0

They Should Have Made Grindelwald a Metamorphmagus in the Fantastic Beasts Movies

preview

Okay, I know that this is all kind of moot now, given the upcoming HBO reboot, but hear me out, this is something that’s been living rent-free in my head and I need to get it off my chest.

In the Fantastic Beasts films, they should have made Gellert Grindelwald a Metamorphmagus.


The most obvious practical benefit is that it would have retroactively fixed the Depp-to-Mikkelsen recasting problem. Instead of just hoping audiences would handwave the switch, the story could have leaned into it.

Grindelwald deliberately adopting a new face, maybe as part of going deeper underground or evading aurors after the events of Crimes of Grindelwald.

What could have been an awkward production footnote becomes an in-universe power flex.


But beyond the damage control angle, I think it would have genuinely enriched the character.

Think about what Metamorphmagi represent thematically.

We only really know one in canon, Tonks, and she’s fundamentally defined by warmth and authenticity.

She changes her appearance playfully, openly, for fun. Her shapeshifting is an expression of who she is, not a mask over it.


Now flip that. A Dark wizard with the same ability, using it for infiltration, manipulation, and political theater.

Grindelwald’s whole ideology is about Wizarding supremacy and the “right” of magical people to rule: there’s something genuinely unsettling about a man preaching purity and identity politics who can literally be anyone at will.

The hypocrisy almost writes itself. Who is the “real” Grindelwald? Does even he know anymore?


It would also have given him a power set that felt distinct from Voldemort.

They’re often compared as the two great Dark Lords, but their methods and aesthetics are quite different: and a Metamorphmagus Grindelwald would have leaned further into that contrast.


Voldemort is about domination through terror and direct confrontation. Grindelwald is about persuasion, charisma, and ideology.

Shape-shifting fits his whole thing in a way it never would have suited Voldemort.

Okay, I know that this is all kind of moot now, given the upcoming HBO reboot, but hear me out, this is something that’s been living rent-free in my head and I need to get it off my chest.

In the Fantastic Beasts films, they should have made Gellert Grindelwald a Metamorphmagus.


The most obvious practical benefit is that it would have retroactively fixed the Depp-to-Mikkelsen recasting problem. Instead of just hoping audiences would handwave the switch, the story could have leaned into it.

Grindelwald deliberately adopting a new face, maybe as part of going deeper underground or evading aurors after the events of Crimes of Grindelwald.

What could have been an awkward production footnote becomes an in-universe power flex.


But beyond the damage control angle, I think it would have genuinely enriched the character.

Think about what Metamorphmagi represent thematically.

We only really know one in canon, Tonks, and she’s fundamentally defined by warmth and authenticity.

She changes her appearance playfully, openly, for fun. Her shapeshifting is an expression of who she is, not a mask over it.


Now flip that. A Dark wizard with the same ability, using it for infiltration, manipulation, and political theater.

Grindelwald’s whole ideology is about Wizarding supremacy and the “right” of magical people to rule: there’s something genuinely unsettling about a man preaching purity and identity politics who can literally be anyone at will.

The hypocrisy almost writes itself. Who is the “real” Grindelwald? Does even he know anymore?


It would also have given him a power set that felt distinct from Voldemort.

They’re often compared as the two great Dark Lords, but their methods and aesthetics are quite different: and a Metamorphmagus Grindelwald would have leaned further into that contrast.


Voldemort is about domination through terror and direct confrontation. Grindelwald is about persuasion, charisma, and ideology.

Shape-shifting fits his whole thing in a way it never would have suited Voldemort.

0

Harry Potter x Maximum Ride crossover fanfic

preview

Apologies if this was the wrong place, but I was hoping to potentially share this fic recommendation here.

The fic is called:

Wings Of A Wizard

by Abby_Ebon

on ao3.


It’s a Harry Potter x Maximum Ride crossover fic, although it’s unfortunately been abandoned.

It’s only three pages, but, at least IMHO, it’s really good, as well as engrossing.

I originally went into it not expecting much, but I ended up being disappointed / annoyed with it being abandoned.

Apologies if this was the wrong place, but I was hoping to potentially share this fic recommendation here.

The fic is called:

Wings Of A Wizard

by Abby_Ebon

on ao3.


It’s a Harry Potter x Maximum Ride crossover fic, although it’s unfortunately been abandoned.

It’s only three pages, but, at least IMHO, it’s really good, as well as engrossing.

