Except when it’s just an email, or worse, a txt message, or worse, a whatsapp message, with no other option for using a proper 2fa generator…
But also, not every site needs 2fa, sometimes I really couldn’t care less if someone managed to hack into something, because I can just make a new account if that happened…
What really bugs me is that TOTP is objectively easier than any other form of 2fa. Just import the library, add the field on your login form, and you’re done.
Email verification is annoying to code, it requires SMTP or an email gateway, is slow for the user, is risky from a security perspective, and to generate the code you probably still have to implement TOTP.
SMS/RCS is even more annoying to code, it almost inevitably requires a third-party gateway, it can work differently if the user is in a different country or on a MVNO or in a low-signal area or just has the wrong astrological sign, is very slow for the end user, is almost useless from a security perspective, and you STILL have to implement TOTP.
WhatsApp messages are somehow even more annoying to code than that, requires an api interaction with Meta (which is never fun and poorly documented), requires the end user to have an account with a specific third party, is slow for the end user, relies on another company’s security posture to determine your own, and you STILL have to implement TOTP.
Making your own app for 2fa is undoubtedly the worst: not only is it annoying to code, it’s an ongoing annoyance that is strained through multiple app stores, adds an additional maintenance and support load, adds additional technical debt, adds an unnecessary attack vector, requires users to download another app, is often unreliable, is often pretty slow for the end user, is a total crapshoot from a security perspective, and guess what? YOU PROBABLY STILL HAVE TO IMPLEMENT TOTP.
Any company that chooses SMS or email verification over TOTP emphatically does not know what they’re doing.
2fa by email is probably slightly easier than TOTP, if the account verification via email is already implemented, but yeah, it’s not like it’s significantly easier…
The real reason is conversion. The majority of users aren’t good at technology, so you risk them losing their TOTP secret. Then the user either just says “screw this site” and leaves, or they take time getting customer support to reset their key.
So depending on the branch and customer base, it can often be much “cheaper” in the end to send login codes via email instead of using TOTP.
Maybe. And I think that could make sense as the PM’s answer, but I also think that a TOTP app is starting to become mainstream enough that it’s not a huge deal.
You don’t have to implement totp for these alternatives… The “thing” about totp is that there’s a shared secret and a timestamp. Due to potential drift in clocks you need a window and period to know how many time steps to test, and how long each is.
But with an email/SMS/WhatsApp, there’s no shared secret. So you can simply send a random code, and store server side when it was generated. Totp makes no sense in that case.
Not that totp is difficult to implement at all. My implementation for work was what, less than 200 lines of C++ I think? I didn’t implement the sha1 myself though.
You do have to implement TOTP, just not necessarily RFC 6238. Time-based one-time passwords require a shared secret, a shared time and a time-to-live. The shared secret is usually the key for generating the code, but can be the code itself. The shared time is still needed in mail authentication between the code generator and the code validator. The thing that’s usually different is the time to live, but in RFC 6238 it is a parameter, so you can implement mail verification with it and a long TTL.
An earlier version of that comment said “something like TOTP,” but I guess I left that out while I was revising it. My point is you have to implement something that does most of what TOTP does anyway, so why not just use the version that’s already been stress tested?
Seriously. Why would i care if someone logs into most of them. What are they going to do watch a movie on my Netflix account, play my kids roblox games, or change my crew on my Rockstar account? It’s unnecessary bs.
Which also doesn’t matter anymore because companies sell our data all the time or just give it away through their own data insecurities. Or yanno, white pages. com and similar exists and its pretty easy to find anything about anyone anytime.
I don’t care. Likelihood is that’s not going to actually cause me anything but an annoyance anyway, so the cost of preventing it can’t be more annoying
Any account that does payment (like your netflix one), will be used to test out stolen credit cards. This will in turn flag your account for fraud. You might not want that. Unless you do, I don’t know
It will be a problem for you when the police decide it’s a civil issue (which they most likely will). Whether the credit card company will help you with this really depends on their policies, and I’m not sure what Netflix is supposed to do about it.
If they said it was a civil issue, that’d mean no charges against me, which would be even better because then I could just make a different netflix account and have no legal issues.
Idk man. I just don’t think it’s a big deal for me.
It’s not about a specific account, it’s about compromising your info.
The info one company considers enough to verify you when you call or chat with customer service, another company will give out freely. They can then hop and skip through those to get access to one of your accounts they actually want.
Your entire online security is only as secure as your most insecure account.
Well yeah, Netflix knows it’s super annoying when your watch history gets messed up. This is the real reason why Netflix (and all the other tech companies) are suddenly pushing so hard for passkeys… it has nothing to do with how much control and influence it’ll give them ;-)
Tell me that at least you use different email and password for every account because if not, then you just get screwed when they hack one account, also, if any of your social accounts gets hacked, it will for sure be used to scam or hack other people.
And usually, the alternative is a text message to a phone, with most temporary number providers blocked.
Nobody really designed it, and there are ways around it, with some tradeoffs, but specific account -> email -> phone -> bank -> legal identity is the typical authentication chain that’s evolved. It’s because any way of signing up that’s too repeatable gets saturated with bots and spammers.
Can we agree that 43-factor authentication would be bad, at least?
Like, it’d pretty weird if it actually happened, but if you start relying on another service that itself relies on another service as one of the factors, you’re opening the door to that.
My work 2fa can go away. I don’t give two shits if everything in the work app is printed in global papers, just stop making me go through a 5 step process to see my fucking roster.
Every time I have to fill out a 2FA at work, I die inside.
Bro, I am not a nVidia CEO, no Chinese spies are interested in the shit on my work computer. Also why do I need 7 different logins for the 7 apps we use, none of which are of any critical importance, none sharing the same password requirements.
Fuck that, IT. My passwords are taped to my monitor.
Almost all sites should allow me to choose whether I want 2fac. And they shouldn’t prompt for it nearly as often as they do - some services do it for every login, most seem to do it every month at least.
yes I do. I will take convivence over security most days. Just because you don't, and you have good reasons to want it to stay, doesn't mean everyone comes to the same conclusion based on similar data.
Although I personally think 2FA is very important in most cases, I agree that mandatory 2FA is annoying. If you want to forego security for convenience, that should be up to you. I’m sure you’re not stupid or ignorant of the risks.
It fails for somebody every day, it adds a dependency for a known unreliable 3rd party that often mangles the identification data it sends back, it is exploited by that 3rd party for extending their monopoly, and it gives that 3rd party (or any hacker that got access to them) full access to impersonate any user it wants.
That’s the user’s choice, that should not be a consideration when choosing authentication methods as long as you tell them how to store it properly (in a reasonable way, probably shouldn’t mention keepass or anything like that).
in a reasonable way, probably shouldn’t mention keepass or anything like that
I avoid all those big tech sites advocating passkeys in recent times anyway, so I did not really have much chance to test it. But my password manager at least seems to be able to properly store and backup passkeys. It’s the import/export should I want to use other software that seems to be universally lacking still.
Who doesn’t use TOTP/HOTP? The brain-less part usually comes into play when they then recommed (or even require…) propietary shit like Google’s authenticator app as if there weren’t enough secure and open source options.
Amazon, Facebook, and many more support TOTP in whatever authenticator you want. I don't particularly like either of those websites but they are massive and directly contradict your claim that no corporation uses this normal method of 2FA.
as a developer it is incredibly frustrating and time consuming
Huh? How? Implementing OTP (which I’m assuming most people here are talking about) is pretty trivial, and once you have it set up, it doesn’t require much maintenance.
This is uterly idiotic but ok. I have decided I do not need to wear seat belt in the car. Just because you do and you have good reasons to want it to stay, doesn’t mean everyone comes to the same conclusion based on similar data.
The day my taxes go towards paying for people who don’t have 2fa, we can discuss whether it should be mandatory. Also, comparing a compromised Netflix account to loss of life, really?
Yeah. Fuck those. I just now have this case, where I cannot login to a service I pay a subscription for. Contact support, wrote explicitly “I looked into the spam folder. I even looked into the logs of my mailserver, your mailserver does not even contact mine”.
Wait for two days, answer is (of course) “have you looked into your spam folder?”, nothing else. As soon as I manage to login, I cancel 😅 (jk, cancelled the payment already). Fuck those.
Yah the first time I saw it I was like wow so clever, but now I’m like why do you disrespect our purest form of online speech for your transactional babble
What other 2FA methods are you looking for? I have seen a couple sites that will call you, but that is really just verbal text messaging.
The stay logged on and trust this system actions are probably controlled by a browser cookie, so won’t work if you don’t allow cookies from that site.
a magic link is not 2FA if it doesn’t also require a password. it’s 1FA, they just replaced the one factor.
honestly i really hate websites that do that and yet don’t allow password-only 1FA. like sure, i understand that the average user’s password discipline is crap, but as a power user i’d really like it if all my accounts weren’t tied to all my other accounts sometimes.
even if you clear your cookies, the session token id still exists for the website
Some websites treat the first login you ever done as a sort of root of trust, for example for account recovery they might ask if you can to verify it is you on that session
Some websites use the number of login sessions and how many recent times you have logged in for theie hidden trust factor, and some may even lockdown your account if it gets too low automaticly
everyone knows to clear their cookies but absolutely nobody thinks to clear their localStorage, sessionStorage, or indexedDB. i have never once in my life seen someone include those when telling someone else to “clear their cookies.” even including cache in that list (e.g. using ctrl+shift+r to refresh the page instead of ctrl+r) is weirdly uncommon.
The stay logged on and trust this system actions are probably controlled by a browser cookie, so won’t work if you don’t allow cookies from that site.
In my experience, they are. In my bowser, I have to explicitly allow the saving of site data if I hope to be able to keep myself logged in. For me, this is fine; I only want to stay logged in on a handful of sites anyway so the tradeoff between adding an exception for some sites vs. allowing every single site I visit to be able to save some piece of data doing god-knows-what (likely helping Facebook and the like track where it is I visit) on my machine is worth it.
I really hate when the login button is hard to find relative to the sign up button. It should be the other way around; you only sign up once, but you log in many times. It should be optimized for the more frequent task.
