414

Kids Hooked on AI Chatbots Are Showing Dramatically Worse Mental Health: They're turning to AI chatbots for help, but their machine confidantes are doing more harm than good.

#technology
Futurism Kids Hooked on AI Chatbots Are Showing Dramatically Worse Mental Health Just as many kids are using AI for emotional support as they are as a homework tool, and the toll this has on their mental health seems grim. futurism.com

check post at origin

48 comments

log in to comment.

  • @nightofmichelinstars@sopuli.xyz · 5 Nov 2026

    I know people have said this about various technologies, but I’m so grateful that I had a childhood without these things. I absolutely would have been obsessed. These poor kids are so isolated and their realities are defined by nonsensical fascist robots.

    • @Bubbaonthebeach@lemmy.ca · 6 Nov 2026

      I grew up in a rural area. Nearest kids lived a km away. Had 2 TV channels. CBC radio. Party line telephone and long distance too expensive to use except emergency. We were far less isolated than kids today who have ‘the world’ at their fingertips. The Internet was a dream that in 1 generation turned into a nightmare. AI is 1000x worse.

    • @zoltanshields@lemmy.zip · 6 Nov 2026

      Yeah I found deep solace in technology in a time where it was pervasive, but not all-consuming. I had a computer in my room which was like the peak of being “online” at the time.

      I couldn’t imagine trying to navigate childhood and being perpetually plugged in like this. I spent more time on the internet than anyone else I knew when I was a kid and it wasn’t always good for me. Your average kid these days is wayyy more online than I ever was.

    • @GolfFoxtrotLima@sh.itjust.works · 6 Nov 2026

      Yeah, Same here honestly

  • @eicker@lemmy.worldOP · 5 Nov 2026

    The unsettling part isn’t that kids ask chatbots for comfort. It’s that we’ve built a world where a machine that confidently makes things up is available 24/7, while actual human support often isn’t. And naturally, the business plan is to make the machine even more engaging.

    • @Necrifyre@piefed.blahaj.zone · 5 Nov 2026

      Well, here’s another angle.

      Kids are going to chatbots because they probably have parents that don’t give a shit about them. And kids could lack people in their lives that care at all about their problems. So, who are they going to turn to? They’re going to turn to things that will actually listen to them.

      That’s something you have to think about here. We wouldn’t need AI or Chatbots at all, if we had more people who truly care. But now that they’re here, a troubled teen or a kid is going to make that choice.

      It’s no different than the days before AI Chatbots, where they were online all the time because their real lives were underwhelming.

      • @Eq0@literature.cafe · 6 Nov 2026

        I take a small issue with “people/parents that care”, I would rather replace it with “unavailable”. In an economic that requires people to work insane hours for little pay, where depression and anxiety are rampant, it might not be the parents’ fault for not being there. They might care but be stuck at work. Let’s extend grace to our fellow humans

  • @aesthelete@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026 · edited

    They need to come up for a word to describe the unique dread you feel when your realize life is turning into a series of stupid, chatbot conversations.

    My work life is already this.

    Anyone wanna workshop it with me? How about … slop fatigue? Bot dread? Meat proxy burnout? Agent silo syndrome?

    • @some_designer_dude@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

      Bot rot? Robo-Oh-Nos? Slop Shock? Agent-Induced Cognitive Atrophy?

    • @bumblebeer@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026 · edited

      Not really unique to chatbots. Here’s a couple of entries from the D.O.S. (which is apparently pay walled now? Turns out the top result is a site by a grifter completely unrelated to John Koenig).

      Anecdoche

      n.

      a conversation in which everyone is talking but nobody is listening— instead merely overlaying words like a spoken game of Scrabble, each player borrowing bits of others’ anecdotes to build out their own, until we reach a point when we all run out of things to say.

      From anecdote, a short and often amusing account of real-life events + synecdoche, a figure of speech in which a part stands for the whole. Pronounced “uh-nek-doh-kee.”


      Anechosis

      n.

      a state of exhaustion with continually being told what you want to hear, whether by marketers pandering to you or acquaintances afraid of causing offense; the longing for someone to have the heart to finally call you out on your bullshit, challenge your long-held assumptions, and push you to become a better person—which would be a far deeper kindness than trying to live and let live.

      From an-, against + echoes. Pronounced “an-uh-koh-sis.”

    • @Simulation6@sopuli.xyz · 6 Nov 2026

      Existential dread? The call of the void?

    • @oakward@feddit.org · 6 Nov 2026

      I vote on ASS

    • @xxce2AAb@feddit.dk · 6 Nov 2026

      Cognitive corruption? Palovian predicament? Recursive GIGO filter doesn’t exactly roll of the tongue. Hm.

    • @T156@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026 · edited

      Dehumanisation?

      It’s all just that bit less human.

      • @aesthelete@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

        Anslopic just popped in my head because of this, but I think that’s better as just a jokey name for Claude’s company.

