@carin_heron@lemmy.blahaj.zone
@carin_heron@lemmy.blahaj.zone
-
on [CW: Transphobia] hot take: trans kids should have normal childhoods, actually in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 6d ago
What you’re describing is yet another form of violence that these sorts of practices inflict, which is the refusal of self-recognition to trans/gnc people. This is a very common thing, and understandably so, because being forced to be cis when you aren’t is incredibly traumatizing and harmful to one’s mental health. Every disorder I have, I exhibit symptoms as a woman, and always have, which meant that I wasn’t diagnosed with major learning disabilities at a young age because I didn’t show symptoms that matched my gender at birth. Cumulative negative health effects are a major problem for trans people who so often experience depression, anxiety, and PTSD alongside negative effects from not only being refused gender-affirming care, but also even the self-understanding to recognize who they are and what they need.
I’m so sorry you’re dealing with that, and it is important to remember that it is never too late. I also started when I was older, and I’m being serious, I felt happy for the first time in my life within two weeks of starting HRT. I didn’t even realize that I had been experiencing derealization for most of my life until I was on HRT long enough to actually feel connected to my body and the world around me. That isn’t the case with everyone – and please do not think it hasn’t worked for you if you start and don’t feel “fixed” after two weeks – but I point this out because I also spent a very long time knowing I was trans and thinking I didn’t need the HRT, or that I didn’t need to make a big deal out of it, but a few injections was all it took to start healing from decades of trauma. Hope you get whatever you need.
-
A lovely anecdote.
I honestly can’t stand any public washrooms, and it’s such a shame that there are very rarely urinals in women’s washrooms, and it’s normally a tossup if they’re even included in gender-neutral ones. So, I still use the men’s because a lot of the time, because I don’t want to touch my skin to a public toilet unless I absolutely have to. I really wish they’d include urinals in women’s washrooms, because they’re also typically more pleasant generally.
-
on [CW: Transphobia] hot take: trans kids should have normal childhoods, actually in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 6d ago
It is honestly such a great example of how disingenuous liberal support of trans people is when our “rights matter,” but that doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t suffer an intensely traumatic childhood for no other reason than the comfort of bigots. I can’t even begin to explain how much easier my life would have been, and so many of them do just think that’s a natural and inevitable thing that trans people have to experience and not like, an arbitrary and pointlessly cruel form of systemic violence.
-
on Full body autonomy! in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 9 Nov 2026
That’s where my mind went to as well, and I’m really not sure if that qualifies as an “addiction.” And again, I don’t think this is something medically substantiated.
-
on Full body autonomy! in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 8 Nov 2026
Now, this is something new to me. What exactly is “addiction to HRT?” And could you refer me to any studies that discuss it in detail?
-
on Full body autonomy! in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 7 Nov 2026
I’m glad somebody posted something this blunt so that we can cut through to the point.
No, it isn’t a libertarian argument, because this isn’t under the principle of access to realize individual freedoms, it is an argument that recognizes that any regulation for access of trans people to the care they deserve is indeed a vector for violence from a system that regularly targets them for genocide. To reduce this to an argument for open access to cigarettes or opiates because “the government can’t tell me what to do” ignores the reality that we are talking about a vulnerable group of people and their access to necessities.
Yes, it would be ridiculous to apply this logic to other medications or drugs, because it is exceptionally rare for that regulation to be directly linked to genocidal policy.
I’ve seen this point come up many times, and it is incredibly dangerous exactly because it makes intuitive sense to people who think morality is universal instead of relational, which most of us are socialized to believe.
-
on Full body autonomy! in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 7 Nov 2026
Oh yes, I didn’t think you were against DIY HRT generally based on your comment.
I do think systemic violence is very much on topic, especially following my comment. We have to be real, every trans issue is a topic related to a group of people who are regularly targetted for genocide. This is why I’m a bit confused about this final point again, about wider access being definitively less effective and more harmful than alternatives, since we don’t really have alternatives.
Every act of cooperation with a liberal-capitalist system is “kicking the can down the road,” since that system fundamentally desires the eradication of queerness. As far as violence goes, I’m not sure how you could argue that, again, an increased generalized risk to the benefit of trans people is in any way more risky than simply continuing the current path, which is civil recognition, when that literally resulted in the current moment of trans genocide and is concurrent with the consistently high rate of self-harm and suicide among trans people. As far as I see it here, your point is that a potential threat to the general population is more of a concern than the very real and immediate threat faced by trans people today.
