#anarchism

posts tagged #anarchism

0

On AI Usage

preview

cross-posted from: lemmy.zip/post/64007684

Introduction

The current socio-political discourse is dominated by a new divisive issue concerning “AI” - so called Artificial Intelligence. While some are vehemently opposed to the idea of AI infiltrating newer and newer aspects of life, some are convinced of its revolutionary transformative power. The question of AI usage in our project of The Brotherhood, has also been put into question and this essay will attempt to put my^[not everyone working on the project, just my own] perspective on it.


What even is “AI”

What is typically referred to as “AI”, is in the more technical corners, known as, LLMs, or Large Language Models. They are a new innovation^[still, pretty old, around 2017-18] in a long line of automation technology, going back to the mid-20th century, not long after the computer itself was starting to become a thing of utmost usefulness.

The long journey of automation

Actually, the computer itself can be seen as the first innovation in this automation technology. After all, the computer is a literal automatic computation^[and much more, of course!] machine, that uses some carefully arranged silicon and phosphorus to manipulate electron flows and deterministically execute some rigorously defined steps.
The idea to take this further and further, was always an ambition of early computer scientists. And as speed and size started getting accessible, effort was made for closer integration with humans. This was not a trivial task as the computer and the human spoke two different languages that might as well be from different universes. From punching cards, where programmers painstakingly “wrote” binary in a literal card to Fortran to programming languages to OS to GUIs and applications, we have made tools, for our tools, for our tools, in a seemingly endless recursion.
One biggest aspect that programmers got interested in, in the very late 20th century, was natural language processing, to further bridge the “language gap”. This is what enabled the early internet, through search engines. Now, this fundamentally differs in structure to previous tools. This is not deterministic, as language itself was not deterministic. So these tools relied on various statistical tools like N-grams, Markov Models, Bayesian inference etc.

The parallel research on Neural Networks

Around the same time, with the advent of neuroscience^[that replaced the previous psychological models of Freud, Jung and Lacan, which were indeed not suited for STEM fields], another curious line of research began with the perceptron.
Very much influenced from early neuroscience, it slowly split from its initial inspiration and drifted towards statistical science, rather than trying to follow the exact structure of brains. This too, went through its own series of innovations with neural networks, backpropagation, Hopfield networks, CNNs, LSTMs etc.
But two innovations were critical for the explosion of interest in this very niche field -

  1. Deep neural networks, that made use of the newly popular GPUs, back in the early 2010s
  2. Transformers, which was the topic of a now, legendary 2017 paper, titled, "Attention is All You Need.

In the early 2020s, it was realised, that these two can be combined and scaled up massively^[and I mean massively] to gain a general semantic understanding of general language. This is where the two paths collided. What started as experimental cognitive research at the intersection of neuroscience and computation, turned into a statistical method to give the computers an understanding of semantic language! Thus began the era of LLMs.

An LLM is simply a statistical model trained to have a general understanding of semantics!


So What’s All the Hype

What is True

The innovation, especially of GPUs and transformers are legit groundbreaking innovations that have broken a very long stall in their respective fields. And their combination to create LLMs are indeed a great engineering feat, even if not that innovative from a purely academic standpoint^[the massive scaling needed, is another level of brute-forcing. Think of the pyramids of Egypt - not as clever as it is awe-inspiring, simply due to scale].
And it is also true that this has opened up the pathway to some commercial usage in a way that was just not possible earlier. In a certain sense, it is an upgradation of the search engines with a powerful fuzzy semantic translator.
It is indeed a great addition to the coding landscape. Programming used to be 80% manual intellectual labour, where you had to go search for that one silly bug, or implement a very simple system for the 100th time. Now, a lot of this can be automated. However, to think, that this makes programming itself obsolete, is very naive. For most serious project, you still need to have great knowledge of computer science, but the entry to programming has been indeed lowered^[which is either very good news, or very disappointing, depending on how much you like to gatekeep your nerdy interests!]. Most serious programmers have simply become a senior software developer and have delegated the manual repetitive tasks to the “AI”, which can understand natural language and turn them into code it has seen before^[if it has been trained in it].

What is the “Bubble”

What remains in heavy doubt is the “efficiency” problem. It is yet very unclear as to whether Moore’s Law will come into play here and decrease costs as time passes by, or whether the architecture itself, despite its genuine innovations, is fundamentally limited. The big corporations are betting on the former.
Meanwhile some “tech-enthusiasts” have become a little too enthusiastic about the range of its applicability. The LLMs, like any sophisticated statistical model, requires massive amounts of structured data. In certain areas like day-to-day coding, or summaries, this is not that hard. However, in areas like robotics, it is still not a “done” job^[just getting structured data itself].
The more laughable matter is that some have put into esoteric questions of consciousness^[philosophical exploration of consciousness, is indeed possible, but requires a level of rigor and seriousness, that is missing from most such discussions] in this new light. This is in part, due to the specific ancestry it has, and mostly just due to human nature of “jumping the bandwagon”.


What About the Political Issues

Now we come to the most important point of this discourse. I will break it down into specific points that are frequently put to question.

The Environmental Hazards

As it now stands, the development and deployment of LLMs remain highly inefficient. But technology and development always comes at the expense of natural resources and equilibrium. The question is not of, whether it is ethical, but who controls/decides how much is sustainable^[moreover, the current climate crisis has already put adequate strain on these resources in a lot of places].
At this point, however, it stops being a environmental concern and starts being a political one. The neoliberals would indeed argue that the market would balance itself when resource scarcity starts being critical, whereas opponents might argue that state intervention is needed to prevent a calamity at all. But whatever the arguments remain about their ideal states, what is true, is that, the real world is none of those “ideal world” situations.
The neoliberal free market does not exist in its full glory, as most of the technological market is monopolised by a few corporations. The current global climate crisis, is a failure of the free-markets of the industrial and the post-industrial era. Whereas state intervention, remains, at best, ineffectual, and at worst, prone to lobbying by the same monopolised corporations.

The conclusion is that the control of such critical decisions, remain concentrated in the hands of a few oligarchs who are prone to taking risky decisions and making mistakes.

The Data “Theft”

It is not unknown that the data that the LLMs are trained on, are public data. However, the access to such LLMs remain out of the hands of the people whose data made it come to fruition. It is also clear that the current copyright laws are not built to handle such cases.
Close-sourced LLMs represent a new kind of injustice with no easy solutions. On one hand, making LLMs accessible to all, would exasperate the “hype-train” and worsen the environmental impact. Whereas, stopping research on such lucrative frontiers would be catastrophically conservative. And again, this comes down to control - control of how and where to gather source data and how to commercialise it. But as long as the monopolies exists, especially on the production of cutting-edge of LLMs, control remains firmly on the hands of the select-few.

The Unemployment Issues

The layoffs have been quite eye-catching, since it happened on high-class educated employees. But this is a constant byproduct of changing times and advancing technology, especially in automation. This can not be avoided without an aversion to technology itself^[which is hard to sell in the modern world!].
However, this never leads to humans not having “any work left to do” at all. No, jobs come and jobs go! But as the current landscape stands, it is indeed the case that many millions of people will get trampled under the changing times - people who have long pursued a high-profile job, only to lose their long-expected market volume or high-end salary.
This represents an utter failure of our social contract. The fact that technological progress comes at the cost of social cohesion, is a reflection of our embarrassing societal technology in comparison to our other feats^[such as engineering, or research, or industrialisation]. An automation, theoretically, should be a boon to the labour force, taking away manual labour, in place of far more interesting jobs and more time for recreation! But alas, instead it represents an existential threat to a substantial section of the population!

No society can last which has a structural opposition to technological progress. The societal technology needs to keep up!


So Where Is The Brotherhood’s Position on This

Now, The Brotherhood is NOT a monolithic entity. The different people in here, has significantly different positions on this^[the division is one of the reasons of this long essay]. However, I have been a significant part of this project from the start, and I can say what my position is, on this.
My philosophy is of pragmatism. One must keep the danger, very very close. The one who lives by the sword, dies by the sword. But one who forsakes the sword, lives under the sword! Currently, as it stands, “AI” is the brand new weapon, in this long warfare of control, of ideology, of dominance, as it always has been. But if the disenfranchised people needs to win, they can not afford to forsake the game. They can only win by playing the same game.
I have used AI IDEs very substantially to build the project - because I am not such a good programmer, and even if I were, I could not have done the entire project, alone, in such a short time. Now I know that this is not a replacement for actual skilled people, and in the best-case scenario, I never would have needed to use it too much. But unfortunately, reality is never perfect, and we had to do get by on what we could!
And that is my philosophy on AI usage. The rules of the game are no different, only the goals of the players and as long as we are working for a noble goal^[actually, we directly respond to that political problem of unemployment], we cannot compromise on not taking the best shot at victory!

The End Justifies The Means 🔥

cross-posted from: lemmy.zip/post/64007684

Introduction

The current socio-political discourse is dominated by a new divisive issue concerning “AI” - so called Artificial Intelligence. While some are vehemently opposed to the idea of AI infiltrating newer and newer aspects of life, some are convinced of its revolutionary transformative power. The question of AI usage in our project of The Brotherhood, has also been put into question and this essay will attempt to put my^[not everyone working on the project, just my own] perspective on it.


What even is “AI”

What is typically referred to as “AI”, is in the more technical corners, known as, LLMs, or Large Language Models. They are a new innovation^[still, pretty old, around 2017-18] in a long line of automation technology, going back to the mid-20th century, not long after the computer itself was starting to become a thing of utmost usefulness.

The long journey of automation

Actually, the computer itself can be seen as the first innovation in this automation technology. After all, the computer is a literal automatic computation^[and much more, of course!] machine, that uses some carefully arranged silicon and phosphorus to manipulate electron flows and deterministically execute some rigorously defined steps.
The idea to take this further and further, was always an ambition of early computer scientists. And as speed and size started getting accessible, effort was made for closer integration with humans. This was not a trivial task as the computer and the human spoke two different languages that might as well be from different universes. From punching cards, where programmers painstakingly “wrote” binary in a literal card to Fortran to programming languages to OS to GUIs and applications, we have made tools, for our tools, for our tools, in a seemingly endless recursion.
One biggest aspect that programmers got interested in, in the very late 20th century, was natural language processing, to further bridge the “language gap”. This is what enabled the early internet, through search engines. Now, this fundamentally differs in structure to previous tools. This is not deterministic, as language itself was not deterministic. So these tools relied on various statistical tools like N-grams, Markov Models, Bayesian inference etc.

The parallel research on Neural Networks

Around the same time, with the advent of neuroscience^[that replaced the previous psychological models of Freud, Jung and Lacan, which were indeed not suited for STEM fields], another curious line of research began with the perceptron.
Very much influenced from early neuroscience, it slowly split from its initial inspiration and drifted towards statistical science, rather than trying to follow the exact structure of brains. This too, went through its own series of innovations with neural networks, backpropagation, Hopfield networks, CNNs, LSTMs etc.
But two innovations were critical for the explosion of interest in this very niche field -

  1. Deep neural networks, that made use of the newly popular GPUs, back in the early 2010s
  2. Transformers, which was the topic of a now, legendary 2017 paper, titled, "Attention is All You Need.

In the early 2020s, it was realised, that these two can be combined and scaled up massively^[and I mean massively] to gain a general semantic understanding of general language. This is where the two paths collided. What started as experimental cognitive research at the intersection of neuroscience and computation, turned into a statistical method to give the computers an understanding of semantic language! Thus began the era of LLMs.

An LLM is simply a statistical model trained to have a general understanding of semantics!


So What’s All the Hype

What is True

The innovation, especially of GPUs and transformers are legit groundbreaking innovations that have broken a very long stall in their respective fields. And their combination to create LLMs are indeed a great engineering feat, even if not that innovative from a purely academic standpoint^[the massive scaling needed, is another level of brute-forcing. Think of the pyramids of Egypt - not as clever as it is awe-inspiring, simply due to scale].
And it is also true that this has opened up the pathway to some commercial usage in a way that was just not possible earlier. In a certain sense, it is an upgradation of the search engines with a powerful fuzzy semantic translator.
It is indeed a great addition to the coding landscape. Programming used to be 80% manual intellectual labour, where you had to go search for that one silly bug, or implement a very simple system for the 100th time. Now, a lot of this can be automated. However, to think, that this makes programming itself obsolete, is very naive. For most serious project, you still need to have great knowledge of computer science, but the entry to programming has been indeed lowered^[which is either very good news, or very disappointing, depending on how much you like to gatekeep your nerdy interests!]. Most serious programmers have simply become a senior software developer and have delegated the manual repetitive tasks to the “AI”, which can understand natural language and turn them into code it has seen before^[if it has been trained in it].

What is the “Bubble”

What remains in heavy doubt is the “efficiency” problem. It is yet very unclear as to whether Moore’s Law will come into play here and decrease costs as time passes by, or whether the architecture itself, despite its genuine innovations, is fundamentally limited. The big corporations are betting on the former.
Meanwhile some “tech-enthusiasts” have become a little too enthusiastic about the range of its applicability. The LLMs, like any sophisticated statistical model, requires massive amounts of structured data. In certain areas like day-to-day coding, or summaries, this is not that hard. However, in areas like robotics, it is still not a “done” job^[just getting structured data itself].
The more laughable matter is that some have put into esoteric questions of consciousness^[philosophical exploration of consciousness, is indeed possible, but requires a level of rigor and seriousness, that is missing from most such discussions] in this new light. This is in part, due to the specific ancestry it has, and mostly just due to human nature of “jumping the bandwagon”.


What About the Political Issues

Now we come to the most important point of this discourse. I will break it down into specific points that are frequently put to question.

The Environmental Hazards

As it now stands, the development and deployment of LLMs remain highly inefficient. But technology and development always comes at the expense of natural resources and equilibrium. The question is not of, whether it is ethical, but who controls/decides how much is sustainable^[moreover, the current climate crisis has already put adequate strain on these resources in a lot of places].
At this point, however, it stops being a environmental concern and starts being a political one. The neoliberals would indeed argue that the market would balance itself when resource scarcity starts being critical, whereas opponents might argue that state intervention is needed to prevent a calamity at all. But whatever the arguments remain about their ideal states, what is true, is that, the real world is none of those “ideal world” situations.
The neoliberal free market does not exist in its full glory, as most of the technological market is monopolised by a few corporations. The current global climate crisis, is a failure of the free-markets of the industrial and the post-industrial era. Whereas state intervention, remains, at best, ineffectual, and at worst, prone to lobbying by the same monopolised corporations.

The conclusion is that the control of such critical decisions, remain concentrated in the hands of a few oligarchs who are prone to taking risky decisions and making mistakes.

The Data “Theft”

It is not unknown that the data that the LLMs are trained on, are public data. However, the access to such LLMs remain out of the hands of the people whose data made it come to fruition. It is also clear that the current copyright laws are not built to handle such cases.
Close-sourced LLMs represent a new kind of injustice with no easy solutions. On one hand, making LLMs accessible to all, would exasperate the “hype-train” and worsen the environmental impact. Whereas, stopping research on such lucrative frontiers would be catastrophically conservative. And again, this comes down to control - control of how and where to gather source data and how to commercialise it. But as long as the monopolies exists, especially on the production of cutting-edge of LLMs, control remains firmly on the hands of the select-few.

The Unemployment Issues

The layoffs have been quite eye-catching, since it happened on high-class educated employees. But this is a constant byproduct of changing times and advancing technology, especially in automation. This can not be avoided without an aversion to technology itself^[which is hard to sell in the modern world!].
However, this never leads to humans not having “any work left to do” at all. No, jobs come and jobs go! But as the current landscape stands, it is indeed the case that many millions of people will get trampled under the changing times - people who have long pursued a high-profile job, only to lose their long-expected market volume or high-end salary.
This represents an utter failure of our social contract. The fact that technological progress comes at the cost of social cohesion, is a reflection of our embarrassing societal technology in comparison to our other feats^[such as engineering, or research, or industrialisation]. An automation, theoretically, should be a boon to the labour force, taking away manual labour, in place of far more interesting jobs and more time for recreation! But alas, instead it represents an existential threat to a substantial section of the population!

No society can last which has a structural opposition to technological progress. The societal technology needs to keep up!


