Jon von Tetzchner, CEO and founder of Vivaldi Technologies, refuses to integrate AI features in its browser and wants human engineers, not AI, to write its code.
1232
Vivaldi CEO explains his anti-AI stance: most users don’t want AI in the browser
Cybernews
Vivaldi anti-AI stance: CEO says users reject it
50%-100% user growth puts Vivaldi anti-AI stance in focus as its CEO says users reject browser AI. See why the shift matters
cybernews.com
267 comments
log in to comment.
“Customers don’t want it” is surprisingly difficult to understand for a lot of companies nowadays. Vivaldi must be run by some sort of language genius.
It’s a private compnay, they don’t have to follow shareholders so it explains it
Methinks shareholders should somehow be concerned what end users want.
Shareholders want the line to go up, currently AI is a thing that makes that happen, long-term effects be damned.
you don’t want to be the one that missed out by not jumping on the train.
Somehow and for now
They are only concerned about money
Which is somehow related.
Yeah but they are usually not that smart, they only think in short term than long term
We have very prominent cases where this is true. But is it also true in general? Idk
Basically any public company right now?
onlythinkaboutnextquarter then thinkaboutnextquarter
step 3) profit?
Not as related as they should be. Stock prices are based on belief, not on reality.
It’s really dumb but it holds true. I work for a company that profits tens of millions per year, and we’re owned by one guy. I’ve worked at places that are owned by hedge funds or giant corporations like GE and you can just tell the difference. Here I’ve been told that if the shop needs something, it’s basically a blank check. The owner gave everyone in the company a $3 raise last year, and we get a 10% bonus of your salary annually as a profit sharing initiative. Annual raises are good, wages are excellent, benefits are some of the best in the country and they do everything they can to keep them as a low cost. We just happen to manufacture things that nobody else in the country does.
Compared to other other more typical companies it’s really night and day. I used to get a 3% annual raise and a “I can’t get you more even though I want to”. And some of the shittiest health insurance imaginable. My coworker broke his foot and they wouldn’t wait on him until he saw a specialist like wtf he literally just needed a cast
“wants”
it’s chromium, it uses ai. i think this guy wants to do marketing
Revolutionary technique, asking if anyone wants a feature before you go all-in on it.
Vivaldis not bad. Good for work where you need different profiles; not crazy resource intensive
I’m on librewolf just now having used vivaldi for about three years as my daily. Great browser, I just fancied swapping the chromium problems for gecko problems for a while :D
And for people like me with a problem closing tabs, the memory management is excellent, killing off anything that hasn’t been used in a while.
You can do that in Firefox too tbf
So what you’re saying is there are two good alternatives out there now?!
No, there is only Firefox.
Firefox gang ✊🏼
It’s my secondary browser. Pretty much just for HDR on YouTube. Firefox still can’t do it.
[deleted]
Would be a really really expected deciding factor for a secondary browser though.
Lmao
Yeah, it’s a good Chromium browser. I used it for a few years before switching to Firefox browsers. If you have to use Chromium, I’d recommend it. If you can though Firefox has been far more enjoyable (I’m using Zen currently).
Idk about not resource intensive but it does browser things happily.
It’s good for work when a woork-related website won’t accept a Gecko-based browser.
I’m not switching to Vivaldi, but it is refreshing to see someone say “I didn’t put X in the product because people don’t want X in the product.”
I’d use Vivaldi if it wasn’t chrorium and closed source, sadly it’s such a turn off
The UI layer is the only part that’s closed source. Vivaldi’s UI is also one of the main reasons people use it.
Yeah but de facto i still cannot see what they put in there
I, too, would use Vivaldi if it wasn’t Vivaldi.
[deleted]
Isn’t Vivaldi largely open source?
the devs like to pretend that it is and say how only a small part of it is proprietary, but it’s a deceptive PR stunt because they’re counting the whole chromium source into that statistic. if we don’t consider the chromium source they didn’t write, their own vivaldi code is largely proprietary.
regardless, a program consisting of 99.9% free code and 0.1% proprietary code is proprietary as a whole - you can’t audit, modify or redistribute copies of it as long as any non-free code is present.
I’ve tried Vivaldi before in the past and it’s UI and cluttered interface turned me way off. I’ve got my own concerns about it still that hasn’t made me jump to it. That being, it relies on the Chrome Web Store to install extensions. If Google themselves decided not to have something on that store and you’re using it on Vivaldi, well you’re SOL.
That’s an advantage for Firefox, that has its own extensions. Some of us are stuck with Firefox despite their interestingly bad choices and historical lack of fulfilling promises on their own behalf. There are still key advantages with Firefox than most browsers.
And even if some of us are tired of Firefox anyway, we’ve got its forks to use.
I’m the inverse. The amount of customization and power user features are what makes it my daily driver, though I agree the reliance on Google isn’t good. Also having their sync data stored e2e encrypted with my own private key is a nice touch. Though if a heavily customizable fork of Firefox with features like that was available I’d likely switch. I don’t have the time to maintain a highly customized userchrome.css that could break with every update, unfortunately
It’s been a long time since I used Vivaldi, but I find Zen browser fits what I remember of Vivaldi.
