According to Huffman, Reddit has grown to the point where personalization is increasingly necessary to help users find relevant communities and discussions.
More lies from Spez.
The change could also benefit Reddit’s advertising business by allowing it to serve more personalized ads
Yesterday I browsed “/r/all” for the first time in like 3 or more years (I stopped using reddit altogether a long time ago). Holy shit I felt like my brain would melt, there was so much ragebait and misinformation that asks for primal engagement. The links I opened that seemed interesting lead to nowhere and the comments were so fucking dumb. Despite all that I kept scrolling looking for that sweet hit, I must have spent at least an hour of my time that I threw away. Thank God I jumped ship when I saw the direction it was heading.
Same. I went to reddit yesterday and it of course served me racist trash.
There are two subs for Sweden, one with 300k subscribers for normal people, and one with like 60k subscribers for terminally online fascists. The latter gets 10x exposure on the frontpage.
The only account left that I have there was porn subscriptions only. I scrolled through it recently: It tries to make me mad about some political bull shit in-between all the NSFW. Really strange 🧐
It’s not entirely wrong, in that Reddit is so full of bots and junk that a sizeable chunk of the site is unusable. Any animal photo subreddit often has more bots than a farm.
It’s either personalise or have the deluge.
Coincidentally, Reddit has just announced plans to shutter their RSS feeds, so if you were using those to personalise your feed, good luck.
It does not, but you can block/unsubscribe from communities that have too many of them on the main feed, or block particular users from showing up, which can help with the repeats. That otherwise takes more logic on RSS, and isn’t really possible on the website.
that will not stop botting at all, bots already can make accounts very easily because they dont care how much gets banned if they can create more, they can automate it. but normal users cant do that, because they will get banned very quickly. what spez saying is a lie anyways.
also reddits have shown to preference not to filter out most propaganda botting anyways.
most users are lurking because they dont want to have account ban.
Pushing people into echo chambers isn’t even needed because people do that themselves. If you’re gonna profile people, autosubscribe all the libs to r/guns and all the conservatives to r/gender theory. At best people will learn something; at worst we’ll get a show.
Reddit continues to be the biggest hurdle to Lemmy’s growth; the average person doesn’t care about how much private companies profit off of their personal data, so convincing them to leave the vastly bigger platform for Lemmy is a challenge.
Completely ignoring Reddit and its potential user migration opportunities would be dooming the Threadiverse to not gaining any new users from the most likely place those users would be.
Just remember Lemmy is only part of a larger network called the Fediverse. If you find you don’t really like it, there are other alternatives like Mbin and PieFed. They’re all pretty good I think, but Mbin is probably my personal favorite. There are also custom lemmy interfaces like old.lemmy.world, as well as lots of different mobile clients.
All the different instances and platforms can tall talk to each other, so you can subscribe to communities you like from any of them, as long as they are connected (aka federated). So somebody on kbin.earth (an Mbin instance) could subscribe to !micromobility@lemmy.world (a community on a Lemmy instance) and post there, browse, etc. even though they’re different websites.
You can sign up for any instance you want and if you hate them all, you can even make your very own.
I’ll share I pretty much only signed up for lemmy.world because I looked up which one had the most users (not that it seems to matter with all the crossover).
I wonder if there’s another instance I’d like more!
I made accounts on a few different ones to check them all out but I started in kbin.social while it was still a thing (the admin had some health issues I heard, hope he’s doing ok). Kbin was the predecessor to Mbin, which got picked up by some other devs thankfully.
Kbin.social was my first too, Ernest was a king and I hope he’s doing well and thriving in life.
Made a handful of alts when it became clear kbin was going away. Ended up using .zip as my main as I like their hands-off approach to moderating/defederation. We’re federated with everyone except malicious/criminal instances by default. If you don’t want to see things you need to block them yourself which I like a lot.
More features and I just prefer the aesthetic of the interface. I use Interstellar on Android but I would describe the mobile interface as very usable so the app isn’t really necessary.
i came from a ban, at the time i remember lemmy was remember during the API crisis, then i just made account, on instance, when it got shut down i went to another instance.
The advantage lemmy has is that unlike reddit, you can easily make a community of the same name, just on a different server in the case of mod disagreements.
Its MUCH harder to powertrip on lemmy, both because the mod tools are ass, and spinning a new community isnt hard.
Didn’t like tenforward have tHe Exodus drama with some mod?
The problem with that rule at Reddit, is that it only exists for the mods, not the users.
So the misbehaving user will pick fights in a sub A, get banned, whine about it in another sub B talking shit of sub A, get banned as well for brigading. Then they go to a 3rd sub C and now actually brigades against subs A and B because their mods invent bullshit rules such as “brigading”.
The unaware users look at this mess and get confused because they can’t recall “brigading” being something forbidden by the general Reddit rules. And while “brigading” is just mod slang for “you shouldn’t incite fights between subs or users” (and anyone can figure it out by searching the word at Google, instead of whining that the mods just like to invent words), there is no rule against this either. Instead there is only a rule for the mods that they have to shut down any user attheir subs who do this.
The consequence is that the unaware users sympathize with the misbehaving one and join their brigade, even if just to taunt the mods into banning them as well. I’ve seen this a lot of times there.
Much harder to powertrip you say? Have you looked in the modlogs and see how moderators ban users in multiple instances that is unrelated to the original instance? It’s very reddit like.
The fact you can look at the mod logs is already something you cant even compare to when using reddit. Youd be suprised how far reddit mods will go.
The ban is also not worth as much as like i mentioned, communities are spread. There isnt always one version of a community of the same name, whereas clones of subreddits on reddit have an insignificant fraction of the traffic compared to a main one.
When a moderator comes in and starts to affect a lot of people, it can cause a mass exodus to a sister community. That doesnt happen really on reddit, because the people left on reddit are slow to change their habits (the fact that most dont use alternatives shows so). The people who use lemmy have generally had the mindset that if you need to switch, then they will do so.
In your first paragraph you hint at shadowbanning.
You can’t even shadowban people at all on Lemmy (as far as I know), while it’s a go-to for unethical Reddit moderators; nothing can be done to stop them and most people don’t even know it exists.
I was shadowbanned from /r/tampa because I asked them to implement removal reasons (a feature that’s existed on Reddit and takes five or ten minutes to set up). That upset /u/md28usmc and he shadowbanned me for it. Asking why I was shadowbanned led to them perma-banning me.
You got a point… What i meant to say is whoever is maintaining the migration of content to lemmy. Hope they put some effort into advertising Lemmy as a viable alternative.
Hi, I’m part of the Community Team for Lemmy.World. We help with finding moderators, make sure communities are kept up, and make sure moderators follow the site rules.
To some extent mods are mods. There will always be people who disagree, vehemently, and some people who resent any rules or moderation at all.
I mention this because there are a couple things I’ve tried to do on our instance to address Reddit mistakes. First, I try to avoid having several large communities under the same mods. The mod who holds a grudge in !trees shouldn’t be able to ban you from !science. (Assuming those are both large communities).
This can be difficult, because you’d be surprised at how few extremely active people are willing to moderate even a tiny community.
The other is that instead of putting out advertisements to recruit for mods, I try to draft mods. So our mods are not limited to those who seek out the position.
As a long time Reddit mod and new Lemmy.World mod, I do lament the lack of many helpful features I’m used to, but I’m glad for:
The significantly reduced likelihood of a moderator going rogue (because a rival community can pop up in its place with the same name and do a better job and the admins here are much more responsive and transparent)
Public-facing mod logs (see previous point)
One of the big reasons I’m even here is /r/tampa’s moderators went off the deep end, quietly shadowbanning people they didn’t like, banning anyone who talked about it, and lying about doing both.
If I were to do something similar with /c/tampa, I trust an admin would remove me and/or someone would start whatever.instance/c/tampa. On Reddit, running /r/FreeTampa (because you can’t just have another /r/tampa), I have to be very careful about talking about why the subreddit even exists or we get slapped for brigading; Reddit is staunchly against anyone constructively criticizing subreddits/moderators.
I have to be very careful about talking about why the subreddit even exists or we get slapped for brigading; Reddit is staunchly against anyone constructively criticizing subreddits/moderators.
the reddit mods of the large subs should not be one on here, because many of them are powermods(they have hordes large accounts under thier belt, plus i heard many of those are in cahoots with the admins of reddit.
what lemmy needs is the niche subs. also indian subs are pretty much taking over reddit, solely because of the sheer number of people in india, apparently they dont have a sole “social media” platform of thier own. and i heard this is drama with india subs, solely because of the BJP bots.
same, they only started appearing on reddit after musk/trump was "deciding to " limit h1b visa last year it was getting more attention than it should. reddit is likely going to be an “indian only reddit” mostly because they have the sheer number of people using it, more than most other countries combined.
Good! Finally the last holdover users will reconsider open source alternatives
LOOOOLOLOL brother, I want some of what you’re smoking because I want to exist in this reality where people are fleeing Reddit rather than flocking to it. This only affects logged-out visitors, not so much “users”. Most platforms have been this way for a long time and seen no such decline either. Pretty much the entire internet is already account-gated.
It mostly affects people who use Reddit to search people discussing stuff. Unfortunately I don’t think the Fediverse is indexed much, plus some niche communities/interests just doesn’t have the critical mass.
Maybe ads have two messages in such a scenario. One advertisement for human viewing and another hidden function with prompt injection, prompt leaking or other function for AI bots. Ah, glorious dystopia…
you see here, bots/AI bots are less useful than you think, it actually detracts from the traffic. because bots dont produce useful traffic to the site at all( they dont post meaningful comments/posts) that AI can scrape.
thats why Open AI/and google stop referencing them in thier “AI slop generators” this forced reddit to make Old reddit inaccesible to lurkers, and now they are forcing log ins. the NEW UI is a horrid feature, even for people who “likes to use REDDIT”.
the sources of bots come from propaganda farms like russian troll farms israeli bot farms, apparently India has thier own bot farms targeted at indian Subs. I suspect the majority of the sub will probably cater to india eventually, because they have 1bn+people who likely wil uses reddit.
the other source is the lowest hanging fruit that reddit filters out, the single users with hundreds of account whos pam on the site.
Well, except for the (apparently) vast swathes of long-time users who get permabanned for bullshit reasons (or no given reason at all) and then can’t make a new account because of “ban evasion.” I guess they just aren’t allowed to experience Reddit at all, even lurking.
I got banned for ban evasion recently. I do have two old accounts, but neither were banned before so idk why lol.
Their website is so shit that I can’t even ask why. The auto mod sent me a DM and says if I want further info to reply to that message, but I have to accept the message request. Which I can’t do because I’m banned.
the reason is that, permban has caused many to just lurk on the site instead. even the ones that still have accts are afraid to login. they want people to login, but htier AI moderation/filters are still yay high. plus its not even stopping most bots / AI botting anyways, they can just create a single use account, post and move onto the next thing.
This is a good point. You lose existing users through attrition. How do you attract new subscribers to a site they cannot see?
They could leave the front top 50 posts of the day available as an attractor. With a “sign up to see more” banner at the end of the scroll. Is current leadership smart enough to do that?
reddit already lost to attrition, which is why they want people login. first the purges came last year, reduced overall traffics and users, but not botters, then AI stop using reddit as a datamine, because its not useful if all your content is also AI generated.
They went with the assumption that as Google buys their data and replaces their links in search queue with LLM gen answers, their organic traffic from searches would get reduced into nothingness, so they can push their login requirement with little drawbacks. They increase price of each ad via personalization in a short run, but without a drag of the likes of Instagram, Discord, Whatsapp etc there would hardly be new users to create content.
maybe they shouldnt do massive purges after the eleciton, and at musks request twice last year, that definitely had an effect users whos has been caught in the crossfire. not only the AI filters ban people on politics, but everyone else using the site, basically they only need a small inkling of “botting” to even ban you.
Sad thing ad networks will perceive it to be better since they better tie tracking between networks and thus better impressions. Don’t matter to me though I just recently gone the next step of filtering Readit out of my search results and have never been happier.
DDG, kagi, searxng, and likely many other engines allow you to hide the domain from results. I use DDG and there you have the ‘3 dots’ button to the right where you can block the site for good.
Surveillance capitalism follows the same rules as capitalism; do whatever is most profitable. The deception/manipulation/propaganda algos are 10-1000x more valuable when they’re able to target you as an individual; across all accounts, space, and time. The users hardest to swindle, who already gave a shit about privacy/anonymity, have already left.
Most advertising on reddit is guerrilla marketing, and reddit either runs their own bots or explicitly enables them to inflate activity and engagement.
Don’t worry, they have all the data on that, and I’m pretty sure they thought of it.
Fact is that most visits from search engines don’t go very deep anyway. They are allowing a brief glimpse at one page before they start prompting you to log in, and that is likely driving logins while barely shortening those SEO visits, which are not of great value in the first place.
It may come as a surprise but websites often have traffic they don’t want. I recall once my boss noticed there was a non-negligible amount of traffic from parts of the world none of our advertisers care about. He built an endless revolving door of promo offers and directed this traffic into it. It didn’t generate much money but it made the rest of our traffic look higher quality right away.
I gave up on reddit when they banned 3rd-party API access. I use Boost for Lemmy so it looks like reddit minus the karma whores, bots, and general shittiness.
I suppose some reddit users might find the distributed nature of the fediverse too complicated, but honestly I’m not sure if those folks would be much of a benefit to us here.
I got permanently banned for reposting the Alex Peretti shooting to bring awareness to it, reddit was constantly removing posts that day. I had my account for 17 years. Then they also banned my alt account that I had for 16 years because of “ban avoidance” - the digital fingerprint they had for me was tied to both accounts apparently.
onbording through apps is good enough that users might not even notice a difference, the main hurdle is understanding the interconnectivity of instances and them actually leaving their jail
i think people will use old reddit on logging in, until reddit removes it. and then people will use reskinning extensions to make it old reddit before reddit finally somehow restricts that too.
I guess I kind of understand why companies want you to be logged in to engage with their platform, as the user metrics are the main selling point to advertisers, but man do I really fucking hate it when a platform forces me to log in by preventing me from using their website. So much so, that I haven’t made an account on Instagram or X or Facebook or whatever dumb social media platform specifically because I can’t browse without signing up. Well, that, and also the greed, the lack of privacy, the tacit endorsement of fascism, et. cetera.
No, I don’t want to make an account.
No, I don’t want to download your app.
No, I don’t want to turn on notifications.
Gah, fuck off with all this horseshit. The internet used to be fun. Now everything is a chore and nobody does anything unless they feel like they can make a profit off of it.
Obviously I think reddit is trash, but I can kind of understand other forums requiring a login (several of the small, private communities I’m a part of require them) but there is no good reason to push people to an app other than avarice.
It’s extra frustrating because I created cosmetic filters for uBlock Origin that allow me to access individual Reddit posts (so I can still read Reddit posts that I find through a search engine) but not any of the feeds so that I can’t waste time scrolling. I can’t use those on the app.
I don’t have a problem with someone making a website for logged in users only. What sucks is making this open anonymous forum that was quite good for years and then locking it down once people are addicted to it. Well, this doesn’t change much for me i deleted my reddit years ago and haven’t been back at all.
also the new UI for reddits very cumbersome, and very intrsuive and not very intuitive to use. you can use extensions to remove the ugly sidebars with random stuff on it, but now you are left with 2 giant empty white spaces in between the doom scroll feed.
only way they can even do this is how much users they already have and how entrenched those users are. Its insane how much people are willing to put up with to keep using the shitty services, just because they have used them for long time.
they apparently lost alot of actual users enough for reddit to become desperate to force logins. i think thats why Facebook did it too, gotta keep those boomers/genxers using it for thier right wing slop. certain health groups(describing thier own diseases) are sitll on fb, but i would not touch it.
i saw a graph somewhere the recent traffic drop was from open AI not scraping anymore.
With all due respect to you and the user above as people, fuck the defeatist attitudes. We’re going to make and keep this little part of the Internet fun, no matter what corporations say. I’ve had a great 3.5 years on Lemmy despite the occasional dramatic event. And I’m counting on myself and every one of us to continue to make it so.
Entropy is also inevitable, but that doesn’t mean we can’t keep a small space of less entropy than average while we’re here.
A similar fate will befall Lemmy at some point, so enjoy it while you can.
press x to doubt.
Seriously, there’s a low chance for that.
lemmy is not a service but an open source software
public lemmy services are ran like a “public service”, for the benefit of the public. an instance cannot just lock down its access to users without exiting the federation. and if it exits the federation, it will become worthless basically, as they’ll lose all the external content. yes lemmy.ml and lemmy.world are too big, which is a problem, but I don’t think they could pull it off easily either.
lemmy developers are loudly marxist, they oppose capitalism. so both the software itself, and the lemmy.ml instance are unlikely to change in the way you tell
I remain utterly discombobulated that 90% of redditors haven’t already migrated here. What exactly are they waiting for? Lemmy clearly is more than good enough already.