As you’ve stated in other comments, there already is HRT misinformation, and the systemic oppression that we experience has necessitated community responses and education campaigns. So, I don’t really see how this would be a problem for trans people specifically, whom already have an information network via the preexistng ones within the trans community. I also don’t see how this would be any more or less difficult to implement in the current cultural moment within the US (and anglosphere) and/or EU contexts, since, again, we are already dealing with the negative consequences of cooperation in the first place. I’m not sure what strategic value there is in foregoing campaigns that can codify trans access to HRT without explicit trans rights in mind, and therefore protection against the repeal of policy on the basis of anti-transness alone.
So, could you please explain what alternatives you’re referring to?
-
on the rule is homophobic in c/onehundredninetysix@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 7 Nov 2026
Patriarchy in this specific context no, since we are still living in it and it is quite literally cancerous. As far as whether societies moved away from patriarchy generally once subscribing to it, that’s tougher to say. Certainly, there are many instances of patriarchal systems oriented around property (a defining feature of what we currently have) also experiencing massive challenges to that way of life before being reinforced by some external patriarchal power. There are also many instances where matrilineal property inheritance coincided with more equally shared power in how society is conducted, such as with the Haudenosaunee and Ansihinaabe in “North America.” The Mississippian civilization that built starkly hierarchal ways of life like what is seen in Cahokia also collapsed very much due to the inequities created by that hierarchy, and historians like Kathleen Duval have argued that the lesson of that collapse is reflected in more egalitarian oral histories and cultural practices in surviving nations.
It’s important to remember that, even though these are certainly not usual cricumstances, the exceptionalism of this particular form of patriarchy is truly limited to its context, not its durability. The fact that these systems can’t exist without challenge tells us that they really can’t survive no matter how much violence they inflict, even if simply because there is no world without women or queerness, or the consequences of refusing that reality.
-
on Full body autonomy! in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 7 Nov 2026
Ahh okay, bringing it up in this context made it appear as though the motivations of either people who subscribe to that misinformation, or the groups that propagate it would align in some way with a potential misinformation campaign that would effect trans peoples’ ability to access information. The systemic violence described below suffices, so I’d be surprised if there was such a campaign that actually worked on what is a substantially different target audience.
I’m privileged to have had that money and time, many trans people do not. It’s important to remember that many of us experience shelter- and other forms of material insecurity at disproportionate rates, and that is not disconnected from the overwhelmingly high suicide and self-harm rates for young trans people. Slow delivery of care with the caveat of privilege for access does literally constitute the systemic violence that perpetuates those rates.
I mentioned this in another comment on this thread, but I think it is a perfectly acceptable cost to introduce a potential generalized risk by expanding access and substantially mitigating the preexisting and specific forms of violence that trans people experience. I don’t see how it is reasonable to argue that a less immediate and threatening risk to a general population which regularly refuses us care is an unacceptable cost to address the needs of our own community. We already have information and support networks in place within our community for this very reason.
-
on Full body autonomy! in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 7 Nov 2026
I wasn’t aware that small children were able to purchase any medication.
-
on Full body autonomy! in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 7 Nov 2026
So, I understand the points you’re making about medication regulation. Certainly, ibuprofen carries enough risk with abuse for the ease of access to be questioned, for example, but I’m unsure of the claim here that there are other ways for open access to HRT.
It seems that the conclusion here is that liberal civil rights campaigns are more effective with less risk, but I’m unsure if that’s the point, since, y’know, that would require trans people to even further risk their safety by cooperating with institutions that are largely dedicated to the genocide of trans people. I’m sure that would carry a less general medical risk since, of course, it is not only trans people making use of these medications, but I don’t see how this could be argued as more dangerous for trans people specifically.
I think it’s also crucial to note here that even the non-violent actions that are necessary to fight for that protection carries the risk of incarceration, and therefore, significantly high chances of sexual violence given the disproportionate rate that trans people experience sexual violence in those cases. Even more, in the US, there are many cases where we’d be asking trans people to risk forceful “detransition” to participate in said campaign, as that is an accepted policy within the US carceral institution.
I do hope I’m misreading the last part of your comment for that reason, as I think that kind of point would ask us to ignore the trans people who died to secure what access we do have (very many of which suffered the consequences I listed above), as well as the reality that these institutions only conceded rights to that access as part of a longer campaign against transness, the consequences of which we are witnessing through the current wave of genocidal policies targetting trans people. With all that in mind, I find it difficult to weigh the valid concerns over medical safety against the specific needs for some of the most vulnerable people in our society. Surely, there is an acceptable risk I’m willing to generalize should that mean fewer trans youth die because they refuse to live without access to themselves.
