physically as far from HR as possible. But I am not a manager, and honestly I do not want to be one. My manager decided that because I was the most recent hire, I was the right person to help her think through this, even though I do not really have the authority or the tools to change how the team operates. I will pass these points along to her, but I do not think much would change without rebuilding the team almost from scratch.

To be clear, I do understand why these things are a problem. I am not trying to defend them or suggest that people are wrong for not wanting to work here. I just wanted to provide more context so I could get advice that was more specific to the situation I was actually asking about. Some of the comments were genuinely helpful, and I was hoping that with a better explanation I might get more of that. But if the answer is still simply that the culture needs to change, I do understand that, and I appreciate your response anyway.

Sincerely,
The Person with the Cardboard Coworker

This is a repost community, I am not the OOP

Title: How do we hire people without them being freaked out by our cardboard coworker?

Source: Ask A Manager

I am not the original poster


Original Post: Mar 18, 2026

Recently my manager asked me to help revise a job posting and the hiring process because the last two people we hired left only a few weeks after starting. One said she didn’t think our workplace had a professional environment, and the other said she realized her values didn’t align with the company. Since I’m the most recent successful hire, my manager wants me to help her understand what was different about how I was selected.

You’re probably assuming my workplace must be toxic or terrible, but honestly it’s the most fun place I’ve ever worked, and that might actually be the problem. Nothing about it fits the usual idea of a bad workplace, but it is definitely … peculiar.

People often eat lunch together. Not everyone every day, but a few times a week most of us end up eating with coworkers. (Not everyone participates. The person who splits tasks with me says she already sees us enough at the office and never joins us, and no one minds.) Lunch is where most of the unusual things happen.

One employee created a betting sheet for which celebrity will be the next to die or get involved in a scandal. You can add one name per month, and if you guess correctly you win a day off. It sounds worse written down than it actually feels, but the people who participate genuinely enjoy it.

Lunch conversations can also drift into very unprofessional territory. The week one employee resigned, the lunch debate was whether extraterrestrials are capable of orgasms. That discussion lasted more than one lunch break because people kept proposing different possible alien anatomies.

But the least professional thing we do might be the cardboard figure sitting at a desk named Robert. Robert has been part of the company culture long before I joined. The story behind him is about a former employee who would arrive, greet everyone, and then disappear until it was time to go home. No one ever knew where Robert was, and whenever someone needed him they couldn’t find him, but the work always appeared completed.

One day the company needed a team photo, and someone grabbed a cardboard box, drew a face on it, added a badge, and included “Robert” in the picture. After the real Robert retired, the box eventually evolved into a full cardboard cutout that now sits at its own desk.

At the end of each month we usually have less work, and there’s a game where someone hides Robert somewhere in the company and everyone searches for him. At the end, everyone gets candy. Not everyone actively participates, one person keeps a map coordinating where Robert hasn’t been searched for yet, some people give suggestions, and others don’t care about the game, but no one objects to it except HR did ban hiding Robert in the interview room and the public-facing areas.

Both employees who resigned witnessed a “Find Robert” search. They didn’t mention it specifically, but I imagine it might have contributed to their impression that the environment wasn’t professional.

My manager wants help finding people who would think these things are funny rather than strange, and she asked how I felt when I started. I happened to begin (luckily or unluckily) when people were decorating Robert with a heart-pattern tie and a box of bonbons while discussing what kind of box Robert would like as a girlfriend. I thought it was weird in a funny way, and it didn’t bother me enough to reconsider the job.

Outside of lunch and the occasional Robert hunt, people are actually very professional during working hours, aside from occasionally greeting the cardboard coworker or decorating him for holidays. We’re a very productive and inclusive team, but I understand how it might seem strange to someone seeing it for the first time.

I honestly don’t know how to help my manager find competent people who would be comfortable with this environment. The person who interviewed me said the team was laid-back, but that definitely didn’t prepare me for what the office is actually like.

Someone suggested hiding Robert for a while, but wouldn’t it be better for new hires to know what they’re getting into? How could we find people who would feel comfortable discussing whether the aliens from Arrival understand sex and also think it’s perfectly normal to greet a cardboard coworker?

I realize your answer might be that our company isn’t the wonderful place I think it is and that we should behave more professionally. But considering that our CEO once hid Robert in his own office during one of the searches, I don’t think the culture will change. (Still, feel free to say so if that’s your view, sometimes an outside perspective is very different.) I’m mainly looking for ideas on how to select people who would actually find this kind of thing fun rather than uncomfortable.

Note: You can read Alison’s response at the link above.


Update: April 6, 2026

Thank you for responding to my letter. After reading the response and comments, I realized that the alien orgasm example drew more attention than I expected, even though I had meant it as one particularly bad example rather than the main issue itself. I wanted to add a little more context and clarify a few points.

The alien orgasm example was an outlier, and one of the worst examples I could remember, which is why I used it. The “alien anatomy” discussion was also less about sex itself than about whether extraterrestrials would experience pleasure or physical sensation the same way humans do, especially if they did not even have bodies like ours. I understand that it was still inappropriate, but some commenters seemed to come away with the impression that sex is a regular topic in the office, and that is not really the case.

A more typical version of these conversations would be discussions about books, movies, and TV shows. We have had conversations like which horror movie character was so stupid that you actively rooted for their death. We have also had conversations like which politician you would “make disappear” if you could get away with it, but when someone pointed out that it was inappropriate, the conversation moved on without any fuss. In general, the conversations tend to get strange in a morbid way rather than in a sexualized one. That is still a problem, of course, just not quite the same one some people focused on.

The office betting pool is less about hostility toward specific celebrities and more about the kind of morbid joking people make about public figures who seem as though they have been old forever. The attitude is usually more “I cannot believe this person is still alive” than “I want this person to die.” Similarly, the “scandals” people talk about are usually things like cheating, wearing something provocative, or being rude to a fan, rather than actual criminal behavior. I do not participate in the betting pool because I would feel too guilty winning a paid day off by correctly guessing someone’s death, but people do sometimes mention their picks during lunch.

I mentioned lunch because that is usually when the conversations can get strange. Most of our work requires concentration, so there is not much chatting during the day, and many people wear headphones most of the time. Team lunches also really are optional. We are a small team inside a large company, so the whole team does not eat together every day, but there are usually six to eight people having lunch together, even if it is not always the same group.

I described cardboard Robert as the strangest part because all the other things are occasional, and lunch itself is optional. Some people never have lunch with the team, and that is completely fine. But Robert is there every day, sitting at a desk and being greeted. It took me about two months to find out there was a death pool, and some time before I heard one of the more inappropriate lunch conversations, but I was introduced to Robert on my first day. My manager even told the team to act normal during my first week so they would not scare me off. The monthly “hunt” for Robert is optional and avoidable, but comments about him happen every day, and new employees are introduced to him as though he is simply part of the team.

In your response, it seemed as though my letter came across as asking, “How can we change our culture so people don’t feel this is a sexualized environment?” I can understand why, given the example I used, but the help I was really hoping for was a little different. What I was trying to ask was something more like, “How can I help my manager hire someone who is likely to fit in here, while also giving candidates a fair sense of what the office is like, so neither side feels misled?” Someone suggested inviting candidates to join a typical team lunch, and that was much closer to the kind of suggestion I had been hoping for.

I also appreciated your point that inappropriate conversations are inappropriate no matter when they happen. I do know that, and I think at least part of the team knows it too, given the ongoing joke that there is probably a reason our room is physically as far from HR as possible. But I am not a manager, and honestly I do not want to be one. My manager decided that because I was the most recent hire, I was the right person to help her think through this, even though I do not really have the authority or the tools to change how the team operates. I will pass these points along to her, but I do not think much would change without rebuilding the team almost from scratch.

To be clear, I do understand why these things are a problem. I am not trying to defend them or suggest that people are wrong for not wanting to work here. I just wanted to provide more context so I could get advice that was more specific to the situation I was actually asking about. Some of the comments were genuinely helpful, and I was hoping that with a better explanation I might get more of that. But if the answer is still simply that the culture needs to change, I do understand that, and I appreciate your response anyway.

Sincerely,
The Person with the Cardboard Coworker

This is a repost community, I am not the OOP

0

[Concluded, New Update] AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours from my work place? [Reddit]

preview

[New Update]: AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours away from my workplace?

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/throwra_nowherehouse

Originally posted to r/AITAH

Previous BoRUs: #1, #2

[New Update]: AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours away from my workplace?

NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----

Thanks to u/arifault for suggesting this BoRU

Tap for Trigger Warning

manipulation, possible controlling behavior, possible misogyny, death of a loved one


RECAP

Original Post: August 4, 2025

I don’t know how to start this. I, (27F) have been with my fiancé (28M) for 5 years. We’ve just recently saved enough for a deposit on a house, and he’s found this cottage in the middle of nowhere, two hours away from where we currently live. The thing is that I already work an hour away. I am a nursery practitioner and I love my workplace, I’ve been there since I was 20 and I’ve worked my way up to a room lead position. Living three hours away from my job would not be ideal, but my fiancé won’t budge on this house. He says it’s perfect within our budget and quirky enough to fit our tastes in home style.

I’ve tried to communicate with him about this issue multiple times, bringing up the fact there’s not even any nurseries in that area that are looking for staff, and I don’t want to find another job that’s a bit further out but start from the bottom again. He says it’ll all work out if I just stop overthinking it, and I’ve been at my current job for so long that it would be nice for me to start fresh.

Another issue is that I want children, they’ve always been a huge dealbreaker for me and I don’t think it would be such a good idea to live so remotely when it comes to children as we will have to get them to/from school or nursery before and after work every day, the nearest school/nursery is a 30 minute drive away from the house he wants and we both start work fairly early and finish quite late. It will also be an issue of their freedom as they grow up, because I think it would be horrible to have to rely on your parents for transportation all the time and have to skip out on plans if they can’t drive you.

He really thinks I’m being dramatic about this and I’ll just ‘figure it out’, so AITAH for not wanting to move so far away from my job and basically all civilisation?

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP was NTA

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: NTA. Y’all didn’t talk about where you wanted to live? You both should have discussed where EXACTLY you wanted a home. You don’t have to move where you don’t want to live.

OOP: We did discuss it, we both want a nice cottage that’s out of the way of lots of people, but there’s options near us, and even more options that are actually closer to my job, that also still have access to regular buses and there’s even a few up for sale in a town with a train station a reasonable walk away. I don’t know why he’s suddenly so set on this house that’s so far out when we have plenty of options available to us that won’t move us hours away.

Commenter 2: NTA. You two are not on the same page. You need to sort that out before you get married.

OOP: I am desperately trying to sort it out. I’m considering telling him that I will end the engagement if he continues to be unreasonable and doesn’t consider my feelings on the matter

Commenter 3: NTA. If you have joined the funds, immediately remove your contributions from the account and safeguard the money. He absolutely will use all of it to buy the cottage. His plan is to isolate you and keep you away from your network of people.

OOP: Luckily I control our finances because I’m better with numbers, so I’ve already transferred my half of the savings into a different account, he won’t even notice. He’s usually very sweet and considerate so I’m not sure what’s got into him about this house. He loves my family and we have the same friend group as we’ve known each other since high school, so I don’t think he’s trying to isolate me

Commenter 4: Is the house also three hours away from his workplace? Or does he WFH?

OOP: He works in tech and he does go physically to work but has the opportunity to WFH if he wants to. He says because it’s ’worked out’ for him it’ll work out for me too and I can always just find another job in a nursery, but I don’t think he gets quite how difficult it is to find a genuinely good job in a great nursery that doesn’t have a toxic environment and crazy high staff turnover

Commenter 5: Who exactly is the “we” who received the money for the deposit? Who did the money come from? if it came from somebody in his family, he is probably being very proprietary about how the money is spent. That isn’t a partnership and this kind of thinking will spill over into other areas of their life. If the money came from someone in your family or if it is somehow attached to your career, like a bonus, then he is a dictator who will force his ideas on you time and again. Buying a house is a partnership. He will expect you to help pay your portion of the mortgage and the upkeep, but you don’t get to say in where the house is located. Is that what you want? NTA

OOP: We’ve been saving for a while, nobody gave us any money. I was already saving before we got together, so was he and after a couple years together we decided to pool our house savings for our future which I now realise was probably a really dumb idea because we aren’t married. I’ve actually put more in than him despite spending less because I’m happy to live a frugal lifestyle while he likes holidays and expensive cars, etc.

Despite *earning less, sorry I’m completely exhausted

 

Update #1: August 6, 2025 (two days later)

UPDATE AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours away from my workplace?

I wasn’t expecting to be able to update this fast, but here we are. First off I want to thank everyone that commented on my last post, and also add some context as I realised my last post may have been lacking some. Fiancé and I have been together five years, but I have known him for twelve years, and in all the time I’ve known him and especially since we got together he’s always been sweet, taken my feelings into consideration and hasn’t actively ignored my opinion like this. It’s always been a two yes, one no situation in decisions before this.

We had a good relationship otherwise, we had date nights once a fortnight, we enjoyed each other’s company, had aligning plans for the future and the same ideals for a relationship. He had watched me go through a few quite bad relationships over the years before we got together and did his best to be the opposite of my exes, though he’s always been quite pushy when it comes to sexual intimacy, so I guess that’s an issue. But other than that it was great, and we had actually had a lot of talks about what we wanted in a house. We had agreed that we wanted a house or cottage either the same distance away or closer to my work, a bit more remote but still with a town or city easily accessible by public transport and car. I’m not sure why he suddenly switched to wanting a house so far out from everything and everyone we both know. We live in the UK, and a two hour drive can have you in basically a whole other world.

Anyway, the actual update. I had annual leave from work yesterday, and my now-ex fiancé was having a WFH day, something he’s been doing more and more frequently as of late. This is another reason he is so okay with the house he wants being where it is, because he can just switch to full time work from home.

In the morning I sat down with him and tried to bring up the house. I laid out my points from my last post yet again and told him I am under no circumstances leaving my job, I love it and I do not want to search for another. I brought up the countless other houses that fit our criteria that are in our area and closer to my work, some of which we have viewed. We haven’t viewed the place he wants yet as we haven’t had the time, and I told him I do not want to as I already know it’s not what I want.

I also asked him if he really thinks it would be okay for me to have a 6 hour round commute every day, especially considering my shift starts at 8am so I would have to leave by 5am every morning and be up by around 4am. My shifts typically finish at 5:30pm, so I wouldn’t even be back home until 8:30pm. Would he be okay with doing all the childcare in the future, housework and just everything that needed to be done because I would not be home for any of it?

He didn’t seem to take any of it to heart, and still insisted I could find another job, maybe one not even in child care, and that’s what finally pushed me over the edge. Child care has been my dream since I was a little girl, and I managed to find an absolute dream of a workplace that I know many child care practitioners would kill to work for. How could I possibly leave that all behind when I’ve worked so hard for it? He told me he’s set on this house, so either I accept it or I leave.

I chose leave. I gave his ring back and told him we’re done, that he’s not being the sweet, considerate man I fell in love with, and I don’t know why he can’t see my side of things in this. I do not want to live a life with somebody that doesn’t consider how I feel in all of this. This completely shocked him and he started begging me to rethink, that we can figure something out, but I refused and went to pack my things.

I’m staying with my brother and his wife now, which is nice because they live closer to my workplace (a 30 minute drive instead of an hour), and I get to spend time with my little nieces. I am hurting, but I also feel like a huge weight has been lifted off my shoulders. I do not deserve to not have my opinion valued, and he certainly did not. I guess it’s onwards and upwards as they say, but I definitely won’t be dating for a long time after this

Relevant / Top Comments

Commenter 1: You mentioned that the two of you had saved up enough for a down payment. If the money is in a joint account add up how much you contributed plus interest on the amount, and withdraw it Fast.

OOP: Hello! Sorry for my absence I have been very busy. I withdrew all money that I contributed from the shared balance before I left my ex-fiancé. It’s all safe in my own bank account now!

Commenter 2: He didn’t even give up. " We can figure something out" means his option is still on the table. He just wants to keep debating even after you dumped him. Man he really wants that house.

Commenter 3: Oh damn. He thought he could strong arm you into agreeing with him. He thought you would relent because you were engaged and you’d never walk away. And then you called his bluff and he realized he didn’t hold the control over you he thought.

Good on you for calling his bluff and being rid of him. He would have 100% used that tactic again and again if you had stayed with him.

Commenter 4: NTA and good job advocating for yourself!!! if current You starts to waver, which is a totally normal emotional cycle for people to go through post break up, just remember that future You will be so glad that you stood up for yourself and made space for better relationships to come.

Update #2: December 4, 2025 (nearly four months later)

UPDATE: AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours away from my workplace?

Reposting here bc I didn’t realise I could only post one update on the AITAH sub

Hi all. Sorry I’ve been almost completely MIA for the last few months, life has been completely hectic, but I wanted to give an update because I saw some people asking for an update. I also saw my post being read on TikTok a few months ago by one of my favourite Reddit story accounts actually and that was crazy, I truly did not think it would end up anywhere but Reddit.

First off, I (27F) want to share some things about my life and how it has been since I left my ex-fiancé(28M). Life has been up and down for me. I found a therapist, and I’ve started to rent a small flat close to my brother’s house, still living below my means as I start to save for a house again, building upon my more than half of the savings I took when I left my ex (It was all my money, I had saved most of it. I did not take any of the money that was his.) The flat is small, but it’s cosy and doesn’t have any of the mess my ex always left around. I was offered a position as assistant manager at my workplace, and while the pay rise would have been nice, I decided to turn it down as I just so love working with the children and I do not want to spend most of my time in an office. Being a room lead is fine with me, I adore my job. My workplace is still great, and I’ve made some really good friends with some newer staff members. I often have a couple of them over for drinks or dinner after work, as a little single ladies club.

My absolutely amazing dad died suddenly and tragically in September, far too soon at 65. He was truly the most incredible man, and I’d been leaning on him a lot for support after I left my ex. He left me a sizeable sum of money, and while I am still waiting for that to come through, I’m planning to put it all into my house fund and I’m hoping to be a homeowner by the summer of 2026. I also adopted a little tortoiseshell cat to keep me company, her name is Lily and she’s the sweetest, cuddliest thing.

I’m slowly getting back into dating, and I actually made the realisation that I like women, so I have been dipping my toes into going on dates with some lovely ladies, which has been great. Nothing serious of course, I’m not ready for that yet, but it’s nice to have some connection with people and explore my newfound dating pool, see what fits me best and figure out my dating boundaries. Overall, while some times have been tough and heartbreaking, my life has improved.

On the ex front, I really did dodge a bullet. My sister has told me countless times that I let a man disrespect me for far too long. He was not the man I thought he was and upon reflection I realise the first red flag was how pushy he was for sex. I believe one comment on my last update called him a sex fiend. My therapist has helped me to realise that coercion was not consent, so I’ve been working through that.

Since we split, he has apparently been posting on Instagram about being an alpha male and how any woman would be lucky to have him. According to mutual friends, he has been listening to lots of horrible and misogynistic podcasts and spews that rhetoric to absolutely everyone he can, and he’s already dating a new girl what who is far from appropriately younger than him at 19. Yuck!! I will never know the full logic of why he wanted me to move so far from everything I know and love, but I feel that the comments saying he wanted me to quit my job and be a SAHM were correct in their assumptions. He couldn’t afford the house he wanted without my part of the savings, so he’s stuck in our old flat.

I had to see him once more after I left just to get the rest of my things from our old place, and he tried to talk to me, asking if we could fix what we had, but I ignored him and simply took everything I needed before leaving and blocking him for good. He’s not worth my time or energy.

I think during our relationship, I lost who I really was and forgot that I am a strong and independent woman. I have always been quite feisty, and I’ve always stood up for myself, but somehow with him I lost those parts of me. They’re back in full force now and I couldn’t be happier with that. I’ve used my found-again spine to fight for what I believe in, and I have been to several marches and protests for Palestine in the last few months, screaming at the top of my lungs, holding banners and waving flags. I have advocated for children’s rights, I have joined clubs and groups, and I have found my voice. Thank you all for your kind words, advice and encouragement. I don’t think I would have left or stayed away if it wasn’t for all of you commenting.

Relevant / Top Comments

Commenter 1: 19!? Poor girl

OOP: I really want to message her and let her know what he’s like, but my sister and friends have told me it would cause more problems for me. She’s so young and I’m afraid for her

Commenter 2: I agree with your sister you dodged a bullet. Go have a great life now that you have found yourself again.

Commenter 3: Yesssssss. You go do what you want from now on. Sad about dad, but awesome otherwise.


#----NEW UPDATE----

Update #3: June 27, 2026 (6.5 months later from the previous update)

(editor’s note: removed the first part of the update as they are links to the original and previous updates)

Six months into the year already, wow! Thank you so much to everyone who has been so supportive on my previous posts!

I (28F) don’t have much to update apart from, as of the 21st of May, I am officially a homeowner! I found a perfect house that’s only fifteen minutes from my workplace. It may not be the out of the way cottage I wanted, but it’s perfect and it’s all mine. I have space to just be me, and enough room for my niblings to sleep over and give my siblings a break.

On the dating front, I’ve been dating a wonderful woman (30F) since late December. I realised shortly after my last update that I wasn’t bisexual, and I am actually fully a lesbian.

We’re still taking it very slow, considering I had just come out of a long term relationship, and she was only recently divorced when we met, but so far so good. She’s absolutely amazing and I can safely say I love her. If things go well, we’ve talked about living together but that won’t happen until at least 2027, as I’m not quite ready for that level of commitment yet. She’s helped me move in and decorate my new house though, which has been lovely as she works in interior design and seems to know exactly how to make a room look incredible.

My ex broke up with the 19 year old in April, from what I’ve been told, citing that she’s “far too immature.” Like, obviously? She’s 19 and you’re 29, idiot. I haven’t heard much else about him because I really don’t care to know about his life, but what I have heard isn’t great. On top of his stupid misogynist stuff, he’s also been on some horribly racist bs. I didn’t mention this in my posts because it didn’t feel relevant, but I am mixed. My mum is Black, and I am very clearly half Black. He was engaged to a woman of colour and he’s racist!!!

All in all, life is good and I escaped a man that probably never really loved me. I hope everyone has had a great year so far, here’s to better beginnings. It may not be much of an update, but I wanted to let you all know it can get so much better 😊.

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

[New Update]: AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours away from my workplace?

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/throwra_nowherehouse

Originally posted to r/AITAH

Previous BoRUs: #1, #2

[New Update]: AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours away from my workplace?

NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----

Thanks to u/arifault for suggesting this BoRU

Tap for Trigger Warning

manipulation, possible controlling behavior, possible misogyny, death of a loved one


RECAP

Original Post: August 4, 2025

I don’t know how to start this. I, (27F) have been with my fiancé (28M) for 5 years. We’ve just recently saved enough for a deposit on a house, and he’s found this cottage in the middle of nowhere, two hours away from where we currently live. The thing is that I already work an hour away. I am a nursery practitioner and I love my workplace, I’ve been there since I was 20 and I’ve worked my way up to a room lead position. Living three hours away from my job would not be ideal, but my fiancé won’t budge on this house. He says it’s perfect within our budget and quirky enough to fit our tastes in home style.

I’ve tried to communicate with him about this issue multiple times, bringing up the fact there’s not even any nurseries in that area that are looking for staff, and I don’t want to find another job that’s a bit further out but start from the bottom again. He says it’ll all work out if I just stop overthinking it, and I’ve been at my current job for so long that it would be nice for me to start fresh.

Another issue is that I want children, they’ve always been a huge dealbreaker for me and I don’t think it would be such a good idea to live so remotely when it comes to children as we will have to get them to/from school or nursery before and after work every day, the nearest school/nursery is a 30 minute drive away from the house he wants and we both start work fairly early and finish quite late. It will also be an issue of their freedom as they grow up, because I think it would be horrible to have to rely on your parents for transportation all the time and have to skip out on plans if they can’t drive you.

He really thinks I’m being dramatic about this and I’ll just ‘figure it out’, so AITAH for not wanting to move so far away from my job and basically all civilisation?

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP was NTA

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: NTA. Y’all didn’t talk about where you wanted to live? You both should have discussed where EXACTLY you wanted a home. You don’t have to move where you don’t want to live.

OOP: We did discuss it, we both want a nice cottage that’s out of the way of lots of people, but there’s options near us, and even more options that are actually closer to my job, that also still have access to regular buses and there’s even a few up for sale in a town with a train station a reasonable walk away. I don’t know why he’s suddenly so set on this house that’s so far out when we have plenty of options available to us that won’t move us hours away.

Commenter 2: NTA. You two are not on the same page. You need to sort that out before you get married.

OOP: I am desperately trying to sort it out. I’m considering telling him that I will end the engagement if he continues to be unreasonable and doesn’t consider my feelings on the matter

Commenter 3: NTA. If you have joined the funds, immediately remove your contributions from the account and safeguard the money. He absolutely will use all of it to buy the cottage. His plan is to isolate you and keep you away from your network of people.

OOP: Luckily I control our finances because I’m better with numbers, so I’ve already transferred my half of the savings into a different account, he won’t even notice. He’s usually very sweet and considerate so I’m not sure what’s got into him about this house. He loves my family and we have the same friend group as we’ve known each other since high school, so I don’t think he’s trying to isolate me

Commenter 4: Is the house also three hours away from his workplace? Or does he WFH?

OOP: He works in tech and he does go physically to work but has the opportunity to WFH if he wants to. He says because it’s ’worked out’ for him it’ll work out for me too and I can always just find another job in a nursery, but I don’t think he gets quite how difficult it is to find a genuinely good job in a great nursery that doesn’t have a toxic environment and crazy high staff turnover

Commenter 5: Who exactly is the “we” who received the money for the deposit? Who did the money come from? if it came from somebody in his family, he is probably being very proprietary about how the money is spent. That isn’t a partnership and this kind of thinking will spill over into other areas of their life. If the money came from someone in your family or if it is somehow attached to your career, like a bonus, then he is a dictator who will force his ideas on you time and again. Buying a house is a partnership. He will expect you to help pay your portion of the mortgage and the upkeep, but you don’t get to say in where the house is located. Is that what you want? NTA

OOP: We’ve been saving for a while, nobody gave us any money. I was already saving before we got together, so was he and after a couple years together we decided to pool our house savings for our future which I now realise was probably a really dumb idea because we aren’t married. I’ve actually put more in than him despite spending less because I’m happy to live a frugal lifestyle while he likes holidays and expensive cars, etc.

Despite *earning less, sorry I’m completely exhausted

 

Update #1: August 6, 2025 (two days later)

UPDATE AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours away from my workplace?

I wasn’t expecting to be able to update this fast, but here we are. First off I want to thank everyone that commented on my last post, and also add some context as I realised my last post may have been lacking some. Fiancé and I have been together five years, but I have known him for twelve years, and in all the time I’ve known him and especially since we got together he’s always been sweet, taken my feelings into consideration and hasn’t actively ignored my opinion like this. It’s always been a two yes, one no situation in decisions before this.

We had a good relationship otherwise, we had date nights once a fortnight, we enjoyed each other’s company, had aligning plans for the future and the same ideals for a relationship. He had watched me go through a few quite bad relationships over the years before we got together and did his best to be the opposite of my exes, though he’s always been quite pushy when it comes to sexual intimacy, so I guess that’s an issue. But other than that it was great, and we had actually had a lot of talks about what we wanted in a house. We had agreed that we wanted a house or cottage either the same distance away or closer to my work, a bit more remote but still with a town or city easily accessible by public transport and car. I’m not sure why he suddenly switched to wanting a house so far out from everything and everyone we both know. We live in the UK, and a two hour drive can have you in basically a whole other world.

Anyway, the actual update. I had annual leave from work yesterday, and my now-ex fiancé was having a WFH day, something he’s been doing more and more frequently as of late. This is another reason he is so okay with the house he wants being where it is, because he can just switch to full time work from home.

In the morning I sat down with him and tried to bring up the house. I laid out my points from my last post yet again and told him I am under no circumstances leaving my job, I love it and I do not want to search for another. I brought up the countless other houses that fit our criteria that are in our area and closer to my work, some of which we have viewed. We haven’t viewed the place he wants yet as we haven’t had the time, and I told him I do not want to as I already know it’s not what I want.

I also asked him if he really thinks it would be okay for me to have a 6 hour round commute every day, especially considering my shift starts at 8am so I would have to leave by 5am every morning and be up by around 4am. My shifts typically finish at 5:30pm, so I wouldn’t even be back home until 8:30pm. Would he be okay with doing all the childcare in the future, housework and just everything that needed to be done because I would not be home for any of it?

He didn’t seem to take any of it to heart, and still insisted I could find another job, maybe one not even in child care, and that’s what finally pushed me over the edge. Child care has been my dream since I was a little girl, and I managed to find an absolute dream of a workplace that I know many child care practitioners would kill to work for. How could I possibly leave that all behind when I’ve worked so hard for it? He told me he’s set on this house, so either I accept it or I leave.

I chose leave. I gave his ring back and told him we’re done, that he’s not being the sweet, considerate man I fell in love with, and I don’t know why he can’t see my side of things in this. I do not want to live a life with somebody that doesn’t consider how I feel in all of this. This completely shocked him and he started begging me to rethink, that we can figure something out, but I refused and went to pack my things.

I’m staying with my brother and his wife now, which is nice because they live closer to my workplace (a 30 minute drive instead of an hour), and I get to spend time with my little nieces. I am hurting, but I also feel like a huge weight has been lifted off my shoulders. I do not deserve to not have my opinion valued, and he certainly did not. I guess it’s onwards and upwards as they say, but I definitely won’t be dating for a long time after this

Relevant / Top Comments

Commenter 1: You mentioned that the two of you had saved up enough for a down payment. If the money is in a joint account add up how much you contributed plus interest on the amount, and withdraw it Fast.

OOP: Hello! Sorry for my absence I have been very busy. I withdrew all money that I contributed from the shared balance before I left my ex-fiancé. It’s all safe in my own bank account now!

Commenter 2: He didn’t even give up. " We can figure something out" means his option is still on the table. He just wants to keep debating even after you dumped him. Man he really wants that house.

Commenter 3: Oh damn. He thought he could strong arm you into agreeing with him. He thought you would relent because you were engaged and you’d never walk away. And then you called his bluff and he realized he didn’t hold the control over you he thought.

Good on you for calling his bluff and being rid of him. He would have 100% used that tactic again and again if you had stayed with him.

Commenter 4: NTA and good job advocating for yourself!!! if current You starts to waver, which is a totally normal emotional cycle for people to go through post break up, just remember that future You will be so glad that you stood up for yourself and made space for better relationships to come.

Update #2: December 4, 2025 (nearly four months later)

UPDATE: AITAH for not wanting to buy a house 3 hours away from my workplace?

Reposting here bc I didn’t realise I could only post one update on the AITAH sub

Hi all. Sorry I’ve been almost completely MIA for the last few months, life has been completely hectic, but I wanted to give an update because I saw some people asking for an update. I also saw my post being read on TikTok a few months ago by one of my favourite Reddit story accounts actually and that was crazy, I truly did not think it would end up anywhere but Reddit.

First off, I (27F) want to share some things about my life and how it has been since I left my ex-fiancé(28M). Life has been up and down for me. I found a therapist, and I’ve started to rent a small flat close to my brother’s house, still living below my means as I start to save for a house again, building upon my more than half of the savings I took when I left my ex (It was all my money, I had saved most of it. I did not take any of the money that was his.) The flat is small, but it’s cosy and doesn’t have any of the mess my ex always left around. I was offered a position as assistant manager at my workplace, and while the pay rise would have been nice, I decided to turn it down as I just so love working with the children and I do not want to spend most of my time in an office. Being a room lead is fine with me, I adore my job. My workplace is still great, and I’ve made some really good friends with some newer staff members. I often have a couple of them over for drinks or dinner after work, as a little single ladies club.

My absolutely amazing dad died suddenly and tragically in September, far too soon at 65. He was truly the most incredible man, and I’d been leaning on him a lot for support after I left my ex. He left me a sizeable sum of money, and while I am still waiting for that to come through, I’m planning to put it all into my house fund and I’m hoping to be a homeowner by the summer of 2026. I also adopted a little tortoiseshell cat to keep me company, her name is Lily and she’s the sweetest, cuddliest thing.

I’m slowly getting back into dating, and I actually made the realisation that I like women, so I have been dipping my toes into going on dates with some lovely ladies, which has been great. Nothing serious of course, I’m not ready for that yet, but it’s nice to have some connection with people and explore my newfound dating pool, see what fits me best and figure out my dating boundaries. Overall, while some times have been tough and heartbreaking, my life has improved.

On the ex front, I really did dodge a bullet. My sister has told me countless times that I let a man disrespect me for far too long. He was not the man I thought he was and upon reflection I realise the first red flag was how pushy he was for sex. I believe one comment on my last update called him a sex fiend. My therapist has helped me to realise that coercion was not consent, so I’ve been working through that.

Since we split, he has apparently been posting on Instagram about being an alpha male and how any woman would be lucky to have him. According to mutual friends, he has been listening to lots of horrible and misogynistic podcasts and spews that rhetoric to absolutely everyone he can, and he’s already dating a new girl what who is far from appropriately younger than him at 19. Yuck!! I will never know the full logic of why he wanted me to move so far from everything I know and love, but I feel that the comments saying he wanted me to quit my job and be a SAHM were correct in their assumptions. He couldn’t afford the house he wanted without my part of the savings, so he’s stuck in our old flat.

I had to see him once more after I left just to get the rest of my things from our old place, and he tried to talk to me, asking if we could fix what we had, but I ignored him and simply took everything I needed before leaving and blocking him for good. He’s not worth my time or energy.

I think during our relationship, I lost who I really was and forgot that I am a strong and independent woman. I have always been quite feisty, and I’ve always stood up for myself, but somehow with him I lost those parts of me. They’re back in full force now and I couldn’t be happier with that. I’ve used my found-again spine to fight for what I believe in, and I have been to several marches and protests for Palestine in the last few months, screaming at the top of my lungs, holding banners and waving flags. I have advocated for children’s rights, I have joined clubs and groups, and I have found my voice. Thank you all for your kind words, advice and encouragement. I don’t think I would have left or stayed away if it wasn’t for all of you commenting.

Relevant / Top Comments

Commenter 1: 19!? Poor girl

OOP: I really want to message her and let her know what he’s like, but my sister and friends have told me it would cause more problems for me. She’s so young and I’m afraid for her

Commenter 2: I agree with your sister you dodged a bullet. Go have a great life now that you have found yourself again.

Commenter 3: Yesssssss. You go do what you want from now on. Sad about dad, but awesome otherwise.


#----NEW UPDATE----

Update #3: June 27, 2026 (6.5 months later from the previous update)

(editor’s note: removed the first part of the update as they are links to the original and previous updates)

Six months into the year already, wow! Thank you so much to everyone who has been so supportive on my previous posts!

I (28F) don’t have much to update apart from, as of the 21st of May, I am officially a homeowner! I found a perfect house that’s only fifteen minutes from my workplace. It may not be the out of the way cottage I wanted, but it’s perfect and it’s all mine. I have space to just be me, and enough room for my niblings to sleep over and give my siblings a break.

On the dating front, I’ve been dating a wonderful woman (30F) since late December. I realised shortly after my last update that I wasn’t bisexual, and I am actually fully a lesbian.

We’re still taking it very slow, considering I had just come out of a long term relationship, and she was only recently divorced when we met, but so far so good. She’s absolutely amazing and I can safely say I love her. If things go well, we’ve talked about living together but that won’t happen until at least 2027, as I’m not quite ready for that level of commitment yet. She’s helped me move in and decorate my new house though, which has been lovely as she works in interior design and seems to know exactly how to make a room look incredible.

My ex broke up with the 19 year old in April, from what I’ve been told, citing that she’s “far too immature.” Like, obviously? She’s 19 and you’re 29, idiot. I haven’t heard much else about him because I really don’t care to know about his life, but what I have heard isn’t great. On top of his stupid misogynist stuff, he’s also been on some horribly racist bs. I didn’t mention this in my posts because it didn’t feel relevant, but I am mixed. My mum is Black, and I am very clearly half Black. He was engaged to a woman of colour and he’s racist!!!

All in all, life is good and I escaped a man that probably never really loved me. I hope everyone has had a great year so far, here’s to better beginnings. It may not be much of an update, but I wanted to let you all know it can get so much better 😊.

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

0

[Concluded] AITAH for walking out of a dinner after being accused of supporting incest? [Reddit]

preview

AITA for walking out of a dinner after being accused of supporting incest?

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/Nearby-Comfortable79

Thank you Reddit user: u/Direct_Catterpillar77 for putting this together

AITA for walking out of a dinner after being accused of supporting incest?

Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole

Tap for Trigger Warning

Biphobia

Original Post - rareddit  Dec 9, 2023

Hey. I’m posting on here because I need people’s opinions on this. It’s so fucking stupid and such a non-issue, (unless I’m wrong about that too) that turned into something bigger.

For reference, this happened on Thursday evening. We are all in our early 20s and all names are fake.

Thursday was our friend “Sarah’s” birthday. To celebrate, our friend group decided to go out for dinner. There were about 10 of us. Everyone was in a good mood and it was really nice to just talk to everybody about whatever for hours, especially since I kind of had a stressful week.

Hours into the dinner, we landed on the topic of movies/TV shows that we were watching. Our friend “Amy” mentioned a show that I had also watched. As soon as she brought it up, I said that I really liked the show, and that the acting, writing and directing was top notch. “Mary” chimed in and said that she really didn’t like the show and how she had been watching other things. Cool. To each their own. Mary then asked me how I felt about the main romantic pairing in the show. I responded that I liked it, and thought the romance was cute. This is where the drama started.

For context, I don’t want to get too much into it because it might be confusing, but basically, the main romantic pairing is between the male lead and the female lead. There are some people who have interpreted that these characters to be related to each other. I do not. But I know that people are free to think whatever they want, and honestly thought that this topic was harmless. Well, I was wrong.

Mary took offense to me saying that I liked the romance. She asked me if I supported incest. I said of course not, as the characters are not related. She said that they ARE related and that me supporting their pairing is supporting incest. Mary then said that I should “educate” myself before saying “stupid shit”. I was dumbfounded and thought she was joking but she was REALLY angry with me about this. She told me to rethink my values because supporting incest makes me a horrible person. I told her she was making harmful accusations over a TV show. Our other friends were telling her to stop, including Sarah, but she kept claiming that I was a disgusting incest supporter. She then claimed I was homophobic, since the male lead is bisexual but still ended up with a woman. Mary just wouldn’t stop saying shit like this.

So here is where I may be the asshole. I left Sarah’s dinner. My friends were asking me to stay but I felt uncomfortable, so I paid for what I ordered and left. Many of my friends reached out to me on Friday to ask if I was okay. Some of them, while they understood why I was upset, said that it was wrong of me to leave Sarah’s birthday dinner and that I should have just ignored what Mary was saying and stuck around. I feel like they may be right and that I may have ruined her birthday by getting up and leaving, but I felt like I couldn’t stay because of Mary throwing accusations at me over something that doesn’t matter.

VERDICT: NOT THE ASSHOLE

RELEVANT COMMENTS

HauntedReader

NTA and Mary seems like she takes things FAR too seriously.

I am super curious what the show is though. Do you mind sharing?

OOP

Loki

HauntedReader

See this doesn’t even make sense with her argument. It wouldn’t be incest because the two aren’t related, they’re literally different variants of the exact same person.

It definitely falls on the weird side of things but definitely doesn’t count as incest.

Also I’m going to assume neither of you finished the series yet so like I’m even more confused by this take.

OOP

I finished the series. I don’t know about Mary. I know that they don’t end up together, but the point is that even in season 2 the implication is still there. But Mary was just upset that they were romantic in the first place.

TOP COMMENTS

mmiggs

Mary is a clear asshole. There’s no question here. And a very stupid asshole, if she thinks that bi people ending up in a relationship with someone of the opposite binary gender is homophobic. (Clue: half of the people that a typical bisexual person is attracted to are of the opposite gender. You might actually expect bi people to be in a relationship with someone of the opposite gender significantly more often than half the time. If you’re a bi man, then your set of possible partners are (for the sake of argument, and there’s some simplification of sexuality here) gay men, bi men, bi women, and straight women. The largest of these groupings, by quite a long way, is the group of straight women.

NTA

~

PurpleMarsAlien

NTA

Mary is acting weird. Attacking someone over fannish beliefs that are not part of current canon is being rather extra and over the top.

And even if this eventually becomes part of canon, someone who like the couple when it was not canon, were not supporting incest. They would have been misled by the creators.

Update  Jan 3, 2024 (Nearly 1 month later)

Hi everyone. First, thank you all for your comments and advice on my last post. It’s been about 4 weeks since the incident at the dinner, and I just wanted to give you guys an update if you’re curious.

First off, I just want to say that I have no hard feelings toward my friends who said that I should’ve stayed. I get me leaving was probably the best thing to do in that situation, but their intentions were purely good: to make sure that Sarah enjoyed her birthday dinner.

I reached out to Sarah and apologized for what happened, and for me leaving so abruptly. She said that I didn’t need to apologize and said that all was good between us. I took her out for drinks. We had a great time.

Now, onto Mary. Since the dinner, I have been texting and calling her, just to talk about what happened. So far, she has either ignored my texts and calls, or given me very short responses, either telling me that she doesn’t want to talk to me, or that she’s busy. Sarah told me that she also reached out to Mary, and while she was actually willing to talk to Sarah, the conversation pretty much went nowhere. Amy also reached out to her. Like many of you were wondering, she asked her if she was a victim of incest. I mean, It would make sense based on her reaction. However, according to Mary herself, no, she wasn’t. As far as I know, she isn’t bisexual either, so it just seems she’s throwing a tantrum over things that have nothing to do with her. Or it’s possible that she’s been spending too much time in online fandoms, but who knows.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

AITA for walking out of a dinner after being accused of supporting incest?

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/Nearby-Comfortable79

Thank you Reddit user: u/Direct_Catterpillar77 for putting this together

AITA for walking out of a dinner after being accused of supporting incest?

Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole

Tap for Trigger Warning

Biphobia

Original Post - rareddit  Dec 9, 2023

Hey. I’m posting on here because I need people’s opinions on this. It’s so fucking stupid and such a non-issue, (unless I’m wrong about that too) that turned into something bigger.

For reference, this happened on Thursday evening. We are all in our early 20s and all names are fake.

Thursday was our friend “Sarah’s” birthday. To celebrate, our friend group decided to go out for dinner. There were about 10 of us. Everyone was in a good mood and it was really nice to just talk to everybody about whatever for hours, especially since I kind of had a stressful week.

Hours into the dinner, we landed on the topic of movies/TV shows that we were watching. Our friend “Amy” mentioned a show that I had also watched. As soon as she brought it up, I said that I really liked the show, and that the acting, writing and directing was top notch. “Mary” chimed in and said that she really didn’t like the show and how she had been watching other things. Cool. To each their own. Mary then asked me how I felt about the main romantic pairing in the show. I responded that I liked it, and thought the romance was cute. This is where the drama started.

For context, I don’t want to get too much into it because it might be confusing, but basically, the main romantic pairing is between the male lead and the female lead. There are some people who have interpreted that these characters to be related to each other. I do not. But I know that people are free to think whatever they want, and honestly thought that this topic was harmless. Well, I was wrong.

Mary took offense to me saying that I liked the romance. She asked me if I supported incest. I said of course not, as the characters are not related. She said that they ARE related and that me supporting their pairing is supporting incest. Mary then said that I should “educate” myself before saying “stupid shit”. I was dumbfounded and thought she was joking but she was REALLY angry with me about this. She told me to rethink my values because supporting incest makes me a horrible person. I told her she was making harmful accusations over a TV show. Our other friends were telling her to stop, including Sarah, but she kept claiming that I was a disgusting incest supporter. She then claimed I was homophobic, since the male lead is bisexual but still ended up with a woman. Mary just wouldn’t stop saying shit like this.

So here is where I may be the asshole. I left Sarah’s dinner. My friends were asking me to stay but I felt uncomfortable, so I paid for what I ordered and left. Many of my friends reached out to me on Friday to ask if I was okay. Some of them, while they understood why I was upset, said that it was wrong of me to leave Sarah’s birthday dinner and that I should have just ignored what Mary was saying and stuck around. I feel like they may be right and that I may have ruined her birthday by getting up and leaving, but I felt like I couldn’t stay because of Mary throwing accusations at me over something that doesn’t matter.

VERDICT: NOT THE ASSHOLE

RELEVANT COMMENTS

HauntedReader

NTA and Mary seems like she takes things FAR too seriously.

I am super curious what the show is though. Do you mind sharing?

OOP

Loki

HauntedReader

See this doesn’t even make sense with her argument. It wouldn’t be incest because the two aren’t related, they’re literally different variants of the exact same person.

It definitely falls on the weird side of things but definitely doesn’t count as incest.

Also I’m going to assume neither of you finished the series yet so like I’m even more confused by this take.

OOP

I finished the series. I don’t know about Mary. I know that they don’t end up together, but the point is that even in season 2 the implication is still there. But Mary was just upset that they were romantic in the first place.

TOP COMMENTS

mmiggs

Mary is a clear asshole. There’s no question here. And a very stupid asshole, if she thinks that bi people ending up in a relationship with someone of the opposite binary gender is homophobic. (Clue: half of the people that a typical bisexual person is attracted to are of the opposite gender. You might actually expect bi people to be in a relationship with someone of the opposite gender significantly more often than half the time. If you’re a bi man, then your set of possible partners are (for the sake of argument, and there’s some simplification of sexuality here) gay men, bi men, bi women, and straight women. The largest of these groupings, by quite a long way, is the group of straight women.

NTA

~

PurpleMarsAlien

NTA

Mary is acting weird. Attacking someone over fannish beliefs that are not part of current canon is being rather extra and over the top.

And even if this eventually becomes part of canon, someone who like the couple when it was not canon, were not supporting incest. They would have been misled by the creators.

Update  Jan 3, 2024 (Nearly 1 month later)

Hi everyone. First, thank you all for your comments and advice on my last post. It’s been about 4 weeks since the incident at the dinner, and I just wanted to give you guys an update if you’re curious.

First off, I just want to say that I have no hard feelings toward my friends who said that I should’ve stayed. I get me leaving was probably the best thing to do in that situation, but their intentions were purely good: to make sure that Sarah enjoyed her birthday dinner.

I reached out to Sarah and apologized for what happened, and for me leaving so abruptly. She said that I didn’t need to apologize and said that all was good between us. I took her out for drinks. We had a great time.

Now, onto Mary. Since the dinner, I have been texting and calling her, just to talk about what happened. So far, she has either ignored my texts and calls, or given me very short responses, either telling me that she doesn’t want to talk to me, or that she’s busy. Sarah told me that she also reached out to Mary, and while she was actually willing to talk to Sarah, the conversation pretty much went nowhere. Amy also reached out to her. Like many of you were wondering, she asked her if she was a victim of incest. I mean, It would make sense based on her reaction. However, according to Mary herself, no, she wasn’t. As far as I know, she isn’t bisexual either, so it just seems she’s throwing a tantrum over things that have nothing to do with her. Or it’s possible that she’s been spending too much time in online fandoms, but who knows.

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

0

[Concluded] My dad ate my birthday cake [Reddit]

preview

My dad ate my birthday cake

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/CloudySide7

Originally posted to r/TwoXChromosomes Thank you Redditor u/choice_evidence1983 for putting this together

My dad ate my birthday cake

Thanks to u/BakingGiraffeBakes & u/queenlegolas for suggesting this BoRU

Trigger Warnings:

Tap for TW

controlling behavior, theft, misogyny


Original Post: June 25, 2026

I’ve been seeing a lot of videos online about how men will weaponize food and how it’s seen as acceptable for men to eat up a lot of food even if it means other people won’t get any of it. That same situation happens a lot with my dad, but I guess I had assumed that since it was my birthday I’d get some of my birthday cake. This happened about two weeks ago but I’m still pissed off and really upset about it.

