I’ve seen trans people on lemmy argue that minors shouldn’t have access to hrt or blockers
What fucking insanity and internalized Transphobic bullshit is that about…
If I had access to at least blockers 20 years ago I would be a much happier and less scarred person, both physically and mentally.
But some people aren’t ready to admit they would rather risk their child or neighbor try and kill themselves than drop bullshit gender norms and stereotypes.
The fact that people think puberty blockers shouldn’t be available until after it’s too late to block puberty is a pretty clear indication that they haven’t actually thought it through for more than a second and are operating on vibes alone.
Maybe we would wait until after someone contracts measles before they can get a vaccine, too. Oh you’re sexually active with multiple partners? Why don’t we wait until you’ve had a risky encounter with HIV before starting PrEP?
The fact that people think puberty blockers shouldn’t be available until after it’s too late to block puberty is a pretty clear indication that they haven’t actually thought it through for more than a second and are operating on vibes alone.
Or they know how cruel it is and support the cruelty.
I think most people don’t realize that. I’ve been supportive of political ideas that I later realized were actually not really that great. Not to this point, but that’s just because I question much more than the average person. The problem is that cognitive dissonance is really hard to get rid of a lot of the time.
my mother’s take is that being trans is just the wrong decision, that it’s a decision no human ever truly enjoys, and that it’s okay to bully and abuse trans people because they may come back to god due to your bullying.
Which is why I italicised most. Some people do truly belive these things, and those people should be shunned, rightly so. I probably should have elaborated on that, sorry if I caused any negative emotions
I wish they were available when I was younger, and that I also knew I was allowed to be a girl. I wanted to be a girl pretty bad, but I thought all people assigned male at birth did.
I had something similar. Voice training brought my voice up to “not necessarily always outing me” from “can I use you in my transphobic attack ad” deep. I can raise it more, and I’m trying to get that to be natural, but yeah voice training is hard and I wish I’d been able to not need it.
Did you manage to get your voice to go up again with training? I only recently learned that voice changing requires training, so I have very little knowledge about it
you can move it up over time, but pitch isn’t the only factor with voice training. a lot of it comes down to reducing how hollow and booming your voice sounds by raising your larynx. i fucking suck at voice training but keeping these things in mind can help over a long time.
I’ve seen some argument about bottom growth being important for functional surgeries (not zero depth) for transfems. But I’m not sure how true that still is and I fail to see how that would be remotely worth it. Like, at least got through the correct puberty first and if later on you want that, you can still go through the unwanted puberty later, right?
There are other bottom surgery options available now that don’t require existing bottom growth. PPT (peritoneal pull through) is the most interesting of them imo since its the one most likely to allow for naturally “getting wet”. (Technically I think the “typical” penile-inversion method also can allow that to happen but its more common with ppt afaik). There’s also at least one other method I’ve read about that allows for bottom surgery without existing bottom growth, and I’m sure more exist but the two I mentioned by name are the ones I’m most familiar with lol.
I can’t help but wonder if testosterone can be used locally without raising overall T levels to achieve the same effect without going through testosterone based puberty? Estrogen cream is used locally for trans men who have issues with vaginal thinning from T. I get that doesn’t necessarily 1:1 translate, but it at least seems worth figuring out if nobody has yet.
Makes sense. I think some people use T-gel to help maintain cis-penis function/size, but no clue how much that would affect system levels for things like hair follicles and vocal cord growth (maybe some combination with systemic antiandrogens would be able to get a good balance?). Still, even if you got those unwanted affects, you wouldn’t get all the damage of going through T-puberty first.
I’m not trans so I’m clueless on the topic. On average, at which age does a person know, with a very high degree of accuracy with little-to-no false positives whether their body doesn’t match their brain?
Whatever that age is, is the age at which I believe HRT should be allowed from. Ideally instead of testimonials there would be some sort of objective medical test, but as far as I know none exist.
Surely the point you’d prefer would be the point that minimizes the sum of false positives and false negatives? Otherwise you’re intrinsically valuing cisgender lives over transgender lives
Value of the human life has no bearing on this. Yes, ideally you would want to minimize both falses.
Most doctors posit that applying the wrong treatment is worse then not applying treatment when needed. It is considered that false positives have a higher negative value than false negatives. The “first, do no harm” doctrine. But under the surface it’s more about liability. A doctor can be held liable for a false positive, but not for false negatives.
I firmly believe that the best solution is to just make puberty blockers readily available. The brain obviously still develops and things can change, but with blockers you can just take them until you’re at an age where you’d know for sure how you identify, and either stop using the blockers and go through puberty of your assigned at birth sex, or use HRT and go through the other puberty, without being irreparably changed by your (biological? Genetic? Idk how to call it) genders puberty
my favourite is when labour said puberty blockers were too dangerous and specifically added a carve out for cis people who are currently taking them to keep using them.
Because the world is the way it is, I wouldn’t tell a trans person trapped in a terrible place to NEVER do DIY, but I would strongly recommend accompanying DIY HRT with a boatload of caution, required reading and independent blood tests to ensure they aren’t inadvertently hurting themselves.
