21 comments

log in to comment.

  • @Neil@netburrow.org · 6 Nov 2026

    One thing I hate about Immich: Their absolute refusal to bake in basic TOTP auth.

    • @warmaster@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

      IMHO, I kinda agree with their decision. I see basic auth as just that, user and pass. Anything else should use a proper solution, and there are tons of excellent options.

    • @MangoPenguin@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 6 Nov 2026

      Isn’t that generally what external auth providers are designed for?

      I imagine it isn’t much of a concern if Immich isn’t exposed to the internet.

    • @Svinhufvud@sopuli.xyz · 6 Nov 2026

      If you want to go the extra mile, you can roll immich with Autelia / Authentik etc. IDP, and use TOTP on that layer.

      • @lemmyvore@feddit.nl · 6 Nov 2026

        One problem is that it’s not much use applying secondary auth methods on the server side if the mobile app can’t use them.

        • @TheOneCurly@feddit.online · 7 Nov 2026

          Immich supports oidc, you should be able to do all auth (including totp) in your auth provider and that all works in the app. I use pocketid with mine and it works everywhere.

        • @silenium_dev@feddit.org · 9 Nov 2026

          The immich mobile app can use OIDC, it just shows you the button on login, which then opens a browser window to login with the external provider

        • @zingo@sh.itjust.works low rep · 6 Nov 2026 · edited

          Yeah. I have notest that when I put Tinyauth in front of Copyparty.

          The Party Up! app, for uploading files to the server ceased to work. Also my WebDAV mount in Dolphin can’t reach it. Unauthorized!

          DuH !!

          Fix one thing to discover another problem.

        • @JustEnoughDucks@feddit.nl · 10 Nov 2026

          Good thing it can use them then.

          Running authelia SSO OIDC with immich in the app for 3 years now.