0

Peeking through nature

The top of a power pole, tightly framed by trees
preview

Trying something a little different, I went for a walk with the kit lens, and consciously kept it toward the wide end.

R7, RF-S 18-150 f3.5-6.3, 44mm f11. Unedited except default corrections and resizing.

Trying something a little different, I went for a walk with the kit lens, and consciously kept it toward the wide end.

R7, RF-S 18-150 f3.5-6.3, 44mm f11. Unedited except default corrections and resizing.

0

Mobile phone camera vs "proper" camera, part 2 [Warning, long post, several pics]

preview

Per the title, this post is fairly long and contains a number of images.

Following on from my earlier thread, and prompted by a few of the comments, I did a comparison using the same camera body, but with the non-L kit glass. I’m not generally a fan of pixel-peeping as images should be taken as a whole, and I’m sure most either don’t care or will be saying “duh” to most of this, but again I found it interesting to quantify visually.

In my case the kit lens is the 18-150 f3.5-6.3 STM. Actually a good little lens, APS-C only though otherwise it’d be a good FF walk-about range. I got it plus the 50mm 1.8 as a kit, and I think the kit at the time was only a little more than the body alone (an extra 200 AUD if my memory serves?). That puts the combo within spitting distance of the same money as the phone, actually a fair bit below based on current flagship prices… don’t get me started haha.

I’m not going to rehash my earlier comments, except to repeat that the intention isn’t to rubbish one or the other, I’m just comparing the two with a couple of basic tests.


First up again, the S23 Ultra.

I don’t know how to force it to use one camera over the other, but I assume that using the 10x zoom for example will use that lens/sensor combo at its native res.

Here’s the reference shot - a 1:1 crop from the middle of the pic, 12MP at 1x zoom. EXIF says 6mm (apparently 24mm FF equiv), f/1.7, ISO 10. I’m assuming then this is the 200MP camera in pixel binning mode.

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 10x (27mm, f/4.9, ISO 50):

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 100x (27mm, f/4.9, ISO 50):

And the full-but-resized version of the 100x shot for reference:

A 1:1 crop of the 50MP 1x (6mm, f/1.7, ISO 10):

I did take a 200MP image as well but the bird took off before I hit the button, if someone is really keen I can post the 1:1 crop of that too but it’s just an empty power line :)


Right, now the R7 + kit lens.

1:1 crop at 18mm f/5.6 ISO 100:

And 1:1 crop at 150mm f/6.3 ISO 125:


To be fair, telephoto isn’t really playing to the phone’s design brief. It can do it, in the same way that I can play tennis.

To that end I did also take a bunch of pictures of a drain cover that was on the footpath just ahead of me, so probably 1.5-2m away from the sensor. And as expected the phone does far better.

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 1x:

At 12MP 10x, still pretty good:

And at 12MP 100x, unsurprisingly very crunchy:


For comparison, the R7 with kit lens. ISO crept up (4000-6400) as they were in the shade and I just left it at the 1/1000 I had been using earlier:

18mm f/11:

And 150mm f/11:


And just out of interest, the 70-200L at 200mm f/11:

And with the TC attached at 400mm f/11:


The phone holds up well at modest focal lengths, but as should be expected it struggles at longer lengths/bigger zooms.

The fact the phone can take calls, play games etc plus be light and fit into a pocket while also taking an objectively pretty decent photo in most sane scenarios is genuinely impressive.

But, luckily for most of us on here, a dedicated camera and ‘real’ glass is still 100% worthwhile.

Per the title, this post is fairly long and contains a number of images.

Following on from my earlier thread, and prompted by a few of the comments, I did a comparison using the same camera body, but with the non-L kit glass. I’m not generally a fan of pixel-peeping as images should be taken as a whole, and I’m sure most either don’t care or will be saying “duh” to most of this, but again I found it interesting to quantify visually.

In my case the kit lens is the 18-150 f3.5-6.3 STM. Actually a good little lens, APS-C only though otherwise it’d be a good FF walk-about range. I got it plus the 50mm 1.8 as a kit, and I think the kit at the time was only a little more than the body alone (an extra 200 AUD if my memory serves?). That puts the combo within spitting distance of the same money as the phone, actually a fair bit below based on current flagship prices… don’t get me started haha.

I’m not going to rehash my earlier comments, except to repeat that the intention isn’t to rubbish one or the other, I’m just comparing the two with a couple of basic tests.


First up again, the S23 Ultra.

I don’t know how to force it to use one camera over the other, but I assume that using the 10x zoom for example will use that lens/sensor combo at its native res.

Here’s the reference shot - a 1:1 crop from the middle of the pic, 12MP at 1x zoom. EXIF says 6mm (apparently 24mm FF equiv), f/1.7, ISO 10. I’m assuming then this is the 200MP camera in pixel binning mode.