I made a birthday cake for my birthday which was two weeks ago. I had one slice of my cake the day of my birthday. Within 2-3 days the cake was gone. My dad ate almost the entire cake and left the empty container in the fridge. I had told him several times to slow down and even bluntly to stop eating it because he was going back for multiple slices a day. It was also in the fridge and later freezer, so it would’ve go bad. I was pretty upset about it and tried to complain about it to my mom, but she yelled at me that I was a bad person for “tempting him” and that it was rude abs cruel of me to leave food in the fridge and not expect people to eat it. I never said he couldn’t have cake, I just wanted to have MY birthday cake.

I don’t know what exactly it is I’m feeling about this whole thing. Sadness and rage I guess? I feel like I should be over it, but I keep getting reminded that I only got one small slice of my birthday cake before a grown man ate the entire rest of it. And it was a really good cake too. Sigh. I know I could just make another cake, but I’m still upset that I’ll never get back it being my birthday cake, does that even make sense? I guess it’s also the concept that I told him to stop and he still ate the cake. Also that he left the empty container in the fridge. Also it was a fairly big cake. It’s not something that should have been gone in 2-3 days consider it’s just me and my parents.

Guess I’m just venting but also wondering why is it acceptable for men to do this to their families but women are the bad guys for getting upset about it? Why is that it’s okay for a man to eat almost his daughter’s entire birthday cake but she’s the rude one for being upset about it?

ETA: The reason I didn’t eat cake in those 2-3 days is because I was constantly out of the house and doing stuff. I went to get a piece on the evening of the 3rd day and saw the empty container in the fridge. The pieces I had put in the freezer were gone when I checked as well. There was none left. I didn’t think I needed for force myself to eat the cake those days because I kept seeing the container in the fridge

ETA 2: To everyone saying cake goes bad after 2-3 days, the cake was in a container in the fridge. That makes it lasts longer, and a simple Google search will tell you that generally speaking cakes can last 5-7 days if stored properly. It was literally in a cake container (the kind they sell to keep cakes fresh longer)

ETA 3: I know I literally said it was a bit of a trend to see these stories posted around, but I’m actually still shocked about how many people have either a very similar or the exact same situation happen to them. And I will say I know it’s not all men, I have a primarily male friend group, so I definitely know that majority of men are not like this. I was more so saying that this specific mentality only seems to be present in men and that I never see women doing this. It’s not all men but it always seems to be a man.

Editor’s note: OOP has made lots of responses, I am listing some for more context that were not mentioned in the original post

Relevant Comments

OOP on the birthday tradition and cake

OOP:

My dad loved ice cream cake. I loathed ice cream cake.

Honestly my entire birthday was just this. I wanted a chocolate pistachio cake, he didn’t. I ended up getting a vanilla cake which he wanted. I didn’t want any ice cream this year and he complained, then went out and bought himself an entire tub of sherbet so he could have ice cream since I “didn’t get any for him”.

In my family the birthday person picks a place to eat on their birthday. I wanted Indian food. My dad hates Indian food so that was out. I wanted Middle Eastern food as my second pick, he didn’t so that was now out. Eventually I said let’s go to Cheesecake Factory, which he agreed to but then complained about the whole time.

In my family birthday person also picks a movie and the family is supposed to all go see it. I picked Backrooms. He didn’t want to see it and since I refused to budge he said he didn’t want to come along so I ended up seeing it by myself

Commenter 2: It’s also a bit telling of your parents’ attitude toward you that you had to bake your own birthday cake.

OOP: I had just wanted to buy a cake already made but both of them threw a stink about it. My dad threw a fit because he didn’t like the kind of cake I originally wanted, and my mom threw a fit because she doesn’t like how store bought cake tastes. So I just changed the flavor and made it myself to try and keep the peace

Commenter 3: The putting back the empty container baffles me. How old are your parents?

As a mom, I’d never eat all of something before checking if everyone else had their share. I know my husband does the same. It’s very upsetting when you are looking forward to food and later find that you can’t have it because someone else ate it or even threw it away without asking you first.

You’re not just upset about the cake but the inconsiderateness of all of it. Don’t feel bad for not “getting over it” because it’s not just about the cake but the idea that your dad didn’t even think about your feelings when he ate all of it knowing he had multiple slices and proceeded to take the LAST one and leave the container for you to find.

I’m so sorry. I hope he has the decency to buy you a new one. Or take you out to get a special slice at a nice bakery. Please know that you deserve to be treated with consideration, and I hope you have people in your life that will do that for you, even if they are people you haven’t met yet but will be part of your life in the future.

OOP:

How old are your parents?

Both are elder Gen X born in the early 1970s

your dad didn’t even think about your feelings when he ate all of it knowing he had multiple slices and proceeded to take the LAST one and leave the container for you to find.

He left a bunch of frosting in the container, so I was literally digging through it to see if there was any actual cake left and he yelled at me for that.

I hope he has the decency to buy you a new one. Or take you out to get a special slice at a nice bakery.

They won’t. Neither of my parents will because they both say I’m being a greedy brat for being upset about this

Commenter 4: Sounds like you need your own fridge with a padlock

I had the same issue as my dad because men don’t fucking think, they just go by their base emotions, in this case I see food I eat food.

I talked to my dad and raised a stink and he stopped, if yours won’t then a mini fridge is a good options

OOP: I asked for a mini fridge, but my parents said no, sadly. I’m only here for the summer since I go to college the rest of year.

I’ve tried to talk to him about this. I’ve been polite, I’ve been firm, hell I’ve actually been mean about it just to try and get my point across, but he always screams at me and then gets my mom to lecture me about “making a big deal out of nothing” and “tempting him with food”

OOP on her father and her birthday cake

OOP: He actually didn’t even bother to show up for when I did blow out my candles😭 Didn’t want to sing happy birthday or watch me blow out my candles but could show up to eat my entire cake

Commenter 5: I’m sorry, HE DIDN’T LIKE THE KIND OF CAKE YOU WANTED… on YOUR birthday.

I don’t know if this is intentionally rage-baiting us at this point, because your parents are both behaving like total assholes. Big yikes also that your dad either has

(a) binge eating disorder (b) zero self-control of his most basic impulses, or © zero respect or consideration for you.

Possibly more than one of those.

Personally I think you should bake another cake, and tell them loudly and specifically not to eat it as it’s YOUR replacement birthday cake, and spike it with surprise ghost chillis.

OOP: I fully believe he has BED because he hordes fast food wrappers. It’s not the first time he’s stolen food from me.

I got a box of protein bars for Christmas (it was a box of 12) and he ate them all and left the empty box in the pantry. Then screamed at me for being upset about it and asking him to replace them. I used to go to Crumbl Cookies more often, and he would eat the cookies I bought with my own money. When I was still in school and buying snacks to bring with my lunch he would eat the entire pack. My mom likes to make large portions of food so we can live off leftovers for the week, and he eats it all in a day or two.

OOP on getting a job to support herself

OOP: They won’t let me get a job while I’m under their roof. I have no savings, no friends that could take me in, no way to get money since I have no car and need their permission to leave the house and the town we live in.

Did OOP get to celebrate her birthday away from her parents?

OOP: I got to go out with my friends, and there’s a boy I like who wished me happy birthday so that was nice! I got to see a movie the following weekend so that was also nice

OOP’s background

OOP: White, deep south America

Commenter 6: Your mom blamed you, too, for tempting him? If I were you, I’d literally make the most fattening/sugary, calorie dense cake I could find a recipe for, and keep it stocked in the fridge for the rest of the summer. Sorry if that’s too petty but I treat myself for my birthday too, so I get it.

OOP: Her exact words were “You just like to be mean and cruel. You leave food in the fridge that he likes and just expect him to not have any of it knowing he likes it, and then you throw a temper tantrum after tempting him with it”

Commenter 7: Let me guess. He doesn’t ever cook or bake a damn thing?

OOP: Correct. When he does cook he makes it how he likes (which for him means no seasonings at all because according to him it “ruins food”) and then yells at us if we don’t like it or complain

 

I got my cake! (Post update from the birthday cake girl): June 28, 2026 (three days later)

So, hello. I’m the girl who posted a few days ago about how my dad ate almost all of my birthday cake while I only got one slice.

Things between me and my dad are still not really on good terms. He had a flip out on me the night of my post because he (the man who never cooks) was hovering over me while I was cooking and trying to micromanage everything I was doing. He was constantly opening the oven after I put stuff in there and repositioning it, lecturing me about what seasonings I was using, asking me repeatedly if I was sure I knew what I was doing. I hate when people hover over me when I’m doing stuff, so this really bothered me. I calmly told him I didn’t need help and that I could do it myself. He then went on a rant about he was trying to “educate and help me” and if he wasn’t wanted then he would just leave. I repeated that I didn’t need any help and he proceeded to take the pot holders I was using and make a show of throwing them across the room before he stormed off.

I told my mom and she just sighed and said that I probably “caught a tone” with him even though I didn’t. I admit that I can sometimes catch an attitude (I’m 19, I think I get a bit of a pass lol) but I swear that this time when talking with him I was calm and levelheaded, I made a point of that when I was telling him I could handle the cooking. So yeah, dad is still a giant toddler, and mom is still an enabler.

Anyways, back to the actually good news and point of this post. Day of my post I ended up borrowing the car later in the day and buying myself the cake I originally wanted for my birthday. It was a Walmart/Marketside cake so nothing special or expensive. It was small so it’s all been eaten by now lol but OMG it was amazing!

My mom didn’t really care for it because it was store bought and my dad outright refused to touch it. He complained about the flavor of the cake and also said he wasn’t going to “set me off” by eating it. My mom did unfortunately make me go bring him a slice and apologize for making him feel that way, which my dad thought was hilarious. He ate the cake despite complaining about it, go figure.

So yeah, while this update isn’t things getting better with either of my parents, especially not my dad, I did end up taking the suggestion of a lot of people and just went out and bought the cake I originally wanted.

ETA: I also saw that my post was reposted on TikTok, so that was quite the surprise to be doom scrolling and then hear a “Reddit Storytime” of my own post, lol.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: It’s really sad that your mother just accepts this kind of bullshit from him and thinks you should too. Does she not want men to treat you right?

You don’t need to keep contact with these people after you move out if it’s not adding anything to your life.

There’s a r/raisedbynarcissists, I found it helpful when I left my shitty parents. My dad was an unemployed food thief as well.

OOP:

Does she not want men to treat you right?

I hate the pull the “it’s just how things are in my family” card but there’s a lot of mean and toxic men in my family. My whole family is a bunch of addicts or untreated mentally illness, and nobody talks about it outside of the “oh we’re all crazy haha” joke.

There was an incident where my mom set me up with a guy, we dated for over a year, and he dumped me for not sleeping with him and my mom was on his side at first and wanted us to get back together. She eventually came around to my side, but it still hurt.

Commenter 2: I’m so mad for you that you have to put up with this fucking bullshit. You deserve better than this. I’m glad you bought your own cake to make yourself happy, but holy shit everything else in your post made me livid.

OOP: Yeah, I think I was just used to it during my teens years, then I moved out for college and it’s making everything affect me a lot more. It’s like I got desensitized from my desensitization.

Commenter 2: So you said you’re 19, are you (hopefully) at your parents’ house just for the summer?

OOP: Yep. Just summers and the winter break when school makes us go back. Probably going to spend Thanksgiving, Easter and Mardi Gras break at school

Commenter 3: good for you! it’s also good that you are clear on who your parents are. you can just observe your dad throwing his tantrum, and your mom adjusting his pacifier, and keep a blank face.

save every dime you make in an account they can’t touch and plot your escape. living alone someday is going to be glorious.

OOP: I can’t wait to live on my own one day. I also can’t wait to one day have my own kids and have them grow up in a house with parents that act like adults

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

My dad ate my birthday cake

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/CloudySide7

Originally posted to r/TwoXChromosomes Thank you Redditor u/choice_evidence1983 for putting this together

My dad ate my birthday cake

Thanks to u/BakingGiraffeBakes & u/queenlegolas for suggesting this BoRU

Trigger Warnings:

Tap for TW

controlling behavior, theft, misogyny


Original Post: June 25, 2026

I’ve been seeing a lot of videos online about how men will weaponize food and how it’s seen as acceptable for men to eat up a lot of food even if it means other people won’t get any of it. That same situation happens a lot with my dad, but I guess I had assumed that since it was my birthday I’d get some of my birthday cake. This happened about two weeks ago but I’m still pissed off and really upset about it.

I made a birthday cake for my birthday which was two weeks ago. I had one slice of my cake the day of my birthday. Within 2-3 days the cake was gone. My dad ate almost the entire cake and left the empty container in the fridge. I had told him several times to slow down and even bluntly to stop eating it because he was going back for multiple slices a day. It was also in the fridge and later freezer, so it would’ve go bad. I was pretty upset about it and tried to complain about it to my mom, but she yelled at me that I was a bad person for “tempting him” and that it was rude abs cruel of me to leave food in the fridge and not expect people to eat it. I never said he couldn’t have cake, I just wanted to have MY birthday cake.

I don’t know what exactly it is I’m feeling about this whole thing. Sadness and rage I guess? I feel like I should be over it, but I keep getting reminded that I only got one small slice of my birthday cake before a grown man ate the entire rest of it. And it was a really good cake too. Sigh. I know I could just make another cake, but I’m still upset that I’ll never get back it being my birthday cake, does that even make sense? I guess it’s also the concept that I told him to stop and he still ate the cake. Also that he left the empty container in the fridge. Also it was a fairly big cake. It’s not something that should have been gone in 2-3 days consider it’s just me and my parents.

Guess I’m just venting but also wondering why is it acceptable for men to do this to their families but women are the bad guys for getting upset about it? Why is that it’s okay for a man to eat almost his daughter’s entire birthday cake but she’s the rude one for being upset about it?

ETA: The reason I didn’t eat cake in those 2-3 days is because I was constantly out of the house and doing stuff. I went to get a piece on the evening of the 3rd day and saw the empty container in the fridge. The pieces I had put in the freezer were gone when I checked as well. There was none left. I didn’t think I needed for force myself to eat the cake those days because I kept seeing the container in the fridge

ETA 2: To everyone saying cake goes bad after 2-3 days, the cake was in a container in the fridge. That makes it lasts longer, and a simple Google search will tell you that generally speaking cakes can last 5-7 days if stored properly. It was literally in a cake container (the kind they sell to keep cakes fresh longer)

ETA 3: I know I literally said it was a bit of a trend to see these stories posted around, but I’m actually still shocked about how many people have either a very similar or the exact same situation happen to them. And I will say I know it’s not all men, I have a primarily male friend group, so I definitely know that majority of men are not like this. I was more so saying that this specific mentality only seems to be present in men and that I never see women doing this. It’s not all men but it always seems to be a man.

Editor’s note: OOP has made lots of responses, I am listing some for more context that were not mentioned in the original post

Relevant Comments

OOP on the birthday tradition and cake

OOP:

My dad loved ice cream cake. I loathed ice cream cake.

Honestly my entire birthday was just this. I wanted a chocolate pistachio cake, he didn’t. I ended up getting a vanilla cake which he wanted. I didn’t want any ice cream this year and he complained, then went out and bought himself an entire tub of sherbet so he could have ice cream since I “didn’t get any for him”.

In my family the birthday person picks a place to eat on their birthday. I wanted Indian food. My dad hates Indian food so that was out. I wanted Middle Eastern food as my second pick, he didn’t so that was now out. Eventually I said let’s go to Cheesecake Factory, which he agreed to but then complained about the whole time.

In my family birthday person also picks a movie and the family is supposed to all go see it. I picked Backrooms. He didn’t want to see it and since I refused to budge he said he didn’t want to come along so I ended up seeing it by myself

Commenter 2: It’s also a bit telling of your parents’ attitude toward you that you had to bake your own birthday cake.

OOP: I had just wanted to buy a cake already made but both of them threw a stink about it. My dad threw a fit because he didn’t like the kind of cake I originally wanted, and my mom threw a fit because she doesn’t like how store bought cake tastes. So I just changed the flavor and made it myself to try and keep the peace

Commenter 3: The putting back the empty container baffles me. How old are your parents?

As a mom, I’d never eat all of something before checking if everyone else had their share. I know my husband does the same. It’s very upsetting when you are looking forward to food and later find that you can’t have it because someone else ate it or even threw it away without asking you first.

You’re not just upset about the cake but the inconsiderateness of all of it. Don’t feel bad for not “getting over it” because it’s not just about the cake but the idea that your dad didn’t even think about your feelings when he ate all of it knowing he had multiple slices and proceeded to take the LAST one and leave the container for you to find.

I’m so sorry. I hope he has the decency to buy you a new one. Or take you out to get a special slice at a nice bakery. Please know that you deserve to be treated with consideration, and I hope you have people in your life that will do that for you, even if they are people you haven’t met yet but will be part of your life in the future.

OOP:

How old are your parents?

Both are elder Gen X born in the early 1970s

your dad didn’t even think about your feelings when he ate all of it knowing he had multiple slices and proceeded to take the LAST one and leave the container for you to find.

He left a bunch of frosting in the container, so I was literally digging through it to see if there was any actual cake left and he yelled at me for that.

I hope he has the decency to buy you a new one. Or take you out to get a special slice at a nice bakery.

They won’t. Neither of my parents will because they both say I’m being a greedy brat for being upset about this

Commenter 4: Sounds like you need your own fridge with a padlock

I had the same issue as my dad because men don’t fucking think, they just go by their base emotions, in this case I see food I eat food.

I talked to my dad and raised a stink and he stopped, if yours won’t then a mini fridge is a good options

OOP: I asked for a mini fridge, but my parents said no, sadly. I’m only here for the summer since I go to college the rest of year.

I’ve tried to talk to him about this. I’ve been polite, I’ve been firm, hell I’ve actually been mean about it just to try and get my point across, but he always screams at me and then gets my mom to lecture me about “making a big deal out of nothing” and “tempting him with food”

OOP on her father and her birthday cake

OOP: He actually didn’t even bother to show up for when I did blow out my candles😭 Didn’t want to sing happy birthday or watch me blow out my candles but could show up to eat my entire cake

Commenter 5: I’m sorry, HE DIDN’T LIKE THE KIND OF CAKE YOU WANTED… on YOUR birthday.

I don’t know if this is intentionally rage-baiting us at this point, because your parents are both behaving like total assholes. Big yikes also that your dad either has

(a) binge eating disorder (b) zero self-control of his most basic impulses, or © zero respect or consideration for you.

Possibly more than one of those.

Personally I think you should bake another cake, and tell them loudly and specifically not to eat it as it’s YOUR replacement birthday cake, and spike it with surprise ghost chillis.

OOP: I fully believe he has BED because he hordes fast food wrappers. It’s not the first time he’s stolen food from me.

I got a box of protein bars for Christmas (it was a box of 12) and he ate them all and left the empty box in the pantry. Then screamed at me for being upset about it and asking him to replace them. I used to go to Crumbl Cookies more often, and he would eat the cookies I bought with my own money. When I was still in school and buying snacks to bring with my lunch he would eat the entire pack. My mom likes to make large portions of food so we can live off leftovers for the week, and he eats it all in a day or two.

OOP on getting a job to support herself

OOP: They won’t let me get a job while I’m under their roof. I have no savings, no friends that could take me in, no way to get money since I have no car and need their permission to leave the house and the town we live in.

Did OOP get to celebrate her birthday away from her parents?

OOP: I got to go out with my friends, and there’s a boy I like who wished me happy birthday so that was nice! I got to see a movie the following weekend so that was also nice

OOP’s background

OOP: White, deep south America

Commenter 6: Your mom blamed you, too, for tempting him? If I were you, I’d literally make the most fattening/sugary, calorie dense cake I could find a recipe for, and keep it stocked in the fridge for the rest of the summer. Sorry if that’s too petty but I treat myself for my birthday too, so I get it.

OOP: Her exact words were “You just like to be mean and cruel. You leave food in the fridge that he likes and just expect him to not have any of it knowing he likes it, and then you throw a temper tantrum after tempting him with it”

Commenter 7: Let me guess. He doesn’t ever cook or bake a damn thing?

OOP: Correct. When he does cook he makes it how he likes (which for him means no seasonings at all because according to him it “ruins food”) and then yells at us if we don’t like it or complain

 

I got my cake! (Post update from the birthday cake girl): June 28, 2026 (three days later)

So, hello. I’m the girl who posted a few days ago about how my dad ate almost all of my birthday cake while I only got one slice.

Things between me and my dad are still not really on good terms. He had a flip out on me the night of my post because he (the man who never cooks) was hovering over me while I was cooking and trying to micromanage everything I was doing. He was constantly opening the oven after I put stuff in there and repositioning it, lecturing me about what seasonings I was using, asking me repeatedly if I was sure I knew what I was doing. I hate when people hover over me when I’m doing stuff, so this really bothered me. I calmly told him I didn’t need help and that I could do it myself. He then went on a rant about he was trying to “educate and help me” and if he wasn’t wanted then he would just leave. I repeated that I didn’t need any help and he proceeded to take the pot holders I was using and make a show of throwing them across the room before he stormed off.

I told my mom and she just sighed and said that I probably “caught a tone” with him even though I didn’t. I admit that I can sometimes catch an attitude (I’m 19, I think I get a bit of a pass lol) but I swear that this time when talking with him I was calm and levelheaded, I made a point of that when I was telling him I could handle the cooking. So yeah, dad is still a giant toddler, and mom is still an enabler.

Anyways, back to the actually good news and point of this post. Day of my post I ended up borrowing the car later in the day and buying myself the cake I originally wanted for my birthday. It was a Walmart/Marketside cake so nothing special or expensive. It was small so it’s all been eaten by now lol but OMG it was amazing!

My mom didn’t really care for it because it was store bought and my dad outright refused to touch it. He complained about the flavor of the cake and also said he wasn’t going to “set me off” by eating it. My mom did unfortunately make me go bring him a slice and apologize for making him feel that way, which my dad thought was hilarious. He ate the cake despite complaining about it, go figure.

So yeah, while this update isn’t things getting better with either of my parents, especially not my dad, I did end up taking the suggestion of a lot of people and just went out and bought the cake I originally wanted.

ETA: I also saw that my post was reposted on TikTok, so that was quite the surprise to be doom scrolling and then hear a “Reddit Storytime” of my own post, lol.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: It’s really sad that your mother just accepts this kind of bullshit from him and thinks you should too. Does she not want men to treat you right?

You don’t need to keep contact with these people after you move out if it’s not adding anything to your life.

There’s a r/raisedbynarcissists, I found it helpful when I left my shitty parents. My dad was an unemployed food thief as well.

OOP:

Does she not want men to treat you right?

I hate the pull the “it’s just how things are in my family” card but there’s a lot of mean and toxic men in my family. My whole family is a bunch of addicts or untreated mentally illness, and nobody talks about it outside of the “oh we’re all crazy haha” joke.

There was an incident where my mom set me up with a guy, we dated for over a year, and he dumped me for not sleeping with him and my mom was on his side at first and wanted us to get back together. She eventually came around to my side, but it still hurt.

Commenter 2: I’m so mad for you that you have to put up with this fucking bullshit. You deserve better than this. I’m glad you bought your own cake to make yourself happy, but holy shit everything else in your post made me livid.

OOP: Yeah, I think I was just used to it during my teens years, then I moved out for college and it’s making everything affect me a lot more. It’s like I got desensitized from my desensitization.

Commenter 2: So you said you’re 19, are you (hopefully) at your parents’ house just for the summer?

OOP: Yep. Just summers and the winter break when school makes us go back. Probably going to spend Thanksgiving, Easter and Mardi Gras break at school

Commenter 3: good for you! it’s also good that you are clear on who your parents are. you can just observe your dad throwing his tantrum, and your mom adjusting his pacifier, and keep a blank face.

save every dime you make in an account they can’t touch and plot your escape. living alone someday is going to be glorious.

OOP: I can’t wait to live on my own one day. I also can’t wait to one day have my own kids and have them grow up in a house with parents that act like adults

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

0

[Concluded] I got a fridge lockbox and it's destroying my relationship [Reddit]

preview

I got a fridge lockbox and it’s destroying my relationship

I am not the OOP, this was originally posted in r/relationship_advice by by u/throwraiwantmysnacks. (Special thanks to u/throwRA1a2b3c4d1 for collecting the original BORU.)

TW:

Tap for spoiler

threats, abuse, possible drug use, destruction of property

Original post (posted August 10th, 2022)

Some background: BF (28m) and I (25f) have been together five years, lived together 3. Our relationship was great, truly. We have a joint account we contribute to monthly to handle joint expenses: rent, groceries, etc. Everything else is split.

BF is 6’3”, 200 lbs and works out daily. He eats a lot to keep up his caloric intake, which is fine, except for this one issue.

We buy snacks and he always eats my half before I can even get to it. Normal food and ingredients he’s fine with, but if it’s quickly accessible, I’ll never get any. We argue, he apologizes, rinse and repeat. This is literally the only bad thing he’s done. Seriously, in all other aspects of our relationship, he’s respectful and considerate. Snacks are where all bets are off.

Anyways, last week I lost it after he finished an expensive cheese we had gotten that I really was looking forward to eating. It was all gone after an hour. I lost my shit. I didn’t speak to him for a day and ended up ordering a fridge lockbox. After our next snack run a couple of days later, I divided each snack in half and locked mine in the lockbox. From his reaction, you’d think I was murdering puppies. He said it was disrespectful and controlling, and how dare I keep food that he paid for from him. When I reminded him my money went into it too, he screamed that he didn’t give a fuck and then left. He slammed the door so hard a picture fell off the wall and broke. He didn’t come back until the next day, but that was to change for work and leave immediately. He came home late and went straight to the guest room.

Four days of this. I broke last night and asked him to please talk about it and he said that he had nothing to say to me until I got rid of the lockbox. Honestly, I’m completely appalled at this reaction and I’m genuinely worried he might be on drugs or having a mental break or something. This is the most irrationally I’ve ever seen a grown man react. He’s ignored me only to randomly ask if I’ve gotten rid of the lockbox. I am not getting rid of the lockbox.

We’re supposed to renew our lease next week. I’m considering cutting my losses and just leaving. Is this relationship even worth salvaging? Is there anything I can do to solve this? He is refusing to communicate unless I get rid of the lockbox which is not happening.

Relevant/Top comments from the original post:

monkeysaurusmom: So what I’m seeing is that he isn’t even a little sorry for pilfering all the snacks. If he were he’d stop. Now, it seems the man child is pitching a full on temper tantrum because you pushed back. Instead of saying “yeah, I’m kind of being a jerk I can understand why you’d do that” he doubles down on his selfish behavior by pulling a silent treatment and this toxic temper tantrum. This is more than a food issue that’s been kicked over. It’s control and a deep seeded selfishness. I would bet you a dollar and a doughnut that if you start rummaging around you’d see there is a lot more of selfish behaviors that you just don’t fight back on.

animateAlternatives: Entitlement is the root of abuse. Abuse isn’t a specific checklist of behavior, it’s a moral framework where the abusive person feels entitled to the victim. OP check out “why does he do that?”, There are free PDFs online. Be careful!!

PhilosopherOk6002: OP, I’d be pissed too if my food (that I also paid for) was always eaten. You wouldn’t have had to get a lockbox if he respected your simple boundary.

But woah, he had a major meltdown over something so small. Based on his reaction, are you sure this is your only problem in the relationship? Does he have any anger or control issues? His response is way out of line & makes me think of a DV situation, esp because of how the picture broke.

Bottom line is that if he scared you or if he’s being unreasonable, you don’t have to make things work. Definitely spend some time reassessing your relationship. Ask yourself if he ever disrespects your boundaries in any other ways & if he ever handles smaller-scale conflicts poorly like this.

Coco_Dirichlet: Many couples have one person who eats more because they are taller or exercise more, and they can still shop together because one partner is not eating everything! His case is way too extreme. You can go 50/50 on some items like staples and special dinners, but not everything and definitely not snacks. It’s like if Chris Hemsworth came to my house to eat every day. He would probably go through my weekly supply food in 2 days.

Edit:

Wait, do you think he could be on steroids?

They cause increase of appetite and mood problems. It can get very dangerous.

UPDATE (Posted 2 days later on the same post)

Hey guys, I don’t know if anyone wanted an update, but here it is. A lot happened.

Boyfriend kept staying out late and refusing to talk. So I tried to talk to my boyfriend about the lockbox again, and I mentioned that I didn’t think the lockbox was the real issue. But he was a brick wall, insisted that it’s abusive and controlling to deny him food. I kept pushing, asking if he was on drugs or cheating. I said him flipping out over something so small and staying out at all hours was suspicious as hell. I said that I thought he was using the lockbox as an excuse to be out of the house doing something bad. Me saying that unleashed an hours-long screaming tantrum that ultimately resulted in him throwing my MacBook against the wall and shattering it. Honestly, I really thought he was going to hurt me.

So, yeah. Called my dad, who called the cops. I don’t want to get too into the legality of it, but I’m pressing charges for destruction of property. It was a $2500 laptop.

Dad and my godfather moved me out yesterday, and I’m now looking for a new place. I don’t have a lot except for clothes, and a couple of kitchen appliances. I left the lockbox, but took my snacks with me, because fuck him. I left it locked, too.

Ex-bf has been spamming me. I’d block him, but I feel like I need this for evidence in case his behavior escalates. I texted him the first night that we are done, took our photos down, everything. He began ranting at me.

Some gems:

  • raging about how I still didn’t get rid of the lockbox
  • Asking for stuff he gifted me back
  • Telling me I owe him money and rent for his new place
  • That I owe him a car(?) I have no idea why he would say this, I have never even driven his current car
  • That my MacBook was old snd worthless and he wouldn’t pay for a new one (I bought it last year brand new)

After about an hour, I guess he realized that we were actually broken up and he couldn’t bitch me down anymore. Then came the paragraphs about how he was gonna marry me, he loves me, he wants to be better for me, that I can keep the gifts and he’ll buy me a better MacBook. He freaked out over seeing I took our pictures down from SM. He then started sending me screenshots of his Google searches of engagement rings and telling me to pick one. He also sent a couple voice messages of him just sobbing.

Any respect I had for him as a person is just completely gone. I want nothing to do with this man. I don’t care if he’s having a breakdown, or on something. He’s not my problem. I screenshotted his messages and forwarded them to his mother. She can deal with her son. That’s the most I’ll ever do for him again.

As for me, I’ll be okay. I have some savings, so taking on full rent for a place as well as deposit and fees won’t be too much. This has been a weird week. I feel like I should be sad, but like I said I lost all respect and don’t feel anything but disdain for him. My parents have been buying me my favorite comfort snacks and being super supportive. They’re gently pushing for therapy, and I think it’s probably a good idea. I’ll start my search once I’m settled in a new place.

Relevant comments after the edit:

Character_Study5220: im proud of u

ur parents r awesome, relationships with boys like this can really mess with ur mindset in the long run - u don’t wanna internalise his shitty treatment of u and therapy can help with that

Deleted user: Save all electronic information that he sends you. DO NOT put stuff on social media about your new place, that can give him clues to where you are living. Talk to your supervisors and notify security at your job, they may ask for a recent picture of him. Take out a restraining order against him if it looks like he is remotely stalking you.

joe-dirt-1001: Sorry that it played out like this, but also glad that you stood your ground and will be moving on to a brighter future.

Stay strong and good luck.

Slow-Analysis6522: I’m glad you’ve sorta solved this. Sometimes the grass is indeed greener on the other side. This man is a textbook abuser.

This last offer is tempting, insist on that last point to see if he at least will give you a new computer for breaking the one you had.

kevin_r13: Yeah I wasn’t sure how the story was going to end but I was going to say that he’s showing some very violent actions, which would have been cause for breaking up but looks like that’s where the story went so stand by your ground and let him deal with the consequences of his actions, including the actions of continuing to eat your share of the snacks.

It was quite easy and controllable to just say , “look we both bought the snacks . I eat this much and I’m going to stop because I love my girlfriend who’s going to eat the other half”.

In fact there’s even the concept of saying I love my girlfriend so much that I’m going to eat only 30 or 40% of the snacks because I want her to enjoy the majority of the snacks.

These kinds of ideas and concepts could have been something he did instead of getting mad calling you names and throwing your property and breaking it

***REMINDER: This is a repost sub. I am not the OOP.***

I got a fridge lockbox and it’s destroying my relationship

I am not the OOP, this was originally posted in r/relationship_advice by by u/throwraiwantmysnacks. (Special thanks to u/throwRA1a2b3c4d1 for collecting the original BORU.)

TW:

Tap for spoiler

threats, abuse, possible drug use, destruction of property

Original post (posted August 10th, 2022)

Some background: BF (28m) and I (25f) have been together five years, lived together 3. Our relationship was great, truly. We have a joint account we contribute to monthly to handle joint expenses: rent, groceries, etc. Everything else is split.

BF is 6’3”, 200 lbs and works out daily. He eats a lot to keep up his caloric intake, which is fine, except for this one issue.

We buy snacks and he always eats my half before I can even get to it. Normal food and ingredients he’s fine with, but if it’s quickly accessible, I’ll never get any. We argue, he apologizes, rinse and repeat. This is literally the only bad thing he’s done. Seriously, in all other aspects of our relationship, he’s respectful and considerate. Snacks are where all bets are off.

Anyways, last week I lost it after he finished an expensive cheese we had gotten that I really was looking forward to eating. It was all gone after an hour. I lost my shit. I didn’t speak to him for a day and ended up ordering a fridge lockbox. After our next snack run a couple of days later, I divided each snack in half and locked mine in the lockbox. From his reaction, you’d think I was murdering puppies. He said it was disrespectful and controlling, and how dare I keep food that he paid for from him. When I reminded him my money went into it too, he screamed that he didn’t give a fuck and then left. He slammed the door so hard a picture fell off the wall and broke. He didn’t come back until the next day, but that was to change for work and leave immediately. He came home late and went straight to the guest room.

Four days of this. I broke last night and asked him to please talk about it and he said that he had nothing to say to me until I got rid of the lockbox. Honestly, I’m completely appalled at this reaction and I’m genuinely worried he might be on drugs or having a mental break or something. This is the most irrationally I’ve ever seen a grown man react. He’s ignored me only to randomly ask if I’ve gotten rid of the lockbox. I am not getting rid of the lockbox.

We’re supposed to renew our lease next week. I’m considering cutting my losses and just leaving. Is this relationship even worth salvaging? Is there anything I can do to solve this? He is refusing to communicate unless I get rid of the lockbox which is not happening.

Relevant/Top comments from the original post:

monkeysaurusmom: So what I’m seeing is that he isn’t even a little sorry for pilfering all the snacks. If he were he’d stop. Now, it seems the man child is pitching a full on temper tantrum because you pushed back. Instead of saying “yeah, I’m kind of being a jerk I can understand why you’d do that” he doubles down on his selfish behavior by pulling a silent treatment and this toxic temper tantrum. This is more than a food issue that’s been kicked over. It’s control and a deep seeded selfishness. I would bet you a dollar and a doughnut that if you start rummaging around you’d see there is a lot more of selfish behaviors that you just don’t fight back on.

animateAlternatives: Entitlement is the root of abuse. Abuse isn’t a specific checklist of behavior, it’s a moral framework where the abusive person feels entitled to the victim. OP check out “why does he do that?”, There are free PDFs online. Be careful!!

PhilosopherOk6002: OP, I’d be pissed too if my food (that I also paid for) was always eaten. You wouldn’t have had to get a lockbox if he respected your simple boundary.

But woah, he had a major meltdown over something so small. Based on his reaction, are you sure this is your only problem in the relationship? Does he have any anger or control issues? His response is way out of line & makes me think of a DV situation, esp because of how the picture broke.

Bottom line is that if he scared you or if he’s being unreasonable, you don’t have to make things work. Definitely spend some time reassessing your relationship. Ask yourself if he ever disrespects your boundaries in any other ways & if he ever handles smaller-scale conflicts poorly like this.

Coco_Dirichlet: Many couples have one person who eats more because they are taller or exercise more, and they can still shop together because one partner is not eating everything! His case is way too extreme. You can go 50/50 on some items like staples and special dinners, but not everything and definitely not snacks. It’s like if Chris Hemsworth came to my house to eat every day. He would probably go through my weekly supply food in 2 days.

Edit:

Wait, do you think he could be on steroids?

They cause increase of appetite and mood problems. It can get very dangerous.

UPDATE (Posted 2 days later on the same post)

Hey guys, I don’t know if anyone wanted an update, but here it is. A lot happened.

Boyfriend kept staying out late and refusing to talk. So I tried to talk to my boyfriend about the lockbox again, and I mentioned that I didn’t think the lockbox was the real issue. But he was a brick wall, insisted that it’s abusive and controlling to deny him food. I kept pushing, asking if he was on drugs or cheating. I said him flipping out over something so small and staying out at all hours was suspicious as hell. I said that I thought he was using the lockbox as an excuse to be out of the house doing something bad. Me saying that unleashed an hours-long screaming tantrum that ultimately resulted in him throwing my MacBook against the wall and shattering it. Honestly, I really thought he was going to hurt me.

So, yeah. Called my dad, who called the cops. I don’t want to get too into the legality of it, but I’m pressing charges for destruction of property. It was a $2500 laptop.

Dad and my godfather moved me out yesterday, and I’m now looking for a new place. I don’t have a lot except for clothes, and a couple of kitchen appliances. I left the lockbox, but took my snacks with me, because fuck him. I left it locked, too.

Ex-bf has been spamming me. I’d block him, but I feel like I need this for evidence in case his behavior escalates. I texted him the first night that we are done, took our photos down, everything. He began ranting at me.

Some gems:

  • raging about how I still didn’t get rid of the lockbox
  • Asking for stuff he gifted me back
  • Telling me I owe him money and rent for his new place
  • That I owe him a car(?) I have no idea why he would say this, I have never even driven his current car
  • That my MacBook was old snd worthless and he wouldn’t pay for a new one (I bought it last year brand new)

After about an hour, I guess he realized that we were actually broken up and he couldn’t bitch me down anymore. Then came the paragraphs about how he was gonna marry me, he loves me, he wants to be better for me, that I can keep the gifts and he’ll buy me a better MacBook. He freaked out over seeing I took our pictures down from SM. He then started sending me screenshots of his Google searches of engagement rings and telling me to pick one. He also sent a couple voice messages of him just sobbing.

Any respect I had for him as a person is just completely gone. I want nothing to do with this man. I don’t care if he’s having a breakdown, or on something. He’s not my problem. I screenshotted his messages and forwarded them to his mother. She can deal with her son. That’s the most I’ll ever do for him again.

As for me, I’ll be okay. I have some savings, so taking on full rent for a place as well as deposit and fees won’t be too much. This has been a weird week. I feel like I should be sad, but like I said I lost all respect and don’t feel anything but disdain for him. My parents have been buying me my favorite comfort snacks and being super supportive. They’re gently pushing for therapy, and I think it’s probably a good idea. I’ll start my search once I’m settled in a new place.

Relevant comments after the edit:

Character_Study5220: im proud of u

ur parents r awesome, relationships with boys like this can really mess with ur mindset in the long run - u don’t wanna internalise his shitty treatment of u and therapy can help with that

Deleted user: Save all electronic information that he sends you. DO NOT put stuff on social media about your new place, that can give him clues to where you are living. Talk to your supervisors and notify security at your job, they may ask for a recent picture of him. Take out a restraining order against him if it looks like he is remotely stalking you.

joe-dirt-1001: Sorry that it played out like this, but also glad that you stood your ground and will be moving on to a brighter future.

Stay strong and good luck.

Slow-Analysis6522: I’m glad you’ve sorta solved this. Sometimes the grass is indeed greener on the other side. This man is a textbook abuser.

This last offer is tempting, insist on that last point to see if he at least will give you a new computer for breaking the one you had.

kevin_r13: Yeah I wasn’t sure how the story was going to end but I was going to say that he’s showing some very violent actions, which would have been cause for breaking up but looks like that’s where the story went so stand by your ground and let him deal with the consequences of his actions, including the actions of continuing to eat your share of the snacks.

It was quite easy and controllable to just say , “look we both bought the snacks . I eat this much and I’m going to stop because I love my girlfriend who’s going to eat the other half”.

In fact there’s even the concept of saying I love my girlfriend so much that I’m going to eat only 30 or 40% of the snacks because I want her to enjoy the majority of the snacks.

These kinds of ideas and concepts could have been something he did instead of getting mad calling you names and throwing your property and breaking it

***REMINDER: This is a repost sub. I am not the OOP.***

0

[Concluded] My CEO is harassing me and my family to stay after resignation [Reddit]

preview

Source: Reddit user choice_evidence1983

My CEO is harassing me and my family to stay after resignation.

I am NOT OOP. OOP is u/Fun_Hovercraft5881

Originally posted to r/auscorp

My CEO is harassing me and my family to stay after resignation.

Thanks to u/wardy_12 for the suggestion


Original Post: February 25, 2026

I am using a burner account because my real account could identify me and my current employer.

I joined my current employer straight out of university eight years ago as a software engineer. I was employee number nine during their startup phase and received stock, which is now just under 3% of the company. The company now has around 120 employees but only 6 of remaining early crew have stock options. Since the day I joined, I have always reported to the Head of Engineering. I have never reported directly to the CEO. Because I joined early, both my partner and I know the CEO and his family in a semi‑work, semi‑social way.

The company built some innovative technology, has good income but has struggled to expand because they lack the funds. I know the CEO/founder has been trying to raise capital or sell the business for about a year now without much luck, and he has been open about this with the early staff.

During my annual review last year, I asked about moving into a more senior role. My manager said the next role up was his, and he joked he had no plans to move. He did say he would support me if I wanted to apply for more senior roles outside the company because he believed I had the skills and experience to step up.

Around October last year, a much larger company reached out to me with a more senior role. After a few interviews, it became clear they were looking to build a competing product to my current employer. I eventually received a provisional offer in January. They reviewed my contract and confirmed I do not have a non‑compete. This was also confirmed by my manager and HR at my current employer. They completed the reference check with my manager and said they got a “stellar reference.”

I received the formal offer, accepted it, and resigned last Thursday. The next day the CEO messaged me asking for a call, where he requested that I postpone my end date to mid‑May. I am not working on any time‑critical projects. When I asked my manager, he said he was also asked to try to convince me to stay until mid‑May. The CEO and my manager mentioned my stock options, which will be forfeited if I leave. I already knew this, but given the state of the company, I’m not concerned about losing them as there is no realistic chance to sell them anyway.

I spoke to my new employer, and they want me to start in March. They are keen to get going and plan to send me to their head office in Europe for induction in April and May. My partner and I want to travel together and enjoy a holiday over Easter while our living and travel costs are covered. Last Friday I emailed my CEO thanking him for the past eight years but confirming my final day would be in March. He called me immediately after receiving the email and again tried hard to convince me to stay until May, again mentioning the stock forfeiture.

Last night the CEO’s wife, who we’ve known since the startup days, called my partner and asked her to talk to me about staying until May. My partner felt very uncomfortable and ended the call quickly.

Over the weekend, I spoke to my current manager, and he said that if he were me, he would try to push back the end date to mid‑May. I also spoke to a family friend who is a lawyer (corporate law), and he confirmed that my contract does not contain a non‑compete. He mentioned that the CEO might want me to stay because the business could be less valuable for sale if I leave to work on a competing product.

I am feeling completely creeped out by this. I still have almost three weeks left in my notice period. I am currently earning about $180,000, and the new job is $200,000.

TLDR: I resigned from my job last week after getting a new job offer, and I have a six week notice period. After I resigned, the CEO has been calling me to change my finish date to mid‑May. Over the weekend, the CEO’s wife even called my partner asking her to convince me to change my end date.

Are these calls legal? Can they block my new job? How do I get them to stop so that I don’t have to deal with awkward conversations for the rest of my notice period?

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: I would ask your lawyer friend about your vesting options for the stock. 3% is not small. Usually you would have a vesting schedule for the stock of when you can exercise your stock option. It shouldn’t be auto forfeiture since its part of your compensation and there should have been a way to retrieve it. Companies must have a way to get your stock otherwise it would be an unlawful benefit you can never receive.

OOP: I looked at this last year. I can exercise my options for just over $100,000 in cash. A former co-worker exercised her options right after COVID and she is still holding them with no way to sell them. Also don’t have a handy $100 grand

Commenter 2: You need to speak with a friend in finance.

If you exercise “options” they become actual “shares” (it’s an option to buy the share at a set price).

You should be able to find out what the current valuation for the company is. You forfeit the “options” if you leave but if you exercise them into shares you own them and still own them if you leave.

Commenter 3: Why are the shares not saleable? Usually the way options work, you can sell them when you exercise the option. E.g., the company is worth a million, and they give you an option for 1000 shares at $100k. Years later, the company is worth 4 million, and 1000 shares are worth $400k. So you exercise your options, sell a quarter of the shares to cover the cost of exercising, and end up with 750 shares worth $300k. Or you cash them all out, and walk away with $300k cash (less tax).

OOP: Company is not public. No one I know is interested buying 3% of a startup/mid stage company which is 60% controlled by the founder.

Commenter 4: Definitely sounds like your CEO is trying to look after you and make sure you get your 3% when the business sells, there’s no other logical explanation to me.

I would ask the CEO to a coffee and just have a mate to mate chat and ask what the main reason for wanting you to stay is so you can make an educated decision. Make sure to go into this chat in a very appreciative way in terms of your time at the company, their support etc. Don’t position it in an accusatory way.

OOP: CEO is currently traveling overseas and is not available for a coffee. All communication has been via teams or phone.

Commenter 5: You know the answer. You want to leave on good terms but you also have to do what’s right for you and your family.

I would politely once again tell them no, and that your decision has been made.

You are happy to forfeit your stock options, the future value of the business is not your problem.

OOP: I have repeatedly said no but the ongoing attempts to make me stay is making me anxious. I feel like they have some nuclear option they have not used yet.

Commenter 6: OP, don’t fumble this. What’s your company ARR, NRR and growth rate atm? You might be throwing away millions. 3% is a large stake for a early employee. Even if it sells for high tens of million, it is still a big number. (editor’s note: Annual Recurring Revenue, Net Revenue Retention)

I’m also a software engineer, early employee and have good relationships with Head of Eng and CEO since the start. I’m not looking to move anywhere but my options get forfeited only 5 years after my departure.

 

Update #1: March 4, 2026 (one week later)

I have received a number of DMs asking for an update.

Thank you to everyone who offered feedback and advice on my original post. I read all your comments, thought things through carefully, and discussed everything with my partner and family.

Most of you suggested that I leave now rather than inconvenience my new employer or risk starting the next role on the wrong foot. My partner has been saying the same thing since I received the offer. After reflecting on your advice, I realized my current employer has been taking advantage of my loyalty, especially by not promoting me or offering meaningful career progression. I’m normally a very passive person, and I think this situation was the push I needed to finally move on.

Over the weekend, I received another phone call from the CEO, and that was the final straw. When I asked why I was being asked to stay until May, he was evasive and non‑committal. So, on Monday, with help from my partner’s brother (a lawyer), I wrote an honest letter to the head of HR and copied in my manager and the CEO.

In the letter, I thanked the CEO, my manager, and the company for the past eight years of experience that ultimately gave me the confidence to lead my own team at my new organisation. I also stated that I felt unduly pressured and harassed to stay significantly beyond my notice period, which could jeopardize my new role. I requested that they stop contacting me about the matter and advised that if it continued, I would consider pursuing legal options to protect my mental health.