-
on Full body autonomy! in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 7 Nov 2026
The connection between politicized medical disinformation surrounding COVID-19, and potential disinformation campaigns targetting trans people is interesting. Is there something in particular you’re referencing, or is this more speculation on a potential issue?
I know my biggest barrier to care was indeed medical clearance and medication/tools restriction. Even with socialized coverage, it was about a thousand dollars and five months of my time to get started; let alone the years I spent waiting to even start the process because I knew that would be the most expensive hurdle. Hardly had to go through the same process for ibuprofen, which also carries fairly severe side effects if abused.
-
on Fetish rule in c/onehundredninetysix@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 3 Nov 2026
Well, I’m sure that’s all they care about erasing – for safety, of course – and this won’t set a precedent of marginalizing “disgusting,” or “deviant” representations of sexuality that could pose a harm to others.
Remember, they think queerness is a kink, and refuse the difference between self-defense and harm.
-
on the rule is homophobic in c/onehundredninetysix@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 1 Nov 2026
This is very true, no amount of suffering is worth committing yourself to injustice, even if the suffering they experience could even be as bad as they seem to think it is. I think it is also important to specify that they enjoy the power patriarchy affords them while still understanding that they aren’t satisfied with this system. Many men resort to anti-feminist, conservative talking points merely out of recognition that their only vectors to a (potentially) more fulfilling way of life is to either implement substantial and fundamental changes to society, or capitalize on preexisting inequities and wrestle away what little is afforded to those beneath them in the hierarchy. They’re not lying when they say that this is miserable, trans women certainly know that the way we raise men is brutal and dehumanizing, even if they access privilege through the process.
The existence of transness also tells us that privilege is indeed not an insurmountable barrier to self-reflection and change, which means the men who choose to be disatisfied and take it out on those whom they know are more vulnerable really are just pieces of shit who could simply not do what they do. God knows they’d suffer less for defying patriarchy than trans women do, and even that is too much of a cost for many of them.
I don’t know if we need to reconstruct it from scratch, even if just because I don’t think we should have a cultural understanding of masculinity that doesn’t remember the harm that came from the social and material relations that the current hegemonic masculinity emerged from. Whatever comes next will always exist with a relationality to this patriarchal system which has caused monumental degrees of harm to human life, and all life on this planet. I also don’t know if I’d call this form of patriarchy a continuity from what preexisted capitalism and European settler-colonialism, since so much of hegemonic masculinity is defined by white supremacy, commodification of nature, property, and so on.
It really is a uniquely – pathologically – violent way of life. I think that is reflected in how obvious it is that men would rather have something different, and simply call misandry because they resent the fact that they don’t have the power to do that while still getting to be disgustingly fixated on dominating others.
-
on Not at all suspiciously specific in c/femcelmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 29 Oct 2026
I don’t even know what counts for that, does anyone have an example? I may lack self-awareness in a way that I could not have hoped to anticipate.
-
on the rule is homophobic in c/onehundredninetysix@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 29 Oct 2026
Yes, but I also think it’s important to specify that men will more often call misandry when women hold them individually accountable for their behaviour, rather than it normally being in response to women challenging the system.
Misandry is what they think it is when women tell them they’re not entitled to sex or to even express misogynistic, patriarchal values. I was called a misandrist once for saying I’m not comfortable with men because of trauma, and the overwhelming consistency in negative experiences with nearly every man I met until I was an adult (at which point I was more free to simply not interact with them).
-
on [Transfem meme] any other eepy princesses up in here? in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 28 Oct 2026
Damn, never heard the term “disaster lesbian” before, and now I feel like I’ve been read to filth.
-
on i don't believe in meme magic but just in case in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 25 Oct 2026
I guess that’s why I’m curious. Again, I’m not trying to shoot it down or be a buzzkill, but yeah most of the time I see people talk about these, it has to do with comfort and a shared symbolism. It honestly may just be that I’m too old to empathize with that, or just that I’ve never been all that comforted by plushes like these.
Edit: This isn’t to say that it is “immature” to be comforted by them, more that I just haven’t had that inclination in a rather long time, and likely have lost connection with it.
-
on i don't believe in meme magic but just in case in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 25 Oct 2026
I don’t want to be a buzzkill, this is seriously something I don’t understand, why do y’all want these? Is it just because of its symbolism of transness at this point?
