I was reminded of this title looking at a list of the most expensive horror games ever made.
To me, it seemed like a case of putting the cart before the horse. They had all these lofty ideas about this stunning environment and super realistic character graphics, but little direction in terms of story or gameplay.
If you’re unfamiliar, The Callisto Protocol was directed by Glen Schofield, one of the Dead Space creators, and supposedly a spiritual successor.
The game got stale and repetitive fast. I honestly don’t remember it that well, but one moment stuck with me: a story event brings the main character back to the cell he essentially started in, and instead of feeling like, oh cool, I get to quickly retread some ground knowing a lot more than I did when I started, or maybe some tension about what I’d find now with stronger enemies lurking about, I just felt… really frustrated, like, annoyed that I hadn’t actually progressed and I’d have to engage in the same mechanics that had already gotten super old.
The story was also just kinda meh. Dead Space had this cool, well-built backstory with Unitology. I remember reading a rumor that Isaac Clarke’s mother was a unitologist and gave away all their money to the church, including funds earmarked for Isaac’s college education. That small connection really intrigued me. But there was still lots of mystery, too–the creatures and the marker seemed otherworldly and unknowable, more cosmic horror than space zombies.
The Callisto Protocol is just, they found an alien on a planet and started experimenting on some prisoners. Not every story needs to be unexpected and unique, and it’s not like Dead Space was completely cliche-free, either, but The Callisto Protocol already so little going for it that it NEEDED an intriguing story, and it just… didn’t have it.
That’s my 2c.
Image source: TheGamer