Which is kind of wild, because I don’t know if a steak has ever looked better on film than the cut shown in this scene. I understand that sentiment may not hold true for folks on vegetarian or vegan diets based on ethical grounds, but that may as well be the Platonic ideal of “fancy steak”.
There was a brand called Meati that made steaks out of mycelium that were so goddamn good. Closest to the real thing I’ve had so far. Unfortunately some shady financial shenanigans cost them their production plant. There’s a new owner trying to get them up and running again though so fingers crossed there.
Every time I visited the twin cities I’d stop by their shop and stock up on a bunch of stuff. Their vegan BBQ ribs and vegan chorizo were so good. I heard that their store burned down a few years ago, but I didn’t realize they kept their online shop open!
Yea, it’s funny because when I heard about them, I heard they made a cookbook after closing down. Like Miyoko’s new books. That it was just a local shop.
I only found the site from looking for the cookbook and found out they are still running and ship now.
He’s vegetarian not vegan. It’s incredibly hard to be a vegan in korea, but it’s very easy to be a vegetarian. The vast majority of halmeoni cooking your food over there basically equivocate vegetarianism and vegan to be the same thing. A lot of traditional foods have hidden animal products in it like shrimp paste for seasoning.
I once tried talking to my like 85 year old Korean granny about it and she strongly explained to me that things like krill were more like plants than animals, which in some ways is kinda true.
Again, it’s kinda weird. I would say it’s fairly easy to be vegetarian since there’s a cultural understanding of vegetarians due to the cultural/religious practices of Buddhist monks.
For one, they typically have more bland foods, and typically live in the mountainous regions where there’s less access to sea food. And again, what a lot of east Asian people consider meat varies from the western nomenclature.
Where instead of basing the ethical delineation on a scientific taxonomy, it’s based more on whether something possesses a soul/conscious. If we examine the issue through that lens it can make sense that an invertebrate like a krill or even coral are closer to plants than mammals.
Restrictive Asian diets don’t sort neatly into western buckets.
By your definition, most practicing ‘vegetarian’ Buddhists are omnivores because of oyster sauce, yet they eat far less animal products than the average western vegetarian due to the low prevalence of dairy products.
Jains, for example, can drink milk and eat butter and ghee, but cannot eat root vegetables, fungi, and fermented foods, while the opposite is true for veganism.
So what do you call people who are vegetarian except for 1% of their diet? I would find it disengenuous to equate that to a regular omnivore diet.
To be used in omega 3 supplements and fish farming. At the same time one can cut both by using omega 3 DHA & EPA supplements based on algae. Doing it for 7 years now. Also the less krill, the less whales and the less whales, the less flourishing ocean eco systems, because of the whale poop loop and whale falls.
I eat smart things only to get smarter. You are what you eat after all. Octoponi, Chimpansessies, Peeps, Dolphones, etc. Ant too since I want hive mind. My brain grows.
I think this is a very arbitrary line to draw, and I honestly don’t think it’s backed up by science. Octopuses may outperform pigs and cows at some tasks, but how do you measure their overall intelligence in a way that’s comparable?
Non-vegans should support vegans, even if they continue to eat meat, because vegans drive better treatment of animals and also drive more attractive non-animal food options.
However, a person must have a brain and also not have meat eating tied to their masculinity.
What really drives me mad is that there’s a dead simple solution - lab-grown meat - that can obviously be the best of both worlds with a bit more development (and in fact is being commercialized already), but is being lobbied against by the meat industry precisely because it’ll be cheaper and better. And nobody seems to be talking about it.
Everyone I know actually unironically feels this way lol and always comes to me for advice on going more vegan. Vegan hatred is a strong flea dip for me though, basically any% criticism of vegans ensures I will likely never speak to you again.
Is it awful of me to have stopped eating meat from animals I think are beautiful and sweet, like cows and pigs, but still eat meat from some animals I think are ugly and mean, like chickens and sheeps?
As a non-vegan, that seems to be morally neutral to me (you’re still eating meat), barring differences in treatment and ecological impact of specific animals (I think cows are particularly bad in terms of environmental impact?)
It’s not, because criticising “vegans” is done to avoid discussing veganism, which is objectively better than meat eating. This does not include people who say, argue whether starving people should eat meat to survive, which is not a criticism of vegans. I’m open to discussing any real life actual moral paradigms with reasonable people.
Basically you’re assuming it’s not purely coincidence. Plenty of my friends eat meat lol. They’re just rational and not the type of person who thinks I deserve to be cross examined for the actions of all people who are also vegan. People who act like I should like, idk, answer for PETA? My life has objectively improved by letting those bridges burn naturally. It’s done wonders for my mental health.
If I go out into the woods and kill a person to eat, it is better than if I enslave a family, force them to breed, and then eat them one by one in perpetuity.
Similarly, hunting is better than factory farming, but that doesn’t mean it’s a good thing to do, outside of some niche conservation projects.
Just eat less meat. You don’t have to go 0-100. Skip the patty, skip the filet. Double up on proteins. Dairy shouldn’t be an end goal but substitute the actual meat for dairy for at least some reduction. Pick the food that is vegan instead of the one using meat stock, etc. Little things here and there. Default to meatless, eat the damn meat if you absolutely have to. Increase this change over time, and make sure to add a vegan B12 supplement. 80% is better than 100%. 60% is better than 80% when you get there. Maybe someday you hit 0%. Achieve perfect through gradual change, don’t shun good if you can’t be perfect.
This is the best advice you can give someone imo. Im like 75% vegan, still have eggs and bacon on the weekends, some chicken with dinner, some other stuff here and there. But mostly its beans/tofu and rice with veggies.
Some people think they have to give up everything all at once right now and of course that seems overwhelming… because it is.
Perfectionism is often used as a shield to prevent change or to avoid challenging yourself or your own rigid thinking. When you see someone saying it’s all or nothing they’re actively sabotaging themselves, often that’s exactly what they want to be doing, plausible deniability
honestly, giving everything up at once was pretty easy? soymilk took a few weeks to get used to, but outside that adjustment i just added more beans to stuff. Worth at least trying before compromising on slaughter.
For you it was easy, which doesn’t have any bearing whatsoever on how easy it will be for any other person. What’s worth trying is anything which reduces the amount of suffering in the world, which is not ‘compromise’, it’s a positive step. One burger a year is an improvement and even if that’s all you can manage it’s better than nothing.
and for all the other people who will find it easy, it’s important to still have a message dissenting the idea that it’s always difficult. I’m saying that going all out and finding if you even need to compromise is better than assuming from the start that a compromise is your only viable option.
One change I made early on was to look for ways to shorten the distance from my food, become familiar with how it gets to my plate and just keep higher standards overall for things like meat.
The experience of buying meat in particular can be heavily abstracted and sanitized. Every big chain supermarket has an area with rows and rows of perfectly packaged cuts. There is not very much information at all about most of it.
Pick up a Styrofoam tray of boneless skinless chicken breasts from the one or two giant conglomerates. Each package is wrapped in plastic. They all have very consistent appearance, evenly colored and equally plump. They are completely odorless. It is chicken but it’s very very far away from being a chicken. It’s been through a lot of hands and miles. You’ve already hit a wall, though, because you’re not getting much more information about that meat besides maybe some marketing terms and a picture of a taco or some shit like that. You’re being sold the idea of it. All of the horrible stuff is obscured. Even the neutral stuff like what it ate, if it was ever sick or given any medications. All that stuff gets pushed into the memory hole and is supposed to never reach the consumer. If you become too curious, and start digging into it on your own, you naturally end up consuming less. They know this.
Contrast that with what’s produced more locally. Try to figure out who in your area is producing with the goal of building up an actual local foodway sustainably. How close can you get to identifiable people actually producing your food? Can you access a co-op, farmers market, CSA?
Folks who do things like regenerative farming and try to build up their soil tend to be very passionate and like to share about it. Visit a nearby farm or ranch. Many have small retail operations. They may deal in larger quantities than you’re used to. Find out the process. If an animal is involved, how is it cared for and what does it do all day? Is the animal improving its surroundings or degrading them? Are you willing to meet your food face to face?
IMO if you’re going to continue eating meat, you owe it to your food to unpack this stuff, examine how it makes you feel to literally “know how the sausage is made”, form deeper connections with your food and community, and find opportunities to make positive changes to your buying habits.
ETA:
not everyone will be able to stomach peeking behind the curtain. But that’s actually good. It means you’re a compassionate human being, and that feeling can be harnessed and channeled into better personal choices.
I’m just tired of seeing all meat-eating equated, too. The Styrofoam chicken is in a completely different category from a fresh whole chicken acquired locally from, say, a nearby farm that prioritizes regenerative practices.
Compare the true costs and impacts of each. You might forget they’re the same species. It turns out that, if you simply let a chicken just… do its chicken things and provide it with what it already knows it needs to satisfy its drives, its natural behaviors and outputs can be directed to benefit the rest of the system. It’s not easy. This is a complex system, and there’s a lot to learn. But if you can get it right, the chicken is healthy and satisfied, it improves other parts of the system during its life, has at least net-zero if not positive net impact environmentally, and you still get to sell it at the end if that’s what you want your operation to be.
The best arguments for not eating meat disagree specifically with what happens at the end of, e.g., a meat chicken’s life. I know not to argue against that. It’s a principled moral stance.
There will probably always be people who want to eat meat. It is very deeply ingrained human impulse. I think it desperately needs to be scaled way way back. The big players in the conventional national industry need to be seized and taken apart, yesterday. Everything good and useful there needs to be pried out of their hands, brought local, and distributed among the people.
If the tables were turned, and local, sustainable models were the norm, we’d eat way less of it, feel way better, and have the community profit instead of extracted from. “Big chicken” would not exist like it does now. We’d be having completely different conversations.
While I agree with the sentiment, I still struggle a bit with this rhetoric. When it comes to misogyny or rasicsm you wouldn’t tell someone to just try and do less of it. The meat & dairy industry is still a whole lot of abuse and exploitation, and I think everyone is probably on board with having nothing to do with it. The friction is just too high I guess.
Actually yes you would.
For the average person in the privileged position, “trying to do less racism” or “trying to be less misogynistic” is the crux of actioning allyship, especially when people are imprinted and socialized from a young age to be/act racist and misogynistic without knowing or understanding it.
Kids can’t necessarily control that, but trying to undo it by being less racist and less misogynistic day by day is the necessary work of anti-racism and feminism.
It also ignores that even allies almost always still hold some misoginy or racism, simply due to upbringing. True allies have to admit that we’re not done progressing.
Not only allies. There is a lot of internalization of misogyny, racism, homophobia, transphobia, etc. if you are a member of one of the affected groups but were raised in such environment.
I agree, but I think framing the goal is important.
I think the better way to go about it is to commit fully from the start. Maybe there’s some hiccups, and then you can reset and try again. I guess it’s very personal however. Some people might benefit from another mindset. Anything that gets people away from abuse, I’m all for.
The friction is precisely why I recommend start small. Better someone eat less meat and stick with it long term, than a full meat diet long term because they went completely meatless at once for a week or two and couldn’t handle it
When it comes to misogyny or rasicsm you wouldn’t tell someone to just try and do less of it.
Idk, these are very different things. If I think about how much I hate (some group) then I may be a racist based on that alone. If I don’t consume animal products but I fantasize about eating a cheeseburger I would still be a vegan.
Nobody is going to literally say “just do less racism” but in practice we often only deal with small parts of someone’s racism.
That’s the thing. If we could use less meat, use less cars, use less fossil fuels, we would all be happier. But me choosing to do these things sounds to people as just bending over for somebody else to use what I don’t use. I just want a happier lifestyle? I’m not doing it for politics or self sacrifice, I’m just taking a step backwarda and realizing that mcdonalds sucks, car commuting sucks.
But I will use the car when I need to go to the countryside and there is no BETTER alternative!
Its not even close to the same. Meat is still food, and it is still nourishment to eat. There is nothing nourishing about bigotry. Its still correct to be vegan. But let’s be grounded in our discourse.
Obligatory mention that you don’t need to cut out meat from your life entirely to have a significant impact on your carbon footprint and your health. Going mostly vegetarian is also an option and its basically been the default of humanity since the agricultural revolution.
“But it’s awkward in social settings”, “What if I’m going out to eat”, “What if it’s the only option”, “What if I am trying but don’t realize something has an animal product”
Idk dude then eat meat in those settings I guess. 95% of your food is consumed outside of those settings so just be 95% vegan or vegetarian.
This. The stuff I cook at home is 100% vegetarian, which is most of my meals.
I simply stopped buying meat when I’m grocery shopping.
When I visit people I eat whatever they have, if they have good vegetarian options i prefer that though.
When I’m going out to eat I do the same.
If you’re not in the mood to have a discussion about it during lunch with your coworkers or whoever just tell them that you do eat meat but chose that one vegetarian option because it looked tasty or whatever.
Since people in my social surrounding think mostly the same I’m about 99% vegetarian.
Obligatory mention that the “carbon footprint” is a tool of the billionair class to put all the blame that belongs to them on us, the consumer without any real power in the markets.
So the best way to cut down on carbon footprint is to be politically engaged. Without systemic change your personal sacrafice will not really do anything.
I’m in this picture and feel pretty neutral about that.
One time I had a hardcore combo meth-heroin addict who was vegan who candidly told me something to the effect of ‘idgaf what I put in my body I just have a moral problem with the livestock industry’ and I was like ‘you know what, based.’ The core issue of that conversation was that dietary sent a roll with dinner and they were like ‘naaah I can tell by the texture they used cows butter’ and like many things in the hospital they’re probably right and also at least they recognized I had no way of fixing it.
No its not fine to oppress others even if you know you are wrong to. You sound like a founding father who writes that slavery is wrong but brutally exploits slaves anyway.
Yup. The leftism leaves so many leftists’ bodies the moment animal liberation comes up. If you recognize the problem, don’t be complacent on the solution.
Unlike so many other rights struggles, basic veganism doesn’t require action, but rather the cessation of harmful actions. In that regard, it’s easier than taking action against other forms of exploitation: simply stop consuming animal products. Plant-based alternatives are readily available (I went vegan in a food desert) and are better for you than eating some poor animal’s flesh.
The biggest hurdle, is the meat-eating culture, and how it is the dominant one in many places, right now. People need certain mental strenght to go againt the culture around them, especially when they have been raised up with it, and not all have that. If all people around you are vegans, and it is considered the norm, a lot of people would become vegan too, just to fit in. As long as meat-eating is seen as normal and people are raised to believe it is normal, many people will continue, even if they agree vegans are right.