So Where Is The Brotherhood’s Position on This

Now, The Brotherhood is NOT a monolithic entity. The different people in here, has significantly different positions on this^[the division is one of the reasons of this long essay]. However, I have been a significant part of this project from the start, and I can say what my position is, on this.
My philosophy is of pragmatism. One must keep the danger, very very close. The one who lives by the sword, dies by the sword. But one who forsakes the sword, lives under the sword! Currently, as it stands, “AI” is the brand new weapon, in this long warfare of control, of ideology, of dominance, as it always has been. But if the disenfranchised people needs to win, they can not afford to forsake the game. They can only win by playing the same game.
I have used AI IDEs very substantially to build the project - because I am not such a good programmer, and even if I were, I could not have done the entire project, alone, in such a short time. Now I know that this is not a replacement for actual skilled people, and in the best-case scenario, I never would have needed to use it too much. But unfortunately, reality is never perfect, and we had to do get by on what we could!
And that is my philosophy on AI usage. The rules of the game are no different, only the goals of the players and as long as we are working for a noble goal^[actually, we directly respond to that political problem of unemployment], we cannot compromise on not taking the best shot at victory!

The End Justifies The Means 🔥

0

What is an Identity? The notion the far-right does not want to be questioned.

preview

I started this as a review of the book “It came from Something Awful” by Dale Beran, as part of my quest to understand online harassment in the context of Gamergate and the rise of alt-right. It turns out this topic overlaps with other points of interest right now, for instance the age-verification moral panic, and the TERF talking points of J.K. Rowling. This lead me to the question, what is this term “identity” we use so broadly, in such politically volatile phrases like “gender identity” and “identity politics”.

The book describes the trajectory from 4chan to the first Trump administration. The author was also the executive consultant for the documentary “The antisocial network”. Reading the book I was initially more interested in the early days of 4chan, rather than Beran’s exercises with interpretations based on Herbert Marcuse and Hannah Arendt. I admit I skipped pages and pages of those, because I was bored to death, and his cursory semantic simplifications painfully sucked my mind void.

However on the second part I started disliking his work more and more. At some point he introduces the idea that Tumblr was 4chan’s “evil sister”. Beran although he is validating transgender people’s identities seems to be squarely right wing and he discreetly shows his allegiance to the alt-right. So perhaps his simplistic semantics on consumerism and identity were not simply innocent exercises in critical theory, but could have the potential of being weaponized. If not the author himself then others certainly have done so. The modern fascist narrative has it that young people spend an excessive amount of time online, in echo-chambers that make them think they are cats and dogs, or “another gender than they really are”, and there is an “epidemic” and a “social contagion”, by the same people who don’t believe neither in “germs” nor “such a thing as a society”.

And it all boils down to that multifaceted word “Identity”. It can be as specific as a government issue identifying document, or as vague as the contents of a troubled teen’s diary (or online musing for that matter). As passing as a pop culture fad, or as stable a glorified national identity. Yet very few people have seriously tried to even define what it is.

Why does the right avoid the definition of identity?

The basis of the 4chan-Tumblr comparison was all about identity: the genetic pariah identity on one side, the one who has accepted and endorsed the narratives of masculine identity as a law of nature; on the other, the silly women who have endorsed what corporate marketing department had brainswashed them into: embracing different identities, exploring different identitites, wear and then toss different identities as decorative tags.

But what is identity? Is it a T-shirt with punk-band logo that we can one day just forget and put on the corporate uniform of “business casual”? A set of descriptive labels one ascribes to oneself? Or is it a deep sense of self-hood?

The right has investments in their own identities too. What about the masculine identity, often willing to kill if it is threatened, or national identity, that is ready to commit atrocities for matters of pride? Let’s stay with national identity for a second. It requires nationalist schooling and a police state to inculcate. Enforcing a different national identity on anyone is broadly understood an act of cruel oppression. But the right is bound to eliminate everything “psychological”, thus it needs to reduce national identity to a spontaneous expression of one’s genes. This requires romantic narratives that reinforce the illusion of genetic continuity, and well defined racial groups as natural kinds. In the current climate of the anti-transgender moral panic we tend to forget that one of the greatest grievances of the right has been the abandonment of racial theories by anthropologists and historians alike. And in order to get back to their patriotic narratives they have no choice but to undo all science.

From debunked race science to MAGA political strategy

Debunked race science was quite popular on 4chan a decade ago, and now it is part of the fascist US Government’s agenda. Beran hardly mentions the racism involved in the phenomena he discusses (for good measure, compare with the book “The Cruelty is the Point” by Adam Serwer, which makes the case that racism is the best explanation of the rise of Trump, and it is also written around Trump’s first term). What is now hot in 4chan? Last week’s special in ‘/sci/’ was whether phrenology and physiognomy were “fine” sciences that were tossed away due to “political correctness”. Many comments agree. This is typical. Psychology and psychiatry are painted as the greatest hoaxes and enemies, resounding the Nazi notions of “Jewish disciplines”. Many people thought this to be unremarkable, sharing themselves the debunked premises of naive empiricism, until they were shattered too by the anti-science Trump administration, regardless of their status as disciplines of astrophysics, meteorology, climate change science, etc.

But it is also funny to read this book, which was written to explain Trump’s first presidency, under the light of the recent revelations about 4chan’s /pol/ origin and function. There is now evidence that Steve Bannon as a right wing strategist saw the potential of mass manipulation and contacted Jeffrey Epstein to introduce him to Christopher Poole. Poole very soon after that conceded to allow ‘/pol/’, the neo-nazi, racist-science board that is now said that paved the way to the second term of Donald Trump. In fact some say that he was re-elected by the generation who were at one time the troubled, sexless teens finding their identity on 4chan. The author accounts for Steve Bannon’s sponsoring of Milo Yiannopoulos as an early alt-right agitator, but he is unaware of how well connected Bannon was, and what was in fact generating the phenomena he describes.

Fascist strategists who want to manipulate teens into being recruited as their stormtroopers don’t want them to read psychology. They don’t want them to even think about identity exploration. They want them to think about a great past that was clean-cut and uncomplicated. They instill fear for the novel and the unknown. They cultivate the worship of a leading personality (The_Donald) as an expression of their own self. The author attributes the endorsement of Trump by the nihilistic youth on 4chan to his promise of “winning”, that resonated well with those convinced they are losers. Heck, you don’t want any of these sheeple going to fucking therapy, do you? (Some analysis suggests that No Nut November was also a fascist psy-op. Good authoritarians know that it is important to control sex in order to manipulate people.)

We should not forget we are talking about teens here. The author describles 4chan and Tumblr as opposites in the following way: The former, a counterculture suspicious of the assimilation of every other counterculture by corporate marketing departments. So suspicious that it denied all values (1990s nihilism leading to the aughts “layers of irony”). The latter (Tumblr goes to college), privileged customer on route for the next reshuffle of the middle class, Karening the fuck out of their universities to cater to their self-serving values, just like customers asking for fancy tops on their expensive fair-trade coffee, rejecting the expensive commodity if it is not exactly to their liking.

Theories of Identity

There is no real treatment of the notion of identity, and it is no accident that there is a fair amount of psychological theory on identity. For instance older theories have it that (self) identity crisis is a developmental stage, emerging in adolescence, and resolution of said crisis can take different forms: among which foreclosure - endorsing a given identity; moratorium - extended exploration of identities and difficulty committing to one; and other states of identity, but I cite as most relevant the ones the author implies by his descripton of 4chan versus Tumblr. So, for example, Lily Alexandre recently revisited her 2021 video about the “millions of dead genders” of Tumblr. The extended vocabulary of genders is a matter of what fits best, and what grows on each person. (For instance “trans girl” has no real semantic difference from “transgender woman”, it is just preferred by some people and not by others, as a self-descriptor). We have also seen the understanding of identity as a “set of self-descriptor labels” in another essay: The one on Hans Georg Moeller, who also hinted to the same problematic notion of “social contagion due to being extremely online” and over-obsessing with labels. As Alexandre points out, being trans and/or gay, and/or autistic, comes with doubt, denial, and other coping mechanisms, and young people coming to terms with their body and their gender might have given rise to this extended vocabulary. And that’s OK. We need those safe spaces for people to figure themselves out.

The case for assertively protective third places

Gender diverse youth (but also youth in the spectrum, youth going through trauma and mental health issues, youth in high risk homes, and others) can go through exploration, and internet communities will provide a safe space for exploration, for which there is a healthy amount and a less healthy amount. Support networks both on- and off- line are critical determinants of what this amount is. Discussing Tumblr, the author makes the void argument that the “radical acceptance of all identities” is as bad as 4chan’s toxicity.

Radical acceptance is a prerequisite for both safety and growth. And his argument, typically a last resort of teacher’s pets in philosophy lectures, takes the form of the self-referential paradox: “Boohoohoo. They don’t accept those who are not radically accepting every identity”. Some journalist wrote a couple years ago stated that GenZ is the most accepting of LGBT. “But they are intolerant of those who are not as acccepting, and this is a paradox they are unwilling to acknowledge. Curious. We are very intelligent”. Well, all these people missed a critical lesson in logic: self-referential propositions are prohibited (Russel & Whitehead). And a lesson in history: If you let the intolerant in, you will have a nazi bar (Karl Popper, paraphrased by me).

You see the results: radical acceptance leads to places like Blahaj. Safe no matter what. If you want to be safe you can go there. Live and let live, or get the fuck out. 4chan, on the other hand, chased out furries and other weird subcultures, ostracized Anonymous as too leftist, to end up being manipulated into being a literal nazi bar celebrating the suicides of trans people. And serving as a breeding ground for the global rise of fascism. Yet the author presents perceived safety as a matter of “feelings”, devoid of the scientific “reason” that is needed in academic departments. “This is unsafe because we say we feel unsafe”, he says.

Milo Yiannopoulos and the manufactured free speech crisis in academia

The author is somewhat lenient to the academic educators, but he thinks should use their authority to reprimand the rowdy students. Their hesitation, Beran says, is understandable because they regularly debate fine points and often have to shift their previously held beliefs under the light of new arguments and/or evidence. However this isn’t by accident. Rather it is the exact series of paradigm shifts that have cause academia to “have a liberal bias”. This is the very process fascists want to undo, and the real reason they are not simply anti-democracy but inherently anti-science. It goes back to first principles. Nevertheless not all cognitive shifts are created equal, but as soon as they happen in the realm of the social or the psychological, the fascist crowd will find a strong advocate in these very same departments: the privileged, male-dominated, and aggressively gatekeeped “hard” sciences, echoing the sexist “reason/feelings” antithesis.

Many forget that before the manufactured “free speech crisis” around Yiannopoulos or TERFs at campuses, we had agitators like UCSB’s Tooby and Cosmides and neoliberal talking head Daniel Dennet fighting “Science Wars”, way before “Culture Wars”, brandishing a hardcore flavor of rape-enabling genetic determinism and social darwinism, targeting social studies and humanities, and attacking population genetics for challenging the notion of race. As early as the Reagan era, the right has been targeting universities, considered as breeding grounds for Democratic voters, legislators and judges, in their strive to achieve total deregulation and corporate unaccountability.

Your critique of identity politics can be either radical or just concern trolling

But the author takes a “vantage centrist” position. Let’s forget all this relevant background. Let’s not go deep into what cognitive shifts in science are. Let’s not go too deep into all this. Let’s stay on online youth subcultures, 4chan and Tumblr. It was the latter, according to him, that “went to college”. But he poses as a serious journalist, who has outgrown 4chan, and had a brief passage through Tumblr, before getting himself a college education. He distances himself from the toxic cesspool. He uses extravagant and outlandish specimen of college identity politics as straw-men (“are babies dressed up as Mulan racist?”), saying that there are serious problems of social injustice that are neglected. “Identity politics” is painted as simply performative despite the fact that he is literally writing about the Black Lives Matter era, and the discussion around systemic injustice was everywhere. Most notably it was the subject of critical race theory, a future target of another right wing moral panic, which served as a preliminary stage of Trump’s second term.

On that account, he is not different from this pick me girl, who says to her primarily young white male audience: “Anyone remembers cultural appropriation? What was that about? No one talks about it now” and “you put the real issues under the table” by whitewashing your speech. And they are right to an extent: Identity politics is not even left-wing, and it is whitewashing inequality. Media representation and vocabulary can only go so far.

But people like these make a misleading argument that can appeal to feelings of social injustice in anyone: There are real problems and we are just covering them up. Then are you folks …radicals? You want to tackle on systemic racism and sexism on the institutional level, and you think political correctness is hypocrisy? So are you organizing a general strike? Are you following the leadership of black trans women in organizing said general strike? (No, you think these are just made-up labels, save the racial supremacy).

What do you do about those “Real issues” then? Are you urban guerillas? Probably just whining about political correctness ruining comedy, appropriating the term free-speech to justify bullying and other oppressive speech and non-speech acts.

This concern trolling by the alt-right is a very insidious stance to take, and one I could never see without the weight carried by the dismissive and expansive use of the term “political correctness” that you can now find everywhere. In the end of the day, these tirades conclude that the “problems”, never named as systemic racism and sexism are to big or too embedded to tackle with. It is like they’re saying “At best we should go-slow about them, for the time being do-nothing, not even using verbal assurances that we acknowledge these disparities are really there. This makes us free thinkers.”

Wait. Where do these methods come from?

There are some serious questions on demographics here. Are all our problems really down to a couple million NEETs? Then there are the methodological issues. This idea of identity crisis as a manifestation of capitalist consumerism flows around in sociology. The argument goes, in the medieval times you had less identity crisis, then you have post-WW2 fears of nuclear annihilation, and many more roles you can choose from due to the technology advancements. Then you also have counterculture and you can choose an identity that is utterly adversarial to the mainstream society you grow up in, although there is a lot of interest in these fields to show that after all the home culture is inescapable and all foreign or opposing elements are assimilated by it.

These methods claim they focus on the systemic instead of reducing macro phenomena to the individual. But what they really do is analyzing the society as if it was an individual in-therapy, or taking an idealized individual and interpreting its meaning-making, or even taking oneself as the specimen, a product of their own culture, and presenting their own meaning making as a general one. I am not trained in sociology, but these are the options I have seen in practice in similar studies.

As far as his academic endeavor is concerned, I think his treatment of counterculture is incomplete unless he outlines the definition and characteristics of “identity”. Caelan Conrad dissects a segment in Rowling’s manifesto that leads many people to claim that she is a trans man in denial, and gay shows that the excerpt in question is masterfully crafted to frame the very definition of being trans as a manifestation of teenage angst, and therefore forming a circular argument. Rowling’s obvious sleight of hand is that it leaves out gender identity and gender dysphoria, therefore comparing apples and oranges: trans teenagers are not anxious cis teenagers. A hint at trans men being women trying to escape patriarchy and taking the bait of “transgenderism”. Central in Rowlings argument, and by extension all transphobes, and it is a denial of identity, a denial that trans people exist, and this has several vile consequences in itself: that trans people should be eliminated and those pushing the idea of gender identity are enemies of the state. Scary stuff!

Conrad points out that if identity is something deeply engendered with the self, and it is very important to correctly develop and protect, or it is a superficial optics and style endeavor that you can turn on and off. If identity is profound and permanent, no cis person can ever be tricked into being trans. The infamous Money experiments, often weaponized by the right, can in fact be read as evidence of the permanence and inevitability of some innate gender identity. And vice versa. If identity is not permanent and escape-able, then cherished religious and national identities can also be trivial and temporary. This is an endgame for the whole philosophical outlook of right-wingers. But there is a timing parameter to it as well. Young adolescents will explore their identities and gender diverse or gay and queer youth will exist, and if they don’t have safe third places for it you will just have a medieval and/or fascist society.

What does this mean for self identity

Identity exploration by gender diverse young people has lead to a new moral panic that is bleeding through to legislation for age verification and mass censorship. As they did with the bathroom moral panic, advocates dismiss this panic with the (correct but understated) fact that exploration does not make kids queer, it just provides more broad and appropriate vocabulary to get know oneself. Yes, but this goes over the heads of the legislators and PTAs. There is a moral panic that will lead to censorship of places like the Fediverse, criminalization or de facto elimination of safe spaces. We now see the first steps of using the detransitioner playbook for autistic people, targeting another demographic whose lives are supported by these spaces.