I sent the letter Monday evening. By Tuesday morning, HR asked me to join a Teams meeting. My manager and the head of HR were there, and they offered to pay out my notice period and end my employment immediately. They also confirmed that neither the CEO, his wife, nor any other company officer would contact me again, except through HR. They provided a separation agreement that seemed straightforward. My lawyer friend reviewed it, and I signed it that evening.

Yesterday, I returned my equipment, said a quick goodbye, and left. This morning, all payments owed to me arrived in my account.

With the extra three weeks of paid leave, my partner and I are now planning to head to Europe earlier, and my new employer just agreed to change the planned flights to make this possible.

TLDR: I told my employer I’m leaving, and I’ve been pressured to stay on well past my notice period. I pushed back, and they ended up offering to pay out my notice and end my employment as of yesterday. Thanks to your advice, I also got an extra three weeks of paid leave.

 

Final Update: June 28, 2026 (over 3.5 months later)

The day after my second post I formally finished up with my previous employer. A week later, we traveled to Europe with airfares for both paid by my new employer. They actually paid for a business class fair for me which we used to buy two economy return tickets. My official work was starting after Easter, so we had almost 4 weeks as a vacation and the pay in lieu was covering all the costs. We travelled around Europe, and I proposed to my partner, and she said yes. We spent Easter with some family in Ireland started work on the 13th of April.

Everything thig was going really well. Plan was to build and market the next generation of the product developed by my previous employer. The new company had the money and resources to make it happen. I worked with their salespeople to work out a value proposition and pitch deck which they would use to approach customers after the summer. My new employer had very good contacts into customers who are also based in Europe and were confident they can convert them quickly. We planned out building a team in Australia and possibly even approaching some my ex-colleagues. My task was to create a technical strategy and help create a more detailed business plan for approval by the board before they took their summer vacation in mid-June.

We came back to Australia in mid-May. I hit the ground running and started working on the technical and business plans. I sent out a few feelers to old colleagues about meeting for a coffee and my new role but there were no replies. Later that week I got a ping from my old manager asking to meet about a coffee. I met with him, and this is where things started to go very wrong. My old colleagues who I had reached out to told him I had done so. They did not want to move. They felt uncomfortable talking to me, hence the coffee meeting.

It turns out my previous employer had been purchased. The CEO has put together a deal where three of their largest customers created a company where they owned 30% each and he owned 10%. This new company then purchased my previous employer. The sale price was just over 35 million Australian dollars. The option and shareholders got cashed out. The non shareholding staff received bonuses of $5,000-$30,000 depending on their length of services. Key staff have been offered 100% of their salary as a bonus per year if they stayed for two more years. He even engineered the options to be bought out without having to exercise them so the options holders could claim the 50% CGT discount for holding them for more than a year.

Message delivered, nicely but firmly, was none of my colleagues wanted to move. Please stop contacting them.

My share would have been about $960,000 before tax. My first rection was anger. Off the cuff, at the coffee meeting, I threatened to sue to get my share. This wrapped up the coffee quickly. I planned to look over my contracts later that weekend with my soon to be brother-in-law/lawyer. But before we could, I got an email from the in-house lawyer for my previous employer. Attached were screen shots of slack conversations, phone logs and copies of emails. The bottom line was the CEO had instructed my manager to do “whatever it takes” to get me to stay until the close and pushed this message repeatedly. They could not tell me the details as they were waiting for regulatory approval from 4 counties as 3 competitors were forming a joint venture with a supplier. That process had been happening for almost 9 months. Any leak or sign of impropriety would sink the whole deal. When I threatened legal action that changed everything. That would have sunk the deal, so they cut all contact quickly and moved on. The email said that considering all the information provided my assertion is wrong and if we commence legal action, they will use this email as evidence when they pursue costs. My fiancée’s brother agreed and I replied back apologizing, completely withdrawing any allegations of impropriety and promising not to sue.

I was devastated. I had left close to a million dollars behind when I changed jobs. My plan for a new team was in tatters. To say I shut down is an understatement. I barely could think straight. I took a few mental health days and managed to find a privately funded psychologist. I am slowly beginning to recover. Even after 6 weeks, even things like planning for the wedding reminds me of what it could have been. To say my relationship is at a low point is an understatement. This weekend we went to buy a couch, and I almost ended up in tears because I thought about what we could afford to spend.

To add insult to injury I was told two weeks ago my board paper for the new venture has been delayed until after the summer break. Informally I get the feeling the board is reevaluating the whole strategy as my previous company has taken the three biggest customers off the table. They are likely to lock in a few others too. Some of the smaller customers may still be an opportunity but the financials are not nearly attractive with just them. I am hoping for the best.

I am barely functional enough to write this post now, and it took all my effort and a weekend to do that.

Even though logically I still have a well-paying job with a good company, have good friends and about to get married soon I can’t stop dwelling on what could have been. I am still at the stage of blaming myself for the way I acted that resulted in this situation. Writing this is has been cathartic and somewhat therapeutic. I am angry or sad all the time. I am sure this will pass eventually but I think I will regret how I acted for the rest of my life.

If I get the courage to revisit this post in the next few days I should be able to answer any questions

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

Source: Reddit user choice_evidence1983

My CEO is harassing me and my family to stay after resignation.

I am NOT OOP. OOP is u/Fun_Hovercraft5881

Originally posted to r/auscorp

My CEO is harassing me and my family to stay after resignation.

Thanks to u/wardy_12 for the suggestion


Original Post: February 25, 2026

I am using a burner account because my real account could identify me and my current employer.

I joined my current employer straight out of university eight years ago as a software engineer. I was employee number nine during their startup phase and received stock, which is now just under 3% of the company. The company now has around 120 employees but only 6 of remaining early crew have stock options. Since the day I joined, I have always reported to the Head of Engineering. I have never reported directly to the CEO. Because I joined early, both my partner and I know the CEO and his family in a semi‑work, semi‑social way.

The company built some innovative technology, has good income but has struggled to expand because they lack the funds. I know the CEO/founder has been trying to raise capital or sell the business for about a year now without much luck, and he has been open about this with the early staff.

During my annual review last year, I asked about moving into a more senior role. My manager said the next role up was his, and he joked he had no plans to move. He did say he would support me if I wanted to apply for more senior roles outside the company because he believed I had the skills and experience to step up.

Around October last year, a much larger company reached out to me with a more senior role. After a few interviews, it became clear they were looking to build a competing product to my current employer. I eventually received a provisional offer in January. They reviewed my contract and confirmed I do not have a non‑compete. This was also confirmed by my manager and HR at my current employer. They completed the reference check with my manager and said they got a “stellar reference.”

I received the formal offer, accepted it, and resigned last Thursday. The next day the CEO messaged me asking for a call, where he requested that I postpone my end date to mid‑May. I am not working on any time‑critical projects. When I asked my manager, he said he was also asked to try to convince me to stay until mid‑May. The CEO and my manager mentioned my stock options, which will be forfeited if I leave. I already knew this, but given the state of the company, I’m not concerned about losing them as there is no realistic chance to sell them anyway.

I spoke to my new employer, and they want me to start in March. They are keen to get going and plan to send me to their head office in Europe for induction in April and May. My partner and I want to travel together and enjoy a holiday over Easter while our living and travel costs are covered. Last Friday I emailed my CEO thanking him for the past eight years but confirming my final day would be in March. He called me immediately after receiving the email and again tried hard to convince me to stay until May, again mentioning the stock forfeiture.

Last night the CEO’s wife, who we’ve known since the startup days, called my partner and asked her to talk to me about staying until May. My partner felt very uncomfortable and ended the call quickly.

Over the weekend, I spoke to my current manager, and he said that if he were me, he would try to push back the end date to mid‑May. I also spoke to a family friend who is a lawyer (corporate law), and he confirmed that my contract does not contain a non‑compete. He mentioned that the CEO might want me to stay because the business could be less valuable for sale if I leave to work on a competing product.

I am feeling completely creeped out by this. I still have almost three weeks left in my notice period. I am currently earning about $180,000, and the new job is $200,000.

TLDR: I resigned from my job last week after getting a new job offer, and I have a six week notice period. After I resigned, the CEO has been calling me to change my finish date to mid‑May. Over the weekend, the CEO’s wife even called my partner asking her to convince me to change my end date.

Are these calls legal? Can they block my new job? How do I get them to stop so that I don’t have to deal with awkward conversations for the rest of my notice period?

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: I would ask your lawyer friend about your vesting options for the stock. 3% is not small. Usually you would have a vesting schedule for the stock of when you can exercise your stock option. It shouldn’t be auto forfeiture since its part of your compensation and there should have been a way to retrieve it. Companies must have a way to get your stock otherwise it would be an unlawful benefit you can never receive.

OOP: I looked at this last year. I can exercise my options for just over $100,000 in cash. A former co-worker exercised her options right after COVID and she is still holding them with no way to sell them. Also don’t have a handy $100 grand

Commenter 2: You need to speak with a friend in finance.

If you exercise “options” they become actual “shares” (it’s an option to buy the share at a set price).

You should be able to find out what the current valuation for the company is. You forfeit the “options” if you leave but if you exercise them into shares you own them and still own them if you leave.

Commenter 3: Why are the shares not saleable? Usually the way options work, you can sell them when you exercise the option. E.g., the company is worth a million, and they give you an option for 1000 shares at $100k. Years later, the company is worth 4 million, and 1000 shares are worth $400k. So you exercise your options, sell a quarter of the shares to cover the cost of exercising, and end up with 750 shares worth $300k. Or you cash them all out, and walk away with $300k cash (less tax).

OOP: Company is not public. No one I know is interested buying 3% of a startup/mid stage company which is 60% controlled by the founder.

Commenter 4: Definitely sounds like your CEO is trying to look after you and make sure you get your 3% when the business sells, there’s no other logical explanation to me.

I would ask the CEO to a coffee and just have a mate to mate chat and ask what the main reason for wanting you to stay is so you can make an educated decision. Make sure to go into this chat in a very appreciative way in terms of your time at the company, their support etc. Don’t position it in an accusatory way.

OOP: CEO is currently traveling overseas and is not available for a coffee. All communication has been via teams or phone.

Commenter 5: You know the answer. You want to leave on good terms but you also have to do what’s right for you and your family.

I would politely once again tell them no, and that your decision has been made.

You are happy to forfeit your stock options, the future value of the business is not your problem.

OOP: I have repeatedly said no but the ongoing attempts to make me stay is making me anxious. I feel like they have some nuclear option they have not used yet.

Commenter 6: OP, don’t fumble this. What’s your company ARR, NRR and growth rate atm? You might be throwing away millions. 3% is a large stake for a early employee. Even if it sells for high tens of million, it is still a big number. (editor’s note: Annual Recurring Revenue, Net Revenue Retention)

I’m also a software engineer, early employee and have good relationships with Head of Eng and CEO since the start. I’m not looking to move anywhere but my options get forfeited only 5 years after my departure.

 

Update #1: March 4, 2026 (one week later)

I have received a number of DMs asking for an update.

Thank you to everyone who offered feedback and advice on my original post. I read all your comments, thought things through carefully, and discussed everything with my partner and family.

Most of you suggested that I leave now rather than inconvenience my new employer or risk starting the next role on the wrong foot. My partner has been saying the same thing since I received the offer. After reflecting on your advice, I realized my current employer has been taking advantage of my loyalty, especially by not promoting me or offering meaningful career progression. I’m normally a very passive person, and I think this situation was the push I needed to finally move on.

Over the weekend, I received another phone call from the CEO, and that was the final straw. When I asked why I was being asked to stay until May, he was evasive and non‑committal. So, on Monday, with help from my partner’s brother (a lawyer), I wrote an honest letter to the head of HR and copied in my manager and the CEO.

In the letter, I thanked the CEO, my manager, and the company for the past eight years of experience that ultimately gave me the confidence to lead my own team at my new organisation. I also stated that I felt unduly pressured and harassed to stay significantly beyond my notice period, which could jeopardize my new role. I requested that they stop contacting me about the matter and advised that if it continued, I would consider pursuing legal options to protect my mental health.

I sent the letter Monday evening. By Tuesday morning, HR asked me to join a Teams meeting. My manager and the head of HR were there, and they offered to pay out my notice period and end my employment immediately. They also confirmed that neither the CEO, his wife, nor any other company officer would contact me again, except through HR. They provided a separation agreement that seemed straightforward. My lawyer friend reviewed it, and I signed it that evening.

Yesterday, I returned my equipment, said a quick goodbye, and left. This morning, all payments owed to me arrived in my account.

With the extra three weeks of paid leave, my partner and I are now planning to head to Europe earlier, and my new employer just agreed to change the planned flights to make this possible.

TLDR: I told my employer I’m leaving, and I’ve been pressured to stay on well past my notice period. I pushed back, and they ended up offering to pay out my notice and end my employment as of yesterday. Thanks to your advice, I also got an extra three weeks of paid leave.

 

Final Update: June 28, 2026 (over 3.5 months later)

The day after my second post I formally finished up with my previous employer. A week later, we traveled to Europe with airfares for both paid by my new employer. They actually paid for a business class fair for me which we used to buy two economy return tickets. My official work was starting after Easter, so we had almost 4 weeks as a vacation and the pay in lieu was covering all the costs. We travelled around Europe, and I proposed to my partner, and she said yes. We spent Easter with some family in Ireland started work on the 13th of April.

Everything thig was going really well. Plan was to build and market the next generation of the product developed by my previous employer. The new company had the money and resources to make it happen. I worked with their salespeople to work out a value proposition and pitch deck which they would use to approach customers after the summer. My new employer had very good contacts into customers who are also based in Europe and were confident they can convert them quickly. We planned out building a team in Australia and possibly even approaching some my ex-colleagues. My task was to create a technical strategy and help create a more detailed business plan for approval by the board before they took their summer vacation in mid-June.

We came back to Australia in mid-May. I hit the ground running and started working on the technical and business plans. I sent out a few feelers to old colleagues about meeting for a coffee and my new role but there were no replies. Later that week I got a ping from my old manager asking to meet about a coffee. I met with him, and this is where things started to go very wrong. My old colleagues who I had reached out to told him I had done so. They did not want to move. They felt uncomfortable talking to me, hence the coffee meeting.

It turns out my previous employer had been purchased. The CEO has put together a deal where three of their largest customers created a company where they owned 30% each and he owned 10%. This new company then purchased my previous employer. The sale price was just over 35 million Australian dollars. The option and shareholders got cashed out. The non shareholding staff received bonuses of $5,000-$30,000 depending on their length of services. Key staff have been offered 100% of their salary as a bonus per year if they stayed for two more years. He even engineered the options to be bought out without having to exercise them so the options holders could claim the 50% CGT discount for holding them for more than a year.

Message delivered, nicely but firmly, was none of my colleagues wanted to move. Please stop contacting them.

My share would have been about $960,000 before tax. My first rection was anger. Off the cuff, at the coffee meeting, I threatened to sue to get my share. This wrapped up the coffee quickly. I planned to look over my contracts later that weekend with my soon to be brother-in-law/lawyer. But before we could, I got an email from the in-house lawyer for my previous employer. Attached were screen shots of slack conversations, phone logs and copies of emails. The bottom line was the CEO had instructed my manager to do “whatever it takes” to get me to stay until the close and pushed this message repeatedly. They could not tell me the details as they were waiting for regulatory approval from 4 counties as 3 competitors were forming a joint venture with a supplier. That process had been happening for almost 9 months. Any leak or sign of impropriety would sink the whole deal. When I threatened legal action that changed everything. That would have sunk the deal, so they cut all contact quickly and moved on. The email said that considering all the information provided my assertion is wrong and if we commence legal action, they will use this email as evidence when they pursue costs. My fiancée’s brother agreed and I replied back apologizing, completely withdrawing any allegations of impropriety and promising not to sue.

I was devastated. I had left close to a million dollars behind when I changed jobs. My plan for a new team was in tatters. To say I shut down is an understatement. I barely could think straight. I took a few mental health days and managed to find a privately funded psychologist. I am slowly beginning to recover. Even after 6 weeks, even things like planning for the wedding reminds me of what it could have been. To say my relationship is at a low point is an understatement. This weekend we went to buy a couch, and I almost ended up in tears because I thought about what we could afford to spend.

To add insult to injury I was told two weeks ago my board paper for the new venture has been delayed until after the summer break. Informally I get the feeling the board is reevaluating the whole strategy as my previous company has taken the three biggest customers off the table. They are likely to lock in a few others too. Some of the smaller customers may still be an opportunity but the financials are not nearly attractive with just them. I am hoping for the best.

I am barely functional enough to write this post now, and it took all my effort and a weekend to do that.

Even though logically I still have a well-paying job with a good company, have good friends and about to get married soon I can’t stop dwelling on what could have been. I am still at the stage of blaming myself for the way I acted that resulted in this situation. Writing this is has been cathartic and somewhat therapeutic. I am angry or sad all the time. I am sure this will pass eventually but I think I will regret how I acted for the rest of my life.

If I get the courage to revisit this post in the next few days I should be able to answer any questions

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

0

[Concluded] My fiancée wants me to get circumcised before our wedding [Reddit]

preview

Source: Reddit user Direct-Catterpillar77

My fiancée wants me to get circumcised before our wedding

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/ThrowRA-000000

My fiancée wants me to get circumcised before our wedding.

Originally posted to r/relationship_advice

BoRU 1 Posted by u/bestupdator

TRIGGER WARNING:

Tap for spoiler

racism

Original Post Feb 11, 2020

We met in the summer of 2018 and got engaged last year. Although our relationship is pretty solid, she can be very hotheaded. For example she gets upset when things don’t go her way and takes it as a personal insult. It’s definitely a “princess” syndrome that can be difficult to deal with but it never caused serious issues.

A couple of months ago she told me that I will get circumcised before our wedding later this year. I said no and she straight up told me that “it’s not a choice”. We argued for a bit and she said that I wouldn’t be attracted to her if she had an “outie” vagina with “extra skin” hanging (her words, not mine). I told her that it’s not really the same thing at all and that I’d be attracted to her regardless. However she got very irritated ignored me for the rest of the evening.

She has not stopped talking about this since that day. Everyday she sends me articles talking about the benefits of circumcision, that it’s totally healthy/safe and why I should do it. She says that “civilized” men get circumcised and that “we’re not like those Europeans”. The thing is, she’s mixed race (half French) and grew up in France so I don’t understand her thought process here. Her ex was French but she repeatedly said that she dislikes French people and wants me to be “better” than that. According to her, that includes getting a circumcision.

Yesterday she brought it up again and I said that she has no right to tell me what to do with my body. She yelled that she spends a lot of time/effort into her appearance and isn’t asking for much in return. While it’s true she spends a lot of money on beauty/hair/facial treatments (around $800 a month) I don’t think you can compare that to a circumcision. She got very upset, calling me “selfish” and “heartless” and basically told me to fuck off. Normally when we argue she doesn’t get that heated but I could hardly tolerate her attitude yesterday.

Later that evening we had sex (yes…I’m stupid) and in the middle of it, she brought up the topic again. It felt very manipulative and when I told her that this is not the right time, she accused me of not loving her and actually started crying. Since she rarely cries this didn’t seem genuine. She got up and told me that “we” will get this done either way and that I shouldn’t let such a small issue ruin what we have. To be honest, that sounded ominous and I don’t even know what to think of it.

Is this something we can work out at all? Throughout our entire relationship she never complained about my uncircumcised penis and now it’s such a big deal to her. It’s giving me anxiety about our future and I don’t even know what to do. We’ve had so many discussions about it and it always ends the same way.

TL; DR My fiancée wants me to get circumcised before our wedding later this year. I said I won’t but she keeps bringing it up and trying to make me feel guilty. Is there any way we can solve this problem?

TOP COMMENTS

AmensFuror

This relationship sounds hellish. I can’t imagine wanting to stay with someone who makes such demands, and who cries during sex in an attempt to influence me. What are you doing?

OOP

I’ll be honest, I don’t know

AMarmaladeSandwich

If you don’t know, there’s no way you should be marrying her.

She’s showing you who she is, I think you should believe her.

~

Leohond15

WOW. This girl sounds absolutely awful. It’s bad enough to try and pressure your partner to change their appearance in small ways, but she’s trying to force you to get an unnecessary procedure on your dick. And harping on it! Her tears were 100% manipulation. You need to tell her that you are absolutely not altering your body for her ridiculous preference, and i it bothers her that much you will leave (and you should). This is a woman that doesn’t respect your bodily autonomy, and therefore doesn’t respect you as a person. I honestly don’t think this relationship will last, and if you stay with her or god forbid go through with this, you’re setting yourself (and potential future children) up for a lifetime of emotional abuse and being controlled.

I have to add too that I find it pretty strange she’s been presumably fucking you for quite some time now and is just insisting you get circumcised now that you’re about to be married.

OOP

That’s what I don’t understand. When we first had sex she didn’t even comment on it. This came out of nowhere and I don’t understand why she didn’t bring it up earlier.

Leohond15

Did you ask her why she suddenly feels this way? I mean, I don’t think the answer will change what I think about her or that this won’t last. But I’m genuinely curious.

OOP

I asked her but she won’t give me a reason. She just says that it’s her preference and that discussed it with her friend

Update Feb 18, 2020 (1 week later)

I don’t know where to start but I’d like to thank everyone on here first. I have received countless PMs, all pretty much saying the same thing. Yet I still wanted to work out things and marry her.

Then a few days after my post we had a huge fight. She threatened me. I won’t give too many details but it was more than enough to give me a wake up call. And that’s when I finally realized that this relationship isn’t healthy or normal. I had those thoughts before but her action that day confirmed it.

Right now I’m in the process of completely removing her from my life. That incident had a significant impact on my mental health and at this point I just need a long break. I have spoken to her parents in private and they’re almost begging me to rethink the whole situation. I won’t.

I still love her but couldn’t do this anymore.

It’s a shock to the system - I went from planning my future with her to now actively cutting off everything that connects us.

I read through all comments again after the incident and they put things into perspective. Thank you again for all the advice and PMs.

TL;DR We are no longer together.

Edit: Post got locked I guess. Thanks for all the kind PMs. (But…please stop asking me to rate the sex out of 10)

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

Source: Reddit user Direct-Catterpillar77

My fiancée wants me to get circumcised before our wedding

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/ThrowRA-000000

My fiancée wants me to get circumcised before our wedding.

Originally posted to r/relationship_advice

BoRU 1 Posted by u/bestupdator

TRIGGER WARNING:

Tap for spoiler

racism

Original Post Feb 11, 2020

We met in the summer of 2018 and got engaged last year. Although our relationship is pretty solid, she can be very hotheaded. For example she gets upset when things don’t go her way and takes it as a personal insult. It’s definitely a “princess” syndrome that can be difficult to deal with but it never caused serious issues.

A couple of months ago she told me that I will get circumcised before our wedding later this year. I said no and she straight up told me that “it’s not a choice”. We argued for a bit and she said that I wouldn’t be attracted to her if she had an “outie” vagina with “extra skin” hanging (her words, not mine). I told her that it’s not really the same thing at all and that I’d be attracted to her regardless. However she got very irritated ignored me for the rest of the evening.

She has not stopped talking about this since that day. Everyday she sends me articles talking about the benefits of circumcision, that it’s totally healthy/safe and why I should do it. She says that “civilized” men get circumcised and that “we’re not like those Europeans”. The thing is, she’s mixed race (half French) and grew up in France so I don’t understand her thought process here. Her ex was French but she repeatedly said that she dislikes French people and wants me to be “better” than that. According to her, that includes getting a circumcision.

Yesterday she brought it up again and I said that she has no right to tell me what to do with my body. She yelled that she spends a lot of time/effort into her appearance and isn’t asking for much in return. While it’s true she spends a lot of money on beauty/hair/facial treatments (around $800 a month) I don’t think you can compare that to a circumcision. She got very upset, calling me “selfish” and “heartless” and basically told me to fuck off. Normally when we argue she doesn’t get that heated but I could hardly tolerate her attitude yesterday.

Later that evening we had sex (yes…I’m stupid) and in the middle of it, she brought up the topic again. It felt very manipulative and when I told her that this is not the right time, she accused me of not loving her and actually started crying. Since she rarely cries this didn’t seem genuine. She got up and told me that “we” will get this done either way and that I shouldn’t let such a small issue ruin what we have. To be honest, that sounded ominous and I don’t even know what to think of it.

Is this something we can work out at all? Throughout our entire relationship she never complained about my uncircumcised penis and now it’s such a big deal to her. It’s giving me anxiety about our future and I don’t even know what to do. We’ve had so many discussions about it and it always ends the same way.

TL; DR My fiancée wants me to get circumcised before our wedding later this year. I said I won’t but she keeps bringing it up and trying to make me feel guilty. Is there any way we can solve this problem?

TOP COMMENTS

AmensFuror

This relationship sounds hellish. I can’t imagine wanting to stay with someone who makes such demands, and who cries during sex in an attempt to influence me. What are you doing?

OOP

I’ll be honest, I don’t know

AMarmaladeSandwich

If you don’t know, there’s no way you should be marrying her.

She’s showing you who she is, I think you should believe her.

~

Leohond15

WOW. This girl sounds absolutely awful. It’s bad enough to try and pressure your partner to change their appearance in small ways, but she’s trying to force you to get an unnecessary procedure on your dick. And harping on it! Her tears were 100% manipulation. You need to tell her that you are absolutely not altering your body for her ridiculous preference, and i it bothers her that much you will leave (and you should). This is a woman that doesn’t respect your bodily autonomy, and therefore doesn’t respect you as a person. I honestly don’t think this relationship will last, and if you stay with her or god forbid go through with this, you’re setting yourself (and potential future children) up for a lifetime of emotional abuse and being controlled.

I have to add too that I find it pretty strange she’s been presumably fucking you for quite some time now and is just insisting you get circumcised now that you’re about to be married.

OOP

That’s what I don’t understand. When we first had sex she didn’t even comment on it. This came out of nowhere and I don’t understand why she didn’t bring it up earlier.

Leohond15

Did you ask her why she suddenly feels this way? I mean, I don’t think the answer will change what I think about her or that this won’t last. But I’m genuinely curious.

OOP

I asked her but she won’t give me a reason. She just says that it’s her preference and that discussed it with her friend

Update Feb 18, 2020 (1 week later)

I don’t know where to start but I’d like to thank everyone on here first. I have received countless PMs, all pretty much saying the same thing. Yet I still wanted to work out things and marry her.

Then a few days after my post we had a huge fight. She threatened me. I won’t give too many details but it was more than enough to give me a wake up call. And that’s when I finally realized that this relationship isn’t healthy or normal. I had those thoughts before but her action that day confirmed it.

Right now I’m in the process of completely removing her from my life. That incident had a significant impact on my mental health and at this point I just need a long break. I have spoken to her parents in private and they’re almost begging me to rethink the whole situation. I won’t.

I still love her but couldn’t do this anymore.

It’s a shock to the system - I went from planning my future with her to now actively cutting off everything that connects us.

I read through all comments again after the incident and they put things into perspective. Thank you again for all the advice and PMs.

TL;DR We are no longer together.

Edit: Post got locked I guess. Thanks for all the kind PMs. (But…please stop asking me to rate the sex out of 10)

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

0

[Concluded] My [26M] gym buddy [35M] is cheating on my sister's [28F] best friend [30F]. I told him we can't be friends anymore. Am I wrong? [Reddit]

preview

Source: Reddit user Direct-Caterpillar77

My [26M] gym buddy [35M] is cheating on my sister’s [28F] best friend [30F]. I told him we can’t be friends anymore. Am I wrong?

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/Ninja-Kiwi

My [26M] gym buddy [35M] is cheating on my sister’s [28F] best friend [30F]. I told him we can’t be friends anymore. Am I wrong?

Original post  Dec 3, 2014

I used to train alone, because I don’t have to take others into account. I have a very irregular schedule and long hours so this works for me. I train whenever I can. I also lift pretty heavy. I met Ben [35M] eight months ago. He joined my gym and we hit it off. He talked to me and asked me if he could train in with me. I was hesitant, but I could use a spotter sometimes. He’s a cop and surprisingly has the same irregular shifts as me. His lifting stats are very close to mine. We started working out together and pushing/motivating each other for higher PR’s. As guys do, we started talking about hook ups, dating and life in general during sets and sometimes we hung out outside of the gym as well. He told me he was dating around and had a few fuck buddies. I thought nothing serious, or exclusive because he was seeing several at the same time.

One day my sister [28F] came to the gym with me. Ben was there too. She recognized Ben as the boyfriend of her best friend Allie [30F]. I asked her if she was sure and what does she mean boyfriend/if they were exclusive. She told me yeah and of course they are exclusive. I quickly changed the subject.

The next time I met Ben at the gym I asked him after our work out about Allie and he confirmed he was indeed dating her. I asked him if she knew about the other girls, he said no she did not. He was basically cheating on her. I felt very guilty and conflicted. I told him I knew Allie and she was a very nice girl and didn’t deserve this kind of behaviour. I said we could no longer be friends and I didn’t want to train together anymore. I told him to cut all contact.

He said he didn’t understand what had changed and said we were good friend and I shouldn’t throw this away. I have to say a part of me still wants to train with him and hang out, because I thought he was a good guy, but then I feel incredibly guilty towards Allie and know I can’t do that to her. Our gym sessions were great and I always felt pumped up. I told Ben ‘No’ and stop texting and/or calling me. He still does and it’s kinda awkward at the gym, but I ignore him. He still wants to be friends. Am I wrong?

Is it my place to tell Allie to dump this guy, because he’s a cheater? Often time the harbinger of bad news gets crucified so I don’t want to tell my sister and burden her with this knowledge and task of telling Allie. What should I do? Tell Allie? Tell my sister? Shrug it off and still train and hang out with Ben?

tl;dr: Found out my gym buddy is the cheating boyfriend of my sisters friend. I got off contact. Am I wrong? Who should tell Allie if anyone?

TOP COMMENTS

PreftigeWhore

You’re not wrong for not wanting to be friends with people who do shitty things.

LePetitChou

Frankly, I think what OP did was an incredible sign of his character.  Plenty of people would have felt  uncomfortable, but would still continue to work out with the scummy cop to avoid “awkwardness.” Some people might have gone a step farther and just cut contact, with no explanation.

But OP did the truly honorable, and uncomfortable, thing by explaining why he was cutting the friendship off.  Good for you, u/Ninja-Kiwi ; it would be a better world if there were more people like you in it.

~

[deleted]

I love how he doesn’t even understand the problem.

He didn’t even have an ‘Oh shit!’ reaction when you told him you knew Allie. Normal people who do something wrong would have that reaction. Normal people would understand immediately that you’ve got a conflict of interest here and would swerve into damage control. Excuses, bragging, I’m-reformed. Something to mitigate the chances you’ll tell.

He didn’t. He’s completely, utterly, remorseless about betraying his girlfriend’s trust.

You should tell literally everyone. This guy is insane and everyone should avoid him.

Update  Dec 6, 2014 (3 days later)

TL;DR of previous Found out my gym buddy was the cheating boyfriend of my sister’s best friend. Cut contact with gym buddy. Gym buddy kept contacting me and wanting to remain friends.

Thank you all for your replies. Some were worried, because Ben is a cop. Well that would never stop me from doing the right thing and am glad I did. I knew I had to tell Allie. You guys gave me the push I needed. I would have wanted to know and would be very upset if someone I knew was aware of my SO cheating and chose not to tell me. I found out the extent of Ben’s douchebaggery. First I told my sister right away that Ben was sleeping around and I wanted to warn Allie. She came with a bombshell! Ben was hitting on her too! That asshole is infuriating me now. Ben sometimes tagged along when my sister and Allie would hang out and Ben would always flirt/hit on my sister. This asshole is making me so furious right now. My sister hadn’t told Allie, because she didn’t want her to get hurt and nothing happened. And never would, because Ben is Allie’s boyfriend and also my sister doesn’t date assholes.

So then I decided to tell Allie. My sister was there too. I decided to take the direct route and rip the truth out like a bushy woman getting a full Brazilian. It would be quick and sting, but not as much as slowly peeling it off. Apparently Allie suspected some douchebaggery going on, because he was being secretive with his phone all of a sudden lately and ‘hide’ when he was texting/turn away the screen etc. Allie was upset, but she did see it coming I guess and was really glad I told her. She said she loved me like a brother of her own and really thanked me for the honesty. She was dumping Ben right away and wants to go No Contact and block him on all media. I was at the gym yesterday and today, but didn’t see him. We’ll see how it goes. I’m not switching gyms because of this asshole. I’ve trained there for years now and know the owner and staff. I really love my gym.

tl;dr: The extent of Ben’s douchebaggery is revealed. I told Allie and she dumped Ben and went NC

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

Source: Reddit user Direct-Caterpillar77

My [26M] gym buddy [35M] is cheating on my sister’s [28F] best friend [30F]. I told him we can’t be friends anymore. Am I wrong?

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/Ninja-Kiwi

My [26M] gym buddy [35M] is cheating on my sister’s [28F] best friend [30F]. I told him we can’t be friends anymore. Am I wrong?

Original post  Dec 3, 2014

I used to train alone, because I don’t have to take others into account. I have a very irregular schedule and long hours so this works for me. I train whenever I can. I also lift pretty heavy. I met Ben [35M] eight months ago. He joined my gym and we hit it off. He talked to me and asked me if he could train in with me. I was hesitant, but I could use a spotter sometimes. He’s a cop and surprisingly has the same irregular shifts as me. His lifting stats are very close to mine. We started working out together and pushing/motivating each other for higher PR’s. As guys do, we started talking about hook ups, dating and life in general during sets and sometimes we hung out outside of the gym as well. He told me he was dating around and had a few fuck buddies. I thought nothing serious, or exclusive because he was seeing several at the same time.

One day my sister [28F] came to the gym with me. Ben was there too. She recognized Ben as the boyfriend of her best friend Allie [30F]. I asked her if she was sure and what does she mean boyfriend/if they were exclusive. She told me yeah and of course they are exclusive. I quickly changed the subject.

The next time I met Ben at the gym I asked him after our work out about Allie and he confirmed he was indeed dating her. I asked him if she knew about the other girls, he said no she did not. He was basically cheating on her. I felt very guilty and conflicted. I told him I knew Allie and she was a very nice girl and didn’t deserve this kind of behaviour. I said we could no longer be friends and I didn’t want to train together anymore. I told him to cut all contact.

He said he didn’t understand what had changed and said we were good friend and I shouldn’t throw this away. I have to say a part of me still wants to train with him and hang out, because I thought he was a good guy, but then I feel incredibly guilty towards Allie and know I can’t do that to her. Our gym sessions were great and I always felt pumped up. I told Ben ‘No’ and stop texting and/or calling me. He still does and it’s kinda awkward at the gym, but I ignore him. He still wants to be friends. Am I wrong?

Is it my place to tell Allie to dump this guy, because he’s a cheater? Often time the harbinger of bad news gets crucified so I don’t want to tell my sister and burden her with this knowledge and task of telling Allie. What should I do? Tell Allie? Tell my sister? Shrug it off and still train and hang out with Ben?

tl;dr: Found out my gym buddy is the cheating boyfriend of my sisters friend. I got off contact. Am I wrong? Who should tell Allie if anyone?

TOP COMMENTS

PreftigeWhore

You’re not wrong for not wanting to be friends with people who do shitty things.

LePetitChou

Frankly, I think what OP did was an incredible sign of his character.  Plenty of people would have felt  uncomfortable, but would still continue to work out with the scummy cop to avoid “awkwardness.” Some people might have gone a step farther and just cut contact, with no explanation.

But OP did the truly honorable, and uncomfortable, thing by explaining why he was cutting the friendship off.  Good for you, u/Ninja-Kiwi ; it would be a better world if there were more people like you in it.

~

[deleted]

I love how he doesn’t even understand the problem.

He didn’t even have an ‘Oh shit!’ reaction when you told him you knew Allie. Normal people who do something wrong would have that reaction. Normal people would understand immediately that you’ve got a conflict of interest here and would swerve into damage control. Excuses, bragging, I’m-reformed. Something to mitigate the chances you’ll tell.

He didn’t. He’s completely, utterly, remorseless about betraying his girlfriend’s trust.

You should tell literally everyone. This guy is insane and everyone should avoid him.

Update  Dec 6, 2014 (3 days later)

TL;DR of previous Found out my gym buddy was the cheating boyfriend of my sister’s best friend. Cut contact with gym buddy. Gym buddy kept contacting me and wanting to remain friends.

Thank you all for your replies. Some were worried, because Ben is a cop. Well that would never stop me from doing the right thing and am glad I did. I knew I had to tell Allie. You guys gave me the push I needed. I would have wanted to know and would be very upset if someone I knew was aware of my SO cheating and chose not to tell me. I found out the extent of Ben’s douchebaggery. First I told my sister right away that Ben was sleeping around and I wanted to warn Allie. She came with a bombshell! Ben was hitting on her too! That asshole is infuriating me now. Ben sometimes tagged along when my sister and Allie would hang out and Ben would always flirt/hit on my sister. This asshole is making me so furious right now. My sister hadn’t told Allie, because she didn’t want her to get hurt and nothing happened. And never would, because Ben is Allie’s boyfriend and also my sister doesn’t date assholes.

So then I decided to tell Allie. My sister was there too. I decided to take the direct route and rip the truth out like a bushy woman getting a full Brazilian. It would be quick and sting, but not as much as slowly peeling it off. Apparently Allie suspected some douchebaggery going on, because he was being secretive with his phone all of a sudden lately and ‘hide’ when he was texting/turn away the screen etc. Allie was upset, but she did see it coming I guess and was really glad I told her. She said she loved me like a brother of her own and really thanked me for the honesty. She was dumping Ben right away and wants to go No Contact and block him on all media. I was at the gym yesterday and today, but didn’t see him. We’ll see how it goes. I’m not switching gyms because of this asshole. I’ve trained there for years now and know the owner and staff. I really love my gym.

tl;dr: The extent of Ben’s douchebaggery is revealed. I told Allie and she dumped Ben and went NC

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER - RULE 7

0

[Concluded] How do I step back from a friendship with an intensely negative and argumentative coworker? [AAM]

Ask a Manager how do I step back from a friendship with an intensely negative and argumentative coworker? www.askamanager.org
preview

Title: How do I stop back form a friendship with an intensely negative and argumentative coworker? Originally posted on Ask A Manager

I am not the OP, this is a repost community.

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

Feeling trapped with a crazy coworker


Original Post: Jul 8, 2025

I’ve been working at a university library for a little over a year now and have had a hard time making friends. Shortly after I started, I befriended a coworker, “Morgan,” who is also relatively new, and it has been nice getting to know them and commiserating about how hard it is to make friends in a new city and workplace.

Over the course of our friendship, Morgan has opened up more and more about the interpersonal problems they’ve had with our colleagues. They describe scenarios where collaborative projects get stalled because other stakeholders stop communicating with them, coworkers they were getting lunch with on a weekly basis suddenly stop responding to chats, and other frustrations with navigating bureaucracy that interferes with their work. It’s hard to tell if Morgan is becoming increasingly disgruntled or if they are now very comfortable with telling me their unfiltered feelings.

I’ve also had to navigate some fairly horrendous problems as a new employee, so it’s been nice to have a coworker who understands and sympathizes with our (somewhat) dysfunctional workplace culture. Morgan has made it very clear to me that they are only here for the time being and have already decided that this is not the city they would like to stay in long-term. Personally, I want to retire here and have worked very hard to improve my situation. It feels very different for me today than it did a year ago, which is why it’s become increasingly difficult to navigate Morgan’s constant negativity.

Morgan can be a lot of fun to talk to, but they’re in an increasingly bad mental space at work. They frequently come to my office to gripe for an hour or two in spite of how busy I am; I’m always actively working and trying to concentrate when they pop into my office. To my fault, they ask if it’s a good time to chat and I always say yes because they’ve been so hurt by our coworkers pulling away and I’m afraid of upsetting them. On top of this, they’ve become increasingly argumentative with me when they’re looking to talk. Again, I would say this is my fault because they are looking to vent and I’m always trying to provide solutions, so I think it’s taken as invalidating Morgan’s feelings.

Morgan is in such a bad mental space at work that seemingly any type of feedback or dialogue that they disagree with comes off as an attack. One of the issues they’ve had with multiple colleagues is that they invalidate Morgan’s feelings. Morgan has described situations where they complained about something to a colleague and rather than agreeing with and consoling Morgan, they essentially said to look on the bright side. For example, Morgan was upset about a change made to their office and the coworker responded with, “At least you have your own office.” Morgan has many examples of conversations like this and cites it as a workplace culture issue. In addition, Morgan holds on to comments like this (that took place months and months ago) and often refers back to them as examples of how bad things are. At this point, I am very afraid of upsetting Morgan because I like them, and their hyper-sensitivity is a bit triggering in light of all the reparative work I’ve done for my position and unit.

One more detail about Morgan that I think plays a factor is their odor. Morgan has a strong mildewy smell wherever they go. The odor fills a room and I can often tell if they’ve recently been in a space because of the smell. I believe Morgan maintains good hygiene practices, but that they are unaware of the fact that a lot of their clothing has developed a pungent mildew odor. Depending on how strongly they smell, it can be very difficult to spend extended periods of time with them. I’ve avoided spending time with them outside of work, like inviting them to my home, because the smell is so off-putting and am wondering if it has contributed to their interactions with coworkers.

How do I take a step back with Morgan without further inciting them?


Alison’s response can be found at the link to the post above


Update: Jul 2, 2026

Your advice was excellent and gave me a lot to think about.

First, I did not have the heart to mention the odor issue to my coworker, primarily because they are often very sensitive around me and I had concerns that they would lash out. Oddly enough, the odor has improved somewhat, so maybe someone else mentioned it to them. That brings me to your point about my intentions with this person.

You are so right that I am spending time with them out of fear, rather than genuine interest. Things with Morgan were great at first when we just chatted about non-work topics. I’ve tried re-routing conversations there when they pop into my office to get us back to that place. It’s worked and not worked. For example, recently they were talking about their frustrations with our administration (quite loudly in my office). I kindly discouraged them and said that we should talk about it over drinks instead. They laughed a little and kept on going with their thoughts.

Since then, I’ve tried being much more direct about being busy and not able to talk when they pop in unexpectedly. I’ve also had multiple one-on-one conversations with them about how uncomfortable it makes me to complain about work in my office because I don’t want our colleagues to overhear and get the wrong idea because they heard a snippet of a conversation. They seemed to understand at the time of the conversations but have continued to complain about our workplace administration (loudly in my office) to the point where I now mostly stop talking to them and focus on my work — somehow this has been quite effective!

I think they are more aware of my discomfort/disapproval of the conversation when I withdraw and it has been seemingly ok/without obvious negative consequences? It’s possible that they are now complaining about how unsupportive I am, but I’m seeing that this is better than the alternative (or past practice with them). Depending on how things go from here on out, I might also try to limit my time with them outside of work. We don’t see each other much but, when we do, it’s a lot of the same draining negativity that I find very stressful and unpleasant to dwell on.

Thank you so much for your advice! As a side note, I couldn’t believe how many people chimed in about front-loading washers and mildew smell!


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

Title: How do I stop back form a friendship with an intensely negative and argumentative coworker? Originally posted on Ask A Manager

I am not the OP, this is a repost community.

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

Feeling trapped with a crazy coworker


Original Post: Jul 8, 2025

I’ve been working at a university library for a little over a year now and have had a hard time making friends. Shortly after I started, I befriended a coworker, “Morgan,” who is also relatively new, and it has been nice getting to know them and commiserating about how hard it is to make friends in a new city and workplace.

Over the course of our friendship, Morgan has opened up more and more about the interpersonal problems they’ve had with our colleagues. They describe scenarios where collaborative projects get stalled because other stakeholders stop communicating with them, coworkers they were getting lunch with on a weekly basis suddenly stop responding to chats, and other frustrations with navigating bureaucracy that interferes with their work. It’s hard to tell if Morgan is becoming increasingly disgruntled or if they are now very comfortable with telling me their unfiltered feelings.

I’ve also had to navigate some fairly horrendous problems as a new employee, so it’s been nice to have a coworker who understands and sympathizes with our (somewhat) dysfunctional workplace culture. Morgan has made it very clear to me that they are only here for the time being and have already decided that this is not the city they would like to stay in long-term. Personally, I want to retire here and have worked very hard to improve my situation. It feels very different for me today than it did a year ago, which is why it’s become increasingly difficult to navigate Morgan’s constant negativity.

Morgan can be a lot of fun to talk to, but they’re in an increasingly bad mental space at work. They frequently come to my office to gripe for an hour or two in spite of how busy I am; I’m always actively working and trying to concentrate when they pop into my office. To my fault, they ask if it’s a good time to chat and I always say yes because they’ve been so hurt by our coworkers pulling away and I’m afraid of upsetting them. On top of this, they’ve become increasingly argumentative with me when they’re looking to talk. Again, I would say this is my fault because they are looking to vent and I’m always trying to provide solutions, so I think it’s taken as invalidating Morgan’s feelings.

Morgan is in such a bad mental space at work that seemingly any type of feedback or dialogue that they disagree with comes off as an attack. One of the issues they’ve had with multiple colleagues is that they invalidate Morgan’s feelings. Morgan has described situations where they complained about something to a colleague and rather than agreeing with and consoling Morgan, they essentially said to look on the bright side. For example, Morgan was upset about a change made to their office and the coworker responded with, “At least you have your own office.” Morgan has many examples of conversations like this and cites it as a workplace culture issue. In addition, Morgan holds on to comments like this (that took place months and months ago) and often refers back to them as examples of how bad things are. At this point, I am very afraid of upsetting Morgan because I like them, and their hyper-sensitivity is a bit triggering in light of all the reparative work I’ve done for my position and unit.

One more detail about Morgan that I think plays a factor is their odor. Morgan has a strong mildewy smell wherever they go. The odor fills a room and I can often tell if they’ve recently been in a space because of the smell. I believe Morgan maintains good hygiene practices, but that they are unaware of the fact that a lot of their clothing has developed a pungent mildew odor. Depending on how strongly they smell, it can be very difficult to spend extended periods of time with them. I’ve avoided spending time with them outside of work, like inviting them to my home, because the smell is so off-putting and am wondering if it has contributed to their interactions with coworkers.

How do I take a step back with Morgan without further inciting them?


Alison’s response can be found at the link to the post above


Update: Jul 2, 2026

Your advice was excellent and gave me a lot to think about.

First, I did not have the heart to mention the odor issue to my coworker, primarily because they are often very sensitive around me and I had concerns that they would lash out. Oddly enough, the odor has improved somewhat, so maybe someone else mentioned it to them. That brings me to your point about my intentions with this person.

You are so right that I am spending time with them out of fear, rather than genuine interest. Things with Morgan were great at first when we just chatted about non-work topics. I’ve tried re-routing conversations there when they pop into my office to get us back to that place. It’s worked and not worked. For example, recently they were talking about their frustrations with our administration (quite loudly in my office). I kindly discouraged them and said that we should talk about it over drinks instead. They laughed a little and kept on going with their thoughts.

Since then, I’ve tried being much more direct about being busy and not able to talk when they pop in unexpectedly. I’ve also had multiple one-on-one conversations with them about how uncomfortable it makes me to complain about work in my office because I don’t want our colleagues to overhear and get the wrong idea because they heard a snippet of a conversation. They seemed to understand at the time of the conversations but have continued to complain about our workplace administration (loudly in my office) to the point where I now mostly stop talking to them and focus on my work — somehow this has been quite effective!

I think they are more aware of my discomfort/disapproval of the conversation when I withdraw and it has been seemingly ok/without obvious negative consequences? It’s possible that they are now complaining about how unsupportive I am, but I’m seeing that this is better than the alternative (or past practice with them). Depending on how things go from here on out, I might also try to limit my time with them outside of work. We don’t see each other much but, when we do, it’s a lot of the same draining negativity that I find very stressful and unpleasant to dwell on.