Certainly I would have a hard time being vegan if I visited Korea for instance, but there are ways. I look at them as different difficulty settings.
Also, the ethos is to avoid harming animals as much as practicable which will vary by individual and situation.
You can be a shitty vegan, it’s not against the rules hehe. Like you can avoid obvious meat or dairy but not bother reading the fine print—that’s better than most people. Or you can try your best but then go eat your craving on the second Sunday of every month, or give yourself two Mulligans a week, or whatever you want. There really are no rules.
Though I’d argue that once you secure your sources of regular plant based food, it’s actually quite easy to just go all the way and stick with it.
This was me and I still think it’s important to sit with this incongruity rather than try to weasel your way out of it with broken logic. Sit with the discomfort of being in conflict with your own ethical knowledge and let it work on you.
I’m not going to look down on someone who eats animal products even though they know better, because I was them not long ago. I know what it feels like to be on both sides of this, as do most vegans.
I would just urge them to keep thinking about it and trying in different little ways to reduce their reliance on animal products here and there.
If you’re open minded about veganism and the problems with animal farming you’re so much closer than you think to actually being able to do it yourself.
This was me and I still think it’s important to sit with this incongruity rather than try to weasel your way out of it with broken logic. Sit with the discomfort of being in conflict with your own ethical knowledge and let it work on you.
100% agree. That’s why I detest people that know it’s wrong, and then say things like what OP in the meme does about how you can “just be wrong” and “just live your life” at the expense of your victims. It’s not a personal choice when there are victims involved, and when you know there are victims and you have the ability to stop, you need to stop.
But when it comes to actually talking to people about this stuff, I agree with gently encouraging them to not run away from their cognitive dissonance and to follow those thoughts to their logical conclusions.
I forgot who I stole it from, but veganism is my favorite example of a position that has nearly unassailable reasoning, but is still utterly unconvincing to most people.
The age old question. Do people make decisions using reasoning? Or do they make decisions based on emotions, and rationalise them afterwards using their reasoning?
I’d say the balancing factor tends to be effort. We are, as living creatures, lazy. That’s how you survive. The level of empathy you need to acquire before the suffering of a chicken you will never meet is going to compete with your desire to eat easily available delicious food made from them is going to have to be very high.
And once you make your choice you’re not going to internalise the idea that you are knowingly operating from a moral code informed by an acceptance of laziness are you? That conflicts with the self identity of being a rational and good person.
Not really. It comes from the position that animals are people, or at least more worthy of consideration than the wants of humans. Neither of which are true in the eyes of basically everyone. Now arguing against factory farming seems to actually be unassailable.
Possibly. Does it sound like “yeah, the problem of humans pushing other life forms into starvation and extinction is solved with this one simple trick”?
I don’t care what people eat. I can genuinely go months or years without thinking about vegans. I never challenged any vegan, vegetarian or whatever other diet out there.
I have been bothered by vegans on multiple occasions including at restaurants more than once.
I’ve had this exact mentality until one day I just stopped eating meat, and generally nothing bad happened to me. It’s not like I miss it, I didn’t lose anything, there’s no sacrifice in my daily life. I just no longer participate in the direct consumption of the product of (still existing and still supported by my work via taxes) the terrible pipeline of infinite suffering, which is something I guess. In the past I’ve also quit smoking and I can tell you dropping animal products from my diet was much easier. So much, it felt underwhelming.
I don’t tend to talk about it, because I know how my “whining” about meat eating would be perceived, especially remembering how I myself loathed anyone who tried to convince me that eating meat might be bad. It’s just such a silly thing to defend and keep doing. Just gobble up those beans, man. They’re delicious. Leave the cow alone. Organize to overthrow the capital class. Marinate your tofu. Don’t be silly. Kill fascists, not the piggies. Come on.
My only issue as a vegan is in the social sphere. I always feel like the weird one, or that if someone cooks a meal just for me, I’m taking a lot of space (not too sure how to say this in English). If appreciate the kindness but it makes me feel awkward.
My experience was the same, I expected a lot of friction dropping meat, but there was just nothing, which felt almost laughable. I do have friends however that have struggled to drop it, so it varies I guess.
Dairy and eggs was a bit harder, because it’s included in so many products and dishes I regularly ate. Takes a bit of time and energy, but when the switch is made, I would say its pretty smooth sailing
Tldr: my jagged journey to being a shitty vegan started with admitting it was ethically superior and then just trying things for fun/challenge.
That was my attitude basically ever since I seriously thought about the ethics for maybe 10 whole minutes. I mean it’s obvious. But it didn’t impact anything I did until I lived on my own for a while. Then I started by cutting out the obviously reprehensible options like restaurants that support factory farming, cheap machine produced stuff, etc. I’d still eat trash from time to time, but I tried to shop for more ethical sounding options, like free to roam stuff.
Many years later I slowly started cooking vegetarian meals more than anything else, and would joke with my wife "look: totally vegan… Except for all the cheese lol. " 100% vegan meals then became a personal challenge then, so tried to make them good without cheese. Nothing bad happened.
I always said I could never be vegan because of cheese, but then I thought what if I JUST quit cheese and dairy (just obvious sources, but not like if it’s in a piece of toast and I can’t tell). Again nothing bad happened. Actually my vegetarian friends were really supportive and showed me lots of vegan dishes.
I still had eggs every day for breakfast and the occasional fish, like sardines or tuna sandwiches. I didn’t know how I could ever quit my morning eggs, and had even tried a couple times.
Then I saw a vegan thread on lemmy here and just asked someone what they ate for breakfast and they gave me a few ideas and I decided to try yet another tofu scramble and that just did it.
I did feel sluggish for a day or two, and maybe a little bit “off” for a week but not even as bad as a cold. Kind of like a hangover. I just stuck with it and ate a bit more to make up for any loss in nutrition, throw in a daily vitamin, and that was just it. And yup, nothing bad happened. Eventually I felt great. The whole time I guess it was just a couple sluggish days away from me.
I said maybe I’d eat meat or dairy just to be easy from time to time, but then Thanksgiving came and went and I really didn’t feel like it. I just brought lentil patties and ate some sides until I wasn’t hungry anymore. Easy peasy.
If anything I feel like going vegan has de-dramatised food and eating for me. It’s simple: you just eat nutritious food that makes you feel good, until you’re satisfied.
But I’m just at the outset. I don’t vet everything, I just don’t partake in anything that is made with animal products as far as I can tell, and as much as I easily can.
I think I could easily go vegan 5 days a week, but I could never give up my weekend breakfasts with eggs, cheese, and the occasional sausage or bacon. Not to mention the homemade lattes :(
I won’t argue for most of the animal-based market but I reject the idea that eggs are inherently unethical. Some of the ways they are produced certainly are (the vast majority even, I assume), but chickens just lay eggs in their day to day life and I don’t think anything is wrong with eating them, though I do acknowledge that finding ethical options is probably more complex than just paying a bit extra for the free range cartons.
I should find a local producer again, then they are usually both cheaper and not factory farmed.
Guinea hens lay 30 - 180 depending on climate, food availability and predation in the wild. Domestic hens are not “bred” into daily laying, their instinctive nature to fill the nest drives them. Appropriate feed, housing and hydration allows that. That, in no way, excuses industrial egg production. However, small numbers raised as pets for egg production are treated very well and mourned at their passing. Is that acceptable?
Domestic hens were still bred into significantly higher egg output capacities.
If you want to tangent off specifically into niche birds, sure a guinea hen has a high natural egg laying capacity, as you stated, if you manipulate it’s environment. Typically in the wild, however, it would lay ~10-20 per year. Your more typical bred domestic chicken that this conversation is actually about has more than twice the capacity of the guinea hen’s natural limit. Let’s keep on topic here though, yeah?
Let me know if you find a farmer who lets the males live, feeds them and cares for them, until they peacefully reach old age, getting absolutely nothing from them apart maybe the joy of seeing them happy.
I have omnivore dentition. To take advantage of it I consume seitan through raw spinach through rare prime rib. The rest of you are welcome to dine on whatever.
I don’t argue about whether or not people should be vegan. I just know that my quality of life would be vastly diminished as I really don’t enjoy most vegan food. If they can nail lab created meat, I’m all for it.
I think you might be shocked how easy it is to eat tasty vegan food, saying you dont enjoy"most vegan food" implies to me that you’ve only had a really limited selection of what’s available.
Highly recommend trying ethiopian food.
Ethiopian veggies are great but yebeg wot is on a different level.
There’s tasty vegan food for sure hut there’s usually a slightly tastier horrifically unethical alternative.
I agree with op, I think vegans are right, I basically support them but ain’t converting. Realizing they were right on food made me a lot less angry that other people don’t feel the same way I do about sweatshop clothes and they, like me are doing their best. Some prioritise animals in tortorous conditions, others prioritise kids in poor ones, others look after drug addled first worlders, everyone’s got their own moral priorities.
Nobody can force you, all I can really hope for is that you try different vegan food and at least give a shit enough to eat less animals.
None of us can be perfect, but we also need to be able to care about multiple causes, and not eating animals is a very easy and tasty one. I care about sweatshop clothes, I care about slave labor in the supply chain for lithium ion batteries, and the genocide in Gaza. I can choose who to vote for and who to shop with and what to eat based on all those goals.
It’s true we’ve only each got like enough moral bandwidth to champion X number of causes it seems. I still view my goal as doing to most with my capacity though, even if I fall short on most.
Yes, but also no. Cooking can be difficult. I’ve built the entirety of how I eat around ease. For example a pot of chili for the week with some cornbread isn’t difficult. I do “burrito bowls” with beans, rice, avocado, salsa, lime juice.
I like to air fry tofu and toss it in sauce.
You’re overthinking it, the things I do don’t even really follow recipes. What’s gonna go in a chili? Whatever you want. Beans, tomatoes, tomato sauce, mushrooms, peppers, zucchini, just sautee some veggies, toss in your beans, seasoning, and sauce, then simmer for a while until it looks good.
Cooking pasta, for example is also super easy. Sautee some vegetables, toss in a jar of premade sauce and simmer while you cook noodles.
This isn’t baking :3
And you think that’s going to make it easier for people who don’t have much experience with cooking? Throwing random stuff together and making it taste good is a skill, especially if it involves unfamiliar ingredients like tofu.
There’s really easy basics to work with, is more my point. Cooking rice or beans isn’t hard, having an idea of what vegetables you like is something most of us already know to some degree. You can always follow recipes if you don’t want to experiment on your own.
Also, it’s not like every meal has to be home cooked? I buy a frozen pizza or nuggets or something pretty often.
None of this is really any different if someone isn’t eating vegan and doesn’t know how to cook.
Tofu can definitely be one a lot of people dislike, I’d usually argue that it’s a food that absorbs flavor and therefore taste depends on how you cook it, but you don’t need to eat tofu.
Veggies, on the other hand, are a very important source of fiber and vitamins and just aren’t optional if you want to be healthy, even if you eat animal products.
They’re a pretty broad range of food, I’m confident you can find something you like. Growing up, my mom would just microwave canned veggies with some butter and salt and I always found it pretty bland, but it doesn’t take a lot to make them really good.
That’s actually why I use chili as an example, all the flavors meld together and it becomes savory (or spicy in my case).
I mean, depending on where you’re from, you can already get most meat products in a convincing non-lab alternative, at least from what I hear from colleagues. (I don’t have an opinion on this, because I don’t like meat. 🫠)
Thanks for your honestly but most food is vegan just with a piece of meat thrown in, or with cheese added on top. If you like those things, you can just sub out the animal part.
I know arguing over personal taste is a fool’s errand, but your tastes are malleable if you’re ever motivated to challenge yourself.
This is a super hot take so bare with me, but the conditions of a lot of vegan food production are also often harmful to the humans that grow the food (I’m talking blood produce) and the growth in popularity of certain superfoods have severely damaged the ecosystems that indigenous populations in the areas where they’re from depended on.
This is not to say being vegan is bad. It’s obviously proven to be better for the environment, and the way that animals are treated is absolutely inhumane.
This is to say however that we should be demanding sustainability in all our food consumption and respect for all living beings. But mostly, it’s to say fuck capitalism.
By vegan food production you must mean processed fake meat? Not all vegans eat a horrible diet.
If you mean vegan food production as in normal non-meat foods such as vegetables than that’s a while opinion. Unless you are Jain or just want to die, we got to eat something.
Most food production in general kills a lot more than I would like especially vegetable and fruit production. Not much to do on the regard though.
Yes I did mean veg and fruit, but I mean that obviously we need to eat but we need to do it in a sustainable and fair way.
Currently a lot of the produce in Canada & the US is grown by migrant labour where people are treated horribly. In Mexico, many of the agricultural production sites are owned by cartels. Quinoa used to be a primary food source for quechuan (peruvian indigenous) people but when it grew in popularity in the west, it became too expensive for those who depended on it. There are many more examples.
What there is to do about it is to demand better agricultural practices and support fair-trade, co-ops, and sustainable food vendors. In the same way we should be / are demanding cruelty-free and sustainable animal products.
Unless you are Jain or just want to die, we got to eat something.
That’s the thing though, why should plants be more eligible for eating than animals? Both are living. Animals are closer to us, so we can understand them better, but that doesn’t mean we aren’t being just as harmful to plants.
I don’t think there’s anything inherently wrong with eating another animal for sustenance. Just the same as there isn’t anything wrong with eating a plant for sustenance. What matters is what we do before we eat them.
As we can. We understand how animals think, because evolutionarily they’re closer to us. We don’t really understand how plants “think” or “feel”, we just decide that because they don’t have what we have that makes it okay.
That understanding has its limits. We’re just cracking on the ways plants (and fungi) may communicate with one another via external chemical signalling. There are things beyond our current understanding, and how a plant “feels” is completely alien to us. Hell, the function of how people “feel” is still not fully understood.
My point is that it’s ultimately arbitrary. We feel pain, and we can imagine animals feeling pain in a similar way, because their neurological systems are similar. We assume plants don’t feel pain - and we can confidently say they don’t feel pain the same way we do, but we can’t say they don’t feel pain at all in a way we don’t yet understand.
Either way though, both plants and animals are living beings, and you are denying them the same opportunity to life by eating them.
Are you stupid? Genuine question, because animals need to eat as well for you to pay someone to murder them. Even going from the assumption that plants suffer too, a plant based diet still causes much fewer plants to die compared to feeding the plants inefficiently to animals to then eat the animals.
Liar. You’re just being a dick here. No bother though.