Foreclosure, the fascist brand of approved adolescence identity, is going to be force-fed to us, as a route to the romanticized 1950s. There is an army of Brownshirts out there called ICE, and soon diverse identity and expression of any kind will be targeted, shoving all normalized people into non-pseudonymous, corporate platforms where each and everyone of their beliefs and attitudes will be algorithmically surveyed and manipulated. This is why it is important to scrutinize and read between the lines of similar white male authors pushing the ideas supporting and refining the premises of right-wing media circuses and moral panics, by diluting nuances and popularizing strawmen.

Their work is silently influencing a number of oblivious centrists and inoculates them to more nuanced analyses provided by activists and advocate organizations, thus establishing a silent majority that will stand on the fence in such critical legislations as trans youth health care and age-verification. Behind the petite-burgeois annoyance of multiple gender labels on niche social platforms, there is a similar reactance to multiple music genre labels. “This is too much information for me, I miss the simpler times when there was only rock, pop, disco, and jazz”. The only difference being, if you apply your simplistic attitude to identity normalization you have a rotten, prescriptive society that crushes people for being different. Which is what the MAGA right wants.

I started this as a review of the book “It came from Something Awful” by Dale Beran, as part of my quest to understand online harassment in the context of Gamergate and the rise of alt-right. It turns out this topic overlaps with other points of interest right now, for instance the age-verification moral panic, and the TERF talking points of J.K. Rowling. This lead me to the question, what is this term “identity” we use so broadly, in such politically volatile phrases like “gender identity” and “identity politics”.

The book describes the trajectory from 4chan to the first Trump administration. The author was also the executive consultant for the documentary “The antisocial network”. Reading the book I was initially more interested in the early days of 4chan, rather than Beran’s exercises with interpretations based on Herbert Marcuse and Hannah Arendt. I admit I skipped pages and pages of those, because I was bored to death, and his cursory semantic simplifications painfully sucked my mind void.

However on the second part I started disliking his work more and more. At some point he introduces the idea that Tumblr was 4chan’s “evil sister”. Beran although he is validating transgender people’s identities seems to be squarely right wing and he discreetly shows his allegiance to the alt-right. So perhaps his simplistic semantics on consumerism and identity were not simply innocent exercises in critical theory, but could have the potential of being weaponized. If not the author himself then others certainly have done so. The modern fascist narrative has it that young people spend an excessive amount of time online, in echo-chambers that make them think they are cats and dogs, or “another gender than they really are”, and there is an “epidemic” and a “social contagion”, by the same people who don’t believe neither in “germs” nor “such a thing as a society”.

And it all boils down to that multifaceted word “Identity”. It can be as specific as a government issue identifying document, or as vague as the contents of a troubled teen’s diary (or online musing for that matter). As passing as a pop culture fad, or as stable a glorified national identity. Yet very few people have seriously tried to even define what it is.

Why does the right avoid the definition of identity?

The basis of the 4chan-Tumblr comparison was all about identity: the genetic pariah identity on one side, the one who has accepted and endorsed the narratives of masculine identity as a law of nature; on the other, the silly women who have endorsed what corporate marketing department had brainswashed them into: embracing different identities, exploring different identitites, wear and then toss different identities as decorative tags.

But what is identity? Is it a T-shirt with punk-band logo that we can one day just forget and put on the corporate uniform of “business casual”? A set of descriptive labels one ascribes to oneself? Or is it a deep sense of self-hood?

The right has investments in their own identities too. What about the masculine identity, often willing to kill if it is threatened, or national identity, that is ready to commit atrocities for matters of pride? Let’s stay with national identity for a second. It requires nationalist schooling and a police state to inculcate. Enforcing a different national identity on anyone is broadly understood an act of cruel oppression. But the right is bound to eliminate everything “psychological”, thus it needs to reduce national identity to a spontaneous expression of one’s genes. This requires romantic narratives that reinforce the illusion of genetic continuity, and well defined racial groups as natural kinds. In the current climate of the anti-transgender moral panic we tend to forget that one of the greatest grievances of the right has been the abandonment of racial theories by anthropologists and historians alike. And in order to get back to their patriotic narratives they have no choice but to undo all science.

From debunked race science to MAGA political strategy

Debunked race science was quite popular on 4chan a decade ago, and now it is part of the fascist US Government’s agenda. Beran hardly mentions the racism involved in the phenomena he discusses (for good measure, compare with the book “The Cruelty is the Point” by Adam Serwer, which makes the case that racism is the best explanation of the rise of Trump, and it is also written around Trump’s first term). What is now hot in 4chan? Last week’s special in ‘/sci/’ was whether phrenology and physiognomy were “fine” sciences that were tossed away due to “political correctness”. Many comments agree. This is typical. Psychology and psychiatry are painted as the greatest hoaxes and enemies, resounding the Nazi notions of “Jewish disciplines”. Many people thought this to be unremarkable, sharing themselves the debunked premises of naive empiricism, until they were shattered too by the anti-science Trump administration, regardless of their status as disciplines of astrophysics, meteorology, climate change science, etc.

But it is also funny to read this book, which was written to explain Trump’s first presidency, under the light of the recent revelations about 4chan’s /pol/ origin and function. There is now evidence that Steve Bannon as a right wing strategist saw the potential of mass manipulation and contacted Jeffrey Epstein to introduce him to Christopher Poole. Poole very soon after that conceded to allow ‘/pol/’, the neo-nazi, racist-science board that is now said that paved the way to the second term of Donald Trump. In fact some say that he was re-elected by the generation who were at one time the troubled, sexless teens finding their identity on 4chan. The author accounts for Steve Bannon’s sponsoring of Milo Yiannopoulos as an early alt-right agitator, but he is unaware of how well connected Bannon was, and what was in fact generating the phenomena he describes.

Fascist strategists who want to manipulate teens into being recruited as their stormtroopers don’t want them to read psychology. They don’t want them to even think about identity exploration. They want them to think about a great past that was clean-cut and uncomplicated. They instill fear for the novel and the unknown. They cultivate the worship of a leading personality (The_Donald) as an expression of their own self. The author attributes the endorsement of Trump by the nihilistic youth on 4chan to his promise of “winning”, that resonated well with those convinced they are losers. Heck, you don’t want any of these sheeple going to fucking therapy, do you? (Some analysis suggests that No Nut November was also a fascist psy-op. Good authoritarians know that it is important to control sex in order to manipulate people.)

We should not forget we are talking about teens here. The author describles 4chan and Tumblr as opposites in the following way: The former, a counterculture suspicious of the assimilation of every other counterculture by corporate marketing departments. So suspicious that it denied all values (1990s nihilism leading to the aughts “layers of irony”). The latter (Tumblr goes to college), privileged customer on route for the next reshuffle of the middle class, Karening the fuck out of their universities to cater to their self-serving values, just like customers asking for fancy tops on their expensive fair-trade coffee, rejecting the expensive commodity if it is not exactly to their liking.

Theories of Identity

There is no real treatment of the notion of identity, and it is no accident that there is a fair amount of psychological theory on identity. For instance older theories have it that (self) identity crisis is a developmental stage, emerging in adolescence, and resolution of said crisis can take different forms: among which foreclosure - endorsing a given identity; moratorium - extended exploration of identities and difficulty committing to one; and other states of identity, but I cite as most relevant the ones the author implies by his descripton of 4chan versus Tumblr. So, for example, Lily Alexandre recently revisited her 2021 video about the “millions of dead genders” of Tumblr. The extended vocabulary of genders is a matter of what fits best, and what grows on each person. (For instance “trans girl” has no real semantic difference from “transgender woman”, it is just preferred by some people and not by others, as a self-descriptor). We have also seen the understanding of identity as a “set of self-descriptor labels” in another essay: The one on Hans Georg Moeller, who also hinted to the same problematic notion of “social contagion due to being extremely online” and over-obsessing with labels. As Alexandre points out, being trans and/or gay, and/or autistic, comes with doubt, denial, and other coping mechanisms, and young people coming to terms with their body and their gender might have given rise to this extended vocabulary. And that’s OK. We need those safe spaces for people to figure themselves out.

The case for assertively protective third places

Gender diverse youth (but also youth in the spectrum, youth going through trauma and mental health issues, youth in high risk homes, and others) can go through exploration, and internet communities will provide a safe space for exploration, for which there is a healthy amount and a less healthy amount. Support networks both on- and off- line are critical determinants of what this amount is. Discussing Tumblr, the author makes the void argument that the “radical acceptance of all identities” is as bad as 4chan’s toxicity.

Radical acceptance is a prerequisite for both safety and growth. And his argument, typically a last resort of teacher’s pets in philosophy lectures, takes the form of the self-referential paradox: “Boohoohoo. They don’t accept those who are not radically accepting every identity”. Some journalist wrote a couple years ago stated that GenZ is the most accepting of LGBT. “But they are intolerant of those who are not as acccepting, and this is a paradox they are unwilling to acknowledge. Curious. We are very intelligent”. Well, all these people missed a critical lesson in logic: self-referential propositions are prohibited (Russel & Whitehead). And a lesson in history: If you let the intolerant in, you will have a nazi bar (Karl Popper, paraphrased by me).

You see the results: radical acceptance leads to places like Blahaj. Safe no matter what. If you want to be safe you can go there. Live and let live, or get the fuck out. 4chan, on the other hand, chased out furries and other weird subcultures, ostracized Anonymous as too leftist, to end up being manipulated into being a literal nazi bar celebrating the suicides of trans people. And serving as a breeding ground for the global rise of fascism. Yet the author presents perceived safety as a matter of “feelings”, devoid of the scientific “reason” that is needed in academic departments. “This is unsafe because we say we feel unsafe”, he says.

Milo Yiannopoulos and the manufactured free speech crisis in academia

The author is somewhat lenient to the academic educators, but he thinks should use their authority to reprimand the rowdy students. Their hesitation, Beran says, is understandable because they regularly debate fine points and often have to shift their previously held beliefs under the light of new arguments and/or evidence. However this isn’t by accident. Rather it is the exact series of paradigm shifts that have cause academia to “have a liberal bias”. This is the very process fascists want to undo, and the real reason they are not simply anti-democracy but inherently anti-science. It goes back to first principles. Nevertheless not all cognitive shifts are created equal, but as soon as they happen in the realm of the social or the psychological, the fascist crowd will find a strong advocate in these very same departments: the privileged, male-dominated, and aggressively gatekeeped “hard” sciences, echoing the sexist “reason/feelings” antithesis.

Many forget that before the manufactured “free speech crisis” around Yiannopoulos or TERFs at campuses, we had agitators like UCSB’s Tooby and Cosmides and neoliberal talking head Daniel Dennet fighting “Science Wars”, way before “Culture Wars”, brandishing a hardcore flavor of rape-enabling genetic determinism and social darwinism, targeting social studies and humanities, and attacking population genetics for challenging the notion of race. As early as the Reagan era, the right has been targeting universities, considered as breeding grounds for Democratic voters, legislators and judges, in their strive to achieve total deregulation and corporate unaccountability.

Your critique of identity politics can be either radical or just concern trolling

But the author takes a “vantage centrist” position. Let’s forget all this relevant background. Let’s not go deep into what cognitive shifts in science are. Let’s not go too deep into all this. Let’s stay on online youth subcultures, 4chan and Tumblr. It was the latter, according to him, that “went to college”. But he poses as a serious journalist, who has outgrown 4chan, and had a brief passage through Tumblr, before getting himself a college education. He distances himself from the toxic cesspool. He uses extravagant and outlandish specimen of college identity politics as straw-men (“are babies dressed up as Mulan racist?”), saying that there are serious problems of social injustice that are neglected. “Identity politics” is painted as simply performative despite the fact that he is literally writing about the Black Lives Matter era, and the discussion around systemic injustice was everywhere. Most notably it was the subject of critical race theory, a future target of another right wing moral panic, which served as a preliminary stage of Trump’s second term.

On that account, he is not different from this pick me girl, who says to her primarily young white male audience: “Anyone remembers cultural appropriation? What was that about? No one talks about it now” and “you put the real issues under the table” by whitewashing your speech. And they are right to an extent: Identity politics is not even left-wing, and it is whitewashing inequality. Media representation and vocabulary can only go so far.

But people like these make a misleading argument that can appeal to feelings of social injustice in anyone: There are real problems and we are just covering them up. Then are you folks …radicals? You want to tackle on systemic racism and sexism on the institutional level, and you think political correctness is hypocrisy? So are you organizing a general strike? Are you following the leadership of black trans women in organizing said general strike? (No, you think these are just made-up labels, save the racial supremacy).

What do you do about those “Real issues” then? Are you urban guerillas? Probably just whining about political correctness ruining comedy, appropriating the term free-speech to justify bullying and other oppressive speech and non-speech acts.

This concern trolling by the alt-right is a very insidious stance to take, and one I could never see without the weight carried by the dismissive and expansive use of the term “political correctness” that you can now find everywhere. In the end of the day, these tirades conclude that the “problems”, never named as systemic racism and sexism are to big or too embedded to tackle with. It is like they’re saying “At best we should go-slow about them, for the time being do-nothing, not even using verbal assurances that we acknowledge these disparities are really there. This makes us free thinkers.”

Wait. Where do these methods come from?

There are some serious questions on demographics here. Are all our problems really down to a couple million NEETs? Then there are the methodological issues. This idea of identity crisis as a manifestation of capitalist consumerism flows around in sociology. The argument goes, in the medieval times you had less identity crisis, then you have post-WW2 fears of nuclear annihilation, and many more roles you can choose from due to the technology advancements. Then you also have counterculture and you can choose an identity that is utterly adversarial to the mainstream society you grow up in, although there is a lot of interest in these fields to show that after all the home culture is inescapable and all foreign or opposing elements are assimilated by it.

These methods claim they focus on the systemic instead of reducing macro phenomena to the individual. But what they really do is analyzing the society as if it was an individual in-therapy, or taking an idealized individual and interpreting its meaning-making, or even taking oneself as the specimen, a product of their own culture, and presenting their own meaning making as a general one. I am not trained in sociology, but these are the options I have seen in practice in similar studies.

As far as his academic endeavor is concerned, I think his treatment of counterculture is incomplete unless he outlines the definition and characteristics of “identity”. Caelan Conrad dissects a segment in Rowling’s manifesto that leads many people to claim that she is a trans man in denial, and gay shows that the excerpt in question is masterfully crafted to frame the very definition of being trans as a manifestation of teenage angst, and therefore forming a circular argument. Rowling’s obvious sleight of hand is that it leaves out gender identity and gender dysphoria, therefore comparing apples and oranges: trans teenagers are not anxious cis teenagers. A hint at trans men being women trying to escape patriarchy and taking the bait of “transgenderism”. Central in Rowlings argument, and by extension all transphobes, and it is a denial of identity, a denial that trans people exist, and this has several vile consequences in itself: that trans people should be eliminated and those pushing the idea of gender identity are enemies of the state. Scary stuff!

Conrad points out that if identity is something deeply engendered with the self, and it is very important to correctly develop and protect, or it is a superficial optics and style endeavor that you can turn on and off. If identity is profound and permanent, no cis person can ever be tricked into being trans. The infamous Money experiments, often weaponized by the right, can in fact be read as evidence of the permanence and inevitability of some innate gender identity. And vice versa. If identity is not permanent and escape-able, then cherished religious and national identities can also be trivial and temporary. This is an endgame for the whole philosophical outlook of right-wingers. But there is a timing parameter to it as well. Young adolescents will explore their identities and gender diverse or gay and queer youth will exist, and if they don’t have safe third places for it you will just have a medieval and/or fascist society.

What does this mean for self identity

Identity exploration by gender diverse young people has lead to a new moral panic that is bleeding through to legislation for age verification and mass censorship. As they did with the bathroom moral panic, advocates dismiss this panic with the (correct but understated) fact that exploration does not make kids queer, it just provides more broad and appropriate vocabulary to get know oneself. Yes, but this goes over the heads of the legislators and PTAs. There is a moral panic that will lead to censorship of places like the Fediverse, criminalization or de facto elimination of safe spaces. We now see the first steps of using the detransitioner playbook for autistic people, targeting another demographic whose lives are supported by these spaces.

