showing posts tagged #atheism — clear

0

"There is no emperor! There's just clothes" - Ursula K. Le Guin, acceptance speech for the 'Emperor Has no Clothes Award'

Freedom From Religion Foundation Ursula K. Le Guin ffrf.org
preview

This speech was delivered in acceptance of the Emperor Has No Clothes Award on Nov. 7, 2009, at the 32nd annual convention of the Freedom From Religion Foundation at the Red Lion Hotel, Seattle.

I’m going to tell you my take on the story of “The Emperor’s New Clothes.” I read it as a kid, in our volume of Hans Christian Andersen’s stories, a big red book which I only read when I was already kind of depressed, because so many of the stories were scary and depressing.

I understood the story, I think, but when the little boy yells “Look! The Emperor has no clothes!”—I also understood why his mother tries to hush him up: He’s rude. And I have to tell you, I didn’t like that little boy. I didn’t identify with him. He’s the kind of little boy who would look at my kind of little girl and yell, “Look! Ursula’s socks don’t match! Nyeaahh!”

I have gone on secretly disliking that little boy for most of eight decades. And I’m going to get back at him, by saying what really bothers me about the whole story.

Now, OK, the two tailors are con men out to cheat the Emperor, and the Emperor is a twit—what else can you expect of an hereditary Emperor? But the tailors, now, there’s talent—they describe the clothes, the gold embroideries and everything, so well, so completely, so dramatically, that he can’t not believe them. They’re great artists, those guys. The poor twit Emperor doesn’t have a chance against them.

And the court and the people don’t have a chance either, because they have agreed to believe that whatever the Emperor says is true is true. So he says he has great new clothes and instead of looking, they shut their eyes and believe him.

And, because he is an Emperor, that is, a man given undue, un­just pow­er over other people, he de­serves his comedown and a comeuppance. Which I hope weakens or destroys his unjust power, though An­der­sen doesn’t say so.

But now, look at the story again and consider that this emperor is a man, probably a potbellied man with hairy legs, who gets fooled by some tricksters into leading a parade stark naked. And the little kid yells, “He has no clothes on!” and everybody finally looks, and he’s standing there bare-assed, with this awful sinking feeling, and everybody laughs and laughs, and jeers and mocks and howls.

Does this begin to sound like a kind of dream you may have had? I certainly have—the one where I find myself in class wearing, for some reason, nothing but a bra and galoshes; the one where I am about to give a viola concert and suddenly realize that I never learned to play the viola—that kind of dream? The dream that tells you: You are inadequate, you are incompetent, you are pitiful, you are naked to your enemies.

I don’t have just one Inner Child. I have lots of them. That dream is one of my Inner Children: the unpleasant little loudmouth know-it-all. What children don’t understand, and can’t understand until they grow up some, is how much the whole fabric and process of human society depends on everybody agreeing to ignore, most of the time, the fact that all of us are, most of the time, inadequate, incompetent, pitiful, and, in fact, naked to our enemies. None of us really has very much in the way of spiritual, moral clothing. We dress ourselves in rags. And we agree to say nothing about it. To a very large extent, it is human charity that clothes us.

If you read the story this way, the little whistle-blower is not the hero. Certainly the Emperor isn’t the hero; he’s just as much a twit as ever, only you can maybe be a bit sorry for him. The people who first sucked up to him and then jeered at him certainly aren’t the hero. We have no hero. Except possibly the little boy’s mother, who said, “Shh! dear! That’s very rude!” That woman knows what manners are, and that they are important—that civilizations depend, quite literally, on civility. My hope for humanity lies in her. Perhaps she will be able to bring up her little boy to be a decent man, a man who doesn’t want to hurt or humiliate anybody else, even a stupid Emperor, even on the FOX Network.

Now, when I try to read the story of “The Emperor’s New Clothes” in still another way, in the context of religion rather than of human power —that is, if I try to see the Emperor as God—a really weird thing happens.
It’s like I’m standing in the crowd watching the Em­per­or’s parade, and I don’t yell it, but I say it: “Where is the Emperor? There is no Emper­or! There’s just clothes!”

What I see is a marvelous costume, very ancient and beautiful—a halo, a triple crown, robes of white and gold—floating along the street, but nothing, nothing inside them. Empty clothes.

Now, I honestly do not think all the tailors who have made those clothes, that God-costume, so busily, for all these centuries, did it or do it deliberately and knowingly as a con game, to deceive us. Maybe in part, but mostly I think the people who sew the garments of God are busy deceiving themselves. Priests, of course, can make a good living out of it and also gain secular power. But lay believers weave those garments day and night, all over the world, and to some of them it is the most important thing they do, and they love doing it. That’s fine with me, so long as they don’t try to make me do it with them.

So, what I value about the Freedom From Religion Foundation, and why I am proud and happy to receive my award from you all, is the great work you do to diminish the place of religion in secular life—my life. I agree with you with all my heart that people who spend their lives sewing doll clothes for a figment of their imagination have no business running a country, making laws, interfering in people’s sex lives, teaching in public schools, or getting us into wars against people who make a different kind of doll clothes for a different figment of the imagination.

Let the tailors of the garments of God sit in their tailor shops and stitch away, but let them stay there in their temples, out of government, out of the schools. And we who live among real people—real, badly dressed people, people wearing rags, people wearing army uniforms, people sleeping on our streets without a blanket to cover them —let us have true charity: Let us look to our people, and work to clothe them better.

This speech was delivered in acceptance of the Emperor Has No Clothes Award on Nov. 7, 2009, at the 32nd annual convention of the Freedom From Religion Foundation at the Red Lion Hotel, Seattle.

I’m going to tell you my take on the story of “The Emperor’s New Clothes.” I read it as a kid, in our volume of Hans Christian Andersen’s stories, a big red book which I only read when I was already kind of depressed, because so many of the stories were scary and depressing.