I originally went into it not expecting much, but I ended up being disappointed / annoyed with it being abandoned.

0

Should we potentially create a Harry Potter Instance?

preview

@threelonmusketeers@sh.itjust.works

Ik that there used to be Diagonlemmy, but, IMHO, we should create an instance that is exclusive to Harry Potter, and the Wizarding World.


Perhaps call the instance Wizarding.World, or something.

That way, Fediverse users who wish to interact with Harry Potter material can, and other users/instances/etc, can defederate/don’t have to.


Harry Potter is only going to become more popular.

The HBO Harry Potter series is coming. Whether we like it or not, the HP fandom is about to have a significant resurgence, and it’s going to find a home somewhere on the internet.


The question is whether that somewhere is Reddit, Discord, and corporate platforms — or whether the Fediverse gets there first and shapes what that community looks like.

People flock to spaces where they feel familiar and welcomed.


Rowling will profit from HP whether a Lemmy instance exists or not.

The Fediverse needs more projects that make immediate sense to people, and it needs to stop ceding entire fandoms to corporate platforms by default.


The move isn’t to reject the fandom.

The move is to build the instance with explicit values — pro-trans, pro-queer, progressive moderation, zero tolerance for bigotry.

Pull HP fans into federated, open spaces and surround them with those values.

That’s far more powerful than gatekeeping.


EDIT:

I Cross-posted this to Fediverse @ Lemmy.World

literature.cafe/post/30408865


EDIT EDIT:

It would also most likely be beneficial, given that the instance would give a space to all of the existing potterheads out there.

Plus, most of the existing instances wouldn’t have to deal with HP/JK conversations and media, because all of the admin and whatnot of the various different instances could tell any users that try to please keep all HP/JK media to the Wizarding.World (or WizardingWorld.Lemmy, or whatever name the instance potentially ends up having).

Ie

Similar to how a Quarantine works.

Plus, it would help to bring in a ton of new users, to the Fediverse.

@threelonmusketeers@sh.itjust.works

Ik that there used to be Diagonlemmy, but, IMHO, we should create an instance that is exclusive to Harry Potter, and the Wizarding World.


Perhaps call the instance Wizarding.World, or something.

That way, Fediverse users who wish to interact with Harry Potter material can, and other users/instances/etc, can defederate/don’t have to.


Harry Potter is only going to become more popular.

The HBO Harry Potter series is coming. Whether we like it or not, the HP fandom is about to have a significant resurgence, and it’s going to find a home somewhere on the internet.


The question is whether that somewhere is Reddit, Discord, and corporate platforms — or whether the Fediverse gets there first and shapes what that community looks like.

People flock to spaces where they feel familiar and welcomed.


Rowling will profit from HP whether a Lemmy instance exists or not.

The Fediverse needs more projects that make immediate sense to people, and it needs to stop ceding entire fandoms to corporate platforms by default.


The move isn’t to reject the fandom.

The move is to build the instance with explicit values — pro-trans, pro-queer, progressive moderation, zero tolerance for bigotry.

Pull HP fans into federated, open spaces and surround them with those values.

That’s far more powerful than gatekeeping.


EDIT:

I Cross-posted this to Fediverse @ Lemmy.World

literature.cafe/post/30408865


EDIT EDIT:

It would also most likely be beneficial, given that the instance would give a space to all of the existing potterheads out there.

Plus, most of the existing instances wouldn’t have to deal with HP/JK conversations and media, because all of the admin and whatnot of the various different instances could tell any users that try to please keep all HP/JK media to the Wizarding.World (or WizardingWorld.Lemmy, or whatever name the instance potentially ends up having).

Ie

Similar to how a Quarantine works.

Plus, it would help to bring in a ton of new users, to the Fediverse.

0

Any good fics where Harry goes to Durmstrang, instead of Hogwarts?

preview

Preferably either a WBWL, or a “Harry’s sibling is the BWL” fic.

Parents preferably still alive.

Perhaps he also potentially strikes up a friendship with Viktor Krum.

I just finished reading Harry Potter and the Boy Who Lived by The Santi (great fic, BTW), but unfortunately, the fic ended up being abandoned.

But now I’m in the mood for some WBWL, Durmstrang!Harry.


