showing posts flaired MAILBOX — clear

0

When sequels go wrong: two which I found surprisingly disappointing.

2
preview

Most of the time I prefer to share content I enjoyed here, but the reality is that not every sequel is going to please everyone, and I’d be lying if I said that I didn’t experience some major disappointments from time to time. To the point, an unliked BD is generally trivial and forgettable, but something which you’d been looking forward to hurts much worse.

I found I Am Their Silence to be a quirky, energetic, effective murder-mystery. Very interesting to see main character Eva Rojas be a gifted psychiatrist who’s also thoroughly bipolar. She also hallucinates three of her dead family members, who can be alternately helpful or hugely annoying. The result was quite a unique, fun experience for me:

Earlier review here:
https://piefed.social/post/1231330

And a formal one, with more sample pages in French:
https://www.bdgest.com/preview-3916-BD-un-polar-a-barcelone-recit-complet.html

Unfortunately I found the follow-up album I’m a Lost Angel to be… pretty terrible indeed. Eva’s formerly hilarious quirkiness devolved in to a far more annoying ‘main character syndrome,’ and Jordi Lefebre’s formerly deft ability to weave together an improbably great story turned in to a case of pure self-indulgence, with virtually every area of the story worse than the one before. TBH, part of this is just “Jordi being Jordi,” in which he routinely renders his characters as overly precious and Disney-esque, but I liked the first album as an exception to that rule, more or less.


Negalyod T1 was the first work I’d read of Vincent Perriot, and while I felt it had some logistical problems, on the whole it was an above-average sci-fi story with some interesting commentary on the human condition and civilisation’s tendency to eventually topple itself. The art was pretty neat – not quite Moebius level – but was fairly original and unique-looking in a dingy - grungy kind of way.

https://www.bedetheque.com/BD-Negalyod-Tome-1-340430.html

Unfortunately, I found tome two to be a complete mess. It dealt with the aftermath of the ‘global threat’ being brought down in the first book, in which the planet became radically transformed, with raging oceans and threats from above, and… I’m not sure what else. Via page after page, we got huge splashies with little context, story-flow or character development, and the satisfying linear development of tome one was completely abandoned. Well, that’s what I got from the first ~100pp anyway, when I gave up out of frustration.

I’d be curious if any of the readers here have had similar experiences with Euro comics they’d been looking forward to.

Most of the time I prefer to share content I enjoyed here, but the reality is that not every sequel is going to please everyone, and I’d be lying if I said that I didn’t experience some major disappointments from time to time. To the point, an unliked BD is generally trivial and forgettable, but something which you’d been looking forward to hurts much worse.

I found I Am Their Silence to be a quirky, energetic, effective murder-mystery. Very interesting to see main character Eva Rojas be a gifted psychiatrist who’s also thoroughly bipolar. She also hallucinates three of her dead family members, who can be alternately helpful or hugely annoying. The result was quite a unique, fun experience for me:

Earlier review here:
https://piefed.social/post/1231330

And a formal one, with more sample pages in French:
https://www.bdgest.com/preview-3916-BD-un-polar-a-barcelone-recit-complet.html

Unfortunately I found the follow-up album I’m a Lost Angel to be… pretty terrible indeed. Eva’s formerly hilarious quirkiness devolved in to a far more annoying ‘main character syndrome,’ and Jordi Lefebre’s formerly deft ability to weave together an improbably great story turned in to a case of pure self-indulgence, with virtually every area of the story worse than the one before. TBH, part of this is just “Jordi being Jordi,” in which he routinely renders his characters as overly precious and Disney-esque, but I liked the first album as an exception to that rule, more or less.


Negalyod T1 was the first work I’d read of Vincent Perriot, and while I felt it had some logistical problems, on the whole it was an above-average sci-fi story with some interesting commentary on the human condition and civilisation’s tendency to eventually topple itself. The art was pretty neat – not quite Moebius level – but was fairly original and unique-looking in a dingy - grungy kind of way.

https://www.bedetheque.com/BD-Negalyod-Tome-1-340430.html

Unfortunately, I found tome two to be a complete mess. It dealt with the aftermath of the ‘global threat’ being brought down in the first book, in which the planet became radically transformed, with raging oceans and threats from above, and… I’m not sure what else. Via page after page, we got huge splashies with little context, story-flow or character development, and the satisfying linear development of tome one was completely abandoned. Well, that’s what I got from the first ~100pp anyway, when I gave up out of frustration.