Even worse. They automatically create an account if you don’t already have one through the login mechanism, so you get multiple accounts that can’t be merged.
All feeding the same backend databases, which access to will eventually end up sold on the market. Good luck if your employer buys it and sees you working on a side project while employed by them (depending on what your contract says).
I think they mean where it tries to send a magic link, and say you signed up under name@yourdomain.com, but also have a Gmail or whatever and you forget and enter name@gmail.com, then it acts like it’s logging you in, but now you have an account also at name@gmail.com.
In theory, but there are services that give you a new email address whether you want one or not, which means the check doesn’t work. You also have users that have a different email accounts with different social logins. My Facebook email is not the same as my Gmail account.
Combine that with automatic sign-up, and you have yourself a duplicate account generator. Please please please just ask me if I want to sign up for a new account. Don’t force it on me just because of the login.
Yea in our case it was tied to the address. The account was per email. But as others have said if you login with a different mail at some point on accident, you then have 2 accounts that would need merging.
Some services create email accounts for me even if I don’t want one. For example, Google and iCloud, so the single sign on can’t tell the difference and considers me different users, depending on how I logged in. It’s not reasonable to expect me to remember which sign on method must be used. It’s not like some random e-commerce platform is the most important thing in my life. It’s really dumb.
Combine that with dark patterns like creating new accounts from the login page without getting user consent first, and I have multiple services where I have to play the login guessing game and see which actual account is the real one.
I do this, for my own website, and for one simple reason: I don’t want to store passwords. I just want a proof your control the email (the website is based on notifying people)
Yes, but 2FA is usually another app, not email. Or even if it’s the same app being in your very password manager, it gets the second password from the algorithm. So if you steal my password, you can login. But stealing these 6 numbers that work for just 30 seconds is useless.
In a proper authentication system you’d still have to provide the 2nd factor after resetting your password. Resetting OTP should require recovery codes that you got when you set it up.
Even worse: instead of your email or phone number. It’s not even username. It’s your fucking account number. I’m looking at you airline and hotel rewards programs. You think I know my fucking account number? Now I need to go into my email and lookup my fucking Airline Advantage number? And Gmail search is complete shit and all of the results I get are from the airline in my spam folder so I have to dig through all of that. Then when I finally do find it, fuck me if I can remember my password because I travel like once every couple of years and I’m hoping that if I keep saving up all of my points then maybe I can get a free flight to a neighboring city in 20 years…
Don’t forget it starts off with only an ‘email’ field and only shows the password field after you fill that out and click a button, just to make sure that the login flow is as crap as possible for your password manager to deal with.
Except you accept cookies in X browser, but not Y browser because that is an emulated system to run a 30yr old program they never bothered to update because it worked great on x86 machines but was never designed for 64 bit.
What really grinds my gears is that every goddamn login site now has separate pages for username and password, so the Autofill {Username}{Tab}{Password}{Enter} scheme doesn’t work anymore.
Now you have to wait an unpredictable amount of time until you can enter your password.
Also another quck vent if someone from my bank is reading this: Please explain to me why I always have to 2FA my browser login with my phone, but not the other way around? How tf is that safer when I can do anything solely on my phone anyway, which has no 2nd factor?
CSAM, my governments authentication platform (before the abbreviation got hijacked) changed the {Username}{Tab}{Password}{Enter} sequence by adding a question mark button next to the username field that is z-indexed between username and password field.
I opened a ticket and a few months later got a reply that it’s an accessibility standard…
So now, after typing in my password and hitting tab, I’m always typing my password into the void.
Yeah, I’ve had a few of those and had that happen.
At least, in that case, you can add a second tab to the sequence. It’s annoying and shouldn’t be necessary, but that should work.
The thing with the two pages is, I never know how long they load and (I have to criticize Keepass) entering “DELAY X-ms” doesn’t really wait for that amount of time, if I enter 10000, it doesn’t wait 10s, more like 2.
So there are two factors I have no clear control over. Should I just enter 100,000,000 and wait a minute every time to login?
Repeat steps 1-6. Sometimes (but rarely) repeat them multiple times.
Now you’re actually logged in.
How hard is it to log in the user if the username and password were correct? If Microsoft can not figure out how to do this, why do other random websites work? Do those websites have some arcane knowledge being held away from Microsoft?
Microsoft oauth login in a browser: type in password, get pop-up “reusing passwords is a security risk. Change password now?”.
I sure wonder why the password to my AD account is the same as the password to my windows account. It’s almost like they’re the exact same account or something.
I don’t think I know how to login to Microsoft. The authenticator app doesn’t work, and it just puts me into an infinite loop of clicking Use alternate method, entering codes, and then it telling me to use the Authenticator app which I just told it I didn’t want to use. I think I cried last time.
Microsoft seem to have integrated XBox Live and microsoft.com (and others, like Minecraft) just enough that they all depend on each other, but not enough to know WTF is going on. Trying to get anything working seems to involve logging into everything and messing with similar but ineffective settings. And, each login to each system does the Azure URL dance.
If you bank is this relaxed about access to the user-facing online banking interface, I’d had to know what kind of security malpractice is going on in their back end.
Nope, but I am surprised that you haven’t written “my former bank” - though I guess most banks are federally insured for amounts that keep us normies covered.
Click ‘Sing in’ button -> takes you to registration page -> insert login and password -> tells you user already exists -> notice it’s the wrong form -> click on ‘already have an account’ below…
Saw this more than once. How the fuck does anyone implement it like that?
Telling the user that the account doesn’t exist is bad practice. Hackers can use it to find out who has an account on what platform and more directly target them with phishing emails
I don’t like to automate it because I get paid every other week and it falls on different days. I just pay my bills first thing when I get paid so I know for sure it’s paid and didn’t bounce
This is why I hate, and don’t understand the “remember for next time”
Just to top up my phone once a month I have to do it. When I last did it, I clicked “remember”, even though I know it rarely works. I went to log in again the very next day to check something, and I have to log in again 😫
I use vanilla Chrome (no extensions at all) on a dedicated Windows install. It’s specifically for certain email accounts, government, banking, etc. Important real life business. I do that specifically so their software can run whatever the fuck unobtruded. Still some accounts will not stay logged in.
Some sites have a fairly short cookie lifetime on purpose. The “keep me logged in” button saves you from having to reenter your credentials every time you open the site in a new tab, but will still only work for a very short time.
Banking websites usually do this and I’ve seen a few government and insurance sites also do it. Our all beloved MS~hit~ often does this too when you use your company account outside of company hardware.
Most of the time something like this happens the website thinks highly enough of itself to warrant the extra caution. Not to say that a lot of sites aren’t just badly made.
Oh hell yes that sounds simple! Maybe we could call these codes “passwords” and call the service a “password manager”. Maybe we could even implement some kind of browser thing to automatically input these in webpages for more convenience.
While I do get your point, the fact that it can be used as a second factor of authentication you just have to touch (best case scenario) instead of looking up you phone messages or open one of your 7 apps of 2FA codes and input that , is pretty neat.
Every site I’ve used a passkey on still has the option of logging in with username and password. A Yubikey is just faster and more convenient (type the pin and touch the device) than opening up my password manager.
Work gave everyone one this year, now we are required to use it.
These are so fucking annoying and so shitty and barely work and now I have this stupid USB thing I have to use on my phone and laptop so it’s constantly plugged in and unplugged and it’s probably going to break within a year, and God did I say how much I fucking hate these stupid Yubikeys?
Thanks, I’ve been willing to buy one when they were hyped some time ago (a decade or something), but changed my mind. Never regretted. Got yourself a nice password manager, that’s plenty.
usually it’s because it’s either an extension interfering or the website declared username/password field with non-consecutive tab index, or the app doesn’t even support tabbing into password field at all
Or the password manager “typing” the password, but it doesn’t fill the box and then the manager dares to say “done!!” even tho it has not done it. Again and again, until you give up and manually add the password in.
“I understand that your username and password are correct, but I just won’t let you log in right now. No, I couldn’t have told you this before you tried to.”
You forgot the “click to verify you are human” (followed by a dumb captcha, maybe 10) just after you click login but before logging in, which makes you, after you pass the captcha, click again to login.
Once they are at the level where they break HTTPS, they can also ask you for the 2FA code or passkey and intercept that through their services, and you’d be hacked anyway.
I didn’t test it (of course), but I think they do for this case.
So we have a man in the middle attack, that proxies traffic to a website through it and just decrypts it without changing it during the login. This is similar to what cloudflare does. The browser has no way to know somebody is spying: HTTPS cerificate is ok(stolen cert), the domain matches the expected(dns poisoning), even the page is exactly the same, so it performs the passkey challenge/response. The only thing that changed is the certificate, which is not suspicious (certificates can change normally!).
The attacker is not able to clone the passkey, but they are able though to steal your session cookies after the login. Instead of giving you the “login success page” they keep you waiting on a loading page while they navigate (with a script) with your stolen session cookies to the “add passkey” page of the site to add theirs.
If the website asks them again for the passkey as confirmation, instead of serving the “login successful page”, they serve the new 2FA prompt to you.
You are left wondering “Didn’t I just do the 2FA? What a buggy site!”. And unknowingly approve adding the attacker’s passkey.
Game over, account fully compromised.
We are lucky that HTTPs is very good for security, they revoke certificates very quickly if this happens, and browsers check the certificate transparency logs making it impossible to forge a new certificate, even if you got hold of a root certificate with private key “4”.
This attack also needs unrealistic level of compromise: stolen and unrevoked certificate + a poisoned DNS. Completely unrealistic scenario, but it’s not passkeys that saved you, it was HTTPS.
When they say passkeys are unphisheable they mean you can’t usually copy them and give them to an attacker, but an attacker can absolutely still add theirs to your account.
That’s tickling a part of my recollection, but I could be crossing wires.
I could have sworn webauthn had a component where the server also signed a challenge for proof of possession of their key.
There’s also the component where the server can assert that the device is of a certain type, from a certain providence, in a way that’s a lot harder to fake. Anyone worth their salt would also notice that the users IP address had gone very weird, and in fact all the addresses for every customer had gone weird and identical (automatically, since no one’s checking that obviously).