Like I said before, what matters is what we do before we eat them. Industrial farming practices are where I see the real problems at - and the key thing is that this is an issue for both meant and plant farming.
Plant based diets can definitely be more efficient, although palm oil is also vegan (and palm oil farming is currently the cause of a massive amount of habitat loss), so just because you have a plant based diet doesn’t mean it’s perfect. But what I’m saying here is that eating plants is not inherently more righteous than eating animals. In practice, it almost certainly is (mainly because of farming practices), but not inherently.
eating meat today doesn’t cause it to have been fed in the past. events in the future cannot cause events in the past. eating meat doesn’t cause past suffering.
So you have no problems with slave labour because the suffering already happened when you buy its products? What about a video of a rape? The rape already happened so it won’t cause further suffering getting off to it.
How hard is it to understand that these animals get tortured and murdered for your consumption and you don’t just happen to come upon a corpse accidentally. Your consumption drives the production.
“Super foods” are kind of fucked, and that’s part of being a good vegan—researching and avoiding things that cause harm (as much as practicable). But those are more a thing in wellness clean eating fad diet circles. Most vegan staples are like rice, beans, pulses, and random veggies.
Nah, there are definitely some vegetarian and vegan foods (especially when we’re talking ultraprocessed foods) that are worse for the environment and worse for your health than just plain meat or cheese.
Genuinely which ones? Everything I can think of is better than meat. Largely because the cows eat a lot of food in the first place with most of it being wasted.
It’s been a good long while since I made my comparisons but i believe Quorn was worse than chicken (but not as bad as beef obviously). In Sweden we also have Anamma which used to be very good, but at some point they removed their classic formulations and suddenly added like 30% sugar to everything (and doubled the price for good measure). Not sure if they’ve walked that back by now, hopefully they have.
No, it’s the ultraprocessed stuff that can be pretty bad. But I think a lot of things have happened in the past decade during which there was also a huge focus on sustainability, so I think the market is better now than it used to be. I’m not up to speed anymore.
In the UK there’s a sweet maker called Candy Kittens. They make, like, vegan Haribo (only better) that tastes really really nice.
They’ve started making their own vegan peanut M&M’s. Instead of chocolate they use a shit ton of palm oil.
It’s “ethically sourced” palm oil, but that’s still a sour thought after you’ve devoured a whole bag of tasty sweet treats in one sitting. It’s still increasing the market capacity for palm oil, which in turn increases demand to destroy habitats eg orangutans in Indonesia and other SE Asian islands.
Cocoa is vegan. Chocolate is usually made with milk products to make it more palatable. The chocolate in peanut M&M’s has milk in it, so they are not vegan.
Except these days milk is largely substituted with palm oil recipes, which is much cheaper, but creates a worse product (often described as waxy) while the industry producing it is tearing down virgin forests for farm land.
we should be demanding sustainability in all our food consumption and respect for all living beings
Hear hear.
Plants are living beings, also. The fact is, unless you photosynthesise, you likely have to consume another living being to survive.
What nearly everyone can agree on is that industrial farming practices are harmful. Not just to the living things we farm, but also to the consumers, who end up consuming a lesser product that is often contaminated by industrial processes that cut corners to save on cost.
I think if you want to be vegan, go for it. Doesn’t work for me. And I’m all good with hunting.
edit: addressing the misunderstanding for down voters. Most hunters don’t go out to kill, but some do. It’s not an easy thing, you remember it for life at least I do. Still have a picture of my dog for decade on my phone. I don’t think the whole hunting thing of trailing a deer is right. I only go for confirmed kills. Separate the spine from the brain. Lung/Heart shots are stupid. If I miss, they live another day. A lot of people hate this mentality.
I get sick from a lot of foods. Don’t get me wrong, I tried it for six months and have never felt sicker. Can’t have wheat, lentils are poison. I don’t want to live a life of rice and beans, granted I love beans and rice (I get fancy Hokkaido rice). Gourds/pumpkins/etc have too much sugar. I don’t want to take supplements. Constantly being hungry wasn’t fun either.
So it’s not as I don’t eat vegetables–onions, garlic, cucumbers, tomatoes, leeks, eggplant, potatoes. But I have to have meat and cheese. I loved making salads until earlier this year… hence my user name.
When I would bike 30 miles a day, I didn’t want to eat a box spaghetti. Like cool my roommate said yeah just do that, I just got a burger halfway. Also the cold makes you a furnace; I mentioned this in another post.
One aspect is that, I lived in places that had ethical farming. And you would take responsibility for a life you take. This goes further than animals.
I don’t think they’re correct, but also why care? If anything they’re helping the environment and living the life they want to live. Good for them and more power to them.
Ig the point is they’re ethically correct just from an environmental standpoint. We should all be doing more to reduce emissions, and veganism is one of the easiest ways to do that.
Do you think there might be a connection between “I like annoying vegans” and them reacting negatively, that says more about you than it does them?
I’ve never met a vegan like that, but I have met dozens of dickhead schoolboy bullies who think eating meat makes them manly, and pwning vegans with their hilarious same two jokes every time even more so
I don’t pretend I’m not an asshole. Most of the time I use my powers for good. This context is purely a guilty pleasure of mine, no excuses, I just like it.
NGL, I do like Lemmy for the fact that I can be 95% sure that I’m arguing with an actual human instead of a bot, unlike every other platform. The ragebait is organic 😊
As someone who gets hard af headaches and migraine from processed and older foods, I’d say they are wrong. at least for me. No way I eat vegan when there are only 3 types of legumes that don’t give me a headache
Preach, I hate the label too…
People try so hard to make it useful but it’s just not… Plenty unprocessed foods will kill you and plenty processed foods are amazingly healthy.
With just a little bit of common sense this wouldn’t be so hard to differentiate. Oats are processed, yes (take the grain, separate the husk, press it, pasteurize it, package it, etc.), but nobody will tell you its processed food, right?
Also isn’t transport a unit operation, wouldn’t make that anything that got moved in an industrial fashion processed? Get a life if that trips you up
Yea didn’t say that I eat processed meats or any form of cheese either, but I can eat fresh meat and fish, eggs and milk. I can also eat young legumes without getting headaches but I am in testing on that front.
Its not about processed but rather age of the product, anything that gets industrially processed (especially protein rich foods) is probably too old.
Edit: fixed typos and inserted missing words for clarity
Oh! Nice to learn about that!
I’ll keep an eye out, although using antihistamines is usually good to clear the headache, thiamine seems to act as an histamine release trigger, so it could be that as well…
The wikipedia page says that there is more and more attention given to the level of biogenic amines in food, so it’s a good news!
here a tyramine list
The biggest differences are tomatoes being fine and broccoli not being fine. Idk how scientific your list is, but all tyramine list are vibes only. E.g. people on reddit being like “yea this gave me a migraine” + the substances grow in a similar fashion, so its no wonder they match mostly 1:1
What a false comparison - unprocessed meat vs processed non-meat. I’m sorry if your lack of food diversity growing up has made you sensitive to beans but you would certainly survive just fine as and when meat was not available. People can live off nothing but potatoes when necessary - ask the Irish. Though it’s also not good to rely on a single type of food - also ask the Irish.
It’s comfort convenience and pleasure. If you could moderate those things in the face of moral responsibility towards other animals then you would indeed stop eating meat. Though it’s a lot easier to pretend it’s not your choice isn’t it?
I should say I eat meat occasionally. And I use technology from companies destroying the world and buy products from companies owned by people I despise. I do not live up to my own ideal ethics and neither do 99% of humans who ever lived. Accepting moral truths does not require you to be morally perfect. It’s a direction to pull towards not a binary measurement of if you’re a valid person.
I’m in the same boat, but with rampant inflammation from endometriosis in my bladder and bowels. I have so many food intolerances that meat is one of the safest things I can eat.
I hate the taste of meat. I hate the texture of meat. This isn’t for pleasure. I can’t eat potatoes or soy, but I love potatoes and soy. I just can’t eat it without pissing blood.
Vegans still still come and try to argue with me about this. They are massively ablest.
Insufferable fucks downvoting because muh-not-perfectly-reasoned. There are years of brain fog and migraine behind this statement from me. Just because you haven:'t heard anything about it doesn’t mean its not real. No I did not grow up with a lack of diversity, but I always had headaches so fuck you
Um, maybe you should look up, why cows give milk in the first place? It’s not like it’s an animal that just randomly produces milk…little hint: why do human mothers produce milk when they gave birth, but don’t do it randomly their whole life 🤔
But is the cow you’re drinking milk from living a decent, happy life? What about the male calves that are born as a result of reproducing milk cows? What happens to them?
This thinking could extend to virtually every choice you make and is completely impossible to systematically justify for an ethical system without going completely and utterly insane.
It is the “Butterfly Effect” of ethics. A select path has impacts beyond the initial obvious moral consideration and then more considerations beyond that.
So where is the line? I don’t know that there is one, but I know that its a waste of energy to follow this line of thinking. One initial intuitive layer of moral consideration is more than the average person even remotely considers, and sometimes not even that much. The way elections have gone in the US over the past few years is a good example of this.
I agree that the line can seem or be arbitrary. I’m just pointing out that the specific example that you gave: “happy cow”, is more a figment of your imagination than a reality. It’s not so much “butterfly effect” as simply “effect”. I’m not judging you. I’m just saying you gave a bad example.
Is the immigrant working in the fields with no healthcare and fleeing ICE living a happy, healthy life? Is the slave worker in Myanmar making the trowel you use in your home garden living a happy, healthy life?
It’s impossible to exist without benefiting from suffering somewhere. At a certain point, you just have to try and do what you can to make it better. In my case, that involves supporting legislation to make the world better, because that will have more impact than a fringe group of people deciding not to wear wool socks.
If you care about those things, and if you consider those necessary to produce crops, then they are also 30-80% necessary to produce a corresponding amount of milk protein.
10-20% of cattle diets are soybeans, corn, or another industrial crop. 25-35% of their protein intake gets converted to milk protein.
Factor in the additional slave labor and worker exploitation involved in all of the other dairy ranching workflows, and it likely makes up the rest of the difference.
I don’t understand this line of reasoning, especially as applied to the original context of “vegetarians are right, but vegans go too far”. Nobody here is pretending they avoid any part in any suffering. Indeed, we all determine for ourselves how much we can live with. For many of us, that line shifts with our needs, wants, knowledge and understanding. I just pointed out that the example of a happy cow, living life and providing milk is a fiction, masking the same realities that leads many people to vegetarianism.
As a Vegetarian I disagree. We’re the most schizophrenic when it comes to animal welfare. No meat as we don’t want to kill for our food, but milk and cheese is only possible when we kill calves and eggs are only possible when we shredder 50% of the baby chicks.
Yes, alternatives are starting to pop up, but they are still in the minority here.
If it’s not about animal welfare, but sustainability Vegans also win, because dairy is pretty bad in this aspect too.
You can’t have mass milk products without killing many calf. I use lots of cow cheese but you need to know all process to have milk and cheese needs to kill calfs, as cow stop usual doing milk after something like a year, after a few month of reduced milk production.
In this sense, animals also would die anyways, so eating meat is sometimes justified aswell (would you eat a cow that would die soon anyway or just let it suffer a natural death? And then waste its meat?)
If I was would I eat beef from a cow that was euthanized just before dying painfully and feel ethically consistent? Sure. If someone wants to argue that would make me not a vegetarian in that case I’m not going to give a shit. That’s just arguing about definitions.
Crazy it’s like you don’t know one single thing about the vegan viewpoint and are arguing entirely against strawmen.
You know, the way people who are wrong and don’t have the maturity to admit it or at least the education to put forth an actual counter argument might do.
I don’t think anyone would deny we are adapted for an omnivorous diet. But we are omnivores rather than obligate carnivores, so meat consumption does remain a choice rather than an imperative. Should our biology dictate our morality?
Should evolutionary proximity dictate our morality?
We understand animals, because they are closer to us than plants. But plants are also living creatures. The fact is, unless you photosynthesise, every large living being has to consume another to survive.
I think the choice is much more complex than meat vs vegan. I think it comes down to farming practices, particularly industrial farming which min/maxes everything and cuts corners as much as they can get away with to save on cost.
Palm oil is vegan. Yet palm oil farming is the cause of a great deal of habitat and species loss. Palm oil is quietly used in a lot of vegan food.
I’m not sure many vegans would agree that palm oil is vegan it can certainly be part of a plant based diet, which is a large part of being vegan, but really only the beginning.
I do agree however that my major complaint with animal products available today are with modern farming practices more than any kind of egoist notions. It’s crazy to me that you can just walk to the back of any grocery store to the glistering wall of pink sheets and just grab one without any sense of reverence, or thought to what’s required to keep that dreaded wall fed 365 days of the year.
I’d still abstain because I’ve yet to see a farmer, even the good ones, corral or kill their animals in a way that didn’t make me want to riot on the spot.
It’s crazy to me that you can just walk to the back of any grocery store to the glistering wall of pink sheets and just grab one without any sense of reverence, or thought to what’s required to keep that dreaded wall fed 365 days of the year.
This is an incredibly succinct way of putting it, thank you.
when the post says “vegans are obviously right”, assuming that to mean that humans are made to not eat meat is a very bad faith interpretation. similar equating can happen when someone says all genders are equal and someone pulls out the sexual dimorphism research to claim they aren’t. there’s missing context of what is being said and what is being interpreted. i dont believe there’s a substantial group of vegans claiming humans are incapable or not ‘evolved’ to eat meat.
i am not debating that humans are apes, most carnivore, or adapted to both meat and vegetables. i don’t agree there, citations needed, but taking it as a mere simplification of facts its fine enough.
there’s complexity to the question of eating meat now that society has reached a point where we no longer need it to sustain ourselves. i am not arguing either way here but an argument there exists and we will need to have an answer to it. just like we didnt evolve to be able to see if our eyes fuck up, but we managed to just have spectacles (and surgery) to fix it. we can adopt to a non-meat diet if that is the answer, whether or not we evolved for it.
i am conflicted on if vegans are right. but i can appreciate that they are at least right on pointing towards the question.
So that by itself is a very good question, but the ability of not consuminy it should not mean the obligation(or prohibition), or even the morals on the wheter of eating or not eating meat.
So thats my argument, we really should not matter that much about what is on the meal of people by itself. Maybe, one day, artificial meat becomes better than normal one and we end up replacing meat, and humannity, accidentally, end up as a vegan species by itself.
The thing is that involving the morally good or wrong about something like food shouldnt be a thing if it can be improved or obsoleted.
