For 2FA: Find a good password manager. They can also handle TOTP (the algorithm most 2FA implementations use), so you just autofill user & password, then autofill the TOTP, done.
I use KeePassXC + sync the DB, but there are plenty of other trustworthy password managers. Plus, if you get in the habit of generating secure passwords using the password manager, one leaked login doesn’t cost you all of them.
What they’re saying is that if all of the multiple factors are stored behind 1 master password in 1 service, the whole purpose of MFA is negated. You’ve just shifted the single point of failure from a website password to your Bitwarden master password.
You all guys simply don’t understand the idea. The idea to not have two or ten password managers. The idea is for the website being compromised, TOTP password won’t compromise the algorithm. Having just one password, stealing it, poof. Having them two, big difference. That’s the idea. They are different. Yes, many sites and services fuck up that by, say, sending them both to your email or something like that. But putting your TOTP into your password manager does not change much into the worse. Not issuing that 2nd password is what makes you less secure.
314 comments
log in to comment.
For 2FA: Find a good password manager. They can also handle TOTP (the algorithm most 2FA implementations use), so you just autofill user & password, then autofill the TOTP, done. I use KeePassXC + sync the DB, but there are plenty of other trustworthy password managers. Plus, if you get in the habit of generating secure passwords using the password manager, one leaked login doesn’t cost you all of them.
The second you put totp codes into bitwarden, it’s no longer mfa.
[deleted]
I do it to, bit it’s not mfa at that point because you have a single point of failure/compromise
It’s intentional, actually, that way I can recover my data as easily as possible. I know how to do this safely.
Also, it can still be MFA which is the way I use it.
What they’re saying is that if all of the multiple factors are stored behind 1 master password in 1 service, the whole purpose of MFA is negated. You’ve just shifted the single point of failure from a website password to your Bitwarden master password.
You all guys simply don’t understand the idea. The idea to not have two or ten password managers. The idea is for the website being compromised, TOTP password won’t compromise the algorithm. Having just one password, stealing it, poof. Having them two, big difference. That’s the idea. They are different. Yes, many sites and services fuck up that by, say, sending them both to your email or something like that. But putting your TOTP into your password manager does not change much into the worse. Not issuing that 2nd password is what makes you less secure.