You’re still fundamentally correct, but it’s worth underscoring how massively you’d have needed to own their infrastructure for the passkeys to be compromised. :)
Some time ago I was browsing less credible part of the internet and got a Cloudflare pop-up asking me to check the captcha tick box. So I did. Then it asked me to verify the check by pasting a command into powershell. Wonder how many people fell for that one
You should blame people that maliciously steal passwords or otherwise access accounts they shouldn’t be. You should be blaming the criminals not random people just trying to log into their email.
You should also blame enshitification for the broader prompt fatigue we deal with that makes things like “Add a passkey? :D” prompts feel so tiring.
I hate that my entire job at the moment is looking after those fucking login/registration flows. It’s NEVER simple, it’s always “Oh we want this in the flow too, and this, and this, and we want all these alternate flows but we want to be anonymous when we log in so we’re logged in, but as nobody, oh and we want to be able to log in as like 10 different emails all at the same time, and also if I sign into one identity provider and then sign into a different one, it should know that and sign me into the new one automatically. Third party cookies? I’m not talking about biscuits!”.
There’s so much bullshit I’ve had to staple onto our existing system just to make the login process even more complicated for business analysts that don’t know what they want.
The typical experience with passkeys is “click login button > browser asks which account you want to use > crypto exchange happens and you are logged in”. So nothing is shown to the site until you ask the browser to do it.
1Password has been my go to. It will autofill 2FA if I register it with 1PW. The sites that still send text and don’t allow authenticator apps still bug the shit out of me.
Somewhat, but the 6 digit code still rotates and my master password is miles long. Then you need to get past the security on the device that it resides on, so that is technically a second factor.
But that’s less likely than whatever random website getting compromised and having stored your password in plaintext, so the 2FA stored next to your password in your password manager still protects you from that
Easy to fall into that 1FA trap. Check out the open source 2FAS Authenticator mobile app and browser extension. It’s the most seamless you can get true 2FA with TOTP
I hate that Microsoft/Google have 1 account for hundreds of services. I want a different account for each service but that requires logging out and back in multiple times.
Get Firefox, and get the container plug-in. It lets you assign sites to containers so for example if you have different account for Xbox and office and GitHub, you assign them each to their own container and it doesn’t share cookies between them. Result is you stay logged in the way you want and you never have to switch accounts.
For 2FA: Find a good password manager. They can also handle TOTP (the algorithm most 2FA implementations use), so you just autofill user & password, then autofill the TOTP, done.
I use KeePassXC + sync the DB, but there are plenty of other trustworthy password managers. Plus, if you get in the habit of generating secure passwords using the password manager, one leaked login doesn’t cost you all of them.
What they’re saying is that if all of the multiple factors are stored behind 1 master password in 1 service, the whole purpose of MFA is negated. You’ve just shifted the single point of failure from a website password to your Bitwarden master password.
You all guys simply don’t understand the idea. The idea to not have two or ten password managers. The idea is for the website being compromised, TOTP password won’t compromise the algorithm. Having just one password, stealing it, poof. Having them two, big difference. That’s the idea. They are different. Yes, many sites and services fuck up that by, say, sending them both to your email or something like that. But putting your TOTP into your password manager does not change much into the worse. Not issuing that 2nd password is what makes you less secure.
My job uses a Yubikey, authenticator, and more than 6 passwords, one of which for some damn reason at random points in a day thinks I’m on a seperate machine and forces me to get a verification code in my email. On top of that, one password resets every 3mo, another at 3 weeks, and the others are like every 8mo. All remember past passwords, will not allow any variation or similarity (you had a twelve char password with a number at the end in 2021, try another). It is a damn struggle creating a new password 12 years in now.
I’d say avout an avg of 40 min per week, since some time is for every day entering all the required info, some days trying 5+ plus password configurations over 10 min, and others using email verification, etc. My company drives us to just have 15s between calls, yet overloads with so much extra shit and slow vpn connections that the real time saved would be in proper system administration. Instead they use salesforce bs and like companies to reinvent the wheel every other year and we use one more extra system that was once combined with another. “Be advised training on new features will be arriving soon” results in groans aplenty. But keep up with that call volume! Oh, and we just offloaded more call queues today because that outsourced call center is getting bogged down and you guys now have 18s between calls. That’s right, 14 queues today! Yay! We make you be efficient because we’re incompetent and can’t do it ourselves! Oh and everyone loves our AI that we train using your calls! They love it so much they like to tell our employees after pissing away 15min with it in looped instructions! Your job is great, tell us in our culture survey how you feel! (Comments have now been removed from surveys, numbered questions only)
Are you allowed to use a password manager, like 1password or Bitwarden? I juggle with docens of passwords per client, all with different expiration dates and complexity rules. A password manager is the only reason I can get them all straight. A good password manager should let you save your passwords, passkeys, recovery codes and MFA codes all in one app locked with a single password + MFA
Nope, no managers. I use the extra secure, no one would ever know where it is method as I work from home (not telling but yeah, it is definitely not under my keyboard. It reall isn’t, but just as bad).
They read it and many other studies. They know better because the Private Equity Overlords know how to successfully run corporations far into the future.
You can think of it kind of like the digital equivalent to a physical key.
When you save a passkey to a device, you’re making that device a “keyholder” for the account in question. You’re basically granting absolute trust to that device.
From that point forward, the device has perpetual access to the account - no password or 2FA needed. The device can also be used to grant new sign-in sessions on other devices, still without a password or 2FA.
Use of a passkey requires using the device’s unlock code or biometric authentication. When they’re on a phone, users can scan a QR code to authorize a sign-in on another device.
Unlike a physical key, a passkey cannot be duplicated. They are cryptographically linked to a device’s physical hardware ID or to a unique ID in a password manager.
This brings us to the irony in the post’s comic. For these gymnastics to take place, the user would have to select “later” every time the passkey prompt comes up. Creating the passkey would make the log in process even easier than the top section (from the user’s trusted devices).
Without any kind of MFA, the top example is actually wildly insecure and it’s largely a matter of time before that account is compromised. “What I want” is the digital equivalent to leaving your front door unlocked - convenience at the expense of security.
It is not being fixed because the people that decide whether it needs fixing or not are so wealthy that they have dedicated servants to take care of that drudgery. You’re an NPC that is a programmable cog in their passive cash flow generator, not a person.
Try losing your phone and see how easy is to recover from that, or having to explain to your grandma how they lost their accounts everywhere because they didn’t have a backup strategy for passkeys, even though they remember the password for the account (!).
There’s also the very big issue of attestation, where websites can force users to use a specific password manager, which doesn’t allow you to move the key to a fully free solution. This was made for companies to force the users to use real hardware tokens or only approved authenticator apps, but nothing prevents google to start forcing you to use only google authenticator to login to google, or for apple to own an iphone to login to a site. Usually all big-company passwors managers don’t have any way to export the key, and you have to wonder why.
This attestation threat is very real: here is somebody that AFAIK was part of the w3c committee that made passkeys threatening to use attestation against keepassxc for allowing the user to export keys: github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/issues/10407
Overall, it feels like yet another complicated technology, that also allows big companies to consolidate power.
Every conclusion you just made is wildly incorrect, or at the very least misleading or misunderstood.
Try losing your phone and see how easy is to recover from that, or having to explain to your grandma how they lost their accounts everywhere because they didn’t have a backup strategy for passkeys, even though they remember the password for the account (!).
If you lose your Amazon passkey, you can switch back to another 2FA method. Same for Google, and honestly, every other place I have a passkey in play. Adding a passkey doesn’t delete your password or other 2FA.
Losing your phone usually doesn’t lose your passkeys anyway. Apple, Google, 1Password, and Bitwarden sync them, so they come back when you sign in on a new device.
There’s also the very big issue of attestation, where websites can force users to use a specific password manager, which doesn’t allow you to move the key to a fully free solution. This was made for companies to force the users to use real hardware tokens or only approved authenticator apps, but nothing prevents google to start forcing you to use only google authenticator to login to google, or for apple to own an iphone to login to a site.
Apple’s and Google’s synced passkeys provide no attestation, so a website can’t cryptographically tell which password manager made them.
A site can read the provider ID (AAGUID), but without attestation it’s self-reported and can be faked, so in the wild it’s useless as a way to block people. It’d be no different from Google requiring you to use Chrome, which they could already do today, but don’t.
Enforced provider restrictions do exist, but only in controlled enterprise setups with hardware keys or managed authenticators, like Entra ID allowlists.
Also, to note: Google Authenticator is a TOTP app. It’s not where Google stores passkeys.
Usually all big-company passwors managers don’t have any way to export the key, and you have to wonder why.
Out of date. Apple added passkey export/import in iOS/macOS 26, and Google added it to Google Password Manager in June 2026. Microsoft is the holdout: it can import but not export yet. Bitwarden also lets the end user export passkeys. The industry standard is built to move passkeys app-to-app, not as plaintext files that could be exfiltrated.
This attestation threat is very real: here is somebody that AFAIK was part of the w3c committee that made passkeys threatening to use attestation against keepassxc for allowing the user to export keys: github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/issues/10407
He asked the KeePassXC project to “put basic protections in place and collaborate with the ecosystem/industry,” and said attestation would allow RPs (websites) to block it. The pressure was real, but it was a warning about plaintext export, not a plan to lock people in. A plaintext passkey file can be grabbed by malware or talked out of someone by a scammer, which is why the industry built an app-to-app transfer standard instead.
Click Log In, it leads to a new page where you choose Personal Account or Business Partner.
Click Personal, it takes you to a page with a Log In button.
Also:
"Would you like to sign in with a Passskey?"
Yes.
“You don’t have a passkey!”
One site I used recently forced Passkey sign-on only, but when I tried to set one up on a second device, it said it would replace the first one! They’re meant to be per-device credentials!
If you use a password manager you can get your passkey and sync it with other devices. But please use an open source one that allows export, or you’ll be tying your login to apple, microsoft or google!
You guys don’t just reset your password every time you log in to something you don’t use daily? They’ll never get my password if even I can’t remember it, moving target!
Does it let you paste the passkey?
Does it let you do normal work with the passkey and not just take a backup or reset your password?