Just like the other person, I used Vivaldi for several years, but then switched to Firefox. Zen is my current browser, and it seems to fit into the place Vivaldi had pretty comfortably. It’s not identical, but it has a similar niche.
just as “most users” don’t want ai baked into their browser, “most users” probably don’t use any addons, or use only one–an adblocker. ad blocking (with configurable filter lists) is built into vivaldi already, no separate addon needed. works well-enough.
that said, the chromium base and its dependency on google to provide the ‘addon store’ is vivaldi’s main detractor, because google has been putting the screws to anything that threatens their business as a data harvesting advertising company.
vivaldi does have some features not found in other browsers or other chromium browsers (excepting some in common with opera). the one i appreciate the most is the configurable toolbars, both items and their positions… similar to how you can configure firefox’s main toolbar.
i do occasionally need a chromium browser for specific tasks. vivaldi is the one i use. usually as a ‘portable’ installation that is easiest to trash when i’m done. it’s also the one i use for a couple streaming sites because it does use chrome addons (but also is not chrome, either).
Does it still have built in mouse gestures? Opera was the first one to have them decades ago and I got so used to it I need addons for that now…
i always have them disabled, but yes. it does.
Ok, thank you. I’ll probably give it a try as a backup browser.
They have improved the UI quite a lot recently imo.
That’s why I use Librewolf/Ironfox on my laptop/phone. All the benefits of Firefox and none of the half-baked promises or bad decisions!
I feel like I could have written this comment word for word. But luckily you already did so now I only have to write this short one.
Note you can sideload extensions essentially. Google’s been fine afaik, but if they did suddenly go crazy it wouldn’t be that hard for Vivaldi and other chromium browsers to run their own store.
They should’ve been running their own store a long time ago. Not wait until Google reaches a line that’ll trigger them to.
got rid of it after i realised its more work to disable every new feature that just gets in the way.
Build Vivaldi on top of Firefox rather than Chrome, and I’m in.
Just use Firefox. It doesn’t have any AI built into it as far as I’m aware.
Its got a whole panel that pops open when you click the button in upper left corner under the tabs.
You can turn all the AI stuff off pretty easily, but yeah.
Yeah I mostly forget that panel even exists.
Unfortunately, vanilla Firefox does have AI built-in, as well as a lot of other garbage. Librewolf is a fork that strips out all that junk, and it bundles in some cool security features as well.
But apparently Vivaldi is good, too.
Then you may not be aware that it is has integrated AI features.
also, yall stop saying firefox sucks because all web browsers capable of the bloated standards are de facto corporate controlled
This ai stuff is like the new clippy the paperclip, GTFO of my phone.
I don’t want features just rolled out without my consent.
Long term I will have to install custom roms and get bank cards from my bank again thanks to AI.
I hate the fact that it’s so hard to buy an android phone without it coming with a load of proprietary apps that I can’t remove. If I want their casino shit, their stupid health apps, whatever - I’ll download it myself. Being unable to uninstall it really pisses me off. I’m pretty sure it’s practically malware. And the AI shit is just as bad - phone I’m on now came with at least 3 different AI apps for whatever. I did actually manage to remove two, but they keep trying to reinstall, could be hiding behind my launcher. And I bought this phone 2 years ago, I can only imagine it’s even harder to get away from these days.
Maybe I’m out of touch, but I think most people just want an operating system and the opportunity to install what they want on it.
I mean, much of it meets all the criteria to be called malware, so it is “walking like a duck” and “quacking like a duck”.
All that bloat is typically cross-marketing agreements made with the makers of those apps to subsidize the phone’s cost without user consent. The part that I find weird is that there have been almost no marketing trials from major players testing the waters to see how much of a market there is for the same products that are not subsidized in this way, available at “full price”. Maybe they’re afraid that would draw too much attention to how atrocious the existing offerings are by comparison. It might put the privacy discussion more into the public discourse, which could be bad for their “business model”.
Yeah, agreed. My suspicion is that the major players have considered this and decided that the value of the customer data they gain from their bullshit malware apps is more than they would make by selling a clean phone, even at premium prices. I don’t know how the numbers break down, but I’m sure they do and they are probably right. Maybe most people would rather have a cheap phone full of tacky bullshit. It would be nice to have the choice tho!
One of the happy accidents that has come from American technofascism is this rennaisance of open-source programming and development and a renewed interest in digital sovereignty. People have been building alternatives to what the tech oligarchs have been cramming down our throats, and it’s not only more secure and more functional, it’s getting more and more accessible to the public.
Take Graphene and PostmarketOS for instance. They’re both extremely easy to install on the right hardware. I haven’t had any complaints yet! :)
I bought a Pixel 9A and a Pixel tablet and installed Graphene because I wanted control over my own device, no unnecessary spyware apps and no forced AI and the ability to just install what I want and both have been great. Everything I’ve needed has basically just worked (a couple of apps required me to change a setting) but there’s a few major outliers to that ‘it just works’ that fortunately I don’t need - like the VW app. I was shocked at how easy it was to install and by Lemmy standards I’m not very tech savvy (although I had an issue with a Linux update on my computer last night and was able to get it working again, so by normal people standards I’m a hacker lol).
Right now it’s fantastic but I worry Google’s crackdown on “sideloading” is going to hinder that open source adoption - anyone who has already done so is probably going to be less squeamish about a couple extra steps and whatever bullshit warnings Google throws at them but for new normies I worry they’re more likely to be scared off. It’s also a sign Google is going to take more steps to fight our rebellion - I did just find out the Pixel 11 will be getting Graphene so I was going to say that’s another Google attack but good news on that one, initially they thought it wasn’t going to be possible.