I’d be curious if any of the readers here have had similar experiences with Euro comics they’d been looking forward to.

0

What was Pál Pusztai aiming for with Jucika, anyway? (he did other comics as well) [notes in post]

preview


https://piefed.social/c/comicstrips@lemmy.world/p/2411619/jucika-and-the-courteous-bus-driver

Jucika celebrates pretty privilege, strip #387.

I’ve debated in the past ’what exactly Pusztai was going for in his Jucika comics?’ That is, is it just the idea that drawing a pretty young woman with the simplest of gag setups is enough to get favorable audience reaction? Was he actually trying to exercise any real creativity on his part, or was he just cynically milking his little cash cow? (if he was like Scott Adams of “Dilbert” fame, then evidently the answer would be yes!)

As for the character of Jucika herself, was she indeed simply out to exercise her pretty-privilege for the most part? Because at other times she’s having to fend off butt-pinching leches, often getting minor revenge on them. And yet at other times, you’ll see her being spontaneously creative and/or sympathetic towards someone / anyone around her visibly having a bad day. Or even sharing borderline intimate moments with her dates and temporary lovers, which also raised questions of her being something of either a gold-digger or a OTOH a ‘liberated woman’ of the time.

In the end, I mostly concluded that Jucika ("YOOTS-ika") was simply a template for a variety of simple gags and light topical humor. Trying to find consistency of character and her ‘true self’ seems mostly like a waste of time, not unlike how few if any background characters (including her romantic dates) in the strip ever appear twice. This in fact is pretty routine in comics and some animated shows– altho the writers do create material for the characters, the characters are also somewhat empty vessels for whatever can be done with them. With The Simpsons for example, you can often see this, particularly taking off around season ten. Lisa Simpson seems like the most consistent character, yet the rest of the family can range from being stumbling, uninspired, passive buffoons, all the way to assertive, creative, progressive individuals. Something like that.

What I also find interesting is that Pusztai did more than just Jucika, as we see here:
https://www.google.com/search?q=pal+pusztai+comics+-jucika&udm=2

Pretty girls, sure, but also a little more broad range of styles and humor subjects, seemingly freelancing quite a bit. Indeed:

Pál Pusztai was a Hungarian graphic artist, known for drawing postcards, advertisements and propaganda pamphlets. From 1959 until his death in 1970, he was a regular contributor to Lúdas Matyi magazine with the groundbreaking comic strip about the sexy ‘Jucika’ (1957-1970) and his military cartoon feature ’Iván és Joe’ (1959-1970). –LBK


https://www.lambiek.net/artists/image/p/pusztai_pal/pusztai_ludasmatyi1960.jpg

“Where have you been, Joe?"
“You know, Ivan, we have a little base in Cuba. We went fishing there this weekend.”

TBH I think I’d already read that Lambiek entry about Pusztai’s other stuff, but had kind of forgotten over time. A big factor here is that I can’t read a lick of Hungarian, so my chance to analyze is cut down by the non-visual gags stuff. Oh well.

Previously-posted Jucika stuff here:
https://piefed.social/search?q=jucika&community=eurographicnovels


https://piefed.social/c/comicstrips@lemmy.world/p/2411619/jucika-and-the-courteous-bus-driver

Jucika celebrates pretty privilege, strip #387.

I’ve debated in the past ’what exactly Pusztai was going for in his Jucika comics?’ That is, is it just the idea that drawing a pretty young woman with the simplest of gag setups is enough to get favorable audience reaction? Was he actually trying to exercise any real creativity on his part, or was he just cynically milking his little cash cow? (if he was like Scott Adams of “Dilbert” fame, then evidently the answer would be yes!)

As for the character of Jucika herself, was she indeed simply out to exercise her pretty-privilege for the most part? Because at other times she’s having to fend off butt-pinching leches, often getting minor revenge on them. And yet at other times, you’ll see her being spontaneously creative and/or sympathetic towards someone / anyone around her visibly having a bad day. Or even sharing borderline intimate moments with her dates and temporary lovers, which also raised questions of her being something of either a gold-digger or a OTOH a ‘liberated woman’ of the time.