Does it let you use the same passkey multiple times or do you just have to create a new passkey every time?
Under normal circumstances you don’t need to do that. If we’re talking about abnormal ones, there are ways around that or use their password + 2FA for that instance but you’d be jumping through hoops anyways.
Does it let you do normal work with the passkey and not just take a backup or reset your password?
Yes
Does it let you use the same passkey multiple times or do you just have to create a new passkey every time?
Each site has a passkey that gets stored in your vault, I don’t see what the problem is here
People in this thread: “Can you just let me log in please? Oh and please also make sure nothing happens to my account, I’m saving my credit card in here, ok? And when I place an order, just use the saved card, no need to ask me, thanks!”
I get that the UX sucks, I get that corpos shouldn’t require an account for meaningless use cases, but man if you’re logging into an actual application that you truly use, especially if there’s money or privacy involved - literally deal with it and wait for the next improvement to have better UX. People are trying to steal your shit and 2FA/Passkeys protect you.
Passwords can fuck right off. We’re done with those.
Passwords are here to stay. There’s too many unfixable problems with key cryptography for it to work in every case. Fundamentally, some things need to be 100% memorizable by their owner.
??? that’s not what passkeys are at all. This is just bullshit security theater.
Passkeys are actually fairly neat, they are mostly just about forcing the user to do the thing they should be doing with passwords anyway, but standardized-ish so that the browser extension doesn’t need to figure out which form field is the username and which is the password.
The two factor code on your distraction machine that you wish you could forego but you also need to have Slack with you at all times because this is just how the world works now
I don’t like Passkey because it’s an overly complicated system, and because it places too much power in entities that I do not trust and I do not want to depend on.
I can’t use Passkey because it lacks support for some of the systems that I use.
It’s fine that it exists, but sadly, some online services have made it mandatory, thereby locking me out of my accounts.
ofc, but I’m asking what services are those to avoid them, because I’ve never seen a mandatory passkey enrollment, or even being mandatory to use it after it’s enrolled. And I must have over a dozen websites with passkeys.
Even my previous job which was a bit tighter on IT sec encouraged, but didn’t require it.
I think the main probem for now is bad third party implementation… several password managers work with passkeys, too, but they all have problems with interoperability, sometimes even with backing them up inside the program.
Not always. Took half hour of going in circles on a service when usinng passkey, we ended up deleting passkey to use login and password to finally get access.
Also pass key is device based so good luck if a their steals your phone. You won’t login again.
Is it really the EU? I know its their fault on the "annoying cookie pop-up" but I thought 2FA has been driving by market conditions, not government regulations, though it wouldn't be the first time politicians took credit by mandating what the market was already delivering
.
cookie popups are still the fault of the corporations because they try to get data they don’t absolutely need. reject still keeps “required cookies” whatever that means, so be thankful they at least need to get your consent for other stuff. (also ublock has a filter list for cookie popups, not clicking the popup at all counts as rejected for all intents and purposes)
314 comments
log in to comment.
2FA is a good thing. You don’t want it to go away.
Except when it’s just an email, or worse, a txt message, or worse, a whatsapp message, with no other option for using a proper 2fa generator…
But also, not every site needs 2fa, sometimes I really couldn’t care less if someone managed to hack into something, because I can just make a new account if that happened…
What really bugs me is that TOTP is objectively easier than any other form of 2fa. Just import the library, add the field on your login form, and you’re done.
Any company that chooses SMS or email verification over TOTP emphatically does not know what they’re doing.
2fa by email is probably slightly easier than TOTP, if the account verification via email is already implemented, but yeah, it’s not like it’s significantly easier…
That is a fair point. But again, you probably have to implement TOTP or something like it anyway, to generate the code.
The real reason is conversion. The majority of users aren’t good at technology, so you risk them losing their TOTP secret. Then the user either just says “screw this site” and leaves, or they take time getting customer support to reset their key.
So depending on the branch and customer base, it can often be much “cheaper” in the end to send login codes via email instead of using TOTP.
Maybe. And I think that could make sense as the PM’s answer, but I also think that a TOTP app is starting to become mainstream enough that it’s not a huge deal.
You don’t have to implement totp for these alternatives… The “thing” about totp is that there’s a shared secret and a timestamp. Due to potential drift in clocks you need a window and period to know how many time steps to test, and how long each is.
But with an email/SMS/WhatsApp, there’s no shared secret. So you can simply send a random code, and store server side when it was generated. Totp makes no sense in that case.
Not that totp is difficult to implement at all. My implementation for work was what, less than 200 lines of C++ I think? I didn’t implement the sha1 myself though.
You do have to implement TOTP, just not necessarily RFC 6238. Time-based one-time passwords require a shared secret, a shared time and a time-to-live. The shared secret is usually the key for generating the code, but can be the code itself. The shared time is still needed in mail authentication between the code generator and the code validator. The thing that’s usually different is the time to live, but in RFC 6238 it is a parameter, so you can implement mail verification with it and a long TTL.
An earlier version of that comment said “something like TOTP,” but I guess I left that out while I was revising it. My point is you have to implement something that does most of what TOTP does anyway, so why not just use the version that’s already been stress tested?
A local marketplace service in brazil only allows me to login using whatsapp codes or sms. When i enter the passowrd they ask for a whatsapp code
I don’t want it for like 95% of the logins I have.
Seriously. Why would i care if someone logs into most of them. What are they going to do watch a movie on my Netflix account, play my kids roblox games, or change my crew on my Rockstar account? It’s unnecessary bs.
The bigger issue is gaining account details and personal info for identity theft.
Which also doesn’t matter anymore because companies sell our data all the time or just give it away through their own data insecurities. Or yanno, white pages. com and similar exists and its pretty easy to find anything about anyone anytime.
They don’t sell your ID or credit card information though, which is information a lot of these kinds of services have.
Who cares if someone steals your identity? Just go on the dark web and buy a new one.
I don’t care. Likelihood is that’s not going to actually cause me anything but an annoyance anyway, so the cost of preventing it can’t be more annoying
Any account that does payment (like your netflix one), will be used to test out stolen credit cards. This will in turn flag your account for fraud. You might not want that. Unless you do, I don’t know
What? Like they’d try and use a stolen credit card to pay for my service?
They won’t be paying, just tokenizing the cards to see if the data is good.
Sounds like it wouldn’t be a problem at all, for me, and really a problem for the police or netflix or the credit card company.
It will be a problem for you when the police decide it’s a civil issue (which they most likely will). Whether the credit card company will help you with this really depends on their policies, and I’m not sure what Netflix is supposed to do about it.
If they said it was a civil issue, that’d mean no charges against me, which would be even better because then I could just make a different netflix account and have no legal issues.
Idk man. I just don’t think it’s a big deal for me.
What? Yeah of course there are no charges against you, you are the victim in this situation.
I misunderstood what this thread was about, I thought it was about someone stealing your credit card information from your Netflix account.
It’s not about a specific account, it’s about compromising your info.
The info one company considers enough to verify you when you call or chat with customer service, another company will give out freely. They can then hop and skip through those to get access to one of your accounts they actually want.
Your entire online security is only as secure as your most insecure account.
Well yeah, Netflix knows it’s super annoying when your watch history gets messed up. This is the real reason why Netflix (and all the other tech companies) are suddenly pushing so hard for passkeys… it has nothing to do with how much control and influence it’ll give them ;-)
[deleted]
Tell me that at least you use different email and password for every account because if not, then you just get screwed when they hack one account, also, if any of your social accounts gets hacked, it will for sure be used to scam or hack other people.
I use the same password where it doesn’t matter at all.
I use different passwords where it matters or where my usual password doesn’t work or was required to be changed.
There are 3 things where I don’t even save the password in a password manager. It stays in my wet memory. They are:
I get the theory, but if it itself relies on some login-based service (like email) it becomes a kind of chicken and egg problem.
Reminds me of all the times I’ve run into “Please provide another email address we can use to verify your signup for this email address.”
So I can’t have an email address unless I already have an email address. It’s the most asinine thing
And usually, the alternative is a text message to a phone, with most temporary number providers blocked.
Nobody really designed it, and there are ways around it, with some tradeoffs, but specific account -> email -> phone -> bank -> legal identity is the typical authentication chain that’s evolved. It’s because any way of signing up that’s too repeatable gets saturated with bots and spammers.
E-mail based 2fa isn’t good, but at least it’s better than having no 2nd factor at all.
Can we agree that 43-factor authentication would be bad, at least?
Like, it’d pretty weird if it actually happened, but if you start relying on another service that itself relies on another service as one of the factors, you’re opening the door to that.
My work 2fa can go away. I don’t give two shits if everything in the work app is printed in global papers, just stop making me go through a 5 step process to see my fucking roster.
Every time I have to fill out a 2FA at work, I die inside.
Bro, I am not a nVidia CEO, no Chinese spies are interested in the shit on my work computer. Also why do I need 7 different logins for the 7 apps we use, none of which are of any critical importance, none sharing the same password requirements.
Fuck that, IT. My passwords are taped to my monitor.
Almost all sites should allow me to choose whether I want 2fac. And they shouldn’t prompt for it nearly as often as they do - some services do it for every login, most seem to do it every month at least.
yes I do. I will take convivence over security most days. Just because you don't, and you have good reasons to want it to stay, doesn't mean everyone comes to the same conclusion based on similar data.
Although I personally think 2FA is very important in most cases, I agree that mandatory 2FA is annoying. If you want to forego security for convenience, that should be up to you. I’m sure you’re not stupid or ignorant of the risks.
As a user its annoying, as a developer it is incredibly frustrating and time consuming.
It fails for somebody every day, it adds a dependency for a known unreliable 3rd party that often mangles the identification data it sends back, it is exploited by that 3rd party for extending their monopoly, and it gives that 3rd party (or any hacker that got access to them) full access to impersonate any user it wants.
What?
Implement TOTP and let your users use their preferred authenticator and none of what you're struggling with will apply.
Which also means you can just copy/paste it alongside username and password with the same manager.
👆️
That’s the user’s choice, that should not be a consideration when choosing authentication methods as long as you tell them how to store it properly (in a reasonable way, probably shouldn’t mention keepass or anything like that).
