626
Motorola Signature 27 with GrapheneOS will cost €1.900
heise online
Signature 27: Motorola’s priciest phone is its first with GrapheneOS support
Motorola’s first smartphone with GrapheneOS support is here, but the high-end Signature 27 is anything but a bargain.
www.heise.de
460 comments
log in to comment.
So it’s going to fail and they’re going to blame Graphene
Looks like it
At least the rumors that it’d be a foldable seem to be wrong.
It’s also initially launching with android 17. The article said that Graphene won’t be ready for it until some time next year. I wonder if the devs are deliberately putting some separation between the hardware launch and OS availability so that they can avoid getting caught up in Motorola’s corporate panic attack when this thing doesn’t sell.
Only priced like one, unfortunately
The foldable is the next one to get support after signature 27.
It doesn’t release with graphene os so that would be stupid, it ships their android.
Not offering a pre-installed GrapheneOS version feels like a misstep. Plenty of people are aware of the brand for security and privacy, and would pay extra to have it pre-installed.
Maybe we will see some re-sellers pop up, but I would prefer direct-from-manufacturer.
Not to mention, they could get the keys right from day one and eliminate (Google’s) “alternate OS is booting” boogieman screen.
This is pure cope, there is no way “plenty of people” are lining up to pay this amount of money for a Motorola phone with a niche operating system.
Just because something isn’t mainstream doesn’t mean it would not make plenty of money.
As was pointed out above, Motorola probably underestimates the casual folks who would pay extra to have GrapheneOS pre-installed, because the GrapheneOS developers are so rabidly against trusting anyone else to do the install.
But many GrapheneOS users just like having a qucik toggle for the microphone and camera.
(Side question: Why the fuck hasn’t such a basic privacy feature made it into basic Android, anyway? Or has it, and I missed it?)
And yes, there’s always a buyer for a phone this expensive. For some people, it will be their only computer for five to ten years, anyway.
They aren’t shipped with GrapheneOS because the developers of GrapheneOS explicitly don’t want this. They dont want any possibility of some backdoor caused by the manufacturer to bring down their reputation.
It not being shipped with GrapheneOS is on purpose.
Yes. I’m waiting for a chill fork of GrapheneOS. I love what the developers have accomplished. LineageOS seems close, but not quite there with features, last I checked.
I was happy with decent default security and privacy in the past, and I could be, again, if it ever returns.
I would be glad to purchase a device from a trusted party, who pre-installed public source code, on open hardware.
I’ll be very pleased if Framework ever releases a phone.
And sure, most people, in general, are clueless, about most things. Point granted.
But the people with a clue about today’s brutal privacy situation want device that is reasonably assured to be respect their wishes, and not chained to the whim of some asshole CEO.
Perfect is lovely. But good enough can still sell very well.
Not having it support tap to pay basically makes it a non starting for selling it.
The amount of stupid selling a phone with out that feature, while the same phone other times it works basically would just cause endless problems.
Yes people are that stupid
Personally, I already balked at the size of the screen (~6.8"). The ridiculous price is just the final nail in the coffin.
Mini tablets were 7 inches.
It’s ridiculous; how am I meant to fit something half the size of my dick in my pocket?
How am I meant to fit something seven times the size of my dick in my pocket?
Did you try tucking?
Wait, is this really the size of a nexus 7?
phones have a different aspect ratio than tablets plus the nexus 7 had giant bezels
Fair point on the bezels.
Just let it hang and sway, let it out bro. This is 🦅 America 🇺🇸, bitches! gunfire, big macs showering from the sky, and jets flying over in formation
(and if you don’t live here then we can bring you some freedom too, and you too can let your freak flag fly)
No thanks. I live in a country freer than the US, you guys keep all that to yourselves.
can i come over to play vidya
Sure, just stay for 90 days only.
EDIT : you can smoke the legal weed only if someone gives it to you for free, you can’t buy any.
More big macs for me 😎
Yikes, I hadn’t looked into the screen size until you mentioned it. They seem to be going after the XL / tablet size type of devices, exactly the ones that I avoid. Oh well, maybe they’ll eventually release a phone with a more normal screen size closer to 6.3".
Couldn’t agree more. I’m currently on the Pixel 6a, and in spite of having perfectly average-sized hands, I feel its 6.1" display is unwieldy. 6.8" is just bonkers.
I’d love a giant screen. I miss my nexus 6.
Oh my damn. I expected something expensive, but this is just way above what I expected.
The Graphene developers did say that future plans could entail even broader Motorola support from GrapheneOS, for cheaper models too. Let’s hope this will be the case…
I’m holding out for a 2027 Moto G.
Give me Edge 60 Neo with graphene and I’d be happy. Small, good battery, good screen, ok-ish camera, nothing else needed.
Yeah it seems to boil down to MTE. Only the latest Flagship Qualcomm Gen6 has it (sans tensor).
So until qualcomms midrange offerings start having MTE we’ll be waiting.
I’d like to have one, but there’s no fucking way a goddamned PHONE is worth $2000
especially today, when updates are so miniscule, I’m in shock when I realize the pixel 7 I got refurbished still works fine, with zero reason to update.
Yep, been doing used pixels for a while now. They’re all the same anyway. I don’t care about the camera.
My kids are dopes and constantly break screens so I’m not about to buy anything nice. We all have the same model and a spare. Broken, eBay screen, bring in the spare, fix the broken one, is now the spare.
You’ll get a new phone when it doesn’t get updates anymore, then you’ll just get the next one up.
Spending more than $300 on a phone is nuts to me. They’re all the same candy bar anyway.
Tried getting a fairphone, but they are so hard to get in the states. only phone upgrade I want.
A brand new phone should cost at most 499 US. anything beyond that is good damn stupid.
Motherfuckers. I would have paid 1k - but that is ridiculous
I have a pixel 10 with 16gb RAM. Nothing has made changing realistic and likely wont for awhile. I hate AI and only wantgOS and a decent camera.
I just refuse to buy anything at these inflated hardware prices due to the AI pandemic.
I’ll just keep all my old tech… Someone is profiting and i’m not getting a better product for it.
Agreed. The worst is the components for self hosting and builfing your own gear is also caught in this. Raspberry Pi prices are crazy
Yup. I really need to upgrade my server it’s 4 core xeon from 2016. But it’ll hold out another few years i’m sure!
I got a pi for HA and another for an arr stack. €200 and I got a great price on them pi400 rgb and pi 16gb.
I would love a nuc and get jellyfin on it.
Who are the customers for such a ridiculous thing?
Drug lords
As someone whos grew up on iPhones this feels reasonable for a high end product…
Reasonable is $900. Just because apple made a $2000 phone doesn’t mean everyone does.
I had a Nexus 4 for $300 way back when, and that was mighty premium enough. We’re all getting screwed and there is no savior. The water has been boiling for over a decade.
My current phone cost $500 and it’s more than powerful & capable enough. Android sucks to use but other than that I have no idea why anyone would get anything more expensive unless they need some really good camera.
Android does suck but is superior to iOS. If only linux was realistic on a phone.
Jolla phone, with SailfishOS exists. Mine will be sent out soon!
I’m typing this from my jolla phone right now! It’s definitely not perfect but I’m really happy with it, and it has totally replaced my android phone at this point.
Good to hear! I can’t wait. Haven’t been this excited for a phone in ages
Mine too! The Sept II batch!
I am intrigued for sure, I want to try them out but none of my drawer phones suit it or postmarket.
There a few limitations, banking, camera, car projection. But they are getting better.
There is android auto support made by a user. Banking depends on the bank. And camera is also getting some community love.
Samsung does too, the aim is office workers in European + USA, which gets a new phone sponsored every few years
Is it? It costs more than any (bar-style) iPhone. This is priced less than the Oppo X9 Ultra and Vivo X300 Ultra, similarly to the Samsung Galaxy S26 Ultra and the Xiaomi 17 Ultra, and priced more than the Apple iPhone 18 Pro Max and Google Pixel 11 Pro XL –the problem is the subsect of people who are happy paying this price and cares about privacy are abysmally minute.
This is the normal cost of a new phone no? If I were buying an Iphone or a samsung i’d expect to pay around the same price.
When I bought my just-barely-not-current-gen ipad pro, it was 1100€.
This phone is more than 60% more expensive than that. I can’t imagine buying a mobile device that costs this much
Oh I did not notice that was in Euro. Jesus christ
My phone actually is a Samsung and was around €400. It works fine, and does all things I want my phone to do without any issues. The only improvement I’d care even marginally about would be a better set of cameras, but until they’d actually be on par with my “real” camera that’s not something I’m willing to pay for.
Yeah the current high end Samsung galaxy ultra is about the same price in Australia.
This is marginally more expensive than flagship phones, but it’s not clear how performance will compare.
I wonder how much of this higher price point is due to the lack of partnerships with companies like Google who will harvest information about you through the device.
Completely wrong target for GrapheneOS. The GrapheneOS demographics, which I belong to, isn’t interested in high-end phones. They want a no nonsense simple phone with lots of storage and security first design.
This will be harmful to GrapheneOS project. It will go like this: no one buys the phone because it’s too damn expensive and full of features the privacy nerds like me don’t care about. Even fewer buy the phone with GrapheneOS pre-installed and it’s a total flop. Motorola stops the partnership saying “we did it and no one wanted it”. No other OEM wants to partner with GrapheneOS after that.
I’m expecting they will launch cheaper models too
I sure hope so. If they release something around the 500€ price range, I would definitely be more interested.
Gotta really wring the juice out of early adopters.
I never got this. We’ve reached phones having hundreds of gigs and I don’t know what I’d be storing on my phone. Phones can be lost or break easily, so I wouldn’t want to store anything valuable. The largest files I have tend to be photos and the like, and they’re too valuable to just sit on a phone.
I synchronize some documents, photos and music between my phone and computer. I need these files on the go. They are saved at home too.
For me it’s mostly music and videos I can play when I don’t have a connection.
Offline downloads of maps can get pretty big
Very fair points have been raised. Offline music, maps etc. Makes sense.
I do want amoled and good gpu and cpu with graphene
Also with open firmware (apparently this doesn’t have any) there is always the question of camera DRM.
Did Grapheneos sell itself out?
No, it sold us.
You can flash eOS by yourself no a fairphone and if inevitably something breaks you don’t have to move everything to another phone, you can easily repair by yourself!
eOS+Fairphone is fairly different proposition. Not equivalent to GrapheneOS in my view. It’s a good option in terms of product ownership. GrapheneOS remains the undisputed best proposition in terms of security.
Why hasn’t GrapheneOS started supporting Fairphones ? Because they don’t meet their security requirements on hardware level. Why hasn’t Fairphone seek partnership with GrapheneOS? Maybe they did and we don’t know about that because it didn’t lead anywhere, probably because the 2 organizations have very different goals.
You are probably thinking the demographic that value privacy and security overlaps with people valuing product ownership, repairability and fair manufacturing. You would be totally correct. I would be delighted to have an all inclusive option at a reasonable price. Today it’s a trade-off decision. Repairability as top value: Fairphone+eOS. Security as top value: Pixel+GrapheneOS.
Sorry I don’t get y’all aren’t top secret whistle blowers and even then better not use a phone for anything related…
CPU is kinda required for all of the encryption and security to work. As for the rest, you’re probably right, although I would be glad to have a good camera on a secure phone (but won’t, at this price point, well)
I have the Pixel 7 and the camera is pretty good already. 2 sensors is perfectly fine.
Yeah, afaik, pixel 10 has the same camera anyway
That’s really out of my budget. I want a phone with graphene, but I can’t take out a mortgage for it.
Get a used pixel 9a for 1/7 the cost, or a new pixel 10a for around 1/4 of the cost
It’s an option I’ll seriously consider when it’s time to change my device, but I’d also prefer a device where I don’t have to manually change the operating system. I’m neither that much of an expert nor do I have time to spare.
It is honestly pretty painless - unlock boot loader, attach device, give appropriate petmission on phone, run install from browser, verify install, lock boot loader.
That said, a dedicated Grapheme device is so exciting. I am not going to spend ~2k on it tho
This is accurate. I’ve been flashing phones with custom ROMs for years now, and doing it through the browser makes it both dead easy and pretty safe. You no longer need to be a tech shaman to do it. Just follow the instructions and you’re good.
Also, if you don’t like it, you can always go back to stock Android (i.e. what was installed before you started tinkering). It’s pretty painless. So roll up your sleeves and explore!
Graphene turned it into a process where you plug your phone in, and just press the buttons on their website in order. Much better experience than when I tried to fiddle with LineageOS
lineage also recently added something similar actually.
You have to press 3 buttons on their website …
Which only works if you use chrome. What is the overlap between gOS users and chrome users?
Chromium works.
There is also an offline flasher? Like if you complain that it is too complex, get chromium, flash it with 3 buttons, remove chromium and be happy. If you are deep enough into everything, that you don’t want to install chromium to flash your device, use the offline installer.
How many Chromium users does GOS have? I don’t know, but their default browser is Vanadium, which is a chromium browser…
This Motorola comes with regular android so you’d have to manually change this as well
I would say that if installing GOS is too complicated for you, you don’t really need it. De-googling, privacy and security take more effort than just owning a phone with some specific OS. Simply having GOS on your phone is meaningless if you don’t know how to use it properly.
Removing spyware from the phone of a complete non-techie means that non-technie has a spyware-free phone.
Sure, it won’t solve every privacy or security concern, but it outright solves a fuck-ton of privacy and security concerns, regardless of how technical the user is.
I’ve been handing GrapheneOS phones to young or elderly people in my life for several years, with very good results, compared to leaving them on iOS or stock malwared Android.
Yeah the graphene team has done an amazing job of making a privacy/security hardened phone that a regular user would really have to go out of their way to break the security.
Typical user will still install WhatsApp, Instagram, Gmail and Facebook, give them all the permissions and willingly input all their data into them. I really don’t see what the benefit of GOS is here. Setting up alternatives for all those apps is more complicated than installing GOS.
I don’t mean this in an insulting way. If following the instructions to install GrapheneOS is too hard or time consuming for someone, there is not much a GrapheneOS phone can do for that person. The biggest liability to security and privacy will be the user, not the phone.
Yeah until those are no longer supported and these expensive ass Motorolas are the only option BC Google is locking down newer models that won’t be able to have GOS installed eventually.
Well if there at one point is no reasonably priced smartphone for graphene I’ll either go lineage or dumb phone.
It’s locking down newer models. Some models still have 6 years of updates ahead of them. It’s a bit too early to start panicking about it.
Yes, I said they’re slowly locking down the newer models. And yeah, older pixels still have some time. But is this crisis we are in gonna end by the time those pixels lose support or are these Motorolas going to be our only option. That’s all I’m pointing out. Yeah, still a little early to panic but if how things have been lately, I think this is looking to be bad for the average person who doesn’t have a lot of money. Over $2,000 USD is absolutely insane.
You got a source for this?
Get a load of Mr. Moneybags over here, having enough equity that he could mortgage something…
$1900 and still no headphone jack.
actually $1599.00 USD: arstechnica.com/…/motorolas-new-signature-27-has-… or androidheadlines.com/motorola-signature-27-price-…
Which would make their claim even more wrong because a nominal tax rate of 10% would make that price $1758.9.
But either way, the point is, $1900
@!$and €1900 aren't the same and either their dollar sign was a typo or they misread.Whoops, I figured this was the usual thing where people in Europe get screwed by paying the euro amount for what we pay in dollars (e.g. where we pay $500 and they pay €500 for the same product). Either way, for $1600 they could have at least included a headphone jack. I would have been very, very tempted despite the price to have GrapheneOS and a headphone jack again.
$2,133.08 USD.
Source: https://eur.currencyrate.today/convert/amount-1900-to-usd.html
Not exactly. Europrices are always after taxes, Muricans always speak of prices before taxes (and tip, if applicable), so just mentally changing the € for $ or vice versa gets you a good enough approximation.
Also, even ignoring taxes, it’s pretty common for tech products to cost the same number of USD, EUR, and GBP.
That was what I assumed, and clearly I was wrong.
Nope. Still wrong according to the above thread. Looks like price in the US would be something like $1599 edit: before tax.
Even if I was ok spending $2300AUD on a phone. No headphone jack, no purchase.
Is an adapter really that terrible?
Yes, and completely unnecessary since your phone already has a DAC in it
Right, at this point I am carrying around a DAP to listen to headphones. Being able to go back to just the phone would be very convenient for me.
Security isn’t for poor people I guess
It reality hhh
It’s annoying because I’ve gotten very security-conscious over the last year, but shit like this makes it feel like I can’t achieve what I want unless I get rich.
I mean, you can get a refurbished unlocked pixel 8 straight from google for $380 and put grapheme on it… Even less if you buy a used phone or third party refurb.
$380’s still a bit steep in my position right now, but I appreciate the ideas. Thank you!
You can get Pixel 6 for 195$ refurbished on Amazon.
Doesn’t that reach EOL very soon?
it does yeah but I’ve got one personally and intend to keep using it regardless.
Buy a second hand or refurb pixel. That’s what I did. Google already got paid, sure, but you don’t give them anything more. It’s not perfect, but it’s an economical solution that doesn’t break the bank and still gets you security. At this point, if you don’t want big tech, may I suggest two tin cans and a string? if you do that, at least Del Monte doesn’t get the recycling deposit back on their empty green bean receptacles.
Welcome to life.