I mean this is just untrue. A large array of products and meds require prescription for nanny state reasons. Estrogen especially is pretty safe compared to for example alcohol or cigarettes or even regular pain medication
Edit: I should add I also always urge people to take blood tests regularly. I’m not suggesting anyone throw caution to the wind
Taking testosterone might be dangerous for men that already naturally produce T, but the levels needed for transitioning are well below what is considered risky. This combined with the guidelines for DIY HRT being very simple and checking your blood tests being straight forward makes it pretty safe as well.
Im a trans man, married to a trans man, and we have both been on testosterone for almost 10 years. We both produce naturally high T and my husband had to lower his due to concerns about blood thickening.
Ive also been involved in quite a few communities of trans people including those who DIY. Ive been vocal about being careful when DIYing testosterone because of the risks, and have advocated to get blood tests to at least monitor, and you know the number one response I get?
“The blood tests are expensive, so i havent gotten one.”
Edge cases don’t justify making a substance illegal or restricted IMO. I think it should take a lot for the state to be able to step in and tell me what I can and can’t do with my body. The vast majority of trans men on T aren’t having complications, and as mentioned I don’t think anyone should skip taking blood tests. It really is a failure of society to make blood tests hard to access.
OP of this thread said DIY could be dangerous. You said no estrogen is safe. I said dont forget about T which can be dangerous. You said T isnt dangerous in normal doses and with blood tests. I said in my experience people dont get blood tests due to costs and some people (like me and my husband) were in a risk group where it was dangerous. You are now saying I think T should be restricted.
I can think DIY testosterone can be dangerous and think people deserve access to healthcare at the same time. They aren’t mutually exclusive.
The topic of the post is making fun of allies saying hormones could be dangerous and that kids shouldn’t get access, so when someone shows up to point out that HRT is dangerous without any additional comments it can come off as scaremongering. DIY HRT is very important to a lot of people and again most people don’t experience side effects.
like we offer children antidepressants when it’s medically necessary and i hope most realize the value in that but when we offer children medicine to treat depression in trans kids it becomes an issue even though antidepressants have fairly comparable side effects to puberty blockers
however unfortunately i think the same people who are against hrt in minors are probably against children having antidepressants. because “kids need to learn to deal with it naturally before adulthood” or some shit
35 comments
log in to comment.
I’ve seen trans people on lemmy argue that minors shouldn’t have access to hrt or blockers
What fucking insanity and internalized Transphobic bullshit is that about…
If I had access to at least blockers 20 years ago I would be a much happier and less scarred person, both physically and mentally.
But some people aren’t ready to admit they would rather risk their child or neighbor try and kill themselves than drop bullshit gender norms and stereotypes.
The fact that people think puberty blockers shouldn’t be available until after it’s too late to block puberty is a pretty clear indication that they haven’t actually thought it through for more than a second and are operating on vibes alone.
Maybe we would wait until after someone contracts measles before they can get a vaccine, too. Oh you’re sexually active with multiple partners? Why don’t we wait until you’ve had a risky encounter with HIV before starting PrEP?
Or they know how cruel it is and support the cruelty.
I think most people don’t realize that. I’ve been supportive of political ideas that I later realized were actually not really that great. Not to this point, but that’s just because I question much more than the average person. The problem is that cognitive dissonance is really hard to get rid of a lot of the time.
my mother’s take is that being trans is just the wrong decision, that it’s a decision no human ever truly enjoys, and that it’s okay to bully and abuse trans people because they may come back to god due to your bullying.
i don’t speak with her anymore.
Which is why I italicised most. Some people do truly belive these things, and those people should be shunned, rightly so. I probably should have elaborated on that, sorry if I caused any negative emotions
I wish they were available when I was younger, and that I also knew I was allowed to be a girl. I wanted to be a girl pretty bad, but I thought all people assigned male at birth did.
*Sigh* I was an eggy little girl, huh?
oh what I’d do to have started blockers, voice dropped harder than anyone in my class yet I was one of two trans women
Well, at least karma or something happened; you’re very pretty :3
I had something similar. Voice training brought my voice up to “not necessarily always outing me” from “can I use you in my transphobic attack ad” deep. I can raise it more, and I’m trying to get that to be natural, but yeah voice training is hard and I wish I’d been able to not need it.
Did you manage to get your voice to go up again with training? I only recently learned that voice changing requires training, so I have very little knowledge about it
you can move it up over time, but pitch isn’t the only factor with voice training. a lot of it comes down to reducing how hollow and booming your voice sounds by raising your larynx. i fucking suck at voice training but keeping these things in mind can help over a long time.
I’ve seen some argument about bottom growth being important for functional surgeries (not zero depth) for transfems. But I’m not sure how true that still is and I fail to see how that would be remotely worth it. Like, at least got through the correct puberty first and if later on you want that, you can still go through the unwanted puberty later, right?
There are other bottom surgery options available now that don’t require existing bottom growth. PPT (peritoneal pull through) is the most interesting of them imo since its the one most likely to allow for naturally “getting wet”. (Technically I think the “typical” penile-inversion method also can allow that to happen but its more common with ppt afaik). There’s also at least one other method I’ve read about that allows for bottom surgery without existing bottom growth, and I’m sure more exist but the two I mentioned by name are the ones I’m most familiar with lol.