I avoid all those big tech sites advocating passkeys in recent times anyway, so I did not really have much chance to test it. But my password manager at least seems to be able to properly store and backup passkeys. It’s the import/export should I want to use other software that seems to be universally lacking still.
Oh, yeah, and of course there’s someone on the internet talking about the MFA protocol that no corporation uses.
That one is obligatory too.
(Anyway, yes, if you need MFA, use TOTP. That’s a non-brainier. Except that corporations don’t have brains.)
Who doesn’t use TOTP/HOTP? The brain-less part usually comes into play when they then recommed (or even require…) propietary shit like Google’s authenticator app as if there weren’t enough secure and open source options.
Amazon, Facebook, and many more support TOTP in whatever authenticator you want. I don't particularly like either of those websites but they are massive and directly contradict your claim that no corporation uses this normal method of 2FA.
Huh? How? Implementing OTP (which I’m assuming most people here are talking about) is pretty trivial, and once you have it set up, it doesn’t require much maintenance.
This is uterly idiotic but ok. I have decided I do not need to wear seat belt in the car. Just because you do and you have good reasons to want it to stay, doesn’t mean everyone comes to the same conclusion based on similar data.
there, now you are getting it.
i dont want you not wearing the seatbelt, it is so easy to do
we live in a society and im tired of paying for stupid doing stupid things
The day my taxes go towards paying for people who don’t have 2fa, we can discuss whether it should be mandatory. Also, comparing a compromised Netflix account to loss of life, really?
comparing cost to society
there is a reason ms forces updates now
Good thing you aren’t in charge of anything, then.
Click login button -> Autofill username, password & totp token -> Done
(And staying signed in not working is an intentional side effect of deleting cookies and temp data on closing the browser…)
I don’t mind 2FA and Passkeys, they’re mostly fine. But I hate, hate, hate forced logins via magic links or 2FA by email or SMS.
Yeah. Fuck those. I just now have this case, where I cannot login to a service I pay a subscription for. Contact support, wrote explicitly “I looked into the spam folder. I even looked into the logs of my mailserver, your mailserver does not even contact mine”.
Wait for two days, answer is (of course) “have you looked into your spam folder?”, nothing else. As soon as I manage to login, I cancel 😅 (jk, cancelled the payment already). Fuck those.
Yah the first time I saw it I was like wow so clever, but now I’m like why do you disrespect our purest form of online speech for your transactional babble
2fa over email is light years better than 2fa over sms for a whole slew of security reasons.
That’s correct (at least most of the time), but it’s still terribly inconvenient.
That’s so true, I want 2FA that runs once a week per device and password login.
What other 2FA methods are you looking for? I have seen a couple sites that will call you, but that is really just verbal text messaging.
The stay logged on and trust this system actions are probably controlled by a browser cookie, so won’t work if you don’t allow cookies from that site.
Timed One Time Passwords (TOTP). It’s what Google Authenticator and a lot of other 2FA apps use.
a magic link is not 2FA if it doesn’t also require a password. it’s 1FA, they just replaced the one factor.
honestly i really hate websites that do that and yet don’t allow password-only 1FA. like sure, i understand that the average user’s password discipline is crap, but as a power user i’d really like it if all my accounts weren’t tied to all my other accounts sometimes.
2FA auth codes, like Ente Auth, or Okta.
Physicak Hardware key is the best.
even if you clear your cookies, the session token id still exists for the website
Some websites treat the first login you ever done as a sort of root of trust, for example for account recovery they might ask if you can to verify it is you on that session
Some websites use the number of login sessions and how many recent times you have logged in for theie hidden trust factor, and some may even lockdown your account if it gets too low automaticly
everyone knows to clear their cookies but absolutely nobody thinks to clear their localStorage, sessionStorage, or indexedDB. i have never once in my life seen someone include those when telling someone else to “clear their cookies.” even including cache in that list (e.g. using ctrl+shift+r to refresh the page instead of ctrl+r) is weirdly uncommon.
In my experience, they are. In my bowser, I have to explicitly allow the saving of site data if I hope to be able to keep myself logged in. For me, this is fine; I only want to stay logged in on a handful of sites anyway so the tradeoff between adding an exception for some sites vs. allowing every single site I visit to be able to save some piece of data doing god-knows-what (likely helping Facebook and the like track where it is I visit) on my machine is worth it.
I really hate when the login button is hard to find relative to the sign up button. It should be the other way around; you only sign up once, but you log in many times. It should be optimized for the more frequent task.
Why do you need a login button? You use a browser? Just download our app, it’s so convenient!*
*for us and our 398 advertising partners.
Do you guys not have phones?
Not everyone wants to download an app anyway, i’d be so glad if i could use many things in the browser even on mobile but well, fuck me i guess?
I think you missed it, but that comment was likely an ironic citation from here:
knowyourmeme.com/…/do-you-guys-not-have-phones
Ooh i see thx
It was definitely an ironic reference to that event, which sadly seems to have fallen into obscurity.
word, friendica used to be like this and I kept getting messages like "this user already exists" half the time I was trying to log in.
To me it’s always felt like a pretty blatant way to say they don’t give a shit about their existing users.
You are supposed to stay logged in all the time so their cookies can track you.
Users unfamiliar with the interface should get the big button.
I love those send me a text 2FAs and they say the code will expire in 30 seconds. And they take forever to come in.
That’s what it feels like waiting the text and it finally comes in.
You should not be using SMS 2FAs anyways as they are very not secure (because of the SMS protocol).
Use TOTP whenever possible (the one where you use an app like Google Authenticator, but you typically should use other FOSS solutions)
There are so many sites that force you to use the SMS 2FA, and I hate it!
For some logins I value so little i don’t even care to have a password on it, I really don’t give a shit if SMS isn’t secure.
Heh tell that to microslop. Every time you gotta log in to the college website. It feels so secure…
this is like when you have to call a customer service phone line and they tell you to try the website
“If you have a disability, simply use this alternative that’s even worse if you have a disability.”
Never seen that one ooof
The problem was those alternatives were even easier for AI, so they kept mutilating them until they’re practically unusable for anyone.
Like CAPTCHAs where the audio version sounds like those “satanic messages” you’d get by playing a record backwards.
wtf. no thank you
The worst way of login:
Login with Google
Login with Facebook
Login with GitHub
Followed by the login that doesn’t let you use a password but sends you a mail with a link instead. Straight from hell.
Even worse. They automatically create an account if you don’t already have one through the login mechanism, so you get multiple accounts that can’t be merged.
Don’t forget the work versus personal accounts, too!
All feeding the same backend databases, which access to will eventually end up sold on the market. Good luck if your employer buys it and sees you working on a side project while employed by them (depending on what your contract says).
Huh? That’s a thing?
I coded a SSO like that where all you did was put in an email and put the code in in like 2nd year of work as a dev.
Is that seriously an issue where that can cause duplication on some platforms?!
I think they mean where it tries to send a magic link, and say you signed up under name@yourdomain.com, but also have a Gmail or whatever and you forget and enter name@gmail.com, then it acts like it’s logging you in, but now you have an account also at name@gmail.com.
Oh I see.
No that’s weird to me. Even if you connect different social auths the platform should connect to the same email address
That is a key word there. Not all of them do. And it’s enough to be a noticeable pain in the ass.
In theory, but there are services that give you a new email address whether you want one or not, which means the check doesn’t work. You also have users that have a different email accounts with different social logins. My Facebook email is not the same as my Gmail account.
Combine that with automatic sign-up, and you have yourself a duplicate account generator. Please please please just ask me if I want to sign up for a new account. Don’t force it on me just because of the login.
Yea in our case it was tied to the address. The account was per email. But as others have said if you login with a different mail at some point on accident, you then have 2 accounts that would need merging.
Some services create email accounts for me even if I don’t want one. For example, Google and iCloud, so the single sign on can’t tell the difference and considers me different users, depending on how I logged in. It’s not reasonable to expect me to remember which sign on method must be used. It’s not like some random e-commerce platform is the most important thing in my life. It’s really dumb.
Combine that with dark patterns like creating new accounts from the login page without getting user consent first, and I have multiple services where I have to play the login guessing game and see which actual account is the real one.
I do this, for my own website, and for one simple reason: I don’t want to store passwords. I just want a proof your control the email (the website is based on notifying people)
Even worse:
Page 1: enter email or phone number
Page 2: enter password
Page 3: enter 2FA
okay, but why the fuck am I entering a password if you’re forcing me to use 2FA?
Corposluts: “iTs MoRe SeCuRe”
BITCH - If I can fucking reset my password with the same email/phone number I use to receive my 2FA, then the password is functionally useless
Well it wouldn’t be 2fa if you don’t use a password. Then it’s just 1fa.
(in case you didn’t know, 2fa stands for two-factor authentication, as in secondary authentication (usually besides a password))
As pointed out, if password can be reset from the same email you receive 2fa codes then it’s 1fa with extra steps.
Yes, but 2FA is usually another app, not email. Or even if it’s the same app being in your very password manager, it gets the second password from the algorithm. So if you steal my password, you can login. But stealing these 6 numbers that work for just 30 seconds is useless.
In a proper authentication system you’d still have to provide the 2nd factor after resetting your password. Resetting OTP should require recovery codes that you got when you set it up.
Damn do I hate websites that do this. It’s always a gamble if Keepass can handle their stupid multi-page form correctly.
this was the first time I read that as Keep ass
I choose to read it and pronounce it as keep ass every time
We are not the same
I tend to keep my ass in my pants, not always, butt usually.
Even worse: instead of your email or phone number. It’s not even username. It’s your fucking account number. I’m looking at you airline and hotel rewards programs. You think I know my fucking account number? Now I need to go into my email and lookup my fucking Airline Advantage number? And Gmail search is complete shit and all of the results I get are from the airline in my spam folder so I have to dig through all of that. Then when I finally do find it, fuck me if I can remember my password because I travel like once every couple of years and I’m hoping that if I keep saving up all of my points then maybe I can get a free flight to a neighboring city in 20 years…
You sound upset, can I offer you a complimentary bag of peanuts? They’re 60% nitrogen!
