0

Hey, Mr. Spaceman: How the Right stole flying saucers and the Democrats lost the weirdos.

Los Angeles Review of Books Hey, Mr. Spaceman | Los Angeles Review of Books lareviewofbooks.org
preview

“The big tent Democratic Party of the 1970s contained everything from Southern white segregationists to the civil rights coalition, along with ethnic constituencies of the old urban political machines, union members, and the young graduates of the New Left. And back then, it still had room for the weirdos, even if the party never quite knew what to do with them. The New Democrats and the Democratic Leadership Council, who took the helm in the 1980s and ’90s and abandoned the ideals of the New Deal and Great Society for a market-friendly centrist program of deregulation and free trade, wanted to professionalize and clean up the image of the party. Wary of embarrassment, they sanded the weirdness off the brand, recasting the Dems as sober and competent—grown-ups who balanced the budget. The freaks weren’t expelled so much as gently disinvited, asked to hold their sage and saucer talk somewhere the big donors couldn’t see.

Faced with Donald Trump’s Republican presidency, the decades-old Democratic fetish for professionalization took on new urgency as it fused with a rhetoric of crisis. Seemingly overnight, what had been the party of suspicion in the post-Watergate era became the great bulwark of the establishment. The defense of institutions became a rallying cry for millions of liberals in the face of Trumpian anomie. People who had grown up certain the CIA wasn’t to be trusted were suddenly retweeting former intelligence officials and lighting candles for the FBI. Pandemic-era “Trust the Science” signs went up on countless blue-state lawns. Norms, standards, credentials, the adults in the room: the entire vocabulary of the Democratic Party reorganized itself around the protection of apparently fragile institutions. Perhaps it was an understandable response to the very real assault on things long taken for granted, but it was also, for anyone who’d ever stopped traffic on a freeway on-ramp, a strange thing to behold in a party that—however reluctantly and partially—was theirs.”

“A party committed to the sanctity of institutions cannot simultaneously house a faction convinced that the government is hiding alien spacecraft in the desert. You can track the eviction of the freaks and seekers in the arc of someone like Trump’s former director of national intelligence Tulsi Gabbard. She was a lifelong Democrat, raised in what has been called a “breakaway Hare Krishna group,” who served as a representative from Hawaii and vice chair of the Democratic National Committee; her blend of consciousness-and-karma rhetoric was a recognizable and quirky fixture of the progressive Left. Today, that exact esoteric cocktail has helped make her a luminary of the Republican Party, which she officially joined in 2024, after a couple years as an independent.

You can see the same horseshoe trajectory in the Make American Healthy Again (MAHA) movement. Ten years ago, the promotion of raw dairy and an aversion to food coloring were Northern California concerns. Now they’re cornerstones of the Trump administration’s health platform. The vanguard of UAP transparency in Congress consists of figures like representatives Eric Burlison and Anna Paulina Luna, as well as Burchett, right-wing elected officials who view the deep state not as a capitalist war machine but as a shadowy cabal keeping secrets from the American taxpayer.”

“The big tent Democratic Party of the 1970s contained everything from Southern white segregationists to the civil rights coalition, along with ethnic constituencies of the old urban political machines, union members, and the young graduates of the New Left. And back then, it still had room for the weirdos, even if the party never quite knew what to do with them. The New Democrats and the Democratic Leadership Council, who took the helm in the 1980s and ’90s and abandoned the ideals of the New Deal and Great Society for a market-friendly centrist program of deregulation and free trade, wanted to professionalize and clean up the image of the party. Wary of embarrassment, they sanded the weirdness off the brand, recasting the Dems as sober and competent—grown-ups who balanced the budget. The freaks weren’t expelled so much as gently disinvited, asked to hold their sage and saucer talk somewhere the big donors couldn’t see.

Faced with Donald Trump’s Republican presidency, the decades-old Democratic fetish for professionalization took on new urgency as it fused with a rhetoric of crisis. Seemingly overnight, what had been the party of suspicion in the post-Watergate era became the great bulwark of the establishment. The defense of institutions became a rallying cry for millions of liberals in the face of Trumpian anomie. People who had grown up certain the CIA wasn’t to be trusted were suddenly retweeting former intelligence officials and lighting candles for the FBI. Pandemic-era “Trust the Science” signs went up on countless blue-state lawns. Norms, standards, credentials, the adults in the room: the entire vocabulary of the Democratic Party reorganized itself around the protection of apparently fragile institutions. Perhaps it was an understandable response to the very real assault on things long taken for granted, but it was also, for anyone who’d ever stopped traffic on a freeway on-ramp, a strange thing to behold in a party that—however reluctantly and partially—was theirs.”

“A party committed to the sanctity of institutions cannot simultaneously house a faction convinced that the government is hiding alien spacecraft in the desert. You can track the eviction of the freaks and seekers in the arc of someone like Trump’s former director of national intelligence Tulsi Gabbard. She was a lifelong Democrat, raised in what has been called a “breakaway Hare Krishna group,” who served as a representative from Hawaii and vice chair of the Democratic National Committee; her blend of consciousness-and-karma rhetoric was a recognizable and quirky fixture of the progressive Left. Today, that exact esoteric cocktail has helped make her a luminary of the Republican Party, which she officially joined in 2024, after a couple years as an independent.

You can see the same horseshoe trajectory in the Make American Healthy Again (MAHA) movement. Ten years ago, the promotion of raw dairy and an aversion to food coloring were Northern California concerns. Now they’re cornerstones of the Trump administration’s health platform. The vanguard of UAP transparency in Congress consists of figures like representatives Eric Burlison and Anna Paulina Luna, as well as Burchett, right-wing elected officials who view the deep state not as a capitalist war machine but as a shadowy cabal keeping secrets from the American taxpayer.”