That’s kind of why I like Lemmy better. Rarely do I see reposted content. At one point I had a spreadsheet where I would log how many times I saw the exact same post on TIL or YSK.
Never thought this would be a badge of honour but I’m also proud I wiped my comments and deleted my account before they inevitably banned me for posting a 🍉 or something.
There were a few small subreddits I hung on for. Just a few niche communities that flew below the radar and avoided some of the bots and other enshitification. But when they forced logon for old reddit. I was done. I’ve been so happy here on Lemmy. I reminds me of how fun reddit used to be.
I would’ve seen their point maybe a couple years ago, but I can’t remember the last time I got to the bottom of the all feed here. And sister, I can scrrrroll. Like I start to grow mushrooms and I’m pretty sure my cat partially melds with me.
I also mod a couple communities on another account. Turns out if you just post things you’re interested eventually other people will join in and then you can just sit back and enjoy.
Yes! Hopefully with Lemmy being a bit more bustling now, the reddit users who are turned off by the login requirement will be more likely to stick around.
Yeah, people like you are changing it to something more palatable. And I’m seeing increases in different users posting/commenting more often rather than just the power users. Idk if it’s crossed the threshold for increasing usability yet, but I’m hopeful for it for the first time since I was new here that it’s slowly becoming better.
Joined Lemmy about a month ago after 17 years of using Reddit. Account was deleted. A once very great haven for open discussion has turned into one of censorship inundated with bots to push propaganda. The writing was on the wall in 2015 and while its demise started slowly the rate enshitification grew.
What I don’t understand is given it’s inundated with bots posting/commenting to direct the narrative, what is the point of creating more obstacles for the common person to be duped. You’d think they’d want to keep it easy access to spread their “message”.
Control and tracking is the reason, and selling that data.
Those “obstacles” are there for profit, and probably some censorship. If the user says something they don’t like, they’re easier to ban or have the algorithm not show the post.
Yeah I feel like with lemmy you could just move to a smaller network/graph of federated servers. Actually I think some splintering of the fediverse would be a good thing if its numbers keep trending up.
Also the fediverse is crazy cheap to access. Like I’ve got a $8/mo CAD server running a dozen websites and a snac2 instance and it doesn’t choke even a bit.
Yeah, and I will say it’s definitely better for posting than I expected. I kinda was expecting very little response, and I think that the small community vibes help people feel comfortable replying to OC posts. That said, there are some things it’s missing (notably to me at least is a sapphic oriented nudes space). But ultimately yeah it’s good and improving, and I do recommend people who’ve been considering posting there give it a try.
Network effect. The communities and discussions are still there. Lemmy has the infrastructure, mostly, but not the users and not the discussions at least not in anywhere near the same volume.
There’s also a few seriously missing features with Lemmy, for example modmail.
I have also found, overall, as stupid and crazy as this may be, when discussing anything involving politics users on Lemmy can be almost militantly closed-minded. I find more intelligent discussions on Lemmy, but I also find more of the ‘you either agree with me or you’re everything that’s wrong with the world’ type.
I have mixed feelings on mod logs personally. They’re great when the mods aren’t trustworthy and nothing is controversial. But I think they leave mod teams vulnerable to coordinated attack, which absolutely will happen if lemmy gets big enough. The mod logs played a (small) role in my decision not to take on mod roles or start communities here.
Mod mail on the other hand is a great tool for communication with basically no downsides
The average redditor doesn’t care about any of this in my experience, they’ll just take all the crap because that’s what they see on all of the internet anyway
I share a bunch of links here from time to time and Lemmy needs communities and content. It is not an insurmountable scenario, because Reddit was also much smaller at the time of the Digg exodus. Lemmy and similar sites in the Fediverse have improved since a few years ago, back when the only topic of conversation was beans and the site ran very slowly.
Is Piefed better? I don’t like how duplicates aren’t combined on Lemmy.
Either you don’t think about which instance to join, and inadvertently join a conservative one. Or you do think about which instance, and it’s daunting.
its the lack of content actually. the last instance that got shut down had way more content than now, because people dont stick to one place and grow them, they just go to ever smaller and smaller communities.
It’s hard to get used to the slower speed of these newer sites. I prefer it, but it took time to prefer it. You get so used to the speed of the giant networks and the emotions it triggers so frequently that the slower pace of smaller networks leaves you in withdrawal. This was why I didn’t use BlueSky as much as I used to use Twitter, but I’ve been starting to enjoy the slower pace of all of these services. I actually have more free time now because the tap runs dry and i log out for the day. I’ve been on the Internet since I was 11, back in 2001, and I’ve had to really wrack my brain to remember what it used to be like. Forums simply didn’t update at the speed sites do today, and I didn’t mind it.
Same. Got banned for using a single word (actually forgot what it haha), and deleted my account. Now that it’s becoming login only, it’s even better to kick my habit.
Platform. I appealed but they weren’t having it. Reddit doesn’t like people causing others of being nazi and colonial fucks.
In one comment I called spez a nazi fuck. He removed that too.
Dude was talking about how the Brits were actually really good for their colonies (how they brought culture and infrastructure there) and how the bengal famine was actually because of the locals themselves.
London was apparently a benevolent european power.
I’ve been straight up IP banned and have only been allowed to lurk till this change fully booted me off. Every time I make a new account it is autobanned before I can get a couple comments off.
At least redlib still works, but once thats done so am i.
Yeah same here, I haven’t had an account for ages now, but I do still occasionally take a look. But first they did the “new reddit” thing, then the API thing so all the apps stopped working, then VPN blocking and now this will (presumably) kill redlib as well. I’m kind of done having to find all these workarounds just to look at a site that obviously doesn’t want me going there and is becoming increasingly worthless anyway. Oh well.
they have been thwarting peoples attempt to be active users for the last year, and now they want them to login. they thought the ones they dint banned were enough to scrape from with AI.
Generally I’m all for things like this, but I don’t want there to be workarounds and backdoors to prolong reddit’s life.
It want the acceleration towards its death to increase. I don’t want people to be able to enjoy it so that the spell of the addiction (one I was guilty of) can be broken.
I think we can all do our part by blocking the website from our search results. Let it just hemorrhage and die with its bot network and shitty people.
Until you find or create a replacement that is easier to use than Reddit/Lemmy/PieFed and appeals to the same gigantic audiences as well as serve heroic amounts of web traffic as much as reddit serves each hour of each day without lag or latency, it will never die within your lifetime.
You could have said the exact same thing about Digg or MySpace 15 years ago.
Reddit is difficult to replace, but not nearly as difficult as you imply. Serving a lot of web traffic with low latency is a well documented and solved problem. And a competitor does not go from zero to 100 million users over night, they have plenty of time to scale. Countless companies have accomplished this.
Reddit is, by and large, an extremely basic concept. It’s a link sharing site with comment trees. Undergrads could spin up a similar website in a week, albeit less scalable. But again, there is plenty of time to figure out the scaling issue.
I think you may have misunderstood what I’m saying: you can’t kill reddit. You can only try to atrophy their users with better sites that only attract their niche audiences, including their shitty users as well.
I don’t want curated posts only of my interest. I love /all for the scrolls. It’s a sad shell of what it used to be with leadership that wishes they were Elon.
Not completely, it works on old reddit. For now. I think they said they’ll be phasing out old reddit so that will stop being an option sooner or later. Probably sooner.
We like to keep if tidy. Please take off your shoes at the login screen and close any country gates behind you. Pick up your litter and tell us a dirty joke.
Sorry, I mistakenly thought this was a platform where divergent opinions can coexist. I’m going to go back to perpetually lurking now so that hopefully the mob will forget about me.
Do we know what percentage of visits are from not logged in visitors? I imagine that all the people that visit reddit through searches for information are not likely to be signing up for a account, so they will be losing a bunch of that traffic and ad revenue.
Putting all that community generated information behind a login screen is a massive loss even if you don’t use the site regularly.
Hell, I feel like the scraping problem still won’t be solved either since I can immediately see a repost/archive site being made that just mirrors reddit using account bots.
Host it in a country that doesn’t recognize US corporate law, and you’ve got an instant in to a massive userbase.
They are going to end up burning the whole thing to the ground in a bid to make investors money on something that never had hard quantifiable monetary value to begin with in a way that you could easily turn up the dial on “line go up” enshitification like Google can with ad impressions.
Its a fancy web forum, a big popular one for sure, but there are God knows how many similar options out there already competing for users. There is a very low ceiling on just how profitable it could ever be as a business all on its own.
There is a reason a lot of these websites, like Gamespot for example, ended up consolidating into holding companies that own a bunch of them.
I stopped using reddit primarily when the 3rd party API blocking started. I had been browsing anonymously to lurk a few different communities for a bit after that, but I often left just being annoyed how much a waste of time it always was. I haven’t been back since the blocked old reddit for anyone not logged in. Can’t say my life is any worse without it.
i use an extension to reskin it as old, but it has it flaws, but more useful than the new UI. i think someone made in response to the old reddit getting canned recently.
Almost certain, although I wonder how far back the tos, or when would the tos have changed, to “give” the data to reddit, and whether it would be admissible in court. I believe many tos which have been accepted online have been thrown out in courts. I may be wrong of course, IANAL.
Have you noticed the news being watered down too? Like I’m seeing some real news here and there mixed with way more stupid fluff pieces in r /news the past year or 2.
Unfortunately I give a shit because I don’t want to have to resort to using an LLM to get an answer to the many obscure questions I have that are rarely answered anywhere else.
I think LLMs are a great tool for searching through lots of information. I just think their monopolization and monolithical mass adoption is bad. The people who run them are bad. The scale at which they do it is bad. The dangers are very real and bad.
But they’re great at sifting through and collating information. Private ones are great. The tech is awesome. The current implementation is problematic. Like we got nuclear energy and atom bombs at the same time. This is that.
It's funny, way back in the mists of history Reddit's original plan was very similar to the Fediverse's. They opened the source for their servers and had plans for how it could interoperate with other independent "reddits".
now its just infinite doomscrolling like tiktok, facebook. and the new reddits UI is so terrible even people “who defends using it” are not happy. there is extensions to remove the sidebars of it.
No matter how I look at it, this will only hurt their user base. Where are they going to get new users? I’m no tech billionaire, but I struggle to see how this benefits the site in the long term. Even if they revert later, the damage will already be done and the site will lose any relevance it once may have had.
I’m not interested in Reddit per se, just curious why they’d think this is a good idea.
The thing with reddit, and why it used to be so much better than other corporate media, is that they’ve always under-monetized their users. Facebook and such earned at least an order of magnitude more per user.
If reddit loses half of its user base and doesn’t gain a single user, but 10x’s their revenue per user, well, they’re still making 5x more money.
They are probably betting on Google still displaying reddit at the top of every search so that normies keep coming in. They seem to have ignored that Google searches now just give you a stitched answer of bullshit Gemini put together so that normies don’t ever click on reddit links.
This is the image of corporations shooting themselves in the foot while passing the same gun around 🤣
Unfortunately that’s not how it works. Once you have a sufficiently large userbase, the network effects are enough to sustain them. A ton of people use facebook still and that has been a logged-in experience forever. Same with instagram.
Userbase doesn’t matter this much this days. What matters is raw data, the best data the better. Random people from the internet bring shitty data, data of logged in users is better.
And if the userbase drops, they can add more bots, who cares, line goes up.
yep, they’ve been turning up the dial for some time now …slowly implementing anti-mobile browsing nags and locking down content by classification. And good on them, nothing will ruin their run faster than their own enshittification efforts.
I feel like reddit will eventually become like Facebook in that only lame people will still use it, but it will be a big enough percentage that it’s going to be unavoidable in a very annoying way.
It’s annoying, because so much of the Internet is linked through Reddit. If I’m not constantly seeing these links, I can just pretend it doesn’t exist. Instead, I’m peppered with links to the Walled Garden, fully knowing I’m not allowed inside
for someone reason i was using new reddit on mobile , instead of using old reddit for a while. until the nagging got really annoying until 2 months ago where i switched to using old reddit redirect and sink it extension to make it usable on mobile. now that is gone too, but im using a reskin extension.
Indian content is a growing prescence on reddit now, likely it will just be mostly indians in the end, since india have sucha large population compared to most countries.
They recently had a mod event where they announced they are restricting ban abilities from mods. Basically AI can ban, mods can choose to unban - but not initiate a ban in the first place.
There are a couple mods I like to hate-watch, once a month or so I swing by and see what kind of BS they have been doing lately. The schadenfreude of watching them mald over this was the best I’ve had all year.
dint know this news, im not surprise. probably came out at the same time they announced there will be AI dominated mods, who will “police” AI-subs. probably realized that overbanning has caused them to lose many users/ and now there are more lurkers than not. at the same time, reddit doesnt want to give up thier ai moderation and filtering.
Yeah this is all second hand from an announcement about something that is “going to happen”. So details might differ from what actually shows up.
And yes I think mod abuse is starting to show up in their bottom line. They need people commenting so they target ads more effectively, same reason they killed r/All. They need to know stuff about you so they can send ads.
Mods being the toxic assholes they are is driving people to lurk, as you stated.
the bannings by reddits own filteriing/AI is causing people to lurk, old reddit makes the site legible. the new UI, even if you use extension to remove some of the features is still horrible to use.
Vast majority of ‘old redditors’ still believe reddit is their home. Its not, there are so many more normies on reddit now, that it is legitimately a normie space. And making it a walled garden is the only way Reddit Inc can grow.
the nice subs are there, but i feel liek theres less traffic tot hose area now, and filled potential spammers solely because people got banned and dont want to log in anymore.
i bounced at the cookie consent dialogue of the linked post. 1751 partners and no umbrella reject, fuck off 🤣
i would not mind reddit becoming life in only if it didn’t feed and feed on ai on the side, ie. if it became a truly human discussion (again). it’s that their plan?
“We’re making the change because it’s better for user experience, better for our ads business, is more in line with safety regulations, and more protective of Reddit data,” he explained.
According to Huffman, Reddit has grown to the point where personalization is increasingly necessary to help users find relevant communities and discussions.
In short- we can’t datamine you if you’re not logged in, we can’t build a behavioral profile on people without accounts, we lick the boots of governments that’ll demand ID checks age verification, and it makes it harder for AI bots to scrape the site without paying us. Really there’s no downside to anyone at all, it’s a win-win. Oh it’s bad for users and bad for the Internet? Is that important? Those groups don’t pay us, right?
To be fair, Reddit has been Zombie Reddit for about 5 years now.
When they received $150 million from Tencent in 2018, the writing was on the wall. You cannot accept that kind of money and keep to the original aspiration. The IPO just accelerated it.
The amount of slop on there nowadays is wild! Even the smallest communities are being overrun with it and they don’t give a damn because it is good for business short term.
According to FediDB there has been a 1.7% growth this month. Meaning 244,051 new accounts have been created on fediverse on the past 30days. Almost 250thousand people in a month. I’m sure this is completely coincidental
they will get rid of old reddit of logged in users eventually, also they put a 6 month requirement to be able to use old reddit. new accounts have no chance.
i am using an extension that basically reskin new reddit as the old one, but it has some kinks to work out though.
classic reddit layout, its reskin, but it might not format the pages correctly, im messing with the options right now. on mobile, theres no way to get rid of the sidebar(the one with the sub rules on it)
What you do here: writing reactions. The discussions are not what I’m used to on Reddit and Slashdot back in the days. It’s probably that the userbase is small. It is what is is and I’m glad that forums like Lemmy exist and I hope they start gaining traction. On the other hand, now I’m back writing content for AI, so is that a win?
started with trumps 1st term, and magically when the gop was threatening the social media for “harm against children” shtick, reddit ban all the subs that were “illicit”.
then came the massive amount of russian bots around 2018, thats when they started banning people for inneundos.
It’s been fucked since the leadup to the 2016 murican election. Wasn’t perfect by any means before that, obviously already had paid shills and astroturfing, but that seems to be when everyone realized how much you could use it to influence people. Really kicked into high gear then
Typical “product owner/manager” mentality to show percentages of engagement growth or whatever stupid KPI they came up with. And those shitheads are the most incompetent and the most high off AI. I just hope enshittification will be complete some day and everything will be brown and smelly (just like those Claude UIs).
Fediverse severs have a bit of a natural size limit, which means site-level moderation is easier. Admins also aren’t motivated by ad impressions or vanity metrics that impress investors, so there’s that, too.
It doesn’t remove bad actors, of course, and there will be no lack of bad admins, but it’s still more friction than exists on corporate sits.
It took me 4 months to wean off from when I first registered to Lemmy to when I made my final goodbye post on Reddit. It’s a transition, everyone can do it on their own time and pace.
when they remove old reddit from lurkers, i started to click on the subs less, because i had to use a reskin extension, and that isnt exactly a 1:1 replcation of old reddit.
Yes. Old.reddit was a lifeline, but it was inevitable the current direction would lead to it’s death.
