0

A democratic republic is the best possible political shell for capitalism

preview

In The State and Revolution, Lenin writes:

A democratic republic is the best possible political shell for capitalism

I do not understand how this could be better for the bourgeoisie than, for instance, a system where elections were restricted to millionaires, or where votes were weighted according to one’s wealth. What advantage does the bourgeoisie gain by exposing political power to the proletarian masses? I am aware that public opinion can be manipulated by bourgeois media, but why take that risk at all? It seems like a vulnerability to me.

This leads to another question:

Suppose a genuine Marxist party runs a successful election campaign, leveraging social media, for example, and wins. Once in power, assuming they don’t get corrupted or killed along the way, they begin to implement Marxist theory, not reformism, much like a Leninist vanguard party would: they expropriate the bourgeoisie, replace the existing state with the dictatorship of the proletariat, arm the workers, bring democracy into the workplace, and so on, essentially establishing socialism. In some countries, the executive branch can even bypass the parliament if it’s an obstacle. Naturally, they would face immense pressure from the bourgeoisie and likely from other countries, but wouldn’t a revolution encounter the exact same pressures? Furthermore, winning an election would likely carry greater perceived legitimacy, both among the domestic population and internationally, than a revolution would. Consequently, global public opinion might be more inclined to support the movement. So, why not favor this path over revolution?

In The State and Revolution, Lenin writes:

A democratic republic is the best possible political shell for capitalism

I do not understand how this could be better for the bourgeoisie than, for instance, a system where elections were restricted to millionaires, or where votes were weighted according to one’s wealth. What advantage does the bourgeoisie gain by exposing political power to the proletarian masses? I am aware that public opinion can be manipulated by bourgeois media, but why take that risk at all? It seems like a vulnerability to me.

This leads to another question:

Suppose a genuine Marxist party runs a successful election campaign, leveraging social media, for example, and wins. Once in power, assuming they don’t get corrupted or killed along the way, they begin to implement Marxist theory, not reformism, much like a Leninist vanguard party would: they expropriate the bourgeoisie, replace the existing state with the dictatorship of the proletariat, arm the workers, bring democracy into the workplace, and so on, essentially establishing socialism. In some countries, the executive branch can even bypass the parliament if it’s an obstacle. Naturally, they would face immense pressure from the bourgeoisie and likely from other countries, but wouldn’t a revolution encounter the exact same pressures? Furthermore, winning an election would likely carry greater perceived legitimacy, both among the domestic population and internationally, than a revolution would. Consequently, global public opinion might be more inclined to support the movement. So, why not favor this path over revolution?

0

Why aren't all proletarians communists?

preview

I really wonder why not all non-rich people are communists, as they would likely see their own condition improved in such a society. I suppose the possible reasons could be:

  1. They don’t understand how the current system exploit us
  2. They don’t know communism or misunderstand it
  3. They fear changing the current system for the “unknown”
  4. They think it can’t work
  5. They are not interested in politics at all
  6. They think that one day they will be rich too
  7. They are too busy being fascist
  8. Something else

I know it’s probably a mix of all of these, but in what proportions exactly? What are the most common reasons?

I really wonder why not all non-rich people are communists, as they would likely see their own condition improved in such a society. I suppose the possible reasons could be:

  1. They don’t understand how the current system exploit us
  2. They don’t know communism or misunderstand it
  3. They fear changing the current system for the “unknown”
  4. They think it can’t work
  5. They are not interested in politics at all
  6. They think that one day they will be rich too
  7. They are too busy being fascist
  8. Something else

I know it’s probably a mix of all of these, but in what proportions exactly? What are the most common reasons?

0

ELI5: Moneyless resource allocation

preview

Hello comrades,

I’m trying to understand how a moneyless economy would allocate resources optimally. Here is a silly example to illustrate the specific problem I don’t understand.

Let’s say that the only vacuum cleaners currently available are corded. A vacuum cleaner company democratically decides to design a cordless stick vacuum cleaner for greater comfort. Consumers are attracted and are starting to choose it over traditional corded vacuum cleaners (for free). Noticing the success of its product, the company produces more of it. Since cordless vacuum cleaners require a lithium battery, more lithium must be extracted from the earth. As we know, lithium is a finite and rare resource. This means a larger portion of the total lithium available is allocated to cordless vacuum cleaners.