I can’t help but wonder if testosterone can be used locally without raising overall T levels to achieve the same effect without going through testosterone based puberty? Estrogen cream is used locally for trans men who have issues with vaginal thinning from T. I get that doesn’t necessarily 1:1 translate, but it at least seems worth figuring out if nobody has yet.
Makes sense. I think some people use T-gel to help maintain cis-penis function/size, but no clue how much that would affect system levels for things like hair follicles and vocal cord growth (maybe some combination with systemic antiandrogens would be able to get a good balance?). Still, even if you got those unwanted affects, you wouldn’t get all the damage of going through T-puberty first.
Some cis women use it for clit growth, and IIRC it’s a “be careful with it but you can be fine if you use it properly”
I’m not trans so I’m clueless on the topic. On average, at which age does a person know, with a very high degree of accuracy with little-to-no false positives whether their body doesn’t match their brain?
Whatever that age is, is the age at which I believe HRT should be allowed from. Ideally instead of testimonials there would be some sort of objective medical test, but as far as I know none exist.
Surely the point you’d prefer would be the point that minimizes the sum of false positives and false negatives? Otherwise you’re intrinsically valuing cisgender lives over transgender lives
Value of the human life has no bearing on this. Yes, ideally you would want to minimize both falses.
Most doctors posit that applying the wrong treatment is worse then not applying treatment when needed. It is considered that false positives have a higher negative value than false negatives. The “first, do no harm” doctrine. But under the surface it’s more about liability. A doctor can be held liable for a false positive, but not for false negatives.
I don’t necessarily disagree, but I don’t agree fully either. I am struggling to articulate why, without saying something that I don’t agree with.
I firmly believe that the best solution is to just make puberty blockers readily available. The brain obviously still develops and things can change, but with blockers you can just take them until you’re at an age where you’d know for sure how you identify, and either stop using the blockers and go through puberty of your assigned at birth sex, or use HRT and go through the other puberty, without being irreparably changed by your (biological? Genetic? Idk how to call it) genders puberty
my favourite is when labour said puberty blockers were too dangerous and specifically added a carve out for cis people who are currently taking them to keep using them.
DIYing most doctor-prescribed drugs is dangerous.
Because the world is the way it is, I wouldn’t tell a trans person trapped in a terrible place to NEVER do DIY, but I would strongly recommend accompanying DIY HRT with a boatload of caution, required reading and independent blood tests to ensure they aren’t inadvertently hurting themselves.
I mean this is just untrue. A large array of products and meds require prescription for nanny state reasons. Estrogen especially is pretty safe compared to for example alcohol or cigarettes or even regular pain medication
Edit: I should add I also always urge people to take blood tests regularly. I’m not suggesting anyone throw caution to the wind
Every time DIY is brought up everyone forgets trans men exist and testosterone is much more dangerous to DIY than estrogen
It’s also much more regulated. At least in the US, estrogen is kinda grey market, but testosterone is straight up illegal without a prescription
Taking testosterone might be dangerous for men that already naturally produce T, but the levels needed for transitioning are well below what is considered risky. This combined with the guidelines for DIY HRT being very simple and checking your blood tests being straight forward makes it pretty safe as well.
Im a trans man, married to a trans man, and we have both been on testosterone for almost 10 years. We both produce naturally high T and my husband had to lower his due to concerns about blood thickening.
Ive also been involved in quite a few communities of trans people including those who DIY. Ive been vocal about being careful when DIYing testosterone because of the risks, and have advocated to get blood tests to at least monitor, and you know the number one response I get?
“The blood tests are expensive, so i havent gotten one.”
Edge cases don’t justify making a substance illegal or restricted IMO. I think it should take a lot for the state to be able to step in and tell me what I can and can’t do with my body. The vast majority of trans men on T aren’t having complications, and as mentioned I don’t think anyone should skip taking blood tests. It really is a failure of society to make blood tests hard to access.
Never did I say that it should be made illegal or restricted.
That’s the topic of the post
OP of this thread said DIY could be dangerous. You said no estrogen is safe. I said dont forget about T which can be dangerous. You said T isnt dangerous in normal doses and with blood tests. I said in my experience people dont get blood tests due to costs and some people (like me and my husband) were in a risk group where it was dangerous. You are now saying I think T should be restricted.
I can think DIY testosterone can be dangerous and think people deserve access to healthcare at the same time. They aren’t mutually exclusive.
The topic of the post is making fun of allies saying hormones could be dangerous and that kids shouldn’t get access, so when someone shows up to point out that HRT is dangerous without any additional comments it can come off as scaremongering. DIY HRT is very important to a lot of people and again most people don’t experience side effects.
like we offer children antidepressants when it’s medically necessary and i hope most realize the value in that but when we offer children medicine to treat depression in trans kids it becomes an issue even though antidepressants have fairly comparable side effects to puberty blockers
however unfortunately i think the same people who are against hrt in minors are probably against children having antidepressants. because “kids need to learn to deal with it naturally before adulthood” or some shit