Speaking of “Old” reddit. I recall there was a thread once where a “famous” redditor managed to game the system and take a thread through it’s natural evolution entirely by themselves. It reached pretty high in /r/all. It looked like this:
Asked a question. Kept replying to it with genuine answers and arguments. Went on tangents, hijacked portions of it, even firing up Godwin’s Law. This person created replies and sub arguments entirely solo. It was basically a entire self-generated thread exposing every direction a viral reddit post could go; I think the redditor was protesting upcoming changes.
Well, I think they’re thinking that AI bots can’t see the page because they can’t log in and it’ll protect open source information from being obfuscated by Ai. In reality though, it just forces inconvenience for the humans.
to google actually, they are paying 60mil this year just to access it. its not a coincidence that google started limiting accounts per phone recently. they want people logged in so they can browser fingerprint people, thier time zones, their devices, thier scrolling and clicking on certain pages, and how long they stay on one page,etc. and they also use this method to ban people too.
Reddit is trying to make sure their results don’t end up being Google Zeroed to the AI Overview of Google. They have a partnership with Google so if they’re not getting organic traffic on their site, they’re losing money and I’m on team reddit can fuck themselves. By doing the log in only they’re trying to curb the ai results on google just showing the answers right away without any traffic to reddit.
So we’re turning towards a culture of you will have to degrade yourself 20x harder/be a full time influencer or hire a full time influencer/media clown, to get traffic.
-How Google Zero Impacts Website Visibility
The rise of Google Zero has changed the way people visit websites online. More zero-click searches and Google’s answers mean that many people do not even go to other sites. This leads to a clear drop in the number of people who click on organic search results. The owners of websites need to deal with problems like flaws or weak spots in code execution. These issues make it even harder for them to get their sites seen.
To keep up with these changes, you must learn what Google now looks for. Use what you learn to fight against lost traffic. This is how you stay important and keep people coming to your site. Being aware of flaws and issues in code execution will help your site work better and help your site show up when people search on Google.
-Decline in Organic Traffic
Organic traffic is now falling for many, especially in the United States. This drop is mostly because more people get what they need from Google’s zero-click searches. In the past, a blog or a business could get a lot of visits from Google, but that has changed. Now, fewer people are coming to their websites. The rise of AI and new ways to search have made this problem even bigger.
Advertisers also face problems. Fewer people leave the search results and visit their websites. For example, an air-purifier review blog lost a lot of its views. That happened because bigger companies take up the top spots and get picked for those search snippets.
To handle this, businesses can try to find new ways to get traffic. They could share their message in niche communities, start a podcast, or focus on getting leads from referrals. This helps them not have to count only on Google’s organic traffic, and it can keep their numbers up even as things change with AI, search, and new tech.
as if it stops AI bots or scraping, especially if reddit is just selling the data upfront to google or openai. plus you can just make accounts in large numbers to counter the login.
They are really saying" we need the lurkers to use an account and start making content, so we can use ai to scrape from it"
Thts nice. Reddit has become a blocked at the router experience. I’ve started blocking a lot of this shitty aggregation of tech garbage. I really need to take the time to limit google more. Most will never see the reason for doing so but for me its quite satisfying to click and link and have it throw up a generic block landing page. I stripped my landing page down to the bare essentials if I ever have need of unblocking a link. Reddit, reddit gets no consideration at all.
I use PfSense with PFblockerNG. I created custom lists of differnt ASN’s with a few tweaks here and there. It breaks a few things out there but as far as I’m concerned they can all pound sand. If a site breaks because of some integration with tech giants than it isn’t anything I have to have.
hey, yesterday I got a three day ban in a topic about Indiana Jones punching Nazis. I said, we could need some movies again where a hero punches right wing extremists. It was flagged as call to violence :D
I joined Matrix today, It’s been 4-5 hours, I’ve seen multiple other users joining aswell, asking for what client is the best one or how to do X. For sure a lil exodus is happening.
I still use Reddit from time to time (without an account) because a lot of sports subs aren’t really prevalent here. But looks like that’s gonna go bye bye.
Make your own! I started !micromobility@lemmy.world because there wasn’t one and now it’s got thousands of subscribers and is more active than r/micromobility (which died activity-wise right around the time of the API fiasco, surely a coincidence).
I created dboft.com (lemmy server) to try to recreate my reddit feed. They were requiring their mobile app... and thats a no go for me. BTW, I didn't recreate my reddit feed... but I like whatever this community better.
thats the reason they are forcing logins, they lost too many to attrition bans, they arnt generating any useful data for ai to scrape. with INdia becoming increasingly common on the site, i dont they will be much useful for manipulation opinions in other countries.
To anybody who needs to use reddit (for answer to some weird question someone posted few years ago) and they are blocked by “sign in to continue”. Ublock origin works pretty well. I have fennec (fireflox clone) with ublock. Someone told me use the zapper of ublock when that pops up, it has worked for me well.
I was testing just now to see if it works and I haven’t got that pop-up. It is possible ublock has already leveled up or I just didn’t use reddit for long enough. It was without logging in.
This is an opportunity for Lemmy and the community.
We must be more free and decentralized.
NO to impositions and opposition to freedom of expression! I’ve just joined Lemmy after REDFASCISTS banned me, also my country -Türkiye- is going to start ID verification to use social platforms that’s another why I migrated to Lemmy.
Freedom in speech,
Freedom in decision!
Let’s ask DuckDuckGo, Brave and other privacy-centric search engines to index Fediverse contents at the top of pages how Kagi has option to search them via a dedicated button.
People are still being routed to Reddit and other enshittificated trash platforms because of search results. At least privacy based SE must route here and Fediverse networks!
For those of you who are interested and still want to go on Reddit for any reason, Redlib still works… kind of. My personal instance running Nachtalb’s fork still works, but not sure for how long
There are still a small shortlist of public instances that are up, and ppl are pushing fixes that circumvent whatever shenanigans Reddit is pulling. Although, some folks are suspecting that Reddit SWEs are monitoring the redlib project with close attention & trying to shut down any workarounds the redlib team finds
On mobile you can still use RedReader to browse reddit anonymously.
I had an old reddit account from before they required an email address. After I commented about the Chinese genocide of the Uyghurs, a hacker used failed login attempts to flag my account, which triggered reddit to demand an email address. I took that as my cue to leave the site altogether.
I deleted my reddit account back in 2023 after the API changes.
I run my own redlib instance to read stuff about some niche interests, but once that stops working i’ll stop that too. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
some folks are suspecting that Reddit SWEs are monitoring the redlib project with close attention & trying to shut down any workarounds the redlib team finds
Reddit was already a shell of itself before AI. I stuck around too long because I didn’t quite like Lemmy when I tried during the API exodus. I eventually left when they started forcing logins. By that time I hadn’t realized just how much the community had degraded till I came here.
It’s like I forgot what online discourse felt like before corporate tentacles strangled reddit. Even the stupid arguments make more sense, and that seems impossible.
True. For me, the quality there pretty much degraded around 2015-6 or at least that was when i started to notice the increase of bot use and such, but some would say it was even before that when one of its founder died. Even after that period it was still tolerable compared to what we have now.
Reddit was already gaining a lot of clout as a public platform. Around that time was when Bannon leveraged reddit influence to drive the Bernie bros and incels to Trump.
I’m guessing that’s when the world stage really took notice of reddit as a tool for political influence.
Yea I do remember the donald, they weren’t really incel though, just a political sub if i am not wrong. Incels had their own subs as well that got purged at the time along with many ones as well. What was good about Reddit back then was that the platform allowed freedom to a large extent, didn’t bother as long as it wasn’t something in your face that violated the rules, either that, or they didn’t care back then.
that was the time when trump won the first term, and putin realized reddit among others was a goldmine for his troll bots. and thats when the banning started.
spez wants it to be a AI datamine, turns out when you ban so many people, it causes them to lurk, so its only propaganda bots, and AI generated content. Also its mostly filled with indian subs too , because the amount of people in india potentially surpasses that of the US, by sheer population numbers, and its not useful to have only indians, since the "continent’ doesnt really affect the US in terms of news, sports, celebrity in that country.
basically this made OPEN AI AND google see reddit as less useful to scrape.
This also points out the problem with using AI in the long term. Reddit’s basically become a micro model of what happens when LLMs start scraping LLM content for content. Fucking tech bros who believe they’re prophets somehow couldn’t have foreseen this.
As crazy as it may sound, Reddit is a treasure trove of information, especially when it comes to niche technology stuff. Would be a shame for them to lock it all behind accounts, and in my case age verification.
yes that is true, i had to make a new account for the first time in 1year+since getting shadowbanned(apparently they lift or stop noticing for non-serial banned people. i had to ask niche questions recently.
That’s sad to see. I’ve been on Reddit since 2011 but my account was banned a few years ago for reasons that were not given (literally said nothing in the ban message so idk what happened) and every appeal has been struck down. Meanwhile it gets filled with garbage spam accounts, AI, just all sorts of crap. It was such a good community back in the day and now it’s just terrible.
After all the dumb changes to reddit and surveillance in general I decided to try and look for an alternative, If I knew it was this easy to get into lemmy I would’ve done it SO much sooner. Also i think this is my first day here? And every time I posted something I got a TON of responses, like I could argue even more attention than I would get on reddit, also the responses were better? Like what? How? There’s way less users here… Just imagine if Lemmy grew just a bit more, doesn’t need to beat reddit at all, just to grow a bit more (with good users ofc) That would be insane, Im having way more fun here already, the community is so much better, the only thing im missing/haven’t found yet, is those r4r reddit-like forums where you get to meet people to dm and stuff
By the time I left reddit I couldn’t remember the last time I had a conversation there. I started a personal rule on reddit where if the top comment was “It’s almost as if…” I would just close the tab and move on.
Whatever followed would be the laziest brain rot. And people voted it to the top.
I use a handful of reddits, usually a few of those lewd ones for like hooking over over voice chat and stuff, kinda fun for that ig, but like as you said, most people there are kinda dumb, most conversations I have there are bland, boring, and end in a day or two at most with ghosting. (met a few cool people tho, its just like… 5% of all the ones I talk to)
the real reason, is they lost alot of traffic from the combination of bans, OPENAI/GOOGLE s own ai not finding reddit useful to scrape anymore. the lurking that people did, was result of the bans. they alleged people were just looking at the summaries from the AI not visiting the site.
When I joined reddit it was well over ten years ago, and the reason I joined was because I searched the net for something and got quite a few answers from there.
I then looked up certain things there but over a bit of time, probably a few weeks or so. Then I decided to join it. (Then it went to shit, the app debacle happened and I left).
Anyways the only reason I joined was because the info/entertainment was easily attainable. If I were forced to join or login all those years ago then I would’ve just moved on.
Christ, most random websites get instantly dismissed if I feel like I’m being forced to join it.
same here, but apparently i joined earlier because i unknowingly made a account on reddit from a nintendo game i was playing. but i truley joined in 2016,
Funny thing is that apple freezes the app (even if you are logged in) and pops up an “age verification” window. You can just close it and continue browsing.
I have an account that I use for my business over on reddit. It’s really quite awful over there now. I was a longtime user, and then left the site in 2023 along with most other non-bots. It’s safe to say that it’s over.
i wonder if you are like those people on a forum i go to, do you make hordes of accounts? people there make money by using hordes of accounts and try to evade the filters to earn money. reddit loves to go after the non-propaganda bots
As others mentioned, it’s been a bot-in-only experience. When bot posts are in a small sub of maybe 1000 people, heh they got rid of the counters, then maybe it’s a dead horse.
all the interesting subs, natureislit, metal, all the subs that have drama or probably AI generated. the new one being dinner diaries, and a little bit of AITA. and the one about reddit stocks/login on reddit, have conservatives ranting on it.
I think the part that drives me away, regardless of what website it is, is down vote no comment. Like okay? I would say it should be required that a comment is left if you down vote something. An up vote can just mean an acknowledgement of your post being read.
They just want to know which accounts are permitted to scrape them for textual LLM training material (because Reddit Inc has a contract with them) vs which ones are not permitted.
The byproduct of this is intensifying a cult like environment where its easier to gaslight people, but that’s ancillary.
Even being able to better drown the user base in more, and more specifically targetted ads, even that ain’t the main thing. Everybody in the online advertising world knows that the actual metrics that ‘describe’ how effective ads are… are largely bullshit, and theyre only going to become more bullshit as more LLM bots are spun up and the average person just has less money.
Its enshittification 101, when user base growth phase stops/plateaus, lock in the user base, squeeze harder and harder untill there just isn’t any money left.
The main thing is maximize profit, ie wealth extraction.
reddit yesterday, eliminated the old reddit for logged out lurkers, its only logged in. i found a reskin extension to make it old reddit, but it has some flaws, i think its new. needs alot of kinks to work out though.
if you want an old reskin extension, its called class reddit layout on extensions, it makes the new ugly UI turn into the old one(it has flaws so be warned)
Lots of wasted white space and I don’t think RES (Reddit Enhancement Suite) works equally great with new one. I was used to old’s UI, had a basic set of RES commands mapped,so always defaulted to old one. New one I dislike.
Change for sake of change is not always good. Old Reddit worked(works technically still) and it is good. It might not have the most modern looking UI but functionally it is way better.
2 ugly side bars with distracting, and the infinite scrolling , plus the amount of space leftover on the sides. also it tends to lag the more you scroll. with old reddit it doesnt have any of that. the new also forces a popup to login eventually.
Reddit is still one of the biggest social media sites on the internet. News about it is important to a lot of people. You're demanding that everyone else conform to your preferences.
Reddit is so full of bots and people pasting AI instead of posting themselves that it was beginning to make me feel genuinely insane. Using that site now is hazardous to your mental health. It always was, but now it is hazardous in entirely new ways. I just cannot believe the absolutely crazy stuff I see from people on there. The AI boosters are just unhinged there.
Those of us still with active Reddit accounts, now might be a good time to gently encourage people on Reddit to check out the Fediverse. Suggest your favourite Fediverse website by URL (don’t just say “Lemmy” or something; we know people trip over themselves to hate on the whole choosing a website thing).
I don’t know if it’s a good idea or a bad idea to mention the state of smaller or niche communities, but it feels more honest to me to just say that we could use more people here who are willing to build an alternative, and not just scroll one.
I’m just waiting for the communities I’m in to move from Reddit hopefully to the Fediverse, and it’ll be goodbye for good.
In the meantime tho, I intend for my account to continue to be somewhat useful while at the same time not really a good marketing data point. I intend to offer RaaS (“Reddit as a Service”) where people who don’t have accounts / can’t log in can ask me to fetch the text of a given post that I find to be of good interest. Crossposting the content from Reddit to here would help to keep the intended conversation alive, without needing Jailbait Spez as an intermediary.
yes i recently asked about a specific appliance problem, and another some local dentists in my area, because sometimes yelp isnt enough and these were older than 1+year posts too.
It was just yesterday that I closed my lurking tabs (again). I had been using old.reddit and initially closed them when they first made it log in only, but then after accidentally clicking a reddit link and seeing old reddit again, it turned out the old reddit redirect addon had added something that made it work again. Don’t know exactly what, maybe it was a reskin, maybe they only blocked it on the client side and it was trivial to bypass.
Then, a few days ago, I noticed that the load more comments links were broken. Then, yesterday, when I refreshed the sub I was lurking, it just opened new reddit instead of old. The redirect wasn’t even giving a loop, so not sure what was going on there. I wonder if this step here is an extra one because they got it working again after I closed the tabs.
Either way, it’s lurk or nothing for me. Quality was noticeably going down ever since the API change anyways, same with activity level. I remember you used to be able to spend a couple hours reading AITA then refresh and all but the most active threads would be different. At this point, you could refresh a day later and still see some stale threads that weren’t even at 1k upvotes. There was still enough to pass some time with but nothing like it used to be.
Though I was surprised at how it never did really slide to the right like I figured it would with all the people talking about being banned for any kind of pushback to far right bs.
I used to look at Reddit every day, several times per day. Anymore, it is once or twice per month. And never very long, becaues the experience has fallen to a terrible low. My only disappointment in Lemmy is that a lot of the niche subs I used to use on Reddit are not here or are very small.
Same here on Android. I think Reddit gave it an exception for accessibility reasons and it still works. Way better an experience than their official client. RedReader has been so good that I didn’t even go hunting for ahem, modded versions of official Reddit client :p.
Not much of a concern for me or anyone else who hates ai, but would this impact google ai’s ability to cite reddit when it tells you to add glue to your pizza, among other things? because i like the poisoned well
apparently its one of the reason reddit is forcing log ins, google ai, and openai find reddits data to be less useful, because theres mostly Ai generated posts now.
This is like owning a million pounds of dog shit and making sure you lock your garage so nobody steals it while you are out.
There has to be way more info out there on the internet now than in 2001, but because of these kinds of assholes it’s mostly unsearchable, and locked in walled gardens. I hope someday soon Reddit is met with more laughter, dismissal, and cringing than an AOL email address. I hope Spez eats some of that South American beef and shits himself.