The problem is that cordless vacuum cleaners are just a convenience option. People can still clean their homes with traditional battery-less corded vacuum cleaners. But some products strictly require a battery, like electric cars for example (I know hydrogen can be used too but that’s just for the sake of the example). To wisely choose the best lithium allocation, we should therefore consider not only the material needs of society (electric cars), but also the adjustable preferences of individuals (cordless vacuum cleaners). We can calculate the total amount of lithium in kilograms needed to produce the electric car batteries we need, but we can’t really compare it with the “desirability” of cordless vacuum cleaners. We could say: just reserve the lithium that’s strictly required, and use the surplus for convenience enhancements, but we can’t predict the total amount we will strictly need ahead of time.

Under capitalism, the rarefaction of lithium is supposed to increase the price of the final product. At some point, consumers will find cordless vacuum cleaners too expensive, stop buying them, and return to traditional corded vacuum cleaners. How would this work in communism without prices? What would stop consumers from grabbing cordless vacuum cleaners until the earth’s lithium runs out, when it could have been put to much better use in electric car batteries? And how do we decide when to stop lithium extraction altogether to stop destroying the environment?

I’m not saying that communism doesn’t work or capitalism is more efficient, I’m just trying to understand. Some argue that the internal planning systems used in today’s large companies could be reused, but I think they are optimized to maximize a single goal, profit, based on prices, so I don’t understand how it could work without them.

Of course my example is stupid. There are probably much better uses for lithium than electric cars and cordless vacuum cleaners, and we should probably use as little as possible of finite resources. Nonetheless, the problem already appears in a simplistic economic model with only 2 products. How would it be solved with longer and more complex supply chains, with multiple vacuum cleaner manufacturers, multiple lithium suppliers, where manufacturers would not know the proportion of lithium they consume and lithium extractors would not know the final allocation of lithium in consumer products?

How would it work in centralized vs decentralized economies?

Hello comrades,

I’m trying to understand how a moneyless economy would allocate resources optimally. Here is a silly example to illustrate the specific problem I don’t understand.

Let’s say that the only vacuum cleaners currently available are corded. A vacuum cleaner company democratically decides to design a cordless stick vacuum cleaner for greater comfort. Consumers are attracted and are starting to choose it over traditional corded vacuum cleaners (for free). Noticing the success of its product, the company produces more of it. Since cordless vacuum cleaners require a lithium battery, more lithium must be extracted from the earth. As we know, lithium is a finite and rare resource. This means a larger portion of the total lithium available is allocated to cordless vacuum cleaners.

The problem is that cordless vacuum cleaners are just a convenience option. People can still clean their homes with traditional battery-less corded vacuum cleaners. But some products strictly require a battery, like electric cars for example (I know hydrogen can be used too but that’s just for the sake of the example). To wisely choose the best lithium allocation, we should therefore consider not only the material needs of society (electric cars), but also the adjustable preferences of individuals (cordless vacuum cleaners). We can calculate the total amount of lithium in kilograms needed to produce the electric car batteries we need, but we can’t really compare it with the “desirability” of cordless vacuum cleaners. We could say: just reserve the lithium that’s strictly required, and use the surplus for convenience enhancements, but we can’t predict the total amount we will strictly need ahead of time.

Under capitalism, the rarefaction of lithium is supposed to increase the price of the final product. At some point, consumers will find cordless vacuum cleaners too expensive, stop buying them, and return to traditional corded vacuum cleaners. How would this work in communism without prices? What would stop consumers from grabbing cordless vacuum cleaners until the earth’s lithium runs out, when it could have been put to much better use in electric car batteries? And how do we decide when to stop lithium extraction altogether to stop destroying the environment?

I’m not saying that communism doesn’t work or capitalism is more efficient, I’m just trying to understand. Some argue that the internal planning systems used in today’s large companies could be reused, but I think they are optimized to maximize a single goal, profit, based on prices, so I don’t understand how it could work without them.

Of course my example is stupid. There are probably much better uses for lithium than electric cars and cordless vacuum cleaners, and we should probably use as little as possible of finite resources. Nonetheless, the problem already appears in a simplistic economic model with only 2 products. How would it be solved with longer and more complex supply chains, with multiple vacuum cleaner manufacturers, multiple lithium suppliers, where manufacturers would not know the proportion of lithium they consume and lithium extractors would not know the final allocation of lithium in consumer products?

How would it work in centralized vs decentralized economies?