Thank you so much for your advice! As a side note, I couldn’t believe how many people chimed in about front-loading washers and mildew smell!


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

0

[Concluded] I secretly tell my deaf girlfriend I love her every day when she can't hear me. She still has no idea [Reddit]

preview

I secretly tell my deaf girlfriend I love her every day when she can’t hear me. She still has no idea.

This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

OOP: u/JustADude183

Published on: r/AskReddit

Story is: CONCLUDED

Story timeline

NOTE: The original post was a reply to an AskReddit question. OOP later posted an update on their own profile.

Trigger Warning: Wholesome


Main Post

^(July 18, 2022)


What’s a secret you’ll never tell your partner but are willing to tell strangers on Reddit?

Using my alt because she follows my main account

My girlfriend of 5 years has been deaf since she was 6. She reads lips pretty well, but prefers Sign Language. I didn’t know a single sign when I met her, but I could tell right away there was something between us so I started learning after I got home from our first date.

Fast forward a few years, I’m now fluent in ASL and we use it to talk almost exclusively. When she’s not looking though, I talk to her even though she can’t hear me or see my lips to read. I tell her how much I love her, how I’m going to marry her someday, how beautiful she is, etc. I’ve even been practicing proposing, so it’s not so terrifying when I actually do it. She has no idea and I plan to keep it that way.

 

NOTE: This story was also reposted to r/wholesome, where OOP shared a lot of additional details in the comments. I’ve included comments from both posts, so don’t skip the comments section.

 

COMMENTS

Present_Champion1662

I need an update on this. That’s wonderful! It’s surprising how many family members of Deaf people that don’t learn sign language.

OOP

She’s lucky, her immediate family are all fluent and most of her extended family has learned at least a few simple phrases and words. My side of the family has started learning too, since they know she’ll be part of the family pretty soon. Most deaf people aren’t so lucky, I’m really glad she has such good people in her life.


Toadie9622

This touched my heart so much. I hope my youngest daughter meets somebody like you.

OOP

I bet she will, I’m not the first guy she’s been with who went to great effort to accommodate her. I’m just the one who was lucky enough to win her over


WinterPickles31

Dude… from the mother of two young Deaf daughters… THANK YOU! The fucking world feels scarily unaccommodating sometimes and it’s so good to know good hearts like yours are out there.

OOP

My girlfriend often feels like the rest of the world would rather she didn’t exist, so I go out of my way to show how glad I am she does. All it takes is one person who really cares to make all the difference, so try to be that difference for your daughters. It helps them more than they’ll ever say


NOTE: The following comments are from the repost on r/wholesome: A legend of a man, this is love right here


OOP

Hey, I’m the OP! A lot of people are asking for an update. It’s only been 4 days so there’s not much to tell, but here you all go anyway.

We’re still together, of course. She’s trying to convince me to get a puppy, I’m having a hard time convincing her not to. I still talk to her when she doesn’t know, and she still has no clue. After some comments on the original post, I’m getting ready to propose soon, but it still won’t be for a little bit. I’ll definitely record it, but I probably won’t post it anywhere. She’d be pretty uncomfortable with that, and tbh I would too. That’s about it I guess, I have no idea why people are so interested in my love life. Y’all are creeps.

EDIT: oh fuck now even more people are pushing for the puppy


TheTTT10

How come you don’t want the puppy? Is it because you don’t like them or is it more economical?

OOP

It’s just economical. We already have two cats, and we aren’t exactly rich. However, she does this thing with her eyes that I just can’t say no to, so…

We’re going to the Humane Society tomorrow. She knows exactly how to convince me.


GunieapigCooper

How did you meet her and why made you connect with her on the first date?

OOP

We met through mutual friends, she had just gotten out of a toxic relationship and they thought she needed a reminder not all guys suck. Still don’t know why they chose me, but I’m so glad they did.

In the first 30 minutes, we both made the same obscure reference. We have practically identical humor, even finishing each other’s jokes, and honestly she was the most beautiful woman I’d ever seen in real life. I’m not exaggerating, she’s WAY out of my league. As for her, she told me on our 1 year anniversary that she knew I was the one because I didn’t even mention that she was deaf, I treated her more normally than even her family. I honestly had no idea I did that, it wasn’t conscious at all, but I sure am glad it worked.


Final update - after 27 days

^(August 14, 2022)


UPDATE: I proposed

After all the comments urging me not to wait, I decided to do it. Life is too short to waste even a day. I bought a very nice ring, silver with three small synthetic diamonds. It’s nothing too special, but it’s exactly her style and expensive by our standards without breaking the bank, so it was perfect.

I told her family my plans and they approved, of course. My family was 100% behind it too. With that arranged, I started planning the proposal. Both of us had already agreed that we didn’t want it to be a huge disruptive event, just the two of us, no family to make a scene. She trusted me to pick a good place. I decided on the beach, and we happen to live just a few hours from one of the best beaches in the world, so it was perfect.

Our anniversary was coming up and we both had the day off. We had planned to go to a local museum, but I asked to change plans to the beach. She was definitely a little suspicious, but she didn’t say anything at the time. At the beach, I let the first few hours pass normally. Just relaxing, playing in the waves, and snacks. I kept the ring hidden in a zippered pocket in my shorts, and even though I knew it was safe, I think I checked it every 5 minutes at least.

When the sun started to go down, I led her away from the crowded area to a more secluded spot. We had a great view of the water, the sun, and some boats further out, but a cluster of palm trees and low bushes blocked us from other people. At this point, she realized something was up. She started looking at me funny, so I knew I had to be quick. I reached for the ring, and…

This is where the anxiety hit. I’m not a very confident person. I knew she would say yes, and I knew I’d planned everything perfectly, there was no possible reason this could go badly, but I was still nearly paralyzed. That’s probably why I dropped the ring.

As soon as I grabbed the ring, it slipped out of my fingers and got lost in the sand. I fucking PANICKED. I got on my knees and started digging through the sand like an animal, the whole time she was trying to ask me what was going on. I wanted to explain, but where would I even start? I found it after about ten seconds, which felt like ten hours, unharmed.

As soon as I picked it up, she saw it and realized what happened. She completely froze for a second, then she started shaking and wheezing like she was having an asthma attack. Then I panicked AGAIN, because I had no clue what was happening and I thought something was even more wrong than it already was. Then I realized she was crying and laughing at the same time, and I started crying and laughing too.

I figured the proposal was already a mess, so it couldn’t get any worse. I held it up to her and just said “I think you dropped this.” It sounded a lot better in my head, to be fair. She fucking lost it, I don’t think I’ve ever seen her laugh that much. Once we both calmed down, I did it right, and of course she said yes. Despite the complications, it couldn’t have gone better, and we’re both very happy. We talked about the wedding a little, and it will probably be sometime next summer, but we haven’t decided yet.

I’m not expecting to make another post on this account after this. As far as I’m concerned our story is told, and now it’s time for the next one to start. I have no idea what’s next for us after the wedding- we’ve talked about living in a van to travel the country, so maybe that. Whatever happens, we’ll still be together, and I’ll still be talking behind her back, for as long as I can. To all you guys, I hope you all have wonderful lives. There’s someone out there for all of us, just be patient and you’ll find them. And if you found them, but haven’t made it official yet- do it. Life is short and you only get one, so you shouldn’t waste a single moment of it. Don’t let anything hold you back.

Jake and Lex, signing off!

 


This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

Please remember to follow the subreddit rules, especially the ones about brigading.

Let’s aim for a respectful and friendly discussion for everyone involved.

I secretly tell my deaf girlfriend I love her every day when she can’t hear me. She still has no idea.

This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

OOP: u/JustADude183

Published on: r/AskReddit

Story is: CONCLUDED

Story timeline

NOTE: The original post was a reply to an AskReddit question. OOP later posted an update on their own profile.

Trigger Warning: Wholesome


Main Post

^(July 18, 2022)


What’s a secret you’ll never tell your partner but are willing to tell strangers on Reddit?

Using my alt because she follows my main account

My girlfriend of 5 years has been deaf since she was 6. She reads lips pretty well, but prefers Sign Language. I didn’t know a single sign when I met her, but I could tell right away there was something between us so I started learning after I got home from our first date.

Fast forward a few years, I’m now fluent in ASL and we use it to talk almost exclusively. When she’s not looking though, I talk to her even though she can’t hear me or see my lips to read. I tell her how much I love her, how I’m going to marry her someday, how beautiful she is, etc. I’ve even been practicing proposing, so it’s not so terrifying when I actually do it. She has no idea and I plan to keep it that way.

 

NOTE: This story was also reposted to r/wholesome, where OOP shared a lot of additional details in the comments. I’ve included comments from both posts, so don’t skip the comments section.

 

COMMENTS

Present_Champion1662

I need an update on this. That’s wonderful! It’s surprising how many family members of Deaf people that don’t learn sign language.

OOP

She’s lucky, her immediate family are all fluent and most of her extended family has learned at least a few simple phrases and words. My side of the family has started learning too, since they know she’ll be part of the family pretty soon. Most deaf people aren’t so lucky, I’m really glad she has such good people in her life.


Toadie9622

This touched my heart so much. I hope my youngest daughter meets somebody like you.

OOP

I bet she will, I’m not the first guy she’s been with who went to great effort to accommodate her. I’m just the one who was lucky enough to win her over


WinterPickles31

Dude… from the mother of two young Deaf daughters… THANK YOU! The fucking world feels scarily unaccommodating sometimes and it’s so good to know good hearts like yours are out there.

OOP

My girlfriend often feels like the rest of the world would rather she didn’t exist, so I go out of my way to show how glad I am she does. All it takes is one person who really cares to make all the difference, so try to be that difference for your daughters. It helps them more than they’ll ever say


NOTE: The following comments are from the repost on r/wholesome: A legend of a man, this is love right here


OOP

Hey, I’m the OP! A lot of people are asking for an update. It’s only been 4 days so there’s not much to tell, but here you all go anyway.

We’re still together, of course. She’s trying to convince me to get a puppy, I’m having a hard time convincing her not to. I still talk to her when she doesn’t know, and she still has no clue. After some comments on the original post, I’m getting ready to propose soon, but it still won’t be for a little bit. I’ll definitely record it, but I probably won’t post it anywhere. She’d be pretty uncomfortable with that, and tbh I would too. That’s about it I guess, I have no idea why people are so interested in my love life. Y’all are creeps.

EDIT: oh fuck now even more people are pushing for the puppy


TheTTT10

How come you don’t want the puppy? Is it because you don’t like them or is it more economical?

OOP

It’s just economical. We already have two cats, and we aren’t exactly rich. However, she does this thing with her eyes that I just can’t say no to, so…

We’re going to the Humane Society tomorrow. She knows exactly how to convince me.


GunieapigCooper

How did you meet her and why made you connect with her on the first date?

OOP

We met through mutual friends, she had just gotten out of a toxic relationship and they thought she needed a reminder not all guys suck. Still don’t know why they chose me, but I’m so glad they did.

In the first 30 minutes, we both made the same obscure reference. We have practically identical humor, even finishing each other’s jokes, and honestly she was the most beautiful woman I’d ever seen in real life. I’m not exaggerating, she’s WAY out of my league. As for her, she told me on our 1 year anniversary that she knew I was the one because I didn’t even mention that she was deaf, I treated her more normally than even her family. I honestly had no idea I did that, it wasn’t conscious at all, but I sure am glad it worked.


Final update - after 27 days

^(August 14, 2022)


UPDATE: I proposed

After all the comments urging me not to wait, I decided to do it. Life is too short to waste even a day. I bought a very nice ring, silver with three small synthetic diamonds. It’s nothing too special, but it’s exactly her style and expensive by our standards without breaking the bank, so it was perfect.

I told her family my plans and they approved, of course. My family was 100% behind it too. With that arranged, I started planning the proposal. Both of us had already agreed that we didn’t want it to be a huge disruptive event, just the two of us, no family to make a scene. She trusted me to pick a good place. I decided on the beach, and we happen to live just a few hours from one of the best beaches in the world, so it was perfect.

Our anniversary was coming up and we both had the day off. We had planned to go to a local museum, but I asked to change plans to the beach. She was definitely a little suspicious, but she didn’t say anything at the time. At the beach, I let the first few hours pass normally. Just relaxing, playing in the waves, and snacks. I kept the ring hidden in a zippered pocket in my shorts, and even though I knew it was safe, I think I checked it every 5 minutes at least.

When the sun started to go down, I led her away from the crowded area to a more secluded spot. We had a great view of the water, the sun, and some boats further out, but a cluster of palm trees and low bushes blocked us from other people. At this point, she realized something was up. She started looking at me funny, so I knew I had to be quick. I reached for the ring, and…

This is where the anxiety hit. I’m not a very confident person. I knew she would say yes, and I knew I’d planned everything perfectly, there was no possible reason this could go badly, but I was still nearly paralyzed. That’s probably why I dropped the ring.

As soon as I grabbed the ring, it slipped out of my fingers and got lost in the sand. I fucking PANICKED. I got on my knees and started digging through the sand like an animal, the whole time she was trying to ask me what was going on. I wanted to explain, but where would I even start? I found it after about ten seconds, which felt like ten hours, unharmed.

As soon as I picked it up, she saw it and realized what happened. She completely froze for a second, then she started shaking and wheezing like she was having an asthma attack. Then I panicked AGAIN, because I had no clue what was happening and I thought something was even more wrong than it already was. Then I realized she was crying and laughing at the same time, and I started crying and laughing too.

I figured the proposal was already a mess, so it couldn’t get any worse. I held it up to her and just said “I think you dropped this.” It sounded a lot better in my head, to be fair. She fucking lost it, I don’t think I’ve ever seen her laugh that much. Once we both calmed down, I did it right, and of course she said yes. Despite the complications, it couldn’t have gone better, and we’re both very happy. We talked about the wedding a little, and it will probably be sometime next summer, but we haven’t decided yet.

I’m not expecting to make another post on this account after this. As far as I’m concerned our story is told, and now it’s time for the next one to start. I have no idea what’s next for us after the wedding- we’ve talked about living in a van to travel the country, so maybe that. Whatever happens, we’ll still be together, and I’ll still be talking behind her back, for as long as I can. To all you guys, I hope you all have wonderful lives. There’s someone out there for all of us, just be patient and you’ll find them. And if you found them, but haven’t made it official yet- do it. Life is short and you only get one, so you shouldn’t waste a single moment of it. Don’t let anything hold you back.

Jake and Lex, signing off!

 


This is a repost sub. I’m not the Original OP (OOP)

Please remember to follow the subreddit rules, especially the ones about brigading.

Let’s aim for a respectful and friendly discussion for everyone involved.

0

[Concluded] I got in a car accident because my company insisted I do an event in a remote town during a blizzard [AAM]

Ask a Manager I got in a car accident because my company insisted I do an event in a remote town during a blizzard www.askamanager.org
preview

Title: I got in a car accident because my company insisted I do an event in a remote town during a blizzard

I am NOT OP.

Originally posted to: Ask A Manager Jan 9, 2017

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

Car Accident, Employer doesn’t care about employee health


Original Post: Jan 9, 2017

I have a part-time job with a promo company sampling food or drinks at events/stores/wherever the brand being sampled pays us to go. The company is SUPER adamant that we do every shift we sign up for or find coverage on our own. My contract flat-out says that if I am in the hospital, they need to see the bill as proof.

Well, I had an event last night during the blizzard that hit my area. It was in this TINY remote town that you have to take back roads to get to. I talked to the store and my employer, but they would not cancel it.

Unsurprisingly, the event was a total bust — no one was coming into this store and I barely gave out any samples, let alone sold anything.

After the event, on my drive home, I hit a patch of black ice and went off the road into a telephone pole. I am okay – just some bumps, bruises, and scratches (my glasses broke). But I’m already feeling sore today and my car is definitely messed up.

I haven’t told my company what happened yet. They are not liable (I signed a form when I started) and that’s fine; I’m not in a lawyer-up-and-make-them-pay rage or anything. But I am really upset they had me do this event – with that location, it would have been a slow one in good weather, let alone bad.

I’m also upset because I know I will be required to find coverage for the shifts I signed up for in the upcoming weeks. I can’t do them if I don’t have a car.

How to I calmly approach all this with my manager? What do I say? How do I express how upset I am without sounding accusatory or rude? I know I’m likely to get emotional no matter what; it was a really stressful experience that I’m going to have to address again and again as I deal with the insurance claims and bills in the next few weeks.


Update #1: Dec 26, 2018

I can’t believe it’s already been 2 years since my letter! To confirm what many people guessed, I was a part-time independent contractor for this company. I shared in the original comments how I told my manager I was in an accident driving home from the event and wouldn’t be able to work for a while. She simply told me to let her know when I could work again and to find someone to cover my upcoming shifts. I tried to push for the company to figure out my shifts but ultimately I had to find coverage myself.

Then I actually couldn’t work for quite some time. By the time I was able to go back to that job, I honestly just wanted nothing to do with them and I quit instead. I mentioned in my resignation how I felt their weather policy is dangerous and they should consider giving the employee some say in if it is safe to drive. My manager didn’t even acknowledge what I said – basically just gave me an “okay, I’ll take you off our lists.”

The funny thing is they NEVER took me off their email list/job board despite several reminders from me. I still get their emails to this day! Most of their emails now are either pleas for someone to take upcoming shifts, about adding/losing clients (they seem to go cycle through clients quickly), offering incentives if you refer a friend to work for them, or sharing that X manager has left “because they couldn’t handle the hours/stress/work-life-balance” or some other kind of aggressive-sounding statement. So, draw your own conclusions there (I certainly have).

But enough about them! I mentioned before that I couldn’t work for a while – it turned out I actually hurt my shoulder pretty bad. I ended up needing surgery and then was in physical therapy for several months. So 2017 was pretty rough.

I have made a full recovery at this point and (finally!) this summer was able to re-join my favorite sport. Plus, my full-time job was SO amazing during this time. They let me work from home while my car was in the shop, gave me all the time I needed for the surgery, didn’t deduct any PTO for my Physical Therapy sessions, and let me work from home on days I was just really sore. I also got a significant raise this year despite all of this craziness in 2017 :)

The whole experience has made me so appreciative of good companies that actually care for employees. In case anyone still needs to hear it: if you don’t put an effort into your people, they’re not going to put an effort into your company!


Update #2: Sep 26, 2019

I had to laugh (and immediately send you an update!) when I received this text message today:

“Hi OP. This is Jane, your manager from Promotion Company. Did you see my email yesterday? We still have some open shifts this weekend! Please text (or email) me your availability so we can get them filled!”

Wow!!! No one from that company has texted me since shortly after my update in December 2018. Someone suggested I start replying questioning their policies again and that worked like a charm to get them to stop contacting me (great suggestion!). I assumed they finally figured out that I really don’t work there anymore!

Out of curiosity, I just checked my filtered emails… and YUP. I’m STILL getting their emails! Multiple a week. Too funny.

I texted Jane back letting her know I quit over 2 years ago and moved out of state several months ago (which is the only state they’re active in). Maybe that’ll finally stop them?!

Otherwise, I’m still at the same wonderful company that got me through my original injury in late 2016; I moved to a different location for my spouse’s new job earlier this year (and now I get to work from home half the week as well!).


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

Title: I got in a car accident because my company insisted I do an event in a remote town during a blizzard

I am NOT OP.

Originally posted to: Ask A Manager Jan 9, 2017

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

Car Accident, Employer doesn’t care about employee health


Original Post: Jan 9, 2017

I have a part-time job with a promo company sampling food or drinks at events/stores/wherever the brand being sampled pays us to go. The company is SUPER adamant that we do every shift we sign up for or find coverage on our own. My contract flat-out says that if I am in the hospital, they need to see the bill as proof.

Well, I had an event last night during the blizzard that hit my area. It was in this TINY remote town that you have to take back roads to get to. I talked to the store and my employer, but they would not cancel it.

Unsurprisingly, the event was a total bust — no one was coming into this store and I barely gave out any samples, let alone sold anything.

After the event, on my drive home, I hit a patch of black ice and went off the road into a telephone pole. I am okay – just some bumps, bruises, and scratches (my glasses broke). But I’m already feeling sore today and my car is definitely messed up.

I haven’t told my company what happened yet. They are not liable (I signed a form when I started) and that’s fine; I’m not in a lawyer-up-and-make-them-pay rage or anything. But I am really upset they had me do this event – with that location, it would have been a slow one in good weather, let alone bad.

I’m also upset because I know I will be required to find coverage for the shifts I signed up for in the upcoming weeks. I can’t do them if I don’t have a car.

How to I calmly approach all this with my manager? What do I say? How do I express how upset I am without sounding accusatory or rude? I know I’m likely to get emotional no matter what; it was a really stressful experience that I’m going to have to address again and again as I deal with the insurance claims and bills in the next few weeks.


Update #1: Dec 26, 2018

I can’t believe it’s already been 2 years since my letter! To confirm what many people guessed, I was a part-time independent contractor for this company. I shared in the original comments how I told my manager I was in an accident driving home from the event and wouldn’t be able to work for a while. She simply told me to let her know when I could work again and to find someone to cover my upcoming shifts. I tried to push for the company to figure out my shifts but ultimately I had to find coverage myself.

Then I actually couldn’t work for quite some time. By the time I was able to go back to that job, I honestly just wanted nothing to do with them and I quit instead. I mentioned in my resignation how I felt their weather policy is dangerous and they should consider giving the employee some say in if it is safe to drive. My manager didn’t even acknowledge what I said – basically just gave me an “okay, I’ll take you off our lists.”

The funny thing is they NEVER took me off their email list/job board despite several reminders from me. I still get their emails to this day! Most of their emails now are either pleas for someone to take upcoming shifts, about adding/losing clients (they seem to go cycle through clients quickly), offering incentives if you refer a friend to work for them, or sharing that X manager has left “because they couldn’t handle the hours/stress/work-life-balance” or some other kind of aggressive-sounding statement. So, draw your own conclusions there (I certainly have).

But enough about them! I mentioned before that I couldn’t work for a while – it turned out I actually hurt my shoulder pretty bad. I ended up needing surgery and then was in physical therapy for several months. So 2017 was pretty rough.

I have made a full recovery at this point and (finally!) this summer was able to re-join my favorite sport. Plus, my full-time job was SO amazing during this time. They let me work from home while my car was in the shop, gave me all the time I needed for the surgery, didn’t deduct any PTO for my Physical Therapy sessions, and let me work from home on days I was just really sore. I also got a significant raise this year despite all of this craziness in 2017 :)

The whole experience has made me so appreciative of good companies that actually care for employees. In case anyone still needs to hear it: if you don’t put an effort into your people, they’re not going to put an effort into your company!


Update #2: Sep 26, 2019

I had to laugh (and immediately send you an update!) when I received this text message today:

“Hi OP. This is Jane, your manager from Promotion Company. Did you see my email yesterday? We still have some open shifts this weekend! Please text (or email) me your availability so we can get them filled!”

Wow!!! No one from that company has texted me since shortly after my update in December 2018. Someone suggested I start replying questioning their policies again and that worked like a charm to get them to stop contacting me (great suggestion!). I assumed they finally figured out that I really don’t work there anymore!

Out of curiosity, I just checked my filtered emails… and YUP. I’m STILL getting their emails! Multiple a week. Too funny.

I texted Jane back letting her know I quit over 2 years ago and moved out of state several months ago (which is the only state they’re active in). Maybe that’ll finally stop them?!

Otherwise, I’m still at the same wonderful company that got me through my original injury in late 2016; I moved to a different location for my spouse’s new job earlier this year (and now I get to work from home half the week as well!).


Do not comment on any linked posts or message the OOP

This is a repost community, I am not OP!

0

[Concluded] my boss pressures me to take sick leave, but I can’t afford to [AAM]

Ask a Manager my boss pressures me to take sick leave, but I can&#039;t afford to www.askamanager.org
preview

I am not OOP, this is a repost community.

Original Title: my boss pressures me to take sick leave, but I can’t afford to

Source: Ask A Manager

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

Workplace Bullying, minor public humiliation

Original: Apr 24, 2018

I work in a small office of less than 10 people, and even then, there’s usually only two or three of us actually working within it on any given day. I started off as an intern but have since been taken on as an employee – though I have never been given a contract stipulating annual leave or sick days. I just know what hours I work and what my rate of pay is. Recently I took time off for a planned holiday and was informed that I do not get paid when I’m not in the office – which is fair enough I guess, as the company is going through a bit of a rough patch, but is making my current conundrum that much more difficult.

My boss is very anal about cleanliness (to the point of overkill, in my opinion, but I accept that it’s not my place to say that), and it’s starting to affect me. I don’t get sick very often, and when I do I usually still come to work unless I feel awful – think a cough or a runny nose. We work in a single room and whenever my boss is in (she’s usually one of the ones out of the office), she complains loudly about my being ill and that I should take a day off in case I get anyone else sick. (I should note – that hasn’t happened yet, as I’m very careful, particularly because she’s so pedantic about this issue. I should also note that I have taken sick leave once, when I felt I was too sick to come in.)

I don’t want to take sick days, as I feel fine aside from the minor ailment, and there’s also the fact that I can’t afford to stay off as often as she expects me to. I don’t get paid for taking sick leave, and I’m finding the constant pressure to stay home when I’m not that unwell rather distressing, because it seems they are completely oblivious to the fact that not everyone can afford to do that! (Everyone – the bosses in particular – take days off willy nilly. I seem to be the only one with a regular schedule as I can’t afford not to work! I also earn the lowest wage in the office – minimum wage).

How should I address this with her? We’re not particularly close, and these occurrences have made me feel even more detached from her, as I find her rather unpleasant. I’m made to feel like I’m disgusting for merely coughing at work.


Update #1: Dec 26, 2018

Based on the advice I’d been given, I decided to knuckle down and focus on getting another job – any other job. I know a lot of people suggested I contact Citizen’s Advice, but I was honestly (and still am) a little wary of doing that, as my father has dealt with them in the past regarding a job issue that was a lot more clear cut and wrong, in my opinion, and that didn’t go well for him.

Anyway, it turned out to be really lucky I was looking for other work, as at the start of May (not even a month after I sent my letter!) they laid me off. It was in a really mean way as well, because my boss came up to me at my desk (in front of my coworkers), and said ‘We’re going to have to lower your hours’ and I was like, ‘Okay, what to?’ My boss: ‘Zero.’ And then she laughed. Yup. Seriously. I couldn’t believe it. I don’t think I’ve ever felt more degraded in my working life. It was as if the whole thing was just a big joke to her. I wasn’t the only person to get laid off that day, but I had also just published their new website days before, so my family and I are pretty sure that played a part in it as well.

Anyway, that sucked, but I had an interview the Monday after for a 6 month full time writing internship. The interview went well – it wasn’t exceptional or anything – but lo and behold, I got the internship!

I’ve now been here a week and it’s amazing. I have holiday and sick pay, and I’m even getting put through their pension scheme! (Though whether that’s worth it right now seeing as it’s just an internship, I don’t know. Any thoughts on that?) I’m also earning the highest wage I’ve ever had! And best of all, I’m doing something I’m really passionate about! Who knew things would work out so well in the end?

I am not OOP, this is a repost community.

I am not OOP, this is a repost community.

Original Title: my boss pressures me to take sick leave, but I can’t afford to

Source: Ask A Manager

Trigger Warning:

spoiler

Workplace Bullying, minor public humiliation

Original: Apr 24, 2018

I work in a small office of less than 10 people, and even then, there’s usually only two or three of us actually working within it on any given day. I started off as an intern but have since been taken on as an employee – though I have never been given a contract stipulating annual leave or sick days. I just know what hours I work and what my rate of pay is. Recently I took time off for a planned holiday and was informed that I do not get paid when I’m not in the office – which is fair enough I guess, as the company is going through a bit of a rough patch, but is making my current conundrum that much more difficult.

My boss is very anal about cleanliness (to the point of overkill, in my opinion, but I accept that it’s not my place to say that), and it’s starting to affect me. I don’t get sick very often, and when I do I usually still come to work unless I feel awful – think a cough or a runny nose. We work in a single room and whenever my boss is in (she’s usually one of the ones out of the office), she complains loudly about my being ill and that I should take a day off in case I get anyone else sick. (I should note – that hasn’t happened yet, as I’m very careful, particularly because she’s so pedantic about this issue. I should also note that I have taken sick leave once, when I felt I was too sick to come in.)

I don’t want to take sick days, as I feel fine aside from the minor ailment, and there’s also the fact that I can’t afford to stay off as often as she expects me to. I don’t get paid for taking sick leave, and I’m finding the constant pressure to stay home when I’m not that unwell rather distressing, because it seems they are completely oblivious to the fact that not everyone can afford to do that! (Everyone – the bosses in particular – take days off willy nilly. I seem to be the only one with a regular schedule as I can’t afford not to work! I also earn the lowest wage in the office – minimum wage).

How should I address this with her? We’re not particularly close, and these occurrences have made me feel even more detached from her, as I find her rather unpleasant. I’m made to feel like I’m disgusting for merely coughing at work.


Update #1: Dec 26, 2018

Based on the advice I’d been given, I decided to knuckle down and focus on getting another job – any other job. I know a lot of people suggested I contact Citizen’s Advice, but I was honestly (and still am) a little wary of doing that, as my father has dealt with them in the past regarding a job issue that was a lot more clear cut and wrong, in my opinion, and that didn’t go well for him.

Anyway, it turned out to be really lucky I was looking for other work, as at the start of May (not even a month after I sent my letter!) they laid me off. It was in a really mean way as well, because my boss came up to me at my desk (in front of my coworkers), and said ‘We’re going to have to lower your hours’ and I was like, ‘Okay, what to?’ My boss: ‘Zero.’ And then she laughed. Yup. Seriously. I couldn’t believe it. I don’t think I’ve ever felt more degraded in my working life. It was as if the whole thing was just a big joke to her. I wasn’t the only person to get laid off that day, but I had also just published their new website days before, so my family and I are pretty sure that played a part in it as well.

Anyway, that sucked, but I had an interview the Monday after for a 6 month full time writing internship. The interview went well – it wasn’t exceptional or anything – but lo and behold, I got the internship!

I’ve now been here a week and it’s amazing. I have holiday and sick pay, and I’m even getting put through their pension scheme! (Though whether that’s worth it right now seeing as it’s just an internship, I don’t know. Any thoughts on that?) I’m also earning the highest wage I’ve ever had! And best of all, I’m doing something I’m really passionate about! Who knew things would work out so well in the end?

I am not OOP, this is a repost community.

0

[Concluded] my dad is dating my boss, and they want me to go to couples therapy with them [AAM]

Ask a Manager my dad is dating my boss, and they want me to go to couples therapy with them www.askamanager.org
preview

I am not OOP, this is a repost community.

Trigger warnings:

spoiler

gas lighting, verbal abuse, burn out, name calling

Original: 05/09/2018

My dad started dating this woman (Jill) about two years ago, after he and my stepmom amicably divorced. As this was going on, I graduated from grad school, ended my student internship, and started looking for jobs. In six months, I applied to 275 jobs and didn’t get a single interview. I was desperate for work when my dad said Jill needed a new executive assistant. Jill is the chair of a nonprofit, and the job came with a good salary and a lot new responsibilities. I had an interview and was offered the job right away.

Immediately, things were much worse than I expected:

• She tells me when to start working either late at night or in the morning. My hours aren’t terribly long, but it is impossible to schedule anything since I don’t know my schedule in advance, and my health and self-care have taken a beating. I don’t have set hours, so she calls and texts at any time, and I never know when I’m done for the day.

• One of my main roles is to work on her book, a memoir about the struggles of being a minority and a woman. My dad, a white man, is writing the entire thing secretly; she hasn’t told her publisher that a ghostwriter is involved, and he is getting no compensation or recognition as she goes around telling everyone that she’s the only woman of this ethnic group to write a book on the subject.

• When I ask clarifying questions, she belittles me (“That’s common sense” or “You know as much as I do”).

• She’s rude and cruel to me in front of others at meetings, events, and on conference calls. Once when I said the way she was talking to me was making me flustered, she yelled that this is how she manages people, that I perceive things the wrong way, and that it’s a problem with me.

• She is always coming up with elaborate rumors about our out-of-state staff. She often says that her former assistant had brain damage; her reasoning was that she was born premature and therefore must have brain damage and be “mentally handicapped.” So-and-so is obese because her kid died and now she’s too emotionally unstable to work. So-and-so must be crazy because he chose to serve on a submarine while in the Navy.

• She doesn’t do anything herself because she doesn’t know how to use Word. She makes me come to her house to print things because she doesn’t want to open them on her computer. I write columns under her name, and then we go through upwards of six drafts as she makes minuscule tweaks, forgets she made those tweaks, and changes them back to the original, all while criticizing me for not making any sense.

• She volunteered to watch her infant granddaughter twice a week, but she started leaving the baby with me while she goes to her law office. I don’t get paid extra for this; she says that would be unfair to the organization.

We go through cycles where I think everything is fine, and then I get yelled at about something small that I didn’t realize was an issue. Every time there’s some sort of problem, I try to change what I do, only to have a new problem spring up that was never an issue before. My job has become one big game of whack-a-mole that I’m being forced to play when I really just want to focus on the mountain of tasks I’ve been assigned. She wants me to be just a personal assistant, but the job responsibilities I have are a lot bigger than that (helping to plan large events and writing for our publications), and tending to her has become a distraction from my work, which I know bothers her. I try to be polite and helpful, but I have so much stuff to do that it’s hard to remind her to respond to emails, especially when usually she snaps that I should know how to respond myself, even when she needs to review things to give the final okay.

She’s also always brought my dad into things. When I first started, she’d say she cared more about me being her assistant than dating my dad, and that if she needed to devote more time to making our work relationship better, she’d end things with my dad. I was constantly terrified of doing something that would make her dump my father. In the months since, my dad has moved in, and they started seeing a couples counselor (Jill constantly threatens to end their relationship).

Last week, I forgot to do something, she reminded me, and I quickly did the task. Hours later at 11 p.m., she accused me of not doing it and started sending me long, mean texts saying, “This is becoming a problem with you,” etc. When I said I had done the task, she said she shouldn’t have had to remind me. I thought I’d just ride the storm out. Everything I said was met with a different criticism, I wasn’t sure what to do, it was late, and this wasn’t productive, so I didn’t respond to her last text (which hadn’t asked anything of me). Soon after, my dad called to say that Jill had yelled at him for half an hour about distracting me from my work. The next day, they went on a weeklong vacation to Mexico, where she had sporadic internet access. She barely emailed me the entire time, leaving me to work on her book.

Yesterday, my father started giving me job advice: morning check-ins and updates with Jill, etc. — things I do every day and have been doing for the past 10 months. Then he said, “Would you be open to seeing our family therapist with us to help with your job?” I told him there was no way I was going to do that. I was really upset afterwards that he would try to put me in that position where they would gang up on me in their therapist’s office, especially when he knows I’ve started seeking out other jobs.

This morning, she told me to come over at 8:30 a.m. When I got there, she and my dad sat opposite me and spent 45 minutes scolding me, citing “complaints” by the out-of-state employees with whom I have great relationships and get along very well. Then she said that the only solution she can think of to deal with my communication problems is for me to join her and my father at their couples therapist. She said I hadn’t forgotten to do the task from the week before and that it was a deeper issue. I was literally cornered in her living room, and I could see from my heart rate monitor that I was at 115 bpm, frantically trying not to hyperventilate. When I said I thought it was inappropriate to go see a therapist with my boss and my dad, she said she would write it into my job requirement or put me on probation. She’s given me two days to agree to therapy or write a list of all the reasons I won’t go with them and what I’ll do to change my behavior. I seriously suspect she has narcissistic personality disorder, and I know from experience that she doesn’t respond well when I try to explain myself or disagree with her.

I’ve been depressed for months, but I’ve reached a new level of desperation. I would work anywhere else — I would do anything else. I’ve been applying to jobs for a couple weeks now, and I would be thrilled to wait tables while continuing my job hunt. My mom says that I won’t be able to get a good job if I’ve quit a job after less than a year and start doing something that isn’t on a larger career path, but all of my friends my age say that my health is more important. I feel so confused, gaslighted, abused — and then I feel like maybe I’m just being a millenial and don’t have what it takes to be successful. Am I just a bad employee? I probably don’t have the best personality for a personal assistant, but I try to work hard, keep organized and professional, and board members go out of their way to compliment me when we’re at meetings and events. Since getting this job, I never complained to my father about his girlfriend or brought her up, but Jill is constantly blurring the boundaries by asking about extremely personal things during work and bringing up work when we’re celebrating holidays and birthdays.

I am miserable and feel so trapped and confused. Is all this normal?! I have so many mixed signals about every aspect of my job, and this situation is taking over my life. What do I do when I have to give my answer to the ultimatum?


Update 1: 09/04/2018

Thank you so much for your advice and support. Here’s an update.

I had to face the ultimatum two days after I first wrote in, so Alison hadn’t posted my letter on the site yet. I decided to call Jill’s bluff; I did all of her work for her and knew she couldn’t get rid of me without everything collapsing. If she continued to threaten my job, I was prepared to say, “Then I think we need to talk about my transition out of this position.”

When I got there, she was so cheery that I knew she didn’t think this would be a fight. She and my dad had me sit across from them again, in the same spot as last time, and just said, “So?” I said, “I’m not going to couple’s therapy with you because it’s really inappropriate, pretty unethical, and a conflict of interest. If you think my job performance needs work, you can hire someone to train me. And I really don’t appreciate being cornered and asked to go to therapy with you when I’d already told Dad I wasn’t interested.”

Over the next hour: – Jill tried to tell me her therapist was the most ethical therapist. – My dad said that we’re both really similar and sensitive, and it’s possible that I’m just being sensitive because Jill is so “direct.” I responded, “That’s insulting, and you don’t know what it’s like to do my job.” – Jill said, “Are you telling me you’re not going to finish the book?” I told her I was actively looking for other jobs. – I used my line about transitioning out of the role, and immediately Jill started backtracking and saying we could revisit this in, say, nine months. She started being friendly again, and said, “I was just telling your dad what a good job you did on that assignment yesterday.” She walked me to the door and tried to blame the whole thing on my dad, saying that she didn’t know I wasn’t comfortable going to therapy with them (even though I made that clear the first time they sat me down), and that she’s a therapy junkie and does it with everyone (which says a lot about her interpersonal relationships).

After that, I felt really strong. I’d been physically sick over this, and was really proud of myself for facing that horrible situation head-on. My husband was still waiting on his green card/work permit, so he was relieved that we still had an income and could pay rent. I continued looking for other jobs. The confrontation seemed to empower my dad a little bit, and over the next few weeks we discussed on a regular basis how he could get out of the relationship. My policy of not saying bad things about Jill had officially ended, and I told Dad all the horrible things she said and did, how her behavior was cyclical, and that she would never change. Not all of this was a surprise, though. I didn’t include these in the first letter because it wasn’t job-related, but my Dad had witnessed on multiple occasions Jill asking me how many people I’d had sex with and whether I was sexually attracted to my husband— lots of very weird, prying questions that felt like they were more about making me uncomfortable than learning more about me. He’d also heard her call our relatives and family friends cruel names like “Stepford Wife,” “Dumb and Dumber,” and “Children of the Corn.” … So he needs to face why he’s okay being with someone who treats his loved ones (and him!) this badly.

My letter published two weeks after the ultimatum, and I’d forgotten that it was scheduled for that Wednesday because I was so busy with everything else that was going on. I was babysitting when I got an email with the link to my AAM letter from my dad with the subject: “Um.” Someone he knew on Twitter had retweeted it. I just felt relieved; I’d already said all of what was in the letter directly to him, and I was so happy to finally have support from someone (Alison, thank you) to show that he was in the wrong. I was so lost and desperate when I wrote my letter, and it was important for him to see that what he was doing was not okay.

I read every single comment. I cried out of happiness to know I wasn’t crazy, that this wasn’t my fault, and that so many people were worried about me. My friends kept texting me screenshots and quotes from their favorite comments, and I felt so lifted up. To the person who offered to buy me Alison’s book: thank you! But I want to buy it myself when I can afford to as a thank you for all that Alison did for me. I took her up on her very generous offer to look over my resume and cover letter, and I made the changes she suggested when I continued sending out applications. To the wonderful person who gave me a free massage: thank you! I decided to get the massage after I got a new job as a treat for moving on. Which brings me to the next part of the story.

The day after my letter was posted, I woke up to eight emails from Jill. I was going through them, responding and completing the tasks she’d assigned, when she texted me asking if I was awake and had seen her email. I responded, “Which one?” and she said, “Which one do you think.” It was hardly the worst thing she’d said or done, but it was so rude and belittling. I heard all the commenters’ voices in my head, and I turned to my husband and said I wasn’t going to do this anymore.

I called a coworker, said that I think I needed to quit, and explained the situation. I told him everything: about the rumors she spreads, about the therapy threat, etc. We scheduled a call with the Vice Chair of the foundation, me, and two other employees (one of whom was resigning because they were moving). I told the Vice Chair everything, said that I loved the work I was doing for the foundation, but that I couldn’t work for Jill anymore. He said that while she’s done a lot for the foundation, she is absolutely impossible to work for. The other employees said they knew that her last assistant put up with a lot of abuse, and they had also noticed that Jill’s behaviors had patterns and cycles. They all said that I do wonderful work, and that they would do whatever they could to keep me, but that it sounded like there wasn’t a way to fix this, so they would help me leave my job in the least traumatic way possible. The Vice Chair said that if he were my father, he would tell me to do the same thing. He said to write a resignation letter effective immediately, otherwise Jill would try to convince me to stay. He also said not to do it in person or on the phone; it needed to be in an email so she couldn’t manipulate me in a conversation. They all reviewed and okayed my resignation letter, and the Vice Chair offered to be a reference. I was so touched that they believed and supported me.

On the advice of the Vice Chair, I gave my dad a heads-up. Dad begged me to do it the next morning (I guess because he would be leaving the house to go to work and wouldn’t have to face her), so I waited until 6 am to press send on my resignation email. I blocked Jill on both my emails and on my cell phone. I had arranged with my coworkers and the Vice Chair to transfer all of my files over to other staff members, so there was nothing Jill could claim only I had access to. Still, everything blew up. Dad kept calling and emailing, saying that I had to return the key to Jill’s (and his) house, that I should work for at least two more weeks, that I should come over and explain to Jill that I resigned because she was emotionally abusive (he said he would protect me). My husband and I left our apartment for a week and stayed with nearby relatives while things quieted down; we were worried Dad and Jill would come to our apartment.

Dad and I haven’t spoken since. Not talking to my dad has been very difficult and I miss him. What helps me is the response I got from Captain Awkward to my AAM letter: “Think of [your dad] as Theoden, King of Rohan while he’s still very much under Grima Wormtongue’s spell. You can love him but your safety depends on working around him. His advice to you sucks. He is not on your side.”

There have been a few times where my dad has reached out to my mom about random work things (“She didn’t give Jill all her files, she didn’t reimburse the foundation for her airplane ticket,” etc.) that I had already arranged with other staff members. Each time is very stressful because I worry that I did something wrong and that I won’t get a good reference from the Vice Chair, but then I remember that I arranged everything with them and that they would contact me themselves if there were a problem. All the staff members supported me, and no sane coworker would deal with a problem by complaining to Jill, having her complain to my dad, having my dad complain to my mom, and having my mom talk to me. It took a lot of talking with my mom before she realized that this situation is completely outside of the norms of professional behavior she’s dealt with, and that she can’t treat this like rational requests from a former employer. She’s now completely supportive of my choice to leave, and she knows I did so with the support of the other staff members.

In the months since, I’ve had a few interviews and signed up with a temp agency. Finally, I got a job! I start a new temp-to-perm position after the holiday weekend, and I’m so excited. My husband’s work permit has also come through, so soon we will have two incomes. Time to go get that massage!

Thank you so much for everything, Alison and the AAM community. I wouldn’t have had the confidence to leave my job if it hadn’t been for your kind words and support.


Final Update 12/3/2019

Things are going okay– very busy. I’m still working at the same company where I was placed by a temp agency. I like my job all right, but the whole office culture has been wearing on me a bit (it’s a bit conservative). What gets me through is knowing that this job gives me and my husband stability, especially since we have two incomes now. It’s also nice to have a very low-stress job where I don’t need to take any of my work home with me, but I’m definitely not fulfilled.

I had a sort of epiphany in March that what I actually want to do is deliver babies (sounds out of the blue, but I actually wrote my master’s thesis on the importance of maternal health care as a measure of progress in developing countries), so now I’m applying to nurse/midwifery courses and waiting to hear back. I won’t know for sure whether I’ve been accepted anywhere until February, and right now I’m taking all my prerequisite courses online, which works out to be a full-time course load on top of my full-time job. It’s a lot! I’ve just done doula training, so I might try to work as a doula for awhile if I don’t get into school on this try. We’ll see!

As for family stuff… nothing has changed. My dad is still with Jill, and we haven’t spoken in person since my first letter (May 2018). We occasionally email and text. I ran into him and Jill on the street a few weeks ago (we were on a very narrow sidewalk and it was only the three of us; yes, he saw me), but he didn’t say hello or smile, and Jill just smirked at me. It was really horrible. My mom is great and doesn’t pressure me to speak to him, but the rest of the family isn’t as nice about it. Everyone obviously found out about my letter, and some relatives haven’t read it, but still think it was wrong of me to air family grievances online (even though it’s anonymous and I never expected my family to see it). My grandparents have asked if I’m “ever going to speak to [my] father again”, which is just so far off base… This isn’t about me being mad and pouting– it’s a matter of self-protection. Now, since I haven’t celebrated Christmas with my extended family on my dad’s side for a few years, I’m getting pressure to come for Christmas because my grandparents “won’t be alive forever.” It’s been really re-traumatizing to have to explain that the situation I was in with Dad and Jill was abusive, and I’m so tired of having to defend myself.

I’m seeing a therapist for support, which has been wonderful! About a year ago, my husband and I got a Cornish Rex kitten, and we’re currently planning a trip to Egypt to see the pyramids and cruise down the Nile. We’re really happy most of the time, and I feel very hopeful about the future.

Thank you and the whole Ask A Manager community!


Bonus Update (at the end of the last update)

I actually got into a great program and am moving to a new city in the spring!


Reminder I am not OOP, this is a repost community.

I am not OOP, this is a repost community.

Trigger warnings:

spoiler

gas lighting, verbal abuse, burn out, name calling

Original: 05/09/2018

My dad started dating this woman (Jill) about two years ago, after he and my stepmom amicably divorced. As this was going on, I graduated from grad school, ended my student internship, and started looking for jobs. In six months, I applied to 275 jobs and didn’t get a single interview. I was desperate for work when my dad said Jill needed a new executive assistant. Jill is the chair of a nonprofit, and the job came with a good salary and a lot new responsibilities. I had an interview and was offered the job right away.

Immediately, things were much worse than I expected:

• She tells me when to start working either late at night or in the morning. My hours aren’t terribly long, but it is impossible to schedule anything since I don’t know my schedule in advance, and my health and self-care have taken a beating. I don’t have set hours, so she calls and texts at any time, and I never know when I’m done for the day.

• One of my main roles is to work on her book, a memoir about the struggles of being a minority and a woman. My dad, a white man, is writing the entire thing secretly; she hasn’t told her publisher that a ghostwriter is involved, and he is getting no compensation or recognition as she goes around telling everyone that she’s the only woman of this ethnic group to write a book on the subject.

• When I ask clarifying questions, she belittles me (“That’s common sense” or “You know as much as I do”).

• She’s rude and cruel to me in front of others at meetings, events, and on conference calls. Once when I said the way she was talking to me was making me flustered, she yelled that this is how she manages people, that I perceive things the wrong way, and that it’s a problem with me.