I understood the story, I think, but when the little boy yells “Look! The Emperor has no clothes!”—I also understood why his mother tries to hush him up: He’s rude. And I have to tell you, I didn’t like that little boy. I didn’t identify with him. He’s the kind of little boy who would look at my kind of little girl and yell, “Look! Ursula’s socks don’t match! Nyeaahh!”

I have gone on secretly disliking that little boy for most of eight decades. And I’m going to get back at him, by saying what really bothers me about the whole story.

Now, OK, the two tailors are con men out to cheat the Emperor, and the Emperor is a twit—what else can you expect of an hereditary Emperor? But the tailors, now, there’s talent—they describe the clothes, the gold embroideries and everything, so well, so completely, so dramatically, that he can’t not believe them. They’re great artists, those guys. The poor twit Emperor doesn’t have a chance against them.

And the court and the people don’t have a chance either, because they have agreed to believe that whatever the Emperor says is true is true. So he says he has great new clothes and instead of looking, they shut their eyes and believe him.

And, because he is an Emperor, that is, a man given undue, un­just pow­er over other people, he de­serves his comedown and a comeuppance. Which I hope weakens or destroys his unjust power, though An­der­sen doesn’t say so.

But now, look at the story again and consider that this emperor is a man, probably a potbellied man with hairy legs, who gets fooled by some tricksters into leading a parade stark naked. And the little kid yells, “He has no clothes on!” and everybody finally looks, and he’s standing there bare-assed, with this awful sinking feeling, and everybody laughs and laughs, and jeers and mocks and howls.

Does this begin to sound like a kind of dream you may have had? I certainly have—the one where I find myself in class wearing, for some reason, nothing but a bra and galoshes; the one where I am about to give a viola concert and suddenly realize that I never learned to play the viola—that kind of dream? The dream that tells you: You are inadequate, you are incompetent, you are pitiful, you are naked to your enemies.

I don’t have just one Inner Child. I have lots of them. That dream is one of my Inner Children: the unpleasant little loudmouth know-it-all. What children don’t understand, and can’t understand until they grow up some, is how much the whole fabric and process of human society depends on everybody agreeing to ignore, most of the time, the fact that all of us are, most of the time, inadequate, incompetent, pitiful, and, in fact, naked to our enemies. None of us really has very much in the way of spiritual, moral clothing. We dress ourselves in rags. And we agree to say nothing about it. To a very large extent, it is human charity that clothes us.

If you read the story this way, the little whistle-blower is not the hero. Certainly the Emperor isn’t the hero; he’s just as much a twit as ever, only you can maybe be a bit sorry for him. The people who first sucked up to him and then jeered at him certainly aren’t the hero. We have no hero. Except possibly the little boy’s mother, who said, “Shh! dear! That’s very rude!” That woman knows what manners are, and that they are important—that civilizations depend, quite literally, on civility. My hope for humanity lies in her. Perhaps she will be able to bring up her little boy to be a decent man, a man who doesn’t want to hurt or humiliate anybody else, even a stupid Emperor, even on the FOX Network.

Now, when I try to read the story of “The Emperor’s New Clothes” in still another way, in the context of religion rather than of human power —that is, if I try to see the Emperor as God—a really weird thing happens.
It’s like I’m standing in the crowd watching the Em­per­or’s parade, and I don’t yell it, but I say it: “Where is the Emperor? There is no Emper­or! There’s just clothes!”

What I see is a marvelous costume, very ancient and beautiful—a halo, a triple crown, robes of white and gold—floating along the street, but nothing, nothing inside them. Empty clothes.

Now, I honestly do not think all the tailors who have made those clothes, that God-costume, so busily, for all these centuries, did it or do it deliberately and knowingly as a con game, to deceive us. Maybe in part, but mostly I think the people who sew the garments of God are busy deceiving themselves. Priests, of course, can make a good living out of it and also gain secular power. But lay believers weave those garments day and night, all over the world, and to some of them it is the most important thing they do, and they love doing it. That’s fine with me, so long as they don’t try to make me do it with them.

So, what I value about the Freedom From Religion Foundation, and why I am proud and happy to receive my award from you all, is the great work you do to diminish the place of religion in secular life—my life. I agree with you with all my heart that people who spend their lives sewing doll clothes for a figment of their imagination have no business running a country, making laws, interfering in people’s sex lives, teaching in public schools, or getting us into wars against people who make a different kind of doll clothes for a different figment of the imagination.

Let the tailors of the garments of God sit in their tailor shops and stitch away, but let them stay there in their temples, out of government, out of the schools. And we who live among real people—real, badly dressed people, people wearing rags, people wearing army uniforms, people sleeping on our streets without a blanket to cover them —let us have true charity: Let us look to our people, and work to clothe them better.

0

AI ‘Resurrection’ of Road Rage Victim Gets Killer’s Prison Sentence Tossed

play · youtube.com
YouTube AI ‘Resurrection’ of Road Rage Victim Gets Killer’s Prison Sentence Tossed youtu.be
preview

Cross posted from lemmy.wtf/post/49914727

In May 2025, an AI-generated video of road rage victim Christopher Pelkey was played in court before his killer was sentenced. The judge praised the AI recreation as “genuine” before sentencing Gabriel Horcasitas to 10½ years in prison. More than a year later, an Arizona appeals court ruled the AI video was “not reliable” and made the sentencing “fundamentally unfair.”

www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwgkvygg5nzvo

Dead Man ‘Speaks’ in Court Through AI Recreation

Cross posted from lemmy.wtf/post/49914727

In May 2025, an AI-generated video of road rage victim Christopher Pelkey was played in court before his killer was sentenced. The judge praised the AI recreation as “genuine” before sentencing Gabriel Horcasitas to 10½ years in prison. More than a year later, an Arizona appeals court ruled the AI video was “not reliable” and made the sentencing “fundamentally unfair.”

www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwgkvygg5nzvo

Dead Man ‘Speaks’ in Court Through AI Recreation

0

My Thoughts on Truthhood

preview

cross-posted from: programming.dev/post/57259387

I wrote this a few months ago and figured I’d go ahead and post it. I originally wrote it as a way to process my feelings about my own beliefs. TW about depression, paranoia, and leaving one’s birth religion.