For anyone who interested in the fic Harry Potter and the BWL:

www.fanfiction.net/s/5353809/0/

The FFN version is only 12 chapters, but there is also a version of the fic on WebNovel, with a lot more chapters:

wbnv.in/a/01jRbmo

Preferably either a WBWL, or a “Harry’s sibling is the BWL” fic.

Parents preferably still alive.

Perhaps he also potentially strikes up a friendship with Viktor Krum.

I just finished reading Harry Potter and the Boy Who Lived by The Santi (great fic, BTW), but unfortunately, the fic ended up being abandoned.

But now I’m in the mood for some WBWL, Durmstrang!Harry.


For anyone who interested in the fic Harry Potter and the BWL:

www.fanfiction.net/s/5353809/0/

The FFN version is only 12 chapters, but there is also a version of the fic on WebNovel, with a lot more chapters:

wbnv.in/a/01jRbmo

0

Audible’s ‘Harry Potter’ Series Expands Cast With Keira Knightley, Kit Harington, James McAvoy, Simon Pegg and More

Variety Audible’s ‘Harry Potter’ Series Expands Cast With Keira Knightley, Kit Harington, James McAvoy, Simon Pegg and More variety.com
preview

Those joining the cast in several fan-favorite roles include:

Kit Harington as Professor Lockhart;

Keira Knightley as Professor Umbridge;

Iwan Rheon as Professor Lupin;

Ruth Wilson as Bellatrix Lestrange;

Ambika Mod as Nymphadora Tonks;

Leo Woodall as Bill Weasley;

Simon Pegg as Arthur Weasley;

James McAvoy as Mad-Eye Moody;

Gemma Whelan as Professor Sprout;

Matt Berry as Sir Cadogan.

Those joining the cast in several fan-favorite roles include:

Kit Harington as Professor Lockhart;

Keira Knightley as Professor Umbridge;

Iwan Rheon as Professor Lupin;

Ruth Wilson as Bellatrix Lestrange;

Ambika Mod as Nymphadora Tonks;

Leo Woodall as Bill Weasley;

Simon Pegg as Arthur Weasley;

James McAvoy as Mad-Eye Moody;

Gemma Whelan as Professor Sprout;

Matt Berry as Sir Cadogan.

0

[Discussion] Ravenclaw Isn’t Just About Book Smarts—It’s About Curiosity, Creativity, and Thinking for the Fun of It

preview

Let’s be real: Ravenclaw gets typecast a lot.

To most people—both in the Books, Fics, and IRL Fandom—Ravenclaws are just “the smart ones.”

The brains of the operation.

The nerds.

The bookworms.

The early-years Hermione Grangers who always know the answer, get top marks, and practically live in the library.


But, at least IMHO, that’s a huge oversimplification.

Not all Ravenclaws are book-smart or even traditionally clever.

What really defines Ravenclaw, to me, is curiosity, creativity, and independent thought.


It’s not just the house of facts—it’s the house of wonder.

It’s where people go when they think differently, and aren’t afraid to let their minds wander into the weird, the beautiful, or the unknown.

Yes, there are plenty of book-smart Ravenclaws—but being a Ravenclaw isn’t about knowing everything, it’s about wanting to know anything.

It’s about being curious, creative, and totally willing to fall down a research rabbit hole at 2AM just because your brain won’t let something go.


Take Luna Lovegood. She’s not exactly acing every exam (no offence, Luna), but she’s one of the most unique, insightful, and artistic characters in the entire series. She sees the world her own way, believes in things others don’t, and doesn’t care what anyone thinks. That’s Ravenclaw energy in its purest form.


Or Cho Chang—more emotionally driven, athletic, and confident. She’s a Seeker, not a scholar. But that doesn’t mean she doesn’t belong. She’s thoughtful, compassionate, and introspective. That’s intelligence too.


Marietta Edgecombe made a morally complicated choice—one that might make people dislike her, but again, it was her decision.


And Padma Patil and Terry Boot? Quietly competent, observant, and not afraid to stand up and question things (see: their role in Dumbledore’s Army).


Here’s the thing: Ravenclaw isn’t just about being smart, it’s about thinking differently.

It’s the house of inventors, artists, theorists, and philosophers.

It’s where questions are asked not for grades or clout, but because we genuinely want to know.

In a lot of ways, Ravenclaw is like the anti-Slytherin.

Two sides of the same coin.


Where Slytherins are cunning and ambitious (usually in pursuit of something—glory, influence, legacy), Ravenclaws will dive into a 3-day magical research binge because a painting blinked weirdly at them and now they need to know the history of magical portrait enchantments since the 12th century.


