1385
Proton users cancel subscriptions following CEO Andy Yen’s “loser thinking” remarks
Cybernews
Proton users cancel subscriptions over CEO’s AI push
8 current and 1 former staff described AI security concerns as Proton users cancel subscriptions over Andy Yen’s remarks. Read what the evidence shows
cybernews.com
350 comments
log in to comment.
I’ve been putting it off, because it took me more than a year to migrate away from Gmail. But this is hard to ignore. I’m tired, fam.
Though, I learned my lesson and bought my own domain. So this pivot should be better.
I would love to chat this through with you. I have some domains but honestly, Iʻve been told so many times to not roll my own…
Do not run your own email server - highly recommend using your own domain though. Use a provider that lets you BYO your domain. Just make sure you get your MX records correct with your DNS provider, most email providers have documentation for this.
The hard thing about email is getting all your contacts to use your he address, it is not migrating your email history. So owing the domain is the most important thing you can do.
You do not have to own your email server, if you have the domain you can go wherever.
You do then have to defend your domain name, which means making sure it will not expire and is locked.
One thing on anyone wondering for migrating mail history, Thunderbird works fine for this, Outlook actually also does is it, I want to say a bit better. You don’t have to regularly use Outlook, but if you map both the old and new account you can drag and drop mail between them and it just works.
Likewise. I never plan to host my own email server. You can bring your own domain to Proton, at least.
ngl, I feel very burried by the effort to “de-google”. Like, Iʻm close, very close, and email is like the last thing to do (along with cloud backup).
I started with cloud backup, it’s going reasonably. I’m using something called Jottacloud which so far has been solid for me and has a lot of different types of backups. Migrated some-odd 25000 photos, slowly getting through the rest of my stuff on google drive. Soon I’ll be below the 15g and switch to free it’ll be great then I can work on the rest of degoogling
It takes so much work and feels impossible the entire time especially while all the rest of life keeps happening. One step at a time I guess
heh. cute.
I started with considerably more, down to the last 50g now, basically tying up loose ends and organizing all the “will organize later” as I move them to my new service
It’s very simple. Buy your domain for the next ten years for under $200. Then find an email provider where you can bring your own domain. Namecheap has always been good to me. Maybe also Hetzner in Germany?
Hetzner provides email with their cheapest webhosting package at €1.60 a month.
Namecheap is a little more pricey than I expected. You pay $89.28/2 years with a promo code - Renews for $143.76/2 years
As others say, buy a domain so it’s easier in the future.
But one thing what helped me was relay email addresses. Whether that’s Addy, Simplelogin (now owned by proton so probably not), Firefox Relay, or another. When you sign up to shit, buy something, etc, use one of these email addresses. When you eventually move to your new email address, you can cutover all those accounts to the new one by changing the settings for where it forwards email to.
You can also use your own domain with a catchall and make up your own whatever@yourdomain if you’re ready for that.
I did my own email server for a while using Mail in a Box. It’s not hard, but it’s a hassle.
Now I just pay like $36 a year I think for Purelymail. Works great.
[deleted]
You don’t need your own server to have the benefit the person you’re replying to is pointing out. If you control the domain, you can just point your DNS at another provider. For example, you can move your catch all inbox in Tuta to a mailbox.org plan with a catch all with a simple DNS update. Then you don’t need to change your email addresses anywhere.
[deleted]
I didn’t say anything about “owning the name” other than just buying a domain in general (which you’d also need to do for something self hosted). I am simply saying that using providers that allow for catch all can give you privacy while also giving you the ability to jump ship.
My primary domain, for example, is not memorable, and it does not have ease of verbal transmission. It’s a string I randomly generated.
What is this endeavor? Control? Your own domain gives you control. Privacy? This is dependent on your provider, VPS, or otherwise. SMTP is generally blocked on residential IPs, so you’re going to have to trust and give up control and some level or privacy somewhere. Having a domain gives you the ability to self host if you desire, and if you don’t want to do that, then having a domain gives you the ability to easily change mail providers if needed, without the need to change hundreds of accounts.
Honestly if your using tuta tho its no different then proton. Both are crap for different reasons. One has crap privacy enforcement and the other is ran by a dick head.
Seriously it baffles me that anyone thinks a german company is remotely trust worthy for security. Its a fucking joke. Any country that has a deal with five eyes should just be assumed its compromised up front. If theres no out side enforcement of security then any promise of it from the inside is worthless.
E2E encryption doesn’t matter when you can’t trust the actual host in the first place.
I was using Tuta to mailbox as an example for this very reason: you can move your catch all inbox from Tuta to mailbox.org, since it also supports catch all. I’m trying to highlight the benefit that using a service with catch all functionality adds, which is flexibility and easy migration. It was not meant as a recommendation to use Tuta.
Not referring to Tuta specifically, but isnt that the point of E2E encryption? That you have assurance even if you don’t trust the host? Unless they don’t demonstrate and publish what encryption mechanism they use of course.
Your not entirely wrong. It’s mostly the fact, that even with e2e your still relying on their word that they aren’t doing something shady or do something stupid. There’s no external force keeping them honest.
One is none two is one. Someone’s word is good but someone’s word, and another keeping them honest is better.
If your going to trust someone else it’s better some form of equality in the deal. As a consumer to a corp that’s basically impossible with out a legal enforcement layer.
Fuck it. Let’s make an easy open source email host and all the corpse can wall us out and we’ll just email each other. Wait this sounds familiar.
What do you mean? That idea is brand new!
Yeah, it's taken me a similar time to migrate away from Gmail and I'm not keen to repeat the process. But if this is what Proton's code quality control is going to be like going forward - employees forced to push improperly-tested code because of their unhinged CEO - I'm going to have to go through the whole process again. Sigh.
I spent the day getting things set up to leave.
Pass went to KeePass, which was easier than I expected.
Drive is now replaced with Filen.io
Standard Notes is now Obsidian
Looking at AirVPN, but not ready to pull the trigger on that yet.
Still looking for a calendar. Thunderbird has one but it’s not on mobile for some reason.
The big one is mail. I was the same as you migrating from gmail so I’m learning my lesson now. Set up Thundermail today and have 3 custom domains set up. Spent hours today swapping out account emails. It’s rough, but I did it to myself. I knew going full Proton ecosystem was a bad idea, but at the time I just wanted out of Google. Take your time.
Baikal and any client that supports CalDAV, my friend.
Thanks, I’ll give it a look. Self hosting is a huge learning curve for me, I hate network stuff lol.
People may not like the idea of what I’m about to say but here’s a thought from someone who also found self hosting to be overwhelming at first and now self hosts everything but email. The learning curve is flatter than you probably imagine it to be if you are doing normal things with mostly default settings. I recommend docker containers to start. Find something you want to host and just follow the directions in the man pages. You might not understand everything initially but you’ll quickly pick it up as you change the handful of variables in a docker compose file to fit your setup. It will also help you get used to how to structure your files and folders in a way that makes things flow easier. Everything in docker can be done in the terminal which also takes away a layer of complexity.
I moved to Linux a while back and only discovered docker after setting everything up. Haven’t got around to learning about it yet, Linux itself was a lot of info lol. Do you use docker containers for like every app you install? Like if I start with an old laptop and try syncthing, should that be installed in a docker container?