I don’t know when I realized I was depressive. It should have been something I figured out early on, but didn’t hit me until later. I guess now is still early for most, given I’m 22. Realizing I lost my religion at the age of 17 made me have to recontextualize my worldview in a way that uprooted me from long held beliefs from birth. That was not easy. I remember at the beginning, just conceptualizing right and wrong as ideas that were not tied to a deity was difficult. The urge to pray was instilled in me since childhood, so it took a while before I stopped feeling it out of habit.

Something that has confused me since I started questioning my former faith is how anyone can believe that “objective” morality is an intelligible concept. Morality is a framework for how an individual conceptualizes the weight of actions and situations. Something is considered immoral if one’s moral framework says so. I specified individuals instead of groups because within groups, there is a mismatch between what people consider moral, making a moral framework an inherently individual phenomenon. Objectivity is the idea that something is true regardless of one’s viewpoint. Gravity pulls me down towards the ground whether I believe it or am conscious to experience it. If a deity claims their moral framework is objective, it simply isn’t. They are labeling their subjective moral framework as one that is true regardless of one’s viewpoint, even though the existence of their moral framework is completely dependent on them as an individual. It’s akin to saying my taste in music is the objective taste in music (which it is, of course). My taste in music is my own subjective experience and is completely contingent on me. How would I establish that something I feel is good is good irrespective of others’ viewpoints? It’s an unintelligible claim.

How do you establish objectivity? I don’t know. I also find objectivity as a concept to be hard to wrap my head around given my previous argument. So how do you establish anything as objectively true? I don’t think you can. Every experience you have is contingent on yourself, making them relative experiences, which would make you reach a similar stopping point as the previous argument. It’s hard to let go of the idea that things need to be objectively true. The closest thing I can get to objectivity is the scientific method, which is an attempt to converge onto truths.

I like to separate things I consider true into two categories: “functional” and “convergent” truths. Functional truths are truths I hold because they’re convenient for perceiving and conceptualizing reality. They’re essentially axioms. I try to minimize these because axioms cannot be verified. I hold my senses as being generally accurate as a functional truth. It’s an unfalsifiable claim, but is also convenient to perceiving and experiencing the world. If a functional truth can’t be verified, they may reduce the accuracy of my held worldview because of a direct or implied assumption coming from that functional truth. One example would be god. I’ve had conversations with folks that hold god as an axiom. That creates implied beliefs that reinforce the supernatural, which are unfalsifiable, but due to people’s axiom that a god exists, it allows them to also believe in supernatural phenomena because one of their axioms supports it. Convergent truths are simply truths that are enforced by many people observing the same phenomenon. It’s the scientific process. If many people experience gravity to the point that we can describe it usually mathematical notation, it’s safe to say it exists.

I’ve struggled with mental illness in the past. Like most people, depression, but also lots of delusions. Deep paranoia about imminent supernatural things that I felt deeply in my heart but knew in my head were delusions. I got to the point that I wasn’t sure whether my reality was real at times. I’ve heard the argument that if life wasn’t real that it wouldn’t be worth living and that you should just lay there until you die because it doesn’t matter. It’s interesting because you get to establish what you think is real up to a certain point. Even if my life wasn’t real, that wouldn’t make the sensations and experiences I have any different. Why should life being real deter me from experiencing it? I don’t hold an opinion on whether my life is real because, frankly, I don’t give a fuck. I still get to drive two hours to see my brother and almost throw my guts up at an Indian restaurant. I still get to hit that riff for the first time after a week of practicing it. I still get to tell my mother how I lost my faith and have to sit there to hear her remarks. Those experiences don’t change.

This idea of relativity in morality is such a shallow topic but once stepped in, instantly engulfs me. Starting meaning from where I draw it is such a freeing yet threatening idea because of the amount of, essentially, creative freedom you have to apply to your own wants. Whenever I make a song, I almost always run into a block. Whether I should add more chords or if I should put another instrument in, after a certain point the amount of freedom I can apply to that song is just too much and I need to take a step back to listen, and listen, and listen and understand what it is will scratch that itch in my brain. I find morality to be a similar concept. Because of the amount of freedom you have to do different things that inevitably feel right or wrong, the possibilities are endless. You have to figure out what direction you want to go in by understanding the width and breadth of your emotions surrounding as many things as you can. This contrasts an “objective” morality which dictates what direction people should tend to go in as better or worse and leaves less decision to an individual. This is not about the merits of individuality, nor am I making an argument for individuality, but I feel more at peace knowing I have a choice.

Sometimes the world doesn’t feel real. Sometimes I need to look at the veins in my mother’s hands, or the leaves on a tree, or hear the happiness in a loved one’s laugh to ground me. Those things feel right. But how do I choose to experience those? When do I choose to experience those? It’s much like creative block. How do I go about expressing and consuming love for those things in my life which I hold sacred? I have to decide. It’s not up to a deity, or a religious figure to tell me how many times I should be doing those things, but it’s my decision. The world doesn’t feel real because I am the experience of sensory information being processed by a flesh calculator. There is no inherent meaning to what or why I want to see things, and I don’t think there’s a higher purpose to what is happening on our planet. Moral relativity is the idea that things matter to individuals, not as some sort of objective Cartesian grid you can plot morality coefficients across, but just as internal, intransitive experiences that can conglomerate on a larger scale to create moral trends across a specific population, time, and place. But it all starts with individuals trying to reach inside to understand themselves, because living is a journey to knowing oneself before it passes.