What’s wrong with AOL mail? It’s been fine for me as a free e-mail provider. Clean webmail interface, app passwords for IMAP and SMTP (Though Thunderbird can also do OAuth2, apparently. It doesn’t work for me.), 1TB of storage. You just have to opt-out of marketing e-mails. They WILL send them. A lot of them. I’d consider it better than Gmail.
Everything changes I guess. Good to hear that it’s solid now. There was a time when AOL was not ahead of the pack and was kind of seen as a remnant of the dial-up era and one of those old-folk companies.
Obfuscation of your advertising/government profile and removal of corporate and government censorship (which now affects more than a quarter of Americans).
Those two things are valuable to the average person. Even the average American given how disliked the average American is by the current government and how many times in the last couple of years government agents have started to arrest people over twitter comments.
It doesn’t, at least not for the average user. It might prevent your ISP from looking at your traffic, but modern networks are far better in that regard with encrypted SSL traffic and DNS than it used to be.
Alone, it’s not the most effective, like the lock on your front door handle. Like the lock on your front door handle, it only keeps out the honest criminals.
Your Advertising profile, in the US the most common one is your Credit/Consumer Profile, tracks your ip address, browsing habits (through super cookies/app sniffing), and your overall fingerprint on the internet. This means Google really does know you visited facebook 12857192 times in the last year, it knows you searched your old crush’s name, and it knows the size of the sex toy you most likely are to buy based on how many seconds you spent on sex-toys.jesus thanks to google analytics plugins tracking your ip address back to the same one you used on google, the same one you used on facebook, etc.
Giving them a common, easily searchable, easily provable (without a warrant) data point to tie all their other data points is literally doing their work for them, and is making them wealthier than all their other business ventures combined. If you use a vpn and regularly change your ip address, fingerprinting is harder. If you use a slightly hardened browser and/or mobile OS, fingerprinting is harder. The less information they have on you, the less information they can sell to the government without a warrant.
This is like if you had a magic button to change the license plate on your car. Flock would be worthless, for the most part. Yes Flock collects a lot of other data, but if you cannot tie that data confidently to a single user, it becomes useless and worthless.
–
Secondly, many VPNs do not keep logs, many do not run their software on persistent media whatsoever, preventing all possible warrant scenarios, even if they were in a country that was able to send them a warrant.
This prevents one data point in government tracking, the easiest one to explain to a judge. The easiest one to explain to a jury. If you make a comment on twitter that ICE doesn’t like, they will subpoena twitter for your ip, subpoena your ISP for your personal information, and then pay you a visit.
Guess what they have to do if you have a VPN? They have to subpoena twitter for your email/phone address/device ID/IMEI/etc, then, with varying levels of difficulty, all of which can be avoided using simple opsec tactics, subpoena all of those related companies, and then hope you used personal information like your personal IP when interacting with any of those services, and then pay you a visit if, with all this extra work ALL OF WHICH HAS A LAYER OF PLAUSIBLE DENIABILITY THE MORE LAYERS YOU HAVE, convince a judge to let them pay you a visit.
Given how quickly it is becoming illegal to be trans in the united states, gay people aren’t far behind, and honestly anyone brown should already be on a vpn and have anonymized online accounts when posting, you should be working on reducing your fingerprint-ability via every means. Given you can get a vpn for 5 euros a month paid through monero, there’s no real excuse not to have that easy extra layer.
I just remembered that there are torrents with crawled text from reddit. I wonder if there’s a way to browse local data like that like you would with a search engine? Reddit’s value is in old content anyway. I never tried it myself but there are tools to browse wikipedia locally like that iirc.
hot take: Reddit has been a “logged-in-only experience” since i started using it 15 years ago. default subs and front page have always been trash brainrot, and the real value of Reddit has always been in niche communities, ie a curated user-specific homepage.
that said, their incessant insistence on brainrot like AITA and AskReddit got me off that platform years ago at this point.
Fuck AI, but I can literally use Cursor to build a wrapper to view reddit in old reddit, no account needed. It’s easy. Also fuck spez and all of his nazi loving admins.
Protect its data? You mean sell off thoughtful, detailed user contributions for AI training. Another $60mil from Google sure looks pertty, don’t it, Spaz?
With how much of the internet they occupy, and how much information they have, they can essentialy seggregate anyone they permaban from society into oblivion.
I mean, this has pretty big ramifications across the web as a whole. This is going to signal to other platforms that they should do the same, and huge swaths of the internet are going to be effectively inaccessible to search engines.
This makes it much harder to find information online without sacrificing more of your privacy. We do care about this.
560 comments
log in to comment.
More lies from Spez.
The actual reason.
spez wants a bubble algorithim to feed their users propaganda slop like facebook
This is it right here. Whoever controls social media controls minds.
Probably not a coincidence with the midterm timing. He just wishes he had done this three weeks ago.
Yesterday I browsed “/r/all” for the first time in like 3 or more years (I stopped using reddit altogether a long time ago). Holy shit I felt like my brain would melt, there was so much ragebait and misinformation that asks for primal engagement. The links I opened that seemed interesting lead to nowhere and the comments were so fucking dumb. Despite all that I kept scrolling looking for that sweet hit, I must have spent at least an hour of my time that I threw away. Thank God I jumped ship when I saw the direction it was heading.
Same. I went to reddit yesterday and it of course served me racist trash.
There are two subs for Sweden, one with 300k subscribers for normal people, and one with like 60k subscribers for terminally online fascists. The latter gets 10x exposure on the frontpage.
Fuck reddit, spez and EA.
The only account left that I have there was porn subscriptions only. I scrolled through it recently: It tries to make me mad about some political bull shit in-between all the NSFW. Really strange 🧐
Feed it to the bots
The actual reasons are certainly numerous but also certainly zero of them are “helping users find relevant communities and discussions”.
pretty much code words for “we need more fresh humans to login , because we just have bots running the site now”
How will fresh humans even know whats in the website if they cant look?
The bots are already logged in. Reddit embraced bot traffic eons ago because it “increases engagement”.
It’s not entirely wrong, in that Reddit is so full of bots and junk that a sizeable chunk of the site is unusable. Any animal photo subreddit often has more bots than a farm.
It’s either personalise or have the deluge.
Coincidentally, Reddit has just announced plans to shutter their RSS feeds, so if you were using those to personalise your feed, good luck.
Just because a login is required will not help with bots.
It does not, but you can block/unsubscribe from communities that have too many of them on the main feed, or block particular users from showing up, which can help with the repeats. That otherwise takes more logic on RSS, and isn’t really possible on the website.
that will not stop botting at all, bots already can make accounts very easily because they dont care how much gets banned if they can create more, they can automate it. but normal users cant do that, because they will get banned very quickly. what spez saying is a lie anyways.
also reddits have shown to preference not to filter out most propaganda botting anyways.
most users are lurking because they dont want to have account ban.
All but a proper search function
Pushing people into echo chambers isn’t even needed because people do that themselves. If you’re gonna profile people, autosubscribe all the libs to r/guns and all the conservatives to r/gender theory. At best people will learn something; at worst we’ll get a show.
Also, fuck Spez and fuck surveillance capitalism.
You’ll just end up with r/anime_titties situation.
/r/marijuana_enthusiasts vs /r/trees
Drawn birds?
more like AI companies not finding reddit useful anymore to scrap= forcing spez to make reddit a login site only.
[deleted]
Reddit continues to be the biggest hurdle to Lemmy’s growth; the average person doesn’t care about how much private companies profit off of their personal data, so convincing them to leave the vastly bigger platform for Lemmy is a challenge.
Completely ignoring Reddit and its potential user migration opportunities would be dooming the Threadiverse to not gaining any new users from the most likely place those users would be.
Good! Finally the last holdover users will reconsider open source alternatives
What we need now is for every modteam on Reddit who have an alternative on Lemmy, to actually advertise it. Now is the time to do so.
A pinned post should do great to point people in the right direction
The holdover users already have accounts, so this change will not affect them.
True, made me log back on and see how it’s going
Not well. Scrolling Reddit sucks now.
Yeah even the porn. We need more self-porn on lemmy!!
Remember when the internet was fun
It’s what made me finally check out lemmy.
Welcome!
Just remember Lemmy is only part of a larger network called the Fediverse. If you find you don’t really like it, there are other alternatives like Mbin and PieFed. They’re all pretty good I think, but Mbin is probably my personal favorite. There are also custom lemmy interfaces like old.lemmy.world, as well as lots of different mobile clients.
All the different instances and platforms can tall talk to each other, so you can subscribe to communities you like from any of them, as long as they are connected (aka federated). So somebody on kbin.earth (an Mbin instance) could subscribe to !micromobility@lemmy.world (a community on a Lemmy instance) and post there, browse, etc. even though they’re different websites.
You can sign up for any instance you want and if you hate them all, you can even make your very own.
This is a great breakdown.
I’ll share I pretty much only signed up for lemmy.world because I looked up which one had the most users (not that it seems to matter with all the crossover).
I wonder if there’s another instance I’d like more!
I made accounts on a few different ones to check them all out but I started in kbin.social while it was still a thing (the admin had some health issues I heard, hope he’s doing ok). Kbin was the predecessor to Mbin, which got picked up by some other devs thankfully.
Kbin.social was my first too, Ernest was a king and I hope he’s doing well and thriving in life.
Made a handful of alts when it became clear kbin was going away. Ended up using .zip as my main as I like their hands-off approach to moderating/defederation. We’re federated with everyone except malicious/criminal instances by default. If you don’t want to see things you need to block them yourself which I like a lot.
It’s likely the one most similar to Reddit, for better or worse.
worlds is the largest one, but its problematic if you dont block the politics communities ones, i made one on lemmytoday as my goto.
What would you say makes Mbin your favorite compared to Lemmy? What mobile app do you use for Mbin?
More features and I just prefer the aesthetic of the interface. I use Interstellar on Android but I would describe the mobile interface as very usable so the app isn’t really necessary.
Welcome!
Sweet, welcome, I’m glad you could make it!
And self hosting, no less. Pretty sweet. Welcome!
Welcome!!
i came from a ban, at the time i remember lemmy was remember during the API crisis, then i just made account, on instance, when it got shut down i went to another instance.
I want to keep Reddit mods off of Lemmy
The advantage lemmy has is that unlike reddit, you can easily make a community of the same name, just on a different server in the case of mod disagreements.
Its MUCH harder to powertrip on lemmy, both because the mod tools are ass, and spinning a new community isnt hard.
Didn’t like tenforward have tHe Exodus drama with some mod?
Do Lemmy instances also have that “no brigading” rule of Reddit that only exists for mods?
Because I think that rule contributed a lot to make mods more heavyhanded on their communities, even if they didn’t intend to.
unfortunately they dont, but its easier to block the whole instance. at least 2 instances crossbanned me, even if barely interacted with those.
Not having that rule might be better.
The problem with that rule at Reddit, is that it only exists for the mods, not the users.
So the misbehaving user will pick fights in a sub A, get banned, whine about it in another sub B talking shit of sub A, get banned as well for brigading. Then they go to a 3rd sub C and now actually brigades against subs A and B because their mods invent bullshit rules such as “brigading”.
The unaware users look at this mess and get confused because they can’t recall “brigading” being something forbidden by the general Reddit rules. And while “brigading” is just mod slang for “you shouldn’t incite fights between subs or users” (and anyone can figure it out by searching the word at Google, instead of whining that the mods just like to invent words), there is no rule against this either. Instead there is only a rule for the mods that they have to shut down any user attheir subs who do this.
The consequence is that the unaware users sympathize with the misbehaving one and join their brigade, even if just to taunt the mods into banning them as well. I’ve seen this a lot of times there.
Much harder to powertrip you say? Have you looked in the modlogs and see how moderators ban users in multiple instances that is unrelated to the original instance? It’s very reddit like.
The fact you can look at the mod logs is already something you cant even compare to when using reddit. Youd be suprised how far reddit mods will go.
The ban is also not worth as much as like i mentioned, communities are spread. There isnt always one version of a community of the same name, whereas clones of subreddits on reddit have an insignificant fraction of the traffic compared to a main one.
When a moderator comes in and starts to affect a lot of people, it can cause a mass exodus to a sister community. That doesnt happen really on reddit, because the people left on reddit are slow to change their habits (the fact that most dont use alternatives shows so). The people who use lemmy have generally had the mindset that if you need to switch, then they will do so.
In your first paragraph you hint at shadowbanning.
You can’t even shadowban people at all on Lemmy (as far as I know), while it’s a go-to for unethical Reddit moderators; nothing can be done to stop them and most people don’t even know it exists.
I was shadowbanned from /r/tampa because I asked them to implement removal reasons (a feature that’s existed on Reddit and takes five or ten minutes to set up). That upset /u/md28usmc and he shadowbanned me for it. Asking why I was shadowbanned led to them perma-banning me.
I think you mean communities (subreddits), and that can appear that way with an instance (server) ban.
You got a point… What i meant to say is whoever is maintaining the migration of content to lemmy. Hope they put some effort into advertising Lemmy as a viable alternative.
Hi, I’m part of the Community Team for Lemmy.World. We help with finding moderators, make sure communities are kept up, and make sure moderators follow the site rules.
To some extent mods are mods. There will always be people who disagree, vehemently, and some people who resent any rules or moderation at all.
I mention this because there are a couple things I’ve tried to do on our instance to address Reddit mistakes. First, I try to avoid having several large communities under the same mods. The mod who holds a grudge in !trees shouldn’t be able to ban you from !science. (Assuming those are both large communities).
This can be difficult, because you’d be surprised at how few extremely active people are willing to moderate even a tiny community. The other is that instead of putting out advertisements to recruit for mods, I try to draft mods. So our mods are not limited to those who seek out the position.
As a long time Reddit mod and new Lemmy.World mod, I do lament the lack of many helpful features I’m used to, but I’m glad for:
The significantly reduced likelihood of a moderator going rogue (because a rival community can pop up in its place with the same name and do a better job and the admins here are much more responsive and transparent)
Public-facing mod logs (see previous point)
One of the big reasons I’m even here is /r/tampa’s moderators went off the deep end, quietly shadowbanning people they didn’t like, banning anyone who talked about it, and lying about doing both.
If I were to do something similar with /c/tampa, I trust an admin would remove me and/or someone would start whatever.instance/c/tampa. On Reddit, running /r/FreeTampa (because you can’t just have another /r/tampa), I have to be very careful about talking about why the subreddit even exists or we get slapped for brigading; Reddit is staunchly against anyone constructively criticizing subreddits/moderators.
And only you as a mod needs to be that careful. The users will keep going to r/tampa and antagonizing r/FreeTampa, or the opposite, as there is no rule that directly forbids regular users from doing it, only the one directed to moderators.
Big, if true.
the reddit mods of the large subs should not be one on here, because many of them are powermods(they have hordes large accounts under thier belt, plus i heard many of those are in cahoots with the admins of reddit.
what lemmy needs is the niche subs. also indian subs are pretty much taking over reddit, solely because of the sheer number of people in india, apparently they dont have a sole “social media” platform of thier own. and i heard this is drama with india subs, solely because of the BJP bots.
The Indian subs were part of what made me leave. I don’t dislike Indian people, the subs are just totally irrelevant to me
same, they only started appearing on reddit after musk/trump was "deciding to " limit h1b visa last year it was getting more attention than it should. reddit is likely going to be an “indian only reddit” mostly because they have the sheer number of people using it, more than most other countries combined.
I see far more “someone else should make a community” than people making communities. I think that’s a bit silly and selfish.
LOOOOLOLOL brother, I want some of what you’re smoking because I want to exist in this reality where people are fleeing Reddit rather than flocking to it. This only affects logged-out visitors, not so much “users”. Most platforms have been this way for a long time and seen no such decline either. Pretty much the entire internet is already account-gated.
Already account-gated and increasingly human-verification-gated as well.
wait til you see ID-gated, and facial scan, thats what facebook does.
It mostly affects people who use Reddit to search people discussing stuff. Unfortunately I don’t think the Fediverse is indexed much, plus some niche communities/interests just doesn’t have the critical mass.
The problem with that is, every mod on reddit already has an account and likely will not notice anything based on this change.
I wonder how advertisers on Reddit will respond to this? It will certainly result in less ad views.
Maybe Reddit will make up for it with all the traffic coming from bots.
Maybe ads have two messages in such a scenario. One advertisement for human viewing and another hidden function with prompt injection, prompt leaking or other function for AI bots. Ah, glorious dystopia…
That’s a fucking rad idea
you see here, bots/AI bots are less useful than you think, it actually detracts from the traffic. because bots dont produce useful traffic to the site at all( they dont post meaningful comments/posts) that AI can scrape.
thats why Open AI/and google stop referencing them in thier “AI slop generators” this forced reddit to make Old reddit inaccesible to lurkers, and now they are forcing log ins. the NEW UI is a horrid feature, even for people who “likes to use REDDIT”.
the sources of bots come from propaganda farms like russian troll farms israeli bot farms, apparently India has thier own bot farms targeted at indian Subs. I suspect the majority of the sub will probably cater to india eventually, because they have 1bn+people who likely wil uses reddit.
the other source is the lowest hanging fruit that reddit filters out, the single users with hundreds of account whos pam on the site.