I use it for every server app I install. Mainly because it easier to migrate applications between machines. Docker gives you a consistent build environment so you don’t have to worry about having 12 versions of Python installed and they are all wrong and then when you find the right one it breaks something else (this was never a common problem for me but it is annoying when it happens.) So, using docker-compose (recommended over cli commands because you can see all in one place what everything does and where it goes) you just edit the compose file to fit your scenario and build it. It is pretty easy and fast. When and if you decide you want everything accessible from the Internet you can read a few guides and knock it out in an afternoon. The reverse proxies can also be run as containers. Here’s the page for the sync thing container. To use it, install docker, create the folders the container calls for, edit the compose file as necessary, go to the folder the compose file is located in and run docker compose up -d and your build will start
Problem is that any vpn not in switzerland is basically an explict step down. Trusting a company that is in a country that has no enforcement means your trusting the company it self entirely to stay honest. At least with proton, no matter what the idiots at the top want. They still have to comply with their local laws.
That alone keeps proton above airVPN if your using a VPN for privacy reasons. It always will, no matter what. The entire country would have to change its laws for that to change.
Now if your just using a VPN for routing purposes or something that security is not a high piro. Then air VPN is fantastic.
Yeah, I’ve been struggling with this. I’m thinking when my mail gets sorted I’ll go down to just the vpn subscription for now. Keeping one service isn’t perfect, but perfect shouldn’t be the enemy of good. keeping 1 of the 8 services is way better than all 8 lol.
Flexibility and diversification is annoying to manage but tends to be the best situation over all.
Proton does things right generally speaking, it’s just ran by an absolute idiot.
So you also have to weigh are your morals and expectations here reasonable to your own acceptance level. Vs your own requirements of the service at hand.
There are plenty of reasons to need a VPN that the extra security and privacy guarantee are beyond worthless. And in those cases staying in proton doesn’t make since if your morals go against the company.
While if you absolutely need that privacy and guarantee switching is a very real risk.
Plenty of people like having privacy but for some it’s actively a life or death situation. So you have to make that call. Where do you sit on that spectrum, and are your morals important enough to take the risk if your on the extreme end?
For most people who aren’t, switching is just a formality and technical consideration.
I mean I believe you, but thoughts on this comment: reddit
This is also a distortion. Proton has a tool that labels which code is AI-generated and which is human-written, which is important for many reasons. It can’t be used to evaluate how much AI somebody is using. The design document for the tool states this clearly. This document is available to all employees: r/ProtonMail - I’m a Proton employee and I’m breaking my silence The security point
The list goes on and on. Same with the security point. I have access to that chat. Andy never said don’t do pen testing. It’s true, he used shitty language and he personally apologized to the whole company. However in that same security chat he also said something 404 omitted: “The baseline is, we must do this plus be faster at the same time” in reference to security testing. r/ProtonMail - I’m a Proton employee and I’m breaking my silence
He agreed with the additional pen testing, and it was even recently implemented at Proton. What he didn’t agree to was it slowing down the pipeline. About hiring engineers
This quote “this is the last year that we hire engineers” is also out of context. At Proton, the engineering and product management roles are merging and we call this new discipline “Product Engineering”. Proton also mostly hires product managers with engineering backgrounds. It means we stop hiring engineers who just code, and hire instead product engineers who also exercise product judgment that AI doesn’t have, not that we don’t hire engineers at all. I know this because I help with hiring for the whole company. One last thing
I want to put a few words out there that aren’t about quotes or screenshots, but about my experience.
To be honest to you, we’re all in a bit of a shock after reading the articles written, and some of the criticism hurts me because it described a company I don’t recognize. Reading the comments on Reddit hurts me because so many of them do not reflect reality. Proton is not rushing into AI without concern for safety, it is actually being done very carefully.
If you’re deciding whether to keep using Proton, I’d just ask that you make that decision after getting the full picture, and not solely on the quotes that have been intentionally taken out of context. Otherwise, you are only hurting the workers that you claim to want to protect.
For some reason your copy paste mangles the text, but the original seems to have some interesting context. I like 404, but it seems like they do as much click bait as anywhere else these days.
Internet journalism is about as yellow as classic journalism ever was. Its always been “click bait” always will be. lol
Gotta always take everything with a grain of salt and assume things are misrepresented either on accident or on purpose. Its a PITA but it is what it is.
The thread here news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50317991 raises some valid concerns about the Reddit post in question. It explicitly even says its been approved by the company, so idunno. 404 Media has done a lot of legit exposés in the last few years. I’m inclined to trust journalists over the guy posting on Reddit with permission from Proton. The screenshots apparently included show Yen telling an employee to do damage control with their personal account on reddit, which really makes things look even worse, doesn’t it?
I’m waiting to see if I’ll start using it.
I canceled my renewal but I’be been putting off finding a replacement because what you said. It’s exhausting.
I use fastmail. Super happy so far.
Thanks for the recommendation! I’ll look it up!
If I’d only put off de-googling a bit longer before I saw the news I could have skipped this hop. Oh well…
I’m eyeballing Tuta. Anyone have other recommendations?
I’d recommend an e-mail provider that supports custom domains, so you can easily switch at any time. I personally use Purelymail; I’ve also heard good things about Fastmail and Migadu.
I’ve never quite finished moving all my domains to Proton from google, but I think I’m leaning towards infomaniak.com for now, on the Business plan with my and my brothers family using the service
Tuta mail and calendar has been a real easy switch. I imported my emails from proton and just started a fresh calendar because I could and it was a good excuse to clean mine up.
The iOS apps work well and the experimental flatpak on desktop has been totally fine.
I have very little complaints so far tbh. I’m not like blown away or anything but everything just seems to work.
Same exact situation. In fact I’m not even fully done migrating away from Gmail although most of my stuff is on Proton now. sigh I guess I’m starting all over again soon.
The only reasonably future proof solution is to get your own domain, and redirect emails sent to @yourdomain.com to your email provider.
Then you can freely change providers in the future but your email addresses stay the same. Doing that costs very little and doesn’t require any self hosting, just buying a domain. Looks professional too.
yes but doesnt that just get flagged as spam?
also many services require a google or apple address to be viable
The mx server ip will be from the email provider with thousands of whitelisted domains. You get lumped in with the rest and cosidered safe. Spam filters use Bayesian statistics, the logic is not what you expect.
No, your emails are still sent from your providers servers and are signed by Proton/Tuta/Gmail/whatever you choose to use. Your domain is the from: field but it was sent by the actual email provider with all the trust behind it.
I never ran into something requiring a Google/Apple address. Some may require a Google account, but you can create a Google account with any email address. You don’t actually need to use Gmail on your Google account.
If you’re willing to run “mail-in-a-box”, with full control of the DNS for your domain name, it sets up all of the security DNS records to not get flagged as spam.
If you’re unwilling or unable to let mail-in-a-box control the full DNS for your domain, mail-in-a-box still has a page that will list every DNS record that needs add to your un-self-hosted DNS. It is many many DNS records, for best spam protection.
My other concern was receiving spam.
But the default spam filter in mail-in-a-box felt immediately noticeably (but just anecdotally) better than the one built into Proton. Which surprised me. I had assumed that I would give up some spam filter quality by self-hosting.
Custom domain without self hosting still requires you to use an email provider, could even be google. The only problem is if you self host and don’t rely on trusted proxies, at which point it depends on the reputation of the IP/Domain etc.
$1/month for a custom domain. One last migration. And then moving platforms is much easier because you don’t need to change the email on every service.
That said, I still hear you.