I appreciate you’re engaging with the question and I’d urge you to keep going.
Here’s a thought experiment: imagine if the only other animals in the planet were other primates, maybe even just Neanderthals. Maybe we ate them in the past, maybe some people still do today. Maybe they’re even farmed. Trapped and milked, or fed and butchered. But it’s all far away from the city, so you don’t even have to think about it, you just go to the back of the store and get your meat or your cheese.
But they are actually people. Not like you and me, sure, but they undeniably have a conscious experience of the world very very similar to ours.
You don’t actually need to eat their body parts or their milk. You can survive just fine without them, it just takes some effort, but most people don’t bother.
Would it still be morally irrelevant whether you ate that meat or not?
It would be more of a thing about sappiency and about their own culture, even considering they could be wildly diferent to us in biology, they could be cephalopods,birds, bears or even plants or funghi,yes, we can survive without them.
My principal point is that que are already asuming too many things about those other sapient beings:
-theyre animals that cannot reproduce sexualy vía grafts
-they have the same fear death than western people
-they may not have canibalistic customs about themselves
And we dont even know if there IS a being that is like that and straight to the point we wouldnt have the alternative to actually subsitute vía emulation.
Being not compulsory to live doens’t mean its not a thing that we can rennounce as fast as a moral vision would like, there is more of nuance and yes, we can survive without animal products but there are big chalenges about It, and more about actually living without them in a normal way,as today we cant really reproduce what meat actually does.
My principal point is that que are already asuming too many things about those other sapient beings: -theyre animals that cannot reproduce sexualy vía grafts -they have the same fear death than western people -they may not have canibalistic customs about themselves
I don’t understand what you mean here. Do you mind clarifying?
I think my answer to this would be that even without worrying over what we don’t know, we can make moral and ethical choices based on what we do know.
It may be imperfect information but if we try our best and admit our ignorance and update our behavior with new information, then I believe we can live in a, for lack of a better word, more virtuous way.
as today we cant really reproduce what meat actually does.
That’s fine because we don’t really need to in order to lead happy, healthy, fulfilling lives. Maybe in the past we did, but basically since the invention of fire starting, it hasn’t been necessary.
So what you’re saying is that - in principle - if we took brain cells from say a 90s kid and then infused them with the genetic material of a fully grown adult Vegan, we could cultivate a batch of neurons that not only have perfect memory, but also are never wrong and thus create the perfect thinking machine artificially created intelligence? Of course it’s not like that’s something I would be able to do by myself in my home. Biological computer chips? That’s not real technology don’t look it up its just uhhh ideas for some SciFi shit. But like, you know. In principle. Just hypothetically hypothesizing and all that…
Veganism isn’t about not eating what was or is “alive”. It’s about “suffering” (and avoiding it as much as possible).
You can find that fundamental belief in Buddhism or Jainism too. If you think about it, you can probably find it in you. Why would anybody want to make any other sentient body suffer?
Veganism can also be about environmental impact. I’m vegetarian mostly because a meat based diet isn’t sustainable on a global scale. While I’m obviously happy about the reduced suffering, it’s importance is only in second place for me.
Tho maybe veganism is pretty much entirely for reducing animals suffering, I’m only a vegetarian and won’t pretend to know for sure.
It’s about the fact that the environment cannot be sustained while everyone eats meat. So it is about the suffering it will cause for me primarily, but to humans and not animals
It’s a widespread misunderstanding but adopting a plant based diet for some reason other than avoiding the exploitation of animals isn’t veganism. Praying five times a day isn’t Islam unless you’re praying to Allah.
they have pain rezeptors they have a basic neural net.
To assume a plant would not suffer is a little outdated.
Even 20 Yeats ago it was already known that plants do feel pain.
I said: they suffer if you hurt them. Not more not less.
“Not more not less”? This is the definition of suffering:
Experiencing pain; characterized by suffering.
The condition of someone who suffers; a state of pain or distress.
as you can, maybe… hopefully… understand, all of those things you wrote above implies sentience. Here, this is from a miracle called wikipedia ☞
Sentience is the ability to experience feelings and sensations. Some theorists define sentience exclusively as the capacity for valenced (positive or negative) mental experiences, such as pain and pleasure.
While plants, as living beings, can perceive and communicate physical stimuli and damage, they do not feel pain simply because of the lack of any pain receptors, nerves, or a brain, and, by extension, a lack of consciousness. Many plants are known to perceive and respond to mechanical stimuli at a cellular level, and some plants such as the venus flytrap or touch-me-not, are known for their “obvious sensory abilities”. Nevertheless, no member of the plant kingdom feels pain, not withstanding its abilitiy to respond to sunlight, gravity, wind, and any external stimuli such as insect bites since they lack any nervous system. The primary reason for this is that, unlike the members of the animal kingdom whose evolutionary successes and failures are shaped by suffering, the evolution of plants is simply shaped by life and death.
To be clear, they don’t sense “pain”. Virtually every organism has receptor proteins that mediate molecular responses to stimuli. In plants, this might be a molecule from a pathogen, a mechanical thing (like an insect biting a leaf), or a molecule associated with damage (cell wall components or energy molecules being found outside where they’re meant to be). Bacteria might excite their flagella to move away from danger, plants might isolate their cytoplasm to restrict pathogens, but these are well-documented physiological pathways only. Nobody is arguing that bacteria are capable of pain.
Only animals with a nervous system have a sense of “suffering” or “pain”, and sure enough they behave a lot like humans in that respect too (by reacting with a response such as fleeing, fighting, screaming, etc). We have physiological responses too, but plants are a lot more like bacteria than animals in that sense. Having receptors and hormones is quite different to having a complex nervous system.
Even if that’s true that plants are conscious and can experience subjective pain (doubt), then it just means we live on a world where it’s really hard to avoid doing harm and that would suck for us as sapient creatures with the knowledge that inflicting pain is wrong, but the end goal would still be to reduce harm to feeling beings as much as practicable.
Yeah I don’t believe the point was raised in good faith (it never is), which is why I addressed it in the hypothetical only—to say even if it were true, it still wouldn’t undermine the vegan position on reducing exploitation.
It sure does, it’s a moral statement. But let me speak them then:
pain is unpleasant and should be avoided as much as practicable
If you care about reducing the pain in others then you should act accordingly
the vegan perspective is to reduce our exploitation of animals as much as practicable
the pain and suffering of animals at the hands of humans matters
we should try to limit the unnecessary pain we cause
there are actions humans can take to lower the amount of pain and suffering in the world
a world with less pain and suffering is preferable to one with more
But seriously, what would you do with the information that plants felt suffering on the level of animals and humans? Would you do nothing with this shocking new evidence?
it also assumes that you can know what will decrease suffering in the future. you can’t.
further, it assumes that inflicting or avoiding suffering is either immoral or moral. only one system I’m aware of states this outright and it’s utilitarianism, which can be summed up " the ends justify the means" which most people think is pretty abhorrent.
Yes and that holds true for all actions—we can never know how our behavior will “sum out” in the future, especially the far far future.
We still make moral decisions based on the imperfect information we have. In fact we have to, because merely existing in the status quo is a moral decision. Even choosing to remove ourselves from existence is a moral decision. On a long enough horizon we can’t tell how anything will play out.
So while can’t know what any of our decisions or lack of decisions will amount to in the future, we still try, and update our assumptions as time goes on.
But there’s no point in arguing whether reducing suffering is moral or not if you’re not even going to grant that attempting to reduce suffering is a worthy goal.
On a long enough horizon we can’t tell how anything will play out.
which is why consequentialism can’t actually tell us the right thing to do. it’s a fatally flawed ethical approach.
since ethics can’t be derived from possible future outcomes, they must come from somewhere else. kant proposes it’s the categorical imperative. divine command theorists propose from God or a holy text.
neither of those systems axiomatically say to reduce suffering.
I feel like you’re getting lost in the world of abstracts. I’m talking subjective, fallible, imperfect, morality—not objective ethics.
There is a concrete instance of a chicken that is being tortured for profit currently. If you’re against that, it’s morally self-consistent to avoid contributing to the system which is torturing the chicken.
341 comments
log in to comment.
Fun fact: The actor in this scene is vegetarian, so they used mushrooms instead of steak
Which is kind of wild, because I don’t know if a steak has ever looked better on film than the cut shown in this scene. I understand that sentiment may not hold true for folks on vegetarian or vegan diets based on ethical grounds, but that may as well be the Platonic ideal of “fancy steak”.
Visually, yes.
However I’ve not met a mushroom that tastes and feels like beef. Impossible burgers get close but it’s far from a steak.
Have you tried the impossible Beyond steak? Highly recommend
I’ve never had Impossible Steak. Do you like Beyond? I’ve noticed some people like one or the other.
Have you tried Lions Mane steak?
https://youtu.be/oaARq5qw3jk
Herbivorous Butcher is really good too and they have a cookbook to make your own.
https://www.theherbivorousbutcher.com/
There was a brand called Meati that made steaks out of mycelium that were so goddamn good. Closest to the real thing I’ve had so far. Unfortunately some shady financial shenanigans cost them their production plant. There’s a new owner trying to get them up and running again though so fingers crossed there.
I used to see their billboard a lot when I worked in Downtown Denver. Never got to try it.
Oh shoot my bad I actually meant beyond steak- I kinda hate the taste of everything Impossible makes lol
Whooaa, cool! I haven’t but I definitely need to; thanks for sharing!
Every time I visited the twin cities I’d stop by their shop and stock up on a bunch of stuff. Their vegan BBQ ribs and vegan chorizo were so good. I heard that their store burned down a few years ago, but I didn’t realize they kept their online shop open!
Yea, it’s funny because when I heard about them, I heard they made a cookbook after closing down. Like Miyoko’s new books. That it was just a local shop.
I only found the site from looking for the cookbook and found out they are still running and ship now.
I make mushroom steak from lions mane. My meat eater friends say its a pretty damn good substitute
Funner fact: the actor in the original Oldboy is also vegan, but he still ate that live octopus.
He’s vegetarian not vegan. It’s incredibly hard to be a vegan in korea, but it’s very easy to be a vegetarian. The vast majority of halmeoni cooking your food over there basically equivocate vegetarianism and vegan to be the same thing. A lot of traditional foods have hidden animal products in it like shrimp paste for seasoning.
I once tried talking to my like 85 year old Korean granny about it and she strongly explained to me that things like krill were more like plants than animals, which in some ways is kinda true.
Sounds like it’s easy to be a pescatarian, but not actually a vegetarian.
Again, it’s kinda weird. I would say it’s fairly easy to be vegetarian since there’s a cultural understanding of vegetarians due to the cultural/religious practices of Buddhist monks.
For one, they typically have more bland foods, and typically live in the mountainous regions where there’s less access to sea food. And again, what a lot of east Asian people consider meat varies from the western nomenclature.
Where instead of basing the ethical delineation on a scientific taxonomy, it’s based more on whether something possesses a soul/conscious. If we examine the issue through that lens it can make sense that an invertebrate like a krill or even coral are closer to plants than mammals.
So nothing, basically.
Restrictive Asian diets don’t sort neatly into western buckets.
By your definition, most practicing ‘vegetarian’ Buddhists are omnivores because of oyster sauce, yet they eat far less animal products than the average western vegetarian due to the low prevalence of dairy products.
Jains, for example, can drink milk and eat butter and ghee, but cannot eat root vegetables, fungi, and fermented foods, while the opposite is true for veganism.
So what do you call people who are vegetarian except for 1% of their diet? I would find it disengenuous to equate that to a regular omnivore diet.
TIL 200k tons of krill are harvested each year.
To be used in omega 3 supplements and fish farming. At the same time one can cut both by using omega 3 DHA & EPA supplements based on algae. Doing it for 7 years now. Also the less krill, the less whales and the less whales, the less flourishing ocean eco systems, because of the whale poop loop and whale falls.
Ahhh, okay. I thought I had read he was vegan, maybe I misremembered or maybe the article was wrong.
May have been the article if it was originally from a Korean source. Like I said they tend to use vegan and vegetarian interchangeably a lot.
Same in Japan… it’s so hard to be vegan.
[deleted]
That’s slightly less fun. I’ll eat a pig or a chicken or a cow but octopodes are too smart for me to eat.
I eat smart things only to get smarter. You are what you eat after all. Octoponi, Chimpansessies, Peeps, Dolphones, etc. Ant too since I want hive mind. My brain grows.
Okay Sylar…
I stopped eating them recently for that reason.
Same. cephalopods in general for me. I still feel bad about eating meat otherwise but I can’t even think about eating octopus
Pigs are smarter than dogs, that’s what makes em taste so good!
I think this is a very arbitrary line to draw, and I honestly don’t think it’s backed up by science. Octopuses may outperform pigs and cows at some tasks, but how do you measure their overall intelligence in a way that’s comparable?
Just realised looking at this that it's the same actor as Ralph from The Sopranos. I've watched both recently too!
But who plays Cypher in the Matrix in The Sopranos universe?
Ralphie
TIL!!!
And Ralph’s wig in The Sopranos is modelled on Christopher Nolan’s hair when he was directing Memento, which also stars the same actor.
Non-vegans should support vegans, even if they continue to eat meat, because vegans drive better treatment of animals and also drive more attractive non-animal food options.
However, a person must have a brain and also not have meat eating tied to their masculinity.
Yeah, you can’t say the conditions we’re subjecting livestock to is “good”. You don’t give up your rights to eat bbq if you admit it.
What really drives me mad is that there’s a dead simple solution - lab-grown meat - that can obviously be the best of both worlds with a bit more development (and in fact is being commercialized already), but is being lobbied against by the meat industry precisely because it’ll be cheaper and better. And nobody seems to be talking about it.
Lower demand for animal products lowers prices for others.
My meat eating isn’t even close to being tied to my masculinity. I hardly even care how myself and others perceive my masculinity.
My meat eating is nearly entirely tied to my enjoyment of the taste of meat.
[deleted]
As a cis dude who wears skirts, pink ball caps, and like dick as much as pussy… Please tell me how much my perceived masculinity matters to me.
[deleted]
Okay Keep telling yourself that. Whatever you need to feel better about yourself.
Everyone I know actually unironically feels this way lol and always comes to me for advice on going more vegan. Vegan hatred is a strong flea dip for me though, basically any% criticism of vegans ensures I will likely never speak to you again.
Is it awful of me to have stopped eating meat from animals I think are beautiful and sweet, like cows and pigs, but still eat meat from some animals I think are ugly and mean, like chickens and sheeps?
