preview
This article/paper is a FASCINATING look at how people grow and share expertise in Craft Workflows at a granular/“grammatical” level. I didn’t know where to share it and interesting shares seems like the best place to given how wildly applicable and interesting this is.
“[Craftsmanship] means simply workmanship using any kind of technique or apparatus, in which the quality of the result is not predetermined, but depends on the judgment, dexterity and care which the maker exercises as he works. The essential idea is that the quality of the result is continually at risk during the process of making; and so I shall call this kind of workmanship ‘The workmanship of risk.’” — David Pye [79]
Craft, as defined by David Pye in the passage above, relies on evolving archives of skill and knowledge, continually shaped by material engagements and emerging tools [49]. As contributors to this growing and collaborative archive, craftspeople experiment with and share their designs, materials, and techniques with others [99]. This exchange is essential to craft’s dynamism: its perpetual practices of adjustment, improvisation, and reinvention establish craft as a living and continually evolving field of practice [5, 19, 20]. Through these practices, expert craftspeople develop not only procedural fluency, but also a supple and nuanced understanding of their craft — situated knowledge that is difficult to articulate yet central to their practice [78]. In many fields and settings, this learning is achieved through extended and embodied co-presence, often through formal and informal apprentice relations organized into wider communities of practice [19, 63]. After long periods of practice [29], expert craftspeople develop a deep understanding of the structure or rules of their craft — the techniques, processes, and procedures by which high-quality objects are produced. But they also understand the conditions under which rules are to be amended or broken and the interpretive freedom needed to navigate unique conditions, materials, and contexts.
A challenge however arises when craft knowledge is shared across distances (remotely) and time (asynchronously). In the absence of face-to-face interactions, craftspeople often rely on static documentation, such as written instructions, video tutorials, and design files, to share knowledge. While these formats convey mechanical procedures that may be useful for novices learning fundamentals, they fail to transmit the tacit knowledge, improvisational actions, and situated adaptations needed for other knowledgeable but non-master craftspeople to navigate similar contexts [96]. These deviations are not random; Goodwin [36] shows how situated actions stem from professional vision, where experts draw on experiential knowledge to interpret and respond to dynamic contexts. With this ability to discern patterns and contextual cues, experts adapt their responses fluidly in shared but distinctive ways through improvisation [11]. Capturing improvisations is challenging, as it requires representing implicit decisions and actions as structured and navigable documentation artifacts [32, 97] that support collaboration and the sharing of situated and tacit knowledge [2].
…
In this paper, we have explored how expert craftspeople capture and share tacit knowledge, improvisational actions, and situated adaptations within evolving communities of practice. Through interviews with expert craftspeople across diverse domains, we developed an elementary grammar that documents the non-linear, iterative, and improvisational nature of craft workflows. From our evaluation of the grammar with expert crocheters, we learned how experts navigate documentation to preserve a dialogue between craftsperson, material, and community. This dialogue emerges in distinct yet interconnected ways: through Reflective Loops where experts respond to material feedback, Branches where they deviate from established procedures, External Links where they reference other knowledge sources, and Revision Loops where they iterate and repair. In addition, practitioners extend and articulate their practice with Granularity Shifts, Segments, and Note-to-Self. With this framing, we argue for an expanded understanding of documentation tools for craft practices, not as static repositories of perfect instructions, but as dynamic scaffolding for craft knowledge to be extended, revised, and linked across distributed communities of craftspeople.
As with any computational system representing knowledge, grammars remain partial representations; Korzybski [61] reminds us, “the map is not the territory.” Documentation serves to augment (not substitute) the hands-on practice and direct material engagement essential to the learning and evolution of practice in craft communities. Nevertheless, computational tools such as CraftLink can make modest but meaningful contributions to these wider practices. Our evaluation revealed opportunities for future work: exploring interfaces more familiar to specific craft communities, investigating how the grammar might support practitioners with varied expertise levels, and studying how documentation artifacts evolve through revising and remixing over time. While our grammar may not capture the full territory of craft practices, it demonstrates how computational tools and techniques, suitably and sensitively deployed, can better support the distinctive conditions of sharing and learning found in craft communities. By formalizing patterns of improvisation, iteration, and repair, we can help make tacit knowledge visible and shareable, supporting craft communities in building distributed and evolving archives that preserve not just final outcomes but the expertise embedded in their creation.
