If they are insinuating that because it’s cheap it’s not sophisticated think again.
You can get motion sensors based on quantum dynamics principles for just $1, they are in all phones today, and those are based on extremely sophisticated theory and production methods. But industry has managed to find ways to make them extremely cheap despite that.
So putting the sophisticated in quotes based on the low price is an oversimplification.
That said, there are probably more sophisticated miniaturized options for spying than the cheap gadget they used.
Sophisticated is commonly used as a comparison to other sinilar things. So a sophisticated computer in 1980 is different from one in 2026 because technology advanced significantly. A lot of common features on cell phones would have been called sophisticated 20 years ago, but not anymore.
In this case sophisticated is intended to mean relative to other similar devices. Since this is a commodity electronic device you can easily buy for under $13 it doesn’t fit the common usage of ‘sophisticated’ for 2026.
Edit:
Goddam people are contrarian here. www.merriam-webster.com/thesaurus/sophisticated
Simple is the first antonym (opposite) stated, and simplistic is number 4.
This place is a cesspool sometimes 🤡
Ok, but you could also say a simple pc about a modern pc, that does not mean it’s actually simple. It’s because it is used in place of ordinary. And ordinary also doesn’t mean simple in the literal sense. Even a “simple” mobile phone is in fact not simple.
Quantum sensors have applications in a wide variety of fields including microscopy, positioning systems, communication technology, electric and magnetic field sensors.
One of these are the perfectly common motion sensor that detects if you move your phone, which is based on quantum phenomenon, like the phase shift between photons send in different directions.
Okay, now you're literally just chewing words to become meaningless.
On this basis, every fucking piece of technology is quantum technology because guess what, the ENTIRE UNIVERSE WE FUCKING LIVE IN is adherent to quantum physics and mechanics, and anything, any technology, any kind of energy transference, can be broken down to some kind of quantum phenomena which would be either directly or indirectly used. A simple steam engine can be quantum. Your bedroom lights - regardless if you use LED, incandescent, neon, or a fucking candle.
The very definition of a quantum sensor is that it utilises a quantum effect DIRECTLY, instead of relying on a transitive property that we measure in a different way. A CCD sensor might rely on "a quanta of light" therefore making it "quantum technology", but it won't be a quantum sensor.
First link: “But your smartphone is not a quantum computer, yet”
The title was a question. The answer the article you linked gave was “it doesn’t use quantum.”
The second link was describing regular effects as having quantum origins. Which is everything! Everything everywhere has a basis in quantum mechanics.
"Radio waves are photons, and their behavior is described by quantum electrodynamics. "
Yes, underpinning the entire universe is quantum mechanics. The light from a campfire is photons. No one would write an article saying, “Cavemen used a sophisticated quantum light source.”
Your claim was that smartphone motion sensors were quantum. You linked to Wikipedia about quantum sensors which did not say anything about phone sensors.
Apple and all phone manufacturers say they use mems motion sensors.
If the device doesn’t use quantum effects directly, it isn’t a quantum sensor.
Otherwise words have no meaning and textbooks would call 1860’s steam engines electric quantum engines because materials are held together with electric effects and atoms have quantum properties.
Well everything uses quantum effects directly at least the highs field like you said. Your definition is therefore bad. But the examples do use gravitons because they measure gravity the same a camera uses photons to measure light, which are both quants and are measured in “easy” ways.
Just because you are posh about it and try to define it as only the large hardron collider
I am extremely ignorant on these things. If what you say is true, it stands to reason that all the claims that “only 3 companies can produce memory chips” are most likely bullshit.
The 3 major makers Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron dominate the market, but they are definitely not alone. especially not since China has entered the market in force.
Seriously how does a multibillion tech company keep a smart tv in their confrence rooms? It has to be modified and its microphones removed, or forever offline at least
What good will onboard encryption be if the device is seized? They will just figure out how to decrypt.
I guess you’d need to set up asynchronous encrypt / decrypt keys, then move the data encrypted end to end. The target device can do the decrypting, while the bug only does encrypting.
If you ever intend to decrypt the data, don’t you need a decryption key?
I think my point stands, you’d need this device to be only capable of encryption. Otherwise, anyone with access to the device can decrypt it. So it goes without saying, you’d have to push the data to a second device which handles decryption.
You can have an encryption key that can’t decrypt the data. That’s what public and private keys are. The device can have a public key to encrypt the data, and then it can only be decrypted with the attacker’s private key. No need to even get it out of the device, you can also perform the decryption on the same device. Just don’t store the private key in there.
Right, but that’s referring to where the encryption key lives, what kind is used, and how. In the above comment, I’m just stating you need a decryption key.
Earlier I rose that you could store the decryption key on a separate device. I thought 0x0 was contesting that idea as “not how encryption works when l implemented properly.”
Obviously not. Do you store your false equivalency fallacies on the internet in clear text? Apparently so, but I won’t call you stupid for it.
How do passwords get stored? Encrypted.
How do they get read? Decrypted.
What performs the encryption? Keys.
What can the keys be derived from? Passwords.