You can try other opensource system depend on your phone
Almost all the other ones are reportedly worse at security than the stock OS, only Graphene is more apparently. At least according to their team, I know they trash Lineage and E a lot.
Try to buy pixel 8 or 9 it’s a little cheapest
Honestly right now my heads at riding out the rest of this phone’s contract (It was a Galaxy A16 I got for free because I needed desperately off my old, end of life S9) and switching to iPhone, cuz that has almost all the security but none of the breakage of a custom rom.
I was really hoping to pay Motorola somewhere around $800-$1200 for a legit option for GrapheneOS that doesn’t involve Google’s hardware.
But at $1600, I don’t think I can justify that.
€1.900 is $2,133 in American, according to a quick Google ask.
Agreed. Can’t justify spending that on a phone. And unfortunately, many others will feel the same, which will result in low sales and it being declared a failure, putting another nail in the coffin for privacy focused consumer products.
I can’t wait until the whole backside is cameras!
found this trypophobia phone !
trypophobia warning
source : yankodesign.com/…/how-many-cameras-is-too-many-ca…
How brainrotted do you have to be to spend that much on a phone with a sealed in 2-year battery?
I thought that’s not even legal to sell in the EU anymore
That requirement applies from products released starting February 18, 2027 so afaik it released just in time to not be required by law to be user replacable.
That’s a veeeeeeery optimistic “up to”. It’s not like a car where you don’t need the full cycle every day and it has proper active thermal management. In fact I would call it an outright lie.
I’m not saying you’re wrong but it’s an entire selling point of this phone. A battery that should be better than Li-ion, with active cooling (a vapor chamber that claims to dissipate 40% more heat).
I’m impressed at the design of my 2023 Moto Razr as far as battery heat management goes. It’s not perfect on this cheaper device but it is efficient. The aluminum sides of the chassis are very good at dissipating heat and they’ve clearly designed it to navigate heat to the sides.
If it were Li-ion I would never consider this device but they didn’t toss a shitty Li-ion battery in it. Not much of a battery expert myself. I’m sure you can’t replace it without paying a dime or some annoying DIY but that’s not particularly relevant to me when every modern phone is the same. Primarily I want faster charge times and longer daily life which this seems to (hopefully) offer.
Edit: I’m sure a vapor chamber is a form of passive cooling, please don’t eat me alive. I mean active in the sense of they did something
Nobody’s gonna buy it, but Motorola gets to say they tried and there just wasn’t a market for GrapheneOS.
Modern Nokia should get into it 😤😭
Some serious piss taking here.
Why are they taking my piss… :( what are they gonna use my piss for :((((
It used to be used for washing laundry, maybe someone is starting a new business
I guess gold was too expensive for showering?
Always better to be pissed off than pissed on, I say
I always thought the same. Odd phrase.
Yeesh. Looks like I’ll be on the used pixel ebay plan for a few more years.
Surely at that price point it is designed to last 8-10 years.
What’s that, it has a glued-in 2 year lithium battery?
welp refurbished pixel it is then
What is the point of a 1900€ phone? What is the target audience? How is it better than a 500€ phone?
Questions more towards Motorola than Graphene, but I doubt the Graphene foundation went into the partnership without knowing what kinds of specific phones would be covered.
In general, flagships get longer software support, much faster processors, sometimes more RAM and storage and usually better cameras.
In particular, this one seems to have a ridiculous camera setup with 200MP (remains to be seen if it’s actually great or just an inflated amount of pixels) and a 7000 mAh battery compared to e.g pixel 11 pro xl’s 5115.
And you can choose between 12 or 16 gigs of RAM. RAM is very expensive right now. Also promising a ridiculously bright screen so maybe this one will be useable outdoors?
At these prices, the Pedophile Elite. Heck, the Trump Phone was half this price!
Yes, but the Trump phone was a 4 or 5 year old HTC budget device, this one is a current flagship.
No one said the pedophile elite was any smart.
Neither did I, I’m just saying that even at this price point this phone will provide some value for all that money when the official pedo phone was expensive AND shit.
¡Admittedly a fair point!
It could targetting the customers of EncroChat.
The discerning drug dealers who want a premium phone.
Look out for rap lyrics mentioning “moto sig 27” in place of glocks and ak47s. 😜
Phones like these have features that power users love like headphone jack, expandable storage, removable battery, and repairability improvements. They also have really good software support too and a lot of OS options, such as both mainline Linux support and Android. And on top of that, a 10+ year support lifetime so you can really get the most out of your hardware. It might be $1000+ USD more expensive than the alternatives, but the freedom, added functionality, and longevity it gives you makes it really worth it!
Phones like what? The phone in question here (signature 27) has none of those features. Sounds like you might be referring to something like the fairphone, but even that dropped the headphone jack.
Ironically, the only phones Motorola kept the sd card and headphone jack on are their low end g series, currently selling for around $400.
I think you misunderstood my post lol, the fact that the signature 27 has none of those features is the point
What the fuck is the point? Like really what the fuck??? Just make an affordable phone is it really that fucking hard??? Sorry for cruising so much but what the actual fuck??? LiKe is it actually hard to conceptualize common sense now a-days??? Like girl we’re 27 and broke and your telling us not only of we want out of the hellscape of Apple vs Android bullshit we either gotta make out own phone or pay 2k€ for a fucking phone?! FOR A PHONE!!! We’ve only bought 1 new phone EVER only purchased pre-used phones and they’ve all been old and even this “new” phone was old when we got it 😭 we’ve been stuck on this shitty ios phone stuff too fucking long and been waiting for like any good android phone and was looking at this like holy shit finally AND NOW IT’S 2 FUCN K EUROS!!!
Another 5 years on the iPhone 12 mini ig
Honestly, I think it’s partly that tech workers are out of touch with reality in terms of pay/income. I’ve heard senior software devs be absolutely floored / in utter disbelief when they’ve heard the average salary in my country – ppl literally laughed, thinking it a joke, because they couldn’t believe anyone could live on so little. They were making double the average right out of university. They have no frame of reference for people who struggle to pay bills, nor do they pay much thought to blowing a few thousand on a gadget.
Pixel 8 renewed is lik 260$ and runs Graphene and has software support thru like 2030 fyi
Thank you, that is actually one phone we’re considering but 3 years of support isn’t very long. We tend to keep the same phone for as long as possible. No need for a new one unless we’re really need it
It should be til late 2030 so closer to 4 years atleast. And the newer pixels are your only option if you want longer support. The issue is they’re exponentially more expensive.
Yeah, has this phone for 5 years now and am thinking that 6 years is a good life expectancy, but even 4 it’s like we would have to go over the same situation all over again 😪
A friend jokingly said we should just make our own phone and rn we’re heavily considering it tbh lol
Are chinese phones banned in EU too? I literally can’t get them here in the US :(
No, don’t think they’re banned here in EU. But like don’t think that they’re not all that much cheaper yeah?
Dude WHY!? That’s more expensive than the Steam Frame with accessories!
…so, how come the phone costs twice as much as the steam frame?
Look! We tried it, and nobody will buy it!!! Nothing to see here, back to stealing everyone’s data!
Yeah, I’m thinking this too. The old "but we gave the option to people, but people just don’t care."
The “option” :
Off the top of my head I’m guessing that the cost isn’t being subsidized by data mining and certain social media companies paying for their apps to be impossible to completely remove.
I honestly would consider it if it had SD card support. I would have purchased it instantly if it came with SD card support and a damn headphone jack. I’m the market for this freaking phone why don’t they figure out what we’re actually asking for?
Extremely few people are asking for a built in sd card slot
The point they are trying to make is that an ubersecure phone with GrapheneOS will have a certain target demographic.
Among that target demographic SD card slots have a demand.
I can’t help it if people have not yet realized the huge cost of memory is a major factor in phone price increases, and that SD cards are a great way to have your full media library on your phone without being beholden to “the cloud”.
But a sdcard could be slightly slower than the integrated eemc storage and consumers could get confused that <manufacturer>’s phones are slow!
Meanwhile, I’m streaming HD video from a 1tb SD card (pre crisis price <$80) over WiFi to a TV. The bottle neck is not the SD card for media. Even emulators don’t need higher speed.
I think people who want private OSes and people who want offline storage for things have a lot of overlap
I don’t understand the complaint about a headphone jack. They make dongles for USBC to headphone. Plug it into your headphone and forget it’s there.
If you need to power at the same time, buy a dongle with a splitter.
3.5 mm headphone jack is much 𝕞𝕦𝕔𝕙 𝖒𝖚𝖈𝖍 more robust than USB-C port. You can slingshot your phone by the headphone cable, and both the phone and the cable will be fine.
USB-C socket gets slightly bent and you cannot charge your phone.
It’s also at the bottom of the phone, so you cannot hold it normally, while the headphone jack is at the top.