The argument would be that they provide " higher quality, more targeted views" which is probably correct.
Most people will fold and get the account, what’s one more " sign in with Google" on top of the 1000 other accounts.
Well, except for the (apparently) vast swathes of long-time users who get permabanned for bullshit reasons (or no given reason at all) and then can’t make a new account because of “ban evasion.” I guess they just aren’t allowed to experience Reddit at all, even lurking.
I got banned for ban evasion recently. I do have two old accounts, but neither were banned before so idk why lol.
Their website is so shit that I can’t even ask why. The auto mod sent me a DM and says if I want further info to reply to that message, but I have to accept the message request. Which I can’t do because I’m banned.
the reason is that, permban has caused many to just lurk on the site instead. even the ones that still have accts are afraid to login. they want people to login, but htier AI moderation/filters are still yay high. plus its not even stopping most bots / AI botting anyways, they can just create a single use account, post and move onto the next thing.
If people can’t see the content when Earth would they sign up?
This is a good point. You lose existing users through attrition. How do you attract new subscribers to a site they cannot see?
They could leave the front top 50 posts of the day available as an attractor. With a “sign up to see more” banner at the end of the scroll. Is current leadership smart enough to do that?
On the former, yes. Maybe we will luck into attrition being greater than the users they will attract.
For the latter–maybe?
At this point I think it is best for Reddit to quietly wind down and just go away. Eventually it is just going to be a right wing hellhole.
reddit already lost to attrition, which is why they want people login. first the purges came last year, reduced overall traffics and users, but not botters, then AI stop using reddit as a datamine, because its not useful if all your content is also AI generated.
I’m not certain that I follow the logic, but I’m also not certain that the logic would make sense if I was following it.
They went with the assumption that as Google buys their data and replaces their links in search queue with LLM gen answers, their organic traffic from searches would get reduced into nothingness, so they can push their login requirement with little drawbacks. They increase price of each ad via personalization in a short run, but without a drag of the likes of Instagram, Discord, Whatsapp etc there would hardly be new users to create content.
maybe they shouldnt do massive purges after the eleciton, and at musks request twice last year, that definitely had an effect users whos has been caught in the crossfire. not only the AI filters ban people on politics, but everyone else using the site, basically they only need a small inkling of “botting” to even ban you.
Sadly
Sad thing ad networks will perceive it to be better since they better tie tracking between networks and thus better impressions. Don’t matter to me though I just recently gone the next step of filtering Readit out of my search results and have never been happier.
Same! I use this
addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/…/ublacklist/
Ah cool I just use the one built in to the search engine I just dont show me results from this domain
Do you mean adding “-site:reddit.com” to all your queries? Or is there a setting that I am missing?
DDG, kagi, searxng, and likely many other engines allow you to hide the domain from results. I use DDG and there you have the ‘3 dots’ button to the right where you can block the site for good.
DDG only lets you do 5 and for me three of those are taken by fox news domains already.
Whaaaaat?! Thanks for the info. Even more reason to finally give a shot at setting up searxng which I assume won’t have a limit like that.
Surveillance capitalism follows the same rules as capitalism; do whatever is most profitable. The deception/manipulation/propaganda algos are 10-1000x more valuable when they’re able to target you as an individual; across all accounts, space, and time. The users hardest to swindle, who already gave a shit about privacy/anonymity, have already left.
Most advertising on reddit is guerrilla marketing, and reddit either runs their own bots or explicitly enables them to inflate activity and engagement.
Don’t worry, they have all the data on that, and I’m pretty sure they thought of it.
Fact is that most visits from search engines don’t go very deep anyway. They are allowing a brief glimpse at one page before they start prompting you to log in, and that is likely driving logins while barely shortening those SEO visits, which are not of great value in the first place.
It may come as a surprise but websites often have traffic they don’t want. I recall once my boss noticed there was a non-negligible amount of traffic from parts of the world none of our advertisers care about. He built an endless revolving door of promo offers and directed this traffic into it. It didn’t generate much money but it made the rest of our traffic look higher quality right away.
spez just wants to give it to AI companies to scrape for a fee, they already charge 60mil/year to let google have the data.
I gave up on reddit when they banned 3rd-party API access. I use Boost for Lemmy so it looks like reddit minus the karma whores, bots, and general shittiness.
I suppose some reddit users might find the distributed nature of the fediverse too complicated, but honestly I’m not sure if those folks would be much of a benefit to us here.
I got permanently banned for reposting the Alex Peretti shooting to bring awareness to it, reddit was constantly removing posts that day. I had my account for 17 years. Then they also banned my alt account that I had for 16 years because of “ban avoidance” - the digital fingerprint they had for me was tied to both accounts apparently.
Fuck reddit.
I got banned for being pro-choice (pro-abortion really) and thinking women are people. They got all my accounts.
Pathetic website.
reddit/spez mostly sucks musks Knob now, and by extension trump and the gop. dont forget that in 2016, they did the same thing, by banning many subs.
onbording through apps is good enough that users might not even notice a difference, the main hurdle is understanding the interconnectivity of instances and them actually leaving their jail
Yep I use voyager and can barely tell a difference. I will admit lemmy from browser is still a bit confusing
i think people will use old reddit on logging in, until reddit removes it. and then people will use reskinning extensions to make it old reddit before reddit finally somehow restricts that too.
lul
I guess I kind of understand why companies want you to be logged in to engage with their platform, as the user metrics are the main selling point to advertisers, but man do I really fucking hate it when a platform forces me to log in by preventing me from using their website. So much so, that I haven’t made an account on Instagram or X or Facebook or whatever dumb social media platform specifically because I can’t browse without signing up. Well, that, and also the greed, the lack of privacy, the tacit endorsement of fascism, et. cetera.
No, I don’t want to make an account.
No, I don’t want to download your app.
No, I don’t want to turn on notifications.
Gah, fuck off with all this horseshit. The internet used to be fun. Now everything is a chore and nobody does anything unless they feel like they can make a profit off of it.
This combo drives me up the fuckin wall.
Obviously I think reddit is trash, but I can kind of understand other forums requiring a login (several of the small, private communities I’m a part of require them) but there is no good reason to push people to an app other than avarice.
It’s extra frustrating because I created cosmetic filters for uBlock Origin that allow me to access individual Reddit posts (so I can still read Reddit posts that I find through a search engine) but not any of the feeds so that I can’t waste time scrolling. I can’t use those on the app.
i cant stand new reddit ui, so i just used a reskin extension(just a warning its not 100% perfect)
forums i understand, im in one other one about “earning money on reddit”
The big problem is most people say “Ugh, fine, I’ll log in with Google,” rather than you and I who say “Ugh, no.”
log in with google is way worse. now you are sharing your data with both Google and Reddit
Emphatically agree, but “normies” gonna “normie.”
Convenience is the primary goal for them.
I don’t have a problem with someone making a website for logged in users only. What sucks is making this open anonymous forum that was quite good for years and then locking it down once people are addicted to it. Well, this doesn’t change much for me i deleted my reddit years ago and haven’t been back at all.
also the new UI for reddits very cumbersome, and very intrsuive and not very intuitive to use. you can use extensions to remove the ugly sidebars with random stuff on it, but now you are left with 2 giant empty white spaces in between the doom scroll feed.
Same same, it’s fucked
only way they can even do this is how much users they already have and how entrenched those users are. Its insane how much people are willing to put up with to keep using the shitty services, just because they have used them for long time.
they apparently lost alot of actual users enough for reddit to become desperate to force logins. i think thats why Facebook did it too, gotta keep those boomers/genxers using it for thier right wing slop. certain health groups(describing thier own diseases) are sitll on fb, but i would not touch it.
i saw a graph somewhere the recent traffic drop was from open AI not scraping anymore.
hard to log in when you get banned so easily, thats why people lurked.
I mean, that’s capitalism. It was inevitable. A similar fate will befall Lemmy at some point, so enjoy it while you can.
With all due respect to you and the user above as people, fuck the defeatist attitudes. We’re going to make and keep this little part of the Internet fun, no matter what corporations say. I’ve had a great 3.5 years on Lemmy despite the occasional dramatic event. And I’m counting on myself and every one of us to continue to make it so.
Entropy is also inevitable, but that doesn’t mean we can’t keep a small space of less entropy than average while we’re here.
lemmy wont become large enough to enshittyfy, its too segregated, its not a one size fit all which reddit is.
press x to doubt.
Seriously, there’s a low chance for that.
I remain utterly discombobulated that 90% of redditors haven’t already migrated here. What exactly are they waiting for? Lemmy clearly is more than good enough already.
Judging by comments it’s almost entirely the lack of content on lemmy puts people off
Most people on reddit are lurkers looking for an infinite scroll.
Which is insane, because reposts were rampant on reddit, to the point that I rarely saw anything new that wasn’t a news article.
That’s kind of why I like Lemmy better. Rarely do I see reposted content. At one point I had a spreadsheet where I would log how many times I saw the exact same post on TIL or YSK.
Smaller communities are better.
Does reddit still have that repostsluthbot?
Yep! Here is far better quality
they also started to recycle multiday old posts too. some have been reposted multiple times in a short amount of time.
With migration comes content.
Yep… now spread the word! I’m forever banned on reddit so can’t
Reddit is banned from me.
Never thought this would be a badge of honour but I’m also proud I wiped my comments and deleted my account before they inevitably banned me for posting a 🍉 or something.
I’m suspicious about people who AREN’T banned from reddit
You mean bots?
The other part is lemmings. A lot of us here are very hostile.
Which to be fair so is reddit. Redditors have always been mercurial but it does feel like in recent years they’ve been much more combative.
Yep they really have
if you encounter the tankie instances, or the blahaj purist , and startrek website instance, then they are super-combative.
There’s so many tankies omg
There were a few small subreddits I hung on for. Just a few niche communities that flew below the radar and avoided some of the bots and other enshitification. But when they forced logon for old reddit. I was done. I’ve been so happy here on Lemmy. I reminds me of how fun reddit used to be.
I would’ve seen their point maybe a couple years ago, but I can’t remember the last time I got to the bottom of the all feed here. And sister, I can scrrrroll. Like I start to grow mushrooms and I’m pretty sure my cat partially melds with me.
As a person who tries to post a lot here to bring more content, it looked a lot different around here even 6 months ago.
Thank you for your service.
I also mod a couple communities on another account. Turns out if you just post things you’re interested eventually other people will join in and then you can just sit back and enjoy.
Yes! Hopefully with Lemmy being a bit more bustling now, the reddit users who are turned off by the login requirement will be more likely to stick around.
Yeah, people like you are changing it to something more palatable. And I’m seeing increases in different users posting/commenting more often rather than just the power users. Idk if it’s crossed the threshold for increasing usability yet, but I’m hopeful for it for the first time since I was new here that it’s slowly becoming better.
Excellent! I love seeing that increase, I love hearing from different types of people.
<3
[deleted]
Or that the content that is here is mostly Star Trek, Linux and loli.
Joined Lemmy about a month ago after 17 years of using Reddit. Account was deleted. A once very great haven for open discussion has turned into one of censorship inundated with bots to push propaganda. The writing was on the wall in 2015 and while its demise started slowly the rate enshitification grew.
What I don’t understand is given it’s inundated with bots posting/commenting to direct the narrative, what is the point of creating more obstacles for the common person to be duped. You’d think they’d want to keep it easy access to spread their “message”.
They have the top google spots now for just about any question on any topic.
Obviously the next step is to use that position to their advantage – hide the content until the user is logged in. The Pinterest Strategy.
Control and tracking is the reason, and selling that data.
Those “obstacles” are there for profit, and probably some censorship. If the user says something they don’t like, they’re easier to ban or have the algorithm not show the post.
A lot of the OG’s have moved over. From Diggs exoduses (exodi? exodipodes?) We’re always the first to move, though. Digital nomads.
And the ones that would have been on Digg had they been born a decade or more earlier.
Eventually everyone else follows us, the new platform turns to shit, and we migrate again.
I hope the open, federated nature of lemmy prevents that…or at least delays it.
Yeah I feel like with lemmy you could just move to a smaller network/graph of federated servers. Actually I think some splintering of the fediverse would be a good thing if its numbers keep trending up.
Also the fediverse is crazy cheap to access. Like I’ve got a $8/mo CAD server running a dozen websites and a snac2 instance and it doesn’t choke even a bit.
Because all the porn is still there
Lemmy sure has porn, it’s just tucked away neatly in other instances that are not federated to the rest of the network.
FediNSFW exists and is growing.
Yeah, and I will say it’s definitely better for posting than I expected. I kinda was expecting very little response, and I think that the small community vibes help people feel comfortable replying to OC posts. That said, there are some things it’s missing (notably to me at least is a sapphic oriented nudes space). But ultimately yeah it’s good and improving, and I do recommend people who’ve been considering posting there give it a try.
Network effect. The communities and discussions are still there. Lemmy has the infrastructure, mostly, but not the users and not the discussions at least not in anywhere near the same volume.
There’s also a few seriously missing features with Lemmy, for example modmail.
I have also found, overall, as stupid and crazy as this may be, when discussing anything involving politics users on Lemmy can be almost militantly closed-minded. I find more intelligent discussions on Lemmy, but I also find more of the ‘you either agree with me or you’re everything that’s wrong with the world’ type.
Wait, there’s no mod mail‽ That’s a really important feature for people trying to mod well
There is the mod log at least. Getting banned on reddit was such a black box of pain. I wonder why I kept sticking my hand in it so often.
I have mixed feelings on mod logs personally. They’re great when the mods aren’t trustworthy and nothing is controversial. But I think they leave mod teams vulnerable to coordinated attack, which absolutely will happen if lemmy gets big enough. The mod logs played a (small) role in my decision not to take on mod roles or start communities here.
Mod mail on the other hand is a great tool for communication with basically no downsides
Nope. Nobody’s bothered to build it.
See github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/5110
The average redditor doesn’t care about any of this in my experience, they’ll just take all the crap because that’s what they see on all of the internet anyway
Most of them don’t know that anything else exists.
I understand that in many of the most popular subreddits (if not site-wide) mentioning Lemmy is forbidden or rewarded with a ban.
They just don’t know we exists, but they will eventually.
I share a bunch of links here from time to time and Lemmy needs communities and content. It is not an insurmountable scenario, because Reddit was also much smaller at the time of the Digg exodus. Lemmy and similar sites in the Fediverse have improved since a few years ago, back when the only topic of conversation was beans and the site ran very slowly.
Is Piefed better? I don’t like how duplicates aren’t combined on Lemmy.
Either you don’t think about which instance to join, and inadvertently join a conservative one. Or you do think about which instance, and it’s daunting.
It isn’t really that daunting, most people can just go to join-lemmy.org and any one there would be fine.
Lemmy is also not quite version 1, it is going to change a lot soon when v1 drops because there is a plugin system.
Hey, that doesn’t have sh.itjust.works!
Maybe because they host a community that harasses the lemmy devs.
But I don’t want users to inadvertently join conservative instances.
Are you sure you want that?
I do want some of them, yes. But perhaps most I want reddit to burn.
spread the word
its the lack of content actually. the last instance that got shut down had way more content than now, because people dont stick to one place and grow them, they just go to ever smaller and smaller communities.
It’s hard to get used to the slower speed of these newer sites. I prefer it, but it took time to prefer it. You get so used to the speed of the giant networks and the emotions it triggers so frequently that the slower pace of smaller networks leaves you in withdrawal. This was why I didn’t use BlueSky as much as I used to use Twitter, but I’ve been starting to enjoy the slower pace of all of these services. I actually have more free time now because the tap runs dry and i log out for the day. I’ve been on the Internet since I was 11, back in 2001, and I’ve had to really wrack my brain to remember what it used to be like. Forums simply didn’t update at the speed sites do today, and I didn’t mind it.
Front page of the internet my ass
How the mighty have fallen.
Deleted my account. Lemmy is my internet home now
Same. Got banned for using a single word (actually forgot what it haha), and deleted my account. Now that it’s becoming login only, it’s even better to kick my habit.
Got banned for telling a colonial apologist and nazi to fuck off.
From the platform or a subreddit?
“Fuck off” isn’t against Reddit ToS.
Platform. I appealed but they weren’t having it. Reddit doesn’t like people causing others of being nazi and colonial fucks.
In one comment I called spez a nazi fuck. He removed that too.
Dude was talking about how the Brits were actually really good for their colonies (how they brought culture and infrastructure there) and how the bengal famine was actually because of the locals themselves.
London was apparently a benevolent european power.
I’ve never heard of, let alone seen such a platform ban.
I’m not saying it’s impossible, but I’m not aware of them banning for that kind of thing.
It was repeated offense. I had got warnings before for insulating people’s limited brain power before.
Tons of people call people dumb on Reddit and never get suspended for it.
I could see them defending spez’s honor, but not just calling random people dumb.