My favourite is when they expire passwords so frequently that literally every time I sign in it forces me to do a password recovery
This one makes me irrationally angry
no, it’s rational
It has the same energy as insurance companies or ISPs that only offer good deals to new customers.
Don’t forget it starts off with only an ‘email’ field and only shows the password field after you fill that out and click a button, just to make sure that the login flow is as crap as possible for your password manager to deal with.
Those are really annoying. They sometimes cause trouble with autofill and it means jumping through 3 pages if 2FA is enabled.
That’s fine. There’s multiple reasons to do that, most notably SSO stuff.
There isn’t any good reason, it breaks password managers. Just give people with special accounts their own log in page.
Don’t forget to accept the cookies [YES] ~[no]~
Don’t not deny allowing access to remove access to cookies!
Except you accept cookies in X browser, but not Y browser because that is an emulated system to run a 30yr old program they never bothered to update because it worked great on x86 machines but was never designed for 64 bit.
Website Title [Sign Up] ~[log in]~
What really grinds my gears is that every goddamn login site now has separate pages for username and password, so the Autofill {Username}{Tab}{Password}{Enter} scheme doesn’t work anymore.
Now you have to wait an unpredictable amount of time until you can enter your password.
Also another quck vent if someone from my bank is reading this: Please explain to me why I always have to 2FA my browser login with my phone, but not the other way around? How tf is that safer when I can do anything solely on my phone anyway, which has no 2nd factor?
I agree it’s stupid, but if you want to know why, here’s a link: news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20294523
I figured it was related to some shit like that.
At least with hardware authenticators, I could understand.
But of course, it is more accomodation for people who are too stupid to keep more than one account and don’t care about privacy at all. Great.
Don’t know what I still expect.
Unfortunately, that page does not explain much. So many meaningless comments. As usually with that garbage site.
CSAM, my governments authentication platform (before the abbreviation got hijacked) changed the {Username}{Tab}{Password}{Enter} sequence by adding a question mark button next to the username field that is z-indexed between username and password field.
I opened a ticket and a few months later got a reply that it’s an accessibility standard…
So now, after typing in my password and hitting tab, I’m always typing my password into the void.
How is any of this related to CSAM at all?
Yeah, I’ve had a few of those and had that happen.
At least, in that case, you can add a second tab to the sequence. It’s annoying and shouldn’t be necessary, but that should work.
The thing with the two pages is, I never know how long they load and (I have to criticize Keepass) entering “DELAY X-ms” doesn’t really wait for that amount of time, if I enter 10000, it doesn’t wait 10s, more like 2.
So there are two factors I have no clear control over. Should I just enter 100,000,000 and wait a minute every time to login?
csam.be
Okay, sorry, I somehow overread that part.
I guess it sounded nice like the old “open Sesame” story, i’m not sure what the letters stand for, if anything
Microsoft’s is even worse.
How hard is it to log in the user if the username and password were correct? If Microsoft can not figure out how to do this, why do other random websites work? Do those websites have some arcane knowledge being held away from Microsoft?
Microsoft Login is genuinely one of the worst designed piece of software I have ever seen. It takes actual skill to login lol.
Microsoft oauth login in a browser: type in password, get pop-up “reusing passwords is a security risk. Change password now?”.
I sure wonder why the password to my AD account is the same as the password to my windows account. It’s almost like they’re the exact same account or something.
I don’t think I know how to login to Microsoft. The authenticator app doesn’t work, and it just puts me into an infinite loop of clicking Use alternate method, entering codes, and then it telling me to use the Authenticator app which I just told it I didn’t want to use. I think I cried last time.
I have no idea how Microsoft got so powerful. Their software is awful
Watching the url bar when logging into MS Azure is quite the ride. It redirects one billion times.
… I was using 1password to store my passkey(s). On Thursday, it failed to login to Microsoft for work.
“Your passkey is valid, but didn’t meet the criteria set by your administrators.”
Screw this, I’m going back to passwords. At least I decide where/how to store this.
Microsoft seem to have integrated XBox Live and microsoft.com (and others, like Minecraft) just enough that they all depend on each other, but not enough to know WTF is going on. Trying to get anything working seems to involve logging into everything and messing with similar but ineffective settings. And, each login to each system does the Azure URL dance.
Your password is 30 days old. Make a new one. It can’t be the same as any of your last 37 passwords.
Mark, is that you?
Finally bout up sign in ~ "iS tHis YoU???!!? [yes][no] "
“Stay signed in”, the biggest lie
some fuckass website i’ll use thrice in my life: you NEED to add a passkey. for SECURITY. it’s IMPORTANT. DO IT!
my bank: heyyyy wanna do 2fa? it’s ok if u don’t… oh u do??? yaysies! ^w^ okay so. we can do sms or app notification :3
This bugs the hell out of me. Why does my Xbox account have better security than my bank?
One product comes from a technology company… the other a bank.
And the bank is supposed to care about security
Because your Xbox account is owned by Microsoft, which has a hidden interest in increasing passkey acceptance other than “it’s more secure”.
What do you mean? What’s wrong with passkeys?
Also the bank:
Wtf are you doing m8? Why your password so fucking long? Keep it to max 6 characters, like a sane person.
Those are some crazy charicters I’m going to need you to keep it letters and numbers only if you know what I mean.
Why did you mix lowercase and uppercase? Are you aware you may need to read the password to a bank manager? Keep it short and simple.
Better: face recognition. In AI age.
If you bank is this relaxed about access to the user-facing online banking interface, I’d had to know what kind of security malpractice is going on in their back end.
would you be surprised to learn they had a massive data breach a few years ago lol
Nope, but I am surprised that you haven’t written “my former bank” - though I guess most banks are federally insured for amounts that keep us normies covered.
Click ‘Sing in’ button -> takes you to registration page -> insert login and password -> tells you user already exists -> notice it’s the wrong form -> click on ‘already have an account’ below…
Saw this more than once. How the fuck does anyone implement it like that?
They dgaf about the paying members, the ones who aren’t paying are the ones they care about signing up.
Don’t forget, if you type in one of your other email addresses by mistake it says something like “sending you a magic link”.
Then it acts like you are signing in, but you are signing up, on a new account, oops, fuckers, just tell me it’s not a valid account.
By the way, having two accounts is not allowed, so we banned both accounts for violating EULA.
Telling the user that the account doesn’t exist is bad practice. Hackers can use it to find out who has an account on what platform and more directly target them with phishing emails
Ok, use the classic “bad username or password”.
Or just properly rate limit so hackers can’t just slam the long in page with a zillion combos.
I just paid all of my bills and had to login to each account. Once a month torture session lol.
i just have my bank do that.
I don’t like to automate it because I get paid every other week and it falls on different days. I just pay my bills first thing when I get paid so I know for sure it’s paid and didn’t bounce
This is why I hate, and don’t understand the “remember for next time”
Just to top up my phone once a month I have to do it. When I last did it, I clicked “remember”, even though I know it rarely works. I went to log in again the very next day to check something, and I have to log in again 😫
Logging in shouldn’t feel like passing an exam. Just let us access our accounts!
bot
Security is important, no doubt. I just think logging in should be secure without making the whole process unnecessarily complicated.
Okay wtf is up with accounts like these? What is the incentive to make a shitty comment bot on lemmy? I don't get it
Most governments have an incentive to poison the opinions and narratives on lemmy
Y'know...fair point
if ousing 2fa code is “like passing an exam,” maybe the internet is too hard for you.
Not all 2fa methods are created equal. “Shit … where did I put my RSA fob?”
And yes: I know there’s an app. The day my employer gives me a phone I might switch to it.
I thought the last one was just my computer being glitchy. So what’s the deal with that?
Fuck if I know. Cross site stuff probably.
Do you clear your cookies often? Or have any fingerprinting mitigation turned on? (I’m just throwing ideas out here, I’m not an expert on this stuff)
I use vanilla Chrome (no extensions at all) on a dedicated Windows install. It’s specifically for certain email accounts, government, banking, etc. Important real life business. I do that specifically so their software can run whatever the fuck unobtruded. Still some accounts will not stay logged in.
Some sites have a fairly short cookie lifetime on purpose. The “keep me logged in” button saves you from having to reenter your credentials every time you open the site in a new tab, but will still only work for a very short time.
Banking websites usually do this and I’ve seen a few government and insurance sites also do it. Our all beloved MS~hit~ often does this too when you use your company account outside of company hardware.
Most of the time something like this happens the website thinks highly enough of itself to warrant the extra caution. Not to say that a lot of sites aren’t just badly made.
What’s this supposed to mean?
Yubikey. It’s basically a passkey but locked onto a physical chip
Oh hell yes, that way if I lose it I can’t log into anything!!
Unless you also register a backup key and carefully store recovery codes whenever a service provides them!
Oh hell yes that sounds simple! Maybe we could call these codes “passwords” and call the service a “password manager”. Maybe we could even implement some kind of browser thing to automatically input these in webpages for more convenience.
While I do get your point, the fact that it can be used as a second factor of authentication you just have to touch (best case scenario) instead of looking up you phone messages or open one of your 7 apps of 2FA codes and input that , is pretty neat.
My password manager supports both, passwords and 2FA. It’s still convenient, and secure too.
You might be into something here
Have had mine on the same keychain for 6 years now, Yubikeys are absolutely worth it, pair it with an AirTag or something similar and you’ll be set.
Every site I’ve used a passkey on still has the option of logging in with username and password. A Yubikey is just faster and more convenient (type the pin and touch the device) than opening up my password manager.
I wanted one of these for a long time.
Work gave everyone one this year, now we are required to use it.
These are so fucking annoying and so shitty and barely work and now I have this stupid USB thing I have to use on my phone and laptop so it’s constantly plugged in and unplugged and it’s probably going to break within a year, and God did I say how much I fucking hate these stupid Yubikeys?
Thanks, I’ve been willing to buy one when they were hyped some time ago (a decade or something), but changed my mind. Never regretted. Got yourself a nice password manager, that’s plenty.