I think I’m going to start using my own domain, so I can change hosts if needed without having to change email addresses. This seems like it’s going to be an issue we’ll always need to be prepared to deal with.
Exact same situation with me. Going to start this weekend on self hosting email and then the transition process. I still have around 6 months left on my proton subscription, so enough time to move everything.
[deleted]
GOG is a good company we all pay for.
Give it a few generations for the selection pressure of the market / the temptations of new leadership to take over.
Not with the AI generated images they use
They no longer use it.
I open it right now and all I see is flashy text with game cover art in the offers/deals pages.
DRM-free is a big plus.
Is there a source or proof on that? Or is it just that you didn’t find it right now on their website?
The big drama was during their “2026 sale”, where they used GenAI promotional art for the event. They also seem to have refused to confirm using GenAI, and at the time made no promise/commitment to stop.
The GOG that knowingly sent out emails with Nazi symbols in?
Didn’t get one.
Talking about GOG the DRM-free digital PC game store.
Yes they sent an email with the subject containing two runes resembling the SS logo.
“They didn’t notice”, but somehow they didn’t send it to German users
This genuinely looked like a mistake, where was it reported they didnt send it to German users? I only saw that it was a German QA team that noticed it.
Article linked elsewhere seems to indicate it didn’t go to German users because the German QA team found the issue before it was sent, but due to an internal communication breakdown the issue didn’t make it back to the international team before the emails had already been sent. GOG immediately apologized for the mistake and changed their internal processes to catch these types of mistakes sooner.
It very much reads like an honest mistake, and even then it only impacted a subset of GOG users because it’s entirely dependent on the font used to render the email subject. The actual Unicode character used was a curved S (a letter from the Greek character set), but certain fonts render it looking more like the infamous SS symbol.
I’m not German and I didn’t get the twisted cross email.
What?
heise.de/…/GOG-apologizes-for-newsletter-with-SS-…
Thanks for posting this. Fucking Lemmy man. That reads like a genuine mistake to me… not everything is a conspiracy lol. If you just read the thread here, you’d believe that GOG were some underground Nazi apologists or something.
Yeah my thoughts exactly.
No, it was a fucking dog whistle for one simple reason: why use the last symbol double? If all of them were doubled or single? Sure, I could believe the mistake angle. But only that one symbol doubled where it doesn’t make any sense to double the “intended” symbol? I don’t believe it. That are too many coincidences necessary for me to believe it.
As the saying goes, always check and double check your sources 😉
Holy shit do people need to get educated on Occam’s Razor.
In this case Hanlon’s Razor might be more relevant ;D
Just discovered that principle, while it’s true for many situations, it’s really effective because not everthing nor always everthing is simpler, the principle itself seems to be simplifying things; in the end, that principle is the same thing that bring us to many right-wing ideas which we heavly criticize
Yes!
GOG published a letter with neo Nazi imagery, knowingly said it wouldn’t be okay in Germany, and sent the email to everywhere else. After a huge outrage they gave a meaningless apology without any real comitment to investigating how it happened or how they would ensure it never happened again.
I have found if you choose providers that do things like run on 100% sustainable energy, you tend to find the places where leadership’s morals overtake their pockets. There are a few mail providers like this.
Coincidentally I was thinking about cancelling just for the financial benefit since I will be making significantly less money soon
Tuta is a good alternative. I am in the process of migrating there right now.
Its an explicitly worse alternative what are you on about. Its in a eyes country. Its literally an explicit step down on every level.
The moment tuta goes to shit there is nothing stepping them from going all the way. At least with proton the legal requirements of the country they are in means that no matter what stupid shit the dickhead at the top does. They are REQUIRED to adhere to a minimum standard.
Tuta has NO legal requirement to do that.
If you remotely care about privacy and enforcement of the standard of care around it. Tuta is like one of the stupidest places you can go.
I considered Germany a plus and they are one of the few options with total E2EE. I have not finished migrating yet, so what alternatives do you recommend?
Sorry, but you saying you’re tired after one switch is pretty funny. Many people here have gone through this several times for many different services etc. You have no idea what being tired actually means in this case.
Saying that others have it worse is putting the wrong person down especially when you dont know anything else about their life. We should be putting the companies and people that put us in the predicament in the first place down. They are the ones causing the problems. Not the commenter you responded to.
I’ve not really shown my hand, either.
For example. I had a Slashdot account before I had a Digg account before I had a Reddit account before I had a Lemmy account.
Do not cite the Deep Magic to me, Witch! I was there when it was written.
what the hell are you even fighting? who are you fighting with? this isnt the meaningless ‘we’re not the same’ bickering is it? if youre tired, act the part: give it a rest.
[deleted]
Say and do stupid shit, get stupid prizes.
Proton’s reputation has been getting shaky. First it was the poorly worded communication regarding support for Republicans. Then the privacy in question when they handed user’s data over to authorities. Now this.
How’s that for loser thinking, Andy?
Ok, the first 2 instances are wildly out of context, don’t know how much it is the case in the newest case.
The congratulations to Trump were for the appointment of Gail Slater, which he very much agreed to because of Slater’s reputation as being “not good for big tech”. (Slater did not last long, as expected)
And the “data transfer” to authorities was a legal requirement imposed by the courts of the country they are in (based on “terrorism” charges by the french authorities - for essentially squatting), with no actually doable legal recourse left (as it often is in “terrrorism” cases). No preexisting data was available. They had to wait for the activist to log in, to catch the IP address of the client connecting to the surveilled account in the live system.
Refusing to comply with lawful orders of the country you are seated in can absolutely wreck your shit, and you might even lose control over your infrastructure people depend on.
And had the activist used an VPN to connect to his mailbox, the story would have probably ended there, especially if the VPN had been Proton itself - the injunction was only for the Mailbox, and VPNs are pretty much untouchable regarding surveillance in Switzerland.
There was something before that about providing a journalists data to authorities or something too.
After a Swiss court order, and they only could provide an IP adressen where the account was first made. Don’t spread partial information that doesn’t reflect wat happened.
This is exactly the sort of thing why im baffled that people are leaving for companies in countries with either little or literally no data privacy laws.
Sure andy is a dipshit. But at least he doesn’t get a god damn say over how some things are done. Because the law sits out side his control.
You make a great point.
But have you never met a CEO who used their access to break the law?
Trust is tricky, and an individual choice.
My security use case isn’t preventing government access.
I think I was pretty clear I didn’t know the full details in my comment. Besides, I don’t see what is misinformation here. And IP address is a user’s data.
Don’t forget about Proton sponsoring Nazi YouTubers.
This is the quoted article: www.404media.co/manifestos-fear-and-loser-thinkin…
Personally I am okay with code being written by AI as long as it is properly being checked and tested. The CEO is a prime example of management becoming a security and safety risk, which all engineers know is very dangerous. It is the same story as what caused the Challenger disaster.
I have a 2 year ProtonVPN Plus subscription so there is not really a point in canceling it right now, but if this situation doesn’t change by the end of those 2 years I’m inclined to not renew it.
That CEO needs to step down, not just for their reputation but for the safety of their software.
Your first sentence is basically impossible. When reviewing code, your insight is always inferior to the person who wrote it. Often my code reviews consist of questioning the programmer on why they’ve done what they have, because I need their perspective as well.
You can’t do that with an LLM because it doesn’t really know why it did things.
And testing properly…? Nobody does that. LLM or human.
I disagree with this. Just reviewing the code is exactly what I mean by “properly being checked and tested”.