Dunno what to say man. Take it up with reddit I guess.
How funny, it’s been a logged out only experience for me for years now.
It’s been a nothing experience for me for years. I don’t miss it, honestly. Life goes on.
Is it “read only” experience?
It’s “giant splash screen over content, telling you to sign in” experience.
I’ve been straight up IP banned and have only been allowed to lurk till this change fully booted me off. Every time I make a new account it is autobanned before I can get a couple comments off.
At least redlib still works, but once thats done so am i.
Yeah same here, I haven’t had an account for ages now, but I do still occasionally take a look. But first they did the “new reddit” thing, then the API thing so all the apps stopped working, then VPN blocking and now this will (presumably) kill redlib as well. I’m kind of done having to find all these workarounds just to look at a site that obviously doesn’t want me going there and is becoming increasingly worthless anyway. Oh well.
they have been thwarting peoples attempt to be active users for the last year, and now they want them to login. they thought the ones they dint banned were enough to scrape from with AI.
Spez: “I’m not logged in here with you—you’re logged in here with me!”
Muahahah 🤭
Former r/jailbait mod Spez, the greedy little pig boy.
It won’t be long before the website is gone entirely and you have to use the app.
I think that’s the overall goal. Much harder to block ads and they can collect a ton more data.
Not really if you use these patches.
I sadistically don’t like this.
Generally I’m all for things like this, but I don’t want there to be workarounds and backdoors to prolong reddit’s life.
It want the acceleration towards its death to increase. I don’t want people to be able to enjoy it so that the spell of the addiction (one I was guilty of) can be broken.
I think we can all do our part by blocking the website from our search results. Let it just hemorrhage and die with its bot network and shitty people.
Until you find or create a replacement that is easier to use than Reddit/Lemmy/PieFed and appeals to the same gigantic audiences as well as serve heroic amounts of web traffic as much as reddit serves each hour of each day without lag or latency, it will never die within your lifetime.
You could have said the exact same thing about Digg or MySpace 15 years ago.
Reddit is difficult to replace, but not nearly as difficult as you imply. Serving a lot of web traffic with low latency is a well documented and solved problem. And a competitor does not go from zero to 100 million users over night, they have plenty of time to scale. Countless companies have accomplished this.
Reddit is, by and large, an extremely basic concept. It’s a link sharing site with comment trees. Undergrads could spin up a similar website in a week, albeit less scalable. But again, there is plenty of time to figure out the scaling issue.
Lol, websites are born and die constantly. Nobody knows what the next big thing will be but reddit will definitely die within our lifetime.
Remember MySpace? How about Friendster?
Sounds like a win either way to me!
I think you may have misunderstood what I’m saying: you can’t kill reddit. You can only try to atrophy their users with better sites that only attract their niche audiences, including their shitty users as well.
Oh no, I was being dumb haha.
Either the site dies, or I do lol. I agree with you, it won’t die before I do.
instagram, tiktok, twitter and facebook likely. facebooks just 99%bots anyways.
Fuck Reddit and Fuck Spez.
Didn’t spez moderate an underage subreddit?
Someone added him as a mod during a time you could add anyone as mod without their consent or knowledge
it might as well have been already, if you use a VPN you’re surely accustomed to the Fedora Teletubby
It’s a shame because it’s genuinely a useful repository of information. I wish infinite humiliation and discomfort upon Reddit’s leadership.
I just came here from there. Reddit is getting weird AF
Welcome. You come to find a more free alternative… You stay for the beans, powdered milk, and art.
Everyone types like they’re the same person
Almost like there’s some kind of technology that finds a linguistic average in a group and communicates through it…
Bots and no-life powermods “streamlining” the communication
Me too. It started with subreddits going to shit because half of the content were repost bots recycling older posts.
Then, it started asking for an ID to be able to interact with subreddits and users with the NSFW label activated.
And now it’s a only logged experience. The platform is on a spiral of enshittification at the same time it puts more barriers to be part of it.
I don’t want curated posts only of my interest. I love /all for the scrolls. It’s a sad shell of what it used to be with leadership that wishes they were Elon.
They just got rid of r/all completely
What the hell? I’d ask why but reason left them long ago.
i wonder how much peopl uses oldreddit on reddit, i was one of htem. thats the only way to use reddit in a pleasant manner.
Not completely, it works on old reddit. For now. I think they said they’ll be phasing out old reddit so that will stop being an option sooner or later. Probably sooner.
Hello guys, thats why I got Lemmy since I have read that today!
Im also new to here, how’s this place?
We like to keep if tidy. Please take off your shoes at the login screen and close any country gates behind you. Pick up your litter and tell us a dirty joke.
A bit less active but you’re not gonna get shadowbanned for no reason :)
Thats nice to know
It’s smaller, it’s slower, but it’s pretty cozy.
Welcome! It can be a pretty fun place around here
Just chant along with the mob “AI is bad” and you’ll fit in just fine on Lemmy.
[deleted]
Sorry, I mistakenly thought this was a platform where divergent opinions can coexist. I’m going to go back to perpetually lurking now so that hopefully the mob will forget about me.
The very reason I switched to Lemmy.
I’m genuinely curious to see their metrics this autumn. It feels like so many old redditors came here!
Do we know what percentage of visits are from not logged in visitors? I imagine that all the people that visit reddit through searches for information are not likely to be signing up for a account, so they will be losing a bunch of that traffic and ad revenue.
Putting all that community generated information behind a login screen is a massive loss even if you don’t use the site regularly.
Hell, I feel like the scraping problem still won’t be solved either since I can immediately see a repost/archive site being made that just mirrors reddit using account bots.
Host it in a country that doesn’t recognize US corporate law, and you’ve got an instant in to a massive userbase.
I will miss the occasional search results from Reddit, particularly for gaming related stuff.
It’s becoming a “fuck this I’m going somewhere else” experience.
They are going to end up burning the whole thing to the ground in a bid to make investors money on something that never had hard quantifiable monetary value to begin with in a way that you could easily turn up the dial on “line go up” enshitification like Google can with ad impressions.
Its a fancy web forum, a big popular one for sure, but there are God knows how many similar options out there already competing for users. There is a very low ceiling on just how profitable it could ever be as a business all on its own.
There is a reason a lot of these websites, like Gamespot for example, ended up consolidating into holding companies that own a bunch of them.
people will like scatter to forums,not necessarily to fediverse.
Fediverse rise!
Yes! Any time now.
The year of the lemmy!
I stopped using reddit primarily when the 3rd party API blocking started. I had been browsing anonymously to lurk a few different communities for a bit after that, but I often left just being annoyed how much a waste of time it always was. I haven’t been back since the blocked old reddit for anyone not logged in. Can’t say my life is any worse without it.
I’ve been using Redlib as a front end on a daily basis for the last year or so but it has stopped working because of the recent changes.
Although I spent a lot of time reading posts and comments there I haven’t missed it as much as I thought I would.
i use an extension to reskin it as old, but it has it flaws, but more useful than the new UI. i think someone made in response to the old reddit getting canned recently.
It hurt itself in its confusion.
“and more protective of Reddit data”
It’s not Reddit data, it’s our fucking data, which, BTW, you have already sold.
The platform is yours and the shareholder’s, the data is ours.
Doubt this is true according to their TOS
Almost certain, although I wonder how far back the tos, or when would the tos have changed, to “give” the data to reddit, and whether it would be admissible in court. I believe many tos which have been accepted online have been thrown out in courts. I may be wrong of course, IANAL.
oh well.
Anyway.
You can’t even find news on reddit anymore. Who gives a shit.
Have you noticed the news being watered down too? Like I’m seeing some real news here and there mixed with way more stupid fluff pieces in r /news the past year or 2.
inb4 lemmy always sucked
yup. an its almost impossible to find anything on ukraine or iran unless you are outright looking for it.
and also reposts. any “breaking news” is immediately drowned on reddit.
Unfortunately I give a shit because I don’t want to have to resort to using an LLM to get an answer to the many obscure questions I have that are rarely answered anywhere else.
I think LLMs are a great tool for searching through lots of information. I just think their monopolization and monolithical mass adoption is bad. The people who run them are bad. The scale at which they do it is bad. The dangers are very real and bad.
But they’re great at sifting through and collating information. Private ones are great. The tech is awesome. The current implementation is problematic. Like we got nuclear energy and atom bombs at the same time. This is that.
Understandable but resorting to Reddit in its current state (with current leadership) is probably worse
That’s what LLMs are great at. With search MCPs they can quickly look through data and hand you a source to answer your question.
I’m aware and that’s the problem. Using LLMs makes me feel guilty because of the resource waste.
I do it locally. Even a local LLM can be super useful in that situation.
Lol, I prefer a [deleted] experience.
The exact opposite of what Aaron Swartz would have envisioned for the site.
It's funny, way back in the mists of history Reddit's original plan was very similar to the Fediverse's. They opened the source for their servers and had plans for how it could interoperate with other independent "reddits".
Steve is the Wish version of Elon you get from Temu though, he’s got nothing of value on any level.
now its just infinite doomscrolling like tiktok, facebook. and the new reddits UI is so terrible even people “who defends using it” are not happy. there is extensions to remove the sidebars of it.
No matter how I look at it, this will only hurt their user base. Where are they going to get new users? I’m no tech billionaire, but I struggle to see how this benefits the site in the long term. Even if they revert later, the damage will already be done and the site will lose any relevance it once may have had.
I’m not interested in Reddit per se, just curious why they’d think this is a good idea.
The thing with reddit, and why it used to be so much better than other corporate media, is that they’ve always under-monetized their users. Facebook and such earned at least an order of magnitude more per user.
If reddit loses half of its user base and doesn’t gain a single user, but 10x’s their revenue per user, well, they’re still making 5x more money.
10 x 0 = 0
They are probably betting on Google still displaying reddit at the top of every search so that normies keep coming in. They seem to have ignored that Google searches now just give you a stitched answer of bullshit Gemini put together so that normies don’t ever click on reddit links.
This is the image of corporations shooting themselves in the foot while passing the same gun around 🤣
Unfortunately that’s not how it works. Once you have a sufficiently large userbase, the network effects are enough to sustain them. A ton of people use facebook still and that has been a logged-in experience forever. Same with instagram.
You don’t have to be signed into Instagram at least to view things someone has shared with you. It’ll nag every now and then but it doesn’t stop you.
For me it stopped me plenty of times.
Yeah, plus, I have all Meta shit blocked in all my VLANs, which doesn’t help either.
I just use this on my phone with a VPN to download whatever it is, see it, and then delete it:
github.com/naicolas-dev/socialmedia-downloader
Has worked every single time. I think it works for TikTok, but that is something I’m not even willing to try.
That’s the thing with money and companies. The only thing that is important is gains in the current quarter. Nothing else matters
Userbase doesn’t matter this much this days. What matters is raw data, the best data the better. Random people from the internet bring shitty data, data of logged in users is better.
And if the userbase drops, they can add more bots, who cares, line goes up.
yep, they’ve been turning up the dial for some time now …slowly implementing anti-mobile browsing nags and locking down content by classification. And good on them, nothing will ruin their run faster than their own enshittification efforts.
I feel like reddit will eventually become like Facebook in that only lame people will still use it, but it will be a big enough percentage that it’s going to be unavoidable in a very annoying way.
the front page is mostly memes, and reposts by AI. plus any political post gets drown out, especially the ones that makes the gop look bad.
Unfortunately… But yeah, you’re likely right… I can see it going that way.
It’s annoying, because so much of the Internet is linked through Reddit. If I’m not constantly seeing these links, I can just pretend it doesn’t exist. Instead, I’m peppered with links to the Walled Garden, fully knowing I’m not allowed inside
for someone reason i was using new reddit on mobile , instead of using old reddit for a while. until the nagging got really annoying until 2 months ago where i switched to using old reddit redirect and sink it extension to make it usable on mobile. now that is gone too, but im using a reskin extension.
It’s quite a shame that the vast majority would rather stay on a platform that hates its users than come here, but I guess that’s how humanity works
I think many people just don’t know about Lemmy and all its wonders
Beans and milk
powdered milk, at that!
Ahh yes, forgive me
Indian content is a growing prescence on reddit now, likely it will just be mostly indians in the end, since india have sucha large population compared to most countries.
Ever since they added automatic translations to their app I’ve noticed a lot of nonanglophones using English-centric subs.
I want Reddit dead.
They recently had a mod event where they announced they are restricting ban abilities from mods. Basically AI can ban, mods can choose to unban - but not initiate a ban in the first place.
There are a couple mods I like to hate-watch, once a month or so I swing by and see what kind of BS they have been doing lately. The schadenfreude of watching them mald over this was the best I’ve had all year.
dint know this news, im not surprise. probably came out at the same time they announced there will be AI dominated mods, who will “police” AI-subs. probably realized that overbanning has caused them to lose many users/ and now there are more lurkers than not. at the same time, reddit doesnt want to give up thier ai moderation and filtering.
Yeah this is all second hand from an announcement about something that is “going to happen”. So details might differ from what actually shows up.
And yes I think mod abuse is starting to show up in their bottom line. They need people commenting so they target ads more effectively, same reason they killed r/All. They need to know stuff about you so they can send ads.
Mods being the toxic assholes they are is driving people to lurk, as you stated.
the bannings by reddits own filteriing/AI is causing people to lurk, old reddit makes the site legible. the new UI, even if you use extension to remove some of the features is still horrible to use.
Just let it go, my friend. You will be so much happier.
No I enjoy it. I’m not sitting there getting angry over anything or having it ruin my day.
Just once and a while swing by and laugh for a bit. It’s like a zoo I guess? But I have more respect for zoos.
“What are the idiots up to today… oh being idiots lol”
You need to share the schadenfreude with the rest of us, brother.
Vast majority of ‘old redditors’ still believe reddit is their home. Its not, there are so many more normies on reddit now, that it is legitimately a normie space. And making it a walled garden is the only way Reddit Inc can grow.
It’s ironic that old.reddit.com was also recently taken away from lurkers.
yea it was yesterday, i had to use a reskin to classic layout its not 100% perfect.
the nice subs are there, but i feel liek theres less traffic tot hose area now, and filled potential spammers solely because people got banned and dont want to log in anymore.
i bounced at the cookie consent dialogue of the linked post. 1751 partners and no umbrella reject, fuck off 🤣
i would not mind reddit becoming life in only if it didn’t feed and feed on ai on the side, ie. if it became a truly human discussion (again). it’s that their plan?
In short- we can’t datamine you if you’re not logged in, we can’t build a behavioral profile on people without accounts, we lick the boots of governments that’ll demand ID checks age verification, and it makes it harder for AI bots to scrape the site without paying us. Really there’s no downside to anyone at all, it’s a win-win. Oh it’s bad for users and bad for the Internet? Is that important? Those groups don’t pay us, right?
Don’t forget concerns about a safe Reddit experience!
“I padded your cell and locked the door, why don’t you feel safe?” - Spez
Aka- need to be able to screen out advertiser unfortunately content.
Give it a few years and Redditors will also be speeing brainrot like ‘he’s gonna unalive himself with a pewpew’.
To be fair, Reddit has been Zombie Reddit for about 5 years now.
When they received $150 million from Tencent in 2018, the writing was on the wall. You cannot accept that kind of money and keep to the original aspiration. The IPO just accelerated it.
The amount of slop on there nowadays is wild! Even the smallest communities are being overrun with it and they don’t give a damn because it is good for business short term.
the downfall is them catering to AI companies for scraping.
That was more a death rattle.
Reddit is killing itself on live
That’s just standard business practice these days.
Short term profits are much more important than the long-term sustainability of the business.
A moment of silence for those gooners who, for one reason or another, need to goon anonymously…
Get ready for the next influx of new users here.
People will sign up for lemmy because they don’t want to sing up for reddit?
Lemmy gets new blood every time Reddit further enshitifies its experience.
Yes
I wonder if this will be the last reddit exodus, I don’t know how they can enshittify further so I imagine those that remain are pretty complacent.
theres another step, they eventually want people to use the APP full stop. old reddit users can use it while logged in, but thats matter of time.
According to FediDB there has been a 1.7% growth this month. Meaning 244,051 new accounts have been created on fediverse on the past 30days. Almost 250thousand people in a month. I’m sure this is completely coincidental
how many of those are bots, because i knows bots/spammers are constantly making the accounts and not actual users.
Not sure if that info is available or even possible to filter out, but i think this happens in every social media site
Honest answer: Significantly less than Reddit.
Bots have no incentive to astroturf unpopular sites.
Such loss to the internet and every single guide over internet…
No more 7yo [removed by moderator] and [deleted by user] most precious tutorials, hints, guides, solutions.
mv reddit /dev/null
Currently old.reddit now requires an account to be logged in in order to view it.
Suspended accounts are also experiencing issues browsing old reddit since the update.
Additionally /r/all has been disabled and trying to access it from old.reddit results in a Reddit message saying “your network has been blocked.”