YubiKey, one of the many examples of loging in via keys
Not recognized by password manager for some fucking reason
That’s the second text on the bottom :)
usually it’s because it’s either an extension interfering or the website declared username/password field with non-consecutive tab index, or the app doesn’t even support tabbing into password field at all
Or the password manager “typing” the password, but it doesn’t fill the box and then the manager dares to say “done!!” even tho it has not done it. Again and again, until you give up and manually add the password in.
Google doesn’t care that your account got stolen, the IT department does
“I understand that your username and password are correct, but I just won’t let you log in right now. No, I couldn’t have told you this before you tried to.”
You forgot the “click to verify you are human” (followed by a dumb captcha, maybe 10) just after you click login but before logging in, which makes you, after you pass the captcha, click again to login.
Do yOu tRUsT tHiS maChiNe?
“No, but I’ll click yes this time because I know what you meant better than you do”
please install an app in your phone which only works once in the phone you installed it first and makes your life a hell the moment you change it.
Bad link won’t autofill though because it’s the wrong url
There are plenty of ways.
DNS poisoning with one of those #4 private keys would be the easiest.
Getting Grandma to add a trusted CA would be another.
Paste bombs into browser terminals.
Something you have is a very important part of keeping people out of your stuff.
Once they are at the level where they break HTTPS, they can also ask you for the 2FA code or passkey and intercept that through their services, and you’d be hacked anyway.
Passkeys don’t work like that. They would, in fact, stop that from happening.
That is of course if the company didn’t let you choose another method
Note: passkeys do aparently work like that, the one thing that they used to protect against it was pulled from the spec.
I didn’t test it (of course), but I think they do for this case.
So we have a man in the middle attack, that proxies traffic to a website through it and just decrypts it without changing it during the login. This is similar to what cloudflare does. The browser has no way to know somebody is spying: HTTPS cerificate is ok(stolen cert), the domain matches the expected(dns poisoning), even the page is exactly the same, so it performs the passkey challenge/response. The only thing that changed is the certificate, which is not suspicious (certificates can change normally!).
The attacker is not able to clone the passkey, but they are able though to steal your session cookies after the login. Instead of giving you the “login success page” they keep you waiting on a loading page while they navigate (with a script) with your stolen session cookies to the “add passkey” page of the site to add theirs.
If the website asks them again for the passkey as confirmation, instead of serving the “login successful page”, they serve the new 2FA prompt to you. You are left wondering “Didn’t I just do the 2FA? What a buggy site!”. And unknowingly approve adding the attacker’s passkey.
Game over, account fully compromised.
We are lucky that HTTPs is very good for security, they revoke certificates very quickly if this happens, and browsers check the certificate transparency logs making it impossible to forge a new certificate, even if you got hold of a root certificate with private key “4”. This attack also needs unrealistic level of compromise: stolen and unrevoked certificate + a poisoned DNS. Completely unrealistic scenario, but it’s not passkeys that saved you, it was HTTPS.
When they say passkeys are unphisheable they mean you can’t usually copy them and give them to an attacker, but an attacker can absolutely still add theirs to your account.
I wasn’t aware they dropped WebAuthN, it was RIGHT THERE… but you’re right.
it’s still a lot easier to get someone to 2FA over the phone and tell them their password manager is flakey, but I def concede
That’s tickling a part of my recollection, but I could be crossing wires.
I could have sworn webauthn had a component where the server also signed a challenge for proof of possession of their key.
There’s also the component where the server can assert that the device is of a certain type, from a certain providence, in a way that’s a lot harder to fake. Anyone worth their salt would also notice that the users IP address had gone very weird, and in fact all the addresses for every customer had gone weird and identical (automatically, since no one’s checking that obviously).
You’re still fundamentally correct, but it’s worth underscoring how massively you’d have needed to own their infrastructure for the passkeys to be compromised. :)
Damn, that’s awful news
Some time ago I was browsing less credible part of the internet and got a Cloudflare pop-up asking me to check the captcha tick box. So I did. Then it asked me to verify the check by pasting a command into powershell. Wonder how many people fell for that one
That’s when you go to your password app and click autofill yourself.
Autofill will typically check the URL of the site, byte for byte.
I wonder if the hacker will accept the whole Bee movie script as a password…
Now you made me wonder if the bee movie script is in a rainbow table somewhere
The SSHole vulnerability supported up to 1k of password characters, as long as you had more than ~300 it would just let you in
Blame the credential stuffers, and then the people that reuse the same stupid password and not bother to use a password manager.
Well that’s a very stupid thing to do.
You should blame people that maliciously steal passwords or otherwise access accounts they shouldn’t be. You should be blaming the criminals not random people just trying to log into their email.
You should also blame enshitification for the broader prompt fatigue we deal with that makes things like “Add a passkey? :D” prompts feel so tiring.
I hate that my entire job at the moment is looking after those fucking login/registration flows. It’s NEVER simple, it’s always “Oh we want this in the flow too, and this, and this, and we want all these alternate flows but we want to be anonymous when we log in so we’re logged in, but as nobody, oh and we want to be able to log in as like 10 different emails all at the same time, and also if I sign into one identity provider and then sign into a different one, it should know that and sign me into the new one automatically. Third party cookies? I’m not talking about biscuits!”.
There’s so much bullshit I’ve had to staple onto our existing system just to make the login process even more complicated for business analysts that don’t know what they want.
What i want:
Click login button
Cryptographic exchange happens
Done
I’d rather my browser not automatically tell sites things about me
If you have javascript enabled, it’s already telling a badrillion things automatically, uniquely fingerprinting you across all webpages.
Uh-huh
The typical experience with passkeys is “click login button > browser asks which account you want to use > crypto exchange happens and you are logged in”. So nothing is shown to the site until you ask the browser to do it.
1Password has been my go to. It will autofill 2FA if I register it with 1PW. The sites that still send text and don’t allow authenticator apps still bug the shit out of me.
Yes, but then you have your 2fa codes along with your passwords in the same store. Which somewhat defeats the purpose of 2fa
Somewhat, but the 6 digit code still rotates and my master password is miles long. Then you need to get past the security on the device that it resides on, so that is technically a second factor.
completely defeats the point of 2FA. that is 1FA
If your password manager is compromised, sure.
But that’s less likely than whatever random website getting compromised and having stored your password in plaintext, so the 2FA stored next to your password in your password manager still protects you from that
Easy to fall into that 1FA trap. Check out the open source 2FAS Authenticator mobile app and browser extension. It’s the most seamless you can get true 2FA with TOTP
I hate that Microsoft/Google have 1 account for hundreds of services. I want a different account for each service but that requires logging out and back in multiple times.
Firefox is the answer.
Get Firefox, and get the container plug-in. It lets you assign sites to containers so for example if you have different account for Xbox and office and GitHub, you assign them each to their own container and it doesn’t share cookies between them. Result is you stay logged in the way you want and you never have to switch accounts.
For 2FA: Find a good password manager. They can also handle TOTP (the algorithm most 2FA implementations use), so you just autofill user & password, then autofill the TOTP, done. I use KeePassXC + sync the DB, but there are plenty of other trustworthy password managers. Plus, if you get in the habit of generating secure passwords using the password manager, one leaked login doesn’t cost you all of them.
The second you put totp codes into bitwarden, it’s no longer mfa.
[deleted]
I do it to, bit it’s not mfa at that point because you have a single point of failure/compromise
It’s intentional, actually, that way I can recover my data as easily as possible. I know how to do this safely.
Also, it can still be MFA which is the way I use it.
What they’re saying is that if all of the multiple factors are stored behind 1 master password in 1 service, the whole purpose of MFA is negated. You’ve just shifted the single point of failure from a website password to your Bitwarden master password.
You all guys simply don’t understand the idea. The idea to not have two or ten password managers. The idea is for the website being compromised, TOTP password won’t compromise the algorithm. Having just one password, stealing it, poof. Having them two, big difference. That’s the idea. They are different. Yes, many sites and services fuck up that by, say, sending them both to your email or something like that. But putting your TOTP into your password manager does not change much into the worse. Not issuing that 2nd password is what makes you less secure.
My job uses a Yubikey, authenticator, and more than 6 passwords, one of which for some damn reason at random points in a day thinks I’m on a seperate machine and forces me to get a verification code in my email. On top of that, one password resets every 3mo, another at 3 weeks, and the others are like every 8mo. All remember past passwords, will not allow any variation or similarity (you had a twelve char password with a number at the end in 2021, try another). It is a damn struggle creating a new password 12 years in now.
How much time do you spend on that per week?
I’d say avout an avg of 40 min per week, since some time is for every day entering all the required info, some days trying 5+ plus password configurations over 10 min, and others using email verification, etc. My company drives us to just have 15s between calls, yet overloads with so much extra shit and slow vpn connections that the real time saved would be in proper system administration. Instead they use salesforce bs and like companies to reinvent the wheel every other year and we use one more extra system that was once combined with another. “Be advised training on new features will be arriving soon” results in groans aplenty. But keep up with that call volume! Oh, and we just offloaded more call queues today because that outsourced call center is getting bogged down and you guys now have 18s between calls. That’s right, 14 queues today! Yay! We make you be efficient because we’re incompetent and can’t do it ourselves! Oh and everyone loves our AI that we train using your calls! They love it so much they like to tell our employees after pissing away 15min with it in looped instructions! Your job is great, tell us in our culture survey how you feel! (Comments have now been removed from surveys, numbered questions only)
Are you allowed to use a password manager, like 1password or Bitwarden? I juggle with docens of passwords per client, all with different expiration dates and complexity rules. A password manager is the only reason I can get them all straight. A good password manager should let you save your passwords, passkeys, recovery codes and MFA codes all in one app locked with a single password + MFA
Nope, no managers. I use the extra secure, no one would ever know where it is method as I work from home (not telling but yeah, it is definitely not under my keyboard. It reall isn’t, but just as bad).
There’s a paper on why constantly changing passwords just erodes security. IT might want to read it
They read it and many other studies. They know better because the Private Equity Overlords know how to successfully run corporations far into the future.
Also… sends code to email account, which requires another round of login hoops.
Tell me about passkeys.
You can think of it kind of like the digital equivalent to a physical key.
When you save a passkey to a device, you’re making that device a “keyholder” for the account in question. You’re basically granting absolute trust to that device.