There are people/companies that just vibe code the hell out of their stuff without any review whatsoever. That’s not something I want to touch.
I was warming up to this. It certainly is better than vibe coding, but I’ve started to see libraries [with this ai policy] push out bigger releases faster with bad ergonomics and unnecessary, undocumented breaking changes, because the ai quietly migrated the internal tests/examples.
Clearly, they’re reviewing large amounts with an eye on new features and they’re not thinking through ergonomics: spending time with it, writing it themselves, and seeing where the sticking points are.
Maybe if you’re using ai for the migration, then-- problem avoided, for now. As time goes on I could see it compounding and becoming a tangled mess that’s not only inaccessible to humans, but requires more and more compute to navigate than thoughtful, handcrafted code.
I disagree.
I agree.
I agree.
Is Andy Yen the asian version of Johnny Cash?
Fuck, that got me.
Shit that made me laugh out loud and my fiance is asleep in the next room
No he’s the Asian version of Eddie Money
I already cancelled a couple of years ago when this same man posted a pro-Trump comment. That seems to have been forgotten about, some people dismissed it as just a comment, I’ve even been downvoted since for trying to warn people, and now look.
Same. Andy the chameleon slowly but surely revealing to be exactly the person he showed us he is. I believed him the first time.
That, plus the fact that they hand over data to cops with no warrant, and now this… I made a Tuta account until I can figure out self hosted email. Proton was supposes to be the good version of Google.
This is terrible, but what is even worse is that they partnered with a Zionist Swiss university, that supports Israeli military and out criminal sanctions against students protesting against the genocide of Palestinians.
Partnership announcement.
Israel military connection and student prosecution.
Oh ffs
Oh come on. Guilt by association for everyone that deals with the ETH Zürich.
Eh, everyone’s got their moral line they won’t cross, and it’s up to them to decide how many levels of association they’ll tolerate.
Look, as a vegan I know how hard it is to draw lines between people who choose to inflict unnecessary suffering and who merely don’t think much about that and live their lives as well as they can. If I would go with that zeal of the antizionist crowd I would expect everyone else to starve because almost nothing is “untainted” (and remain very opportunistic with my own consumption standards)
What zeal? I just posted information that for me is important in how I make a decision. Are you also against the BDS movement for pointing out companies that do business with a government committing genocide? As a vegan, would you buy (vegan) shoes from a company that also makes leather shoes, but only buys leather from a company that skins cows alive? Would you not tell people “Hey, this shoe company is getting their leather from a company that skins cows alive. Maybe avoid them?”, if you saw a post about that shoe company? (fyi, not that i think that anything that happens with animal factory farming is ethical)
I am not looking down on anyone in this post or calling them unethical for not focusing on this point. I understand that different people have different thresholds to take action and different things which are important for them. I don’t expect anyone to be perfect or to only search for untainted things. Just to try to do better for the world with their choices, wherever they can. I also know I am very privileged to be able to make the choices I have that align with my moral standards, and that a lot of people are not able to do that.
Since here it’s about a university, the comparison would rather be “would I buy vegan shoes made from a technology developed at a university that also partners with other universities in which – among many other things that happen in a university – also someone busies himself with skinning cows alive.”
And here I come back to my original response. Oh come on, how far do you want to go with a moral outrage with guilt by association?
With such a moral attitude, taken seriously, I would starve barefoot. But I don’t, and I also don’t suggest it to others. Veganism has a hard stance as it is. I would refrain from such a stretchy argument purely to protect the perceived sanity of the movement.
Antizionists quite regularly use these stretchy guilt by association arguments. that is the zeal I mean.
I understand where you are coming from. We have different thresholds to consider this an issue, and that’s fine.
My problem with ETH Zurich is not only the collaboration with the Israeli university, but also that thy brought criminal charges against students peacefully protesting their partnership with Israel. That to me shows that they support the Israeli genocide of Palestinians. That makes them guilty. Not by association, but by their actions.
Thanks for that. I am putting the facts as I understood out there, and stating my opinion on it. Not trying to force anyone to side with me.
You know someone’s value by the company they choose to keep, in my opinion.
They made the choice to partner with a university that supports genocide. No one forced them.
By that logic you probably also cancel anyone who uses Microsoft, because undoubtedly they also make business with Israel.
First of all, I am not cancelling anyone. I am choosing with my wallet which organization align with my ethical standards.
Unfortunately Microsoft has a stranglehold with M365, so I also have to be practical. But I do not do any business with Microsoft directly, and actually prefer organizations which also do not use Microsoft where I can. It’s the same with Amazon or Cloudflare for example. I do not do any business with them directly, but also it is impossible to avoid organizations that don’t work with them because they run most of the internet.
In the case of Proton, it’s an add-on to an add-on service which is not the core part of their business.
I feel this attitude of it’s all or nothing is very defeatist and is used as an excuse to not try to make better choices. Just because not all of my choices are 100% aligned with my ethical values due to the world we live in, it does not mean I should not make better choices where I can.
To me it looks like you apply standards rather arbitrary, not because the standards are reasonable in the first place, but to loudly proclaim your moral stance. Which is antizionist, and in the internet hardly distinguishable from its bigger sister antisemitism. And particularly the arbitration is a reason to suspect your comment has little to do with Protons CEOs stance towards AI, but much more with intoxicating everything with antizionist rhetoric.
How am i being arbitrary? How is it not reasonable to not want to give money to institutions that do business with people directly supporting the Israeli military?
Semitism is a religion, Zionism is a political ideology. Not every Zionist is a Jew and not every Jewish person is Zionist.
I have nothing against Jewish or Israeli people for that matter. In fact I fully support all the Israeli people currently protesting against the genocide.
I just pointed out an addition reason to move away from proton which matters to me. Is it not an important reason to you, then fine.
Hm let’s see. Do you support those same Israelis also should they succeed and want to continue to live in their own country?
First thing. Do you accept that israel is commiting a genocode in Palestine, and that its immoral?
Now for my answer to your question. I am not naive enough to say its not a complicated issue. Many generations have passed since Palestinian land was stolen to form Israel. The same can be said for a lot of other countries, but it’s not as recent history as here.
I am not smart enough to come up with an answer, but I am sure smarter people can come up with something that is fair to Palestinians whose land were stolen and population murdered, and Israelis who were born there because of actions taken many generations ago.
But while the Israeli government is literally irradicating the Palestinian people, this is an irrelevant discussion. The Zionist goal is to conquer Palestine and get rid of all the Arabs in the process. The fact that they are commiting crimes against humanity, which are on pat (if nor worst) to what the Nazis did to the Jews is unquestionable. Is it too much to say we should boycott any organizations enabling and or defending genocide?
The term genocide has two very distinct meanings. One is the juridical meaning, and I believe there is enough substance to have this disputed at the ICC. I’m all for bringing netanyahu and his bunch to justice, and even should the genocide not hold up for some reason, there certainly will be enough evidence crimes against humanity so they can serve a long long time.
The other is the moral meaning. But in my eyes this is very overused by the antizionist zeal. It was already used right on October 7th before Israel did any reaction to the hamas attacks, and for every single action since. The story of the boy who cried wolf comes to mind.
it’s arguments like this which makes the movement seem so uneducated:
The Nazis took every single Jew (and communist, and disabled or homosexual person, or any other scapegoat group) of any age they could find, in Germany, or any conquered country and put them into wagon trains. The trains would take the victims to Dachau or another concentration and working camp, if they were lucky. Dachau is a museum nowadays, school classes go in there joking, and come out very very sober. It’s worth a visit.