This article/paper is a FASCINATING look at how people grow and share expertise in Craft Workflows at a granular/“grammatical” level. I didn’t know where to share it and interesting shares seems like the best place to given how wildly applicable and interesting this is.
“[Craftsmanship] means simply workmanship using any kind of technique or apparatus, in which the quality of the result is not predetermined, but depends on the judgment, dexterity and care which the maker exercises as he works. The essential idea is that the quality of the result is continually at risk during the process of making; and so I shall call this kind of workmanship ‘The workmanship of risk.’” — David Pye [79]
Craft, as defined by David Pye in the passage above, relies on evolving archives of skill and knowledge, continually shaped by material engagements and emerging tools [49]. As contributors to this growing and collaborative archive, craftspeople experiment with and share their designs, materials, and techniques with others [99]. This exchange is essential to craft’s dynamism: its perpetual practices of adjustment, improvisation, and reinvention establish craft as a living and continually evolving field of practice [5, 19, 20]. Through these practices, expert craftspeople develop not only procedural fluency, but also a supple and nuanced understanding of their craft — situated knowledge that is difficult to articulate yet central to their practice [78]. In many fields and settings, this learning is achieved through extended and embodied co-presence, often through formal and informal apprentice relations organized into wider communities of practice [19, 63]. After long periods of practice [29], expert craftspeople develop a deep understanding of the structure or rules of their craft — the techniques, processes, and procedures by which high-quality objects are produced. But they also understand the conditions under which rules are to be amended or broken and the interpretive freedom needed to navigate unique conditions, materials, and contexts.
A challenge however arises when craft knowledge is shared across distances (remotely) and time (asynchronously). In the absence of face-to-face interactions, craftspeople often rely on static documentation, such as written instructions, video tutorials, and design files, to share knowledge. While these formats convey mechanical procedures that may be useful for novices learning fundamentals, they fail to transmit the tacit knowledge, improvisational actions, and situated adaptations needed for other knowledgeable but non-master craftspeople to navigate similar contexts [96]. These deviations are not random; Goodwin [36] shows how situated actions stem from professional vision, where experts draw on experiential knowledge to interpret and respond to dynamic contexts. With this ability to discern patterns and contextual cues, experts adapt their responses fluidly in shared but distinctive ways through improvisation [11]. Capturing improvisations is challenging, as it requires representing implicit decisions and actions as structured and navigable documentation artifacts [32, 97] that support collaboration and the sharing of situated and tacit knowledge [2].
…
In this paper, we have explored how expert craftspeople capture and share tacit knowledge, improvisational actions, and situated adaptations within evolving communities of practice. Through interviews with expert craftspeople across diverse domains, we developed an elementary grammar that documents the non-linear, iterative, and improvisational nature of craft workflows. From our evaluation of the grammar with expert crocheters, we learned how experts navigate documentation to preserve a dialogue between craftsperson, material, and community. This dialogue emerges in distinct yet interconnected ways: through Reflective Loops where experts respond to material feedback, Branches where they deviate from established procedures, External Links where they reference other knowledge sources, and Revision Loops where they iterate and repair. In addition, practitioners extend and articulate their practice with Granularity Shifts, Segments, and Note-to-Self. With this framing, we argue for an expanded understanding of documentation tools for craft practices, not as static repositories of perfect instructions, but as dynamic scaffolding for craft knowledge to be extended, revised, and linked across distributed communities of craftspeople.
As with any computational system representing knowledge, grammars remain partial representations; Korzybski [61] reminds us, “the map is not the territory.” Documentation serves to augment (not substitute) the hands-on practice and direct material engagement essential to the learning and evolution of practice in craft communities. Nevertheless, computational tools such as CraftLink can make modest but meaningful contributions to these wider practices. Our evaluation revealed opportunities for future work: exploring interfaces more familiar to specific craft communities, investigating how the grammar might support practitioners with varied expertise levels, and studying how documentation artifacts evolve through revising and remixing over time. While our grammar may not capture the full territory of craft practices, it demonstrates how computational tools and techniques, suitably and sensitively deployed, can better support the distinctive conditions of sharing and learning found in craft communities. By formalizing patterns of improvisation, iteration, and repair, we can help make tacit knowledge visible and shareable, supporting craft communities in building distributed and evolving archives that preserve not just final outcomes but the expertise embedded in their creation.