Foreclosure, the fascist brand of approved adolescence identity, is going to be force-fed to us, as a route to the romanticized 1950s. There is an army of Brownshirts out there called ICE, and soon diverse identity and expression of any kind will be targeted, shoving all normalized people into non-pseudonymous, corporate platforms where each and everyone of their beliefs and attitudes will be algorithmically surveyed and manipulated. This is why it is important to scrutinize and read between the lines of similar white male authors pushing the ideas supporting and refining the premises of right-wing media circuses and moral panics, by diluting nuances and popularizing strawmen.

Their work is silently influencing a number of oblivious centrists and inoculates them to more nuanced analyses provided by activists and advocate organizations, thus establishing a silent majority that will stand on the fence in such critical legislations as trans youth health care and age-verification. Behind the petite-burgeois annoyance of multiple gender labels on niche social platforms, there is a similar reactance to multiple music genre labels. “This is too much information for me, I miss the simpler times when there was only rock, pop, disco, and jazz”. The only difference being, if you apply your simplistic attitude to identity normalization you have a rotten, prescriptive society that crushes people for being different. Which is what the MAGA right wants.

0

May Day – A living legacy

preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/46627

May Day – A living legacy thecollective Fri, 05/01/2026 - 14:46


From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/46627

May Day – A living legacy thecollective Fri, 05/01/2026 - 14:46


From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

0

Tag yourself. I'm wife guy

preview

Image description:

Text which reads “Every squad got the following:”

two rows with pictures and a caption beneath them. from top left to bottom right read left to right:

Young Nestor Makhno: “The Militant”

Old Peter Kropotikin: “The Wife Guy”

Old Karl Marx: “The [twinkle emoji] Drama [twinkle emoji] [painting nails emoji]”

Young Mikhail Bakunin: “Fucks”

Someone in a ski mask with a pipe who appears to be gay in San Francisco, black in South Africa, an Asian in Europe, a Chicano in San Ysidro, an anarchist in Spain, a Palestinian in Israel, a Mayan Indian in the streets of San Cristobal, a Jew in Germany, a Gypsy in Poland, a Mohawk in Quebec, a pacifist in Bosnia, a single woman on the Metro at 10pm, a peasant without land, a gang member in the slums, an unemployed worker, an unhappy student and, of course, a Zapatista in the mountains, the exploited, marginalised, oppressed minorities resisting and saying `Enough’, every minority who is now beginning to speak and every majority that must shut up and listen, every untolerated group searching for a way to speak, Everything that makes power and the good consciences of those in power uncomfortable: “The Enby”

Emma Goldman: “The Fugitive”

Mao Tse-Tung (Zedong): “The Zoomer”

Old Lucy Parsons: “The One Who Actually Did The Assignment”

Image description:

Text which reads “Every squad got the following:”

two rows with pictures and a caption beneath them. from top left to bottom right read left to right:

Young Nestor Makhno: “The Militant”

Old Peter Kropotikin: “The Wife Guy”

Old Karl Marx: “The [twinkle emoji] Drama [twinkle emoji] [painting nails emoji]”

Young Mikhail Bakunin: “Fucks”

Someone in a ski mask with a pipe who appears to be gay in San Francisco, black in South Africa, an Asian in Europe, a Chicano in San Ysidro, an anarchist in Spain, a Palestinian in Israel, a Mayan Indian in the streets of San Cristobal, a Jew in Germany, a Gypsy in Poland, a Mohawk in Quebec, a pacifist in Bosnia, a single woman on the Metro at 10pm, a peasant without land, a gang member in the slums, an unemployed worker, an unhappy student and, of course, a Zapatista in the mountains, the exploited, marginalised, oppressed minorities resisting and saying `Enough’, every minority who is now beginning to speak and every majority that must shut up and listen, every untolerated group searching for a way to speak, Everything that makes power and the good consciences of those in power uncomfortable: “The Enby”

Emma Goldman: “The Fugitive”

Mao Tse-Tung (Zedong): “The Zoomer”

Old Lucy Parsons: “The One Who Actually Did The Assignment”

0

Do you ever meet those people who just exude praxis?

preview

I’m talking to my sister earlier, and find out she’s set up this entire mutual aid network in her neighborhood. I asked where she got the idea, or if she followed a guide – nope. She just vibed out something that I’ve struggled to make happen for a decade. In like a few months! And she does this stuff all the time, her entire life! But if you ask how she does it she just shrugs. She doesn’t even ask for help or think of it as some exceptional thing, she’ll casually drop that she teaches courses on recognizing child abuse for three years without telling anyone.

This isn’t like a condemnation or anything, like “oh, go read theory.” Like, she did it solely off vibes! If anything I’m jealous. I’m also not saying this invalidates theory, just confused as to how on earth someone can just do this on a whim! And where I can learn to do it too!

I’m talking to my sister earlier, and find out she’s set up this entire mutual aid network in her neighborhood. I asked where she got the idea, or if she followed a guide – nope. She just vibed out something that I’ve struggled to make happen for a decade. In like a few months! And she does this stuff all the time, her entire life! But if you ask how she does it she just shrugs. She doesn’t even ask for help or think of it as some exceptional thing, she’ll casually drop that she teaches courses on recognizing child abuse for three years without telling anyone.

This isn’t like a condemnation or anything, like “oh, go read theory.” Like, she did it solely off vibes! If anything I’m jealous. I’m also not saying this invalidates theory, just confused as to how on earth someone can just do this on a whim! And where I can learn to do it too!

0

"Anti-Fascism" is the Leftism of Fools (bad title, see comments!)

play · youtube.com
YouTube "Anti-Fascism" is the Leftism of Fools www.youtube.com
preview

cross-posted from: anarchist.nexus/…/anti-fascism-is-the-leftism-of-…

It’s about how merely anti-fascist art and movements can be recuperated and made safe by capitalism. Blow it up 🏴🏴🏴🏴

cross-posted from: anarchist.nexus/…/anti-fascism-is-the-leftism-of-…

It’s about how merely anti-fascist art and movements can be recuperated and made safe by capitalism. Blow it up 🏴🏴🏴🏴

0

"Anti-Fascism" is the Leftism of Fools (bad title, see comments!)

play · youtube.com
YouTube "Anti-Fascism" is the Leftism of Fools www.youtube.com
preview

cross-posted from: anarchist.nexus/…/anti-fascism-is-the-leftism-of-…

It’s about how merely anti-fascist art and movements can be recuperated and made safe by capitalism. Blow it up 🏴🏴🏴🏴

cross-posted from: anarchist.nexus/…/anti-fascism-is-the-leftism-of-…

It’s about how merely anti-fascist art and movements can be recuperated and made safe by capitalism. Blow it up 🏴🏴🏴🏴

0

intro: the international people's core

play · youtube.com
YouTube The People's Core First Episode - Seeds for Liberation youtu.be
preview

first episode of The Peoples Core yt channel aired 3 months ago but 5 core members explain what the IPC is all about.

this movement is internationalist & revolutionary following the principles of the Black Panther Party as it was in the past.

check out their website where you can read the 4 Winds Approach 2 Revolution

fourwinds.uate.net/chapters/introduction/

first episode of The Peoples Core yt channel aired 3 months ago but 5 core members explain what the IPC is all about.

this movement is internationalist & revolutionary following the principles of the Black Panther Party as it was in the past.

check out their website where you can read the 4 Winds Approach 2 Revolution

fourwinds.uate.net/chapters/introduction/

0

Any active anarchist discord servers?

preview

I’m having a hard time finding a discord server where I could engage in real-time discussions around anarchism. I have a lot of questions and I prefer to learn by asking people questions directly. I’ve read the anarchyfaqs (skimmed) and some more, but need a place to ask all my little and big questions.

Please let me know. Most servers I find seem dead, 2 of the 3 I was in kicked me for saying 9/11 was an inside job ;-;.

I’m having a hard time finding a discord server where I could engage in real-time discussions around anarchism. I have a lot of questions and I prefer to learn by asking people questions directly. I’ve read the anarchyfaqs (skimmed) and some more, but need a place to ask all my little and big questions.

Please let me know. Most servers I find seem dead, 2 of the 3 I was in kicked me for saying 9/11 was an inside job ;-;.

0

bash the fash in sunderland

preview

no to farage in sunderland
reform are coming to the north east again to spread their hate, lies & division. come show them they aren’t welcome.
thursday 26th of march 2026
sunderland live arena, raignton meadows, DH4 5PH
meet at 6pm at the entrance to the carpark.

no to farage in sunderland
reform are coming to the north east again to spread their hate, lies & division. come show them they aren’t welcome.
thursday 26th of march 2026
sunderland live arena, raignton meadows, DH4 5PH
meet at 6pm at the entrance to the carpark.

0

🎉genocide factory down🎉

“On 20th March 2026, the Earthquake Faction struck the epicenter of the Israeli weapons industry in Europe. In Pardubice, Czech Republic, Elbit Systems' "Centre of Excellence" was newly built in collaboration with LPP, to service the global expansion of Israel's biggest weapons producer.  Whilst the development, production and training center was empty, The Earthquake Faction intervened to destroy its equipment and set the factory ablaze. No one was harmed.  The site is used to develop weaponry used by the Zionist entity to massacre people daily in Palestine, Lebanon, Iran, and across West Asia.
preview

For our full communiqué and more videos/images which are free to distribute, see our website: earthquakefaction.net

Updates on Telegram at t.me/earthquake_faction”

linky to calla twitter source

(obviously don’t go to those websites without at least vpn or tor)

For our full communiqué and more videos/images which are free to distribute, see our website: earthquakefaction.net

Updates on Telegram at t.me/earthquake_faction”

linky to calla twitter source

(obviously don’t go to those websites without at least vpn or tor)

0

What do we do with the "broken steps"?

preview

Context: a broken step is someone or something within your community which only the locals know to avoid.

Suppose we have a confederation, and someone within the confederation is accused of being dangerous to others in some way. If we kick them out then what stops them from going somewhere else and repeating the pattern? Or coming back for revenge? Or, Stirner Forbid, they’re innocent? And even if they are dangerous, is that any reason to turn them away? We make considerations when it comes to wolves and cacti but draw the line at cousins? But they could hurt the community… you see my dilemma.

Edit: this is not a hypothetical, but I don’t want to get into details. We’re not going to beat anyone up because we can’t confirm anything actually happened.

Context: a broken step is someone or something within your community which only the locals know to avoid.

Suppose we have a confederation, and someone within the confederation is accused of being dangerous to others in some way. If we kick them out then what stops them from going somewhere else and repeating the pattern? Or coming back for revenge? Or, Stirner Forbid, they’re innocent? And even if they are dangerous, is that any reason to turn them away? We make considerations when it comes to wolves and cacti but draw the line at cousins? But they could hurt the community… you see my dilemma.

Edit: this is not a hypothetical, but I don’t want to get into details. We’re not going to beat anyone up because we can’t confirm anything actually happened.

0

a civic implementation plan against state threats

play · youtube.com
YouTube AMERICA’S REAL THREATS - And Our Plan To Reduce Them (Without WASHINGTON) youtu.be
preview

get educated by this former BPP elder. he explains in a calm structured way a concrete civic implementation plan.

he says: we break down the major threats facing americans right now and explain exactly what Standards, Not Force (SNF) will do — lawfully, calmly, and strategically — to reduce risk in daily life without depending on washington.

get educated by this former BPP elder. he explains in a calm structured way a concrete civic implementation plan.

he says: we break down the major threats facing americans right now and explain exactly what Standards, Not Force (SNF) will do — lawfully, calmly, and strategically — to reduce risk in daily life without depending on washington.

0

Urgent Mutual Aid

Ko-fi Support skitzo goblin ❤️ ko-fi.com
preview

from my sibling elsewhere in the fediverse:

🛟 Hey,

I need financial support for myself and my kitten. I was sick through most of the January and got little money in February. This is my only safety net.

It’s been rough, lately. And I’ve got a kitten to take care of.

PayPal: radnow@tutanota.com

All help appreciated. I’m sorry.

MutualAid MutualAidRequest @mutualaid@a.gup.pe @MutualAidNet @mutualaid@gup.yap.tf

from my sibling elsewhere in the fediverse:

🛟 Hey,

I need financial support for myself and my kitten. I was sick through most of the January and got little money in February. This is my only safety net.

It’s been rough, lately. And I’ve got a kitten to take care of.

PayPal: radnow@tutanota.com

All help appreciated. I’m sorry.

MutualAid MutualAidRequest @mutualaid@a.gup.pe @MutualAidNet @mutualaid@gup.yap.tf

0

launch 🏴gif's artidote collective 🏴

🐍⛑️ gif's artidote 🐍⛑️ 🐍⛑️ gif's artidote 🐍⛑️ gifsartidote.life
preview

gif"s artidote is seeking an antidote to toxicity through art, music, community events, discussion, activism, mutial aid & solidarity.

to that end i have set up a collective.

check it out here, and if you’re inspired, come join me!

opencollective.com/gifs-artidote

through my personal activities as an artist, blogger, student crim/psy & community activism i am seeking to create a (local & global) community collective to de-toxify human behaviour by starting with my self & encouraging others to do the same.

i live by my motto: change the world, start with your self.

read more on my website’s home,- & about pages.

i am working on a manifesto but due to my own limitations that’s a work in progress.

i need others’ contributions & i am only just starting out so if you like my ideas, come join me & contribute.

i am based in teesside, north yorkshire, england & this initiative is starting in my own local community, but my aim is to create a global network of people who commit to the manifesto we create, debate & maintain together.

i only take the initiative, & set out a basis, but as we grow this #collective, through discussion & debate based on anarchist principles, i hope the collective will take lead & develop independently.

gif"s artidote is seeking an antidote to toxicity through art, music, community events, discussion, activism, mutial aid & solidarity.

to that end i have set up a collective.

check it out here, and if you’re inspired, come join me!

opencollective.com/gifs-artidote

through my personal activities as an artist, blogger, student crim/psy & community activism i am seeking to create a (local & global) community collective to de-toxify human behaviour by starting with my self & encouraging others to do the same.

i live by my motto: change the world, start with your self.

read more on my website’s home,- & about pages.

i am working on a manifesto but due to my own limitations that’s a work in progress.

i need others’ contributions & i am only just starting out so if you like my ideas, come join me & contribute.

i am based in teesside, north yorkshire, england & this initiative is starting in my own local community, but my aim is to create a global network of people who commit to the manifesto we create, debate & maintain together.

i only take the initiative, & set out a basis, but as we grow this #collective, through discussion & debate based on anarchist principles, i hope the collective will take lead & develop independently.

0

Review of Their Wars - Our Dead: Anarchist Reflections on Anti-Militarism

preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/24355

Politics:

Anarchism

History:

2022: Russo-Ukrainian War

Facts:

Books, art and culture

Publications:

Revolutionary Perspectives

(Alex Alder and Bill Beech (eds.), Their Wars – Our Dead: Anarchist Reflections on Anti-Militarism (2025, PM Press), · Since the war in Ukraine, the anarchist movement in the UK and elsewhere has split on the question of internationalism. The authors of this book are in the internationalist camp and have published it in order to make their views known. As internationalists, we welcome this effort by our comrades. The authors state they do not wish to simply rehash the debates of the last three years but want “to reflect on the place of anarchism in anti-militarism historically, and at present moment” (p.6) and seek “to learn from the past in order to figure out a revolutionary yet realistic course of anarchist anti-militarism today”. (p.25)

The six authors are based in Ireland, Scotland, Wales, and England. They have been or continue to be members of organisations such as the Anarchist Communist Group (ACG), Solidarity Federation (SolFed), Organise!, or the AnarCom Network (ACN). Some of them are known to us and have participated in the No War but the Class War (NWBCW) initiative.(1)

The authors of the introduction, Alex Alder and Bill Beech, summarise how, following the war in Ukraine, anarchists in Great Britain caught war fever.(2) That so many anarchists succumbed to warmongering is due to the weakness of both the anarchist current and the workers’ movement in general. Some pro-war anarchists acknowledge this weakness and in fact use it as an argument in favour of compromising with the ruling class. Some anarchists’ enthusiasm for Corbynism is also seen as a precursor to the falling in line with warmongering.(3) It should be noted this is also found outside the UK, with anarchists backing Mélenchon’s party in France for example.