In the end, I mostly concluded that Jucika ("YOOTS-ika") was simply a template for a variety of simple gags and light topical humor. Trying to find consistency of character and her ‘true self’ seems mostly like a waste of time, not unlike how few if any background characters (including her romantic dates) in the strip ever appear twice. This in fact is pretty routine in comics and some animated shows– altho the writers do create material for the characters, the characters are also somewhat empty vessels for whatever can be done with them. With The Simpsons for example, you can often see this, particularly taking off around season ten. Lisa Simpson seems like the most consistent character, yet the rest of the family can range from being stumbling, uninspired, passive buffoons, all the way to assertive, creative, progressive individuals. Something like that.

What I also find interesting is that Pusztai did more than just Jucika, as we see here:
https://www.google.com/search?q=pal+pusztai+comics+-jucika&udm=2

Pretty girls, sure, but also a little more broad range of styles and humor subjects, seemingly freelancing quite a bit. Indeed:

Pál Pusztai was a Hungarian graphic artist, known for drawing postcards, advertisements and propaganda pamphlets. From 1959 until his death in 1970, he was a regular contributor to Lúdas Matyi magazine with the groundbreaking comic strip about the sexy ‘Jucika’ (1957-1970) and his military cartoon feature ’Iván és Joe’ (1959-1970). –LBK


https://www.lambiek.net/artists/image/p/pusztai_pal/pusztai_ludasmatyi1960.jpg

“Where have you been, Joe?"
“You know, Ivan, we have a little base in Cuba. We went fishing there this weekend.”

TBH I think I’d already read that Lambiek entry about Pusztai’s other stuff, but had kind of forgotten over time. A big factor here is that I can’t read a lick of Hungarian, so my chance to analyze is cut down by the non-visual gags stuff. Oh well.

Previously-posted Jucika stuff here:
https://piefed.social/search?q=jucika&community=eurographicnovels

0

Casual Friday: how SUPERMAN influenced my love of BD (watercolor artist: "RobFandandgo")

preview

Christopher Reeve (Robin Williams’ best friend) was the first movie-actor to portray the S-man. Previously, there had been George Reeves, a really good portrayal in the 50’s sense IMO, yet heavily outdated by the 80’s.

Now, for sure there’s a full essay to write upon all that, but… let’s just go with some clips? In particular, the way that Reeve shifts from Clark Kent to Kal-El is just… breathtaking. (plus, all hail the brilliant Margot Kidder)

“You wouldn’t let me die!!"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lgy3VcTk0lI

“As usual, Lois, I don’t know what you’re talking about…"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UQfoKtbUm74

“Gotcha!"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtrXDq5OTn4

(not sure how the above sequences meshes with the below; like she discovered him 2x?)

And finally:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0CN7eo0_Mo

I’ve spoken extensively here before about how American comics helped shape my love of BD. For the most part, I feel like it’s been a logical maturation. But in truth, BD also ignited something within me… a certain fire that somehow never dies.

For sure, there is much more to say about all this, but that’s all I’ve got to say for now!
(insert Porky Pig noises)

Christopher Reeve (Robin Williams’ best friend) was the first movie-actor to portray the S-man. Previously, there had been George Reeves, a really good portrayal in the 50’s sense IMO, yet heavily outdated by the 80’s.

Now, for sure there’s a full essay to write upon all that, but… let’s just go with some clips? In particular, the way that Reeve shifts from Clark Kent to Kal-El is just… breathtaking. (plus, all hail the brilliant Margot Kidder)

“You wouldn’t let me die!!"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lgy3VcTk0lI

“As usual, Lois, I don’t know what you’re talking about…"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UQfoKtbUm74

“Gotcha!"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtrXDq5OTn4

(not sure how the above sequences meshes with the below; like she discovered him 2x?)

And finally:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0CN7eo0_Mo

I’ve spoken extensively here before about how American comics helped shape my love of BD. For the most part, I feel like it’s been a logical maturation. But in truth, BD also ignited something within me… a certain fire that somehow never dies.

For sure, there is much more to say about all this, but that’s all I’ve got to say for now!
(insert Porky Pig noises)