0

Lagging Federation From Lemmygrad

preview

The latest posts on Lemmygrad have not federated to Hexbear (5450 behind currently). There was an outage there recently which probably contributes.

The latest posts on Lemmygrad have not federated to Hexbear (5450 behind currently). There was an outage there recently which probably contributes.

0

Weird Federation Quirk, Round: I Lost Track, but maybe 3 - lemmus.org has blocked us, but indirect content federates

preview

At some point, it appears lemmus.org has decided to block us, though they still appear on both our linked and allowed instance lists: lemmus.org/instances

Unsurprisingly:

  • there are some new posts in an active comm there: lemmus.org/c/shmups
  • I can see some old posts in it, with 1 local subscriber: hexbear.net/c/shmups@lemmus.org
  • Attempting to subscribe to that comm myself gets stuck in a “Subscribe Pending” state
  • A post made to an instance that does still federate with us has no comments from Hexbear users: lemmus.org/post/21636557

Surprisingly:

Anyways, I continue to not understand how federation actually works. I said something in the past about lopsided federation, but that was a case where federation in both directions was the expectation, and it’s clearly not the case this time - it seems like lopsided is perhaps exactly what we expect.

Since Hexbear’s side of things seem to be working as expected, and so does the lemmus side, I’m not going to follow up with any admin pings myself on this one, but figured I’d document it still in case someone else strongly feels like partially federating with an instance that won’t federate back should be changed.

At some point, it appears lemmus.org has decided to block us, though they still appear on both our linked and allowed instance lists: lemmus.org/instances

Unsurprisingly:

  • there are some new posts in an active comm there: lemmus.org/c/shmups
  • I can see some old posts in it, with 1 local subscriber: hexbear.net/c/shmups@lemmus.org
  • Attempting to subscribe to that comm myself gets stuck in a “Subscribe Pending” state
  • A post made to an instance that does still federate with us has no comments from Hexbear users: lemmus.org/post/21636557

Surprisingly:

Anyways, I continue to not understand how federation actually works. I said something in the past about lopsided federation, but that was a case where federation in both directions was the expectation, and it’s clearly not the case this time - it seems like lopsided is perhaps exactly what we expect.

Since Hexbear’s side of things seem to be working as expected, and so does the lemmus side, I’m not going to follow up with any admin pings myself on this one, but figured I’d document it still in case someone else strongly feels like partially federating with an instance that won’t federate back should be changed.

0

PSA: grad and hb having federation problems

preview

cross-posted from: lemmygrad.ml/post/10944631

as far as i can tell, hexbear users are seeing all content from grad including comments and posts but lemmygrad users arent seeing any content from hexbear, so if you make a post in a hb comm and arent getting replies this is why


Comment from @muad_dibber@lemmygrad.ml suggests it’s an issue on the Hexbear sending side @CARCOSA@hexbear.net

cross-posted from: lemmygrad.ml/post/10944631

as far as i can tell, hexbear users are seeing all content from grad including comments and posts but lemmygrad users arent seeing any content from hexbear, so if you make a post in a hb comm and arent getting replies this is why


Comment from @muad_dibber@lemmygrad.ml suggests it’s an issue on the Hexbear sending side @CARCOSA@hexbear.net

0

Socialism@lemmygrad.ml not federating new posts

socialism@lemmygrad.ml viewed from hexbear showing the most recent post is a year old
preview

There are newer posts: lemmygrad.ml/c/socialism

I haven’t checked other comms holistically, but spot checking GenZedong, the only missing post is due to a user being banned on hexbear.

There are newer posts: lemmygrad.ml/c/socialism

I haven’t checked other comms holistically, but spot checking GenZedong, the only missing post is due to a user being banned on hexbear.

0

Federation with discuss.tchncs.de - I think it’s intended? But it’s broken

preview

It looks like federation from Hexbear to discuss.tchncs.de works, but not the other way around. For example, on db0 we can see a user reply to a Hexbear comment, but it doesn’t show up when viewed from Hexbear. Maybe this is an intentional side effect of how (de?)federation works, but this post seems to suggest we intend to be federated, we appear in their linked instances, and not in their blocked instances, while our linked instances shows them, but allowed does not (it has discuss.techncs.de though, which appears to no longer exist?)

Anyways, it seems like the relationship shouldn’t be so one-sided. Either neither direction should work, or both should, but maybe there’s just something I don’t understand here.

E: also adding a screenshot of my comment to the post, because while I assume y’all can see it, I don’t really fully understand what happens with posts/comments in this comm:

It looks like federation from Hexbear to discuss.tchncs.de works, but not the other way around. For example, on db0 we can see a user reply to a Hexbear comment, but it doesn’t show up when viewed from Hexbear. Maybe this is an intentional side effect of how (de?)federation works, but this post seems to suggest we intend to be federated, we appear in their linked instances, and not in their blocked instances, while our linked instances shows them, but allowed does not (it has discuss.techncs.de though, which appears to no longer exist?)

Anyways, it seems like the relationship shouldn’t be so one-sided. Either neither direction should work, or both should, but maybe there’s just something I don’t understand here.

E: also adding a screenshot of my comment to the post, because while I assume y’all can see it, I don’t really fully understand what happens with posts/comments in this comm: