0

What are you thoughts about (semi-) centralized moderation? (Updated with a more decentralized idea)

preview

As the Fediverse grows, the amount and frequency of harmful spam also increases. The feudalistic structure of the network creates notable moderation overhead as every instance admin has to ban offending remote accounts and remove their content themselves, if the originating instance does not act quick enough or such delete actions are not federated properly.
An example (and my motivation for this post) are reports from the last days about accounts which post CSAM content. This is especially problematic, as media content gets duplicated to every receiving instance.

The following idea came to my mind: A software which sits on top of Activity Pub and creates a kind of court. Instances of this software are independent courts. All users can elect admins / mods of their home instance as judge. Everyone can post a case via normal Fedi posts to the court and the elected judges give a verdict via majority vote (votes are also normal Fedi comments with special formatted content). Once a case has a verdict, all instances should immediately apply the decided action against the offending content / account. This can be done via a bot which is set as an instance moderator and follows the published verdicts of a court instance the local admin trusts.

This way swift action can be applied through all instances which follow the court at once. By having periodic elections it is kept democratic.

And the task of the court is to defend universal rules all following instances agree on. Not to handle politics between instances.


What are you thoughts on this matter? Or do other approaches to solve this issue already exist?


Update:
From this came the idea that instances can follow mod actions of other instances and apply them if x% of other instances did the same.

I think this is an interesting approach which might be better than my proposal. So I would like to hear your thoughts about this too.

As the Fediverse grows, the amount and frequency of harmful spam also increases. The feudalistic structure of the network creates notable moderation overhead as every instance admin has to ban offending remote accounts and remove their content themselves, if the originating instance does not act quick enough or such delete actions are not federated properly.
An example (and my motivation for this post) are reports from the last days about accounts which post CSAM content. This is especially problematic, as media content gets duplicated to every receiving instance.

The following idea came to my mind: A software which sits on top of Activity Pub and creates a kind of court. Instances of this software are independent courts. All users can elect admins / mods of their home instance as judge. Everyone can post a case via normal Fedi posts to the court and the elected judges give a verdict via majority vote (votes are also normal Fedi comments with special formatted content). Once a case has a verdict, all instances should immediately apply the decided action against the offending content / account. This can be done via a bot which is set as an instance moderator and follows the published verdicts of a court instance the local admin trusts.

This way swift action can be applied through all instances which follow the court at once. By having periodic elections it is kept democratic.

And the task of the court is to defend universal rules all following instances agree on. Not to handle politics between instances.


What are you thoughts on this matter? Or do other approaches to solve this issue already exist?


Update:
From this came the idea that instances can follow mod actions of other instances and apply them if x% of other instances did the same.

I think this is an interesting approach which might be better than my proposal. So I would like to hear your thoughts about this too.

0

Tools for Canvas: Cotemplate

preview

Cotemplate is a tool for creating “Megatemplates”: a template the size of the whole canvas which contains multiple independent templates.
This has two main advantages: teams can see where space is left when placing their artwork and users without a team who want to help various artworks can get the template directly without having to ask around for a URL.

You can find the Cotemplate for this year’s Canvas here: …goip.de/…/20260520-Canvas26_main

You can create your own team in the menu opened by the button top right. Everyone with the team credentials can add and manage templates of this team. Once placed, an image is visible for everyone (so outside the team too).
To login as a team-member you have to go to the login page.

I also want to highlight the following features:

  • Direct URL to the current megatemplate is copied into your clipboard when clicking the small clipboard icon in the top middle.
  • Individual templates can be (de-)selected in the list (opened by the button top left).

Cotemplate is a tool for creating “Megatemplates”: a template the size of the whole canvas which contains multiple independent templates.
This has two main advantages: teams can see where space is left when placing their artwork and users without a team who want to help various artworks can get the template directly without having to ask around for a URL.

You can find the Cotemplate for this year’s Canvas here: …goip.de/…/20260520-Canvas26_main

You can create your own team in the menu opened by the button top right. Everyone with the team credentials can add and manage templates of this team. Once placed, an image is visible for everyone (so outside the team too).
To login as a team-member you have to go to the login page.

I also want to highlight the following features:

  • Direct URL to the current megatemplate is copied into your clipboard when clicking the small clipboard icon in the top middle.
  • Individual templates can be (de-)selected in the list (opened by the button top left).