• She is always coming up with elaborate rumors about our out-of-state staff. She often says that her former assistant had brain damage; her reasoning was that she was born premature and therefore must have brain damage and be “mentally handicapped.” So-and-so is obese because her kid died and now she’s too emotionally unstable to work. So-and-so must be crazy because he chose to serve on a submarine while in the Navy.

• She doesn’t do anything herself because she doesn’t know how to use Word. She makes me come to her house to print things because she doesn’t want to open them on her computer. I write columns under her name, and then we go through upwards of six drafts as she makes minuscule tweaks, forgets she made those tweaks, and changes them back to the original, all while criticizing me for not making any sense.

• She volunteered to watch her infant granddaughter twice a week, but she started leaving the baby with me while she goes to her law office. I don’t get paid extra for this; she says that would be unfair to the organization.

We go through cycles where I think everything is fine, and then I get yelled at about something small that I didn’t realize was an issue. Every time there’s some sort of problem, I try to change what I do, only to have a new problem spring up that was never an issue before. My job has become one big game of whack-a-mole that I’m being forced to play when I really just want to focus on the mountain of tasks I’ve been assigned. She wants me to be just a personal assistant, but the job responsibilities I have are a lot bigger than that (helping to plan large events and writing for our publications), and tending to her has become a distraction from my work, which I know bothers her. I try to be polite and helpful, but I have so much stuff to do that it’s hard to remind her to respond to emails, especially when usually she snaps that I should know how to respond myself, even when she needs to review things to give the final okay.

She’s also always brought my dad into things. When I first started, she’d say she cared more about me being her assistant than dating my dad, and that if she needed to devote more time to making our work relationship better, she’d end things with my dad. I was constantly terrified of doing something that would make her dump my father. In the months since, my dad has moved in, and they started seeing a couples counselor (Jill constantly threatens to end their relationship).

Last week, I forgot to do something, she reminded me, and I quickly did the task. Hours later at 11 p.m., she accused me of not doing it and started sending me long, mean texts saying, “This is becoming a problem with you,” etc. When I said I had done the task, she said she shouldn’t have had to remind me. I thought I’d just ride the storm out. Everything I said was met with a different criticism, I wasn’t sure what to do, it was late, and this wasn’t productive, so I didn’t respond to her last text (which hadn’t asked anything of me). Soon after, my dad called to say that Jill had yelled at him for half an hour about distracting me from my work. The next day, they went on a weeklong vacation to Mexico, where she had sporadic internet access. She barely emailed me the entire time, leaving me to work on her book.

Yesterday, my father started giving me job advice: morning check-ins and updates with Jill, etc. — things I do every day and have been doing for the past 10 months. Then he said, “Would you be open to seeing our family therapist with us to help with your job?” I told him there was no way I was going to do that. I was really upset afterwards that he would try to put me in that position where they would gang up on me in their therapist’s office, especially when he knows I’ve started seeking out other jobs.

This morning, she told me to come over at 8:30 a.m. When I got there, she and my dad sat opposite me and spent 45 minutes scolding me, citing “complaints” by the out-of-state employees with whom I have great relationships and get along very well. Then she said that the only solution she can think of to deal with my communication problems is for me to join her and my father at their couples therapist. She said I hadn’t forgotten to do the task from the week before and that it was a deeper issue. I was literally cornered in her living room, and I could see from my heart rate monitor that I was at 115 bpm, frantically trying not to hyperventilate. When I said I thought it was inappropriate to go see a therapist with my boss and my dad, she said she would write it into my job requirement or put me on probation. She’s given me two days to agree to therapy or write a list of all the reasons I won’t go with them and what I’ll do to change my behavior. I seriously suspect she has narcissistic personality disorder, and I know from experience that she doesn’t respond well when I try to explain myself or disagree with her.

I’ve been depressed for months, but I’ve reached a new level of desperation. I would work anywhere else — I would do anything else. I’ve been applying to jobs for a couple weeks now, and I would be thrilled to wait tables while continuing my job hunt. My mom says that I won’t be able to get a good job if I’ve quit a job after less than a year and start doing something that isn’t on a larger career path, but all of my friends my age say that my health is more important. I feel so confused, gaslighted, abused — and then I feel like maybe I’m just being a millenial and don’t have what it takes to be successful. Am I just a bad employee? I probably don’t have the best personality for a personal assistant, but I try to work hard, keep organized and professional, and board members go out of their way to compliment me when we’re at meetings and events. Since getting this job, I never complained to my father about his girlfriend or brought her up, but Jill is constantly blurring the boundaries by asking about extremely personal things during work and bringing up work when we’re celebrating holidays and birthdays.

I am miserable and feel so trapped and confused. Is all this normal?! I have so many mixed signals about every aspect of my job, and this situation is taking over my life. What do I do when I have to give my answer to the ultimatum?


Update 1: 09/04/2018

Thank you so much for your advice and support. Here’s an update.

I had to face the ultimatum two days after I first wrote in, so Alison hadn’t posted my letter on the site yet. I decided to call Jill’s bluff; I did all of her work for her and knew she couldn’t get rid of me without everything collapsing. If she continued to threaten my job, I was prepared to say, “Then I think we need to talk about my transition out of this position.”

When I got there, she was so cheery that I knew she didn’t think this would be a fight. She and my dad had me sit across from them again, in the same spot as last time, and just said, “So?” I said, “I’m not going to couple’s therapy with you because it’s really inappropriate, pretty unethical, and a conflict of interest. If you think my job performance needs work, you can hire someone to train me. And I really don’t appreciate being cornered and asked to go to therapy with you when I’d already told Dad I wasn’t interested.”

Over the next hour: – Jill tried to tell me her therapist was the most ethical therapist. – My dad said that we’re both really similar and sensitive, and it’s possible that I’m just being sensitive because Jill is so “direct.” I responded, “That’s insulting, and you don’t know what it’s like to do my job.” – Jill said, “Are you telling me you’re not going to finish the book?” I told her I was actively looking for other jobs. – I used my line about transitioning out of the role, and immediately Jill started backtracking and saying we could revisit this in, say, nine months. She started being friendly again, and said, “I was just telling your dad what a good job you did on that assignment yesterday.” She walked me to the door and tried to blame the whole thing on my dad, saying that she didn’t know I wasn’t comfortable going to therapy with them (even though I made that clear the first time they sat me down), and that she’s a therapy junkie and does it with everyone (which says a lot about her interpersonal relationships).

After that, I felt really strong. I’d been physically sick over this, and was really proud of myself for facing that horrible situation head-on. My husband was still waiting on his green card/work permit, so he was relieved that we still had an income and could pay rent. I continued looking for other jobs. The confrontation seemed to empower my dad a little bit, and over the next few weeks we discussed on a regular basis how he could get out of the relationship. My policy of not saying bad things about Jill had officially ended, and I told Dad all the horrible things she said and did, how her behavior was cyclical, and that she would never change. Not all of this was a surprise, though. I didn’t include these in the first letter because it wasn’t job-related, but my Dad had witnessed on multiple occasions Jill asking me how many people I’d had sex with and whether I was sexually attracted to my husband— lots of very weird, prying questions that felt like they were more about making me uncomfortable than learning more about me. He’d also heard her call our relatives and family friends cruel names like “Stepford Wife,” “Dumb and Dumber,” and “Children of the Corn.” … So he needs to face why he’s okay being with someone who treats his loved ones (and him!) this badly.

My letter published two weeks after the ultimatum, and I’d forgotten that it was scheduled for that Wednesday because I was so busy with everything else that was going on. I was babysitting when I got an email with the link to my AAM letter from my dad with the subject: “Um.” Someone he knew on Twitter had retweeted it. I just felt relieved; I’d already said all of what was in the letter directly to him, and I was so happy to finally have support from someone (Alison, thank you) to show that he was in the wrong. I was so lost and desperate when I wrote my letter, and it was important for him to see that what he was doing was not okay.

I read every single comment. I cried out of happiness to know I wasn’t crazy, that this wasn’t my fault, and that so many people were worried about me. My friends kept texting me screenshots and quotes from their favorite comments, and I felt so lifted up. To the person who offered to buy me Alison’s book: thank you! But I want to buy it myself when I can afford to as a thank you for all that Alison did for me. I took her up on her very generous offer to look over my resume and cover letter, and I made the changes she suggested when I continued sending out applications. To the wonderful person who gave me a free massage: thank you! I decided to get the massage after I got a new job as a treat for moving on. Which brings me to the next part of the story.

The day after my letter was posted, I woke up to eight emails from Jill. I was going through them, responding and completing the tasks she’d assigned, when she texted me asking if I was awake and had seen her email. I responded, “Which one?” and she said, “Which one do you think.” It was hardly the worst thing she’d said or done, but it was so rude and belittling. I heard all the commenters’ voices in my head, and I turned to my husband and said I wasn’t going to do this anymore.

I called a coworker, said that I think I needed to quit, and explained the situation. I told him everything: about the rumors she spreads, about the therapy threat, etc. We scheduled a call with the Vice Chair of the foundation, me, and two other employees (one of whom was resigning because they were moving). I told the Vice Chair everything, said that I loved the work I was doing for the foundation, but that I couldn’t work for Jill anymore. He said that while she’s done a lot for the foundation, she is absolutely impossible to work for. The other employees said they knew that her last assistant put up with a lot of abuse, and they had also noticed that Jill’s behaviors had patterns and cycles. They all said that I do wonderful work, and that they would do whatever they could to keep me, but that it sounded like there wasn’t a way to fix this, so they would help me leave my job in the least traumatic way possible. The Vice Chair said that if he were my father, he would tell me to do the same thing. He said to write a resignation letter effective immediately, otherwise Jill would try to convince me to stay. He also said not to do it in person or on the phone; it needed to be in an email so she couldn’t manipulate me in a conversation. They all reviewed and okayed my resignation letter, and the Vice Chair offered to be a reference. I was so touched that they believed and supported me.

On the advice of the Vice Chair, I gave my dad a heads-up. Dad begged me to do it the next morning (I guess because he would be leaving the house to go to work and wouldn’t have to face her), so I waited until 6 am to press send on my resignation email. I blocked Jill on both my emails and on my cell phone. I had arranged with my coworkers and the Vice Chair to transfer all of my files over to other staff members, so there was nothing Jill could claim only I had access to. Still, everything blew up. Dad kept calling and emailing, saying that I had to return the key to Jill’s (and his) house, that I should work for at least two more weeks, that I should come over and explain to Jill that I resigned because she was emotionally abusive (he said he would protect me). My husband and I left our apartment for a week and stayed with nearby relatives while things quieted down; we were worried Dad and Jill would come to our apartment.

Dad and I haven’t spoken since. Not talking to my dad has been very difficult and I miss him. What helps me is the response I got from Captain Awkward to my AAM letter: “Think of [your dad] as Theoden, King of Rohan while he’s still very much under Grima Wormtongue’s spell. You can love him but your safety depends on working around him. His advice to you sucks. He is not on your side.”

There have been a few times where my dad has reached out to my mom about random work things (“She didn’t give Jill all her files, she didn’t reimburse the foundation for her airplane ticket,” etc.) that I had already arranged with other staff members. Each time is very stressful because I worry that I did something wrong and that I won’t get a good reference from the Vice Chair, but then I remember that I arranged everything with them and that they would contact me themselves if there were a problem. All the staff members supported me, and no sane coworker would deal with a problem by complaining to Jill, having her complain to my dad, having my dad complain to my mom, and having my mom talk to me. It took a lot of talking with my mom before she realized that this situation is completely outside of the norms of professional behavior she’s dealt with, and that she can’t treat this like rational requests from a former employer. She’s now completely supportive of my choice to leave, and she knows I did so with the support of the other staff members.

In the months since, I’ve had a few interviews and signed up with a temp agency. Finally, I got a job! I start a new temp-to-perm position after the holiday weekend, and I’m so excited. My husband’s work permit has also come through, so soon we will have two incomes. Time to go get that massage!

Thank you so much for everything, Alison and the AAM community. I wouldn’t have had the confidence to leave my job if it hadn’t been for your kind words and support.


Final Update 12/3/2019

Things are going okay– very busy. I’m still working at the same company where I was placed by a temp agency. I like my job all right, but the whole office culture has been wearing on me a bit (it’s a bit conservative). What gets me through is knowing that this job gives me and my husband stability, especially since we have two incomes now. It’s also nice to have a very low-stress job where I don’t need to take any of my work home with me, but I’m definitely not fulfilled.

I had a sort of epiphany in March that what I actually want to do is deliver babies (sounds out of the blue, but I actually wrote my master’s thesis on the importance of maternal health care as a measure of progress in developing countries), so now I’m applying to nurse/midwifery courses and waiting to hear back. I won’t know for sure whether I’ve been accepted anywhere until February, and right now I’m taking all my prerequisite courses online, which works out to be a full-time course load on top of my full-time job. It’s a lot! I’ve just done doula training, so I might try to work as a doula for awhile if I don’t get into school on this try. We’ll see!

As for family stuff… nothing has changed. My dad is still with Jill, and we haven’t spoken in person since my first letter (May 2018). We occasionally email and text. I ran into him and Jill on the street a few weeks ago (we were on a very narrow sidewalk and it was only the three of us; yes, he saw me), but he didn’t say hello or smile, and Jill just smirked at me. It was really horrible. My mom is great and doesn’t pressure me to speak to him, but the rest of the family isn’t as nice about it. Everyone obviously found out about my letter, and some relatives haven’t read it, but still think it was wrong of me to air family grievances online (even though it’s anonymous and I never expected my family to see it). My grandparents have asked if I’m “ever going to speak to [my] father again”, which is just so far off base… This isn’t about me being mad and pouting– it’s a matter of self-protection. Now, since I haven’t celebrated Christmas with my extended family on my dad’s side for a few years, I’m getting pressure to come for Christmas because my grandparents “won’t be alive forever.” It’s been really re-traumatizing to have to explain that the situation I was in with Dad and Jill was abusive, and I’m so tired of having to defend myself.

I’m seeing a therapist for support, which has been wonderful! About a year ago, my husband and I got a Cornish Rex kitten, and we’re currently planning a trip to Egypt to see the pyramids and cruise down the Nile. We’re really happy most of the time, and I feel very hopeful about the future.

Thank you and the whole Ask A Manager community!


Bonus Update (at the end of the last update)

I actually got into a great program and am moving to a new city in the spring!


Reminder I am not OOP, this is a repost community.

0

[Concluded] I spent a ton of time helping 2 employees who hate each other … now they’re dating [AAM]

Ask a Manager I spent a ton of time helping 2 employees who hate each other ... now they&#039;re dating www.askamanager.org
preview

I am NOT OOP, this is a repost community.

Original Post: May 6, 2024

Over the last few months, one of my people (Alice) has repeatedly come to me about conflict with a neighboring department’s person (Mary). Both are at the same fairly junior level — they’re a few years out of school. The conflict has always seemed odd, and fairly amorphous, but both Alice and Mary have been very upset, including claims of bullying and issues with sharing of materials.

I observed their interactions, and they seemed somewhere between tense and rude. I coached Alice on professional behavior in the workplace, and Mary’s manager did the same with Mary.

Mary’s manager and I spent a lot of energy trying to figure out what was happening, and if one of the two of these people was the aggressor. Part of the problem has always been how little reason there seemed to be for this disagreement — nothing that happened seemed to justify the outsized anger at each other. For example, Mary once told me that she could not be in the same room with Alice without blacking out with overwhelming fury.

HR got involved, as did the union, and I have talked with more union reps and HR members in the last few months than I had in the preceding several years. This affected office morale enough that Mary’s manager and I have had conversations with the union about the path towards firing both of them, despite the fact that both are very high performers.

This week Alice came into my office and happily told me that it had been solved: she and Mary have made up and have begun dating. This comes after a long week last week of complaints about Mary’s behavior, and a further escalation up the ranks in HR.

I am furious. I don’t consider myself a person who gets angry easily, but I am there now. I coached these young women through a workplace conflict in good faith, and it turns out this was just some highschool pigtail pulling? I genuinely trusted Alice, and (while keeping open eyes about her faults) have taken the point of view that it is my job to protect my people.

I have not said anything, and I don’t know what I want to say. I certainly won’t address it until I can think this through with a level head, and maybe I should just be glad everything is over and let this go. Any advice?


Update: January 15, 2026 (2 years later)

Alice and Mary did break up, although I’m not sure exactly when. After the breakup, they weren’t friendly (and in general they refused to speak to each other) but there hasn’t been the same insanity as before.

However, without this backdrop of extreme tension, other issues (maybe unsurprisingly) became more obvious. While both of them are very good at the technical aspects of their jobs, as you might imagine, they have turned out to be quite difficult. Both of them have had serious issues with being incredibly sensitive about credit apportionment, and both have become increasingly resistant to feedback. Alice has been gently encouraged to find a job in another field, and left a few months ago. I’ve been shocked at how much easier everything is with her gone. I can’t even point to exactly what the problem was, but suddenly my team has become more flexible and collaborative.

Mary is still around, but I mostly avoid directly working with her. I’ve heard her gossiping about “the ex that nearly destroyed her career,” but as far as I’m concerned, that’s not my problem.

Personally, I’ve honestly responded to this by trying to be a little less approachable. That’s probably not the recommended advice, but, as a youngish-looking woman in a very male dominated field, I feel like I get stuck with dealing with drama and interpersonal issues more than I should. I cannot and do not want to be everyones mom/big sister figure. I try to make it clear to my people that I’m here for them, but honestly I’m very okay with other departments’ junior people thinking I’m scary. I am curious if anyone has advice on this: I want to be a force for good in the workplace, but I’m also just TIRED.

Credit to u/choice_evidence1983 for the work in this post.

I am NOT OOP, this is a repost community.

Original Post: May 6, 2024

Over the last few months, one of my people (Alice) has repeatedly come to me about conflict with a neighboring department’s person (Mary). Both are at the same fairly junior level — they’re a few years out of school. The conflict has always seemed odd, and fairly amorphous, but both Alice and Mary have been very upset, including claims of bullying and issues with sharing of materials.

I observed their interactions, and they seemed somewhere between tense and rude. I coached Alice on professional behavior in the workplace, and Mary’s manager did the same with Mary.

Mary’s manager and I spent a lot of energy trying to figure out what was happening, and if one of the two of these people was the aggressor. Part of the problem has always been how little reason there seemed to be for this disagreement — nothing that happened seemed to justify the outsized anger at each other. For example, Mary once told me that she could not be in the same room with Alice without blacking out with overwhelming fury.

HR got involved, as did the union, and I have talked with more union reps and HR members in the last few months than I had in the preceding several years. This affected office morale enough that Mary’s manager and I have had conversations with the union about the path towards firing both of them, despite the fact that both are very high performers.

This week Alice came into my office and happily told me that it had been solved: she and Mary have made up and have begun dating. This comes after a long week last week of complaints about Mary’s behavior, and a further escalation up the ranks in HR.

I am furious. I don’t consider myself a person who gets angry easily, but I am there now. I coached these young women through a workplace conflict in good faith, and it turns out this was just some highschool pigtail pulling? I genuinely trusted Alice, and (while keeping open eyes about her faults) have taken the point of view that it is my job to protect my people.

I have not said anything, and I don’t know what I want to say. I certainly won’t address it until I can think this through with a level head, and maybe I should just be glad everything is over and let this go. Any advice?


Update: January 15, 2026 (2 years later)

Alice and Mary did break up, although I’m not sure exactly when. After the breakup, they weren’t friendly (and in general they refused to speak to each other) but there hasn’t been the same insanity as before.

However, without this backdrop of extreme tension, other issues (maybe unsurprisingly) became more obvious. While both of them are very good at the technical aspects of their jobs, as you might imagine, they have turned out to be quite difficult. Both of them have had serious issues with being incredibly sensitive about credit apportionment, and both have become increasingly resistant to feedback. Alice has been gently encouraged to find a job in another field, and left a few months ago. I’ve been shocked at how much easier everything is with her gone. I can’t even point to exactly what the problem was, but suddenly my team has become more flexible and collaborative.

Mary is still around, but I mostly avoid directly working with her. I’ve heard her gossiping about “the ex that nearly destroyed her career,” but as far as I’m concerned, that’s not my problem.

Personally, I’ve honestly responded to this by trying to be a little less approachable. That’s probably not the recommended advice, but, as a youngish-looking woman in a very male dominated field, I feel like I get stuck with dealing with drama and interpersonal issues more than I should. I cannot and do not want to be everyones mom/big sister figure. I try to make it clear to my people that I’m here for them, but honestly I’m very okay with other departments’ junior people thinking I’m scary. I am curious if anyone has advice on this: I want to be a force for good in the workplace, but I’m also just TIRED.

Credit to u/choice_evidence1983 for the work in this post.

0

[New Update]: AITAH: For telling my husband to not bring his sick ex to our house and not get personally involved in nursing [Reddit]

preview

[New Update]: AITAH: For telling my husband to not bring his sick ex to our house and not get personally involved in nursing

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/amibengweird

Originally posted to r/AITAH, r/Redditor_Updates, & OOP’s own page

Previous BoRUs: #1

[New Update]: AITAH: For telling my husband to not bring his sick ex to our house and not get personally involved in nursing

NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----

Editor’s note: made small edits for ease of readability

Thanks to u/soayherder & u/queenlegolas for suggesting this BoRU

Trigger Warnings:

spoiler

death, emotional infidelity, late-stage renal disease


RECAP

Original Post: October 18, 2025

So I am 35 (F) and my husband is 39 (M). We have been married for 5 years. Before marrying to me he was with his high-school sweetheart for a decade. Apparently they had compatibility issues and then lost contact. Now his ex has got a kidney failure and is on dialysis and has come in our city for treatment and according my husband she contacted my husband through a mutually friend.

And now my husband wants to help her. Very politely I had asked my husband, does she not have her own people to help and nurse her, why contact him all of a sudden after years. My husband was pissed and said how can I be so petty and I’m mature regarding a patient asking such stupid questions and that he expects better from me.

Then I said if the situation is so dire then let’s get her a place in our flat in other locality and if you are so adamant then let’s finance her nursing facility what is need of getting personally involved like a nurse and that I don’t want to get involved in personally nursing his ex or in her medical recovery process in person nor do I want to go to see her in hospital with him. And my husband said he is just disappointed in me that I am showing jealousy over a long ended relationship and cannot show maturity even with a patient.

So AITAH

Guys some people are accusing me of lying and copying . I will give you the screenshot of nursing home visitation slip . Please tell me how to upload pictures .

Edit: I am really very thankful to mods for responding to my appeal against my post being labelled Fake. Thank you so much for reconsidering things mods

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP was NTA

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Something is fishy about the response, kind of sounds like gaslighting. Not sure I have enough context a judgment, but he is asking a lot of you to bring one of his exes into your home. Could be because it’s in writing that your offer to help in other ways sounded sarcastic but I still feel his response is rather strong for him making a big ask of you. I would possibly ask the same question but understand that you are not obligated to say yes.

Commenter 2: Did he really say that he wanted the ex to move in?

OOP: Yes he did. He said it will be better if she is in closeups. I don’t know I just feel uncomfortable. I am not accusing him of anything, nor do I have anything against that woman, but I feel sick

Commenter 3: Caring is one thing and caretaking quite another. Once he starts to help it is quite possible that her needs will increase; it is also important to consider that her condition may be long lasting. NTA.

Commenter 4: I feel the ex is trying to find a kidney donor.

OOP: Not really she has a donor and if she wished she could have got some other shelter but …I don’t know why she had to come in my life

If the ex has a donor, why isn’t the surgery taking place?

OOP: they had some issues related to blood antibodies, that is what my husband told me

Commenter 5: NTA. This is not jealousy. It sounds like he wants to be the hero and take her in but do none of the actual work. Also, it is inappropriate. This is his ex and they don’t even know each other anymore.

I would die on this hill. If he brings her to your home against your will, you should leave to stay with family or friends. I bet he gets a nurse or gets her out real quick when he has to do the caretaking.

Commenter 6: And the fact he just decided this expecting the OP to just take on this kind of work is crazy of him. Stand your ground OP you’re going to be fine if you do

OOP: Exactly he said this with a poker face that he would want me to murse like what .I don’t know if I recognize my husband anymore .I dated this man for 4 years have been married for five , have two little 3 year olds and he is angry with me not wanting to see his ex in hospital and not wanting to nurse her

OOP responds to multiple downvoted comments about helping a friend out in need

OOP: Old friend they were not in contact for years . And she is not just a friend she is his ex someone who was way more emotionally intimate relation than a friend .

And your taxes assertion just proves my point we INDIRECTALLY FINANCIALLY sponsor for health of strangers , don’t go on getting involved with them in person wanting to stay at side as an emotional support tool .

And just because you and your folks are okay with strangers in home it does not mandate everyone to do it .

Since you are so open to taking care of strangers please take my husband’s ex too in your kind and compassionate vicinity

Commenter 7: Is your husband a nurse?

If she’s dying, and he wants to visit with her what’s the big deal? At the end of one’s life it’s not uncommon to want to reach out to old friends and family for closure …

I don’t really understand the jealous and outrage. This feels like a massive overreaction. Has he been unfaithful before?

OOP: What kind of selfish and entitled demand it is to expect a married man to suddenly get involved in your mess leaving everything behind. Being an emotional support tool, caretaking in person when you are vulnerable all these emotionally intimate things are exclusive to one’s spouse. I would have been outraged even if it was a platonic female friend in picture let alone an ex with whom one had sexual and emotional intimacy with.

Do you want me to play a third wheel in my own marriage

Commenter 8: Is she asking for him to take care of her or is she just checking in that she’s in the area and he can stop by and visit??

If she’s asking you to put her up and give her a place to stay inappropriate

If she’s asking for a visit: you’re over reacting

They were together for a decade… He’ll always be family

OOP: She is asking him to take care of her in person . She expects him to be at her side during medical checkups.

Is it not an outrageous demand . Where does this entitlement comes from .

And the family bullshit. You don’t become a family to someone after a decade old no contact. When you have broken up things are done now the other party does not owe you anything. If you were such an inseparable family, you should not have taken a divorce to begin with. And the most important thing I am not obliged to put up with this "she will always be a family ". I have always preferred no contact and no mingling side

 

Update #1: October 19, 2025 (next day)

I tried to have another conversation with my Husband, and my parents are soon visiting my house. But I don’t think we have made any progress. I talked pretty politely that it is very unfair to me and my boys (I have two 3 year old twins) that he is willing to be an emotional support tool to an ex and is, so hell bent to be at her side. Caring about acquaintances is a different thing, but issuing things like being an emotional support tool, caretaker all this should be exclusive to one’s spouse. And issuing it to any third party even if it is a platonic female friend will be the foundation stone of an emotional affair, let alone issuing it to an ex.

He told me that it is tragic that I don’t trust him even after being together for nine years (we dated for 4 years, have been married for 5) and accusing him of having an affair. It is natural for people to care about their loved ones, acquaintances especially when they are sick and being an emotional support tool, being a caretaker, being at one’s people’s side is the bare minimum one can do and does not automatically translate into an emotional affair and it is sad that I am so narrow minded that I am taking offense in him being personally involved with his ex. Ideally, I too should have volunteered to help his ex, visited her, consoled her shown some empathy instead of being an insecure person.

I said - “I am not negating the fact that we should help a sick person, and we get nurses and doctors involved and assist financially but you offering emotional intimacy to her does not go down my throat.”

He once again said - Tossing just money to a sick person is so cold hearted on my part and a patient needs to see that people are available for her, to which I said I am not obliged to be available for her nor are you, nobody will blame you for not taking responsibility of your ex’s life troubles.

He cut me in between and said what a selfish take and how he will be selfish to not respond properly to a person asking help. Clieve one of my twins woke up and our conversation ended.

Additional Information from OOP in comments

OOP: I would like to share my reflections and lessons .Emotional infidelity is real. Do not let anyone convince you that being someone else’s caretaker or emotional anchor is simply helping. When your partner begins to show up for someone else in ways that belong within your relationship, it becomes emotional cheating. It starts quietly, under the label of compassion, but it erodes trust just as surely as any affair.

Illness does not erase boundaries. I have sympathy for anyone who is unwell, but compassion does not mean allowing someone to disregard the limits of your marriage. Being sick does not make a person’s motives pure, and pain does not grant them moral permission to cross into another person’s life. And just because a person is ill , It does not mean their intentions are pure or they automatically become nice humans

You can be kind and still say no. I offered fair and humane alternatives, such as arranging professional nursing care and contributing financially. He wanted personal involvement, the kind that blurred emotional lines, and that was never acceptable. Refusing such involvement is not cruelty, it is clarity

Boundaries protect dignity. You can show empathy without surrendering your self-respect. It is not selfish to insist on peace within your own home. The people who call it insecurity often fail to understand that boundaries are the foundation of mutual respect.

Affiliation with exes is a danger zone no matter how many years have passed feelings can resurface anytime in fact nostalgia and distance makes things way more of a slippery slope in my case it is one decade . You cannot stop cheaters from cheating, but you can save yourself from being a pawn who is being played .

+

And the most important thing, people please be financially independent and keep your financial affiliations as independent as possible . The only relief I have in this mess is that I earn a good amount of money and have side ventures .Outside academia, I have a few side ventures that help keep me financially stable and mentally occupied. I co-own a small academic editing service with two colleagues from the department, where we review research papers and grant proposals for independent scholars. It started casually during the lockdown and now runs steadily, bringing in a decent secondary income. I also rent out a small studio flat .The rent covers most of the expenses related to my boys .

My salary as a professor covers the essentials, but the side ventures keep me secure. They allow me to make decisions without fear of losing footing. That is the one thing this entire experience has reaffirmed independence is not only emotional, it is structural

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: I don’t see this ending well at all.

OOP: Me too, I can sense myself getting divorced

OOP on drawing boundaries and providing financial help for the ex

OOP: Did you not read my post - I said if the situation is so dire we can get financial help issued from a distance. The only place I am drawing a line is personal involvement. Before marriage I had told him that I prefer men who are in no contact with exes. I don’t want those complications on table, he agreed to it. Yet I am bending backward and am getting involved in things related to his ex. Couldn’t he understand me a little bit too.

Commenter 2: I understand that your finances are blended. Start unmixing them now.

The fact is that this is an ax. They are an ex for a reason. And when you create a new family elsewhere, one thing that should not come between you is an ex.

What he is doing is deflecting. Trying to make you out to be a bad person for not destroying your family and taking care of somebody’s ex.

His assertion that you’re terrible for not volunteering yourself as bullshit. That is him trying to change the subject and turn everything around on you. It’s not appropriate. It is manipulated. It is coercive. And it is what people do who know they’re fucking up.

And you are right. You cannot be that close to an ex helping them through something so very personal and not become entangled on an emotional level.

We are human beings. We have feelings and thoughts and emotions. And normally, we know enough to recognize that our feelings and emotions can lead us astray. The proximity can increase old feelings, even when we know that’s not a good thing.

He doesn’t have to admit it for you to admit it. He’s just trying to get you to admit that he’s right and you’re wrong, but you’re not.

So he is showing you where you stand. He is showing you that he will not even consider what you’re saying, and instead, he will take anything you say, even if it is objectively, reasonable, and try to make you out to be a terrible person. To try to induce guilt in you so that you just back off.

Again, manipulated behavior. If you have a spouse or a partner who loves you, and they’re telling you something, even if you don’t wanna hear it, you should at least consider it.

In your case, you can consider what he said and throw it away immediately because you know it’s trash. In his case, he doesn’t want to hear that he’s tearing his family apart. So again, he tries to make you ought to be a terrible person.

That alone is grounds for leaving the relationship as far as I’m concerned. Because he is showing me who he is. He is showing me that he won’t consider what I’m saying. That he won’t consider my feelings. That he won’t believe my lived experience as far as what our relationship is doing right now and what his actions are doing to me and our family.

So you don’t trust me? You don’t believe me? And you’re going to try to minimize everything? I don’t stick around for that bullshit. I just don’t. I don’t have time or patience for it.

OOP: A handful of our finances are blended, and I am looking forward to disentangle them, but while it happening in background I will give my marriage a last try with the involvement of my parents.

What’s funny is that our house is entirely my property not a joint asset and he has the audacity to think he will relocate his ex in my home which is mine in every sense. I earn more than my husband, I have been a way bigger contributor in every responsibility be it financial or familial, yet he cannot keep one boundary of mine. My gut says either he is having an affair or will have one very soon, though I have never mentioned it in person. Things are not looking good

 

Editor’s note: OOP made the same Update #2 onto another subreddit, I am adding comments from that sub for more context

Update #2: October 26, 2025 (one week later)

It has been one week since I first made that post here and it feels as if centuries have passed in mere 7 days .A lot has happened, and I feel a kind of numb and dumb .So as most of you expected , My husband and I are getting divorced.

His ex, who has kidney failure and is on dialysis, did not reach out only because she needed help. She reached out because she wanted him back. Her illness is real, but her intentions were not. She eventually admitted that to me directly(and she was quite blatant in this regard maybe her illness has made her irritable and scornful but that is how it was) Right now, I feel strangely calm. It is not unexpected, but I am still unable to process that a man can leave a relationship of one decade with 2 kids (We dated for 4 years have been married for 5 and have two twins who are 3 year olds) like this with 0 visible regret. My parents are with me, helping me stay steady for my twin boys who just turned three. They are too young to understand what is happening, but they keep me grounded

After everything came to light, my husband admitted that she was the one who ended their relationship years ago because she thought he lacked drive and stability. He never really got over her. Seeing her again, fragile vulnerable and remorseful, reopened old feelings he had never dealt with. (And in my mind I was like jerk you could have admitted it from day 1 instead of gaslighting me but I guess I was just speechless there).

I actually met her by coincidence three days ago. My husband had been visiting the hospital frequently, and one afternoon he forgot his insurance file which also contained some of our joint investment papers. Since I was disentangling things from him in background while waiting for my parents to come and giving my marriage a last chance, I had gone to collect it from the administrative office at the dialysis unit. The dialysis unit was tucked in a quieter wing separated from the main outpatient block. Outside the Renal chamber waiting area was attached. I was standing there waiting for the administrative officer to bring out the insurance file when she appeared with a nurse

She recognized me right away, and before I could even introduce myself and told the nurse to give us room for a moment, The nurse was hesitant in leaving an immunocompromised person, but she insisted on a couple of minutes of privacy and then, she asked me, “You are his (my husband’s name) wife, right?” (I swear to God, I have not met this woman for once, so I don’t know how she recognized me in a glance). I said yeah she asked me to sit down for a moment. And then she said, I was planning to bring this up gradually to you, but It is better we met here, I guess today or tomorrow you have to know this, there isn’t any use beating around the bush, So I will straight come on the point. I know you probably think I’m intruding, but I never stopped loving him (I was like what the actual fuck, no way it is real and In reality she was married to another man for a while who I guess died in some accident, so it is not like she was some cinematic protagonist spending her life single pinning for my jerk of a husband as she was sounding). I was the one who ended things, and I regret it deeply. I just want to be with him again, even if it’s only for whatever time I have left.”

I swear to almighty sitting above 7 heavens, I am not exaggerating a single word. These were her exact words I left the file counter without saying anything. In the side corridor near the elevator lobby, I would have Brust into violent sobs had nurses and other people not been moving there too. When I got home and told my husband what had happened, he did not deny it. He said he could not help how he felt and that being around her made him realize he still loved her. At this point, I did not think I had anything else to say.

I am now a single mother of twin boys, and honestly, I am fine. I earn much more than my husband and the house we live in is entirely my property. The apartment is in the southern academic district, not far from the old university campus where I teach. It is a three-bedroom flat on the fourth floor of a quiet residential block I bought it seven years ago when I was promoted to associate professor, using my savings and part of a research grant I had received for curriculum development. When this all came to light, I asked him to leave, and he did. It was not a dramatic fight. I told him calmly that if his heart was with her, that is where he should go. there is no legal obstacle in it . He had contributed little to the mortgage or maintenance, and the property was always mine. He did try to bring up we are intertwined on other financial fronts. And honestly even if it is partial entanglement What complicates things now are the shared investments and educational funds we set up for our twin boys. We have a joint mutual fund account, a children’s savings bond, and a small commercial investment in a co-working space near the railway junction.

The co-working space investment is another area of dispute. Although the capital came from me, the business registration lists both our names for tax convenience, which was his idea only . Now he is attempting to claim half the profits from the current lease cycle .My lawyer has filed for a forensic accounting review to prove the monetary trail originates from my personal savings.

This is looking exhausting in theory only and there are few more entanglements that will be too much to type and not to forget the legal proceedings of divorce which we have not started yet and not to forget custody stuff.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: I’m not sure what the laws are where you reside, but does he have claim to half of your earnings since you make more than him?

He’s in for a rude awakening when he realizes the fairytale love story is nothing but that, a fairytale. The fog he’s under will eventually lift and his pathetic self will come crawling back to the safety net you’ve built for him. He’s still a loser and his ex most likely will figure that out soon enough if she doesn’t pass away before that happens.

OOP: No alimony laws don’t work like that here in my country. He would not have any claim on my hard earned money .

It is just the investments we have done together or the financial fronts where we are entangled is a mess that will take time to be sorted properly .

I will be putting an update when I am done handling these things

Commenter 2: Wow. The dying ex is a trash human, but your STX is one as well. I guarantee after she dies and he grieves, he will try to crawl back. Fuck that. Out of curiosity, do you guys have mutual friends who are taking his side in all this?

OOP: Not yet people outside home are unaware of our divorce yet , we have not started our official splitting process .

And we have very less mutual ‘friends’. At best acquaintances . I am a pretty private and introvert kind of person, and my entire circle is from my university , teacher researchers students and his circle is different .

Commenter 3: This post seems so silly. Why would he go thru a divorce & sever himself financially from a woman who makes more money than him & owns the home they live in just to nurse a sick woman who will die soon? Seems to me like he’d just lie & sneak around behind his wife’s back to spend time w/the ex until she’s gone then pretend it never happened. He’s such a fool. Seriously. His friends & family should berate him for being a total idiot.

OOP: BECAUSE HE CAN CLAIM ON MANY OF OUR JOINT INVESTMENTS AS HE IS DOING NOW, EVEN THOUGH THE CAPITAL CAME FROM ME. And multiple people cheat, cheat after being married, after having kids, why do they do that? Please go and ask them the question? If you get the answer please tell it to me.

Because I too am trying to figure out WHY? Why on earth will a man cheat and cheat like that with 0 visible regrets after being together for one decade . Why would he not think of my kids even ? I did everything one can do as a spouse and a partner , always bore the bigger part of familial and financial responsibilities the why?

 

I filed for divorce today, and I feel strangely calm but hollow.: October 31, 2025 (five days later)

I filed for divorce today. Dated for 4 years, Five years of marriage, twin boys who are three, and a husband who decided to go back to his ex. She came back into his life because of a medical issue, and he turned into her caretaker. I drew boundaries, he called me insecure. Now it’s over.

I’m a professor, and I earn well. My house is in my name, so at least that’s clear. But the rest is tangled. There’s a small joint property near Railway Station and some mutual funds for the kids’ education that both our names are on. It’s exhausting sorting through all of it.

I’m not falling apart. I’m functioning, working, raising my boys, But it’s lonely. I’ve never been the kind of person who keeps a big circle of friends, and right now, that silence feels heavier than usual. My parents are here but they are with kids right now and how much can I burden them with my emotional turmoil ,just wanted to vent it somewhere

 


#----NEW UPDATE----

Update: His EX died!: July 11, 2026 (8.5 months later from the last update)

It has been around eight months since my last update, and I honestly never expected to post here again. A few days ago, I learned through mutual friends that his ex passed away.

I have not spoken to him like long conversation or something like that since I filed the divorce , so I don’t know how he is doing, and I don’t intend to find out either . We had legal conflicts over shared financials, but it was more or less handled through solicitors, so our personal interaction is almost nil .Earlier he used to check on kids, but we did not use to talk . He has stopped checking on kids for quite a while .Life has settled into a new routine. My focus is on raising my sons and moving forward. They are growing up quickly, and they deserve stability more than anything else. I had suicidal thoughts self-esteem issues in the beginning, but I guess I am doing mentally better now .

I just thought I should update you guys . Thank you to everyone who offered advice and kindness when I needed it.

Editor’s note: OOP did not leave any comments here in this latest update

Top Comments

Commenter 1: Please don’t take him back when he comes crawling back to you. He should rot for what he did.

Commenter 2: He’s not even checking on his kids?? Yikes. He had more sympathy for his ex than he does for his own living children.

I hope you and the kids are doing well and don’t miss him ♥️.

Commenter 3: Glad life has settled with a new routine, and you are getting on a path for yourself and your children now growing up, it’s in his choice of not checking on the kids which will bite him in the ass. That is not your responsibility nor your concern ever, it will be on him.

I do hope you are kind to yourself during this time, and I do hope you alongside your children can move from this chapter of your life once it is all settled, you are doing the best you can, and you are taking the steps of that. I’m glad you are doing better mentally at this time, I do wish you and your children the best.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

[New Update]: AITAH: For telling my husband to not bring his sick ex to our house and not get personally involved in nursing

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/amibengweird

Originally posted to r/AITAH, r/Redditor_Updates, & OOP’s own page

Previous BoRUs: #1

[New Update]: AITAH: For telling my husband to not bring his sick ex to our house and not get personally involved in nursing

NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----

Editor’s note: made small edits for ease of readability

Thanks to u/soayherder & u/queenlegolas for suggesting this BoRU

Trigger Warnings:

spoiler

death, emotional infidelity, late-stage renal disease


RECAP

Original Post: October 18, 2025

So I am 35 (F) and my husband is 39 (M). We have been married for 5 years. Before marrying to me he was with his high-school sweetheart for a decade. Apparently they had compatibility issues and then lost contact. Now his ex has got a kidney failure and is on dialysis and has come in our city for treatment and according my husband she contacted my husband through a mutually friend.

And now my husband wants to help her. Very politely I had asked my husband, does she not have her own people to help and nurse her, why contact him all of a sudden after years. My husband was pissed and said how can I be so petty and I’m mature regarding a patient asking such stupid questions and that he expects better from me.

Then I said if the situation is so dire then let’s get her a place in our flat in other locality and if you are so adamant then let’s finance her nursing facility what is need of getting personally involved like a nurse and that I don’t want to get involved in personally nursing his ex or in her medical recovery process in person nor do I want to go to see her in hospital with him. And my husband said he is just disappointed in me that I am showing jealousy over a long ended relationship and cannot show maturity even with a patient.

So AITAH

Guys some people are accusing me of lying and copying . I will give you the screenshot of nursing home visitation slip . Please tell me how to upload pictures .

Edit: I am really very thankful to mods for responding to my appeal against my post being labelled Fake. Thank you so much for reconsidering things mods

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP was NTA

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Something is fishy about the response, kind of sounds like gaslighting. Not sure I have enough context a judgment, but he is asking a lot of you to bring one of his exes into your home. Could be because it’s in writing that your offer to help in other ways sounded sarcastic but I still feel his response is rather strong for him making a big ask of you. I would possibly ask the same question but understand that you are not obligated to say yes.

Commenter 2: Did he really say that he wanted the ex to move in?

OOP: Yes he did. He said it will be better if she is in closeups. I don’t know I just feel uncomfortable. I am not accusing him of anything, nor do I have anything against that woman, but I feel sick

Commenter 3: Caring is one thing and caretaking quite another. Once he starts to help it is quite possible that her needs will increase; it is also important to consider that her condition may be long lasting. NTA.

Commenter 4: I feel the ex is trying to find a kidney donor.

OOP: Not really she has a donor and if she wished she could have got some other shelter but …I don’t know why she had to come in my life

If the ex has a donor, why isn’t the surgery taking place?

OOP: they had some issues related to blood antibodies, that is what my husband told me

Commenter 5: NTA. This is not jealousy. It sounds like he wants to be the hero and take her in but do none of the actual work. Also, it is inappropriate. This is his ex and they don’t even know each other anymore.

I would die on this hill. If he brings her to your home against your will, you should leave to stay with family or friends. I bet he gets a nurse or gets her out real quick when he has to do the caretaking.

Commenter 6: And the fact he just decided this expecting the OP to just take on this kind of work is crazy of him. Stand your ground OP you’re going to be fine if you do

OOP: Exactly he said this with a poker face that he would want me to murse like what .I don’t know if I recognize my husband anymore .I dated this man for 4 years have been married for five , have two little 3 year olds and he is angry with me not wanting to see his ex in hospital and not wanting to nurse her

OOP responds to multiple downvoted comments about helping a friend out in need

OOP: Old friend they were not in contact for years . And she is not just a friend she is his ex someone who was way more emotionally intimate relation than a friend .

And your taxes assertion just proves my point we INDIRECTALLY FINANCIALLY sponsor for health of strangers , don’t go on getting involved with them in person wanting to stay at side as an emotional support tool .

And just because you and your folks are okay with strangers in home it does not mandate everyone to do it .

Since you are so open to taking care of strangers please take my husband’s ex too in your kind and compassionate vicinity

Commenter 7: Is your husband a nurse?

If she’s dying, and he wants to visit with her what’s the big deal? At the end of one’s life it’s not uncommon to want to reach out to old friends and family for closure …

I don’t really understand the jealous and outrage. This feels like a massive overreaction. Has he been unfaithful before?

OOP: What kind of selfish and entitled demand it is to expect a married man to suddenly get involved in your mess leaving everything behind. Being an emotional support tool, caretaking in person when you are vulnerable all these emotionally intimate things are exclusive to one’s spouse. I would have been outraged even if it was a platonic female friend in picture let alone an ex with whom one had sexual and emotional intimacy with.

Do you want me to play a third wheel in my own marriage

Commenter 8: Is she asking for him to take care of her or is she just checking in that she’s in the area and he can stop by and visit??

If she’s asking you to put her up and give her a place to stay inappropriate

If she’s asking for a visit: you’re over reacting

They were together for a decade… He’ll always be family

OOP: She is asking him to take care of her in person . She expects him to be at her side during medical checkups.

Is it not an outrageous demand . Where does this entitlement comes from .

And the family bullshit. You don’t become a family to someone after a decade old no contact. When you have broken up things are done now the other party does not owe you anything. If you were such an inseparable family, you should not have taken a divorce to begin with. And the most important thing I am not obliged to put up with this "she will always be a family ". I have always preferred no contact and no mingling side

 

Update #1: October 19, 2025 (next day)

I tried to have another conversation with my Husband, and my parents are soon visiting my house. But I don’t think we have made any progress. I talked pretty politely that it is very unfair to me and my boys (I have two 3 year old twins) that he is willing to be an emotional support tool to an ex and is, so hell bent to be at her side. Caring about acquaintances is a different thing, but issuing things like being an emotional support tool, caretaker all this should be exclusive to one’s spouse. And issuing it to any third party even if it is a platonic female friend will be the foundation stone of an emotional affair, let alone issuing it to an ex.

He told me that it is tragic that I don’t trust him even after being together for nine years (we dated for 4 years, have been married for 5) and accusing him of having an affair. It is natural for people to care about their loved ones, acquaintances especially when they are sick and being an emotional support tool, being a caretaker, being at one’s people’s side is the bare minimum one can do and does not automatically translate into an emotional affair and it is sad that I am so narrow minded that I am taking offense in him being personally involved with his ex. Ideally, I too should have volunteered to help his ex, visited her, consoled her shown some empathy instead of being an insecure person.

I said - “I am not negating the fact that we should help a sick person, and we get nurses and doctors involved and assist financially but you offering emotional intimacy to her does not go down my throat.”

He once again said - Tossing just money to a sick person is so cold hearted on my part and a patient needs to see that people are available for her, to which I said I am not obliged to be available for her nor are you, nobody will blame you for not taking responsibility of your ex’s life troubles.

He cut me in between and said what a selfish take and how he will be selfish to not respond properly to a person asking help. Clieve one of my twins woke up and our conversation ended.