From Leftcom via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/24355

Politics:

Anarchism

History:

2022: Russo-Ukrainian War

Facts:

Books, art and culture

Publications:

Revolutionary Perspectives

(Alex Alder and Bill Beech (eds.), Their Wars – Our Dead: Anarchist Reflections on Anti-Militarism (2025, PM Press), · Since the war in Ukraine, the anarchist movement in the UK and elsewhere has split on the question of internationalism. The authors of this book are in the internationalist camp and have published it in order to make their views known. As internationalists, we welcome this effort by our comrades. The authors state they do not wish to simply rehash the debates of the last three years but want “to reflect on the place of anarchism in anti-militarism historically, and at present moment” (p.6) and seek “to learn from the past in order to figure out a revolutionary yet realistic course of anarchist anti-militarism today”. (p.25)

The six authors are based in Ireland, Scotland, Wales, and England. They have been or continue to be members of organisations such as the Anarchist Communist Group (ACG), Solidarity Federation (SolFed), Organise!, or the AnarCom Network (ACN). Some of them are known to us and have participated in the No War but the Class War (NWBCW) initiative.(1)

The authors of the introduction, Alex Alder and Bill Beech, summarise how, following the war in Ukraine, anarchists in Great Britain caught war fever.(2) That so many anarchists succumbed to warmongering is due to the weakness of both the anarchist current and the workers’ movement in general. Some pro-war anarchists acknowledge this weakness and in fact use it as an argument in favour of compromising with the ruling class. Some anarchists’ enthusiasm for Corbynism is also seen as a precursor to the falling in line with warmongering.(3) It should be noted this is also found outside the UK, with anarchists backing Mélenchon’s party in France for example.


From Leftcom via This RSS Feed.

0

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

We Will Free Us Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires www.wewillfreeus.org
preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/23895

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

On the same day community members gathered to grieve the killing of Renee Good at the hands of an ICE agent in Minneapolis, something shifted in downtown Portland, Oregon. What began as a vigil and flag burning across from the federal courthouse transformed, almost organically, into an autonomous zone that held space through the night and reignited a conversation many people have been having quietly for months: What if mourning isn’t enough? What if we actually hold ground?

“What started as a permanent vigil just… grew,” one participant said. “People had yarn in their pockets and wrapped it around a corner of the park, and that became the seeds for the first barricade. Then folks were like, fuck it, and started dragging street barricades over. It all snowballed from there.”

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Earlier that evening, a large rally had taken place at City Hall, organized by groups including DSA. Like many mass demonstrations, it drew a crowd, delivered speeches, and then… ended after an hour. People began to disperse. And as they did, frustration was audible.

“There were people literally walking away saying, ‘That’s it? That’s all we’re gonna fucking do?’” they recalled. “A lot of those same people ended up coming over where the flags were burning.”

Just a block away, others had already begun something different. A vigil was forming in Chapman Square, a park across the street from the federal courthouse. American flags were burned in protest. Candles and offerings appeared. Yarn was strung around a corner of the park, a small, almost symbolic boundary.

Then people who had just left the larger rally started walking over. They didn’t just watch. They joined.

More makeshift barriers appeared. Street materials were dragged into place. What had been described as a vigil quickly became a defended space. Not through a centralized call, but through a shared feeling: we can’t just march, go home, and wait for the next tragedy to listen to all the same speeches again.

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

photos from the permanent vigil

“It was a rebellion,” they said. “Not just about Renee. It was about everything that led to her murder. It was people saying, we’re done responding passively.”

While Renee Good’s murder was the immediate spark, participants say the space was about more than a single event. It was about the cycle people are exhausted by… outrage, march, speeches, dispersal, repeat. All while the systems responsible for this violence remain untouched.

This time, instead of dispersing, people stayed.

Indigenous community members played a central role in establishing a sacred fire at the site, grounding the space in ceremony, remembrance, and resistance. People said this was also a way to honor earlier anti-ICE organizing that began in Portland in January 2025, when Indigenous community members held weekly sacred fires outside the ICE facility long before summer crowds grew.

That history often gets erased. This space made it visible again. “This was about honoring the people who paved the way.”

“It set an amazing tone,” the participant said. “You had Indigenous community members who don’t just show up when something’s trending. Their whole existence is resisting settler colonialism. Being in space with that guidance changed how people understood what we were doing.”

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Photos of barricades at the vigil

The fire burned from around 8:30 p.m. until roughly 10 a.m. the next morning, the sacred fire burned for about 14 hours before police moved in at a moment when many supporters had gone to provide court support elsewhere. Participants say the timing was deliberate.

But it didn’t end there.

On January 9th, a few days after Good was murdered by ICE, Border Patrol shot Luis David Nino-Moncada and Yorlenys Betzabeth Zambrano-Contreras, a Venezuelan couple in Portland, Oregon. The sacred fire returned, this time in a location chosen with sharper political symbolism. The new site sat within view of the county jail (often called the “(in)Justice Center”), the federal courthouse, and City Hall.

“These institutions claim to represent justice. The fire was there to say otherwise.”

The second gathering expanded beyond vigil into political education and open discussion. People spoke not only about grief, but about responsibility, naming City Hall’s role in permitting the ICE facility, the courts’ role in deportation pipelines, and the broader illusion that these institutions are neutral.

“This time it was way more intentional,” the participant said. “The sacred fire represents truth. And it was surrounded by institutions of lies.”

At one point late in the night, a small group of right-wing agitators drove by and attempted to provoke people at the fire. Those present faced a choice: extinguish the fire to prevent harassment, or hold their ground.

They chose to stay.

The agitators eventually left. The fire kept burning.

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

For those there, the moment was symbolic of something larger: when people remain rooted together, especially under Indigenous guidance and ceremony, intimidation loses some of its power.

Participants drew connections between the autonomous zone and other forms of repression in Portland, especially police harassment of mutual aid groups and community resource distros. In those cases, simply feeding people or existing in shared public space has drawn heavy police presence and legal threats.

To many involved, the message from the state is clear:
Autonomy itself is what’s criminalized.

In that context, defending a vigil, holding a sacred fire, and refusing to disperse becomes more than symbolic. It becomes a direct challenge to who is allowed to occupy land, make decisions, and care for community outside state control.

Both nights of the autonomous space coincided with other actions happening across Portland, including large demonstrations at the ICE facility. With multiple events unfolding at once, police resources were stretched thin. Participants say that mattered.

It was a reminder of an old movement lesson: authorities can easily manage one large, predictable protest. They struggle when resistance becomes decentralized, simultaneous, and self-directed.

People came to mourn Renee Good. They stayed because mourning alone felt like surrender.

What emerged downtown wasn’t a perfectly planned occupation or a pre-announced autonomous zone. It was something messier and more alive: a community deciding, in real time, not to go home.

And in that decision, to hold a fire, to defend space, to gather under Indigenous guidance, to speak openly about the failures of local institutions, many participants say they glimpsed something that felt less like protest and more like practice.

Not just responding to violence.
But rehearsing a world beyond it.

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires


From We Will Free Us via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/23895

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

On the same day community members gathered to grieve the killing of Renee Good at the hands of an ICE agent in Minneapolis, something shifted in downtown Portland, Oregon. What began as a vigil and flag burning across from the federal courthouse transformed, almost organically, into an autonomous zone that held space through the night and reignited a conversation many people have been having quietly for months: What if mourning isn’t enough? What if we actually hold ground?

“What started as a permanent vigil just… grew,” one participant said. “People had yarn in their pockets and wrapped it around a corner of the park, and that became the seeds for the first barricade. Then folks were like, fuck it, and started dragging street barricades over. It all snowballed from there.”

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Earlier that evening, a large rally had taken place at City Hall, organized by groups including DSA. Like many mass demonstrations, it drew a crowd, delivered speeches, and then… ended after an hour. People began to disperse. And as they did, frustration was audible.

“There were people literally walking away saying, ‘That’s it? That’s all we’re gonna fucking do?’” they recalled. “A lot of those same people ended up coming over where the flags were burning.”

Just a block away, others had already begun something different. A vigil was forming in Chapman Square, a park across the street from the federal courthouse. American flags were burned in protest. Candles and offerings appeared. Yarn was strung around a corner of the park, a small, almost symbolic boundary.

Then people who had just left the larger rally started walking over. They didn’t just watch. They joined.

More makeshift barriers appeared. Street materials were dragged into place. What had been described as a vigil quickly became a defended space. Not through a centralized call, but through a shared feeling: we can’t just march, go home, and wait for the next tragedy to listen to all the same speeches again.

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

photos from the permanent vigil

“It was a rebellion,” they said. “Not just about Renee. It was about everything that led to her murder. It was people saying, we’re done responding passively.”

While Renee Good’s murder was the immediate spark, participants say the space was about more than a single event. It was about the cycle people are exhausted by… outrage, march, speeches, dispersal, repeat. All while the systems responsible for this violence remain untouched.

This time, instead of dispersing, people stayed.

Indigenous community members played a central role in establishing a sacred fire at the site, grounding the space in ceremony, remembrance, and resistance. People said this was also a way to honor earlier anti-ICE organizing that began in Portland in January 2025, when Indigenous community members held weekly sacred fires outside the ICE facility long before summer crowds grew.

That history often gets erased. This space made it visible again. “This was about honoring the people who paved the way.”

“It set an amazing tone,” the participant said. “You had Indigenous community members who don’t just show up when something’s trending. Their whole existence is resisting settler colonialism. Being in space with that guidance changed how people understood what we were doing.”

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Photos of barricades at the vigil

The fire burned from around 8:30 p.m. until roughly 10 a.m. the next morning, the sacred fire burned for about 14 hours before police moved in at a moment when many supporters had gone to provide court support elsewhere. Participants say the timing was deliberate.

But it didn’t end there.

On January 9th, a few days after Good was murdered by ICE, Border Patrol shot Luis David Nino-Moncada and Yorlenys Betzabeth Zambrano-Contreras, a Venezuelan couple in Portland, Oregon. The sacred fire returned, this time in a location chosen with sharper political symbolism. The new site sat within view of the county jail (often called the “(in)Justice Center”), the federal courthouse, and City Hall.

“These institutions claim to represent justice. The fire was there to say otherwise.”

The second gathering expanded beyond vigil into political education and open discussion. People spoke not only about grief, but about responsibility, naming City Hall’s role in permitting the ICE facility, the courts’ role in deportation pipelines, and the broader illusion that these institutions are neutral.

“This time it was way more intentional,” the participant said. “The sacred fire represents truth. And it was surrounded by institutions of lies.”

At one point late in the night, a small group of right-wing agitators drove by and attempted to provoke people at the fire. Those present faced a choice: extinguish the fire to prevent harassment, or hold their ground.

They chose to stay.

The agitators eventually left. The fire kept burning.

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

For those there, the moment was symbolic of something larger: when people remain rooted together, especially under Indigenous guidance and ceremony, intimidation loses some of its power.

Participants drew connections between the autonomous zone and other forms of repression in Portland, especially police harassment of mutual aid groups and community resource distros. In those cases, simply feeding people or existing in shared public space has drawn heavy police presence and legal threats.

To many involved, the message from the state is clear:
Autonomy itself is what’s criminalized.

In that context, defending a vigil, holding a sacred fire, and refusing to disperse becomes more than symbolic. It becomes a direct challenge to who is allowed to occupy land, make decisions, and care for community outside state control.

Both nights of the autonomous space coincided with other actions happening across Portland, including large demonstrations at the ICE facility. With multiple events unfolding at once, police resources were stretched thin. Participants say that mattered.

It was a reminder of an old movement lesson: authorities can easily manage one large, predictable protest. They struggle when resistance becomes decentralized, simultaneous, and self-directed.

People came to mourn Renee Good. They stayed because mourning alone felt like surrender.

What emerged downtown wasn’t a perfectly planned occupation or a pre-announced autonomous zone. It was something messier and more alive: a community deciding, in real time, not to go home.

And in that decision, to hold a fire, to defend space, to gather under Indigenous guidance, to speak openly about the failures of local institutions, many participants say they glimpsed something that felt less like protest and more like practice.

Not just responding to violence.
But rehearsing a world beyond it.

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires

Autonomy in Practice: Permanent Vigil’s and Sacred Fires


From We Will Free Us via This RSS Feed.

0

Does anyone have experience or resources on setting up a food distro? Specifically a mobile food distro.

preview

I’ve thought about this for a while now. I was thinking of getting a food truck then just giving away food and taking donations. If the cops come and say move I can pull down the block. Disaster requires help I can show up and hand out stuff.

I’ve thought about this for a while now. I was thinking of getting a food truck then just giving away food and taking donations. If the cops come and say move I can pull down the block. Disaster requires help I can show up and hand out stuff.

0

TotW: Meaningful OpSec

preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/22689

TotW: Meaningful OpSec thecollective Sun, 01/25/2026 - 08:00

MEANINGFUL OPSEC; OR, NOW, YOU DON’T HAVE A PERSONAL FBI AGENT

I’ve been considering operational security and security culture a lot since the Turtle Island Liberation Front (TILF) case broke. For such a small group, about seven people, two were feds (well, one was a paid informant, the other was an FBI agent).

I am reminded of the joke myth of a CPUSA meeting that a federal infiltrator attends in order to arrest the attendees. Then all the other members are also feds. Cue the laugh track.

Despite the colossal fuck-up of being infiltrated, TILF had a plan that seemed based in strong Opsec. From The United States District Court For The Central District Of California: “The plan described multiple operational security measures the co-conspirators should take to conceal their identities, such as the use of a burner phone that would be disposed of after the bombings by ‘submerging it in a concrete brick after destroying the sim and then disposing of the brick in a body of water.’” and: the use of ‘BlacBloc’ overtop of a layer of ‘grey/casual bloc’ on top of normal street clothes, and noted to keep hair very tightly concealed and to wear gloves for the purpose of avoidance of leaving behind DNA” further: “participants should leave their personal devices at home and to make sure the devices were set up to stream a long movie during the time of the attacks, so as to craft an alibi.” Even a pebble in the show to alter their walking and material acquisition advice to avoid suspicion, were discussed.

A question I am stuck on is how can you have thought through these particular aspects of prep work and on the ground Opsec and allow yourself to be infiltrated by two Feds? As a friend said, “Because their security was missing the trees for the forest.”

From CrimethInc’s “What is Security Culture?” The difference between protocol and culture is that culture becomes unconscious, instinctive, and thus effortless; once the safest possible behavior has become habitual for everyone in the circles in which you travel, you can spend less time and energy emphasizing the need for it, or suffering the consequences of not having it, or worrying about how much danger you’re in, as you’ll know you’re already doing everything you can to be careful. It seems, from what is available, TILF had strong protocols for their “Operation Midnight Sun,” but not a real culture to develop secure, safe relationships to avoid infiltration. They posted calls for direct action and revolution on social media, one that was easily connected to a member of TILF (and thus, the radical section that sought to do the attack). They let relatively new people into the plan: the informant and later the FBI agent. The difference in attitudes about security by the same people is striking.

By having a strong focus (and in the case of TILF, reasonable ones in regards to the plan) on only some parts of Security Culture and not a whole picture, you leave gaps in the culture. For most people, this is “well, the feds are watching” and thus their security culture centers that primary concern, as opposed to it being part of a wider network of concerns. And let us be real: most of us do not have the feds particularly watching our actions or groupings, outside of the concerns of a general surveillance state. This all comes at the expense of, say, local cops, right-wing agitators, or the common person who may overhear or see something they shouldn’t.

So, while TILF did have personal FBI agents inside their network, it was because of a failure of their security culture leading up to that point. Had it been a stronger culture, maybe “Operation Midnight Sun” would have been another CNN news segment we’d forget by the next day.

Questions

What security concerns do you find are most overlooked in anarchist circles? What about overdone?

How are security concerns changing in light of the development of companies like Flock Safety, Oracle and Palantir?

What are ways security culture and protocols change between anarchist groupings, particularly those separated by geography? (Say, in different cities or countries)

From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/22689

TotW: Meaningful OpSec thecollective Sun, 01/25/2026 - 08:00

MEANINGFUL OPSEC; OR, NOW, YOU DON’T HAVE A PERSONAL FBI AGENT

I’ve been considering operational security and security culture a lot since the Turtle Island Liberation Front (TILF) case broke. For such a small group, about seven people, two were feds (well, one was a paid informant, the other was an FBI agent).