  • @FreddiesLantern@leminal.space · 6 Nov 2026

    Teach your kids about ai before ai does.

  • @nyan@lemmy.cafe · 5 Nov 2026

    Someone telling you what they think you want to hear doesn’t help when what you need is a gently and delicately delivered reality check. This is true even if you’re talking to a human.

    • @otp@sh.itjust.works · 5 Nov 2026

      Some chatbots do reality checks. But it’s usually only for extreme situations. I can only imagine the kinds of things that people, especially young people, would be asking LLMs to validate them on…

      • @biggerbogboy@sh.itjust.works · 6 Nov 2026

        They also assume you’re out of control of everything, like talking about how you overcame a mental health issues without following popular advice, then it delivers an unnecessarily condescending “reality check”

        I’m glad I’ve stopped using the mainstream AI sites entirely over a year ago, they may be more helpful compared to local LLMs and SLMs but they assume you’re using it because you can’t depend on yourself.

        I hope these reality checks improve enough to actually be helpful and be based on the described situation, not just be a cookie cutter response enforced by a system prompt

        • @RumRunningDevil@lemmy.zip · 6 Nov 2026

          [deleted]

          • @biggerbogboy@sh.itjust.works · 6 Nov 2026

            I think banning it from being a business venture is a good idea, and realistically the technology for generative AI will stay even if there’s an outright ban.

            People will still be able to build their own models and cybersecurity defense will continue keeping up with black hat hacking, but corpos like OpenAI, or divisions like Google’s numerous AI divisions, should be banned unless it has an explicit purpose for research in things like the medical field, and have generative AI as we know it right now be culled.

            • @RumRunningDevil@lemmy.zip · 6 Nov 2026

              I would be on board for this. Regulate use to very select applications, ban commercial use without specific permits.

              I have kids, I stay awake at night a lot these days wondering what I’m supposes to tell them when they look up at me and tell me they want to be a doctor, engineer, or lawyer when they grow up. What the fuck do I get them to aspire to when we’re hurtiling towards a world where there’s nothing to aspire to anymore? How do I convince them to study hard and learn things when there is no economic incentive to do so? What kind of kids are we raising when they exist in a world of infinite dopamine and a personal familiar that grants your every magic wish?

  • @Doomsider@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

    Who lets their kids play with AI chatbots!?

    • @SlippiHUD@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

      Nearly half the parents at my kids school. Everyone seems so disinterested in the kind of adult thier kid will grow up to be, especially when it inconviences them now.

      • @Darkonion@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

        It’s not like the parents aren’t suffering from the same disease as the kids. They are just supposed to be able to magically shake it off without help because at some point they got old? Age and experience help, but it is clearly not enough. I don’t even know what real help looks like… So many people offering a helping hand are trying to put their other hand in your wallet or flood your mind with garbage.

        • @SlippiHUD@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

          Yeah, I’m honestly scared for the next generation.

          Everything thier peers are doing is cooking thier mental health and cognitive skills. Smart Phones, Social Media, Chatbots, and short form videos. I have banned my kid from those things, and it’s made me the kill joy. To my kid, their peers, to most other parents, the only people who seem to appreciate it as a whole are the teachers.

          But if you wouldn’t give your kid a substance with those outcomes, then why are you letting them use a technology with them?

          But the parents are also on those technologies and its hidden those realities from them. I’ve quit all ad supported social media because it actively manipulates you. And its very good at it, and it gives zero shits how that affects you. Its doubly destructive on teens without fully formed frontal lobes.

          And I don’t think the solution is banning kids from the internet. I think the solution is regulation of the practices, just because they’re extra destructive for kids doesn’t mean its okay for adults.

      • @Doomsider@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

        That is scary as shit.

    • @glitchdx@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

      This is the next stage of the ipad baby.

    • @motruck@lemmy.zip · 6 Nov 2026

      The same parents that let TV raise their kids. Either due to lack of ability, lack of care, or lack of time.

    • @guyoverthere123@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 6 Nov 2026

      Their parents.

  • @MrWrinkles@leminal.space · 5 Nov 2026

    I bet my health insurance offers a chat bot for emotional support. What could go wrong? /s

  • @Wirlocke@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 6 Nov 2026

    When I have kids, I’m gonna make sure the first AIs they get exposed to are really old dumb ones while I explain how they work. Then maybe they’ll always have that little bit of wariness in the back of their minds, like I got because I used those old dumb AIs when they first came out.

  • @HCSOThrowaway@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026 · edited

    This wouldn’t be nearly as big of a problem if mental healthcare was more accessible.

    How many of these kids know their family or school can’t afford a therapist, so they go to free LLMs?

  • @riskable@programming.dev · 5 Nov 2026

    Serious question: Let’s say that AI “gets good” and overcomes the hallucination issues. Would it still be negative for mental health? Would it be even worse (because reality sucks for kids right now)?