How’s Postmarket compare to Graphene? I went with Graphene because fewer development targets are usually a good thing for the end user, but that tablet end of support is closer than I’d like…
Would give it a try if it wasn’t proprietary.
Hell, I’d use it if it wasn’t Chromium.
i still yearn for an alternative reality where opera never abandoned it’s engine
It’s hard to convince me to switch away from Firefox, but Vivaldi doesn’t seem like a horrible choice if you need Chromium for WebUSB or something.
If you really need Chromium … just use Chromium?
yeah, ungoogled chromium is boss
Vanadium appreciates the mention.
Is there a way to get a good adblock on Vanadium? I’ve still got it set as default on my phone but mostly use Firefox for regular stuff, but it’s so annoying to click a link in the Lemmy app and it opens in Vanadium with ads.
Not sure.
I use Vanadium as my clean-room browser, with no addons etc, when I want a page to just-work.
Oh, yeah that seems like a really good use for it.
Helium is great too.
Been using it as my daily and am really happy
Vivaldi is pretty nice though
That may be. I prefer using fully open source browsers though.
Nice!
I really hope Vivaldi stays good. It’s basically the only browser I’m considering usable. I’ll make do with something else in a pinch, but surfing the web without Vivaldi is like not having a hand.
I’m using it for stuff that doesn’t work without Chromium (like a translation tool that doesn’t break SPA forms) but yeah not being able to use my custom adblockers concerns me.
Same. If it weren’t a Chromium browser I’d explore it more, it seems to have a lot of neat options.
Waterfox is better, it’s open source, not based on chromium and has a split DNS resolution path through their own servers and cloudlfare. A few tweaks in about:config and it’s by far the best option out there.
What are some of your about:config tweaks?
There are several, depending on your level of paranoia, you may want to only change a few or go deep into the rabbit hole. Basically when you install waterfox, you should first check the regular settings, for example, strict enhanced traffic protection in the privacy and security tab is a good start, there are more in other tabs that you can navigate quite easily and are pretty straightforward.
In about:config, one of the most important is geo.enabled, this one should definitely be set to false, it’s even recommended on the arch Linux wiki. You can also set both privacy.fingerprintingProtection and privacy.resistFingerprinting to true (the second one will, among other things, set your local clock static at UTC 0, so the payload you send out will always show UTC timezone, wherever you are). However, keep in mind that the second one will also break some websites that you’ll visit as well as slowing down your browsing experience a bit.
In the end it’s always a trade off between privacy and convenience, so you can explore and see the config that works best for your particular case.
Thanks!
And it’s also free of AI.
The repo has a CLAUDE.md brother
Sure it is. Does it have mouse gestures?
I’ve liked Librewolf so far. I haven’t tried Waterfox yet.
Firefox has locally run AI features you can turn off easily. I don’t see the harm. Occasionally I use the translation feature for foreign websites.
If you ask me, Firefox gets a lot of shit and it’s blown completely out of proportion. Are they without flaw? Of course not, but it’s not nearly as bad as people want you to believe.
AI features should be opt in, not opt out. Every time it updates it also often turns those features back on (at least a couple times for me)
I turned it off once and it stayed off.
The AI features are why I switched to Waterfox, as they promised to not implement the Firefox’s AI-stuff. That promise has held, at least so far.
Good to know. I see they are available both on Linux and android, so all bases covered.
It’s a purity race to oblivion : people who know and care use Firefox. They switched away from the default and by that very action they are in the tiny minority who actually has a grasp at problems and dare try to do something about. They are vocal about it, put efforts into the process so they in general want “more” and “better” according to their own criteria. It doesn’t stop there though, once they have moved away for privacy or open source or sovereignty or whatever else, they want the other criteria and it won’t stop.
It is recursive though, people who care a lot about some criteria move away from Firefox, the now “mainstream” within that community, then use e.g. Waterfox or LibreWolf. You can see this in any community which moves away from the mainstream choice really. There is a vocal minority within the minority and they do have genuine reasons and concern.
Once you use LibreWolf I bet there are other forks, etc, etc.
For those people what Firefox is doing is actually very bad because it goes back to what they wanted to move away from.
I will add, that enshittification is a big part of the process. Money drives companies do things users do not like, and the only power we hold against that, is to walk away. If we do not use that power, things will only get worse, or end up in a monopoly situation, where you lose most of that power, and all of it, if it is something, you must use.
What often happens is, that the wave kind of starts as a small movement away, and when the enshittification goes too far (and competition has not been killed successfully yet), it gets bigger and bigger. And that wave brings money, which either starts or hastens the enshittification process of the product people moved to. And the cycle repeats.
Instead I switched to Waterfox which is just Firefox with all of the bullshit excluded.
The problem isn’t what is in Firefox now, it’s what will be in Firefox in the future. It’s their clearly established predilection for mindless trend-chasing and willingness to ignore their users’ clearly stated wishes in order to pack the damn thing full of crap nobody wants anyway rather than actually utilize their comparatively meager resources towards actually developing the actual browser part of the browser. That’s a huge issue.
the problem with Firefox AI implementation was more of a communication issue.