Sheep aren’t mean. Just very, very, very stupid.
Agree! We raised three lambs at home and they were all unbelievably stupid and slightly suicidal.
Horses are even more stupid, but to be fair, we eat them too.
As a non-vegan, that seems to be morally neutral to me (you’re still eating meat), barring differences in treatment and ecological impact of specific animals (I think cows are particularly bad in terms of environmental impact?)
If we go by bug logic, if it’s a freaky little bloodsucking chicken than maybe but I’m still not sure honestly
Oh but otherwise no that’s mean c’mon what’d chickens do
Id eat owls and raccoons because they like to murder the chickens. Does eating then for revenge count lol
As long as you serve them cold?
It took me a second to get this. As in revenge, a dish best served cold?
[deleted]
I get it. It’s like when nazis killed jews because they thought they are icky
comparing Jews to animals is what Nazis do
Tbh this is kind of a stupid behavior, if it’s a valid criticism i don’t see why you’d have to react like that
It’s not, because criticising “vegans” is done to avoid discussing veganism, which is objectively better than meat eating. This does not include people who say, argue whether starving people should eat meat to survive, which is not a criticism of vegans. I’m open to discussing any real life actual moral paradigms with reasonable people.
Basically you’re assuming it’s not purely coincidence. Plenty of my friends eat meat lol. They’re just rational and not the type of person who thinks I deserve to be cross examined for the actions of all people who are also vegan. People who act like I should like, idk, answer for PETA? My life has objectively improved by letting those bridges burn naturally. It’s done wonders for my mental health.
In that case it’s probably not a valid criticism
I am not gettin this, sorry
Maybe don’t be a bot that doesn’t understand the social connotations around being vegan? Idk lol you are getting blocked
No really i did not understood the phrase, english is my 2nd language so I do not understand some stuff…but i guess we gotta be rude :/
What are your thoughts on someone going into the woods and catching wild game?
Those are the kings woods and they should be hanged.
He deered to kill a King’s dare.
Keep your monarchy to yourself lol
If I go out into the woods and kill a person to eat, it is better than if I enslave a family, force them to breed, and then eat them one by one in perpetuity.
Similarly, hunting is better than factory farming, but that doesn’t mean it’s a good thing to do, outside of some niche conservation projects.
Thank you for your perspective!
Just eat less meat. You don’t have to go 0-100. Skip the patty, skip the filet. Double up on proteins. Dairy shouldn’t be an end goal but substitute the actual meat for dairy for at least some reduction. Pick the food that is vegan instead of the one using meat stock, etc. Little things here and there. Default to meatless, eat the damn meat if you absolutely have to. Increase this change over time, and make sure to add a vegan B12 supplement. 80% is better than 100%. 60% is better than 80% when you get there. Maybe someday you hit 0%. Achieve perfect through gradual change, don’t shun good if you can’t be perfect.
This is the best advice you can give someone imo. Im like 75% vegan, still have eggs and bacon on the weekends, some chicken with dinner, some other stuff here and there. But mostly its beans/tofu and rice with veggies.
Some people think they have to give up everything all at once right now and of course that seems overwhelming… because it is.
Perfectionism is often used as a shield to prevent change or to avoid challenging yourself or your own rigid thinking. When you see someone saying it’s all or nothing they’re actively sabotaging themselves, often that’s exactly what they want to be doing, plausible deniability
I’m a cold turkey kind of guy. Slippery slopes are hard to navigate but clean cuts are easy.
Do what works for you. If cold turkey works, excellent. Not everyone can, and taking a gradual approach may be more realistic for them instead.
You like the cold turkey or are you the vegan?
honestly, giving everything up at once was pretty easy? soymilk took a few weeks to get used to, but outside that adjustment i just added more beans to stuff. Worth at least trying before compromising on slaughter.
For you it was easy, which doesn’t have any bearing whatsoever on how easy it will be for any other person. What’s worth trying is anything which reduces the amount of suffering in the world, which is not ‘compromise’, it’s a positive step. One burger a year is an improvement and even if that’s all you can manage it’s better than nothing.
and for all the other people who will find it easy, it’s important to still have a message dissenting the idea that it’s always difficult. I’m saying that going all out and finding if you even need to compromise is better than assuming from the start that a compromise is your only viable option.
No assumptions made here, just the observation that a positive step is not a compromise.
One change I made early on was to look for ways to shorten the distance from my food, become familiar with how it gets to my plate and just keep higher standards overall for things like meat.
The experience of buying meat in particular can be heavily abstracted and sanitized. Every big chain supermarket has an area with rows and rows of perfectly packaged cuts. There is not very much information at all about most of it.
Pick up a Styrofoam tray of boneless skinless chicken breasts from the one or two giant conglomerates. Each package is wrapped in plastic. They all have very consistent appearance, evenly colored and equally plump. They are completely odorless. It is chicken but it’s very very far away from being a chicken. It’s been through a lot of hands and miles. You’ve already hit a wall, though, because you’re not getting much more information about that meat besides maybe some marketing terms and a picture of a taco or some shit like that. You’re being sold the idea of it. All of the horrible stuff is obscured. Even the neutral stuff like what it ate, if it was ever sick or given any medications. All that stuff gets pushed into the memory hole and is supposed to never reach the consumer. If you become too curious, and start digging into it on your own, you naturally end up consuming less. They know this.
Contrast that with what’s produced more locally. Try to figure out who in your area is producing with the goal of building up an actual local foodway sustainably. How close can you get to identifiable people actually producing your food? Can you access a co-op, farmers market, CSA?
Folks who do things like regenerative farming and try to build up their soil tend to be very passionate and like to share about it. Visit a nearby farm or ranch. Many have small retail operations. They may deal in larger quantities than you’re used to. Find out the process. If an animal is involved, how is it cared for and what does it do all day? Is the animal improving its surroundings or degrading them? Are you willing to meet your food face to face?
IMO if you’re going to continue eating meat, you owe it to your food to unpack this stuff, examine how it makes you feel to literally “know how the sausage is made”, form deeper connections with your food and community, and find opportunities to make positive changes to your buying habits.
ETA:
not everyone will be able to stomach peeking behind the curtain. But that’s actually good. It means you’re a compassionate human being, and that feeling can be harnessed and channeled into better personal choices.
I’m just tired of seeing all meat-eating equated, too. The Styrofoam chicken is in a completely different category from a fresh whole chicken acquired locally from, say, a nearby farm that prioritizes regenerative practices.
Compare the true costs and impacts of each. You might forget they’re the same species. It turns out that, if you simply let a chicken just… do its chicken things and provide it with what it already knows it needs to satisfy its drives, its natural behaviors and outputs can be directed to benefit the rest of the system. It’s not easy. This is a complex system, and there’s a lot to learn. But if you can get it right, the chicken is healthy and satisfied, it improves other parts of the system during its life, has at least net-zero if not positive net impact environmentally, and you still get to sell it at the end if that’s what you want your operation to be.
The best arguments for not eating meat disagree specifically with what happens at the end of, e.g., a meat chicken’s life. I know not to argue against that. It’s a principled moral stance.
There will probably always be people who want to eat meat. It is very deeply ingrained human impulse. I think it desperately needs to be scaled way way back. The big players in the conventional national industry need to be seized and taken apart, yesterday. Everything good and useful there needs to be pried out of their hands, brought local, and distributed among the people.
If the tables were turned, and local, sustainable models were the norm, we’d eat way less of it, feel way better, and have the community profit instead of extracted from. “Big chicken” would not exist like it does now. We’d be having completely different conversations.
While I agree with the sentiment, I still struggle a bit with this rhetoric. When it comes to misogyny or rasicsm you wouldn’t tell someone to just try and do less of it. The meat & dairy industry is still a whole lot of abuse and exploitation, and I think everyone is probably on board with having nothing to do with it. The friction is just too high I guess.
Actually yes you would. For the average person in the privileged position, “trying to do less racism” or “trying to be less misogynistic” is the crux of actioning allyship, especially when people are imprinted and socialized from a young age to be/act racist and misogynistic without knowing or understanding it. Kids can’t necessarily control that, but trying to undo it by being less racist and less misogynistic day by day is the necessary work of anti-racism and feminism.
It also ignores that even allies almost always still hold some misoginy or racism, simply due to upbringing. True allies have to admit that we’re not done progressing.
Not only allies. There is a lot of internalization of misogyny, racism, homophobia, transphobia, etc. if you are a member of one of the affected groups but were raised in such environment.
I agree, but I think framing the goal is important.
I think the better way to go about it is to commit fully from the start. Maybe there’s some hiccups, and then you can reset and try again. I guess it’s very personal however. Some people might benefit from another mindset. Anything that gets people away from abuse, I’m all for.
The friction is precisely why I recommend start small. Better someone eat less meat and stick with it long term, than a full meat diet long term because they went completely meatless at once for a week or two and couldn’t handle it
Idk, these are very different things. If I think about how much I hate (some group) then I may be a racist based on that alone. If I don’t consume animal products but I fantasize about eating a cheeseburger I would still be a vegan.
Nobody is going to literally say “just do less racism” but in practice we often only deal with small parts of someone’s racism.
On a societal level that IS how we progress… Sorry but don’t let idealism block progress
comparing women and minorities to animals is what misogynists and racists do
Agreed.
And realizing that all humans are animals is what biologists do.
Analogies don’t prove anything, so we can play this game all day
That’s the thing. If we could use less meat, use less cars, use less fossil fuels, we would all be happier. But me choosing to do these things sounds to people as just bending over for somebody else to use what I don’t use. I just want a happier lifestyle? I’m not doing it for politics or self sacrifice, I’m just taking a step backwarda and realizing that mcdonalds sucks, car commuting sucks.
But I will use the car when I need to go to the countryside and there is no BETTER alternative!
to a vegan it kinda sounds equivalent to “just don’t be racist most days of the week, thats a good start”
Its not even close to the same. Meat is still food, and it is still nourishment to eat. There is nothing nourishing about bigotry. Its still correct to be vegan. But let’s be grounded in our discourse.
Nah
Obligatory mention that you don’t need to cut out meat from your life entirely to have a significant impact on your carbon footprint and your health. Going mostly vegetarian is also an option and its basically been the default of humanity since the agricultural revolution.
“But it’s awkward in social settings”, “What if I’m going out to eat”, “What if it’s the only option”, “What if I am trying but don’t realize something has an animal product”
Idk dude then eat meat in those settings I guess. 95% of your food is consumed outside of those settings so just be 95% vegan or vegetarian.
This. The stuff I cook at home is 100% vegetarian, which is most of my meals. I simply stopped buying meat when I’m grocery shopping.
When I visit people I eat whatever they have, if they have good vegetarian options i prefer that though.
When I’m going out to eat I do the same. If you’re not in the mood to have a discussion about it during lunch with your coworkers or whoever just tell them that you do eat meat but chose that one vegetarian option because it looked tasty or whatever.
Since people in my social surrounding think mostly the same I’m about 99% vegetarian.
It’s really beef that is the vast majority of emissions just cutting that out of your diet gets most of the environmental benefits of vegetarian.
And sheep. Cutting dairy is generally a pretty easy swap.
In this economy I’m buying less meat just because it’s so expensive
Sadly the price of beans and tofu is also rising, unless you buy in bulk.
25lbs of pinto beans and 20 lbs of dry rice is a month of staple meals and costs ~$35 at costco
Obligatory mention that the “carbon footprint” is a tool of the billionair class to put all the blame that belongs to them on us, the consumer without any real power in the markets.
So the best way to cut down on carbon footprint is to be politically engaged. Without systemic change your personal sacrafice will not really do anything.
We have a new word for it where I live; flexitarian (not a joke). It’s like you’d eat meat sometimes. Sounded weird but I actually like it now.
I think I know this word since the late 2000s.
I’m in this picture and feel pretty neutral about that.
One time I had a hardcore combo meth-heroin addict who was vegan who candidly told me something to the effect of ‘idgaf what I put in my body I just have a moral problem with the livestock industry’ and I was like ‘you know what, based.’ The core issue of that conversation was that dietary sent a roll with dinner and they were like ‘naaah I can tell by the texture they used cows butter’ and like many things in the hospital they’re probably right and also at least they recognized I had no way of fixing it.
No its not fine to oppress others even if you know you are wrong to. You sound like a founding father who writes that slavery is wrong but brutally exploits slaves anyway.
Yup. The leftism leaves so many leftists’ bodies the moment animal liberation comes up. If you recognize the problem, don’t be complacent on the solution.
Unlike so many other rights struggles, basic veganism doesn’t require action, but rather the cessation of harmful actions. In that regard, it’s easier than taking action against other forms of exploitation: simply stop consuming animal products. Plant-based alternatives are readily available (I went vegan in a food desert) and are better for you than eating some poor animal’s flesh.
The biggest hurdle, is the meat-eating culture, and how it is the dominant one in many places, right now. People need certain mental strenght to go againt the culture around them, especially when they have been raised up with it, and not all have that. If all people around you are vegans, and it is considered the norm, a lot of people would become vegan too, just to fit in. As long as meat-eating is seen as normal and people are raised to believe it is normal, many people will continue, even if they agree vegans are right.
Be the change. We’d get nowhere if everyone lets that stop them.
Oh yes, absolutely. I was trying more to make a point, about how it is important to understand the reasons behind, if we want to affect that behavior.
Certainly I would have a hard time being vegan if I visited Korea for instance, but there are ways. I look at them as different difficulty settings.
Also, the ethos is to avoid harming animals as much as practicable which will vary by individual and situation.
You can be a shitty vegan, it’s not against the rules hehe. Like you can avoid obvious meat or dairy but not bother reading the fine print—that’s better than most people. Or you can try your best but then go eat your craving on the second Sunday of every month, or give yourself two Mulligans a week, or whatever you want. There really are no rules.
Though I’d argue that once you secure your sources of regular plant based food, it’s actually quite easy to just go all the way and stick with it.
This was me and I still think it’s important to sit with this incongruity rather than try to weasel your way out of it with broken logic. Sit with the discomfort of being in conflict with your own ethical knowledge and let it work on you.
I’m not going to look down on someone who eats animal products even though they know better, because I was them not long ago. I know what it feels like to be on both sides of this, as do most vegans.
I would just urge them to keep thinking about it and trying in different little ways to reduce their reliance on animal products here and there.
If you’re open minded about veganism and the problems with animal farming you’re so much closer than you think to actually being able to do it yourself.
