I'm surprised it is all women! Is this a complete list? I can understand why transwomen would be more motivated to get involved in politics, but its still surprising to me that its 100% women.
But ātrans-ā (and ācis-ā!) is also a prefix. cf. ātransnationalā, ātransalpineā, ātranscranialā, ātranscodeā, etc. To be clear, Iām not saying we shouldnāt insist on the space, but implying that it would otherwise be malformed or ungrammatical is a bad argument.
I assume Trans Women got socialized as men in their formative years of childhood, so no matter how much they might have not fit in they certainly got an underlying message of being capable, they didnāt get corrected for being ābossyā or loud or demanding and probably got discouraged from being āsubmissiveā in any way.
Even people who donāt believe in gendernorms will enforce them subconciously on kids and male socialization is just so much more likely to produce people who ask and fight for leadership roles.
I am not questioning their womanhood in any way, just to be clear.
The downvotes are wild. Children are socialized differently based on the gender they were assigned at birth - thatās a fact.
Growing up being called ābossyā does hell on oneās ability to speak out for oneās self. That shit turned me into a doormat in my teens, and enabled people to take advantage of me both in my personal life and professional life well through my 20s. Society worked hard to try to make me small and quiet, to put up with crap instead of speaking out when things were wrong. Itās a mess that Iām still in the process of untangling, and I have little doubt many AFAB have gone through the same thing.
Though with all that said, Iād like to hear directly from transmen about their experiences in this regard.
āMale socializationā is very controversial and itās used to justify some bad stuff (and everything you said applies much more to me than to my cis sister, but thatās anecdotal). I wonāt deny that trans men (two words) have a different upbringing than cis men but please focus on that rather than trans women.
Absolutely. It is very delicate because any transperson is marginalized, yet you can still see patriarcal tendencies with transpeople. Transwomen tend to be relatively more visible and vocal than transmen who seem to get doubly invisiblized.
I feel like there is a risk of being labelled as transphobic to discuss this, which is pretty unfortunate because it is felt by some transmen (see communities of transmen excluding transwomen for them not to dominate discourse).
46 comments
log in to comment.
I'm surprised it is all women! Is this a complete list? I can understand why transwomen would be more motivated to get involved in politics, but its still surprising to me that its 100% women.
Bentley Hudgins is non-binary
Cool!
trans is an adjective, you likely wouldnāt say tallwomen
But ātrans-ā (and ācis-ā!) is also a prefix. cf. ātransnationalā, ātransalpineā, ātranscranialā, ātranscodeā, etc. To be clear, Iām not saying we shouldnāt insist on the space, but implying that it would otherwise be malformed or ungrammatical is a bad argument.
You are linguistically correct - thats why transgender is one word, as a concept. As a noun, theres a space because trans/cis becomes an adjective. :)
I assume Trans Women got socialized as men in their formative years of childhood, so no matter how much they might have not fit in they certainly got an underlying message of being capable, they didnāt get corrected for being ābossyā or loud or demanding and probably got discouraged from being āsubmissiveā in any way.
Even people who donāt believe in gendernorms will enforce them subconciously on kids and male socialization is just so much more likely to produce people who ask and fight for leadership roles.
I am not questioning their womanhood in any way, just to be clear.
The downvotes are wild. Children are socialized differently based on the gender they were assigned at birth - thatās a fact.
Growing up being called ābossyā does hell on oneās ability to speak out for oneās self. That shit turned me into a doormat in my teens, and enabled people to take advantage of me both in my personal life and professional life well through my 20s. Society worked hard to try to make me small and quiet, to put up with crap instead of speaking out when things were wrong. Itās a mess that Iām still in the process of untangling, and I have little doubt many AFAB have gone through the same thing.
Though with all that said, Iād like to hear directly from transmen about their experiences in this regard.
āMale socializationā is very controversial and itās used to justify some bad stuff (and everything you said applies much more to me than to my cis sister, but thatās anecdotal). I wonāt deny that trans men (two words) have a different upbringing than cis men but please focus on that rather than trans women.
Absolutely. It is very delicate because any transperson is marginalized, yet you can still see patriarcal tendencies with transpeople. Transwomen tend to be relatively more visible and vocal than transmen who seem to get doubly invisiblized.
I feel like there is a risk of being labelled as transphobic to discuss this, which is pretty unfortunate because it is felt by some transmen (see communities of transmen excluding transwomen for them not to dominate discourse).