Additional Information from OOP in comments

OOP: I would like to share my reflections and lessons .Emotional infidelity is real. Do not let anyone convince you that being someone else’s caretaker or emotional anchor is simply helping. When your partner begins to show up for someone else in ways that belong within your relationship, it becomes emotional cheating. It starts quietly, under the label of compassion, but it erodes trust just as surely as any affair.

Illness does not erase boundaries. I have sympathy for anyone who is unwell, but compassion does not mean allowing someone to disregard the limits of your marriage. Being sick does not make a person’s motives pure, and pain does not grant them moral permission to cross into another person’s life. And just because a person is ill , It does not mean their intentions are pure or they automatically become nice humans

You can be kind and still say no. I offered fair and humane alternatives, such as arranging professional nursing care and contributing financially. He wanted personal involvement, the kind that blurred emotional lines, and that was never acceptable. Refusing such involvement is not cruelty, it is clarity

Boundaries protect dignity. You can show empathy without surrendering your self-respect. It is not selfish to insist on peace within your own home. The people who call it insecurity often fail to understand that boundaries are the foundation of mutual respect.

Affiliation with exes is a danger zone no matter how many years have passed feelings can resurface anytime in fact nostalgia and distance makes things way more of a slippery slope in my case it is one decade . You cannot stop cheaters from cheating, but you can save yourself from being a pawn who is being played .

+

And the most important thing, people please be financially independent and keep your financial affiliations as independent as possible . The only relief I have in this mess is that I earn a good amount of money and have side ventures .Outside academia, I have a few side ventures that help keep me financially stable and mentally occupied. I co-own a small academic editing service with two colleagues from the department, where we review research papers and grant proposals for independent scholars. It started casually during the lockdown and now runs steadily, bringing in a decent secondary income. I also rent out a small studio flat .The rent covers most of the expenses related to my boys .

My salary as a professor covers the essentials, but the side ventures keep me secure. They allow me to make decisions without fear of losing footing. That is the one thing this entire experience has reaffirmed independence is not only emotional, it is structural

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: I don’t see this ending well at all.

OOP: Me too, I can sense myself getting divorced

OOP on drawing boundaries and providing financial help for the ex

OOP: Did you not read my post - I said if the situation is so dire we can get financial help issued from a distance. The only place I am drawing a line is personal involvement. Before marriage I had told him that I prefer men who are in no contact with exes. I don’t want those complications on table, he agreed to it. Yet I am bending backward and am getting involved in things related to his ex. Couldn’t he understand me a little bit too.

Commenter 2: I understand that your finances are blended. Start unmixing them now.

The fact is that this is an ax. They are an ex for a reason. And when you create a new family elsewhere, one thing that should not come between you is an ex.

What he is doing is deflecting. Trying to make you out to be a bad person for not destroying your family and taking care of somebody’s ex.

His assertion that you’re terrible for not volunteering yourself as bullshit. That is him trying to change the subject and turn everything around on you. It’s not appropriate. It is manipulated. It is coercive. And it is what people do who know they’re fucking up.

And you are right. You cannot be that close to an ex helping them through something so very personal and not become entangled on an emotional level.

We are human beings. We have feelings and thoughts and emotions. And normally, we know enough to recognize that our feelings and emotions can lead us astray. The proximity can increase old feelings, even when we know that’s not a good thing.

He doesn’t have to admit it for you to admit it. He’s just trying to get you to admit that he’s right and you’re wrong, but you’re not.

So he is showing you where you stand. He is showing you that he will not even consider what you’re saying, and instead, he will take anything you say, even if it is objectively, reasonable, and try to make you out to be a terrible person. To try to induce guilt in you so that you just back off.

Again, manipulated behavior. If you have a spouse or a partner who loves you, and they’re telling you something, even if you don’t wanna hear it, you should at least consider it.

In your case, you can consider what he said and throw it away immediately because you know it’s trash. In his case, he doesn’t want to hear that he’s tearing his family apart. So again, he tries to make you ought to be a terrible person.

That alone is grounds for leaving the relationship as far as I’m concerned. Because he is showing me who he is. He is showing me that he won’t consider what I’m saying. That he won’t consider my feelings. That he won’t believe my lived experience as far as what our relationship is doing right now and what his actions are doing to me and our family.

So you don’t trust me? You don’t believe me? And you’re going to try to minimize everything? I don’t stick around for that bullshit. I just don’t. I don’t have time or patience for it.

OOP: A handful of our finances are blended, and I am looking forward to disentangle them, but while it happening in background I will give my marriage a last try with the involvement of my parents.

What’s funny is that our house is entirely my property not a joint asset and he has the audacity to think he will relocate his ex in my home which is mine in every sense. I earn more than my husband, I have been a way bigger contributor in every responsibility be it financial or familial, yet he cannot keep one boundary of mine. My gut says either he is having an affair or will have one very soon, though I have never mentioned it in person. Things are not looking good

 

Editor’s note: OOP made the same Update #2 onto another subreddit, I am adding comments from that sub for more context

Update #2: October 26, 2025 (one week later)

It has been one week since I first made that post here and it feels as if centuries have passed in mere 7 days .A lot has happened, and I feel a kind of numb and dumb .So as most of you expected , My husband and I are getting divorced.

His ex, who has kidney failure and is on dialysis, did not reach out only because she needed help. She reached out because she wanted him back. Her illness is real, but her intentions were not. She eventually admitted that to me directly(and she was quite blatant in this regard maybe her illness has made her irritable and scornful but that is how it was) Right now, I feel strangely calm. It is not unexpected, but I am still unable to process that a man can leave a relationship of one decade with 2 kids (We dated for 4 years have been married for 5 and have two twins who are 3 year olds) like this with 0 visible regret. My parents are with me, helping me stay steady for my twin boys who just turned three. They are too young to understand what is happening, but they keep me grounded

After everything came to light, my husband admitted that she was the one who ended their relationship years ago because she thought he lacked drive and stability. He never really got over her. Seeing her again, fragile vulnerable and remorseful, reopened old feelings he had never dealt with. (And in my mind I was like jerk you could have admitted it from day 1 instead of gaslighting me but I guess I was just speechless there).

I actually met her by coincidence three days ago. My husband had been visiting the hospital frequently, and one afternoon he forgot his insurance file which also contained some of our joint investment papers. Since I was disentangling things from him in background while waiting for my parents to come and giving my marriage a last chance, I had gone to collect it from the administrative office at the dialysis unit. The dialysis unit was tucked in a quieter wing separated from the main outpatient block. Outside the Renal chamber waiting area was attached. I was standing there waiting for the administrative officer to bring out the insurance file when she appeared with a nurse

She recognized me right away, and before I could even introduce myself and told the nurse to give us room for a moment, The nurse was hesitant in leaving an immunocompromised person, but she insisted on a couple of minutes of privacy and then, she asked me, “You are his (my husband’s name) wife, right?” (I swear to God, I have not met this woman for once, so I don’t know how she recognized me in a glance). I said yeah she asked me to sit down for a moment. And then she said, I was planning to bring this up gradually to you, but It is better we met here, I guess today or tomorrow you have to know this, there isn’t any use beating around the bush, So I will straight come on the point. I know you probably think I’m intruding, but I never stopped loving him (I was like what the actual fuck, no way it is real and In reality she was married to another man for a while who I guess died in some accident, so it is not like she was some cinematic protagonist spending her life single pinning for my jerk of a husband as she was sounding). I was the one who ended things, and I regret it deeply. I just want to be with him again, even if it’s only for whatever time I have left.”

I swear to almighty sitting above 7 heavens, I am not exaggerating a single word. These were her exact words I left the file counter without saying anything. In the side corridor near the elevator lobby, I would have Brust into violent sobs had nurses and other people not been moving there too. When I got home and told my husband what had happened, he did not deny it. He said he could not help how he felt and that being around her made him realize he still loved her. At this point, I did not think I had anything else to say.

I am now a single mother of twin boys, and honestly, I am fine. I earn much more than my husband and the house we live in is entirely my property. The apartment is in the southern academic district, not far from the old university campus where I teach. It is a three-bedroom flat on the fourth floor of a quiet residential block I bought it seven years ago when I was promoted to associate professor, using my savings and part of a research grant I had received for curriculum development. When this all came to light, I asked him to leave, and he did. It was not a dramatic fight. I told him calmly that if his heart was with her, that is where he should go. there is no legal obstacle in it . He had contributed little to the mortgage or maintenance, and the property was always mine. He did try to bring up we are intertwined on other financial fronts. And honestly even if it is partial entanglement What complicates things now are the shared investments and educational funds we set up for our twin boys. We have a joint mutual fund account, a children’s savings bond, and a small commercial investment in a co-working space near the railway junction.

The co-working space investment is another area of dispute. Although the capital came from me, the business registration lists both our names for tax convenience, which was his idea only . Now he is attempting to claim half the profits from the current lease cycle .My lawyer has filed for a forensic accounting review to prove the monetary trail originates from my personal savings.

This is looking exhausting in theory only and there are few more entanglements that will be too much to type and not to forget the legal proceedings of divorce which we have not started yet and not to forget custody stuff.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: I’m not sure what the laws are where you reside, but does he have claim to half of your earnings since you make more than him?

He’s in for a rude awakening when he realizes the fairytale love story is nothing but that, a fairytale. The fog he’s under will eventually lift and his pathetic self will come crawling back to the safety net you’ve built for him. He’s still a loser and his ex most likely will figure that out soon enough if she doesn’t pass away before that happens.

OOP: No alimony laws don’t work like that here in my country. He would not have any claim on my hard earned money .

It is just the investments we have done together or the financial fronts where we are entangled is a mess that will take time to be sorted properly .

I will be putting an update when I am done handling these things

Commenter 2: Wow. The dying ex is a trash human, but your STX is one as well. I guarantee after she dies and he grieves, he will try to crawl back. Fuck that. Out of curiosity, do you guys have mutual friends who are taking his side in all this?

OOP: Not yet people outside home are unaware of our divorce yet , we have not started our official splitting process .

And we have very less mutual ‘friends’. At best acquaintances . I am a pretty private and introvert kind of person, and my entire circle is from my university , teacher researchers students and his circle is different .

Commenter 3: This post seems so silly. Why would he go thru a divorce & sever himself financially from a woman who makes more money than him & owns the home they live in just to nurse a sick woman who will die soon? Seems to me like he’d just lie & sneak around behind his wife’s back to spend time w/the ex until she’s gone then pretend it never happened. He’s such a fool. Seriously. His friends & family should berate him for being a total idiot.

OOP: BECAUSE HE CAN CLAIM ON MANY OF OUR JOINT INVESTMENTS AS HE IS DOING NOW, EVEN THOUGH THE CAPITAL CAME FROM ME. And multiple people cheat, cheat after being married, after having kids, why do they do that? Please go and ask them the question? If you get the answer please tell it to me.

Because I too am trying to figure out WHY? Why on earth will a man cheat and cheat like that with 0 visible regrets after being together for one decade . Why would he not think of my kids even ? I did everything one can do as a spouse and a partner , always bore the bigger part of familial and financial responsibilities the why?

 

I filed for divorce today, and I feel strangely calm but hollow.: October 31, 2025 (five days later)

I filed for divorce today. Dated for 4 years, Five years of marriage, twin boys who are three, and a husband who decided to go back to his ex. She came back into his life because of a medical issue, and he turned into her caretaker. I drew boundaries, he called me insecure. Now it’s over.

I’m a professor, and I earn well. My house is in my name, so at least that’s clear. But the rest is tangled. There’s a small joint property near Railway Station and some mutual funds for the kids’ education that both our names are on. It’s exhausting sorting through all of it.

I’m not falling apart. I’m functioning, working, raising my boys, But it’s lonely. I’ve never been the kind of person who keeps a big circle of friends, and right now, that silence feels heavier than usual. My parents are here but they are with kids right now and how much can I burden them with my emotional turmoil ,just wanted to vent it somewhere

 


#----NEW UPDATE----

Update: His EX died!: July 11, 2026 (8.5 months later from the last update)

It has been around eight months since my last update, and I honestly never expected to post here again. A few days ago, I learned through mutual friends that his ex passed away.

I have not spoken to him like long conversation or something like that since I filed the divorce , so I don’t know how he is doing, and I don’t intend to find out either . We had legal conflicts over shared financials, but it was more or less handled through solicitors, so our personal interaction is almost nil .Earlier he used to check on kids, but we did not use to talk . He has stopped checking on kids for quite a while .Life has settled into a new routine. My focus is on raising my sons and moving forward. They are growing up quickly, and they deserve stability more than anything else. I had suicidal thoughts self-esteem issues in the beginning, but I guess I am doing mentally better now .

I just thought I should update you guys . Thank you to everyone who offered advice and kindness when I needed it.

Editor’s note: OOP did not leave any comments here in this latest update

Top Comments

Commenter 1: Please don’t take him back when he comes crawling back to you. He should rot for what he did.

Commenter 2: He’s not even checking on his kids?? Yikes. He had more sympathy for his ex than he does for his own living children.

I hope you and the kids are doing well and don’t miss him ♥️.

Commenter 3: Glad life has settled with a new routine, and you are getting on a path for yourself and your children now growing up, it’s in his choice of not checking on the kids which will bite him in the ass. That is not your responsibility nor your concern ever, it will be on him.

I do hope you are kind to yourself during this time, and I do hope you alongside your children can move from this chapter of your life once it is all settled, you are doing the best you can, and you are taking the steps of that. I’m glad you are doing better mentally at this time, I do wish you and your children the best.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

0

[Concluded] My (M) partner (F) cheated on me with someone (M) we were planning a threesome (MFM) with - Figuring out how to move forward and heal [Reddit]

preview

My (M) partner (F) cheated on me with someone (M) we were planning a threesome (MFM) with - Figuring out how to move forward and heal

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/SheCheatedOnMe_TA

My (M) partner (F) cheated on me with someone (M) we were planning a threesome (MFM) with - Figuring out how to move forward and heal

Originally posted to r/Swingers

TRIGGER WARNING:

spoiler

Infidelity, mental health struggles

Original Post  March 10, 2023

Hi, TLDR at the end.

Edit: Also posting this here because I don’t think people could relate in other relationship subreddits… Also, we’ve been together for nearly 6 years now and have been in the lifestyle for 2.

To preface this, it is important to know mine and my partner’s understanding of our lifestyle. We engage in threesomes, mostly MFMs together. We’ve specifically said this is an activity we do together and anything apart from that would be cheating and that we would never be with someone who cheats on their partner.

What happened…

My partner and I were at a bar a few weeks ago with some live music. It was a good show with friends and we all had a good time. After the show ended, I went to the bathroom and when I returned, I was happily surprised to hear the lead singer asked if my partner was single and if he could buy her a drink. She told him she was taken, and that was the end of that. I couldn’t imagine much happened since it was just a small bar venue and I was back after just a few minutes.

The next day, she tells me she found his instagram page (not hard due to his band) and I asked her if this is someone she would consider having an MFM in the future with. She said she was interested and reached out to him to see if this would be something he would be interested in. After messaging each other back and forth, we were happy to find out he participates in the swinging community as well and would be very excited to join. We made plans to link up after his next show the following week. At this point, I began asking her to make a group chat so we can all be on the same page, but she never does. This is not normal since we’ve always made group chats in the past.

Unfortunately, I came down with a nasty cold and was unable to go out the following weekend, so I told her to have a girl’s night out and still enjoy the show and get to know the guy a bit better. As the night goes on, they go from one bar to the next. I text her at 2:00 AM letting her know I’m about to fall asleep but to text me if she needs anything. She responds they’re grabbing food and should be coming home soon.

Next thing I know, she’s coming home at 6:00AM, is excited to see me, has a big smile on her face, and tells me what a great time she had. She was supposed to be getting a ride from her friend (F) which is what I believe happened at this point. I was happy to see how happy she was. She told me a bit about the night, got ready for bed, and that was the end of that. This was the night she cheated on me with him.

Over the course of the next week, she begins talking to me about how she’s been starting to want to have casual one night stands and how she never got to experience a “hoe” phase as we like to call it. It really starts to bother me at this point that she has not made a group chat with us yet after repeatedly asking her. She keeps saying she will but never does. Further, we planned to meet up during this week on Saturday and it would start off with her going with him to the botanical gardens in our area, followed by them coming to our house.

At this point, she’s asked if she could essentially have a solo session with him before I join them in our bedroom. I’m feeling very uncomfortable at this point with everything going on, how there is no group chat still, and that they’re going out on a date without me. Especially with the amount of texting they had been doing back and forth (without me). For whatever reason though, I agree it’ll be okay. Come that Saturday though, he bails on her last minute and the night never happens.

That was a breath of relief for me. I told her that he missed his one chance at a solo session with her. I thought that was basically the end of it and that he had cold feet.

Over the next week, I start getting very paranoid about that night she came home so late. I ask her more details about it and that’s when I find out he brought her home and not her friend. Her friend had gone over to his house with her and said it was getting late and that they should leave, but my partner didn’t want to. This was her final opportunity to make the right decision… but she didn’t… Her friend knows what happened but did not tell me which I am also very upset about.

At this point I basically knew she slept with him. I began asking if they fooled around at all and she began lying to me. Then she started saying they just kissed but she told him to stop. I know we’re human, and I know if I was in that situation, I think it would have gone on a lot further. I told her I can’t imagine how they couldn’t have fooled around, but I’ll choose to believe it for now.

The next day, I was feeling sick to my stomach. I confronted her one last time and asked her what it was like having sex with him… At this point she burst into tears. She admitted to everything. The lying, and sneaking, the sex. Everything.

I was furious. I couldn’t even look at her. I went to my office to be alone and process what she had just told me. I was absolutely disgusted. How could she do this to me? I never thought she’d be capable of something like this. We had LITERALLY just had the conversation about cheating or swinging without each other would result in a break of trust and the relationship and she went ahead and did it.

AND THE FACT SHE WANTED TO SLEEP ALONE WITH HIM IN MY HOUSE?! MY BED?!

I wouldn’t look her in the eyes for the next few hours. She couldn’t stop crying and saying how stupid she was and how much she regretted her decision.

I’ve made my fair share of mistakes in the past. I’ve even told her that I think the relationship should end (big mistake) roughly a year ago due to shifting opinions on whether or not we want kids one day. But we were able to talk it over and figure it out.

I’ve also made another mistake when we first got into the lifestyle roughly 2 years ago. One that I feel very guilty about, but not nearly as much anymore after what happened. The same way she told this guy that she shouldn’t sleep with him, but did anyway (and wanted to do it again very clearly), something similar happened with us. I was particularly horny one day after a night out with her and one of our other male partners in the lifestyle. At the end of the night, we did the same thing that guy did and talked her into having a threesome that night. She ended up saying yes, and we had a great time, but she was very upset with me and our other partner for being pushy about it. Apparently it’s okay when a complete stranger does it though.

The night she confessed is also the same night I (mostly) cooled off. I do still love her. I’m even turned on by the idea of her with him and I’ve communicated that with her. It’s the break in trust, feelings of exclusion & not being wanted, and the consistent lying that hurts the most. In her words, she thought she could replicate the night she spent with him, but then I would be included and it would make everything okay. Clearly that didn’t happen.

It’s been a few weeks since then. I feel much better about everything, but I still don’t trust her like I used to. I’m going out of town for a week on business and am scared of what will happen while I’m gone. She’s still a student and has several exams next week, but idk.

We’ve spoken about how in this lifestyle, we are left more susceptible to mistakes and accidents in the sexual space. How tunnel vision can kick in and sex is the only thing on the mind. Similar to other hobbies that can result in injury, except this is in the realm of emotional hurt. Part of the healing has actually been her reciting in great detail exactly how the night played out, down to the exact way he touched her and she touched him while making love together. It has become a very hot scene in the bedroom and I do see myself being okay with broadening our lifestyle. It’s a shame it had to occur like this though.

TLDR; Partner hooks up with a guy we just met that we were planning a threesome with behind my back while I was at home sick and continued to lie and leave me out of all conversations with this person when it is not the lifestyle we agreed upon. She even wanted to schedule the actual threesome with him, but go out on a date with him and let him have the first round with her before I joined.

I can forgive her for sleeping with him, but I am having so much trouble accepting the lying and secrets and continuous disregard to include me in the conversations that were being held. I also have trouble with the amount of conscious decisions that were made to leave me out of the loop for so long up to the point of no return. I am still going back and forth in my mind of what to do. For now I have chosen to stay with her and rebuild the relationship, but at times I have feelings of paranoia of it happening again behind my back.

Thoughts? I know this lifestyle is built on trust and consent, but I feel like both my trust and consent were broken.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

classic4imaduckie

I’d be so done with this relationship. Sorry dude. Trust is everything. Lifestyle or vanilla.

OOP

I feel like I’d be throwing away the past 5 years over one (maybe several) huge mistakes on her end that took place over the course of about three weeks.

But to your point… my trust was broken… I’ve never had any thought in my mind that she would be capable of something like this…

She is the first person I’ve ever committed to in my life which makes this even harder.

Update Oct 3, 2023 (7 Months Later)

Hi everyone. It’s been a little over half a year since this post. Not making a TLDR for this one.

I really was hoping I could salvage it.

I’ve been doing what I can to move on but I haven’t been able to. I don’t think she has been putting in the necessary effort on her end either. Between her depression and what she did, I feel like I’ve been carrying this relationship for the two of us. I don’t think she is capable of being in a relationship let alone putting in the work that needs to be done to repair this one.

At least I can tell myself I tried… as hard as anyone could ask really.

Our six year anniversary was this past summer. I can’t even remember what we did.

I’m currently on a business trip and have not gotten an ounce of sleep tonight. It’s 6:15 AM at the moment and all I’ve been thinking about is how this isn’t working.

I guess it gave me the physical distance I needed to come to this conclusion.

I’ve thought about ending things now and then, but wasn’t ready or didn’t believe it. I thought there was still something I could do. But I’ve been trying to swim upstream for too long now without any help. I can’t keep carrying all this weight.

I do want to make note of something though. I think this relationship was already on its way out. This event just brought about its downfall sooner, which in a way… I’m thankful for.

It wasn’t the lifestyle that caused this to happen. Her and I started dating in our young 20s and have been growing a lot together over time. For a while, I thought we were incredibly compatible, but honestly it was in all the wrong ways. We make good roommates, not partners. She isn’t the person I met back when I was still in college, and neither am I. With that said, I think we’ve grown apart and it brought out a lot of ugliness along the way.

A thought I struggled with for a long time is thinking this other guy completely flipped my world upside down. As if he somehow caused this to happen. In reality, I should thank him. He helped me realize that this relationship was not meant to last a lot sooner than I would have on my own. I was blind to the signs and needed a wake up call.

Another thought I struggled with is how much love, time, and attention I’ve invested in this relationship. It was my first true relationship I’ve ever had. I always wanted it to be the one. Someone called me out in the last post on sunk cost fallacy… damn were you right.

With all that being said, I’m worried of what she’ll do when I break things off. I don’t hate her. I still care for her. With her depression and self harm tendencies, I think this could push her over the edge. We live together in my house, her whole world will be tossed upside down. She is still in school, no job, I’m not sure what she’ll do or where she’ll go… Maybe to her parents? Although they haven’t always been the most supportive…

I’ve felt like the bad guy for so long these past few months. As if everything wrong with this relationship was somehow the result of me as a person. If she goes as far to… I don’t know what I’d do with myself.

I really appreciate the support you all gave in my last post.

Although I didn’t want to believe what most of you said, I really do believe you were right in the end.

I hope I’m strong enough to go through with this.

I hope she finds happiness someday.

I hope I’m okay with it if she finds it sooner than I do.

OOP Did post 2 small updates in comments in relies on:

Feb 16, 2024

OOP

How are you doing now? It’s been a few months since we’ve separated, but we have been talking about starting over again.

May 28, 2024

We’ve been split since October of last year and haven’t gotten back together. We talk here and there, get dinner together now and again, but we’ve both still got a lot of work to do if we are going to come back to each other.

I wish it worked out for you. That’s one of the areas I’m hesitant with rekindling my relationship to be honest. It happening again.

But my bigger fear is not having the chance to try once we are at a point where we are both ready

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER

My (M) partner (F) cheated on me with someone (M) we were planning a threesome (MFM) with - Figuring out how to move forward and heal

I am not The OOP, OOP is u/SheCheatedOnMe_TA

My (M) partner (F) cheated on me with someone (M) we were planning a threesome (MFM) with - Figuring out how to move forward and heal

Originally posted to r/Swingers

TRIGGER WARNING:

spoiler

Infidelity, mental health struggles

Original Post  March 10, 2023

Hi, TLDR at the end.

Edit: Also posting this here because I don’t think people could relate in other relationship subreddits… Also, we’ve been together for nearly 6 years now and have been in the lifestyle for 2.

To preface this, it is important to know mine and my partner’s understanding of our lifestyle. We engage in threesomes, mostly MFMs together. We’ve specifically said this is an activity we do together and anything apart from that would be cheating and that we would never be with someone who cheats on their partner.

What happened…

My partner and I were at a bar a few weeks ago with some live music. It was a good show with friends and we all had a good time. After the show ended, I went to the bathroom and when I returned, I was happily surprised to hear the lead singer asked if my partner was single and if he could buy her a drink. She told him she was taken, and that was the end of that. I couldn’t imagine much happened since it was just a small bar venue and I was back after just a few minutes.

The next day, she tells me she found his instagram page (not hard due to his band) and I asked her if this is someone she would consider having an MFM in the future with. She said she was interested and reached out to him to see if this would be something he would be interested in. After messaging each other back and forth, we were happy to find out he participates in the swinging community as well and would be very excited to join. We made plans to link up after his next show the following week. At this point, I began asking her to make a group chat so we can all be on the same page, but she never does. This is not normal since we’ve always made group chats in the past.

Unfortunately, I came down with a nasty cold and was unable to go out the following weekend, so I told her to have a girl’s night out and still enjoy the show and get to know the guy a bit better. As the night goes on, they go from one bar to the next. I text her at 2:00 AM letting her know I’m about to fall asleep but to text me if she needs anything. She responds they’re grabbing food and should be coming home soon.

Next thing I know, she’s coming home at 6:00AM, is excited to see me, has a big smile on her face, and tells me what a great time she had. She was supposed to be getting a ride from her friend (F) which is what I believe happened at this point. I was happy to see how happy she was. She told me a bit about the night, got ready for bed, and that was the end of that. This was the night she cheated on me with him.

Over the course of the next week, she begins talking to me about how she’s been starting to want to have casual one night stands and how she never got to experience a “hoe” phase as we like to call it. It really starts to bother me at this point that she has not made a group chat with us yet after repeatedly asking her. She keeps saying she will but never does. Further, we planned to meet up during this week on Saturday and it would start off with her going with him to the botanical gardens in our area, followed by them coming to our house.

At this point, she’s asked if she could essentially have a solo session with him before I join them in our bedroom. I’m feeling very uncomfortable at this point with everything going on, how there is no group chat still, and that they’re going out on a date without me. Especially with the amount of texting they had been doing back and forth (without me). For whatever reason though, I agree it’ll be okay. Come that Saturday though, he bails on her last minute and the night never happens.

That was a breath of relief for me. I told her that he missed his one chance at a solo session with her. I thought that was basically the end of it and that he had cold feet.

Over the next week, I start getting very paranoid about that night she came home so late. I ask her more details about it and that’s when I find out he brought her home and not her friend. Her friend had gone over to his house with her and said it was getting late and that they should leave, but my partner didn’t want to. This was her final opportunity to make the right decision… but she didn’t… Her friend knows what happened but did not tell me which I am also very upset about.

At this point I basically knew she slept with him. I began asking if they fooled around at all and she began lying to me. Then she started saying they just kissed but she told him to stop. I know we’re human, and I know if I was in that situation, I think it would have gone on a lot further. I told her I can’t imagine how they couldn’t have fooled around, but I’ll choose to believe it for now.

The next day, I was feeling sick to my stomach. I confronted her one last time and asked her what it was like having sex with him… At this point she burst into tears. She admitted to everything. The lying, and sneaking, the sex. Everything.

I was furious. I couldn’t even look at her. I went to my office to be alone and process what she had just told me. I was absolutely disgusted. How could she do this to me? I never thought she’d be capable of something like this. We had LITERALLY just had the conversation about cheating or swinging without each other would result in a break of trust and the relationship and she went ahead and did it.

AND THE FACT SHE WANTED TO SLEEP ALONE WITH HIM IN MY HOUSE?! MY BED?!

I wouldn’t look her in the eyes for the next few hours. She couldn’t stop crying and saying how stupid she was and how much she regretted her decision.

I’ve made my fair share of mistakes in the past. I’ve even told her that I think the relationship should end (big mistake) roughly a year ago due to shifting opinions on whether or not we want kids one day. But we were able to talk it over and figure it out.

I’ve also made another mistake when we first got into the lifestyle roughly 2 years ago. One that I feel very guilty about, but not nearly as much anymore after what happened. The same way she told this guy that she shouldn’t sleep with him, but did anyway (and wanted to do it again very clearly), something similar happened with us. I was particularly horny one day after a night out with her and one of our other male partners in the lifestyle. At the end of the night, we did the same thing that guy did and talked her into having a threesome that night. She ended up saying yes, and we had a great time, but she was very upset with me and our other partner for being pushy about it. Apparently it’s okay when a complete stranger does it though.

The night she confessed is also the same night I (mostly) cooled off. I do still love her. I’m even turned on by the idea of her with him and I’ve communicated that with her. It’s the break in trust, feelings of exclusion & not being wanted, and the consistent lying that hurts the most. In her words, she thought she could replicate the night she spent with him, but then I would be included and it would make everything okay. Clearly that didn’t happen.

It’s been a few weeks since then. I feel much better about everything, but I still don’t trust her like I used to. I’m going out of town for a week on business and am scared of what will happen while I’m gone. She’s still a student and has several exams next week, but idk.

We’ve spoken about how in this lifestyle, we are left more susceptible to mistakes and accidents in the sexual space. How tunnel vision can kick in and sex is the only thing on the mind. Similar to other hobbies that can result in injury, except this is in the realm of emotional hurt. Part of the healing has actually been her reciting in great detail exactly how the night played out, down to the exact way he touched her and she touched him while making love together. It has become a very hot scene in the bedroom and I do see myself being okay with broadening our lifestyle. It’s a shame it had to occur like this though.

TLDR; Partner hooks up with a guy we just met that we were planning a threesome with behind my back while I was at home sick and continued to lie and leave me out of all conversations with this person when it is not the lifestyle we agreed upon. She even wanted to schedule the actual threesome with him, but go out on a date with him and let him have the first round with her before I joined.

I can forgive her for sleeping with him, but I am having so much trouble accepting the lying and secrets and continuous disregard to include me in the conversations that were being held. I also have trouble with the amount of conscious decisions that were made to leave me out of the loop for so long up to the point of no return. I am still going back and forth in my mind of what to do. For now I have chosen to stay with her and rebuild the relationship, but at times I have feelings of paranoia of it happening again behind my back.

Thoughts? I know this lifestyle is built on trust and consent, but I feel like both my trust and consent were broken.

RELEVANT COMMENTS

classic4imaduckie

I’d be so done with this relationship. Sorry dude. Trust is everything. Lifestyle or vanilla.

OOP

I feel like I’d be throwing away the past 5 years over one (maybe several) huge mistakes on her end that took place over the course of about three weeks.

But to your point… my trust was broken… I’ve never had any thought in my mind that she would be capable of something like this…

She is the first person I’ve ever committed to in my life which makes this even harder.

Update Oct 3, 2023 (7 Months Later)

Hi everyone. It’s been a little over half a year since this post. Not making a TLDR for this one.

I really was hoping I could salvage it.

I’ve been doing what I can to move on but I haven’t been able to. I don’t think she has been putting in the necessary effort on her end either. Between her depression and what she did, I feel like I’ve been carrying this relationship for the two of us. I don’t think she is capable of being in a relationship let alone putting in the work that needs to be done to repair this one.

At least I can tell myself I tried… as hard as anyone could ask really.

Our six year anniversary was this past summer. I can’t even remember what we did.

I’m currently on a business trip and have not gotten an ounce of sleep tonight. It’s 6:15 AM at the moment and all I’ve been thinking about is how this isn’t working.

I guess it gave me the physical distance I needed to come to this conclusion.

I’ve thought about ending things now and then, but wasn’t ready or didn’t believe it. I thought there was still something I could do. But I’ve been trying to swim upstream for too long now without any help. I can’t keep carrying all this weight.

I do want to make note of something though. I think this relationship was already on its way out. This event just brought about its downfall sooner, which in a way… I’m thankful for.

It wasn’t the lifestyle that caused this to happen. Her and I started dating in our young 20s and have been growing a lot together over time. For a while, I thought we were incredibly compatible, but honestly it was in all the wrong ways. We make good roommates, not partners. She isn’t the person I met back when I was still in college, and neither am I. With that said, I think we’ve grown apart and it brought out a lot of ugliness along the way.

A thought I struggled with for a long time is thinking this other guy completely flipped my world upside down. As if he somehow caused this to happen. In reality, I should thank him. He helped me realize that this relationship was not meant to last a lot sooner than I would have on my own. I was blind to the signs and needed a wake up call.

Another thought I struggled with is how much love, time, and attention I’ve invested in this relationship. It was my first true relationship I’ve ever had. I always wanted it to be the one. Someone called me out in the last post on sunk cost fallacy… damn were you right.

With all that being said, I’m worried of what she’ll do when I break things off. I don’t hate her. I still care for her. With her depression and self harm tendencies, I think this could push her over the edge. We live together in my house, her whole world will be tossed upside down. She is still in school, no job, I’m not sure what she’ll do or where she’ll go… Maybe to her parents? Although they haven’t always been the most supportive…

I’ve felt like the bad guy for so long these past few months. As if everything wrong with this relationship was somehow the result of me as a person. If she goes as far to… I don’t know what I’d do with myself.

I really appreciate the support you all gave in my last post.

Although I didn’t want to believe what most of you said, I really do believe you were right in the end.

I hope I’m strong enough to go through with this.

I hope she finds happiness someday.

I hope I’m okay with it if she finds it sooner than I do.

OOP Did post 2 small updates in comments in relies on:

Feb 16, 2024

OOP

How are you doing now? It’s been a few months since we’ve separated, but we have been talking about starting over again.

May 28, 2024

We’ve been split since October of last year and haven’t gotten back together. We talk here and there, get dinner together now and again, but we’ve both still got a lot of work to do if we are going to come back to each other.

I wish it worked out for you. That’s one of the areas I’m hesitant with rekindling my relationship to be honest. It happening again.

But my bigger fear is not having the chance to try once we are at a point where we are both ready

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT THE OOP

DO NOT CONTACT THE OOP’s OR COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS, REMEMBER

0

[Concluded] I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick [Reddit]

preview

I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick

DO NOT COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS. I am NOT OP. Original post by u/throwRA531800807734 in r/relationship_advice

trigger warnings: >!Sexual assault, domestic violence, gaslighting, boundary violations!<

mood spoilers:

spoiler

Bizarre, happy ending


 

Original Post: June 30, 2025

I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick

My boyfriend (27m) and I (24f) have been together for 1 year and 3 months. Our relationship has been very loving but has started to get bumpy ever since we moved in together for our 1 year anniversary.

A little backstory:

I’m in college right now pursuing my master’s degree in Archaeology while also working as a library clerk to earn money. Whereas my boyfriend works as a magician for parties and events. Despite our different career paths, I’ve never had a problem with his career choice because it makes him happy. He has always found a way to make every day magical which has been sweet. About 9ish months into our relationship I had the opportunity to go on a 2 month archeological excavation in another country for school. Despite us becoming long distance, he had no problem with me going and he was very happy for me. He would send me gifts, letters, and he even sent things for my colleagues in order to brighten up their days. While we were doing long distance we made plans to move into an apartment when I got back due to how much we missed each other. And a few days after I returned we moved in together which has been awful so far.

Before living together we would see each other a few times a week due to my busy schedule but now that we live together we see each other all the time. And he has started to do magic ALL THE TIME. He will make my keys “disappear” as I’m trying to go to work or school, he tries to practice his card tricks on me while I’m doing homework, he makes the cleaning rag “vanish” when I ask him to clean, and he has recently done something that makes me want to end the relationship. I have never been in this serious of a relationship before so I don’t want to throw our loving relationship away just because of these bad few months.

Last month we were getting steamy and he went down on me which isn’t unusual. While he was going down on me he was saying some dirty talk here and there. I was lost in the moment for obvious reasons but I snapped out of it when he said, “Oh, how did that get in there?” And I watched him pull a coin from my crotch. He found the coin moment hilarious but it just took me out of the moment and instantly made me annoyed so we stopped. Later I told him that him doing the magic in the bedroom made me literally dry up so I asked him to keep that kind of magic out of the bedroom. He explained to me that he was trying to make me laugh/have fun and he didnt apologize for it. I talked with some of my friends about it and they thought it was funny so I figured that I was overreacting and needed to lighten up a bit. But he didnt do any magic tricks in the bedroom for the next few weeks.

However, four days ago we were having sex and he suddenly started to yell “OW!” So I quickly got off of him and was asking what was wrong. He tells me, “I think there’s something in you. Let me check.” I laid on the bed like I was at the goddamn gyno because I trusted that if something was wrong then he would find it. After like two minutes he says, “Oh, here it is.” And I watched as he was pulling up a long ribbon thing that kept going and going and going. It took a second for me to realize that it was one of his magic tools that he had purposely put in me while he was “checking to see what he felt.” He found it hilarious and couldn’t stop laughing while he was pulling the string more and more. I ripped the thing out while doing itand I yelled at him for doing another magic trick like that even though i told him not to. He told me that he was just adding more fun to our sex life and that he wanted to see what the magic trick would look like if it was coming out from a crotch. (The original magic trick involves putting the coil thing in your own mouth and pulling out the plastic string for a while.) I was pissed off so I made him go stay at his parents house for past few days. This morning, I talked with him some more but he still thinks that its not a big deal.

I get that he’s a magician and that he loves magic but I’m still upset about him breaking that boundary I had set. I’m fine with his magic tricks 85% of the time but sex is where I draw the line. I am demisexual so I need to have a strong, trusting, and close relationship with someone before I can even think about having sex with them. So him breaking my boundary has really hurt me and I’ve lost my trust in him. However, everyone I have talked to about the situation says that what he did was hilarious. And I have been told by multiple people that I’m overreacting which is why I decided to go to reddit.

We have built a strong relationship and I really saw myself marrying him one day. I fully trusted him and now I dont know if I ever can again. Should we break up? Or can we fix this and stay together? I’m lost so I’d appreciate any advice. Thanks.

TOP COMMENTS OOP did not answer to any of the comments on the original post, and many Redditors were accusing her of being fake

u/ezagreb:

The magic is gone; it’s time for you to disappear.

u/Different-Version-58:

I hope this is fake…but in case this is real, please say this out loud to yourself and see how it feels as it hits your ear: Your partner, after you already told him that you did not consent to magic tricks in the bedroom, inserted a magicians’ prop into your vajayjay and laughed. A magicians prop that likely was not designed to and may not even be safe/sterile to insert into human genitalia. IN ADDITION, you told him how it made you feel and he continues to find it hilarious. He knows he made you uncomfortable and upset by inserting a MAGICIANS PROP into your vajajay, and STILL finds it funny. Would he be laughing if you put it up is butt hole during sex, and said Ta Dah!? He sexually violated you, and finds it hilarious. Nothing that you have said makes him thinks it’s anything other than funny haha. He thinks it’s ok to violate your physical and sexual boundaries for a joke.

 

First Update: July 03, 2025 (3 DAYS LATER)

UPDATE: I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick

First off no, this story isn’t AI or fake. It’s sadly true but I can understand why people would think that its AI due to the absurdity of it. Secondly, thank you everyone for the advice in the comments of my previous post. I was lost and looking for some advice because of the uncomfortable situation and people around me felt differently about it than I did. People in the comments were right and I should trust my own feelings rather than searching for answers from the people around me. That’s something that I’ve struggled with my whole life because my family is very reliant on each other and my parents are both helicopter parents. So I learned from young age that I couldn’t trust my own instincts because other people know better. Which is why I asked my friends and mom about the situation. I have a lot more work to do in trusting myself but at least I’m working on it now.

Here’s the update:

After my previous post, I read through some of the comments and realized that what my boyfriend did would be considered assault. It wasn’t something that I had even considered because I was only seeing it as him doing something stupid in the bedroom that broke my boundary and made me uncomfortable. But seeing those comments opened up my eyes a lot. If he was willing to break my boundary only after a year of dating and could do that to me in the bedroom than what else could he be capable of?

I met with him the next day at our apartment and I told him about my feelings which he didn’t seem to care about. I showed him the reddit post so that he could see that other people were also uncomfortable with what happened. He read through your comments but when he saw the word ‘assault’ being used a few times he got really aggravated. I had never seen him that angry before but he was screaming nonstop and he even whipped my coffee mug across the room. I ended up crying because I was scared and I think that snapped him back to reality or something because he stopped yelling and was trying to comfort me. I made him leave our apartment again because I didnt want to be around him anymore. That night my friends helped me pack up my stuff and they took me to my parents house which is where I’m at now.

After I was out of the apartment and safe, I called him and broke up with him over the phone because I didn’t feel comfortable doing it in person after his previous reaction. I’m so upset that I wasted over a year of my life dating him and even thinking about a future with him. Thank you all for giving me the courage to follow my feelings and break up with him for good. I really appreciate it. Also, thank you for all the jokes its lightened the mood and has helped me feel a bit better about this situation. Yes ezagreb, the magic is gone and its time for me to disappear.

 

Second, and Last, Update: July 12, 2026 (1 YEAR LATER)

1 YEAR LATER UPDATE: I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick

I wasn’t planning on updating this again but I’m still receiving messages about it so I thought that I should put a mini-update here in case anyone wanted one:

For starters, I have not spoken to him since our breakup. Everything that I’ve learned about him since the breakup has been through mutual friends and social media posts. He tried to speak to me when we ran into each other at the grocery store once and I just kept walking as if I didn’t know who he was. I saw on Facebook that he’s still a magician and he advertises himself on our hometown page all the time. He has a 19 year old girlfriend which is disgusting considering he’s 28 years old and will be 29 in 6 months. But I don’t know anything else about their relationship besides the age gap. I haven’t heard about anything nefarious that he’s done over the past year (besides getting with his teenage girlfriend). And that’s all that I know about him.

Now for my update:

I graduated from college with my Master of Arts in Archaeology 2 months ago, moved out of my hometown, turned 26 a couple days ago, and now I’m currently living and working in Ireland. I’m still single and just focusing on my work for now. I’m apart of an excavation team here in Ireland and I’ll be moving back to America sometime next year.

Also, I’m not a library clerk anymore but I did work as one from 2019-early 2026. I’ve gotten angry messages from people claiming that I was lying about being a library clerk and an Archaeology student because they thought that it was too “perfect” ??? I don’t know how to make you guys believe that I’m real besides doxxing myself or something at this point (which I don’t want to do because I don’t want my professional career to be tied to my ex-boyfriend post). But I was a library clerk and studying Archaeology at the same time. Also, people said that I spelled Archaeology wrong. I have mountains of books about the subject and there are two different ways to spell it. There is ‘Archaeology’ and ‘Archeology.’ I’ve always used the Archaeology spelling and my professors at college didn’t have any issue with it so I don’t know why people on Reddit did lol. It’s also the spelling that is used by the American Anthropological Association which I was apart of back when I was in college. I just wanted to point that out because, again, I have gotten many angry messages about my post “being AI” and me “being fake.”

And on the topic of me “being fake,” people were saying that I was fake because my account was new and I didn’t reply to comments. However, in order to post on r/relationshipadvice the rules stated that I NEEDED to use an account that started with throwRA which is why there was nothing else on my account. I was desperate for advice so I quickly made a new reddit account and I posted about my situation. I had never posted on reddit before so I wrote the post, posted it, and I went to sleep because I thought that only a couple people would see it. By the time I woke up the post was locked and I wasn’t allowed to respond to any comments.

There’s nothing else that I can do to prove that I’m real or that I went through this situation with my ex. But I still wanna thank you all for giving me the confidence to leave him. It was a terrible and scary situation that could’ve been worse and I feel like my life has gotten 100 times better since I broke up with him. Thank you to the people who were kind to me- especially in my update post. I felt extremely lost last year and the kind (and funny) comments truly helped me deal my breakup.

I don’t think that I’ll give anymore updates on here unless I find out that something crazy happened with my ex. But for now I’d love to leave him in the past and focus on my future. Goodbye.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOP – BoRU

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick

DO NOT COMMENT ON LINKED POSTS. I am NOT OP. Original post by u/throwRA531800807734 in r/relationship_advice

trigger warnings: >!Sexual assault, domestic violence, gaslighting, boundary violations!<

mood spoilers:

spoiler

Bizarre, happy ending


 

Original Post: June 30, 2025

I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick

My boyfriend (27m) and I (24f) have been together for 1 year and 3 months. Our relationship has been very loving but has started to get bumpy ever since we moved in together for our 1 year anniversary.

A little backstory:

I’m in college right now pursuing my master’s degree in Archaeology while also working as a library clerk to earn money. Whereas my boyfriend works as a magician for parties and events. Despite our different career paths, I’ve never had a problem with his career choice because it makes him happy. He has always found a way to make every day magical which has been sweet. About 9ish months into our relationship I had the opportunity to go on a 2 month archeological excavation in another country for school. Despite us becoming long distance, he had no problem with me going and he was very happy for me. He would send me gifts, letters, and he even sent things for my colleagues in order to brighten up their days. While we were doing long distance we made plans to move into an apartment when I got back due to how much we missed each other. And a few days after I returned we moved in together which has been awful so far.

Before living together we would see each other a few times a week due to my busy schedule but now that we live together we see each other all the time. And he has started to do magic ALL THE TIME. He will make my keys “disappear” as I’m trying to go to work or school, he tries to practice his card tricks on me while I’m doing homework, he makes the cleaning rag “vanish” when I ask him to clean, and he has recently done something that makes me want to end the relationship. I have never been in this serious of a relationship before so I don’t want to throw our loving relationship away just because of these bad few months.

Last month we were getting steamy and he went down on me which isn’t unusual. While he was going down on me he was saying some dirty talk here and there. I was lost in the moment for obvious reasons but I snapped out of it when he said, “Oh, how did that get in there?” And I watched him pull a coin from my crotch. He found the coin moment hilarious but it just took me out of the moment and instantly made me annoyed so we stopped. Later I told him that him doing the magic in the bedroom made me literally dry up so I asked him to keep that kind of magic out of the bedroom. He explained to me that he was trying to make me laugh/have fun and he didnt apologize for it. I talked with some of my friends about it and they thought it was funny so I figured that I was overreacting and needed to lighten up a bit. But he didnt do any magic tricks in the bedroom for the next few weeks.

However, four days ago we were having sex and he suddenly started to yell “OW!” So I quickly got off of him and was asking what was wrong. He tells me, “I think there’s something in you. Let me check.” I laid on the bed like I was at the goddamn gyno because I trusted that if something was wrong then he would find it. After like two minutes he says, “Oh, here it is.” And I watched as he was pulling up a long ribbon thing that kept going and going and going. It took a second for me to realize that it was one of his magic tools that he had purposely put in me while he was “checking to see what he felt.” He found it hilarious and couldn’t stop laughing while he was pulling the string more and more. I ripped the thing out while doing itand I yelled at him for doing another magic trick like that even though i told him not to. He told me that he was just adding more fun to our sex life and that he wanted to see what the magic trick would look like if it was coming out from a crotch. (The original magic trick involves putting the coil thing in your own mouth and pulling out the plastic string for a while.) I was pissed off so I made him go stay at his parents house for past few days. This morning, I talked with him some more but he still thinks that its not a big deal.