Firefox keeps adding stuff like this to its browser and it keeps messing up a good thing. I don’t mind them adding experiments, but they keep trying to add stuff that places them as intermediaries in some kind of convenient “service” that is offered.
for whatever reason they just can’t stop from shoving all that stuff into their main product instead treating it as a side project
adult person right here. true G.
AI is just a more destructive and environmentally catastrophic NFT.
What do they have to do with each other?
NFT tried to be an alternative to currency, But it almost endangered the economy and general affordability guarantees the same way AI used up water sources and federally protected forests
To be clear NFTs tried to be a replacement to traditional proof of asset ownership like paper deeds and such. Then a bunch of people used that to create contracts for ownership of links to assets and sold that to speculative investors, aka morons, and thus another actually neat technology with a good niche dies.
Similar to the blockchain being an amazing technology that could instantly verify transactions with complete accuracy; and instead got used for alternative currencies.
Cryptocurrencies (blockchain-backed contract ownership of assigned mathematical conclusions) tried to be currency, NFTs in popular culture tried to be art (as in how art is actually bought and sold in the real world for money laundering.)
AI (GAN including LLMs), like blockchain and NFTs, has its extremely specific narrow use case for society - one that is currently overblown and is being used incorrectly in all parts of society, and wasting the resources used and tarnishing the technology at the same time.
Crypto is working out great for criminals and NK.
It’s Not About the Technology, It’s About the Money
In a mechanical sense not a whole lot, but in both the reason why they are being focused on and what it does to the cost of computer parts they are quite similar. NFTs, Metaverse, and AI have all gotten the focus they have because the tech industry has been chasing the high of the internet and later smart phone booms, they all want the next big thing but they are all ignorant to fact that the only reason said booms worked was because of the broad utility which AI and NFTs have little of.
I think AI should be a choice, not something every browser has to push on its users. Everyone has their own preferences.
The recent controversy on House House makes me (only a little) worried that for the next century, most people will be hardline 100% never-AI, instead of just “Stop shoving it everywhere, stop copying artwork”. As people like Bernie have said, it’s an automation technology that can have nice effects should those use cases receive careful consideration. We just don’t often get that consideration.
I will never understand why the push to AI was so freaking AGGRESSIVE. Like, take it, shove it down your throat, avoidance of AI is BANNED, type of bullshit. It should speak for itself when it works.
So just the way Firefox does it? Only local models, all configurable?
Perhaps
based af. I’m installing Vivaldi right now, holy shit.
It’s Chromium based.
I’m uninstalling it right now!
They’re right. Vivaldi is based
…on chromium
the superior browser engine sorry not sorry (i’ve had way too much trouble with everything gecko-based even though i want to support it, the technical issues make it nearly impossible)
I just vibe code my own browser, with blackjack and hookers.
cool. open source your product and i might consider using it
The arrogance in this statement, lol. :)
I mean sure, I get it, but what I dont get is why a company would have paid engineers working on a product and give it away for free if that’s their only income stream? How will they pay their engineers? Pay for office space? Make a profit?
It’s funny that people expect free stuff but complain when their data is being sold to ad agencies. :)
Like, shit, why can’t I sit here on my throne and have companies give me free stuff and maybe I will decide to use it from the kindness of my heart. :)
Firefox is open-source, and shares the same business model as Vivaldi.
Mozilla has revenue directly from Google search that is keeping the company afloat.
You probably know this. Otherwise you should have asked yourself how they can have offices and employees with no income to the company…
Vivaldi does too.
If Google ever becomes certain that their monopoly state is in no danger of being broken by legislature, they stop financing Firefox, and Mozilla immediately dies to bankruptcy.
I think your example serves the other guy’s point…
If Google ever stops developing Chromium with a Free/permissive license, then Vivaldi dies too.
In short: Google has full control over the entire browser market either way.
Well, that’s true… For the moment
Can you say more? Do you mean that people may want AI in the browser soon? I’m just curious.
Most likely they notice the pattern that corporations are inherently slimy, selfish, and shortsighted. It might be anti-ai now a days but how long will that last?
I kinda find this idea cool like theres other browsers like Firefox that makes AI optional to choose
Great, now cover over why you rolled over for manifest v2 shitcanning. YOU WERE MY CHOSEN ONE VIVALDI , I NEED A CHROME BACKUP
That’s not hard to explain: it would require a ton of resources to maintain a fork with manifest v2, for a small usecase. Vivaldi is a small company compared to say Mozilla.
Plus the main usecase for v2, ad blockers, is already covered by their built in one.
Yup Vivaldi + ublock origin is still perfect for any web browsing. I’m remarkably surprised I still don’t get YouTube ads.
Basically they don’t have the manpower to maintain a whole Chromium fork that still supports manifest v2. Even if they kept it in for a while, every upstream change might break things on their end.
It sucks and it’s the main reason why I recently switched from Vivaldi to Floorp, at least on some of my machines. Vivaldi’s ad blocker just isn’t comparable to uBlock Origin.
How is Floorp?
It’s fine. Occasionally I feel like the performance is a bit worse (for example I need to set my energy profile to balanced to keep videos from stuttering while Vivaldi plays them fine on the lowest setting) but overall I am happy enough.
Floorp is my favorite Firefox fork currently
Ahh, damn, right. Nah i’m happy with LibreWolf for all the things that Firefox does well. I do wish its fingerprinting score was higher.
I still need Chrome for too much work, though.