I can’t wait for the site to completely die.
they will get rid of old reddit of logged in users eventually, also they put a 6 month requirement to be able to use old reddit. new accounts have no chance.
i am using an extension that basically reskin new reddit as the old one, but it has some kinks to work out though.
Would you mind sharing the name of that extension, please?
classic reddit layout, its reskin, but it might not format the pages correctly, im messing with the options right now. on mobile, theres no way to get rid of the sidebar(the one with the sub rules on it)
And age verification is a thing. I miss the excellent discussions. I don’t see them here. It’s a list of comments, no reactions.
What do you mean by reactions, like the badge things, or conversations?
What you do here: writing reactions. The discussions are not what I’m used to on Reddit and Slashdot back in the days. It’s probably that the userbase is small. It is what is is and I’m glad that forums like Lemmy exist and I hope they start gaining traction. On the other hand, now I’m back writing content for AI, so is that a win?
Yeah… The certainty that this very conversation will be scraped and monetized is a real bummer. Makes me less likely to share my real self online.
Yeah, LLM battles lately. Reddit’s been falling for like 10 years by now. The last five have been free fall, though.
started with trumps 1st term, and magically when the gop was threatening the social media for “harm against children” shtick, reddit ban all the subs that were “illicit”.
then came the massive amount of russian bots around 2018, thats when they started banning people for inneundos.
Nobody cares about Reddit these days. The bots took it over years ago. Like so many things, there was a time when it mattered.
It’s been fucked since the leadup to the 2016 murican election. Wasn’t perfect by any means before that, obviously already had paid shills and astroturfing, but that seems to be when everyone realized how much you could use it to influence people. Really kicked into high gear then
I used to think people were going OTT getting so angry about shills and saying it was a death knell. They were right
Typical “product owner/manager” mentality to show percentages of engagement growth or whatever stupid KPI they came up with. And those shitheads are the most incompetent and the most high off AI. I just hope enshittification will be complete some day and everything will be brown and smelly (just like those Claude UIs).
I’ve been trying to distance myself from Reddit and I think that settles it for me. I can get my share of the dead internet elsewhere!
Update:
I deleted my Reddit Account. Now, I must consider moving off Proton…so much change.
Lemmy is less active but could be good. I fear the third party cunts will excel here now that reddit is gone. Astroturfing andthelikes.
Fediverse severs have a bit of a natural size limit, which means site-level moderation is easier. Admins also aren’t motivated by ad impressions or vanity metrics that impress investors, so there’s that, too.
It doesn’t remove bad actors, of course, and there will be no lack of bad admins, but it’s still more friction than exists on corporate sits.
I’ll make my own dead internet, with hookers, and cocaine!
It took me 4 months to wean off from when I first registered to Lemmy to when I made my final goodbye post on Reddit. It’s a transition, everyone can do it on their own time and pace.
when they remove old reddit from lurkers, i started to click on the subs less, because i had to use a reskin extension, and that isnt exactly a 1:1 replcation of old reddit.
Yes. Old.reddit was a lifeline, but it was inevitable the current direction would lead to it’s death.
Speaking of “Old” reddit. I recall there was a thread once where a “famous” redditor managed to game the system and take a thread through it’s natural evolution entirely by themselves. It reached pretty high in /r/all. It looked like this:
Asked a question. Kept replying to it with genuine answers and arguments. Went on tangents, hijacked portions of it, even firing up Godwin’s Law. This person created replies and sub arguments entirely solo. It was basically a entire self-generated thread exposing every direction a viral reddit post could go; I think the redditor was protesting upcoming changes.
Neat.
Well, I think they’re thinking that AI bots can’t see the page because they can’t log in and it’ll protect open source information from being obfuscated by Ai. In reality though, it just forces inconvenience for the humans.
Can’t sell something you can get for free after all…
That’s really giving them too much credit.
This is all about data collection and data theft, to sell your data to advertisers
to google actually, they are paying 60mil this year just to access it. its not a coincidence that google started limiting accounts per phone recently. they want people logged in so they can browser fingerprint people, thier time zones, their devices, thier scrolling and clicking on certain pages, and how long they stay on one page,etc. and they also use this method to ban people too.
Reddit is trying to make sure their results don’t end up being Google Zeroed to the AI Overview of Google. They have a partnership with Google so if they’re not getting organic traffic on their site, they’re losing money and I’m on team reddit can fuck themselves. By doing the log in only they’re trying to curb the ai results on google just showing the answers right away without any traffic to reddit.
So we’re turning towards a culture of you will have to degrade yourself 20x harder/be a full time influencer or hire a full time influencer/media clown, to get traffic.
-How Google Zero Impacts Website Visibility
The rise of Google Zero has changed the way people visit websites online. More zero-click searches and Google’s answers mean that many people do not even go to other sites. This leads to a clear drop in the number of people who click on organic search results. The owners of websites need to deal with problems like flaws or weak spots in code execution. These issues make it even harder for them to get their sites seen.
To keep up with these changes, you must learn what Google now looks for. Use what you learn to fight against lost traffic. This is how you stay important and keep people coming to your site. Being aware of flaws and issues in code execution will help your site work better and help your site show up when people search on Google.
-Decline in Organic Traffic
Organic traffic is now falling for many, especially in the United States. This drop is mostly because more people get what they need from Google’s zero-click searches. In the past, a blog or a business could get a lot of visits from Google, but that has changed. Now, fewer people are coming to their websites. The rise of AI and new ways to search have made this problem even bigger.
Advertisers also face problems. Fewer people leave the search results and visit their websites. For example, an air-purifier review blog lost a lot of its views. That happened because bigger companies take up the top spots and get picked for those search snippets.
To handle this, businesses can try to find new ways to get traffic. They could share their message in niche communities, start a podcast, or focus on getting leads from referrals. This helps them not have to count only on Google’s organic traffic, and it can keep their numbers up even as things change with AI, search, and new tech.
source: vcsolutions.com/…/what-is-google-zero-impact-on-w…
as if it stops AI bots or scraping, especially if reddit is just selling the data upfront to google or openai. plus you can just make accounts in large numbers to counter the login.
They are really saying" we need the lurkers to use an account and start making content, so we can use ai to scrape from it"
Thts nice. Reddit has become a blocked at the router experience. I’ve started blocking a lot of this shitty aggregation of tech garbage. I really need to take the time to limit google more. Most will never see the reason for doing so but for me its quite satisfying to click and link and have it throw up a generic block landing page. I stripped my landing page down to the bare essentials if I ever have need of unblocking a link. Reddit, reddit gets no consideration at all.
I love this!
I use an extension to block it from my search results but a router level block of reddit would be great.
I use PfSense with PFblockerNG. I created custom lists of differnt ASN’s with a few tweaks here and there. It breaks a few things out there but as far as I’m concerned they can all pound sand. If a site breaks because of some integration with tech giants than it isn’t anything I have to have.
Considering my account was banned, I guess I can’t browse reddit anymore.
See that’s the intersting bit. They still let you browse even if you are banned. They won’t let an ad watching product go to waste.
I had it deleted since it was of no use to me anymore.
hey, yesterday I got a three day ban in a topic about Indiana Jones punching Nazis. I said, we could need some movies again where a hero punches right wing extremists. It was flagged as call to violence :D
Pretty much all bans I got were sarcastic incitements to violence or something like that.
Oh ffs. Was it a person or bot mod that did that?
I think automated, but the last sentence of that message is contradicting itself:
Clear as mud
Maybe don’t hand out bans like a single old lady on Halloween. I got banned for saying we need to punch all Nazis.
I can log and read a source for some tech help, then leave immediately. If you want engagement, unban everyone and return to the wild west.
Investors won’t have that!
Gotta be “”“advertiser friendly”“”…
… Even if that means “human unfriendly”
Shareholders ruin everything they get ahold of.
more like a HOA violation, so you have multiple accounts they all get trashed when one gets banned. assuming you arnt using evasion methods.
Fuck you spez, you fucking usurper.
Excuse me, that’s “Fuck u/spez”
ALien that hatched after his metamorphosis before the IPO.
Coincidentally, the fediverse is suddenly gaining a lot of new users, especially Lemmy/Piefed
I joined Matrix today, It’s been 4-5 hours, I’ve seen multiple other users joining aswell, asking for what client is the best one or how to do X. For sure a lil exodus is happening.
Yo lemmoooo
I still use Reddit from time to time (without an account) because a lot of sports subs aren’t really prevalent here. But looks like that’s gonna go bye bye.
Make your own! I started !micromobility@lemmy.world because there wasn’t one and now it’s got thousands of subscribers and is more active than r/micromobility (which died activity-wise right around the time of the API fiasco, surely a coincidence).
i wiped my account back during the great migration.
years of contributions, gone. fuck it.
i only occasionally lurk in one game sub since.
i absolutely will not login or make an account just to read public forum messages written by the public.
I created dboft.com (lemmy server) to try to recreate my reddit feed. They were requiring their mobile app... and thats a no go for me. BTW, I didn't recreate my reddit feed... but I like whatever this community better.
Welcome!
Thank you!
My account was already suspended, so I sure as hell & coming back
thats the reason they are forcing logins, they lost too many to attrition bans, they arnt generating any useful data for ai to scrape. with INdia becoming increasingly common on the site, i dont they will be much useful for manipulation opinions in other countries.
To anybody who needs to use reddit (for answer to some weird question someone posted few years ago) and they are blocked by “sign in to continue”. Ublock origin works pretty well. I have fennec (fireflox clone) with ublock. Someone told me use the zapper of ublock when that pops up, it has worked for me well.
I was testing just now to see if it works and I haven’t got that pop-up. It is possible ublock has already leveled up or I just didn’t use reddit for long enough. It was without logging in.
Instead of the zapper, use the dropper and make it a permanent rule in your ublock
Yep, I zap away and it works fine.
i use sink it extension to block the nagging. and has other features too.
if you want to use the old redd layout, its called classic reddit layout, it looks like old reddit, but it has some kinks on mobile more than desktop.
This is an opportunity for Lemmy and the community.
We must be more free and decentralized. NO to impositions and opposition to freedom of expression! I’ve just joined Lemmy after REDFASCISTS banned me, also my country -Türkiye- is going to start ID verification to use social platforms that’s another why I migrated to Lemmy.
Freedom in speech, Freedom in decision!
Let’s ask DuckDuckGo, Brave and other privacy-centric search engines to index Fediverse contents at the top of pages how Kagi has option to search them via a dedicated button.
People are still being routed to Reddit and other enshittificated trash platforms because of search results. At least privacy based SE must route here and Fediverse networks!
I think that would be really good for these networks. A little bit of visibility wouldn’t be bad.
For those of you who are interested and still want to go on Reddit for any reason, Redlib still works… kind of. My personal instance running Nachtalb’s fork still works, but not sure for how long
There are still a small shortlist of public instances that are up, and ppl are pushing fixes that circumvent whatever shenanigans Reddit is pulling. Although, some folks are suspecting that Reddit SWEs are monitoring the redlib project with close attention & trying to shut down any workarounds the redlib team finds
On mobile you can still use RedReader to browse reddit anonymously.
I had an old reddit account from before they required an email address. After I commented about the Chinese genocide of the Uyghurs, a hacker used failed login attempts to flag my account, which triggered reddit to demand an email address. I took that as my cue to leave the site altogether.
Haha, that just means you did something that stung them. Look at Mbappe now, he’s being completely sidelined and having his contract terminated.
yeah same here
I deleted my reddit account back in 2023 after the API changes. I run my own redlib instance to read stuff about some niche interests, but once that stops working i’ll stop that too. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I would be amazed if they didn’t.
im use a reskin extension on the browser, was really hoping some of the apps would replicate something similar to old reddit UI.
Not defending that site at all, but not sure who’s to blame more here, Reddit or the whole AI shitshow?
Reddit was already a shell of itself before AI. I stuck around too long because I didn’t quite like Lemmy when I tried during the API exodus. I eventually left when they started forcing logins. By that time I hadn’t realized just how much the community had degraded till I came here.
It’s like I forgot what online discourse felt like before corporate tentacles strangled reddit. Even the stupid arguments make more sense, and that seems impossible.
True. For me, the quality there pretty much degraded around 2015-6 or at least that was when i started to notice the increase of bot use and such, but some would say it was even before that when one of its founder died. Even after that period it was still tolerable compared to what we have now.
Agreed. The run-up to the 2016 election was the writing on the wall for me.
Reddit was already gaining a lot of clout as a public platform. Around that time was when Bannon leveraged reddit influence to drive the Bernie bros and incels to Trump.
I’m guessing that’s when the world stage really took notice of reddit as a tool for political influence.
there was quite a few incel subs on reddit. including remember the “the-donald” and others.
Yea I do remember the donald, they weren’t really incel though, just a political sub if i am not wrong. Incels had their own subs as well that got purged at the time along with many ones as well. What was good about Reddit back then was that the platform allowed freedom to a large extent, didn’t bother as long as it wasn’t something in your face that violated the rules, either that, or they didn’t care back then.
that changed around 2018, when people were getting banned for the slightest inneundos too.
that was the time when trump won the first term, and putin realized reddit among others was a goldmine for his troll bots. and thats when the banning started.
prepping for the ipo is when it really started to go to shit and it’s been a non-stop shower since.
same, after API-drama, noticed a significant amount more warnings and bans from the site, and other have reported the same.
Reddit is volontary part of the whole AI shitshow so both are to blame
spez wants it to be a AI datamine, turns out when you ban so many people, it causes them to lurk, so its only propaganda bots, and AI generated content. Also its mostly filled with indian subs too , because the amount of people in india potentially surpasses that of the US, by sheer population numbers, and its not useful to have only indians, since the "continent’ doesnt really affect the US in terms of news, sports, celebrity in that country.
basically this made OPEN AI AND google see reddit as less useful to scrape.
This also points out the problem with using AI in the long term. Reddit’s basically become a micro model of what happens when LLMs start scraping LLM content for content. Fucking tech bros who believe they’re prophets somehow couldn’t have foreseen this.
Yes.
I still check Reddit for news and local politics and stuff.
Good riddance I guess… no way would I create an account now with all the PII they require.
There really isn’t a good replacement I’ve aware of for tracking deals, either.
redflagdeals is pretty good
As crazy as it may sound, Reddit is a treasure trove of information, especially when it comes to niche technology stuff. Would be a shame for them to lock it all behind accounts, and in my case age verification.
This should be even more incentive to diversify knowledge away from Reddit
yes that is true, i had to make a new account for the first time in 1year+since getting shadowbanned(apparently they lift or stop noticing for non-serial banned people. i had to ask niche questions recently.
It still is the most reliable way of tech support. Unfortunately.
Reddit is incredibly chaotic, and their systems frequently crash for no apparent reason. Plus, there are more ads than posts.
And more bots than people
And more AI slop than original content
hence thats why they are forcing people to login.
Nearly 20 years on Reddit. I survived the Digg Wars, API/RiF fiasco, and the infiltration of bots.
But I am so done with the anti-user direction Reddit has gone. So here I am.
The API thing is what did it for me, glad youre done with them!
That’s sad to see. I’ve been on Reddit since 2011 but my account was banned a few years ago for reasons that were not given (literally said nothing in the ban message so idk what happened) and every appeal has been struck down. Meanwhile it gets filled with garbage spam accounts, AI, just all sorts of crap. It was such a good community back in the day and now it’s just terrible.
Same here. No idea why my 12 year old account was shadow banned. Appealed and never got a response. Now it’s just bots and junk.
I HAD 11year one that got shadowbanned, waited a year, new account, i occasionally touch it, but i stopped because of the new changes.
its mostly memes mostlypolitical, or a news that is politically relevant. plus fake outrage subs, like AITA, DINNER DIARIES,ETC.
Hello Lemmy!!
Time to log out from reddit.
Hoping this triggers an exodus to lemmy and mbin to make the communities a little more active.
Don’t care. Not there anymore.
I was barely using it from a mobile browser for a game I liked. Looks like I’ll go 0% reddit then.
Is it just me or has Reddit become really right wing and even more full of bots in the last 3 weeks?
pretty much, turns out when you ban alot of users calling out right wing crimes, its only going to have astroturfing from trolls for right wings.
You got banned for calling out genocide too?
After all the dumb changes to reddit and surveillance in general I decided to try and look for an alternative, If I knew it was this easy to get into lemmy I would’ve done it SO much sooner. Also i think this is my first day here? And every time I posted something I got a TON of responses, like I could argue even more attention than I would get on reddit, also the responses were better? Like what? How? There’s way less users here… Just imagine if Lemmy grew just a bit more, doesn’t need to beat reddit at all, just to grow a bit more (with good users ofc) That would be insane, Im having way more fun here already, the community is so much better, the only thing im missing/haven’t found yet, is those r4r reddit-like forums where you get to meet people to dm and stuff
By the time I left reddit I couldn’t remember the last time I had a conversation there. I started a personal rule on reddit where if the top comment was “It’s almost as if…” I would just close the tab and move on.
Whatever followed would be the laziest brain rot. And people voted it to the top.