-
on The Transfem Imperative in c/transmemes@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 17 Oct 2026
Yeah, it’s another injury forced on us. But, it also allows you to foster an optimism for the unbelievable in a way that most people are highly discouraged from ever hoping for. Some of you may meet this with humour, but try accepting the discomfort and learning how to live with it, use it, and get excited from it.

That’s very kind of you, I’m glad to hear that my comment was helpful. There’s a lot of other things to touch on here.
That’s a very good question regarding what I was actually attributing the violent acts to. So, when I say that these practices are violent, it is true that individuals are carrying out those practices and play a role in reproducing their use in our medical/educational/legal institutions, but it is important to remember that it the systemic nature of this violence that is so problematic. The very construction of gender within an imperialistic, capitalist system is oriented around property and the systems of power that controls the ownership of property, which means that the practice of refusing transness’ existence as anything other than – at best – a medical disorder has been in use for the past three centuries at least. This is because, in order to secure the generational ownership of property and concentrate the right of ownership into an arbitrary, privileged group, women’s bodies are objectified for their reproductive capacity, and ownership over that reproductive capacity was legally secured for white men. If those bodies are for anything other than reproducing this way of life through control over the children who inherit property and privilege, then they are a threat to the very foundation of this system.
Consequently, doctors come into their profession after a lifetime of socialization which primes them to devalue trans people through an understanding of gender as some natural, biological binary that is made synonymous with “sex.” So, they do not need to directly and overtly commit violence or malpractice against trans people to either be part of an institution that is fundamentally opposed to the existence of trans people, or to hold some internalized perceptions of trans people that could even subconsciously effect the care that their patients get. Even if they’re someone who is consciously empathetic toward trans people, whatever actions or beliefs that are afforded to them are inevitably mediated through a system that is fundamentally opposed to the existence of transness, and has only recently capitulated a degree of recognition after a sufficient amount of disruption.
When trans people are refused the language and understanding to interpret how this system injurs them and why, it disorients them not only in relation to themselves and their bodies, but the entire world around them as well. The doctors who did not accurately diagnose dysphoria because of their own lack of language and knowledge are by no means personally liable for the systemic violence they are a part of, but the fact remains that it is a form of violence which they participate in, willfully or otherwise. The system is the perpetrator of that violence, and individuals only have so much power afforded to them to comply with or challenge that system. I’ve had a similar experience where, if they simply did not understand gender and sex as synonymous, and attributed diagnostical values to symptoms along the line of sex, then I would have very well received treatment for ADHD and PTSD much earlier in my life.
As far as the physical changes of transition goes, those are all such valid concerns to have. I wasn’t quite as hairy as you were, but I was exceptional at performing masculinity as well. Big, strong, and I always better at like, styling masculinity in my outfits and appearance. I also happen to be more masc as a woman than a man, because men don’t actually own the elements of masculinity that I’ve always liked anyway. If you found that you enjoyed those elements of masculinity, you don’t have to let go of them until you want to, and you may very well find that you just outgrew them too. For years before I transitioned, I often worried whether it was just better to continue being a masculine man, or masc non-binary, or whatever, just because I’m more comfortable being better at masc performativity in many ways. And it’s true, a lot of femme performative maintenance is extra labour, and the bar for men’s style and appearance is so much lower.
On that note, I can honestly say that I never cared about my body until I started transitioning. I tried to many times, but I honestly could never look at it and feel like it was something I loved. Of course, I have injuries and health issues to manage as a consequence of not treating it well, and that I didn’t treat it well was a barrier to a more immediate feeling of euphoria once I started transitioning. The first time I saw myself in the mirror and liked what I saw, I realized why it wasn’t just a lack of will or ability to take care of it before. I seriously do not know whether my experience with derealization is relatable to most trans women, but I did not even realize I had it until well after I had started transitioning. It was like focusing my eyes for the first time. I think these are very reasonable and valid concerns to have, especially since you understand the gravity of taking on health complications as you age. My experience has taught me that I would have seriously had worse health outcomes if I simply spent all my effort on trying to resolve those health issues (including substance abuse).
I have to admit that I did not take on much of a health risk by starting HRT besides the standard increase in cardiovascular complications that simply comes with estrogen, but I could have easily taken on more with the relief that it has provided. Like, I enjoy working out now, and I can’t emphasize enough what a miracle that is.
I really don’t know what’s best for you, and please, do not feel as though your experiences have to be similar to mine to feel valid as a trans woman or whatever gender identity you arrive at that feels right for you. Every concern you’ve mentioned here is completely valid and relatable, so I do hope that this helps make the right choice for you much clearer.