64 comments

log in to comment.

  • @anton@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 21 Oct 2026

    We should improve society somewhat meme with “technology” replacing “society” and 14 standards xkcd as a response

  • @UiUiUiUiUi@piefed.nl · 21 Oct 2026 · edited

    Meanwhile everyone is using Discord (still after Chinese funding, enshittification, age verification)

    A fringe moved to non federated options Fluxer Haven Stoat

    Matrix is too expensive to host, xmpp has no clients to use IRC can’t even edit a message.

    • @svcg@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 21 Oct 2026

      Editing messages is for cowards. Just dno’t make mistake.

    • @ik5pvx@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026

      IRC can’t even edit a message.

      you say that like if it were a bad thing

    • @Scoopta@programming.dev · 21 Oct 2026

      There are plenty of XMPP clients out there that work great… finding one that supports all the features you actually care about…now that’s the hard part. XMPP has too many opt in extensions and it’s very hit and miss with clients

      • @UiUiUiUiUi@piefed.nl · 21 Oct 2026

        A bare minimum includes: Editing, notifications, 1-1 calls, group calls voip, emoji reactions, discord servers aka matrix space aka fluxer community, mobile app.

        Sorry but nothing in the xmpp space gets close. I’m looking for a viable Discord alternative not a gTalk competitor from 10 years ago.

        • @Scoopta@programming.dev · 21 Oct 2026

          Yes, you basically restated my point, I’m not really disagreeing, but saying there aren’t any clients isn’t really the case either.

    • @Calfpupa@lemmy.ml · 21 Oct 2026

      Chinese funding, nothing wrong with that. A CEO funding genocide however.

    • That reminds me, I should try to set up a Bolt bridge for my Discord-Stoat server pair again.

  • @RushLana@piefed.blahaj.zone · 21 Oct 2026

    I hate the original “14 standards” xkcd comic with a passion. People should try shit and see if it works, if multiple standards works then compatibility layers/bridges will also be built.

    I’m happy that multiple DE exist, I love having multiple choice for my init system (and I say this while liking a lot of what systemD offer), bootloader, text editor, etc…

    • @DeadDigger@lemmy.zip · 21 Oct 2026

      See you have to be careful because with that approach you can get a USB c situation

      • @prettybunnys@piefed.social · 21 Oct 2026

        ONE PLUG FOR EVERYTHING.

        just hope the plug has the right pinout, and the cable the right capacity.

        • @HeyThisIsntTheYMCA@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026

          that explains my fucking headlight what is refusing to charge about 25%. slapped a better cable on there and it’s getting up to 50% now.

          i just want it to last 60 miles dammit.

          • @Eheran@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026

            That’s not on USB C mate. Shitty products will always exist. Like some can only be powered/charged from USB A to C, not C to C, since they didn’t add a resistor to the CC line. A microscopic sub 1 cent part.

      • @defiance@lemmy.ml · 21 Oct 2026

        Consider me ignorant but whats the USB-C situation ?

        • @Johanno@feddit.org · 21 Oct 2026

          I am guessing that they are referring to the situation, that while all usb-c can be connected to each other you can have very different ones. Fast data transfer and slow. 10 watt and 100 watt and so on

          • @defiance@lemmy.ml · 21 Oct 2026

            Fair enough, but isnt most of that circumvented by getting good cables ?

            Tbh USB-C was a godsend I bought in early but I prefer having to grapple wether my cables are up to par than if I have a fitting one at all :D

            • @Johanno@feddit.org · 21 Oct 2026

              I find the current situation much better than having 33 usb standards and a cable for each and 99 adapters…

              So yes it is better. Every usbc cable will work (also I think there are less “power only” cables now)

              • @kus@programming.dev · 21 Oct 2026

                Yes, the current situation with a baseline is definitely better than what it was before.

        • @DeadDigger@lemmy.zip · 21 Oct 2026 · edited

          Well … Sigh in short because it is meaningless.

          As a condensed half true and a bit hyperbole summary: Usb-c is first and foremost just a connector definition. So getting a usb-c cable is basically saying you will have a cable with this plug and a specific wire configuration. But you can omit wires if you don’t need them and still have a USB c cable. So from the phyisical definition this means your cable can have a plug that connects into a socket and is not wired internally at all. You can still call this a USB cable. That is why apple usb-c cables are often unable to transfer data, for example. This is done for downward compatibility with the USB standard.

          The USB standard defines the functional properties of a USB cable. Depending on which version, which can be any number between 1.0 and 3.2 or thunderbolt, you have different lower and upper bounds that are possible. Except with USB 1.0 to 3.0 you don’t have lower bounds, you can omit parts of the specification completely and you can still call it a USB 2 or whatever cable. This means just because you have a USB c cable it does not give you any information about it’s capabilities. Except if it is thunderbolt or USB 3.2 because these have minimum requirements.