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 10x (27mm, f/4.9, ISO 50):

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 100x (27mm, f/4.9, ISO 50):

And the full-but-resized version of the 100x shot for reference:

A 1:1 crop of the 50MP 1x (6mm, f/1.7, ISO 10):

I did take a 200MP image as well but the bird took off before I hit the button, if someone is really keen I can post the 1:1 crop of that too but it’s just an empty power line :)


Right, now the R7 + kit lens.

1:1 crop at 18mm f/5.6 ISO 100:

And 1:1 crop at 150mm f/6.3 ISO 125:


To be fair, telephoto isn’t really playing to the phone’s design brief. It can do it, in the same way that I can play tennis.

To that end I did also take a bunch of pictures of a drain cover that was on the footpath just ahead of me, so probably 1.5-2m away from the sensor. And as expected the phone does far better.

A 1:1 crop at 12MP 1x:

At 12MP 10x, still pretty good:

And at 12MP 100x, unsurprisingly very crunchy:


For comparison, the R7 with kit lens. ISO crept up (4000-6400) as they were in the shade and I just left it at the 1/1000 I had been using earlier:

18mm f/11:

And 150mm f/11:


And just out of interest, the 70-200L at 200mm f/11:

And with the TC attached at 400mm f/11:


The phone holds up well at modest focal lengths, but as should be expected it struggles at longer lengths/bigger zooms.

The fact the phone can take calls, play games etc plus be light and fit into a pocket while also taking an objectively pretty decent photo in most sane scenarios is genuinely impressive.

But, luckily for most of us on here, a dedicated camera and ‘real’ glass is still 100% worthwhile.

0

Mobile phone vs "proper" camera

preview

Long post warning.

This was going to be a reply to an earlier thread, however as the question comes up from time to time in photography discussions, I figured having direct comparisons would be of benefit to the community. That other thread was talking about telephoto (birds/wildlife) so that’s the example I’m using.

First off, I’m not comparing convenience, and I’m in no way rubbishing mobile phone cameras. They are ridiculously good, particularly given their on-paper specs, and in many situations they’re the better option if for no other reason than that you have it with you. With the many tricks they employ, from taking multiple shots and layering them for noise reduction, to simulated bokeh, auto-applied sky optimisations etc the point-and-shoot results are incredible. For a spur of the moment pic of friends, an interesting thing you see on the way home from work, making a note of something you’ve seen at the shops, taking a look at that thing behind the cupboard you can’t quite get your eyes at the right angle to see - they are unbeatable. A lot of people are just after pics to look back fondly on, which they might post up on social media where they’ll be heavily compressed and only seen on small screens by people who don’t know or care what SLR stands for. For those people, pics from a phone camera do the job just fine.

But for this post we’re talking about outright quality of the resulting image, and in that regard it’s important to acknowledge that phone cameras do have their limitations. Beefy processors and incredibly smart software can only do so much to get around the physics of short focal lengths and tiny sensors. There are reasons that National Geographic and ESPN aren’t saving themselves a fortune and just issuing their photographers with a phone.

I am not a professional, I won’t even claim to be particularly good, but I hope this is of some value to someone. And if not it was a good way to kill a bit of time on a rainy day.


So with all that out of the way - I was bored and thought I’d take a couple of example pictures. The weather was crap, and the pics are by no means showcasing anything special, but I’m hoping they’re enough to help visualise the difference between two devices that can do broadly the same job, but with wildly different compromises.

First up, pics from the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra. Not top of the pile I’m sure, but it’s what I have, and I’m comparing it against a body released a year earlier so I reckon it’s fair enough, particularly given the S23U was a flagship at the time and its camera was a marketing point. Aside from zoom and resolution I left the settings alone as that’s what the vast majority of users will do, and I dare say the defaults would give the best results anyway.

At 200MP. EXIF says it was at 6mm, ISO 10, f/1.7, 1/583s, though with the software trickery I’m not sure how comparable those figures are. Zoom isn’t available in this mode, this is a 1:1 crop:

At 50MP. EXIF suggests the same settings as above except 1/580s. As with 200MP there’s no zoom in this mode, another 1:1 crop:

And in its regular 12MP pixel binning mode, which does allow zooming, at 10x (its max optical zoom IIRC). These next few are full uncropped images, resized down for posting:

12MP at 30x, heavily software-assisted:

12MP at 100x, its max magnification:

For comparison, standing in the exact same spot, I took the pics below within a minute of the above. Canon R7, 70-200 f/2.8 IS USM Z + 2x TC. 400mm, 1/800, f/6.3, ISO 500. Near-zero processing effort has gone into this, just the auto-applied optical corrections and colour profile in DxO Photolab, then denoise and cropping/resizing for posting. It took longer to export and rename the files than to edit. And before it’s mentioned, yes I’m aware that apparently the TC does affect image quality, though in my experience it’s minimal, and there aren’t too many ways to get 400 5.6 without spending a fortune and/or losing versatility. That said if anyone wants to buy me a 400 f/2.8 I’d happily reshoot the photos!

