cross-posted from: https://piefed.world/c/tech/p/1525937/reddit-is-turning-user-conversations-into-ai-powered-product-reviews
38
Reddit is turning user conversations into AI-powered product reviews
Introducing Reddit Reviews
Discover Reddit Reviews, a new experience that organizes product conversations and highlights the most important takeaways from across our communities.
redditinc.com
7 comments
log in to comment.
A few years ago discovered excluding some usernames from a product search can turn reddit results from dozens of hits to none. I noticed those accounts were in all likelihood using keyword notifcations so they could reply to any post mentioning certain model numbers.
In the era of billions of different models of products, there really isn’t many people writing about everything. What you get outside of the popular brands and models is nothing at all.
It’s more of a red flag than anything if I go looking for reviews and find too much posting about a random product model that isn’t a household brand name or obviously popular model. If it’s a popular item then I wouldn’t have needed to be digging through the internet for reddit comments anyway.
To be honest, even before AI it felt like a lot of product recommendations were fake.
The part that bothers me isn't the AI, it's that nobody in those threads was writing a review. They were talking to each other. Reddit took a conversation between people and sold it as a product, and the people get nothing, not even the choice to opt out.
I run a forum, so I thought about this when writing the terms. What we ended up with is simple. What you write is yours, you can export all of it any time, and it's out of AI training unless you say otherwise. It cost me nothing to promise, it would cost Reddit a product line. That's the whole difference.
How can we poison the well?
Reddit has become its own worst enemy.
This just in: Reddit still shithole!
But seriously, there was a point where you could say what you wanted on Reddit and at worst, your comment would get removed. Then “woke” went mainstream (i’ve been woke a long time before that) and Reddit mods became lords of their own little Barney Fife fiefdoms handing out permabans to anyone who gently questioned the popular consensus. I’m not sure what specifically changed, but it’s been downhill since then. I’m not so sure it hasn’t sucked longer than it was cool at this point.