I miss the audio jack and agree with you, but all my phones always had audio jack on the bottom not far from the USB port
That varied between brands and models, some had it at the top some at the bottom. There was no industry standard for the location.
True.
But!
USB port is invariably at the center of the bottom side, there’s no industry standard but it’s a popular convention. Which means it’s inconvenient to hold a charging phone with either right or left hand.
Headphone jack is near the corner of the phone, top or bottom, it’s convenient to hold with one hand - left or right depends on the manufacturer, but many opt for the jack to the left for right-handed users.
This I actually don’t agree with. I don’t often charge my phone when i also need it (usually I’m sleeping when it charges), but on the rare occasion that i do, it’s not in the way and I can’t really see why it would be? How are you holding your phone since it’s inconvenient? Standing in your palm??
Not standing on my palm exactly, but the plug is definitely pushing into it.
And forget about playing games in landscape orientation, the USB cable is totally in the way, while it’s manageable with headphone cable.
I actually prefer the headphone jack on the bottom, but other than that I pretty much agree
That’s just more shit to carry. I don’t want to have pockets overflowing with dongles.
The dongle stays plugged into the headphones don’t it. You’re carrying headphones and dongle as one piece.
Who the fuck is going out with their headphones plugged in 100% of the time?
I think what they mean is that you leave the dongle plugged into the headphone cable, not that you leave the dongle plugged into the phone.
Oh right
As I already said, you plug it into the end of your headphone jack. It’s not something you carry separately.
Your headphone cable is now 1cm longer. It’s the same as if you bought headphones with a USBC cable.
Except for when I switch my headphones to another device that uses the 3.5mm, or if I switch from in-ear to over-ear, if if I want to plug my phone into my stereo. In all those cases I have to move the dongle around.
You shouldn’t need dongles to use headphones. There is no rational reason a phone can’t have a headphone jack, it’s just Apples insanity spreading to the rest of the phone manufacturers.
It’s actually hard to buy a single dongle. They’re like 4 for $9. So you put one on everything.
For home stereo I bought a Bluetooth dongle and leave that plugged into the stereo.
So it’s not perfect, but it’s not like you can’t plug in your phone.
I was angry about headphone jacks for a long time but it’s easier to pick your battles and motion to more important things
So your power/data USB C port can snap off?
How about we have the boys in engineering work up a more durable dedicated audio port for something that will be plugged in when on the go?
We can give it:
A solid, round metal plug for infinite 360-degree rotation, neutralizing cable-twist strain that would otherwise warp a rigid USB-C port.
A hollow-tunnel design with out the fragile internal circuit “tongue” found in USB-C, making it nearly impossible to snap or bend through accidental force.
And as a bonus, heavy-duty internal spring contacts that tolerate dirt and high insertion counts, and linear release mechanism so the cable will pop out cleanly during a violent tug instead of tearing up the phone’s internal electronics.
We can call this MIRACLE as the 3.5mm headphone jack. The kids will love it!
I miss the headphone jacks too but I feel like people you guys are idolising it as if it was a god-tier jack when it is/was just okay. 3.5mm jacks would break on me all the time. I’ve literally had the 3.5mm plug break off inside the port before
They are not perfect but they are objectively more durable, cause less damage to the device if they fail, and you don’t loose your power and data port if it fails from daily use.
I know I broke more USB cables in 15 years than audio jacks over 40 years, and I was way harder on electronics 20-30 years ago. (That poor CD to car cassette adapter took some high Gforce impacts, and the walkman just lived in a backpack with the cable plugged in).
I don’t recall ever having a 3.5mm fail, for me the wire always failed first. USB on the other hand (pretty much any of them) it’s just a matter of time
I’ve been using one of these USB headphone jacks… and I’d go back to the 3.5 mm audio jack in a heartbeat.
Why?
All in all, its just annoying… all because manufacturers ramrod Bluetooth down our throats, charge us more for Bluetooth headphones, force us to leave Bluetooth on 24/7 (so we can use our devices to relay everyone else’s tracking pucks/tags) and the manufacturers save $0.03 on each device by not having a headphone jack.
It’s just another example of forcing the customer into things they don’t want (just like A.I.).
Be careful with those magnetic dongles, I’ve read it can be quite easy to fry your device with them.
Also I have one of the apple usb-c to 3.5mm adapters and it’s like they designed it to be a flimsy point of failure - RIP 3.5mm jacks.
tech.yahoo.com/…/stop-using-magnetic-usb-c-140117…
I like GrapheneOS but I don’t like it that much. 2 thousand dollars… God damn.
Yeah, still, id rather just go with a fairphone running linux. This whole phone and price tag is ridiculous, literally a monstrosity
You can run linux on a fairphone???
Imma blow this persons mind
Yes, the fairphone can run pmos(or nura now i guess) which is linux based. It actually boots linux as far as i know and doesnt pull shenanigans like ubuntu touch for compatibility.
In short, yes.
That’s it that’s the whole answer honestly. As with anything Linux there is a ton of progress being done by very few people & your milage may vary.
Read the wikis, watch the hands-on videos & you’ll get an idea if it’s ready enough for you. But, imho, it’s a good project & totally worth it for me as it is.
Article text below. No links, and definitely not their “198 data partners”
They call GrapheneOS a “custom ROM”. Both gOS and Android are based on AOSP, which means either both are custom ROMs or neither is. But nobody calls Android a custom ROM.
The OEM install is the default ROM and anything else is a custom ROM. Vanilla AOSP would also be considered custom in this situation.
I want a new 5.5" smartphone with graphene OS that costs $200 or less. I don’t want tablet sized phones and I don’t want expensive thousand dollar phones. All I care about is that the phone can make phone calls and respects my privacy.
Well, this is defintely not good for the GrapheneOS project. they’ve already been criticized for being only accessible by techbros and people with sufficient resources to buy a Pixel. A lot of people were assuming a lower price from Motorola. This is crazy.
I just bought a pixel 10a open box for like $350.
Like I get some people are stuck on Walmart specials, but how cheap does it need to be before its not considered a purchase for the privileged by you?
Well, its not just the money, its the fact that it is a Google product. Many of us, outside the USA don’t trust anything that Google produces, including Android itself (which is why degoogled phones are a thing) nor do we want to fuel the techno fascists running the company.
I’m outside the US. I brought several broken Pixels Pros & fixed them with Chinese parts. I run GrapheneOS on all of them. None of my money went to Google. I even sold one with GrapheneOS still installed & the buyer understood what that meant.
You don’t need to trust ungoogled phones, you just need to trust the forensic analysis, cyber security reports & new patches that point towards a cryptographically safe environment.
I hate Google as much as any of you Lemmies but there are ways. Plenty.
Ah y antes de que digan mamadas de privilegio y así… gano en axolopezones y estoy a la mitad entre bajos ingresos y pobreza 🫠
You obviously don’t :)
Grapheme runs tests on googles firmware regularly.
If it was actively doing something it shouldnt, they’d notice.
You could argue there could be something hidden in the firmware for use by the state when they REALLY REALLY REALLY want to get into something, and are willing to blow a good backdoor on it. But that’s also something you deal with on any modern PC, unless you wanna party like its 2011 and run an old FX-Series AMD chip, or a librebooted machine with ME Cleaner. (See Intel ME/AMD PSP)
The pixel is still a product of Google that Google benefits from when you purchase it. Some if us want to avoid contributing to their power as much as we can. Not purchasing a Pixel one of those choices.
Android needs to be replaced as well. I still hold hope for mobile Linux.
Google doesn’t own the PC market.
I usually buy a refurbished Pixel a generation or so behind the current. At least it doesn’t directly support Google. Not perfect, but it’s what I can afford.
I understand that logic. But it’s the very fact of even owning something that they produced is enough for me to reject it. if for nothing more than I don’t want people seeing that i use a pixel phone because then, I benefit Google by acting as free advertising for their devices. Is my view extreme? Maybe, but i really hate the tech oligarchs. They have ruined so much in this world.
How would anyone know? They don’t have broadcasts that say “This is a Pixel”. No racist, but all phones look alike to me. I can’t tell one from another, especially in a case.
Oh no I’m not saying I like the situation, I’m just saying its currently the only good option if you want something that works this instant.
I love the idea of desktop Linux in my pocket, I daily drove an OG Pine Phone for a year. After a year for daily driving a Cosmo communicator.
The support just isn’t there and I really really wish it was. I honestly think the federal government needs to step in and fund FLOSS development, but lmao good luck, they don’t even pay for cancer treatments.
You mean Chromebooks vomit emoji
Yeah same, they also choose to drop support for phones as soon as official support drops which is a bit dumb (most firmware are feature complete and don’t have security issue, on the other hand not delivering OS updates with security fixes is definitly dangerous).
I much prefer the philosophy of LineageOS: you don’t want to throw away your 10 years old phone? Just put the latest android version on it and go on!!