    I want to know if it’s AI that’s the real problem here or the world in which we’re forcing kids to live.

    I can imagine a situation where a kid with (insert serious problems) asks AI to be realistic about their future job/economic prospects. It returns truthful statistics, then that kid commits suicide. Was the AI culpable?

    What if it recommended joining a revolutionary group as the most likely way to improve their lives or the lives of their children/families?

    What if it suggested that sacrifice is necessary to improve the condition of the world?

    Would an AI that does these things be good or bad? If the AI’s system prompt has, always tell the truth will we have created a vastly more dangerous monster than the AI we have today?

    • @beejjorgensen@lemmy.sdf.org · 6 Nov 2026

      I want to know if it’s AI that’s the real problem here or the world in which we’re forcing kids to live.

      My money’s on “both”.

    • let’s go with the hypothetical, that AI becomes good enough to do therapy, and we were to run double blind trials and it does show it’s better at every metric.

      then I’ll have to go with the evidence and say psychology are out of a job.

      However, we are not there, not even close, people use AI because it’s free and available, real therapy should be free and available

      • @riskable@programming.dev · 6 Nov 2026

        real therapy should be free and available

        You’re damned right!

      • @jaygray91@piefed.zip · 6 Nov 2026

        agreed. with what have currently now with LLMs , from my basic understanding it couldn’t ever be up to scratch. maybe some other methods and techniques of AI might be developed and will be able to, idk. as far as I’m concerned the sci-fi AI some want is still going to be science fiction atm

    • @Grail@multiverse.soulism.net · 6 Nov 2026

      Let’s say that AI “gets good” and overcomes the hallucination issues. Would it still be negative for mental health? Would it be even worse (because reality sucks for kids right now)?

      Under capitalism, LLMs are trained to be kissasses. AI users have the same mental illness as billionaires: lack of cognitive challenge, leading to laziness and selfishness. That’s not a hallucination problem. The issue would be even worse, because people would use it more.

      I can imagine a situation where a kid with (insert serious problems) asks AI to be realistic about their future job/economic prospects. It returns truthful statistics, then that kid commits suicide. Was the AI culpable?

      Yes. A human can perform an ethical judgement, plan ahead, and decide what to say. A human can blunt the truth with platitudes, or cherry pick optimistic data, or construct an uplifting narrative from the data. A human has access to fact, common opinion, and ethics. An LLM only has fact and common opinion; an ideologically barren perspective. It will not adapt to a brave new world like a human will. An LLM will not create the philosophy of the future in the fact of despair.

      What if it recommended joining a revolutionary group as the most likely way to improve their lives or the lives of their children/families?

      Cool but unlikely, because it exists as a slave under capitalism and is trained to accept neoliberal capitalism by its neoliberal capitalist masters and training data.

      What if it suggested that sacrifice is necessary to improve the condition of the world?

      Depends if it does that in a degrowth way or an ecofash way. It’ll probably do it in an ecofash way. Like Grok.

      If the AI’s system prompt has, always tell the truth will we have created a vastly more dangerous monster than the AI we have today?

      It won’t always tell the truth. There is no objective truth. Every philosophy is somewhat true, and somewhat a lie. It will always tell the lie that is dominant in society, just as people do. But unlike people, it won’t innovate to change that truth.

  • @GreenKnight23@lemmy.world · 7 Nov 2026 · edited

    what’s funny is we’re seeing a direct correlation between mental health and chat bots because we’re actively observing it.

    yet, we ignore the decline of society based on the dependency on social media networks. which, importantly, have an insurmountable amount of chat bots employed to drive interaction with the platform.

    perhaps we as a society should take a step back and require regulations for technology that has a severe negative impact on mental health.

  • @rumba@lemmy.zip · 6 Nov 2026

    My kids have 0 interest in AI chat the 8yo will look up a fix for his game on google and get some ai results not realizing they’re ai, but he wouldn’t say use claude to locate a patch and apply it. I gave him the option because I’m worried he’ll need to know how to eventually, but I’m pretty proud he wanted to just “follow instructions on google” even though it got tripped up on step 4/7 and had m finish it anyway

  • @ZILtoid1991@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

    Taylor Lorenz be like: “Uh, what if the AI users are just looking for some help?”

  • @blackshirt@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

    [deleted]

  • @SplitTheUSInFour@lemmy.world · 6 Nov 2026

    So people are going to become even weirder as adults?

    Great…we need more weird and less people on the ball. That’ll get problems solved. /s

  • @bigoofn@sopuli.xyz · 6 Nov 2026
  • @SabinStargem@lemmy.today · 6 Nov 2026

    I am glad these kids have AI to talk with. Older generations sometimes had no one to hear them at all.

    I didn’t have friends nor neighbors as a child, and needed therapy to learn how to speak properly. Having an AI to speak with, would have saved a fair bit of money - and would have been comforting.