100% agree. That’s why I detest people that know it’s wrong, and then say things like what OP in the meme does about how you can “just be wrong” and “just live your life” at the expense of your victims. It’s not a personal choice when there are victims involved, and when you know there are victims and you have the ability to stop, you need to stop.
But when it comes to actually talking to people about this stuff, I agree with gently encouraging them to not run away from their cognitive dissonance and to follow those thoughts to their logical conclusions.
I forgot who I stole it from, but veganism is my favorite example of a position that has nearly unassailable reasoning, but is still utterly unconvincing to most people.
The age old question. Do people make decisions using reasoning? Or do they make decisions based on emotions, and rationalise them afterwards using their reasoning?
I’d say the balancing factor tends to be effort. We are, as living creatures, lazy. That’s how you survive. The level of empathy you need to acquire before the suffering of a chicken you will never meet is going to compete with your desire to eat easily available delicious food made from them is going to have to be very high.
And once you make your choice you’re not going to internalise the idea that you are knowingly operating from a moral code informed by an acceptance of laziness are you? That conflicts with the self identity of being a rational and good person.
Sometimes one, sometimes the other, sometimes somewhere in the middle.
[deleted]
Not really. It comes from the position that animals are people, or at least more worthy of consideration than the wants of humans. Neither of which are true in the eyes of basically everyone. Now arguing against factory farming seems to actually be unassailable.
Maaan. That is me, with so many things. At least I’m moving in the right direction, or so I like to tell me.
Your getting ready for your moment to strike. I believe in you.
Imagine someone being disturbed because you choose not to eat something. 🤣
It’s usually vice versa: someone who chose not to eat something is disturbed by anyone and everyone else who does not do the same
Well the meat industry does in fact affect climate (synthetic fertilizers are made with fossil methane), which indeed disturbs everyone.
But whatever you choose not to eat has absolutely no effect on anyone.
true for any industry. look for how badly we have fucked up our soil
it does. what I choose to not eat I need to compensate, so there is no choice of not eating something, only real choice is what to eat
You forget to consider amounts. Some industries and foods have more effect than others, and the less you eat, the less of an effect you have.
*the less humans are on the planet, the lesser footprint we leave. It should be handled this way but alas, we are not even close
The reason we take care of a fish tank, is to maintain the fish.
We did not setup the planet to plant humans here now, did we?
You did not setup a planet.
Exactly. So what are you trying to say with that fishtank?
Consider the amount of corn and soy grown for livestock.
consider the amount of whatever we will have to grow to substitute meat
That would be much less than what we grow for that meat.
Possibly. Does it sound like “yeah, the problem of humans pushing other life forms into starvation and extinction is solved with this one simple trick”?
It doesn’t. But you pointed out soil degradation. Just wanted to point out the impact of animal agriculture on soil degradation.
As you said, we can only choose what to eat.
Yup. We are doing all kinds of wrong things
I don’t care what people eat. I can genuinely go months or years without thinking about vegans. I never challenged any vegan, vegetarian or whatever other diet out there.
I have been bothered by vegans on multiple occasions including at restaurants more than once.
[deleted]
I’ve had this exact mentality until one day I just stopped eating meat, and generally nothing bad happened to me. It’s not like I miss it, I didn’t lose anything, there’s no sacrifice in my daily life. I just no longer participate in the direct consumption of the product of (still existing and still supported by my work via taxes) the terrible pipeline of infinite suffering, which is something I guess. In the past I’ve also quit smoking and I can tell you dropping animal products from my diet was much easier. So much, it felt underwhelming.
I don’t tend to talk about it, because I know how my “whining” about meat eating would be perceived, especially remembering how I myself loathed anyone who tried to convince me that eating meat might be bad. It’s just such a silly thing to defend and keep doing. Just gobble up those beans, man. They’re delicious. Leave the cow alone. Organize to overthrow the capital class. Marinate your tofu. Don’t be silly. Kill fascists, not the piggies. Come on.
I have a little suffering every now and then as a treat. But I have greatly reduced my intake.
My only issue as a vegan is in the social sphere. I always feel like the weird one, or that if someone cooks a meal just for me, I’m taking a lot of space (not too sure how to say this in English). If appreciate the kindness but it makes me feel awkward.
But I like being silly!
My experience was the same, I expected a lot of friction dropping meat, but there was just nothing, which felt almost laughable. I do have friends however that have struggled to drop it, so it varies I guess.
Dairy and eggs was a bit harder, because it’s included in so many products and dishes I regularly ate. Takes a bit of time and energy, but when the switch is made, I would say its pretty smooth sailing
Vegans don’t want you to not have fun in life. We want you to live your life and let others live theirs, too.
People don’t wanna by hypocrites as if that can ever be truly avoided
Tldr: my jagged journey to being a shitty vegan started with admitting it was ethically superior and then just trying things for fun/challenge.
That was my attitude basically ever since I seriously thought about the ethics for maybe 10 whole minutes. I mean it’s obvious. But it didn’t impact anything I did until I lived on my own for a while. Then I started by cutting out the obviously reprehensible options like restaurants that support factory farming, cheap machine produced stuff, etc. I’d still eat trash from time to time, but I tried to shop for more ethical sounding options, like free to roam stuff.
Many years later I slowly started cooking vegetarian meals more than anything else, and would joke with my wife "look: totally vegan… Except for all the cheese lol. " 100% vegan meals then became a personal challenge then, so tried to make them good without cheese. Nothing bad happened.
I always said I could never be vegan because of cheese, but then I thought what if I JUST quit cheese and dairy (just obvious sources, but not like if it’s in a piece of toast and I can’t tell). Again nothing bad happened. Actually my vegetarian friends were really supportive and showed me lots of vegan dishes.
I still had eggs every day for breakfast and the occasional fish, like sardines or tuna sandwiches. I didn’t know how I could ever quit my morning eggs, and had even tried a couple times.
Then I saw a vegan thread on lemmy here and just asked someone what they ate for breakfast and they gave me a few ideas and I decided to try yet another tofu scramble and that just did it.
I did feel sluggish for a day or two, and maybe a little bit “off” for a week but not even as bad as a cold. Kind of like a hangover. I just stuck with it and ate a bit more to make up for any loss in nutrition, throw in a daily vitamin, and that was just it. And yup, nothing bad happened. Eventually I felt great. The whole time I guess it was just a couple sluggish days away from me.
I said maybe I’d eat meat or dairy just to be easy from time to time, but then Thanksgiving came and went and I really didn’t feel like it. I just brought lentil patties and ate some sides until I wasn’t hungry anymore. Easy peasy.
If anything I feel like going vegan has de-dramatised food and eating for me. It’s simple: you just eat nutritious food that makes you feel good, until you’re satisfied.
But I’m just at the outset. I don’t vet everything, I just don’t partake in anything that is made with animal products as far as I can tell, and as much as I easily can.
I think I could easily go vegan 5 days a week, but I could never give up my weekend breakfasts with eggs, cheese, and the occasional sausage or bacon. Not to mention the homemade lattes :(
If you do it, you can say you’re still 5/7 days superior, and that’s a perfect score
We’ll both catch flack from the good vegans, but if that’s what you think you can handle, go for it. Just keep an open mind and keep experimenting. :)
I won’t argue for most of the animal-based market but I reject the idea that eggs are inherently unethical. Some of the ways they are produced certainly are (the vast majority even, I assume), but chickens just lay eggs in their day to day life and I don’t think anything is wrong with eating them, though I do acknowledge that finding ethical options is probably more complex than just paying a bit extra for the free range cartons.
I should find a local producer again, then they are usually both cheaper and not factory farmed.
Wild hens lay 10 to 15 eggs a year. We selectively bred them into the horror of daily laying.
We did a similar thing with sheep, they shouldn’t have that much wool at all
Guinea hens lay 30 - 180 depending on climate, food availability and predation in the wild. Domestic hens are not “bred” into daily laying, their instinctive nature to fill the nest drives them. Appropriate feed, housing and hydration allows that. That, in no way, excuses industrial egg production. However, small numbers raised as pets for egg production are treated very well and mourned at their passing. Is that acceptable?
Domestic hens were still bred into significantly higher egg output capacities.
If you want to tangent off specifically into niche birds, sure a guinea hen has a high natural egg laying capacity, as you stated, if you manipulate it’s environment. Typically in the wild, however, it would lay ~10-20 per year. Your more typical bred domestic chicken that this conversation is actually about has more than twice the capacity of the guinea hen’s natural limit. Let’s keep on topic here though, yeah?
The unethical part is the reason there’s so many more hens than cockerels (the male chicks get killed off early).
Let me know if you find a farmer who lets the males live, feeds them and cares for them, until they peacefully reach old age, getting absolutely nothing from them apart maybe the joy of seeing them happy.
Yeah this is why I could maybe be vegetarian in the future but never vegan.
Didn’t realize they are the king of what can be argued.
Well now you do ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Well obviously this person disagrees 🤷
If you are eating boring meat like chicken breast or ground beef you might as well make it vegan or get some fat on it
I have omnivore dentition. To take advantage of it I consume seitan through raw spinach through rare prime rib. The rest of you are welcome to dine on whatever.
You also have the genetic capability to procreate with your mother
Hail seitan!
Yeah the vegans are definitely right.
Munches on my cheese
I don’t argue about whether or not people should be vegan. I just know that my quality of life would be vastly diminished as I really don’t enjoy most vegan food. If they can nail lab created meat, I’m all for it.
I think you might be shocked how easy it is to eat tasty vegan food, saying you dont enjoy"most vegan food" implies to me that you’ve only had a really limited selection of what’s available. Highly recommend trying ethiopian food.
Ethiopian veggies are great but yebeg wot is on a different level.
There’s tasty vegan food for sure hut there’s usually a slightly tastier horrifically unethical alternative.
I agree with op, I think vegans are right, I basically support them but ain’t converting. Realizing they were right on food made me a lot less angry that other people don’t feel the same way I do about sweatshop clothes and they, like me are doing their best. Some prioritise animals in tortorous conditions, others prioritise kids in poor ones, others look after drug addled first worlders, everyone’s got their own moral priorities.
Nobody can force you, all I can really hope for is that you try different vegan food and at least give a shit enough to eat less animals. None of us can be perfect, but we also need to be able to care about multiple causes, and not eating animals is a very easy and tasty one. I care about sweatshop clothes, I care about slave labor in the supply chain for lithium ion batteries, and the genocide in Gaza. I can choose who to vote for and who to shop with and what to eat based on all those goals.
It’s true we’ve only each got like enough moral bandwidth to champion X number of causes it seems. I still view my goal as doing to most with my capacity though, even if I fall short on most.
The issue with that is that cooking is difficult and eating out is expensive.
Yes, but also no. Cooking can be difficult. I’ve built the entirety of how I eat around ease. For example a pot of chili for the week with some cornbread isn’t difficult. I do “burrito bowls” with beans, rice, avocado, salsa, lime juice. I like to air fry tofu and toss it in sauce.
That only works if you already know how to cook the dish.
You’re overthinking it, the things I do don’t even really follow recipes. What’s gonna go in a chili? Whatever you want. Beans, tomatoes, tomato sauce, mushrooms, peppers, zucchini, just sautee some veggies, toss in your beans, seasoning, and sauce, then simmer for a while until it looks good. Cooking pasta, for example is also super easy. Sautee some vegetables, toss in a jar of premade sauce and simmer while you cook noodles. This isn’t baking :3
And you think that’s going to make it easier for people who don’t have much experience with cooking? Throwing random stuff together and making it taste good is a skill, especially if it involves unfamiliar ingredients like tofu.
There’s really easy basics to work with, is more my point. Cooking rice or beans isn’t hard, having an idea of what vegetables you like is something most of us already know to some degree. You can always follow recipes if you don’t want to experiment on your own. Also, it’s not like every meal has to be home cooked? I buy a frozen pizza or nuggets or something pretty often.
None of this is really any different if someone isn’t eating vegan and doesn’t know how to cook.
I guess I just don’t like tofu or vegetables
Tofu can definitely be one a lot of people dislike, I’d usually argue that it’s a food that absorbs flavor and therefore taste depends on how you cook it, but you don’t need to eat tofu. Veggies, on the other hand, are a very important source of fiber and vitamins and just aren’t optional if you want to be healthy, even if you eat animal products. They’re a pretty broad range of food, I’m confident you can find something you like. Growing up, my mom would just microwave canned veggies with some butter and salt and I always found it pretty bland, but it doesn’t take a lot to make them really good. That’s actually why I use chili as an example, all the flavors meld together and it becomes savory (or spicy in my case).
I mean, depending on where you’re from, you can already get most meat products in a convincing non-lab alternative, at least from what I hear from colleagues. (I don’t have an opinion on this, because I don’t like meat. 🫠)
That is definitely not the case. Most meat alternatives are still pretty awful
Are you from the US?
I very much doubt it would be unless you’re already artificially limiting what you’re eating
Thanks for your honestly but most food is vegan just with a piece of meat thrown in, or with cheese added on top. If you like those things, you can just sub out the animal part.
I know arguing over personal taste is a fool’s errand, but your tastes are malleable if you’re ever motivated to challenge yourself.
I eat a lot of meals that are just grilled chicken, German sausage, or charcuterie plate. They really aren’t the same without meat and dairy.
I used to too. I get it.
Do I even get a choice in the matter? I hat this town. J tried to escape with tofu, cant even sneakily become vegan.
ok.
i eat vegetarian most of the month but i gotta have a steak at some point
[deleted]
Good on you. I poisoned myself once because I used lemon juice instead of vinagre to lower the ph while making it.
Stick to the recipe, the ingredients and keep everything clean.
“You don’t eat the food I like, so you’re WRONG!!! 🤪” - 😂
I don’t care what you eat. Do you care what I eat?
[deleted]
This is a super hot take so bare with me, but the conditions of a lot of vegan food production are also often harmful to the humans that grow the food (I’m talking blood produce) and the growth in popularity of certain superfoods have severely damaged the ecosystems that indigenous populations in the areas where they’re from depended on.
This is not to say being vegan is bad. It’s obviously proven to be better for the environment, and the way that animals are treated is absolutely inhumane.
This is to say however that we should be demanding sustainability in all our food consumption and respect for all living beings. But mostly, it’s to say fuck capitalism.
By vegan food production you must mean processed fake meat? Not all vegans eat a horrible diet.
If you mean vegan food production as in normal non-meat foods such as vegetables than that’s a while opinion. Unless you are Jain or just want to die, we got to eat something.
Most food production in general kills a lot more than I would like especially vegetable and fruit production. Not much to do on the regard though.
Yes I did mean veg and fruit, but I mean that obviously we need to eat but we need to do it in a sustainable and fair way.