This morning I went on a walk and saw a squirrel stealing a tomato from someone’s garden. It was a green tomato that it could barely bite into, being roughly half its size. I was feeling like nothing really mattered and putting one foot in front of the other felt like trudging through mud. This squirrel had given me eyes that told me not to knock on that house’s door to tell on it. I’m not a snitch. I had originally planned on running, but I couldn’t run in the mud. My mind switches between the ideas of “feeling nothing matters, so why should anything matter” and “so many things matter to me, why should nothing matter”. I don’t really know why it switches like that, but I prefer the latter. The former places me in the mud. The latter lets me giggle at the squirrel and go on with my day.

cross-posted from: programming.dev/post/57259387

I wrote this a few months ago and figured I’d go ahead and post it. I originally wrote it as a way to process my feelings about my own beliefs. TW about depression, paranoia, and leaving one’s birth religion.

I don’t know when I realized I was depressive. It should have been something I figured out early on, but didn’t hit me until later. I guess now is still early for most, given I’m 22. Realizing I lost my religion at the age of 17 made me have to recontextualize my worldview in a way that uprooted me from long held beliefs from birth. That was not easy. I remember at the beginning, just conceptualizing right and wrong as ideas that were not tied to a deity was difficult. The urge to pray was instilled in me since childhood, so it took a while before I stopped feeling it out of habit.

Something that has confused me since I started questioning my former faith is how anyone can believe that “objective” morality is an intelligible concept. Morality is a framework for how an individual conceptualizes the weight of actions and situations. Something is considered immoral if one’s moral framework says so. I specified individuals instead of groups because within groups, there is a mismatch between what people consider moral, making a moral framework an inherently individual phenomenon. Objectivity is the idea that something is true regardless of one’s viewpoint. Gravity pulls me down towards the ground whether I believe it or am conscious to experience it. If a deity claims their moral framework is objective, it simply isn’t. They are labeling their subjective moral framework as one that is true regardless of one’s viewpoint, even though the existence of their moral framework is completely dependent on them as an individual. It’s akin to saying my taste in music is the objective taste in music (which it is, of course). My taste in music is my own subjective experience and is completely contingent on me. How would I establish that something I feel is good is good irrespective of others’ viewpoints? It’s an unintelligible claim.

How do you establish objectivity? I don’t know. I also find objectivity as a concept to be hard to wrap my head around given my previous argument. So how do you establish anything as objectively true? I don’t think you can. Every experience you have is contingent on yourself, making them relative experiences, which would make you reach a similar stopping point as the previous argument. It’s hard to let go of the idea that things need to be objectively true. The closest thing I can get to objectivity is the scientific method, which is an attempt to converge onto truths.

I like to separate things I consider true into two categories: “functional” and “convergent” truths. Functional truths are truths I hold because they’re convenient for perceiving and conceptualizing reality. They’re essentially axioms. I try to minimize these because axioms cannot be verified. I hold my senses as being generally accurate as a functional truth. It’s an unfalsifiable claim, but is also convenient to perceiving and experiencing the world. If a functional truth can’t be verified, they may reduce the accuracy of my held worldview because of a direct or implied assumption coming from that functional truth. One example would be god. I’ve had conversations with folks that hold god as an axiom. That creates implied beliefs that reinforce the supernatural, which are unfalsifiable, but due to people’s axiom that a god exists, it allows them to also believe in supernatural phenomena because one of their axioms supports it. Convergent truths are simply truths that are enforced by many people observing the same phenomenon. It’s the scientific process. If many people experience gravity to the point that we can describe it usually mathematical notation, it’s safe to say it exists.

I’ve struggled with mental illness in the past. Like most people, depression, but also lots of delusions. Deep paranoia about imminent supernatural things that I felt deeply in my heart but knew in my head were delusions. I got to the point that I wasn’t sure whether my reality was real at times. I’ve heard the argument that if life wasn’t real that it wouldn’t be worth living and that you should just lay there until you die because it doesn’t matter. It’s interesting because you get to establish what you think is real up to a certain point. Even if my life wasn’t real, that wouldn’t make the sensations and experiences I have any different. Why should life being real deter me from experiencing it? I don’t hold an opinion on whether my life is real because, frankly, I don’t give a fuck. I still get to drive two hours to see my brother and almost throw my guts up at an Indian restaurant. I still get to hit that riff for the first time after a week of practicing it. I still get to tell my mother how I lost my faith and have to sit there to hear her remarks. Those experiences don’t change.

This idea of relativity in morality is such a shallow topic but once stepped in, instantly engulfs me. Starting meaning from where I draw it is such a freeing yet threatening idea because of the amount of, essentially, creative freedom you have to apply to your own wants. Whenever I make a song, I almost always run into a block. Whether I should add more chords or if I should put another instrument in, after a certain point the amount of freedom I can apply to that song is just too much and I need to take a step back to listen, and listen, and listen and understand what it is will scratch that itch in my brain. I find morality to be a similar concept. Because of the amount of freedom you have to do different things that inevitably feel right or wrong, the possibilities are endless. You have to figure out what direction you want to go in by understanding the width and breadth of your emotions surrounding as many things as you can. This contrasts an “objective” morality which dictates what direction people should tend to go in as better or worse and leaves less decision to an individual. This is not about the merits of individuality, nor am I making an argument for individuality, but I feel more at peace knowing I have a choice.

Sometimes the world doesn’t feel real. Sometimes I need to look at the veins in my mother’s hands, or the leaves on a tree, or hear the happiness in a loved one’s laugh to ground me. Those things feel right. But how do I choose to experience those? When do I choose to experience those? It’s much like creative block. How do I go about expressing and consuming love for those things in my life which I hold sacred? I have to decide. It’s not up to a deity, or a religious figure to tell me how many times I should be doing those things, but it’s my decision. The world doesn’t feel real because I am the experience of sensory information being processed by a flesh calculator. There is no inherent meaning to what or why I want to see things, and I don’t think there’s a higher purpose to what is happening on our planet. Moral relativity is the idea that things matter to individuals, not as some sort of objective Cartesian grid you can plot morality coefficients across, but just as internal, intransitive experiences that can conglomerate on a larger scale to create moral trends across a specific population, time, and place. But it all starts with individuals trying to reach inside to understand themselves, because living is a journey to knowing oneself before it passes.