Where are those keys stored? On the damned device.
Are you telling me, fuck all to the popular mantra that: if they have physical access to device, you’re boned?
State sponsored forensic programs bypass TPM and shit all the time, requiring physical access.
So where is your hypothetical security coming from? To me, it sounds like you’re needlessly giving me a hard time on a subject I probably understand better than you.
A one-way function can make recovering a secret computationally infeasible, but it doesn’t eliminate the implications of allowing the device to decrypt its own data.
I presume you’re referring to a workflow where a password is put into the device, fed through a one way function to derive the key, then the key is used. So the key is derived and never stored on disk.
Nonetheless, your key was in memory. There’s an attack surface for any forensic team. There’s also the capability of trying to brute force the password in a virtual environment after having cloned the device. FBI did this to an iPhone that had full reset after 10 failed attempts.
There’s also the capability to compromise the OS, leave the device there, wait for an admin to come by and supply the password themselves.
I don’t really see how the manner by which you derive your key affects the fact that having the key on device is a vulnerability. It may mitigate the vulnerability but you’re talking about corporations and government entities with practically unlimited budgeting. If the vulnerability exists, it will be explored.
I still think my points stands. It would be stupid for someone committing espionage to allow the same device to also decrypt the data.
OpenAI told me in an email that it used its own AI models to analyze data from the device—including forensic images of the data stored on the device—to find their suspect.
a microphone is cheap. you don’t need a battery if you can plug it in somewhere, be it a real power source, or a usb port or display output on something else.
60 comments
log in to comment.
Actual image of OpenAI and Kash Patel’s FBI meeting:
If they are insinuating that because it’s cheap it’s not sophisticated think again.
You can get motion sensors based on quantum dynamics principles for just $1, they are in all phones today, and those are based on extremely sophisticated theory and production methods. But industry has managed to find ways to make them extremely cheap despite that.
So putting the sophisticated in quotes based on the low price is an oversimplification.
That said, there are probably more sophisticated miniaturized options for spying than the cheap gadget they used.
Sophisticated is commonly used as a comparison to other sinilar things. So a sophisticated computer in 1980 is different from one in 2026 because technology advanced significantly. A lot of common features on cell phones would have been called sophisticated 20 years ago, but not anymore.
In this case sophisticated is intended to mean relative to other similar devices. Since this is a commodity electronic device you can easily buy for under $13 it doesn’t fit the common usage of ‘sophisticated’ for 2026.
Language is messy. I sometimes think of sophisticated as the opposite of simple.
It kind of is, isn’t it?
Edit:
Goddam people are contrarian here.
www.merriam-webster.com/thesaurus/sophisticated
Simple is the first antonym (opposite) stated, and simplistic is number 4.
This place is a cesspool sometimes 🤡
Depends on what you mean by is.
And depends on what you mean by depends. 🤔
🤗
Complex is the opposite of simple.
Complex is a synonym of sophisticated within this use case
[deleted]
No, it isn’t.
(Source: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ohDB5gbtaEQ461260665047)
I stand corrected. 😋
A computer from the 80’s is still a sophisticated device.
Not compared to modern top end hardware, which is how the word is used in this context.
Ok, but you could also say a simple pc about a modern pc, that does not mean it’s actually simple. It’s because it is used in place of ordinary. And ordinary also doesn’t mean simple in the literal sense. Even a “simple” mobile phone is in fact not simple.
Which sensor in phones uses quantum states? Do you mean things like SQUIDs? They are a completely different beast than classical sensors like MEMS.
Motionsensors
Do you mean the Soli radar? That ended up in what, 2-3 phone models altogether?
Most phones do not have motion sensors.
No literally a common motion sensor.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_sensor
One of these are the perfectly common motion sensor that detects if you move your phone, which is based on quantum phenomenon, like the phase shift between photons send in different directions.
None of the current phone IMUs utilise quantum phenomena for measurement. They're MEMS/FOG/RLG systems.
Quantum IMUs are the size that requires rack mounting.
OK but still the GPS using timing based on an atomic clock in space is absolutely sophisticated, and that is in even the cheapest smartphones today.
Your claim was quantum phenomena utilisation in phone sensors.
Let's stop moving the goalposts please.
I’m just tiring of the negativity here, so this is my last response in this thread.
qt.eu/…/how-your-smartphone-uses-quantum-mechanic…
…epochsandechoes.com/7-mind-blowing-ways-your-sma…
Okay, now you're literally just chewing words to become meaningless.
On this basis, every fucking piece of technology is quantum technology because guess what, the ENTIRE UNIVERSE WE FUCKING LIVE IN is adherent to quantum physics and mechanics, and anything, any technology, any kind of energy transference, can be broken down to some kind of quantum phenomena which would be either directly or indirectly used. A simple steam engine can be quantum. Your bedroom lights - regardless if you use LED, incandescent, neon, or a fucking candle.
The very definition of a quantum sensor is that it utilises a quantum effect DIRECTLY, instead of relying on a transitive property that we measure in a different way. A CCD sensor might rely on "a quanta of light" therefore making it "quantum technology", but it won't be a quantum sensor.