If they were less lucky they would be brought to Auschwitz or Treblinka or another of the 6 extermination camps. There they were carefully registered, stripped of clothes, dignity and anything remotely of worth, and then either put directly into the gas chambers. Or they were put into the camp from which workers were selected for moving the bodies into the furnaces. Alternatively, from the camp they were picked for a death march, or a ride on a truck, where the exhaust was funneled into the loading area, with the purpose to asphyxiate the victims. Or they were picked for experiments from the likes of Joseph Mengele. Or or or …
The list of Nazi crimes is much longer than this. And it is also very well documented. These things happened without a doubt.
I see many accusations against the IDF, and the list of accusations of crimes against humanity is long and worth following through before the ICC. But the Nazi comparison only shows you have no real historic perspective.
Everyone go vote at their feedback website. There are several posts in the General Suggestions section that suggest Andy Yen step down. Mark them as critical.
Yes, abusing their feedback website will certainly make them do what you want instead of dismissing you as the crazy fringe people you are.
“Crazy fringe people” is literally who Proton was marketed to. Mainstream audience is perfectly fine with Gmail, if they piss off the “fringe” they’re pissing off their main userbase.
People giving customer feedback are crazy?
AbusingRightly using!
They've started collecting red flags like they were the Soviet Union. Welp, this is the last one I'll watch them pick up, though.
What a fucking time to be alive.
“I want to get off Mr. Bones’ Wild Ride!"
It’s terrible.
Peanut butter jelly time to be alive?
It’s a bit surprising how many CEO’s express disdain for their users and employees.
When employees are reduced to an “input resource” number on a spreadsheet, and they sit insulated from user complaints, and likely surround themselves with sycophants, I suppose it’s inevitable.
Power corrupts, you can see it all around us once you start looking.
Yes, but also the corporate world has a nasty tendency to promote psychopaths to CEO positions because they think a lack of humility is the same as competence.
It’s not just in the corporate world. Trump is a good example. He’s a complete douchebag and obviously has no clue about anything, but he somehow makes up for it with his extreme self-confidence.
The world is extremely complex, so it’s understandable that posers who claim to have figured it out are popular. I think many people even know that the guy they’re following is full of shit, but they can’t accept that they are victims of forces they don’t control or even understand, so they lie to themselves to at least feel a little bit of security.
They aren’t all bad though yet all of them generally get a bad rap because the internet accepts conspiracy theories as gospel. I’ve worked the tech industry for three decades now and will argue the middle management make up most of the psychopathic population per capita.
Well yeah but where do you think they get the CEOs from?
Not surprising one bit if you understand how Capitalism works. We are just tools of the bourgeoisie.
Those who’ve never known hunger, hate to share even a morsel or crumb.
It should be common knowledge but marketing and legal teams spend lots of money and time protecting them.
You mean PR department. Marketing department does market research and ads
PR department is propaganda department. When propaganda earned a negative reputation, Edward Bernays, the same person who wrote the book that coined the term Propaganda coined the term PR to replace it in an American corporate context.
In a lot of companies those roles overlap.
No, I mean marketing the org. They own the brand. C-level activities directly impact brand so marketing works to mitigate impact.
Its a great metric for a corporate job. Still into how they decide what features are built for their products, what gets priority. Best places I worked at always involved customer feedback in some way. Arrogant line go up places always chat about looking at competitors and feeling out the market.
Turns out when you build things customers want, they keep being customers. Who woulda thunk.
All you have to do as a CEO is shut the fuck up and let your product do the talking. The less I hear about your shit views the more likely I am to stay with your product.
The issue is to become a successful CEO you tend to have to believe your own lies and very quickly surround yourself with sycophants. Whats more if you buck this trend you tend to limit your skillset as societally we reward bullshit more than results.
South Park really got it right this season lol
When someone shows you who they really are, believe them the first time. And sadly, this is who Proton is right now, this guy. And this is who the Proton board is, people who support this guy and his vision.
This is proton. Shop accordingly.
The original 404 Media article.
404 Media is a great publication with a strong track record. They are worth paying for.
So true, they’ve really been rapidly climbing in my books over the last year especially. One of my favorite news sources rn. Would love recommendations for ones of similar quality outside tech, for any topics?
He’s literally why I never signed up with Proton. Bullett dodged.
Same, and a got a lot of downvote for saying I didn’t trust them. Custom domain + 1Tb nextcloud is my jam and really not that expensive.
Is it selfhosted
Same here. I am really getting tired of managing my exim4 setup, but since he made the trump comments I didn’t trust him or proton by extension.
If anyone nowadays builds something they can’t just bask in the success, the feel the need to spew ideologies all of a sudden.
Not everyone can be VLC
I am, once again, offering to take over as CEO of Proton.
My work focuses on nonprofit-stakeholder-government relations. Specifically how organizations mediate between state agencies and stakeholders. No agenda beyond aligning mission, vision, and values, and keeping it that way.
Reach out if you prefer that to help guide Proton somewhere other than the trash bin of distrust.
Ok it is yours good luck
Your confidence in my abilities is both recognized and appreciated.
I’ve heard enough. If I was on the board, you’d have my vote. ✅
Thank you virtual non-board member!
You’re welcome. 🤝🏾
You habe my vote!
Huzzah! I’m getting more votes than I ever did for school government!
The only reason I haven’t cancelled yet is because I moved my family, including my parents, onto a family plan with them, and that’s going to be a lot of work to move everyone again.
But this shit fucking sucks. I recommended this product to my loved ones because it’s supposed to be trustworthy and secure, and now I find out it’s neither of those things.
If you’re a Proton customer right now and not in a position to simply cancel your account, submit a support ticket laying out your concerns. I got a detailed and lengthy response back within a day (one that was clearly not a form letter either, it directly addressed all the points I raised). Flooding their support channels will make it clear that they are in some serious shit here.
Write to the Proton Foundation too. Demand that Yen be removed from the board and the company, and that serious changes be made to the leadership at Proton to ensure this never happens again.
I’m moving off of proton due to this and it’s just me. It’s still difficult finding a better solution. Good luck.
I’d recommend either Fastmail, Posteo or Mailfence for email, Cryptpad for Drive, Keepass for Vault, NymVPN for VPN, and literally any FOSS calendar app for calendar.
I moved to mailbox.org for mail and vaultwarden and Obscura for pass and vpn.
The advice I use for myself is always assume a service will either turn shitty enough that you need to leave, or just shut down due to some reason, so I try and only use services that make it easy to move away from.
So instead of Proton or Tuta, use a normal email provider that provides IMAP and supports a custom domain name. There are good ones around for privacy and features like Mailbox.org or similar.
A domain is ~$12/year and ensures you (hopefully) never need to change a bunch of emails on accounts again even if moving to a different email provider.
That’s great advice, when you don’t have to explain to your elderly parents why you need to migrate their email for the second time in six months.
Yeah, I canceled my sub. I have no idea if the CEO of my new email provider is any better, but I know that Yen is abusive to his employees, and that matters to me. I know he’s deep in the throes of AI psychosis, and that makes me not trust him at all. I’m gone.
The services I use could be run by child-raping centaurs for all I know. But they keep their mouths shut and stay in the shadows. Ignorance is bliss.
Certainly hoping the child-raping centaurs aren’t running my email server… but I think there’s a little more here than blissful ignorance. I think it matters that, even if my new mail CEO is as bad as Yen, he hopefully sees that he’ll be punished if he acts like Yen. Because I’m not the only one that has left Proton: I think Yen is really going to feel the heat. Hopefully that deflates the egos of other techbro overlords…
What did you end up switching to?
mailbox.org
Ah okay. I considered that one but Tuta had double the storage for the same price, so I went with them.
Slagging off his employees, slagging off his customers. Real bright spark this guy.
This guy sounds like a Mini Musk and I hate Musk.
If they are gonna have no qc and insecure code, they should also lower the price, right?
I took my payment method off so it can’t auto renew. If there aren’t significant changes, I’m gone. Really sucks because I bought all in on their product stack, just pretty much all of it. Oh well.
Guilty.
And I made sure they knew precisely why.
He really doesnt understand the user base that Proton built over the years. He sounds like an asshole that was built by a Tiger mom and Frog dad.
Fire that loser, maybe then (some) people come back.
I suspected my distrust of Proton would eventually prove right. Too bad.
Too late Andy. You are not going to be part of the tech overlord aristocracy, no matter how much you simp now.
Maybe it’s a good thing for you. May avoid the french doctor’s invention that way.
Some people should just never hold any sort of power. Most people shouldn’t, but some motherfuckers in particular.
[deleted]
I’m so tired of this
Does anyone have VPN replacement recommendations? (Besides mullvad, already looking into them)
Rethink mullvad: https://www.theregister.com/software/2026/07/21/some-mullvad-vpn-customers-tunnel-for-exit-after-co-founder-donates-millions-to-populist-party/5275012
God Dammit. Guess no mullvad. Thanks for this
what about nord?
Surely you aren’t serious.
not serious. but it was sincere. which clearly you are not capable of.
There is no need for hostility.
NordVPN has documented issues with:
Indeed. There was never ever any need for the unnecessary hostility you started with here. It shouldn’t take all this for you to Be nice.
In what way do you perceive my words here to be hostile? I said only that I suspected you were kidding: I assumed you understood that NordVPN is a famously bad VPN. Again, it hid a data breach for 18mo.
You, however, accused me of an incapability of sincere thought, which is hostile and insulting.
I have not been hostile or rude to you, despite your hostility and brashness toward me. I struggle to see how you are offended, or how you took an imagined slight as justification for verbal rock-slinging.
Wow.
Youre a manipulative little dipshit.
populism bad again?
“Populist” is media kid gloves speak for “right-wing Russian propaganda idiots”.
ivpn, nym, or airvpn
Any of them got port forwarding?
AirVPN does, I have used them for 6 years or so ans been pretty happy.
Thanks, might look into that.
PIA. I never really trusted them but they’re cheap and my trust for the rest has lower the bar
Will look into these! Thanks!
I use Windscribe.
ivpn
I believe AirVPN is a solid one, port forwarding support too.
I’ve had PIA for about a year now with no issues.
Been using fastmail for the past 5 years. Really happy with the service.
I like how they’re just sticking with email and not trying to build a full ass replacement for the whole Google Suite.
I wouldn’t mind an ass replacement.
Too bad they keep a lot of data in US servers, even when you choose EU hosting.
I feel like a good rule of thumb for Andy to say something, seemingly publicly or privately, is to just take a breath and then shut the fuck up instead. It seems like nothing he ever says brings comfort and confidence to his company’s users.
And to think…I ALMOST went through and paid for a subscription a couple of days after I started my migration from Google.
How has the board not fired him over this shit show yet
It didn’t affect them economically
It will.
He’s majority share holder.
If true, him stepping down won’t change a thing.
I’m so glad I delayed switching over to proton.
Also fuck that guy. What an ass.
What did you end up switcheroo-ing to?
I went with Tuta because of the value/GB. Also they feel fully committed to the users’ rights and privacy.
On a side note, he’s smart for letting a lot of people back out of Proton services. The VPN speeds are better now.😆
Never used them because their software wasn’t open source, and thus meant I would be unable to switch to another provider. Seems I made the right choice.
And to think…I ALMOST went through and paid for a subscription a couple of days after I started my migration from Google.
I’ve been procrastinating on buying their full subscription too. Now I’m glad.
So what do we have tot use then? All tech is so globalised that even EU-based soft is not independent/safe tot use. If Proton is not good anymore, what is?
Highly recommend mailbox.org with a custom domain
The only software that is acceptable to run as SaaS is email, rest should be either self hosted or not ran at all. And even email should be chosen wisely - I’ve has good experience with Tuta, as their emails are encrypted, that’s why you can’t use a desktop client, unless you find a way to decrypt these malls yourself via some kind of automation.
mailfence.com I might switch to this.
Could make more progress on LibreMail. github.com/mikegioia/libremail
[removed]
Seems nice, BUT it’s American, and thus, subject to the American government’s laws and whims.
It’s their company, so this is just an undisclosed advertisement.
At first glance seems like a very solid approach.
Posteo mail, excellwnt provider, good ethics posteo.de/en
More expensive per GB than Tuta, for those wondering.
Mine is paid up for another 8 months and will not be renewed. Im looking at replacements as we speak
This article only speaks about reddit users, how can you be privacy focused and not want to be part of a tech bro company and then use reddit?
Reddit’s terrible privacy practices are what made me leave years ago. Everything you look at and do is sold to Google. Making it a browser fingerprint profiling gold mine.
People on reddit thinking they’re practicing privacy are often asking questions like “I used my friend’s microwave? Does the FBI have my phone number now?” They’re mostly idiots.
No one on Privacy Guides is canceling, or least they’re not public about it. Because of their desire for privacy.
Yet another case of “you either die the hero, or you live long enough to become the villain”
Except the lifespan for the former seems to be about 6 months :)
Aparently it should have been, either you die a hero or live long enough for people to find out you were always the villian :)
God dammit… this totally validates my procrastination in signing up.
Im pretty buggered here, there’s no other VPN that does two things I need, per app routing and port forwarding. There’s lots that do the former and a few that do the latter, Proton is the only one that does both.
Correct me if my information is out of date, please.
Private internet access.
Their image is weird because they have the less SEO friendly name ever and all their promotion is made with AI nowadays. It wasn’t a few years back and they’ve been around for a while. But they do both per app routing and port forwarding.
Also, encryption, volatile storage, privacy conscious, a good server spread, etc.
PIA is developed and operated by Israeli devs fwiw [0]. They were acquired in 2019 and a lot of people cancelled/moved on then because Kape has a horrible reputation.
0: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kape_Technologies
Good to know. Had no idea.
I’ve been using them for almost a decade. They’re cheap AF and serviceable.
Windscribe does port forwarding with a “pro” account. I’m not sure what per app routing is, is that more of a client capability?
Split tunneling, I’d forgotten the name earlier. It basically means that you can say only x browser and/or y game uses the vpn while everything else just uses the Internet normally.
Ah, yeah, that’s a feature in the windscribe app.
Finally migrated to Proton in July, cancelled yesterday; had paid for the full year but have already started moving.
I was so happy to be supporting a company I believed in and was looking forward to the services getting better and better… Then the crap started to kick off: re-interviews for all, with us or against us mentality, cancelling the re-interviews, doubling-down and insulting your team, behaving like a petulant child. Then Bart posted the tone-deaf AI manifesto…and that seems to be it so far…
I get that AI is here, I get that the cat is out of the bag. It’s fair to suggest that it is no longer possible to not use AI in the codeflow… For me this less about AI=good/Bad, more about attitude and behaviour; and how that shapes the ethos.
Where are you moving to?
I started building a homelab a few years back. Levelling-up my Linux knowledge and succeeding with dockers and VMs on the NAS but not, until now, on dedicated hardware. It’s currently functional-with-bumps, but the WAN at home is a 10 year old neurotic DSL with only 120Mbit/50Mbit. So not fast-fast/24-7. Remote access is via Tailscale. Good for Calendar, Notes, and (potentially, if and when the “Error when trying to connect (Bad healthcheck status)” thing is resolved) Office. So it currently, for me, is a kind of proof of concept:
That I can, in fact, host my own services on my own hardware and retain total control over all of my data therein.
Will probably get a mini ITX somethingorother or a used Thinkcentre within the next week or two; plonk Nextcloud AIO in a Proxmox thingy/VM and get that running well locally before migrating it to a dedicated off-site, probably Hetzner. The off-site then eventually becomes the production, with the local for dev and testing before pushing.
I could even take the time to do Pen-testing, for example, but access would be exclusively via Tailscale/Wireshark anyway - so no internet facing TCP services at all.
New users (family or friends), would access exclusively via Tailscale/Wireshark.
While I digress, my point is that I ultimately want a solution that is not fucking Google. is not fucking Google indicates that my options are, and ultimate choice is, based purely on trust.
Proton are offering exactly and precisely what I want and need!! :
“A better internet starts with privacy and freedom” “Trusted by over 100 million users and organizations” “Communicate and browse. Privately.” “Store, share, collaborate. Securely.”
It’s simple! The interfaces are simple! Great VPN. Reliable Password manager. Works perfectly on all my devices. The office bits and the calendar are simple; kind of like a polished Google Documents from twenty years ago. They’re not as functional as any of my other officey things; in a quirky but sometimes annoying way; but I didn’t mind at all because:
I trusted and believed in the core ethos of Proton.
Great products. Perfect offer. Trust.
Andy’s abhorrent behaviour, and the way this whole fuckup has been absurdly non-handled with a total lack of responsibility, completely destroyed my trust. Pretty damn fast too. Sorry for the rant but I’m so so tired of it all and it pissed me off.
To answer your question:
I trust the fractured services and self-hosting more now.
What about you?
I have had really good experiences with SimplyMail. Extremely inexpensive, worth the little bit of money for me. I self host stuff, been meaning to look into Stalwart. Looks pretty cool (willing to hear of anyone thinks otherwise).
what do u reccommend guys
Tutamail is great for mails
Love me more EU tech independence alternatives. Been using them for a month when I first read the rumors that led to the 404 article.
I just switched to custom domains and Thundermail
I recently switched to a custom domain and it’s probably the best 12 bucks a year to spend. If you ever have to switch email providers for whatever reason it’s super easy because the domain is yours and you just need to update DNS records to your new email provider rather than updating your email address on tons of separate sites
Absolutely. I’m kicking myself for not doing it when I moved to Proton in the first place but I didn’t know much about this stuff and needed an easy switch.
Additionally the other bonus to migrating from Proton is diversifying. Now if one company enshittifies it only affects one account.
What are you using for your domain emails?
Fastmail , I am liking them more than Tuta and they are pushing the newer better jmap protocol.
I’ve been using Zoho for over a decade now for nearly all my transactions. Gmail comes in handy for account related things. For web subscriptions that matter zero to me if hacked I use proton.
I highly suggest Thundermail (tb.pro) if you wanna switch to a libre email provider. Mozilla hosts stalwart and their own libre mail client for you, along with providing 15 mail aliases and 3 custom domains, for a small price. I have been using it as my daily since past few months. I haven’t found any bugs despite it being in beta.
Given Mozilla’s AI stance I can’t see it as an improvement. I never want to side with NOT-Mozilla but the way they handled the Firefox AI stuff was messy at the bare minimum.
As a direct Proton Mail replacement I’m migrating to tuta.com. Which funnily enough just got a Thunderbird add-on recently.
messy, but at least handled?
I saw this earlier and got excited, just to find out it was just a browser tab inside of thunderbird.
It is but it also means they are actually doing stuff for their users, I want to see et grow into something more thorough in the future, for now it’s progress.
I signed up yesterday. Really liking it so far but I’m still messing around with it. Do you have your app synced? I’m trying to figure out if I can change the settings on one PC and have them affect another PC/phone without exporting.
Thunderbird application settings being client side, have a separate sync design, unrelated to thundermail. I don’t remember whether they finished it, but I do remember they were working on a sync feature.
Got it. I suppose Thundermail is new so they’re still working on things.
I don’t trust Mozilla
Was thinking of switching after the BS from last year. My subscription ended this month and I’ve finally finished changing my services. Also did not want everything in one basket.
Checking privacytools.io, I see they have choices that aren’t great alternatives to Proton’s ecosystem. For example, NordVPN (not a great product) and Mullvad (didn’t the owner contribute to a Swedish nazi party?)
So…is there a curated set of recommendations to replace all Proton products?
I’d recommend either Fastmail, Posteo or Mailfence for email, Cryptpad for Drive, Keepass for Vault, NymVPN for VPN, and literally any FOSS calendar app for calendar.
A) Thank you kind internet person. B) That’s quite the username.
傻逼 ! He pays the price for hubris.
This guy might just be hamming it up to fluff up his resume for Grok AI or something
I've been trying Proton stuff out off and on for years. I'm gonna quit trying it out.
Canceled mine. Only did it for a month when Mulvad had their shit exposed. Lord. I feel for those who have to fully migrate.
As much as I think this Andy fellow is a douche, I appreciate Proton is encrypting all my stuff, which is still way better than gmail. For that, I will continue paying for the service. It’s just so much work to switch over email - I don’t want to have to do it again.
I mean it only matters if the person you communicate with is also on Proton. All correspondence you have with anyone using Outlook/Gmail will still allow Microsoft/Google to read your emails
This is true.
[removed]
While I appreciate you letting us know of your service, I think you should make it clearer that it’s your company.
Sorry, I thought I did. I’ll repost and add a disclosure.
Could be that advertising is generally not allowed in this community (or this instance)… You should be able to contact the mods via the modlog if you’re interested :)
[deleted]
Where is this company based?
Bon jour Mailo…
The Suisse should boot Yen out of their country.
What are equal or better replacements for their software suite: email, vpn, cloud storage, password manager, AI?
All of the advice I give depends on your preferred level of privacy. If I had to give you all of these services in 1 provider I’d suggest Infomaniak, a Swiss tech company. www.infomaniak.com/en/ksuite/kdrive VPN: Mullvad (it collects less data from the user, even) Email: not sure about this. I never used Proton Mail since it didn’t work for me with IMAP protocols by design. Password Manager: Bitwarden or self-hosted Vaultwarden AI: I use DuckDuckGo’s Duck.ai interface, although I’m not entirely sure if that measures up to the privacy standard you need.
I’ll add Psono for a self-hosted password manager since the future of Bitwarden isn’t clear.
Depends on what you need. Tuta for Mail is great. If you’d like to self host password managers, stuff like Keepass/Vaultwarden/Bitwarden. You can also choose to pay for Bitwarden if you’d prefer a managed infrastructure. The only AI I’m familiar with that has some level of self respect is Mistral with Le Chat. Not familiar with VPN/Cloud storage.
What other email service is free and not a pos? Does one exist? Gotta pay to play I gues…
No free service is good if you care about privacy.
Tuta has a free Option.
Well unless i self host but im not doing that for email, no smarty enough
Many smarty enough people still find hosting service worth paying for.
If you grab a cheap domain, many domain registrars throw email hosting in for cheap or free.
What exactly does that mean, just buying a domain name also gets you email ? And I can just use it through Thunderbird ?
When paying for a hosting it could include email service, but I’ve never used it. Probably better setting up your own email server or similar.
Well, before that I was already wondering if I should keep it because I don’t use it that much. That just settled the debate.
Its been getting out of hand, im starting the migration tonight, anyway the only thing i really need is the VPN, which i can get elsewhere.
I put it off
Yikes i have 100s of mail redirections setup via simplelogin, which proton acquired months after I setup. I was with proton as well seperately , but If that acquisition hadnt happened the switch wouldve been easier. Atleast i havent used much of drive or their office stuff and I stayed with Bitwarden not using pass. Just a bit of calendar . Its going to take ages to point all the services to new emails. Itll be weeks of migrating to do it safely. And im on a duo plan so getting wifey off proton (and she does use pass) is going to be a hassle. Took long enough to get there . A lesson in not sticking many eggs in one basket. Atleast we got off Google after decades of that enshittisphere. Custom domain time too. If i still use a redirector i need to have a system and not setup so many addresses. Wonder if I can keep simplelogin alone while I migrate?
[removed]
IVPN all the way?
Don’t these people understand that there is space between “lovingly handcrafting code” and 100% ai with no supervision.
It’s the tone that gets me here more than the content. “Loser thinking” is the level of comment you’d expect from the likes of Elon Musk. Combine this with Andy Yen’s Trump-sympathising it builds a picture.
Fediverse hates AI like US Republicans hate women and children.
The Fediverse should hate gen-AI.
But that’s not what the CEO is implementing in the company.
No, this is the frediverse if the word ai comes up there is no nuance. Only hate.
How many. I’m tired of shitty reporters not using real numbers to drum up moments. Of course it’s another 404 garbage piece.
Yeah lets cancel and move to m$ or google.
/s
No one on this sub understands sarcasm?
I have seen already on reddit that that
it’s really funny how different this story reads by the developers than by 404 Media. The PR on the story got traction before they could do anything about it. It seems like no one knows where the quote came from and we now have a flock of whistleblowers saying they don’t recognize any of this. No sources, just a hivemind collectively referencing the same sourceless allegations. Someone successfully brought down Proton.
I don’t pay for Proton services, so I don’t really have any say, I just want to know what’s true here.
If there’s a public verified quote of Andy Yen saying “Hey, that’s a misquote, I believe strongly in secure practices that don’t use AI”, please link us to it.
It is not that hard to put out a public statement when an unfair accusation makes the rounds.
Proton already put a half-assed official comment last time Andy showed signs of brain damage, rather than shuffling him into a role where he does less harm.
If there is a public statement, I’ll weigh it in that context.
I mean, for fucks sake, they have my personal email address. They could reach me with a retraction if they gave a fuck.
So no, no benefit of the doubt for these clowns.
Do you have any sources for what you’re seeing? 404 has a pretty good track record.
Do I have sources for something that didn’t happen? No, proving a negative is impossible.
Buy hey, I am all for everyone making their own decision and giving their money to corporations based on their own morality, not mine. I don’t pay for their services, so it is easy for me to underplay this.
Gotcha, no one claimed it didn’t happen! (No sources).
AI/tech bro hate bandwagon. All aboard.
It’s a hot topic. If CEO/CTO didn’t want to alienate users, they should’ve kept their mouths shut lmao.
The problem with CEOs and tech bros is they think I give a shit what they’ve got to say. All of them. Elon is the worst on this, has to have an opinion on everything, just STFU.
I mean, I do give a shit what they say.
Andy Yen said “I’m going to fuck up a service you rely on.”
I took them at their word and canceled.
the developers also admitted to the “loser thinking” quote in reddit but just glanced over it saying Andy will work on better communication.
The same Andy who also some years ago said
"Great pick by @realDonaldTrump. 10 years ago, Republicans were the party of big business and Dems stood for the little guys, but today the tables have completely turned. People forget that the current antitrust actions against Big Tech were started under the first Trump admin.”
There were many antitrust actions filed before Trump and during Biden (against Microsoft, IBM, standard oil etc). Calling Trump a friend of the little guys just because he added some more is either missing the mark completely at best, manipulative at worst. Tariffs, Trump coins, Melanie coins all were designed to funnel money from the little guys to the big guys. How do you trust the decisions of a person that makes such a comment so confidently. This is your typical run of the mill billionaire or wanna-be a billionaire thinking they have brilliant ideas on everything because they were successful in one venture.
At first I thought all of the anti Proton posts was Google killing their competitor. Then there are just too many instances of the CEO being a dipshit. I want you to be right, but it is starting to look like some of this is real.
AI is great, but it’s certainly over used.
And under quality.
No. Generative AI is bad, its use and development are moral failures, and everything it makes is worthless.
Writing whole apps with AI is over using it…
True. So is any use of it, but that is particularly bad.
I'm building my own email server. It receives mail, checks it for spam and forgery, stores it securely, lets apps read it, and sends outgoing mail. It handles a lot of domains on one system, with nothing important tied to a single machine, so parts can fail or restart without losing anything. It's written in Rust... for safety, and I'm using AI heavily to write and test the code. It's big, mostly because email has decades of standards and quirks, and every mail client has to work with it.
Which is it?
This is a very apropos question these days.
What?
This seems like maybe a bad idea. But I might be wrong. Best of luck!
Thanks!
Why would you do that when stalw.art exists? Sounds like a recipe for disaster
Sorry dweebs, they’re not even going to notice the dozens of you leaving.
Commence downvotes.
This is the one product used by people who care enough to do something. We already moved from Google because we hate the monopolistic enshitification and want privacy. We will move again, this dumb shit ceo doesn’t know his customer base.
Exactly. The only people willing to pay premium prices for privacy instead of surrendering their data to surveillance capitalists are people with a low tolerance for bullshit.
This always happens with tech companies. You develop loyalty to the company and then become personally offended when they fail to meet your standards, and you assume that all other users are similar to you.
Most of their revenue would be from corporate contracts. An infinitesimal portion of their revenue base is interested in this.
If they cared about you the CEO wouldn’t have said and done what he has.
Are you basing this on how you feel about Proton or actually have some reference/data to back it up? Proton is a heavily individual user subscription based company, calling business contracts most part of their revenue probably misses the mark by a large margin. The fact that they do PR and damage control on reddit all the time and pretend to care about public criticism just validates this more.
To continue this more it seems Proton has about 50000 firms registered to its domain
technologychecker.io/technology/proton-mail
most of which seem like small business with less than 100 employees
www.appsruntheworld.com/…/protonmail
where on individual level Proton has about 100mil accounts. That doesn’t look minor to me.
It is like saying Trump wouldn’t even notice you not voting for him.
I don’t argue in analogies. Trump isn’t being elected. The difference is scale - there just aren’t enough proton users who care about this.
If there weren’t Proton wouldn’t be trying to do PR and damage control in reddit. Proton is small enough and not a large monopoly like google or microsoft is, there is more competition (which keeps shooting itself in the foot all the time but anyways…). So it can be affected by this.
So brave.
No no no, commence block, that’s FAR more effective.