Currently a lot of the produce in Canada & the US is grown by migrant labour where people are treated horribly. In Mexico, many of the agricultural production sites are owned by cartels. Quinoa used to be a primary food source for quechuan (peruvian indigenous) people but when it grew in popularity in the west, it became too expensive for those who depended on it. There are many more examples.
What there is to do about it is to demand better agricultural practices and support fair-trade, co-ops, and sustainable food vendors. In the same way we should be / are demanding cruelty-free and sustainable animal products.
Fully agree. Good point on labor too, I was considering insects and rodents.
That’s the thing though, why should plants be more eligible for eating than animals? Both are living. Animals are closer to us, so we can understand them better, but that doesn’t mean we aren’t being just as harmful to plants.
I don’t think there’s anything inherently wrong with eating another animal for sustenance. Just the same as there isn’t anything wrong with eating a plant for sustenance. What matters is what we do before we eat them.
Plants cannot think or feel as animals can. Arguing a tomato has the emotions and thought of a dog or pig is just silly.
Killing a pig versus a tomato is not the same thing dawg
this can’t be proven
As we can. We understand how animals think, because evolutionarily they’re closer to us. We don’t really understand how plants “think” or “feel”, we just decide that because they don’t have what we have that makes it okay.
Just making up whatever you want aren’t you?
“I’m not a plant therefore idk what their nonthinking minds are thinking”
Who is we in your statement? Pretty sure modern botany understands how plants work and interact.
That understanding has its limits. We’re just cracking on the ways plants (and fungi) may communicate with one another via external chemical signalling. There are things beyond our current understanding, and how a plant “feels” is completely alien to us. Hell, the function of how people “feel” is still not fully understood.
My point is that it’s ultimately arbitrary. We feel pain, and we can imagine animals feeling pain in a similar way, because their neurological systems are similar. We assume plants don’t feel pain - and we can confidently say they don’t feel pain the same way we do, but we can’t say they don’t feel pain at all in a way we don’t yet understand.
Either way though, both plants and animals are living beings, and you are denying them the same opportunity to life by eating them.
Are you stupid? Genuine question, because animals need to eat as well for you to pay someone to murder them. Even going from the assumption that plants suffer too, a plant based diet still causes much fewer plants to die compared to feeding the plants inefficiently to animals to then eat the animals.
Liar. You’re just being a dick here. No bother though.
Like I said before, what matters is what we do before we eat them. Industrial farming practices are where I see the real problems at - and the key thing is that this is an issue for both meant and plant farming.
Plant based diets can definitely be more efficient, although palm oil is also vegan (and palm oil farming is currently the cause of a massive amount of habitat loss), so just because you have a plant based diet doesn’t mean it’s perfect. But what I’m saying here is that eating plants is not inherently more righteous than eating animals. In practice, it almost certainly is (mainly because of farming practices), but not inherently.
eating meat today doesn’t cause it to have been fed in the past. events in the future cannot cause events in the past. eating meat doesn’t cause past suffering.
are you stupid
you, uh, doing okay champ?
Award for not even tangentially hitting the point I made goes to you my dear zoophile <3
calling me a zoophile is baseless.
What do you call someone who abuses animals for their own pleasure? Is paying someone else to do the abuse for you so much better?
I’m not doing either of those
I addressed the assertion that eating meat causes suffering. that’s simply untrue.
So you have no problems with slave labour because the suffering already happened when you buy its products? What about a video of a rape? The rape already happened so it won’t cause further suffering getting off to it.
How hard is it to understand that these animals get tortured and murdered for your consumption and you don’t just happen to come upon a corpse accidentally. Your consumption drives the production.
this is some pretty tortured logic.
You would know a thing or two about torture, don’t you?
you’re wrong. it’s not causal.
lol
“Super foods” are kind of fucked, and that’s part of being a good vegan—researching and avoiding things that cause harm (as much as practicable). But those are more a thing in wellness clean eating fad diet circles. Most vegan staples are like rice, beans, pulses, and random veggies.
I’m doing more good as an antinatalist than any vegan
I’m doing both!
Not that it’s a contest :p
They hated him, for he spoke the truth.
Nah, there are definitely some vegetarian and vegan foods (especially when we’re talking ultraprocessed foods) that are worse for the environment and worse for your health than just plain meat or cheese.
Genuinely which ones? Everything I can think of is better than meat. Largely because the cows eat a lot of food in the first place with most of it being wasted.
It’s been a good long while since I made my comparisons but i believe Quorn was worse than chicken (but not as bad as beef obviously). In Sweden we also have Anamma which used to be very good, but at some point they removed their classic formulations and suddenly added like 30% sugar to everything (and doubled the price for good measure). Not sure if they’ve walked that back by now, hopefully they have.
Oh you are talking about fake meat stuff, I was thinking of normal ingredients.
No, it’s the ultraprocessed stuff that can be pretty bad. But I think a lot of things have happened in the past decade during which there was also a huge focus on sustainability, so I think the market is better now than it used to be. I’m not up to speed anymore.
In the UK there’s a sweet maker called Candy Kittens. They make, like, vegan Haribo (only better) that tastes really really nice.
They’ve started making their own vegan peanut M&M’s. Instead of chocolate they use a shit ton of palm oil.
It’s “ethically sourced” palm oil, but that’s still a sour thought after you’ve devoured a whole bag of tasty sweet treats in one sitting. It’s still increasing the market capacity for palm oil, which in turn increases demand to destroy habitats eg orangutans in Indonesia and other SE Asian islands.
TL;DR palm oil is vegan.
Wait isn’t chocolate vegan though? Why substitute chocolate with palm oil?
Cocoa is vegan. Chocolate is usually made with milk products to make it more palatable. The chocolate in peanut M&M’s has milk in it, so they are not vegan.
Except these days milk is largely substituted with palm oil recipes, which is much cheaper, but creates a worse product (often described as waxy) while the industry producing it is tearing down virgin forests for farm land.
Ah, OK. I basically only eat dark chocolate so I forgot that “candy” usually is non-vegan.
Hear hear.
Plants are living beings, also. The fact is, unless you photosynthesise, you likely have to consume another living being to survive.
What nearly everyone can agree on is that industrial farming practices are harmful. Not just to the living things we farm, but also to the consumers, who end up consuming a lesser product that is often contaminated by industrial processes that cut corners to save on cost.
I feel like you’re not getting the vegan ethos…
In the era of awesome spices and sauces and wide ranging produce available year round there is very little reason to eat meat.
But also yummy & convenient
I think if you want to be vegan, go for it. Doesn’t work for me. And I’m all good with hunting.
edit: addressing the misunderstanding for down voters. Most hunters don’t go out to kill, but some do. It’s not an easy thing, you remember it for life at least I do. Still have a picture of my dog for decade on my phone. I don’t think the whole hunting thing of trailing a deer is right. I only go for confirmed kills. Separate the spine from the brain. Lung/Heart shots are stupid. If I miss, they live another day. A lot of people hate this mentality.
I’m not gonna try and convince you, I promise, but just out of curiosity why doesn’t it work for you?
I get sick from a lot of foods. Don’t get me wrong, I tried it for six months and have never felt sicker. Can’t have wheat, lentils are poison. I don’t want to live a life of rice and beans, granted I love beans and rice (I get fancy Hokkaido rice). Gourds/pumpkins/etc have too much sugar. I don’t want to take supplements. Constantly being hungry wasn’t fun either.
So it’s not as I don’t eat vegetables–onions, garlic, cucumbers, tomatoes, leeks, eggplant, potatoes. But I have to have meat and cheese. I loved making salads until earlier this year… hence my user name.
When I would bike 30 miles a day, I didn’t want to eat a box spaghetti. Like cool my roommate said yeah just do that, I just got a burger halfway. Also the cold makes you a furnace; I mentioned this in another post.
One aspect is that, I lived in places that had ethical farming. And you would take responsibility for a life you take. This goes further than animals.
Yeah that makes a lot of sense. All anyone can do is their best and it sounds like that’s what you’re doing 🫡
I don’t think they’re correct, but also why care? If anything they’re helping the environment and living the life they want to live. Good for them and more power to them.
Ig the point is they’re ethically correct just from an environmental standpoint. We should all be doing more to reduce emissions, and veganism is one of the easiest ways to do that.
I just like annoying vegans. They call me the most metal slurs like “carnist” and “bloodmouth”.
Do you think there might be a connection between “I like annoying vegans” and them reacting negatively, that says more about you than it does them?
I’ve never met a vegan like that, but I have met dozens of dickhead schoolboy bullies who think eating meat makes them manly, and pwning vegans with their hilarious same two jokes every time even more so
I don’t pretend I’m not an asshole. Most of the time I use my powers for good. This context is purely a guilty pleasure of mine, no excuses, I just like it.
Just saying, I’ve met dozens of annoying vegans. And I’ve heard both of those insults.
The other middle schoolers must think you are a bad ass.
I’ve been around a LOT of vegans and I have never heard those terms… is this an online thing?
came from the vegan community here on lemmy
So like… one of THE most online platforms possible. Got it, lmao
Lemmy is one of the social media platforms of all time.
NGL, I do like Lemmy for the fact that I can be 95% sure that I’m arguing with an actual human instead of a bot, unlike every other platform. The ragebait is organic 😊
Part of why I’m here instead of reddit these days. Even if I 100% disagree with the other person, at least they’re a person.
I dunno why, but now Im really craving a good steak.
As someone who gets hard af headaches and migraine from processed and older foods, I’d say they are wrong. at least for me. No way I eat vegan when there are only 3 types of legumes that don’t give me a headache
Define “processed”? Because most forms of meat and pretty much all forms of dairy are processed…
Boiling a damn potato, without adding salt in the water or even peeling it, makes it processed already…
Preach, I hate the label too… People try so hard to make it useful but it’s just not… Plenty unprocessed foods will kill you and plenty processed foods are amazingly healthy.
Yea that’s not what this comment is about but try again
With just a little bit of common sense this wouldn’t be so hard to differentiate. Oats are processed, yes (take the grain, separate the husk, press it, pasteurize it, package it, etc.), but nobody will tell you its processed food, right? Also isn’t transport a unit operation, wouldn’t make that anything that got moved in an industrial fashion processed? Get a life if that trips you up
Ithink you’re the one lacking common sense - misusing words because of trends. :D
Yea didn’t say that I eat processed meats or any form of cheese either, but I can eat fresh meat and fish, eggs and milk. I can also eat young legumes without getting headaches but I am in testing on that front. Its not about processed but rather age of the product, anything that gets industrially processed (especially protein rich foods) is probably too old.
Edit: fixed typos and inserted missing words for clarity
Yeah, i found that out recently, it’s related to the level of histamine in the food.
It’s tyramine for me, but similar concept and similar foods
Oh! Nice to learn about that! I’ll keep an eye out, although using antihistamines is usually good to clear the headache, thiamine seems to act as an histamine release trigger, so it could be that as well…
The wikipedia page says that there is more and more attention given to the level of biogenic amines in food, so it’s a good news!
That is interesting to learn. Well as long as tomatos are fine for me I am gonna rule out histamine, but eggplants and broccoli that makes me go ouch
Here’s a detailed list for histamine, in case it might be useful for anyone: histaminintoleranz.ch/…/SIGHI-Leaflet_HistamineEl…
here a tyramine list The biggest differences are tomatoes being fine and broccoli not being fine. Idk how scientific your list is, but all tyramine list are vibes only. E.g. people on reddit being like “yea this gave me a migraine” + the substances grow in a similar fashion, so its no wonder they match mostly 1:1
What a false comparison - unprocessed meat vs processed non-meat. I’m sorry if your lack of food diversity growing up has made you sensitive to beans but you would certainly survive just fine as and when meat was not available. People can live off nothing but potatoes when necessary - ask the Irish. Though it’s also not good to rely on a single type of food - also ask the Irish.
It’s comfort convenience and pleasure. If you could moderate those things in the face of moral responsibility towards other animals then you would indeed stop eating meat. Though it’s a lot easier to pretend it’s not your choice isn’t it?
I should say I eat meat occasionally. And I use technology from companies destroying the world and buy products from companies owned by people I despise. I do not live up to my own ideal ethics and neither do 99% of humans who ever lived. Accepting moral truths does not require you to be morally perfect. It’s a direction to pull towards not a binary measurement of if you’re a valid person.
I’m in the same boat, but with rampant inflammation from endometriosis in my bladder and bowels. I have so many food intolerances that meat is one of the safest things I can eat.
I hate the taste of meat. I hate the texture of meat. This isn’t for pleasure. I can’t eat potatoes or soy, but I love potatoes and soy. I just can’t eat it without pissing blood.
Vegans still still come and try to argue with me about this. They are massively ablest.
Your name is incredibly funny to me in that context. Anyways, stay strong and hopefully you find some nice recipe to make it a more pleasant journy!
Insufferable fucks downvoting because muh-not-perfectly-reasoned. There are years of brain fog and migraine behind this statement from me. Just because you haven:'t heard anything about it doesn’t mean its not real. No I did not grow up with a lack of diversity, but I always had headaches so fuck you
Vegans are not correct.
Vegetarians? Arguably yes. Not vegans.
If the cow I’m drinking milk from is living a decent happy life its not immoral for me to drink it.
I’m not even a vegetarian though, so I will say that the spirit of this tweet at least makes sense to me. I get it.
Um, maybe you should look up, why cows give milk in the first place? It’s not like it’s an animal that just randomly produces milk…little hint: why do human mothers produce milk when they gave birth, but don’t do it randomly their whole life 🤔
But is the cow you’re drinking milk from living a decent, happy life? What about the male calves that are born as a result of reproducing milk cows? What happens to them?
This thinking could extend to virtually every choice you make and is completely impossible to systematically justify for an ethical system without going completely and utterly insane.
It is the “Butterfly Effect” of ethics. A select path has impacts beyond the initial obvious moral consideration and then more considerations beyond that.
So where is the line? I don’t know that there is one, but I know that its a waste of energy to follow this line of thinking. One initial intuitive layer of moral consideration is more than the average person even remotely considers, and sometimes not even that much. The way elections have gone in the US over the past few years is a good example of this.
I agree that the line can seem or be arbitrary. I’m just pointing out that the specific example that you gave: “happy cow”, is more a figment of your imagination than a reality. It’s not so much “butterfly effect” as simply “effect”. I’m not judging you. I’m just saying you gave a bad example.