Vivaldi is a proprietary Chromium reskin.
Librawolf is simply firefox and I do, but there are things that need chrome. I need both of them for certain things.
IMO Librewolf ain’t simply Firefox, and I don’t think folks would say this if they gave Librewolf a chance. A lot of the corporate cruft/AI-adjacent stuff is removed, it’s not just a reskin with adblock. It’s a holistically better browser experience.
Edit: removed unintentional double negative
I’m running Libre, it’s my main, but can’t use my webflashers, the support in google meet, sound and screen sharing is crap.
It’s not a simple thing that I like chrome. A great deal of crap i need for work demands it.
And then I end up on Brave because I’m running a bunch of Manifest V2 plugins.
Also, firefox can’t seem to get anti-fingerprinting right. Noone wants to be ready to lie and randomize data but brave.
I simply want to stop using brave as my second browser, I don’t even want it installed, but I’m stuck with it.
Funny you say that because some sites just don’t work in librewolf, which is because it is protecting you, but still adds to friction.
For things that specifically need a Chromium-based browser, like WebUSB, I use ungoogled-chromium.
Ungoogle-chromium still has manifestV2?
No. Ungoogled-chromium is literally just Chromium with the Google shit stripped out. If you want manifest v2, use something based on Firefox, like Librewolf.
yeah already main Libre, but that does nothing for me when I need webUSB webSerial or to use google meet sharing.
I just keep two browsers around for different purposes.
That’s what I do, but I don’t want brave to be one of them :)
I think you’ll find what you need in either Brave or Helium, or both.
Brave does what I need. I just really fucking hate those people. Last time I tried Helium i had to abandon, but fuck if I can remember why.
I’m about the same. I feel like Brave has a bunch of questionable trash built in, but unlike other services or software with questionable trash and clutter, Brave let’s you super easily flick the switch to turn all of it off, and crucially, they actually respect your choice, and never pester you with any of that crap again, after optinh out.
Helium does seem like a really good, cleaner browser, though. Sort of like Brave, but without any of the icky cruft. I basically have it on stand by, so that I can jump ship as soon as I need to. I think in order for me to switch, either Brave needs to do, change or introduce something that directly affects me as a user in a way I can’t abide, or Helium needs to introduce an equivalent of Brave Shields. Despite the huge overlap with uBlock Origin, my experience is that the combination of the two provides a better level of protection than either of them are able to afford on their own, and what with the current state of the web, that’s not something I’d be thrilled to compromise on. If that wasn’t a concern I’d probably be using elinks as my main browser!
I could leave Brave because I don’t trust the CEO not to sell my browsing habits as long as the new target browser plays nice with google meet and sharing audio with single tabs and provides randomized fingerprint protection.
My husband has a lot of nostalgia for opera (long story, don’t ask) but some of the dubious connections there made them a non-option for us as we got more into internet privacy. He was super happy when I switched him over to Vivaldi.
opera died for me when it abandoned it’s own engine
I was an Opera user for a decade. I think their designers left to start Vivaldi.
That’s correct. They wanted to build Opera the way it could have been if different choices were made. I think they built something really good.
I never heard that connection but I do know it was sort of intended as a spiritual successor to opera, so if true, that would make a LOT of sense
Jon von Tetzchner used to be the CEO of Opera.
Vivaldi is great, I switched from Opera as soon as the beta was released. Been in Vivaldi for years and years now.
Im never leaving zen, its been stable for a while now, was so ass when I started using it, now I never lose anything, forgot it used to be rough
Does the vimium plugin work on zen yet? That was the only pain point that was holding me back from switching last time I tried it.
I will always advocate ai for shit like this, just make it work yourself, debug it by using it. Make it show you it’s work, sometimes it’s a simple edit, have it avoid restructuring and use minimal code. Can easily be done for free. Ik it’s obviously preferred to have official support but for things like plugins, I just get to use them now instead of waiting for my issue to never be resolved.
Eh, until there is actual support I’ll just use a browser that supports what I need. Zen is nice, but the difference isn’t great enough for me to want to spend a whole bunch of time making things work.
This guy is my new hero.
Yeah, loved Vivaldi until it started randomly corrupting my profiles after not starting up correctly. Now I’m back on Firefox -_-
I use AI on a daily basis and I don’t want AI in my browser. The desire to integrate AI into everything is not smart.
Been on the wolf for quite some time, but I gotta respect Vivaldis values
Bro looked at steams pro consumer behavior and thought “hmm, I wonder if I could do that too?”
[deleted]
If we ignore privacy and open-source considerations for a moment, Vivaldi has been one of my favorite browsers. They embraced vertical tabs, they offer customizability instead of forcing everyone into the same mold, and it doesn’t have all the anti-features (AI specifically) that some other browsers have.
I’m gonna give them a high five while continuing to use LibreWolf/IronFox.
Unsurprisingly simple. I like this guy…assuming he’s mistress free ofc
AI is much too energy consuming to be a default option.
Been using it for years on my phone. It’s great. Some webpage doesn’t work well with it though but imo those are the site not worth visiting.
HIRE THIS MAN
Can’t understand we’ve gotten this far and no one has mentioned Helium.
I Zen Browser and Vivaldi. Vivaldi is great.
[deleted]
Imagine that tomorrow Tetschner goes crazy and starts dating a Chinese spy. Or joins the Trumpist sect…
remember when they let Homer design a car?
same shit happens when users get to design software.