I use a handful of reddits, usually a few of those lewd ones for like hooking over over voice chat and stuff, kinda fun for that ig, but like as you said, most people there are kinda dumb, most conversations I have there are bland, boring, and end in a day or two at most with ghosting. (met a few cool people tho, its just like… 5% of all the ones I talk to)
I wonder how much of Reddit’s operating costs stem from the decision to host images and video. Seems like if it was just text, it would be dirt cheap.
the real reason, is they lost alot of traffic from the combination of bans, OPENAI/GOOGLE s own ai not finding reddit useful to scrape anymore. the lurking that people did, was result of the bans. they alleged people were just looking at the summaries from the AI not visiting the site.
That reminds me of a site I used to go to.
Good riddance
When I joined reddit it was well over ten years ago, and the reason I joined was because I searched the net for something and got quite a few answers from there.
I then looked up certain things there but over a bit of time, probably a few weeks or so. Then I decided to join it. (Then it went to shit, the app debacle happened and I left).
Anyways the only reason I joined was because the info/entertainment was easily attainable. If I were forced to join or login all those years ago then I would’ve just moved on.
Christ, most random websites get instantly dismissed if I feel like I’m being forced to join it.
same here, but apparently i joined earlier because i unknowingly made a account on reddit from a nintendo game i was playing. but i truley joined in 2016,
Funny thing is that apple freezes the app (even if you are logged in) and pops up an “age verification” window. You can just close it and continue browsing.
(… At least for now)
If you can close it, then that’s old enough.
I have an account that I use for my business over on reddit. It’s really quite awful over there now. I was a longtime user, and then left the site in 2023 along with most other non-bots. It’s safe to say that it’s over.
i wonder if you are like those people on a forum i go to, do you make hordes of accounts? people there make money by using hordes of accounts and try to evade the filters to earn money. reddit loves to go after the non-propaganda bots
Nope
As others mentioned, it’s been a bot-in-only experience. When bot posts are in a small sub of maybe 1000 people, heh they got rid of the counters, then maybe it’s a dead horse.
all the interesting subs, natureislit, metal, all the subs that have drama or probably AI generated. the new one being dinner diaries, and a little bit of AITA. and the one about reddit stocks/login on reddit, have conservatives ranting on it.
I think the part that drives me away, regardless of what website it is, is down vote no comment. Like okay? I would say it should be required that a comment is left if you down vote something. An up vote can just mean an acknowledgement of your post being read.
They just want to know which accounts are permitted to scrape them for textual LLM training material (because Reddit Inc has a contract with them) vs which ones are not permitted.
The byproduct of this is intensifying a cult like environment where its easier to gaslight people, but that’s ancillary.
Even being able to better drown the user base in more, and more specifically targetted ads, even that ain’t the main thing. Everybody in the online advertising world knows that the actual metrics that ‘describe’ how effective ads are… are largely bullshit, and theyre only going to become more bullshit as more LLM bots are spun up and the average person just has less money.
Its enshittification 101, when user base growth phase stops/plateaus, lock in the user base, squeeze harder and harder untill there just isn’t any money left.
The main thing is maximize profit, ie wealth extraction.
reddit yesterday, eliminated the old reddit for logged out lurkers, its only logged in. i found a reskin extension to make it old reddit, but it has some flaws, i think its new. needs alot of kinks to work out though.
if you want an old reskin extension, its called class reddit layout on extensions, it makes the new ugly UI turn into the old one(it has flaws so be warned)
Read this as foreskin extension for some reason.
Can you elaborate on what you don’t like about the new reddit UI? Just curious as a designer
this has to be a joke
Lots of wasted white space and I don’t think RES (Reddit Enhancement Suite) works equally great with new one. I was used to old’s UI, had a basic set of RES commands mapped,so always defaulted to old one. New one I dislike.
Change for sake of change is not always good. Old Reddit worked(works technically still) and it is good. It might not have the most modern looking UI but functionally it is way better.
It is a buggy SPA.
2 ugly side bars with distracting, and the infinite scrolling , plus the amount of space leftover on the sides. also it tends to lag the more you scroll. with old reddit it doesnt have any of that. the new also forces a popup to login eventually.
I’m so sick of hearing about Reddit. I left that place to come here and every other discussion is about Reddit.
Anyone know a third choice for news aggregation?
A 3rd choice would be even more niche, and all it would do is talk about how they left both reddit and lemmy.
Infinite recursion
So you’re saying we need a fourth alt, where the complain they left reddit, lemmy, and the third one?
Reddit is still one of the biggest social media sites on the internet. News about it is important to a lot of people. You're demanding that everyone else conform to your preferences.
Where am I demanding that people conform to me exactly?
I said I was sick of it and looking for somewhere else to go. Hence asking for alternatives.
also alot of people came to the fediverse from reddit specifically.
Tildes?
Reddit is so full of bots and people pasting AI instead of posting themselves that it was beginning to make me feel genuinely insane. Using that site now is hazardous to your mental health. It always was, but now it is hazardous in entirely new ways. I just cannot believe the absolutely crazy stuff I see from people on there. The AI boosters are just unhinged there.
It’s mostly the very popular subs that are bot magnets.
Half of the Reddit answers are now copy paste or heavily inspired by AI.
Those of us still with active Reddit accounts, now might be a good time to gently encourage people on Reddit to check out the Fediverse. Suggest your favourite Fediverse website by URL (don’t just say “Lemmy” or something; we know people trip over themselves to hate on the whole choosing a website thing).
I don’t know if it’s a good idea or a bad idea to mention the state of smaller or niche communities, but it feels more honest to me to just say that we could use more people here who are willing to build an alternative, and not just scroll one.
We’ll be flooded with redditors though.
It’s Digg 2.0 all over again!
I’ve heard that Reddit bans you for any mention of the Fediverse (or any alternatives at this point )
These posts and comments about reddit are akin to stalking your ex on Facebook and reveling in their unraveling.
I’m just waiting for the communities I’m in to move from Reddit hopefully to the Fediverse, and it’ll be goodbye for good.
In the meantime tho, I intend for my account to continue to be somewhat useful while at the same time not really a good marketing data point. I intend to offer RaaS (“Reddit as a Service”) where people who don’t have accounts / can’t log in can ask me to fetch the text of a given post that I find to be of good interest. Crossposting the content from Reddit to here would help to keep the intended conversation alive, without needing Jailbait Spez as an intermediary.
I would like to subscribe. Make one with global news, Red Sox, and furries.
Furries sounds doable and fun! Red Sox too, I just wouldn’t understand wth I am reposting XD
i wonder how much people are using oldreddit while loggedin. i think a small drove of peeople will leave once they remove old reddit entirely.
Thanks for curing my reddit addiction, spez.
If you hate New Reddit like I do, then it already is.
the new REDDIT ui/or the app is terrible, very anti-inuitive.
addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/…/ublacklist/
I currently use this to block reddit from my search results.
Oh no. Anyway.
It’s infuriating because Reddit is still a good source of information on really specific topics. Time to make a throwaway account I guess.
yes i recently asked about a specific appliance problem, and another some local dentists in my area, because sometimes yelp isnt enough and these were older than 1+year posts too.
The one site I will accept an AI summary from. Deleted my account 4+ years now.
What is Reddit?
It’s some kind of off-brand Lemmy as far as I know.
Damn, that’s a way better answer. Wish I’d thought of it.
I think it’s the sound a confused frog makes.
It was just yesterday that I closed my lurking tabs (again). I had been using old.reddit and initially closed them when they first made it log in only, but then after accidentally clicking a reddit link and seeing old reddit again, it turned out the old reddit redirect addon had added something that made it work again. Don’t know exactly what, maybe it was a reskin, maybe they only blocked it on the client side and it was trivial to bypass.
Then, a few days ago, I noticed that the load more comments links were broken. Then, yesterday, when I refreshed the sub I was lurking, it just opened new reddit instead of old. The redirect wasn’t even giving a loop, so not sure what was going on there. I wonder if this step here is an extra one because they got it working again after I closed the tabs.
Either way, it’s lurk or nothing for me. Quality was noticeably going down ever since the API change anyways, same with activity level. I remember you used to be able to spend a couple hours reading AITA then refresh and all but the most active threads would be different. At this point, you could refresh a day later and still see some stale threads that weren’t even at 1k upvotes. There was still enough to pass some time with but nothing like it used to be.
Though I was surprised at how it never did really slide to the right like I figured it would with all the people talking about being banned for any kind of pushback to far right bs.
I haven’t even needed it for technical issues lately. So go ahead, I guess.
I wonder if Libreddit (i think it’s name) still works
It’s Redlib now. And it still works for the time being.
Alr then
Unless you looking to access Reddit’s porn what other reason could you possibly have to use it?
Redlib or Libreddit it works without Javascript, doesnt nag you to download the app, does not force you to sign in and so on
one can simply visit the pornsites, or olnlyfans that the subs steal the content from.
doesn’t that cost money though?
[deleted]
I used to look at Reddit every day, several times per day. Anymore, it is once or twice per month. And never very long, becaues the experience has fallen to a terrible low. My only disappointment in Lemmy is that a lot of the niche subs I used to use on Reddit are not here or are very small.
I use RedReader when I absolutely have to check reddit for something.
Same here on Android. I think Reddit gave it an exception for accessibility reasons and it still works. Way better an experience than their official client. RedReader has been so good that I didn’t even go hunting for ahem, modded versions of official Reddit client :p.
Not much of a concern for me or anyone else who hates ai, but would this impact google ai’s ability to cite reddit when it tells you to add glue to your pizza, among other things? because i like the poisoned well
Google already has exclusive access to Reddit…
apparently its one of the reason reddit is forcing log ins, google ai, and openai find reddits data to be less useful, because theres mostly Ai generated posts now.
>Reddit is becoming an alog experience
What would Marx do?
youtu.be/8FJTK_iNA5s
Yeah which is why I don’t go there anymore lol
I thought it had been like that for a while
They’ve been nibbling away at the logged out experience, month to month.
is reddit still a thing or is just bots talking to each other?
This is like owning a million pounds of dog shit and making sure you lock your garage so nobody steals it while you are out.
There has to be way more info out there on the internet now than in 2001, but because of these kinds of assholes it’s mostly unsearchable, and locked in walled gardens. I hope someday soon Reddit is met with more laughter, dismissal, and cringing than an AOL email address. I hope Spez eats some of that South American beef and shits himself.
What’s wrong with AOL mail? It’s been fine for me as a free e-mail provider. Clean webmail interface, app passwords for IMAP and SMTP (Though Thunderbird can also do OAuth2, apparently. It doesn’t work for me.), 1TB of storage. You just have to opt-out of marketing e-mails. They WILL send them. A lot of them. I’d consider it better than Gmail.
Everything changes I guess. Good to hear that it’s solid now. There was a time when AOL was not ahead of the pack and was kind of seen as a remnant of the dial-up era and one of those old-folk companies.
This is already the experience if you’re on a common VPN, which you should be if you live pretty much anywhere in the world.
A VPN is just someone else’s Internet connection. The average person does not get any benefits.
Obfuscation of your advertising/government profile and removal of corporate and government censorship (which now affects more than a quarter of Americans).
Those two things are valuable to the average person. Even the average American given how disliked the average American is by the current government and how many times in the last couple of years government agents have started to arrest people over twitter comments.
Yes, but also mixing your traffic with hundreds or thousands of others. To blend in
But how does a VPN prevent those things?
It doesn’t, at least not for the average user. It might prevent your ISP from looking at your traffic, but modern networks are far better in that regard with encrypted SSL traffic and DNS than it used to be.
Alone, it’s not the most effective, like the lock on your front door handle. Like the lock on your front door handle, it only keeps out the honest criminals.
Your Advertising profile, in the US the most common one is your Credit/Consumer Profile, tracks your ip address, browsing habits (through super cookies/app sniffing), and your overall fingerprint on the internet. This means Google really does know you visited facebook 12857192 times in the last year, it knows you searched your old crush’s name, and it knows the size of the sex toy you most likely are to buy based on how many seconds you spent on sex-toys.jesus thanks to google analytics plugins tracking your ip address back to the same one you used on google, the same one you used on facebook, etc.
Giving them a common, easily searchable, easily provable (without a warrant) data point to tie all their other data points is literally doing their work for them, and is making them wealthier than all their other business ventures combined. If you use a vpn and regularly change your ip address, fingerprinting is harder. If you use a slightly hardened browser and/or mobile OS, fingerprinting is harder. The less information they have on you, the less information they can sell to the government without a warrant.
This is like if you had a magic button to change the license plate on your car. Flock would be worthless, for the most part. Yes Flock collects a lot of other data, but if you cannot tie that data confidently to a single user, it becomes useless and worthless.
–
Secondly, many VPNs do not keep logs, many do not run their software on persistent media whatsoever, preventing all possible warrant scenarios, even if they were in a country that was able to send them a warrant.
This prevents one data point in government tracking, the easiest one to explain to a judge. The easiest one to explain to a jury. If you make a comment on twitter that ICE doesn’t like, they will subpoena twitter for your ip, subpoena your ISP for your personal information, and then pay you a visit.
Guess what they have to do if you have a VPN? They have to subpoena twitter for your email/phone address/device ID/IMEI/etc, then, with varying levels of difficulty, all of which can be avoided using simple opsec tactics, subpoena all of those related companies, and then hope you used personal information like your personal IP when interacting with any of those services, and then pay you a visit if, with all this extra work ALL OF WHICH HAS A LAYER OF PLAUSIBLE DENIABILITY THE MORE LAYERS YOU HAVE, convince a judge to let them pay you a visit.
Given how quickly it is becoming illegal to be trans in the united states, gay people aren’t far behind, and honestly anyone brown should already be on a vpn and have anonymized online accounts when posting, you should be working on reducing your fingerprint-ability via every means. Given you can get a vpn for 5 euros a month paid through monero, there’s no real excuse not to have that easy extra layer.
Excellent comment. Thank you for taking the time.
I just remembered that there are torrents with crawled text from reddit. I wonder if there’s a way to browse local data like that like you would with a search engine? Reddit’s value is in old content anyway. I never tried it myself but there are tools to browse wikipedia locally like that iirc.
RIP
I’m sure this change will work out for them. What could go wrong?
Ah, you noticed, huh?
hot take: Reddit has been a “logged-in-only experience” since i started using it 15 years ago. default subs and front page have always been trash brainrot, and the real value of Reddit has always been in niche communities, ie a curated user-specific homepage.
that said, their incessant insistence on brainrot like AITA and AskReddit got me off that platform years ago at this point.
Fuck AI, but I can literally use Cursor to build a wrapper to view reddit in old reddit, no account needed. It’s easy. Also fuck spez and all of his nazi loving admins.
The point of Spez's plan is to make it so you would need an account for that, though.
Oh, that fuckstick can try.
If the site literally refuses to send you data unless you're logged in then it doesn't matter what wrapper you've got around the empty shell.
I’ll go as far as writing a bot that makes a burner email and generates an account linked to said burner. Depends how slow my day job is.
Then you've got an account.
We'll see how much personal verification information Reddit ends up requiring on that email, I guess.
I guess we will. If people vibe coded the PS5 onto PC, then I may be able to slap something together. I’ll let you know if I get it working.
Here’s a link to the Reddit thread, for no particular reason.
https://old.reddit.com/user/spez/comments/1xiupm0/about_that_login_screen/
Sign to stop my occasional reddit use.
The only reason I was going was for free games but now I have an app called steam letter
So really, not a single reason for me left to go there. FGoS and FGF were the only reasons I visited over the last 3 years
Twitter required log in only too.
Not according to Morphe’s law
This sound good for Lemmy. Congratulations!
Aww man, I’m gonna miss lurking on r/gallifrey
is it fully rolled out in the world? I am still able to access reddit without an account.
not yet, but they will likely make a “must login to view content” type of popup. they already removed old reddit for lurkers.
And nothing of value was lost.
Fuck reddit already.
alreddit?
ok i don’t have addiction to reddit
Protect its data? You mean sell off thoughtful, detailed user contributions for AI training. Another $60mil from Google sure looks pertty, don’t it, Spaz?
So does [deleted]. Go fuck yourself!
Totally unaffected. Haven’t even visited that site for several years.
Pretty sure I needed to sign up to lemmy for the app to work
Depends on the instance.
All the big instances I know of are public without an account.
With how much of the internet they occupy, and how much information they have, they can essentialy seggregate anyone they permaban from society into oblivion.
Nobody cares.
Who cares? The whole point of Lemmy is to idk… NOT reddit? Fuck them. Or are we all afraid we can’t steal content from there
They couldn’t they harder to rank this shithole if they tried.
No one here cares
I mean, this has pretty big ramifications across the web as a whole. This is going to signal to other platforms that they should do the same, and huge swaths of the internet are going to be effectively inaccessible to search engines.
This makes it much harder to find information online without sacrificing more of your privacy. We do care about this.
I care, but sort of the same way I care about seeing my former high school bullies in the police blotter.