Those people have been fooling themselves. It has been clear for quite a while that the partnership would apply to “flagship” phones for now. That’s corporate code for: “phones that are unnecessarily expensive and chock-full with tech that most people don’t need, but buy anyway in order to (unsucessfully) impress others”.
My god
Lil group project
I know the Signature is supposed to be their ‘ultra flagship’, but 2 grand?
The worst thing is that I’d even be half interested it it wasn’t this expensive…
I dont exactly have a problem spending $2000 on something, but $2000 for a phone is just stupid.
I guess you could say that about a lot of things; cars, etc.
But just on principle. That phone is not costing 4x more to make, and is not giving me 4x the value as a $500 phone. Or, fuck, give me 10x the value of the $200 phone I have right now that does absolutely everything I want (I guess a better camera would be nice).
All this stuff about the memory crisis; I don’t think phones suddenly cost 4x more to make and if they do, how about don’t put fucking 16GB of RAM in phones?
I can see 16GB phones being useful, but there needs to be cheaper options
The only use I can see for them is gaming and there are better devices for that, for less money.
Running your own LLM models is another one I guess, but I don’t think there’s many people doing that.
Some of us enjoy mobile gaming
But if you had the choice between playing on a phone and playing on a Steam Deck/ROG Ally/MSI thing would you still stick to your phone?
Yes :) because firstly I can carry my phone in my pocket everywhere and secondly it’s nice to not have Yet Another Device.
I’d pay 2 grand for a car if it was running
I would maybe consider spending $2000 on a phone if it was functionally as usable as a laptop. Which Android is not.
Apple could totally make their new phones work with MacOS as they’ve shown with the MacBook Neo, when connected to a monitor, but they won’t.
It would be pretty amazing if they did though.
I think a powerful Linux phone plus a laptop chassis that connects to the phone somehow and turns it into a laptop would be really nice
The company that made the Nexdock is planning to make a phone. It will be Android but it can bring up a full Linux desktop that can access the Android storage. I am considering getting it and only using Android for calls, texts, and a couple apps while I install phosh UI in the distro and focus on using that.
nexphone.com
yeah the issue with these is cooling, that’s why neo turned whole chassis into a heatsink, so I’m a bit sceptical based on the quick showcase video they show on the webpage.
The iPhone run power intensive games, would macos really be much worse than that?
Im sure OEMs could figure it out.
I do not have $2000 so I would mind spending that much on anything
I have an expensive phone. It’s a Fold 6 - I got it after using a Fold 3 for 4 years, and replacing it when the outer screen of all things stopped working, and the trade-kn on my old phone was still worth like $1,200 towards the new one even with a broken screen.
I used to get a new-model mid-range phone every year or 2. Now when I buy I go for the previous year’s flagship and use it for a longer period. Financially it’s probably a wash, though I know I could absolutely be spending less and be just fine.
But it’s the piece of personal tech I interact with the most and for that I’m able to afford it, so I’m willing to spend the money.
What is this obsession with cramming 5+ cameras into phones
Some of us like to take photos. I have an S24 ultra and I regularly use all of the cameras.
Same with my Pixel 8 Pro. Macro, wide angle, astrophotography mode, night sight - I use them all.
Its like they say, every great photographer can be attributed to their use of 5 cameras
A great photographer will have different lenses for different subjects. They will carry it around in a large bag. Many do in fact own multiple cameras too.
The most famous photographers who produce iconic work often master one kit.
Mastery of a tool doesnt come from constantly changing out gear. Theres a space for multiple kits but the point is to have less gear and spend more time shooting and mastering the craft.
If you lean on gear diversity then youre just sacrificing skill development, and thus. Its a skill issue.
Newsflash: The average person using their phone to take photos shoots different things and at different distances because they do it for enjoyment when the opportunity presents, rather than trying to perfect anything. There are people taking thousands of photos a year on phones, who do not purposefully master or practice anything. It’s not a competition, they’re not trying to get their photo shared across the entire world.
A modern smartphone allows you to have those different lenses available in seconds. It doesn’t detract from your time shooting, nor do you have to lug around extra gear, or spend extra for yet another multi-thousand euro lens.
I do wonder, however, which photographer will have one cheap lens for shooting portraits, sports events, wild animals and mountain ranges. Is that even possible?
2 have different optical zooms, one is wide angle, and one is “normal” and can take macro photos. On any given day I use all of em. The differences in photo quality and detail captured is very real.
A jack of all trades is a master of none.
I have literally bought a car once for less than this.
(Used and pretty old, but still, a whole fucking car).
Your car will also outlive any phone by decades…
This is $3000 CAD. I’ve bought a car for less than half that price.
There’s no reason for a phone to be that expensive. Laptops are cheaper and they do more wtaf
I can get a decent laptop, a phone and a nice diner for 2 for less than that.
Yeah no, even the 300-350€ (don’t remember it exactly anymore) I spent on my Pixel 9a were overpriced to me, I don’t even need half of the storage, RAM and CPU speed in here. We really need way less capable but equally as secure phones, who the fuck needs that much computing power to browse websites and write on Signal?
This is kinda surprising to me. I constantly feel limited by the 8GB ram in my Pixel. I thought it would be a noticeable upgrade from my previous 6GB but it honestly barely is. Apps are killed in the background immediately after leaving them and tabs are very quickly unloaded. Even with nothing open, I typically only have <2 free gigs. Everything is very bloated these days to the point where it’s fairly common for even websites to consume several hundred megabytes of RAM on their own. Might be fine for some but I don’t see myself buying anything with less than 16GB in the future if I can avoid it.
CPU power is much less of a big deal, but Google tensor is kind of anemic and it shows. My phone struggles to even compute cloudflare security checks sometimes and apps take a pretty long time to install. Thermal management and efficiency/battery drain is downright terrible. Video calls absolutely kill the battery.
I don’t personally have a need for a ton of storage on a phone, but I can understand why people would if they’re torrenting or have local media, etc.
That said, I don’t really want to spend this amount of money on anything less than perfect. This thing is way too large for me physically and it probably won’t be very repairable either. Currently debating whether to buy a pixel 9 or 10 pro now vs wait for a cheaper moto option.
For me I’ve never noticed these issues on my Pixel 9a, but I really only use it for basic stuff. Still, you are kinda right, I definitely feel like Android, even GrapheneOS, is super inefficient compared to my 8GB ThinkPad with my own Arch-based disto on it, the 8GB there definitely “feel like more” compared to my Pixel. Battery life is fantastic tho, I usually plug it in over night with 80% left, rarely 60% at most when I used it a bunch during the day.
(slightly off on a tagent but relevent)
i mean at this point, i feel like phones are just hostile, and computers are the last bastion of freedom in the digital world. run linux, connect to phone hotspot then you are free to use whatever encrypted programs you want, bypassing “client side scanning” or whatever bullshit they want to implement. like… from how i see it, google will eventually kill the bootloader unlock from pixels, and the vast majority of phones, even if bootloader unlockable, does not have relocking with custom keys and also lineage is kinda insecure (at least thats that seems to be the internet consensus), even if it might be more private.
Phone should just be a “modem/router” thing, your gateway to the internet, the actual stuff should just be done on a portable computer. Australia already started a whitelisting thing for phone, its only a matter of time.
This is mostly how I’ve been using my smartphone and tablet for years when it comes to computing (still use the smartphone as an actual phone) - when I’m out and about the smartphone is just a hotspot for when I have no free WiFi and I do most stuff on the tablet.
The problem is that there are very few Linux tablets and they’re all on the large size (10"+) hence you can’t just carry them in your back pocket or coat pocket.
So that means Android tablets, which means you’re still running Google’s eavesdropping OS.
Further, more and more companies and even official institutions now push you to use their apps in Android. Just recently my bank decided to scrap their perfectly sane and secure secondary authentication mechanism (which was literally a plastic card with lots of codes and thus pretty much not hackable and whose weaknesses were entirelly known and consistent for all users) for mandatory installation of their Android banking app on people’s smartphones to use (I! Kid! You! Not!) the phone’s fingerprint and facial-recognition systems (thus being exposed to the weaknesses of who knows how many different HW and SW combinations).
Yeah sure, and how on earth does a regular Joe using their banking app when out of home then?
Lol, I mean banks already require KYC and have your real identity on record so you could just use it on your phone running the official corporate-built mobile os, I mean my point is, you aren’t even supposed to use VPN for online banking cuz they’ll just flag your connection, that connection is supposed to look as “normie” as possible (hence why it kinda breaks with graphene os). I’m talking about activities that you were previously using GrapheneOS/Custom ROMs for, like the stuff you want privacy for.
1900 euros for 512 gb with no sd card slot. 24-bit/192kHz audio support, but no headphone jack. Why even bother?
I really hope the next generation of Moto G gets graphene support. Somehow their low end phones end up with more useful features than the flagships.