I want AI in my browser, as long as it is zero data retention (edit: used ZDR) and hosted in Europe with local hosting as an option. AND if it can be fully turned off.
If somehow it all gets worked into becoming less detrimental I think it just needs to be reworked from the way Google and such tries to do it. Summaries shouldn’t be a default response. Waste of space/resources and can be very frustrating. At least in duckduckgo I’ve seen they try to chop it from responding, then if you want the summary you can click the down arrow so you get it.
So many quick searches result in useless data spewing on for umpteen lines taking up the whole page just for someone to glance at it and scroll past it all to a site that is specific to the data search.
Zdr?
Zero data retention
I’m going to stick with Firefox but also because they take the same stance.
Excel when they aren’t. Firefox bundles AI with their browser. Sure they let you turn it off. But it’s turned on by default and still there.
I’m fine with that, I’m not about to turn on them when I’m given a choice and they do many other great things
They should use AI testing to find exploits. It’s good at that.
If its like a built in translator and a chat ui and you can opt-in(or at bare minimum opt-out) its fine for me I guess
Seems much of Lemmy is still married to Firefox despite all their slop and Alphabet funding.
I’m going to keep beating the Vivaldi drum as their mission has always been clear. Yes I understand the chromium backbone, but as long as uBlock continues to work I’m staying on board.
You can like one thing without having to shit on the other. Firefox is fine. Vivaldi is cool. Simple as that. Not everything is a team sport.
The browser wars require browser fighting words, I am always happy to hear critique about these products… especially in 2026 when the corpo’s meta game is to completely stifle any and all bad PR / reviews / discussion.
I’m not shitting, just explaining reason I don’t like it.
Seems more like you’re explaining why you think others shouldn’t like it.
Try not to read into it too much.
You typed it out to be read. Now you don’t want people to read to much in to it after I guess not liking the reception.
I typed out why I don’t like it. I know exactly how people here feel about Firefox. It’s very predictable. Its the one AI software they will defend tirelessly.
What browser do you use? If you hate Chrome and Firefox, that's really going to limit your choices. Derivatives of both of those must be forbidden too because all of those would cease to exist if the base browsers vanished.
Something WebKit based? Or are you using something based on the Goanna fork of Gecko?
Who’s hating, I thi k maybe you responded to the wrong comment?
Was this you?:
Your wording appeared to imply a solid dislike for Alphabet which I then took to be transferred onto their own browser - Chrome - and the browser who takes Alphabet's dime - Firefox.
I can see that there might be other ways to interpret that sentence and get the true shade of meaning you intended, but I'm not sure which one it is if it isn't the one I thought it was.
Oh, I thought it was obvious that I’m using Vivaldi.
I don’t like Alphabet. I think it’s really hypocritical though for all the people that use Firefox even though it doesn’t perform nearly as well and is a pro Ai browser paid for by Google to criticize those that use a chromium forked browser built by a company dedicated to privacy and avoiding AI. To me at least obviously better to support something that has taken free code from Google and repurposed it to be very anti Google than to support something that has deep financial ties to Google. I know you all disagree, I get it that, but this is where I stand.
Chromium is still Chromium. Would I rather that Mozilla got off their AI kick and didn't have to take Alphabet's dime? Sure.
But at least I'm not using a Chromium.
My emergency browser is the MiniBrowser that comes with the WebKit packages on Linux.
As for speed, I don't see any issue. Maybe I might if I switched between browser engines on a regular basis, so I don't do that.
Demonstrating that you’re not on the same team!
Definitely a free thinker! Not big on teams.
Nah, they don’t just like it; they’re married to it. And with that into the clan that wanders around the steppes, downvoting every thing that challenges them and their beloved. This is, in essence, The Browser War that really doesn’t have any other participants.
Is their beloved good? lol, well it’s constantly in the news for all the wrong reasons. Is it a good experience? If you’re into being a sub, yes. Does it perform well? Such questions are not allowed in the clan, but they believe it to be so based on clan size.
Most of all, they swear against Chromium, but park their Steam icons right next to Firefox on their desktop trays.
There is no mercy for anyone seen not using Firefox. Mixed-browser friendships are an abomination. Not caring much about extensions is death.
You seem to have got all worked up over this.
Just so you know, caring about what browser someone uses and recommending one are two separate things.
I couldnt give a fuck if you use Vivaldi, Chrome, Safari, Firefox, Edge or anything else.
I just prefer to recommend the open source ones, that are not holding a massive market share and run on an engine that is controlled by Google.
Like, relax, use Chrome to your heart's content, if that is what makes you happy.
He gets worked up over lots of things. It’s an old account with no comment history that sprung up in the last few days being oddly aggressive and toxic.
It is weird.
I wasn’t even talking about browsers… Sort of just a loose comparison of Firefox fans and the hordes of Genghis. You can pretend they’re fans of something else, if you like.
so you are worried about the alphabet funding but use a chromium based browser?
Right. This is really. Really fucking weird.
Yes, I said that, why is this phrased as a question? Money has a huge influence. I’d rather use something thats getting something free from gooe (chromium core) than a something from a company getting paid by them
there’s also something to be said for having a backwards-compatible configuration and history that stretches over 25 years. it’s why i stayed on gecko when switching browser.
Edit: apparently vivaldi is closed-source? huh.