This morning I went on a walk and saw a squirrel stealing a tomato from someone’s garden. It was a green tomato that it could barely bite into, being roughly half its size. I was feeling like nothing really mattered and putting one foot in front of the other felt like trudging through mud. This squirrel had given me eyes that told me not to knock on that house’s door to tell on it. I’m not a snitch. I had originally planned on running, but I couldn’t run in the mud. My mind switches between the ideas of “feeling nothing matters, so why should anything matter” and “so many things matter to me, why should nothing matter”. I don’t really know why it switches like that, but I prefer the latter. The former places me in the mud. The latter lets me giggle at the squirrel and go on with my day.

0

He Left the Mormon Church, Then Exposed It. (Religion terrifies the shit out of me.)

play · youtube.com
YouTube He Left the Mormon Church, Then Exposed It. www.youtube.com
preview

Christain talking smack about another cult. Gotta keep up on the enemy of thinkin. The only pin I could put in it is “repooped turds”

Christain talking smack about another cult. Gotta keep up on the enemy of thinkin. The only pin I could put in it is “repooped turds”

0

My UU Experience As An Atheist

preview

I’m an atheist. Although I was raised in the Christian church of my people, I slowly progressed to agnosticism in my teens and from there to atheism by my mid-twenties.

When my marriage began to approach its long-overdue end, my then-wife (not an atheist, but not a Christian either; she was basically ignorant on the whole subject) decided that we should join a church as a family - not necessarily to avoid the split, but so that we would maintain a family connection even if we got divorced. I didn’t oppose the idea, although I did note that there were some churches that I wouldn’t be willing to join. As it worked out, we ended up joining a local Unitarian Universalist church. I was fine with that, as they are explicitly open to agnostics and atheists (and pretty much anything else, as far as I could tell).

I rather enjoyed the church, even if I’d have preferred to have slept in on Sundays. It was nice to have a regular social event; my then-wife had pretty much kept us all clear of any social activities. The congregation were pleasant people, albeit mostly older, affluent, and white. There were enough children for several Sunday school classes, though. The doctrine was liberal and tolerant. I very much liked the open pulpit for “prayers and concerns”; I’m very comfortable with public speaking, so I went up when the spirit moved me (so to speak). I volunteered at the church library and as a Sunday school teacher. My son went to Sunday school and very much enjoyed it. He also attended the OWLS program and got a lot out of it. I joined the writing group at the church as well.

But there were things that bothered me.

It felt as if the one black family that attended the church were being, well, used. They were always placed in the first pew right in front of the pulpit, as if they were on display. They were asked to address the congregation from the pulpit almost every week. I couldn’t shake the impression that they weren’t entirely comfortable with that. What’s more, the church spent two YEARS discussing putting up a “black lives matter” banner; much of the discussion focused on how to get the Mayor and the Chief of Police to attend the banner-hanging ceremony, and get maximum coverage on the news. At a meeting on the subject I couldn’t resist pointing out that two years of discussion was two years of police shooting black Americans every day.

The church leadership often spoke proudly of the UU ministers and members who put their lives on the line during the Civil Rights era. If they’d taken the same incredibly long deliberative approach that the church leadership was taking about the BLM banner (I said), we would STILL not have civil rights - which we basically don’t, anyway. The black family spoke up and agreed with me. But the minister and other leaders quickly shut that down. They accused me of being a radical, of demanding that they become a dictatorship by forcing quick decisions. I wasn’t allowed to speak again, and no changes were made.

I started speaking at the pulpit during “prayers and concerns” about the many wars that our government was waging all over the world, bombing the innocent and helpless (including children) every day using our tax dollars. I received a few kind replies from elderly members of the congregation (basically old hippies), but once again there was no action. It became more and more clear that these were people who were there to congratulate themselves on their enlightenment and profound goodness without actually doing much about it. I used to joke privately that their arms were all sprained from patting themselves on the backs.

There were a few other atheists in the congregation. We had meetings about once a month. Again, they were enjoyable - but it felt as if the leadership and the minister kept trying to shoehorn us into the category of “humanists”, rather than atheists. The minister dropped in to those meetings occasionally, and I couldn’t help but feel rather patronized.

For all their proclaimed tolerance, they seemed uncomfortable with out-and-out atheism. On the occasions that atheism was mentioned at all during a service, it was ALWAYS in conjunction with agnostics and humanists - as if we were a single indistinguishable group. And I couldn’t help but notice that although they had flags hung in the church with symbols of many faiths, there were none representing atheism - or even humanism, for that matter!

Eventually my marriage ended. My ex kept attending for a year or so, but then she met a Catholic man (the holiest felon and domestic abuser you could ask to meet) and she stopped showing up and dropped out of our lives. My son and I kept attending church for a while, but when he graduated out of Sunday school we both agreed that we didn’t feel at home there.

So we stopped going. I enjoyed being part of a group, but I wasn’t comfortable with what I perceived as their hypocrisy. Nor did I like being treated as a second-class citizen. If I could find an atheist “church” or a more sincere UU one, I’d certainly consider going. But as it stood, I wasn’t comfortable in that congregation.