          Because the functional and constructional definition is so wide ranged the standard does not give you any meaningful information. Which means it’s basically useless.

  • @nastronot@lemmy.zip · 21 Oct 2026 · edited

    Fediverse is better at everything except onboarding. The access methods are complicated and ill explained for users who expect an app and simple signup. Regular users have no idea what an instance is. Even people who are TRYING to join the fediverse willingly pile in lemmy.world because it’s the default on most apps. There needs to be a round robin assigner to instances that opt in in order to spread users around who don’t care which general instance they join.

    The fediverse feels like old internet which I like but is also a barrier to people just looking for easy alternatives.

    • @Glitterkoe@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026

      Onboarding is the same as for email, which most people seem to pass just fine. Fedi instance is analogous to an email provider. I would even vouch to move from the ‘<some fedi type> instance’ hosting-based terminology to the ‘<some fedi type> provider’ user-centric terminology.

      IMO it’s the content discovery across instances and the subtler implications of your chosen provider that are harder to grasp.

      • @villainy@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026

        The average person has Gmail or Apple Mail because that’s what their phone had them set up, or (unfortunately) just uses their work email for everything. They’re not out there weighing alternatives.

      • @nastronot@lemmy.zip · 21 Oct 2026

        Normies tend to stick with the first email they are signed up for. For a lot of younger Gen Z email is a non factor.

      • @EmptyAsparagus@piefed.social · 22 Oct 2026 · edited

        its great that you can explain that, its not at all obvious to people new to the space. email is way more common, too, so IMHO not really comparable.

    • @grrgyle@slrpnk.net · 22 Oct 2026

      I love this round robin instance assigner idea.

      • @nastronot@lemmy.zip · 22 Oct 2026

        I’m know there’s things I haven’t thought of but getting them in is most important.

        Call it an incubator flag or whatever. Get them in so they can learn what all this has to offer. As they gain knowledge they can make a choice where they end up.

        Presenting a user with a list of instances with weird dorky names is the fastest way to get a normie to delete an app. Unless that’s what you want: a fedi-filter

  • @jbloggs777@discuss.tchncs.de · 21 Oct 2026

    Someone is an optimist…

    Why photoshop an XKCD comic?

    • @ignotum@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026 · edited

      I assume they mean the new standard, good or bad as it might be, simply isn’t adopted, so we are still stuck with the 14 bad ones

      Edit: I misread it, but this would also make for a good variation of the original :P

      • @stormdelay@sh.itjust.works · 21 Oct 2026

        I read it more like the new, better standard is never developed because someone used the real xkcd as an argument against making the new standard

        • @ignotum@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026

          Oh wow yeah not sure how i didn’t notice that she responds with the original comic, you’re absolutely right

        • @Eheran@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026

          I have another way to see it: There is a good new standard but the bad old ones stick around. Like Torx, there is still a ton of Philips etc.

      • @Signtist@bookwyr.me · 21 Oct 2026

        Pretty sure it’s trying to say these people would have maybe made a better standard, but didn’t try because they read the original comic and didn’t want to make a 15th shitty standard.

    • @apotheotic@beehaw.org · 21 Oct 2026

      “Why Photoshop an XKCD comic?” because they were making a point directly related to the XKCD comic?

  • @LegoBrickOnFire@lemmy.world · 22 Oct 2026

    A friend made this:

  • @nightlily@leminal.space · 21 Oct 2026

    Calling IRC a shitty standard sure is a take.

  • @NotAnonymousAtAll@feddit.org · 21 Oct 2026

    Adding yet another standard to the list of competing standards is not the right move.

    Just giving up and doing nothing is also not the right move (if you are in a position to actually do something and you have reason to care).

    The right move:

    Look at the details of all the competing standards. Evaluate their technical merit. Evaluate their organizational setup and potential to improve. Pick one. Push for its universal adoption and/or improvement.

  • @myszka@lemmy.ml · 22 Oct 2026

    There’s DeltaChat!

    Also Fluxer, a FOSS Discord clone, is getting beta federation this year.

    • @mnemonicmonkeys@sh.itjust.works · 22 Oct 2026

      Fluxer is using a pre-existing protocol though

      • @myszka@lemmy.ml · 22 Oct 2026

        Ah yeah, I mixed protocols with platforms using them. DeltaChat does have its own protocol though - Chatmail.

  • @HugeNerd@lemmy.ca · 22 Oct 2026

    USB-C

  • @db2@lemmy.world · 21 Oct 2026

    Why use two different 4 fonts though

    • @Ephera@lemmy.ml · 21 Oct 2026

      I genuinely thought it was a reference to the other four thing currently happening…

  • @grrgyle@slrpnk.net · 21 Oct 2026

    More standards! A million standards! A kaleidescope of possibilities, for every preference