I get that he’s a magician and that he loves magic but I’m still upset about him breaking that boundary I had set. I’m fine with his magic tricks 85% of the time but sex is where I draw the line. I am demisexual so I need to have a strong, trusting, and close relationship with someone before I can even think about having sex with them. So him breaking my boundary has really hurt me and I’ve lost my trust in him. However, everyone I have talked to about the situation says that what he did was hilarious. And I have been told by multiple people that I’m overreacting which is why I decided to go to reddit.

We have built a strong relationship and I really saw myself marrying him one day. I fully trusted him and now I dont know if I ever can again. Should we break up? Or can we fix this and stay together? I’m lost so I’d appreciate any advice. Thanks.

TOP COMMENTS OOP did not answer to any of the comments on the original post, and many Redditors were accusing her of being fake

u/ezagreb:

The magic is gone; it’s time for you to disappear.

u/Different-Version-58:

I hope this is fake…but in case this is real, please say this out loud to yourself and see how it feels as it hits your ear: Your partner, after you already told him that you did not consent to magic tricks in the bedroom, inserted a magicians’ prop into your vajayjay and laughed. A magicians prop that likely was not designed to and may not even be safe/sterile to insert into human genitalia. IN ADDITION, you told him how it made you feel and he continues to find it hilarious. He knows he made you uncomfortable and upset by inserting a MAGICIANS PROP into your vajajay, and STILL finds it funny. Would he be laughing if you put it up is butt hole during sex, and said Ta Dah!? He sexually violated you, and finds it hilarious. Nothing that you have said makes him thinks it’s anything other than funny haha. He thinks it’s ok to violate your physical and sexual boundaries for a joke.

 

First Update: July 03, 2025 (3 DAYS LATER)

UPDATE: I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick

First off no, this story isn’t AI or fake. It’s sadly true but I can understand why people would think that its AI due to the absurdity of it. Secondly, thank you everyone for the advice in the comments of my previous post. I was lost and looking for some advice because of the uncomfortable situation and people around me felt differently about it than I did. People in the comments were right and I should trust my own feelings rather than searching for answers from the people around me. That’s something that I’ve struggled with my whole life because my family is very reliant on each other and my parents are both helicopter parents. So I learned from young age that I couldn’t trust my own instincts because other people know better. Which is why I asked my friends and mom about the situation. I have a lot more work to do in trusting myself but at least I’m working on it now.

Here’s the update:

After my previous post, I read through some of the comments and realized that what my boyfriend did would be considered assault. It wasn’t something that I had even considered because I was only seeing it as him doing something stupid in the bedroom that broke my boundary and made me uncomfortable. But seeing those comments opened up my eyes a lot. If he was willing to break my boundary only after a year of dating and could do that to me in the bedroom than what else could he be capable of?

I met with him the next day at our apartment and I told him about my feelings which he didn’t seem to care about. I showed him the reddit post so that he could see that other people were also uncomfortable with what happened. He read through your comments but when he saw the word ‘assault’ being used a few times he got really aggravated. I had never seen him that angry before but he was screaming nonstop and he even whipped my coffee mug across the room. I ended up crying because I was scared and I think that snapped him back to reality or something because he stopped yelling and was trying to comfort me. I made him leave our apartment again because I didnt want to be around him anymore. That night my friends helped me pack up my stuff and they took me to my parents house which is where I’m at now.

After I was out of the apartment and safe, I called him and broke up with him over the phone because I didn’t feel comfortable doing it in person after his previous reaction. I’m so upset that I wasted over a year of my life dating him and even thinking about a future with him. Thank you all for giving me the courage to follow my feelings and break up with him for good. I really appreciate it. Also, thank you for all the jokes its lightened the mood and has helped me feel a bit better about this situation. Yes ezagreb, the magic is gone and its time for me to disappear.

 

Second, and Last, Update: July 12, 2026 (1 YEAR LATER)

1 YEAR LATER UPDATE: I (24f) want to break up with my magician boyfriend (27m) due to his inappropriate magic trick

I wasn’t planning on updating this again but I’m still receiving messages about it so I thought that I should put a mini-update here in case anyone wanted one:

For starters, I have not spoken to him since our breakup. Everything that I’ve learned about him since the breakup has been through mutual friends and social media posts. He tried to speak to me when we ran into each other at the grocery store once and I just kept walking as if I didn’t know who he was. I saw on Facebook that he’s still a magician and he advertises himself on our hometown page all the time. He has a 19 year old girlfriend which is disgusting considering he’s 28 years old and will be 29 in 6 months. But I don’t know anything else about their relationship besides the age gap. I haven’t heard about anything nefarious that he’s done over the past year (besides getting with his teenage girlfriend). And that’s all that I know about him.

Now for my update:

I graduated from college with my Master of Arts in Archaeology 2 months ago, moved out of my hometown, turned 26 a couple days ago, and now I’m currently living and working in Ireland. I’m still single and just focusing on my work for now. I’m apart of an excavation team here in Ireland and I’ll be moving back to America sometime next year.

Also, I’m not a library clerk anymore but I did work as one from 2019-early 2026. I’ve gotten angry messages from people claiming that I was lying about being a library clerk and an Archaeology student because they thought that it was too “perfect” ??? I don’t know how to make you guys believe that I’m real besides doxxing myself or something at this point (which I don’t want to do because I don’t want my professional career to be tied to my ex-boyfriend post). But I was a library clerk and studying Archaeology at the same time. Also, people said that I spelled Archaeology wrong. I have mountains of books about the subject and there are two different ways to spell it. There is ‘Archaeology’ and ‘Archeology.’ I’ve always used the Archaeology spelling and my professors at college didn’t have any issue with it so I don’t know why people on Reddit did lol. It’s also the spelling that is used by the American Anthropological Association which I was apart of back when I was in college. I just wanted to point that out because, again, I have gotten many angry messages about my post “being AI” and me “being fake.”

And on the topic of me “being fake,” people were saying that I was fake because my account was new and I didn’t reply to comments. However, in order to post on r/relationshipadvice the rules stated that I NEEDED to use an account that started with throwRA which is why there was nothing else on my account. I was desperate for advice so I quickly made a new reddit account and I posted about my situation. I had never posted on reddit before so I wrote the post, posted it, and I went to sleep because I thought that only a couple people would see it. By the time I woke up the post was locked and I wasn’t allowed to respond to any comments.

There’s nothing else that I can do to prove that I’m real or that I went through this situation with my ex. But I still wanna thank you all for giving me the confidence to leave him. It was a terrible and scary situation that could’ve been worse and I feel like my life has gotten 100 times better since I broke up with him. Thank you to the people who were kind to me- especially in my update post. I felt extremely lost last year and the kind (and funny) comments truly helped me deal my breakup.

I don’t think that I’ll give anymore updates on here unless I find out that something crazy happened with my ex. But for now I’d love to leave him in the past and focus on my future. Goodbye.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOP – BoRU

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

0

[Concluded] Teenagers pushed us too far and probably got their family evicted. [Reddit]

preview

Teenagers pushed us too far and probably got their family evicted.

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/MortynMurphy

Originally posted to r/neighborsfromhell

Teenagers pushed us too far and probably got their family evicted.

Trigger Warnings:

spoiler

destruction of property


Original Post: May 24, 2026

I try to be a polite neighbor. You’re not going to see me often and I won’t seek out conversation, but when new neighbors move in, I will go and introduce myself and offer mine and my spouse’s phone number. This is a nice neighborhood, it’s completely normal to give Christmas baskets or let someone’s dog out if they need it, stuff we did for our previous next door neighbors. No one would complain about a random party on a holiday weekend, I won’t be bothered by your kids playing loudly on the sidewalk, people behave but aren’t unreasonable about expectations. Especially since we live in townhouses that are all connected, there’s just no way to eliminate all neighbor noise. All this to say that I don’t think we have unreasonable community expectations.

Since these new neighbors moved in the vacant rental next to ours we have had nothing but trouble. They have only been here a couple of months, but they are the second-worst neighbors we have ever had. The absolute worst was a couple at our first apartment who resolved conflicts via fisticuffs.

The first annoyance was a normal one. Their bass was too loud through the walls, a common problem since people aren’t aware of how thin the walls are. (We did the same thing. Our previous neighbors texted, we apologized and adjusted settings, confirmed they couldn’t hear it anymore, and all was well.) We work from home and needed to be in meetings, so we went over to ask them to turn it down and no one answered. Finally we texted the mother, and the music only happened in late afternoon between the time when her kids would get home from school and when she would get home from work. Since it was a couple of hours maximum we let it go and didn’t schedule any meetings during those times. We were kids once, too.

Then Spring Break happened. Either the mother works both days and nights or simply spends 18 out of 24 hours outside the house. Twice in one night my husband had to sternly tell her daughters’ friends to stop looking in our cars, leaning on our cars, and screaming after midnight. Five feet from our front door, by the way.

Then the next night we catch them doing it AGAIN! My husband opens the door to one of the drunk little idiots *popping a squat and pissing less than a foot from our car!* My husband, being a reasonable man, starts yelling angrily at them for PISSING IN FRONT OF OUR DOOR. The hooligan closest to sober remembered basic survival instincts and began wrangling the rest of them into the house, apologizing sloppily but profusely. Apparently a very angry, very big, very bearded man yelling will do that to ya.

Later we have yet another text exchange with the mother. We make our stance known and I’m quite proud of myself for keeping my temper in check. She said she will handle it and we end the conversation on good terms. Even then we were willing to try and be nice and give them another chance. We were little asshole teens once and chalked it up to the high of spring break. We hosed off the pavement and tried to generate a level of patience hitherto unforeseen in either of us.

We had about a week of peace, but the good times couldn’t last. The teen girls have developed a small collective of devoted derelict boys who hang around outside their house several afternoons a week. They once again leaned on our cars, looked into our cars, and were little assholes when my husband came outside. They tried to mouth off but when he asked them to repeat themselves they scuttled down the sidewalk. Rinse and repeat for a couple of weeks.

That brings us to last night. We’re fun and exciting people, so we were idly scrolling our phones while watching something. Suddenly there was a loud *bang!* and we noticed a phone flashlight on our back patio. They had **broken through our fence** and were scrambling for a way out. We hear/vaguely see whoever it is crash through our garbage cans on the other side. His options were either to run that course, risk the 10+ft drop into woods, or escalate to breaking and entering in a state where he would have probably become a statistic.

In an obviously rare moment of intelligence, he chose the first option. The whole thing freaks us the hell out, and by the time we get our heads on right and go out front we see those same goddamn teens scattering through the neighborhood like mice. One of them didn’t get far enough away and tried to casually act like he was just walking by, but when we confronted him he was clearly rattled. We weren’t about to detain a child because we’re not psychotic, so we let him go. He scampered off to wherever little shits go when they’re not ruining everyone’s evening.

The neighbor on the other side of the Problem House had someone break into their back area as well going the opposite direction, and I panicked. I reached out to the mom, convinced her daughters may have been hurt or they were robbed. She brushed me off and got a little rude when I told her the trespassers had definitely come from her house and that every other neighbor said the same thing.

That is until a random “uncle” appeared, driven home by someone else. He listened to us and fed us the usual bullshit people do when they don’t want to deal with anything. Lots of empty apologies and excuses for why the kids are alone. But apparently he told the mom that four adults were all saying the same thing: The working theory is that the boyfriends somehow knew an adult was coming back (probably location sharing) so they panicked and left out the back.

The mom tried to walk back her attitude and apologized after hearing how many witnesses there were, but I am not very forgiving once I’m at a certain point. It’s something I’m working on. I did not accept her apology. Later when we reviewed our camera footage from the whole night, we saw the same little shit we stopped go into her house with the others about an hour before they trespassed. The same little shits *come back later after the trespassing* and lean on our cars, climb on our cars, and film themselves lip synching for whatever reason. So we decided to go nuclear. To quote the certified BadAss™ Cobra Bubbles, “thus far you have been adrift in the sheltered harbor of my patience.”

Mommy Dearest had no way of knowing this, but the neighbors we were friendly with that had lived there before? They were very good friends with the homeowner. It was very easy to get his number from them, text him, and bing bang boom suddenly my husband is on the phone with a very embarrassed guy whose apologies were much more coherent than piss-girl’s friend. He was really very appreciative of the Google drive link with video of every single issue we have had (a few I’ve left out just to save space). Complete with time stamps! The other neighbors got his phone number as well. We learned some interesting info from him. The mom gave us a different name than the one he had, there were only supposed to be two people total living there (we see five or more living there regularly), other fun things I’ll leave to your vivid imaginations. Needless to say, they’re in violation of their lease with just this. But one thing my husband and I have in common is that we are very thorough.

So the next step was the police report. Did you know that in my state you can file a non-emergency report online for things like someone on your back porch late at night or people casing your car? It’s really very easy! Our HOA isn’t open until Monday (edit, sorry, Tuesday!) but they had a nice little contact page we filled out. The other neighbors also filed reports and contacted the HOA. However bad my Saturday night was, I think their upcoming week might be worse.

My husband informed the mother via text of all the steps we had taken and that our cameras are always on, front and back. She has been silent and absent from the home since I did not accept her apology last night and laid out exactly how much trouble her kids have been when she’s not around (which is always). Not sure what will happen next, a little concerned about retaliation from the little dingleberries. But now we have a paper trail, an immediate line of communication to the landlord, and they’re aware they’ve been being recorded the entire time. Any escalation beyond this is their choice. ETA that I don’t think the eviction is in motion yet or anything at all. I don’t know anything other than they are in direct violation of their lease in multiple ways, and that in my state that’s a wrap on your tenancy.

TLDR: Turns out, being a little asshole, having little assholes over as guests, and your little asshole guests trespassing late at night is in violation of most lease contracts. Maybe don’t case cars and break fences while you trespass in the era of home cameras. And maybe consider for a brief moment that your neighbors might just have your landlord’s personal phone number.

Update #1 05/25/2026: the mom finally came home at around 2:30 in the morning with a literal warehouse of younger kids. She put them in the house and then left herself in a different car that was there to pick her up. The uncle or whoever he was is at the house with the new set of kids and we saw no sign of Shitlings & Co last night. My husband thinks the mom and older teenagers are avoiding their own house since we’ve now taken to sitting on our porches.

Update #2 05/26/2026: I have had terrible insomnia for the past two nights since getting the shit scared out of me by the trespassing. I have confirmed with a couple of other neighbors that they contacted the HOA, owner, and filed a police report for a missing Apple Watch from one of their cars for the same night. They said they would, but it was nice to get the confirmation and vent to each other. If the kids choose to retaliate they would have to target multiple people, all of whom have cameras. Still no sign of Shitlings & Co, normally a day off school summons them like maggots to a carcass. Our front camera is not in an obvious spot, so my husband thinks it might have freaked them out to learn they’d been being recorded the whole time. I’m so angry I want to go piss next to *her* driver’s side door. But that would technically be right next to my car again, and that would be counterintuitive.

Update #3 06/01/2026: Still no sign of Shitlings & Co. They haven’t shown themselves since the night they broke our fence down. Our cars and property have been left alone entirely, but the neighbors on the other side of the NFH asked for some camera footage since they woke up to some gas missing out of their car during the week. Then they asked for footage again on Thursday, since some *other* kids staying at the NFH were climbing all the way on the roof and hood of her car and the camera they ordered hadn’t gotten here yet. She was *heated* and came out yelling at them because her roof is now dented, the adults came rushing out to usher the kids inside for only a minute, and then the whole crowd bundled up into their cars and left. I think they know they’re on thin ice. I wasn’t part of this confrontation, I heard about it/saw it on my cameras later when she asked for the footage. Idk what her next steps will be, I would want my roof repair paid for, but I also understand not wanting to deal with them in that way.

The landlord had a meeting scheduled with the mother that he called a “walkthrough and HOA citation review” for noon on Sat, 05/30. She claimed a family emergency and asked to push it back until Sunday at noon. Then she asked to push it back until 5. The landlord was openly irritated by the third rescheduling. He offered this information by the way, we did not ask. The landlord ended yesterday by reporting he had told the mom “what her options were going forward.” What those options entail, he did not say. It has been eerily quiet since yesterday evening when we told us that. I don’t want to speculate since I genuinely have no information beyond this. All I know is I heard vacuuming and cleaning for a while on Sunday, (normal amount for landlord visit in my opinion) and then absolute silence.

I hope this is concluded, but based on my experience with teenagers like Shitlings & Co they tend to forget lessons pretty quick. Hopefully the landlord and whatever he said helped the neighbors understand the precarious position their teenagers’ “friends” put them in.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: They didn’t get evicted because of one mistake, they got evicted because they treated the neighborhood like a free trial for bad decisions

OOP: I don’t know if the eviction is actually in motion yet or what, but based on how upset the landlord was I would be shocked if they are here next month.

Commenter 2: The month changes in a few days. You will know IF the landlord takes the rent, your next-door jerks are staying. I hope NOT. But landlords and a chance to increase rent for more tenants that are already there, is hard to pass up!

OOP: You’ll be happy to hear he’s not our landlord! It won’t affect our monthly budget in any way if they are evicted.

OOP explains more about the violations of a lease in their state

OOP: In our state, violating a lease is curtains on your tenancy unless you have a particularly patient landlord. That doesn’t happen often. And HOAs are particularly powerful here, they can fine the owner into oblivion for the tenant not following community guidelines while evicting the tenant themselves. They only allow renters that follow community guidelines, full stop. Considering their office is going to open up this week to multiple complaints about one family, I’m hopeful.

So between all the lease violations and not following HOA guidelines (which also violated their contract), the landlord might actually have to evict them if he wants to keep being able to rent out his place at all.

+

Between that, the trespassing, the payment problems the landlord said he’s been having, the pee incident, and all the videos of these incidents we sent, he said he’s pulling out all the stops. We may get to see a show starring the Sheriff’s department at the end of the month!

+

In my state violating your lease contract, which they have in at least five ways we know of, is enough for the landlord to evict ASAP at the end of the paid month. They also have been having payment problems. We live in one of the worst states for tenant’s rights.

Commenter 3: Eviction is a process and at the very least, requires 30 day notice. If the tenant only has a few months left on their lease, the landlord may just let the lease run out, and not renew it. Giving these people 30 days to pack up and get out, may makes things worse

OOP: Not in my state baybeeee! The one time being one of the lowest ranked states for tenant rights is working in our favor. Tenants can be booted out in 72hrs if the landlord can prove it’s for good reasons. Given all the stuff we’ve handed to him I think he’s got a good chance. On top of that the HOA is about to unleash a shit storm, and has the power to evict the tenants themselves in our state. Ours is very reasonable about plants, decorations, door color, etc., but they come down hard on shit like this.

Why didn’t OOP call the police from the beginning?

OOP: Because I live in a state where it was more likely those kids would become a hashtag and a headline if we did. And while I’m pissed off, they weren’t violent and I don’t think that would have been the safest escalation for anybody. They have been told that we will call the cops if we see their friends near our property again, though.

Commenter 4: Eviction takes a long time. Watch yourself take care.

OOP: We have taken precautions. They know they’re being filmed now. We also don’t live in a state where tenants get a lot of rights, and our HOA only allows tenants if they follow community guidelines. Between footage of them violating both their lease and the community guidelines (which also violated their lease), I’m pretty hopeful they won’t be in our hair much longer.

Commenter 5: I would have called the cops for underage drinking. Probably would have saved you a lot of headaches while causing a lot of legal headaches for the tenant and landlord.

OOP: That was our first thought as well, but for that to work we would have to have a single cop around here that didn’t start drinking in their teens and wouldn’t be delighted to overreact to some stupid kids. Now that we’ve had our property actually trespassed on, we’ll be calling the cops immediately next time something happens.

Has OOP dealt with similar situations like that with any other teenagers?

OOP: We had a nice lovely neighborhood for the four years we’ve lived here. There are some other teens that live on the other side of the neighborhood that genuinely just do kid stuff like riding their bikes around and playing basketball after school, filming TikToks together down by our little park area, just normal stuff. The only time I’ve had to say anything was when I was in a meeting working from home and they were squealing a bit loud. I popped my head out and said I was working from home and asked if they could keep it down until I got out of my meeting. They were polite, apologized, and didn’t resume whatever they were doing until after the time had passed. I even told their mom when I saw her how much I appreciated her kids just being chill and respectful about it, I didn’t mind them playing I just needed to be able to hear my meeting. Those kids don’t come over to our side anymore because of the little assholes we live next to.

 

Update: July 14, 2026 (over one month later from Update #3 in the original post)

UPDATE: Teenagers pushed us too far and probably (definitely) got their family evicted.

Thankfully the conclusion to this whole situation is not dramatic!

After we went nuclear, we had absolutely no issues except for the couple of things from the small updates on the last post. After the first weekend of June we barely even saw signs of human life. If it hadn’t been for the car appearing and disappearing, I would have thought they had already been kicked out. I’m not sure what happened inside, but the only activity was a U-haul parked there on and off over a couple of days a couple weeks ago. We have not seen either of the teenage girls since the landlord meeting. I know that my own mother would have tied me up like a pretzel and shipped me off to Camp Greenlake to dig holes for a year. Shitlings & Co disappeared off the face of the Earth for a couple of weeks, although we did see a couple of them walking back from a nearby gas station a few days ago so they’re clearly still around the neighborhood. I guess doing TikTok dances on the hoods of the neighbors’ cars, breaking down fences, and ultimately helping get her family evicted is not a good way to keep your girl interested. Young love is tough that way.

Today (ETA; yesterday, I wrote this late last night) the landlord came by to ask how things have been and to let us know they were officially evicted a couple of weeks ago. They had been having payment problems as well. Both us and the neighbors on the other side of the problem house submitted HOA complaints and police reports that helped him push things along and he seemed to really appreciate it. The power of documentation once again proves itself.

I’m personally a bit conflicted now that the anger from my first post has cooled off a bit. To reiterate, we never had a problem with regular neighbor noise and would never have complained about that. We want kids to play on our sidewalk, we want friends to chat in the parking lot, we don’t care if you have a party on the weekend. Pissing drunk next to my car, screaming outside our bedroom windows at 2am on a weeknight, blasting bass hard enough to rattle the pictures on my walls, and breaking into our back patio area late at night do not fall under “normal neighbor noise and activities.”

On one hand, life is already hard for a single parent, and I wish that we could have worked things out between us as neighbors without getting all litigious. But on the other hand we did try talking it out between adults first. And maybe don’t piss off your neighbors, violate your lease, AND not pay rent. Hopefully they found a place that works for them, and I hope those kids don’t keep making their mom’s life hard.

TLDR: They’re evicted, have been for a couple weeks. We suspected as much after seeing them pack a U-haul, but otherwise wanted to mind our own business and be done with the situation. Landlord came by to confirm and say thanks earlier today.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Happy for you, though I don’t think a good landlord should provide that kind of specific information (specifically that they were having payment issues.) Also, I’m betting if they had paid they’d still be your problem, it wasn’t the disturbance that caused the eviction.

OOP: Oh I agree with you entirely on the information part. Not so sure about the second point, in our state HOAs are very powerful and violating HOA guidelines is a good way to get renting banned from the neighborhood.

Downvoted Commenter: ooooof, struggling single mom with teens that are hard to control while working 2 or more jobs at odd hours… That eviction could legitimately ruin her life. IDK man, something makes me feel like this was not remotely a proportional response to teens being teens and there were a lot of better ways to try and handle this before making a family homeless… I’ve been a wayward youth of divorce and making friends with your neighbors and learning not to shit where you eat so to speak is a very important life skill they clearly needed help with.

OOP: Did you read the first post? At all? We tried to talk to the mom first. Multiple times. Someone urinated next to our car, on video, four feet from our front door. Screaming at 2am on a weeknight. Then they broke into our back patio by busting our fence down and that was the last straw. We tried for months not to go nuclear. At a certain point it goes from “being a patient neighbor” to “being a doormat.”

Commenter 2: Fair outcome, you didn’t get them evicted; their repeated choices did. Hopefully it’s a wake-up call, because ignoring warnings, breaking the lease, and not paying rent is a disaster recipe no family can outrun.

OOP: Like I said in the first post we really tried to talk things out with the mom first. Several times. My husband grew up bouncing around bc the people in his family didn’t know how to act, and that’s not something I want for any kid.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

Teenagers pushed us too far and probably got their family evicted.

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/MortynMurphy

Originally posted to r/neighborsfromhell

Teenagers pushed us too far and probably got their family evicted.

Trigger Warnings:

spoiler

destruction of property


Original Post: May 24, 2026

I try to be a polite neighbor. You’re not going to see me often and I won’t seek out conversation, but when new neighbors move in, I will go and introduce myself and offer mine and my spouse’s phone number. This is a nice neighborhood, it’s completely normal to give Christmas baskets or let someone’s dog out if they need it, stuff we did for our previous next door neighbors. No one would complain about a random party on a holiday weekend, I won’t be bothered by your kids playing loudly on the sidewalk, people behave but aren’t unreasonable about expectations. Especially since we live in townhouses that are all connected, there’s just no way to eliminate all neighbor noise. All this to say that I don’t think we have unreasonable community expectations.

Since these new neighbors moved in the vacant rental next to ours we have had nothing but trouble. They have only been here a couple of months, but they are the second-worst neighbors we have ever had. The absolute worst was a couple at our first apartment who resolved conflicts via fisticuffs.

The first annoyance was a normal one. Their bass was too loud through the walls, a common problem since people aren’t aware of how thin the walls are. (We did the same thing. Our previous neighbors texted, we apologized and adjusted settings, confirmed they couldn’t hear it anymore, and all was well.) We work from home and needed to be in meetings, so we went over to ask them to turn it down and no one answered. Finally we texted the mother, and the music only happened in late afternoon between the time when her kids would get home from school and when she would get home from work. Since it was a couple of hours maximum we let it go and didn’t schedule any meetings during those times. We were kids once, too.

Then Spring Break happened. Either the mother works both days and nights or simply spends 18 out of 24 hours outside the house. Twice in one night my husband had to sternly tell her daughters’ friends to stop looking in our cars, leaning on our cars, and screaming after midnight. Five feet from our front door, by the way.

Then the next night we catch them doing it AGAIN! My husband opens the door to one of the drunk little idiots *popping a squat and pissing less than a foot from our car!* My husband, being a reasonable man, starts yelling angrily at them for PISSING IN FRONT OF OUR DOOR. The hooligan closest to sober remembered basic survival instincts and began wrangling the rest of them into the house, apologizing sloppily but profusely. Apparently a very angry, very big, very bearded man yelling will do that to ya.

Later we have yet another text exchange with the mother. We make our stance known and I’m quite proud of myself for keeping my temper in check. She said she will handle it and we end the conversation on good terms. Even then we were willing to try and be nice and give them another chance. We were little asshole teens once and chalked it up to the high of spring break. We hosed off the pavement and tried to generate a level of patience hitherto unforeseen in either of us.

We had about a week of peace, but the good times couldn’t last. The teen girls have developed a small collective of devoted derelict boys who hang around outside their house several afternoons a week. They once again leaned on our cars, looked into our cars, and were little assholes when my husband came outside. They tried to mouth off but when he asked them to repeat themselves they scuttled down the sidewalk. Rinse and repeat for a couple of weeks.

That brings us to last night. We’re fun and exciting people, so we were idly scrolling our phones while watching something. Suddenly there was a loud *bang!* and we noticed a phone flashlight on our back patio. They had **broken through our fence** and were scrambling for a way out. We hear/vaguely see whoever it is crash through our garbage cans on the other side. His options were either to run that course, risk the 10+ft drop into woods, or escalate to breaking and entering in a state where he would have probably become a statistic.

In an obviously rare moment of intelligence, he chose the first option. The whole thing freaks us the hell out, and by the time we get our heads on right and go out front we see those same goddamn teens scattering through the neighborhood like mice. One of them didn’t get far enough away and tried to casually act like he was just walking by, but when we confronted him he was clearly rattled. We weren’t about to detain a child because we’re not psychotic, so we let him go. He scampered off to wherever little shits go when they’re not ruining everyone’s evening.

The neighbor on the other side of the Problem House had someone break into their back area as well going the opposite direction, and I panicked. I reached out to the mom, convinced her daughters may have been hurt or they were robbed. She brushed me off and got a little rude when I told her the trespassers had definitely come from her house and that every other neighbor said the same thing.

That is until a random “uncle” appeared, driven home by someone else. He listened to us and fed us the usual bullshit people do when they don’t want to deal with anything. Lots of empty apologies and excuses for why the kids are alone. But apparently he told the mom that four adults were all saying the same thing: The working theory is that the boyfriends somehow knew an adult was coming back (probably location sharing) so they panicked and left out the back.

The mom tried to walk back her attitude and apologized after hearing how many witnesses there were, but I am not very forgiving once I’m at a certain point. It’s something I’m working on. I did not accept her apology. Later when we reviewed our camera footage from the whole night, we saw the same little shit we stopped go into her house with the others about an hour before they trespassed. The same little shits *come back later after the trespassing* and lean on our cars, climb on our cars, and film themselves lip synching for whatever reason. So we decided to go nuclear. To quote the certified BadAss™ Cobra Bubbles, “thus far you have been adrift in the sheltered harbor of my patience.”

Mommy Dearest had no way of knowing this, but the neighbors we were friendly with that had lived there before? They were very good friends with the homeowner. It was very easy to get his number from them, text him, and bing bang boom suddenly my husband is on the phone with a very embarrassed guy whose apologies were much more coherent than piss-girl’s friend. He was really very appreciative of the Google drive link with video of every single issue we have had (a few I’ve left out just to save space). Complete with time stamps! The other neighbors got his phone number as well. We learned some interesting info from him. The mom gave us a different name than the one he had, there were only supposed to be two people total living there (we see five or more living there regularly), other fun things I’ll leave to your vivid imaginations. Needless to say, they’re in violation of their lease with just this. But one thing my husband and I have in common is that we are very thorough.

So the next step was the police report. Did you know that in my state you can file a non-emergency report online for things like someone on your back porch late at night or people casing your car? It’s really very easy! Our HOA isn’t open until Monday (edit, sorry, Tuesday!) but they had a nice little contact page we filled out. The other neighbors also filed reports and contacted the HOA. However bad my Saturday night was, I think their upcoming week might be worse.

My husband informed the mother via text of all the steps we had taken and that our cameras are always on, front and back. She has been silent and absent from the home since I did not accept her apology last night and laid out exactly how much trouble her kids have been when she’s not around (which is always). Not sure what will happen next, a little concerned about retaliation from the little dingleberries. But now we have a paper trail, an immediate line of communication to the landlord, and they’re aware they’ve been being recorded the entire time. Any escalation beyond this is their choice. ETA that I don’t think the eviction is in motion yet or anything at all. I don’t know anything other than they are in direct violation of their lease in multiple ways, and that in my state that’s a wrap on your tenancy.

TLDR: Turns out, being a little asshole, having little assholes over as guests, and your little asshole guests trespassing late at night is in violation of most lease contracts. Maybe don’t case cars and break fences while you trespass in the era of home cameras. And maybe consider for a brief moment that your neighbors might just have your landlord’s personal phone number.

Update #1 05/25/2026: the mom finally came home at around 2:30 in the morning with a literal warehouse of younger kids. She put them in the house and then left herself in a different car that was there to pick her up. The uncle or whoever he was is at the house with the new set of kids and we saw no sign of Shitlings & Co last night. My husband thinks the mom and older teenagers are avoiding their own house since we’ve now taken to sitting on our porches.

Update #2 05/26/2026: I have had terrible insomnia for the past two nights since getting the shit scared out of me by the trespassing. I have confirmed with a couple of other neighbors that they contacted the HOA, owner, and filed a police report for a missing Apple Watch from one of their cars for the same night. They said they would, but it was nice to get the confirmation and vent to each other. If the kids choose to retaliate they would have to target multiple people, all of whom have cameras. Still no sign of Shitlings & Co, normally a day off school summons them like maggots to a carcass. Our front camera is not in an obvious spot, so my husband thinks it might have freaked them out to learn they’d been being recorded the whole time. I’m so angry I want to go piss next to *her* driver’s side door. But that would technically be right next to my car again, and that would be counterintuitive.

Update #3 06/01/2026: Still no sign of Shitlings & Co. They haven’t shown themselves since the night they broke our fence down. Our cars and property have been left alone entirely, but the neighbors on the other side of the NFH asked for some camera footage since they woke up to some gas missing out of their car during the week. Then they asked for footage again on Thursday, since some *other* kids staying at the NFH were climbing all the way on the roof and hood of her car and the camera they ordered hadn’t gotten here yet. She was *heated* and came out yelling at them because her roof is now dented, the adults came rushing out to usher the kids inside for only a minute, and then the whole crowd bundled up into their cars and left. I think they know they’re on thin ice. I wasn’t part of this confrontation, I heard about it/saw it on my cameras later when she asked for the footage. Idk what her next steps will be, I would want my roof repair paid for, but I also understand not wanting to deal with them in that way.

The landlord had a meeting scheduled with the mother that he called a “walkthrough and HOA citation review” for noon on Sat, 05/30. She claimed a family emergency and asked to push it back until Sunday at noon. Then she asked to push it back until 5. The landlord was openly irritated by the third rescheduling. He offered this information by the way, we did not ask. The landlord ended yesterday by reporting he had told the mom “what her options were going forward.” What those options entail, he did not say. It has been eerily quiet since yesterday evening when we told us that. I don’t want to speculate since I genuinely have no information beyond this. All I know is I heard vacuuming and cleaning for a while on Sunday, (normal amount for landlord visit in my opinion) and then absolute silence.

I hope this is concluded, but based on my experience with teenagers like Shitlings & Co they tend to forget lessons pretty quick. Hopefully the landlord and whatever he said helped the neighbors understand the precarious position their teenagers’ “friends” put them in.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: They didn’t get evicted because of one mistake, they got evicted because they treated the neighborhood like a free trial for bad decisions

OOP: I don’t know if the eviction is actually in motion yet or what, but based on how upset the landlord was I would be shocked if they are here next month.

Commenter 2: The month changes in a few days. You will know IF the landlord takes the rent, your next-door jerks are staying. I hope NOT. But landlords and a chance to increase rent for more tenants that are already there, is hard to pass up!

OOP: You’ll be happy to hear he’s not our landlord! It won’t affect our monthly budget in any way if they are evicted.

OOP explains more about the violations of a lease in their state

OOP: In our state, violating a lease is curtains on your tenancy unless you have a particularly patient landlord. That doesn’t happen often. And HOAs are particularly powerful here, they can fine the owner into oblivion for the tenant not following community guidelines while evicting the tenant themselves. They only allow renters that follow community guidelines, full stop. Considering their office is going to open up this week to multiple complaints about one family, I’m hopeful.

So between all the lease violations and not following HOA guidelines (which also violated their contract), the landlord might actually have to evict them if he wants to keep being able to rent out his place at all.

+

Between that, the trespassing, the payment problems the landlord said he’s been having, the pee incident, and all the videos of these incidents we sent, he said he’s pulling out all the stops. We may get to see a show starring the Sheriff’s department at the end of the month!

+

In my state violating your lease contract, which they have in at least five ways we know of, is enough for the landlord to evict ASAP at the end of the paid month. They also have been having payment problems. We live in one of the worst states for tenant’s rights.

Commenter 3: Eviction is a process and at the very least, requires 30 day notice. If the tenant only has a few months left on their lease, the landlord may just let the lease run out, and not renew it. Giving these people 30 days to pack up and get out, may makes things worse

OOP: Not in my state baybeeee! The one time being one of the lowest ranked states for tenant rights is working in our favor. Tenants can be booted out in 72hrs if the landlord can prove it’s for good reasons. Given all the stuff we’ve handed to him I think he’s got a good chance. On top of that the HOA is about to unleash a shit storm, and has the power to evict the tenants themselves in our state. Ours is very reasonable about plants, decorations, door color, etc., but they come down hard on shit like this.

Why didn’t OOP call the police from the beginning?

OOP: Because I live in a state where it was more likely those kids would become a hashtag and a headline if we did. And while I’m pissed off, they weren’t violent and I don’t think that would have been the safest escalation for anybody. They have been told that we will call the cops if we see their friends near our property again, though.

Commenter 4: Eviction takes a long time. Watch yourself take care.

OOP: We have taken precautions. They know they’re being filmed now. We also don’t live in a state where tenants get a lot of rights, and our HOA only allows tenants if they follow community guidelines. Between footage of them violating both their lease and the community guidelines (which also violated their lease), I’m pretty hopeful they won’t be in our hair much longer.

Commenter 5: I would have called the cops for underage drinking. Probably would have saved you a lot of headaches while causing a lot of legal headaches for the tenant and landlord.

OOP: That was our first thought as well, but for that to work we would have to have a single cop around here that didn’t start drinking in their teens and wouldn’t be delighted to overreact to some stupid kids. Now that we’ve had our property actually trespassed on, we’ll be calling the cops immediately next time something happens.

Has OOP dealt with similar situations like that with any other teenagers?

OOP: We had a nice lovely neighborhood for the four years we’ve lived here. There are some other teens that live on the other side of the neighborhood that genuinely just do kid stuff like riding their bikes around and playing basketball after school, filming TikToks together down by our little park area, just normal stuff. The only time I’ve had to say anything was when I was in a meeting working from home and they were squealing a bit loud. I popped my head out and said I was working from home and asked if they could keep it down until I got out of my meeting. They were polite, apologized, and didn’t resume whatever they were doing until after the time had passed. I even told their mom when I saw her how much I appreciated her kids just being chill and respectful about it, I didn’t mind them playing I just needed to be able to hear my meeting. Those kids don’t come over to our side anymore because of the little assholes we live next to.

 

Update: July 14, 2026 (over one month later from Update #3 in the original post)

UPDATE: Teenagers pushed us too far and probably (definitely) got their family evicted.

Thankfully the conclusion to this whole situation is not dramatic!

After we went nuclear, we had absolutely no issues except for the couple of things from the small updates on the last post. After the first weekend of June we barely even saw signs of human life. If it hadn’t been for the car appearing and disappearing, I would have thought they had already been kicked out. I’m not sure what happened inside, but the only activity was a U-haul parked there on and off over a couple of days a couple weeks ago. We have not seen either of the teenage girls since the landlord meeting. I know that my own mother would have tied me up like a pretzel and shipped me off to Camp Greenlake to dig holes for a year. Shitlings & Co disappeared off the face of the Earth for a couple of weeks, although we did see a couple of them walking back from a nearby gas station a few days ago so they’re clearly still around the neighborhood. I guess doing TikTok dances on the hoods of the neighbors’ cars, breaking down fences, and ultimately helping get her family evicted is not a good way to keep your girl interested. Young love is tough that way.

Today (ETA; yesterday, I wrote this late last night) the landlord came by to ask how things have been and to let us know they were officially evicted a couple of weeks ago. They had been having payment problems as well. Both us and the neighbors on the other side of the problem house submitted HOA complaints and police reports that helped him push things along and he seemed to really appreciate it. The power of documentation once again proves itself.

I’m personally a bit conflicted now that the anger from my first post has cooled off a bit. To reiterate, we never had a problem with regular neighbor noise and would never have complained about that. We want kids to play on our sidewalk, we want friends to chat in the parking lot, we don’t care if you have a party on the weekend. Pissing drunk next to my car, screaming outside our bedroom windows at 2am on a weeknight, blasting bass hard enough to rattle the pictures on my walls, and breaking into our back patio area late at night do not fall under “normal neighbor noise and activities.”

On one hand, life is already hard for a single parent, and I wish that we could have worked things out between us as neighbors without getting all litigious. But on the other hand we did try talking it out between adults first. And maybe don’t piss off your neighbors, violate your lease, AND not pay rent. Hopefully they found a place that works for them, and I hope those kids don’t keep making their mom’s life hard.

TLDR: They’re evicted, have been for a couple weeks. We suspected as much after seeing them pack a U-haul, but otherwise wanted to mind our own business and be done with the situation. Landlord came by to confirm and say thanks earlier today.

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: Happy for you, though I don’t think a good landlord should provide that kind of specific information (specifically that they were having payment issues.) Also, I’m betting if they had paid they’d still be your problem, it wasn’t the disturbance that caused the eviction.

OOP: Oh I agree with you entirely on the information part. Not so sure about the second point, in our state HOAs are very powerful and violating HOA guidelines is a good way to get renting banned from the neighborhood.

Downvoted Commenter: ooooof, struggling single mom with teens that are hard to control while working 2 or more jobs at odd hours… That eviction could legitimately ruin her life. IDK man, something makes me feel like this was not remotely a proportional response to teens being teens and there were a lot of better ways to try and handle this before making a family homeless… I’ve been a wayward youth of divorce and making friends with your neighbors and learning not to shit where you eat so to speak is a very important life skill they clearly needed help with.

OOP: Did you read the first post? At all? We tried to talk to the mom first. Multiple times. Someone urinated next to our car, on video, four feet from our front door. Screaming at 2am on a weeknight. Then they broke into our back patio by busting our fence down and that was the last straw. We tried for months not to go nuclear. At a certain point it goes from “being a patient neighbor” to “being a doormat.”

Commenter 2: Fair outcome, you didn’t get them evicted; their repeated choices did. Hopefully it’s a wake-up call, because ignoring warnings, breaking the lease, and not paying rent is a disaster recipe no family can outrun.

OOP: Like I said in the first post we really tried to talk things out with the mom first. Several times. My husband grew up bouncing around bc the people in his family didn’t know how to act, and that’s not something I want for any kid.

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

0

[Final Update]: AITAH for making my husband's groomswoman wear a wig or be disinvited from our wedding? [Reddit]

preview

[Final Update]: AITAH for making my husband’s groomswoman wear a wig or be disinvited from our wedding?

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/Throwaway09Acc

Originally posted to r/AITAH

Previous BoRUs: #1

[Final Update]: AITAH for making my husband’s groomswoman wear a wig or be disinvited from our wedding?

Thanks to u/soayherder & u/Direct-Caterpillar77 for suggesting this BoRU

Editor’s note: added paragraph breaks for readability*

Trigger Warnings:

spoiler

accusations of infidelity, mental health issues, stalking / harassment, mentions miscarriages


RECAP

Original Post: November 1, 2024

My boyfriend (now fiancé) asked me to marry him 2 months ago. To give a little background, I met him at a farmer’s market when I was 18 and he was 26, we are now 24F and 32M. We’ve been together for a little bit over 5 years, and I’m very happy with him.

Now, to the story, my fiancé’s friend, Brittany, has been friends with him since they were in elementary school. Throughout our early dating days, I expressed I was not a fan of this woman. There are many reasons as to why, such as us not having common interests and absolutely polar opposite moral codes, but the main one was her interest in embarrassing me and my fiancé, possibly because she likes him.

When we were first starting to go on dates, she had shown up and tried to invite herself to the date because he had told their mutual friend group chat where he was taking me. She then decided that she would go to the same restaurant, and had tried to make a scene about him cheating on her and that she was heartbroken. It escalated very quickly and it ended with me asking the manager to get her trespassed, as she was delusional and I, nor my date, did not want her around. This sort of situation happened 3 more times, even going as far as showing up to his grandparent’s house to stop me from meeting his family.

At that point, I made it clear to him that if anything like that were to happen again, I’d be out of there. Which he completely understood and agreed with me, wholeheartedly. He convinced his friend group to go low communication about Brittany with him because she was acting weird around him and they all understood and disagreed with her actions. He had extremely low contact after that point, and I learned years later that she had gotten major therapy, even checked herself into a mental hospital, and went on medication to stop these absolutely unhinged personality traits.

Around 4 years later, they reconnected through a mutual friend’s birthday party we were all at and she genuinely seemed like she had changed personality-wise from the person I had met 5ish years ago. We still didn’t agree on most things, but she apologized for the way she had acted previously and owned up to all the BS she tried to pull with him. So, I just kept my guard up, but encouraged my fiancé to make friends with her again. I’m NOT friends with her, but I am friendly towards her.

Skipping to now, I have been planning this wedding basically since I was born (overexaggerating, but it has been in my thoughts since I was a young child). The wedding will not happen for another two years. The theme is supposed to be similar to DnD style fantasy. A Renaissance wedding with blue, orange, and red as the basic color scheme.

Most of the wedding would be held outside at a local state park, but part of it would be held inside. Specifically, the cake and food would be cut and served inside, as well as some of the guest photos. This is the important part. I have a personal friend, Bri (28F) who does professional pictures at Renaissance festivals across the US. Her job is to drive around across the country to Ren fairs and take pictures for certain venues. It’s a very cool job, and I love seeing the pictures. However, she does editing for some of these venues with a green screen to make it look more “aesthetic” or to totally change the scenery behind the people in the photo.

For example, she showed me mock ups for me in the past, showing silly people in costumes being chased by goblins and trolls, a dragon breathing fire behind a party of knights, and even a garden of lights with Faeries flying through it, etc. It’s silly stuff and is for people to have fun with. My idea was to incorporate this into my wedding.

The guests would choose whatever background they’d like from a catalog that my friend and I put together, and Bri or her teammate would take pictures of them throughout the day. These pictures would be uploaded electronically and then be edited by her after the wedding. These were mandatory for all guests that wanted to participate, so I could use the pictures for post cards and scrapbooking (It’s my hobby).

The people who wanted to take part in this activity would have to check a box on the save the date form I sent out. My assumption is that most guests would be doing this, as most of the people that will be invited are extremely rambunctious and love activities involving being silly.

I do want to make it clear, these would not be the only pictures taken at the wedding. There still would be normal pictures being taken of the wedding itself, as well as photos that will likely be framed and used as decorations that would have NO green screen of my husband and I, and the wedding party.

A few days after he had proposed, my fiancé asked me if I’d feel comfortable with him inviting Brittany to the wedding as a groomswoman. Honestly, I was fine with it. Until the topic of her hair came up. In the year or so that he had reconnected, she cut and dyed her hair a lime green with a cool undertone and highlights. I honestly really like it, and it suits her facial structure extremely well.

However, I was worried about the green screen and her hair, so I invited her to my friend’s home awhile later so we could see if the screen would blend with her hair. Unfortunately, it did. In the pictures, you could see a major “glitch” with every background we tried because of her hair.

I asked my friend if there was a way to edit around it, and she said there was, but it would be an extra amount of money because it would be way, way more time to go through and possibly edit multiple photos of her with groups of people and herself so the picture wouldn’t glitch. I’m very against this, as our budget has to be semi-perfect. We are accounting for accidents and issues, but not extra money to my friend’s business because of one woman’s choice of dye blending very well with the green screen.

While I do love her hair, I asked if she’d wear a wig to the wedding so she could still be included in the green screen pictures, even offered to get it professionally done and I’d pay for that. This is when she became very angry with me. To sum up what she had said, her being asked to wear a wig was basically me saying I wanted to cover her “self”. That her hair was an expression of herself and that she loved it. I told her that I loved it as well, but in order for her to be included, she would need to wear a wig, as the green in her hair cannot just be covered up via a hat or other headwear. She has been saying that I just don’t want to include her in the wedding.

As a compromise against the wig, I proposed that she gets more pictures of her having fun taken at the wedding itself, instead of the green screen. She didn’t like this idea because she claims it isn’t fair all the other guests get to be put in a fun picture and she’s the only one not allowed. Though I sort of agree with her, it isn’t to the fault of my own. So, I offered that she paid for the extra editing costs it would be to take and edit more of her pictures.

At first, she was fine with the idea. Until I mentioned that the extra editing would cost around $100 for just a singular picture to be taken and edited by my friend, and the final price depended on how many photos she ended up in on the greenscreen. Then, she declined the offer and tried to throw it in my face that Bri’s prices were outrageous. I disagreed with her sentiment about the prices, and I haven’t spoken to her since then.