Not really closed source all the way, only aspects of it. It’s still both weird and offputting, but it is slightly different.
By only aspects of it they mean the chromium base. What makes vivaldi not the same as chromium is proprietary
What?
The official words: https://vivaldi.com/blog/technology/why-isnt-vivaldi-browser-open-source/
It was my understanding that the closed source part was limited to their visual aspects, as the functional changes they make have to adhere to the licence of chromium. Unless that’s changed; I haven’t looked into it in a couple of years. It’s where their “skin” applies that they keep it proprietary in other words.
That Chromium backbone is exactly why. Firefox or forks of it are preferred. Other browsers using different engines can also be recommended, but I only know of some WIP projects right now. Also, Vivaldi is proprietary, not open source.
Oh wait it’s Chromium?! I have things that need that to work, so even tho I EXCLUSIVELY use FF forks for browsing on my computer, I have to dip into edge (eww) for those web applets to work. Would Vavldi be a good alternative? Better than… ugh… BRAVE, anyway?
Yes, Vivaldi is a good chromium browser when some oddball site doesn’t work.
You know what works great with FF&Forks; ad-blockers that aren’t sellouts.
Perfect, I’ll snag that for the like four hardware things I have that need Chromium for settings, and continue using FF forks for anything real!
Yeah, or just use Ungoogled Chromium, that's about as raw as it gets without any proprietary shit.
I’d recommend helium, it’s my favorite chromium browser because it’s fairly customizable and very privacy-respecting. I’d say it’s like the librewolf of chromium, for lack of a better comparison.
Thank you! That sounds even better, I’ll look into that!
IE6 teaches us that a multi-engine web is best, though…
UBlock origin is just so much better than any other ad blocker, and it’s Firefox’s main feature.
So Firefox main feature is something made not by Firefox? That’s a little sad. Why not use uBlock on Vivaldi?
Because it’s chromium-based and Google broke that possibility on purpose. It’s what they get for being Google’s bitch.
It works just fine if you aren’t using chrome. It’s not broke in chromium.
Googles bitch? You mean firefox? The company that wouldn’t exist without a regular paycheck from google?
They wouldn’t be mooching on Google’s tit to survive if Mozilla played their cards better. But they haven’t and now are reliant on them.
Firefox is still the better browser, and frankly I can’t just get over that anything else is simply chrome with a skin.
I like Vivaldi, it is my secondary browser, but Firefox is preferred. But good for you, anything is better than Brave. Vivaldi has some great aspirations of being a suite like Mozilla was back in the day, but if they want to do that, they need to make their upgrades not break their sync. The fact that happens so often makes me worry a little about their overall system.
Does casting tabs to a TV work?
Why would you cast tabs specifically to a TV and not just cast to the entire TV Itself and just make it a big pseudo monitor? 🤔
Because if you’re just casting a video, you can still use your PC/phone while it’s playing.
But you can do that if you cast directly from desktop too lol, maybe I’m just misunderstanding what exactly is going on here. I swear it’s way simpler / reliable to just cast directly from the OS, at least in my experience 🤷
Continuing to use Firefox so that Google has to keep wasting their money on it to avoid the antitrust lawsuit >>>
As someone who’s extremely picky about my browsers/extensions/etc AND who’s forced to use Edge and Chrome at work…. I make due with Firefox because everything else is just off enough that I can’t commit to ‘em longterm
For anyone saying it’s Chromium based as a reason to not use it: how is Mozilla any better at this point? Can you point to anything notable and positive that Mozilla has done in the past idk 10 years or so? They won’t even include adblocking with their browser our of fear they lose Google’s support.
Maintaining a viable cross platform 3rd party browser with proper extensions support including Ublock and strict tracking controls?
None of that is unique to Firefox though. Vivaldi has all those features too and adblock don’t even require an extension its just built in, Mozilla doesn’t even include adblocking by default.
An additional engine is important because otherwise the implementation becomes the standard instead of the engine following the standard. That is a risk to further competition. We saw that when IE won too hard over Netscape.
It’s not “proper extensions support” if they don’t work half the time, and start working only after the website is loaded. Breaks gestures support completely, for instance.
Firefox is great, don’t get me wrong, but there’s A LOT wrong with its extensions system.
Ad-blocker extensions aren’t crippled, browsers are fully open source including cloud services instead of Google’s open core model and Mozilla has a better track record on this sort of stuff. Also technically Firefox does have built-in ad blocking capabilities now but for some reason there isn’t a UI for it yet.
I’d consider not making adblocking built in part of the browser to be crippling the browser, who wants that? But if Mozilla did include it they’d lose millions in funding from guess who.
If you go to
about:configand enableprivacy.trackingprotection.content.protection.enabled, then you can add the blocklists toprivacy.trackingprotection.content.protection.test_list_urlsand use the built-in adblocker. I think Waterfox also builts a UI on top of this.Interesting feature but you lost 90% of users at “if you go to about:config”, Meanwhile since 2020 when you first launch vivalidi they just ask if you want to enable it
Who values their users more, the advertising company that has been shoveling in unwanted features to their browser for over a decade while leaving the most wanted one behind “about:config” or a 3rd party extension, or the one who’s browser actually has features people actually asked for?
Waterfox is great, hopefully they can continue without google’s support whenever google decided to pull the plug on firefox now that they no longer need it as anti-trust insurance.