Oh, one other thing: I was a regular panelist at a regional convention for 25 years. I spoke on all sorts of subjects, but the most popular one (I think) was a series of panels I proposed for atheists and theists to talk and better understand each other. It was a wonderful experience; standing-room-only crowds, and a wonderful atmosphere of mutual understanding. But at one of the panels, the then-President of American Atheists (who was also on the panel) was offended when I mentioned that I attended a UU church. He called me an “Uncle Tom” atheist with considerable scorn. In fairness, he was promoting a book he’d just had published, a typical “new atheist” tome insulting Christians; my advocacy of dialog and mutual understanding was pretty much diametrically opposed to his thesis. But after the panel a number of members of the audience rushed up to me enthusiastically to support my approach.

It’s amusing that both a hardcore atheist and “tolerant” progressive Christians were uncomfortable that an atheist would attend a church!

I’m an atheist. Although I was raised in the Christian church of my people, I slowly progressed to agnosticism in my teens and from there to atheism by my mid-twenties.

When my marriage began to approach its long-overdue end, my then-wife (not an atheist, but not a Christian either; she was basically ignorant on the whole subject) decided that we should join a church as a family - not necessarily to avoid the split, but so that we would maintain a family connection even if we got divorced. I didn’t oppose the idea, although I did note that there were some churches that I wouldn’t be willing to join. As it worked out, we ended up joining a local Unitarian Universalist church. I was fine with that, as they are explicitly open to agnostics and atheists (and pretty much anything else, as far as I could tell).

I rather enjoyed the church, even if I’d have preferred to have slept in on Sundays. It was nice to have a regular social event; my then-wife had pretty much kept us all clear of any social activities. The congregation were pleasant people, albeit mostly older, affluent, and white. There were enough children for several Sunday school classes, though. The doctrine was liberal and tolerant. I very much liked the open pulpit for “prayers and concerns”; I’m very comfortable with public speaking, so I went up when the spirit moved me (so to speak). I volunteered at the church library and as a Sunday school teacher. My son went to Sunday school and very much enjoyed it. He also attended the OWLS program and got a lot out of it. I joined the writing group at the church as well.

But there were things that bothered me.

It felt as if the one black family that attended the church were being, well, used. They were always placed in the first pew right in front of the pulpit, as if they were on display. They were asked to address the congregation from the pulpit almost every week. I couldn’t shake the impression that they weren’t entirely comfortable with that. What’s more, the church spent two YEARS discussing putting up a “black lives matter” banner; much of the discussion focused on how to get the Mayor and the Chief of Police to attend the banner-hanging ceremony, and get maximum coverage on the news. At a meeting on the subject I couldn’t resist pointing out that two years of discussion was two years of police shooting black Americans every day.

The church leadership often spoke proudly of the UU ministers and members who put their lives on the line during the Civil Rights era. If they’d taken the same incredibly long deliberative approach that the church leadership was taking about the BLM banner (I said), we would STILL not have civil rights - which we basically don’t, anyway. The black family spoke up and agreed with me. But the minister and other leaders quickly shut that down. They accused me of being a radical, of demanding that they become a dictatorship by forcing quick decisions. I wasn’t allowed to speak again, and no changes were made.

I started speaking at the pulpit during “prayers and concerns” about the many wars that our government was waging all over the world, bombing the innocent and helpless (including children) every day using our tax dollars. I received a few kind replies from elderly members of the congregation (basically old hippies), but once again there was no action. It became more and more clear that these were people who were there to congratulate themselves on their enlightenment and profound goodness without actually doing much about it. I used to joke privately that their arms were all sprained from patting themselves on the backs.

There were a few other atheists in the congregation. We had meetings about once a month. Again, they were enjoyable - but it felt as if the leadership and the minister kept trying to shoehorn us into the category of “humanists”, rather than atheists. The minister dropped in to those meetings occasionally, and I couldn’t help but feel rather patronized.

For all their proclaimed tolerance, they seemed uncomfortable with out-and-out atheism. On the occasions that atheism was mentioned at all during a service, it was ALWAYS in conjunction with agnostics and humanists - as if we were a single indistinguishable group. And I couldn’t help but notice that although they had flags hung in the church with symbols of many faiths, there were none representing atheism - or even humanism, for that matter!

Eventually my marriage ended. My ex kept attending for a year or so, but then she met a Catholic man (the holiest felon and domestic abuser you could ask to meet) and she stopped showing up and dropped out of our lives. My son and I kept attending church for a while, but when he graduated out of Sunday school we both agreed that we didn’t feel at home there.

So we stopped going. I enjoyed being part of a group, but I wasn’t comfortable with what I perceived as their hypocrisy. Nor did I like being treated as a second-class citizen. If I could find an atheist “church” or a more sincere UU one, I’d certainly consider going. But as it stood, I wasn’t comfortable in that congregation.

Oh, one other thing: I was a regular panelist at a regional convention for 25 years. I spoke on all sorts of subjects, but the most popular one (I think) was a series of panels I proposed for atheists and theists to talk and better understand each other. It was a wonderful experience; standing-room-only crowds, and a wonderful atmosphere of mutual understanding. But at one of the panels, the then-President of American Atheists (who was also on the panel) was offended when I mentioned that I attended a UU church. He called me an “Uncle Tom” atheist with considerable scorn. In fairness, he was promoting a book he’d just had published, a typical “new atheist” tome insulting Christians; my advocacy of dialog and mutual understanding was pretty much diametrically opposed to his thesis. But after the panel a number of members of the audience rushed up to me enthusiastically to support my approach.

It’s amusing that both a hardcore atheist and “tolerant” progressive Christians were uncomfortable that an atheist would attend a church!

0

How Do I Witness to My Atheist Friend?

preview

From alt.atheism on Usenet, many many years ago:

I have a friend who’s an atheist. Naturally as a Christian I’m very concerned for his soul. How can I witness to my atheist friend?

I have a sure-fire way for you to witness to your friend.

Go to your local lumber and hardware store. Purchase the following:

  • 1 nine-foot railroad tie or length 8”x8” lumber
  • 1 six-foot length of 2”x6”
  • 1 pack of heavy-duty 6” nails
  • 4 large spikes

I assume you can get a small shovel, a hammer, and a sharp-ended crowbar. If not, you’ll have to buy those too.