Is the immigrant working in the fields with no healthcare and fleeing ICE living a happy, healthy life? Is the slave worker in Myanmar making the trowel you use in your home garden living a happy, healthy life?
It’s impossible to exist without benefiting from suffering somewhere. At a certain point, you just have to try and do what you can to make it better. In my case, that involves supporting legislation to make the world better, because that will have more impact than a fringe group of people deciding not to wear wool socks.
If you care about those things, and if you consider those necessary to produce crops, then they are also 30-80% necessary to produce a corresponding amount of milk protein.
10-20% of cattle diets are soybeans, corn, or another industrial crop. 25-35% of their protein intake gets converted to milk protein.
Factor in the additional slave labor and worker exploitation involved in all of the other dairy ranching workflows, and it likely makes up the rest of the difference.
Again, if you care about those things.
I don’t understand this line of reasoning, especially as applied to the original context of “vegetarians are right, but vegans go too far”. Nobody here is pretending they avoid any part in any suffering. Indeed, we all determine for ourselves how much we can live with. For many of us, that line shifts with our needs, wants, knowledge and understanding. I just pointed out that the example of a happy cow, living life and providing milk is a fiction, masking the same realities that leads many people to vegetarianism.
As a Vegetarian I disagree. We’re the most schizophrenic when it comes to animal welfare. No meat as we don’t want to kill for our food, but milk and cheese is only possible when we kill calves and eggs are only possible when we shredder 50% of the baby chicks.
Yes, alternatives are starting to pop up, but they are still in the minority here.
If it’s not about animal welfare, but sustainability Vegans also win, because dairy is pretty bad in this aspect too.
there are people who make cheese without killing animals. An example ☞
Élever des chèvres et faire du fromage www.youtube.com/watch?v=UgD8b3UV6qU
You can’t have mass milk products without killing many calf. I use lots of cow cheese but you need to know all process to have milk and cheese needs to kill calfs, as cow stop usual doing milk after something like a year, after a few month of reduced milk production.
In this sense, animals also would die anyways, so eating meat is sometimes justified aswell (would you eat a cow that would die soon anyway or just let it suffer a natural death? And then waste its meat?)
Well, I’m not a vegetarian anyway.
If I was would I eat beef from a cow that was euthanized just before dying painfully and feel ethically consistent? Sure. If someone wants to argue that would make me not a vegetarian in that case I’m not going to give a shit. That’s just arguing about definitions.
Cows need to be pregnant to make milk.
Theyre not? We are apes,apes like of veggies and meat.
Plus, we are one of the most carnivore of the big apes,our guts are adapted to both meat and vegetables, we are not able to decompose celulose.
Crazy it’s like you don’t know one single thing about the vegan viewpoint and are arguing entirely against strawmen.
You know, the way people who are wrong and don’t have the maturity to admit it or at least the education to put forth an actual counter argument might do.
I don’t think anyone would deny we are adapted for an omnivorous diet. But we are omnivores rather than obligate carnivores, so meat consumption does remain a choice rather than an imperative. Should our biology dictate our morality?
No, but our morality cant really dictate our biology either.
Then why did my parents pay a doctor to chop off my foreskin?
Should evolutionary proximity dictate our morality?
We understand animals, because they are closer to us than plants. But plants are also living creatures. The fact is, unless you photosynthesise, every large living being has to consume another to survive.
I think the choice is much more complex than meat vs vegan. I think it comes down to farming practices, particularly industrial farming which min/maxes everything and cuts corners as much as they can get away with to save on cost.
Palm oil is vegan. Yet palm oil farming is the cause of a great deal of habitat and species loss. Palm oil is quietly used in a lot of vegan food.
I’m not sure many vegans would agree that palm oil is vegan it can certainly be part of a plant based diet, which is a large part of being vegan, but really only the beginning.
I do agree however that my major complaint with animal products available today are with modern farming practices more than any kind of egoist notions. It’s crazy to me that you can just walk to the back of any grocery store to the glistering wall of pink sheets and just grab one without any sense of reverence, or thought to what’s required to keep that dreaded wall fed 365 days of the year.
I’d still abstain because I’ve yet to see a farmer, even the good ones, corral or kill their animals in a way that didn’t make me want to riot on the spot.
Imo it’s just too easy to simply abstain.
This is an incredibly succinct way of putting it, thank you.
we are clearly adopted to live in the savannah yet many would choose a constructed home. curious
And? the thing is that still we can make do, its like implying a modern PC cannot run a NES game.
You have to emulate stuff btw.
giving the most benefit of the doubt to you here.
when the post says “vegans are obviously right”, assuming that to mean that humans are made to not eat meat is a very bad faith interpretation. similar equating can happen when someone says all genders are equal and someone pulls out the sexual dimorphism research to claim they aren’t. there’s missing context of what is being said and what is being interpreted. i dont believe there’s a substantial group of vegans claiming humans are incapable or not ‘evolved’ to eat meat.
i am not debating that humans are apes, most carnivore, or adapted to both meat and vegetables. i don’t agree there, citations needed, but taking it as a mere simplification of facts its fine enough.
there’s complexity to the question of eating meat now that society has reached a point where we no longer need it to sustain ourselves. i am not arguing either way here but an argument there exists and we will need to have an answer to it. just like we didnt evolve to be able to see if our eyes fuck up, but we managed to just have spectacles (and surgery) to fix it. we can adopt to a non-meat diet if that is the answer, whether or not we evolved for it.
i am conflicted on if vegans are right. but i can appreciate that they are at least right on pointing towards the question.
So that by itself is a very good question, but the ability of not consuminy it should not mean the obligation(or prohibition), or even the morals on the wheter of eating or not eating meat.
So thats my argument, we really should not matter that much about what is on the meal of people by itself. Maybe, one day, artificial meat becomes better than normal one and we end up replacing meat, and humannity, accidentally, end up as a vegan species by itself.
The thing is that involving the morally good or wrong about something like food shouldnt be a thing if it can be improved or obsoleted.
I appreciate you’re engaging with the question and I’d urge you to keep going.
Here’s a thought experiment: imagine if the only other animals in the planet were other primates, maybe even just Neanderthals. Maybe we ate them in the past, maybe some people still do today. Maybe they’re even farmed. Trapped and milked, or fed and butchered. But it’s all far away from the city, so you don’t even have to think about it, you just go to the back of the store and get your meat or your cheese.
But they are actually people. Not like you and me, sure, but they undeniably have a conscious experience of the world very very similar to ours.
You don’t actually need to eat their body parts or their milk. You can survive just fine without them, it just takes some effort, but most people don’t bother.
Would it still be morally irrelevant whether you ate that meat or not?
It would be more of a thing about sappiency and about their own culture, even considering they could be wildly diferent to us in biology, they could be cephalopods,birds, bears or even plants or funghi,yes, we can survive without them.
My principal point is that que are already asuming too many things about those other sapient beings: -theyre animals that cannot reproduce sexualy vía grafts -they have the same fear death than western people -they may not have canibalistic customs about themselves
And we dont even know if there IS a being that is like that and straight to the point we wouldnt have the alternative to actually subsitute vía emulation.
Being not compulsory to live doens’t mean its not a thing that we can rennounce as fast as a moral vision would like, there is more of nuance and yes, we can survive without animal products but there are big chalenges about It, and more about actually living without them in a normal way,as today we cant really reproduce what meat actually does.
I don’t understand what you mean here. Do you mind clarifying?
I think my answer to this would be that even without worrying over what we don’t know, we can make moral and ethical choices based on what we do know.
It may be imperfect information but if we try our best and admit our ignorance and update our behavior with new information, then I believe we can live in a, for lack of a better word, more virtuous way.
That’s fine because we don’t really need to in order to lead happy, healthy, fulfilling lives. Maybe in the past we did, but basically since the invention of fire starting, it hasn’t been necessary.
(I am not vegan)
Apes eat meat. Humans do industrial farming. These things are not the same.
Which can be more ecologic given newer tech and incentives
It could be, but it isn’t.
Go tell that to a gorilla. Being a great ape, ‘it’ would punch you to a pulp and go eat some “celulose” (sic). You would rot in vain.
apes can eat also bugs, bugs are animals
So what you’re saying is that - in principle - if we took brain cells from say a 90s kid and then infused them with the genetic material of a fully grown adult Vegan, we could cultivate a batch of neurons that not only have perfect memory, but also are never wrong and thus create the perfect thinking machine artificially created intelligence? Of course it’s not like that’s something I would be able to do by myself in my home. Biological computer chips? That’s not real technology don’t look it up its just uhhh ideas for some SciFi shit. But like, you know. In principle. Just hypothetically hypothesizing and all that…
Plants are alive too. Vegans are just plant racists.
Veganism isn’t about not eating what was or is “alive”. It’s about “suffering” (and avoiding it as much as possible).
You can find that fundamental belief in Buddhism or Jainism too. If you think about it, you can probably find it in you. Why would anybody want to make any other sentient body suffer?
Veganism can also be about environmental impact. I’m vegetarian mostly because a meat based diet isn’t sustainable on a global scale. While I’m obviously happy about the reduced suffering, it’s importance is only in second place for me.
Tho maybe veganism is pretty much entirely for reducing animals suffering, I’m only a vegetarian and won’t pretend to know for sure.
that’s confusing. I don’t know how to reply.
why is “environmental impact” concerning you if it’s not for the suffering it causes and will cause?
It’s about the fact that the environment cannot be sustained while everyone eats meat. So it is about the suffering it will cause for me primarily, but to humans and not animals
It’s a widespread misunderstanding but adopting a plant based diet for some reason other than avoiding the exploitation of animals isn’t veganism. Praying five times a day isn’t Islam unless you’re praying to Allah.
Vegan is just not eating stuff from animal, someone’s reasoning for that varies.
We are only just beginnig to understand what plants feel. They have hormons they have pain rezeptors they have a basic neural net.
To assume a plant would not suffer is a little outdated.
Even 20 Yeats ago it was already known that plants do feel pain. they inform surrounding plants about pain and they react to it.
Even if we took that as true, directly eating plants still kills fewer plants than feeding them to animals and then eating those animals.
100% true. Mine was not an anti-vegan comment just a pro-plant comment. I guess many didnt get that.
to assume plants are sentient is a charognard propaganda
outdated? pfff… Receptors doesn’t mean “pain rezeptors”. Don’t seed confusion.
Sentient who said sentient? I said: they suffer if you hurt them. Not more not less.
“Not more not less”? This is the definition of suffering:
as you can, maybe… hopefully… understand, all of those things you wrote above implies sentience. Here, this is from a miracle called wikipedia ☞
this too is from wikipedia ☞
ALL organisms can sense and respond to their environments or else they will be easily killed. Bacterial signalling molecules and receptors exist too.
This is very different to the concept of pain or suffering.
Would you care to elaborate?
Whats is the difference between “sensing pain and reacting to it” to “the concept of pain” you mentioned?
To be clear, they don’t sense “pain”. Virtually every organism has receptor proteins that mediate molecular responses to stimuli. In plants, this might be a molecule from a pathogen, a mechanical thing (like an insect biting a leaf), or a molecule associated with damage (cell wall components or energy molecules being found outside where they’re meant to be). Bacteria might excite their flagella to move away from danger, plants might isolate their cytoplasm to restrict pathogens, but these are well-documented physiological pathways only. Nobody is arguing that bacteria are capable of pain.
Only animals with a nervous system have a sense of “suffering” or “pain”, and sure enough they behave a lot like humans in that respect too (by reacting with a response such as fleeing, fighting, screaming, etc). We have physiological responses too, but plants are a lot more like bacteria than animals in that sense. Having receptors and hormones is quite different to having a complex nervous system.
thank you for patiently explaining
Even if that’s true that plants are conscious and can experience subjective pain (doubt), then it just means we live on a world where it’s really hard to avoid doing harm and that would suck for us as sapient creatures with the knowledge that inflicting pain is wrong, but the end goal would still be to reduce harm to feeling beings as much as practicable.
Concious? Who said that? Thats a little far fetched dont you think? An other comment also, started talking about “sentient plants”
Whats going on with you guys? XD
You dont need to be concious or sentient to feel pain and suffer.
My point still stands exactly as stated doesn’t it? Suffering bad, more suffering worse; reducing suffering better.
100% it does. I didnt attack that. Only that plants dont feel pain. Thats just wrong.
Yeah I don’t believe the point was raised in good faith (it never is), which is why I addressed it in the hypothetical only—to say even if it were true, it still wouldn’t undermine the vegan position on reducing exploitation.
What??
I see, you want me to be the bad guy and to you it doesnt matter if that is the truth or not.
Any chance you are american?
this has a lot of unspoken moral assumptions in it
It sure does, it’s a moral statement. But let me speak them then:
pain is unpleasant and should be avoided as much as practicable
If you care about reducing the pain in others then you should act accordingly
the vegan perspective is to reduce our exploitation of animals as much as practicable
the pain and suffering of animals at the hands of humans matters
we should try to limit the unnecessary pain we cause
there are actions humans can take to lower the amount of pain and suffering in the world
a world with less pain and suffering is preferable to one with more
But seriously, what would you do with the information that plants felt suffering on the level of animals and humans? Would you do nothing with this shocking new evidence?
it also assumes that you can know what will decrease suffering in the future. you can’t.
further, it assumes that inflicting or avoiding suffering is either immoral or moral. only one system I’m aware of states this outright and it’s utilitarianism, which can be summed up " the ends justify the means" which most people think is pretty abhorrent.
Yes and that holds true for all actions—we can never know how our behavior will “sum out” in the future, especially the far far future.
We still make moral decisions based on the imperfect information we have. In fact we have to, because merely existing in the status quo is a moral decision. Even choosing to remove ourselves from existence is a moral decision. On a long enough horizon we can’t tell how anything will play out.
So while can’t know what any of our decisions or lack of decisions will amount to in the future, we still try, and update our assumptions as time goes on.
But there’s no point in arguing whether reducing suffering is moral or not if you’re not even going to grant that attempting to reduce suffering is a worthy goal.
which is why consequentialism can’t actually tell us the right thing to do. it’s a fatally flawed ethical approach.
since ethics can’t be derived from possible future outcomes, they must come from somewhere else. kant proposes it’s the categorical imperative. divine command theorists propose from God or a holy text.
neither of those systems axiomatically say to reduce suffering.
I feel like you’re getting lost in the world of abstracts. I’m talking subjective, fallible, imperfect, morality—not objective ethics.
There is a concrete instance of a chicken that is being tortured for profit currently. If you’re against that, it’s morally self-consistent to avoid contributing to the system which is torturing the chicken.
Is it not?