Goddammit, and here I was hoping I could finally get a phone with a Snapdragon for decent emulation. As much as I love Graphene, I may try out something like LineageOS for my next phone.
Welp. So much for that. Fairphone it is.
Me too! FairPhone gang RISE UP! 🤝🏾
If I didn’t need an iPhone for my company. Fairphone is what I’d use.
That’s the one reason it actually makes sense to carry two phones. Go get the Fairphone. It can’t hurt. ;)
L M F A O
Jesus fucking Christ is it made of gold??
Not entirely.
Lol. These corporations have lost their fucking minds.
How about two middle class cameras instead of 5 high-end, for a price point of 800 €…
I mean, is this on purpose, so they can say “nobody wanted it” ?
F*ck me, 2000 dollars?! I really wanted to give this a go, but def not for that amount of money
i’m not sure what is justified but presuming they aren’t making money selling your info then they have to make up that cost elsewhere.
I understand privacy and good data governance has a price, and i am willing to pay quite a price for a good product. But 2000 is quite a lot
There is no phone on earth that should cost 2000 fucking dollars
GrapheneOS reigns surpreme. We should all use it. But I am not buying a phone for €2000. Count me out.
Oof. I was excited for this, but I think I’m just going to go with a Fairphone with /e/OS at that price point. I don’t think I need the ultra high levels of privacy GrapheneOS has, I just want to get out of the invasive Google/Samsung ecosystem.
It’s pretty funny that your alternative is a phone and operating system that GrapheneOS has spent years trying to bully out of the market.
Well they ain’t bullying out shit from me with their 2k phone lmao.
Hear! Hear! I was excited about the prospect of a Razr with Graphene, but then I saw the news about both costs (and also that foldables just kinda suck in terms of longevity). I was kind of between a Nothing 4a Pro and the Fairphone 6+ with /e/OS. I’m sold on the latter. The Nothing has a cool design, but it’s still pretty locked-in on Android and a bunch of AI crap (even though it seems minuscule and optional). The idea of a completely repairable phone appeals to me. Plus I can print a clear plastic back cover for the thing to re-live the glory days of my clear teal and purple Motorola pager.
Yeah, the Nothing Phone looks cool as hell, but… that’s basically all it has going for it lol. The AI features were also an ick move, just the fact they decided to go in that direction was enough to scare me away, since that was one of the things I’m looking to escape from with my current Google/Samsung phone (piss off, Bixby). I especially found it ironic given the Nothing Phone’s whole minimalist design philosophy.
Tbf I think they’re basically taking fairly generic algorithmic models for photo editing and voice-to-text and slapping the “AI” moniker on them for marketing/funding purposes. I played with a 4a Pro at Best Buy the other day and the “AI” seemed about par for the course with what my iPhone 16 has (I’ve not updated to iOS27). The option to add Gemini and stuff was there, of course, but the “essentials” stuff was basic.
The Glyph is cool. But not enough to get me on board. It just felt like I was given a veneer of something different but once you get past NothingOS it’s really just Google all the way down.
This is where I’m at honestly. I figured it would be expensive, but that’s jumping the shark imo
Signature is their pro max. Just wait for a new “edge” with GrapheneOS support.
Not justifying the price, its stupid expensive. But please don’t act like this will be the only Motorola with GrapheneOS support.
Uh it must be a whole lot more than their pro max because the IPhone 18 pro max was only $1,300
Oof.
That’s about how much my Framework Desktop cost. I think I’ll stick with my Pixel Fold.
Just use your pc as your phone. Luggables are coming back in style, baby!
I used my Nexus 7 as my phone for a year or so in high school, so it wouldn’t even be that unusual. A large briefcase and ups when mobile…
I mean… I did buy the carrying handle… 🤔
Wow, this is really disappointing. I’ve been waiting for this to upgrade my older phone and finally get on GrapheneOS without using a Pixel. This is just straight up unaffordable for a large majority of the population. Shame on Motorola and Lenovo for this price point. Did you even try to read the room? Maybe someone will release a cheaper GrapheneOS phone next year. I’m sick of waiting for something reasonable to show up.
What phone are you currently using?
The plans with Motorola are going further than this model, from what I understood future cheaper models will start supporting GrapheneOS too. They just started with the flagship and will probably start working downwards until it wouldn’t be economically feasible to have all the necessary security features incorporated in the phone.
True hardware costs in 2026 without residuals from advertisers
That’s the device’s cost, no matter if you install GOS on it or not.
Fuckin’ ouch. I don’t know if I can justify this 😂
I want Graphene* with decent periscope zoom … that isn’t Google. But ouch. Tho I do get that it doesn’t get any subsidies from preinstalled bloatspyware.
(*well, I want a Linux phone with 10× zoom camera, but I might as well wish for a dragon)
Oh, just Graphene compatible, my bad (I think this isn’t even the fist time I forgot that, ffs).
Do phone makers get subsidies to ship their hardware with Android preinstalled ? I didn’t know that
Not for Android directly (tho very encouraged via monopoly bcs Google gets all your data via playservices + profits via playstore), but for other proprietary spyshit (eg preinstalled Facebook app, sometimes users can’t even uninstall the app, unless they fiddle with adb) & additionally in cases of megacorps manufacturers get further revenue from users via their own telemetry shit (eg Samsung collects data from your environment that Google misses & sells it to data brokers).
(Why else would a random company preinstall so much third party shit? Ofc they don’t do it for free. And everyone is interested in spyphone quantity bcs more users means more data. Much like gaming consoles & printers are kinda subsidized/can sell at a manufacturing loss.)
So sellers of hardware without for-profit stores & no further revenue streams from spying on you have to charge users clients all the cost upfront on the sticker price.
(Not to be confused with the fact that spy-free phones don’t have such economies of scale as eg Samsung so their costs per unit are noticeably higher bcs of that too.)
For phones like these, which are primarily going to be used by nerds, tech enthusiasts and tinkerers, this is poor launch strategy from Motorola.
Most of the audience for something like this will be turned off by this and all the hype they generated will fizzle out a bit.
They should have started with a mid range launch first, get enthusiasts to rave about it and then upsell these extravagant features to less involved consumers.
Yep, I’m someone who was very excited to try but now that price can’t be justified. I’d rather just not even have a mobile phone or go with a ‘dumb’ phone for emergencies once the time comes for an upgrade.
Ehh.
Best way to get over the idea of being a cheap brand is sell something for a high price that people actually buy, and on top of that hopefully rave about it.
I use to have used a lot of Motorola phones in my life with the last being a Moto G. Amazing phones. Features like chop flashlight and double tap to turn of screen were game changers. The speed and graphics were on par with what I needed. Great phones.
But do I as a consumer see Motorola as a “flagship” phone. If you gave me unlimited money to buy a phone would I go out and have gotten the top of the line Motorola over my S25+? It could possibly be comparable to the S25 Ultra. I don’t even know why I would need an S25 Ultra. But I don’t know what the top of the line Motorola phone is or was at that time.
This could change that. And that is what they need because they do make great phones in my experience.
I am not denying that having a flagship is good for Motorola or that something they can’t pull off.
It’s just that the GrapheneOS phone seemed like it was for the tinkering XDA forums custom ROM users. And not many of them drop so much money on a phone. 1500+ phones are for people who want their phone to be a status symbol.
Motorola isn’t a status symbol yet, like it was during Razr days. I doubt people who can actually afford this care about GrapheneOS or want to worry about a hundred things that come with non standard OS.
Yeah, fuck this. I’ll happily stay on my Pixel 8 Pro until 2032.
Yah… Thats too much, if they cut that in half I would ignore it not being up to the repairability standards of fairphone, but if I cant expect that device to last 10 years then ill just wait for the next one…
that cost more than my car lmfao pass
can’t wait to see this thing flop and sell 99% android only to rich fucks who don’t care, and then Motorola say “oops look like Graphene sucks, ending partnership bye”
I really hope that the Graphene developers pointed out to Motorola that this price point would not sell that well to their community, so that it would be expected. From what I understood, there are already plans to support lower models in the future too.
there goes my ability or desire to have one. see ya.
CAD$2,983. Yeah, no thanks.
Absolutely not
Any chance we get a Lite or an “a” series of this phone? Or a more affordable Motorola that meets GrapheneOS’ strict hardware requirements?
Based on my understanding, yes. There will be more affordable models later, they’re supposed to have a full line-up.
But for now, the affordable GOS phone is still a Pixel.
Id rather get a 2nd desktop tower.
You’ll need a lot more than 2000 for that.
You could definitely get a tower for that price…without the RAM! XD
Huh, only about 4 bucks? Why is it so cheap?