If a Slytherin gets asked, “Why is the sky blue?”, they’ll learn the answer to impress someone or gain leverage.

Ask a Ravenclaw, and they’ll go full conspiracy board on it at 3AM, muttering about light refraction and magical atmosphere density just because their brain demanded answers.


In a way, Ravenclaw is almost the anti-Slytherin. Not because they oppose each other—but because Ravenclaws often seek knowledge with no endgame in mind. Just for the joy of the journey.

So yeah, sure, we’ve got the bookworms and the high-achievers.

But Ravenclaw is also the home of artists, oddballs, dreamers, inventors, philosophers, codebreakers, and magical conspiracy theorists.

It’s not just about what you know—it’s about what you’re willing to explore.


Anyone else feel like Ravenclaw deserves a little more love for the creative side of the house?

Let’s be real: Ravenclaw gets typecast a lot.

To most people—both in the Books, Fics, and IRL Fandom—Ravenclaws are just “the smart ones.”

The brains of the operation.

The nerds.

The bookworms.

The early-years Hermione Grangers who always know the answer, get top marks, and practically live in the library.


But, at least IMHO, that’s a huge oversimplification.

Not all Ravenclaws are book-smart or even traditionally clever.

What really defines Ravenclaw, to me, is curiosity, creativity, and independent thought.


It’s not just the house of facts—it’s the house of wonder.

It’s where people go when they think differently, and aren’t afraid to let their minds wander into the weird, the beautiful, or the unknown.

Yes, there are plenty of book-smart Ravenclaws—but being a Ravenclaw isn’t about knowing everything, it’s about wanting to know anything.

It’s about being curious, creative, and totally willing to fall down a research rabbit hole at 2AM just because your brain won’t let something go.


Take Luna Lovegood. She’s not exactly acing every exam (no offence, Luna), but she’s one of the most unique, insightful, and artistic characters in the entire series. She sees the world her own way, believes in things others don’t, and doesn’t care what anyone thinks. That’s Ravenclaw energy in its purest form.


Or Cho Chang—more emotionally driven, athletic, and confident. She’s a Seeker, not a scholar. But that doesn’t mean she doesn’t belong. She’s thoughtful, compassionate, and introspective. That’s intelligence too.


Marietta Edgecombe made a morally complicated choice—one that might make people dislike her, but again, it was her decision.


And Padma Patil and Terry Boot? Quietly competent, observant, and not afraid to stand up and question things (see: their role in Dumbledore’s Army).


Here’s the thing: Ravenclaw isn’t just about being smart, it’s about thinking differently.

It’s the house of inventors, artists, theorists, and philosophers.

It’s where questions are asked not for grades or clout, but because we genuinely want to know.

In a lot of ways, Ravenclaw is like the anti-Slytherin.

Two sides of the same coin.


Where Slytherins are cunning and ambitious (usually in pursuit of something—glory, influence, legacy), Ravenclaws will dive into a 3-day magical research binge because a painting blinked weirdly at them and now they need to know the history of magical portrait enchantments since the 12th century.


If a Slytherin gets asked, “Why is the sky blue?”, they’ll learn the answer to impress someone or gain leverage.

Ask a Ravenclaw, and they’ll go full conspiracy board on it at 3AM, muttering about light refraction and magical atmosphere density just because their brain demanded answers.


In a way, Ravenclaw is almost the anti-Slytherin. Not because they oppose each other—but because Ravenclaws often seek knowledge with no endgame in mind. Just for the joy of the journey.

So yeah, sure, we’ve got the bookworms and the high-achievers.

But Ravenclaw is also the home of artists, oddballs, dreamers, inventors, philosophers, codebreakers, and magical conspiracy theorists.

It’s not just about what you know—it’s about what you’re willing to explore.


Anyone else feel like Ravenclaw deserves a little more love for the creative side of the house?

0

Why Hufflepuff Might Actually Be the Most Terrifying House at Hogwarts [DISCUSSION]

preview

cross-posted from: literature.cafe/post/22174688

Okay, hear me out before you roll your eyes.


A lot of people—both in-universe characters and fans IRL love to dunk on Hufflepuff.

“The House of Duffers,”

“The Leftovers,”

“The ones who weren’t brave, smart, or ambitious enough.”

etc.