More like the company that values their users enough to make both the browser core and its cloud integrations open source versus a company that slapped a proprietary reskin that can’t be forked on top of Chromium.
I hope Vivaldi can survive when Google cripples Chromium like they’re doing with AOSP since its browser engine is literally made by them
The UI being closed is a valid criticism for sure. I’ve read their reasoning for it and having seen how some corps abuse open source I find it a fair move, much more so then I consider not including an Adblock option out of the box, or whatever pocket was and shoveling in AI no one asked for. Certainly other people will have different priorities and I can respect that too.
But they “abused” open source software themselves, so I’m going to call bullshit on that
Which the forks removed because unlike Vivaldi Firefox is open source
That’s why you’re shipping Chrome with a very attractive skin and set of add-ons, by modern measure (reminiscent of Britannica electronic versions from year 2001 or I don’t know what), that’s still not as functional, convenient and generally awesome as Opera 12.
I’m not qualified to give anyone business advice, especially JvT, just think that in web browser market the field is so dead (as in captured by oligopoly) that retrospectively they were more likely to succeed forking a subset of Web standards and explicitly positioning continuations of Opera as a client for that and not mainstream Web.
Or claiming compliance with W3C standards and rejecting WHATWG etc.
And, of course, making it a paid product again, perhaps with a free version with ads and part of features locked (as it were before they made the browser free but with Google search and Google payments from that, what could go wrong ; I suspect those people were still psychologically a Norwegian state telecom company project and wanted some “public” sort of funding with product free to use, and remember how Google was positioning itself almost like a non-commercial entity). Compared to the amount of ads on webpages, this is nothing, and back then people were still a bit more computer literate in general and that they’d understand.
That’s not a heavier task than competing with Chrome/Safari/etc was as Opera Software, and perhaps that’s not even a heavier task that Vivaldi is doing.
I mean, W3C standards at least end somewhere and are not defined by what their combined competition collectively decides as fast as they need.
But it’s been 13 years already, and back then seriously thinking of dropping/forking the Web as a platform, or at least Google “standards” of it, wasn’t possible. Now there’s Telegram attaining more and more functionality, and other messengers and siloed services, and non-siloed ones, like NOSTR and Gemini (hypertext, not AI).
Anyway, there’s just one thing I don’t understand about them, if Google killed their business, why try it again depending on Google again? Couldn’t they base it on WebKit? On Firefox?
Google didn’t kill their business. Opera moved to chromium to save money.
The end user does not give a shit what engine their browser is built on. They care that [a] it has the features they want and [b] works well. Webkit still does not satisfy [a] and neither would running a subset of web standards. Firefox I’m not sure about. That said, running off chromium has worked fine for them so far.
That’s all fine except it turned out that most of Opera users did give a shit. It was a very convenient browser, with much of its convenience connected to the engine. Usability features connected to webpage source viewing and editing in place, caching of page snapshots, being rather fast on most websites ( yes, some crazy shitload of JS could hang or even crash it, but for most of the Web it was faster and used less memory ), various display settings ( like adaptive page width ) to override shitty websites.
Their main product was usability, but it was a somewhat tall building hugely based on features of their browser engine.
Anyway, this doesn’t even matter, Chropera as a browser is something most people don’t even notice. Opera before Chrome was one of the main browsers.
It also had a torrent client, an RSS client, and a few other things, all very convenient.
And yes, Google did kill their business (that shell still possessing the brand isn’t interesting).
My best guess is that everyone is optimising their websites for Chrome for the most part, so forking Firefox would potentially be seen as a negative for users. Most likely why almost all companies fork Chrome instead of literally anything else.
I mean, if firefox didn’t kneecap themselves every so often then probably people would also optimize for firefox. One example, WebUSB. I can configure my keyboard from a website. No need to install any 3rd party native app. On chrome, you have webserial on Android even. So I do have PWA that I can use to read sensor over serial via OTG. Not only that, chrome also support PWA install even on desktop. Firefox removed PWA ability to be installed on the desktop. That’s why technically electron is not needed if companies aren’t so greedy to spy on your pc using more invasive method. Just ship the html, css, assets and js then let the browser be the sandbox. No need to ship the browser itself.
Oh yes, there were plenty of fools crying “oh Google, oh holy Google, deliver us from having to test for many browsers”, so that was a pressure too, people just can’t learn that oligopoly is bad and monopoly is worse.
I really do appreciate that he has enough sense to recognize everyone hates AI, I just wish he also had enough sense to recognize Vivaldi sucks.
There’s a name I haven’t heard for a while, but kudos I guess. Been using Brave for the blue moon when I need a browser with unreasonable access to subsystems (like yearly perhaps) and I know they have suckage, but yearly. Any reason to change (linux)?
Personally, Zen and the art of less bullshit. YMMV.
Wow, this was minus five a little while ago, doesn’t seem so bad. Did I trigger a bot farm or am I missing something?
Remind me in a year (2027-11-13): Vivaldi has gone bankrupt.
Ironically we don’t have bots here so you’re asking a human to just remember.
@remindme@mstdn.social 3 minutes
This is awesome, thank you.
You’re very welcome 🙂
I obviously will have such a thing any day now.
We do, actually. Hang on as I find the saved comment with the code
I was wrong
@remindme@mstdn.social 1 year
@remindme@mstdn.social 1 year