Anyway, as shot, just resized for posting, showing the framing at 400mm (+ crop factor giving 640mm FF equiv):

Tighter framing (via cropping):

And a 1:1 crop of the main subject. It was windy af and the power line in front was moving quite a lot:

There you have it.

I’m sure someone can pick holes in my method but IMHO the difference is obvious. And if you read all the way down to the end, I hereby award you a virtual fist bump.

(Edit: text formatting)

Long post warning.

This was going to be a reply to an earlier thread, however as the question comes up from time to time in photography discussions, I figured having direct comparisons would be of benefit to the community. That other thread was talking about telephoto (birds/wildlife) so that’s the example I’m using.

First off, I’m not comparing convenience, and I’m in no way rubbishing mobile phone cameras. They are ridiculously good, particularly given their on-paper specs, and in many situations they’re the better option if for no other reason than that you have it with you. With the many tricks they employ, from taking multiple shots and layering them for noise reduction, to simulated bokeh, auto-applied sky optimisations etc the point-and-shoot results are incredible. For a spur of the moment pic of friends, an interesting thing you see on the way home from work, making a note of something you’ve seen at the shops, taking a look at that thing behind the cupboard you can’t quite get your eyes at the right angle to see - they are unbeatable. A lot of people are just after pics to look back fondly on, which they might post up on social media where they’ll be heavily compressed and only seen on small screens by people who don’t know or care what SLR stands for. For those people, pics from a phone camera do the job just fine.

But for this post we’re talking about outright quality of the resulting image, and in that regard it’s important to acknowledge that phone cameras do have their limitations. Beefy processors and incredibly smart software can only do so much to get around the physics of short focal lengths and tiny sensors. There are reasons that National Geographic and ESPN aren’t saving themselves a fortune and just issuing their photographers with a phone.

I am not a professional, I won’t even claim to be particularly good, but I hope this is of some value to someone. And if not it was a good way to kill a bit of time on a rainy day.


So with all that out of the way - I was bored and thought I’d take a couple of example pictures. The weather was crap, and the pics are by no means showcasing anything special, but I’m hoping they’re enough to help visualise the difference between two devices that can do broadly the same job, but with wildly different compromises.

First up, pics from the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra. Not top of the pile I’m sure, but it’s what I have, and I’m comparing it against a body released a year earlier so I reckon it’s fair enough, particularly given the S23U was a flagship at the time and its camera was a marketing point. Aside from zoom and resolution I left the settings alone as that’s what the vast majority of users will do, and I dare say the defaults would give the best results anyway.

At 200MP. EXIF says it was at 6mm, ISO 10, f/1.7, 1/583s, though with the software trickery I’m not sure how comparable those figures are. Zoom isn’t available in this mode, this is a 1:1 crop:

At 50MP. EXIF suggests the same settings as above except 1/580s. As with 200MP there’s no zoom in this mode, another 1:1 crop:

And in its regular 12MP pixel binning mode, which does allow zooming, at 10x (its max optical zoom IIRC). These next few are full uncropped images, resized down for posting:

12MP at 30x, heavily software-assisted:

12MP at 100x, its max magnification:

For comparison, standing in the exact same spot, I took the pics below within a minute of the above. Canon R7, 70-200 f/2.8 IS USM Z + 2x TC. 400mm, 1/800, f/6.3, ISO 500. Near-zero processing effort has gone into this, just the auto-applied optical corrections and colour profile in DxO Photolab, then denoise and cropping/resizing for posting. It took longer to export and rename the files than to edit. And before it’s mentioned, yes I’m aware that apparently the TC does affect image quality, though in my experience it’s minimal, and there aren’t too many ways to get 400 5.6 without spending a fortune and/or losing versatility. That said if anyone wants to buy me a 400 f/2.8 I’d happily reshoot the photos!

Anyway, as shot, just resized for posting, showing the framing at 400mm (+ crop factor giving 640mm FF equiv):

Tighter framing (via cropping):

And a 1:1 crop of the main subject. It was windy af and the power line in front was moving quite a lot:

There you have it.

I’m sure someone can pick holes in my method but IMHO the difference is obvious. And if you read all the way down to the end, I hereby award you a virtual fist bump.

(Edit: text formatting)