I’ve always been a fan of Motorola - my current phone is the Edge plus and is 3 years old. Had to replace the battery but otherwise a solid phone. My phone budget has been as high as $500 but will never exceed that. 2k for a phone in this economy is beyond unacceptable. Its moronic. Still a phone and nothing special - just incremental improvements. I dont see this selling.
1,900 Euro equals 2,117.10 United States Dollar
Disappointing.
What’s the best way to get a new, unlocked pixel (any supported version) for < $500 without needing to have a new contract with a carrier?
Just keep an eye on slickdeals? Wait till a new version comes out and look for sales on the old version?
Honestly i’d just get a renewed pixel 8
Lol. That username. Jeezus.
If in the states, micro center carries refurbished models under 500.
I got mine used from best buy, lots of used phones with low mileage
Used market if thats an option locally?
Why does it need to be new? I’ve been buying second hand for a while with warranty and it’s been great.
Just buy used
The 9a/10a models should be around that price new. You’ll have an easier time finding something refurbished or used though.
I got a used pixel 8a on ebay for $200, dont need sales or carriers. Im sure you can find used newer models for cheap online
Still some space back there for a few more cameras.
Lmao that is such a joke
Well … guess I’m still going to be stuck with used older pixels. There’s no way in hell I’m spending 1900€ for a goddamn phone.
Freedom and moral improvement?
Charge them an unreasonable price.
A jail you carry around?
Affordable time!
I’m still fine with my Motorola phone.
Not paying more than €700 for anything with a bump that big.
A phone that is >10mm thick in 2026 for €1400-1900?
No SD card slot?
No 3.5mm port?
Fuck off ahaha, what are we even paying for?!
This was already reported. Expensive flagships will release first, with more affordable devices to follow. Motorola already makes some of the best budget devices.
The fact that a phone costs that much is still completely heinous and sets the bar WAY too fucking high.
Or it tells you how much the hardware costs without the manufacturer offsetting the price with the level of data collection and ads they can sell from it?
Or, more realistically, Motorola doesn’t move a ton of volume compared to Google, Samsung, or Apple so i imagine they aren’t getting amazing bulk pricing on high end parts for this
I believe this is logical. Most realistically feelings>logic on lemmy. Probably some poor ass who feels threatened
And how do you finance the high and long lasting firmware maintenance required by Graphene OS, to stay secure? Is there any anouncement even suggesting that in a reasonable timeline or are you merely engaging in wishful thinking. I’d be surprised if they ever went below midrange with a GrapheneOS device.
This first step in the collaboration is not about long lasting firmware maintenance, it’s about getting device manufacturer and software developer to talk with each other at all.
Financing security stuff is easy, you cut parts and features until simple and secure parts remain, then you don’t update the hardware and do long term quality control, bug fixing and pen tests.
Plus mass production.
The way you DONT do it, is price yourself out of all demographics that care about it being a different OS. “High-end don’t care” is covered by Apple.
That’s not how Android and AOSP work though and that is the foundation for both, firmware and GrapheneOS. You already have a disadvantage from moving away from the source, which is Google, so that even increases the effort react very rapidly to make up for that. All of that is not cheap.
I would assume you don’t need to go crazy expensive like with that phone now but to see that happening in the budget segment, where they probably invest next to nothing in software and security, just to get by, is naive.
If Graphene is reading this: You just lost me and my family. Will look for other options. Woo hang on to the Pixels till we can’t.
Well I don’t think Graphene OS devs chose the price of the phone lol. This is just the Motorola phone that has the hardware Graphene requires. Like a security chip. Give it a few years and this phone will be on the used market for 400$.
I find hard toiImagine GOS went into a deal without clearly defining the parameters of the partnership, which in my silly mind assume it to include the specifications of the hardware, desired price point, amongst the many many other things.
Also an $800 phone would be $150 on the used market in the same few years.
Meanwhile there are some dudes from the West running around factories in China right now getting a custom phone built to their specifications. And somewhere between the two extremes lie a multitude of outcomes that would have been far better than this one.
I’d like to hear GOS official rationale to this one.
Well you realize there are two sides to a partnership right? Motorola is a for profit company. They want to make money. They’re not gonna subsidize our security. Graphene likely will support their cheaper phones in the future, but part of the deal was this phone being first I’m sure.
We’ll have to wait and see…
Not speaking to the viability of GOS’s opinion of Motorola’s pricing on this having any effect or their options for influencing that price, but I do think you are giving the GOS devs far more credit than I have ever seen them earn when it comes to business savvy.
As much as I support the projects mission and their willingness to call a spade a spade, the people that run the project would get eaten alive in an actual board room discussing things like gross revenue and per component margins. Which is where these kinds of decisions are made.
It makes sense to me that the first phone to get updated hardware that GOS requires, would be the flagship. I suspect cheaper phones will get the same - perhaps not the cheapest ones, but probably the G series at least.
Well, about 5 or 6 more years at most then. Google reduced the Pixel’s security so Graphene devs deemed the 11 not good enough.
And if you don’t care about security as much, there are multiple other ROMs to consider that you could run on MUCH cheaper phones, don’t need a flagship at all, just something with an open bootloader and a community.
Don’t blame Graphene for Motorola’s hardware.
“Prices never go down, they only go up.”
-Every company today
Makes sense the next gen of phones will all be the same. Rams to expensive
That’s pretty ridiculous. For some it might be still a great option, staying clear of Google hardware and true hardened security for jobs where you need it. But they really plan to sell it as if it were made from gold.
Yea I can see it being mostly bought by companies (or drug lords) but for normal persons I don’t think many can justify the price…
I think rather of journalists, dissidents who can afford it etc.
Yep, I’ve been saying this. They are now slowly putting GOS out of reach for many. Pixels are slowly being locked down by Google to where GOS won’t be able to be installed on newer models, so the only option left will be these ridiculously priced Motorola’s or old Pixels that won’t be supported much longer. Really makes you wonder what is truly going on with GOS now.
Not many years from now the every man just won’t be able to afford a decent phone.
Can’t say I would be opposed to going back to land lines. You wanna call me? Wait till I’m home.
Sure they will, just sign on this dotted line and you’ll pay monthly. Give us your previous $1.5k phone and we will give you credits on your bill every month, but that credit will disappear if you change anything about your plan or want a new phone.
Oh wait.
Actually, with resources getting scarce, we should already get comfortable with the idea that a phone should be expensive, and be repairable enough to last for many years!
Sheesh, glad I didn’t wait until it got out and just a bought a pixel 10
Which color you got
The black one
That’s nice. I have the blue one
Same but bought a refurbished Pixel 9 Pro XL
I’ll just wait for it to fail, then possibly buy it refurbished or if the price drops dramatically.
How can they even justify the price? Samsung’s flagship “only” costs 1750€ and even Apple is lower at 1850€, and that’s assuming the 1900€ price is for the 512GB variant and not the 256GB where Samsung and Apple would be even cheaper (1550, 1600). Are they really thinking people will choose them over the most popular brands when they are more expensive and less established?
Damn…I didn’t realize phones had gotten so expensive. Curious how much they’re worth after 1 year. Anybody know how much the buyback is for a 1-year old Apple/Samsung flagship?
About tree fiddy
Motorola has made some really good phones, over the years.
I recently ordered a Pixel 10a. Wasn’t too sure about about the future with Motorola phones in terms of GrapheneOS. With that price tag, it looks like a better decision for now…
If it costs that much, it better come with at least 10 years of updates. And I guarantee it won’t.
Nothing can justify that price. They’re just charging that because they think they can.
I agree. It’s absolutely ridiculous.
They say it will get “up to” 7 years of security updates, so 10 years is already out.
Hell, even 7 years is 50/50. “Up to” is slimy salesman speak for “usually less than”
Where is it getting 1900 euros from? I’m seeing news saying it’s priced at 1600 USD which is around 1400 euros, not 1900.
m.gsmarena.com/motorola_signature_27_5g-14955.php
Obviously still a steep price but thats 500 euros different.
Outside of price point, this is the first time I think I’ve seen a phone have 7000 mah battery. Thats like tablet levels of battery life which is kinda insane.
…
That seems to have been an error, Germany also gets 7000mAh according to other news outlets that said the same thing and then corrected themselves in an edit.
I’m disappointed that it will not SHIP WITH Graphene, but at least it will be a VERY HIGH END phone for privacy-minded people who are also very irresponsible with their money. It’s something, but it’s not what I was hoping to learn.
Well if you do flash it yourself you are sure that no one tampered with the install though. Instead of it shipping with it preinstalled
They aren’t shipped with GrapheneOS because the developers of GrapheneOS explicitly don’t want this. They dont want any possibility of some backdoor caused by the manufacturer to bring down their reputation.
It not being shipped with GrapheneOS is on purpose.
That could be. I just imagined a person being able to just outright BUY the graphene device, and thought that would be a world I’d like to live in. (Not for two grand though)
I’m glad the last phone I got was the Pixel 10 Pro XL. Guess I’ll do the full 7 years of GOS updates then.