Throughout this whole ordeal, my fiancé has been on my side, but he has been upset over her possibly not being there. While he does agree with me about not wanting to pay more for just her, as well as that she’s being overdramatic, he has sympathy for her being the only person being left out of this choice activity. While I also have sympathy, I just don’t see an alternative here. We can’t use a blue screen over a green screen because the colors of the wedding are blue, red, and orange. And, I don’t wish to pay for a new screen for my friend’s business just because of one person. And the alternatives I have come up with, she has shot down.

So, my final decision was to ask him to disinvite her from the wedding to not create further drama, if she does not want to wear a wig. After long talks between us, he agreed with me and sent her a message that she would be disinvited entirely and would be welcome to celebrate with just us, after our honeymoon had ended. They met up soon afterwards and he stayed firm on the matter, despite her crying and still refusing to do anything to correct her hair. She still believes that me asking her to do this is because of some power imbalance and that I just want to bully her, which I don’t think I’m doing. She has a year to think it over.

I can tell this situation bothers him though, and I’ve addressed it a few times. All of the times I have, he says it is for the best, as she would just ruin the photos she was in with the green screen and could cost us to delete hundreds of pictures, purely based on her actions.

I agree, but it still bothers me that I’m doing something wrong.

Especially since after this incident, her mom and dad have reached out to me to scold me for abusing my power against their daughter on one of the biggest parties she’s ever been invited to. Even my friends are split on the issue, all of them having sympathy for her but some of them saying I’m an AH because I won’t just let her come to the wedding and have someone to block her from taking any pictures with the green screen.

And, just to make sure the record is straight, I am not trying to force her to change her hair in any way. I do not want her to dye it differently, nor would I expect her to. I purely just want a non-green wig to be put on her head for the wedding and then she can remove it afterwards. I would normally say that she could remove it after the greenscreen portion, but I’m still working out if I’m just going to let it stay up for the entire day of the wedding, or if I’m going to hold other activities for everyone and have Bri close the photo stuff down. Again, wedding isn’t for another two years, so I’m able to think it over for at least a year.

I dunno, am I the asshole?

TL;DR: My husband’s groomswoman won’t wear a wig for my wedding due to her believing it is her sense of pride. While I do like her hair, she could potentially ruin pictures of a greenscreen photo op activity I will be having at my wedding, costing us more than $1000 for pictures I cannot use, and even more money if I got her Photoshopped out or blended in with the background. All other alternatives given to her have been denied. This has caused my husband to give her an ultimatum where he outlines that she will be uninvited if she does not agree to the terms within a year. Am I the AH for this?

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP received mixed reactions

OOP responds to multiple comments regarding the photo booth and background

OOP: I will add some context to that, as I thought I made it clear, but apparently not. The activity with the greenscreen is open to be used by everyone that signed up for it (mostly so I can get an accurate number of people that will have multiple pictures taken of them). I would encourage them to do it in groups, so if one person’s hair is making it glitch, and you have multiple people in a picture, it turns into a more than just $100 venture, it turns into $1000s of dollars that I simply do not have. Bri told me that the total price could potentially quadruple the price I’m willing to pay because it would take hours to photoshop every single picture Brittany is in.

this woman as a guest was always an option, but they decided to invite her to be more than that, and are now reneging because of hair.

Guests are welcome to the greenscreen too, that is why uninviting her was on the plate because if she doesn’t want to be left out of a portion of the wedding, then how else would I get her to not take pictures with other people with the greenscreen?

OOP on Brittany’s green dyed hair situation

OOP: I didn’t mention this only because I was already typing a lot, and forgot to add it, but she has more appointments booked to get her hair touched up with more green coloring in the next 2 years because of the fading that color like that does.

I only recently found out this information from my fiancé before we decided to tell her about the issue.

If her hair isn’t green for whatever reason in a year, or she changes her mind about not minding that she isn’t allowed to be in the greenscreen pictures, I’m sure something could work out differently and that wouldn’t affect much at all.

+

So the easiest solution would be for her to just not be in those photos, right?

This is correct and I agree with you. The issue is that I’m being made into the bad guy because she doesn’t want to be left out of 1 of the 4 big activities I have ideas for the wedding. I didn’t include all the other stuff because I wasn’t trying to pile on about how badly she’s taking this, as the post is already very long. But, she’s yelled at me, cried, called my fiancé 33 times while he was at work, and more. All because I can’t fix that she physically cannot be in greenscreen pictures without ruining them because I do not want to afford a major increase on my spending.

I don’t get why OP is jumping to uninviting her over the much simpler “I’m sorry we can’t afford the extra to accommodate your hair colour for those pictures, if you won’t pay or wear a wig then you won’t be in them.”

A lot of people keep saying this and I think I should have made it more clear.

We didn’t uninvite her, technically. The conversation between her and my fiancé was more similar to(to the best recollection of his memory):

Fiancé: “We need to talk about your antics ever since OP told you that you couldn’t be in the green screen pictures.”

Brittany: “Okay, I was going to bring it up to you, but I thought you’d make the better choice once we got to talk in person.”

Fiancé: “I have decided that I don’t want you to be at my wedding if you won’t just choose how to temporarily alleviate the issues with the photo op and your hair.”

Brittany: “What? You would uninvite me over this? Why can’t she(me) just have her editor friend edit my pictures, so my hair doesn’t get cropped out and ruin the look of the pictures?”

Fiancé: “Because it costs a lot more for Bri to spend 4-5 hours on each photo (over exaggeration on his part) to individually and manually put your hair back to normal. There’s a long process involved and she charges by the hour for editing like that. We’re already paying a lot for wedding photos because OP and I want to use them for years to come, and we can’t afford another large sum of money for Photoshop editing added to the 1200 photo package. Even if sent them digitally to a different editor, than Bri, we’d still be looking at an additional $1000 tacked onto it.”

Brittany: starts crying “I thought you wanted me at your wedding, and wanted my niece to be the ring bearer. I want to be in those photos because they look like so much fun. She just doesn’t want me there, so she’s saying I can’t come, all because I just want to be included with everyone else for the photo op. I just don’t understand why you won’t pay the $1000 and be done with it. You make a lot of money, and so does she.”

Fiancé: “Your sister agrees with OP and I about this topic. She thinks you’re being ridiculous and dying on the wrong hill. Your niece is still on the table to be the ringbearer, even though we’ve never explicitly said so, just asked her mom if she could do that without getting too nervous in front of all the people. Either way, it doesn’t matter. I would like you to be there, but if you’re going to make being in the photo op your hill, I’m not going to tolerate it. I do not want you ruining my wedding because you decided to throw a fit, while you’re there, that you can’t be in the photo op. Or, worse, you photo-bomb pictures so you can be in them. OP has made it clear on the outcomes of the photos to you. You look like you are bald, and you block pieces of people behind you because of your hair. Unfortunately, that means you can’t be included because we are paying per photo, not for the time.”

Brittany: starts getting a little hysterical and then stands up “Fine, if you’re not going to let my hair be the way it is, I’m just not going to go. I want to be in the photo op. I don’t understand why you can’t pay for the extra editing costs for me because I’m your oldest friend. We have been together since we were 4 and 5, I just don’t understand why you’d choose that woman(me) over me in this situation. She is abusing her power. She doesn’t understand that the photo op is a major part of the wedding (it isn’t, it’s just an activity) and she is not including me in it.”

I didn’t know this part happened until I was typing this comment with my fiancé but here is some added dialog

Fiancé: “Okay, Brittany. In that case, if you won’t fix this situation, whether it be to just not participate in the photo op or wear a wig/cover your hair, I don’t want you there to cause drama. If you do decide to change it in the next year before we have to book the exact amount of people for the venue, you are more than welcome to be there as a guest, but I do not want you as a groomswoman anymore. You’ve made me uncomfortable with how you’re treating my future wife, and your endless barrage of insults towards her is not going to be tolerated. You have insulted her, so you have insulted me. I believed you had changed for the better, but I was wrong. The only reason your invite even still stands, with conditions, is because your family is very dear to me, and I love your sister like a daughter.”

She starts crying hysterically and tries to grab him by the sleeve, but he pulls away, gets up from the bar, and walks out of the restaurant.

So, yeah, that’s the entire conversation to the best of my fiancé’s ability. Basically, she’s being incredibly difficult and stubborn over wanting us to pay $1000+ for extra editing because she knows we have the money, we just don’t want to pay it only for her.

Honestly, if the situation was different, I would have been persuaded to pay half of the cost of the editing and just taken the loss on the photos she happened to be in. I would have done that as the last compromise, over just covering her head temporarily. But with her constant insults, endless barrage of complaints that aren’t related to this post, and her being extremely rude to me and my partner about the wedding photos… It just isn’t in the cards for me now.

 

Update #1: November 7, 2024 (six days later)

I honestly didn’t think I’d post an update at all this year because I mostly got the confirmation I needed to know I was mostly correct in my assumption that she’d cause more drama at the wedding than necessary, and that I’d be correct in that I would be okay to disinvite her. I was trying to be detailed in that post, but in this one I’m going to be a little less detailed.

Basically, 3 days ago, I was sent my post on messenger from Brittany. She is a notorious Reddit lurker, apparently, and saw it a few hours after it was posted. It didn’t even have to get multiple upvotes because she just reads the ones available on the “recent” category. I told her I posted because I had a lot of inner conflict towards my involvement with my fiancé choosing to disinvite her if she can’t just make some form of sacrifice to not be in the green screen/wear a wig so she can be included. She got extremely mad at me. Called me names, threatened that I’d be sued for defamation, etc. This honestly just made me realize how little she actually changed. Of course, I showed my fiancé, and he was appalled at her actions. He said he was going to block her and did so that day, and so did I.

Yesterday, I woke up to 43 missed calls from a number I did not recognize, that ended up to be her and a dozen voicemails claiming that I was stealing my fiancé away from her again, that I had purposefully targeted her for just wanting to be included with everyone else, and so on. I do not know how she got my number, but I obviously blocked it.

After that, I reported her to the police on the non-emergency line because I didn’t know if I would be needing to fear for my safety. I’m really glad I did this. After my fiancé had left for work, she showed up to our home and knocked on the door. I cracked a window near the door and asked what she wanted. She said, whilst crying, that I needed to let her in the house because it was her right to be with my fiancé, not me. She started kicking at the door and I told her to knock it off.

Immediately, I just started dialing the non-emergency police number for my nearest precinct because I already knew what was happening in that moment, and I was supposed to be clocking in for work on my computer at that moment. I texted my boss and she excused my absence for the day as well. As I was doing this, I kept repeating, “Go away, I called the police, and I do not want you here. You are trespassing.” She was saying all kinds of things I don’t wish to repeat here, but the lesser of the things she was saying involved:

- Calling me a white r*cist pig (She is mixed race, and so am I)

- Saying she was 8months pregnant with my fiancé’s baby (there’s quite literally zero proof of this, including no baby bump, despite being a fairly thin woman)

- Screaming that she would take me to hell

- Trying to break my metal outside door, but instead hurting herself instead.

And so on.

Basically, she had a full-on meltdown. The police came, saw that was trying to break my door down, and immediately put her in cuffs and sat her down. She was claiming this was her house and that she’d lived there for 10 years, that I had broken in and locked her out, etc.

Of course, because of her psychotic appearance, I was questioned and once given the real story… As well as being able to provide proof that I was the owner of the home, she was taken to the police station. As far as I’m aware, she was booked for the night and was let go today. I did agree to a temporary no-contact order and my fiancé, and I are going to proceed with a permanent one.

Her parents called after they heard she was put in a holding cell, and apologized profusely. Apparently, Brittany had lied to them about the extent of her actions and downplayed a lot of it. On the exterior, she seemed fine and well-rounded. But, mentally, she had snapped again from not taking her meds for a year. She never told her parents this, just acted normally until one of her triggers came back; my fiancé. No, he didn’t do anything wrong, she just had a major trigger when it came to him because of a deeply obsessive personality disorder.

I wasn’t trying to air her dirty laundry about her medical history the last post, but she was diagnosed with BPD and a large handful of disorders caused by trauma she had endured in her childhood from her great grandfather. She’s an unhealthy person, and I regret even allowing her to have the notion that we had forgiven her for her past.

I’m pretty shaken from this ordeal… and I can’t believe this was all because of a god damn greenscreen and some pictures that were supposed to just be treated as silly holiday cards for my foreseeable future. This is making me rethink the idea altogether, to be completely honest. Maybe I’ll just rent an adult bouncy house because that seems more fun than green screened professional photography 😭.

Anyways, that’s the update. Thanks for reading and the advice I was given in the last post!

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: My god. I would LOVE to be as calm and collected as you. Teach me your ways! In all seriousness though, I hope you’re ok. Don’t let her get to you. Do your wedding the way you want! Wishing you all the very best xxxx

OOP: Oh I was NOT calm and collected, I was crying and feeling very scared. The ONLY reason I was able to make rational decisions is because I had mentally and physically prepared myself for another incident like this happening because I was a victim of a non-sexual assault during a break-in at my mom’s house when I was 14 and it made me terrified of not knowing what to do if an incident like this ever occurred again. I was acting on instinct.

Therapy and an incredible women’s defense coach got me to this point. I also live in Texas, so castle doctrine was on my side.

Commenter 2: This woman is an absolute lunatic. Make sure that you get a permanent restraining order. You should also consider security for your wedding venue because she’s more than likely going to show up and do something crazy again.

Good luck OP, you’re going to need it.

OOP: I already have security in the works that was unrelated to this incident… Now it’s a “for sure having a small security team!” 😅

Commenter 3: This situation isn’t about a green screen or pictures. It’s about an extremely unstable person refusing to follow their doctor’s orders. The hair and picture problems are, at best, the catalyst for her breakdown, but it most certainly isn’t the cause. It’s your and your fiancé’s day, so if y’all decide to do something other than the pictures go right ahead. However, I would hate for you to regret not doing it because of one nutball.

 


#----OLD NEW UPDATE----

Editor’s note: the final update is over a month old, and it has not been posted here onto the sub

Final Update: May 26, 2026 (over 18 months later from the first update)

Final update because I still occasionally get messages asking if the wedding ever happened and what ended up happening with Brittany.

My last update was posted back in November of 2024, so it’s been about a year and a half now. Honestly, I didn’t think I’d ever update again (×2) because after the police involvement and restraining order, I mostly just wanted to move on with my life and stop thinking about the situation entirely.

But a LOT has changed since then, and I was listening to a YouTuber read a story and it reminded me to check in with this account.

First off, I’m married! Just… not in the way we originally planned. After everything that happened with Brittany, the giant Renaissance/DnD wedding slowly stopped feeling exciting and started feeling exhausting. Even though my dad had a giant wedding like that, I started really evaluating if he wanted me to actually get married like him, or if he just wanted me to have a wonderful wedding and honeymoon.

Other things have now happened with my family. And I’m just over them, as well.

Between the police involvements this last year, changing routines, the restraining order process, and honestly just being stressed constantly for months afterward, planning this huge elaborate fantasy wedding stopped being fun.

Life sort of smacked us in the face in the best possible way, and it made it all worth it anyways. After a long line of pregnancy issues and basically accepting that I might never get pregnant, or at least bring a baby to term, I found out I was pregnant. The second I saw the positive test, something in my brain shifted from: “I want the biggest coolest fantasy wedding imaginable” to “I literally just want peace and happiness before this baby gets here.”

Instead, we ended up doing a much smaller “shotgun” winter wedding this past December with around 30 guests total, and about 60 people invited to the reception afterward. My husband’s family is massive, so that was genuinely about as much as we could shorten it without causing a civil war.

The entire aesthetic changed too.

Instead of the giant colorful Renaissance/DnD wedding, I ended up going with my secondary option that I had played with when I was originally planning the idea of a similar wedding to my dad’s. It was the idea of a snowy white wedding aesthetic from the ending of Nanny McPhee. Specifically the winter wedding at the very end of the movie. I have loved that scene since I was little and something about it always felt so magical and soft and romantic to me. My grandma also loves that movie. Every time we would watch it, she would cry. And then I would cry. She would point to the screen and say, “Look how beautiful she is.” With tears in her eyes. So that became the new inspiration.

I decided to change it due to the size difference. I felt that going all out with the bright colors was amazing, but that we could just invite family to a Renaissance festival, and we could all have fun there drinking themselves silly, instead.

Everyone wore white, silver, soft blues, etc. My dress had embroidered snowflakes all over it with tiny pearl details that made it look frosted over. It honestly looked like it had snow settled into the fabric. It reminded me so much of Evangeline’s dress from the movie and I was obsessed with it. Still am, I’m even planning to get a piece put into my wedding band.

I loved that wedding just as much as I loved the original fantasy one I had planned in my head for years.

It felt calmer. More intimate. Less of a giant party. More of a loving environment.

And, to anyone wondering, we did the greenscreen photo-op!

My friend Bri thought it would be hilarious after everything that happened, so instead of DnD backgrounds, she made a bunch of winter and Christmas themed backgrounds instead. I helped, of course. Snowy castles, Christmas villages, giant decorated trees, cheesy Hallmark-style edits, ice caves, etc. People absolutely LOVED it. And I LOVE the Christmas cards I got from it.

My uncle had himself into shielding himself from an army of snowmen with cannons, and one of my cousins made herself look like she was flying through a blizzard on a reindeer. It was genuinely one of the funniest parts of the reception.

So yes. After all of that insanity… the greenscreen survived.

As for Brittany, her parents were invited to the reception. I know some people will think that’s weird, but despite everything, my husband still cares about them a lot. They apologized to us multiple times after the incident happened and genuinely seemed devastated by the entire situation. None of this was really their fault.

While we were talking during the reception, they ended up telling us more about what happened after my last update.

Apparently, after Brittany was placed into long-term psychiatric treatment following the incident at our house, her parents ended up getting access to her phone because she obviously couldn’t keep it while institutionalized and they were trying to sort out her bills, work issues, etc.

And apparently that’s when they discovered she had been stalking my husband for years. Pictures of him leaving work. Pictures of him outside our old house. Pictures of him pumping gas. Pictures taken from inside her car while following him. Some were years old, during the time we had cut her out. And, some were recent (as of Dec 2025). Some of them had hearts drawn all over them.

One of them was photoshopped to make it look like she was naked and laying on top of him while he slept on our porch outside. Apparently she had entire folders dedicated to him on her phone. It was honestly one of the most disturbing things I have ever seen in my life.

Needless to say, a pretty significant amount of the money my dad left me for the original wedding ended up going toward buying a new house in a completely different area after all of that came out. After we found out about it, we decided our baby would be safer out of the old house.

I also want to give my husband a lot of credit throughout all of this because I genuinely do not think I could have handled this situation as gracefully as he did. This entire ordeal absolutely crushed him emotionally for a while. Despite everything Brittany did, he still cared about her as someone he had known since childhood, and I think realizing that the version of her he thought had “gotten better” wasn’t actually real really messed with him for a long time. At the same time though, he never once wavered when it came to protecting me, our home, or our relationship. The second things crossed the line into harassment and stalking, he completely cut contact, fully cooperated with the restraining order process, helped us move, got a better paying job in our new area, changed routines with me so I’d feel safer, and has honestly been my rock through all of it. Even now, I think part of him still mourns the loss of someone he thought was one of his oldest friends, but he also understands now that what she felt towards him was never a healthy friendship in the first place. Especially after seeing those pictures.

Legally speaking: We were granted a temporary restraining order a few months after my last update. That expired in January of last year and thankfully we have had absolutely zero contact since then. From what her parents told us, Brittany is still receiving psychiatric treatment and apparently still has not fully accepted reality regarding my husband. She still hasn’t come to understand she wasn’t dating my husband, and he has never claimed to want to be with her.

It’s sad. At this point, it really doesn’t feel like it is a Reddit post anymore. It mostly just feels like watching somebody completely destroy their own life because they refused help for too long. I don’t even know if she ever even took the medication she was prescribed or if they were just not working. In my non-professional opinion, she seems schizophrenic. I hope she gets genuine help where she is now, but I never want to see her again.

On a much happier note:

Our daughter is due in July.

Her name is going to be Caroline Evangeline.

And I genuinely cannot wait to meet her.

Thanks for reading.

TL;DR - We ended up cancelling the giant Renaissance/DnD wedding after everything with Brittany became emotionally exhausting, and after years of pregnancy issues, I unexpectedly got pregnant. We instead had a much smaller winter-themed wedding inspired by the ending of Nanny McPhee, complete with a Christmas-themed greenscreen photo-op that everyone loved. Brittany is currently still receiving psychiatric treatment after her parents discovered she had apparently been stalking my husband for years and keeping thousands of photos/edited images of him on her phone. Because of that, we moved to a completely different area using part of the wedding money my dad left me. Thankfully, we’ve had zero contact with her since the restraining order situation ended last year, and now we’re just focused on preparing for our daughter, Caroline Evangeline, to arrive in July.

Concluding Comments

Commenter: Congrats on the wedding and the baby, and I love the name.

OOP: I appreciate it! It comes from two of my favorite movies! Caroline (from Coraline) and Evangeline…You get it. Thank you!

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP

[Final Update]: AITAH for making my husband’s groomswoman wear a wig or be disinvited from our wedding?

I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/Throwaway09Acc

Originally posted to r/AITAH

Previous BoRUs: #1

[Final Update]: AITAH for making my husband’s groomswoman wear a wig or be disinvited from our wedding?

Thanks to u/soayherder & u/Direct-Caterpillar77 for suggesting this BoRU

Editor’s note: added paragraph breaks for readability*

Trigger Warnings:

spoiler

accusations of infidelity, mental health issues, stalking / harassment, mentions miscarriages


RECAP

Original Post: November 1, 2024

My boyfriend (now fiancé) asked me to marry him 2 months ago. To give a little background, I met him at a farmer’s market when I was 18 and he was 26, we are now 24F and 32M. We’ve been together for a little bit over 5 years, and I’m very happy with him.

Now, to the story, my fiancé’s friend, Brittany, has been friends with him since they were in elementary school. Throughout our early dating days, I expressed I was not a fan of this woman. There are many reasons as to why, such as us not having common interests and absolutely polar opposite moral codes, but the main one was her interest in embarrassing me and my fiancé, possibly because she likes him.

When we were first starting to go on dates, she had shown up and tried to invite herself to the date because he had told their mutual friend group chat where he was taking me. She then decided that she would go to the same restaurant, and had tried to make a scene about him cheating on her and that she was heartbroken. It escalated very quickly and it ended with me asking the manager to get her trespassed, as she was delusional and I, nor my date, did not want her around. This sort of situation happened 3 more times, even going as far as showing up to his grandparent’s house to stop me from meeting his family.

At that point, I made it clear to him that if anything like that were to happen again, I’d be out of there. Which he completely understood and agreed with me, wholeheartedly. He convinced his friend group to go low communication about Brittany with him because she was acting weird around him and they all understood and disagreed with her actions. He had extremely low contact after that point, and I learned years later that she had gotten major therapy, even checked herself into a mental hospital, and went on medication to stop these absolutely unhinged personality traits.

Around 4 years later, they reconnected through a mutual friend’s birthday party we were all at and she genuinely seemed like she had changed personality-wise from the person I had met 5ish years ago. We still didn’t agree on most things, but she apologized for the way she had acted previously and owned up to all the BS she tried to pull with him. So, I just kept my guard up, but encouraged my fiancé to make friends with her again. I’m NOT friends with her, but I am friendly towards her.

Skipping to now, I have been planning this wedding basically since I was born (overexaggerating, but it has been in my thoughts since I was a young child). The wedding will not happen for another two years. The theme is supposed to be similar to DnD style fantasy. A Renaissance wedding with blue, orange, and red as the basic color scheme.

Most of the wedding would be held outside at a local state park, but part of it would be held inside. Specifically, the cake and food would be cut and served inside, as well as some of the guest photos. This is the important part. I have a personal friend, Bri (28F) who does professional pictures at Renaissance festivals across the US. Her job is to drive around across the country to Ren fairs and take pictures for certain venues. It’s a very cool job, and I love seeing the pictures. However, she does editing for some of these venues with a green screen to make it look more “aesthetic” or to totally change the scenery behind the people in the photo.

For example, she showed me mock ups for me in the past, showing silly people in costumes being chased by goblins and trolls, a dragon breathing fire behind a party of knights, and even a garden of lights with Faeries flying through it, etc. It’s silly stuff and is for people to have fun with. My idea was to incorporate this into my wedding.

The guests would choose whatever background they’d like from a catalog that my friend and I put together, and Bri or her teammate would take pictures of them throughout the day. These pictures would be uploaded electronically and then be edited by her after the wedding. These were mandatory for all guests that wanted to participate, so I could use the pictures for post cards and scrapbooking (It’s my hobby).

The people who wanted to take part in this activity would have to check a box on the save the date form I sent out. My assumption is that most guests would be doing this, as most of the people that will be invited are extremely rambunctious and love activities involving being silly.

I do want to make it clear, these would not be the only pictures taken at the wedding. There still would be normal pictures being taken of the wedding itself, as well as photos that will likely be framed and used as decorations that would have NO green screen of my husband and I, and the wedding party.

A few days after he had proposed, my fiancé asked me if I’d feel comfortable with him inviting Brittany to the wedding as a groomswoman. Honestly, I was fine with it. Until the topic of her hair came up. In the year or so that he had reconnected, she cut and dyed her hair a lime green with a cool undertone and highlights. I honestly really like it, and it suits her facial structure extremely well.

However, I was worried about the green screen and her hair, so I invited her to my friend’s home awhile later so we could see if the screen would blend with her hair. Unfortunately, it did. In the pictures, you could see a major “glitch” with every background we tried because of her hair.

I asked my friend if there was a way to edit around it, and she said there was, but it would be an extra amount of money because it would be way, way more time to go through and possibly edit multiple photos of her with groups of people and herself so the picture wouldn’t glitch. I’m very against this, as our budget has to be semi-perfect. We are accounting for accidents and issues, but not extra money to my friend’s business because of one woman’s choice of dye blending very well with the green screen.

While I do love her hair, I asked if she’d wear a wig to the wedding so she could still be included in the green screen pictures, even offered to get it professionally done and I’d pay for that. This is when she became very angry with me. To sum up what she had said, her being asked to wear a wig was basically me saying I wanted to cover her “self”. That her hair was an expression of herself and that she loved it. I told her that I loved it as well, but in order for her to be included, she would need to wear a wig, as the green in her hair cannot just be covered up via a hat or other headwear. She has been saying that I just don’t want to include her in the wedding.

As a compromise against the wig, I proposed that she gets more pictures of her having fun taken at the wedding itself, instead of the green screen. She didn’t like this idea because she claims it isn’t fair all the other guests get to be put in a fun picture and she’s the only one not allowed. Though I sort of agree with her, it isn’t to the fault of my own. So, I offered that she paid for the extra editing costs it would be to take and edit more of her pictures.

At first, she was fine with the idea. Until I mentioned that the extra editing would cost around $100 for just a singular picture to be taken and edited by my friend, and the final price depended on how many photos she ended up in on the greenscreen. Then, she declined the offer and tried to throw it in my face that Bri’s prices were outrageous. I disagreed with her sentiment about the prices, and I haven’t spoken to her since then.

Throughout this whole ordeal, my fiancé has been on my side, but he has been upset over her possibly not being there. While he does agree with me about not wanting to pay more for just her, as well as that she’s being overdramatic, he has sympathy for her being the only person being left out of this choice activity. While I also have sympathy, I just don’t see an alternative here. We can’t use a blue screen over a green screen because the colors of the wedding are blue, red, and orange. And, I don’t wish to pay for a new screen for my friend’s business just because of one person. And the alternatives I have come up with, she has shot down.

So, my final decision was to ask him to disinvite her from the wedding to not create further drama, if she does not want to wear a wig. After long talks between us, he agreed with me and sent her a message that she would be disinvited entirely and would be welcome to celebrate with just us, after our honeymoon had ended. They met up soon afterwards and he stayed firm on the matter, despite her crying and still refusing to do anything to correct her hair. She still believes that me asking her to do this is because of some power imbalance and that I just want to bully her, which I don’t think I’m doing. She has a year to think it over.

I can tell this situation bothers him though, and I’ve addressed it a few times. All of the times I have, he says it is for the best, as she would just ruin the photos she was in with the green screen and could cost us to delete hundreds of pictures, purely based on her actions.

I agree, but it still bothers me that I’m doing something wrong.

Especially since after this incident, her mom and dad have reached out to me to scold me for abusing my power against their daughter on one of the biggest parties she’s ever been invited to. Even my friends are split on the issue, all of them having sympathy for her but some of them saying I’m an AH because I won’t just let her come to the wedding and have someone to block her from taking any pictures with the green screen.

And, just to make sure the record is straight, I am not trying to force her to change her hair in any way. I do not want her to dye it differently, nor would I expect her to. I purely just want a non-green wig to be put on her head for the wedding and then she can remove it afterwards. I would normally say that she could remove it after the greenscreen portion, but I’m still working out if I’m just going to let it stay up for the entire day of the wedding, or if I’m going to hold other activities for everyone and have Bri close the photo stuff down. Again, wedding isn’t for another two years, so I’m able to think it over for at least a year.

I dunno, am I the asshole?

TL;DR: My husband’s groomswoman won’t wear a wig for my wedding due to her believing it is her sense of pride. While I do like her hair, she could potentially ruin pictures of a greenscreen photo op activity I will be having at my wedding, costing us more than $1000 for pictures I cannot use, and even more money if I got her Photoshopped out or blended in with the background. All other alternatives given to her have been denied. This has caused my husband to give her an ultimatum where he outlines that she will be uninvited if she does not agree to the terms within a year. Am I the AH for this?

AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP received mixed reactions

OOP responds to multiple comments regarding the photo booth and background

OOP: I will add some context to that, as I thought I made it clear, but apparently not. The activity with the greenscreen is open to be used by everyone that signed up for it (mostly so I can get an accurate number of people that will have multiple pictures taken of them). I would encourage them to do it in groups, so if one person’s hair is making it glitch, and you have multiple people in a picture, it turns into a more than just $100 venture, it turns into $1000s of dollars that I simply do not have. Bri told me that the total price could potentially quadruple the price I’m willing to pay because it would take hours to photoshop every single picture Brittany is in.

this woman as a guest was always an option, but they decided to invite her to be more than that, and are now reneging because of hair.

Guests are welcome to the greenscreen too, that is why uninviting her was on the plate because if she doesn’t want to be left out of a portion of the wedding, then how else would I get her to not take pictures with other people with the greenscreen?

OOP on Brittany’s green dyed hair situation

OOP: I didn’t mention this only because I was already typing a lot, and forgot to add it, but she has more appointments booked to get her hair touched up with more green coloring in the next 2 years because of the fading that color like that does.

I only recently found out this information from my fiancé before we decided to tell her about the issue.

If her hair isn’t green for whatever reason in a year, or she changes her mind about not minding that she isn’t allowed to be in the greenscreen pictures, I’m sure something could work out differently and that wouldn’t affect much at all.

+

So the easiest solution would be for her to just not be in those photos, right?

This is correct and I agree with you. The issue is that I’m being made into the bad guy because she doesn’t want to be left out of 1 of the 4 big activities I have ideas for the wedding. I didn’t include all the other stuff because I wasn’t trying to pile on about how badly she’s taking this, as the post is already very long. But, she’s yelled at me, cried, called my fiancé 33 times while he was at work, and more. All because I can’t fix that she physically cannot be in greenscreen pictures without ruining them because I do not want to afford a major increase on my spending.

I don’t get why OP is jumping to uninviting her over the much simpler “I’m sorry we can’t afford the extra to accommodate your hair colour for those pictures, if you won’t pay or wear a wig then you won’t be in them.”

A lot of people keep saying this and I think I should have made it more clear.

We didn’t uninvite her, technically. The conversation between her and my fiancé was more similar to(to the best recollection of his memory):

Fiancé: “We need to talk about your antics ever since OP told you that you couldn’t be in the green screen pictures.”

Brittany: “Okay, I was going to bring it up to you, but I thought you’d make the better choice once we got to talk in person.”

Fiancé: “I have decided that I don’t want you to be at my wedding if you won’t just choose how to temporarily alleviate the issues with the photo op and your hair.”

Brittany: “What? You would uninvite me over this? Why can’t she(me) just have her editor friend edit my pictures, so my hair doesn’t get cropped out and ruin the look of the pictures?”

Fiancé: “Because it costs a lot more for Bri to spend 4-5 hours on each photo (over exaggeration on his part) to individually and manually put your hair back to normal. There’s a long process involved and she charges by the hour for editing like that. We’re already paying a lot for wedding photos because OP and I want to use them for years to come, and we can’t afford another large sum of money for Photoshop editing added to the 1200 photo package. Even if sent them digitally to a different editor, than Bri, we’d still be looking at an additional $1000 tacked onto it.”

Brittany: starts crying “I thought you wanted me at your wedding, and wanted my niece to be the ring bearer. I want to be in those photos because they look like so much fun. She just doesn’t want me there, so she’s saying I can’t come, all because I just want to be included with everyone else for the photo op. I just don’t understand why you won’t pay the $1000 and be done with it. You make a lot of money, and so does she.”

Fiancé: “Your sister agrees with OP and I about this topic. She thinks you’re being ridiculous and dying on the wrong hill. Your niece is still on the table to be the ringbearer, even though we’ve never explicitly said so, just asked her mom if she could do that without getting too nervous in front of all the people. Either way, it doesn’t matter. I would like you to be there, but if you’re going to make being in the photo op your hill, I’m not going to tolerate it. I do not want you ruining my wedding because you decided to throw a fit, while you’re there, that you can’t be in the photo op. Or, worse, you photo-bomb pictures so you can be in them. OP has made it clear on the outcomes of the photos to you. You look like you are bald, and you block pieces of people behind you because of your hair. Unfortunately, that means you can’t be included because we are paying per photo, not for the time.”

Brittany: starts getting a little hysterical and then stands up “Fine, if you’re not going to let my hair be the way it is, I’m just not going to go. I want to be in the photo op. I don’t understand why you can’t pay for the extra editing costs for me because I’m your oldest friend. We have been together since we were 4 and 5, I just don’t understand why you’d choose that woman(me) over me in this situation. She is abusing her power. She doesn’t understand that the photo op is a major part of the wedding (it isn’t, it’s just an activity) and she is not including me in it.”

I didn’t know this part happened until I was typing this comment with my fiancé but here is some added dialog

Fiancé: “Okay, Brittany. In that case, if you won’t fix this situation, whether it be to just not participate in the photo op or wear a wig/cover your hair, I don’t want you there to cause drama. If you do decide to change it in the next year before we have to book the exact amount of people for the venue, you are more than welcome to be there as a guest, but I do not want you as a groomswoman anymore. You’ve made me uncomfortable with how you’re treating my future wife, and your endless barrage of insults towards her is not going to be tolerated. You have insulted her, so you have insulted me. I believed you had changed for the better, but I was wrong. The only reason your invite even still stands, with conditions, is because your family is very dear to me, and I love your sister like a daughter.”

She starts crying hysterically and tries to grab him by the sleeve, but he pulls away, gets up from the bar, and walks out of the restaurant.

So, yeah, that’s the entire conversation to the best of my fiancé’s ability. Basically, she’s being incredibly difficult and stubborn over wanting us to pay $1000+ for extra editing because she knows we have the money, we just don’t want to pay it only for her.

Honestly, if the situation was different, I would have been persuaded to pay half of the cost of the editing and just taken the loss on the photos she happened to be in. I would have done that as the last compromise, over just covering her head temporarily. But with her constant insults, endless barrage of complaints that aren’t related to this post, and her being extremely rude to me and my partner about the wedding photos… It just isn’t in the cards for me now.

 

Update #1: November 7, 2024 (six days later)

I honestly didn’t think I’d post an update at all this year because I mostly got the confirmation I needed to know I was mostly correct in my assumption that she’d cause more drama at the wedding than necessary, and that I’d be correct in that I would be okay to disinvite her. I was trying to be detailed in that post, but in this one I’m going to be a little less detailed.

Basically, 3 days ago, I was sent my post on messenger from Brittany. She is a notorious Reddit lurker, apparently, and saw it a few hours after it was posted. It didn’t even have to get multiple upvotes because she just reads the ones available on the “recent” category. I told her I posted because I had a lot of inner conflict towards my involvement with my fiancé choosing to disinvite her if she can’t just make some form of sacrifice to not be in the green screen/wear a wig so she can be included. She got extremely mad at me. Called me names, threatened that I’d be sued for defamation, etc. This honestly just made me realize how little she actually changed. Of course, I showed my fiancé, and he was appalled at her actions. He said he was going to block her and did so that day, and so did I.

Yesterday, I woke up to 43 missed calls from a number I did not recognize, that ended up to be her and a dozen voicemails claiming that I was stealing my fiancé away from her again, that I had purposefully targeted her for just wanting to be included with everyone else, and so on. I do not know how she got my number, but I obviously blocked it.

After that, I reported her to the police on the non-emergency line because I didn’t know if I would be needing to fear for my safety. I’m really glad I did this. After my fiancé had left for work, she showed up to our home and knocked on the door. I cracked a window near the door and asked what she wanted. She said, whilst crying, that I needed to let her in the house because it was her right to be with my fiancé, not me. She started kicking at the door and I told her to knock it off.

Immediately, I just started dialing the non-emergency police number for my nearest precinct because I already knew what was happening in that moment, and I was supposed to be clocking in for work on my computer at that moment. I texted my boss and she excused my absence for the day as well. As I was doing this, I kept repeating, “Go away, I called the police, and I do not want you here. You are trespassing.” She was saying all kinds of things I don’t wish to repeat here, but the lesser of the things she was saying involved:

- Calling me a white r*cist pig (She is mixed race, and so am I)

- Saying she was 8months pregnant with my fiancé’s baby (there’s quite literally zero proof of this, including no baby bump, despite being a fairly thin woman)

- Screaming that she would take me to hell

- Trying to break my metal outside door, but instead hurting herself instead.

And so on.

Basically, she had a full-on meltdown. The police came, saw that was trying to break my door down, and immediately put her in cuffs and sat her down. She was claiming this was her house and that she’d lived there for 10 years, that I had broken in and locked her out, etc.

Of course, because of her psychotic appearance, I was questioned and once given the real story… As well as being able to provide proof that I was the owner of the home, she was taken to the police station. As far as I’m aware, she was booked for the night and was let go today. I did agree to a temporary no-contact order and my fiancé, and I are going to proceed with a permanent one.

Her parents called after they heard she was put in a holding cell, and apologized profusely. Apparently, Brittany had lied to them about the extent of her actions and downplayed a lot of it. On the exterior, she seemed fine and well-rounded. But, mentally, she had snapped again from not taking her meds for a year. She never told her parents this, just acted normally until one of her triggers came back; my fiancé. No, he didn’t do anything wrong, she just had a major trigger when it came to him because of a deeply obsessive personality disorder.

I wasn’t trying to air her dirty laundry about her medical history the last post, but she was diagnosed with BPD and a large handful of disorders caused by trauma she had endured in her childhood from her great grandfather. She’s an unhealthy person, and I regret even allowing her to have the notion that we had forgiven her for her past.

I’m pretty shaken from this ordeal… and I can’t believe this was all because of a god damn greenscreen and some pictures that were supposed to just be treated as silly holiday cards for my foreseeable future. This is making me rethink the idea altogether, to be completely honest. Maybe I’ll just rent an adult bouncy house because that seems more fun than green screened professional photography 😭.

Anyways, that’s the update. Thanks for reading and the advice I was given in the last post!

Relevant Comments

Commenter 1: My god. I would LOVE to be as calm and collected as you. Teach me your ways! In all seriousness though, I hope you’re ok. Don’t let her get to you. Do your wedding the way you want! Wishing you all the very best xxxx

OOP: Oh I was NOT calm and collected, I was crying and feeling very scared. The ONLY reason I was able to make rational decisions is because I had mentally and physically prepared myself for another incident like this happening because I was a victim of a non-sexual assault during a break-in at my mom’s house when I was 14 and it made me terrified of not knowing what to do if an incident like this ever occurred again. I was acting on instinct.

Therapy and an incredible women’s defense coach got me to this point. I also live in Texas, so castle doctrine was on my side.

Commenter 2: This woman is an absolute lunatic. Make sure that you get a permanent restraining order. You should also consider security for your wedding venue because she’s more than likely going to show up and do something crazy again.

Good luck OP, you’re going to need it.

OOP: I already have security in the works that was unrelated to this incident… Now it’s a “for sure having a small security team!” 😅

Commenter 3: This situation isn’t about a green screen or pictures. It’s about an extremely unstable person refusing to follow their doctor’s orders. The hair and picture problems are, at best, the catalyst for her breakdown, but it most certainly isn’t the cause. It’s your and your fiancé’s day, so if y’all decide to do something other than the pictures go right ahead. However, I would hate for you to regret not doing it because of one nutball.

 


#----OLD NEW UPDATE----

Editor’s note: the final update is over a month old, and it has not been posted here onto the sub

Final Update: May 26, 2026 (over 18 months later from the first update)

Final update because I still occasionally get messages asking if the wedding ever happened and what ended up happening with Brittany.

My last update was posted back in November of 2024, so it’s been about a year and a half now. Honestly, I didn’t think I’d ever update again (×2) because after the police involvement and restraining order, I mostly just wanted to move on with my life and stop thinking about the situation entirely.

But a LOT has changed since then, and I was listening to a YouTuber read a story and it reminded me to check in with this account.

First off, I’m married! Just… not in the way we originally planned. After everything that happened with Brittany, the giant Renaissance/DnD wedding slowly stopped feeling exciting and started feeling exhausting. Even though my dad had a giant wedding like that, I started really evaluating if he wanted me to actually get married like him, or if he just wanted me to have a wonderful wedding and honeymoon.

Other things have now happened with my family. And I’m just over them, as well.

Between the police involvements this last year, changing routines, the restraining order process, and honestly just being stressed constantly for months afterward, planning this huge elaborate fantasy wedding stopped being fun.

Life sort of smacked us in the face in the best possible way, and it made it all worth it anyways. After a long line of pregnancy issues and basically accepting that I might never get pregnant, or at least bring a baby to term, I found out I was pregnant. The second I saw the positive test, something in my brain shifted from: “I want the biggest coolest fantasy wedding imaginable” to “I literally just want peace and happiness before this baby gets here.”

Instead, we ended up doing a much smaller “shotgun” winter wedding this past December with around 30 guests total, and about 60 people invited to the reception afterward. My husband’s family is massive, so that was genuinely about as much as we could shorten it without causing a civil war.

The entire aesthetic changed too.

Instead of the giant colorful Renaissance/DnD wedding, I ended up going with my secondary option that I had played with when I was originally planning the idea of a similar wedding to my dad’s. It was the idea of a snowy white wedding aesthetic from the ending of Nanny McPhee. Specifically the winter wedding at the very end of the movie. I have loved that scene since I was little and something about it always felt so magical and soft and romantic to me. My grandma also loves that movie. Every time we would watch it, she would cry. And then I would cry. She would point to the screen and say, “Look how beautiful she is.” With tears in her eyes. So that became the new inspiration.

I decided to change it due to the size difference. I felt that going all out with the bright colors was amazing, but that we could just invite family to a Renaissance festival, and we could all have fun there drinking themselves silly, instead.

Everyone wore white, silver, soft blues, etc. My dress had embroidered snowflakes all over it with tiny pearl details that made it look frosted over. It honestly looked like it had snow settled into the fabric. It reminded me so much of Evangeline’s dress from the movie and I was obsessed with it. Still am, I’m even planning to get a piece put into my wedding band.

I loved that wedding just as much as I loved the original fantasy one I had planned in my head for years.

It felt calmer. More intimate. Less of a giant party. More of a loving environment.

And, to anyone wondering, we did the greenscreen photo-op!

My friend Bri thought it would be hilarious after everything that happened, so instead of DnD backgrounds, she made a bunch of winter and Christmas themed backgrounds instead. I helped, of course. Snowy castles, Christmas villages, giant decorated trees, cheesy Hallmark-style edits, ice caves, etc. People absolutely LOVED it. And I LOVE the Christmas cards I got from it.

My uncle had himself into shielding himself from an army of snowmen with cannons, and one of my cousins made herself look like she was flying through a blizzard on a reindeer. It was genuinely one of the funniest parts of the reception.

So yes. After all of that insanity… the greenscreen survived.

As for Brittany, her parents were invited to the reception. I know some people will think that’s weird, but despite everything, my husband still cares about them a lot. They apologized to us multiple times after the incident happened and genuinely seemed devastated by the entire situation. None of this was really their fault.

While we were talking during the reception, they ended up telling us more about what happened after my last update.

Apparently, after Brittany was placed into long-term psychiatric treatment following the incident at our house, her parents ended up getting access to her phone because she obviously couldn’t keep it while institutionalized and they were trying to sort out her bills, work issues, etc.

And apparently that’s when they discovered she had been stalking my husband for years. Pictures of him leaving work. Pictures of him outside our old house. Pictures of him pumping gas. Pictures taken from inside her car while following him. Some were years old, during the time we had cut her out. And, some were recent (as of Dec 2025). Some of them had hearts drawn all over them.

One of them was photoshopped to make it look like she was naked and laying on top of him while he slept on our porch outside. Apparently she had entire folders dedicated to him on her phone. It was honestly one of the most disturbing things I have ever seen in my life.

Needless to say, a pretty significant amount of the money my dad left me for the original wedding ended up going toward buying a new house in a completely different area after all of that came out. After we found out about it, we decided our baby would be safer out of the old house.

I also want to give my husband a lot of credit throughout all of this because I genuinely do not think I could have handled this situation as gracefully as he did. This entire ordeal absolutely crushed him emotionally for a while. Despite everything Brittany did, he still cared about her as someone he had known since childhood, and I think realizing that the version of her he thought had “gotten better” wasn’t actually real really messed with him for a long time. At the same time though, he never once wavered when it came to protecting me, our home, or our relationship. The second things crossed the line into harassment and stalking, he completely cut contact, fully cooperated with the restraining order process, helped us move, got a better paying job in our new area, changed routines with me so I’d feel safer, and has honestly been my rock through all of it. Even now, I think part of him still mourns the loss of someone he thought was one of his oldest friends, but he also understands now that what she felt towards him was never a healthy friendship in the first place. Especially after seeing those pictures.

Legally speaking: We were granted a temporary restraining order a few months after my last update. That expired in January of last year and thankfully we have had absolutely zero contact since then. From what her parents told us, Brittany is still receiving psychiatric treatment and apparently still has not fully accepted reality regarding my husband. She still hasn’t come to understand she wasn’t dating my husband, and he has never claimed to want to be with her.

It’s sad. At this point, it really doesn’t feel like it is a Reddit post anymore. It mostly just feels like watching somebody completely destroy their own life because they refused help for too long. I don’t even know if she ever even took the medication she was prescribed or if they were just not working. In my non-professional opinion, she seems schizophrenic. I hope she gets genuine help where she is now, but I never want to see her again.

On a much happier note:

Our daughter is due in July.

Her name is going to be Caroline Evangeline.

And I genuinely cannot wait to meet her.

Thanks for reading.

TL;DR - We ended up cancelling the giant Renaissance/DnD wedding after everything with Brittany became emotionally exhausting, and after years of pregnancy issues, I unexpectedly got pregnant. We instead had a much smaller winter-themed wedding inspired by the ending of Nanny McPhee, complete with a Christmas-themed greenscreen photo-op that everyone loved. Brittany is currently still receiving psychiatric treatment after her parents discovered she had apparently been stalking my husband for years and keeping thousands of photos/edited images of him on her phone. Because of that, we moved to a completely different area using part of the wedding money my dad left me. Thankfully, we’ve had zero contact with her since the restraining order situation ended last year, and now we’re just focused on preparing for our daughter, Caroline Evangeline, to arrive in July.

Concluding Comments

Commenter: Congrats on the wedding and the baby, and I love the name.

OOP: I appreciate it! It comes from two of my favorite movies! Caroline (from Coraline) and Evangeline…You get it. Thank you!

 

DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7

THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP