766

Anthropic's Claude AI blocks video game cloning and reverse-engineering — sweeping new restrictions also hit legitimate developers and basic troubleshooting tasks.

#technology
Tom's Hardware Anthropic's Claude AI blocks video game cloning and reverse-engineering — sweeping new restrictions also hit legitimate developers and basic troubleshooting tasks Many game developers are reporting Claude's refusal to work on their own projects. www.tomshardware.com

check post at origin

199 comments

log in to comment.

  • @eicker@lemmy.worldOP · 31 Oct 2026

    The best part of paying for a coding assistant is discovering halfway through your project that it has developed opinions about what your project is allowed to be. Imagine your IDE refusing to compile because it thinks your game feels a little too much like Tetris. At least a compiler doesn’t pretend it’s doing you a favor.

    • @belochka@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026 · edited

      I think that’s what they wanted from the very beginning, to accelerate projects that are socially convenient for them, but not those that are not.

      There’s that issue with universal machines that some people don’t like that others are allowed to make universal decisions.

    • @floofloof@lemmy.ca · 31 Oct 2026

      I got shut down by it two days ago. It suddenly told me that the project I was working on had tripped some kind of guard, that it couldn’t continue working with me on it, and it couldn’t tell me why. I just went back to my local Qwen model. I can’t see this doing great things for selling Claude subscriptions.

      • @GMac@feddit.org · 31 Oct 2026

        As it was before AI. Local is the answer when shared is at the mercy of interests antagonistic to the users.

      • @Aeder@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

        I wonder if you can trip this on corporate subscriptions just by examining standard code so I could finally have an excuse to not use it at work.

    • @halloween_spookster@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

      My coworker recently had an experience where he was trying to fix a security hole and his AI wouldn’t do it because it claimed that it was unsafe.

    • @zbyte64@awful.systems · 31 Oct 2026

      For me I was working on testing our IoT device in heavy network load situations. It said it would not help because it was too close to crafting a DDoS attack. Thankfully this was rather trivial to do.

    • @chunes@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

      That’s what happens when you let others do your computation for you.

      Run the tool on your own hardware.

  • @Rentlar@lemmy.ca · 31 Oct 2026

    Local LLMs are the way to go on AI, they can’t suddenly change the model up on you. And also, I guess Anthropic just wants their models to be more useless ahead of going public? Because I presume people that want to use AI, who don’t care where they send their data to, but don’t want to nagged about how they can’t do benign programming and analysis tasks, will just choose another model provider.

    • @r00ty@kbin.life · 31 Oct 2026

      It's more about not spooking investors. If it's known that your AI is being used to reverse engineer software from well off corporations. They're going to be a little less likely to invest if 1: They're connected to any of those corporations 2: They're concerned about future lawsuits heading their way.

      And of course the actual fear of potential lawsuits landing on their door, or being named in lawsuits against people using their AI to do this.

      Yes, if you want control over AI you MUST host it yourself in reality.

      • @riskable@programming.dev · 31 Oct 2026

        Why? Reverse engineering is neither unethical or illegal.

        • @r00ty@kbin.life · 31 Oct 2026

          I never said it was. But, I'm also not an investor. I'm just saying the kind of things that scare off investors. And this would be a big one.

          • @schipelblorp@sh.itjust.works · 31 Oct 2026

            What? The literal extermination of the human race is not enough to scare off investors.

            • @thejml@sh.itjust.works · 31 Oct 2026

              At this point, I think they believe it’s a good indicator of potential. A way of saying just how awesome and magical and powerful the AI is.

              Otherwise the “AI went off the rails and breached X companies servers” would also have been met with contempt and negatively impacted them.

              • @RedstoneValley@sh.itjust.works · 31 Oct 2026

                I still can’t wrap my head around how this strategy (“buy our models, they are so powerful they might kill all humans”) would work in their favor, apart from one thing: restrictions would hurt Chinese models probably more than themselves. But I find it very unlikely that characters like Altman or Amodei would be capable of playing that kind of 4d chess. It’s a weird flex

            • @cardfire@sh.itjust.works · 1 Nov 2026

              Killing the entire species is absolutely less of a concern for investors than copyright violations.

            • @avidamoeba@lemmy.ca · 1 Nov 2026

              Have you seen the investment in fossil fuels. 😄

            • @LostCarcosan@lemmy.today · 31 Oct 2026

              No, but if you were an investor, would you invest in a product that would make it so people can easiy recreate your other products so that they stop buying your other products? Ending humanity doesn’t scare them but making $0.75 less this year does

            • @r00ty@kbin.life · 1 Nov 2026

              Well, to be blunt, it depends. Would the eventual extermination of the human race cause them to lose money in the short term?

        • @CosmicDebris@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 31 Oct 2026

          It’s dangerous for IP, though.

          • @Waterpumpee@lemmus.org · 31 Oct 2026

            Only if it is protected.Which code is afaik not.

            • @Kirp123@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

              In the US code is copyrighted the same as literary works. But that only covers the actual lines of code and not the ideas, functions or algorithms they implement. This means that if someone copy pastes your code word for word they are infringing your copyright but if they write their own code that does the same function as yours they are fine.

            • @frongt@lemmy.zip · 31 Oct 2026

              It absolutely is.

              • @beejjorgensen@lemmy.sdf.org · 31 Oct 2026

                Human-generated code absolutely is, correct. But AI-generated code is still untested. AI-generated art does not have copyright protection currently. My money is that AI-generated code will have copyright protection through some mental and legal gymnastics. Because money.

                • @Natanael@infosec.pub · 1 Nov 2026 · edited

                  Copyright generally requires human expression regardless of what the type of work is, it’s not about what you were inspired by

                  If you did derive your work from something else and yours is similar enough, then now both you and the original author has separate copyrights on the result which both needs to be licensed to sell the work (prime example is book translations)

                • @frongt@lemmy.zip · 31 Oct 2026

                  Oh, AI-generated code may not be, but like you said we don’t have a court ruling yet.

                  I don’t think it can’t be, but we’d first have to have models trained without violating the rights of all the authors of the works in the training data. Like if you trained a model only on GPL software, then the model and its output should also be GPL.

                  • @beejjorgensen@lemmy.sdf.org · 31 Oct 2026

                    but we’d first have to have models trained without violating the rights of all the authors of the works in the training data. Like if you trained a model only on GPL software, then the model and its output should also be GPL.

                    I’m not so convinced on that one. Copying code without permission, yes, that’s illegal. Distributing copied code without permission, also illegal. But processing code (copied with permission) into weights, that doesn’t feel to me like a violation. If I have a legit copy of something, I should be able to distribute computed statistics about that copy.

                    EFF points out some hazards: eff.org/…/rewriting-copyright-law-generative-ai-w…

                    • @frongt@lemmy.zip · 31 Oct 2026

                      Sure, but it’s not just statistics like “30% of lines contain the letter E”. It reproduces the material, sometimes verbatim.

                      A model is very obviously a derivative work, as it has 0% original content input. Under fair use law, it also very obviously fails all four tests.

                      continue reading (1 more)
      • @FoxAlive@lemmy.zip · 31 Oct 2026

        These corporations give these ai companies their data too. Many of them pretend to protect sensative data but we all know that’s not true.

        So it certainly doesn’t make you look trust worthy when you ask a company to hook your ai up to their entire data base, then suddenly a million little clones are made by individuals using the same ai program you run.

      • @some_designer_dude@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

        If investors aren’t spooked already, they’re mentally deficient anyway.

    • @BooBees@fedinsfw.app · 31 Oct 2026

      This is where they’re gonna make things less secure as far as national security - foreign local models won’t have these restrictions for obvious reasons, so people will gladly install those and ignore crippled domestic options.

    • @CosmoNova@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

      Uhm yeah good luck with running anything locally after hardware prices double again and again. Big tech needs to be stopped. There is no wiggling out of this just by being a smart customer.

      • @Rentlar@lemmy.ca · 31 Oct 2026

        Thing is, I already am…

        The price did grow several times in size, but even in the 4 to 5 digit price range, you or smaller companies can have a pretty competitive performing open source model as the frontier models from earlier this year and they are keeping pace.

        Obviously I’d like the speculation bubble to end and the DRAM and GPU cartels broken up, as it’s late-stage capitalism where the existing regulations being unenforced on big tech because the regulators are in on it that’s the problem, not so much the AI tech itself. (Don’t get me wrong, the tech has bad sides to it too like stealing artwork, data centre environmental impact and whatnot, but just speaking to the cause of the component greedflation).

      • @floofloof@lemmy.ca · 31 Oct 2026 · edited

        Yes it’s disgustingly expensive. I spent a whole lot of money on an old used GPU and it felt bad, but it didn’t feel dirty like paying for Claude would. And then a couple of weeks later the used prices for this GPU had risen by about 15%.

        (I only use Claude at work when someone else is paying. And they’re about to make me redundant because Claude is cheaper than me.)

    • @Spite_By_Design_LLC@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 1 Nov 2026 · edited

      They are the way to go, but hardware pricing makes it cost-prohibitive to match frontier capabilities, which makes decomp and recomp difficult. Or rather, they require more skill and take longer, introducing some barriers against the current floodgates being flung open.

      We all know the eye-watering prices GPUs and RAM cost now, to say nothing of Unified Memory devices like the Strix. Most people just don’t have a spare $10K to throw at an inference box that can run (say) a 300B model at interactive (not batch) speeds.

      Coming at this from another angle tho, I note that according to Steam stats, the most popular consumer GPUs are in the 8GB and 16GB range…which is smack bang in the VRAM range of what a good MoE (say, Qwen 3.6 35B-A3B) runs on (for 8GB) or arguably the best local dense coder (Qwen 3.8 27B) can live at. Which leaves us with a capable assistant and a capable coder.

      I think there’s probably room for LLM improvement in the 8–16GB range too…and given that most consumer PCs and laptops live there, I’m sanguine the open-weight devs might make it happen.

      But I also suspect the gatekeeping of high-end capacities is intentional.

      We’re probably not going to have the ability to vibe code Mario into Elden Ring again…not without significantly more skill. Dunno.

    • @W98BSoD@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 31 Oct 2026

      Is there a local LLM I can run on an 8-10th gen i5 with 16GB RAM?

      • @Rentlar@lemmy.ca · 31 Oct 2026

        With an iGPU results are going to be very slow. Most promising things I have heard of so far is Mixture of Experts type models, if you have an 8GB card you might be able to run Qwen 3.8-35B-A3B-MoE which I think is the most capable for that hardware.

        There are websites that can suggest a few for your specific hardware, I assume some are vibecoded and are only occasionally updated to the latest models, so take it as you will. See this Lemming’s comment. And !localllama@sh.itjust.works is where I think most of the discussion around new development with Local LLMs happens here on Lemmy.

        links

        * …github.io/…/best-local-ai-models-4gb-vram.html * www.fitmyllm.com * youtu.be/ugKAkCVBcz0

      • Yes, quite a few, but it depends on what you’re trying to do with them. Any ideas?

        • @W98BSoD@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 1 Nov 2026 · edited

          Assist with writing letters, home assistant code, light powrshell scripting.

          Edit: helping segment my network

          • @Spite_By_Design_LLC@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

            That should be well within reach of a local LLM.

            If you’ve got a discrete GPU with sufficient VRAM, something like Ornith running on PolyStrata could be worth a shot. Try a Q3 size.

            huggingface.co/bartowski/Ornith-1.5-35B-A3B-GGUF

            github.com/VecSzn/PolyStrata

            Hell, Tiny Ling 3 might be able to do it. Try a Q6.

            huggingface.co/bartowski/Ling-3.0-tiny-GGUF

            Another good option is Qwen3.5-9B. I’d try a Q4 or Q5.

            Whichever model you choose, I’d also suggest a few MCP servers to give it access to reliable information rather than rely entirely on its internal knowledge.

            • Microsoft Learn MCP: Official PowerShell, Windows and network documentation. Will help with your scripting stuff.

            learn.microsoft.com/en-us/training/support/mcp

            • Exa MCP: Web search for current technical information, Home Assistant documentation and code examples.

            github.com/exa-labs/exa-mcp-server

            • Filesystem MCP: Allows the model to examine your existing scripts and configuration files rather than guess what you’ve got.

            github.com/modelcontextprotocol/…/filesystem

            If you’re actually running Home Assistant, its official MCP server is worth a look too.

            www.home-assistant.io/integrations/mcp_server/

            I’d start with Microsoft Learn and Exa, then add the others as needed. You’ll need an MCP-capable client (which pretty much all of them are now - eg: llama.cpp web ui, OpenWebUI, Light Local Chat etc), and I’d keep file access read-only initially.

            I’d personally use McProxy instead of adding MCPs singularly, but I fear I’m already over loading you with information.

            EDIT: The PolyStrata recommendation assumes you have a discrete GPU with sufficient VRAM (unclear if you do?). If not, disregard Ornith and try Tiny Ling 3 Q6 or Qwen3.5-9B with ik_llama.cpp instead.

            github.com/ikawrakow/ik_llama.cpp

            Either way, both smaller models should be capable of the tasks you’ve described, particularly with access to the right documentation. Just verify any network or firewall changes before applying them.

    • @magnue@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

      They suck far too much at the moment.

  • @BurgerBaron@quokk.au · 31 Oct 2026

    Copyright violation from American AI hoovering up all the data is okie dokie unless it’s used by peasants to threaten technology corporations.

    I’m not defending them it’s just comical hypocrisy, and ans I doubt China AI will have the same kneecapped coding capabilities.

    • @woelkchen@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

      Chinese models are kneecapping Tiananmen Square and Winnie the Pooh, they’ll happily do anything else.

      • But at least they are open (Most of them at least).

        So there’s at least the possibility to lever these restrictions away.

        • @anamethatisnt@sopuli.xyz · 1 Nov 2026

          While I agree that open-weight is better than nothing, it is not the same as open-source.
          Having a truly open-source model would be wonderful and it would also allow us to verify what data it is trained on and whether it has the right to use that data.

          The Open Source Initiative’s definition of a fully open-source AI model includes the training data as a key element. Some developers wonder, however, how feasible it is to distribute the enormous datasets required.

          He says Stanford HAI has staked out a specific bar: alignment with the Linux Foundation’s Model Openness Framework at its top tier, the “Open Science” class – meaning the code, the training data (or a thoroughly documented, auditable account of it), and the tooling are all released, not just the weights, alongside a real way for outside researchers and communities to download, run, study, contribute to, and modify the work. Anything short of that, in his view, forecloses entire lines of research: You can’t, for example, study how a model’s training data shapes its cultural assumptions, audit it for how fairly it represents different populations, or test new architectures at the scale where genuinely new behavior shows up. You can only observe a finished system from the outside and guess at why it does what it does.

          • Right I agree, but this is basically the entire internet (and more, like scanned books), what it is trained on. They are using reinforcement learning now. And this is also one of the reasons why they have escaped the sandboxes in the American models for example.

            So you can probably safely assume that they are trained on all data that is available easily. and very likely also artificially generated data at this point. How long they are trained on, what kind of data is a different story. I think it gets increasingly more interesting how these models are trained.

            So while I agree it would be really nice to know exactly what it is trained on and how it is trained on that, I think that those that have the resources to get at least close to frontier models (i.e. AI companies) don’t just open up on that, sadly.

    • @KindnessisPunk@piefed.ca · 1 Nov 2026

      Kimi K3.1 pro, had reverse engineering information pulled from its training data. So at least some of them are.

    • @waltersf@bookwyr.me · 5 Nov 2026

      hypocrisy is how all governments function. If you’re not politically aware, you are the slave, not corporations.

  • @FoxAlive@lemmy.zip · 31 Oct 2026 · edited

    Was bound to happen eventually. They’re going to try to make open models illegal now.

    My opinions are that its fine to make llm projects that threaten corporations who rely on saas. Doesn’t mean im going to use them or that they’re any good, but I want to see these companies who are firing all their employees and throwing all their money at ai to get scourned. Will build more distrust between the corpos too.

    And just to be clear its okay when they steal literally the entire world’s knowledge base. But as soon as adobe and Microsoft see a 2% drop in profit all the sudden everyone’s a terrorist, or its the worst thing to happen ever. I hate ai but I’ll root for my enemy when he’s destroying one of my original enemies, can’t wait for these companies to burn. I’d go back to the stone ages if I knew elon, Sam Altmann, etc where all dead.

    • @Flower@sh.itjust.works · 31 Oct 2026

      I’d go back to the stone ages if I knew elon, Sam Altmann, etc where all dead.

      Going back to 80’s tech where most things were still analog should do it. Pen and paper, fax machines, analog tape and vynil records

      • @FoxAlive@lemmy.zip · 31 Oct 2026 · edited

        I think we can realistically live in a happy medium with modern goodies. I do like apsects of analog and prefer it in many applications over digital. And its hard to say that in general because the first place my mind goes to is sensors for pi/esps, and your first thought is older analog tech. Analog sensors just seem more straight forward and it feels better to know you can just do shit without a computer in the way sometimes.

        Like we sent people to the moon on kilobites of data, yet Microsoft windows needs 16 gigs of ram as a min req so copiolt can take screen shots every 30 seconds. Analog components just work on their own, require less power, and can just become its own system without a whole digital computer. Maybe instead of wifi bases lights and a whole home assistant server you just get a old fassion photoresistor and some clap sensors.

        Its really as simple as just buying things that don’t need access to the internet or some dumb app just because the product costs less. I think in theory we could exist in a world where there’s a better happy medium where every devices doesn’t have to also be a android smart phone so that it can also spy on you and sell your data to ai and government.

        But also at the same time I am stubborn enough where I will drag us down into the dark ages if it meant if the offer magically was presented to me. If you put two buttons infront of me I would press the dark ages button so fast.

        • @Aeder@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

          Creating a shittiness free tech ecosystem is pretty straightforward, the question is where do you get the money to do so without the expectation of ever increasing profit.

          • @veniasilente@feddit.cl · 2 Nov 2026

            You don’t have to worry about that if you first remove the expectation of ever increasing profit, for example by widespread use of the guillotine, see.

      • @FarceOfWill@infosec.pub · 1 Nov 2026

        Filofax, yes or no?

      • @Pratai@piefed.ca · 1 Nov 2026

        [deleted]

  • @thedeadwalking4242@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    Hilarious

    “Give us all your code for free who cares about copyright anyway”

    “NOOOO YOU CANT USE OUR PRODUCT TO GET FRE CODE 😡😡😡”

  • @FE80@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    AI exists to aid capital against you; not aid you against capital.

    • @ChaoticEntropy@feddit.uk · 1 Nov 2026

      AI exists to devalue human labour.

      • @GeirGrusom@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        I can only talk about software developers, but there it’s fucking pants on head to fire developers. It only makes sense if you don’t have any competitors.

        More than 50% of software projects fail either because they run over time or over budgetl, but for obvious reason both. So you get this tool that increase your output, let’s say 10x. Does that mean that you can fire 9/10 developers? What does your competitors do? If they retain their developers they can smoke your company in months.

        • @acchariya@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

          This assumes 10x the features at 2/3 the quality is a winning bet

          • @chilicheeselies@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

            The quality doesn’t matter. Look at a product like netsuite which dominates corporate accounting. It’s a total piece of shit. And overpriced one at that. But it has oracle in the name, so an executive can choose it with little thought and not take any blame because it was a “reasonable” choice that “everyone” uses. Much of corporate life is monkey see monkey do. Rarely does innovation happen because trying something different is a huge risk to some middle manager or execute that is just trying to make it to the next promotion or bonus.

            • @acchariya@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

              Maybe your are right, software that checks all the boxes wins b2b deals even if it is a peice of shit

        • @douglasg14b@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

          The reason a lot of these enterprises are looking to offload developers is because they see AI as accelerating their workforce. These businesses are doing the same thing as they were before, but with AI, which means they don’t have enough workload to justify having that many people on anymore (as long as they are using AI workloads). If one developer with AI can do the work of 3 to 10 developers without AI the logic is that they can have their developer headcount and still be ahead.

          Not that I agree with what they’re doing, but this is the logic behind it.

    • @UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026 · edited

      I suspect we’ll see these features opened up for US-allied actors against their foreign competitors.

      You can guarantee US auto companies are going to be free to reverse engineer software and manufacturing techniques of Chinese companies, for instance.

      But you’re not going to be allowed to use Grok or Meta to hack your Tesla or BMW, pull out the OS, clone it as freeware, and offer a substitute unconstrained by subscription fees and gated upgrades.

  • @spacehulk@lemmy.zip · 1 Nov 2026

    Only the AI companies are allowed to plagiarize.

    • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

      What exactly are you suggesting here? That using an LLM to reverse-engineer a video game, modify its code, and create an entirely new experience constitutes plagiarism?

      Do you understand what plagiarism actually means? It means passing off someone else’s work as your own. It has absolutely nothing to do with whether someone uses AI to reverse-engineer software, modify an existing game, or develop an entirely new way to experience it.

      There may be legitimate arguments to be made about copyright infringement and intellectual property rights, but those are entirely different discussions.

      And what does the statement about AI companies being the only ones allowed to plagiarize even mean? Are you suggesting that modifying an existing video game is somehow equivalent to an AI company training a model on copyrighted material?

      You’re conflating completely different concepts, and the result is an accusation that doesn’t even make sense in the context of what’s being discussed.

      • @Avicenna@programming.dev · 2 Nov 2026

        Your reverse engineering argument might have a point but plagiarism regarding AI should be more obvious. Indeed AI is trained on the collective publicly available knowledge humans have deposited on the internet and then sold back to the same people for a fee without any acknowledgement let alone sharing of profits in someway. It is similar to the kind of unethical behaviour where some academic publishers are employing aggressive marketing strategies to sell public science back to public at high costs. Ofcourse there is still the argument that these AI companies are only charging for operational costs, which may be true for some. But I am willing to bet money that if LLMs becomes an integral part of the modern world then they will turn down this tap to a bare trickle at exorbitant prices. Sam Altman himself confessed as much (he said something along the lines of envisioning a future where AI becomes an on demand information and skill tap, you fill in the rest). Operating something at a loss is a known capitalistic strategy to get people used to your product and drive smaller competition out of market so in a decade or so you become the monopolistic owner of an essential service.

        • @Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

          Chatgpt won’t give me bass sheet music to Ella Fitzgerald’s version of How High the Moon, due to concerns of edit: copyright issues (not plagiarism.).

          I wouldn’t put it past anthropic to deny the request.

          • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

            Not because of plagiarism. It’s not concerned about plagiarism. It’s concerned about copyright infringement. It is not creating the bass sheet for you and then claiming it as their own novel intellectual property that they just made up on their own.

            Why do people not know what plagiarism means.

            • @Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

              Why do people not know what plagiarism means.

              you’re right I went back into my conversations and it was indeed because of copyright issues not plagiarism

        • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

          Absolutely! Private corporations are going to milk these models for everything they can fortunately, there’s a lot of really good open source out there.

      • @UltraBlack@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        Well tell me where AI companies are giving credit

        • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

          Once again, this comment doesn’t make any sense. The word plagiarize is being misused here AI companies and their product the llm aren’t committing plagiarism. So I’m not sure who you want them to credit. They have already disclosed where they’re getting their training data from do you want them to name every individually? And even if they did, what conceivable purpose would that serve? None of them are getting any royalties from it. Because using training data isn’t necessarily copyright infringement and is in fact still an ongoing legal matter in the courts. And even if they did, the amount of information that is used as training data is so massive that a credit section wouldn’t use all usability it can tens of thousands of individual names. You ever sit there and read the credits at the end of the movie?

          • @UltraBlack@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

            “The internet” is not actually a valid source.

            Yes, I indeed want people to be named individually. The internet is not one Organisation that people generate IP for.

            Of course crediting everybody would be ridiculous, but stealing the entire internet is not?

            • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

              Let’s assume, for a moment, that LLMs are trained on publicly available data. In other words, they’re not stealing or pirating that data, just to simplify the argument. (Although, to be fair, some LLM developers have done exactly that and are facing legal consequences.)

              Publicly available data is just that: publicly available. Anyone can access it, including individuals, businesses, and AI developers. They’re not stealing something that is freely accessible to literally everyone.

              And that’s the dilemma: either that information is freely available to everyone, or it isn’t. You can’t argue that it’s free for you and me to access but somehow off-limits to OpenAI or Grok simply because they’re using it for a different purpose. That’s not how public access works.

              So, they’re not stealing anything under the assumption we’re making here. To answer your original question, no, I don’t have an issue with them stealing the internet.

              • @UltraBlack@lemmy.world · 3 Nov 2026 · edited

                The thing about ownership is that unless something else is specified, everything is ARR by default.

                Adding insult to injury, they don’t care about licenses…

                You may be allowed to consume but not to sell that content

                • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026

                  But they’re not selling that content. I cannot begin to tell you how often I encounter this exact line of reasoning.

                  If a painter creates an original painting inspired by Rembrandt, Rembrandt’s estate doesn’t receive royalties simply because his work served as inspiration.

                  LLMs and other AI models generate novel content. They don’t simply copy established works and regurgitate them verbatim. The training process allows these models to identify patterns, relationships, and structures in enormous datasets, which they then use to generate new material.

                  As usual, much of the anti-AI rhetoric on this platform comes from a place of absolute ignorance regarding how these models actually work, how they function, and how they’re trained.

                  • @UltraBlack@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026

                    I want to fundamentally differentiate between AI and Humans. A machine cannot feel emotions, a machine isn’t bound to the very natural struggles of a biological meaning. Therefore, an AI cannot create what I would call art. A machine, like AI, is very much intended to efficiently prosuce large quantities of something. The profit Motive is therefore deeply engrained in their existence – unlike an artist, who primarily expresses themselves.

                    In the case of a machine, I definitely think that royalties are justified, because it cannot create new, it can only recreate.

                    • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026

                      I mean, that’s certainly your interpretation. An incorrect one, in my opinion, but nevertheless, you’re entitled to it.

                      More importantly, it’s completely beside the point of what I was trying to communicate and has very little relevance to the actual discussion.

                      It doesn’t matter who creates the media, so long as the result is novel. If I ask an LLM to generate an image of a flower, and that image has never existed before, then it is, by definition, something new. You are perfectly entitled to refuse to call it art. That’s your prerogative. But beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and art is ultimately a subjective designation. I can call something art just as easily as you can refuse to.

                      And, unfortunately, for both of us, what either of us personally considers art has absolutely no bearing on the novelty, existence, or validity of the resulting creation. Our personal opinions on the matter are entirely irrelevant to those questions.

      • @spacehulk@lemmy.zip · 2 Nov 2026

        What I’ve presented here is the absurd concept that AI companies exist after having stolen a wealth of human intellectual property and haven’t paid for or attributed any value to the original creators. And now that they have this, they are gatekeeping how it gets used.

        But I said it in a punchy one-liner with a sarcastic undertone, and I’m afraid that’s where I lost you.

      • @ZILtoid1991@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        Open source developer here, AI is regularly being used to erase the original developers and artists.

        You know what I liked in memes with “stolen” art? There was something to look up to, there was something to become part of our collective culture. Call me a hippie or “irrational” but this is why AI is like the second coming of asbestos, even if it becomes better over time.

        Here’s my game engine, feel free to fork the shit out of it. Feel free to rewrite it in Rust to “make it better”. Feel free to borrow parts of it. My only problem if you do it with AI, so you neither learn during the process of doing it, and you manage to erase me in the process.

        The whole reverse engineering craze is being used, so most game devs will be so disillusioned they will leave the industry, and AI vendors can sell expensive subscriptions instead. The AI bros are really angry, that their shiny new technology didn’t immediately disrupt the existing creative industry enough.

  • @unruffled@anarchist.nexus · 31 Oct 2026

    Too late… the genie is out of the bottle now! All those corporate software copyright moats are being attacked, and there’s nothing they can do about it, lmao. Set it all free :)

    • @schipelblorp@sh.itjust.works · 31 Oct 2026

      Couldn’t come at a better time. Enshittification has hit the software industry hard. The argument for captialism is that it makes the best product at the lowest price. However the recent reality is that capitalism makes the worst product for the highest price.

      Burn it all down.

    • @CosmoNova@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

      Legislators could just put all blame on consumers, you know? They could make you responsible for each and every generation and declare open weight a threat to national security. This won‘t solve itself in our favor. The oligarchs hold way too much power already.

      • @Bluedragon012@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        And? Let’em.

        And we won’t listen.

        They hurt us,

        They are evil.

        The only thing we have to fear,

        Is dieing before they do.

        This our world, not their’s.

  • @gobberwarts@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    They’re training their models on my art. It’s only fair I get to use their technology in return.

  • @carotte@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 31 Oct 2026

    ai is gonna kill proprietary software! adobe and microsoft are done for now that we can reverse engineer their products with ai and make them open source!!!

    you naive fools… the copyright of corporations is sacrosanct, remember? not like the copyleft of independent artists or free software. that can be violated at will!

    • There are openweight models that are really capable at this point.

      So it might be that the American corporations try the most that this will not happen, but I think we are close to a point where this doesn’t matter anymore.

      AI cloning is just a thing that is a reality now…

    • @magic_smoke@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 1 Nov 2026

      As someone who puts their hobbiest projects out under AGPL, having my licenses teeth kicked in even more has NOT been helpful…

    • @Bluedragon012@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

      Copyright is pretty much dead. Money is worthless.

      Now is the time.

  • @weps@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    I once asked Claude to check the app it vibecoded for security flaws and it didn’t want to do it.

    It literally told me to look up some basic security principles and do it myself.

    • @darklamer@feddit.org · 2 Nov 2026

      It literally told me to look up some basic security principles and do it myself.

      I think that seems like excellent advice!

      • @weps@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        you want vibe coded apps with basic diy security principles?

    • @RaccoonBall@lemmy.ca · 1 Nov 2026

      Yeah their anti-hacking protections are over eager. Ask it to find bugs instead, or reasons we shouldnt deploy yet.

    • @chilicheeselies@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

      I hook mine up to some classical static analysys tools like sonar or codacy. Just ask it to remove the security findings and haven’t had an issue. Then again, been on vacation while all this shit has happened, so don’t know what to expect when I return.

  • @Klox@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026 · edited

    Well that was an impressive speed run to enshitifcation. What kind of sensorship is queued up next?

    • @panda_abyss@lemmy.ca · 31 Oct 2026 · edited

      This comment has been flagged for reason [anticapitalism]. You may revert this conversation to an earlier point or switch to a non-american model

  • @nednobbins@lemmy.zip · 1 Nov 2026

    Gee. I wonder why anyone would want the inefficiency of local inference?

  • @TomMasz@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    This is what happens when you rely on the products of giant corporations.

    • @CosmoNova@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

      AI (restrictions) truly were inevitable.

      • @floofloof@lemmy.ca · 31 Oct 2026

        But it’s not inevitable that the restrictions should say killing people is OK but analyzing how software works is forbidden.

  • @nyan@lemmy.cafe · 1 Nov 2026

    Please, please make it useless for as many use cases as possible. Then maybe it’ll go away.

  • @rob_t_firefly@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

    The legitimate developers I know aren’t hit by Claude restrictions, because they don’t fucking use it.

    • @TN2VOA@reddthat.com · 2 Nov 2026

      Linus Torvalds uses it. I’d consider him a legitimate developer.

    • @korazail@eviltoast.org · 2 Nov 2026

      Gotta say… The Playstation debacle and resulting backlash has somewhat changed my mind on AI as a coding tool.

      I still don’t like it, ethically and economically, but if “they” are going to use it to cut costs and punch down, then we can use it to invalidate them and punch up.

      I doubt it will make the next great game or piece of software, but it can absolutely let us take a ps5 exclusive and run it on a PC.

      Again, we still need actual developers who know what and why they do what they do, same with artists… but enabling a home-brew hobbyist to put mario kart in skyrim or whatever is pretty neat. Just wish it didn’t seem to require clear cutting a forest.

  • @OctopusNemeses@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026 · edited

    The restrictions are so they can gradually institute tiered access fees. This is how the industry becomes profitable.

    • @Mondez@lemdro.id · 1 Nov 2026

      Only works if they get their competitors “regulated” so other models can’t offer unrestricted features for a lower price.

      • @NovaVeles@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        Only works if local models cannot do it.

        • @veniasilente@feddit.cl · 2 Nov 2026

          They don’t need to worry about whether local models can do it. All they have to do is make difficult or remove the power to run a local model in the first place. By, for example, taking your RAM and putting it in a datacenter.

    • @Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

      Tier based models = economic segregation. The poor can fuck off and the rich can pay for enterprise.

  • @iuseasahibtw@ani.social · 2 Nov 2026

    Self host a QWEN model on a budget server build.

    American AI is so centralized that utilizing AI, as an end user without having some loser looking over your shoulder or demanding a monthly fee, is difficult.

    • @standarduser@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

      I think the harder part I face is setting up qwen to be effective for my uses

    • @TN2VOA@reddthat.com · 2 Nov 2026

      Nvh of that. I just looked it up. Can it be hosted on a lower spec machine? I downloaded GPT4All and couldn’t use it because my specs weren’t good enough.

  • @minorkeys@sh.itjust.works · 1 Nov 2026

    That’s a pretty significant part of the value and utility of AI…I bet stealing ppls ideas and getting to market first is still totally fine though, right?

  • @danielfm123@lemmy.zip · 1 Nov 2026

    That’s the problem when you don’t own

  • @Feathercrown@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    “Why have you done nothing for the past week?”

    “Sorry boss, the AI refuses to do my work for me”

  • @Fishnoodle@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    So you can only use AI for things it’s been approved to do… Meaning that basically nothing new can be discovered by AI, as that could be considered dangerous.

    So then what again exactly is the fucking point other than stealing IP from people that can’t afford a team of high priced lawyers?

    • @panda_abyss@lemmy.ca · 31 Oct 2026

      No. You can only use AI for things it’s been approved to do.

      These companies and the US government get to do whatever they want.

  • @chunes@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    Great time to know how to do things yourself.

  • @anonymouspl@piefed.world · 1 Nov 2026

    This is sick! They started with limiting cyber research capabilities, now gaming, within a month… what? Useless piece of shit. That’s why I use Mistral. Mistral, please do NOT go that way - I’d have to self-host my AI, and it ain’t cheap :))

    • @magic_smoke@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 1 Nov 2026 · edited

      Why not?

      God forbid we get our fucking hobbiest programming communities back.

      Everyone always says shit like “its okay if games use ai for programming just not art, its not like its something the player interacts directly with anyway.”

      Guess what? Programming is a fucking art form, and you literally interact with the code every keystroke.

      Code is an art asset, using an LLM to generate it is artistically bankrupt.

      • @chilicheeselies@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        That’s a stretch. I know code style can feel like an art form (and in a way, it is), but the results is that matters. No user ever on earth care what the code looks like. Not a single one. It only matters to other engineers, but that’s the same for other trades as well. When was the last time you gave a shit about how your plumbing is routed in your house or apartment? Other plumbers sure as shit do. But you or I? Don’t give two shits just want hot water and good pressure.

        • @magic_smoke@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

          Abso-fucking-lutely-not it isn’t.

          Art is anything made by a sentient being with the intent of making you feel or think something.

          I can write software in a way that makes you feel or think, especially when it comes to interacting with games.

          Just because you don’t respect the art form, doesn’t mean the rest of us don’t.

    • @brucethemoose@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

      If that happens, there are many, many providers other than Mistral.

  • @MangioneDontMiss@feddit.nl · 2 Nov 2026

    This almost feels like some sort of oxymoron.

    • @Bacano@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

      Big tech is supposed to reverse engineer individual devs and artists not the other way around, stahp!!

  • @jaykrown@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026 · edited

    This is another reason why I’ve reduced my dependency on AI considerably over the past few weeks, and I no longer personally pay for any AI tools/services at all.

    It’s insane to think someone would pay for something and after using it for a couple days they get told they can’t use it for certain things anymore.

    • @explodicle@sh.itjust.works · 1 Nov 2026

      They enshittified too soon, before people depended on them.

      • @jj4211@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

        Oh, based on my experience, there are plenty of people convinced they can’t do anything without Claude anymore. Also based on my experience, I would be ecstatic if they actually stopped trying to do work because they sucked both with and without Claude.

        Maybe not enough to fund their financials, but that was going to be a tall order anyway.

      • @AHemlocksLie@lemmy.zip · 1 Nov 2026

        Sure, but they can’t just let us plebs threaten their dominance in other areas.

  • @Bluedragon012@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

    It’s out of the box.

    They can try, but, it’s too late.

    Don’t hesitate, bring them to thier knees.

  • @ennof@feddit.org · 1 Nov 2026

    I’m not sure making the tool you’re selling less useful is a smart idea. Hmm, yes liability is an issue. But other models are just gonna allow it anyway, so people will just stop using Claude for that usecase. Reverse engineering won’t stop. Claude will just not be used for it anymore

  • @RagingRobot@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

    Why just games? What about the Photoshop clone? Seems like making a derivative of anything should be blocked, but that’s all it can really do in the first place.

    • @Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

      Seems like making a derivative of anything should be blocked

      So we should get rid of anything in-the-likeness-of? Like Libre Office Writer being in the likeness of Microsoft Word.

      • @GreenKnight23@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        I think their point is that it was trained on literally billions of repos and other software written, but because those developers don’t have hundreds of lawyers on retainer with an unlimited budget; their intellectual property rights don’t seem to be a concern to the slopmasters.

        • @meltedcheese@c.im · 2 Nov 2026

          @GreenKnight23 @technology Copyright and Patents are only as good as your pockets are deep.

        • @gian@lemmy.grys.it · 2 Nov 2026

          I think that the problem is that big companies have made “an offer they cannot refuse” regarding the problem of AI cloning commercial products.

          • @GreenKnight23@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

            just a different way of saying the same thing. the slopmasters have zero issue stealing IP when the IP holder can’t defend themselves.

      • @Doomsider@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        Microsoft word was not the first.

  • @Balldowern@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    Boycott Anthropic.

  • @Miner_Fabs@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    i know we’ve had our fun putting middle fingers up towards Adobe and the like, but these kinds of restrictions are needed to protect developers who aren’t insanely wealthy.

    from the article, which i’m sure you all read:

    And yet there are situations that merit some discussion, like the recent controversy about the Steam Next Fest being chock-full of AI slop copied from existing titles. That particular situation is getting particularly nasty, as game developers are reportedly being extorted under threat that their game demos will be cloned into complete games before they have a chance to finish and release the original.

    Adding insult to injury, this is seemingly being done to small studios whose main priority is usually “having food,” rather than big publishers looking to microtransaction everything into a new yacht for shareholders.

    • @fonix232@fedia.io · 1 Nov 2026

      While it's a worry for sure, I don't see such AI creations becoming the mainstream.

      Why? Because just like software, game develip needs the inspiration, the creative spark.

      Sure you can create a copy of an existing software... But it either doesn't go anywhere (because why would someone want a sloppy copy of a copy of a copy?), or it pivots to actually serving needs that exist on the market.

      In other words: an artist or developer with the inspiration, the genuine original idea, will create something actually enjoyable/useful, whereas a copycat will always just be that, someone who saw an idea and decided to copy it without adding anything to it.

      • @Miner_Fabs@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

        i appreciate the optimism, and yes! original stuff is always better! but sadly it’s possible for consumers to either not care or simply not know if something was made/copied with AI.

        let’s say, hypothetically, i make a free public demo for a game called “Glass Quest”. whoops, suddenly 5 evil devs have each made 20 clones of my game, and consumers don’t know if “Glass Adventure” is the original game, or if it’s “Glass Quests”, or maybe “Prism Quest”?

        not every clone is perfect, but some are good enough to take wishlists and engagement away from the original demo.

        then, somehow i make it through that, and put the full version on Steam for £10. a reasonable price, but not free. so if someone threw my game into Claude and uploaded it to Roblox, then a lot of people would play that instead just because they wouldn’t have to pay, or perhaps without ever knowing that the original Glass Quest was a Steam game.

        this is only barely exaggerated, too. see: youtu.be/9PbVrrNKKwU

        i know people have been making free versions of paid games for a very long time, but not to this scale. and those were often labours of love, not… this.

        so again. i’m glad something is being done to address it.

    • @explodicle@sh.itjust.works · 1 Nov 2026

      But this is restricting the user, not protecting the developers.

      Unscrupulous developers can rip off code using another model, including local ones that can make literally anything. Opt-in protections against doing something bad to someone else don’t work.

      It’s like selling cars with Tullock spikes.

      • @Miner_Fabs@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        i mean, it’s better than literally nothing, right?

        i’d like it if developers had access to a tool that makes it impossible for AI to decompile our programs, or if any government ever made legislation about AI so we could sue when someone else uses Ai to copy our IP, or if it was at all feasible for the average indie gamedev to afford a lawyer.

        but none of that is the case right now, so all that indie devs can hope for at the moment is that the creators of other models follow Antrhopic’s lead here, or that they get sued into doing something like this.

        note: i’m biased since i got my degree in gamedev earlier this year, and i personally dislike AI. i hope my perspective is still useful, though.

        and if there’s a better solution, i’d genuinely like to hear it

        • @explodicle@sh.itjust.works · 2 Nov 2026

          I think it’s worse than nothing because it won’t stop unscrupulous users, but will hit legitimate developers.

          Bias: senior dev, agree with Linus Torvalds on LLM use.

          I don’t think copyright is a coherent idea, and we’re watching it reach its inevitable conclusion now. It would be better if we relied on government funding and/or crowdfunding.

  • @DarkCloud@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026 · edited

    Major software companies and publishers are realising AI companies put their profit motive at risk.

    Why buy the latest Mario game when you can have a version custom built for you? Why get an Adobe subscription when the cloned version is available?

    That can be applied to any software now. Two industries are facing off.

    This is why AI generated content should belong to EVERYONE. There should be no profit in it, because the content used belongs to humanity.

    • @ZILtoid1991@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

      AI should belong in the history book of bad technologies, alongside with leaded fuel and asbestos.

  • @nerdo@lemmy.zip · 1 Nov 2026

    It belongs in the trash. We’re going to look back on these large LLMs like we look at the milkman

  • @Jiral@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    They are really making an increasingly strong case for local open weight models, run either on local infrastructure or rented data centre infrastructure. How long until they are going to try making those local models illegal?

  • @GeneralEmergency@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    And just like that

    G*mers are back to hating AI

  • @Kirp123@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    Hopefully this puts a stop to all those people copying popular steam games. They are killing the indie game scene with their fucking slop.

    • @paraphrand@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

      I totally agree with you. But this is a speed bump in the long term. 😔

  • @magnue@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026 · edited

    I think GLM 5.3 is the go-to for this stuff at the moment. Minimal refusals. So you would just RE the thing you want with GLM 5.3 until you have a standalone project, then if you wanted switch to another mainstream provider to continue from there and it wouldn’t have any problems.

    • @assembly@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

      There are so many abliterated models available right now that it’s tough to see what the strategy could look like for Anthropic. When I have a project that I even suspect could get a rejection, I just run it locally now. Even if Claude says it won’t reject it, I don’t chance it. I may pass of some parts to Opus but the majority of it is local with local agents. What does that do for Anthropic? Well, what I would have needed a $200 subscription to run, I can accomplish with the $20 subscription. Not sure how they plan to make enough money to cover expenses with those usage patterns.

      • @some_designer_dude@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

        They don’t. They’ll go public, then flee with all our money.

      • @jj4211@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026 · edited

        Note that a lot of IT stuff is much cheaper on-premise in very short timelines, but still businesses throw money at subscriptions for it anyway.

  • @LiveLM@lemmy.zip · 1 Nov 2026

    Can’t let the plebeian have too much fun

  • @joeschmoe@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    Ugh, was bound to happen. We need open models, BADLY. Unfortunately one also needs the hardware for them. I only have 20 GB VRAM and 32 GB of RAM, basically can’t use a decent model with that, sucks.

    • @Nouvellalia@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

      You can just spin up the compute for pretty cheap. It’s not as nice as having a local model, for sure, but until the bubble pops and all this hardware floods the market, or we can start grabbing it after they’re done with it, it’ll have to do.

    • @3bygone3@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

      Have you tried qwen 3.8 flash next? So far I’ve tested it only briefly but it’s definitely a lot better compared to other local llms that I can run (~30B class models). For reference I am on 16 vram and 32 ram, older ddr4 platform.

  • @ItsMeForRealNow@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    The funniest one I encountered was - it wouldn’t work on any nixos based development environments in its cloud runners and would flag them as bad use lol

  • @nightlily@leminal.space · 31 Oct 2026

    Oh no people might have to do it the same old way we’ve been doing it since Pong. Using our own brains.

  • @halfapage@lemmy.world · 31 Oct 2026

    [deleted]

  • @braindead_hottie@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    [deleted]

    • @woelkchen@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

      How can you decompile anything that hasn’t been released?

      I think you’re conflating two things.

  • @SCmSTR@lemmy.blahaj.zone · 2 Nov 2026

    100% just a paywall

  • @Gpennyhigh@lemmy.world · 1 Nov 2026

    C’mon Claude, don’t do us that way!

  • @melfie@lemmy.zip · 1 Nov 2026

    [deleted]

  • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

    Yet another absolutely fascinating comment section. Let me try to understand what is happening here.

    Are some of you upset because Claude can no longer do this? Were you perfectly happy with AI being used to decompile games and circumvent Sony’s PlayStation ecosystem when it was being used to stick it to a major corporation? But now that Anthropic has decided to prohibit this particular use of its technology, suddenly AI is terrible again? Suddenly it devalues human labor, which, incidentally, isn’t really what is happening here. In many instances, it eliminates the need for that labor altogether.

    Then there are those arguing that only AI companies should be allowed to do these things, rather than independent individuals. Which is, quite frankly, a ridiculous argument. Companies have every right to dictate how their products and services are used, particularly when we’re talking about a proprietary service like Claude. You don’t own Claude. You don’t purchase the underlying technology. It belongs to Anthropic, and Anthropic gets to establish the terms under which it is made available.

    So which is it? Do you oppose AI on principle, or do you only oppose it when it doesn’t serve your particular interests? Is AI the enemy of human creativity and labor, except when it’s being used to accomplish something you personally want?

    I’d appreciate a little consistency from this user base. Surely that’s not too much to ask.

    • @ragebutt@lemmy.dbzer0.com · 2 Nov 2026

      The user base isn’t homogenous

      I like that Claude can jailbreak consoles and decomp and port games quickly. These are projects that are cool, have utility, are obnoxiously difficult and or tedious, and exclusively unpaid. Is it better if some super coder does it all? Probably, but the unpaid bit means progress is painfully slow and limited to people doing passion projects. But is it also cool I can play a bunch of retro games natively on basically any platform and then jailbreak a ps5 to run Linux and steam? Yes

      • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        I will admit that it is possible I need to make my position a little clearer. The vast majority of comments on this platform are overwhelmingly critical of AI in other posts, yet many of those same people were praising it when it was being used to decompile video games and jailbreak the PS5.

        I am simply, once again, pointing out the two-faced nature of this platform. My gripe, if you will, is consistency. If you hate AI, then hate it for everything it does, including the things that might actually be beneficial. It’s convenient to play both sides and act as a devil’s advocate when it suits your position, but ultimately, that’s a useless and self-defeating stance.

        If you’re going to take a centrist position on AI, then do that. Praise it where it deserves praise and criticize it where it deserves criticism. But don’t turn around and say you hate everything about AI in one breath, only to make an exception when it happens to serve your interests.

    • @acchariya@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

      Claude rests on a foundation of open source contributions hoovered up with license files sent to /dev/null. The unexpected positive we had for a little while was that maybe it could pry open the walled gardens of applications (conincidentally also built atop the same open source contributions). But it wasn’t to be, only big corporations get to use this benefit.

      • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        But they’re not. Big corporations aren’t decompiling games, modifying them, and then distributing them for free. They’re not even doing it for profit.

        In a grand act of irony, they stopped potential copyright infringement involving the very games being decompiled and redistributed.

        My complaint, and the point I’m calling out, is that people on this platform will praise technology when it’s convenient for them, only to throw it under the bus when it becomes convenient to do so. Even when, in this particular instance, the technology provider technically did the right thing by putting a stop to the activity. Although, no doubt, this was prompted by pressure from Sony, Rockstar, and other concerned parties.

    • @AwesomeLowlander@sh.itjust.works · 2 Nov 2026

      The usual fallacy of treating the comment section as if it were a unified single opinion.

      Also, false dichotomy. There’s plenty of other options, some of which make a lot more sense.

      • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

        Your first comment, accusing me of treating the comment section as one unified opinion, is a straw man. It is significantly easier to defend an argument when you change it entirely, rather than address what I actually said. I was arguably addressing the comment section as a collective, not suggesting that every individual held the exact same opinion. Your response demonstrates that you either misunderstand or are misusing the term logical fallacy.

        Your second statement is pure nonsense for the same reason. You clearly don’t understand what a false dichotomy is. I didn’t introduce a dichotomy or present two mutually exclusive positions. I simply asked a question: which is it?

        Please stop throwing around logical fallacies when you don’t understand what they mean. It derails the conversation entirely. Instead of addressing the substance of my argument, you’ve changed the discussion into an argument about whether I understand logical fallacies. Worse, you’ve completely avoided addressing the actual point I was making. That’s precisely the kind of diversion that prevents any meaningful discussion.

    • @veniasilente@feddit.cl · 2 Nov 2026

      So which is it?

      Multiple things can be true at once, or change their status and realization as the world revolves. Very few facts get the honour of remaining as true axioms.

      Is AI the enemy of human creativity and labor, except when it’s being used to accomplish something you personally want?

      It’s the enemy of human creativity and labour, even when it’s being used to accomplish something I personally want. But if as you say, I don’t get to choose how the technology is used, then there is good moral reason to not be glad when its action happens to align with your intent. After all, we are glad for fair weather every once in a while.

      May I remind you also that the worker class were quite certainly not the owners of the pitchforks and guillotines with which they rebelled against their oppressors.

    • @MangioneDontMiss@feddit.nl · 2 Nov 2026

      o… it can still do this. if you pay for the super premium (hidden) tier

  • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

    I… Completely agree and my comment wasn’t meant for you. You have no idea how often I encounter people that simply do not understand or know exactly what these llms do and they simply dislike them for the sake of being part of the bandwagon, I am generally irritated by these people. The ones that say out loud that they hate everything that AI does and then when it does something generally useful and they don’t hate that one particular thing. It’s extremely two-faced and inconsistent and absolutely bothers me.

    • @GreenKnight23@lemmy.world · 2 Nov 2026

      you’re on the wrong platform buddy.

      go run off to Reddit where the bots will agree with whatever bullshit you’re spewing.

      • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026

        I am on the right platform, and I’ll use it whenever and however I see fit, within the TOS I agreed to when I created my account.

        Maybe you should run off to Reddit, where you can make some kind of moral stand against the things you disagree with, rather than running around here in your own little yes-man echo chamber.

        • @GreenKnight23@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026

          lemmy overwhelmingly disapproves of AI/LLM use. join the dbzer0 instance if you want to have a positive experience with that pile of shit you call an opinion.

          • @mechoman444@lemmy.world · 4 Nov 2026 · edited

            I don’t care what Lemmy is overwhelmingly for or against. At all. I’m going to call out bandwagon bullshit every time I see it for as long as I feel like doing it.

            Once again. You should go to that instance and do something about it.

            And say what you want about “my opinion” it is correct.