342 comments

log in to comment.

  • @ComradeMiao@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026 · edited

    By vegan food production you must mean processed fake meat? Not all vegans eat a horrible diet.

    If you mean vegan food production as in normal non-meat foods such as vegetables than that’s a while opinion. Unless you are Jain or just want to die, we got to eat something.

    Most food production in general kills a lot more than I would like especially vegetable and fruit production. Not much to do on the regard though.

    • @trashcroissant@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 4 Nov 2026

      Yes I did mean veg and fruit, but I mean that obviously we need to eat but we need to do it in a sustainable and fair way.

      Currently a lot of the produce in Canada & the US is grown by migrant labour where people are treated horribly. In Mexico, many of the agricultural production sites are owned by cartels. Quinoa used to be a primary food source for quechuan (peruvian indigenous) people but when it grew in popularity in the west, it became too expensive for those who depended on it. There are many more examples.

      What there is to do about it is to demand better agricultural practices and support fair-trade, co-ops, and sustainable food vendors. In the same way we should be / are demanding cruelty-free and sustainable animal products.

    • @TWeaK@lemmy.today · 4 Nov 2026

      Unless you are Jain or just want to die, we got to eat something.

      That’s the thing though, why should plants be more eligible for eating than animals? Both are living. Animals are closer to us, so we can understand them better, but that doesn’t mean we aren’t being just as harmful to plants.

      I don’t think there’s anything inherently wrong with eating another animal for sustenance. Just the same as there isn’t anything wrong with eating a plant for sustenance. What matters is what we do before we eat them.

      • @ComradeMiao@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026

        Plants cannot think or feel as animals can. Arguing a tomato has the emotions and thought of a dog or pig is just silly.

        Killing a pig versus a tomato is not the same thing dawg

        • @commie@lemmy.dbzer0.com low rep · 5 Nov 2026

          Plants cannot think or feel

          this can’t be proven

        • @TWeaK@lemmy.today · 4 Nov 2026

          as animals can.

          As we can. We understand how animals think, because evolutionarily they’re closer to us. We don’t really understand how plants “think” or “feel”, we just decide that because they don’t have what we have that makes it okay.

          • @ComradeMiao@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026

            Just making up whatever you want aren’t you?

            “I’m not a plant therefore idk what their nonthinking minds are thinking”

            Who is we in your statement? Pretty sure modern botany understands how plants work and interact.

            • @TWeaK@lemmy.today · 4 Nov 2026

              That understanding has its limits. We’re just cracking on the ways plants (and fungi) may communicate with one another via external chemical signalling. There are things beyond our current understanding, and how a plant “feels” is completely alien to us. Hell, the function of how people “feel” is still not fully understood.

              My point is that it’s ultimately arbitrary. We feel pain, and we can imagine animals feeling pain in a similar way, because their neurological systems are similar. We assume plants don’t feel pain - and we can confidently say they don’t feel pain the same way we do, but we can’t say they don’t feel pain at all in a way we don’t yet understand.

              Either way though, both plants and animals are living beings, and you are denying them the same opportunity to life by eating them.

      • @Lileath@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 4 Nov 2026

        Are you stupid? Genuine question, because animals need to eat as well for you to pay someone to murder them. Even going from the assumption that plants suffer too, a plant based diet still causes much fewer plants to die compared to feeding the plants inefficiently to animals to then eat the animals.

        • @TWeaK@lemmy.today · 4 Nov 2026

          Are you stupid? Genuine question

          Liar. You’re just being a dick here. No bother though.

          Like I said before, what matters is what we do before we eat them. Industrial farming practices are where I see the real problems at - and the key thing is that this is an issue for both meant and plant farming.

          Plant based diets can definitely be more efficient, although palm oil is also vegan (and palm oil farming is currently the cause of a massive amount of habitat loss), so just because you have a plant based diet doesn’t mean it’s perfect. But what I’m saying here is that eating plants is not inherently more righteous than eating animals. In practice, it almost certainly is (mainly because of farming practices), but not inherently.

        • @commie@lemmy.dbzer0.com low rep · 5 Nov 2026 · edited

          eating meat today doesn’t cause it to have been fed in the past. events in the future cannot cause events in the past. eating meat doesn’t cause past suffering.

          are you stupid

          • @ElcaineVolta@kbin.melroy.org · 5 Nov 2026

            you, uh, doing okay champ?

          • @Lileath@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 5 Nov 2026

            Award for not even tangentially hitting the point I made goes to you my dear zoophile <3

            • @commie@lemmy.dbzer0.com low rep · 5 Nov 2026

              calling me a zoophile is baseless.

              • @Lileath@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 6 Nov 2026

                What do you call someone who abuses animals for their own pleasure? Is paying someone else to do the abuse for you so much better?

            • @commie@lemmy.dbzer0.com low rep · 5 Nov 2026

              I addressed the assertion that eating meat causes suffering. that’s simply untrue.

              • @Lileath@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 6 Nov 2026

                So you have no problems with slave labour because the suffering already happened when you buy its products? What about a video of a rape? The rape already happened so it won’t cause further suffering getting off to it.

                How hard is it to understand that these animals get tortured and murdered for your consumption and you don’t just happen to come upon a corpse accidentally. Your consumption drives the production.