Read your own links!
First link: “But your smartphone is not a quantum computer, yet”
The title was a question. The answer the article you linked gave was “it doesn’t use quantum.”
The second link was describing regular effects as having quantum origins. Which is everything! Everything everywhere has a basis in quantum mechanics.
"Radio waves are photons, and their behavior is described by quantum electrodynamics. "
Yes, underpinning the entire universe is quantum mechanics. The light from a campfire is photons. No one would write an article saying, “Cavemen used a sophisticated quantum light source.”
Your claim was that smartphone motion sensors were quantum. You linked to Wikipedia about quantum sensors which did not say anything about phone sensors.
Apple and all phone manufacturers say they use mems motion sensors.
You were wrong. Get over yourself.
And read the links you provide as proof.
I mean everything electric is a quantum sensor not to defend anything
edit: further g sensors and accelerometers implemented by piezoelectricity are quantum sensors. They just use materials that make the sensing easy
If the device doesn’t use quantum effects directly, it isn’t a quantum sensor.
Otherwise words have no meaning and textbooks would call 1860’s steam engines electric quantum engines because materials are held together with electric effects and atoms have quantum properties.
Well everything uses quantum effects directly at least the highs field like you said. Your definition is therefore bad. But the examples do use gravitons because they measure gravity the same a camera uses photons to measure light, which are both quants and are measured in “easy” ways. Just because you are posh about it and try to define it as only the large hardron collider
I am extremely ignorant on these things. If what you say is true, it stands to reason that all the claims that “only 3 companies can produce memory chips” are most likely bullshit.
I hate the way the world is going right now.
The 3 major makers Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron dominate the market, but they are definitely not alone. especially not since China has entered the market in force.
Could have just hacked the TV like a normal pro.
Why hack it? Just buy the data from LG
Seriously how does a multibillion tech company keep a smart tv in their confrence rooms? It has to be modified and its microphones removed, or forever offline at least
These meeting rooms have commercial displays but also they have the google or microsoft office speakers anyway
China’s already got control of that!
Openais products must be shit at coding if it unsuccessfully encrypted the sdcard as asked to
What good will onboard encryption be if the device is seized? They will just figure out how to decrypt.
I guess you’d need to set up asynchronous encrypt / decrypt keys, then move the data encrypted end to end. The target device can do the decrypting, while the bug only does encrypting.
Thats not how encryption works when implemented properly
How so?
If you ever intend to decrypt the data, don’t you need a decryption key?
I think my point stands, you’d need this device to be only capable of encryption. Otherwise, anyone with access to the device can decrypt it. So it goes without saying, you’d have to push the data to a second device which handles decryption.
You can have an encryption key that can’t decrypt the data. That’s what public and private keys are. The device can have a public key to encrypt the data, and then it can only be decrypted with the attacker’s private key. No need to even get it out of the device, you can also perform the decryption on the same device. Just don’t store the private key in there.
Right, but that’s referring to where the encryption key lives, what kind is used, and how. In the above comment, I’m just stating you need a decryption key.
Earlier I rose that you could store the decryption key on a separate device. I thought 0x0 was contesting that idea as “not how encryption works when l implemented properly.”
No
Oh… so how do you decrypt your data without a decryption key? Don’t tell me you use a password…
Do you store your password on the device in cleartext? Thats stupid.
Just no, youre plain wrong.
Obviously not. Do you store your false equivalency fallacies on the internet in clear text? Apparently so, but I won’t call you stupid for it.
Are you telling me, fuck all to the popular mantra that: if they have physical access to device, you’re boned?
State sponsored forensic programs bypass TPM and shit all the time, requiring physical access.
So where is your hypothetical security coming from? To me, it sounds like you’re needlessly giving me a hard time on a subject I probably understand better than you.
Sigh
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-way_function?wprov=sfla…
A one-way function can make recovering a secret computationally infeasible, but it doesn’t eliminate the implications of allowing the device to decrypt its own data.
I presume you’re referring to a workflow where a password is put into the device, fed through a one way function to derive the key, then the key is used. So the key is derived and never stored on disk.
Nonetheless, your key was in memory. There’s an attack surface for any forensic team. There’s also the capability of trying to brute force the password in a virtual environment after having cloned the device. FBI did this to an iPhone that had full reset after 10 failed attempts.
There’s also the capability to compromise the OS, leave the device there, wait for an admin to come by and supply the password themselves.
I don’t really see how the manner by which you derive your key affects the fact that having the key on device is a vulnerability. It may mitigate the vulnerability but you’re talking about corporations and government entities with practically unlimited budgeting. If the vulnerability exists, it will be explored.
I still think my points stands. It would be stupid for someone committing espionage to allow the same device to also decrypt the data.
They will never find out
I have a couple of these in a drawer somewhere. Who should I “hack”?
Hack the planet!
Super Intelligence.
[deleted]
a microphone is cheap. you don’t need a battery if you can plug it in somewhere, be it a real power source, or a usb port or display output on something else.