I am reminded of the joke myth of a CPUSA meeting that a federal infiltrator attends in order to arrest the attendees. Then all the other members are also feds. Cue the laugh track.

Despite the colossal fuck-up of being infiltrated, TILF had a plan that seemed based in strong Opsec. From The United States District Court For The Central District Of California: “The plan described multiple operational security measures the co-conspirators should take to conceal their identities, such as the use of a burner phone that would be disposed of after the bombings by ‘submerging it in a concrete brick after destroying the sim and then disposing of the brick in a body of water.’” and: the use of ‘BlacBloc’ overtop of a layer of ‘grey/casual bloc’ on top of normal street clothes, and noted to keep hair very tightly concealed and to wear gloves for the purpose of avoidance of leaving behind DNA” further: “participants should leave their personal devices at home and to make sure the devices were set up to stream a long movie during the time of the attacks, so as to craft an alibi.” Even a pebble in the show to alter their walking and material acquisition advice to avoid suspicion, were discussed.

A question I am stuck on is how can you have thought through these particular aspects of prep work and on the ground Opsec and allow yourself to be infiltrated by two Feds? As a friend said, “Because their security was missing the trees for the forest.”

From CrimethInc’s “What is Security Culture?” The difference between protocol and culture is that culture becomes unconscious, instinctive, and thus effortless; once the safest possible behavior has become habitual for everyone in the circles in which you travel, you can spend less time and energy emphasizing the need for it, or suffering the consequences of not having it, or worrying about how much danger you’re in, as you’ll know you’re already doing everything you can to be careful. It seems, from what is available, TILF had strong protocols for their “Operation Midnight Sun,” but not a real culture to develop secure, safe relationships to avoid infiltration. They posted calls for direct action and revolution on social media, one that was easily connected to a member of TILF (and thus, the radical section that sought to do the attack). They let relatively new people into the plan: the informant and later the FBI agent. The difference in attitudes about security by the same people is striking.

By having a strong focus (and in the case of TILF, reasonable ones in regards to the plan) on only some parts of Security Culture and not a whole picture, you leave gaps in the culture. For most people, this is “well, the feds are watching” and thus their security culture centers that primary concern, as opposed to it being part of a wider network of concerns. And let us be real: most of us do not have the feds particularly watching our actions or groupings, outside of the concerns of a general surveillance state. This all comes at the expense of, say, local cops, right-wing agitators, or the common person who may overhear or see something they shouldn’t.

So, while TILF did have personal FBI agents inside their network, it was because of a failure of their security culture leading up to that point. Had it been a stronger culture, maybe “Operation Midnight Sun” would have been another CNN news segment we’d forget by the next day.

Questions

What security concerns do you find are most overlooked in anarchist circles? What about overdone?

How are security concerns changing in light of the development of companies like Flock Safety, Oracle and Palantir?

What are ways security culture and protocols change between anarchist groupings, particularly those separated by geography? (Say, in different cities or countries)

From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

0

Minneapolis Responds to the Murder of Alex Pretti

preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/22631

Minneapolis Responds to the Murder of Alex Pretti thecollective Sun, 01/25/2026 - 03:23


From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/22631

Minneapolis Responds to the Murder of Alex Pretti thecollective Sun, 01/25/2026 - 03:23


From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

0

The Diggers' Song by Gerrard Winstanley, 17th century, England, performed by Chumbawamba

play · youtube.com
YouTube Chumbawamba - The Diggers' Song www.youtube.com
preview

Context: The Diggers were a small but radical group of agrarian socialists and Protestant dissidents in 17th-century England who, after the execution of Charles I, occupied common land in 1649 to cultivate it collectively and challenge private property and enclosure. Their communities were harassed and dispersed by landowners and authorities by 1650, but their ideas about communal land use and economic equality left a lasting legacy in later social movements.

Context: The Diggers were a small but radical group of agrarian socialists and Protestant dissidents in 17th-century England who, after the execution of Charles I, occupied common land in 1649 to cultivate it collectively and challenge private property and enclosure. Their communities were harassed and dispersed by landowners and authorities by 1650, but their ideas about communal land use and economic equality left a lasting legacy in later social movements.

0

State integration forced on Rojava

Freedom Press State integration forced on Rojava - Freedom Press freedomnews.org.uk
preview

Recent weeks’ clashes between Syrian state forces and Kurdish forces have developed into a multi-front assault on Rojava, threatening open war as a means of forcing it to integrate into an Islamist state structure. Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) are resisting sustained attacks using drones and heavy weapons by Damascus-affiliated militias in Hasakeh and Raqqa, including near two prisons housing thousands of Islamic State (ISIS) fighters. SDF confirmed that repeated assaults on al-Shaddadi prison were initially repelled at heavy cost before the facility ultimately fell with thousands of ISIS fighters escaping, despite its proximity to a US-led coalition base that did not intervene.

Recent weeks’ clashes between Syrian state forces and Kurdish forces have developed into a multi-front assault on Rojava, threatening open war as a means of forcing it to integrate into an Islamist state structure. Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) are resisting sustained attacks using drones and heavy weapons by Damascus-affiliated militias in Hasakeh and Raqqa, including near two prisons housing thousands of Islamic State (ISIS) fighters. SDF confirmed that repeated assaults on al-Shaddadi prison were initially repelled at heavy cost before the facility ultimately fell with thousands of ISIS fighters escaping, despite its proximity to a US-led coalition base that did not intervene.

0

Two Forgotten Historians of American Anarchism

preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/19473

Two Forgotten Historians of American Anarchism thecollective Tue, 01/13/2026 - 04:07


From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/19473

Two Forgotten Historians of American Anarchism thecollective Tue, 01/13/2026 - 04:07


From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

0

The Political Repression and Resistance of Eloxochitlán de Flores Magón, Oaxaca

preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/18869

The Political Repression and Resistance of Eloxochitlán de Flores Magón, Oaxaca thecollective Sat, 01/10/2026 - 06:50

This week, an interview we just conducted with Madeleine Wattenbarger and Axel Hernández of the Cooperativa de Periodismo in Mexico and Ambar Ruiz of Radio Zapote about the case of autonomous resistance and repression in the Mazateca community of Eloxochitlán de Flores Magón in Oaxaca, Mexico, so named for being the birthplace of the Cipriano Ricardo Flores Magón, revolutionary Mexican anarchist who was murdered by medical neglect by the US prison system in 1922 (check out our 2022 episode on the history).

We talk about the rise to economic and political power of the family of Manuel Zepeda and his daughter Elena, their weaponization of the judiciary against community defenders resisting a hijacking in 2014 of the traditional community assembly and the years of organizing by Mazateca women whose loved ones face long prison sentences. We also speak about the case of Miguel Peralta, a Mazateca anarchist challenging his 5 decade sentence related to this case, as well as the recent murder by medical neglect while in prison of militant anarcho-punk Yorch Esquivel at the hands of the Mexican state at the behest of UNAM.

From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/18869

The Political Repression and Resistance of Eloxochitlán de Flores Magón, Oaxaca thecollective Sat, 01/10/2026 - 06:50

This week, an interview we just conducted with Madeleine Wattenbarger and Axel Hernández of the Cooperativa de Periodismo in Mexico and Ambar Ruiz of Radio Zapote about the case of autonomous resistance and repression in the Mazateca community of Eloxochitlán de Flores Magón in Oaxaca, Mexico, so named for being the birthplace of the Cipriano Ricardo Flores Magón, revolutionary Mexican anarchist who was murdered by medical neglect by the US prison system in 1922 (check out our 2022 episode on the history).

We talk about the rise to economic and political power of the family of Manuel Zepeda and his daughter Elena, their weaponization of the judiciary against community defenders resisting a hijacking in 2014 of the traditional community assembly and the years of organizing by Mazateca women whose loved ones face long prison sentences. We also speak about the case of Miguel Peralta, a Mazateca anarchist challenging his 5 decade sentence related to this case, as well as the recent murder by medical neglect while in prison of militant anarcho-punk Yorch Esquivel at the hands of the Mexican state at the behest of UNAM.

From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

0

Iranian anarchists: Uprising is “genuine self-organisation by ordinary people”

preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/18867

Iranian anarchists: Uprising is “genuine self-organisation by ordinary people” thecollective Sat, 01/10/2026 - 06:43


From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/18867

Iranian anarchists: Uprising is “genuine self-organisation by ordinary people” thecollective Sat, 01/10/2026 - 06:43


From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

0

There is Hope, But We Must Build It | Cooperation Tulsa 2025 Year in Review

play · youtube.com
YouTube Land, Food, and Freedom: Building Power Outside the State | Cooperation Tulsa 2025 www.youtube.com
preview

cross-posted from: lemmy.sdf.org/post/48741557

Finally some good fucking news 🏴🏴🏴

cross-posted from: lemmy.sdf.org/post/48741557

Finally some good fucking news 🏴🏴🏴

0

There is Hope, But We Must Build It | Cooperation Tulsa 2025 Year in Review

play · youtube.com
YouTube Land, Food, and Freedom: Building Power Outside the State | Cooperation Tulsa 2025 www.youtube.com
preview

cross-posted from: lemmy.sdf.org/post/48741557

Finally some good fucking news 🏴🏴🏴

cross-posted from: lemmy.sdf.org/post/48741557

Finally some good fucking news 🏴🏴🏴

0

There is Hope, But We Must Build It | Cooperation Tulsa 2025 Year in Review

play · youtube.com
YouTube Land, Food, and Freedom: Building Power Outside the State | Cooperation Tulsa 2025 www.youtube.com
preview

cross-posted from: lemmy.sdf.org/post/48741557

Finally some good fucking news 🏴🏴🏴

cross-posted from: lemmy.sdf.org/post/48741557

Finally some good fucking news 🏴🏴🏴

0

Article from 2022 by an Iranian Anarchist discussing some underlying issues which may be contributing to the stuff in Iran right now

preview

Edit: I updated the title per suggestions.

Edit: I apologize for snapping at people in the comments. I was arguing with someone earlier today and bad habits make preventable mistakes. I’ll do better.

I deliberately didn’t talk about the current events going on in Iran with the justification that a) I’m not from there b) I don’t know enough. But this article takes some concepts I thought I knew and spits them back at me.

I kept quiet about Israel for a long time because I was afraid of being called a bigot, and I will regret that until I die. So why am I suddenly willing to do this again when it comes to Iran? Because some of their interests align with mine? Because I’m afraid of pissing off reactionaries even within leftist spaces and then losing access to them?

What sort of Anarchist, leftist, or being capable of empathy would I be if I remain silent when I know something is wrong.

Edit: I updated the title per suggestions.

Edit: I apologize for snapping at people in the comments. I was arguing with someone earlier today and bad habits make preventable mistakes. I’ll do better.

I deliberately didn’t talk about the current events going on in Iran with the justification that a) I’m not from there b) I don’t know enough. But this article takes some concepts I thought I knew and spits them back at me.

I kept quiet about Israel for a long time because I was afraid of being called a bigot, and I will regret that until I die. So why am I suddenly willing to do this again when it comes to Iran? Because some of their interests align with mine? Because I’m afraid of pissing off reactionaries even within leftist spaces and then losing access to them?

What sort of Anarchist, leftist, or being capable of empathy would I be if I remain silent when I know something is wrong.

0

The War on Terror Turns Left - UNICORN RIOT

UNICORN RIOT The War on Terror Turns Left - UNICORN RIOT unicornriot.ninja
preview

#solidarity to my siblings in occupied #TurtleIsland & global colonies, as the so-called u.s.a. has invaded economically, politically & now military too pretty much everywhere.

#organise #educate & #resist in any way you can.

we got your back & fight alongside you everywhere. the #Global99% #antifa #press #media #news #BreakingNews #GlobalDirectAction

✊️🏴🌍🌎☮️🖤

#solidarity to my siblings in occupied #TurtleIsland & global colonies, as the so-called u.s.a. has invaded economically, politically & now military too pretty much everywhere.

#organise #educate & #resist in any way you can.

we got your back & fight alongside you everywhere. the #Global99% #antifa #press #media #news #BreakingNews #GlobalDirectAction

✊️🏴🌍🌎☮️🖤

0

International Statement: We Denounce the Imperial Offensive on Venezuela

Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation International Statement: We Denounce the Imperial Offensive on Venezuela www.blackrosefed.org
preview

cross-posted from: hexbear.net/post/7201207

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/16418

This statement was prepared and signed by member organizations of the Latin American Anarchist Coordination – Coordinación Anarquista LatinoAmerica (CALA). Black Rose/Rosa Negra (BRRN) was invited to sign the statement as a sibling organization.


The Latin American Anarchist Coordination and sibling organizations condemn the threats of direct intervention in Venezuela by the US government, driven by the Trump administration.

These attempts and threats of intervention are not isolated incidents, nor are they a temporary response to alleged problems of “security,” “drug trafficking,” or “terrorism.” On the contrary, they are part of a long history of imperial interference in Latin America and the Caribbean, the effects of which have systematically fallen on the oppressed peoples and classes of the region.

The story is well known: every time the United States has invoked these pretexts, the result has been social devastation, loss of sovereignty, and violence. Panama in 1989, Iraq in 2003, and multiple interventions in our region show that this is not about “defending democracy,” but rather about political, military, and economic control. In the case of Venezuela, these threats come on top of more than a decade of economic blockade that has hit the daily lives of the people hard, deepening shortages, precariousness, and the deterioration of material conditions of existence.

In this respect, it is essential to emphasize that imperialist aggression does not punish ruling elites, but instead falls directly on the popular sectors. Blockades, sanctions, military intimidation, and financial suffocation are not “surgical” tools: they are mechanisms of economic warfare that seek to break the resistance of an entire people, discipline them, and force them to accept a subordinating order.

A recent and striking example of this logic is the act of piracy and blatant theft of a Venezuelan oil tanker by armed US military personnel, which was detained and appropriated under the protection of unilateral sanctions. Beyond the legal technicalities with which Washington attempts to justify these actions, what is evident is an exercise in modern piracy: the use of military, judicial, and financial power to appropriate resources. This is not only an attack on the Venezuelan state, but also a direct aggression against the people, because every shipment seized, every asset retained, and every property confiscated deepens the living conditions imposed by the blockade.

What’s more, their disregard for the lives of the people is evident in the absolute ease with which they launched explosives at fishing boats off the Venezuelan coast, taking away not only those people’s livelihoods, but also their lives and their right to defend themselves against unproven accusations. The massacre was televised and celebrated by those at the top.

These types of actions clearly reveal what the “international order” defended by the United States means today: a system in which major powers arrogate to themselves the right to decide who can trade, who can produce, and who deserves to be punished. International law is selective, flexible for allies, and brutally rigid for those who do not submit. In this context, the seizure of ships, the freezing of assets, and economic sanctions function as weapons of war, even though they are presented as administrative measures.

The recent awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to María Corina Machado follows the same logic of cynicism and double standards. These types of awards do not express universal values, but rather geopolitical alignments. Far from representing a genuine defense of the rights of the Venezuelan people, this recognition operates as a political gesture by imperial powers toward a leader who has openly endorsed sanctions, economic blockades, and threats of intervention. The Venezuelan right wing, far from offering a way out for the working classes, thus presents itself as a necessary partner in a strategy that deepens social suffering and dependence.

The explicit reappearance of the Monroe Doctrine in recent US government documents and statements only confirms this course of action. The old slogan “America for Americans” — that is, for Washington’s interests — is once again being asserted without euphemisms, reinstating the idea of Latin America as a natural zone of domination. This threatens not only Venezuela, but all the peoples of the continent, by legitimizing interventions, economic pressure, coups d’état, and the forced alignment of governments that stray from imperial interests. A prime example of this has been the Trump administration’s unprecedented intervention in Argentina in recent months, specifically in domestic economic policy, the foreign exchange market, and even the electoral process, giving a sudden boost to Milei’s government.

In the current context, the United States is no longer an unchallenged power, but it remains a central player in a world order based on violence, plunder, and imposition. Its growing aggressiveness also reflects its own internal crises and its need to reaffirm its control over strategic territories rich in oil, minerals, water, and biodiversity. Latin America, once again, appears as the spoils and rear guard of an imperial project that remains deeply dangerous.