From that point forward, the device has perpetual access to the account - no password or 2FA needed. The device can also be used to grant new sign-in sessions on other devices, still without a password or 2FA.
Use of a passkey requires using the device’s unlock code or biometric authentication. When they’re on a phone, users can scan a QR code to authorize a sign-in on another device.
Unlike a physical key, a passkey cannot be duplicated. They are cryptographically linked to a device’s physical hardware ID or to a unique ID in a password manager.
This brings us to the irony in the post’s comic. For these gymnastics to take place, the user would have to select “later” every time the passkey prompt comes up. Creating the passkey would make the log in process even easier than the top section (from the user’s trusted devices).
Without any kind of MFA, the top example is actually wildly insecure and it’s largely a matter of time before that account is compromised. “What I want” is the digital equivalent to leaving your front door unlocked - convenience at the expense of security.
So it’s the same concept as using a pair of ssh keys to sign in.
Never heard of websites asking about passkeys, so i’m curious. I probably just Baader-Meinhof’d myself and start seeing it everywhere.
See it's like a password, only we called it something different.
Logging in is a 17 button process these days.
It is not being fixed because the people that decide whether it needs fixing or not are so wealthy that they have dedicated servants to take care of that drudgery. You’re an NPC that is a programmable cog in their passive cash flow generator, not a person.
I hate passkeys. Fuck off with your passkeys. I will stop using Amazon because it won’t stop trying to add a passkey into my bitwarden
There’s a lot of other better reasons to stop using amazon, but if that’s the one for you, it’s still a victory if you stop using them.
What’s wrong with passkeys? my preferred method. Hell I wish everything just used those and no email password shit
Try losing your phone and see how easy is to recover from that, or having to explain to your grandma how they lost their accounts everywhere because they didn’t have a backup strategy for passkeys, even though they remember the password for the account (!).
There’s also the very big issue of attestation, where websites can force users to use a specific password manager, which doesn’t allow you to move the key to a fully free solution. This was made for companies to force the users to use real hardware tokens or only approved authenticator apps, but nothing prevents google to start forcing you to use only google authenticator to login to google, or for apple to own an iphone to login to a site. Usually all big-company passwors managers don’t have any way to export the key, and you have to wonder why.
This attestation threat is very real: here is somebody that AFAIK was part of the w3c committee that made passkeys threatening to use attestation against keepassxc for allowing the user to export keys: github.com/keepassxreboot/keepassxc/issues/10407
Overall, it feels like yet another complicated technology, that also allows big companies to consolidate power.
Every conclusion you just made is wildly incorrect, or at the very least misleading or misunderstood.
If you lose your Amazon passkey, you can switch back to another 2FA method. Same for Google, and honestly, every other place I have a passkey in play. Adding a passkey doesn’t delete your password or other 2FA.
Losing your phone usually doesn’t lose your passkeys anyway. Apple, Google, 1Password, and Bitwarden sync them, so they come back when you sign in on a new device.
Apple’s and Google’s synced passkeys provide no attestation, so a website can’t cryptographically tell which password manager made them.
A site can read the provider ID (AAGUID), but without attestation it’s self-reported and can be faked, so in the wild it’s useless as a way to block people. It’d be no different from Google requiring you to use Chrome, which they could already do today, but don’t.
Enforced provider restrictions do exist, but only in controlled enterprise setups with hardware keys or managed authenticators, like Entra ID allowlists.
Also, to note: Google Authenticator is a TOTP app. It’s not where Google stores passkeys.
Out of date. Apple added passkey export/import in iOS/macOS 26, and Google added it to Google Password Manager in June 2026. Microsoft is the holdout: it can import but not export yet. Bitwarden also lets the end user export passkeys. The industry standard is built to move passkeys app-to-app, not as plaintext files that could be exfiltrated.
He asked the KeePassXC project to “put basic protections in place and collaborate with the ecosystem/industry,” and said attestation would allow RPs (websites) to block it. The pressure was real, but it was a warning about plaintext export, not a plan to lock people in. A plaintext passkey file can be grabbed by malware or talked out of someone by a scammer, which is why the industry built an app-to-app transfer standard instead.
Good to know that they added exporting!
It might make it a bit more acceptable for me, if it’s possible to move the keys to an open password manager.
The initial implementation with the risk of lock-in soured me so much that I just gave up and never looked at it ever again.
I also don’t trust FAANG companies, and them pushing the technology so hard made it an instant turn-off.
I use OSS Vaultwarden backend with bitwarden client. Works great.
Nah fucking email code every time! Just let me use ausernsme and password fucking god damned it. I don’t want my email involved in this process!
But if they don’t constantly verify that your using that email, the spam that they send you later would be worthless
Galaxy brain: if nobody can log in, nobody can hack us.
Click Log In, it leads to a new page where you choose Personal Account or Business Partner.
Click Personal, it takes you to a page with a Log In button.
Also:
One site I used recently forced Passkey sign-on only, but when I tried to set one up on a second device, it said it would replace the first one! They’re meant to be per-device credentials!
If you use a password manager you can get your passkey and sync it with other devices. But please use an open source one that allows export, or you’ll be tying your login to apple, microsoft or google!
You forgot the part where it shows your username on the profile link like you’re already logged in before they make you do all that bullshit.
Work just forced Windows Hello on the company computers.
WTF; how is an unchanging 4 digit PIN more secure than my 14 character password?
You guys don’t just reset your password every time you log in to something you don’t use daily? They’ll never get my password if even I can’t remember it, moving target!
Click login button -> Use your passkey -> Done
Does it let you paste the passkey?
Does it let you do normal work with the passkey and not just take a backup or reset your password?
Does it let you use the same passkey multiple times or do you just have to create a new passkey every time?
Under normal circumstances you don’t need to do that. If we’re talking about abnormal ones, there are ways around that or use their password + 2FA for that instance but you’d be jumping through hoops anyways.
Yes
Each site has a passkey that gets stored in your vault, I don’t see what the problem is here
People in this thread: “Can you just let me log in please? Oh and please also make sure nothing happens to my account, I’m saving my credit card in here, ok? And when I place an order, just use the saved card, no need to ask me, thanks!”
I get that the UX sucks, I get that corpos shouldn’t require an account for meaningless use cases, but man if you’re logging into an actual application that you truly use, especially if there’s money or privacy involved - literally deal with it and wait for the next improvement to have better UX. People are trying to steal your shit and 2FA/Passkeys protect you.
Passwords can fuck right off. We’re done with those.
Passwords are here to stay. There’s too many unfixable problems with key cryptography for it to work in every case. Fundamentally, some things need to be 100% memorizable by their owner.
I got a new phone and tried using the Merlin birding app but now I need to enter an email, receive an email, confirm using the link in the email…
…and then enter the user name and password I’ve been using to log into the app for years.
And it’s not just once but every time I use the app, it’s a nightmare, and I don’t want to give any extra information I don’t have to.
website login is fine. app login rejects same login/pass. fml
Ah yes, the authentication scourge of the internet, passkeys.
Repeat forever. That is how corporate passkeys seem to work nowadays.
Enter the code e-mailed to you. It arrives ten minutes later. This code is expired.
??? that’s not what passkeys are at all. This is just bullshit security theater.
Passkeys are actually fairly neat, they are mostly just about forcing the user to do the thing they should be doing with passwords anyway, but standardized-ish so that the browser extension doesn’t need to figure out which form field is the username and which is the password.
The two factor code on your distraction machine that you wish you could forego but you also need to have Slack with you at all times because this is just how the world works now
I wanted to put something about Reminging for your phone in that text as well, but it would be too long.
And then someone halfway across the world is just allowed to walk in
Why does this meme presume a log in is even necessary!!
It doesn’t
I’m done offering users to use passwords. Makes the auth code so much simpler and defers the security to the user’s email or passkey storage.
Why are you hating on passkeys? They are awesome! So much more convenient than passwords.
I don’t like Passkey because it’s an overly complicated system, and because it places too much power in entities that I do not trust and I do not want to depend on.
I can’t use Passkey because it lacks support for some of the systems that I use.
It’s fine that it exists, but sadly, some online services have made it mandatory, thereby locking me out of my accounts.
Making it mandatory is incredibly stupid.
This is confusing me. Where are passkeys mandatory? Everywhere I have it configured they’re an additional way to sign in, never the only one.
That just means none of the services you use have made it mandatory. Consider yourself lucky.
ofc, but I’m asking what services are those to avoid them, because I’ve never seen a mandatory passkey enrollment, or even being mandatory to use it after it’s enrolled. And I must have over a dozen websites with passkeys.
Even my previous job which was a bit tighter on IT sec encouraged, but didn’t require it.
Sorry, but I don’t post lists of services I use, for the same reason that I don’t post lists of places I go.
I hope your luck continues to be good.
I think the main probem for now is bad third party implementation… several password managers work with passkeys, too, but they all have problems with interoperability, sometimes even with backing them up inside the program.
This is my answer—passkeys suck. Maybe in another decade they’ll be usable.
tbh if you actually use passkeys the entire hassle is gone
Nnnnnnnnnnnope. Not even close.
Well, it is for me. I can sign in with one click, can’t get better than that.
Now what happens if you lose that device? What about if you need to log in on a new device?
It’s a synced password manager, all devices have the passkey
I can only speak for myself, but I often can't find where I put my device that the passkey is on.
ah, I use a password manager, so it’s always in hand
If you just create a passkey, it’s exactly like the top one
Not always. Took half hour of going in circles on a service when usinng passkey, we ended up deleting passkey to use login and password to finally get access.
Also pass key is device based so good luck if a their steals your phone. You won’t login again.
Blame the EU
Is it really the EU? I know its their fault on the "annoying cookie pop-up" but I thought 2FA has been driving by market conditions, not government regulations, though it wouldn't be the first time politicians took credit by mandating what the market was already delivering
.
cookie popups are still the fault of the corporations because they try to get data they don’t absolutely need. reject still keeps “required cookies” whatever that means, so be thankful they at least need to get your consent for other stuff. (also ublock has a filter list for cookie popups, not clicking the popup at all counts as rejected for all intents and purposes)