Invite your friend to meet you at a relatively private public area - a low hill surrounded by trees would be ideal. Arrive there an hour early. Dig a two-and-a-half foot deep hole at the top of the hill, just big enough for the railroad tie.

Next, nail the 2x6 perpendicularly onto the railroad tie, two and a half feet from one end. Use at least four heavy nails.

This next part may be a little tricky; you may want to have a (Christian) friend help you. Use the spikes to nail your wrists to the end of the 2x6, and you feet to the longer end of the protruding railroad tie. Make sure to put the spikes through your wrists, not your palms; if you put them through your palms they’ll rip through. You’ll flop forward and look ridiculous, and you won’t convert anybody.

Have a friend (or two) lift the railroad tie and slide the base into the hole you dug. They should make sure that the railroad tie stands up firmly; if necessary, they can pack some stones around the tie in the hole.

Have someone jab you firmly in the side of your abdomen with the sharpened crowbar, making a deep hole. By now, your atheist friend should have arrived.

Die.

Come back to life.

Your friend is now ready for conversion.

From alt.atheism on Usenet, many many years ago:

I have a friend who’s an atheist. Naturally as a Christian I’m very concerned for his soul. How can I witness to my atheist friend?

I have a sure-fire way for you to witness to your friend.

Go to your local lumber and hardware store. Purchase the following:

  • 1 nine-foot railroad tie or length 8”x8” lumber
  • 1 six-foot length of 2”x6”
  • 1 pack of heavy-duty 6” nails
  • 4 large spikes

I assume you can get a small shovel, a hammer, and a sharp-ended crowbar. If not, you’ll have to buy those too.

Invite your friend to meet you at a relatively private public area - a low hill surrounded by trees would be ideal. Arrive there an hour early. Dig a two-and-a-half foot deep hole at the top of the hill, just big enough for the railroad tie.

Next, nail the 2x6 perpendicularly onto the railroad tie, two and a half feet from one end. Use at least four heavy nails.

This next part may be a little tricky; you may want to have a (Christian) friend help you. Use the spikes to nail your wrists to the end of the 2x6, and you feet to the longer end of the protruding railroad tie. Make sure to put the spikes through your wrists, not your palms; if you put them through your palms they’ll rip through. You’ll flop forward and look ridiculous, and you won’t convert anybody.

Have a friend (or two) lift the railroad tie and slide the base into the hole you dug. They should make sure that the railroad tie stands up firmly; if necessary, they can pack some stones around the tie in the hole.

Have someone jab you firmly in the side of your abdomen with the sharpened crowbar, making a deep hole. By now, your atheist friend should have arrived.

Die.

Come back to life.

Your friend is now ready for conversion.

0

Atheism: BANNED, because...

preview

I was a regular panelist at a regional New England science fiction convention for decades. Part of my participation was suggesting panel topics every year. One topic I suggested was atheism, specifically conversations between theists and atheists.

Like many American atheists, I was raised as a Christian, evolving to agnosticism and finally atheism in my teens and twenties. I noticed over the years that although many atheists were quite familiar with religion in general and Christianity in particular, the reverse was NOT true - most Christians had never knowingly met an atheist, and what they “knew” about atheists in general were nightmares they learned from pastors and the media.

So I decided to encourage Christians and atheists to understand each other better by fostering dialog between them online. There were some great conversations; sadly, virtually all of them were deleted when the sites they were on were taken down.

Back to the atheism panels at the convention: They were HUGELY popular. Absolutely jammed, standing room only. The atmosphere was the most positive experience I ever had at panels there, and I’d been on hundreds of panels there over a quarter-century. People from the audience would rush up to the panel afterwards, bursting with enthusiasm. The next panel would have to push everyone out of the room.

But things were going on behind the scenes. New leadership came in to the con; highly enlightened leadership which made a particular point of their moral superiority. Bathrooms became gender-free. Food in the con suite and Green room became gluten-free, meat-free, and sugar-free - and, of course, taste-free. It was basically all the lentil casserole you could eat, which for many of us was absolutely none.

The attitude of the new leadership towards the atheism panels was particularly odd. They started by changing the panel descriptions from focusing on friendly conversation and mutual understanding between theists and atheists to confrontation; literally nothing more than arguments between the two groups. At which point they then cancelled all of the atheism panels, because “they’re nothing but arguments”.

The final revelation came to me through back channels. Programming and the con committee had deliberately decided to permanently cancel atheism as a topic because “Atheism only interests straight white males”. Apart from the obvious hypocrisy of a self-proclaimed safe space con to justify banning a topic on that basis (and believe me, they allowed all sorts of topics of interest only to sub-groups), the claim wasn’t even true! The audiences at the atheism panels were easily among the most diverse of any I ever saw.

Things went downhill for the con from there. Old-timers were ruthlessly purged. I was banned from Programming because I’d used a balloon as part of my cosplay which was latex; latex wasn’t banned at the con, but that was still sufficient reason for excommunication. In a major scandal, it came out that some of the new leadership had been molesting and r@ping some attendees; the con leadership as a whole worked together to cover that up for as long as possible. Last I’d heard total attendance was down by 2/3.

But isn’t it interesting that atheism was the one acceptable target for complete exclusion?

I was a regular panelist at a regional New England science fiction convention for decades. Part of my participation was suggesting panel topics every year. One topic I suggested was atheism, specifically conversations between theists and atheists.

Like many American atheists, I was raised as a Christian, evolving to agnosticism and finally atheism in my teens and twenties. I noticed over the years that although many atheists were quite familiar with religion in general and Christianity in particular, the reverse was NOT true - most Christians had never knowingly met an atheist, and what they “knew” about atheists in general were nightmares they learned from pastors and the media.