Defending people’s self-determination—dominated, exploited, and oppressed classes within so-called “national” contexts—does not imply idealizing governments or denying internal contradictions inherent in the Venezuelan process, of which we are critical, but rather rejecting foreign intervention outright and affirming the right of every dominated, exploited, and oppressed class to fight for the improvement of their destiny without threats, blockades, or occupations. In this sense, we affirm that organization in the face of this situation cannot come from above or be delegated to state structures, but can only be built from below, through popular organization and the direct participation of those who sustain daily life under conditions of siege.

The case of the looted ship, like the economic blockade as a whole, shows that imperialism does not seek to “correct” governments, but rather to subjugate entire peoples through hunger, isolation, and collective punishment.

In Venezuela, as in the rest of Latin America, even amid the difficulties caused by bureaucratization, limitations, and tensions with the state that tend to weaken grassroots organization; communes, territorial spaces, and forms of popular organization sustain daily material and social resistance in the face of the blockade, shortages, and imperialist aggression.

Our struggle goes beyond the borders imposed by states and unites us with all oppressed classes. The imperialist government of the North has taken a xenophobic, racist, and persecutory stance toward migrant communities within its territory. The attack on Venezuela is ideologically based on the racism that is inherent in the US state—as in other states—and that radiates internally and externally in favor of the dominant classes of that country.

In the face of this offensive, as anarchists we denounce the US government and maintain that the solution will not come from stronger states or disputes between powers, nor from the so-called international organizations created by and for states, but from the construction of a strong people, organized from below, with political independence and a real capacity to contest power.

The history of Latin America shows that every advance of imperialism has encountered resistance even in adverse conditions. This sustains dignity and the capacity for a collective response. It is the material basis of popular power from below.

In the face of imperialism neutrality is not possible. Either you are on the side of domination, plunder, and war, or you are on the side of the oppressed.

Our commitment is long-term but clear: to strengthen popular organization, deepen resistance, and build from below an emancipatory horizon for the oppressed classes of the world.

Imperialism will not pass!

Long live those who fight!

Coordinación Anarquista Latinoamerica (CALA)

  • Federación Anarquista Uruguaya (FAU) – Uruguay
  • Federación Anarquista Santiago (FAS) – Chile
  • Coordenação Anarquista Brasileira (CAB) – Brazil
  • Federación Anarquista Rosario (FAR) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Resistencia (OAR) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Tucumán (OAT) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Cordoba (OAC) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Santa Cruz (OASC) – Argentina
  • La Tordo Negro – Organización Anarquista Enterriana – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Impulso – Argentina

Sibling Organizations

  • Black Rose Anarchist Federation / Federación Anarquista Rosa Negra (BRRN) – USA

The post International Statement: We Denounce the Imperial Offensive on Venezuela appeared first on Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation.


From Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: hexbear.net/post/7201207

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/16418

This statement was prepared and signed by member organizations of the Latin American Anarchist Coordination – Coordinación Anarquista LatinoAmerica (CALA). Black Rose/Rosa Negra (BRRN) was invited to sign the statement as a sibling organization.


The Latin American Anarchist Coordination and sibling organizations condemn the threats of direct intervention in Venezuela by the US government, driven by the Trump administration.

These attempts and threats of intervention are not isolated incidents, nor are they a temporary response to alleged problems of “security,” “drug trafficking,” or “terrorism.” On the contrary, they are part of a long history of imperial interference in Latin America and the Caribbean, the effects of which have systematically fallen on the oppressed peoples and classes of the region.

The story is well known: every time the United States has invoked these pretexts, the result has been social devastation, loss of sovereignty, and violence. Panama in 1989, Iraq in 2003, and multiple interventions in our region show that this is not about “defending democracy,” but rather about political, military, and economic control. In the case of Venezuela, these threats come on top of more than a decade of economic blockade that has hit the daily lives of the people hard, deepening shortages, precariousness, and the deterioration of material conditions of existence.

In this respect, it is essential to emphasize that imperialist aggression does not punish ruling elites, but instead falls directly on the popular sectors. Blockades, sanctions, military intimidation, and financial suffocation are not “surgical” tools: they are mechanisms of economic warfare that seek to break the resistance of an entire people, discipline them, and force them to accept a subordinating order.

A recent and striking example of this logic is the act of piracy and blatant theft of a Venezuelan oil tanker by armed US military personnel, which was detained and appropriated under the protection of unilateral sanctions. Beyond the legal technicalities with which Washington attempts to justify these actions, what is evident is an exercise in modern piracy: the use of military, judicial, and financial power to appropriate resources. This is not only an attack on the Venezuelan state, but also a direct aggression against the people, because every shipment seized, every asset retained, and every property confiscated deepens the living conditions imposed by the blockade.

What’s more, their disregard for the lives of the people is evident in the absolute ease with which they launched explosives at fishing boats off the Venezuelan coast, taking away not only those people’s livelihoods, but also their lives and their right to defend themselves against unproven accusations. The massacre was televised and celebrated by those at the top.

These types of actions clearly reveal what the “international order” defended by the United States means today: a system in which major powers arrogate to themselves the right to decide who can trade, who can produce, and who deserves to be punished. International law is selective, flexible for allies, and brutally rigid for those who do not submit. In this context, the seizure of ships, the freezing of assets, and economic sanctions function as weapons of war, even though they are presented as administrative measures.

The recent awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to María Corina Machado follows the same logic of cynicism and double standards. These types of awards do not express universal values, but rather geopolitical alignments. Far from representing a genuine defense of the rights of the Venezuelan people, this recognition operates as a political gesture by imperial powers toward a leader who has openly endorsed sanctions, economic blockades, and threats of intervention. The Venezuelan right wing, far from offering a way out for the working classes, thus presents itself as a necessary partner in a strategy that deepens social suffering and dependence.

The explicit reappearance of the Monroe Doctrine in recent US government documents and statements only confirms this course of action. The old slogan “America for Americans” — that is, for Washington’s interests — is once again being asserted without euphemisms, reinstating the idea of Latin America as a natural zone of domination. This threatens not only Venezuela, but all the peoples of the continent, by legitimizing interventions, economic pressure, coups d’état, and the forced alignment of governments that stray from imperial interests. A prime example of this has been the Trump administration’s unprecedented intervention in Argentina in recent months, specifically in domestic economic policy, the foreign exchange market, and even the electoral process, giving a sudden boost to Milei’s government.

In the current context, the United States is no longer an unchallenged power, but it remains a central player in a world order based on violence, plunder, and imposition. Its growing aggressiveness also reflects its own internal crises and its need to reaffirm its control over strategic territories rich in oil, minerals, water, and biodiversity. Latin America, once again, appears as the spoils and rear guard of an imperial project that remains deeply dangerous.

Defending people’s self-determination—dominated, exploited, and oppressed classes within so-called “national” contexts—does not imply idealizing governments or denying internal contradictions inherent in the Venezuelan process, of which we are critical, but rather rejecting foreign intervention outright and affirming the right of every dominated, exploited, and oppressed class to fight for the improvement of their destiny without threats, blockades, or occupations. In this sense, we affirm that organization in the face of this situation cannot come from above or be delegated to state structures, but can only be built from below, through popular organization and the direct participation of those who sustain daily life under conditions of siege.

The case of the looted ship, like the economic blockade as a whole, shows that imperialism does not seek to “correct” governments, but rather to subjugate entire peoples through hunger, isolation, and collective punishment.

In Venezuela, as in the rest of Latin America, even amid the difficulties caused by bureaucratization, limitations, and tensions with the state that tend to weaken grassroots organization; communes, territorial spaces, and forms of popular organization sustain daily material and social resistance in the face of the blockade, shortages, and imperialist aggression.

Our struggle goes beyond the borders imposed by states and unites us with all oppressed classes. The imperialist government of the North has taken a xenophobic, racist, and persecutory stance toward migrant communities within its territory. The attack on Venezuela is ideologically based on the racism that is inherent in the US state—as in other states—and that radiates internally and externally in favor of the dominant classes of that country.

In the face of this offensive, as anarchists we denounce the US government and maintain that the solution will not come from stronger states or disputes between powers, nor from the so-called international organizations created by and for states, but from the construction of a strong people, organized from below, with political independence and a real capacity to contest power.

The history of Latin America shows that every advance of imperialism has encountered resistance even in adverse conditions. This sustains dignity and the capacity for a collective response. It is the material basis of popular power from below.

In the face of imperialism neutrality is not possible. Either you are on the side of domination, plunder, and war, or you are on the side of the oppressed.

Our commitment is long-term but clear: to strengthen popular organization, deepen resistance, and build from below an emancipatory horizon for the oppressed classes of the world.

Imperialism will not pass!

Long live those who fight!

Coordinación Anarquista Latinoamerica (CALA)

  • Federación Anarquista Uruguaya (FAU) – Uruguay
  • Federación Anarquista Santiago (FAS) – Chile
  • Coordenação Anarquista Brasileira (CAB) – Brazil
  • Federación Anarquista Rosario (FAR) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Resistencia (OAR) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Tucumán (OAT) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Cordoba (OAC) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Santa Cruz (OASC) – Argentina
  • La Tordo Negro – Organización Anarquista Enterriana – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Impulso – Argentina

Sibling Organizations

  • Black Rose Anarchist Federation / Federación Anarquista Rosa Negra (BRRN) – USA

The post International Statement: We Denounce the Imperial Offensive on Venezuela appeared first on Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation.


From Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation via This RSS Feed.

0

International Statement: We Denounce the Imperial Offensive on Venezuela

Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation International Statement: We Denounce the Imperial Offensive on Venezuela www.blackrosefed.org
preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/16418

This statement was prepared and signed by member organizations of the Latin American Anarchist Coordination – Coordinación Anarquista LatinoAmerica (CALA). Black Rose/Rosa Negra (BRRN) was invited to sign the statement as a sibling organization.


The Latin American Anarchist Coordination and sibling organizations condemn the threats of direct intervention in Venezuela by the US government, driven by the Trump administration.

These attempts and threats of intervention are not isolated incidents, nor are they a temporary response to alleged problems of “security,” “drug trafficking,” or “terrorism.” On the contrary, they are part of a long history of imperial interference in Latin America and the Caribbean, the effects of which have systematically fallen on the oppressed peoples and classes of the region.

The story is well known: every time the United States has invoked these pretexts, the result has been social devastation, loss of sovereignty, and violence. Panama in 1989, Iraq in 2003, and multiple interventions in our region show that this is not about “defending democracy,” but rather about political, military, and economic control. In the case of Venezuela, these threats come on top of more than a decade of economic blockade that has hit the daily lives of the people hard, deepening shortages, precariousness, and the deterioration of material conditions of existence.

In this respect, it is essential to emphasize that imperialist aggression does not punish ruling elites, but instead falls directly on the popular sectors. Blockades, sanctions, military intimidation, and financial suffocation are not “surgical” tools: they are mechanisms of economic warfare that seek to break the resistance of an entire people, discipline them, and force them to accept a subordinating order.

A recent and striking example of this logic is the act of piracy and blatant theft of a Venezuelan oil tanker by armed US military personnel, which was detained and appropriated under the protection of unilateral sanctions. Beyond the legal technicalities with which Washington attempts to justify these actions, what is evident is an exercise in modern piracy: the use of military, judicial, and financial power to appropriate resources. This is not only an attack on the Venezuelan state, but also a direct aggression against the people, because every shipment seized, every asset retained, and every property confiscated deepens the living conditions imposed by the blockade.

What’s more, their disregard for the lives of the people is evident in the absolute ease with which they launched explosives at fishing boats off the Venezuelan coast, taking away not only those people’s livelihoods, but also their lives and their right to defend themselves against unproven accusations. The massacre was televised and celebrated by those at the top.

These types of actions clearly reveal what the “international order” defended by the United States means today: a system in which major powers arrogate to themselves the right to decide who can trade, who can produce, and who deserves to be punished. International law is selective, flexible for allies, and brutally rigid for those who do not submit. In this context, the seizure of ships, the freezing of assets, and economic sanctions function as weapons of war, even though they are presented as administrative measures.

The recent awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to María Corina Machado follows the same logic of cynicism and double standards. These types of awards do not express universal values, but rather geopolitical alignments. Far from representing a genuine defense of the rights of the Venezuelan people, this recognition operates as a political gesture by imperial powers toward a leader who has openly endorsed sanctions, economic blockades, and threats of intervention. The Venezuelan right wing, far from offering a way out for the working classes, thus presents itself as a necessary partner in a strategy that deepens social suffering and dependence.

The explicit reappearance of the Monroe Doctrine in recent US government documents and statements only confirms this course of action. The old slogan “America for Americans” — that is, for Washington’s interests — is once again being asserted without euphemisms, reinstating the idea of Latin America as a natural zone of domination. This threatens not only Venezuela, but all the peoples of the continent, by legitimizing interventions, economic pressure, coups d’état, and the forced alignment of governments that stray from imperial interests. A prime example of this has been the Trump administration’s unprecedented intervention in Argentina in recent months, specifically in domestic economic policy, the foreign exchange market, and even the electoral process, giving a sudden boost to Milei’s government.

In the current context, the United States is no longer an unchallenged power, but it remains a central player in a world order based on violence, plunder, and imposition. Its growing aggressiveness also reflects its own internal crises and its need to reaffirm its control over strategic territories rich in oil, minerals, water, and biodiversity. Latin America, once again, appears as the spoils and rear guard of an imperial project that remains deeply dangerous.

Defending people’s self-determination—dominated, exploited, and oppressed classes within so-called “national” contexts—does not imply idealizing governments or denying internal contradictions inherent in the Venezuelan process, of which we are critical, but rather rejecting foreign intervention outright and affirming the right of every dominated, exploited, and oppressed class to fight for the improvement of their destiny without threats, blockades, or occupations. In this sense, we affirm that organization in the face of this situation cannot come from above or be delegated to state structures, but can only be built from below, through popular organization and the direct participation of those who sustain daily life under conditions of siege.

The case of the looted ship, like the economic blockade as a whole, shows that imperialism does not seek to “correct” governments, but rather to subjugate entire peoples through hunger, isolation, and collective punishment.

In Venezuela, as in the rest of Latin America, even amid the difficulties caused by bureaucratization, limitations, and tensions with the state that tend to weaken grassroots organization; communes, territorial spaces, and forms of popular organization sustain daily material and social resistance in the face of the blockade, shortages, and imperialist aggression.

Our struggle goes beyond the borders imposed by states and unites us with all oppressed classes. The imperialist government of the North has taken a xenophobic, racist, and persecutory stance toward migrant communities within its territory. The attack on Venezuela is ideologically based on the racism that is inherent in the US state—as in other states—and that radiates internally and externally in favor of the dominant classes of that country.

In the face of this offensive, as anarchists we denounce the US government and maintain that the solution will not come from stronger states or disputes between powers, nor from the so-called international organizations created by and for states, but from the construction of a strong people, organized from below, with political independence and a real capacity to contest power.

The history of Latin America shows that every advance of imperialism has encountered resistance even in adverse conditions. This sustains dignity and the capacity for a collective response. It is the material basis of popular power from below.

In the face of imperialism neutrality is not possible. Either you are on the side of domination, plunder, and war, or you are on the side of the oppressed.

Our commitment is long-term but clear: to strengthen popular organization, deepen resistance, and build from below an emancipatory horizon for the oppressed classes of the world.

Imperialism will not pass!

Long live those who fight!

Coordinación Anarquista Latinoamerica (CALA)

  • Federación Anarquista Uruguaya (FAU) – Uruguay
  • Federación Anarquista Santiago (FAS) – Chile
  • Coordenação Anarquista Brasileira (CAB) – Brazil
  • Federación Anarquista Rosario (FAR) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Resistencia (OAR) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Tucumán (OAT) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Cordoba (OAC) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Santa Cruz (OASC) – Argentina
  • La Tordo Negro – Organización Anarquista Enterriana – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Impulso – Argentina

Sibling Organizations

  • Black Rose Anarchist Federation / Federación Anarquista Rosa Negra (BRRN) – USA

The post International Statement: We Denounce the Imperial Offensive on Venezuela appeared first on Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation.


From Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/16418

This statement was prepared and signed by member organizations of the Latin American Anarchist Coordination – Coordinación Anarquista LatinoAmerica (CALA). Black Rose/Rosa Negra (BRRN) was invited to sign the statement as a sibling organization.