Even Snape makes digs at them, and let’s be honest, fandom memes haven’t helped either.

But the more I think about it, the more I’ve come to believe that Hufflepuff might actually be the most terrifying house of them all.


Think about it:

Hufflepuffs are known for being loyal, hard-working, and unafraid of toil.

That’s the kind of person who will dedicate their entire existence to avenging a loved one.


You kill their cat?

They’ll study dark magic in secret for years if they have to.

They won’t just hex you and move on—they’ll destroy your entire legacy.

Slowly.

Thoroughly.

Lovingly.


Imagine a Hufflepuff going full Sebastian Sallow, mastering dark magic not for power or ego, but because someone crossed the line.

Perhaps a Family Member is Sick, or Cursed (a la Sebastian Sallow).

Perhaps they hurt someone that they loved, i.e a family member, a spouse, a child, etc.

Or Worse.


And unlike Sebastian, they wouldn’t spiral —they’d stay focused.

Disciplined.

Unrelenting.


Or a Hufflepuff who goes full John Wick because someone messed with their Kneazle.

They’re not flashy about it. No big speeches. Just quiet, efficient vengeance.


And it doesn’t have to be dark.

These are the same people who will build an empire: legal, underground, or somewhere in between, whether it’s a chain of apothecaries, a magical transport syndicate, or an underground dueling circuit, - through sheer persistence.

You laugh at them now, and 10 years later they own the Leaky Cauldron, 47% of Diagon Alley, control every Floo connection west of Surrey, and your wand mortgage.


We always talk about Gryffindors being Brave, Ravenclaws being Smart, Slytherins being Cunning…

but Hufflepuffs?

They endure.

They grind.

They don’t give up (they most likely don’t even know the MEANING).

And that, my friends, is terrifying.


I say this as someone who’s not even a Puff—I’m a proud Slyther-Claw hybrid—but I’d never underestimate a Hufflepuff.

Not for a second.


Anyone else ever thought about this?

Or have headcanons of Hufflepuff characters that could go toe-to-toe with the best (or worst) of any other house?

cross-posted from: literature.cafe/post/22174688

Okay, hear me out before you roll your eyes.


A lot of people—both in-universe characters and fans IRL love to dunk on Hufflepuff.

“The House of Duffers,”

“The Leftovers,”

“The ones who weren’t brave, smart, or ambitious enough.”

etc.


Even Snape makes digs at them, and let’s be honest, fandom memes haven’t helped either.

But the more I think about it, the more I’ve come to believe that Hufflepuff might actually be the most terrifying house of them all.


Think about it:

Hufflepuffs are known for being loyal, hard-working, and unafraid of toil.

That’s the kind of person who will dedicate their entire existence to avenging a loved one.


You kill their cat?

They’ll study dark magic in secret for years if they have to.

They won’t just hex you and move on—they’ll destroy your entire legacy.

Slowly.

Thoroughly.

Lovingly.


Imagine a Hufflepuff going full Sebastian Sallow, mastering dark magic not for power or ego, but because someone crossed the line.

Perhaps a Family Member is Sick, or Cursed (a la Sebastian Sallow).

Perhaps they hurt someone that they loved, i.e a family member, a spouse, a child, etc.

Or Worse.


And unlike Sebastian, they wouldn’t spiral —they’d stay focused.

Disciplined.

Unrelenting.


Or a Hufflepuff who goes full John Wick because someone messed with their Kneazle.

They’re not flashy about it. No big speeches. Just quiet, efficient vengeance.


And it doesn’t have to be dark.

These are the same people who will build an empire: legal, underground, or somewhere in between, whether it’s a chain of apothecaries, a magical transport syndicate, or an underground dueling circuit, - through sheer persistence.

You laugh at them now, and 10 years later they own the Leaky Cauldron, 47% of Diagon Alley, control every Floo connection west of Surrey, and your wand mortgage.


We always talk about Gryffindors being Brave, Ravenclaws being Smart, Slytherins being Cunning…

but Hufflepuffs?

They endure.

They grind.

They don’t give up (they most likely don’t even know the MEANING).

And that, my friends, is terrifying.


I say this as someone who’s not even a Puff—I’m a proud Slyther-Claw hybrid—but I’d never underestimate a Hufflepuff.

Not for a second.


Anyone else ever thought about this?

Or have headcanons of Hufflepuff characters that could go toe-to-toe with the best (or worst) of any other house?