So I decided to encourage Christians and atheists to understand each other better by fostering dialog between them online. There were some great conversations; sadly, virtually all of them were deleted when the sites they were on were taken down.

Back to the atheism panels at the convention: They were HUGELY popular. Absolutely jammed, standing room only. The atmosphere was the most positive experience I ever had at panels there, and I’d been on hundreds of panels there over a quarter-century. People from the audience would rush up to the panel afterwards, bursting with enthusiasm. The next panel would have to push everyone out of the room.

But things were going on behind the scenes. New leadership came in to the con; highly enlightened leadership which made a particular point of their moral superiority. Bathrooms became gender-free. Food in the con suite and Green room became gluten-free, meat-free, and sugar-free - and, of course, taste-free. It was basically all the lentil casserole you could eat, which for many of us was absolutely none.

The attitude of the new leadership towards the atheism panels was particularly odd. They started by changing the panel descriptions from focusing on friendly conversation and mutual understanding between theists and atheists to confrontation; literally nothing more than arguments between the two groups. At which point they then cancelled all of the atheism panels, because “they’re nothing but arguments”.

The final revelation came to me through back channels. Programming and the con committee had deliberately decided to permanently cancel atheism as a topic because “Atheism only interests straight white males”. Apart from the obvious hypocrisy of a self-proclaimed safe space con to justify banning a topic on that basis (and believe me, they allowed all sorts of topics of interest only to sub-groups), the claim wasn’t even true! The audiences at the atheism panels were easily among the most diverse of any I ever saw.

Things went downhill for the con from there. Old-timers were ruthlessly purged. I was banned from Programming because I’d used a balloon as part of my cosplay which was latex; latex wasn’t banned at the con, but that was still sufficient reason for excommunication. In a major scandal, it came out that some of the new leadership had been molesting and r@ping some attendees; the con leadership as a whole worked together to cover that up for as long as possible. Last I’d heard total attendance was down by 2/3.

But isn’t it interesting that atheism was the one acceptable target for complete exclusion?

0

Happy Blasphemy Day!

preview

Be safe, but be blasphemous as well, my fellow free-thinking heathens!

Keep passing the time in a meaningful way until you become worm food, my fellow creatures of star-stuff!

Be safe, but be blasphemous as well, my fellow free-thinking heathens!

Keep passing the time in a meaningful way until you become worm food, my fellow creatures of star-stuff!

0

Jesus Christ, not a US citizen, let's remove him from the United States :)

preview

Just a thought I had today that helped me deal with all the bad news I read this morning. Hope you get a laugh out of this.

Just a thought I had today that helped me deal with all the bad news I read this morning. Hope you get a laugh out of this.

0

How do you deal with living in a religious world?

preview

I’ve been an atheist for 20+ years now (ex-catholic). Early in my atheism, followed the typical new-atheism route; reading Dawkins, watching tons of debates and interviews, participating in forums, joining atheist and rationalist groups. I went through an angry atheist phase, and then into a compassionate rationalist phase, seeking to understand religions and religious people, and to guide those who might be on the fence.

For many years I was optimistic about the future, thinking that rationality would spread and accelerate around the world. That newer generations would discard their religion and adopt progressive attitudes. More recently, and obviously due to current world events, I’ve lost hope in a brighter future. I suppose I set myself up for disappointment. I think you could make an argument that in the very long run (centuries), people are getting more educated, rational, and secular, but it seems clear that is not a guarantee in the short term. Looking at the rise of Christian nationalism in the US, misogynistic laws, anti-LGBT sentiments, the absolute loss of freedom for women in Afghanistan, etc; Even my close family are some mix of religious, conspiracy theorists, and anti-vaxxers. Evidently, humanity can easily regress decades worth of progress in an instant.

I’m sure we all have coping mechanisms, relationships and activities we enjoy, escapism to take our mind off things. If you put those aside, how do you deal with living in a religious, irrational world that will likely not improve in our lifetimes? Can we reason our way to a positive mindset? Is cope all we have?

Thanks in advance for your replies. I will read every single one of them.

I’ve been an atheist for 20+ years now (ex-catholic). Early in my atheism, followed the typical new-atheism route; reading Dawkins, watching tons of debates and interviews, participating in forums, joining atheist and rationalist groups. I went through an angry atheist phase, and then into a compassionate rationalist phase, seeking to understand religions and religious people, and to guide those who might be on the fence.

For many years I was optimistic about the future, thinking that rationality would spread and accelerate around the world. That newer generations would discard their religion and adopt progressive attitudes. More recently, and obviously due to current world events, I’ve lost hope in a brighter future. I suppose I set myself up for disappointment. I think you could make an argument that in the very long run (centuries), people are getting more educated, rational, and secular, but it seems clear that is not a guarantee in the short term. Looking at the rise of Christian nationalism in the US, misogynistic laws, anti-LGBT sentiments, the absolute loss of freedom for women in Afghanistan, etc; Even my close family are some mix of religious, conspiracy theorists, and anti-vaxxers. Evidently, humanity can easily regress decades worth of progress in an instant.

I’m sure we all have coping mechanisms, relationships and activities we enjoy, escapism to take our mind off things. If you put those aside, how do you deal with living in a religious, irrational world that will likely not improve in our lifetimes? Can we reason our way to a positive mindset? Is cope all we have?

Thanks in advance for your replies. I will read every single one of them.

0

US: Contact your Rep about H.R. 9495, the Stop Terror-Financing and Tax Penalties on American Hostages Act

American Humanist Association Action HQ - American Humanist Association www.votervoice.net
preview

From the American Humanist Association: contact your Congresscritter - tell them to oppose H.R. 9495, the Stop Terror-Financing and Tax Penalties on American Hostages Act.

From the American Humanist Association: contact your Congresscritter - tell them to oppose H.R. 9495, the Stop Terror-Financing and Tax Penalties on American Hostages Act.