The Latin American Anarchist Coordination and sibling organizations condemn the threats of direct intervention in Venezuela by the US government, driven by the Trump administration.

These attempts and threats of intervention are not isolated incidents, nor are they a temporary response to alleged problems of “security,” “drug trafficking,” or “terrorism.” On the contrary, they are part of a long history of imperial interference in Latin America and the Caribbean, the effects of which have systematically fallen on the oppressed peoples and classes of the region.

The story is well known: every time the United States has invoked these pretexts, the result has been social devastation, loss of sovereignty, and violence. Panama in 1989, Iraq in 2003, and multiple interventions in our region show that this is not about “defending democracy,” but rather about political, military, and economic control. In the case of Venezuela, these threats come on top of more than a decade of economic blockade that has hit the daily lives of the people hard, deepening shortages, precariousness, and the deterioration of material conditions of existence.

In this respect, it is essential to emphasize that imperialist aggression does not punish ruling elites, but instead falls directly on the popular sectors. Blockades, sanctions, military intimidation, and financial suffocation are not “surgical” tools: they are mechanisms of economic warfare that seek to break the resistance of an entire people, discipline them, and force them to accept a subordinating order.

A recent and striking example of this logic is the act of piracy and blatant theft of a Venezuelan oil tanker by armed US military personnel, which was detained and appropriated under the protection of unilateral sanctions. Beyond the legal technicalities with which Washington attempts to justify these actions, what is evident is an exercise in modern piracy: the use of military, judicial, and financial power to appropriate resources. This is not only an attack on the Venezuelan state, but also a direct aggression against the people, because every shipment seized, every asset retained, and every property confiscated deepens the living conditions imposed by the blockade.

What’s more, their disregard for the lives of the people is evident in the absolute ease with which they launched explosives at fishing boats off the Venezuelan coast, taking away not only those people’s livelihoods, but also their lives and their right to defend themselves against unproven accusations. The massacre was televised and celebrated by those at the top.

These types of actions clearly reveal what the “international order” defended by the United States means today: a system in which major powers arrogate to themselves the right to decide who can trade, who can produce, and who deserves to be punished. International law is selective, flexible for allies, and brutally rigid for those who do not submit. In this context, the seizure of ships, the freezing of assets, and economic sanctions function as weapons of war, even though they are presented as administrative measures.

The recent awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to María Corina Machado follows the same logic of cynicism and double standards. These types of awards do not express universal values, but rather geopolitical alignments. Far from representing a genuine defense of the rights of the Venezuelan people, this recognition operates as a political gesture by imperial powers toward a leader who has openly endorsed sanctions, economic blockades, and threats of intervention. The Venezuelan right wing, far from offering a way out for the working classes, thus presents itself as a necessary partner in a strategy that deepens social suffering and dependence.

The explicit reappearance of the Monroe Doctrine in recent US government documents and statements only confirms this course of action. The old slogan “America for Americans” — that is, for Washington’s interests — is once again being asserted without euphemisms, reinstating the idea of Latin America as a natural zone of domination. This threatens not only Venezuela, but all the peoples of the continent, by legitimizing interventions, economic pressure, coups d’état, and the forced alignment of governments that stray from imperial interests. A prime example of this has been the Trump administration’s unprecedented intervention in Argentina in recent months, specifically in domestic economic policy, the foreign exchange market, and even the electoral process, giving a sudden boost to Milei’s government.

In the current context, the United States is no longer an unchallenged power, but it remains a central player in a world order based on violence, plunder, and imposition. Its growing aggressiveness also reflects its own internal crises and its need to reaffirm its control over strategic territories rich in oil, minerals, water, and biodiversity. Latin America, once again, appears as the spoils and rear guard of an imperial project that remains deeply dangerous.

Defending people’s self-determination—dominated, exploited, and oppressed classes within so-called “national” contexts—does not imply idealizing governments or denying internal contradictions inherent in the Venezuelan process, of which we are critical, but rather rejecting foreign intervention outright and affirming the right of every dominated, exploited, and oppressed class to fight for the improvement of their destiny without threats, blockades, or occupations. In this sense, we affirm that organization in the face of this situation cannot come from above or be delegated to state structures, but can only be built from below, through popular organization and the direct participation of those who sustain daily life under conditions of siege.

The case of the looted ship, like the economic blockade as a whole, shows that imperialism does not seek to “correct” governments, but rather to subjugate entire peoples through hunger, isolation, and collective punishment.

In Venezuela, as in the rest of Latin America, even amid the difficulties caused by bureaucratization, limitations, and tensions with the state that tend to weaken grassroots organization; communes, territorial spaces, and forms of popular organization sustain daily material and social resistance in the face of the blockade, shortages, and imperialist aggression.

Our struggle goes beyond the borders imposed by states and unites us with all oppressed classes. The imperialist government of the North has taken a xenophobic, racist, and persecutory stance toward migrant communities within its territory. The attack on Venezuela is ideologically based on the racism that is inherent in the US state—as in other states—and that radiates internally and externally in favor of the dominant classes of that country.

In the face of this offensive, as anarchists we denounce the US government and maintain that the solution will not come from stronger states or disputes between powers, nor from the so-called international organizations created by and for states, but from the construction of a strong people, organized from below, with political independence and a real capacity to contest power.

The history of Latin America shows that every advance of imperialism has encountered resistance even in adverse conditions. This sustains dignity and the capacity for a collective response. It is the material basis of popular power from below.

In the face of imperialism neutrality is not possible. Either you are on the side of domination, plunder, and war, or you are on the side of the oppressed.

Our commitment is long-term but clear: to strengthen popular organization, deepen resistance, and build from below an emancipatory horizon for the oppressed classes of the world.

Imperialism will not pass!

Long live those who fight!

Coordinación Anarquista Latinoamerica (CALA)

  • Federación Anarquista Uruguaya (FAU) – Uruguay
  • Federación Anarquista Santiago (FAS) – Chile
  • Coordenação Anarquista Brasileira (CAB) – Brazil
  • Federación Anarquista Rosario (FAR) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Resistencia (OAR) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Tucumán (OAT) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Cordoba (OAC) – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Santa Cruz (OASC) – Argentina
  • La Tordo Negro – Organización Anarquista Enterriana – Argentina
  • Organización Anarquista Impulso – Argentina

Sibling Organizations

  • Black Rose Anarchist Federation / Federación Anarquista Rosa Negra (BRRN) – USA

The post International Statement: We Denounce the Imperial Offensive on Venezuela appeared first on Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation.


From Black Rose/Rosa Negra Anarchist Federation via This RSS Feed.

0

Response to the Pro-War Left's "Petition"

preview

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/16177

Response to the Pro-War Left’s “Petition” thecollective Mon, 12/29/2025 - 08:13

from Some anarchists from Central Europe, Eastern Europe, and the Balkans via email

A statement in support of Solidarity Collectives and ABC-Belarus has been published on the internet, signed by a number of groups and individuals. solidaritycollectives.org/…/on-silencing-voices-f…

We are publishing our response, which is not, however, a dialogue with these open and covert supporters of militarism. We simply want to share our analysis publicly and strengthen the connection between people with an anti-militarist and revolutionary defeatist perspective.

The statement to which we are responding was written by supporters of the war, who reproduce a binary narrative for this purpose: empathetic and supportive Eastern European anarchists versus arrogant and unsupportive anarchists from Western Europe. This narrative is false and manipulative. Those who share this narrative refuse to acknowledge that criticism of pro-war projects such as Solidarity Collectives and ABC (Belarus) also exists within the anarchist milieu in Eastern Europe. The signatories of the statement ignore this anti-militarist tendency in their narrative or lie when they claim that these are Putinists or pro-Russian propagandists. They repeatedly claim that the “Eastern European voice” is overlooked in Western Europe, while they themselves overlook anti-militarist and anti-war voices from Eastern European regions. It should be added that these overlooked voices also come from a relatively large number of people directly from the war zone. By this we mean not only anarchist collectives, but also other working-class people who refuse to support the war efforts of “their” and neighboring states. Let’s look at how many people have deserted from the Russian and Ukrainian armies and how many people in both countries are avoiding mobilization(1). Hundreds of thousands of people are ignored by this “radical left” that tells us it represents the voices of Eastern Europe and fights against the arrogance of the West. Their binary narrative is hypocritical. The contradiction is not between anarchists from the West and those from the East. There is only a contradiction between the revolutionary and counterrevolutionary tendencies, which exist in all regions.

We quote from their statement: “They are writing various kinds of “statements” condemning work in support of Ukrainian resistance to the Russian invasion.”

We respond: We do not condemn resistance to the Russian invasion. We are not even opposed to armed struggle, as long as it does not replicate militaristic logic and is directed against states and their armies. However, we reject the strategy of conventional warfare and militaristic forms of struggle. From an anarchist perspective, resistance to the aggressive policies of one state (e.g., Russia) should not be a practical service in the defense of another state (e.g., Ukraine). We support autonomous resistance against Putinism and Russian imperialism, but also against the Zelensky regime and EU/NATO imperialism. This is anarchist resistance against war. From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/16177

Response to the Pro-War Left’s “Petition” thecollective Mon, 12/29/2025 - 08:13

from Some anarchists from Central Europe, Eastern Europe, and the Balkans via email

A statement in support of Solidarity Collectives and ABC-Belarus has been published on the internet, signed by a number of groups and individuals. solidaritycollectives.org/…/on-silencing-voices-f…

We are publishing our response, which is not, however, a dialogue with these open and covert supporters of militarism. We simply want to share our analysis publicly and strengthen the connection between people with an anti-militarist and revolutionary defeatist perspective.

The statement to which we are responding was written by supporters of the war, who reproduce a binary narrative for this purpose: empathetic and supportive Eastern European anarchists versus arrogant and unsupportive anarchists from Western Europe. This narrative is false and manipulative. Those who share this narrative refuse to acknowledge that criticism of pro-war projects such as Solidarity Collectives and ABC (Belarus) also exists within the anarchist milieu in Eastern Europe. The signatories of the statement ignore this anti-militarist tendency in their narrative or lie when they claim that these are Putinists or pro-Russian propagandists. They repeatedly claim that the “Eastern European voice” is overlooked in Western Europe, while they themselves overlook anti-militarist and anti-war voices from Eastern European regions. It should be added that these overlooked voices also come from a relatively large number of people directly from the war zone. By this we mean not only anarchist collectives, but also other working-class people who refuse to support the war efforts of “their” and neighboring states. Let’s look at how many people have deserted from the Russian and Ukrainian armies and how many people in both countries are avoiding mobilization(1). Hundreds of thousands of people are ignored by this “radical left” that tells us it represents the voices of Eastern Europe and fights against the arrogance of the West. Their binary narrative is hypocritical. The contradiction is not between anarchists from the West and those from the East. There is only a contradiction between the revolutionary and counterrevolutionary tendencies, which exist in all regions.

We quote from their statement: “They are writing various kinds of “statements” condemning work in support of Ukrainian resistance to the Russian invasion.”

We respond: We do not condemn resistance to the Russian invasion. We are not even opposed to armed struggle, as long as it does not replicate militaristic logic and is directed against states and their armies. However, we reject the strategy of conventional warfare and militaristic forms of struggle. From an anarchist perspective, resistance to the aggressive policies of one state (e.g., Russia) should not be a practical service in the defense of another state (e.g., Ukraine). We support autonomous resistance against Putinism and Russian imperialism, but also against the Zelensky regime and EU/NATO imperialism. This is anarchist resistance against war. From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

0

URGENT APPEAL for #armstrong2

preview

🚨Support one half of the Armstrong 2 with their legal fees!🚨 Scan the QR code or go to bit.ly/tommie-armstrong2

Tommie is a mental health worker who allegedly took action against #RafaelAdvancedDefenceSystems in May this year with one other comrade, in an action referred to as the ‘#Armstrong2’. They don’t qualify for legal aid, so need your help with fundraising!

Tommie says “As someone working in healthcare, I want to express particular solidarity to #Palestinian healthcare workers (and international colleagues who have travelled to help)- saving lives in a care system intentionally targeted by the #Israeli military. The ongoing imprisonment and torture of many of them horrifies me.”

Support them by sharing this post and donating what you can to bit.ly/tommie-armstrong2

www.instagram.com/p/DSVWLyIiJDb

#FreePalestine 🇵🇸 #MutualAid #UKfascism

🚨Support one half of the Armstrong 2 with their legal fees!🚨 Scan the QR code or go to bit.ly/tommie-armstrong2

Tommie is a mental health worker who allegedly took action against #RafaelAdvancedDefenceSystems in May this year with one other comrade, in an action referred to as the ‘#Armstrong2’. They don’t qualify for legal aid, so need your help with fundraising!

Tommie says “As someone working in healthcare, I want to express particular solidarity to #Palestinian healthcare workers (and international colleagues who have travelled to help)- saving lives in a care system intentionally targeted by the #Israeli military. The ongoing imprisonment and torture of many of them horrifies me.”

Support them by sharing this post and donating what you can to bit.ly/tommie-armstrong2

www.instagram.com/p/DSVWLyIiJDb

#FreePalestine 🇵🇸 #MutualAid #UKfascism

0

The voice of an anarchist who fled Ukraine to escape mobilization and war

preview

cross-posted from: hexbear.net/post/6943504

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/11749

The voice of an anarchist who fled Ukraine to escape mobilization and war thecollective Thu, 12/04/2025 - 15:10

Mainstream media and even some “anarchist” or “radical left” media outlets bombard us with reports about soldiers on the front lines, but stubbornly refuse to listen to the voices of those who reject war and violent mobilization for war purposes. We take a different approach. We prefer to give space to the voices of those who fled the war rather than to hypocrites who describe the war as a liberation struggle.

Viatcheslav is an anarchist who fled mobilization. To quote him: “I refused to join the army and fled at the beginning of the war in 2022. It’s not that I particularly like Putin’s regime; I know very well that he is a dictator and that under his regime I would have no freedom and, as an anarchist, my life would even be in danger. But I have no desire to sacrifice my life so that the Ukrainian bourgeoisie can enjoy their privileges, so that the sons of oligarchs my age can continue to sunbathe on the beaches of Odessa while I tremble with fear in a trench, waiting to be bombed by a drone. War is also a class issue: if you are rich, it is very easy to obtain a medical certificate and be exempted from going to the front. That is not my case. It is not fair. That is why I decided to leave. Here in France, I was not welcomed with open arms.”

From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

cross-posted from: hexbear.net/post/6943504

cross-posted from: news.abolish.capital/post/11749

The voice of an anarchist who fled Ukraine to escape mobilization and war thecollective Thu, 12/04/2025 - 15:10

Mainstream media and even some “anarchist” or “radical left” media outlets bombard us with reports about soldiers on the front lines, but stubbornly refuse to listen to the voices of those who reject war and violent mobilization for war purposes. We take a different approach. We prefer to give space to the voices of those who fled the war rather than to hypocrites who describe the war as a liberation struggle.

Viatcheslav is an anarchist who fled mobilization. To quote him: “I refused to join the army and fled at the beginning of the war in 2022. It’s not that I particularly like Putin’s regime; I know very well that he is a dictator and that under his regime I would have no freedom and, as an anarchist, my life would even be in danger. But I have no desire to sacrifice my life so that the Ukrainian bourgeoisie can enjoy their privileges, so that the sons of oligarchs my age can continue to sunbathe on the beaches of Odessa while I tremble with fear in a trench, waiting to be bombed by a drone. War is also a class issue: if you are rich, it is very easy to obtain a medical certificate and be exempted from going to the front. That is not my case. It is not fair. That is why I decided to leave. Here in France, I was not welcomed with open arms.”

From anarchistnews.org - We create the anarchy we want in the world via This RSS Feed.

0

I've created a document with a collection of issues with capitalism

preview

cross-posted from: sh.itjust.works/post/50796592

I feel like it will always be a work in progress, but I thought it’s in a good enough state to share it.

If you have any recommendations for related books/articles/etc. that are worth checking out, and if you have anything to add/change/improve in the document, please let me know :)

cross-posted from: sh.itjust.works/post/50796592

I feel like it will always be a work in progress, but I thought it’s in a good enough state to share it.

If you have any recommendations for related books/articles/etc. that are worth checking out, and if you have anything to add/change/improve in the document, please let me know :)