Same here with the 9 Pro XL, got it refurbished couple months ago, my previous Motorola phone was starting to give up and I just couldn’t wait anymore. I’m glad I didn’t wait.
I had to buy a Pixel 10 recently for hedging the fact the Motorola may be too expensive and not live up to the hype. So far I’m glad I’ve gotten it, but here to hoping they sell enough to keep making them and I can pick one up on the used market.
Same here, bought a Pixel 9 Pro XL couple months ago because I just couldn’t wait any longer. Glad I did.
Glad I bought a pixel 10 pro XL about a month ago… Seems like I can hold it out as long as possible hopefully… Hopefully this will bite motarola and show this is stupidity.
Dafuq.
I didn’t know that for the sake of my privacy I have to spend such a sum of money, like it costs almost like an iPhone or a normal computer, it’s just crazy😱😱😱
A normal iPhone is less than half that price.
You can still use GrapheneOS on a a Pixel.
making the Google pixel MSRP seem like a good deal LMAO
I’m fine with my Pixel 10
Pixel 10 gang ✊✊✊
It’d be cool to get the ThinkPhone with Graphene.
Sigh, I guess I’m interested based on the brand and the OS. But that’s hard to swallow. I really want this sort of product. I guess they have to make up for all the kickbacks they won’t be getting from the bloatware that will no longer be there.
That’s the phone price irrelevant of what OS it has. Graphene team said cheaper compatible models are coming.
How did we get to a point where a phone is so important? I want the $59 flip phone. Shove you Cr’apps where the sun don’t shine. 2k to be spammed in three ways, fuck it.
How could we not get to this point? Personal computing has been transforming the world for decades and the inevitable point of that was always having one in our pockets.
The pricing is stupid, but that we got here with phones is not. It’s a personal computer with a radio in it.
That’s how my linux phone was. Never did I think I would be doing overseas classes in Japan on a phone with mouse. [Ignore all the other issues in this situation]
I really hope that the Pixel 12’s will be supported again by GrapheneOS or a cheaper option will be made by Motorola. Otherwise I will have to keep my Pixel 10 with Graphene alive forever (?). I do not expect there to be a real second-hand market for this Device to get your hand on one for cheap.
There is still hope for the 11 series. It all comes down whether MTE support will be confirmed or not. I expect we will have an answer in a couple months.
Check out LineageOS as well, the phone compatibility is way bigger (you may not have the security hardening of GrapheneOS but you will also have a much longer support).
You cannot relock the bootloader with LineageOS and that causes problems with some apps.
Looks like I better hope the year of the Linux phone arrives before I need to replace my current phone, unless this is followed up by announcing some more budget friendly lines that also meet GrapheneOS’ minimum requirements.
The GrapheneOS developers have been publicly saying that there are plans to support lower tier models in the future.
I guess I’ll upgrade to a Pixel 8 Pro instead
I have one with Graphene OS and I would recommend it. Only downside is the battery life which isn’t great. With screen on I can only get 4-5 hours of battery life. I’ve gotten used to carrying a power bank with it when I will be using it heavily.
So basically not an upgrade from my Pixel 6 Pro then. Irritating that Google/GrapheneOS abandons phones that work perfectly fine since that’s the only reason I’m even considering an upgrade.
Let me guess.because of the RAM crisis.
It’s €1400 in other EU countries.
That’s my next 7 phone budget.
Welp, I’ve waited a long time for this phone. They have lost their shit if they think we’re gonna buy this. They are NOT Apple! Looks like I’m getting a FairPhone 6+ instead.
freedom just got a pricetag… and it’s effin’ steep
It’s not even really freedom because it still struggles to run normal Linux programs
in context of Android phone it is freedom. Linux phones are whole 'nother game altogether
In 2012 I built a PC that could play Skyrim on Ultra settings for $1200. That includes the cost of the monitor and peripherals.
How much is it with standard android? How can we do a comparison?
Installing Graphene took me exactly 3 clicks and 20 minutes on a pixel. What a joke, 200€ for that.
[deleted]
1700 with standard
So privacy costs 200 euro
just one more camera bro, they will pay more than for a pc, trust be bro
[deleted]
Ah yes, unrepairable overpriced slop in collaboration with toxic narcissist nerds.
Dont’t know why you are downvoted, the toxicity of GrapheneOS main maintainer is very documented (harassing resellers of GrapheneOS which is something totally legal, attacking Louis Rossman which is actually a support of Graphene, etc.).
Many resellers are honeypots from the government that implemented backdoors. That’s why.
Maybe someone thought I was talking about users of graphene and then the herd-effect came in.
It looks like it wants to bite me
Motorola Spider
Bubble buhhrsssttt
I’ll give you $200
The back looks ugly. Why so many stupid lenses? A phone should have no more than two.
Normal, telephoto/zoom, wide-angle, led flash. Not sure what the last one is.
Used Pixel with Graphene or Fairphone with e
Maybe they will have some insane incentives with the providers?
And wasn’t one or more coming with Graphene?
Is support getting dropped for pixel phones?
No, but Google is showing more and more stubborness with their future Pixels so GrapheneOS wants to make sure that they have an alternative manufacturer. The Pixel 11 series is still not supported by Graphene due to it not have MTE support yet.
I just buy previous gen Google Pixel. And only if I need a phone… I got a Pixel 9 brand new in December 2025 for 441€ including fast charger (as a gift). Sold by Amazon.es
I thought people were complaining about the price but then I realized it isn’t even a folding phone!? Wtf is this media package too, the photos of this thing are like, bad?
2020 I got a phone from Motorola, it cost about 100 Dollar … It was perfect for more than three Years, but than someone stole it
[deleted]
In the middle of the ram and storage problems you expect tech to some out cheaper?
Actually mostly seriously yes. It’s not the consumers fault we’re getting gangbanged, to no benefit as well, the fuck are we just accepting another shaft like ‘well there is no alternative so I’ll take it and say thank you’.
Companies: “who could have predicted that scarcity that we created would have caused price gouging? oh won’t somebody please think of the customers!” hitting ‘post’ and then bathing in their profits
If you want a low volume phone in the middle of the RAM and storage prices this is what it costs if its still around in a couple years it’ll cost less.
The price is inline with Librems Liberty phone
Yeah? At this price I’ll just not buy this new phone and keep my old, cheaper to produce, phone. The consumer/buyer doesn’t have to care why it’s expensive, they have to decide if the price is acceptable or not. Motorola could have chosen cheaper components and made a phone that’s worse, but also cheaper. That would have likely have been a phone I’d buy but instead they made a flagship that costs 1900€.
At this price It’s just not worth it for me.
no worries, every motorola gets a 3x price at start to milk the idiots
I’m ready to bargain so that the motorola would sell me this freak with the ugly Graphene system. start with $200 and downgrade
Wow!
Just look at that Big, Beautiful Bill Pedophile Price Tag!
So many of you are being so irrational and ungrateful. Do you know how much work the Graphene team likely did to make this happen? This means Graphene is less dependent on Google hardware in order to exist (ie, if Google decides to lock bootloaders in future Pixel models it won’t end the project). An expensive high-end phone brings along rich people and corporate users who will hopefully donate to the project. The engineers at the Graphene project work so much and it would be nice to see more appreciation.
No one is being forced to buy this highest end model. There are plenty of Pixels they support and will continue to support and they likely they will support other models that will be much cheaper over time. If you don’t want to buy a $2K phone, don’t buy this model. Problem solved! Or wait for more people to be selling this phone used and buy a used version of this model. Also, having this much RAM means that it’s more likely this can run virtualized ARM operating systems and can work like a desktop when plugged in, although I am not sure if it can do that.
Bootlick some more. Nobody is grateful and nor should anyone ever be “grateful” to a corporation.
I’m not bootlicking anything. I have no relationship with the Graphene project and the only time I tried to find out more about the project I was quickly banned for some reason. I think being pissed at open source developers who give away software for free is crazy as fuck.
Fuck off. Calling people ungrateful because they wanted an alternative to spyware shit and then get presented with this device that is so far outside a reasonable price for a phone. I’m sure you’re just waiting to jump in when people don’t buy it, as you’ve suggested, and then there are no additional models produced with some snarky comments about there being no demand.
No you fuck off!
But yes, your point that the wrong price point may create the illusion of no demand for privacy, hurting the ability to make lower cost non-spyware devices, is a good point. I simply hadn’t thought of that and only saw later comments about that idea.
So, a security OS, but people are letting a third party install it so security is as good as any other option.
There’s nothing stopping you from flashing the firmware as soon as you get it.
I don’t think this comment gets enough attention. This is exactly the problem here. You can’t trust any company not to compromise the security on their product.
The issue is its not true. The phone just supports GrapheneOS, it doesn’t come with it, you still have to do that