folks,i know this is OT but i decided to post here as i’m sure there are a lot of people here that work in IT and know what thay are talking about. The recent MS failure is what i would like your opinion on.
from what I’ve seen, MS declared that a bunch of servers went offline and the load had to be spread on remaining servers. They fail to identify what caused the first bunch of servers encountering issues and they claim it was mot related to a hacker attack (why would they, it would lead to massive panic and distrust). So, then what caused the issue in the first place? Could it have been a piloted denail of service attack?
I’m sure the truth will emerge in coming days but was interested in the more tech savy people’s opinione. In the meantime i rejoyce for not having to depend of third party infrastructure at home, thanks to my little homelab.
A further consideration is that this does once again prove that companies that put all their eggs in one basket, are at yhe mercy of big tech. i experienced this personally at works where comunication by Teams and Outlooks was pretty much halted for hours.
38 comments
log in to comment.
Info about the root cause: infosec.exchange/@k3ym0/117607080678996785
Too real
You can tell it’s fake, because the EVP understood what was going on
That gave me a good chuckle, thanks!
Brillant! If only it were true and confirmed. MS stock prices would plumet …
Sounds like a closed case to me.
Maybe the real treasure was the stock price growth we made along the way?
“we”? XD
Whoops!
I’m sure it all came down to poor upper management decisions which they will try to blame on technology
Or on the poor lower level man that forgot to follow procedures …
By 2030 AI is gonna completely replace sysadmins as the cause of outages.
The main reason for problems: Bad IT administration that relies way too much on Microsoft.
There’s been rumours about insufficient capacity on Microsoft cloud services around Europe for a while. Unofficial of course, and who knows how many “broken phones” has been on the chain before me, so don’t take that as a fact. However, Microsoft stated that the problem started when they increased capacity, so maybe some initial synchronization or load balancing starting up caused extra load on the servers already running on pretty much full load and caused cascading failure.
Of course I don’t know for sure and I don’t expect we’ll get a full technical brief with details and the main reason is management problems no matter what’s the technical cause. I hope at least someone wearing a suit starts to think that maybe cloud isn’t really the answer to everything. And it’s not just 3654, a shit ton of different cloud services relies on AWS, Cloudflare and other players and if any of those goes down they’ll take considerable chunk of business critical infrastructure with them.
Have heard similar rumor about capacity. And yes, MS seems to be especially bad about chasing AI at the expense of their core products.
I blame Jensen’s leather jacket. It’s clearly way too powerful.
EDIT: There’s…a 3rd mistress now? Giggity.
Why speculate when you will get it dfrom the horses mouth in a couple days?
But my 2¢ is a bad code being deployed.
just one?
Upper management should do things and moves to avoid bad code deploying.
Why should upper manglement have a say in this? They only thing any manglement should say is Yes to a digital twin for a test environment to catch crap like this before it becomes a global outage.
Preventing expensive accidents is a part of survival strategy. Should be interesting topic for any CEO and every level of management. In reality they just hope accidents won’t happen?
Because the horse lies
Something something health control on too much servers shut them down, which made the others overloaded. My money is on the health monitoring being vibecoded.
All I can say for sure, is that nobody knows for sure.
I think it is a cascading effect some unmaintained and forgotten server gave out causing others to fall.
Thats what think not based on any facts.
I worked at a place that was running COBOL written in the 1970s that supported thousands of other services across the globe.
it was not redundant. it was not HA. there was just one.
the man who wrote the software died in 1995.
nobody understood what it did, or how to maintain it.
I would say, with the recent layoff from Microslop, your assessment might be more accurate than most think.
I doubt Microslop would pass up the opportunity to blame a hacker group or AI at this point. they look like a bunch of incompetent assholes. since they are being vague about it, and won’t immediately state a root cause, that can only mean it’s incompetence.
At the moment, we can only guess. My guess: an update (maybe of a load balancer) went wrong. We will never know for sure.
Maybe this is theproblem with big tech. They will never confess and what strikes me is that businesses and governments just won’t wake up
I’m sure this day loss of productivity and not even a total outage will have everyone hiring teams to run their email. I’m sure it’ll be cheaper and definitely more reliable 🙄
Y’all really don’t understand how the money flows or how expensive it is to run this shit.
The money flows from Microsoft to schools and universities to condition them them to think MS is the only option and then from Microsoft to non-tech people in deciding positions as bribes and favours so they decide to pay MS a fortune for shitty SAAS. It’s basically corruption used as an investment.
Oh, you meant that side of the money… Yeah, not expensive at all. There is a reason everybody can get email for free or for very little money if you need advanced functions and active service. And there is a reason the big providers are now basically running with whitelists only, because every idiot and their mom can run their own service. There is a reason why simple office solutions you can also get for free are nowadays –like so many other things– porvided as SAAS: to make money off idiots and paid morons.
The focus is more about not all depending on the same third party, that has more and more outages as months pass.
This community isn’t really the place for pragmatic takes on this kind of stuff. It’s largely homelab style hobbyists that have no idea about running anything for more than maybe 2-3 people (probably solo in most cases).
Unfortunately none of the actual professional communities from reddit seem to have active equivalents on Lemmy.
As if r/sysadmin has any actual professional admin actively posting?
Do you really think a self hosting community has no idea how difficult and time consuming self hosting email is?
Yes, this is basically a bunch of home lab enthusiasts. There’s nothing wrong with that but doing it for even a small business of 50 people is extremely different in terms of requirements.
Have you spent any time in these ‘home lab enthusiasts’ spaces? Nobody here is suggesting that you should go and self host email. Nobody is making it sound easy. In fact if you look at posts talking about email, almost every time the subject of email comes up you have a significant portion of the community saying it’s outright not worth self hosting email. It’s such a time consuming and opaque process to figure out why email isn’t being sent or received that few do so.
Yeah, any time someone says “I’m thinking about hosting for a business” my answer is “run away screaming”. Or set up as a business yourself. Never ever provide for a business as an individual, especially not without being paid enough to insure yourself.
100% yes. Absurdly common in tech